Taxmann's Indirect Tax Laws (IDT) | CRACKER

Contents % ' !

0

Chapter-wise Marks Distribution

I-5

Previous Exams Trend Analysis (May 2018 Onward) (New Syllabus) Chapter-wise Comparison with Study Material

I-7 I-13

PART I GOODS & SERVICES TAX N O I T C U D O R T N I N !

A I D N ) N I 4 3 '

Chapter 1

1.3

4 3 ' R E D N U Y L P P U 3

Chapter 2

2.1

4 3 ' F O S E G R A H #

Chapter 3

3.1

4 3 ' F O S N O I T P M E X %

Chapter 4

4.1

Y L P P U S F O E C A L 0

Chapter 5

5.1

Y L P P U S F O E M I 4

Chapter 6

6.1

Y L P P U S F O E U L A 6

Chapter 7

7.1

T I D E R C X A T T U P N )

Chapter 8

8.1

N O I T A R T S I G E 2

Chapter 9

9.1

S E T O N T I B E D D N A T I D E R C E C I O V N I X A 4

Chapter 10

10.1

L L I " Y A W %

S D R O C E R D N A S T N U O C C !

Chapter 11

11.1

I-15

% ' !

0

Chapter 12

X A T F O T N E M Y A 0

12.1

Chapter 13

S N R U T E 2

13.1

Chapter 14

D N U F E 2

14.1

Chapter 15

K R O W B O *

15.1

Chapter 16

E C R E M M O C C I N O R T C E L %

16.1

Chapter 17

T I D U A D N A T N E M S S E S S !

17.1

Chapter 18

T S E R R A D N A E R U Z I E S H C R A E S N O I T C E P S N )

18.1

Chapter 19

Y R E V O C E R D N A S D N A M E $

19.1

Chapter 20

S E S A C N I A T R E C N I Y A P O T Y T I L I B A I ,

20.1

Chapter 21

S E I T L A N E P D N A S E C N E F F /

21.1

Chapter 22

N O I S I V E R D N A S L A E P P !

22.1

Chapter 23

G N I L U R E C N A V D !

23.1

Chapter 24

S N O I S I V O R P S U O E N A L L E C S I -

24.1

Chapter 25

Y T U D S M O T S U C M O R F S N O I T P M E X E F O Y V E ,

Chapter 26

Y T U D F O S E P Y 4

Chapter 27

S D O O G D E T R O P X E D N A D E T R O P M I F O N O I T A C I F I S S A L #

Chapter 28

T C !

S M O T S U # E H T R E D N U N O I T A U L A 6

28.1

27.1

26.1

25.3

Chapter 29

S D O O G F O N O I T A T R O P S N A R T D N A N O I T A T R O P X E N O I T A T R O P M )

29.1

3 4 . % 4 . / #

I-16

CUSTOMS & FTP PART II

3 4 . % 4 . / #

I-17 % ' !

0

G N I S U O H E R A 7

Chapter 30

30.1

K C A B W A R D Y T U $

Chapter 31

31.1

D N U F E 2

Chapter 32

32.1

Y C I L O 0 E D A R 4 N G I E R O &

Chapter 33

Solved Paper: May 2022

33.1 P.1

C

5

H

A

P

T

E

R

Place of Supply

5.1 PLACE OF SUPPLY IN CASE OF SUPPLY OF GOODS (SECTIONS 10 AND 11 OF IGST ACT, 2017) 5.1.1 Movement of Goods [Section 10(1)(a)/(b)] Q. 1.

Asha Enterprises, supplier of sewing machines, is located in Kota (Rajasthan) and registered for purpose of GST in the said State. It receives an order from Deep Traders, located in Jalandhar (Punjab) and registered for the purpose of GST in the said State. The order is for the supply of 100 sewing machines with an instruction to ship the sewing machines to Jyoti Sons, located in Patiala (Punjab) and registered in the said State for purpose of GST. Jyoti Sons is a customer of Deep Traders. Sewing machines are being shipped in a lorry by Asha Enterprises.

TAXMANN®

Briefly explain the following: (a) the place of supply under IGST Act, 2017; (b) the nature of supply:- whether inter-State or intra-State and (c) Whether CGST/SGST or IGST as would be applicable in this case.

Statutory Provisions

10(1)(a)

NATURE OF SUPPLY

PLACE OF SUPPLY

T I A M ERT N MEE T I I T S P I EDC O HO E T R G TF E A H SOT DTO ONO OET GMY ER EV E HO V T I L FME O ED R NHO OTF I HS T A CE CI T OHA ,WN RN EE O IS VL OP R MPE UP ESR HEE T H HT STO E Y VBY L N RA OE VH Y NT I EB YH R L O WT P P N USE SDI P EOI HOC G T E FR EO E R TH E N T HE R 7MO

Section (IGST Act)

S D O O ' F O T N E M E V O F O E S A # N I Y L P P U 3 F O E C A L 0 R O F

[May 2019, Old, 4 Marks]

Ans.

-

-

10(1)(b)

H C U S F O S S E N I S U B F O E C A L P L A N PO I S CR NE I P R PD ER HI 4H T ENRDE E H HI ET OF T S M T D N OC EE E T AE R R V DI D T I EDF E EC R EOB E E HY L VT LR I LNAA S E HA DOWS H N TN EOYI R SBE O A R NSS R SEOI DPSWE OYRRP E N E OA D PH GR R TI DO EO H R HTH I RT T O N E EETEHS

E I R T L P D E HT TO I I T T HC A O FO FH EO 7R TG

.

i

The place of supply

S I S D O O G N HO CI UC T SE DF I 3 O; A S Y N ELO P HP S T R U E TS A FP HO H T EC CU AS L F P O ES HS T E SD N I I TNS I A U

YSB= L DF P

POO UOE C SGA T HEL C CHP! UTA L S 4 P3 F I O C ' N) E I S R E A PH C T EF N HO ) T

In the given case:

deemed

third person

has received

b

N A H T S A J A

2

S E S I R P R E T N % A H S !E NB EL EL WI TW E B BA YJ L N P U P0 U SS FR O E ED CA AR L 4 P P EE HE T S$ UD HN 4A

Jalandhar, Punjab

5.1

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.2

For first Supply:

S E T A T 3 T N E R E F F I D O W T N I E R A B A J N U 0

Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H T

The nature of supply

N A S I Y L P P U S

T C !

inter-State supply

Y L P P U S R E H T O N A

S E V L O V N I N O I T A U T I S S I H 4

For Second Supply:

S N O 3 I T O Y * D N A B A J N U 0 R A H D N A L A *

S R E D A R 4 P E E $ N E E W T E B

DE4 NH3 AT' ) N E A H H T T F S O A J

A N 2

O I R T E C I E L S P P F O U S S F M O R N E T O I N T I A C O L E H T E C N I 3

ii

T N E M E V O M S E V L O V N I Y L P P U S E H T E C N I S E S A C S I H T N )

B A J N U 0 A L A I T A 0

E H T T A S D O O G E H T F O N O I T A C O L E H T E B L L I W Y L P P U S F O E C A L P S D O O G F O O4 T 3 Y' R ) E VE I H L ET DF RO O F S E

T

A

N I MN O RI E T T SC DE O3 O; G F O T N E M E V O M EE

HI

T HT CN I E H I P WI TC A E ER E MH IT T

=

T C !

Patiala Punjab

For Second Supply:

Ans.

Statutory Provisions: Please refer Q. 1 Raman Row Enterprises

Nero

Place of Kolkata supply

GST

Aurangabad Inter State

4 3 ' ) O T E L B A I L Y L P P U S

iii

Inter-State

4 3 ' ) O T E L B A I L Y L P P U S

Nature

Fabri-

-

E G R A HE

C I D L

U O H S W O 2N NO A M A 2

ii

Nero Enterprises cana

EI E MMI

IRT T E N ETE HSI T P DI TO C A OE SGR D E OFH OOT GTO ENT HEY M T R EE FV V O OL I N E OMD I T ER A CHO OTF L S NE EET HHA 4WN

i

Supply between

D AA T A B KA L G O N +A R U !

Raman Row, a registered supplier under GST in Mumbai, is directed by Nero Enterprises, Kolkata to deliver goods valued at ` 12,00,000 to Fabricana of Aurangabad in Maharashtra.

Raman Row makes out an invoice at 9% tax rate under CGST and SGST respectively (scheduled rate) and delivers it locally in Maharashtra. Discuss and comment on the above levy of tax and determine the tax liability of goods in the above circumstances.

[May 2018 Old, 4 Marks] A T A IK A L BO M+ U

Q. 2.

TAXMANN®

For first Supply: IGST

A R T N I N A S I T I S A 4 3 ' 3 D N A 4 3 ' # O T E L B A I ,

Y L P P U S E T A T 3

CGST/SGST or IGST

Y L P P U S E T A T 3 R E T N I N A S I T I S A

iii

a

18% 18% IGST

IGST

`

`

Place of supply [Based on IGST Act, 2017] Q. 3.

R E D N U S A E B L L A H S Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H 4

EO HN T S I SE DR OE OH GT FE O C TI N N E3

MT N EE VI OP I MC E ER VE L O H VT NO I T TY O R NE V SI E L OE DD F YO L P E PM UI ST EE HH T T FT I A TS C D !O 4O 3G 'F )O N EO HI T T A FC O O L E H T

S I Y NL OP I P T U C ES 3F RO E E PC A SL !P

Ans.

Quickdeal Enterprises (Ahmednagar, Gujarat) opens a new branch office at Hissar, Haryana.

It purchases a building for office from Ruhani Builders (Hissar) along with pre-installed office furniture and fixtures. Determine place of supply of the pre-installed office furniture, and fixtures.

(MTP May, 2018 Marks) c

S I S D O O G H C U S F O Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H T E S A C N E V I G E H T N I S E R U T X I F D N A E R U T I N R U F E C I F F O F O T N E M E V O M Q. 4.

A N A Y R A ( R A S S I (

S E S I R P R E T N % L A E D K C I U 1

T N E I P I C E R E H T O T Y R E V I L E D F O E M I T E H T T A N O I T A C O L R I E H T

i.e.,

Parth of Pune, Maharashtra enters into an agreement to sell goods to Bakul of Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh. While the goods were being packed in Pune godown of Parth, Bakul got an order from Shreyas of Shimoga, Karnataka for the said goods. Bakul agreed to supply the said goods to Shreyas and asked Parth to deliver the goods to Shreyas at Shimoga.

