San Diego Community College District 2009 Sustainability Summary

SAN DIEGO COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT

2009 Sustainability Summary Presented to SDCCD Board of Trustees

January 28, 28 2010 1

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Waste Diversion The District continues to divert a significantly higher percentage of its waste stream than the 50% required by legislation.

2006

2007 72%

2008*

City College

70.6%

74.3%

Mesa College g

57.8%

59%

66.9%

Miramar College

61.2%

69.5%

70.2%

Continuing Education

62.5%

92.4%

87.7%

District Office/DSC

63 3% 63.3%

78%

66 66.4% 4% 2

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Per Capita Diversion (Per SB 1016) Pounds per day disposal p y p Target Reported Target Institution (Employee) (Employee) (Student) City <4.7 0.5 <0.2 Mesa <3.1 0.6 <0.2 Miramar <3.2 0.8 <0.2 Continuing Education <2.7 2.1 <0.1 District Office/DSC <1.8 0.2 --

Reported (Student) 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.0 --

3

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Gas Usage

4

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Electrical Usage

5

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Electrical Usage – Self‐Generated ,3 3 73

3, 37 9

,4 64 3, 33 6

4,000,000

,5 46

4,500,000

4, 14 0

4, 368

,4 33

Electrical Use Self-Generated

2, 498

3,000,000 kWHR

Mesa College

,5 32

3,500,000

Miramar College

2,500,000 2,000,000 1,500,000 1,000,000 500,000 0

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

6

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

kWH per Square Foot

11 .

88 8

11 .

46 1

11 .

6

11 .1 2

4

46

4 11 .

82

12.000

11 .

44 8

12

.05

5

0 .49 12

14.000

13 .

15 7

kWh/Square Foot

10.000

kWh

8.000 6.000 4.000 2 000 2.000 0.000 2000-01

2001-02

2002-03

2003-04

2004-05

2005-06

2006-07

2007-08

2008-09

Year

7

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Water Usage

8

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Solar Initiative (PPA with Borrego Solar) Site

Type

Production (kWh)

City LRC Roof City Harry West Gym Roof District Office Parking Lot Carport District Office Building Roof West City Carport Mid-City Roof Miramar Parking Lots Carport Mesa Parking Structure Carport Mesa Parking Lot #1 Carport Mesa Parking Lot #2 Carport

140,060 257,858 422,490 42 283 42,283 388,403 82,844 1,833,468 303,079 590,870 848,947

TOTAL

4,910,302

Estimated Start-up Date (2010) September October September September September September September September September October

99

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Solar Projects Outside PPA ECC Skills Center Installed a 56 kW SDG&E-owned SDG&E owned PV system. system Expected to generate 98,112 kWh annually and save 54 tons of CO2 annually.

City College CTC Will install 51 kW District-owned PV system. Expected to generate 80,918 kWh annually and save 44 tons of CO2 annually.

Miramar College Classroom Buildings Plans to install a 100kW District District-owned owned PV system on new classroom buildings. Expected to generate 175,200 kWh annually and save 96 tons of CO2 annually.

