Sustainable Luxury in Hospitality: from an Oxymoron to a Tautology Feb. 2024 Essay by Frank M. Pfaller Founder President HoteliersGuild Academy of Hospitality Arts HoteliersGuild CoutureHospitalityConcept
This essay encapsulates the significance and advantages of sustainability in the luxury hospitality industry, guided by the insights and research compiled. It serves as an instrumental resource for industry stakeholders, offering a comprehensive HoteliersGuild CoutureHospitalityConcept understanding and practical application of sustainable measures.
Introduction Encouragingly, the luxury hotel industry - not least due to increasing pressure from committed investors, developers and asset managers - has finally begun to focus even more on the issue of sustainability, recognising its crucial role in long-term success and positive impact on society. This paper is intended to summarise the most important scientific findings on sustainability in the luxury hotel industry and is aimed at hoteliers, the abovementioned segments of our industry and, of course, society in general, and I am particularly pleased to take this opportunity to mention that we at the HoteliersGuild are proud to have been pioneers in this important field for more than two decades. When I founded the Guild with the collaboration of just a few highly motivated, renowned industry leaders as an initiative to introduce and promote "sustainability in luxury hospitality", it faced skepticism and was often seen as a contradiction. The idea of combining luxury with sustainability seemed paradoxical, as luxury was traditionally associated with excess and opulence, while sustainability emphasised conservation and responsibility. However, over the years, this perspective has thankfully undergone a significant shift. What was once considered an oxymoron has evolved into a tautology, a statement that is inherently true. Thanks to the dedicated collaboration of HoteliersGuild members around the globe and under the experienced leadership of some of the brightest academic minds and practitioners within the HoteliersGuild Academy of Hospitality Arts, this noble cause has gained significant momentum over the years. (Special Edition LookBook on Eco-Hospitecture | Sustainable Architecture by Matteo Thun | Great Plains Conservation&Foundation and LookBook No. 2) Science-Based Findings on Sustainability in Luxury Hospitality Sustainability Practices in Luxury Hotels: Luxury hotels are implementing practices that improve energy efficiency, reduce water consumption, waste, carbon emissions, and enhance biodiversity, while also engaging in social practices like community involvement and providing a healthy work environment (Pereira, Silva & Dias, 2021). From the very start of my career, it quickly became clear that I would have two favourites in our industry: Architects and Chefs. So please allow me to start this science based paper with these two very important segments.
HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept
Sustainable Architecture & Design in Hospitality Incorporating sustainable architecture and design in hospitality not only enhances the aesthetic appeal and functionality of spaces but also plays a critical role in promoting environmental stewardship, cultural preservation, and public health. (Sensible Sustainable Solutions by Bill Bensley) Sustainable architecture and design in hospitality are pivotal in achieving environmental, social, and economic sustainability goals. Adaptive re-use (AR) has emerged as a significant strategy within sustainable development in hospitality, offering social, environmental, and economic benefits. AR involves repurposing existing buildings for new uses, thus preserving cultural heritage and reducing the environmental impact associated with construction and demolition. This approach aligns with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, particularly in promoting sustainable cities and communities, and responsible consumption and production practices (Liang & Wong, 2020). Innovative interior design strategies also play a crucial role in cultural sustainability within hospitality. Heritage boutique hotels, for instance, demonstrate how interior designs can sustain and showcase a nation's cultural heritage and identity. This is achieved through a blend of traditional and modern design elements, creating a unique brand image of cultural sustainability (Almurbati, 2020). Moreover, sustainable architectural design in hospitality extends to health and safety, especially in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. Architectural designs incorporating biomedical systems and infection prevention control strategies have become increasingly important in safeguarding both staff and guests. This holistic approach to design demonstrates the interplay between architecture, health, and sustainability (Amran et al., 2022). Sustainable Food Experiences in Luxury Gastronomy: Michelin-starred chefs emphasize both functional (sustainable and healthy food, eco-friendly practices) and experiential (sensory, creativity, pleasure, aesthetics) aspects of sustainable luxury food experiences (Batat, 2020). The study by Batat (2020) provides a comprehensive exploration of the sustainable luxury food experiences in the context of Michelin-starred restaurants. The research underscores that these chefs don't just focus on the functional aspects of sustainability, such as sourcing sustainable and healthy ingredients or employing eco-friendly practices in their kitchens. They extend their commitment to sustainability into the very experience of dining, considering
HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept
