P O R T F O L I O LANDSCAPE
shreeni benjamin
Balkrishna Vithaldas Doshi, Pritzker Prize winner 2018
Shreeni Benjamin B.Arch (Bachelor of Architecture) - 2015 Indubhai Parekh School of Architecture, Rajkot CGPA : 3.6/4 M.Arch (Master of Landscape Architecture) - 2019 Centre for Environment and Planning, Ahmedabad CGPA : 3.0/4 Email : greenduststudio@gmail.com Registered Architect under Council of Architecture, India CA/2016/79143 Professional membership of Indian Society of Landscape Architects B-66/S 2018
Achievements
Skill
Young Talent Architecture Award_Asia edition
: 2020
Graphisoft Archicad
Indian Society of Landscape Architects Award ISOLA Prabhakar Bhagwat Award for Best Thesis
: 2019
Autocad
Singapore Institute of Landscape Architects Awards : 2019 Best Design Showcase - Bronze Outstanding Contextual Analysis and Investigation- Bronze Planting Design - Bronze Ghana, Accra Affordable Housing Design Competition :2018 Part of the Winning Firm (DPC, Ahmedabad), Junior Architect
Profe s s i o n a l
Lumion 3D Photoshop CC Lightroom CC Adobe Indesign CC Adobe Illustrator CC
Pra c t i ce
Freelance Landscape Architect, Ahmedabad
Vastushilpa Consultants, Ahmedabad
Dec 2019- At present Position: Landscape Consultant Contributed to the design & planning of the following projects • Residential landscape Planning for Mr. Dave, Anand • Residential landscape Planning for Mr. Mansukh, A’bad • Residential landscape Planning for Mr. Joseph, A’bad • Residential Interior Planning for Mr. Martin, A’bad
May 2012- Jan 2013 (9 months) Position: Trainee Architect Contributed to the design & development of the following projects • Ishira House, 250 sqmt • Bhadra Plaza, 19000 sqmt • IIM Udaipur, 78000 sqmt • IIT Gandhinagar Housing, 1050 sqmt
Nature of Work involved Conceptual Masterplan, Presentation drawings, Working drawing, Research
Nature of Work involved Model making, Presentation drawings, Site visit, Working drawing, Case studies, Report writing
Jerde Partnership, Los Angeles
Design & Planning Counsel, Ahmedabad
Dec 2020- At present Position: Assistant to Senior Landscape Consultant Contributed to the design & development of the following projects • Powerlong Retail park- Xiamen China • Pukoh Industrial park- Wenzhou China • Ningbo Transit Oriented development-Ningbo China • Jinan Retail Park- China
Feb 2016 - May 2017 (15 months) Position: Assistant Architect Contributed to the design & development of the following projects • Multi-level Parking, 6000 sqmt • Daman-Ganga Riverfront Development, 1.75 km • Chandola Lakefront Development, 3.5 sqkm
Nature of Work involved Conceptual Masterplan, Presentation drawings, Working drawing, Research
Nature of Work involved Concept Design, Landscape Design, Detail Design, Coordination, Working drawing, Presentation drawing, Site visit, Case studies, Report writing
Exaggerating existing contrast
6
Understanding the river Vishwamitri and its offered landscape in its entirety from upstream to delta including its processes of evolution and associations with the surrounding biodiversity and the urban fabric. The attempt is to instigate the connection between the river and a memory through a landscape design insertion at a designated stretch within the city. The “Exaggerating existing contrast” focuses on the exaggerating the existing prominent physical features of the site that portrays a contrasting experience on the banks of river.
‘Urban Greening - as the Pace-Maker for the Metabolism of the City’ Looking from a top down perspective to the details of the treatment policies this project questions the larger organizing system of open spaces at an urban scale. Considering the city as an organism, the concern is to identify its state of health by understanding the state of its inhabitants. Furthermore providing strategies to counter the imbalance of the metabolic state through the physical infrastructure or policies of the city. The place of intervention targeted to heal the city is the commuting physical network.
20
Landscape detail design
28
Farm like landscape situated between the fringe of a rapidly developing city and a small village. The area is sparse with quiet few residences. Most of the people own holiday homes in the given vicinity. The theme for such a residential area is considered to be adapting the spatial character of both the context that is the city and the village. The aim is to bring out the best of both contexts in a structured and comfortable way. The adaptations from the village context began with observing the seating spaces, the use of the river or lake for recreation and the mounds or slopes as vantage points. The design incorporates mostly tall grasses and slopes to bring back the topography of a village settlement with some aloof as well as congruent seating spaces pertaining to the nature of the users and attempts to generate a farm-like landscape ambiance manipulating it through modern technology and systems.