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

A G O M I H 3

S A Y E R H 3

Karnataka

Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh

A K A T LA U N KR AA "+

L U K A "

H T R A 0

(b) In given case:

Y L P P U S A T O N S I Y T I V I T C A D I A S E H T S N O I S I V O R P D E N O I T N E M E V O B A E H T F O W E I V N )

Y T I L I B A E G R A H C R O F T N E V E E L B A X A T E H T S I v Y L P P U S h E C N I S 4 3 ' O T E L B A I V E L T O N S I T I

E4 C3 N' EF (O

E S A C N E V I G E H T N I E S I R A T O N S E O D Y L P P U S F O E C A L P F O N O I T S E U Q E H T S U H 4

5.2 LOCATION OF THE SUPPLIER OF SERVICE AND THE LOCATION OF THE RECIPIENT OF THE SERVICE IS IN INDIA (SECTION 12)

5.2.1 Services Related to Immovable Property [Section 12(3)]

TAXMANN®

3 5 N I R E M O T S U C A O T D E I L P P U S Y L T C E R I D E R E W A N I H # M O R F D E R U C O R P S D O O G E H 4

R NEO I H STC T E FA T O A R T S T 3 N MO

RC F EE L SH A I TTHH YF NCE T OIUB R SS E PHDFI OCEOH RAN T PEIEN M C ENRNI I L D E E B T S E AEE BB VDDA I R OARE C MMO S HE MSDTR IAENP EDTIE C EE HT RB T LOY L AO EE D R C R RA E T YAM H G S L S E E 7IT A EARS CR S I I S AIA V H P R T B EN E S S E IL FSOB E O TA CN I N YV IO L P R DS PEEA R USE E SRT R R EONE F EH HE T TT U N O L EH A VMC EEU E HR S T GN OA O T RT NO N OT E I T C M R AE OR PT E ONR ROG PCA

SNE4 E 3 COH' T I I N V F) 5O R E E SH S S IT E S FT F O AAO B TT N 3E ET HE I L P NTU I E 2 C N R EE O; R F S DFDI E I E ND R T A O U RNPT I I E R I R DME L O PI EC T PL N UP SO SPI I EU N D HSE 5 T ST

NEA E CC EI T A EV OT L WR 3 TESH I S E B C YA F T TO R E N E EEP N MUOI L RG EA N EVPI R Y EL EL G ATB Y A AR T RN VE OO O I TT P C RMO AO R R PMP T OIE N L OREB CPHA AETV FHEO R T O E HM E M CD NRWI EA E G S S BEEH T R I AS R F = O O EI S T H E I HT AL R T EU R R NNT ) IEA2

R TE N H ET MO DN NA EO MT A Y I !RD ON T I 4R ) 3R O T 'EN T #E I L G EB N HA I T R XE EA T DT N I V N E )OS ) N D ) EO EH L O U TG DNH EIC HEU CCS 3A LT DPU I AO A H S MT EOI HR W T F Y SR ND I O DOI T EOR DGR DFE AOT YL E NL B EP EPA BUX A SST A YN HE L O MN AE NH T N I E C TA C L !!P

R E H T I E N E B L L A H S H C I H W S E I T I V I T C A

S NS

OE I T C C I V AR S E NS AF R T O SY E L lP I P C EU PS SR O N S D O O G F O Y L P P U S S A D E T A E R T

F Y E O R VE NO V I OML I E T A ED CH R OT O L E

ENFI E S HH E T S T A SWAY I ENE Y IR M M L H IR P 3 PTE

UETT SHSN FTDI E T O O A P O I ESG C CD E AOFR O L OT P E G H N EEE T HH O MT 4T DHSF ECSO V EE U N I S I E C S CFU A EOB L Y R P L SP FE A POH HU E LS CT U AY KFL AOP L E G LN "C A EAP I D HL IR PC T EN T O H A I CE HTRC P D T B DNE!L L H EAT I LW MSS U D IKY EO EO SAL D"P DG SEO P I OFU HG T OS T )

new activity

Schedule III to the CGST Act

of

-

Place supply

Bareilly

Bareilly

Pune

Supply between

located in

As per Section 12(3) of IGST Act, 2017 :more than one State

Ans.

The place of supply in relation to immovable property is the location of immovable property.

Suppose a road is constructed from Delhi to Mumbai covering multiple states. What will be the place of supply of construction services?

[Nov. 2019, 5 Marks]

Q. 6.

(a) Statutory Provision:

Ans.

Mr. Z, a supplier registered in Hyderabad (Telangana), procures goods from China and directly supplies the same to a customer in US. With reference to the provisions of GST law, examine whether the said activity of supply of goods by Mr. Z to customer in US is taxable under GST. [RTP, Nov. 2019] If yes, determine the place of supply of the same.

Q. 5.

Statutory Provisions: Please refer Q. 1 Ans.

5.3 You are required to determine the place of both supplies in the above situation.

[RTP, Nov. 2018/Nov. 19]

Shimoga 5.1.2 Import/Export of Goods (Section 11)

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.4

EXAMINER’S COMMENT In case I, some examinees were not aware that the place of supply of services directly in relation to an immovable property located outside India, where service provider and service recipient are located in India is the location of recipient in terms of section 12(3) of the IGST Act, 2017. Resultantly, they wrong answered the place of supply to be the location of immovable property.

Q. 7.

Place of Supply of services Whether Goods and Service tax is leviable on the following services an interior decorator provides service of beautification of spaces in Srinagar.

Ans.

Ans:

ER NSC OII I4 I M3 TYV T A R R H' L E E S E S P A O R O F +T NR O E I L D YPY B L N E L A P T L A I C L EBP A U U E R VS I B OFML D L DMOMA AH E E* DMC S I I AFS V EL OE P OR C RE 4I E PH V H5R SWT E E ES CEEH I S C S TI V A A R H L GT C E P NS S NI EE FH DU O VUH TTILT G C C EE ND PBEIN H L SA A LT A E IY N D R H R NSINO I T YE)I R F R LO O R PF E E PE T URLE O 3 E L HB TFH C A !O4WX E OA D 4C ETT 3A T S F 'LA E O I )0CL T FEOP I O HLPB T EAM YB4 A

TO3E R T E H NPD'T OOE N R D I R I T A PNG H C T EEEA I T 3L NW N B I I RA S E RRL L PVO3A SO EF D B !ME H T MA LI C L IC A HH OO T LSW

(Modified 2 Marks, May 2005)

5.2.2 Event Management Services [Section 12(7) of IGST Act, 2017] Q. 8. Mr. Murthy, an unregistered person and a resident of Pune, hires the services of M/s. Sun Ltd. and event management company registered in Delhi, for organising of the new product launch in Bengaluru. (i) Determine the place of supply of services provided by M/s. Sun Ltd.

Ans.

E YR L P A PR UE SI L FP O P EU CS AD L P N EA HT T N FE O I P NC I OE I T R A H NT I MO RB E N T E E DH RW OP F I SH E S DR I O V OS RN POS P HS W CF O I L OL H O WGF NS I A N GE I S B S L A L I FW O Y YL AP WP U YS BF DO EE DC I A V L OP RE PH S4 E CA

I V I RR D E EN PS ) SFN !O I

TAXMANN®

(ii) What would your answer be in case the product launch takes place in Bangkok? (iii) What would your answer be in case Mr. Murthy is a registered person and product launches take place in Bengaluru and Bangkok?

[May 2018, 5 Marks] Section 12(7) of IGST Act, 2017

E

I D L E H Y L L A U T C A S I T N E V E E R E H W E C A L 0

E

I T N E I P I C E R E H T F O N O I T A C O L

event

held

event

unregistered held outside India registered

Pune

S HE T O K A BT NH I C

N U A L T C

EUK

O D I K OG NR OP N SR A R E" E HD PT HE N CHA U U SWR

Z FI U O L V A EG NS OA N I E T C A E" CH N OT I L N O S R E P

Q. 9.

unregistered India Bengaluru

A S I E C I V R E S F O T N E I P I C E R F )

iii

N A S I E C I V S I R E S F O TD N N EA I P N I C O ES R R E FP )

ii

Place of supply

N AN SI I E C I V S I R E S F O TD N N EA I P N I C O ES R R E FP )

i

Pune

Determine the place of supply for the following independent cases under the IGST Act, 2017: (i) Grand Gala Events, an event management company at Kolkata, organises two award functions for Kalyan Jewellers of Chennai (Registered in Chennai) at New Delhi and at Singapore. (ii) Perfect Planners (Bengaluru) is hired by Dr. Kelvin (unregistered person based in Kochi) to plan and organise his son’s wedding at Mumbai.

Will your answer be different if the wedding is to take place at Malaysia?

[May 2018, Nov. 18 Old, 2½ x 2 = 5 Marks] i

Statutory Provision

Place of supply

SD E N NE H E T OI Z I HS T N# I C S NA E UGNS FRIA DODC E E RR E R A A H E WE T T S AR H I T EOG EO HPR T A B EG I N S N S R I A Y E L C3L P NDLP ENEU W VA ES I I* G F H O EL NE HE A T C YA N$L I L W A EE+P C. I NT RA I ON 3 A F F DO AE ZR I N EO N T AS I T IA GG R EC OR O FA L O E YOH ATT WDS E I YI DY BV L P EOP CR I PU V SS R I E F TO S N NE E EV C HE A L 7NP

T A N E FNI O O P SI NR C OE E I PR T

Ans.

As per section 12(7)(a)(i) of IGST Act, 2017 :-

-

location of Kalyan Jewellers i.e., Chennai

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

Statutory Provision

Place of supply

TSN Y I N L O P ETI I T P N P A U EC I S C VO EE F L R O E EDH E

E CN C

I A ATI V S L D E I R P

L D E I Y E E S EL H T H P R EE N T Y P HT L E L = U T I S A A S I P EG I I FU S S C T E O Y A C E AR CREA L NNCS A F EUAI T -O L VSP N ; N I I G O AE V I E=I T HN IDE A T V NE R C H E NL) O E T V I L N E+IE E E CR DR E W H L N$ T EH O I S 3 ;HW ( I F NDNEO H EI OR OT I T ETFE A ZTAIC C S A I D I L O N G P N L AE

A T E GR E N H R D H E ONTE L T I FUS P IH N O I A C YAYYI E L D L AOP R L NF A WTP ) O YDUU BESTEN C D D FAI EI O O SI CV ST T I O I A V RETUC R PCNOO E A EDL SSP L V NI E L ETEEE H HNH EHT E T HSI S 7V T IY ENE TP L NORN S E AR EP HV EW FP U O ES

ii

5.5

As per section 12(7)(a)(ii) of IGST Act, 2017 :-

Mumbai

if the wedding is to take place outside India Kochi

YEN AHI O WTT EA YR C BE O L SHE E H CWT I NS V O R I I E TY S A L FCP O OP L U YE S L P HF PT U O S E SI C FNA

O L

OP

SE ER

CE

A LPHT T P AC EDI !

HED R T N4 E TS T)3 A E I ' HG D) T I ES F ER R NTO A UU W O D ANL TAE

O OH NTS I EDT R E N E DE N I WV VO I SOET E REC EP E H NTT S I FF MNI O AED XVNS EEAM R DE ENL T MAE N OFHI SO T NY LN L OA E I T I U P TATI R Z C C I A AE PNS R A I BGT E URN H SOE T FVO F NO E )

EXAMINER’S COMMENT

ii

E CI

AH L C P EO K+ AF T O OD T A S E IT GS NI N I D A DS I EY WA L EA HT FE I YB L O P T PY UL SP F P OU ES CF AO L P E C EA HL T P RE OH F T SD E E R I N U O QT I EN R SE NM OY I T L S G E N UO QR EW R Y E E HH WT YI A L T S N Y A A TA L L U SE T 2A

a ii

Q. 10. Damani Industries has recruited Super Events Pvt. Ltd., an event management company of Gujarat, for organising the grand party for the launch of its new product at Bangalore. Damani Industries is registered in Mumbai. Determine the place of supply of the services provided by Super Events Pvt. Ltd. to Damani Industries.

