Print Edition of The Observer for Thursday, December 1, 2016

The independent

To uncover

newspaper serving

the truth

Notre Dame and

and report

Saint Mary’s

it accurately

Volume 51, Issue 60 | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

Haitian nun leads panel on health Sister Bernadette Nicolas, students discuss methods for treating AIDS, tuberculosis in Haiti

By AIDAN LEWIS News Writer

Sister Bernadette Nicolas, a nun and nurse from Haiti, spoke about her work with AIDS and tuberculosis patients in Haiti on Wednesday night in DeBartolo Hall. Nicolas is a member of the Congregation of the Little Sisters of St. Therese of the Child Jesus, which she said is dedicated to helping those living in poverty in Haiti.

“The congregation was founded to take care of patients in the mountains of Haiti, where there are sisters working in 10 geographical areas,” Nicolas said. “We provide education, healthcare and social work.”

Nicolas said the sisters noticed the lack of care available

to many AIDS and tuberculosis patients in Haiti, and decided they needed to take action.

“One day, somebody went to our funder to explain the situation,” Nicolas said. “Our funder asked the sisters to go and visit these [AIDS patients].

We started to visit them each Sunday, with food and many things for them. We took care of them.”

Since this humble beginning, Nicolas said the sisters have opened up a hospital dedicated to helping AIDS and tuberculosis. Natural Baptiste, a freshman who presented at the event, said tuberculosis is an enormous problem in Haiti and is called “the disease of the poor.” see HAITI PAGE 3

ROSIE LoVOI | The Observer

Freshman Ryan McAndrews speaks on methods for treating disease in the developing world. McAndrews, along with other students and Sister Bernadette Nicolas, focused their discussion on health in Haiti.

SMC Club of Los Angeles releases new ornament

Coursicle aids in class registration

By NICOLE CARATAS

By ANDREW CAMERON

Saint Mary’s Editor

News Writer

The Saint Mary’s Los Angeles Alumnae Club recently released the second in its series of five Collegethemed Christmas ornaments, this one featuring Le Mans Hall.

Susan Rice, class of 1961, said the Club decided to make Christmas ornaments celebrating different aspects of the College’s history to serve as a reminder of the alumnae’s time at the College.

“We thought that we wanted [an ornament] — and we thought a lot of other people would want one too — that depicts Saint Mary’s, because we love Saint Mary’s,” Rice said. “There’s so many wonderful buildings that have a nostalgi[c] feeling that we like.”

The ornaments also will be used to give back to the College, Rice said.

“We hope, at the end of the day, that the money we make, we can return to the College for scholarship, but that’s a couple years down the road,” she said.

The first ornament in the planned series of five came out in the winter of 2015 and featured The Avenue, whereas this year’s

Class registration is a struggle college students must face every year, but this past year Notre Dame students have had access to Coursicle, a website designed to make designing a course schedule and registering for classes easier.

The service was founded by Joe Puccio, who graduated from the University of North Carolina

NEWS PAGE 3

Chapel Hill in 2016, and Tara Aida, who graduated from Harvard University in the same year. It allows students to browse classes, make sample schedules and receive a text when a class opens up.

Puccio said in an email interview that the idea for Coursicle came from his own struggles with registering for classes.

“When I was an incoming see COURSICLE PAGE 4

Carroll Hall hosts Christmas party SUSAN RICE | The Observer

The new annual ornament released by the Saint Mary’s Club of Los Angeles. This year the ornament depcits LeMans Hall.

ornament features the front of Le Mans Hall, with open doors and Christmas wreaths.

“We all loved this [year’s] one,” Rice said. “We thought it had a lot of charm. For those of us who don’t get to Indiana very much, it brought back memories of snow and the

SCENE PAGE 5

campus at Christmastime.”

Rice said these ornaments help celebrate Saint Mary’s, especially since Christmas is an important part of the time spent on campus.

“We all have wonderful see ORNAMENT PAGE 4

VIEWPOINT PAGE 7

By MEGAN VALLEY Associate News Editor

As Notre Dame students are beginning their last round of papers and exams, the residents of Carroll Hall are busy decking the halls and trimming the trees for Carroll Christmas. The dorm’s signature event starts at 7:30 p.m. on Friday, with the traditional Christmas

Hockey PAGE 12

tree-lighting ceremony.

“We always begin by lighting a tree,” sophomore Carroll Christmas commissioner Matthew Valenti said. “Someone gives a speech about Carroll Christmas and Carroll Hall in general, and there’s a big countdown to lighting the tree that maintenance does for see CARROLL PAGE 4

Women’s Basketball PAGE 12

2

TODAY

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

Question of the Day: ndsmcobserver.com

Have a question you want answered?

Email photo@ndsmcobserver.com

What was your last Google search?

P.O. Box 779, Notre Dame, IN 46556 024 South Dining Hall, Notre Dame, IN 46556 Editor-in-Chief Margaret Hynds Managing Editor Business Manager Kayla Mullen Emily Reckmeyer

Asst. Managing Editor: Alex Carson Asst. Managing Editor: Zach Klonsinski Asst. Managing Editor: Clare Kossler News Editor: Katie Galioto Viewpoint Editor: Claire Radler Sports Editor: Marek Mazurek Scene Editor: Erin McAuliffe Saint Mary’s Editor: Nicole Caratas Photo Editor: Chris Collins Graphics Editor: Susan Zhu Multimedia Editor: Wei Cao Online Editor: Jimmy Kemper Advertising Manager: Olivia Treister Ad Design Manager: Madison Riehle

Emily Salerno

Anna Kairis

sophomore Farley Hall

junior Cavanaugh Hall

“Best hospitals in California.”

“Chad Michael Murray and wife.”

Nick Palutsis

Brendan Besh

junior O’Neill Hall

junior Stanford Hall

“Chastity.”

“Starboy The Weeknd lyrics.”

Erica Siatczynski

Lauren Hill

junior Badin Hall

junior Breen-Phillips Hall

“Scott Nestler.”

“Performance measure and data mining.”

