16 minute read
Great Achievements
William LeMessurier
Educator and Innovative Engineer
By Robert Hossli, RA, NCARB and Ronald Flucker, P.E.
The story of William LeMessurier’s engineering accomplishments was featured in the September 2012 issue of STRUCTURE magazine. The author, Richard G. Weingardt, quoted William Theon, a long-time personal friend and professional partner: “Bill loved teaching as much as engineering and was always at his best with an audience.” This is a chapter in Bill’s productive life not covered in Mr. Weingardt’s article – a time when he was working with students on collaborative projects, often sponsored by industry. During the early 1960s, Bill lectured at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and was a key member of project teams that involved graduate students from the architectural and engineering departments. He wanted to give those students a chance to try out their theoretical training on real-life architectural and engineering problems, and let them receive financial benefits from corporate grants. Bill played a major role in one particular project sponsored by the Applied Research Laboratory (ARL) of The United States Steel Corporation (USS). By 1960, the flat-slab concrete structural system had, for several reasons, virtually eliminated structural steel as a competitive material in high-rise residential construction. Concerned with this, USS charged the ARL with developing innovative ideas that might help regain a share of that market. Bob Hossli, an ARL research consultant and recent graduate of MIT, had been impressed with the team headed by architect Marvin Goody and engineer Albert Dietz that designed and tested
Figure 2: Embassy Suites (now Conrad) Hotel in New York City.
the glass fiber reinforced polyester shells of the Monsanto-sponsored “House of the Future.” With this in mind, he suggested that MIT submit a proposal for an interdisciplinary research project to develop an economically competitive structural steel frame solution for high-rise residential buildings. This proposal was accepted, with Bill LeMessurier as the engineer and Marvin Goody as the architect on the team. Several meetings took place without much progress. Then, as LeMessurier told it, one night, when he could not fall asleep, he had a “eureka” moment. Quoting from the USS Technical Report, Staggered Truss Framing Systems for High-Rise Buildings, he envisioned a
“… system … of story-high trusses spanning transversely between columns at the exterior of the building and arranged in a staggered pattern. The floor system acts as a diaphragm, transferring lateral loads in the short direction to the trusses. Lateral loads are thereby resisted by truss diagonals and are transferred into direct loads in the columns. Therefore, the columns receive no bending moments in the transverse direction. Columns can thus be oriented so that the strong axis is available to help resist bending due to longitudinal wind forces.
“The interior of the building is column free, and clear spaces are defined and
limited only by intersecting floor and truss planes. Trusses are typically penetrated by one rectangular opening to provide a corridor space. However, other openings can be provided in the truss to allow for door opening if required by the architectural room arrangement.” (Figure 1) Bill presented the idea to the MIT team, which accepted it heartily as the answer to the sponsor’s charge. In January 1967, the MIT team developed and presented to USS a thorough report about the system, how to design the structure, how to lay out various configurations for occupancy, and how to construct it. Upon review by ARL and USS’s Construction Marketing Department, in which Ron Flucker worked, it was judged to be immensely successful. The system would be extremely cost-competitive and adaptable to many floor layouts, could be built to the same height limitations as flat-slab concrete, and utilized rolled steel shapes as the principal structural elements. USS also recognized that the idea was patentable, but decided that it would be more in its best interests, and those of its structural steel fabricator customers, to keep the concept in the public domain. The American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC) got wind of the concept through its Boston Regional Engineer and invited LeMessurier to present a paper describing the
system at its June 1966 annual Engineering Convention in Boston. As a result of this early exposure, the fi rm of Bakke & Kopp, Inc. of Minneapolis decided to use the system for the frame of a local housing authority’s seventeenstory high-rise apartment building for the elderly, which was constructed in 1968. U. S. Steel then began promoting the system and it caught on. Although no accurate count exists, it is estimated that some one hundred buildings (or more) have been constructed using the system, including one designed by LeMessurier’s fi rm, the Lafayette Place Hotel in Boston. While most buildings have been modest in size, typically 10 to 20 stories (Figures 2 and 3), some have bordered on monumental like the 30-story Resorts International Hotel in Atlantic City, which has withstood several hurricanes. Bill LeMessurier’s “eureka” moment has resulted in a successful concept for high-rise steel framing. Perhaps more important to him was the learning experience provided for fi ve graduate student assistants in the MIT Civil Engineering and Architectural Departments. Th e authors wish to recognize the assistance of Tabitha Stine of AISC in researching this article and providing the accompanying images. All graphics courtesy of AISC.▪
Figure 3: Boston Convention Center Hotel.
