Legal Perspectives

The Hyatt Regency Disaster Revisited

By Matthew R. Rechtien, P.E., Esq.

The more than three decades that have passed since the collapse of hanging walkways at Kansas City’s Hyatt Regency Hotel have turned that catastrophe into the textbook cautionary tale for structural engineers. No other collapse (save maybe the World Trade Center) has led me to as many discussions within and out of the profession. I recall my own mentor, Javier Horvilleur, discussing it with laypeople and peers at least twice a year. It is the profession’s quintessential “teachable moment.” So, with Santayana’s warning in mind that “[t]hose who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it,” this article takes a fresh look, from a legal perspective, at some of the enduring lessons it holds.

Background

In the late 1970s, Gillum-Colaco, Inc. (“GCE”) agreed to perform all structural engineering services for the design and construction of the hotel. GCE designated Jack Gillum (“Gillum”) as engineer of record, but put Daniel Duncan (“Duncan”) in day-to-day charge of the project. GCE’s design called for second and fourth floor walkways to hang from the roof of the atrium they spanned by six continuous or “single” steel rods that were to connect to each walkway through “box” connections. GCE designed – insufficiently, it turns out; by one estimate, the design expressed in the drawings carried only 60% of what the local building code required – the box connections so that the second floor walkway would not hang from the fourth floor walkway. The steel fabricator proposed a “double rod” system, in which the six rods would become twelve, and the second floor walkway would hang from the fourth floor walkway, amplifying the load on the box connections. Duncan, who seemingly failed to detect the load amplification, approved the fabricator’s proposal and vouched for its soundness without doing what (he later admitted) would have been necessary to confirm it. Neither Gillum nor Duncan reviewed the shop drawings reflecting the change, despite GCE’s policy that drawings of non-redundant connections receive more than the technician’s review of sizes and materials that they got.

Disciplinary Proceedings

In 1981, after just a year of service, the box connections failed and the walkways collapsed, killing more than 100 revelers. In 1984, Missouri’s Board for Professional Engineers commenced disciplinary proceedings against Duncan, Gillum and GCE. After a 27-day hearing, the tribunal (the “Commission”) conducting the proceedings issued findings covering 442 pages. The Commission found all three grossly negligent and revoked their licenses.

Legal Challenges

Duncan, Gillum and GCE (the “Appellants”) unsuccessfully appealed their discipline up to the Missouri Court of Appeals. That court rejected all of their “legalistic” challenges. It rejected their claim that the governing statute’s gross negligence standard was unconstitutionally vague, and that discipline was improper because no one shortcoming amounted to gross negligence. It also rejected the Appellants’ claim that their negligent design of the rods was not a basis for discipline because the rods did not fail, responding that in a disciplinary proceeding – unlike in a negligence lawsuit – causation is irrelevant. In addition, the Court rejected Gillum’s and GCE’s contention that neither could be disciplined vicariously for Duncan’s misconduct. The Court also rejected the Appellants’ more substantive attacks on the sufficiency of the evidence, and pointing to the following: 1) Duncan was responsible for designing and approving the building structure; 2) The walkways fell in that scope; 3) “… [T]he walkways offered a potential of great danger to human life if defectively designed;” 4) Duncan approved the fabricator’s change, recommended it to the architect, and approved shop drawings reflecting it without confirming its acceptability; 5) The change effectively doubled the box connection load; and, 6) Duncan never reviewed the shop drawings, even though such review is an “engineering function” that even GCE’s in-house policies required he do.

Courtesy of Dr. Lee Lowery, Jr., P.E.

On those facts, the Court affirmed that “[t]he conduct of Duncan from initial design through shop drawing review and through the subsequent requested connection review … supports the Commission’s finding of conscious indifference to [non-delegable] professional duty.” The Court also affirmed Gillum’s “gross negligence” and resulting discipline because he failed, as engineer of record, “to assure that the Hyatt engineering designs and drawings were structurally sound … prior to impressing thereupon his seal,” and failed “to assure adequate shop drawing review.”