Office Manager & General Info

Ph: (574) 631-7471 Fax: (574) 631-6927 Advertising

(574) 631-6900 ads@ndsmcobserver.com Editor-in-Chief

(574) 631-4542 mhynds@nd.edu Managing Editor

(574) 631-4542 kmullen2@nd.edu Assistant Managing Editors

(574) 631-4541 acarson1@nd.edu, zklonsin@nd.edu, ckossler@nd.edu Business Office

(574) 631-5313 News Desk

(574) 631-5323 news@ndsmcobserver.com Viewpoint Desk

(574) 631-5303 viewpoint@ndsmcobserver.com Sports Desk

(574) 631-4543 sports@ndsmcobserver.com Scene Desk

(574) 631-4540 scene@ndsmcobserver.com Saint Mary’s Desk

ncaratas01@saintmarys.edu Photo Desk

(574) 631-8767 photo@ndsmcobserver.com Systems & Web Administrators

(574) 631-8839 Policies The Observer is the independent, daily newspaper published in print and online by the students of the University of Notre Dame du Lac and Saint Mary’s College. Editorial content, including advertisements, is not governed by policies of the administration of either institution. The Observer reserves the right to refuse advertisements based on content.

The news is reported as accurately and objectively as possible. Unsigned editorials represent the opinion of the majority of the Editor-in-Chief, Managing Editor, Assistant Managing Editors and department editors. Commentaries, letters and columns present the views of the authors and not necessarily those of The Observer.

Viewpoint space is available to all readers. The free expression of all opinions through letters is encouraged.

Letters to the Editor must be signed and must include contact information.

Questions regarding Observer policies should be directed to Editor-in-Chief Margaret Hynds.

Post Office Information The Observer (USPS 599 2-4000) is published Monday through Friday except during exam and vacation periods.

A subscription to The Observer is $130 for one academic year; $75 for one semester.

The Observer is published at: 024 South Dining Hall Notre Dame, IN 46556-0779 Periodical postage paid at Notre Dame and additional mailing offices POSTMASTER Send address corrections to: The Observer P.O. Box 779 024 South Dining Hall Notre Dame, IN 46556-077 The Observer is a member of the Associated Press.

All reproduction rights are reserved.

Today’s Staff News

Sports

Emily McConville Lucas Masin-Moyer Jordan Cockrum

Ben Padanilam R.J. Stempak

Graphics

Scene

Andrea Savage

Kelly McGarry

Photo

Viewpoint

Chris Collins

Sarah Hynds

Corrections The Observer regards itself as a professional publication and strives for the highest standards of journalism at all times. We do, however, recognize that we will make mistakes. If we have made a mistake, please contact us at (574) 631-4541 so we can correct our error.

CHRIS COLLINS | The Observer

Sophomore Jaihee Choi of Breen-Phillips Hall hangs lights around her door for the dorm’s annual Christmas decorating competition. The competition is between sections; Choi lives on the first floor, which counts as one section in the competition.

The next Five days:

Want your event included here?

Email news@ndsmcobserver.com

Thursday

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

Monday

Yoga in the Galleries Snite Museum of Art 4 p.m. - 5 p.m.

Relax with free yoga class. Open to all experience levels.

Higgins Labor Café: Laboring Under Climate Change Geddes Hall 5 p.m. - 6 p.m.

Open to ND community.

Winter Wonderland Saint Mary’s campus all day ND, SMC and Holy Cross students are welcome for winter fun.

ND Jazz Band Concert DeBartolo Performing Arts Center 7 p.m. - 8 p.m.

Free but ticketed.

Blood Drive Fitzpatrick Hall of Engineering 9 a.m. - 3 p.m.

Drink water before and bring a photo ID.

“From Us to Me” DeBartolo Performing Arts Center 7 p.m. - 9:30 p.m.

Free tickets available at the Nanovic Institute.

EXALT Evening Adoration Zahm House chapel 7:30 p.m. - 9 p.m.

Students may come and go as they please.

Saint Mary’s Madrigal Dinner Regina Hall 4:30 p.m. - 5:30 p.m.

Tickets available at moreaucenter.com.

Advent Lessons and Carols Basilica of the Sacred Heart 7:15 p.m. - 8:15 p.m.

Open to the public.

SMC Festival of Short Plays Little Theatre 8:30 p.m.

Students perform five 10-minute plays.

News

ndsmcobserver.com | thursday, december 1, 2016 | The Observer

3

Student senate

Librarians discuss finished, future renovations

By DEVON HARFORD News Writer

During Wednesday night’s Senate meeting, University librarian Diane Walker and sociology librarian Jessica Kayongo presented on past, present and future renovations of Hesburgh Library.

The librarians showed the senators before-and-after pictures as well as design simulations and drawings of the sections of the library that have not been renovated yet.

“We have been renovating in stages,” Walker said. “We have completed the entrance gallery, Level 10, Level 4 and the new Scholars Lounge.”

The Scholars Lounge was opened for the first time on Wednesday and quickly filled,

Walker said.

“People have already discovered it,” Walker said. “I encourage you all to take a look at it early, before it fills up again tomorrow.”

The new space is intended to be an open study space, with no guarantees of quiet, Walker said.

“You won’t find another area like it anywhere on campus,” she said.

The 10th floor has gained new seating and a reading room, while the fourth floor has become library staff work space. The main concourse is also complete.

The next big development, coming in December or January, will be the completion of the east wall of the concourse.

“There is a very deliberate attempt to make the concourse a good first impression for people

coming through in student tours, football games, everything,” Kayongo said.

Walker said the new designs have included more natural light.

Kayongo said LED lighting also brightens spaces and is more energy efficient.

Future plans for the library, although already designed, will be implemented in pieces in order to keep the library open for use. Technology Row is a section which will contain the Center for Digital Scholarship, other specialized computers and equipment and a work spaces for the subject librarians.

Additionally, there is a new teaching and collaboration hub, designed to house instruction spaces, group study spaces, mobile chairs and tables and hosting

spaces for campus partners.

“More happens in the library than just people checking books in and out,” Kayongo said.