Mending the gap : Landscape Conservation for the island of Aliabet
38
The island is a part of the river Narmada’s estuary which has formed connections with the mainland due to the depositions afflicted by the anthropogenic activities like the construction of the Sardar Sarovar Dam. Once an ecologically rich and diverse chunk of land, Aliabet was a home to bountiful wetland birds and animals. Overlooked social cost of the dam has left Aliabet to become a desert and a saline wasteland. This research study is an attempt to understand the drivers and the ecological services of Aliabet in order to provide strategies to reactivate its Wetland habitats and revive its place in the larger ecological chain
Miscellaneous Poster to illustrate the Importance of trees in different urban and rural context and Documentation of Trees and Biodiversity for the Centre of Environment and Planning University, Ahmedabad
58
01
Landscape Garden Design: Vishwamitri River banks
E x a g g e r a t i n g
t h e
Due to the presence of various neotectonic plates near the river basin, the river exhibits a narrow, highly sinuous and deeply incised meandering channel. The Vishamitri river flows for most of its length in the Gujarat Alluvial Plain which further endorses the meandering pattern. The climate of this region is characterized by a hot summer and a general dryness except during the monsoon season. The Dhadhar valley and the adjoining regions fell under the semi-arid bio-climatic zone. This broad division has been made on the basis of the intensity and duration of precipitation, temperature and duration of dry season. According to the classification, the climate in this zone is described as tropical accentuated, as dry season exceeds more than seven months and the rainfall is of the order of 500-1000 mm. Recently the region is observing frequent flash floods. As per the current situation in the city of Vadodara, people are facing their back to the river and only use it as a dumping or sewage ground. Also, Vishwamitri is one of the famous Crocodile breeding grounds for decades which makes it nearly impossible to enter the river.
8
e x i s t i n g
c o n t r a s t
River Vishwamitri Length
: 70 km
Catchment Area : 3423 sqkm Forest types
: Dry mixed deciduous type
Bio-diversity
: Crocodile, Panther, Otter,
Chinkara, Jackal, Mongoose, Indian hare, Indian porcupine
Source: Pavagardh Hills
River Vishwamitri Catchment Area
Dhadhar Vadodara city Site
Middle course of river Features Meanders Erosion and Deposition Wider channels Flood plains Heavy sediment load Ox-bow lakes
9
F a b r i c
o f
t h e
s i t e
As one approaches the site the first nuance one perceives is that of a large open space with almost a flat ground, consisting of sparse or absolutely no vegetation. On exploring the open space further, one witness the river coming to life. In this journey, contrasting physical features of the site like the gradual slope of the barren land turning to undulating bends, steep slope and deep valley transcending into a river are observed. Presence of a ridgeline between the river edge and the flat patch of the site is a natural threshold that divides the two distinct spheres in the site.
Steep slope towards the Dense Riparian vegetation river approach along the meanders
Gradual slopes on the Barren Upland
Sparse Vegetation on the flat land
ep
ste
al
water
land
u grad
water
land
empty flat/ empty wet/ dense
valley
Broad
hill
all
t e,
ns de short plantation shade
flat
depression
er
g din
ord
en
asc
sho
rt/
den
No plantation / Barren
se
10 flat
Nature of all the elements from this ridgeline onwards, on either side, undergoes changes which are evidently notable through their physical features or appearance. The design approach is to identify such similar contrasting spatial experiences and exaggerating them in order to create two distinct experiences at the same place and time; which is at the river edge and on the flatter portion of land. This is the only approachable space on site. The identifiable and exaggerated features to be created are limited only to the three main parameters that constituents the entire site, which is the topography, vegetation and water bodies.
Panoramic view overlooking the northern horse-shoe meander 4
Existing Contrasts between the different Habitats Barren Upland Water dispersing/ Run-off Open, Dispersed/ Sparse Free Movement Vistas & View Uniform/ Montonuous Multi-directional/Radial Wide Brown Flat, Gradual
River Habitat Water collection Closed, interconnected Contained/ Threshold Obstruction Diverse Uni-directional/Line Narrow 1 Green Bendy/Steep
water
Den
se/
res t
5
3
3
2
2
1
rict
ed
gradual steep
11 raised
valley
o f
t h e
s i t e
p r o p o s a l
e x i s t i n g
p r o p o s a l
e x i s t i n g
F a b r i c
The existing contrast has been exaggerated through the physical features like the presence of the riparian forest in the center versus a raised upland forest in the center. And the continuous unidirectional river stream around the site versus a collecting 12
stagnant water pond inside the site, replicating the wetlands on the stretch of the Vishwamitri river with the same palate of the grasses and shrubs. The height of the meadow in relevance to the existing gradual slope of the site. Also the presence of the orderly culitvated crops versus the chaotic riparian forest.
Overlapping the analytical drawings together brings out the physical features interconnected more prominently. This attempt helps to identify areas that can support the design intentions . 13
Drainage path Impervious surface Forest/ Dense Plantation Sparse Vegetation Flat barren land Sparse Vegetation
The superimposition of different parameters together exposes various overlooked and undefined characters of the terrain. There are certain decisions taken to create a upland forest in the centre to experience the contrast of having
14
a ridge to the exisiting valley. The water logged area is excavated further to extend the water sheet and feel the presence of a larger stagnant water body in contrast to the exisiting the flowing unidirectional river water channel.
15
Dense forest Meadows Grasslands Agriculture Wetlands/Marshland
Meadows -Grasses and Wild Flowers on a gradual slope
Grasslands
Wetlands found along the stretch of the River Vishamitri
Corn fields at the floodplains of Vishwamitri
The sparse vegetational area is converted to grassland for a clear vision of the garden around with the backdrop of the highly noticeably upland forest. The different versions of vegetation to add to the contrast orderly includes the farm fields of
corn and wheat and the meadows of the wild flowers and grasses that gives an opportunity to view the garden clearly from any area and experience the contrast. Wet meadows also replicate the existing wetlands around the banks.