10

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

CCC/IOU Incentives 2006-09 SDCCD COMPLETED PROJECTS CAMPUS

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

kWh SAVINGS

THERM SAVINGS

INCENTIVE PAID

ECC and City College

Exterior Lighting Controls

64,866

-

$

9,730

ECC

Welding Machine Replacement

49,432

-

$

7,416

Mesa College

Chiller Conversions/ Boiler replacement

$

77,841

Mesa College g

Exterior Lighting g g Controls

$

9,399 ,

Miramar College

Motors, Turbocor, Boiler retrofits

$

54,938

Miramar College

Exterior Lighting Controls

41,115

-

$

6,167

City College

Exterior Lighting Controls

88,791

-

$

13,319

City College

Boiler replacement

$

3,639

City College

Turbocor Chiller Retrofit

City College

Parking Garage Lighting Upgrade

CE Mid City Campus

Exterior Lighting Controls

CE Mid City Campus

T-Stat and EMS Upgrade

TOTAL ENERGY SAVINGS

199,622 62,657 , 186,257

-

13,600 7,163

3,639

216,406

-

$

69,250

90,272

-

$

13,541

5 124 5,124

-

$

769

-

$

19,579

24,402

$

285,588

81,580

1,086,122

11

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

SDG&E Savings by Design Project Name City College LRC Renovation

Est. T-24 %

Est. kWh saved

Est. Therms Saved

Est. Owner Incentive

N/A

30,006

339

$2,641

West City Center

38 1% 38.1%

243 715 243,715

-204 204

$52 305 $52,305

Miramar College Field House

16.6%

140,434

1,535

$13,801

Mesa College Police Station

23.6%

23,876

178

$7,050

Mesa College g Parking g Garage g

55.4%

366,100 ,

0

$18,305 ,

Educational Cultural Complex Skills Center

21.5%

122,266

2,273

$32,334

Allied Health

11.4%

57,502

149

$17,122

Miramar College LLRC

22.6%

248,754

1,192

$68,741

Vocational Technology Center (City College)

23.8%

260,953

2,691

$77,586

Voc. Tech. Parking Structure

56.5%

314,344

0

$15,717

Student Services

30.0%

393,240

0

$170,156

Classrooms A & B

25 0% 25.0%

246 304 246,304

2 060 2,060

$91 129 $91,129

Autotech Career Bldg

25.0%

18,442

0

$8,397

Miramar Parking Structure #1

86.4%

354,536

0

$11,111

2,820,472

10,213

$586,395

Total

12

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LEED is an internationally recognized green building certification system, providing third‐ party verification that a building was designed and built using strategies aimed at improving performance across all the metrics that matter most: improving performance across all the metrics that matter most: • • • • •

Energy savings Water efficiency Reduction of CO2 emissions Improved indoor environmental quality Stewardship of resources and sensitivity to their impacts.

The four certification levels include Platinum, Gold, Silver and Basic Certification

13

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

LEED – City College LEED Gold – Arts & Humanities Building Business Technology Building Career Technology Center Career Technology Center LEED Silver – General Purpose Classroom Building R Building (Learning Resource Center) Science Building Science Building C Building M Building

C Career Tech Center T hC

General Purpose Classroom Building

Arts & Humanities/Business quad R Building (already certified!)

Science Building ld

14

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

LEED – Mesa College LEED Gold – Allied Health Building Police Station LEED Silver – Student Services LEED Silver – Student Services Math and Science Building

Police Substation Allied Health Building Allied Health Building

Student Services

Math and Science Building

15

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

LEED – Miramar College LEED Platinum – Police Station LEED Gold – Heavy Duty Advanced Transportation Tech. Center Arts & Humanities Classroom Building Business & Mathematics Classroom Building LEED Silver – Library Learning Resource Center (LLRC) Automotive Technology Career Bldg. Expansion St d t U i Student Union LEED Certified – Hourglass Park Field House Aviation Maintenance Tech. Center Expansion Business & Mathematics Police Station Student Union

LLRC Arts & Humanities 16

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

LEED – Continuing Education LEED Gold – North City Campus LEED Silver – West City Campus Linda Vista Campus i d i Cesar Chavez Center Skills Center at ECC

West City Campus

Cesar Chavez Center

North City Campus

Linda Vista Campus

ECC Skills Center 17

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Sustainability Awards October 2009 Green California Community College Summit 2009 Leadership Award (Instructor) – Dr. Dr Karon Klipple Klipple, Professor of Mathematics and Co-Chair, Environmental Stewardship Committee, City College June 2009 9th Annual UC/CSU/CCC Sustainability Conference Best Practice - Lighting Design/Retrofit: Harry West Gym, City College Best Practice - Student Sustainability Program: City College Urban Farm Honorable Mention - Best Overall Design: West City Campus Campus, Continuing Ed Ed. May 2009 American Society of Civil Engineers (SD Chapter) 20th Annual Awards Award of Merit – West City Campus American Institute of Architecture – Annual Design Awards Design Visionary Award - P Building Renovation at City College

