The good and the bad: two book reviews

On the shelf

The good and the bad: two book reviews

À chacun son gout, as the French say: “To each his own,” or if you prefer, “There’s no accounting for taste.” Best to keep that thought in mind in this review.

Regarding fiction, my taste runs to welldeveloped characters, a plot line that keeps me flipping the pages, some overarching point to the story, a verbal stew with at least a dash of humor, and writing that demonstrates vigor and skill.

In “The Book Haters’ Book Club” (Park Row, 2022, 352 pages), Gretchen Anthony gives us all these elements, and more. Her story of Irma Bedford, coowner of the Over the Rain Bookshop in Minneapolis, her grown daughters Laney and Bree, her beloved and deceased best friend Elliot, and others offers an abundance of intrigue, humor, lots of chatter about books, and insights into the human personality.

For some reason unknown even to her daughters, Irma is selling the shop at a rockbottom price to a shady firm that intends to tear down the building and replace it with condominiums. Laney, who left Minneapolis years ago becoming the lover of a stock-car driver whom she later married — they now own a tire store together in California — has little interest at first in what happens to the shop, but Bree, who has worked since she was a girl, is devastated.

And so is the grieving Thom Winslow, life partner of Elliot, the man who had invested his time and treasure in the store along with Irma until his unexpected death. While Elliot still lived, Thom was deeply jealous of that relationship and of the time Elliot spent at the shop. As “The Book Haters’ Book Club” progresses, Thom, Bree and Laney join forces to save Over the Rainbow and unravel the mysteries Elliot left behind, secrets hidden away by Irma. Meanwhile, all of them, plus Irma, learn more about themselves as well, about the choices they’ve made in life, the mistakes they’ve made, and the value of family, true friendship and love.

Every few chapters, Elliot breaks up the narrative of this story, speaking from a place beyond the grave where he seems to spend a good deal of time drinking cocktails and conversing with another love of his life, Judy Garland. Elliot comments on the rest of the characters, offers information about his own life — “I was born to a mother so cold she wore a cashmere coat in Miami Beach” — and several times blows the rest of us kisses: “Mwah! Mwah! Mwah!”

For me, the part of “The Book Haters’ Book Club” that sparkled brightest was the repartee between sisters Laney and Bree, and their humor. Here, for example, is Laney’s description of another long day of dealing with the trials delivered by the bookshop. “The past few hours had left her drained, as if Pandora hadn’t just opened her box, but jumped out naked and high, hallucinating and screaming ‘RUN FOR YOUR LIVES!’”

If you want a good story, and if you’re a sucker for books about books as I am, then Gretchen Anthony’s “The Book Haters’ Book Club” is made for you. •••

That same week that I read Anthony’s novel I also plowed through “No Plan B” (Delacorte Press, 2022, 368 pages), the latest in the Jack Reacher series by Lee Child and his brother, Andrew Child. Inspired by a friend several years ago to give the Reacher series a try, I’ve read a good number of these novels. They’re what I think of as popcorn books, a tasty treat to munch on but not particularly memorable.

And memorable the Reacher books are not. They are formulaic, their plots as predictable as the sunrise. Ex-military policeman Reacher roams the United States, hitching rides or taking the bus, carrying only a toothbrush and cash, replacing his clothing with garb purchased from second-hand

stores, and living by his wits. Like an oldtime knight errant, he defends the weak and the helpless he meets on his travels against bad guys. He’s 6’5” tall and weighs 250 pounds, so pummeling many of his opponents rarely causes him to break a sweat. In “Plan B,” Reacher punched out so many thugs and crooks that I gave up keeping count, though I did wonder what his knuckles must look like after so many collisions with the skulls and jaws of his enemies. After a while, Jeff Minick Writer I also lost track of his reasons for tearing apart this spider web of criminals in “No Plan B.” Some of these villains operate a corrupt private prison system, while another man, a pyromaniac tracking down those he blames for his son’s death, enjoys killing his victims by spreading a napalm-like substance over their naked bodies and then lighting

them up.

I finished “Plan B,” but before I was even halfway through, the popcorn had grown stale. The characters, the plot, were all cardboard and no corn.

My Reacher-enthusiast friend once owned a T-shirt inscribed “What would Reacher do?” At this point, I admit I don’t really care. I imagine the Child brothers will keep pumping out books about Reacher’s exploits — they do make money — but I won’t be there to read them. As Jack Reacher says in the final line of “Plan B,” when he’s once again hitting the road, “It’s time for somewhere new.”