15
Agriculture Grassland Upland Forest Wetland Meadow Existing Riparian Forest
16
Meadows and Grasslands
Transitional zones between the meadows and the riparian zone
Grasslands constituting areas with different kind of grasses
Corn fields and Barley fields replicating the stretch of Vishwamitri
Wild flowers & grasses found along the banks of Vishwamitri river
Tephrosia perpurea
Eichhornia crassipes
Ipomea aquatica
Eichhornia crassipes
Tridax procumbens
Pennisetum purpureum
Stenotaphrum secundatum
Cynodon dactylon
17
"Wetlands"
Transitional zones between the meadows and the riparian zone
Eichhornia crassipes
18
Hygroryza aristata
Plants having temporary inundation play a crucial role in the regulation of water flow water quality to whole catchments
Eichhornia crassipes
Neptunia prostata
Permanent inundation provides fauna water even during the drought
Murdannia loriformis
"Upland Forest"
Palette
found along the vishwamitri
river
Forests are high ground water recharge areas, which plays an integral role in sustaining water resources, protecting water quality, and attenuating river floods. More specifically, afforestation can absorb rainwater, disperse surface runoff, purify pollutant, and thereby reduce pollutant load into the rivers and streams and produce clean water.
Eucalytpus
Albizia lebbek
Parkia speciosa
Plumeria alba
e
19
Part Plan
Sections across the site
20
21
02 U r b a n
The Pace-maker for the metabolism of the city
Reduces flood risk
Aesthetic quality
Transpiration cooling
Encourages biodiversity
Streets in the city Ecological Corridors
92.55 µg/m³ PM 2.5 Unhealthy Category Per capita emission of CO2 emission is 0.42kg/day *
Gujarat Pollution Control Board
10-12 %
INCREASE/ YEAR 29 lakhs till 2017 Estimated no. of vehicles 68 lakhs till 2050 *
Surat Mobility study- CEPT
Peri-urban fringe Nutritional hot-spot
14.03 %
DEATHS Due to heavy traffic and rash driving Journal of Indian Acad Forensic Medicine *
STR EET S
IN
S U R AT:
D I STUR B ED
S T R E E T S : PA RT
O F
THE
Improved Air quality
E C O S YS TE M
G r e e n i n g
22
Industries
Urbanisation
City of Surat Area: 326 km Population: 4.5 million
City of Surat 40% of Streetscapes Overtly utilized public spaces
H A B I TAT TR E E
O F
A
City of Surat 0.81% of Designated open spaces Underutilized public spaces
N AT U R A L
W h y “U r ban Gr e e n i n g ”?
Natural Processes carried out by a tree
20%
CHILD OBESITY Adolescent Children found obese due to lack of infrastructure *
National Journal of Medical Research
115
BRIDGES & FLYOVERS Heavy concrete heat accumulating structures across the city as part of the streetscapes * Surat Mobility study- CEPT
Trees are the mediators in the organisms known as the city that runs the ecological processes for sustenance. Absence of these mediators can create health issues for the organism and its inhabitants. A growing pile of research suggests that planting more urban trees, if done right, could save tens of thousands of lives around the world each year by soaking up pollution and cooling down deadly heat waves. “A lot of cities still think of trees as just ornamentation,” says Rob McDonald, the lead scientist for the Nature Conservancy’s Global Cities program. City like Surat which is booming in its population, pollution and infrastructure lacks one of the most important component for its sustainable growth i.e. Trees. It can eradicate all its disrupted conditions in the city particularly in the movement corridors.