Section 12(7)(a)(i) of IGST Act, 2017

-

SI UA DB NM ) U IN A M E AI S $E RI OR T F S DU ED Z N I ) N I AN GA R OM SA I $ EF R OO L N A O GI NT AA C "O TL A E YH T T R S A I PY HL P CP NU US A LF TO C E UC DA OL RP P I EA HB T M EU S A CNN EI VD I E G R E ET HS T I G NE I R

ES CE NI I R 3 T -

E

I E M A S E H T N I A M E R L L I W R E

I WA SB N AM EU HT IS A E I BR UT S $U TD A N ) DI EN S I A N AM GA R $ OF S IO YN T O R I T A A PC HO CL NE H UT AS L I TY C L UP DP OU RS PF EO HE T C EA S L A P CE H NT ) Q. 11. The ADINA GROUP being an event organizer located at New Delhi organized MISS INDIA 2022 beauty pageant in India in the following cities for M/s. PCC MISS INDIA, who is an unregistered person, on 1st July, 2022: City

New Delhi

No. of days Fee in `

Chennai

Kolkata

15

20

25

15 Crores

20 Crores

25 Crores

Total 60 60 Crores

Required: (A) Find the place of supply of service if contract specifies clear details.

Ans.

(B) Find the place of supply of service it contract specifies lump sum amount of 50 Crores.

(A) The place of supply of service if contract specifies clear details:

I A N N E H #

4 3 ' )

A T A K L O +

4 3 ' )

4 3 ' 4 5

4 3 ' 3

4 3 ' #

I H L E $ W E .

I H L E $ W E .

Total

I H L E $ W E .

Kolkata

Location of Place of supply of Nature of GST supplier of service (where the service respective event is held) I H L E $ W E .

Chennai

` In crore

New Delhi

No. of days

City

TAXMANN®

O R P S I T N E V E N A F O N O I T

A T ZN I E N I AP GI C R E OR FF O O YN AO WT I A YC BO EL CE I H V T R E S I S Y NL EP HP WU S F O E C A L P N O S R E P D E R E T S I G E R A O T D E D I V

Ans.

Will your answer be different if the product launch party is organised at Dubai?

[RTP, Nov. 2018] Solution.

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.6

(B) The place of supply of service if contract specifies lump sum amount of 50 crores.

4 3 ' 4 5

4 3 ' 3

4 3 ' # 4 3 ' )

GST

4 3 ' )

50.00

A T A K L O +

I H L E $ W E .

60

Place of supply of service = where the respective event is held I A N N E H #

I H L E $ W E .

No. of days

I H L E $ W E .

I H L E $ W E .

Total

Kolkata

Chennai

Location of supplier of service

New Delhi

` In crore

City

5.2.3 Miscellaneous Services: Services Related to an Immovable Property Section 12(3), Admission to an Event 12(6) & Event Management Services 12(7) Q. 12. Musicera Pvt. Ltd., owned by Nitish Daani - a famous classical singer- wishes to organise a ‘Nitish Daani Music Concert’ in Gurugram (Haryana). Musicera Pvt. Ltd. (registered in Ludhiana, Punjab) enters into a contract with an event management company, Supriya (P) Ltd. (registered in Delhi) for organising the said music concert at an agreed consideration of ` 10,00,000. Supriya (P) Ltd. books the lawns of Hotel Dumdum, Gurugram (registered in Haryana) for holding the music concert, for a lump sum consideration of ` 4,00,000. Musicera Pvt. Ltd. fixes the entry fee to the music concert at ` 5,000. 400 tickets for ‘Nitish Daani Music Concert’ are sold.

TAXMANN®

You are required to determine the CGST and SGST or IGST liability, as the case may be, in respect of the supplies involved in the given scenario.

Will your answer be different if the price per ticket is fixed at ` 450?

Ans.

D E V L O V N I E R A S E I L P P U S E E R H T N O I T A U T I S N E V I G E H T N )

Note: Rate of CGST and SGST is 9% each and IGST is 18%. All the amounts given above are exclusive of taxes, wherever applicable.

[RTP May 2019] Place of supply

Haryana

E RFAH O E T S Y E FA B O W L Y L L Y A P H PB S UD T SE N OE FD T O I V V NE EO O CR L I AP A SR L S P I U SM T E EC L HI DU 4V AC

-

inter alia,

IGST @ 18% on value of supply

E H T S I S E C I

V E R

I E S T FN O E I P YI L C P PE UR SE H FT O F EO C ANB L O A P I J T N A EC U HO 0 4L

=

T E K C I T R E P

T E K C I T

;

place where the event is actually held.

Ludhiana

`

`

IGST @ 18% on value of supply

IBE L H AB LJ E A I $NV UE L R0E E AB I L L PNI A L PI UHW D SU 4 3 E, H ' T Y) FP L S O E T NPA OUT S I 3 FT T A O N CEE OC R L AE EL F F HPI E T D HN ET CD I E NN I R 3 AA

F S RO I E G S Y E FA R O W A Y L O Y E P T H PBFT T

UDO NS SE EI FD NVN O I OEO V I L S EO T A R A CR R E Z AP U P I L T N P D L SA U E E EC GC R HI R E 4V OAT

Services Section 12 7 a i of IGST provided by Act, 2017 :Supriya (P) Ltd. to Musicera Pvt. inter alia, Ltd. by way of organising the location music concert. of such person

T RYN L EP I E L P R P E UF PS F UFI SOD E ECN I A HL

E TP EL R EA B FH A OT I V DAE NNN L OAA E I YB T B RL AA L JAI CN (W OU L 0 4 EAM3 HN A TA R' G) S EIUE H CDRT NUUA I, 'T 3 3

As per the provisions of section 12 6 of the IGST Act, 2017 :

M A R G U R U ' E B L L I W Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H 4

Statutory Provision Services provided by Musicera Pvt. Ltd. to audiences by way of admission to music concert.

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

CGST

SGST

Consideration for supply

`

location immovable property is located inter alia,

YE ML M

P E AP A L R S B G A UU I RSEV UFHL E 'OTE NB

REIL E CEI L I R L AA W P L PP 4 U A3 SEN ' EHA3 HTY T RD FDAN O N(A NA 4 O M3 I T AA' A CNR# OAG U Y L E R T ERU A HA' T 4( 3

-

EE BI

L L A M HU SD SM E CU I $ V R L E E S T FO O ( YEA L N P HA PT Y UFR SO A FN( O OM EI TA CA AC R L G OU P L R EEU HH ' 4T

As per the provisions of section 12 3 c of the IGST Act, 2017 :

F EGC OML BNN IU YOAZ C V F L I CO L P N A PAMAR

UFMGU E R T SOI LH Y U YOC T FAN E R OWA OYEH NFNBT EYI A LH CBN L Y A ASO T C L HI EIR P CTE SH A I P D V ER NW O O OR HE T IA MP 4S T

Services provided by Hotel Dumdum to Supriya (P) Ltd. by way of accommodation in the Hotel lawns for organising the music concert.

5.7

`

`

`

TNYY O T A I NEW L I SEYB I HBI A TT L N ERD4 O E VF 3 D' EE I EI ) CV OO HR T PRN O PE E T EB NHCL T I OF V L I I )R S W E S S I NSE MA FR E DEOH AML Y4 O) P TP T E T UV 4 H SO G3F B I ' O R A R T M C OO

ET F R P N NF SI OT E O I R P T P A MNN R I EE I E DXG D I E E S NENN A O OBH I CL LCT N EI LE L HWI T TWM FI I S NRA E EW HS T T R N E NAC O N S O R C E P C I S RTU E PAM D EO XT l N O SI NI S ATS HEI K T M CD ET I R A OYF RO MT

`

As per Notification No. 9/2017 ` `

-

S T N I O P N I D E N O I T N E M S E I L P P U S F O T C E P S E R N I R E W S N A E H T N I E G N A H C O N E B L L I W E R E E V HO T B RA E V E WD ON (A

i

ii

iii

Section 12(7)

-

SNE E H D CAT L I O E V E T H R B E Y NL S LL L FOA A I O HU S ESST I S C MYA A L CDP S PI NAU I T FS N O E FV YOE AEE WC H AT YLE BPR EE DHH ET RDTW I E E NC V PO EA SR VL !P EP

I FA O N !N E R H -#

Gurugram

Section 12(7),

DHE LE I CH C R UT NE SE AT O B S YI T L NG L P AEI A HH ERS S HAR T O Y O ET SL R P D N E P E O N HI UO LPS WP S S R PGFE OP UN SI EH ENC G R C AU I A L SP S SA S E F EO C RH IO TN V F R NSI O E RS OTT E N S A YR PR EC SA EV O !L PEL

D T I H ,L :E 9$ 8

Delhi

Goa

Reason ENEH R ACC A A U L FP SO S E F C E N O I H V O T N R I T E O A S NT I S OA I EN SC R E ARO HGEL WRPE O DH ET FR O E E B T YS AI L L GA WE YRH B S A Y DOL P ETP N RI TUO L E P N S PP ESR SU VFE !S EOP

F O A !O 3' ) !

Admission to the event

Place of supply

A O ' !

3 ) !

Assigning of sponsorship

Recipient

A O ' !

3 ) !

Organisation of the event

Supplier F O I H D C T ,O !+ "

Service supplied

Section 12(6)

5.2.4 Telecommunication Services [Section 12(11)] Q. 14. Mr. Q has availed land-line services from MTNL registered in Delhi. The telephone is installed in residential premises in Mumbai and the billing address is of office of Mr. Q in Delhi.

2. Mr. Q has availed post-paid mobile services from MTNL registered in Delhi. Mr. Q is registered under GST law in Delhi but the billing address is of residential premises of Mr. Q in Mumbai.

3. Mr. Q has purchased pre-paid mobile vouchers of MTNL registered in Delhi through internet banking. Mr. Q is registered under GST law in Delhi but in MTNL’s records the address of Mr. Q is that of his residence in Mumbai.

TAXMANN®

Ans.

S W O L L O F S A D E N I M R E T E D E B L L A H S Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H 4

Q. 13. The All India Scientists Association (AISA) registered in Goa, contracted with event managers M/s. BA Ltd. of Kochi for organising the National seminar of scientists at Gurugram and the highly esteemed real estate company XYZ Ltd. of Delhi offered sponsorship for the seminar.

Mr. A, a scientist from Chennai paid for the fees to attend the seminar at the Goa office of the AISA. Determine the place of supply of the various services supplied herein.