A grand reading room with rows of study tables will also be added to act as a “traditional heads down, quiet study space,” Kayongo said. The area will be where the fishbowl currently sits and will include the floor above.

Other additions include a fireplace and a museum-quality gallery to showcase the Special Collections and Archives, along with more spaces for lectures and other audience events.

“We are going to make this into a 21st century library,” Walker said.

After praising the progress made in the Library renovations, the Senate passed several resolutions regarding hall elections. One

added the phrase “social media” to a previous resolution on how to campaign appropriately online in student elections.

Another resolution standardized the formation of candidate slates.

A third required campaign groups to use Google Groups for their activities and prohibited the use of Listservs and other University services for non-official business.

Another resolution stated that votes to abstain would not be counted in the percentages that determine who wins a hall election. There will still be there option to vote “abstain” and express individual opinion, but abstentions will not influence the outcome of the election.

Contact Devon Harford at dharford@nd.edu

Paid Advertisement

Haiti Continued from page 1

Paid Advertisement

“In low-income countries, 238 per 100,000 people are infected with active tuberculosis, whereas in high income countries, like America, 21 out of 100,000 people are infected,” Baptiste said. “The reason why it’s so prevalent in low income countries is because of poor sanitation and a lack of proper nutrition.”

For this reason, Nicolas said she felt inspired to provide any assistance she could to those who were suffering.

“It is very hard to see the young people die from tuberculosis or AIDS,” Nicolas said. “But it was very important for me to be there to help our people.”

Nicolas said that although working in the hospital is very rewarding, it has brought with it a multitude of challenges, such as inadequate resources for giving patients the treatment they need.

“We don’t have enough personnel to take care of the people,” Nicolas said. “I have to do many things. In the morning we have to visit these people and see if they have enough food for a balanced diet. During the midday, we have to take them to see the doctor. I also have to educate them about their condition and provide medicines.”

Another problem, Nicolas said, is that some patients come at a point too late in the disease for any treatment to make a real difference.

“Sometimes when they try to receive a consultation, they die before we can see them,” Nicolas said.

However, Nicolas said word is spreading in Haiti about the hospital and the care it provides.

“We had one young man who came after he had first gone to a voodoo priest for help,” Nicolas.

“He lost all his money to this voodoo priest. But one day, someone told him to go to the hospital.

When he came, he got much better. It is a testament to the hospital that someone told him to stay away from the voodoo priests and come to the hospital instead.”

Contact Aidan Lewis at alewis9@nd.edu

4

NEWS

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

Coursicle Continued from page 1

first-year at UNC, I spent several hours trying to plan out my class schedule, and then when I finally went to register for my classes, I got into only one of the five I needed to take,” Puccio said. “So that night, I started working on a program that would text me when a class I wanted had an available seat.”

Puccio said a friend thought he should open it up to other students, and the service soon grew by word of mouth. By the next semester, 1800 students had signed up for Coursicle.

“A few months later, [Aida]

Ornament Continued from page 1

memories — special ways in which Christmas was celebrated, or pre-Christmas and Advent were celebrated on campus, before we left to go home or spend our holidays somewhere else,” Rice said. “It ties in the season, the memory of Saint Mary’s as a Catholic women’s college that celebrates the religious traditions and the beauty of the campus, the heritage of

Carroll Continued from page 1

us. We do what we can for the front of the building ourselves.”

Valenti said this year’s event will feature the traditional Christmas tree lighting ceremony; performances from student music groups, including the Undertones; an hourlong set from Student Standups; and cookies, hot chocolate and prizes for “Reindeer Games” such as cornhole, putt-putt and a wreath toss.

As always, the freshmen of Carroll Hall will be playing the part of Santa and his elves, Valenti said.

“That’s the other big attraction,” he said. “We have a Santa and we have a Mrs. Clause — we always try to get the most bearded freshman to be Mrs. Clause, just to have a good time with that — and then there are elves running everything.

“It’s just a bunch of adults running around in elf costumes, which is a lot of fun.

Some of them are small enough to where they look the part, and then others definitely do not.”

Over 900 people have RSVP’d to the Carroll Christmas Facebook event, with another 600 saying they were “interested.”

“Last year, 1,500 to 2,000 people cycled through the dorm,” Valenti said. “I think at one point there was over 1,000 [in the dorm] at once. We’ve started advertising earlier, and more people have heard about

suggested we try to solve the other side of registration: the arduous process of figuring out what classes to take and trying to fit them all into a non-overlapping schedule,” he said. “Part of the reason this task is so arduous is because the software the university provides to search for classes is usually very outdated and tedious to use. So, Coursicle really came out of a pain that we, as well as our friends, were experiencing while we were students.”

When Coursicle was initially launched in 2013, it was only available at UNC. Puccio and Aida then expanded to three other schools: the University of Pennsylvania, Appalachian

State University and the University of Notre Dame.

They chose those schools because “we wanted to launch at schools that were academically strong and had a midsize to large undergraduate population,” Aida said. “I also had a few high school friends who went to Notre Dame, and when I showed them Coursicle, they really liked it and said it would be useful. It was the same situation for Penn and Appalachian State.”

Now, the app has dozens of schools to choose from.

Coursicle has also expanded the services it offers since it launched. In the summer of 2014, the founders added the schedule view, allowing

students to see the classes they are considering laid out in a calendar. Later, they introduced the ability for students to log in with Facebook to see what classes their friends are considering, as well as the ability to save multiple schedules.

“All of these features have been in response to user requests, which we typically use to guide our development,” said Aida.

Puccio said they have other ideas for improving Coursicle, such as allowing students in the same class to chat with each other and create collaborative study guides. Also in the works is a feature for providing recommendations for classes based on what classes

a student has already taken.

Puccio believes Coursicle can be a valuable tool for helping students get into the classes they want while minimizing the stress of the registration process.

“Coursicle is useful because it helps college students plan and get into their perfect class schedules,” he said. “By doing so, Coursicle helps relieve some of the stress and tedium involved with the course registration process. This is important because registration can be extremely stressful and has rather important consequences.”

the Sisters, the planning that they did [and] the commitment they had to women’s education. So it all comes together.”