18

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Sustainability Presentations “Get Green, Go Lean! How Lean Construction, Integrated Project Delivery and LEED Can Help You Optimize Project R lt Results and Maximize Efficiencies” d M i i Effi i i ” Presentation to Community Colleges Facilities Coalition (CCFC) November 4, 2009 Dave Umstot, Lance Lareau, John Messick

“Green Construction and Integrated Project Delivery” Presentation to Green California Community College Summit October 6, 2009 Dave Umstot

19

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Sustainability Presentations “LEEDing the Way” “Daylighting Retrofit Best Practices” Presentation to the UC/CSU/CCC Sustainability Conference June 22‐23, 2009

“LEEDing the Way: Developing and Implementing a Districtwide Green Building Policy” Green Building Policy Presentation to Smart and Sustainable Campuses Conference National Association of College and University Business Officers April 7 2009 April 7, 2009 20

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

District Standards Hand Dryers vs. Paper Towels Hand dryers reduce the cost of maintenance and custodial services and are more environmentally friendly.

Financial Benefits Save $1,000 per year, per dryer in paper towel costs Additional savings from reduced trashcan liner use Energy efficient, drawing as little as 1150 watts Sanitary Benefits Help restrooms stay cleaner Reduce bacteria on hands Dry hands in 12 seconds; remove 99.9% of bacteria from air used to dry hands 21

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Sustainability at City College Campus & Community Outreach – Annual Earth Fair, Bike Fair – Green Speaker Series - including films and field trips – Student Club, RecycleMania, Flex sessions • Policy & Procedure – Sustainability Policy and Procedure, GHG Report – Campus and District ESC • Curriculum & Programs – Solar Technology Certificate – Sustainability Certificate and AA – Sustainable Urban Agriculture Certificate and AA – Integration in existing programs • Results – Recycler of the Year – Urban Land Institute Smart Growth Award – Green California CC Faculty Leadership Award

22

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Sustainability at Mesa College • November 2009: Students and faculty broke ground and planted the first seedlings in the Green Garden on the Mesa. The garden’s produce is used by Culinary Arts students in the MFusion culinary laboratory.

• Each semester: The ESC’s Eco Awareness Series offers green lectures and films to the campus community. it • During Canyon Day 09, 50 volunteers hauled five truckloads of trash, non-native plants and an even dozen shopping carts out of Tecolote canyon.

And around campus…

• Water-guzzling lawns are being replaced with rock and natural nat ral gardens. gardens • In the classroom, committees and departments, documents are distributed via email and posted online,, saving g trees and dollars.

Mesa College Recycling Program v2

www.sdmesa.edu/ecomesa

23 23

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Sustainability at Miramar College

Faculty Sustainability Coordinator hired Spring 2009

Organic Garden/ Composting

Stormwater detention and filtration system

S a t Irrigation/ Smart gat o / Sustainable Landscaping

Sustainability in the Curriculum Workshops Water Bottle Resolution

24

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Greenhouse Gas Inventory SDCCD Emissions Split (FY2008): 25,003 Total MT eCO2

2% 2% 3% 3%

Commuting

1%

0%

Purchased Electricity On-Campus Stationary (Natural Gas)

3%

Scope 2 Transmission & Distribution Losses from Electricity

9% 46%

Directly Financed Outsourced Travel (District-funded) Paper Direct Transportation (Fleet Services) Solid Waste ((Landfilled Waste))

31%

Refrigerants & Chemicals Agriculture (Synthetic & Organic Fertilizers)

25

SDCCD 2009 Sustainability Summary

Greenhouse Gas Inventory 30,000

Sco pe 2 T & D Lo sses P aper

Total Em missions (Metric c Tons eCO2)

25,000

Wastewater So lid Waste

20,000

Study A bro ad A ir Travel Directly Financed Outso urced Travel Co mmuting

15,000

P urchased Steam/Chilled Water P urchased Electricity

10,000

A griculture Refrigerants & Chemicals

5,000 Direct Transpo rtatio n On-Campus Statio nary

0 2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

Year

26

SAN DIEGO COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT

Questions?

David D id U Umstot t t Vice Chancellor F iliti M Facilities Managementt dumstot@sdccd.edu (619)388 6546 (619)388-6546

27