Massive grey structures 23
P L A N T I N G STRATEGIES
Road width 4.5 m
Length of the stretch No of trees Total length in the site No of trees planted
10 m 5 (Dia = 5m) 21288 m 10,644
Road width 7.5 m
Length of the stretch No of trees Total length in the site No of trees planted
10 m 4 (Dia = 5m) 1021m 409
Road width 12m
4.5
7.5
12
Population : 38390 Area : 1.0 sqkm No. Of Vehicles (estimated) : 11362 Total CO2 emitted : 4.5 tonnes Tree density (GFD) : 8 per Hectare No of trees present : 800 Open space : 45%
Roads & Driveways 24
(4,42,497 sqmts)
: 40%
Length of the stretch No of trees Total length in the site No of trees planted
10 m 2 (Dia = 10 m) 2442 m 489
4.5
GUIDE
LINES
OP EN S PAC E C ATEGORY
Infrastructure greens Plantation along roadside
Pit size 1.25 x 2 m Pit
1.25 mts x 1.25 mts
Planting distance (c/c)
Trees planted inside the residential setback to provide enough clearance for the street
Large trees : 10m Small trees : 5m
Tree cover
15% area of Roads and Highways
Tree species and theme Follow the species matrix 7.5
Trees planted inside the residential setback to provide enough clearance for the street
Extended living room = 4.5 m wide Street
1.25m Median for plantation 1.50m Walkway
12
Walkways closer to the driveway to increase the flexibility of the street for other purposes
Congregational space = 12m wide Street
25
P L A N T I N G STRATEGIES
Road width 18m
Length of the stretch 10 m No of trees 3 (Dia = 10 m) Total length in the site 1137 m No of trees planted 342
Road width 24m
Length of the stretch 10 m No of trees 3 (Dia = 10, 12 m) Total length in the site 966 m No of trees planted 290
Road width 42m
18
Population Area No. of Vehicles (estimated) Total CO2 emmitted Tree density (GFD) No of trees present Open space
Roads & Driveways 26
24
42
: 38390 : 1.0 sqkm : 11362 : 4.5 tonnes : 8 per Hectare : 800 : 45%
(4,42,497 sqmts)
: 40%
Length of the stretch 10 m No of trees 4 (Dia = 10 m) Total length in the site 1006 m No of trees planted 403
T RE E C O VER
Achieved after incorporating the strategies Trees (dia =10) = 1524 Area = 119,237 sqm Trees ( dia = 5) = 11,053 Area = 216,915 sqm TOTAL TREES = 12577
1m Walkway
1.25m thick plantation
1.25m thick plantation
1.25m thick plantation
33.6%
Walkways protected by plantation from pollution and high temperature
Total tree cover achieved for the site : 336,152 sqmts/ 1 sqkm Urban greening can increase the tree cover by 30% only using the STREETSCAPES
1.50m Walkway
1.50m thick plantation
1.25m Median for plantation
1.50m median
1.25m Median for plantation
1.50m thick plantation
1.50m Walkway
24
Cutting down a lane on each side to provide a designated parallel parking
Regulated corridor = 24m wide Street
1.50m thick plantation 1.50m Walkway
Median for plantation 1.25m
B.R.T.S
1.25m
Median for plantation
45
1.50m Walkway 1.50m thick plantation
)
18
B.R.T lane seperated via median plantations, designated parallel parkings
City Identity = 42m wide Street
27
S P E C I E S CALCULATOR FOR EFFICIENT USE Aesthetics Shade & Buffer Pollution Mediators Species
Carbon Sequestration efficiency
Evergreen
Density (foliage density)
Form (broad or narrow)
Upright (provides clearance)
Seasonal Variation
Fast growing
2 1 2 2 4 2 4 5 10 4 8 6 8 10 3 4 2 1 4 2 2 2 2 4 4 4 2
8 8 6 8 4 8 8 6 4 8 8 6 8 6 6 2 2 10 8 8 4 6 2 8 0 0 8
4 8 6 8 4 6 8 8 6 8 2 6 4 0 8 6 6 10 10 6 10 8 8 6 6 6 6
2 8 8 6 6 6 8 8 8 8 2 6 3 0 4 4 8 10 10 8 10 8 8 6 8 8 6
10 8 6 2 8 8 6 8 8 6 8 8 8 8 4 8 8 2 8 8 8 8 8 8 6 8 8
0 4 8 2 6 6 2 2 2 4 2 2 4 2 6 8 6 2 4 6 6 4 4 2 6 6 4
8 8 8 6 8 8 6 6 6 8 8 8 8 6 4 4 8 2 2 2 8 8 8 6 0 6 8
Polyalthia longofolia Alstonia scholaris Delonix regia Achras sapota Terminalia catappa Cassia siamea Azadirachta indica Mangifera indica Tectona grandis Peltophorum pterocarpum Casuarina equisetifolia Pithecellobium dulce Eucalyptus globulus Acacia chundra Acacia auriculifornis Butea monosperma Albizia lebbeck Ficus benghalensis Tamarindus indica Spathodea campanulata Erthyrina variegata var Dalbergia sissoo Melia azedarach Ailanthus excelsa Mitragyna parviflora Holoptelea integrifolia Millingtonia hortensis
P R O P O S E D
T H E M E S
4.5 m COMMUNITY ROAD Extended living room Pollution Mediators Aesthetics Shade Preferable Biodiversity
28
0% 20% 50% 10% 20%
12 m LEVEL space
F O R
4
O F
NEIGHBORHOOD Congregation
Pollution Mediators Aesthetics Shade Preferable Biodiversity
10% 40% 20% 10% 10%
T H E
S T R E E T S
F O U N D
T H E
S I T E
45 m BRT ROUTE City Identity
24 m INTERNAL ROAD Regulated corridor
Pollution Mediators Aesthetics Shade Preferable Biodiversity
I N
40% 20% 20% 10% 10%
Pollution Mediators 40% Aesthetics 45% Shade 5% Preferable 5% Biodiversity 5%
to choose for Urban greening St ra tegy fo r Da Calculator m a ge co nt rospecies l
How to use the Calculator 1. Choosing the theme for the Street based upon the purpose of the street for eg: 4.5 m COMMUNITY LEVEL ROAD - Extended living room
Preferable Biodiversity Fast growing
Hardy
Brittle branches
Less Butresses
Deep root system
Encouraging Biodiversity
8 8 8 6 8 8 6 6 6 8 8 8 8 6 4 4 8 2 2 2 8 8 8 6 0 6 8
8 10 10 5 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
5 10 10 5 5 10 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 10 10 5 5 10 10 5 10 10 5 5 5
10 8 2 4 10 8 10 6 10 8 10 8 8 10 10 10 10 2 6 8 8 6 8 8 10 6 10
10 10 5 9 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 8 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 8 10 8 8 10 10 10
1 6 2 2 1 2 2 6 2 4 2 2 2 2 0 8 4
Score
57 74 61 49 63 70 66 67 68 69 63 64 63 58 58 70 70 62 68 70 73 63 63 64 58 61 69
10
4 6 4 0 0 1 4 4 6
C A L C U L A T I O N
%
2. Selecting the respective characteristic of the trees which suffices the activity/purpose of the street highly. for eg: The street requires to be shaded, thus allocating maximum or higher weightage to the head SHADE Shade -50% , and the rest of them accordingly Pollution Mediators - 0%, Aesthetics - 20%, Preferable - 10%, Biodiversity - 20% 3. Using the above allocated % get the score for all the mentioned trees in the list 50%Shade (Density + Form + Upright) + 20% Aesthetics (Form, Upright + Seasonal Variation) + 10% Preferable (Hardy + Weak branches + Less Buttresses + Deep root system) + 20% Biodiversity Choose the trees with high score from the result.
