Legacy - September 2016

Legacy

…………………..

IIssssuuee 5599 | S Seepptteem mbbeerr 22001166

Matching the Hatch Since 2011

o Inside: o Game Fishing o Special Investigation o Opinion o Activism o Habitat o Salmon Feedlots oo Alternative Electricity

Cover photo: Musgamagw Dzawada’enuxw First Nation deliver eviction notice prior to removing Cermaq’s Atlantic salmon feedlots – The Fight is on

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Legacy Wild Game Fish Conservation International Wild Game Fish Conservation International (WGFCI): Established in 2011 to advocate for wild game fish, their fragile ecosystems and the cultures and economies that rely on their robust populations.

LEGACY – Journal of Wild Game Fish Conservation: Complimentary, nononsense, monthly publication by conservationists for conservationists LEGACY, the WGFCI Facebook page and the WGFCI website are utilized to better equip fellow conservationists, elected officials, business owners and others regarding wild game fish, their unparalleled contributions to society and the varied and complex issues impacting them and those who rely on their sustainability.

LEGACY exposes impacts to wild game fish while featuring wild game fish conservation projects, community activism, fishing adventures and more. Your photos and articles featuring wild game fish from around planet earth are welcome for possible inclusion in an upcoming issue of LEGACY. E-mail them with captions and credits to Jim (wilcoxj@katewwdb.com).

Successful wild game fish conservation will ensure existence of these precious natural resources and their ecosystems for future generations to enjoy and appreciate. This is our LEGACY.

Wild Game Fish Conservation International Founders

Bruce Treichler

Jim Wilcox

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Contents Game Fishing Planet Earth – Then and Now _______________________________________ 4 Summer 2016 memories__________________________________________________________________________________ 4

Open Letter __________________________________________________________________ 5 Cedar Bouta, Washington State Department of Ecology ____________________________________________________ 5

Community Activism, Education and Outreach ____________________________________ 6 Stopping Farmed Salmon at the Cash Register_____________________________________________________________ 6 “It’s an abonimation to our way of life” ____________________________________________________________________ 7 Video: The Fight is On! ___________________________________________________________________________________ 8 Salmon feedlot mort tote with farmed and wild fish _________________________________________________________ 9 Olympia Trout Unlimited August Meeting _________________________________________________________________ 11

Habitat _____________________________________________________________________ 12 Is the Hood Canal bridge killing fish? ____________________________________________________________________ 12 Video: Chitaapi “Cat Face Mountain” – No Consent to mine ________________________________________________ 14

Salmon Feedlots – Weapons of Mass Destruction, Floating Cesspools _______________ 15 Salmon farming on the rise in Washington _______________________________________________________________ 15

Renewable Energy: Geothermal, Waves, Tidal, Solar, Wind, Hydropower ______________ 20 Hydropower ____________________________________________________________________________________________ 20

Forward The August 2016 issue of “Legacy” marks fifty eight consecutive months of our complimentary eMagazine; the no-holds-barred, watchdog journal published and distributed by Wild Game Fish Conservation International.

Wild game fish are our passion. Publishing “Legacy” each month is our self imposed responsibility to help ensure the future of these precious gifts entrusted to our generation for their conservation.

Please read then share “Legacy” with others who care deeply about the future of wild game fish and all that rely on them.

Sincerely,

Bruce Treichler James E. Wilcox

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Game Fishing Planet Earth – Then and Now Summer 2016 memories Aboard Slammer - Westport, Washington

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Open Letter Cedar Bouta, Washington State Department of Ecology Ms. Bouta, Re. Salmon farming on the rise in Washington

With all due respect to you and the Washington Department of Ecology we have the following concerns: Ocean-based salmon farms are, in fact, salmon feedlots standards (salmon aquaculture) that contain exemptions designed to make finfish aquaculture feasible here (industry driven?) the company will have to measure the pH of the water column and pollution in the sediment beneath its pens (fox guarding the hen house) The deeper the water, the stronger the current, the more the waste will be dispersed. (the deeper the water the stronger the current and the greater the impact of Pacific storms - the greater the risk of escapes from salmon feedlots) Icicle voluntarily conducts underwater video surveillance (fox guarding the hen house) Bouta says escapes don’t really pose a threat. (farmed salmon pose significant environmental and human health risks - these are exacerbated when they escape.)