how each dish appeals to the senses, unleashes creativity, delivers pleasure, and satisfies aesthetic expectations. In the realm of sustainable and healthy food, Michelin-starred chefs prioritize ingredients that are locally sourced, organically grown, and ethically produced. This approach ensures minimal environmental impact and supports local communities and ecosystems. The chefs are committed to reducing food waste, conserving water, and minimizing energy usage, reflecting a holistic approach to environmental stewardship. Beyond these functional aspects, there is a strong emphasis on the experiential dimension of dining. Michelin-starred chefs craft dishes that are not only sustainable but also sensorially engaging, integrating textures, flavors, and aromas that captivate the diner. The presentation of the food is meticulously designed to be visually appealing, often resembling works of art. The creativity in combining ingredients and techniques from various cuisines results in unique culinary experiences that are both innovative and enjoyable. Moreover, the dining experience is orchestrated to deliver maximum pleasure, from the ambiance of the restaurant to the service provided. The chefs and their teams strive to create an atmosphere that complements the culinary offerings, enhancing the overall dining experience. In essence, the study highlights that sustainability in the luxury gastronomy sector as practiced by Michelin-starred chefs is a multifaceted concept. It's not only about the responsible sourcing of ingredients and eco-friendly kitchen practices but also about creating a memorable, enjoyable, and aesthetically pleasing dining experience that resonates with the patrons on multiple levels (Batat, 2020). Financial Performance and Sustainability: Hospitality firms investing in environmental programs often experience improved financial performance, suggesting a virtuous cycle of sustainability and profitability (Singal, 2014). The relationship between financial performance and sustainability in the hospitality industry, as highlighted by Singal (2014), reveals a compelling narrative about the business benefits of environmental stewardship. Singal's study, spanning from 1991 to 2011, involved a comprehensive analysis of data from the MSCI’s Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) Indices and Standard and Poor’s credit ratings. The findings provide substantial evidence that hospitality firms investing in environmental programs often see improved financial performance over time. This creates a 'virtuous cycle' where sustainable practices lead to better financial outcomes, which in turn, encourage further investment in sustainability. HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept
Key insights from this research include: Higher Investment in Environmental Programs: Compared to businesses in other industries, hospitality firms, on average, invest more in environmental programs. This heightened commitment to sustainability is a distinguishing feature of the hospitality sector. Fewer Environmental Concerns: These firms also have significantly fewer environmental concerns, reflecting a proactive approach to managing their environmental impact. Financial Performance Leading to Increased Investments: The study found a positive feedback loop where strong financial performance encourages hospitality firms to increase their investments in sustainability initiatives. Long-term Benefits: Importantly, the decision to 'go green' pays off in the future, suggesting that investments in sustainability are not just morally and environmentally right but also financially prudent. Market Support for Sustainability Efforts: The implication is that customers, investors, and governmental bodies are increasingly supportive of hospitality firms that take genuine steps towards sustainability. This support often translates into financial gains for these firms. Singal's research underscores the importance of sustainability in the hospitality industry not just from an environmental perspective but also from a financial one. It suggests that sustainable practices are not merely cost centers but strategic investments that can enhance a firm’s financial performance and competitive advantage in the long run (Singal, 2014). This finding is especially pertinent for stakeholders in the hospitality industry, including hoteliers, developers, investors, and asset managers, who are increasingly looking to balance profitability with environmental responsibility. Consumer Perception and Sustainability Communication: The way luxury hotels communicate their commitment to sustainability can significantly influence consumer perceptions and booking decisions, with an emphasis on perceived integrity and environmental concern (Amatulli, Angelis & Stoppani, 2021). The research delves into the nuanced ways in which luxury hotels can leverage sustainability communication to influence consumer perceptions and decisions. Their study posits that sustainability-focused marketing communication can significantly elevate consumers' willingness to book a room in a luxury hotel by enhancing their perception of the hotel's integrity. The study found that when luxury hotels emphasize their dedication to environmental sustainability in their communication, it positively impacts HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept
consumers' perceptions, leading to a higher likelihood of booking compared to communication focused solely on customer service. This outcome is predominantly driven by the perceived integrity of the hotel, which is bolstered by sustainability-focused communication. Additionally, the study suggests that this effect is even more pronounced among consumers who already have a strong dispositional environmental concern. These consumers are more likely to respond positively to sustainability-focused communication, as it resonates with their personal values and beliefs about environmental responsibility. The research contributes to our understanding of sustainable luxury tourism and hospitality by providing a novel theoretical framework. It demonstrates the critical role of perceived integrity in shaping consumer responses to luxury hotels' commitment to sustainability. This insight is particularly valuable for luxury hotel marketers, as it highlights the importance of effectively communicating sustainability efforts to enhance consumer perception and drive booking decisions. In essence, the study underscores the strategic value of sustainability communication in the luxury hospitality sector, suggesting that such communication is not just a corporate responsibility exercise but a potent tool for influencing consumer behavior and