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.8 Ans.

S I S S E R D D A G N I L L I B E H T H G U O H T L !

Place of supply

E B L L A H S S E C I V R E S

S E C I V R E S F O T P I E C E R R O F D E L L A T S N I S I E N I L N O I T A C I N U M

S EI HE T N I L E N O H P E L E T E H T E R E H W E C A L P

Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H T T U B I H L E $ N I

M O C E L E T E H T E R E H W N O I T A C O L E H T E B L L A H S E N I L N O I T A C I N

-

U M M O C E L E T D E X l F O Y A W Y B S E C I V R E S N O I T A C I N U M M O C

Section 12(11)(a),

E L E T F O Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H T

R E P S !

i

Statutory Provision

Mumbai i.e.

D E L L A T S N I E H T F O S S E R D D A G N I L L I B E H T E C N I 3

FD S N O E R CO I O I T N C V A OE R CT I R E I AE S N FUCH O OT YMLN L MEO P S POHE UCTC SEEV I FL EBR O T LE L E S CRAF AOHO F S L T P N S N OS EI I E HT I T CAI P EBC NDE NIR OAE CPH T TF ES L I O O B S OPS E MNR FOD O DD YEA ADG I N WV I OL L YR I BP B

R E P S !

Section 12(11)(b),

E C A L P E H T I A B M U N I S I T N E I P I C E R

ii

N I E B L L A H S Y L P P U S F O

Mumbai

S E C I V R E S F O R E I L P P U S E H T F O R E E MB PU L L S-A A H FS 1O Y T P AL R HP -T U FSS I O F DO SR S E O E C CA R DEP L R DS A E H E,T C.I N4A I -B 3 SNGED E H N E O CT L I T I L I I L FA V AI V R CBOA E I D F N S R S FUOO I N O C E O E YMI C T L R I MA P V E POCH R OT CL E UE S SL END FE O I THOA T S E CREEP O B C AF E LIR L V L N P A R P O E H EI S S H HT SFC T CI O ES U T NA S N NBE F I ODI S CI PE A I EP C C L I EV I ER B R OREE MPHS N T F FOFO O O D R SE YES I RADE L I E RP V PWO DP SYR DU !BP AS

iii

Section 12(11)(c),

-

Mumbai

R O G N I K N A B T E N R E T N I H G U O R H T E D A M S I E G R A H C E R E H T R O

TAXMANN®

T N E M Y A P F O E D O M C I N O R T C E L E R E H T O XX AA T T EE MH OT CG NN ) I N FI O M SR ME RE T E T D NR I O TF O T NN DA NV AL E E R R I S I TT C N !E 4D I 3S 'E #R N EO HN T FA O S I NH OH I S T E C EK 3A F2 O

SR NOT I S A I H V OT T RC PA NF I NE OH P4 U S D N E PT EC D!

Ans.

E C I V R E S Y N A F O Y T I L I B A X A T E H T W A L 4 3 ' R E D N 5

T C E R R O C T O N S I H H S E K A 2

R F O N O I T N E T N O C E H 4

Q. 15. Mr. Rakesh has a permanent residence at Surat. He has a savings bank account with Surat Branch of BOB Bank. On April 1, 2021, Mr. Rakesh opened a safe deposit locker with the Surat Branch of BOB Plink Mr. Rakesh went to USA for official work in December, 2021 and has been residing there since then. Mr. Rakesh contends that since he is a non-resident during the year 2022-23 in terms of the Income-tax Act, GST cannot be levied on the locker fee charged

by BOB Bank for the year 2022-23. Examine the correctness of the contention of Mr. Rakesh.

(Modified RTP, Nov. 2014)

D N A G N I K N A B F O Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H T

N O I T C E 3 R E P S !

M I H Y B D E V I E C E R S E C I V R E S F O Y T I L I B A

-

T EFA HOR T SU ND3 R OO E SC C E EN CR I I V ES R HD E T N S RA FE T O PA TSR N AU ET 3 I P NE I EB C I EP R ID L ECU HEO R T FW FO O E NC NO I OT V I I R T AE A S CCF OOO L L E EH Y HT L P T EP ES U BA S LCF L A S O I HH E ST C NNA O) L SS P R E E E H CT PI YV T NR A ER AS OFU T O3 SRN E EI CL I S I PI V R PY E UN S SA LE P A I HM C NTO F C AO NS G I F N DI RRK E ON HCA T EB O R

4 3 ' O T E L B A I L E B D L U O W E E F R E K C O L Y R O T I R R E T E L B A X A T N I S L L A F Q. 16. ‘PQ’, a statutory body, deals with all the advertisement and publicity of the Government. It has issued a release order to ‘Moon Plus’ channel (registered in State ‘A’) for telecasting an advertisement relating to one of the schemes of the Government in the month of September 20XX. The advertisement will be telecasted in the States of ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’, ‘D’ and ‘E’. The total value of the service contract entered into between ‘Moon Plus’ and ‘PQ’ is ` 10,00,000 (exclusive of GST).

You are required to determine the place of supply of the services in the instant case as also the value of supply attributable to the States of ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’, ‘D’ and ‘E’.

Further, compute the GST liability [CGST & SGST or IGST, as the case may be] of ‘Moon Plus’ as also advise it as to whether it should issue one invoice for the entire contract value or separate State-wise invoices.

The other relevant information is given hereunder:

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

States

IGST CGST

SGST

(b) Where agreement exists:

D R A G E R S I H T N I O T N I D E R E T N E T N E M E E R G A R O T C A R T N O C E H T F O S M R E T N I

S NE EC EI V WR TE E BS T TN N EE MM E ES ET I R R G E AV RD OA TF C AO R E T U N L OA CV AE T HA CN UO SI T FR O O EP CO NR EP S BE AH ET HS T E C NI ) V R E S F O T N E I P I C E R D N A R E I L P P U S E H T Where agreement does not exist:

TAXMANN®

S E C I V R E S T N E M E S I T R E V D A F O Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H T SD E E CN I I V M R E R S E T EE HD T S OE T I R EO L B T I AR T R U E BT I N R T O T I A N T5 N

US OT E MA T A3 EE HV T I T OC T E NP OS I E T R R OE PH OT RN PI NN I O ST I I A YN R I O TM I E R S R S E I T D NF OO I N Y 5A

EW T Y A B T 3 D HE CD AI V EO R OP T

D E T

S A S CE DL AU O R2 B4 S3 I ' T ) N EE H MT EF S O I T

R E E VL DU AR H ET HI T W EE R C E HN A WD R SO E I C R C OA T I N R I R E D T E T NU OP I N M 5O C S E S I T A T D 3 E T TA N N EI R M E F E F I S D S I OD T

ED L E B Y AA T L U P B I R N T U T A R

N O I S I V E L E T N O T N E M E S I T R E V D A F O E S A C E H T N I

R E P S !

N I D E T A N I M E S S I D E C I V R E S T N E M E S I T R E V D A F O E U L A V E H T O T E L B A T U B I R T T A T N U O M A E H T S L E N N A H C

E T A T 3 H C U S N I L E N N A H C H C U S F O P I H S R E W E I V E H T F O S I S A B E H T N O D E T A L U C L A C E B L L A H S E T A T 3 A

Y L E M A N

R E N N A M G N I W O L L O F E H T N I D E T A L U C L A C E B L L A H S N R U T N I H C I H W

Y R O T I R R E 4 N O I N U

E T A T 3 H C A E N I L E N N A H C H C U S F O S R E W E I V F O R E B M U .

E H T Y B D E H S I L B U P S E R U G l P I H S R E W E I V L E N N A H C E H T M O R F D E N I A T R E C S A E B N A C P I H S R E W E I 6

R E T R A U Q N E V I G A F O K E E W T S A L E H T R O F S E R U G I &

L I C N U O # H C R A E S E 2 E C N E I D U !

T S A C D A O R "

R E T R A U Q G N I D E E C C U S E H T R O F P I H S R E W E I V G N I T A L U C L A C R O F D E S U E B L L I W

N A H T E R O M F O G N I S I R P M O C N O I G E R A O T E T A L E R S E R U G l P I H S R E W E I V L E N N A H C E H T E R E H 7

T A H T F O Y R O T I R R E T N O I N 5

E T A T 3 A R O F S E R U G l P I H S R E W E I V E H T Y R O T I R R E T N O I N 5

E T A T 3 E N O

Population as per latest census (in crores) ! " # $ %

C l I C E P S S E C I V R E S T N E M E S I T R E V D A H C U S F O Y L P P U S E H T F O E U L A V E H D 4 E T A N I M E S S I D

D E Y A L P

N U R

# % " $

D E T S A C D A O R B S I T N E M E S I T R E V D A E H T E R E H W

S E I R O T I R R E T N O I N 5 R O S E T A T 3 H C U S F O H C A E N I G N I E B

!

S YA T I R N OE HK T A U T AI S LT A N CE OM L AE E RR OG A YR DO OT BC A YR R T ON T O U C T A E T H S T AN I TD N E El MT I NN RE E D VI OS E 'I R EO T T A I R T R 3 E T AN TI O N EN M5 NR RO E S VE OT A 'T 3 LE A R H T T N R EO #F T EN HA T E OM T

rule 3(f) of the IGST Rules, 2017

(c)

section 12(14) of the IGST Act, 2017

(a)

R E P S !

Statutory Provisions:

Ans.

Viewership figures of ‘Moon Plus’ channel in the last week of June 20XX as provided by the Broadcast Audience Research Council States

5.9 Table 1

Table 2

The applicable rate of tax is as under:

[RTP May 2020]

Y R O T I R R E T N O I N 5

E T A T 3 T A H T F O S N O I T A L U P O P E H T F O O I T A R N I D E T A L U C L A C E B L L I W N O I G E R

S U S N E # T S E T A L E H T N I D E N I M R E T E D S A

E

C

H DET NMI AA W SD !

EA @ HE ET R T E A T C 3 N

E RH E I T L S C P E !

T PA UT 4 S3 3 ET' HN ) T EE FR O H ET F NF F IO OD I T O A CW OT L

EN HI T E N R O SA I E T C C I %E V @ 3 R E ; S

F$ O @ Y L # P @ P U" S@ FS O E T A

T = ST 3 E C I

L !

YP L T P P A U PS H T UE ST F O FA O T S3 E R CE N AN T L O P I I T EC ER E HA NT S )

a

liable to IGST

`

`

`

`

five separate invoices

TAXMANN®

A

`

`

` ` `

Proportionate value of advertisement services for States ‘A’, (‘B’ + ‘C’) and(‘D’ + ‘E’)

D

FN O O EI T CC AE L S P F EO HS T DM R NE AT N !

I @ Y EL T P A P T 3 U

S RE E T I A L P T P3 UA SR T FN O I NN OA I T S A CI OE L M EA HS T E HS T EU CH NT ES I HD N E TA A

T

3

E MT AC S !

