TWILIGHT GROVES: SENIOR LIVING COMMUNITY A THESIS REPORT Submitted by
SHUBANGI SURYANARAYANAN In partial fulfillment for the award of the degree of
BACHELOR OF ARCHITECTURE
MEASI Academy of Architecture 87 Peter’s Road, Royapettah, Chennai 600014
ANNA UNIVERSITY : CHENNAI 600025 May 2021
ANNA UNIVERSITY : CHENNAI 600025 BONAFIDE CERTIFICATE Certified that this thesis report on “Twilight Groves: Senior Living Community“ is the bonafide work of “Shubangi Suryanarayanan“ who carried out the thesis work under my supervision.
SIGNATURE
SIGNATURE
Ar. K.V. Shivakumar, M.Arch
Prof. N. Altaf Ahmed Director MEASI Academy of Architecture
Assistant Professor MEASI Academy of Architecture
87 Peter’s Rd. Royapettah Chennai 600014
87 Peter’s Rd. Royapettah
SIGNATURE EXTERNAL EXAMINER
i
SUPERVISOR
Chennai 600014
SIGNATURE EXTERNAL EXAMINER
DECLARATION I declare that this thesis titled “Twilight Groves: Senior Living Community” is bonafide work done by me, under the supervision of Ar. K.V. SHIVAKUMAR at MEASI Academy of Architecture, Chennai during the period December 2020 – May 2021. I further declare that the work reported herein does not form part of any other thesis based on which a degree or award was conferred on any earlier occasion.
Chennai Date: 23.07.2021
Student’s signature SHUBANGI SURYANARAYANAN
ii
Acknowledgements The satisfaction that accompanies the successful completion of any task would be incomplete without the mention of the people who have made it possible. It is my great privilege to express my gratitude and respect to all those who have guided and inspired me during the course of this thesis project. First and foremost, I express my sincere gratitude to the Director of MEASI Academy of Architecture, Prof. N. ALTAF AHMED, B.Arch., F.I.I.A., M.R.S.H., F.A.E.P., for providing the necessary facilities for the completion of my thesis project. I would like to express my gratitude to the Dean of the institution Dr. A.N.SACHITHANANTHAN, B.Arch., MT, PhD, F.I.T.P, F.I.I.A Cert. in Housing (London), for being a constant source of support, encouragements, and guidance through my years of undergraduate study that has culminated in this Thesis. My special thanks to the Head of the Department, Prof. S.KESAVALU (B.E (Hons), M.Sc.M.I.ECert. in C.A.P & D. for his valued structural assistance, inspiration & guidance during the progress of this project. I also express sincere thanks to my Internal Review Panel, Prof. S. RAVI, for his encouragement and guidance. I am also thankful to Ar. KALPANA BALAJI, for her suggestions and advice given during the various stages of my thesis review sessions. I wish to express my sincere appreciation to my supervisor, Ar. K.V. SHIVAKUMAR, who convincingly guided and encouraged me to be professional and do the right thing even when the road got tough. Without his persistent help, the goal of this project would not have been realised. Finally, I would like to thank Mr. Parameshwaran from Coimbatore who helped me formulate my study and Mr. Aravamudhan from Serene Adinath who showed me the practical functioning of senior homes along with his team. My gratitude to Ar. Nirupama Suresh from Natraj and Venkat Associates, for her thoughtful insights during my site study.
iii
I wish to dedicate this work to my grandparents who were my inspiration to take up this project, for they have given me many happy moments to look back to as we grew older together. I would also like to acknowledge the support and great love of my family and friends. They kept me going on and this thesis would not have been possible without their input.
iv
Abstract More often than not retirement communities are thought to be analogous to old age institutions. This makes a few people sceptical when it comes to moving into such facilities even when they are in dire need of it. Now, with a rising market for such communities, this thesis started with a quest to create a well-balanced old age in such places. Throughout the project, in-depth literature reviews and case studies were compiled to derive a set of design considerations for the elderly. Additionally a survey conducted for people who live here and those who will in the near future gave an understanding on the expectations from such facilities and their aspirations. With these in mind, a holistic approach was adopted in designing ‘Twilight Groves: Senior Living Community’. Primary studies showed that the kinds of communities that exist in India are either gated communities for the aged or intensive specialised facilities treating the semi-ambulatory. This design takes inspiration from the CCRC (Continuing Care Retirement Communities) model that caters to the needs of a wide age group of people in their 60s and beyond. The aim was to create a transitional living unit which accommodates both assisted living and independent living within the same campus. Three guiding principles that helped shape this proposal were: (i) Sense of homeliness (ii) Sense of independence (iii) Sense of community. Contrary to the earlier need for a ‘hotel-like treatment’ in such facilities, the present generation of the 60+ population are more active and view retired life as means to explore themselves. The idea of community gardening proposed in this campus makes recreational ‘family’ time productive and overall, self-sustaining. While doing so, this thesis project also infuses community spaces with their dwelling units in an attempt to recreate their childhood backyard experience.
