The Arabian Publication for Family Businesses Volume 15 Jul-Sep 2012
42
48
62
68
Dialogue between Generations: The Elnefeidi Family Dialogue between the second and third generation members Conversation with Bakul Jain, DCW Ltd., India On the ingredients of running a successful family business in India
Interview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum Insights and advice from a next generation family business member Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee: A Family with Flavour On a family’s passion for coffee and the Yemeni coffee industry
Next Generation Special Features
the
driving the family business into the future
tharawat magazine
THE ARABIAN PUBLICATION FOR FAMILY BUSINESSES Volume 15 Jul-Sep 2012
The Arabian Publication for Family Businesses
42
48
62
68
Dialogue between Generations: The Elnefeidi Family Dialogue between the second and third generation members Conversation with Bakul Jain, DCW Ltd., India On the ingredients of running a successful family business in India
Interview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum Insights and advice from a next generation family business member Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee: A Family with Flavour On a family’s passion for coffee and the Yemeni coffee industry
Publisher and Founder Dr. Hischam El Agamy Editor-in-Chief Ramia M. El Agamy
editor@tharawat-magazine.com
Next SPECIAL FEATURES
Assistant Editor Wafa Nasser Farhoud
wafa@tharawat-magazine.com
Editor-at-Large Farida F. El Agamy Creative Director Emad Khourfan
emad@tharawat-magazine.com
Photography Simon Charlton www.simoncharltonphotography.com Eric Mijares In-house Photographer Translation House Tarjomeh Localization Ltd., Dubai, UAE Printing House Al Ghurair Printing, Dubai, UAE Acknowledgements Many thanks go to The authors for their work and input. The advertisers for their kind contribution. The readers for their feedback on the previous issues and their continuous interest in Tharawat magazine. The Al Ghurair’s printing facilities for their excellent work.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
the
Generation driving the family business into the future
VOL 15 | Jul - Sep 2012 Any other use, including but not limited to, the publication, reproduction, modification, distribution, transmission, republication, display, creation of derivative works, or performance of the content, or any other use of the Content for commercial reasons, is strictly prohibited without the express written consent of Tharawat Media FZ LLC. If you wish to use content or artwork from Tharawat magazine please e-mail: info@tharawat-magazine.com To advertise in Tharawat magazine please e-mail or call: advertising@tharawat-magazine.com +971 (0)4 452 6578 www.tharawat-magazine.com ISSN-2077-3714 Tharawat magazine is printed on recycled woodfree paper. Illustrations: Getty / Gallo Images Disclaimer
Tharawat magazine is published four times a year by Tharawat Media FZ LLC, a company registered in Dubai Media City. Reproduction without permission is strictly prohibited. All content in this publication, including but not limited to all text, visual displays, images, and data (“Content”) is the property of Tharawat Media and its content suppliers or licensors and is protected by the United Arab Emirates and International copyright laws. The compilation of all content in this magazine, including but not limited to the collection, arrangement, assembly, and coordination of content, is the exclusive property of Tharawat Media and is protected by United Arab Emirates and International copyright laws. The content in this magazine may be viewed as information gathering resource. Tharawat Media FZ LLC cannot be held responsible for any unsolicited material.
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
1
contents
VOLUME 15 | JULY - SEPTEMBER 2012
10
Contributors Abdullah Al Zubair
The Zubair Corporation Muscat, Oman
Ahmed Ali Al-Hamdani Chairman, Al-Hamdani Export for Yemen Mocha Coffee, Yemen
Alexandra Sharpe
Partner at Peter Leach & Partners, UK
Amin Elnefeidi
President, Elnefiedi Group, Sudan
Anees R. Sultan
Head of Supply Division W.J. Towell & Co., Oman
Bakul Jain
Managing Director, DCW Limited, India
Ben Eavis
Corporate Responsibility Manager – International, DLA Piper Middle East LLP
Caroline Fattal Fakhoury
Vice President, Fattal Holding, Lebanon and Managing Partner, Praesta Middle East
Vice-Chairman, Al Ghurair Investment LLC, and Chairman, Al Ghurair Foods, UAE
Loay Anwar Ali Sultan, Supply Chain Officer, ENHANCE (Towell Group Company), Oman
Parimal Merchant
Director, Center of Family Managed Businesses, S.P. Jain Institute of Management and Research, India
Musab Elnefeidi
Kenana Sugar Company, Sudan
Prof. Craig Aronoff
Raid Maqbool Sultan, Marketing Manager, W.J.Towell & Co, Oman
Dr. Rania Labaki
Associate Professor of Management Sciences, University of Bordeaux IV, France
Chris Venter
Hassan Elnefeidi
Saleh Mohammed Al Habib
Crescent Petroleum, UAE
Board Member & General Manager, Seven RentA-Car, Elnefeidi Group, Sudan
VP Business Development Moh’d. Al Habib Real Estate, AlHabib Holding, KSA
José Luis Jiménez
Tony Bury
Banca March Family Business Fund, Spain
Dr. Hischam El Agamy
Founder and Executive Director, Tharawat Family Business Forum and Tharawat magazine, UAE and Switzerland
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
16
20
Family Business Consulting Group, USA
Razan Jafar
HR & Admin Director, Elnefeidi Group
2
Essa Al Ghurair
Founder, Mowgli, UK
Wafa Elnefeidi
Marketing manager, Bank of Khartoum, Sudan
Regulars 06 P ublisher’s Note
A few words by the publisher.
08 G lobal Family Business News
The moves of family firms across the globe.
10 F amilyBusiness2FamilyBusiness
The interactive survey results showing opinions of family members on the problems of the fictional Al Mamnoon family.
79 I nteractive
Our Tharawat magazine online activities and the Family Business Social Media page showing our picks from Twitter, Facebook, and Linkedin.
Zaid M. Al Habib
External Auditor - E&Y, Mohammed Al Habib Holdings, KSA
www.tharawat-magazine.com
VOLUME 15 | JULY - SEPTEMBER 2012 contents
32
42
26
36
Features
Special Features
48
52
16 Aligning Family and Business Culture 32 T he Next Generation: Visions of the Discover the family business culture model explaining the impact of values on behaviour and artefacts.
20 C SR in Arab Family Businesses: A Checklist
A checklist designed for family firms.
26 B anca March - A Family Business Investing in Family Businesses
One of the most successful banks in Europe is family-owned and has established a family business fund.
Future
A few opinions and quotes from next generation members.
36 A Conversation with Prof. Craig Aronoff Perspectives on the next generation in family businesses.
42 D ialogue between Generations: The Elnefeidi Family, Sudan
Dialogue between the second and third generation members of the Elnefeidi family.
48 I nterview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum
Insights and advice from a next generation family business member.
52 Q &A with Dr. Rania Labaki
Discussion on a successful next generation.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
3
contents
VOLUME 15 | JULY - SEPTEMBER 2012
58
62
68
74
Spotlight 58 F amily Managed Businesses in India:
The Opportunities and the Challenges
ExposĂŠ on characteristics, opportunities and challenges of Indian families and their businesses.
62 A Conversation with Bakul Jain, Managing Director of DCW Ltd.
Bakul Jain speaks about running a family business in one of the fastest growing economies in the world.
4
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
SMEs 68 A l Hamdani for Coffee: A Family with Flavour
Discover the century-old Yemeni Al Hamdani family business that has stayed true to its dedication to coffee for many generations.
74 M owgli: Mentorship in the Middle East
An exclusive interview with Mowgli Founder Tony Bury unveils the importance of mentorship for businesses in the Middle East.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
COMPLEXITY CONFUSES. CLARITY INSPIRES.
Structure is fundamental to successful wealth planning. We can help you make the right choices. Our global experts will set up your wealth in forms that safeguard your assets, optimise your financial affairs and meet the needs of your family. Life isn’t always structured. But we are.
rhoneservices.com
Publisher’s Note
Dear readers, This issue has caused a lot of excitement in the Tharawat
In the first part of our Spotlight series on Indian family
magazine offices: Between organising our photo shoot for
businesses, we enjoy an introduction by Parimal Merchant,
the Next Generation special feature, getting to know family
and are honoured by the stimulating interview we had with
business pioneer Prof. Craig Aronoff, creating the first CSR
Bakul Jain, Managing Director of DCW Ltd. Finally, our SME
check list for family businesses and starting our new Spotlight
section includes the fascinating story of the Al Hamdani
section on family businesses in India, there was hardly a
family business from Yemen and a conversation with Tony
moment to catch our breath. So here it is, our issue 15:
Bury, founder of the Mowgli foundation, on the importance of mentorship for entrepreneurs in the Middle East.
Following
our
usual
introductory
pieces
on
the
first pages (Global Family Business News and the
We hope you enjoy reading this issue.
FamilyBusiness2FamilyBusiness Survey), we begin this issue with an interesting mix of content in our features section: Alex Sharpe delivers an insightful analysis of family business culture, which is followed by the first check list for CSR in Arab family businesses developed by Ben Eavis and our Editor-in-Chief Ramia El Agamy. Also in this section you will find out more about one of Europe’s last familyowned banks, Banca March, and its decades-old strategy of investing in other family businesses. Our Special Feature is dedicated to, arguably, the greatest challenge and opportunity that family businesses face: The Next Generation. Various testimonials from next generation members from Arab family businesses are followed by the insights from family business members of different ages and origins: Read our great interviews with the Elnefeidi family and with Razan Jafar from the Crescent Petroleum company as well as two expert articles from Prof. Craig Aronoff and Dr. Rania Labaki.
6
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
Dr. Hischam El Agamy Publisher and Founder Tharawat magazine Tharawat Publishing FZ-LLC
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Where family and business come together
August 29-31st, 2012 The Langham Hotel Mayfair, London
The Continuum Family Business Conference is a yearly conference bringing together leading business families from the Middle East, Asia, Europe and Latin America. Continuum is a unique opportunity for families to meet, enjoy a family-focused program, exchange experiences, debates on global and regional issues and share visions.
for registration conference@tharawat.org or visit www.continuum2012.org www.tharawat.org
GLOBAL FAMILY BUSINESS NEWS
GLOBAL FAMILY BUSINESS
7 8 5
9
6
4 3
1
2 10
News
Read up on the latest news of family businesses all over the world
01 | Mexico
Carlos Salim Stakes in YPF 8.4% stake in YPF, Argentina’s Oil Company was taken over by the Mexican billionaire Carlos Salim. The Eskenazi family of Argentina borrowed billions of U.S. dollars through their holding company Grupo Peterson to acquire a quarter of YPF but failed to repay the debts, especially, after losing access to the YPF dividends due to the recent nationalisation of the company. Salim’s Bank Grupo Financiero Inbursa SAB was one among many financial institutions that received the YPF shares as a collateral, making Salim the fourth-largest shareholder of the company. The world’s richest person, Carlos Salim, hasn’t come to a final decision whether to keep the stakes in YPF or not.
Carlos Salim
8
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
02 | Hong Kong
Li Ka-shing’s Succession Plan In a move that is considered controversial amongst business leaders in Asia, Hong Kong’s richest man Li Kashing put an end to the investors’ speculations about his succession plan and named his eldest son Victor as the next in line to the familyowned conglomerate, Cheung Kong. For almost a decade, the 47 year-old has been the Managing Director at Cheung Kong and the Deputy Chairman at Hutchison. To preserve the family business values and success, the newly appointed successor will be surrounded by a loyal team of a long-time managers and assistants of his father Li Ka-shing.
03 | UAE & Qatar
Damas and Mannai Corp More than 75% of the shareholders in the Dubai-based jeweller, Damas, have accepted to sell 66% of the company’s shares to the Qatari conglomerate, Mannai Corp. 14% of the remaining shares will go to EFG Hermes and 15% will remain in the hands of the Abdullah brothers. Mannai Corp., which will become the majority stakeholder of Damas, will delist Damas from NASDAQ Dubai. 04 | Italy
Ermenegildo Zegna Goes East Ermenegildo Zegna the top Italian luxury goods groups, is opening its first stores in Algeria and Morocco, which will establish a presence for the family company in Africa and the Middle East. The century-old group’s expansion extends into foreign markets such as China and the US and is combined with their attempts to acquire other high end Italian brands.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
GLOBAL FAMILY BUSINESS NEWS
09 | Italy & US
05 | USA
Woolpert Family Loss
Fiat Industrial and CNH Merger
The president and CEO of the Graniterock construction company, Bruce W. Woolpert, died in a boat accident in Florida in June 2012. The company has appointed the nonfamily board member Mark Kaminski to be chairman and acting chief executive of the 112 year-old familyowned company. The late Bruce Woolpert took over his family company 25 years ago and succeeded to turn it into one of the best places to work for in America according to Fortune 500’s listing.
Fiat Industrial, the world’s third-largest Capital Goods group by revenue, has proposed to merge with the group’s majority owned US listed unit, CNH. The newly merged company will be listed at the New York Stock Exchange and secondarily in Europe. The merger will guarantee Fiat a better access to capital markets away from the debt crisis in the Euro zone countries.
06 | Italy
Benetton’s New Chairman The board of directors of the Italian retailer Benetton has named Alessandro Benetton the new Chairman of the group his family controls by owning 73% of its shares. The appointment of the Harvard Business School graduate came after the resignation of the founder of the group, Luciano Benetton in April 2012.
07 | Germany
10 | Philippines
German Family Business Trends
Ayala Corporation
A 2011 survey conducted by Deutsche Bank and the BDI industry federation showed that 40% of family-owned companies in Germany are increasing their manpower and half of them are considering investment opportunities. Two thirds of the 408 firms surveyed in the study are hoping for a better economic future and are evaluating their economic outlook for 2012 as good or very good. According to the study, the majority of the German family companies are still heavily depending on bank financing instead of bringing in outside investors on board.
Ayala Corporation, Philippines’ oldest conglomerate, is forming a joint venture with Metro Pacific Investments Corp. (MPIC) under the name of ‘Light Rail Manila Holdings, Inc’ to extend the Light Rail Transit Line 1 (LRT). The P60-billion Philippine Peso project will be identified under the government’s Public-Private Partnership (PPP) program and will be open for companies to bid for. Both local and international companies have expressed their interest in the project.
08 | Switzerland
Reichle & De-Massari (R&M) The family-owned Swiss cable provider, Reichle & De-Massari (R&M) has declared its ambitious expansion plan in the Middle East and Africa. Besides increasing the company’s presence in the local markets, R&M addresses the scarcity of proper technical expertise in the region by providing technical training to both its employees and partners.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
9
Introduction FamilyBusiness2FamilyBusiness
The fictional Al Mamnoon Group is a successful Kuwaiti family business that is run by the second generation after its founder, Mohammed Al Mamnoon, faced sudden health issues and had to retire. With his two sons Rashid and Khalid in charge the business continues to strive. So much so that the third generation is gradually joining the family business in various different ways. This transition is challenging for the family and results in a few difficulties between Rashid and Khalid. Find out what advice Arab family business leaders give to the Al Mamnoon Group through this issue’s Tharawat magazine case study survey.