E4 H3 T ' N) I EE FR H O AT EYF S LO A P CP U

NS )

all the remaining cases

supply of services in State ‘A’

B

‘A’, (‘B’ + ‘C’) and (‘D’ + ‘E’)

Viewership figures of ‘Moon Plus’ channel as provided by the Broadcast Audience Research Council in the last week of June 20XX

IGST @ 18%(`) SGST @ 9%(`) CGST @ 9%(`)

Proportionate value of advertisement services (`) States

Viewership ratio of ‘Moon Plus’ channel in the States

D+E B+C A States

Proportionate value of advertisement services in the States ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘C’, ‘D’ & ‘E’ Population ratio in the States ‘B’ &‘C’ and ‘D’ & ‘E’ Population as per latest census (in crores) States

L L I% W@

L

E

N$ N@ A # H@ C

S "

U@

L

0

!

N O @ O Y -E L @M

EA S AN CS E NT E A VT I 3 G E EH HT T F NO I YH L

CE P T PAA

UET

SR3

FOT

F O A

S H

E

T

C

O

A

T L

P G

T N I N % N # E

I

R A $ " E T F R F E I D P E E V U L l A V E R E

A E H UT ES R S G E N HII O T T A ETC E CV I NA D I N ! " # $ % 3HI

SD EE I HI A T R OS ST E E I H RT CR I V EF T R O E NS S O N I FN O O I T5I S N V S EE O I P T R I A P C T E3 E R TH N 4 DE NR

AE

F RF E II D L P OS PT E UE L U SL B 2 EA HT 4 T U3 NI B' ER ) ET WTF TAO S E

E BC E TV I L N U R EE R MS H ETT ENI R EW G M E AE C RS N OT IA TE R D C R AV O R DC W T AC N O OFAL E CONB AEID U D FL E A O ET VT A EE U L CT P U NA B M EN A S OT O BI E TCR AR EA EO HPBE L T OI L L RW U NP R )

Ans.

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.10

Computation of Value of Supply

Computation of state-wise Value of Supply

`

`

`

Computation of GST liability of ‘Moon Plus’:

Nature of Supply:

liable to CGST and SGST

Q. 17. Determine Place of supply in case of the advertisement service provided to the Central Government for the test and union Territories. In the absence of contract or agreement?

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

N I K C A R T Y A W N LI I A A R R T ET HA T H FT O R O HF T G N E ,

NE I T A A T T R 3 E PH C SA L L IE B N NI O S T N E M E S I T R E V D A G EN HI T RV OA H F S ER

L Y E B R AMO YUI T AS R PN R E TOT N C UON O OT I MGN N5 !I -

L C EIT HOE F T NOS E O I S N T A N P E M M O E C S I S T FA R O E G VKD DCN !AA B

N I S N O I T A T 3 Y A W L I A 2 F O R E B M U .

N O S T N E M E S I T R E V D !

E U T R I V Y B H C I H W N O I T A T S O I D A R H C U SF OO T T R EA L P B AS YI AE PM TA N N US OT I MF !O

N O S T N E M E S I T R E V D !

E E N WCE H ENVT I R GO VEI I D LU AF E P N!FI N OH ATKS S HA R EE CC EW EDWE HATI T OS V RA M" G L N O EI REH T F A H T L DTRU E O C NYF L B I A A SC T E DR R R E E UO CHG F S S I I& A DR L

E EB E LST BUC I U P R N NEA ASUB U E CR Q OL LG #I PU I N HGHWI SlCRD R R E E E P A E T I E R WH C S A C ES E I UU R2 6E QS -

TS NEEA OHR U HS T I TT G N EYAFE H R R O # AOTST T F N I O S OR OE T R I YT T EER A T T OAL L A NT E U L OIP H R E I R T R ON E SNT PI 5 E NED R UEOHE N GTITI N A F lT 5OM P3

O R I I E E E H T T T N A SO A E R R T D E 3 N N S WA AIA EH D R I Y T E V O T R LEFA O R E L S T I U NOE R NMRCR E A ULT A HFGC N COlE G O PB EN I I HI N L H L5 T S SI IR ER W R PE E E WNA T HME OT OII 7C VG3 -

X E L P I T L U M A N I S N E E R C S R O L L A

Y HR AO T MI R ER NE I T C AN O OI T N E5 L B

AE YT AA PT T3 N H UC OA ME N !I

N I S T N E M E S I T R E V D !

TRDE N E E R EV NP MOO R IE LT E L SA RN I ON T RDP E EPA VD DIAM AVEE EOBH HRLT L P I T N NWI TE E A EI NEC RBV ID E ERN T N VE) I ASF R HHO E S VOC4 U OT S S5 D F T EO D N EMEN A M U E EEL AS E D S I

T VTN A E E R T B I E H3 E VL LTL R DA SLE AH UAH FS HTT O 4SD E G EC E N S A I B A IOI VD CR R MC ENA NS S ) )

N O S T N E M E S I T R E V D !

-

N O I N 5

E T A T 3 H C A E

N I S R E B I R C S B U S T E N R E T N I F O Y RR E O BI T MR R UE .4

Manner Prescribed:

TAXMANN®

N I L E N N A H C H C U S F O S R E W E I V F O

R E B M U .

N O T N E M E S I T R E V D !

each State/union

inter-

N I D E T A C O L S G N I D R A O H E H T R O F E L B A Y A P T N U O M !

N O S T N E M E S I T R E V D !

cinema

tory

halls

Territory

television channels

Y R O T I R R E T N O I N 5

E T A T 3 H EC HA T E RN OI F L EA L I B R AE YT AA PM TH N UC U OS MF !O N O E S O H NT I SNS T A N N HI ET A R MRT E EH S T I TO R

E V D !

radio

each State/Union territory stations

each State/Union territory

rail-

distribution of a specific number

HM C

G ST A E UP E I OE R RK A S I T HI R T LDH I S SS T T N E 4 E m M AS ER E L A S I D S T T R N E E E L V L H A D PC !

way tickets

billing addresses

utility bills

each State/Union Terri-

trains

each State/

hoard-

Union territory ings

each State/Union territory

net

-

printed material

LE L R A A NH I C TI N EH MW EN S I O TI R T E A VC I DL AB NU AP GR NO I R H E SP I L A B P US PW RE ON F EA L F B AO YSN AN I PO D TIE T I N H S UDI L OEB EU MH !T P

S N O I T A C NI I L SB T U N EP MD N EA S I T R E V D ! news-

papers

Factor which Determines the Proportionate value of service attributable to the Dissemination in each State/Union Territory Type of Advertisement Sr. No.

5.11

TYR E E T NRR ROA T E A T L U U N Q I GT EE S H2 A T L MME OOH RCT F ER DL O EEF N4S I EE A HR T T R U E YG CB I S & D A E EH ) BS !

NI AL2 CB4 SU P R A E S I E BR D I N R U) C GF S BlO URY SET B T I I ER R NC O RS H E BT T UU N S! )

TSS T NEA NE OHH T I OT TT G I A YFA ER L R OLE AO UH T IYPT OR R ON R T OP I E T ET I D EE T A NR RHN L OETI E T I F R N M O S5NO R E O E

I R I T UENTE A T GA 5R D lT ES EH A R3T E TY E A BN T N R I O3IO R C D T N I A S ER BA T R R H A UT E OL T SE F U N TR CO SL E I NOEAN R C RMU E E5 FGB T

O N lLE I EGRLT A A N E H TIBHT 3 S S I I S ER TU R NA R C PS OH E S I TN HMBG OUEFE 7C SROC N O I N 5

E T A T 3 H C A E N I S R E B I R C S B U S M O C E L E T F O Y RR E O BI T MR R UE .4

R RDO R E E F E H CS T DR S IE A A L S U EBU BU Q P E G NSBN L AE I L D CRI E EUWE G L R C l C E C R T I S U R C R S A E E MBUH Q I OR T NR CE CS EB O L VF E I UG T S R ASAE MRB NO OR I I C SCFS S E R L E EEB R BT U U I GS EI R C H& E S H BT T UM)G S !N O 2 R4 I T MF A O EL CDH U E EN C TL L IYA E A 4T BC

GR I D R NEER B I S ITE A I R L T R C U PS N C O LI MBA N OUC CSE E 5 E

B HL LT E C T L R I

YAAS T C H R U OS3S MT T Y A N OI R HE CRO R T C T EE I L FT TR E S T NROE AOEST T N I A ON N OL T OI 5 E T I E A H N T A E5LT U L T N E

PI A R T EO T D S3A PE E ETEN R UN3HI GOTTM FR l AO N H E HAT T OE CHRI UTO AD SEFT ERSRS E O R EA R E HY U HMG T R FlNO 7O IT -

5.3 SECTION 13 OF IGST ACT: LOCATION OF SUPPLIER OF SERVICE OR THE LOCATION OF THE RECIPIENT OF SERVICE IS OUTSIDE INDIA TAXMANN®

GG NN I TI D A E L E U C CC L A U CS RE OH F T R DO EF S UR S E EB BI R LC L I S WB U RS A T EE YN LR A E I T C N NI AF

NO R lR A E NEY EBL VMA I I U G C NN AE A N FH O Tl

REE E HB DT L N L I S

UU W L H

LT E A F DS TNAN O O ACI S N T I C H S E T E S

O N R D I E D EOYN L T S P A PU C

U D

SE N N E FI VNO I M G OER I E T CT EC AE HE L 4S D P

T SN E E CI I V P I R C E E S R FF O O YN L O P PI T UA SC O FL O E EH

CT E AI SI

L P ES E ESC HAI C T V SR SI E H UT S HN F 4I O

LETSF L O O H A S HTNEN NO SESI SRI I S E T E SU A CHE BC I C 7 V O FL R VO I E S R E EH S E E S CS FI T R O U V F E TR O OB N E TCL ES LS

I Y N F A P R EA E O I HC I C YI P NSI EP L V R CIYR EPEDLE HURRPS O P T F FSEEUO F H H S O O T T R FE NEF NO OCO I I L I A EP E T L L NB CP A P AU OA RCEI L O E HTLPS I L A PE T A EE CV SH EO HT H !T BL AT

N I D E L L l L U F E R A S N O I T I D NE OS CA EC VN lE V EI HG T E LH L !

T

Y N A F O Y L P P U S E H T S N A E M S E C I V N R E E H S FW O E TC R I OV PR XE ES

New York

As per section 2(6) of the IGST Act, 2017

ii

section 13(2) of the IGST Act, 2017

i

H G U O R H T S T N E M E S I T R E V D !

SMS

Factor which Determines the Proportionate value of service attributable to the Dissemination in each State/Union Territory Type of Advertisement Sr. No.

In the given case

Statutory Provision

Ans.

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.12

-

5.3.1 Section 13(2): Residual provisions

Q. 18. R Ltd., a chips manufacturing company based in New York, intends to launch its products in India. However, the company wishes to know the taste and sensibilities of Indians before launching its products in India. For this purpose, R Ltd. has approached GE Consultants, Delhi to carry out a survey in India to enable it to make changes, if any, in its products to suit Indian taste.