F O R
E A C H
H E A D
Aesthetics Shade & Buffer
Preferable
Pollution Mediators Species
a longofolia scholaris egia pota a catappa mea hta indica a indica grandis rum pterocarpum equisetifolia obium dulce us globulus undra riculifornis nosperma bbeck ghalensis us indica a campanulata variegata var sissoo darach excelsa a parviflora ea integrifolia nia hortensis
Carbon Sequestration efficiency
2 1 2 2 4 2 4 5 10 4 8 6 8 10 3 4 2 1 4 2 2 2 2 4 4 4 2
Biodiversity
Evergreen
Density (foliage density)
Form (broad or narrow)
Upright (provides clearance)
Seasonal Variation
Fast growing
8 8 6 8 4 8 8 6 4 8 8 6 8 6 6 2 2 10 8 8 4 6 2 8 0 0 8
4 8 6 8 4 6 8 8 6 8 2 6 4 0 8 6 6 10 10 6 10 8 8 6 6 6 6
2 8 8 6 6 6 8 8 8 8 2 6 3 0 4 4 8 10 10 8 10 8 8 6 8 8 6
10 8 6 2 8 8 6 8 8 6 8 8 8 8 4 8 8 2 8 8 8 8 8 8 6 8 8
0 4 8 2 6 6 2 2 2 4 2 2 4 2 6 8 6 2 4 6 6 4 4 2 6 6 4
8 8 8 6 8 8 6 6 6 8 8 8 8 6 4 4 8 2 2 2 8 8 8 6 0 6 8
A%
B%
C%
Hardy
Brittle branches
Less Butresses
Deep root system
Encouraging Biodiversity
8 10 10 5 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
5 10 10 5 5 10 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 10 10 5 5 10 10 5 10 10 5 5 5
10 8 2 4 10 8 10 6 10 8 10 8 8 10 10 10 10 2 6 8 8 6 8 8 10 6 10
10 10 5 9 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 8 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 8 10 8 8 10 10 10
1 6 2 2 1 2 2 6 2 4 2 2 2 2 0 8 4
D%
A % + B % + C % + D % + E % = 100
E%
10
4 6 4 0 0 1 4 4 6
29
Score
57 74 61 49 63 70 66 67 68 69 63 64 63 58 58 70 70 62 68 70 73 63 63 64 58 61 69
03
Landscape Detail Design
R u r b a n
l aSt n ra d te s cgya pfoer Da f oma r ge w ecoe nt k ro e nl d
The project was to design Landscape for a given 31 unit weekend house township. The design included landscaping and paving for the driveways and footpaths along with two large Common Open Place (approx. 2000 sqmts each) and the landscape design for a club house. The COPs were divided as formal and informal places for events which were made in the order of their appearance. The COP 1 appears immediately as one enters the Housing premise and thus was designed with a formal space in mind with a larger open lawn area to with-hold the events and small functions and also with an enclosed space to hold meetings and events indoors. The other COP is designed with more informal set of seatings and connections for all kinds of users. It includes a jogging track, shaded plaza and a volleyball court to encourage community relations along with leisure activities. After the Master planning and schematic design for the parks, the design was further worked out for the COP 2. The detailed design was done particularly for the Water-feature, Bench and a Mound.
h o u s e
COP 2 Linear strip of garden parallel to Jogger’s track adjoining the property line
COP 2 The linear park across the volleyball court, Another entry to the park
COP 2 The plaza in the center integrates spaces of diverse spatial quality from a splash pool to shaded seating spaces
30 Plan, COP 2
COP 2
COP 1
Main Entrance
Master-Plan
31
COP 1 The Entrance plaza overlooking the trail to meditation platforms and the entry to Multi-purpose lawn area
Plan, 32 COP 1
COP 1 The exterior of the COP 1 from the secondary entrance from the meditation garden
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
COP 1 Aerial view of the Multipurpose area overlooking the entrance
COP 1 -Overview
COP 1 Entry to the Club house
33
34
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
Plaza Bench Details
Central Plaza, during the night
Central Plaza, Shaded seating areas in the afternoon sun
35
36
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
Water feature Details
37
The water-feature is an integrated part of the Plaza-design. The mound in the center of the COP acts as a backdrop to the waterfeature in the front which has a splash pool, foaming jet play area and a seating area. The supply tank of the water-feature is placed 38
on a very gradual slope of the mound with a manhole cover that allows storage of 4” of soil to facilitate the growth of lawn grass on top it to allow it to hide under the mound. The supply tank carries filter and pump to suffice the need of the water-feature
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
Water-feature Details
39
04 m e n d i n g t h e g a p
Landscape Conservation for the island of Aliabet
BEFORE Degraded edge
Encrusted salt
AFTER
Coastal management is one of the most important parameter of urban planning for a resilient future. Especially in today’s time when the planet is subjected to high risks due to the extreme changes the natural processes are undergoing, it becomes mandatory to look at the existing ecosystem services and it’s impact in a larger spectrum.