Robert Hossli, RA, NCARB (bhossli@providencepoint.org), is a retired architectural development engineer who worked for US Steel, Westinghouse, Reynolds Metals, Armarlite Division of Anaconda Aluminum, H. H. Robertson, and Centria and was a member of ASTM and AAMA Standards Committees. Ronald Flucker, P.E. (rl ucker@verizon.net), is a retired structural engineer who worked for ALCOA, US Steel, AISC, and J&M Turner in areas of structural research, product and engineering development, and promotion for structural steel.
ADVERTISEMENT–For Advertiser Information, visit www.STRUCTUREmag.org
Software
AceCad Software
Phone: 610-280-9840 Email: sales@acecadsoftware.us Web: www.acecadsoftware.com Product: StruM.I.S Description: An all encompassing steel fabrication management solution that harnesses information fl ow and work processes through the steelwork contract between departments, suppliers and clients; from estimate/tendering, through procurement and production into construction. StruM.I.S extends integration to ensure workfl ow with your current systems for maximum organizational success.
Computers & Structures, Inc.
Phone: 510-649-2200 Email: info@csiberkeley.com Web: www.csiberkeley.com Product: ETABS 2013 Description: Th e most technologically-advanced software available to structural engineers today. ETABS 2013 defi nes the future of building design, setting the stage for unsurpassed capability and effi ciency. Featuring versatile modeling technology, stunning graphics, effi cient numerical methods and powerful optimization algorithms, ETABS 2013 off ers unprecedented integration and productivity.
CSC
Phone: 877-710-2053 Email: sales@cscworld.com Web: www.cscworld.com Product: Tedds Description: Tedds gives you access to a large library of automated structural calculations, all to US codes, for tall multi-storey structures. Use a single software solution for all common elements and materials, and then create and export transparent report documentation. Product: Fastrak Description: Model, analyze and design complex, multi-storey steel buildings to US codes with speed and ease. Work in 2D or 3D views to create any building structure and export to BIM platforms such as Autodesk Revit.
Devco Software, Inc.
Phone: 541-426-5713 Email: rob@devcosoftware.com Web: www.devcosoftware.com Product: LGBEAMER v8 Description: Analyze and design cold-formed cee, channel and zee sections. Uniform, concentrated, partial span and axial loads. Single and multi-member designs. 2007 NASPEC (2009 IBC) compliant. ProTools include shearwalls, framed openings, X-braces, joists and rafters. Digital Canal
Phone: 800-449-5033 Email: clint@digitalcanal.com Web: www.digitalcanal.com Product: VersaFrame Description: VersaFrame has the key features needed to “get the job done” without becoming overly complex. Includes steel design (AISC 13th) and concrete design (ACI 2011). Try it free at the website.
GT STRUDL
Phone: 404-894-2260 Email: casec@ce.gatech.edu Web: www.gtstrudl.gatech.edu Product: GT STRUDL Description: Off ers linear and nonlinear static and dynamic analysis features including response spectrum, transient and pushover analyses, plastic hinges, discrete dampers, base isolation, and nonlinear connections. Auxiliary GT STRUDL features available for the Base Plate Module and GT64M MultiProcessor Solver.
Integrated Engineering Software
Phone: 406-586-8988 Email: info@iesweb.com Web: www.iesweb.com Product: VisualAnalysis Description: A great tool for tall building design including area loads, streamlined design features, and a “stay out of your way” attitude. Tall buildings are more than just a “total model” and VisualAnalysis is excellent for all kinds of investigations and analysis.