Rice said another alumna in the club, Rebecca Votto Bennett ’93, had the idea for the series, and did research to make sure that each of the five ornaments related to the College’s history.

“The Avenue we knew would be the first, because The Avenue is something that means something to everybody, and so many people

have wonderful memories of the very first time they visited the campus with The Avenue,” she said. “The second one, Le Mans, that’s an anniversary, and that’s what our plan is for the rest of them. There is either an anniversary of something the Sisters [of the Holy Cross] did, or the construction of some other significant part of Saint Mary’s history.”

According to Rice, the College was helpful in promoting the ornaments and ensuring the accuracy of the history. Each ornament

includes a short essay about the significance of what the ornament represents.

Last year, the ornament featuring the Avenue sold out, and Rice said she expects this year’s to sell out as well.

“People have bought gifts for their aunts, their sisters or other people who have either attended Saint Mary’s or visited Saint Mary’s or loved it,” she said. “People have been very positive, so we’re hoping that enthusiasm will continue.”

Junior Stefanie Dyga said

she purchased last year’s ornament because of its beautiful design, but also as a gift for her mother.

“My mom loves it because even though I am far away, it’s a little piece of Saint Mary’s on her tree before I come home for Christmas,” Dyga said.

According to Rice, the theme of the next ornament will be announced during graduation in the spring.

it. … Hopefully, we can get above 2,000. That’s the goal.”

Valenti said the entire dorm helps with decorating the hall just a few days before the event.

“We start the earliest we can,” he said. “We have Carroll Mass on Tuesday, then all the furniture gets moved into the chapel and we start staying up late decorating after that.

“You can’t beat just being up at 3 a.m., blaring Christmas music. It doesn’t seem like it’s going to get done, but, somehow, it always does.”

Carroll Christmas is free for all of its attendees.

“We don’t try to make any money off this,” Valenti said.

“We have a big party, is basically what it is. We’re not doing it for anyone or anything. We have Lakeside, in the spring, that we do for the Boys and Girls Club, but for this, we just spend money so people can celebrate Christmas.”

Since Carroll Hall is located behind the lakes on the University campus, Valenti said Carroll Christmas is one of the only times of the year that other students come to the dorm. “[Carroll Hall] is kind of like the North Pole, in a sense,” he said.”You can’t just wander into Carroll — it’s a deliberate attempt to go there. But people are willing to make the trek for this, and I think it’s definitely worth the extra five-minute walk past Lyons to come have a good time.”

Contact Megan Valley at mvalley@nd.edu

Follow us on Twitter. @NDSMCObserver Paid Advertisement

Contact Andrew Cameron at acamero2@nd.edu

Contact Nicole Caratas at ncaratas01@saintmarys.edu

5

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

By MAGGIE WALSH Scene Writer

On Friday, Nov. 25 every tiny tree, shrub and blade of grass along Broadway was already covered in white Christmas lights, but it was the Beacon Theatre that attracted eyes as night set in on New York City. The LED marquee at the legendary venue boasted the sold-out show about to begin. The crowds lined up outside were almost exclusively in their thirties and forties, with a good percentage of stereotypical hipsters.

Tonight, almost to the day, was the 25th anniversary of the first gig of nerd-rock band Guster. From the size of the crowd and the excitement in the air — not to mention the small museum dedicated to their career that lined the Beacon vestibule — Guster has a lot to be proud of.

Formed out of a dorm room at Tufts University, Guster started out exclusively acoustic. One of their gimmicks, even after they gained popularity, was to forgo drums in favor of a set of bongos. 25 years later, they continued this tradition when they took the stage following their opening act, Pisapia Love-In (founded by former member Joe Pisapia). Bongo player Brian Rosenworcel was insanely entertaining to watch, not only for his enthusiastic playing, but also for his amusing facial expressions.

Their opening song “What You Wish For” was greeted by screaming fans within the first beats of the bongo. When the bridge of the chorus began, instruments paused and

By ERIN McAULIFFE Scene Editor

“Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” begins with a scan of The Daily Prophet and articles that warn of a “dark wizard terror threat,” setting the film’s tone of fear mongering, bigotry and social unrest in a darkly detailed 1920s New York City that poignantly translates to today’s climate.

The film is a continuation of J.K. Rowling’s exhilaratingly imaginative wizarding world, but the opening scene depicts British magizoologist Newt Scamander (Eddie Redmayne) on a ship across seas to New York.

For the first time, we see the American wizarding community.

David Yates, director of “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix” through “Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows: Part 2,” translates his shadowy, bewitching macrocosm to America with ease. U.S. audiences will feel a new sense of engagement with the film, noting familiar landmarks and seeing their own emotions reflected on the big screen through the addition of a central No-Maj character (American for “muggle”).

Unlike the Harry Potter series, the “Fantastic Beasts” screenplay was entirely written by J.K. Rowling. Rowling had a clean slate to create a prelude to Scamander’s encyclopedia-esque guide to magical creatures without die-hard fans to comment on things “left out” or pass judgment on whether the movie is better than the book.

Because Rowling has the freedom to tackle new issues with new characters, she is able to explore social

lead singer Ryan Miller belted out, “Come out, come out, wherever you are,” backed by the nearly 3,000 fans packed into the theatre. The majority of the audience knew and sang every word zealously. At the end of the song, Miller jokingly bowed and said, “Thank you, and good night!”

The crowd laughed and Miller continued, “I think we’re going to keep the chitter chatter to a minimum so we can play as long as possible.”

True to their word, Guster crammed as many songs as they could into their two-hour set. They continued with “Gangway” off their newest album, “Evermotion,” which fans seemed to enjoy just as much as the next song, “Manifest Destiny.” Their former band mate and opener Joe Pisapia joined them on harmonica for “Backyard,” and stayed on stage, donning an electric guitar, for infectiously upbeat “Bad, Bad World.”