Lessons

The story of the Hyatt collapse is, for me, a little like the classic film The Natural. With each look, I get a bit something different out of it; it is a Rorschach test. The remainder of this article shares a few of my observations. “Heavy lies the head that wears the

crown” – William Shakespeare

The Hyatt case demonstrates that, as a legal matter, the “buck stops” at the engineer of record. The Court did not focus on Gillum’s errors of commission, or failings as an engineer, but on his failings as a manager. It found that as the engineer of record, “Gillum was by statute responsible for” not only the drawings that his firm drafted, but also the resulting shop drawings. Gillum “accepted such responsibility when he entered into the contract and utilized his seal.” The Court rejected Gillum’s every effort to downplay these legal implications of affixing his seal and disown the failed connection. Citing

what it dubbed the “plain and unambiguous language” of Missouri’s “controlling regulatory statutes,” the Court concluded that Gillum’s sealing of the plans made “him responsible for the entire engineering project and all documents connected therewith …” including the design of connections “whether he in fact designs them himself or not.” Bottom line: by stamping the structural drawings without qualification, Gillum was by law responsible for the structure and the collapse. “Custom reconciles us to

everything” – Edmund Burke

Customs are a pervasive and persistent source of law in our “common law” legal system. The Hyatt case is, however, an object lesson on the limitations of those customs as a source of law. It demonstrates how customs do not survive collisions with statutes. The Court rejected Gillum’s argument that “usual and customary engineering practices” entitled him to rely on the fabricator for the design of the box connections because it conflicted with the plain language of Missouri’s engineering practice statute. The lesson is that while custom may have shifted the practical responsibility for the box connection design, it could not have affected a transfer of the legal responsibility, a lesson Gillum learned the hard way. Keep “the main thing the main

thing” – Steven Covey

The Hyatt case demonstrates that not all beams are created equal. Perhaps recognizing its audience, the Court put this in mathematical terms: “the level of care required of a professional engineer is directly proportional to the potential for harm arising from his design …” It was the importance of the box connections that amplified the gap between what the Appellants did, and what they should have done. This importance elevated what the Court said “might [have] constitute[d] inadvertence” had “no danger exist[ed] … to conscious indifference,” i.e., gross negligence, because “the potential danger to human life [wa]s great.” Accordingly, it is not just a good idea for engineers to allocate their scarce design resources with a mind towards the potential for harm; it is the law. This potential for harm matters in at least one other way. It has been said that “nondoctrinal” – legally irrelevant – facts often drive judicial decision-making. The great jurist Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. expressed this as “hard cases make bad law.” Once the Appellants’ gross negligence was established, their discipline (or liability) should not necessarily have been driven by the magnitude of the horror that happened to result. Reading the Court’s opinion, however, and its multiple allusions to the patent danger of the walkways, it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that Gillum, Duncan and GCE left the Court with a particularly “hard case,” which may have factored into the hard result. “Attitude is a little thing that makes

a big difference” – Winston Churchill

The Hyatt case demonstrates the price of admission to the structural engineering profession. Gillum faced discipline not just for gross negligence, but also for what the Court called “unprofessional conduct … in his refusal to accept his responsibility … and his denial that such responsibility existed.” It was not just what he did that mattered, but his attitude and his defense of the allegations against him. The Court noted that Gillum’s “refusal to accept a responsibility so clearly imposed by the [engineering practice] statute manifests both the gross negligence and unprofessional conduct found by the Commission.” The Court agreed with the Commission that Gillum’s “cavalier” attitude about his “responsibilities as an engineer” and his steadfast refusal to admit the responsibility that law imposed on him, as the engineer of record, was a separate and independent breach of his obligations as a professional engineer. The Hyatt case is a grim reminder that whatever may go in hard-nosed commerce outside of the profession will not necessarily pass muster within it, and that the esteem that comes with membership in a learned profession may be hefty. “… Hoist with his own petard… ”

– William Shakespeare

All firms have internal policies; they serve worthy purposes, like managing risk. The Hyatt case demonstrates not the imprudence of these policies, but of adopting them casually. That is because one lesson of the case is that having a policy that you do not follow may be worse than not having it at all. Because, as the Court put it, the Appellants’ “own internal procedures” “called for a detailed check of all special connections” like the box connection; the Court treated their failure to make the check as proof of their negligence. A policy that was (surely) intended to reduce Appellants’ exposure ended up increasing it. Finally, the Hyatt case demonstrates that ambiguity in design injects risk into the shop drawing review process. Though the case involved many missteps, the first was Duncan’s failure to address the box connection design in his drawings. Although Duncan testified that “he intended for the fabricator to design the [box] connections,” his drawings failed to include, for example, the loads that might have communicated his intention to the fabricator. As a result, the fabricator “prepared its shop drawings on the basis that the connections shown on the design drawings had been designed by the structural engineer.” Thus, although either engineer or fabricator could have designed the connection, the ambiguity of the drawings, their failure to express clearly the engineer’s intentions, meant that neither did. Of course, there was still time to rectify this oversight. Nevertheless, the clear lesson is that ambiguity in the design injected tremendous risk into the shop drawing process, a process that is often poorly suited to address significant design decisions.