The Al Mamnoon Family and the Third Generation Challenge
T
he Al Mamnoon group was established in
Over the years, Mohammed and his two sons worked very
1967 in Kuwait by Mohammed Al Mamnoon.
hard to build a strong and diversified group of companies.
With great commitment and hard work
In the 90ies the Al Mamnoon group established activities in
Mohammed grew his small trading business
agriculture, finance and real estate, as well as a successful
into a diversified business group in few years.
cement factory.
Mohammed’s first son Rashid chose to pursue his engineering
In the 2000s however, Mohammed faced sudden health
studies in Egypt. While in Cairo, he got married to Mona
problems. He trusted Rashid’s expertise and sense of business
Al Masri, whose family owned and operated a large cotton
and put him in charge of the day-to-day business activities. As
plantation in Egypt and they had three children together
the two brothers got on well, they decided to start a holding
after they moved back to Kuwait: Ahmed, Marwa and Tarek.
structure, Al Mamnoon Investments, to ensure that the family’s ownership remained clearly structured. Both Rashid and
Khalid, Mohamed’s second son, had always been passionate
Khalid would own 30% each while Mohammed kept 40%, and
about the fine food and service industry and wanted to
remained the non-executive Chairman. The brothers arranged
establish the Al Mamnoon Group as a leader in five-star
the management of the companies amongst themselves.
hospitality. However, his father was reluctant to start a
10
business so different from the core activities of the company
In the meantime, two of Rashid’s three children, Ahmed
in trade and manufacturing.
and Marwa, finished their studies and decided to go and
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
FamilyBusiness2FamilyBusiness Introduction
Rashid and Khalid got together to discuss the situation of the next generation. After the discussion, they were both unsatisfied.
live in Egypt to work in the Al Mamnoon Cotton business
in Egypt. Their uncle Khalid did not appreciate this, since
which Rashid had founded together with his wife’s family.
neither Ahmed nor Marwa had ever worked in another field
Ahmed and Marwa worked for the two cotton factories in
than the cotton industry.
Cairo (spinning and yarn manufacturing) and in Alexandria (the weaving plant).
Meanwhile, Ali, Khalid’s son, has not been very motivated to stay in the family business. One night, he was out with
Khalid and his wife Alia had two children, Ali and Yasmeen.
a group of friends and he started to express his frustration
Since he finished his studies in 2004, Ali is active in the family
about his situation. One of his friends captured his angry
business as a junior manager of Al Mamnoon Investment, the
speech on video and posted it online. What was supposed to
holding company. Yasmeen followed her father’s passion for
be a normal chat between a group of friends, now became
fine food and is a highly decorated Chef in London. With
hot gossip in the Kuwaiti business community.
offers to open her own restaurant in Europe, Yasmeen is still reluctant to join the family business.
Rashid and Khalid got together to discuss the situation of the next generation. After the discussion, they were both
In 2011, Ahmed and Marwa returned to Kuwait after the
unsatisfied: Rashid felt that Khalid did not want his children
political unrest in Egypt. The future of the Al Mamnoon
to join managerial positions, even though they had been
cotton factories was uncertain. Back in Kuwait Ahmad and
working for a while. Khalid on the other hand felt his brother
Marwa wanted to work as mid-level managers, as they had
was angry with him because of Ali’s remarks.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
11
Introduction FamilyBusiness2FamilyBusiness
Survey Results
After sending out the Al Mamnoon case study in a survey to over 100 family business executives, responses produced the following results.
On a scale from 1 to 5, how justified to you think Khalid’s negative reaction to giving Ahmed and Marwa managerial positions in the group?
Very unjustified
Unjustified
00%
42.86%
Neutral 28.57%
Justified 28.57%
Very justified 00%
Would it be beneficial for Ahmed and Marwa to have some education before joining the family in Kuwait?
Very unlikely
Unlikely
00%
00%
Neutral 00%
Likely
Very Likely
71.43%
28.57%
Will Ali’s action have an impact on the Al Mamnoon family reputation?
12
Very unlikely
Unlikely
14.29%
28.57%
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
Neutral 00%
Likely
Very Likely
28.57%
28.57%
www.tharawat-magazine.com
FamilyBusiness2FamilyBusiness Introduction
Do you think that what Ali did is something that the family can control and solve internally?
85.71% YES 00% NO 14.29% Other: Has to be solved internally and publicly
Should the Al Mamnoon family consider getting into the food industry to fulfill Yasmeen’s ambitions?
71.43% YES 14.29% NO 14.29% Other: If beneficial, depending on a feasibility studies.
Results Summary for the Al Mamnoon Family
When summarising the results above we can see that respondents have the following opinions on the Al Mamnoon family case:
85.71% 71.43% 71.43% 42.86% The great majority of surveyed family members believe that the problem caused by Ali’s mistake can be solved within the family.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Over 70% agree that the Al Mamnoon family should go into the food industry to fulfil Yasmeen’s ambitions and to provide her with a place in the family business.
Respondents believe it would be beneficial for Ahmed and Marwa to get some further education before joining the family business.
Less than half of the respondents believe that Khalid’s negative attitude towards his nephew and niece joining the business is not justified.
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
13
FEATUREs
FEATURES 16
20
26
Discover the family business culture model explaining the impact of values on behaviour and artefacts.
A CSR type check list designed for family firms in the Middle East.
One of the most successful banks in Europe is familyowned and has established a family business fund.
Aligning Family and Business Culture
www.tharawat-magazine.com
CSR in Arab Family Businesses: A Checklist
Banca March-A Family Business Investing in Family Businesses
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
15
FEATURES
Aligning Family and Business Culture
Aligning Family and Business Culture
How to Create Competitive Advantage Originally an anthropological term within the social sciences, “culture” is, in everyday language, a word typically associated with the characteristics and customs of nationalities, religions or regions. Since the 1980s, the term “culture” has been applied to businesses and many companies now put considerable time and resources into strengthening their “corporate culture”. However, families have cultures too; it follows that, in a family business, a family can use its own culture to create considerable competitive advantage for its business. Alexandra Sharpe, Partner at Peter Leach & Partners, UK, expands on the considerable advantages that can be gained from aligning family and business values.
What is “Family Culture”?
drive and how the family dines together (types of
Every family, business-owning or not, has its own
food, quietly or loudly, formal or relaxed).
culture. In practice, family culture is what binds any family together, it is what informs people’s
Family Behaviours:
perceptions about a given family and it is what
The next layer within the culture model is
creates a family’s and reputation. It is what makes
“behaviours”, both conscious and unconscious:
every family unique. While, in theory, culture has
Within family culture, behaviours include how a
been defined and explained in many different
family deals with conflict, grief, celebration and
ways, a useful model for business families to
philanthropy, how a family shows love, greets
adopt, if they want to use their family culture to
new spouses, and has fun together. In summary,
create advantage for their business, is the one
behaviours describe how families go about their
depicted in Figure 1. According to this model,
activities and how are things get done.
culture is comprised of three layers, with family values at the core:
Family Values: At the heart of a family’s culture are the family’s
16
Family Artefacts:
deeply held “values”: Values are what drive
An “artefact” here describes culture at its most
behaviour and what lead to certain artefacts
visible level: Artefacts are the surface-level aspects
within a family’s culture. Therefore, as it is
of culture that are easy to observe. Examples
impossible to observe values directly, people
within a family’s culture include the type of dress
interpret what a particular family’s values are
the family wears (traditional or modern, modest
by the way they behave and the artefacts they
or colourful), the sort of cars the family chooses to
observe. For example, you might infer that a family
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Aligning Family and Business Culture
FEATURES
Figure 1: Family Culture Model developed by Peter Leach & Partners based on social psychologist Edgar Schein’s conception of culture
Family Values
Family Behaviours
Family Artefacts
Family Artefacts
Artefacts are the surface-level aspects of culture that are easy to observe from the outside.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Family Behaviours
Behaviours can for instance include how a family deals with conflict, grief, celebration and philanthropy.
Family Values
Values are what drive behaviour and what lead to certain artefacts within a family’s culture.
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
17
FEATURES
Aligning Family and Business Culture
that often attends charitable events includes philanthropy as a core value or that a family who spends a lot of time together deeply values “unity” or “togetherness”.
Family and Business: Implications for Culture When a family owns a business, things can get complicated: As much as a family has a culture, so does a business. Business culture can be structured into values, behaviours and artefacts. In a family business, the family and the business culture meet. When both are aligned considerable benefit can be generated. A strong family culture aligned with a strong business culture can create a powerful brand identity, with an extra dimension that other business models simply cannot compete with. In addition, a strong connection between the values of the family and the business tends to result in a strong connection between the next generation of family members and the business. Moreover, a business with a strong value-led culture, owned by a family with strong, identifiable values and principles, can result in a motivated, high-performing workforce.
Firstly, families should articulate what their underlying core values are. This can be achieved,
At the start of the lifecycle of a family business, this
using the model of culture described above, by
alignment is created naturally as the founder creates
spending time considering what is unique about
the business with his/her own values; but as the family
their family’s artefacts and behaviours, telling stories
and the business grow, the culture of both becomes
and thinking about what the unwritten, unspoken
more complex and can fall out of alignment. In these
rules are within their family. Once understood, these
cases, either the family’s values change over time or
values can then be clearly communicated to future
the business’s culture evolves first. Therefore, after
generations and the accompanying behaviours that
the first generational transfer, additional attention is
are expected can be discussed. By a family discussing
required to ensure that the family business capitalises
and revisiting their values on a regular basis and
on its family ownership by continuing the alignment
of course through key family members leading
of the family’s and the business’ culture.
by example, the continuity of their culture can be maintained and passed down through generations.
18
Using Family Culture to Gain Competitive Advantage
Secondly, once the family has clearly articulated its
In order for a business to gain competitive advantage
values, the next step to create competitive advantage
from a family’s culture, considerable work is needed:
from family culture, is to ensure that the family’s
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Aligning Family and Business Culture
FEATURES
In reality, it is not really about creating alignment; it is about constantly re-creating alignment between the family and the business culture. between the two, work can be done to ensure continuity of the business’ culture. This involves embedding the underlying values of the business into all of its systems and processes. Doing so within the HR function is especially important, as after all, it is a business’ staff that demonstrates the values of the firm on a day-to-day basis. For example, recruitment processes can be designed in such a way that people are hired whose values are consistent with those of the business, and appraisals and incentive plans can values are understood by external stakeholders:
be structured in a way that encourages employees to
This is how the identity of the family can add value
live the values of the firm.
to business reputation. Many families do this by either creating a booklet or adding this information
In reality, it is not really about creating alignment; it
to their website. The key here is that the values
is about constantly re-creating alignment between
communicated are not entirely of aspired nature –
the family and the business culture. As the family
the behaviour of the family must be consistent with
and businesses develop, so will their cultures and,
the stated values. If family members are observed
therefore, a continuous process is needed to enable
to behave in accordance with their values, over time
the family and business culture to evolve together.
people begin to expect certain positive attributes
By taking the steps outlined above and putting time
from them and considerable goodwill is created.
and energy into revisiting the culture of the family
However, if there is inconsistency between the values
and the business, a family business can generate
that are communicated and the behaviour of the
potentially
family distrust may arise.
advantage.
Thirdly, once the family’s values are understood, it is also possible to test to what extent they are aligned with the business. Assuming there is alignment
www.tharawat-magazine.com
powerful
long-term
competitive
Author Alexandra Sharpe, Partner at Peter Leach & Partners, UK
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
19
FEATURES
CSR in Arab Family Businesses
CSR in Arab Family Businesses A Checklist Family businesses are said to be the backbone of Arab economies. They are strongly embedded in their communities and consider themselves responsible not only for their own welfare but also for that of the people around them. They take great care in transmitting their values both to the next family generations as well as their non-family stakeholders. While culture and religion dictate many of these values, each family adds its own ingredient that often is based on a specific characteristic that can be traced back to the business founder. Generally, philanthropy is a great part of Arab culture and there is need of it for the region faces many social and environmental challenges that need to be addressed by the private sector. Like many other things in the family business, strategies around social engagement, while successful, tend to be informal. More and more, however, strategic CSR activities are emerging with families dedicating funds to job creation, poverty alleviation, education, and the arts, which are aligned with their core business activities. But what is Corporate Social Responsibility and how have and can Arab family businesses successfully implement it? In this article Ben Eavis, International CSR Manager at the world’s largest law firm, DLA Piper, and Ramia M. El Agamy, Editor-in-Chief of Tharawat magazine, propose definitions of CSR, why it is a fit for family businesses, and, finally, a CSR checklist providing you with a tool to find out what type of CSR strategist you really are.
20
On Corporate Social Responsibility
Strategic CSR goes beyond charity and philanthropy,
Corporate Social Responsibility (also known as
it is about ensuring that businesses are serving the
Corporate Responsibility or Sustainability) can
interests of society and the environment, whilst
be defined as conducting business in a way that
in turn the self-interest of the company. The
not only aims to make a financial return but that
concept of CSR is underpinned by the idea that
encourages full awareness of the economic, social
corporations can no longer act as isolated economic
and environmental impacts of an organisation’s
entities operating in detachment from broader
activities. Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
society. Key areas of CSR include environmental
describes the behaviours of an organisation that
protection, the wellbeing of employees, financial
go beyond basic legal compliance and one that
transparency, suppliers ethical and environmental
promotes a vision of responsible business practice,
responsibilities and impacts on the community and
transparency, and accountability to stakeholders.
civil society in general.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
CSR in Arab Family Businesses
FEATURES
A robust approach to managing CSR is to divide the business activities into four key areas: Creating jobs Community regeneration Strategic community engagement Employee volunteering Cause related marketing Company donations and philanthropy
Energy efficiency Waste management Supply Chain efficiency Carbon foot print reduction Sustainable design Biodiversity Environmental Management System
COMMUNITY
quality, diversity E and inclusion Fair pay and benefits Learning and development Reward and recognition Employee health and wellbeing Employee engagement Health and safety
ENVIRONMENT
Responsible marketing Responsible advertising Ethical and environmental standards of suppliers Treat suppliers as partners Respect customers and protect vulnerable customers
WORKPLACE
MARKETPLACE
A robust approach to managing CSR is to divide the
way that also creates value for society by addressing
business activities into four key areas:
its needs and challenges. The creation of shared value
Community - Managing the impact of the
is a new way to achieve economic success that links
business on the community
to the core of the business.