Pisapia wasn’t their only guest. About halfway through the show, Miller introduced another musical guest, a choir from Long Island called The Silver Chords, comprised almost exclusively of elderly women. The Silver Chords joined Guster for “Empire State” and “All the Way Up to Heaven,” during which an adorable soloist from The Silver Chords sang the entirety of her solo verse off a crumpled piece of paper. “You guys look way nicer than we do,” Miller joked as the choir, many decked out in pearls, reassembled themselves in between songs. Guster’s other guests included a three-part horn section known as the Unihorns and a giant, blow-up teddy bear named Big Friend, inspired by

the cover art of their debut album, “Parachute.”

Perhaps the most memorable part came at the very beginning of the encore, when Miller, who went guitarless for one of the first times during the show, realized that his pants zipper had been down for the whole set. He made a face at the crowd mid-song, and even fans singing along paused to laugh. After the song, he told the crowd a funny story about purchasing the “lady pants” in a Canadian thrift store. The story quickly turned into an improvised disco jam with a rap vocal, complete with the hilarious hook, “My camel toe is showin’ through the front row, front row!”

The 25 years have treated Guster well. Their live sound is just as rich as their recorded albums and their sense of humor and humility made them entertaining to watch.

They clearly still enjoy making music and being around each other. In lieu of an encore, they asked longtime fan Nicky, who Miller called “the coolest weirdo ever,” to come up and accept the encore on behalf of all of their longtime fans. They concluded with “So Long” played on acoustic instruments at the front of the stage as band member Luke Reynolds held up handmade signs containing the lyrics and the entire Beacon audience sang along. They ended their set by returning to how they started out 25 years before: group sing-alongs, acoustic instruments, laughter and fun.

pessimism in a new realm. Although the film is set in the 1920s and the Harry Potter series was technically more modern, “Fantastic Beasts” finds Rowling effectively depicting current American unrest. The opening scene parallels the big city terror-threats explored in films like 2008’s “The Dark Knight.” The intolerance expressed by the “Second Salemers” that picket the wizards’ way of life and yell statements like, “The people behind this are not like you and me!” could fit in today’s protest-heavy headlines. There is even a scene where a presidential candidate touted as “America’s Future” is killed while giving a speech — take that as you will.

The relatable depiction is made even more realistic by the addition of a central No-Maj character, endearing aspiring-baker but current canning factory worker Jacob Kowalski. The addition of a character that oohs and ahs at strudel baked in midair and suitcases that contain an expansive zoo brings the audience quite literally into the movie.

Jacob embarks on a Pokemon-Go style chase across New York City for the creatures that scatterbrained Newt Scamander has accidentally let loose. The creatures range from a perky platypus to a reckless rhinoceros, each outfitted with quirks like kleptomania or a literal hot head. It seems a bit too fitting with a release date the week before Black Friday that Rowling has created an extensive line-up of cuddly just-in-time-for-Christmas merchandise. It also appeals to the new generation of Potterheads that the five-part series will create.

The series is also creating a new cast of characters, of which the supporting roles shine. Dan Fogler gives

a convincing performance as Scamander’s perplexed sidekick Kowalski, whom most of the movie’s characters and audience come to adore. Alison Sudol (the indie artist behind A Fine Frenzy) does a lot with a small role as ethereal Legilimens Queenie, defying the sexism of the time and role as she intimidates male coworkers while wearing luxuriously pink ensembles that would put Umbridge in her place.

For fans of the original series, there are nods at the plot throughout: a love interest of Lestrange descent, a lava-fueled Whomping Willow-esque scene in Central Park and the mention that Dumbledore supported Scamander’s controversial initiative to educate wizards on magical creatures, a direct Potter-parallel. There are even a few proverbs uttered by Scamander, such as “worrying means you suffer twice,” that sound like they might have originated with the headmaster.

“Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” expands the wizarding world we have come to know and love across seas without leaning on the original series’ initial characters or plot as a crutch. Rowling is free to explore political and social concerns with the entirety of New York City (wizard and No-Maj characters alike) as a backdrop, a more fitting canvas than a wizarding school ever was. Bright new characters and creatures delight against Yates’ signature umbral world. It is a film that affectingly reflects modern trends from PokemonGo to political protests inside a delightfully magical fantasy.

Contact Maggie Walsh at mwalsh30@nd.edu

Contact Erin McAuliffe at emcaulif@nd.edu ANDREA SAVAGE | The Observer

6

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

Have we gotten the message?

Inside Column

Reviving Secret Santa

Mimi Teixeira and Niko Porter BridgeND

Elizabeth Greason Sports Writer

When it comes to Christmas, traditions are kind of my thing.

Christmas music can only be played once we’ve finished Thanksgiving dinner. My parents and I host Christmas Eve dinner and presents are opened between dinner and dessert, and no sooner. When we pull out the Christmas crackers, everyone must wear the big, limp paper crown that inevitably comes flying off. Once everyone leaves, we curl up on the couch and my dad reads “’Twas the Night Before Christmas.”

On Christmas Day, each of my parents and I can open exactly one present before Mass and everything else needs to wait.

The entire O’Brien family — everyone on my mom’s side — rolls up to my aunt’s house for Christmas dinner. And all of the O’Brien family grandkids participate in Secret Santa.

Secret Santa started when suddenly my mom and her four siblings woke up and there were 13 grandkids. It was dubbed excessive for everyone to buy everyone a present, so the tradition began in which each grandchild draws names and is assigned to one other cousin, becoming their Secret Santa.

Everyone gave a present and got a present, so it worked.

At some point, the adults decided Secret Santa ended once you turned 21 and as everyone got older, it essentially became a thoughtless gift-card exchange. But it was still fun. It gave us a chance, or even an excuse, to interact with the cousins we might only see a few days each year.

And then, a few years ago, the traditions I hold so dear began to crumble. Christmas fell in the middle of the week, so it was decided it would be easier to not celebrate Christmas on Christmas, but to instead create our own holiday, O’BFFC, or O’Brien Family Fake Christmas. Everyone got together and celebrated Christmas, but not actually on Christmas. It took place on the weekend closest to Christmas, which makes sense but was not the same.

And then, last year, the unthinkable happened.

