August2013teach

Page 1

School Systems to Submit Differentiated Pay Plans Published by the TENNESSEE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION August 2013 y Vol. 45, No. 1 y www.teateachers.org Special Membership Edition

The Tennessee Department of Education (TDE) is requiring all school systems to submit differentiated pay plans this fall, and has tried to reset expectations on what will constitute an acceptable plan. A state law passed in 2007 requires every system to have a differentiated pay plan to aid in staffing hard-to-staff subject areas and schools, and to hire and retain Continued on page 13 highly qualified teachers.

TEA Urges Caution About Ramping up Testing

The stakes on testing have rocketed skyward in recent years. Test scores are now the foundation of teacher evaluation. Poor test scores can prompt a state takeover of a school. Jobs can be lost and professional standing jeopardized by low test scores. Judging by what state officials are planning, there is a real possibility testing stakes will keep rising. Recently proposed changes to teacher license renewal are rooted in test scores. New local pay plans demanded by the state could be based on test scores. A proposal to allow state officials to override local school boards on charters based on test scores is also in the works.

Licensure Based on Test Scores? For the first time in state history, Tennessee education officials are proposing to tie teaching licenses to student test scores. The Tennessee Department of Education is proposing to put teaching careers at risk as student test scores are expected to drop due to recently implemented and newly anticipated changes in state and national testing standards. According to the Tennessee Department of Education, “Using performance data collected through teacher evaluations, the department will ensure that all educators meet and maintain minimum standards of performance.” Does this mean licensure based on test scores? It will if Tennessee Education Commissioner Kevin Huffman gets his way. Tennessee has 20 types of teaching licenses at present. They are granted after a candidate passes one or more Praxis tests, and remain valid for 10 years. Huffman has proposed to increase the acceptable Praxis scores, reduce the number of license types and cut the number of years a professional license will be valid to six years. Under Huffman’s proposal, the initial license will be valid for three years. “We oppose any further penalty on the teaching profession,” said TEA President Gera Summerford. “Tennessee’s teachers are working as hard as they ever have, adapting to the everContinued on page 13 intensifying reforms.”

page 3

State officials are ramping up the consequences for teachers based on a few days of student testing in the spring of each year, just when these scores could plummet due to upcoming changes in curriculum. Tennessee is implementing Common Core State Standards next year, the greatest shift in standards and curriculum ever attempted. Fundamental to the Common Core is a change in testing. The state will no longer use TCAP, moving instead to a new test that measures the new Common Core standards. The problem with that is when you change the test, scores drop due to changes in format. Add to that massive upheavals in curriculum and teaching practice demanded by Common Core, and historic drops in test scores seem likely. Continued on page 4

How Good Is Tennessee?

Questions grow about Education Commissioner Kevin Huffman’s policies Last January, Tennessee Education Commissioner Kevin Huffman made a presentation to the Senate Education Committee with the theme that Tennessee schools are at the bottom of the barrel, implying that the quality of teaching and learning in our state needed a drastic overhaul. Huffman used fourth-grade reading and math NAEP scores—a national test that does not line up well with state curriculum—as a foundation for his presentation. The conclusion? Huffman’s reform efforts should get Tennessee out of the proverbial barrel. The problem, according to political observers and education experts, is that Huffman’s use of statistics showing Tennessee at the bottom doesn’t really measure up. Continued on page 11


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.