The survey is to be solely based on the oral replies of the surveyees; they will not be provided any sample by R Ltd. to taste. GE Consultants will be paid in convertible foreign exchange for the assignment.

With reference to the provisions of GST law, determine the place of supply of the service. Also, explain whether the said supply will amount to export of service?

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

The foreign customer then directly places purchase order on the Indian vendor for purchase of the specified goods. Bansal Ltd. charges its foreign customer cost plus 20% mark up for services provided by it.

For the month of June, 2022, the company has charged US $ 2,00,000 (exclusive of GST) to its foreign customer. With reference to the provisions of GST law, examine whether the said supply will amount to export of service?

D T , L A S N A " F O N O I T A C OS L I EH HC T I H E W

I

Mumbai

NN I O I YT L A P C PO UL SE FH O T ES CI A S LE P C I EV HR T E S Y R A I

D

ER NME I ORL I E P T CTP N EI U S S F RO E E H E PS T SA F !C O

(ii) As per section 2(6) of the IGST Act, 2017

TAXMANN®

EY R BA I ND AE CM R SE ET CN I I V R ES SA DD E II S A E F I SS C I SV EA R HL E TCS

S SRDSNAE E OEDEEC NTL OEDI LO T lN EEAGWUVN DGC TLR EU F E C OB O NSC AEY I RC NML STOA AAP O E RNPI NSN T D U E I RS SO TK W R E E C U O E V O O O !R GS HCD ET I 4BT HH A E S S T E 3AHT RUCN U B 'N A O S O )AWT I S SS L EEYI H N E E C HMBA T I I OL T T O SP I R FONFBRP T O R E U O v O S UC RP Y R SE SOE REE APG SROS I

NEOHR D R

C AI MWO EER H V N H T OMTRRRNO A R O O O E I T E SB YOSOR C T N EI NHRWE R 3h AWOTPO

GEE D HH N T T I T ,T N A L T AI ED S EN L NI WA C AA TR "F E BE E CRSM NODOR I TO OS S GO D NG UN EI S GFCE A NO V CA N Y SR GN L I I R A P H E I AP T RD UON NSS ) I F)

EEI N D HI T D RSE OTN SUI O E SM CI I R V ET E R CE E I V S FRD E O S I S RF E Y I O L L P P TP PN U UES I SP EI F C HE O T FRE O C EA NHL OTP I F T O E A HF C ONTO O L S I A ET M I A HC D R T NT E O) FL )

A I D N ) E D I S T U O S I E C I V R E S F O Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H T

(c)

EL YNI N HE O S TR

ERN E D O NMPI T ATC TA O N NA ENI TL CES I IP R V RADX EEA% SC H T I FIFW O V OR ET SE RSN C EFE N I OMA L P

D

PTHR S ON UNL IICI SE O B P C T I A AC EC T HES E NS TREI

F FSO O N O ET I CC AA L S P N A ER S T A CS I NH ET VI A I G D EN H) N T I NS I

I E Y C EL I CP V NP R I U E 3 S S

T A R I ON D

PE A N XH I ) EW D E D E N I C ) S I T N U V I R O D E S E D T E Y A T N C A A O C F L O O L S S Y I I E L E P C C P I I V U V R S R E E E S S H F F T O O S T N R N E E A L I I E P P I M P C U E S S R E C E E I H T H V T R E S F O

(b)

does not tantamount to export

(a)

b

NNNY EIIB EERD COE BI SV TD A RETN HE GIA ESNM R FAE CO A I H I P V D C R R RN XE E E I ) S LEV F HP E CPNE RO G UUI K HN SSE RER WA OH O S" F F T E TY E N EEV EBLPR B UE MDT I RS YER E N AVEA 2 PIVI E ND E ECO ECNH HR )T T

section 13 of the IGST Act, 2017.

N A

E D I S T U O S I E C I V R E S F O Y L P P U S F O E C A L A P I ED N H) T

In the given case

Statutory Provision

Ans.

S A D E R E D I S N O C E B L L I W E M A S E H T

D E T A C O L S I E C I V R E S F O

TA N I ED I N P ) I C E ED R I S T EU HO T (e)

N I D E T A C O L S I E C I V R E S F O R E I L P P U SI A ED N H) T (d)

(i)

(c)

export of service (b)

(a)

5.13

Q. 19. Bansal Ltd., Mumbai, provides support services to foreign customers in relation to procuring goods from India. The company identifies the prospective vendor, reviews product quality and pricing and then shares the vendor details with the foreign customer.

RNE S OI U TEL A B C A V R O E T T

N HD ONTE OOI CI N TTM EA NR HC OE T OT I T F,R E O OD PR S O O M3R PD R/ E E 0NC T T I E EL NNT I EA L O EHTC T S L B S ATEE H N C NE T I I V F MMO R REH E E S EC T R R E G AO $A EF

E C N A R &

S I R A 0

D E T A C O L S L E S S E V R O T A O B R O% Y4 T !

R 4 E P3 OE RN PO EN L B A AH VT OE R MO M )M N FI )

!

3 5

K R O 9 W E .

T N E I P I C E R F O N O I T A C O , N E H T A I D N ) E D I S T U O N O I T A C O L F )

-

T A O B RD OE T YA T R C E O PL O RE PB O ET L B D AE VD ON E MT MN II ER HO T D HE T CA I H C O WL TS A I L NE OS I S T E A CV OR ,O

GNGYC EN NAT RI GG I WE I DS YU ED E T L$OYS R EC ,"U PNR O OIOTN( I N O RSR T EI E S PE GT T E CN !AU EI D L V) O ' E B RTT AE C L AME VS ET T T SMO ODI %O( H ME C C C TR MA F R!O !E )L -

N E H T T C A R T N O C R O T N E M E G N A R R A F O E C N E S B !

[May 2018, 5 Marks] Explain the relevant provisions of law to support your conclusions.

I A B M U -

o

3 / 0

In the given case Statutory Provision

D E B I R C S E R P E B Y A M S A S I S A B E L B A N O S A E R N /

E R E H E C I V R E S F O T N E I P I C E R E H T F O N O I I TA A CB OM L EU HT E B L3 L / A H0 S YN I L A P P* UH S SI FR O A E( CF AO L P N EO HI T 4A C O L E H T G N I E B

S I Y T R E PD OE RT PA C E O LL B AE VB OO MT D ME ID EN HE T T N EI R E R HO WD E ET CA AC L O 0 L O T N O I T A L E R N I Y L T Y C T ER R E I P D O DR EP I L E P L PB UA SV SO E CM I M V I R E N 3A

PLACE OF SUPPLY

Conclusion -

S I R A 0

E R E H D E T A U T I S Y T R E P O R P E H T F O N O I T A C O L E H T E B L L A H S Y L P

PE UC SN FA O R & E CS AN L P A EP H 4 3 / 0

E C N A R &

Conclusion -

K R O 9 W E .

I H L E $

I

NATURE OF SUPPLY

Sec. No.

I A B M U -

I H L E $

II

Properties situated at Location of Mr. Harish Jain

Location of Mr. Mahendra Goyal Case

TT SH N T N I EE I W P M I C E EHC S R I N L A B EA D HT R T SO C DEC NYA L AE

ERNN CEIO I I VMNT RTOC E SE OR S S NE N F O EPI R T RAC N E NO I EI L CTI P T S A I PID V N UR A SE L AP S EFFX HO O% T (e)

PLACE OF SUPPLY NATURE OF SUPPLY

Sec. No.

TAXMANN®

(d)

DNRD EGEN VIVA E I E

R E RA COE I EFH D R E N NL BW) EI F ET SO R BE EK E SV N A PA HNU " EO CCRE N I N I V V E AR R I C E E ID S S V NE HR )2 CE US SFNE ROIH O RRT F E Y O I T L B N EP E D P G E MUN T T YSA I AEH M PH TCR EY XE HB EP T

Case 1 : If location of service provider and service recipient in India then place of supply is to be determine as per Section 12 Ans.

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.14

5.4 LOCATION OF SUPPLIER OR LOCATION OF RECIPIENT IS OUTSIDE INDIA [SECTION 13] 5.4.1 Services Related to Immovable Property [Sections 12(3) & 13(4)]

Q. 20. Mr. Mahendra Goyal, an interior decorator provides professional services to Mr. Harish Jain in relation to two of his immovable properties. Determine the place of supply in the transactions below as per provisions of GST law in the following independent situations:

o

Case 2: Where Location of Supply or Location of Recipient is outside India then place of supply is to be determined as per Section 13

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

Q. 21

5.15

Determine the place of supply of service in each of the following independent cases: (1) A Delhi based builder provides construction services to Gujarat based company in respect of construction of its new building in Dubai.

Ans.

Provision

-

i.e.

Q. 22

T E E N % C I EB BH LI T PO7L ST "AW E R S!HL NI"SL I

N EAY S O-CFR T ) E I I O V T :R T O I A NI T S N E R R CO SR I S I LDFEE F I O P T EO C DE T EXA YHL PEC L B SLO CA P EAL PIX CR UHA EES NN R WT I I A S F F%O TO EMU 7T S E I H O A C"B C CI DA !M SH EL A I " P I H WR -E T RE) NFAH H ) OCT:T

TE ANEA L I B L RB E DL AA R LJ EA X T A NA HU4 I CS'@ DOY F ELL O YP T DT I P I R V T OEUNB RPSEM I POFP A R O E I SP C H E ET E CL EC R I N V BA I R EH AL E V0HT S O TI E N W M F S S A O

L

A T MS L Y CI A I N R O S NOFT O H A I I T I T H C H R A T I NG R CH OF E NT OW4 I !L )

Fact

R YEEO L R H T CTED H E W Y E R T T TI R A D C EC E CO ! P D AL 4EOL DRPS 3I P I E 'V HY )OL ET FR T B O PA ERD BEE SV E P T

OL LOA

C A R I MH C V PO NR S L OEM EE Y I L I S L T B B C FOPA EOTPV O UO T 3TNS CI OFM RE D E E PTOMD PS A L SE EIN EC !R E R AET NNLHN P T

I I I RE EY EO ER Y LB LH L T B P CTE A P D H O E W VT U Y EO R T T I S TD R C T EA DFN E CCMEOE !DP AOMDEI L 4EOL P 3DRPSINCI A E I P F L T EI) C 'V P N E )OEHY I R L E T FR T O PBERDRHE E E A T H SVBPTOA T L E

OADI OL

F C I ARCEDO O M V P H T N NR S LA N M E E E OS C)O IYL I BOET I L D T B L I C FOPA A SC OST EOTPV T I 3TNUO U O S O RC OL D Y M I F E E T E D PPTO ER B M D E E SA L SE E T I N L E P L !R C A E R A OC ET AH RO H L I NI NP NP TI

LS

(2) A USA based company has been awarded mineral exploration contract in respect of specific sites Iraq by a Chennai based corporation.