Nemetschek Scia
Phone: 877-808-7242 Email: info@scia-online.com Web: www.nemetschek-scia.com Product: Scia Engineer Description: Looking to migrate to, or improve your 3D design workfl ows? Scia Engineer links structural modeling, analysis, design, drawings, and reports in ONE program. Design to multiple codes. Tackle larger projects with advanced non-linear and dynamic analysis. Plug into BIM with IFC support, and bidirectional links to Revit, Tekla, and others.
POSTEN Engineering Systems
Phone: 510-275-4750 Email: sales@postensoft.com Web: www.postensoft.com Product: POSTEN Multistory Description: Th e most effi cient & comprehensive post-tensioned concrete software in the world that not only automatically designs the tendons, drapes, as well as columns, but also produces highly effi cient, cost saving, sustainable designs with automatic documentation of material savings for LEED. No guessing, no fi ddling, no time wasting.
All Resource Guides and Updates for the 2013 Editorial Calendar are now available on the website, www.STRUCTUREmag.org. Listings are provided as a courtesy. STRUCTURE® magazine is not responsible for errors. RISA Technologies
Phone: 949-951-5815 Email: info@risatech.com Web: www.risa.com Product: RISAFloor Description: RISAFloor and RISA-3D form an unrivaled building analysis and design package. Modeling has never been easier whether you’re doing a graphical layout, importing a BIM model (from Autodesk Revit Structure), or prefer spreadsheets. Full code checks and optimization for six diff erent material types makes RISA your fi rst choice in buildings.
S-FRAME Software Inc.
Phone: 203-421-4800 Email: info@s-frame.com Web: www.s-frame.com Product: S-FRAME® Analysis and Design Description: An easy-to-use structural modeling, analysis and design environment for tall buildings, bridges, frames, trusses, industrial buildings, plate/shell structures, and cable structures for seismic analysis, staged construction, slab design, Direct Analysis Method, linear and nonlinear static and time history analyses, moving load analysis, buckling load evaluation and more. Product: S-CONCRETE Design Description: Use S-CONCRETE to analyze and design reinforced concrete columns, beams and wall sections in an interactive design environment. Th e powerful analysis capabilities are coupled with an intuitive, interface with optional auto-design capabilities and comprehensive international standards. Auto-design single sections or batch process thousands of designs in one run.
Firms Leslie E. Robertson Associates, R.L.L.P.
Phone: 212-750-9000 Email: sawteen.see@lera.com Web: www.lera.com Product: Structural Engineering Description: A120-person M/WBE fi rm providing structural engineering services to architects, owners, contractors, and developers. Established in 1923, we have designed numerous landmark projects, both nationally and internationally. Our long tradition of innovative design together with our advances in technology has brought LERA to the forefront of the engineering profession.
The Masonry Society
Phone: 303-939-9700 Email: info@masonrysociety.org Web: www.masonrysociety.org Product: Publications Description: A non-profi t professional organization of volunteers, dedicated to the advancement of masonry knowledge. Th rough our Members, information & opinions about all aspects of masonry are discussed & debated. Th e resulting information is disseminated to provide guidance to the masonry industry on aspects of design, construction, & repair.
Walter P Moore and Associates
Phone: 404-898-9620 Email: tsanti@walterpmoore.com Web: www.walterpmoore.com Product: Innovative Engineering Description: WPM provides innovative engineering solutions to buildings of all types, all over the world.
WSP USA
Phone: 212-687-9888 Email: contact.structures@wspgroup.com/us Web: www.wspgroup.com/usa Product: Structural Engineering Description: The High Rise Center of Excellence within WSP’s global consultancy. Services include high and low rise building design, peer review and value engineering, forensic engineering structural investigations, building renovations and alterations, blast resistant design, construction inspection, 3D visualization, building information modeling (BIM) and steel detailing.
Suppliers
Construction Specialties, Inc.
Phone: 800-526-6930 Email: sgaskill@c-sgroup.com Web: www.c-sgroup.com Product: Blast Louvers Description: Blast protection, air movement and rain defense rolled into one. Government buildings, VA hospitals, computer centers and power plants are particularly vulnerable to explosive threats. C/S has developed six Blast Resistant models designed to withstand blasts up to 8 PSI and capable of meeting government requirements. Product: Expansion Joint Covers Description: Provides a covered transition across the expansion or movement joint openings of a building, which remains unaffected by the relative movement of the two surfaces on either side of the joint. These covers can be extremely large and complex on base isolated-buildings in seismic hotbeds.