Environment - Managing the impact of business on the environment
CSR in Arab Family Businesses
Workplace - Ensuring the business has a diverse,
The Arab world faces many challenges on the social
skilled and healthy workforce and promotes
and environmental level: Unemployment, access
diversity, and fair pay.
to education, water scarcity, waste management,
Marketplace - Responsible business behaviour
employee equality, and many other issues.
throughout the supply chains and through the marketing and development of products and
Family businesses, especially in the Arab world,
services.
are uniquely well equipped to design lasting and successful CSR strategies. Due to their natural
Activities and policies within these four areas lead to
inclination towards longevity and their understanding
the creation of “shared value�, which can be defined as
of how their success depends on their standing in the
the policies and operating practices that enhance the
community, Arab family businesses inherently carry
competitiveness of a company while simultaneously
all the characteristics of CSR strategists.
advancing the economic and social conditions in the communities in which it operates. The principle of
Some have commented that Arab business families
shared value involves creating economic value in a
are not being strategic and transparent in their
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
21
FEATURES
CSR in Arab Family Businesses
philanthropy. This criticism may stem from the fact that whilst many families are renowned for the their charity, it is rarely known whether they engage in actual CSR planning. It stands to argue that in a region where the concept of CSR is still relatively young, there may be very little visibility of those families that have CSR policies in place. It is known that many family businesses in the region have engaged in extensive activities for the purposes of job creation, poverty alleviation, environmental sustainability, equal treatment of minorities and many other causes. The fact is that for Arab society at large, the longevity of family businesses is of the greatest importance. In a way assuring the longevity of family businesses is a social responsibility in itself. This highlights how important it is for family businesses to educate themselves and others in the CSR field and to set an example for the private sector in the region.
How much CSR are you already doing? Often family businesses are not aware to what extent they already engage in CSR activities. In family businesses this is often the case; many business
Often businesses are not aware to what extent they already engage in CSR activities.
families do not think twice about the “good” they are doing and rarely think of giving it names or formulating it into policies. Here are a few examples
legal services in the world. This engagement sees the
of family and non-family businesses that have made
firm utilise their greatest resource, their people, to
efforts in formulating CSR strategies aligned with their
contribute to their local and global communities.
businesses: Cause related marketing - Burjuman Shopping Centre, Community
22
Dubai
Strategic Community Engagement - DLA Piper
The Burjuman Pink Breast Cancer Walkathon is
In each of the firm’s offices around the world, DLA Piper
an annual event to raise awareness and campaign
make a commitment to public services by dedicating
on breast cancer. This event not only raises a lot of
their lawyer’s time and legal expertise to projects
money for this worthwhile cause but in turn raises the
related to education, enterprise and equality. In 2011,
profile of the Burjuman shopping centre and increases
DLA Piper donated more than 193,000 hours, for a
customers visiting the shopping centre, thereby
contribution of $108 million worldwide through their
increasing revenues. Such cause-related marketing
pro bono and community engagement programmes.
when executed well is a classic win-win between a
This makes them the largest provider of pro bono
business and the community.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
CSR in Arab Family Businesses
Environment
FEATURES
calories contained in their products. Within the
Zero waste - Interface
Middle East some fast food retailers even include
The carpet tile company, Interface, has developed a
the calories contained in their products on their
leading sustainability strategy called Mission Zero.
menus to enable their consumers to make informed
A key aspect of this strategy has been to eliminate
food choices. Many fast food companies have
all forms of waste in every area of their business.
introduced healthy alternatives to give customers
After achieving their early goals of sending zero
more choices, which do not have a detrimental
operational waste to landfill, Interface extended
impact on their health.
their efforts throughout their entire supply chain. Workplace Energy Efficiency - UK supermarket sector
Health and Safety - Al Futtaim Carillion
The UK supermarkets regularly compete on prices but
Al Futtaim Carillion has a strong commitment
more recently the comparison has been redefined to
to health and safety and to ensuring that labour
the goal of energy reduction and efficiency. Tesco have
and safety standards of their own people as well
introduced the target of being a zero carbon business
as their contractors are a top priority. Improving
by 2050, whilst this is the most ambitious target it is
their health and safety performance is one of their
so far away that it is hard to relate to. Probably a more
key strategic objectives.
realistic and leading target is Sainsbury’s commitment to reduce their absolute environmental footprint by
Health and Wellbeing - Du
50%. This required a $1 billion investment but will
Telecommunication provider Du has developed and
eventually save the company money. Waitrose have
implemented an engaging, multi layered approach
similar targets but are a fraction of the size of the other
to helping employees understand and address some
two businesses.
of their cardiovascular risks by implementing a range of assessments, appointing a full time
Marketplace
physician, a calendar of health and wellness events,
Responsible Supply Chain - Burberry
activity programmes, educational material and
Burberry believes that its products should be made
workshops as part of its developing health and
only in factories that comply with local labour
wellbeing strategy. Engaging a workforce on a
and environmental laws and by workers who can
well-designed health and wellbeing programme
exercise their right to freedom of association as well
provides the basis for employees to understand their
as collective bargaining. Members of Burberry’s CSR
basic health needs (blood pressure, cholesterol,
team are ensuring the implementation of the policy
diabetes, weight etc.) to which small adjustments
throughout the supply chain, working in partnership
to their lifestyle (diet, activity level etc.) can have
with third-party auditors and NGOs as appropriate
significant impact upon their quality of life and
to approve and assess the activities of suppliers. The
performance, both at home and at work.
team conducted over 700 audits, capacity building and hotline interventions in 2010/11.
These are all examples of firms having implemented CSR strategies within the four areas introduced.
Responsible marketing - Fast food retailers
The shapes and forms of CSR activities, however,
There is a growing trend for fast food retailers to
are endlessly variable and naturally depend on the
openly disclose the nutritional content and the
business undertaking them.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
23
FEATURES
CSR in Arab Family Businesses
What type of CSR strategist are you?
Find out what type of a CSR strategist you are by going through the checklists below: Community You engage in philanthropic activities that have little or nothing to do with your core business Your family business reacts to ad hoc charity initiatives that are brought to your attention You support one or two charities per year
Workplace You have HR policies in place that enforce equal opportunities Your employees receive fair and reasonable pay and benefit from the work that they do Family and non-family employees are evaluated based on the same criteria You have health and safety policies in place Your employees are regularly asked for their opinions on matters concerning them Marketplace You enforce high quality in customer support You established a robust anti-bribery and corruption policy You are transparent and allow customers to make informed decisions (e.g. Health advice on cigarettes) You treat suppliers as partners. You put in place fair payment terms for all suppliers
Community You collaborate with non-profit organisations to deliver community programmes and workshops You have employed a dedicated person responsible for community initiatives or CSR Your family board members are involved in community work You are actively sharing and learning from best practice in the region Your employees and family members take part in volunteering actions
Workplace You enforce CSR targets by including them in KPIs for your employees Your family and non-family employees, including board and management, are rewarded and recognised for their CSR work You have flexible working times and family friendly practices in place Your employees are given the opportunity to develop their skills through courses Marketplace You manage the impact of products or services and any unwanted consequences from normal use and actively discourage product misuse You actively manage ethical and environmental responsibility of your suppliers by implementing a policy on ethical and environmental sourcing You regularly realign your products and services to new market standards and social needs You address the issues surrounding the normal use of you core products (e.g. Toyota has popularised vehicles using less petrol)
24
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
CSR Reactive You are a family business that is working on a strategy for its philanthropy and CSR activities. Certain policies are already in place and are being enforced by individual family members. Your CSR practices are in their initial stages but have not spread throughout the whole family business yet.
Your family business is>>>
Environment You have developed an environmental management system that covers key areas of impact of your business You purchase more sustainable resources such as FSC certified wood products, recycled paper, etc. You have formulated short term environmental targets
Your family business is >>>
Environment You undertake little or no environmental activities You enforce recycling in your company You react to proposed ad-hoc environmental initiatives such as beach and desert clean ups You talk over environmental issues in family meetings
You are a family business that is aware and reactive to social and environmental issues. While you are active in your community and care for your employees, you do not have a fixed CSR strategy in place and not everyone in the family is aware of the social and environmental impact of the business.
CSR Proactive
www.tharawat-magazine.com
CSR in Arab Family Businesses
Community You have established a strategy addressing community issues relevant to your business You measure the impacts of business and community benefits You are developing cross-sector partnerships and are shaping best practice in community investment Your family name is linked to various education and social initiatives in your community
Workplace You use volunteering as a tool to train and develop employees. You have established a diverse and inclusive workforce You have developed a health and well being strategy and have implemented it Your family includes a commitment to CSR as a part of its value statements
You are a family business that has a CSR strategy and enforces it on many levels. The whole family and all employees are involved in the CSR activities. Your social and environmental engagement is the basis of your overall corporate strategy.
Marketplace You enforce responsible marketing of products (e.g. no advertising of products to children that are age-inappropriate) You audit suppliers to check compliance with policy on ethical and environmental sourcing You redesign products that can cause issues for consumers (e.g. removing fat, salt, sugar from food products) and withdraw harmful products from the market You develop cross-sector partnerships and shape best practice in responsible marketing and responsible supply chain management
Your family business is >>>
Environment You include environmental issues in board decision-making Your long-term environmental targets (5-15 years) have been developed and are being endorsed by the management and the family Your family has a reputation in environmental activism You look beyond your own business and work with suppliers and customers to reduce their environmental impact You develop cross-sector partnerships and shape best practice in environment
FEATURES
CSR Proficient
This test is by no means exhaustive and there are many
from core business activities
more aspects that define types of CSR strategies.
Appoint a family sub-committee that constantly
Establishing successful CSR practices in your family
works on CSR strategy
business can only be done by understanding that
Learning from other family businesses in the
a full commitment is required. Ideally, the whole
community sharing best practices
family and all non-family employees recognise the need for social and environmental awareness. If a
By establishing CSR strategies and enforcing them
family wants to get started with its CSR strategy
throughout the organisation, business families can
or move from one type to the next, the following
create competitive advantages while at the same
recommendations may be helpful:
time meeting social and environmental needs of the community.
Understand what CSR means as opposed to philanthropy and charity Consult with third party CSR and Corporate Philanthropy experts Sit with the family and understand social and environmental responsibilities that you derive
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Authors Ben Eavis Corporate Responsibility Manager International, DLA Piper Ramia M. El Agamy, Editor-in-Chief, Tharawat magazine
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
25
FEATURES
Banca March Family business fund
The Banca March was established in 1926 on the Balearic island of Palma de Mallorca by Juan March and his family. The March family quickly expanded across the neighbouring islands and has since become one of the leading banks in Europe. After nearly one century of existence Banca March is still entirely family-owned. Apart from the Balearic Islands, it has branches in the Canary Islands, Madrid, Barcelona, Zaragoza, Valencia, Alicante, Malaga, Cadiz, Luxembourg and London. The March family has always been known to invest into other family businesses. Recently, the family-owned bank has taken this strategy a step further by creating a family business fund. Tharawat magazine explores what makes a family business invest in family businesses.
Banca March
A Family Business investing in Family Businesses
About Banca March
and is one of the largest Spanish financial groups
The Banca March Group includes a variety of
with one of the highest solvency ratios in Europe
activities such as banking, investment and pension
(Core Capital of 26%). The bank is now in the
fund management, handled by March Gestión,
hands of the four brothers and sisters of the third
as well as insurance activities. Through its listed
March family generation: Carlos, Juan, Gloria and
holding company, Corporacion Financiera Alba, the
Eleonor March. With the fourth generation slowly
March group also owns long-term stakes in Spanish
taking their place on the company’s board the
firms. In recent European banking stress tests the
family seems to be gearing up for another century
Marches came out on top, which in the public eye is
of family ownership.
to a great deal attributed to the bank being owned
26
by a family with conservative values and business
Banca March is probably the only family-owned
ethics. Banca March has been ranked the first bank
Bank in Spain and today employs over 1400
in Europe for two years in a row by the World Bank
people. The March family is also known for its
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
26 percent
Banca March is one of the largest Spanish financial groups with one of the highest solvency ratios in Europe (Core Capital of 26%).
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Banca March Family business fund
1955
FEATURES
philanthropy; it established the Fundación Juan
bank holds family businesses in most of its private
March patrimonial and operative institution
investment portfolios. Taking their committment
dedicated to fostering culture and the arts in
to family-owned firms a step further, Banca March
In 1955 the Fundación Juan March was dedicated to fostering culture and the arts.
1955. Through the Fundacion, the March family
established a unique portfolio that only invests in
also supports research in its Centre for Advance
family businesses. But why are family businesses a
Studies and sponsors the Banca March Chair of
good investment? According to José Luis Jiménez,
Family Business at the University of the Balearic
CEO of March Gestión, family businesses are more
1400
Islands.
profitable than non-family business in the long-
year
employees Banca March employs over 1400 people.
run partly because they are more conservative:
The Family that Invests in Families
“Anytime you talk to a family member, they are
The March family has always considered family
talking about the next generation and what they
businesses a viable investment opportunity. This
want to leave them. They are not only talking about
strategy has led to considerable success and the
short-term results.”
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
27
FEATURES
Banca March Family business fund
25
Fact is that more than 15% of the companies listed
Most family businesses on the long run perform
in S&P 500 and Stoxx 600 are family businesses.
much better than non-family business. The Banca
Moreover, historically, family businesses have
March has experienced this first hand by investing
outperformed non-family businesses and also have
in them for the last 30 years and carrying out
percent
a better earning predictability. The Banca March’s
specific research on this topic. The research
family business fund is a vote of confidence that
appointed by Banca March aims to explain why
the intrinsic values of family businesses heighten
family businesses perform better than non-family
their odds of survival even during economic crises.
business. A first conclusion is that family businesses
25% of the company at least must be in the hands of one single family.
grow and create employment despite the crisis and
How Families Qualify
that they seem to go for low leverage and controlled
For a family firm to qualify as an investment
risk in investment.
opportunity in the eyes of the Banca March, 25%
28
of the company at least must be in the hands of one
Banca March did not only start the fund because
single family. Ideally, a senior family business member
of its own convictions with regards to family
is active in the executive committee or the board
businesses but did it in response to investors
of directors. The March family feels that a family
asking for such opportunities. Many family offices
member involved at top level is an advantage because
for instance seem to prefer to invest in family-
they know their business better than anyone else.
owned companies because they are aligned with
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Banca March Family business fund
FEATURES
Through its family business fund, the March family does not only think of the next generation of the family but applies that thinking to the next generation of investors as well. the organisation to the next generation. However, Banca March has found that companies that have reached the third and fourth generation mostly show the greatest potential as they tend to have strong protocols and structures in place. The
30 years
The Banca March has experienced this first hand by investing in family businesses for the last 30 years.