Conclusion

The Hyatt Regency disaster was a tragedy for the victims and for the engineers involved. In a larger sense though, it was also a tragedy for the structural engineering profession. The best we can do to honor the victims, the engineers involved, and the profession, is to listen to this alarm bell, heed the enduring lessons, and improve our practices. My hope is that this article contributes to that effort.▪

Matthew R. Rechtien, P.E., Esq. (MRechtien@BodmanLaw.com), is an attorney with Bodman PLC in Ann Arbor, Michigan, where he specializes in construction law, commercial litigation, and insurance law. Prior to becoming a lawyer, he practiced structural engineering in Texas for five years.

The facts and quotations in this article are adapted from Duncan v. Missouri Board for Architects, Professional Engineers and Land Surveyors, 744 S.W.2d 524 (Mo. App. E.D. 1988). The full opinion by Missouri’s Court of Appeals is a good read for anyone with further interest in the subject.

Disclaimer: The information and statements contained in this article are for information purposes only and are not legal or other professional advice. Readers should not act or refrain from acting based on this article without seeking appropriate legal or other professional advice as to their particular circumstances. This article contains general information and may not reflect current legal developments, verdicts or settlements; it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

ADAPT Corporation Phone: 650-306-2400 Email: info@adaptsoft.com Web: www.adaptsoft.com Product: ADAPT-Builder Suite Description: For the integrated and effi cient design of concrete buildings. Streamline your process by using one model to run your gravity and lateral designs. Don’t waste time by maintaining separate data for your slab, foundation, column and wall designs. Designs post-tensioned and mild reinforced projects. Seamlessly integrates with Revit Structure.

American Wood Council Phone: 202-463-2766 Email: info@awc.org Web: www.awc.org Product: Connection Calculator Description: Provides users with a webbased approach to calculating capacities for single bolts, nails, lag screws and wood screws per the 2005 NDS. Both lateral (single and double shear) and withdrawal capacities can be determined. Wood-to-wood, wood-to-concrete, and wood-to-steel connections are possible. Product: Span Calculator Description: Performs calculations for ALL species and grades of commercially available softwood and hardwood lumber as found in the NDS 2005 Supplement. Joists and rafter spans for common loading conditions can be determined. A “span options” calculator allows selection of multiple species and grades for comparison purposes.

Bentley Systems Phone: 610-458-5000 Email: katherine.fl esh@bentley.com Web: www.bentley.com Product: STAAD.Pro V8i SELECTseries 5 Description: Analyze and design almost every form of structure, steel & concrete. Enhanced with integration into a wider design workfl ow using Bentleys ISM, leading to substantially quicker and more effi cient design processes. Analyze with linear or a range of non-linear methods, static, dynamic and seismic. Design with codes from around the world. Product: RAM Structural System V8i Release 14.06 Description: Increase your productivity. 64 bit for faster analysis of larger models. Enhanced interoperability with BIM programs. Modeling and visualization enhancements for loads and decks. Expanded implementation of AISC 341 and AISC 358 Seismic design. Enhancements to fl oor framing and lateral analysis and design, for both concrete and steel.

Product: ProStructures V8i SELECTseries 6 Description: Representing a huge step forward for structural engineers, designers, and detailers, ProStructures V8i combines structural steel and reinforced concrete into a single consistent application that does not require a separate CAD platform to run. ProStructures V8i empowers teams to deliver well-designed and high performing structures.

CADRE analytic Phone: 425-392-4309 Email: cadresales@cadreanalytic.com Web: www.cadreanalytic.com Product: CADRE Geo 6.2 Description: Geodesic design application for generating a wide variety of geodesic and spherical models for CAD or FFA applications. Output are clean DXF fi les suitable for structural analysis applications. Produces detail design data for domes such as hub and panel layouts, dimensions, dihedral angles, volume, surface area. Multiple breakdown method supported.