(Modified 3 Marks, Nov. 2014)

Determine the place of supply in the following independent cases:—

(ii) Vidhyut Pvt. Ltd. imports electric food processors from China for its Kitchen Store in Noida, Uttar Pradesh. Vidhyut Pvt. Ltd. is registered in Uttar Pradesh. (iii) Mr. Aatmaram, a manager in a Bank, is transferred from Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh to Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh. Mr. Aatmaram’s family is stationed in Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh. He hires Gokul Carriers of Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh (registered in Uttar Pradesh), to transport his household goods from Kanpur to Bhopal. (iv) Bholunath, a resident of New Delhi, opens his saving account in New Delhi branch of Best Bank after undergoing the KYC process. He goes to Amritsar for some official work and withdraws money from Best Bank’s ATM in Amritsar thereby crossing his limit of free ATM withdrawals.

i

NE RE H OE T DH FD EW O R I L A YO P NL PO PB UT IP SA UN SC SO DO FN OL O E O K GEEA H C FTA T O SL E YIPR L E E A P L HS PC T I UH D EO SE S FV O A O G RCE EO N CT H E AO L VT P MG I HD T CL A A EIO H HHS R T W T N NONTE E WL EIAB OS S N S UO DE E V HI SV A Y 4TH A A N

C L D I OY A RL E RA H ET TOH F TBTE R TA N SE C I R !CORH N R A W 4I EA 3AKK R EAU U 'K T P )I I NHA EL HEEA* T CE3T FNB O R O AEN YV D EAYN V H BA NS

ODDI

H LL CO O NAOSE ODGS$ I DW TRHO A C CO E EOU 3BS G.

Ans.

(v) Mr. Chakmak, an architect (New Delhi), enters into a contract with Mr. Zeeshaan of New York to provide professional services in respect of immovable properties of Mr. Zeeshaan located in Pune and New York.

(RTP-May 21) e

i.e.

a

FN O O S YR AE WP YD BE R SEN

T E CSI O I I G T V E A R R T E R N S O FUP O N S N YAA L R PO TT PDR UE I E SD H IT FV O OR ERO CPF ARR L EE P I RV EUO HOD T CE D RN OA L I H A E TMR C YA !B S D GO 4N 3I O 'D G )UH L EC C HI NU T S FSH O DC OI OH

G W

FT O A NNN OOO I I I T T T C A A ET C RO S OL RP E E PSH N AT SR S !T I

iii

ETH N HE S T E S D E A A IR D R P NE0 ) R HA NT T I DNT EI5 T S A R UD OH I P4 O M .

ID S I NE ETD A EC T , BO

ELT VSV AI0 R HE T U ST Y DRH OOD OPI GM6 IY EE HH B T D FTE I ET RR EO HP WM I ES TC C D AO !L 4PO 3EG E 'HH T )S T EI F HS O T DY FO L P O OP GU FS O

F YO L NP E C OP I A T U L C SP EF E S H ROT E EE PC S AA SL !P C

ii

TAXMANN®

(i) Mr. Sahukaar (New Delhi) boards the New Delhi-Kota train at New Delhi. Mr. Sahukaar sells the goods taken on board by him (at New Delhi), in the train, at Jaipur during the journey.

EEE DNL C EO BNV I I I L AOR T P PAXNE S UCAAT T O H SL ET C SEHE E E TRI T NN CO I H IOC V R NNMR E AONA I S I HT F ET A DO R CE Y EO E TP L HRL A O ECP WM HL OU T

S TSEF AIRO Y A

D L E SC P TE E I P A L C I L !PUTP R S P E E 4UFP H 3SOO T ER 'EC Y )R APR EAL E OE

L HYP T B I T E T RN AR FR U O EHVE 0 PTOT OY E

RRML

O MB T PI A Y ERIX NL E R R A OB O E H TT I AT T T E I V E C R R EOLEHE T S B S M A N A T HM I XCN E T A I L N B O WITE IA E T VA DNH X I G AAT A CT ET ONEO R I LE H H NNTAT O G O

NN II I

N T TA A EII D C L N NE OCUO N OR L L I I I C T TNA3 NA C C EIG IO S YNYNL R I L O OI RT D E E T C UT IA H PE R L CT R RC SI E NT OI S !D L I v

R R E E E E HHI HT T L T P FEP O O S U DNA CS NO E AI NH T ET A GC VF NO I I G O K L ES N AEHD R BHTO T NC FSI I O E SR NU YO L E SHH P PR4T UE N SPSI E YC FN S IE O V C EARI COEV R ATSE L F SO P S E RO F EC II E HV T L T R P N EPE I SUP G SI N I C EE KHR TO T C RFE !B O H 4KST F 3CDO R OO 'T )S N C O EI EGR T HN T IEA FDHC O T O U L NL C E I N

HI ST I H E

L CSE

SI I E V Y$ CR NI L EP W V OR S PE I FU T E C O S S. EL TF S AN I EO RC I E EK NP PA C I N C AA SNE L !lR B P

F O E C A L P E H T T A H T S I E C I V R E S F O T R O P X E S A Y F I L A U Q O T

EA CD I I V N R ) E S E D FI O S T YU L P O PE UB ST AS RU OM F SE NI C OV I T R I E D S ND OI CA ES F HO T FY O L P EP NU /S

S E RS TH OE N T PC EF MOMO IRT P A Y L E TR I R N

A ET

R H OMC T PA UN SO ME R RI ET T T OC HFE EC R S UDO A E HSRT I R CE U O I Q T S H F I EV WA R O DI SE SR DT P OR H D CN OO I GP H O EX C HEWE T ET3 FRA; H A O E TDTC C N I ENA V R PAH E SS TS SR E E R H E C NO HC I T U RO DP S E F I LTAO I N P T PEDN N UM) E STN I P A SE I I E C EE RS CT I R V RUF R E YO E HN S T N FOAO O YOI T YNTA L AT C P PRUO = UOPL F E SA GH

NT

FI I O

D E ENBS IT C)TS C O A US! LN T OE4 P IHC3 ED O T I HE R' WP 4T )

TOY I L TP K NSP L !O U OS ST

E EH -H T YTY BSL T DAN AA EI DD T I V NL U O)S RNE PI

2E S

C E T I R C V I OR V E DPS R X E E S MEF ERRO I T HO E R T FH O R FE T P O EX YPR E L YOS P L FA PL E UABY U ST F SI FC L HA O AT EENU CR OQ AA MT L S O P

E N EC RO HI O V T D ERFS E A S S E I A S D I CEN R NH)P R ET E N E VR I T I E D G N E % EHS HWU T I T ENK NC I AEN ELE! VPBS OEE BHV ATAESHY HIDB S T S EE FER T S O I C R OV I WP PR ERXE E I ES T V N EF N% BO )

F SO EEI CRE T O NF MO EE HR AN DESD NHEN A4HA T

S

E YC I PV N L O PR I T UE T C SS C F E!EO

S 4T Y3A= T

B'3

D)A EER

H T NT

T N RF C I E

VON! O A4

G T3 S O ' I N ) N

YO E L IS IH P

T PC YT L UEP F O SSP

FU FO

O S ES CME

H A

LR ETN F P T D O ENNO4 I HIAT Y C 3 T L AE ' P I S AP ) D I D UNFO O ) NS T ) SE E N L M I ET B DASRA T I I E I 3 S L T YTS U AL N I P R I OT P; E N SI UY M I LA SP T N F N PS AO ET UE I S O E H P I NCET C T AA SL EI S R PT U Y H EL E34 P HP R HE T T

S TD EU CSENO I C NEN NO I HS IA 3 G T

Determine place of supply along with reasons in the following cases:

Q. 24

i.e.

M/s Ankit Enterprises is of the assumption that it is an export transaction and therefore, it is entitled to treat it as a zero-rated supply and decides that no tax is payable under LUT although the rate applicable to such services for domestic supplies is CGST 9%, SGST 9% and IGST 18%.

State the provisions relating to the above supply of service and explain whether the stand taken

by M/s Ankit Enterprises is correct and also determine the tax, if applicable, as the goods are now moving out of Haryana.

[Nov. 20] TAXMANN®

FN O O ET I CA AT L R P O EP S HN T A NT R OR SI R E E H PT R DO EF R R E E T S V I O G S ER R E NI R UR NA A# L SU I K O M' AO R T A D ME TD A N !A H TE N R EA I S P D I C O EO R G EE HR T E H EW S A N CO NI ET VA C I O G L

EER HU HT T P NS IN I YA L EP + CP NU I 3 S iv

i.e.

Ans.

M/s Joinder Drills of Australia exports rough rock cutting diamonds to M/s Ankit Enterprises of India, a registered supplier in the State of Haryana. M/s Ankit Enterprises is expected to process them into tools and export the same to the supplier in Australia. The process does not involve any sophisticated process other than cutting, polishing and finishing. M/s Ankit Enterprises requests M/s Joinder Drills for use of such tools for his business in India for 3 months, which is agreed to by the supplier. It then exports it to the Australian supplier, invoicing it for ` 12,00,000 for processing it into the required tool.

Q. 23

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.16

i.e.

a

i.e.,

`

`

c

(i) Mr. X, an architect (Kolkata), provides interior decorator services to Mr. Y of New York (USA) in relation to his immovable property located in New Delhi.

(ii) Mr. A (a Chartered Accountant registered in Kolkata) supplies services to his client in Bhubaneswar (registered in Bhubaneswar, Odisha).

9 , 0 0 5 3 & / % # ! , 0

( #

5.17

(iii) ABC Ltd. of Patna imported certain goods from XYZ Inc. of USA. The goods were imported through vessel and delivery of goods was taken at Kolkata, whereafter the movement terminates and the goods are stored. (iv) Mr. X, registered in Guwahati, has availed land-line services from BSNL. The telephone is installed in residential premises in Kolkata and the billing address is office of Mr. X in Guwahati. (v) Mr. X, residing in Chennai, is travelling with an Indian Airline aircraft and is provided with movie-on-demand service for ` 100 as on-board entertainment during Delhi-Chennai leg of a Bangkok-Delhi-Chennai flight. (vi) Mr. X of Kolkata purchased online tickets for Aquatica water park in Mumbai. (vii) Mr. Z, an unregistered person of Kolkata, sends a courier from New Delhi to his friend in Chennai, Tamil Nadu while he was on trip to New Delhi. (viii) Mr. X, a registered person in Ranchi, Jharkhand, buys shares from a broker in Patna on NSE, Mumbai. Determine the place of supply of brokerage service.

Ans.