March family knows from its own decades of family their clients’ values and philosophies. Through its
history which faced them with many economic and
fund the March family has invested in all types of
political changes, how crucial such structures are
family companies: The core criteria is the quality of
and how they increase the odds of survival for
the business model not the origins of the business
family businesses.
or even its sectors or market capitalization, as confirms José Luis Jiménez. The fund selects the
Through its family business fund, the March
right businesses through its investment committee;
family does not only think of the next generation
a body constituted by the bank’s most distinguished
of the family but applies that thinking to the next
professionals who undertake an analysis of the
generation of investors as well. The family has its
economic environment, as well as the investment
own wealth fund and continues to invest, along
strategy with regard to the family businesses.
with its clients, into family businesses. Certainly, seeing a century-old family business such as the
Considering the Stage of the Company
Banca March investing and believing in family
Whether a family business is a good investment
businesses, cannot fail but be credible and,
opportunity or not is largely determined by what
hopefully, encourage others to do the same.
stage it is at. If the company is at a transition stage it can be riskier to invest as not all family businesses have been successful in handing over
www.tharawat-magazine.com
IN COLLABORATION WITH José Luis Jiménez, CEO, March Gestión
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
29
SPECIAL FEATURES
Next Generation Special Features
the
driving the family business into the future
30
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
SPECIAL FEATURES
32
36
42
48
52
The Next Generation: Visions of the Future
A Conversation with Prof. Craig Aronoff
Dialogue between Generations: The Elnefeidi Family, Sudan
Interview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum
Q&A with Dr. Rania Labaki: A Successful Next Generation
Opinions and quotes from next generation members.
Perspectives on the next generation in family businesses.
Dialogue between the second and third generation members of the Elnefeidi family.
Insights and advice from a next generation family business member.
Discussion on a successful next generation.
Every family business, no matter what its origins are, is concerned with the next generation. For many business families success is not only measured by its financial performance and growth, but also by how successfully the firm transitions from one generation to another and for how long the family retains ownership. The role of the next generation comprises the responsibility to preserve what was built by the parent generation and to leave its own mark by creating new value. Family members are considered part of the next generation at all ages as not only those family members that have just joined the business are included, but also those that are at senior management level. This special feature section is dedicated to the next generation. In a series of expert articles and interviews with family business members, we explore the various challenges that the next generation faces, what advantages it can bring to the family business, and why it is so important to communicate expectations between family members.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
31
SPECIAL FEATURES
THE NEXT GENERATION: VISIONS OF THE FUTURE
The Next Generation:
Visions of the Future The Next Generation of family businesses harbours talent, innovation, and more than anything opinions. Tharawat magazine recorded views of seven successful family business members and their insights on helping the business and the family ahead.
Anees Sultan Head of Supplies Division W.J. Towell & Co., Oman
I see the parent generation managing stakeholder with great levels of trust and respect. I would like the new generation to continue this practice, although I would suggest that levels of trust are checked with appropriate levels of independent views and advisors as stakes are usually higher as one becomes involved in group business level discussions, and allegiances have a tendency to shift with people’s interests. Respect, however, is something that I see missing in many new generation managers, which includes respect for the staff, for the client (many don’t even visit or know their clients) and indeed respect for work. This can be evident in showing up late or not working for a targeted goal or KPI. I would encourage the young generation to study engineering, IT, law, accounting, finance, or even medicine and economics, but not necessarily have a long-term career in these fields. The discipline and knowledge, as well as the analytical framework is essential in today’s business environment. Business requires a lot of value-added production and the world is infinitely more competitive now than before. On managing family, I think many parent generation members don’t start handing over part of their skills and knowledge until late in the game. This puts the new generation at a great disadvantage and may threaten the stability of the business. I feel they should make their voices heard and should organise meetings with the elders to stress the issue of the gradual time-honored hand over, provided of course they have acquired adequate levels of knowledge and experience. The next generation should instill a sort of training academy for all future generation, make a budget for it and run a highly competitive program to shape the best possible talent to lead the business in the future.
32
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
THE NEXT GENERATION: VISIONS OF THE FUTURE
SPECIAL FEATURES
Raid Maqbool Sultan Marketing Manager 5th Generation W.J.Towell & Co., Oman
In terms of job responsibilities, family members should be treated the same as non-family members. However, family members’ career paths are different, because they end up owning and managing the business. They need to be retained and the best way to treat them differently is to train them. Of course, planning education for the family members needs to be aligned with their career path.
Saleh Mohammed Al Habib VP Business Development, Moh’d. Al Habib Real Estate 2nd Generation Al Habib Holding, KSA
Family members should not be treated differently from non-family members. It’s not healthy for the business and it might affect the sustainability and the retention of talent.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
33
SPECIAL FEATURES
THE NEXT GENERATION: VISIONS OF THE FUTURE
Abdullah Al Zubair 3rd Generation The Zubair Corporation, Oman
Succession planning is one of the main challenges for family businesses, without it companies will most likely suffer and, in some cases, might not only end family relationships but also the business itself.
Zaid M. Al Habib
Abdullah M. Al Habib
Zaid Mohammed Al Habib External Auditor – Ernst&Young 3rd Generation Mohammed Al Habib Holding, KSA
As long as the family business has an educational plan for the next generation in place, they should invest to achieve it. The success depends on the plan itself; it has to be focused on developing the individual’s skills and potential, which will be used for the progress of the institution.
34
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
THE NEXT GENERATION: VISIONS OF THE FUTURE
SPECIAL FEATURES
Loay Anwar Ali Sultan Supply Chain Officer 5th Generation ENHANCE (Towell Group Company), Oman
It is important for the new generation to work outside the family business, especially if they work in wellknown regional or international organisations. This will allow them to confront different kinds of opinions and gain wide experiences, which they can apply once they join the family business. It will also teach them to be more responsible in their decisions as they are treated as normal staff and not as business owners.
Caroline Fattal Fakhoury Vice President 4th Generation Fattal Holding, Lebanon Managing Partner, Praesta Middle East
I strongly support the idea of having clearly written conditions of employment for family members wanting to join their family business. It is a key piece of the family governance jigsaw that sets expectations and helps avoid potential nepotism and related family conflicts.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
35
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Perspectives on the Next Generation in Family Businesses
A Conversation with Prof. Craig Aronoff
Perspectives on
the Next Generation in Family Businesses
Prof. Craig Aronoff has been in the family business field for near to 40 years. In 1994, he established together with family business pioneer and colleague Prof. John Ward the Chicago-based Family Business Consulting Group, which grew to be a hub of family business experts, serving family businesses in the US and internationally. Aside the vast amount of written material that Prof. Aronoff has produced over the years as an academic and consultant, he has also worked with hundreds of business families. Tharawat magazine taps into his extensive knowledge and finds out more about him, the agenda he sets for family businesses today, and his recommendations to the next generation.
36
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Perspectives on the Next Generation in Family Businesses
C
SPECIAL FEATUREs
raig Aronoff was born the eldest of three children in Atlanta, Georgia. In his youth, Craig used to help out in his father’s small entreprise. Looking back at that time he confesses: “It became clear to me by the age
of twelve that I would not join my father’s business. I started to make plans to leave for college when I was still in 8th grade and that is what I did.” Craig Aronoff became a business management professor, teaching organisational behaviour, theory, and communication for many years. When we hint at his reputation as one of the pioneers in family business research and education, Prof. Aronoff modestly replies that family businesses have always been of interest to many but that the subject had been neglected mid20th century, when researchers steered their focus towards the management of multinational corporations: “Everyone was serving primarily large public corporations and moved away from helping individuals developing resources for their families and communities. I feel that we have gotten back to a more traditional view nowadays.”, he says and confirms our belief that looking at the family business model is more relevant today than ever. In 1994, together with Prof. John Ward, he founded The Family Business Consulting Group, Inc. resulting in his collaboration with hundreds of families all over the world.
When a family business is successful, it becomes all about taking responsibility and assuming stewardship.
The Relevance of Family Businesses The role of family businesses remains undiminished in today’s economies: They are often principal job creators
Studies show that many of the largest businesses in the
and community benefactors. “I think it has always been the
world are or at least started out as family businesses.
role of family businesses to act in a way that is responsive
“Economies should really be looked at as stools with
not only to the economic but to the social and cultural
three legs: Governments, publicly traded enterprises, and
needs of their communities. A business family’s view on
privately owned entreprises.” Prof. Aronoff declares. “Such
making money tends to be fundamentally different from
a stool can be awfully wobbly if the latter leg is not there
that of non-family corporations. When a family business is
and in an economic era like the present we feel this keenly.”
successful, it becomes all about taking responsibility and
He adds that in times of crisis family businesses tend to be
assuming stewardship.”, adds Prof. Aronoff. It is why, even
more people oriented and are known to retain staff in spite
after several decades, he continues to enjoy his work with
of down-turns; a strategy that is shown to be rewarding
business families.
when economic times improve.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
37
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Perspectives on the Next Generation in Family Businesses
The Changes in Understanding the Family Business Like any other discipline, the family business field and best practice has changed considerably over the years. When we ask Prof. Aronoff about this, however, he underlines, that it
d) Assuring outstanding leadership for the family and the business. e) Developing policies for the integration of the next generation.
is more likely that it is our understanding of family firms that has evolved rather than they in themselves. In his decades of
Prof. Aronoff further elaborates: “Our understanding of how
experience, he has seen the family business practice focus shift
the family business works is broader and more systemic. It
from a management to an ownership and family relationships
is not just reduced to picking the best manager or CEO. For
related approach. According to Prof. Aronoff, the priorities for
example, I remember once working with the third generation
family businesses nowadays are the following:
of a family business; they were three cousins. The initial
a) Understanding what it means to be owners.
question that concerned the second generation was who
b) Having a vision as owners and agreeing on values and
should lead the business. I convinced the family to let the
goals by learning to speak in one voice. c) The setting up of a good governance structure.
38
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
three cousins work together to articulate their visions for the company, their understanding of the relationship between
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Perspectives on the Next Generation in Family Businesses
The mistakes in dealing with the next generation:
1
Raising children with a sense of entitlement
2
Leaving the next generation a legacy that is hard to structure
3 4
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Founders tend to create high accountability for themselves but do not create management models that are easily replicable. best practice for yourself. Rather than doing so I encourage anyone to observe what mistakes others make and to learn from them.” He identifies the following four major mistakes he has witnessed in family businesses dealing with the next generation:
Falling short of fostering strategic awareness
The first mistake often happens in the early childhood of family members: If children are raised with a sense of entitlement and no understanding of hard work, things become tricky very early on. “Sometimes allowing your children to fail and learn how
Paying inadequate attention to building family identity
to overcome adversity can be greatly beneficial.”, underlines Prof. Aronoff. He adds that if children are raised believing that they are not accountable, it could lead to serious problems in the family business. “You can hire non-family CEOs and other executives and keep the business going to buy time, but you still need to develop the key qualities in family members if you
the business and the family, and their view on governance
want them to take responsibility.”
structures. The three cousins came back to their elders with a 25-page document including their collective vision
The second mistake Prof. Aronoff observes in business
of the future. They had concluded that the issue wasn’t so
families, is to leave the next generation a legacy that is hard
much which one of them would become CEO, but rather
to structure. The founding generation often enjoys great
the company’s ability to establish the right kind of business
autonomy. Founders tend to create high accountability for
structures, vision, and goals in order for the family business
themselves but do not create management models that are
to survive for many generations to come.“
easily replicable. The next generation is then confronted with the dilemma of deciding what structures to apply, which
The Mistakes in Dealing with the Next Generation
can lead to conflicts, as Prof. Aronoff emphasises: “This is
One of the main concerns for family businesses remains
usually a first to second generation, although sometimes
the successful handover to the next generation. When we
even a second to third generation problem. One of the
ask Prof. Aronoff about the best-practice in successfully
greatest mistakes that can be made with the next generation
dealing with the next generation he argues: “Going out and
is to underestimate the importance of establishing a good
accepting somebody else’s idea of best-practice means that
governance system to make it possible for them to carry on
you are resigning yourself from the beginning not to create the
the legacy. It is like setting them up to fail.”
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
39
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Perspectives on the Next Generation in Family Businesses
The third mistake Prof. Aronoff describes as follows: “Founders or parent generations often have strategies, which
Major areas of responsibility of the next generation:
though brilliant, are not clearly articulated. Formulating strategy is a meaningful process leading to better understanding your strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. The discipline to implement and change your strategy is necessary.” According to Prof. Aronoff it is only through fostering this strategic awareness that a successful way of integrating the next generation into the family business can be found. The fourth mistake is inadequate attention to building family identity, cohesiveness and teamwork. In sibling and cousin generations, family teams typically fulfill the responsibilities of governance and ownership and often, management as well.
How the Next Generation Can Make it Work Equally important as avoiding the above mentioned mistakes, are recognising the responsibilities of the next generation members towards the family business. Prof. Aronoff defines five major areas of responsibility that the next generation should address to make it work: 1. Considering the multiplicity of roles and responsibilities any family business member faces, the right education is a key factor for the next generation to be successful. “How can you formulate your vision?”, Prof. Aronoff asks. “You do it by educating yourself, you do it by studying, you do it by
1
Articulating your vision
2
Becoming a deserving heir
3
Making the most of yourself in every respect
4
Innovating within the framework
5
Practicing patience
thinking, you do it by interacting with other successful family businesses, and you do it by understanding the required compromise. And why do you have to do these things? To
business itself.” He mentions the great risk of ‘Successors,
prepare yourself to articulate a vision for yourself and for
who want to be CEO, but don’t want to do CEO’: “They
your family business, which you’re going to be responsible
want all the perks and the status and respect, but they fail
for at some point.”
to understand that continuously building the family business and others commitment to it are huge responsibilities.”
2. “You have got to show that you are a deserving heir,”,
40
Prof. Aronoff begins emphatically, “and you have got to do
3. The world continues to change at a fast pace and family
that through mental labour: Work on gaining perspective,
businesses must change with it. The next generation holds a
maturity and discipline as well as accountability. The
crucial role in this: “The world changes and we depend upon
combination of all these factors will not only preserve but
the youth to embrace and understand new technology and
advance the family business. It is about leadership in the
its implications. If they are really seeking to grasp how the
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Perspectives on the Next Generation in Family Businesses
Part of the strengthening process for the next generation is to learn how to intellectually confront their elders. I think that it can be done respectfully, and that the conflict is not necessarily a bad thing.