Concrete Masonry Association (CMACN) Phone: 916-722-1700 Email: info@cmacn.org Web: www.cmacn.org Product: CMD12 Description: Structural design of reinforced concrete and clay hollow unit masonry elements. Design of masonry elements in accordance with provisions of Ch. 21 of 1997 UBC, 2001 through 2013 CBC or 2003 through 2012 IBC and 1999 through 2011 Bldg. Code Requirements for Masonry Structures (TMS 402/ACI 530/ASCE 5) CSC Phone: 877-710-2053 Email: sales@cscworld.com Web: www.cscworld.com Product: Fastrak Description: Th e essential design and drafting software for steel buildings. Design simple or complex buildings to US codes. Produce clear and concise documentation including drawings and calculations. Utilize BIM technology to integrate with leading design software. Product: Tedds Description: Powerful software that will automate your daily structural calculations. Access a large library of automated structural calculations to US codes, write your own calculations in Microsoft Word, produce clear and detailed report documentation and also perform powerful 2D frame analysis. Download free trial at the website.

Decon USA Inc. Phone: 866-332-6687 Email: frank@deconusa.com Web: www.deconusa.com Product: JORDAHL® EXPERT Software for Anchor Channels Description: Provides a transparent verifi cation of all calculations for anchoring channels in concrete, based on AC232 and ACI 318, Appendix D criteria. Th e software features design optimization for determining an economical and safe design. Th e JORDAHL EXPERT Software can be downloaded at the website.

Design Data Phone: 402-441-4000 Email: marnett@sds2.com Web: www.sds2connect.com Product: SDS/2 Connect Description: Enables structural engineers using Revit Structure for BIM to intelligently design steel connections and produce detailed documentation on those connections. SDS/2 Connect is the only product that enables structural engineers to design and communicate connections based on their Revit Structure design model as part of the fabrication process.

ALL PAST ISSUES

News, Events, Book Reviews, Letters to the Editor and more!

Devco Software, Inc. Phone: 541-426-5713 Email: rob@devcosoftware.com Web: www.devcosoftware.com Product: LGBEAMER v8 Description: Analyze and design cold-formed cee, channel and zee sections. Uniform, concentrated, partial span and axial loads. Single and multi-member designs. 2007 NASPEC, including the 2010 Supplement (2013 IBC) compliant. Pro-Tools include shearwalls, framed openings, X-braces, joists and rafters.

Digital Canal Corporation Phone: 800-449-5033 Email: glageju@digitalcanal.com Web: www.digitalcanalstructural.com Product: Structural Software Updates Description: Digital Canal released 7 upgrades that likely apply to you. Th ese include the latest Design Code upgrades for: Retaining Wall, Masonry Wall, Wind Analysis, Concrete Beam, Concrete Colum, Pile Cap and VersaFrame. Steel Design 14th Edition is expected soon. Visit the website for free trials.

FabTrol Systems, Inc. Phone: 541-485-4719 Email: info@fabtrol.com Web: www.fabtrol.com Product: FabTrol Pro Description: Steel Fabrication Management Software

Hilti, Inc. Phone: 800-879-8000 Email: us-sales@hilti.com Web: www.us.hilti.com Product: PROFIS Anchor and PROFIS DF Description: Hilti off ers two design programs for structural engineers. PROFIS Anchor performs anchor design for cast-in-place and Hilti post-installed anchors using ACI 318, Appendix D provisions. PROFIS DF Diaphragm optimizes design of steel deck roof and fl oor diaphragms using the SDI Diaphragm Design Manual, 3rd Edition provisions.

IES, Inc. Phone: 800-707-0816 Email: sales@iesweb.com Web: www.iesweb.com Product: ShapeBuilder Description: Architect asking for fl air? Fabricator all out of square? Contractor breaking your plan? Th en you need ShapeBuilder man!

Losch Software Ltd Phone: 323-592-3299 Email: LoschInfo@gmail.com Web: www.LoschSoft.com Product: LECWall Description: Concrete column and sandwich wall panel design and analysis with mild or prestressed reinforcement. Includes a complete handling check.

MDX Software Phone: 573-446-3221 Email: info@mdxsoftware.com Web: www.mdxsoftware.com Product: MDX Software Curved and Straight Steel Bridge Design and Rating Description: Steel bridge design & rating software for AASHTO ASD, LFD, LRFD, LRFR specs. Nemetschek Scia Phone: 877-808-7242 Email: info@scia-online.com Web: www.nemetschek-scia.com Product: Scia Engineer – Updated Description: Looking to migrate to, or improve your 3D design workfl ows? Scia Engineer links structural modeling, analysis, design, drawings, and reports in one workfl ow. Design to multiple codes. Tackle larger projects with advanced non-linear and dynamic analysis. Plug into BIM with IFC, and bidirectional links to Revit, Tekla, and others.