(i)

(iv)

E H T S I E N I L NS

OE I T C A I V C R IE N US F MO MT P OI CE EC L E E R T R DO EF XD lE L FL O A T YS AI N WS I YE BN SI L E CN I O V I T R A E S C I FN O U YM L P M PO UC SE FL E O T EE CH AT L E P R EE HH 4W N A T O A I T KA L C O O +L

(v)

T S R l E H T F O N O I T A C O L Y EE HN T R SU I O TJ F A E R H C T R R I A O F NT AH G DI Rm A OR BO T NF A OR SC E R I CA I V T R A E H S T FF O O YE L R P U PT UR SA P FE O ED CF AO L T P N EI HO 4P D E K L OU KD GE NH AC "S

(vi)

T N E M E S U M A N A O T N O I S S I M D A F O Y A W Y B D E D I V O RD PE T SA E C CO I V L R S E I S K FR O A YP L E P PH UT E SR FE O EH CW AE L C PA EL HP 4E H T I A S BI MK R UA -P

(vii)

RD E E I D R UN OA CH YE R BA SS DD OO OO GG FH O C NU OS I T H A C T I R OH PW ST NA AN R T O I FT O A C YO AL WE H YT BS SI E N CO I S V R R E E P S D FE O R YE L T

P S N PI O UGI E SR T A FA T O R NO EA P CH S AT N L P R A E R EH T HT R 4O I E NH I H T O L SR E R O $E F PR WAE EO V .T O

(viii)

E B L L A H S S NE OC S RI V E R PE S YF NO AR OE T I L SP E P CU I V S R E E H S T GF NO I K S OD RR BO C KE CR OE T S H FT O N YO L S PE PC UI SV R FE O S EF CO AT L P N E EI HP I 4C E DR NE AH HT KF RO A N HO *I

T A IC H CO NL AE H 2T EYN HRI A E T VD SL I N I ) SEO DDT OR OOD GFT S, HE : CT UA9 N SI 8 FM Y O B R YE D L TL P O PSS UDS O SO T E FG K O FC EO A CTP AN T L EU I P MC EE S HV I T B SOF DMO OEY L OH P GT P FHU O CS I TH F N O EWE MTC A EAL VEP OME IH MT ET SH E E VTR L O TF O VAE

NSRW D E I OH O YO 4 L N P GT K PEN C UH U E ST I , P EFI S HOC I T NES EORE I R EN T E I HL A HC T R I O! OT 7L

(ix)

S ET HE T K EC BA LP L AT I HU SC S

YI L BW P O PFN UOK SYC FLU P O P, EUS CS I AF E L O T P U EO EC HA R T I LT TPA F EH A HA R T C W R SU I U' A NHA A4T

A D DR K RA L A OOO BB+ N NNI OOS R DNE EEG I K L N A P E T PE S S UR A SA P ESE R DH A T SOO DOT OGS OHE C GU N I ES L HH R I T !

C EI R HN E A HWD I TN WA ) RNY E OB I HT T A D R L CO UO &L S Q. 25

[Place of supply of services provided in relation to training and performance appraisal] Dobriyal Technocrats Ltd., registered in Gurgaon, Haryana, is engaged in manufacturing heavy steel machinery. It enters into an agreement with Mindsharp Associates, registered in Delhi, for imparting motivational training to the top management of Dobriyal Technocrats Ltd. in a 5-day residential motivational training programme at an agreed consideration of ` 20,00,000.

TAXMANN®

R E T R O P M I E H T F O N O I T A C O L E H T S I A I D N ) O T N I D E T R O P M I S D O O G F O Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H 4

A N T A 0

(iii)

E D A M S E C I V R E S D E l I C E P S E H T T P E C X E SN

E CO I S V R R E E P S FH O C U Y LS P F PO UN SO FI O T A EC CO AL L P E H ET HS 4I N A HO SS I R D E /P D RE A R WE SS T E NI G AE BR UA HO "T

(ii)

S Y E I L T B R EA E CV P I V O O R R MP E S ML E FI O B NA TA V N EOO I T P NM I C OM ET I I R E A FL H ET O R E NNR O IE IY T H L A CT CW OE E L RC RIA ODL DP RE E E I I H L L T P P S PPI UUS SSR SO EE T HC A T I R V FR O O C E E NSD F OO I R T O YI A CLR OPT E P L UI N ES R F FO E HOT EA WC H EL AT S PG A CEI N HD AT U NAL ) C I D N I I H N D L ) YE E T E T R $D A E IP C S WT O OL EU RS .OP I

(ix) XYZ Ltd., New Delhi entered into contract with an Indian airline for the supply of biscuit packets for further supply by airline to the passengers in Kolkata-Guwahati route. The biscuits were loaded on board in Lucknow.

(Jan. 21)

ii

R E D N U S A D E N I M R E T E D S I S E I L P P U S E V O B A E H T F O H C A E F O T C E P S E R N I Y L P P U S F O E C A L P E H 4

SE E B CL I L V A R H E S S FN O O YS L R P E PP UD SE FR O E ET S CI AG L E P ER HA T O T L A I S A R TP C !P 4A 3E 'C )N EA HM T R FF O O R E P D

N

A NG ON I I N N T I C O A ER S S R FTE O O P T SN H NO C OI U I TS SA I LF V OEO RRN PNO I ED I T HE A T C RDO I E VL PO E SR H !P T

DP O ET R E S T T S I I O G

ETA R GN EN A IY HN T R IA OA T R( ST E LN T A A O NA I C OG I OT R SA S VU !I T' PO RM A H

SGD DNT I ND , I I S -V T OA YR R BP C DFO EO N I H L YC P PAE UW4 SYL SB A E Y R CD I I V TB R ,O E S$ S FTF A O O R YC N L O P O PNT I H UC A SE C F4 O O L ELE CAH AYT I L R S P B I EO T H$ N T E E M T R ONE F EG I E A P R N I E C A HE M 4R

F A T O N Y O L P I P T C U N

S U D E FGFT O N H A I CC EZ U O CI L ANSS A L O P I GT R Y EO N T HR OE R I T T O P FAO L YE R T R R P E N E I L PD TO B C A REV !P D IO 4EV L OM 3B 'ARM P )VS I E EOE H HMI CT T MV H FI RC O YEI NSH AGW N NI T I D A

U NL N O CI O IN T NA T IA OD I NC T OOO C I L EMT S CE MN H FO UT O CFE SC SB NA S L OF E L I A NH OI S I VYSS OAUY R BT PW R LE EYA P HBI O T SCR l E RC P F E O H PIY V C R SE NU !S AS i.e.

SE E N H T T A A RH I C T OS OFA SMJ S !UA PH2 RCA A HMN SUA DHR N#M I E LE -T E .

OO T ( M F UO HSM CM U MOH UOC HRM #EU LHH T E # T HL O T E (I T YWO BG( N DO E LH EA I L T LF P L PA UHO SEN O SC I E NA T CE I RC VE O R F L E SNE O FC H O T YFE L O B P L PNL O UI A TH SA FD S O EOE C M AMM L MA P R EOG C HC O T A R EF P R O OY G F N E A I R N WI E A HYR 4BT

FT 4E OA 3L B ER 'A CU )C A3 I L FL E O PPB PEL L HI AT

W E

BNL Y OP LI NL TP OAA H I U CS T SO C F E LO S E

NE T OC C A ADNL R NAP T AHE N TH O E T C RS

OU E L MH G ST NN 4 I A S

O Y I DR RT E C E O T DEDI I NSV R R UOO E I R T R EA PE R L A NEB ERA SC A E X SA CSE I S T C I V I E H R V T H E R T S NE N ) S G I NE HN I C L O N B UT I GA I A CSC S F I E I L O DP L H PC E RA IH OT H I T R OWE E N T B N SO TL I L I GA

E N HT H I S A T DYR A E RL O P J CTC PU NC CU I ' !!S 3

[Dec. 2021, 4 Marks]

Note: Your answer should also include relevant provisions of law.

AE I B D L NL ) A H OS T N Y I L P DP EU T S R OF PO ME IC A SL DP OE OH GT FE O S A YC L P PN UE SV I FG O E EH CT AI N L P S EU HH T 4

R E T R O TP C M !I 4E 3H 'TA )FK O FNA O T O A I TN A R NCA + OO L I T E C U HR ET S U L REA B E G L PA L N E SH " !S

ii

c

ii

a

i

N O I T A D O M M O C C A F O Y A W Y B S E T A I C O S S !

PE RM A HM SA DR NG I O -R OP T G MN I UN I HA CR MT E UH HT #G L N EI T Z O I (N A YG BR DO ER DO I F V L OE RT PO SH E D CI I A V S R E N 3I

i.e.

Q. 26. Determine the Place of Supply in respect of the following independent instances under the provisions of IGST Act, 2017: TAXMANN®

i

F O Y A W Y B

D T , S T A R C O N H C E 4 L A Y I T R BN OE $M E OG T A N SA E T M A I P C OO ST S S !I T PO RT A G HN SN I DI NA I R -T L A YN BO DI T EA V DI I T V OO RM PG SN E I CD I VI V R O E R 3P

i

Ans.

D E V L O V N I E R A S E I L P P U S O W T N O I T A U T I S N E V I G E H T N ) Ans.

8 !

4 3 % # ) 6 2 % 3

3 $ / / '

) 4 2 !

0

5.18

Mindsharp Associates books the conference hall alongwith the rooms of Hotel Chumchum, Neemrana (registered in Rajasthan) for the training programme, for a lump sum consideration of ` 12,00,000.

You are required to determine the place of supply in respect of the supply(ies) involved in the given scenario.

[RTP Nov. 2021]

inter alia,

(i) Miss Poorva, an interior design consultant having office at Chennai (Tamil nadu), provided professional services to Mr. Nihil, who resides in Dubai, for his two immovable properties under single contract, one property is outside India at Singapore and another at Surat (Gujarat).

(ii) United Traders, having a registered place of business at Bengaluru (Karnataka) imported instruments used in COVID treatment from London (UK) through Vizag (Andhra Pradesh) Port.

Indirect Tax Laws (IDT)|CRACKER AUTHOR PUBLISHER DATE OF PUBLICATION EDITION ISBN NO NO. OF PAGES BINDING TYPE

: : : : : : :

Mahesh Gour, K.M. Bansal, V.S. Datey TAXMANN June 2022 6th Edition 9789356222052 520 PAPERBACK

Rs. : 795 | USD : 44

Description This book is prepared exclusively for the Final Level of Chartered Accountancy Examination requirement. It covers the questions & detailed answers strictly as per the new syllabus of ICAI. The Present Publication is the 6th Edition & updated till 30th April 2022 for CA-Final | New Syllabus | Nov. 2022/May 2023 exams. This book is authored by CA (Dr.) Mahesh Gour & CA (Dr.) K.M. Bansal, under the guidance of CMA V.S. Datey. This book incorporates the following noteworthy features:

· Strictly as per the New Syllabus of ICAI · Coverage of this book includes: o All Past Exam Questions, including:  CA Final May 2022 Exam (New Syllabus) o Questions from RTPs and MTPs of ICAI · [Tabular Presentation of Answers] for easy learning · [Arrangement of Questions in Chronological Format] both ‘topic-wise’ & ‘category-wise’

· [Chapter-wise Marks Distribution] for Past Exams from May 2017 onwards

· [Trend Analysis] for Previous Exams from May 2018 onwards, for New Syllabus

· [Comparison with ICAI Study Material] Chapter-wise comparison with ICAI Study Material

· [Most Updated & Amended] This book is updated & amended up to 30th April 2022

ORDER NOW