When penned salmon escape,” Bouta says, “they tend to stay near the pen. And they’re good eating.” (Escaped Feedlot salmon have been caught in Puget Sound tributaries (their flesh is mushy and laden with toxins) To put new net pens in the strait, the company will have to clear a long line of regulatory hurdles.

In addition to the state DOE, Clallam County, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Coast Guard will all weigh in. Finally, the state Department of Natural Resources will have to grant a lease. (Will also need consultation with local tribes and Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission) Your comments lead us to believe that you are disregarding decades-long global experience and science regarding these issues.

Puget Sound shall not be a cesspool for industrial waste!

The Department of Ecology is Washington's environmental protection agency. Our mission is to protect, preserve and enhance Washington's land, air and water for current and future generations.

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Community Activism, Education and Outreach

Stopping Farmed Salmon at the Cash Register

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

“It’s an abonimation to our way of life” Watch video: Salmon feedlot eviction letter delivered Related: CBC - 72 hours to vacate: First Nation gives eviction notice to salmon farm

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Video: The Fight is On!

Farm employees tried to block the landing dock with a huge cedar tree

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Salmon feedlot mort tote with farmed and wild fish

Robert Corlett We used to take totes of ice out to Industrial Salmon sites, so that they could ice down their ' fresher morts'. We would then transport the 'morts' to the processing plant. Now you must understand, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, Health Canada and Fisheries and Oceans had no objections as according to them consumers were not at risk. On the plus side, they were easier to chew!

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Olympia Trout Unlimited August Meeting

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Habitat

Is the Hood Canal bridge killing fish?

August 17, 2016 A recent study of juvenile steelhead by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration found an unusually high mortality on the south side of the 55-year-old bridge, but a lower death rate on the north side.

There are several theories about the bridge and its impact on juvenile fish. The conservation group Long Live the Kings is hoping a new study will end the mystery.

“In addition to the effects on steelhead and perhaps on juvenile salmon, there’s also some concerns that the bridge might be affecting water quality,” said Long Live the Kings executive director Jacques White.

Young fish headed out to sea from spawning grounds in the south are stopping at the center of the bridge. As they swim around the structure near the water’s surface, they become prey for the hungry seals that prowl the area looking for an easy meal.

Biologists say the juvenile fish may do this because they're confused by the pontoons blocking their path. The constant noise of traffic could also contribute to the problem. But they could also simply be taking advantage of the artificial reef the bridge creates, allowing them to feed on zooplankton, and get trapped in pools in the bridge's interior. Once there, they can easily be eaten by the ever present seals.

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels “It’s almost like a mousetrap,” said Hans Daubenberger, a biologist for the Port Gamble S’Klallam tribe, which is helping fund the study. “There’s cheese or bait in the trap and they stay there, and the seals have learned this.”

The bridge may also be contributing to the Hood Canal's low oxygen levels, acting as a boom blocking the flow of currents in and out of the narrow body of water.

The study will cost $2.4 million. Funding provided by Long Live the Kings and the S’Klallam tribe is paying for a large chunk of the cost. The organization is looking for around $1.6 million from state and federal grants.

Rep. Derek Kilmer, of the 6th Congressional District, who toured the bridge during an unveiling of the study on Wednesday, said finding an answer that works for fish and people is important.

“There’s an understanding that this is a bridge that’s really important to transportation for those who live in the Olympic Peninsula and those who want to get onto the Olympic Peninsula,” Kilmer said.

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Video: Chitaapi “Cat Face Mountain” – No Consent to mine

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Salmon Feedlots – Weapons of Mass Destruction, Floating Cesspools

Salmon farming on the rise in Washington

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels Human travelers have I-5 and I-90. Salish Sea salmon have the Juan de Fuca Strait.

It’s the route that they all swim on their way to and from the wide Pacific — the salmon from the Elwha and all the rivers of Puget Sound, plus many salmon returning to Canada’s Fraser River, which are the main local food source for Puget Sound orcas and have always formed the bulk of Puget Sound’s commercial catch.

