5 FEATURE
OPINION
CLAUDINE GAY RESIGNATION
THE VOL. 59, NO. 5
9 CENTERSPREAD
DHTH: LANTERNS
CIVIC ENGAGEMENT
MISSION SAN JOSE HIGH SCHOOL
By the NumbeRs: Digital standardized testing
“I prefer digital testing because it is easier to prevent cheating, and digital testing can also save paper that can be used for other things such as worksheets." — Evan Cai, 10
By Anandita Devata, Shuhan Jin, Michael Qu & Lucas Zhang Beginning in spring 2024, College Board will switch all SAT assessments from paper-and-pencil to a digital format, following a larger trend of an increasing online presence in education. From January 13 to January 17, the Smoke Signal conducted a schoolwide student survey with 138 responses and interviewed students and faculty to gain insight into the transition from paper to digital testing and its benefits and shortcomings.
background When the coronavirus pandemic began in 2019, numerous fields, including education, started to switch to a predominantly online setting. After a couple of years of meeting through platforms like Zoom and Google Meet, many teachers and students noticed the flexibility of conducting tests online and have integrated digital methods into their curriculum despite the return to in-person school. According to nation-wide surveys conducted by Bay View Analytics in 2018 and 2022, 67% of instructors reported requiring students to use an online homework system in 2022, a increase compared to 37% in 2018. Following nearly two years of distance learning due to the coronavirus pandemic, according to Tokyo Academics, College Board issued a pilot project in which the organization administered the digital SAT to a select group of students in exchange for gift cards starting in 2021. In January 2022, the organization announced that the SAT and PSAT would officially switch to a new digital format soon. The first wave began in 2023, with the SAT administered digitally to international students in the spring and the PSAT transitioning to an online format globally in the fall. Starting from 2024, all SAT tests, including those in the US, will
Opposition & Support The student body is divided on the general shift to digital testing, with a majority of 50.7% of the surveyed students preferring written tests while 18.1% prefer digital tests and 31.2% have no preference. “I prefer to stick to physical tests because digitally, there are always those errors that can happen — the internet can cut out and Chromebooks can shut down,” Sophomore Daojing Lin said. The student body’s opinions on the SAT align with the general preference for paper exams. 44.9%% of students would rather take the physical SAT while 26.1%% of students prefer the digital version. Many students pointed out a concern with looking at a screen for two hours, stating that the strain made it more difficult to pay attention. "Digital testing makes it easier to navigate long passages and makes my neck hurt less from looking down, but paper testing is easier on the eyes," Senior Alyssa Chen said. Despite the general unpopularity of the digital SAT, certain aspects of the change were well-received, with 78.3% of students believing the shortened passages in the reading and writing section would improve their test-taking ability. Additionally, 53.6% of students found that the provided online calculator would improve their overall performance. “The graphing calculator they give you can help solve almost everything in the math section and is easy to use,” Junior Ester “I would [support a switch to digital standardLeng ized tests] because ... a good high school is said. going to prepare you to be successful at the college you want to go to. ... I believe that in most situations, at least in core classes, we can say that the digital classroom is something that everyone should be accustomed to and acquainted with.” — Social Sciences Teacher Keith Kottenbach
"I took the PSAT digitally and the SAT on paper. I feel like it was easier for me to concentrate [on the SAT]. When I'm reading on paper, I'm a lot more used to it than reading things on a screen. For the PSAT, I feel like it was a lot quicker to pick answers and definiteily more fast-paced than the paper test." — Aliana Wang, 10
Paper Vs. Digital Tests In regards to the SAT, the digital version is a shorter assessment than the written one, only taking around two hours instead of three, and has fewer questions as well. The Reading section and the Writing and Language section have been combined, and the Math section no longer differentiates between no calculator and calculator parts since the testing window provides an online graphing calculator throughout the section. The Reading and Writing and Math sections have two modules each, and both modules for each subject include a mix of the same types of questions. One of the most controversial changes in the digital SAT is its adaptive nature. According to a statement from College Board, students’ answers to certain problems in the first module for a subject will determine the types of questions that will appear in the following module. “The paper test is probably more accurate in assessing all takers overall since everyone gets the same set of questions. With [the] digital [test], it didn’t seem like people earned their score, but [it felt] more like they were lucky that they got easier questions overall,” Leng said. In a broader sense, paper and digital tests have always had significant differences, not just in test organization. Switching to online tests affects question variety, students’ study habits, and overall student performance. In a 2015-16 study conducted by American Institutes for Research (AIR), AIR Researchers James Cowan and Ben Backes analyzed scores of Massachusetts students throughout the state during the first two years of switching to online testing. In these two years, about half of Massachusetts students took the state test Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) online, while the other half took the paper version. Cowan and Backes found that even with the same test content and environment, students taking the assessment digitally scored significantly lower than their peers who took the same test on paper. “The students who took the test online performed as if they’d had five fewer months of academic preparation in math and 11 fewer months of preparation in English,” an AIR researcher said. While it is difficult to pinpoint the exact reason for the results, Cowan and Backes believe the primary cause is due to the difficult transition into computer-based testing, as many students and teachers were more accustomed to traditional paper tests.