After much — flawed — thought and debate by the adults and much protest from the under-21 cousins, Secret Santa was done away with altogether. There were some mumblings about making donations in each other’s names instead but as far as I know, that never happened. Only three of the five families came to Christmas and while it was much more calm and tame than years past, just like O’BFFC, it was not the same.

So this year, we, the kids, are taking Christmas back.

Over Thanksgiving break, texts flew around the O’Brien cousin world, figuring out a way we could bring Secret Santa back, our excitement bubbling over as each cousin got on board with the plan. And trust me when I say that Secret Santa is back and better than ever.

With two more cousins aging out this year, it would be almost 50-50 for cousins under 21 to cousins who were “too old.” So we tossed the age limit. I don’t know whose idea the age restriction was, but it seems ridiculous to tell half the family they’re too old for Christmas spirit. Everyone is back in and everyone is excited. Almost all 13 of us are old enough to pick out gifts for each other on our own and we’re willing to put in the thought and effort to make Secret Santa worthwhile.

Or should I say 14 of us? With the inaugural O’Brien cousin wedding on the horizon in August, we added one more name to the hat. My future cousin, or as my grandma now delights in calling him, her grandson in-law, Victor is — willingly — being thrown into the O’Brien family head-first.

What better way to become part of the O’Brien family than to become part of our crazy obsession with Christmas?

Simply put, Secret Santa matters. It’s not about the present you get, it’s about the family you embrace. It brings us together and forces us to learn about each other and think about each other. It forces us to show up on Christmas Day. And it’s a tradition. And for me, Christmas wouldn’t be Christmas without Secret Santa.

Contact Elizabeth Greason at egreason@nd.edu The views expressed in the Inside Column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer.

With the advent of social media, political activism has been intimately tied to a keyboard.

Today, radical ideas displayed upon laptop screens are the most prominent and popular mode of initiating social change. Although venues such as Facebook and Instagram have changed the face of modern society, has it effectively changed the political sphere in which we currently live? Within primary school, it was not uncommon to learn about the flavors of protesting. Whether discussing Civil Rights Era sit-ins or Vietnam War draft card burnings, the millennial generation has obtained an intimate understanding of the power of political activism. Because of this, it is not uncommon to hear commentary from elder generations in regards to the lack of substantial political involvement that has existed since the turn of the 21st century.

However, it is clear to see that the face of our generation may be reverting back to the protests of the days of our grandparents. So have we gotten the message?

In regards to the forms of social media political involvement that have become relatively commonplace, the UN coined the term “slacktivism,” explained thus: “This term combines the words slacker and activism and posits that people who support a cause by performing simple measures are not truly engaged or devoted to making a change.” The greatest difference between slacktivism and 1960s protests are not necessarily the venues through which ideas are conveyed, but rather is the underlying commitment to physical presence.

Slacktivism is satisfying in that it fills the need of young, idealistic people to feel that they are working towards a better world and affecting change without requiring those involved to risk much. In signing petitions, sharing statuses and reposting articles, we signal that we care — and we often actually do — without having to back that commitment with any real sacrifice. We can support various causes, ranging from animal rights to racial justice to environmental concerns all from the comfort of our couches, and often we get the added social benefit of showing others that we care publicly.

Even when we have gotten up to protest, we have stood on college campuses, which often revel in productive student demonstrations.

However, the risk of consequences for these

actions are relatively small, but the media follows and reposts, lending to the feeling that there is a real contribution and change being made. However, the negligible amount of personal sacrifice that millennials are willing to take on also takes away from the effectiveness of activism and protests. Physical presence while protesting is an American tradition, and for a while it seemed as though our generation was relatively characterized by an air of abstinence … until now.

A modern example of this currently exists within the North Dakota Standing Rock reservation. The Lakota, Nakota, and Dakota Native Americans are protesting the North Dakota Access Pipeline. This conflict between indigenous peoples and the United States government is characterized by a mixture of land, environmental and Native American rights. Whether or not one is in favor of the pipeline, one must acknowledge the risk those are taking by using their physical presence at the site of protest.

Because of this, there is legitimized hope in that the political system will respond to the pleas of the protesters.

Well done, committed social movements create change. People see that there is a strong and deeply considered dedication to an issue, which leads them to seek understanding or reexamine their existing views. This is not a call to get out there and protest everyday because that would be the same kind of scattered commitment that exists online. However, when an issue emerges that is profound and that strikes someone as requiring change, when there is a real conviction that the law is not supporting the promises of the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution or a commitment to human rights, it is valuable to put some skin in the game. Demonstrating a deep belief in an issue and real commitment both creates a stronger and more honest dialogue and contributes positively to our political life in a way that paying lip service to an issue or engaging in a brief, emotional protest cannot.

BridgeND is a bipartisan student organization that brings students from across the political spectrum together in discussions concerning public policy issues. The viewpoints expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of BridgeND, but are the individual opinions of the authors. Contact BridgeND at bridgend@nd.edu or follow them on Twitter at @bridge_ND The views expressed in this column are those of the authors and not necessarily those of The Observer.

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

7

Save the brain cells Erin Thomassen The Examined Life

Breaking news: millions of brain cells have been murdered this past football season at the University of Notre Dame. At the final home game, the serial killer known as the Depressant struck for the sixth time this year, killing thousands of unsuspecting civilian brain cells.

As shown by its track record, the Depressant does not abide by just war theory. Both happy and sad memories are subject to suppression, as well as newly encoded information such as the names of roommates’ parents.

The highest density of killings was in the Joyce Center Lot and at Innovation Park. Investigators were called in to sweep the crime scene. Confronted with conflicting evidence about the identity of the killer, investigators hypothesize that the Depressant may be a drug lord with many underlings. They identified a series of suspect bottles and cans, which have been carted to the recycling facility for further inspection.

These mass killings have had highly destabilizing effects on brain cell survivors, especially in highly connected brain centers, typical at an academic hub like Notre Dame.

“I consolidate in fear,” a short-term memory neuron residing in the hippocampus reported. “I have been attempting to push all my knowledge through systems consolidation. If systems consolidation completes, other lobes will house the important information I store, so no knowledge will be lost if I am in the next round of Depressant victims.”