SPECIAL FEATUREs
seem to have the intention ever to retire. Sometimes these next generation members are in their 40ies and 50ies and want to know whether they should stay or whether they still should try themselves outside the family business.” Prof. Aronoff pauses, reflects, and then resumes: “Either decision is the right decision if you make it for the right reasons and either decision is the wrong decision if you make it for the wrong reasons.” He continues to explain that as a rule, if the next generation is not retiring by the time they are in their 70ies, he encourages the next generation members to go and talk with the older generation. “If the parent generation confirms that they do not intend to leave the business in the foreseeable future then a next generation member might want to consider
world works, and how not only they themselves but their
what that means to them. They might want to join another
enterprises, resources, and assets can fit into it in a more
organisation where they can provide leadership more directly.
productive way, family business continuity becomes more
This can be done respectfully and without resentment towards
likely. As a next generation you need to find the motivation
the family business if everyone communicates successfully.
to want to make the most of yourself, understanding that you
There may always be a way back into the family business at
are potentially set up to have a great impact on the world,
a later stage. I recommend to be broad and flexible in your
your community, and your family.”, stipulates Prof. Aronoff.
understanding of the roles in your family. Combine that with patience, communication, and taking responsibility for
4. He goes on to explaining that, in order for the next
yourself. Don’t sit there and wait for life to happen to you.
generation to make things work, they should understand
Done well, you can find success whichever decision you take.”
that family business values can be implemented in numerous different ways. Maintaining the family’s values does not
It Cannot Always Work Without Conflict
mean that the next generation needs to deploy them in the
Many next generation members reading this will inevitably
same way as previous generations. “Being innovative within
feel the urge to protest and say that they have tried to
an existing framework is an art that the next generation
contribute in various ways but were either discouraged or
needs to learn how to master. Those who succeed usually
the attempt resulted in conflict. We ask Prof. Aronoff whether
develop into leaders. It’s those who are kicking and
he thinks that conflict can be avoided when next generation
screaming because they are not getting their way who
members try and make their mark in the family business:
will not make any progress. It is very much like achieving
“I’m not sure if it can be accomplished without a little bit
happiness: If you pursue it directly you don’t get it but if you
of conflict. Part of the strengthening process for the next
pursue it indirectly it often becomes a by-product of all the
generation is to learn how to intellectually confront their
other things that you are doing.”
elders. I think that it can be done respectfully, and that the conflict is not necessarily a bad thing. You learn over time
5. “Then there is probably the most crucial factor to make
how to skilfully inject your own thinking into the family
it work in the family business.”, here Prof. Aronoff smiles
business.” Prof. Aronoff smiles affectionately when thinking
indulgently. “Patience is what is hardest for the next
of the family businesses he has worked with over the years
generation, and it truly is very hard to be patient. I have been
and adds: “I agree that it is never simple or easy; but then
in a position to advise a number of people whose parents don’t
again nothing worthwhile in this life ever is.”
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
41
SPECIAL FEATUREs
The Elnefeidi Family, sudan
Dialogue between Generations:
The Elnefeidi Family
Sudan
42
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
The Elnefeidi Family, sudan
SPECIAL FEATUREs
The Elnefeidi Group is one of Sudan’s most prominent family businesses. The late Bashir Elnefeidi, founder of the Elnefeidi Group, started to work with his two brothers in 1934 in a small retail shop, which they grew into wholesale trade. This partnership continued until 1974 when Bashir started to focus his activities on transportation. The brothers expanded the business into other sectors such as agriculture, the oil industry and property development. The family’s investment activities kept on growing under the leadership of Bashir and expanded into the largest transport companies in Sudan and excelled in Chad, Ethiopia and the horn of Africa. Over the years, the Elnefeidi Group diversified into industry, trading and other services. Tharawat magazine met with Amin, Wafa, Hussein and Musab Elnefeidi and witnessed an insightful dialogue on values, the next generation and the future of the family firm. Amin Elnefeidi, President, Elnefeidi Group, 2nd generation Wafa Elnefeidi, Graduate from Towson University, 3rd generation, currently employed outside the group in the field of marketing at Bank of Khartoum in accordance with the family protocol (two years external experience required before joining the family business) Hussein Elnefeidi, Board Member and General Manager of Seven Rent-A-Car, Elnefeidi Group, 3rd generation Musab Elnefeidi, Graduate from Liverpool University as Mechanical Engineer, 3rd generation, currently employed outside the group at Kenana Sugar Company Chris Venter, HR & Admin Director, Elnefeidi Group
What are the chief character traits of the Elnefeidi
second generation has really taken what the late
family?
founder established to the next level and expanded the business beyond the field of transportation.
Hussein: I think we are patriotic and humble.
The family is always extremely particular about values and ethics.
Musab: I would say we are a very tightly knit family. What are the core values that the Elnefeidi group Wafa: I think we are humanitarian, in sync, and put great
stands for?
emphasis on values and traditions. Amin: We grew up in an environment in which we care Chris: The Elnefeidi family really embraces people and
about what our investment add to the community.
involves you into the family. They are known for
We want to instill this in our third generation like
that and also for their social responsibility. The
my father did with us.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
43
SPECIAL FEATUREs
The Elnefeidi Family, sudan
Musab: I think to our family it is important to be seen for the values we stand for, which are clearly aligned with the needs of the community and should benefit all stakeholders. What would you like the business to stand for in the future? Hussein: We want to develop the country. We always look at how our investments are going to help the community. I guess that is what I meant by us being a patriotic family. Amin: Yes, we always think about how our businesses can add to the community. Recently we have been concentrating more on agriculture. We think that this adds not only to Sudan but to the whole region. We are also getting interested in green energy. These are the areas that we want to focus on. What do you think are the three main characteristics that a family member needs to be successful? Wafa: Use your individuality but at the same time stay in sync with everyone. If you lose your individuality you lose what you can bring to the business. Another point is open communication; communicate clearly what your vision is. For me the most important thing is not to get lost in problems but to maintain what makes you unique. Thirdly, don’t lose sight of what the vision of the company is and how it was run by the first and the second generation. Musab: I also think that being on good terms with all family members is important, as well as to be well educated and self-motivated. Hussein: In addition to what I said earlier I think that ethics, integrity, being hard-working, down-to-earth, and understanding is fundamental. Amin: I think commitment and being open to say what you believe in is crucial. But at the end of the day you have to be flexible and align yourself with the family’s needs. Chris: The Elnefeidi family does not take a decision unless there is full
I think that ethics, integrity, being hard-working, down-to-earth, and understanding is fundamental.
agreement. Decisions are not finalised unless the family has fully
44
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
The Elnefeidi Family, sudan
SPECIAL FEATUREs
discussed matters and listened to all perspectives. They never give up the belief in this family. Family comes first, even before the business. What do you think the next generation should bring to the family business? Hussein: The next generation should come up with new ideas that are good for the company and that the family can benefit from. They should maintain the values of the business while trying to grow it. Wafa: I would say that the next generation needs to keep the momentum going. Our third generation includes members from aged 1 to 36 years. We like to divide it into generation 3A and 3B and 3C. Hussein, Musab and myself are the generation 3A and we want to keep the momentum so generation 3C can still benefit and be exposed to the same values the second generation has transferred to us. Amin: I believe the next generation should think of how they can develop the family’s investment and make it more advanced and more beneficial to the community. This should come before implementing new ideas. New ideas are good because improvements always open new horizons. When we added new lines to the business we didn’t neglect the existing core activities and we always tried to improve it. That this is what we
I suggest finding common ground between different generations and using that as a stepping-stone to get over issues that may come up later.
would like to see the third generation doing. We developed the family business from a company that depends on owner’s management into a corporate structure. We need the next generation to reinforce this. This is why an outside experience is very important for young members before they join us because we need them to bring in new ideas. This cannot be done unless someone has the chance to be exposed to the outside world, experience which they can then transfer to the family values.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
45
SPECIAL FEATUREs
The elnefeidi family, sudan
Does the role of the parent generation change when the young family members join the business? Amin: It should! We are expecting their ability to take over responsibility to increase day by day. The next generation should relieve the parent generation from a lot of the duties and the role of the parent generation should be more about directing and planning rather than day-to-day work. This is our hope. Chris: We have successfully integrated several members from the third generation so far. Now there is even a detailed process in place to take care of the next generation joining the business and the responsibilities that should be appointed to them. What do you think the measures that could be put in place in order to ensure that no misunderstandings can occur? Amin: The best measure is good communication. We are trying to set a good example for the next generation. We try to open a dialogue and to set rules for the family like the family protocol, and to be fair in judgment but it’s not an easy thing to do. Wafa: Sometimes I wish there was a magic dust that you could use to trade bodies with someone else for a day in order to understand other family members’ perspective. Communication is hard sometimes. I suggest finding common ground between different generations and using that as a stepping-stone to get over issues that may come up later. Musab: It’s the way that we were raised that makes the big difference; we grew up seeing how close our uncles were to each other. It helped
Being on good terms with all family members is important, as well as to be well educated and self-motivated.
us with our siblings and cousins. We all live close to each other and see each other everyday, which we love. Wafa: We were raised as siblings, not as cousins. Most of the time our cousins are also our best friends. We spend a lot of time together even with the extended family, which is good for the business as well. Hussein: We want to preserve what our ancestors left us and just carry it on. I think we trust each other a lot. It is this trust that makes us succeed.
46
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
www.tharawat.org
www.tharawat-magazine.com
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Interview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum
Interview with
Razan Jafar Crescent Petroleum
On Being Part of the Next Generation Crescent Petroleum is an upstream oil and gas company with headquarters in Sharjah, UAE, and offices all over the world. It is part of the Crescent Group of companies, which includes activities in power, port management, logistics, contracting, healthcare, private equity and real estate. The group has been in existence for over four decades and behind its success lies the hard work and full commitment of the Jafar family. Today, the family is making the transition from the first to the second generation. In an exclusive interview, Tharawat magazine gets to know the Jafar family’s youngest member: After graduating from Cambridge University, as well as completing her legal training at the Norton Rose Group, Razan Jafar is following her father and two brothers’ footsteps into the family business and is leaving a mark very much her own.
48
The Outside Experience
throw you in the deep end.’ I said to him that I wanted to be
We are sitting opposite a young woman who cannot be
able to stand on my own two feet. My brother Majid argued
described as anything else but a “modern lady”. “I have never
that it was important for me to work in a law firm and, if
done an interview like this before”, she says modestly. Fact is
I liked it, I might want to do that and not join the family
that Razan Jafar is the youngest of the Jafar’s second family
business.” Razan’s eldest brother Majid himself started his
business generation. Less than a year ago she followed her
career outside the family business. Feeling that this was an
two elder brothers Majid and Badr into the family business,
important experience, he strongly believed his sister should
Crescent Petroleum. We wonder whether it has always been
be given the same opportunity. Razan did get a job at a top
Razan’s plan to join the family business and get a charmingly
London-based international law firm, and qualified as a UK
direct reply: “To be honest, it wasn’t. It’s a very recent
solicitor. “I enjoyed what I did; I found it very rewarding.
development. When I graduated I applied for jobs to get
Then I truly was intrigued by the family business and I
a legal training contract, which is usual for law graduates.
wanted to explore it.” She adds that the fact that she loves
One day my father asked me ‘What are you doing? You’re
her family played a great role in this. “I respect my father and
going to come back and work with me!’” Razan recollects
brothers not just because they are family but also because of
her father’s words affectionately. “My father said: ‘You will
what they do and how they do it. I did hesitate before joining
learn way more with me. I will give you real work and I will
the family business. Once you’re in, you’re in!”
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Interview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum
SPECIAL FEATUREs
The Inside Experience Razan’s external experience provided her with qualities she felt she would need in the family business. “You learn good habits from working full-time at multi-national corporations, and it’s so important to acquire that discipline early on in one’s career. I learnt so much that can’t even be pinpointed but it all adds up to value that I hopefully bring to the family business”, she says, thinking back. As soon as Razan joined the family business, her father gave her a lot of responsibility. She confesses to us that she had never been more nervous than during her first few weeks in the family business. “In a corporate environment you know your place and you know everybody else’s place too. When my father said he’d throw me in the deep end, he meant it! He told me to handle most things myself and to use my own judgement.” Razan goes on to describe how her father’s confidence in her gave her more confidence in herself. She soon found herself participating actively and usefully making her mark in the business. “It has been really great and things have changed rapidly in my life: I studied law but when I joined I wanted exposure to all aspects of the business, and to see it from all viewpoints and not just through a legal lens. My brothers’ roles are really specific as they have been in the business for a while and have established their own domains, using their individual strengths for the ultimate benefit of the business. I am not at that point
When my father said he’d throw me in the deep end, he meant it! He told me to handle most things myself and to use my own judgement.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
49
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Interview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum
yet; it will take time. I am a director at the group level and I
us as second generation members. He encourages us to
sit on the board, but to know exactly what I want to do, and
take the reins effectively. Since we joined the business he
more importantly where I can usefully contribute and add
is mostly handling high-level matters. He wants to give us
value, I want to spend a year doing a bit of everything. This
the responsibility and is open to our ideas. We are given the
includes shadowing my father and working directly alongside
room to breathe and be creative, and I know that this is not
him.” Razan affirms that her legal training gives her a unique
usual, especially not in family businesses.”
view of the family business, yet after joining the business she discovered that she enjoys many other areas as well.
The Next Generation Challenges Next generation members often face challenges in the family
How it Feels
business especially when they have just joined it. Razan
In many ways Razan describes her experience in the family
knows of a few: “A great challenge for the next generation
business as a sort of process that helped her come into her
family members is to be treated as professionals in their own
own. She tells us that even though she had done well in
right by others. It can be difficult to gain respect inside and
all her studies and also in her previous work experience,
outside the family business, particularly by the old hands.
she still never felt as if she had quite gotten the confidence
When you tell people that you work for your family they
that went with her position. This changed when she joined
sometimes believe that you have an easy life. I think that
the family business. Razan leans back into her chair and
there is absolutely nothing wrong with the parent generation
frowns a little: “The one thing that I did feel when I got here was that I have relevant knowledge. I surprised myself by understanding that all my skills had grown over the years and that I could now use them effectively. My confidence started growing when I shared ideas with my father; he liked them and encouraged me to share them with others.” In a company that is all about chemistry, physics, and engineering, the young woman sitting opposite us is finding her way. She is the first woman to join the family business at the executive level. She laughs outright when she confirms
I think that there is absolutely nothing wrong with the parent generation being tough on the next generation; I think it is even healthy for everybody else in the business to see this.
that sometimes she is even the only woman in the room. “All the senior executives here are men. But I am used to it now.” Man or woman, Razan believes that every individual
being tough on the next generation; I think it is even healthy
in the family brings different strengths to the table. The
for everybody else in the business to see this. It is normal to
three Jafar siblings complement each other in the business
work twice as hard to earn the respect of your peers and of
and also have a strong relationship outside the office. “We
your colleagues to demonstrate that you are in the business
socialise together and enjoy it. We don’t talk about work; we
because you want to be but also because you deserve it.”
talk about personal things and share everything together.”