40
The island of Aliabet is an example of one such change of process. The island is a part of the river Narmada’s estuary which has formed connections with the mainland due to the depositions afflicted by the anthropogenic activities like the construction of the Sardar Sarovar Dam. Once an ecologically rich and diverse chunk of land, Aliabet was a home to bountiful wetland birds
Filled up creeks Vegetated creeks
Salt marsh
Halophytes
Nesting grounds and animals. Overlooked social cost of the dam has left Aliabet to become a desert and a saline wasteland. This research study is an attempt to understand the drivers and services of Aliabet in order to provide strategies to revive and regain its position in the larger ecological chain.
High
Medium
Low
Salinity tolerant species
41
Aravali protocontinental plate a river Singhbhum protocontinental plate
d Narma
Dharwar protocontinental plate
The Narmad rift valley was a result of the upliftment between the Protocontinental plates of Aravali, Dharwar and the Singhbhum fracturing along the Precambrian patterns. Image .
b Cam ift ay R
Kachchh Rift valley
Ravines
Younger tidal flats
da Rift
a Narm valley
Older Tidal flats
State of Gujarat, Alia-bet highlighted with the Rift valley system at the Gulf of Khambhat, which is a part of an active estuarine area and thus undergoes regular changes in terms of deposition and shifting. Image .
The configuration of the Landforms like the Older tidal flats, younger tidal flats and Ravines respective in the mouth of the river Narmada. Image .
Bharuch
Bhadbhut
Gulf of khambhat
Aliabet 238 sqkm2
Ankleshwar
Scale nearb
Narmada river
Lower Narmada trail of Sardar sarovar dam to the Gulf of Khambhat. Narmada River, west of Bhadbhut, enters in t These distributaries circle Aliabet, and merges in the Gulf of Khambhat. Along with the two banks of the waterway, mudflat Image .
42
Understanding St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt rofluvial l dynamics of Aliabet
Image . Sardar sarovar dam
Image .
has affected the river channel drastically
Bedaghat, source of river Narmada
Sardar sarovar dam
of the population in towns and villages by
the delta region, part into two dis-tributaries. ts and swamps are framed.
Image .
Local fishing tribal community by the banks
Artificially dammed Narmada, loss of more than 10,000 hectares forests resulted in to the deposition of silts on the beds, heading into blocking the entire rift valley. The dam also resulted in thinning out the river channel which impacted its adjoining river ecology and biodiversity. The flow-rate of the river dropped drastically and it affected the overall level of the water which in turn raised the hidden islands and shoals in the estuary.
Ahmedabad
Map . Ahmedabad, Area : 452
The stable banks of Narmada due to forests are now devoid of its steady agents, which opens them now to destruction through floods. Minus the forests this river is facing raging torrents in the rains and dried up water courses in the summer. One of the shoals has resulted in to a considerably huge island named Aliabet which conserves a diverse and rich ecosystem of the Estuary.
Aliabet
sqkm2
Map . Aliabet, Area : 238 sqkm2
43
01. Before Sardar Sarovar Dam, Aliabet was an island and was 04. After the floods, the water recedes back to the sea surrounded by river water channels on all the sides leaving behind loads of sediment, which is then left for the river water to clean up during ebb.
02. Aliabet was part of an active and perenial estuary where the 05. River water has now lost the pressure to flush out the water was a part of a varying salinity throughout the year sediments in to the sea leading to the sediment deposition
03. During Floods and high tides the sea water currents travels 06. More deposition leads to the formation of Sand bars North and North-Eastern part of the Gulf of Khambhat and Shoals, also many submerged sediments emerges in the absence of adequate flushing
44
Understanding St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt rofluvial l dynamics of Aliabet
07. The process leads to the shifting of the Mudflat towards the mainland to an extend that it completely fills up the river water channel on the other side of the island. Forming a landwise connection to the island.
The island is going to observe more deposition in the near future in the southern most part. Seaward growth of aliabet indicates tint possibly the rate of deposition of sediments by river is greater than the rate of removal by sea waves and currents which is due to the narrow expense of gulf of Khambhat. During floods Narmada brings huge load of sediments and deposits on the bank of Aliabet in the form of a thin veneer every year. This may also contributes to the seawards extension of foreset beds. The older tributary area is not going to face any more erosion and will form a stable part of the main land
08. The East-West aligned island faces saline water to a larger extent which shifts the ecological plane and leaves the island devoid of its natural vegetation
The island is facing high level of salinity ingression due to extremely low flushing from the river water which is resulting into the declination of the local grass ”Aal” and Wetland ecosystem The anthropogenic pressure has intervened in the fluvial processes leading to the decrease in brackish water to quiet a large extend.