Motivation for the change According to an announcement from College Board, the results of its pilot digital SAT program showed that 80% of the participants were less stressed when they were taking the digital test compared to when they took the paper-and-pencil SAT. All educators involved in the program also reported a positive experience with the new test format. The results of College Board’s pilot program showed that the new version of the test is easier for educators to administer and is more accessible to a wider range of students due to the incorporation of accommodations like a screen reader and assistive technology software. Moreover, according to a Forbes article, SAT tutors from Ivy Tutors Network who have analyzed the digital exam stated that the questions on the new version of the test more accurately reflect texts and scenarios that students will encounter in college, making the digital assessment a better indicator of student performance in higher education. According to College Board, the adaptive nature of the digital test will make the PSAT and SAT more secure by adding variety in the questions that students get on their assessments, significantly lowering the chances of students cheating on the test. Also, on the traditional exam, if one test was compromised, College Board could have to cancel scores for an entire cluster of students, which is something that the digital test’s added layer of security will help prevent. College Board states that the increased relevance in the test content and the increased security provided by the adaptive nature of the new test are some of their primary motivations behind the SAT format switch. “I think the overall technological movement has prompted [College Board] to hop on the trend and make its process more efficient,” Senior Danielle Rayne Fermin said. Following the trial run, College Board began administering digital versions of the SAT and PSAT assessments internationally starting in March 2023. The organization then started changing its tests to be digital within the US as well, beginning with the PSAT 8/9 for eighth and ninth graders and the PSAT/ NMSQT in the fall of 2023 and leading up to the SAT in Spring 2024.
how much of an increase in digital which version of the sat do you prefer? testing have you seen in your classes 19.6% over the past 26.1% few years? 5.8% 44.9%
47.8% 26.8%
None Small amount
www.thesmokesignal.org
January 26, 2024
41717 PALM AVENUE, FREMONT, CA 94539
“I don’t think [the digital SAT is] equitable for the vast majority of the country. The kids in our district have a pretty good access to laptop and WiFi, but not every place has that.” — AP Coordinator Pete Vaz
THIS MONTH
GUIDE TO LOCAL MUSEUMS
SMOKE SIGNAL
“Learning and thinking actually has to do with the whole body ... When it comes to writing on paper, versus typing on it on a keyboard, it’s a different modality of engaging with the material.” — English Teacher Brian Rath
ONLINE
20
10-11 GRAPHICS
PERCY JACKSON AND THE OLYMPIANS
ORQUÍDEAS ALBUM REVIEW
Released weekly on Disney+, Percy Jackson and the Olympians is an eight-episode TV show based on Rick Riordan's novel series of the same name. Read the Smoke Signal's review of the show on our website.
Released on January 12, ORQUÍDEAS is the upcoming fourth album by Colombian-American singer-songwriter Kali Uchis. The album will feature artists such as Peso Pluma and JT. Check out the Smoke Signal's review online.
Moderate amount Significant amount
29%
Paper Digital
No preference
FOR MORE COVERAGE, VISIT www.THESMOKESIGNAL.ORG