v
1
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Introduction
2
3
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Introduction
4
5
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Literature Study
6
7
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Literature Study
8
9
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Literature Study
10
11
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Literature Study
12
13
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Literature Study
14
15
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Literature Study
16
17
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Literature Study
18
19
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Case Study
20
21
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Case Study
22
23
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Case Study
24
25
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Case Study
26
27
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Case Study
28
29
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Case Study
30
31
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Analysis
32
33
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Site Study
34
35
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Site Study
36
37
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Site Study
38
39
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Concept Development
40
41
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Concept Development
42
43
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Master Plan | 44
45
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Master Plan | 46
47
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Sector Cluster | 48
49
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Sector Cluster | 50
51
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Inner Circle Cluster | 52
53
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Inner Circle Cluster | 54
55
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Plotted Development | 56
57
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Plotted Development | 58
59
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Plotted Development | 60
61
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Assisted Living | 62
63
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Respite Care and Guest Accommodation | 64
65
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Administration and Health Care | 66
67
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Community Kitchen | 68
69
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Design
Super Market | 70
Design Features
71
72
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Conclusion
Conclusion
Bibliography • CBRE. “Senior Housing Market Insight Q3 | 2019.” Senior Living, 2019, cbre.com/ nationalseniorhousing. • CommonFloor.com. “What Are Different Types of Retirement Homes in India?” www.Commonfloor.Com, 31 July 2013, www.commonfloor.com/guide/whatare-different-types-of-retirement-homes-in-india-27457. • D’Souza, Melanie. “Reimagining Aging through Campus Communities.” Issuu, 27 May 2017, issuu.com/melaniedsouza/docs/reimagining_aging. • Eastman, Perkins. Building Type Basics for Senior Living. 2nd ed., Wiley, 2013. • “Estimation of Water Requirement for Drinking and Domestic Use.” National Building Code of India, 2016th ed., vol. 1, New Delhi, Bureau of Indian Standards, 2016, p. Section 3, www.cgwa-noc.gov.in/LandingPage/Guidlines/ NBC2016WatRequirement.pdf. • Footohi, Azita. “Azita Footohi - Senior Comprehensive Thesis Project.” Issuu, 19 June 2020, issuu.com/azitafootohi/docs/footohi_natural_healing_center. • Gibberd, Frederick. Town Design by Frederick Gibberd. 6th ed., Great Britain, The Architectural Press, 1959, 1977. • Gupta, Ankur. “Top Active Senior Living Trends In India.” Makaan, 20 Mar. 2017, www.makaan.com/iq/news-views/top-active-senior-living-trends-in-india. • International WELL Building Institute. www.wellcertified.com/certification/v2. Accessed 11 Jan. 2021. • JLL. “Senior Living Sector in India.” Jones Lang LaSalle Property Consultants (India) Pvt Ltd, 2015, www.jll.co.in. • “List of Old Age Homes in India.” SeniorIndian.Com, www.seniorindian.com/ old_age_homes_list.htm. Accessed 9 Dec. 2020. • “Market for ‘Senior Citizen Homes’ Picking up in India.” Commonfloor.Com, www.commonfloor.com/guide/market-for-senior-citizen-homes-picking-up73
in-india-25010. Accessed 9 Dec. 2020. • Neufert, Ernst Peter Neufert. Architects’ Data: 3rd (Third) Edition. Wiley, John & Sons, Incorporated, 2003. • Raman, Selvakumar, and Gangadhara K. “Vegetable Varieties for Urban Home Garden.” Breeding of Nutra Rich Varieties/Hybrids in Temperate Root Crops, 2018. ResearchGate, www.researchgate.net/publication/344322605_Vegetable_Varieties_for_Urban_Home_garden. • Ramanujam, Nivethaa. “Making Chennai Green Again.” The Hindu, 13 Apr. 2017, www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/energy-and-environment/green-drive-in-chennai/article17987685.ece. • Sugandhi, Prachi. “Senior Living.” Issuu, 5 May 2016, issuu.com/prachisug/docs/prachi_sugandhi_senior_living.
74
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Biblioraphy
• Swastik Foundation. “Project Proposal for Old Age Home.” Swastik Foundation, 2016, swastikfoundationoldagehome.org.
75
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Annexure
76
77
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Annexure
78
79
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Annexure
80
81
Twilight Groves : Senior Living Community | Annexure
82