50
Razan’s face lights up affectionately. “We are there for each
Another challenge Razan identifies for the next generation is
other.” When we ask her what she thinks the secret ingredient
one that depends on the stage the family is in; she explains:
is for this type of family cohesion, she has her answer ready:
“You need the right governance system in place. A family
“My father is not a typical first generation member; he is
business always has real challenges, so the rules are best
very hands off and he is happy to delegate, particularly to
addressed and put in place early on. It is up to the next
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Interview with Razan Jafar, Crescent Petroleum
SPECIAL FEATUREs
generation to implement these systems and enforce them.
a casual place, and really being a family is important. When
Fixing a problem or an issue is much harder than preventing
you do that you realise that business is important but family
it in the first place.”
is equally if not more so.”
“But I think that the greatest challenge of all is to maintain the
Finally, Razan puts it very simply: “The role of the next
awareness that as new family generations join the business,
generation is to preserve old value, to create new value,
the complexity of the organisation increases.” Razan adds
and also to hold the family together.” After talking to her,
that awareness and communication among generations is
we think this particular next generation member is going to
key. “Open dialogue, being brutally honest, sitting down in
have no problem living up to the task.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
51
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Q&A with Dr. Rania Labaki
Q&A with
Dr. Rania Labaki A Successful Next Generation
Dr. Rania Labaki, Associate Professor of Management Sciences at the University of Bordeaux IV and researcher specialised in finance and family business management, is an expert when it comes to the many challenges that family businesses can face with the next generation. In this Q&A, Dr. Labaki gives valuable advice on how to successfully manage transitions between generations while respecting values and regulating emotions.
How can family businesses transfer family values and
the document itself. All generations should be encouraged to
knowledge to the next generation?
take part in the process of writing the charter by identifying their values, illustrating them, and reflecting on their
Family businesses have a unique competitive advantage
implementation. This will make of the next generation an
compared to other businesses. This advantage stems from
integral part of the process by being clearly aware of the
family values and tacit knowledge that are transferred from
values and taking on responsibility to transfer them on to
generation to generation. This transfer is a crucial, ongoing
the future generation.
and long-term process. It normally starts informally at a very early age; whether it is at the dining table, during the
The organisation of family business-related workshops
traditional family gatherings, or even in the company itself,
or regular company visits for the next generation
by listening to family stories and business issues and the
also contribute to the development of knowledge and
way they are dealt with, the next generation progressively
preservation of values. Involving the next generation
develops business skills and gets inspired by the founder’s
into the family’s social activities such as philanthropy or
values. This process is key to encourage favorable attitudes
family foundations gives a practical opportunity for the
of the next generation towards their roles of successors.
next generation members to operationalise the knowledge and values learned, which they can later execute them at
At later stages of the family business this informal process can
the business level.
be complemented by formal family governance mechanisms.
52
When the business spans many generations, it is often more
The next generation should also play an active rather than
difficult for the senior generation to instill the family values
a passive role by becoming value leaders. They should not
in the next generation. A family charter outlining the family
take the family values for granted but also contribute
business values contributes to this endeavor. The process of
to adapting them to the changing environment while
setting up a family charter is however more important than
maintaining their roots.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Q&A with Dr. Rania Labaki
www.tharawat-magazine.com
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
53
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Q&A with Dr. Rania Labaki
What are the measures that should be taken on the family and the business level to be prepared for the integration of the next generation into the business? Over the life cycle, the family business generally evolves from a founder’s ownership stage to a siblings partnership followed by a cousins’ consortium. It progressively spans an increasing number of next generation members. Starting the third generation there is a higher potential for family relationships to weaken; the emotional attachment to and identification with the family business may fade away. Family business managers should strive to motivate the next generation to integrate into the business while acknowledging that this should happen voluntarily and on a merit basis. It needs in fact to be considered that the next generation members may have different professional goals that are not compatible with the family business industry or available positions. They might have conflicting interests with the generation in charge of the business’ strategic and financial policies. On the other hand, they might be highly motivated to join the business but not have the professional and personal qualifications to do that. Family business managers should be careful in the selection process of future successors and make sure that their judgment is not biased.
Educational themes for the next generation should not only be focused on the business level but also address the personal, family, and social levels.
Educating the next generation about the family business helps cultivating pride and responsibility and strengthens their identification with the family and the business. Enhancing inter-generational communication is also important because it keeps the next generation in the loop and fosters their
next generation with specific educational tools:
desire to follow the path of their predecessors. By encouraging the next generation to participate in family What are the most important educational tools that the
business-related events, family business managers provide
next generation in family businesses needs?
them with a unique opportunity to interact with next generation members from other businesses all around the
54
In addition to the traditional requirements that pertain
world, share their experiences and learn from each other in
to any business, such as high level of education in
a confidential and friendly atmosphere. It is often at these
specialisations that are congruent with the business
events that the next generation members get to finally realise
activities and professional experience outside the family
that they are not the only ones facing complicated family
business, family business managers should provide their
business issues.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Q&A with Dr. Rania Labaki
SPECIAL FEATUREs
Educational themes for the next generation should not
and express unexpected types of emotions might cause
only be focused on the business level but also address
destructive conflicts.
the personal, family, and social levels. In order to explore the related topics, the educational formats should also be
Emotional regulation appears a relevant challenge. The
diverse, ranging from case studies presentations by families,
family business CEO (Chief Executive Officer) should also
to interactive discussions with inspirational speakers and
play the role of the CEO (Chief Emotional Officer) regulating
experts in different fields such as psychology, finance,
the family members’ emotional dissonance. By developing
management or governance, to group work among next
their emotional intelligence capabilities and setting up the
generation members and/ or senior generation members
right governance mechanisms they will learn more about the
to stimulate collaboration and mutual learning.
family’s expectations and reduce the possibility of emotions leading to conflict.
How can the emotional factor between the different generations in family businesses be regulated?
From your experience, what are the biggest concerns the next generation has?
Emotions are an integral part of any organisation but are of particular importance in the family business. They emerge
The biggest challenge for the next generation is undeniably
and influence two systems rather than one; the business
succession. The low rates of survival of family businesses
system on one side and the family system on the other.
during succession (less that 5% of family businesses make
Therefore, emotions triggered and/or expressed in the family
it to the fourth generation) are a clear indication of the
can influence the business and vice versa. Notwithstanding
difficulties of passing on the baton from one to the next
the beneficial influence of positive emotions such as love
generation. The succession process encompasses several
and happiness in strengthening family cohesion and the
sub-challenges for the next generation: The major ones are
convergence of family and business interests, negative
overcoming resistance and maintaining good relationships
emotions can also have a positive effect:
between generations. In many cases, the senior generation is reluctant to let go and to trust the next generation with
Emotions such as guilt might lead to reparative actions that
managing the business. Resistance to succession comes not
enhance the future business performance, while emotions
only from the family manager but also from other senior
such as regret might lead to better future decision making.
family members who may feel threatened by losing power. Resistance can also relate to other next generation members
What emotions should be regulated between generations
who are fiercely competing against each other to grab the
and when? It is rather the discrepancy between the type of
opportunity of managing the business. Added to this,
emotions felt and the type of emotions expressed, also called
there is the resistance of non-family stakeholders, such as
“emotional dissonance”, that may have dramatic effects and
employees, suppliers or clients towards new successor(s).
should be regulated.
The next generation members have to struggle in order to achieve legitimacy. This entails proving themselves
The degree of emotional dissonance is highly correlated
on professional and human levels in the family business
with the family business culture. In some cultures,
while being respectful to the senior generation. It also
the expression of certain emotions is prohibited in the
means being patient while remaining open to learn from
family and/or the business. Oftentimes the expression
the senior generation and showing understanding of the
of emotions refers to implicit rules in the family. Family
difficult psychological forces they are facing during the
members that do not abide by these emotional rules
succession process.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
55
SPOTLIGHT india FAMILY BUSINESSES
INDIA SPOTLIGHT ON
PART1
And its family businesses 58
Family Managed Businesses in India - The Opportunities and the Challenges
ExposĂŠ on characteristics, opportunities and challenges of Indian families and their businesses.
56
Tharawat Magazine Volume 15
62
A Conversation with Bakul Jain, Managing Director of DCW Ltd. Bakul Jain speaks about running a family business in one of the fastest growing economies in the world.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
india FAMILY BUSINESSES
SPOTLIGHT
6.9 India’s Real GDP growth at 6.9% in 2011
3.3 3.3 thousand square kilometer is the surface of the Indian subcontinent
1.727
4 India is the world’s fourth largest economy
In 2011 the Indian GDP was at $1,756.8bn according to IMD WCY.
1.22
India is home to over 1.22 billion people speaking hundreds of different dialects
It is estimated that around 90% of Indian businesses are family-owned. In a country that is home to one of the fastest growing economies in the world, family businesses play a a crucial part through their economic contribution and through their role in society at large. While India has produced many major conglomerates under family management, the majority of its family businesses are SMEs and were established after the 1980ies. With this first part of our two-part spotlight series, Tharawat magazine embarks on a discovery journey of the history and achievements of Indian family businesses.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
57
SPOTLIGHT FAMILY MANAGED BUSINESSES IN INDIA
FAMILY MANAGED BUSINESSES IN INDIA THE OPPORTUNITIES AND THE CHALLENGES Family businesses are the lifeline of India’s economy. Almost 90% of Indian businesses are family-owned, which makes the rest of the business community largely dependent on them. Be it as their vendors, transporters, contractors or distributors; non-family corporations collaborate with family firms on various levels. Parimal Merchant, Director of the Center of Family Managed Businesses, S.P. Jain Institute of Management and Research, India, explores in this article the challenges and opportunities that Indian family businesses face.
A
58
lthough family businesses are vital to the
third of the companies listed in 1970 had vanished by 1983.
Indian economy, little attention is paid
In reality, survey findings reveal that the average life of a
unless there is an opportunity to criticise
corporation in Japan and Europe is no longer than 12.5
them. They are often accused of a lack of
years independently of whether they are family-owned or
professionalism, of nepotism, infightings,
not (Jagdish Sheth, “The Self-Destructive Habits of Good
and mismanagement. There is a famous cliché, which is
Companies“). There are many reasons for short life cycles
quoted frequently and seems to have been accepted as a
in businesses, yet, family ownership is often particularly
universal truth: The first generation builds, the second
mentioned. In reality, however, the contrary is frequently
generation consolidates, and the third generation destroys
the case: Family businesses on average not only outlive, but
the family business. When accusing family businesses of
also outperform non-family corporations. A Morgan Stanley
such a short life span it is often conveniently forgotten that
study shows that family firms generated Return on Equity of
longevity is an objective difficult to achieve for any business.
18.5% as compared to 14.1% from non-family corporations
In 1982 the book “In Search of Excellence” by Tom Peters and
(John Ward 2007, quoted by Amy Schuman, FBCG, Inland
Rober H. Waterman listed 62 companies as high performers.
Press, February, 2010). A Newsweek (April 12, 2004) study
By 1992 most of them were languishing. Similarly, in
shows that family firms outperform their rivals in all leading
Fortune magazine’s yearly list of top 500 companies; one-
stock indexes of Europe.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
FAMILY MANAGED BUSINESSES IN INDIA
SPOTLIGHT
Indian Family Businesses The majority of Indian family businesses are quite young. India faced wars in 1962, 1965 and 1971; it was only after 1980 that the economic environment became more business friendly. As a result the period from 1980 to 1995 was one in which a large number of family businesses were established and prospered. Many of those family businesses split up over the last few years due to family differences. There are some families with large business operations, but the majority are SMEs. Family businesses have a culture that is often at the same time entrepreneurial, flexible, paternalistic, agile and frugal. Since the family’s name is at stake, they stand for values, long-term commitment, relationship orientation, and dependability. Indian family firms are also highly efficient. They often have to work with limited resources and make the most out of it. A multinational car plant can get free land from the Indian government and access to financing from capital markets, but for the majority of family businesses each step is a challenge. Yet, they embrace it with a true entrepreneurial spirit. Indian family businesses also have distinct advantages, particularly that of vigilant ownership. The family owners’ commitment and visibility leads to higher productivity in the business. Their dedication and perseverance enables
90 18.5 14.1
percent of Indian businesses are family-owned a Morgan Stanley study shows that family firms generated Return on Equity of 18.5% as compared to 14.1% from non-family corporations
them to extract opportunities from complex non-routine problems. In addition, family firms also tend to be less bureaucratic and can take fast decisions. Their stakes are
1. The Next Generation
emotional as well as economical and they are likely to look
The greatest challenge concerns the gap between family
for sustained value creation. As a result they can move faster
generations: A business founder is used to doing everything
with unconventional logic, can go counter-cyclical and can
himself. Thus developed the unique culture of the present
reach for new opportunities.
Indian family business: Inward-looking, owner centric, smaller scale, with a restricted perspective, and conservative
The Challenges
mindset. This culture eventually becomes a hurdle in
Indian family businesses enjoy various advantages due
absorbing ‘outsiders’. The same culture also poses a serious
to their inherent characteristics and a social culture that
challenge in absorbing the next generation family members:
supports their structures. However, these advantages can
Different generations, seeing the world differently are
be destroyed if the family is not united; as the family grows,
supposed to work together. It can be a difficult thing as the
the challenge is to keep a sense of unity. These are a set of
young generation is often in a hurry and has big ambitions,
typical challenges that Indian family businesses face today:
while their elders are more conservative and skeptical.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
59
SPOTLIGHT FAMILY MANAGED BUSINESSES IN INDIA
The gap keeps on getting wider and wider. When conflict
Having founded the business, the owner is used to having insight
escalates between fathers and sons it is often the mother,
into all aspects of his business. Allowing the same insight to an
who takes the role of CEO (Chief Emotional Officer). This is
outsider can be hard. On the other hand non-family employees
a common story in many Indian family businesses.
may also have difficulties in adjusting to the family business culture. They are used to structured corporate environments.
2. Attracting and Retaining Non-family Employees
In family businesses that structure may be missing.