Agreed. (Jeff Minick reviews books and has written four of his own: two novels, “Amanda Bell” and “Dust On Their Wings,” and two works of nonfiction, “Learning As I Go” and “Movies Make the Man.” minick0301@gmail.com)

Martin, Zacharias book reading

Cynthia Newberry Martin and Lee Zacharias will be reading from their respective works at 3 p.m. Saturday, Nov. 19, at City Lights Bookstore in Sylva.

Zacharias will give us a sense of her latest novel, “What a Wonderful World This Could Be.”

Martin’s first novel, “Tidal Flats,” won the Gold Medal in Literary Fiction at the 2020 Independent Publisher Book Awards and the 14th Annual National Indie Excellence Award for Fiction. Martin’s second novel, “Love Like This,” will be published in April 2023. citylightsnc.com or 828.586.9499. the new book titles that the library has received. Particular attention will be paid to “under the radar” titles and authors, new releases and other books that the staff is excited about.

All are welcome and no registration is required. For more information on when the club will meet, please call the library at 828.586.2016.

This club is co-sponsored by the Friends of the Jackson County Public Library. The JCPL is a member of Fontana Regional Library (fontanalib.org).

Students search for aquatic life in the Oconaluftee River.

Scott Campbell/Casablanca Digital Media photo

Celebrating ‘Long Man’

Eastern Band Cherokees work together to care for their rivers

BY GREGORY D. SMITHERS CONTRIBUTING WRITER (This story was originally published in New Security Beat, the blog of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars’ Environmental Change and Security Program.)

On a crisp autumn morning, the Yellowhill Community Center in Western North Carolina buzzed with excitement as more than 120 Cherokees and their allies shared conversations, laughter and a hearty breakfast. They had descended upon the center in the Qualla Boundary on Oct. 19 to mark the second annual Honoring Long Man Day in the homelands of the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians.

Part river cleanup and part celebration, the day was an occasion to take climate action and reflect on the ongoing importance of rivers in Cherokee life.

After morning prayers and a few words of gratitude were offered by Principal Chief Richard Sneed, the purpose of the gathering was articulated by Juanita Wilson, an EBCI member and the driving force behind Honoring Long Man Day: the participants were present to take care of “Ganvhidv Asgaya (Long Man), the river, with his head in the mountain and feet in the sea.”

Micah Swimmer, another EBCI member and driving force behind Honoring Long Man Day, seconded Wilson’s message. In coming together to “clean up our rivers,” observed Swimmer, “it is also important, as Cherokee people, to remember the respect we have for the water. That is our medicine. Nothing survives without water.”

LIVING RIPARIAN HISTORY

For centuries, Cherokees have shared reverential stories about rivers and riparian landscapes. The branches and streams that flow into rivers all display unique personalities. These waterways teem with life during the day and sleep at night. The Eastern Band’s ancestors followed these rivers, building impressive earthen mounds and establishing villages along fertile riverbanks.

But Cherokee ancestors didn’t simply live “in” the mountains of Southern Appalachia; they lived “with” them and became part of the riparian world of Southern Appalachia.

When Europeans began invading the Cherokees’ mountain homelands in the 16th century, local knowledge keepers continued to follow well-established practices of going to water to cleanse bodies and souls. Medicine people turned to nearby streams to heal the sick, and Cherokee horticulturalists carried baskets of water to irrigate crops. Most importantly, rivers were, and are, storytellers, sharing knowledge about the health of riparian ecosystems to those willing to listen.

EXPLORING BIG COVE

This history was at the forefront of my mind on Oct. 19 as cleanup crews broke up to receive last-minute instructions and head off to the different communities on the Qualla Boundary. I joined a crew headed for Big Cove — a small, relatively isolated community, located in the northeast corner of the Qualla Boundary.

It takes about 20 minutes to drive from downtown Cherokee to Big Cove. When we arrived at our rendezvous point, I was reminded of the beauty of this part of the Boundary, and also why Cherokees fought so hard to resist removal and remain rooted to this place in the early 19th century. Soaring mountains reach toward the sky here, while streams and branches trickle and flow through the hollers before discharging into the Oconaluftee River downstream.

With fall leaves crunching under our feet, I comment on the low water levels.

“It feels like Hurricane Ian has sucked all the moisture out of this place,” one crew member responded.

A quick glance at the USGS National Water Dashboard confirmed what we could see: river discharge was well below average. The low water levels revealed a riverbank in which sediment had started to conceal empty beer cans, discarded silverware snagged between rocks, and the scourge of our time — plastics — which have seemingly taken up residence under virtually every tree and fern.

This stream at Big Cove also draws our attention to this waterway’s resilience. Despite pockets of trash, the ecosystem still looked healthy. Yet this narrow branch tells us something essential about our own role in preserving it. Over lunch, an elder reminded me that we “two-legged creatures” need to act with greater “care and responsibility for our water.”