preferences (Amatulli, Angelis, & Stoppani, 2021). Sustainable Service Innovation: Sustainable service innovation in hospitality involves multiple factors like market position, customer satisfaction, service orientation, environmental thinking, employee involvement, and government policy (Horng, Wang, Liu, Chou & Tsai, 2016). Objective: This study investigates the key characteristics and indicators of sustainable service innovation (SSI) in the hospitality industry, focusing on how they shape the industry's future direction and sustainability. Methods: The research employed content analysis based on interviews with 17 experts in hospitality management from Taiwan, including academic scholars, government officers, and top-level managers. The participants' insights, drawn from an average of 20 years of experience in the field, were analyzed in relation to Amabile’s componential theory of creativity and innovation. Findings: The study identifies 11 major characteristics indicative of SSI in hotel management. These characteristics encompass market position, customer satisfaction, service orientation, environmental thinking, employee involvement, incentive mechanism, human resource development, HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept
environmental services, cultural resource management, government policy, and school education. These elements collectively define a comprehensive view of sustainable service innovation in the hospitality industry. Conclusion: The study highlights the multifaceted nature of sustainable service innovation in hospitality, emphasizing the importance of a broad range of factors from market positioning to educational initiatives. It provides both theoretical and practical implications for current and future trends in sustainability and innovation in the hospitality sector. Implications: This research offers valuable insights for practitioners and policymakers in the hospitality industry, suggesting that a holistic approach to sustainable service innovation can significantly influence the industry's future sustainability and growth. Sociocultural Considerations in Sustainable Hospitality: Successful implementation of sustainability in luxury hospitality requires understanding local sociocultural dynamics, as seen in case studies from Bali, Indonesia, highlighting the influence of local values and community engagement on sustainability initiatives (Binder & Varga, 2015 - See also: What luxury hoteliers have to contend with today by Frank M. Pfaller) My journey into the world of sustainability in hospitality began also in Bali, where my involvement in several luxury projects sparked a deep personal interest in this field. Since then, the pursuit of sustainability in the hospitality industry, especially in luxury hotels, is increasingly becoming a focal point for stakeholders. However, the implementation of sustainable initiatives, particularly those proposed by international stakeholders, encounters various challenges. Objective: This paper focuses on the sociocultural barriers that luxury hotels in Bali, Indonesia, face in implementing sustainable practices. It aims to highlight the unique sociocultural dynamics that significantly influence managerial decisions and the success of sustainability projects in this region. Methods: The research is centered on understanding the sociocultural specificities of Balinese society that impact sustainable development in luxury hotels. The study delves into unique organizational and communal values prevalent in Bali, such as bapakism (paternalism), banjar (community councils), kira kira (approximation or flexibility), and suka duka (shared happiness and sorrow). Findings: The study reveals that these sociocultural elements are integral to the Balinese society and play a critical role in the decision-making process within luxury hospitality settings. The paper underscores the complexity of the local sociocultural environment and its implications for the management of luxury hotels. HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept
Conclusion: To facilitate the successful implementation of sustainable development projects in Bali, it is essential to have a profound understanding of the local sociocultural dynamics. The research highlights the importance of creating awareness and establishing efficient intercultural communication among stakeholders to ensure the success of development projects in this context. Implications: The findings of this study are crucial for stakeholders in the hospitality industry who are looking to implement sustainable practices in culturally diverse settings like Bali. It serves as a guide for understanding and navigating the sociocultural landscape, which is a critical factor for the successful integration of sustainability in luxury hospitality. Reference: Binder & Varga, 2015 Closing Words Sustainability in luxury hospitality is multifaceted, encompassing environmental, social, and economic dimensions. The integration of sustainable practices not only enhances the guest experience and environmental footprint but also contributes to financial performance and market positioning. The HoteliersGuild Academy of Hospitality Arts plays a pivotal role in advancing sustainability within the luxury hospitality sector. This complex and essential aspect of the industry spans environmental, social, and economic realms. The Academy's efforts in promoting sustainable practices not only elevate the guest experience and reduce environmental impact but also positively influence financial outcomes and enhance market standing. At HoteliersGuild, our commitment to sustainability is rooted in the belief that it is a crucial strategic component for those in luxury hospitality. This approach is in harmony with modern consumer expectations and broader societal norms. The Academy's extensive expertise is a key resource for our members and strategic partners, aiding them in adopting, implementing, and effectively communicating sustainable practices.
HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept
"Sustainable Luxury, Our Shared Signature – HoteliersGuild at the Heart of the CHC Alliance."
HoteliersGuild
CoutureHospitalityConcept