09. The present condition may increase the deposition of the island towards the sea
45
2 0 11 1
19 7
2 00 4
Maps generated from the remote sensing tool indicates heavy loss of habitats over the period of years. The 1974 map indicates the spread of mangroves on the island on a large scale. Over the period of years mangroves disappear drastically and salt pan and salt marsh which were absent before starts appearing. One of the reason for such affliction is also due to the communities that uses mangroves for wood fire. Also the increase in salt pans have drastically changed the terrain. Salinity ingression in the land has changed the ecology distinctly.
Map . 1974
Map . 2001
Salt Marsh
Mudflats
Mangrove
Salt Pan
Scrubland
22.4 % Mudflats 0.5 % Mangroves
Creeks
27.1 % Salt Marsh 7 % Depression 20 % Salt pan 1.2 % Settlement Map . 2011
Mudflat Mangroves Scrub Shoals
46
Settlement
18.8 % Scrubland
Salt Marsh Salt Pan Creek Depression
2.4 % Creeks Graph . Present
configuration of land use , 2019
Depression
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
Site Analysis
2m 4m 6m 8m Map . Neap Tides
0
2.5
5
10 km
The average of the regular tides that occurs everyday is estimated 1-1.2m
Map .
Contour map
0
2.5
5
10
Most part of aliabet undergoes submersion during floods. The average elevation of the land is 5m and the Highest Amplitude tide (H.H.T) reaches till 6m. The North-eastern part of the land where the “Jat Maldharis” (Animal Herders) reside and few areas in the centre along with the constructed embankments remains dry during H.H.T
0 2.5 5 10 km Map . Spring Tides The average of periodical tides that occurs twice a month is estimated between 3.5-4 m
Map . High high tides
0
2.5
5
10 km
The highest amplitude of tide 6m during flooding of the sea
Map . Land-use
Mud flat Salt Marsh Scrubland
0
Mangroves Depression Ponds
2.5
5
10
Settlements Salt pan Connection
47
Central plains of Aliabet after monsoon
Image .
Vegetated Mudflats after monsoon
Dominant species of flora & fauna in Aliabet
Image .
Common crane
Reef Haron
White Egret
Image .
Salt pans after monsoon
Macrobrachium Sesuvium rosenbergi portulacastrum
Tenualosa ilisha
48
Avicennia marina
Intertida zone
Pond grey heron
Black headed gull
Grey Shrike
Red necked Flamingo
Brown pelican
Painted Stork
Estimated number of Buffalos left in Aliabet are around 1500
Image .
Porteresia coarctata
Settlements in the vast plains of Aliabet
White necked Kingfisher
Image .
De
Portable water boug nearby towns
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
Threats and Concern
Diminishing of the brackish water-zone
Narmada estuary is famous for the Hilsa fish that breeds in the ocean water but travels back to the brackish water for the rest of year. Sedimentation and Salinity ingress has reduced the rare mix of various saline
levels and temperature of the brackish water to a larger extent, damaging its dependent ecology like the Mangroves and the “Aal grass”. Reduction in the number of Hilsa fish and Aal grass have also rendered the number of Wetland birds very less.
Reduction in the Residentary and Migratory birds
Suaeda nudiflora
al
Land affected due to salt
Older aluvial plain
egraded coastlines of Alia-bet
ght from s
Temporary huts made from hay stacks and wooden posts.
Various migratory birds from China, Siberia and Russia are said to visit Gulf of Khambhat and Alia Bet. Around 20,000 flamingos, thousands of waterfowls can be seen in the salt- pans of Aliabet from October to March. The only residing community the “Jat maldharis”(Animal herders) who thrive on
there Camels, buffalos and goats depend on the local vegetation. Camels have now adapted to survive on both, dry land and in the sea. They swim in seawater and feed on saline plants and mangroves. Presently there are about 600-650 camels.
49
01
Replenishing mangroves using salt-tolerant species
02
Preventing Salinity ingress
Prevention of Coastal Erosion by providing a natural surge Barrier
Filtration of sediments at both the ends of land and water
Nursing grounds for local and migratory fishes and crustaceans
By introducing barriers at the strategic locations leads to conservation of water and prevention of sea-water to flood and degrade the resources further.
U n d e r s t a n d i n g S a l i n i t y g r a St d arat te i ogy n fo r D
Figure . Salinity - High tide
Figure . Salinity - Spring tide
Figure . Salinity - High tide - After construction of
Figure . Salinity - Spring tide - After construction of
Embankments
Embankments
Less Moderate Extemely
Figure . Areas under embankment : Salinity level - Less
50
Figure . Areas under embankment : Salinity level -
Extremely low to moderate
for Damage Control St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt roStrategy l
03
04
Fresh water conservation
Cultivating fodder for the grazing animals
BRACKISH
+
SALT
FRESH
Conservation of fresh water can help re-generate the lost habitats of varying salinity and biodiversity.