CTS Cement Manufacturing
Phone: 800-929-3030 Email: jong@ctscement.com Web: www.ctscement.com Product: Type K Shrinkage Compensating Cement Description: Install concrete structures and industrialsize floors using Type-K shrinkage-compensating cement products with no curling, no drying shrinkage cracking and no intermediate saw cut joints. Product: Rapid Set® Cement Products Description: Use Rapid Set cement products for concrete repairs, restoration and new construction, and achieve high durability, fast strength gain and structural or drive-on strength in one-hour. Decon® USA Inc.
Phone: 866-332-6687 Email: frank@decon.ca Web: www.deconusa.com Product: Studrails® Description: The North American standard for punching shear enhancement at slab-column connections. Studrails are produced to the specifications of ASTM A1044, ACI 318-08, and ICC ES 2494. Decon Studrails are also being increasingly used to reinforce against bursting stresses in banded post-tension anchor zones. Product: Anchor Channels Description: Decon USA is the exclusive representative of Jordahl in North America. Hot rolled Anchor Channels are embedded in concrete and used to securely transfer high loads. Their main application is for flexible connections of glazing panels to high-rise buildings. Anchor Channels with welded-on rebar or corner pieces are available.
Ecospan Composite Floor System
Phone: 770-296-4097 Email: rbullens@vulcraft-al.com Web: www.ecospan-usa.com Product: Composite Floor System Description: An innovative, simple, effective and economical method of providing open web structural components for elevated floor construction while incorporating benefits of lightweight composite design. UL fire rating, G561, for 1, 2 and 3 hours and a STC sound rating of 57.
New Millennium Building Systems
Phone: 260-868-6000 Email: kevin.disinger@newmill.com Web: www.newmill.com Product: Steel joists, metal decking, castellated beams, BIM design, Flex-Joist Description: New Millennium engineers and manufactures standard steel joists, architecturally unique steel joists, steel decking, and FreeSpan castellated beams for wide-span bay designs. A leader in BIM-based steel joist design; recently introduced the Flex-Joist Gravity Overload Safety System, for early warning in the event of roof overloads.
Pile Dynamics, Inc.
Phone: 216-831-6131 Email: www.info@pile.com Web: www.pile.com/pdi Product: QC systems for foundations of Tall Bulidings Description: World leader in Deep Foundations QA/QC system brands: Pile Driving Analyzer® and CAPWAP® (Dynamic Load Testing/Pile Driving Monitoring), Pile Integrity Tester, Thermal Integrity Profiler, PIR (Automated Monitoring Equipment for augercast/CFA piles), Cross-Hole Analyzer (CSL), GRLWEAP (wave equation analysis of piles), SPT Analyzer, E-Saximeter (driving logs), more. Powers Fasteners
Phone: 985-807-6666 Email: jack.zenor@sbdinc.com Web: www.powers.com Product: Concrete Anchoring Description: FREE – Anchor Design Software – Powers Design Assist. Helps tall Building designers deal with the complexity of ACI 318 Appendix D. Powers Fasteners now has 23 Product Code Compliance ICC ES Reports! Visit our website to download the software.
Simpson Strong-Tie®
Phone: 925-560-9000 Email: web@strongtie.com Web: www.strongtie.com Product: Strong Frame® Special Moment Frame Description: The new code-listed Strong Frame special moment frame is a unique lateral system solution for new construction and soft-story retrofit. With patented Yield-Link™ structural fuse technology, the links bear the brunt of lateral forces during a seismic event, keeping the structural integrity of the beams and columns intact.
Vulcraft/Verco Group
Phone: 402-844-2570 Email: mike.klug@nucor.com Web: www.vulcraft.com Product: Steel Decking Description: Used in many applications, but is particularly well suited to roofing and flooring. Vulcraft/ Verco group manufactures many different types of deck, including roof deck, floor deck, composite floor deck and cellular deck. A full line of deck accessories, such as end closure and pour stop, is also available.