IDENTITYAND INTERCONNECTEDNESS

Chief Sneed shared a similar message with me earlier that morning.

“Days like this create opportunities when we work together,” Sneed explained. “It brings us back to center, to that interconnectedness as tribal people.”

Sneed evoked two principles that are fundamental to Cherokee identity: gadugi, the concept of working cooperatively together, and tohi, or health and balance. Honoring Long Man Day showcased gadugi, revealing how 21st-century F

Volunteers remove 3,380 pounds of trash from EBCI waters

More than 200 people came together to remove 3,380 from the waterways of Cherokee lands in Western North Carolina during the second annual Honoring Long Man Day Wednesday, Oct. 19. The day included a breakfast, blessing and river cleanup in recognition of the Cherokee Long Man, Ganvhidv Asgaya, whose head lay in the mountains and feet in the sea — a living river. A revered figure among the Cherokee, Long Man provided water for drinking, cleanliness, food and numerous cultural rituals tied to medicine and washing away bad thoughts and sadness.

During the inaugural event in 2021, 460 pounds of recyclables were collected in Snowbird, while 2,200 pounds were collected in the Cherokee area. This year, 206 volunteers collected 1,240 pounds of trash in Snowbird and Cherokee County plus 2,140 pounds in the Cherokee area. This volunteer force included 43 students, teachers and parents from New Kituwah Academy; 126 adults from Cherokee; and 37 volunteers in Snowbird and Cherokee County.

Members of the Mississippi Band of Choctaw and Poarch Band of Creek Indians joined in solidarity. Organizer Juanita Wilson hopes to expand that intertribal connection in 2023. Also new this year was a land stewardship component for kids that involved planting native trees such as white oak and hickory, and learning about aquatic creatures and native reptiles.

— Holly Kays, outdoors editor

Cherokees are leading a coalition of Native and non-Native people to duyuk’dv’I, “the correct way” or “right path,” by caring for local waterways.

Walking on the right path is not done alone; it involves a whole of community effort. This ethos buttresses all elements of Honoring Long Man Day. “Water is life,” Swimmer reminded me, “that’s true. That’s what we believe. All tribes believe that.” In the Cherokee language, ama gvnida, “water is life,” remains a fundamental tenet of Cherokee thinking.

THE NEXT GENERATION

Both Wilson and Swimmer understand this. And it is why they are passionate about sharing this message with Cherokee children.

At Oconaluftee Island Park, located in downtown Cherokee, a group of 43 students, teachers and parents from the nearby New Kituwah Academy listened to lessons about riparian ecosystems and got their hands dirty planting nine trees — a combination of white oak and hickory. These students embodied duyuk’dv’I, speaking to each other in Cherokee and working together to care for a popular picnic spot.

Watching the students from New Kituwah plant those trees, I couldn’t help but feel that they were exemplars of ulisgedi detsadayelvsesdi, which calls upon us to “treat each other’s existence as being sacred or important.” They treated each other, those young trees and the waters of the Oconaluftee with immense care.

As the day’s activities came to a close, Wilson referred to those who participated

Volunteers pick up trash on the Qualla Boundary.

Scott Campbell/Casablanca Digital Media photo

as “just a small community group” coming together to care for Cherokee rivers. Yet this “small community” is powerful. With Cherokee leadership, they are showing that movements often begin from a small group of dedicated volunteers who care for the land and water and are willing to work together. In being part of Honoring Long Man Day, I observed that something special seems to be happening in the mountains of Western North Carolina.

Gregory D. Smithers is professor of history at

Virginia Commonwealth University and a British Academy Global Professor based at the

University of Hull, England. He is currently writing a book about water in Cherokee history and culture.

Maggie. Between the Blue Ridge and Great Smoky Mountains rests one of the best golf courses in North Carolina

1819 Country Club Drive, Maggie Valley MAGGIEVALLEYCLUB.COM

JOIN TODAY and 100% of your initiation fee will be waived!

Offer valid for Full Privilege Golf & Individual Golf Memberships. Contact Caitlin Bledsoe at 828-926-4831 for information.

golf | fish | hike | raft | dine | play | stay

InN spwNe spaperIn N , W re e T us st

“When lo geneoooking for swal neer and i oinf rmation, h wo much ouw ld ou t oy rust each type f sou o cer

geneofor aer swl ne and i oinf rmation?”

In the latest Edelman rust B rT ,Barometer % 61 ed erwans t ar ditional media.

’tYou can’t o ge et a mor t dit aditr

i lth ional than n spwe a s.per rust is rT Our ance avRele e.

B

TW Who fin

ished last? S il Social medi dia

ce:Sour .edewww ewherlman.com, wnlooucandoy eport.oadthe2020r