Cultivation of fodder strengthens the only residing tribal community and their livestock, increasing the ownership and repsonsibility towards the degrading island more.
a m a ge w ico t hntro r e sl p e c t t o E m b a n k m e n t s
Figure . Salinity - Neap tide
Figure . Summer catchment area Figure . Salinity - Neap tide - After construction of
Embankments
Figure . Winter catchment area
Figure . Areas under embankment : Salinity level -
Extremely low to null
Figure . Monsoon catchment area
51
0
2.5 5
10 km Map . 02 Spring tides
Map . 01 Existing Salinity gradation
More than 90% of the area are subjected to salinity
Less Moderate Extemely
Extend of the spring tides
Map . 05 High tides
Map . 06 High tides after embankments
Extent of the high tides floods. By flooding the existing rainwater pools of the high tides helps generating a brackish water zone in the conserved rain-water area.
Introducing a second level of embankment higher then the highest amplitude of tides.
52
for Damage Control St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt roStrategy l
Map . 03 Spring tides after embankments
Map . 04 Spring tides Rainwater pools
Creating embankments above the height of the spring tides at strategic intervals to prevent the saline water from flooding the land.
The rain-water can be then conserved in the areas of depressions which were earlier flooded by the sea water.
0
2.5 5
10 km
Map . 07 High tides - Rain water pools
Map . 08 Achieved Salinity gradation after 3-4 seasons
Water conserved after monsoon in the areas covered under the second level of embankments can be purely rain-water which percolates to improve the salinity of the land.
Achieved state of salinity after embankments helps promote native vegetation and inhabit local biodiversity
Less Moderate Extemely
53
SALT FRESH BRACKISH
water - After monsoon
0
2.5
5
10 km
Stages of Development
Map . Retained
Map . 01 Replenishing Mangroves followed by salt marsh
54
Map . 02 Freshwater and Brackish water habitats
and Planting Palette St ra tegy fo r Da m a geDevelopment co nt roStages l
Planting palette for the different saline habitats SALINE
Sesuvium portulacastrum
Leptochloa fusca
Salsola iberica
Haloxylon Paspalum salicornicum vaginatum
Salsola iberica
Paspalum vaginatum
BRACKISH
Atriplex halimus
Salicornia brachiata
Salvadora persica
Suaeda nudiflora
Aeluropus lagopoides
Juncus effusus
Cressa cretica
Terminalia arjuna
Heleochloa Cyperus setulosa conglomeratus
Limonium stocksii
Fimbristylis tenera
Typha angustata
Echinocloa colonum
Tradescantia Heliotropium supinum axillaries
Salvadora persica
Sporobolus Halopyrum Porteresia maderaspatanus mucronatum coarctata
Map . 03 Grasslands preceded by wetland habitats
FRESH
Tamarindus Cyperus iria indica
Syzygium cumin
Map . 04 Woodlands
55
Map . 05
Succession of Woodlands to Dense forests and addition of the farmlands to cultivate the fodder.
Brown pelican
Cuttlefish
Hilsa ilisha
Reef Haron
Painted Stork
Black headed gull
Indian skimmer
Bar-tailed godwit
Red naped ibis
Glossy ibis
Macrobrachium rosenbergi
Common Sandpiper
Red necked Flamingo
Saru crane
Little egret
Black necked stork
Percolation
After 20 - 30 YEARS
56
White necked Kingfisher
High marsh Low marsh Brackish- Marsh land Mangrove Swamps Intertidal flat
Common crane
Pond grey heron
Black hair-crested drongo
Red-wattled lapwing
Grey Shrike
Crested lark
Percolation Fresh water wetland
Up
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
Conceptual Masterplan
Platform Overflow drain E-concrete Boulders packed with sand
Figure .
Impenetrable concrete foundation mattress
Embankment section
Mangrove swamps Salt Marsh Brackish wetlands Fresh water ponds Grasslands Woodland Dense forest Farming Embankments
Embankment wall after 1-2 monsoon season Figure .
E-concrete is an eco-friendly material that allows the growth of oysters and corals on its surface along with moss and algae. This promotes the growth of small fishes and shrimps sheltering around it.
Spotted owlet
Greater flamback
Black kite
Dense forest pland forest/ Terrestrial bird habitat
Indian robin
Malabar Trogon
Purple sunbird
Common crane
Little egret
Shikara
Pond grey heron
River tern
Coppersmith barbet
European roller
Greater coucal
Red naped ibis
Kharai camel
Percolation
Common myna
Indian peafowl
Bllue hair-crested drongo Merops orientalis
Anthus campestris
Jungle babbler
Percolation
Freshwater ponds High marsh Fresh-water Wetland
Settlements Dry deciduous forests
Farming
57
After the construction of embankments
Embankments as platforms for the tourist
Water-retaining ponds during the winter
E-concrete
Wetland habitats generated for the birds and residentary grazers after the construction of embankments Figure .
58
St ra tegy fo r Da m a ge co nt ro l
SUMMER
Aliabet Revived
MONSOON Embankment E-concrete
Catchment ponds
Figure .
Conservation pools close to the ‘Animal herder’ community
59
05 i m p o r t a n c e o f t r e e s Miscellaneous
60
61
05
62
Miscellaneous
D o c u m e n tat i o n o f t r e e s & b i o d i v e r s i t y
63
Thank you
72