Product: Steel Joist and Joist Girders Description: Open web-steel joists and joist girders are an engineered, truss-like construction component used to support loads over short and long spans. Steel joists and joist girders provide an economical system for supporting floors and roofs. Vulcraft joists and joist girders are designed/manufactored in accordance with the Steel Joist Institute.
SOILSTRUCTURE.COM
Substructural Software
1. Soldier Pile/Wood Lagging 2. Multi-Level Tieback Walls 3. Laterally Loaded Drilled Pier 4. Anchored or Cant. Sheetpile 5. Cantilever Retaining Wall
Only $280 to $450. Nothing to ship.
Same Day Email Activation
Free Downloads at: http://www.SoilStructure.com
Susan M. Frey
An Engineer’s Engineer
Susan (Sue) M. Frey, P.E., S.E., passed away on Sunday, May 12, 2013 at her home. Sue received her B.S. and M.S. from Purdue University, graduating in 1977. Later that year, she was hired as a structural engineer at CH2M HILL in Corvallis, OR, where she spent her entire career designing everything from concrete water storage reservoirs and wastewater treatment plants to performing arts centers. Sue was known as a tremendous mentor, both for junior staff and for advanced technical excellence across the firm, through her role as Structural Engineering Global Technology Leader. Sue served on the Civil Engineering Advisory Council at Purdue for many years. Purdue University awarded her the Civil Engineering Alumni Achievement Award in 2005. In 2010, she won the CH2M HILL CEO Excellence Award in the category of respect. She also contributed her time to many national and international professional societies, helping to advance the improvement and refinement of building codes and design practices through The Masonry Society, The Masonry Standards Joint Committee, The Structural Engineers Association of Oregon (President 1997 – 1998), the American Concrete Institute, The American Waterworks Association, and the National Council of Structural Engineers Associations (NCSEA). She was an adjunct professor for Design of Masonry Structures at Oregon State University, and was a masonry seminar and webinar instructor for the Northwest Concrete Masonry Association. Recently, she was appointed by the Governor to the Oregon State Board of Examiners of Engineering and Land Surveying as a board member. Sue was also honored with a Special Merit for Lifetime Achievement Award from the Structural Engineers Association of Oregon (SEAO). She was the SEAO delegate to NCSEA, was very active on the NCSEA Licensure Committee and taught the Masonry portion of the NCSEA Structural Examination Review Course. Sue is survived by her husband of 33 years, Rich, and her two children, Jamie and Patrick. Sue served her profession as few do and made countless friends in the process. She was an inspiration to all that she met, constantly being upbeat and courageous during her 10 year battle with cancer. She was an engineer’s engineer. She will be sorely missed by her family, her countless friends and the structural engineering profession to which she gave so much. Donations in Sue’s memory may be made to the Good Samaritan Hospital Foundation Survivorship Fund, 3600 NW Samaritan Drive, Corvallis, OR 97330, or the Susan M. Frey Civil Engineering Scholarship Fund, Purdue University, 403 West Wood Street, West Lafayette, IN 47907-2007 (check should include note “for the Susan M. Frey Civil Engineering Scholarship Fund.”). Online condolences may be sent to: www.mchenryfuneralhome.com.
ADVERTISEMENT–For Advertiser Information, visit www.STRUCTUREmag.org
Linear and nonlinear soluti ons to extend your structural analysis capability
Strand7 combines Windows nati ve pre and post processors with a suite of powerful solvers giving you unparalleled functi onality in a single applicati on. Construct models, run analyses and investi gate results simultaneoustly using a seamless interface.
Some of Strand7 Features:
• Submodeling • Data Libraries • User-defi ned beam secti ons • Import from Staad, SAP2000,
Nastran and Ansys models • Automati c mesh generati on • Concrete Analysis - Creep and
Shrinkage • Constructi on Sequence
Simulati on • Isotropic, orthotropic, anisotropic, soil, rubber materials
A Confi denti al Unbuilt Project - Image and Model courtesy Halvorson and Partners
Extensive range of Solvers:
Strand7 includes stati c, dynamic, transient and heat transfer solvers. These all have linear and powerful non linear capabiliti es. Material, geometric and contact non linearity can be analyzed simultaneously.
Beaufort Analysis, Inc.