Other neurons hope to save themselves through resistance. Those in the tolerance center have spearheaded blockades to defend themselves against high Depressant dosages. They hope that these measures would result in a smaller death toll from the same

Depressant dose.

Neurons in dopamine receptors, on the other hand, see no issue with the killings. They rejoice when the inhibiting neurons are killed off. “More depressant means less rules. The entire brain enters a state of chaos. Fun is had by all.”

Older neurons do not agree with this logic. They are wary of organizing resistance, though, and have resigned themselves to probable slaughter. That doesn’t prevent them from voicing their complaints.

“Overseas,” an elderly neural housed in the temporal center recalls, “brain cells are not subject to total war.” Rather than one or two slaughters on the weekends, European brain cells experience more regular and moderate challenges.

“A glass of wine with dinner, we can handle that,” the frontal lobe control executive predicts. One of these glasses actually provides benefits to other regions of the body, as reported by the central nervous system.

“A funneled six-pack,” she counters, “increases fat cell count and unleashes biological and chemical warfare on the motor control, decision-making and memory consolidation centers of the brain.” It is also seldom consumed with commensurate solid calories, meaning the city centers are given few resources with which to withstand the attacks.

Far left-brain and right-brain cells are calling for civil war, blaming the aforequoted control executive of the frontal lobe for failing to prevent and even masterminding the Depressant attack. “I don’t understand how she has gotten off scot-free,” a parietal neuron remarks. “She is in charge of decision-making, and thus is the one choosing to imbibe, subjecting our citizens to the dangers of the Depressant.”

The control executive shifts the blame to the mirror neurons. She claims that their influence is so strong that she cannot possibly counter their automatic imitation of the behavior the subject encounters on game day. “As subjects cannot help yawning when they see

others yawn, they cannot help downing the Depressant when they see others doing so.”

The mirror neurons protest that their function is to send signals to the subject to imitate perceived behavior. Subjects only yields to these commands if their executive control center is too weak to form their own decisions. Furthermore, the consequence-assessment center is suppressed after the Depressant has infiltrated the system, preventing the subjects from reevaluating the possible harmful outcomes of their decisions.

The control executive finally proposed a plan to avoid future Depressant invasions. Frontal planning neurons will quantify maximum Depressant thresholds. If the subject nears these thresholds, warning signals will be sent to the control center to prevent further Depressant consumption.

Additionally, confidence neurons in the speechproduction areas will be bolstered to help subjects realize that they are capable to extended small talk with visiting parents without assistance provided by the Depressant.

Finally, neurons in elder, graduated subjects who may wish to relive past glories through Depressant consumption will go through further educative training to understand the damage done to their brain by the Depressant.

“Concussions are getting all the press these days,” the control executive laments. Thankfully brain cells are becoming aware of the dangers posed by the Depressant. It remains to be seen whether subjects will act in accordance with her recommendations to save the brain cells.

Ms. Thomassen is a senior studying mechanical engineering. She lives at the Château off campus, with four friends and more crêpes. She can be reached at ethomass@nd.edu The views expressed in this column are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer.

LETTER TO THE EDITOR

I am not a victim On Election Night, I was amazed when I gradually saw states turning red on my television screen.

Granted, if I were able to switch out then-presidential nominee Donald J. Trump for Sen. Marco Rubio or Sen. Ted Cruz, I would have. Nevertheless, given the outcome of the primary elections, I had accepted and supported our presidential nominee.

Once Pennsylvania was called and Clinton had conceded, I was overwhelmed. Americans made their voices heard through the ballots and proved that they were also ready for a change. To say that this made me proud of our constitutional republic would be an understatement.

However, to my surprise, on Wednesday morning my mailbox was f looded with emails regarding classes being cancelled, safety pins being given out, immediate prayer services taking place and services on campus offering their “safe spaces.”

The emails I received from the administration insinuating that Trump’s victory proves a threat to my existence as a minority and a woman is ridiculous. It seems as though I am objectively viewed as a victim of an election that ultimately placed a “white male” in the Oval Office.

As a Hispanic, Republican woman from the San Francisco Bay Area who was raised in a family that overwhelmingly votes Democrat, hearing opposing political views is nothing new. However, being called a “fake Mexican,” a “disgrace,” and being told that “my heart is full of hate” through social media and in person has been astonishing.

The amount of times I have been told my “white privilege is showing” is comical to say the least.

Trump supporters have been called racists, but the ultimate form of prejudice is when it’s expected and assumed that all women, or even all Hispanics, must have identical ballots. We all have our reasons why we voted the way we did, and to assume that

someone voted red because they are chauvinistic, hateful individuals is nothing short of a selfrighteous disposition. To say you voted for Hillary because you “stand against hate” yet continue to act hatefully and judgmentally toward people who voted for Trump is hypocritical at best.

To provide “safe spaces” and handout safety pins is in no way preparing anyone for the real world.

When I am working at my first job, post college, it would be a stretch to assume they have safe spaces available to protect my feelings. I understand how polarizing this election has been, but to act as if Trump’s election is the end of the world seems outrageous. Claiming someone is “extremely privileged” because his or her personal choices are different than yours is also a tad extreme.

The faculty and administration have not been shy in supporting the student protests, but do they also support the students who stand with the president-elect? Do they stand with them against the hate they have received? Personally, I have grown tired of this campus depicting those who lean right as horrendous individuals. Meanwhile, there are posters for undocumented students, female students, Muslim students, Black students, Hispanic students, minority students and LGBTQ+ students stating, “We accept you for who you are.”

I fail to fathom why white students have been left off of these posters and are ultimately seen as “the oppressors” on campus. I understand the call for diversity, and being a Mexican-Nicaraguan daughter of an immigrant, I have not been blind to it.

However, to portray me as a monster because I voted for a candidate who insists on a strict border policy and a stronger national defense to defeat the ideology of radical Islamic terrorism, a serious threat to this nation, is incredible.