Now, Icicle Seafoods — recently acquired by Canada’s Cooke Seafood — wants to raise Atlantic salmon in 9.7 acres of salmon net pens in the strait, just east of Port Angeles.

Although it has its critics, salmon aquaculture isn’t new in Puget Sound — and certainly not elsewhere. British Columbia aquaculture produces salmon worth nearly half a billion (Canadian) dollars a year. And B.C. is a minnow compared to the salmon-raising industries of Norway (where salmon aquaculture is booming) and Chile (where it’s not.)

Icicle already has eight salmon aquaculture operations in the Sound, including one at Port Angeles tucked in behind Ediz Hook. The company’s plan for putting pens out in the Strait has been driven by U.S. Navy plans to expand its base on Ediz Hook, which won’t physically displace the existing pens but will ruin the neighborhood for salmon. Pile driving for the Navy project, scheduled to begin late this year, would actually kill salmon in nearby pens. Icicle has decided to move its operation.

Under Icicle’s planned new development, 14 circular pens, each 126 feet in diameter, would be kept in place by a network of two-to- four-ton steel anchors. The new pens would produce 20 percent more salmon than the old. They would be the first anchored this far offshore in Washington waters.

Actually, they would be the first anchored anywhere in Washington for many years. And they might not be the last.

Critics have worried for years that pen-raised salmon will escape, leading to competition and even interbreeding with wild populations. They also worry that captive fish will infect wild salmon with disease. And they point to the wastes that can build up in water and sediment below the pens. The prospect of new pens in the Strait may bring fresh attention to some of these old concerns.

Cedar Bouta of the Washington Department of Ecology (DOE), which regulates water quality, disputes the longstanding idea that that net pens are basically aquatic feed lots. Bouta says that net pens do, of course, have to meet water quality standards — albeit standards that contain exemptions designed to make finfish aquaculture feasible here.

The Icicle project will require a national pollutant discharge elimination system permit.

Under the permit, the company will have to measure the pH of the water column and pollution in the sediment beneath its pens. The impact of a pen depends a lot on location, Bouta explains. The deeper the water, the stronger the current, the more the waste will be dispersed.

Editorial Comment: Cedar Bouta is clueless regarding water quality impacts associated with ocean-based salmon feedlots.

Standards and their enforcement are not based in science Editorial Comment: Fox guarding the hen house.

The deeper waters of the Strait of Juan de Fuca experience significant Pacific Ocean wind storms that often oppose outgoing tides – cage damage and escapes likely

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels The new pens in the Strait would have deeper water and stronger currents than any of the existing ones.

In addition, she says, Icicle voluntarily conducts underwater video surveillance, so that if feed is coming through the nets uneaten, it can suspend feeding. It also leaves nets fallow every couple of years.

What about escape, a particular fear here because of the existence of salmon species that are already threatened? Farmed Atlantic fish have escaped. But they haven’t survived long. Icicle will need a plan to prevent escapes and one to recapture fish that do escape, but Bouta says escapes don’t really pose a threat.

Editorial Comment: 100% Bovine Excrement.

Escaped Atlantic salmon compete with wild Pacific salon – they also populate local rivers

She says 7.5 million Atlantic salmon have been released here since the 1940s, when some people actually thought it would be a good idea to establish populations of them here. None survived. The National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) has assured the state that interbreeding or establishing new populations isn’t an issue. When penned salmon escape,” Bouta says, “they tend to stay near the pen. And they’re good eating.” So fishermen, granted a special season, are quite happy to catch the escapees.

Some risks may be exaggerated in popular imagination. However, Bouta says, “disease is a concern.” Four years ago, infectious hematopoietic necrosis virus (IHNV) swept through Icicle’s pens off Bainbridge Island. To control the disease, the company slaughtered and sold the fish — the pathogens weren’t dangerous to humans — and moved the pens.

To put new net pens in the strait, the company will have to clear a long line of regulatory hurdles. In addition to the state DOE, Clallam County, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Coast Guard will all weigh in. Finally, the state Department of Natural Resources will have to grant a lease. The different agency approvals aren’t really coordinated; state agency staff members just finished two days of meetings in Olympia to talk about coordinating the ways they permit and monitor net pens.

(Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife, which oversees disease in farmed salmon, has no place in the queue.)

Editorial Comment: No mention of coordinating with local tribes and the Northwest Indian Fisheries Commission – major oversight!

As in Canada, NMFS is responsible for protecting wild salmon while promoting ocean-based salmon feedlots.

Federal court battles are expected

Under the Endangered Species Act, if the new project is likely to jeopardize a threatened or endangered species, National Marine Fisheries Service will have to formally consult. But NMFS and other agencies may conclude that no formal consultation is needed. If so, bet on the issue winding up in federal court.

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels Failures to consult on the impacts of existing net pens have already wound up in federal court. Wild Fish Conservancy, which has warned that the Strait proposal would open the door to pens throughout the region, last year sued NMFS and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). It is challenging NMFS’ 2011 determination that Puget Sound commercial salmon farms are not likely to have any adverse effect on threatened salmon runs and what it calls “NMFS’ and EPA’s failure to reconsider that determination in light of the 2012 IHNV outbreak.”

Washington created rules that exempt fish farms from water quality standards. If EPA thought the operation of fish farms was likely to jeopardize threatened or endangered species, it had to consult formally with NMFS. Instead, EPA decided the action wasn’t likely to jeopardize listed species. An informal consultation took place, and NMFS concurred. The plaintiffs argue that the failure to consult formally was arbitrary and capricious. They also argue that after the 2012 disease outbreak — which amplified the amount of virus in the water right when juvenile salmon were migrating through the net pen areas —raised red flags about potential impacts, both agencies violated federal law by not formally consulting.

The impact of disease on wild fish has become a much more public concern north of the border.

British Columbia has over 70 salmon aquaculture operations, which are both regulated and promoted

by Canada’s Department of Fisheries and Oceans. It also has the Fraser River sockeye. An enormous sockeye run in 2010 notwithstanding, Fraser River fish have been in obvious trouble for decades. After a disastrously small run in 2009, the Canadian government set up the commission to figure out what was going wrong.

The so-called Cohen commission didn’t come up with a simple answer. It did suggest that the same government agency shouldn’t both regulate and promote aquaculture. And it did point to potential links between aquaculture and disease in wild fish.

The issue of salmon diseases became highly politicized. Scientists who had found — highly unwelcome — salmon pathogens in British Columbia told Cohen that they felt Canadian government officials under the Conservative Party had tried to intimidate them. A Nanaimo-based government molecular geneticist, Kristi Miller, was told not to publicly discuss her work. Canada’s current Liberal government has decided that Miller and other scientists should be free to speak with the press.

Miller is now helping lead what has been called “the most comprehensive study of salmon health ever undertaken,” looking at 45 different pathogens in 26,000 fish. “One of the things that came out of Cohen was the need for strong and objective science,” Miller explains in an interview. Keeping the research objective has been tricky: “One of the difficulties is that most fish veterinarians [in B.C.] are trained to work with industry.” Therefore, “we brought in a histopathologist out of Scotland and one out of Italy. Our work on epidemiology is all being done out of Prince Edward Island.”

Finding disease links between farmed and wild salmon poses “actually the hardest question,” Miller says. Cause-and-effect relationships are hard to prove.

It’s long been suspected that any disease that costs a salmon its competitive edge may quickly make it something else’s dinner. But where’s the evidence?

Miller explains that researchers have been going to great lengths to find it. They’re even stealing fish from birds. For example, she says, they’ll check the salmon smolts in rhinoceros auklet nests to see how many of them contain pathogens.

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels And they’re establishing a link between disease and predation. Many scientists had assumed it existed, she says, but no one had shown it before. Now, she says, it’s clear that “infection status does influence the risk of predation.”

Does all that research, which has the support of both industry and environmental groups in Canada, have any bearing on this side of the border? The same biological mechanisms work here. But Miller’s teams are still at work researching the spread of disease from farmed salmon to wild ones. And how soon the information being developed in B.C. might influence the government agencies or courts on the U.S. side of the Strait remains to be seen.

September 2016 Wild Game Fish Conservation International 2016– Transitioning from Fossil Fuels

Renewable Energy: Geothermal, Waves, Tidal, Solar, Wind, Hydropower Hydropower