Onset Phone: 508-759-5900 Email: sales@onsetcomp.com Web: www.onsetcomp.com Product: HOBOlink Description: Onset’s enhanced HOBOlink web-enabled software platform provides 24/7 data access and remote management for Onset’s web-based HOBO U30 data logging systems. Users can schedule automatic delivery of exported data fi les via email or FTP and have the fl exibility to confi gure data export in a highly customized way.

Opti-Mate, Inc. Phone: 610-530-9031 Email: optimate@enter.net Web: www.opti-mate.com Product: Bridge Engineering Software Description: Software for straight and curved steel bridges, trusses and sign structures with AASHTO code checks. Software titles include Merlin Dash, Descus, TRAP and SABRE.

Pile Dynamics, Inc. Phone: 216-831-6131 Email: info@pile.com Web: www.pile.com/pdi Product: GRLWEAP Description: GRLWEAP Wave Equation Analysis of Piles: simulates pile driving, predicts driving stresses, hammer performance, the relation between bearing capacity and net set per blow and total driving time. Helps select job-adequate hammers. 800+ preprogrammed hammers, several analysis options. Off shore Piles version available. Codes may allow leaner design with GRLWEAP analysis. POSTEN Engineering Systems Phone: 510-275-4750 Email: sales@postensoft.com Web: www.postensoft.com Product: POSTEN Multistory Description: Built with LEED in mind, whether 64 bit or 32 bit, POSTEN Multistory’s many advanced & proprietary algorithms simplify Post-tensioning while actually designing the structure (as opposed to merely analyzing your design) with effi cient use concrete & steel (as opposed to merely Code Compliance).

Powers Fasteners Phone: 985-807-6666 Email: jack.zenor@sbdinc.com Web: www.powers.com Product: Powers Design Assist 360 Online Description: Online Software to design to ACI 318 Appendix D.

RISA Technologies Phone: 949-951-5815 Email: info@risa.com Web: www.risa.com Product: RISAFloor Description: Designs and optimizes building systems constructed of steel (composite and noncomposite), concrete, wood and CFS, as well as combinations of materials. Automatic live load reduction, additive or exclusive fl oor area loads, vibration calculations and more make RISAFloor the fi rst choice for the design of all types of building systems.

S-FRAME Software Phone: 203-421-4800 Email: info@s-frame.com Web: www.s-frame.com Product: S-FOUNDATION Description: Quickly design, analyze and detail isolated, combined, continuous, wall, and strap footings, as well as mat and pile foundations, in one complete program. S-FOUNDATION automatically generates, manages and solves the underlying FE model. Reports include all results, material totals, intermediate calculations, equations employed and design clauses. BIM Links. continued on next page

All Resource Guides and Updates for the 2014 Editorial Calendar are now available on the website, www.STRUCTUREmag.org. Listings are provided as a courtesy. STRUCTURE® magazine is not responsible for errors.

Simpson Strong-Tie Phone: 925-560-9000 Email: web@strongtie.com Web: www.strongtie.com Product: Simpson Strong-Tie® Holdown Selector Web App Description: Holdowns are typically used to prevent shearwall segments from overturning. The Simpson Strong-Tie Holdown Selector is a quick and easy tool that selects the optimum solution based on the type of installation, factored load and the species of the post. Visit the website to use the app. Product: Simpson Strong-Tie® Anchor Designer™ Software Description: The latest anchorage design tool for structural engineers. It quickly and accurately analyzes an existing design or suggests anchorage solutions based upon user-defined design elements in cracked and uncracked concrete conditions. The real-time design features a fullyinteractive 3D graphic user interface. Product: Simpson Strong-Tie® Literature Library Mobile App Description: It’s easy to take Simpson Strong-Tie catalogs with you. With the new and improved version of the Literature Library app, you can access all Simpson Strong-Tie catalogs, fliers and technical bulletins on your mobile devices. Download the app and start customizing your “library.” Visit the website to download the app.