Another possible challenge is non-family employees joining
60
the family firm: The culture, which has solidified over time,
It is important that time is bestowed on new professionals so
becomes a barrier for accepting ‘outsiders’. Business owners
they can settle. Many Indian family business owners end up
are often at a loss as to how much authority a non-family
selecting non-family employees based on their performance
employee should be able to attain. In most Indian family
in the corporate world without paying much attention to
businesses stakes are high: It is not easy to put their own
their ‘fit’ with their own firm’s culture. They forget to spend
destiny in the hands of non-family employees.
time in facilitating the settling down process.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
FAMILY MANAGED BUSINESSES IN INDIA
SPOTLIGHT
The next generation has to learn to appreciate their parents’ wisdom and understand at the same time that there is no substitute for hard work.
increasingly it will have to respond to these demands. It is only reasonable for family businesses to tap into this huge source of talent.
The Realities The Indian business landscape has started expanding fast. With the involvement of the older generation alone, such growth is unthinkable. While the parent generation needs to accept this, the next generation has to learn to appreciate their parents’ wisdom and understand that there is no substitute for hard work. The solution to these challenges requires an understanding of the family business dynamics and a separation of people from problems. Family business members should learn that no one is wrong but that each generation 3. Women of the Family Joining the Family Business
has a different culture. Once families learn about these
Indian family businesses are still largely male dominated.
cultures and understand the need to appreciate different
The role of women in business and employing women is
perspectives, whether young or old, they will be able to
largely accepted and encouraged in India. However, when
harmoniously work with professionals as well as across
it comes to hiring women in the family business, there are
generations. Thus, if family businesses can manage these
reservations. Within the Indian social context of business
dynamics, they will be better placed to reap the benefits
families, bringing up the children is considered primarily
of the great range of opportunities in the Indian economy
a responsibility of the mother. Thus, whenever the issue of
and beyond.
women in the family business is raised, it is subject to her ability to balance between her duties at home and her duties at work. However, as more and more women are highly educated, they are demanding a say in the family business. The traditional family model is still disapproving of it, yet
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Author Parimal Merchant, Director of the Center of Family Managed Businesses, S.P. Jain Institute of Management and Research, India
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
61
SPOTLIGHT Conversation with Bakul Jain, Managing Director of DCW Limited
A Conversation with
Bakul Jain Insights from the Managing Director of DCW Limited, India
DCW was established in 1925 as one of the first Soda Ash factories in India. Behind the lucky horseshoe, that serves as the DCW Limited’s logo, stands a hard working family: In the 1930ies Sahu Shriyans Prasad Jain took over the management of the factory and grew it together with his family into the industry leader it is today. Bakul Jain is the eldest member of the 3rd generation of this family business. He joined the family in 1975, when he was given the responsibility of looking after a cutlery manufacturing company belonging to the family group – Kishco Cutlery Private Limited. After almost four years of gaining experience, he undertook a one-year MBA. After graduating, he returned to India and resumed his work with the family. In 1982, he joined DCW Limited as Vice President in its Caustic Soda Division. Working with his two uncles and three cousins, Bakul Jain today is the Managing Director of DCW Limited, and is on the Board of a number of other public and private companies. He is the Trustee of the family’s various charitable trusts, serves on the Board of the International Association for Human Values India, as well as a member of the Board of Management of the Bombay Hospital Trust and S.P. Jain Institute for Management and Research. Tharawat magazine speaks to Bakul Jain about his family, his business, and his recommendations to other family businesses.
62
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Conversation with Bakul Jain, Managing Director of DCW Limited
SPOTLIGHT
Left: Sahupuram Complex, Top Right: “Padma Bhushan” Sahu Shriyans Prasad Jain, Bottom Right: Bakul Jain, Managing Director DCW Ltd. DCW Ltd has been run successfully by your family since
India is a country that has undergone dramatic
the 1940s. What are the Jain family characteristics that
transformations throughout the last decades. What
have contributed to this continuous success?
were the moments where the Jain family made key strategic changes in DCW Ltd. to adapt to the
The family has always understood that to be successful, one
macroeconomic context?
must display a combination of vision, dedication and drive. Vision is critical to identifying business opportunities, but
The family has always been keenly aware of its environment
this isn’t enough. Without the dedication and focus to follow
and the context in which it operates, which has enabled it to
through on the execution, DCW would not be where it is
take advantage of changes in the macroeconomic context.
today.
The significant changes that India has experienced have been great opportunities for the family to build and grow
Another hallmark of our family has been our commitment to
DCW Ltd.
a larger perspective, such as social service and community development. We have always recognised that no business
As independence beckoned, my family understood the need
can exist in isolation, and have hence always been committed
for industrialising a nascent nation, and decided to enter
to improving the world around us.
the chemicals industry by acquiring a soda ash plant in the Western state of Gujarat.
All of these qualities have been handed down in our family starting with my grandfather, the late respected
As India’s impetus for domestic industrialisation grew in
Sahu Shriyans Prasad Jain, and have been critical to our
the 1960s and 1970s, the family was quick to seize the
continued success.
opportunity to expand across India by setting up a chemical
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
63
SPOTLIGHT Conversation with Bakul Jain, Managing Director of DCW Limited
Top: Sahupuram Complex Next page: Kamlavati Higher Secondary School founded by the Jain family complex in the Southern state of India, Tamil Nadu. Later,
of the business is a privilege, not a right, and comes with
foreseeing the growing importance of the petro-chemicals
the responsibility to grow it for the next generation of the
industry, we entered this nascent sector in 1970 with one
family, and also for all the other stakeholders such as the
of the first integrated PVC resin plants. The family also
shareholders, customers, employees and the community at
constructed a beneficiated ilmenite manufacturing plant,
large. Making sure the children grow up with and imbibe
a global first.
this attitude is critical for the family’s continued personal and professional success.
How does the Jain family prepare the next generation for joining the family business?
Additionally, in today’s day and age, education is key, both formal and informal. The next generation should strive to
64
The family has always instilled a sense of duty into its
be educated at the best schools and experience working
younger generation, and has taught them that being a part
with the best companies and people before being allowed
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Conversation with Bakul Jain, Managing Director of DCW Limited
SPOTLIGHT
professional managers to make sure that DCW executes the family’s vision. Moreover, as the third generation of the family has received the best education and have been exposed to considerable work experience, they can be considered as “professionals” in their own right. How do you value the importance of Indian family businesses in relation to the economy and what challenges do they face today? Family businesses account for the lion’s share of India’s
We believe that our family structure and operating style has been an advantage to DCW Ltd. Having a visionary founder instill the right skills and beliefs into the next generation has helped the family be nimble and focus on creating long term value.
corporate activity, and hence continue to remain critical to the economy. Furthermore, family-run companies can take a long-term view on value, and can hence look to build businesses that will benefit the economy in the long run, something that is not always possible at companies only focused on their next quarter’s results. The key challenges family businesses face today is lack of focus amongst the younger generations, and a lack of critical mass to build truly world-class companies. These can be addressed by ensuring that the younger generation has the right education and work experience, or by shifting to professional management. The best run businesses can then look to consolidate in their respective industries and build world-leading companies.
to have managerial responsibilities at DCW.
What is your advice to the next generation of Indian family businesses?
Do you feel that being a family business has brought specific advantages and/or disadvantages in running
The next generation should strive to build on the
an industrial group such as DCW Ltd.?
achievements of their predecessors, and not just rest on their laurels. This requires hard work, dedication and
We believe that our family structure and operating style
a certain entrepreneurial zeal. If they are not able to or
has been an advantage to DCW. Having a visionary founder
interested in doing this, they should know enough to leave
instill the right skills and beliefs into the next generation has
the management of their inherited businesses to professional
helped the family be nimble and focus on creating long term
managers, and only remain involved as shareholders. They
value, in a way that is not possible at less tightly controlled
should have the wisdom and clarity to separate ownership
groups. Having said that, we have a significant number of
from management if need be.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
65
OffErING
hIgh qualIty INtErNshIps tO thE yOuNG generatIon MEMbErs Of
famIly OWNEd
COMpANIEs IN
thE MENA
arabian nextgen
InternshIp program If you are
a member of the next generation of a business family who ... Wants to gather experience outside of the family business or Wants to learn about other family businesses inside and beyond the Middle East or Wants to learn more about a specific trade, industry or profession or Wants to start establishing his or her professional network or Wants to innovate Contact nextgen@tharawat.org to get all the information on the Arabian NextGen Internship program; or call : +971 (0)4 452 6578
arabian nextgen www.tharawat.org
www.Arabian-Nextgen.org
SMEs
Family Business
SMEs 68
74
Discover the century-old Yemeni Al Hamdani family business that has stayed true to its dedication to coffee for many generations.
An exclusive interview with Mowgli Founder Tony Bury unveils the importance of mentorship for businesses in the Middle East.
Al Hamdani for Coffee A Family with Flavour
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Mowgli: On Mentorship in the Middle East
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
67
SMEs
Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee
Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee
A Family with Flavour - Yemen
The Al Hamdani family business is over a century old. Its true passion and the source of its continuous success lie in the flavour and quality of Yemeni mocha coffee beans and the family’s long experience in the coffee industry. In a short profile and an interview with Ahmed Ali Al Hamdani, Chairman of Al-Hamdani for Mocha Coffee, we discover the incredible journey of a Yemeni family business transcending challenges and time.
68
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee
O
SMEs
ver 130 years ago, Ahmed Naser
expanding the business outside Yemen. The family
Ahmed Al Hamdani established
business started to develop the business by directly
what is today known as the
exporting coffee to Saudi Arabia, Qatar and other
renowned Yemeni coffee company
Arab countries and to find agents throughout the
“Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee”
Gulf countries.
with his son Ahmed. Father and son started their endeavour in Bani-matar (Baoan market is where
The Al Hamdani family continued to be involved
coffee farmers from various Yemeni cities meet to
in planting as well as processing coffee and the
sell their coffee bean crops), Yemen, in 1870. Bani-
family’s many coffee farms in Bani-matar are
matar is till date well-known for the quality of its
managed by local farmers. It is part of the Al
coffee beans. The Al Hamdani family collected and
Hamdani’s strategy to provide local coffee farmers
bought coffee beans from the whole region. They
with interest-free loans in order to help them to
peeled and cleaned the coffee beans manually and
reap the crops. The family began with providing
sold the them in Hodeidah and Aden.
coffee farmers with this service over 70 years ago and has dramatically increased the number
ABOVE: Mocha coffee bean plantations, Yemen
In 1994 the main branch of the Al Hamdani for
of loans over the past few years. Yemeni coffee
Mocha Coffee company was relocated to the
farmers continue to face substantial financial
capital, Sana’a which is about 25 kilm far of Bani-
burdens as their activities often require substantial
matar. This strategic decision played a great role in
investment in infrastructure.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
69
SMEs
Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee
The Al Hamdani family business attribute their success to the fact that they have kept their dedication to the coffee industry in the family.
Over the last century, the progress in technology
The Al Hamdani family has faced many challenges
has played an important role in the coffee industry.
to maintain the quality standards associated with
Nowadays, modern machinery is used at all stages
the reputation of the Yemeni mocha coffee beans.
when processing coffee beans; sorting, peeling
One of the challenges is caused by Yemeni as well as
and clearing. The Al Hamdani family began to
national fake companies to export non Yemen Coffee
incorporate such new technology into their business
beans under the name of green Yemen mocha coffee
from 1991. The main purpose behind this was to
beans. There is an inherent need for global standards
increase the efficiency of the production process as
and specifications for Yemeni mocha coffee. Another
well as to maintain the high standards in quality.
challenge is that the coffee industry lacks support
The family felt the benefits of these changes quickly
from the public sector. Due to the lack of services
and was able to increase production.
and facilities provided to coffee farmers, coffee
LEFT: Peeling and clearing coffee beans RIGHT: Sun-drying of coffee beans
planting has decreased in many areas in Yemen. A In 2000, the Al Hamdani company opened its first
third challenge is the scarcity of water, which adds
branch outside Yemen in Saudi Arabia andQatar
to the problem because most of the coffee farms in
under the name of (Green gold Corporation) . In
Yemen fully depend on rainwater.
2006, another branch was opened in Kuwait(Green
70
gold Corporation). In 2008 , the Coffee Processing
The Al Hamdani family business has braved many
Factory, a complete coffee factory with new
challenges over its century of existence. They
machinery and mills was built in Yemen, with high
attribute their business success to the fact that they
production power .
have successfully kept their dedication to the coffee
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee
SMEs
Q&A with Ahmed Ali Al Hamdani Chairman, Al Hamdani Mocha Coffee Ahmed Ali Al Hamdani joined the family business in the 1980ies as part of the fourth generation. He is presently the Chairman of Al-Hamdani for Mocha Coffee. His experience in the coffee industry, he feels, has developed his knowledge in many areas of life. His passion for the industry and for the family business drives him to continue innovation. What were the three most important things
Al-Hamdani for Mocha Coffee is part of the
that you have changed or added to the
Yemen Mocha Coffee Association; what is
business since you joined the company?
the role of this association?
Opening locally branches for the company.
The association is still very young: It was
Exploring new European and Arab market
established in 2008 by the Al-Hamdani and the
through many agents for Mocha coffee in these
Al-Kabous family for best practice in the Yemeni
markets for our products.
coffee industry. We are hoping the association will
Founding a complete factory to process Yemeni
be very active in the future and to encourage and
mocha coffee beans.
train the Yemeni coffee farmers. Our chief role is
In 1995 we added Many European markets to our
to support the coffee farmers by providing and
export list side beside to Arabic market including
facilitating access to loans for them.
Canada, USA, Japan. We have succeeded in becoming a trusted coffee brand in these markets.
Today, the association has eight members who are merchants and over 100 members who are coffee farmers. Due to the current situation in Yemen,
We are hoping the association will be very active in the future and to encourage and train the Yemeni coffee farmers. Our chief role is to support them by facilitating their access to loans.
however, the association cannot develop or expand its activities as rapidly as we would wish. How do you transfer your passion for coffee to the next Al Hamdani generation? I try to transfer the passion for coffee to the next generation of our family by making them participate in the field as well as telling them about my experience. We teach the next generation
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
71
SMEs
Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee
everything about the coffee business and involve them in it as well. There are ten young members of the family who have already joined the business. What are your future plans for Al-Hamdani for Mocha Coffee?
We are a family that feels proud of this business even though we are active in other trading streams as well. Our main focus has always been the mocha coffee business.
