The
S outhern C ross
November 26 to December 2, 2014
Daswa pilgrim centre site blessed
Page 3
Reg No. 1920/002058/06
No 4901
www.scross.co.za
Fr Rolheiser: Why people are leaving Church
R7,00 (incl VAT RSA)
The consecrated life explained
Page 12
Page 10
Parliament’s ‘circus’ a threat to democracy BY STUART GRAHAM
T
Redemptorist Father Sean Wales lifts the cup and the host during a Mass in the chapel (or tabernacle) of Elijah in the church of the Transfiguration on Mount Tabor during a pilgrimage to the Holy Land, Jordan and Cairo this month. The pilgrimage was of Holy Redeemer parish in Bergvliet, Cape Town, which Fr Wales is serving as parish priest before he takes up his position as newly-elected provincial of the Redemptorists. Members of the group noted that Elijah and Fr Wales sported similar beards. (Photo: Gail Fowler)
Pope confirms 2015 trip to US
P
OPE Francis said he would attend the World Meeting of Families in Philadelphia in September 2015, making it the first confirmed stop on what is expected to be a more extensive papal visit to North America. The announcement had been widely ex-
pected, since Pope Benedict XVI had said before his retirement that he hoped to attend the September 22-27 Philadelphia event. Popes typically fulfill their predecessors’ publicly known travel plans, as Pope Francis did in July 2013 when he attended World Youth Day in Rio de Janeiro.—CNS
HE use of a police riot squad to deal with a disagreement in Parliament is “highly problematic” and shows a deep misunderstanding of the Constitution, according to an official of the Catholic Parliamentary Liaison Office. Mike Pothier said the incident, which happened when an Economic Freedom Fighter (EFF) member of parliament refused an order to leave the house after calling President Jacob Zuma a “thief”, disregarded the right of parliamentarians’ to free speech. “Police don’t have the jurisdiction to just barge in where they like,” he said. “The respect of freedom of speech and the respect of the rights of MPs in the National Assembly is paramount,” Mr Pothier said. “You do not call in a riot squad to deal with a parliamentary issue. This shows a deep misunderstanding of the Constitution.” This month’s chaos followed upheaval in Parliament in August when EFF MPs heckled Mr Zuma on when he would reimburse taxpayers for upgrades to his private homestead in Nkandla in KwaZulu-Natal after Public Protector Thuli Madonsela found Mr Zuma had benefited unduly from the upgrades. President Zuma has not returned to the chamber since the incident. Mr Pothier said the regular fights in the National Assembly are bad for democracy because they undermine public respect for Parliament. “People already have a sceptical perception about how hard MPs work and how seriously they take their work,” said Mr Pothier. “This kind of spectacle doesn’t enhance that reputation of Parliament. It is not good for democracy and it risks making Parliament look like a circus.” In this month’s incident, opposition parties shouted down National Assembly speaker Baleka Mbete when she tried to prevent them from bringing motions related to the spending on security upgrades to Mr Zuma’s homestead. Members of the riot police unit entered the Assembly when EFF MP Ngwanamakwetle Mashabela refused to obey an order for her to leave the house. Ms Mashabela, who had called Zuma a thief, was defended by opposition MPs who scuffled with the police.
Mr Pothier said much of the problem stemmed from the “problematic fact” that Ms Mbete held the position of speaker while also acting as the chairwoman of the ANC. “The speaker must be non-partisan and enjoy the respect of all MPs across the house,” said Mr Pothier. He noted that previous speakers such as Max Sisulu and Frene Ginwala held senior positions in the ANC but still enjoyed the respect of most MPs. Neither were seen as pursuing ANC agendas as the speakers of Partliament. “We can debate whether Baleka Mbete has used or misused her position, but the perception is there... You cannot wear both of those hats. You cannot have an office bearer pursuing interests of party. You would expect her to act even-handedly in a non-partisan way.” Mr Pothier said the conflict in the assembly is likely to continue until Ms Mbete steps down. It would be better, he said, if she was replaced by an MP who does enjoy the confidence and respect of the house. The EFF meanwhile, should also take a share of the blame for what has happened. “Even if you don’t like the speaker, you cannot just ignore her rulings. The person who sits in the speaker's seat is like a judge in the court—there is a line you can’t really cross,” he said. Mechanisms exist for parties who are unhappy with the speaker, Mr Pothier noted. “You can stage a walkout as a sign of displeasure. An opposition party could bring the place to a halt, even though you are in the minority. There are non-disruptive and non-disrespectful ways of registering your displeasure.” The EFF, he said, used Parliament to whip up emotions so that they can gain headlines and exposure to “bolster their brand”. “The EFF has crossed the line in the way they have refused to accept the rulings of the speaker. They are overly provocative and the speaker and ANC have risen to that bait.” Mr Pothier said the police should only be called in when a situation in the house is critical. “Parliament has a sergeant-at-arms and its own security guards. If things are heated that security staff could be brought in. The police should be involved only when all options have been exhausted and the situation is critical.”
Cross PILGRIMAGE 2015 For info HOLY LAND • ROME • TURIN phone Gail at
The Southern
7 - 21 May 2015
See the Holy Land, the pope and the Shroud of Turin with ARCHBISHOP WILLIAM SLATTERY
076 352 3809 or 021 551 3923 info@fowlertours.co.za fowlertours.co.za
Jerusalem | Bethlehem | Nazareth | Boatride on Sea of Gailee | River Jordan | Turin with reserved viewing of the Holy Shroud | Florence |Papal Audience in the Vatican |Catacombs | Ancient & Baroque Rome | Four Major Basilicas | and much more...