SPACE GASS Phone: 559-897-5697 Email: steve@spacegass.com Web: www.spacegass.com Product: SPACE GASS 12 Description: Contains new super fast analysis and graphics engines, making it one of the fastest structural analysis programs around. Large models of 10,000 nodes or more analyze in just a few seconds, and you can view your fully rendered results in smooth real-time with the new graphics engine.

Standards Design Group, Inc. Phone: 800-366-5585 Email: info@standardsdesign.com Web: www.standardsdesign.com Product: Wind Loads on Structures 4 Description: Performs computations in ASCE798, 02 or 05, Section 6 and ASCE7-10, Chapters 26-31. Computes wind loads by analytical method rather than simplified method, provides basic wind speeds from a built-in version of wind speed, allows user to enter wind speed, has numerous specialty calculators. Product: Window Glass Design 5 Description: Performs all required calculations to design window glass according to ASTM E 1300-09. This software also performs window glass design using ASTM E 1300 02/03/04, ASTM E 1300-98/00 and ASTM E 1300-94. GANA endorses WGD5 as best tool available in designing window glass to resist wind and longterm loadings.

Strand7 Pty Ltd Phone: 252-504-2282 Email: anne@beaufort-analysis.com Web: www.strand7.com Product: Strand7 Description: An advanced, general purpose, FEA system used worldwide by engineers, designers, and analysts for a wide range of structural analysis applications. It comprises preprocessing, solvers (linear and nonlinear static and dynamic capabilities) and postprocessing. Features include staged construction, quasi-static solver for shrinkage and creep/relaxation problems.

StrucSoft Solutions Phone: 514-731-0008 Email: info@strucsoftsolutions.com Web: www.strucsoftsolutions.com Product: MWF Advanced Floor Description: Extend the power and reach of Revit® & MWF with MWF Advanced Floor. This upgrade to the popular framing extension allows engineers and estimators to engineer and determine optimum joists for their projects. Take advantage of a finite element analysis engine and the almost limitless configurations you expect from MWF.

Structural Engineers Inc. Phone: 540-731-3330 Email: tmmurray@floorvibe.com Web: www.floorvibe.com Product: FloorVibe v2.10 Description: Proposed floor designs can be analyzed to determine if they meet the human tolerance limits in the AISC Design Guide 11 Floor Vibrations due to Human Activity using FloorVibe. Floor framing can be hot-rolled, build-up sections, or joists. Expert advice is provided for all required input and for results.

All Resource Guides and Updates for the 2014

Editorial Calendar are now available on the website, www.STRUCTUREmag.org. Listings are provided as a courtesy. STRUCTURE® magazine is not responsible for errors. StructurePoint Phone: 847-966-4357 Email: info@structurepoint.org Web: www.StructurePoint.org Product: Reinforced Concrete Analysis and Design Programs Description: PCA’s concrete design suite is now: spSlab, spColumn, spMats, spWall, spBeam & spFrame. Formerly pcaSlab, pcaColumn, pcaMats, pcaWall, pcaBeam & pcaFrame. These programs are widely used for analysis, design & investigation of reinforced concrete buildings, bridges and structures. The programs provide support for ACI 318 and CSA A23.3 standards.

Struware, LLC Phone: 904-302-6724 Email: email@struware.com Web: www.struware.com Product: Struware Code Search Description: Provides easy to use updated structural engineering software. So quick and easy the software will pay for itself the first time you use it. Programs include Code Search (wind, seismic, snow, dead & live loadings), CMU walls, tilt-up concrete walls, floor vibration and concrete beams. Demos at the webiste.

USP Structural Connectors Phone: 952-898-8772 Email: info@uspconnectors.com Web: www.uspconnectors.com Product: USP Specifier™ Description: Simplifies the access to information on over 3,000 structural connectors through an intuitive and graphical desktop interface. Looking up connector capacities, viewing code evaluation reports and even mapping from competitor products to USP products are a snap with just a couple of clicks. Download Specifier today from the website.

WoodWorks® Software Phone: 800-844-1275 Email: sales@woodworks-software.com Web: www.woodworks-software.com Product: Design Office 10 Suite Description: Wood Engineering software: Conforms to IBC 2012, ASCE 7-10, NDS 2012, SDPWS 2008; SHEARWALLS: designs perforated and segmented shearwalls; generates loads; rigid and flexible diaphragm distribution methods. SIZER: designs beams, columns, studs, joists up to 6 spans; automatic load patterning. CONNECTIONS: Wood to: wood, steel or concrete.