My future plans are to stretch market our brand all over the world in order to promote the high quality of Yemen mocha coffee beans;
The Al-Hamdani family has been in this field for
a quality that cannot be found in any other
over 130 years; what do you think is the main
coffee and increasing the production power of
reason behind the success and the continuity
Mocha coffee through stretch the planted land
of your family business?
of Mocha coffee. We participate in many coffee
72
fairs internationally in such as China, Denmark,
We are a family that feels proud of this business even
Germany as well as Ethiopia. We are also
though we are active in other trading streams as well.
participating in the Scae World Coffee-2012 Fair
Our main focus has always been the mocha coffee
in Vienna - Austria
business.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
Clockwise: Picking the coffee bean crops; Al Hamdani for Mocha Coffee participating in an international trade fair; Al Hamdani factory producing and processing Yemeni Mocha coffee in Sanaa
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Committed to enhancing life Aluminium Foundation Readymix Masonry Marble
SMEs
Mowgli, On Mentorship in the Middle East
Mowgli
On Mentorship in the Middle East With unemployment in the MENA region rising and now standing at 10.3%, the highest regional rate in the world (ILO, 2011), Arab countries alone need to create approximately 80 million new jobs by 2020 (World Bank). It is a daunting goal. One way to address this enormous task and to tackle unemployment is the incubation and support of sustainable entrepreneurship and SME development. The organisation Mowgli, founded by Tony Bury, does its part by providing mentorship to entrepreneurs in the Middle East.
T
ony Bury, a serial entrepreneur
sustainable job creation, and social and economic
with over 45 years of experience
development. The organisation achieves this by
in the Middle East, believes that a
recruiting, training and matching mentors and
highly effective way to create long
entrepreneurs in relational and business mentoring
term,
employment
relationships through their unique Mowgli Mentor
opportunities is by mentoring, supporting and
sustainable
Experience (MME) programs. The role of the
empowering entrepreneurs who start and grow
mentor in this relationship is to provide hope and
businesses and helping them to develop their
aspiration, to help entrepreneurs build confidence,
own leadership and decision-making capability.
mitigate risk, focus on individual personal
Following that conviction Bury founded the
development, expand their business, and address
mentorship organisation “Mowgli Foundation�.
challenges along the way.
Mowgli’s mission is to provide mentors who inspire,
74
support and empower entrepreneurs in achieving
Interestingly it is not only the entrepreneurs, the
their business and personal potential, encouraging
mentees that benefit from this relationship and
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Mowgli, On Mentorship in the Middle East
SMEs
Q&A with Tony Bury Founder of Mowgli What inspired you to start The Mowgli Foundation? Fast growing markets have produced entrepreneurs, who have developed businesses that have set fantastic examples in fighting unemployment and have greatly contributed to poverty alleviation. The ABOVE: Mowgli Mentoring Experience (MME)’ Programs
exchange: Bury realized that the mentors, too hugely
moment I understood their positive role in society,
benefit from the experience through their own
I concluded that we really need to find ways to
personal and leadership development. The learning
support entrepreneurs. After extensive research I
process is often a period of self-discovery resulting in
quickly realised that the thing that entrepreneurs
the development of new skills and competencies that
needed the most were mentors, people who support
can be applied within their own professional and
them on their journey. This is how the idea of
personal lives. From published reports to Mowgli’s
Mowgli was born.
own impact analyses and reports, mentoring has a clear and proven influence on the ability of
Initially, I knew little about mentoring. But when I
entrepreneurs to grow their business sustainably,
started researching the topic I saw that I myself had
learn, develop and mentor others. It is for this reason
many people in my life who to me were mentors,
that Mowgli strives to place mentoring at the heart
and I began to appreciate the concept. When
of enabling entrepreneurship, as well as personal
we started Mowgli in 2008 mentoring wasn’t a
and business leadership.
widely spread practice in the Middle East, though
undoubtedly it is happening informally between
To date, Mowgli, run by Tony Bury together with a
many people.
high-energy team including his daughter Kathleen, has successfully run 24 MME programs in Jordan,
Why is mentorship so important to the Middle
Lebanon, Syria, Palestine and the UK. They have
East?
trained around 200 mentors and matched them with high growth potential entrepreneurs, from all
The Middle East is faced with dramatic youth
backgrounds, ages and sectors, to undertake a year-
unemployment. When we looked into ways of how
long mentoring relationship supported by Mowgli.
society could solve this problem, different strategies
In line with their plans to launch in Egypt, Tunisia,
came to mind. Mostly, however, Arab countries
Morocco, Algeria, Qatar and the UAE, Mowgli has
have to get more private sector ownership over
successfully secured funding to deliver a further
commercial businesses. Supporting entrepreneurs,
20+ MME programs within 2012-13, training up
creating SMEs and developing them is one way of
to a further 240 mentors within the MENA alone.
going about this.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
75
SMEs
Mowgli, On Mentorship in the Middle East
However, becoming a successful entrepreneur in the Middle East is still largely dependent on what kind
Figure 1: The Hero’s Journey, Joseph Campbell: The Journey of the Entrepreneur under Mentorship
of relationships you have in the business community. This makes it hard for many entrepreneurs to get
7
access to interesting opportunities. To support them on their journey and help them get access to these
9
opportunities, we first have to understand how
A New Perspective
entrepreneurs work. The first building blocks for any entrepreneurs to be successful are their hopes and aspirations. Therefore, the first thing mentoring does is support entrepreneurs in exactly that. I cannot tell you the difference that the following words make to
10 The Return
1
Ordinary World
8
Facing the Darkness
6
The Journey
Trials, Allies & Enemies
The Hero’s Journey 4 2
an entrepreneur: ‘I believe in what you are doing and
The Call to Change
3
Meeting the Mentor
5
Crossing the Line
Refusing the Call
I believe that you are able to do it.’ Just that kind of encouragement is a fantastic experience. It is the whole point of mentorship. In a next step we focus on business competency, which consists of three components: Knowledge, skills and behaviour. If you have the highest level of knowledge and the highest level of skills but do not demonstrate consistent behaviour, your competency is rated low. This is why in mentorship
The importance of mentorship in the Middle East goes far beyond supporting entrepreneurship to developing different models of leadership.
we focus on behaviour. Whenever you listen to successful entrepreneurs they will tell you that it was a mentor who significantly helped in that area.
easy, they do not necessarily have the skills to grow the organisation at a later stage when processes
The key element that you see in Figure 1 is the
and structures are needed. A mentor can assist in
personal development journey that we all go through
deciding what additional skills the entrepreneur
from time to time, including entrepreneurs. You can
needs and needs to bring in at this growth stage.
see that there is a thunderstorm at a certain stage:
The third critical moment is when an entrepreneur
Each entrepreneur goes through these turmoils.
becomes very successful, his ego may start to grow
There are three critical moments in an entrepreneur’s
and he/she begins to make decisions that are not in
life cycle where he/she needs a mentor most: Often,
his/her personal or business interest. A mentor can
at the very beginning, when financial performance is
help check this behaviour.
poor, they are all stressed out and they make wrong
76
decisions. A mentor is exactly the person to talk to
The importance of mentorship in the Middle East goes
because entrepreneurs can hardly tell their friends
far beyond supporting entrepreneurship to developing
and family that they are going bankrupt next week.
different models of leadership. My definition of
Another critical moment is when entrepreneurs
leadership is simple: To serve is to lead; if I serve you
realise that while starting the business was fairly
and you follow me and then I will become a leader.
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Mowgli, On Mentorship in the Middle East
SMEs
The greatest thing that one human being can do for
The word “Mentor” is often greatly misused: Some
another is to mentor them and if you cannot mentor,
people think of mentoring as providing advice,
you cannot lead. That is why I believe mentoring is so
others think of coaching as mentoring. In reality
important: it actually develops leadership.
coaching is about performance enhancement. In mentorship the mentor needs to be able to be
Our mentors give their time to entrepreneurs
involved and understand what are the issues in the
without expecting anything back or receiving
entrepreneur’s personal life, which is impacting his
financial compensation, but they always confirm
or her business life and vice versa. It requires a high
that they get such joy from doing it. They enjoy
degree of trust. Mentors as a rule have to have or
seeing their mentees develop their decision making
to develop a high level of emotional intelligence.
and leadership capability around the advice that is given and that the guidance and support is
Are the relationships between mentors and
appreciated. Mentors therefore get just as much
the entrepreneurs continued after the Mowgli
out of the mentor/mentee relationship as the
program?
entrepreneurs that they are supporting and often say that the mentee actually becomes their mentor.
Following the 3 day mentor training and mentee-
Many have come back to me and told me that being
mentor matching program, we facilitate a one year
a mentor has helped them deal with challenges in
mentoring program and after that the mentor and the
other, sometimes more personal, areas of life as well.
entrepreneur are free to continue their relationship on their own. Although they remain part of the Mowgli
What are the major do’s and don’ts of
Family (alumni), we do not monitor them for our
mentorship?
official impact reports. Of the 80% of the relationships that last the one year with Mowgli, 97% go on to a
Of course, a mentor is someone who listens and tells
second year, and so far 95% have gone on to the third
you the truth and not necessarily what you want
year. The relationship with the mentors doesn’t have
to hear, but at the same time they should not be
to be maintained on a daily basis, but if a trusting
judgemental. What is also really important is that
relationship is developed, they usually remain in your
the mentor should not have any vested interest in
life. In addition, both parties need to understand that
the performance of their mentee. For instance, if the
the mentorship relationship is absolutely symbiotic, if
mentor has an interest in shares of the entrepreneur’s
it is not, the relationship falls apart. In fact the mentees
business then that corrupts the value of the
are the drivers of the relationship: if they do not keep
mentorship program.
in touch with the mentor, the relationship will fail.
The other aspect that is really important for a
One of the greatest benefits of our Mowgli
mentor is that in case of failure they do not criticise
program is that we partner entrepreneurs up
their mentees or discourage them, but support them
with one “official” mentor but during the program
in getting back up, celebrating and learning from
they are able to benefit from numerous unofficial
the experience. In the future, I would like mentees
mentors at the same time. It is this experience that
to share their failures because it is so important
we try to provide and that we hope contributes to
to share these experiences with the community,
the sustainable success of entrepreneurs in the
especially in the Middle East.
Middle East.
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
77
MIRACULOUS, UNFORGETTABLE FULL OF EXPECTATION
BUT FOR MILLIONS OF CHILDREN, IT’S ALL THEY GET. Every year 3.1 million babies die in their first month of life. EVERY ONE leaves a heartbroken family. EVERY ONE of us can stop children dying. To find out more about the campaign and how you can help, go to www.everyone.org
Registered charity England and Wales 1076822.
Anna Kari
The fIrST day Of LIfe...
interactive
The Tharawat magazine website keeps expanding its functions to provide our readers with more and more interactive content. Check out who is featured and what is new this month in our Interactive section. Home
About us
News
Magazines
Authors
Subscriptions
COMING SOON The ArAbiAn PublicATion for fAmily businesses The ArAbiAn PublicATion for fAmily businesses Volume 10 Apr-Jun 2011
Volume 11 Jul-Sep 2011
The ArAbiAn PublicATion for fAmily businesses The ArAbiAn PublicATion for fAmily businesses Volume 13 Jan-Mar 2012 Volume 14 Apr-Jun 2012
16 Profile: Pictet&Cie.
Centuries of history and an interview with Senior Managing Partner Jacques de Saussure.
38 Interview with Moh’d A. Al Obaidly
Group Managing Director of the OITC GROUP, Qatar.
32 Philanthropy in 14 Profile: van Bommel Nine generations of shoe-making Family Businesses excellence and three young Philanthropic activities that brothers in charge. increase family cohesion.
46 Interview with 62 Toukan Enterprise Essa Al Ghurair
Vice Chairman of Al Ghurair A family-owned soap factory Investments and Chairman of in Nablus, and an interview Al Ghurair Foods, UAE. with Chairman Farouk Toukan.
30 Family Business Relationships
Solutions to toxic relationship patterns in family firms.
64 The Naji Family
Arabesque architecture and art preserved over generations by the Naji family based in the USA and Morocco.
12 40
Ahmed Seddiqi
& Sons - A Family History of Precision
60 years of passion for luxury watches.
Alserkal Group A Family Business Going Green
Profile of the Alserkal Envirol plant.
60 70
Ajegroup
16
The most Global
Q&A with Mohammed Alkhorayef
The vision behind the Alkhorayef Peruvian Family Group’s agricultural expertise A Peruvian family firm goes East.
52
Abdul Latif Jameel Community Initiatives
Drivers of Talent management in the Middle East
Drivers of talent management in A family’s quest for job creation. Middle Eastern markets and firms
42 58
The Nuqul Group: HR Systems in the Family Business
Pillars and standards for efficient HR systems in family businesses
Q&A with Veronica Maldonado, Venezuela
The Maldonado family history and their pursuit of good ownership
sPeciAl feATures
Human Capital
Special FeatureS
Family Business
family business
Diversification The balancing act of managing the familiy business portfolio
Internationalisation
SPECIAL FEATURES: Family Businesses Driving Environmental Strategies
Finding the key to successful internationalisation for family-owned firms
Developing people in- and outside the family
COVER 014.indd 1
COVER OPTIONS9.indd 1
4/2/12 10:25 AM
1/1/11 10:27 AM
THARAWAT MAGAZINE BACK ISSUE STORE Tharawat magazine is launching its back issues store, which will allow our readers to purchase any and all issues of Tharawat magazine. With PayPal and Credit Card payment the checkout will be made easy and fast.
OUR FEATURED AUTHOR: Caroline Fattal Fakhoury, Vice President of Fattal Holding, Lebanon and Middle East Managing Partner, Praesta: Caroline’s article on “Family Business Relationships” in Volume 11, 2011 accurately describes the challenges we encounter when dealing with family members and provides tools to overcome them.
THE THARAWAT MAGAZINE WEBSITE
www.tharawat-magazine.com Discover the Arabian publication for family businesses online
www.tharawat-magazine.com
Volume 15 Tharawat magazine
79
interactive
FAMILY BUSINESS SOCIAL MEDIA
We live in the age of social media and much of our knowledge and information is drawn from sources that are referred to us on facebook, linkedin, twitter and other. The family business topic is no exception. in our interactive section, we bring to you the social media sources on family business topics that we recommend and follow, as well as our own favourite tweets and posts.
Family Business Social Media
Facebook.com/tharawat.magazine
Check out our Likes on Facebook The Tharawat magazine Team uses the Facebook page to post family business news items and announcements about upcoming issues. We have over 19’000 fans and are enjoying the interaction with them on a daily basis. Other family business pages we like are:
Fondazione Zegna Family business Emernegildo Zegna’s philanthropic foundation. Business Families Foundation Provide educational material for business families. Ford Motor Company Century-old family business Ford Motors.
80
Tharawat magazine Volume 15
@Tharawatmag
With our Twitter account we follow many interesting Tweets: @WJTowell: We are following the 5th generation family business from Oman. @FFIGlobal: A leading family business education and services provider.
Linkedin hosts many interest groups amongst which are many relevant to family businesses Join Group UK Family Business Research Community, for researchers of family firms Join Group Family Business United, provides international family firm news and stories.
www.tharawat-magazine.com