While I have the utmost respect for professors

and the administration at this institution, it would be a lie to say political opinions were not made clear this past week. This is true not only within the tri-campus community, but at college campuses around the country. Now more than ever, conservative college students have voiced concerns over their grades being jeopardized for expressing views contrary to those of their professors.

However, while I have witnessed this unfortunate circumstance occur to my peers, I have absolute faith in the integrity of Saint Mary’s College.

On Jan. 20, 2017, Donald J. Trump will be the next president of the United States of America. I understand the importance of open dialogue on college campuses, but ultimately masking your views in an academic setting to avoid offending the ideology of someone else is harmful to intellectual growth.

Consistently spewing hateful rhetoric towards people who hold opposing viewpoints and tastefully disagreeing are two different actions. While this is a time to unite as Americans and move forward in preparation for new leadership, it is also a time to stay true to beliefs.

To my fellow deplorables: Remember that you too have a voice, so do not back down. While it is important to listen and learn from those around you, it is also important to stand your ground. Reject the fatal concept of identity politics. Do not let the fear of being labeled a traitor, racist, sexist, homophobe or bigot diminish your ability to stand strong in your conservative beliefs. Keep showing up at the polls and let God handle the rest. As Alexander Hamilton once stated, “If you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything.”

Christina Herrara class of 2018 Nov. 17

8

DAILY

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

Crossword | Will Shortz

Horoscope | Eugenia Last Happy Birthday: It’s up to you to make the changes that will make you feel good about your future. This is a year to complete the changes you’ve been contemplating and put an end to the situations that have been slowing you down or adding confusion to your life. Look for professional opportunities that suit your skills and qualifications. Your numbers are 8, 10, 14, 27, 32, 41, 44.

ARIES (March 21-April 19): Express your thoughts and put some muscle behind your plans. You can get ahead if you focus on using your skills to your benefit instead of helping someone else advance. Conversations can reveal valuable information that will encourage a wise choice.

TAURUS (April 20-May 20): Watch how others react and prepare to counter any situation that shows instability. Don’t give in to anyone who tries to push you into something you cannot afford. Someone will offer false information about a deal you consider.

GEMINI (May 21-June 20): It’s up to you to bring about change if you don’t like the direction things are heading in your life. Don’t wait for someone else to make the first move. Take control and don’t look back. Good fortune and opportunity are within your reach.

CANCER (June 21-July 22): Keep moving forward regardless of what others decide to do. As long as you keep your plans simple and affordable, you will enjoy the outcome. A partnership will undergo difficulties if you cannot agree. Be willing to do the legwork.

LEO (July 23-Aug. 22): Travel to a destination that has something exciting or exotic to offer. Participate in a seminar or experience that will challenge you to use your talents in new and interesting ways. Important partnerships will develop.

VIRGO (Aug. 23-Sept. 22): A change at home may be useful if it keeps a dispute from developing. Getting to the bottom of things will take time and must be done properly if you are to come out on top. Offer incentives.

LIBRA (Sept. 23-Oct. 22): Channel your energy into activities and events that will allow you to stand out in the crowd. The response you get from someone who can change your life will give you a reason to expand your interests.

Follow your dreams.

SCORPIO (Oct. 23-Nov. 21): A professional change or dealing with institutions that can help you stabilize your financial future will pay off.

Use your strengths to help you gain ground and convince others to see the potential in your plans. Romance is featured.

SAGITTARIUS (Nov. 22-Dec. 21): Emotions will swell and excitement will mount. Discipline and control will be required if you want to take advantage of something that appears to be too good to be true. Step up and take action and you will succeed.

CAPRICORN (Dec. 22-Jan. 19): Someone with lofty ideas will try to persuade you to be a follower. Don’t feel intimidated by a pushy individual when you have what it takes to offer something far more substantial. Do your own thing and forge ahead.

AQUARIUS (Jan. 20-Feb. 18): Take your time and do your best. Negotiate on your own behalf and turn something you enjoy doing into a fruitful venture.

Helping others will bring high rewards. Someone from your past will make a difference to your future.

PISCES (Feb. 19-March 20): You’ll lose out if you let someone take over. Do whatever you do best and get involved in the issues that concern you the most. An honest evaluation of the relationships you have with others will lead to needed changes.

Birthday Baby: You are bold, enthusiastic and playful. You are strategic and intelligent.

JUST ADD WATER | JOHN Roddy & ERic carlson

Sudoku | The Mepham Group

Jumble | David Hoyt and Jeff knurek

Draw comics.

Email Margaret at mhynds@nd.edu

Work Area

Make checks payable to and mail to: The Observer P.O. Box 779 Notre Dame, IN 46556

Published Monday through Friday, The Observer is a vital source of information on people and events in the Notre Dame and Saint Mary’s Community.

Join the more than 13,000 readers who have found The Observer an indispensable link to the two campuses. Please complete the accompanying form and mail it today to receive The Observer in your home.

Enclosed is $130 for one academic year Enclosed is $75 for one semester Name Address City State Zip

Classifieds

ndsmcobserver.com | thursday, december 1, 2016 | The Observer

Sports Authority

9

nba | pistons 121, Celtics 114

Playoff committee Caldwell-Pope tallies 25 in will be tested Pistons’ win over Celtics Michael Ivey Sports Writer

We are currently in the third year of the relatively new four-team College Football Playoff format. The first two years of the format, there was little controversy in deciding who the four teams to participate in the playoff would be. That will all change this year.

Two teams already seem set: Alabama and Clemson.

If those two teams win their conference’s championship game on Saturday, they will be set to make a return trip to the playoff. That leaves two spots up for grabs, and this is where things get complicated.

The Big Ten has surprisingly been one of the strongest conferences in the country this season. The best team in the Big Ten appears to be Ohio State, who just beat arch-rival Michigan in a 30-27, double-overtime thriller. You would assume the Buckeyes would be one of the teams playing Saturday for their conference’s championship.

But they aren’t.

Instead, that distinction belongs to Penn State, who beat Ohio State earlier this season — the only loss of the season for the Buckeyes.

Penn State only suffered one conference loss on the season to Michigan, who just suffered their second conference loss of the year to the Buckeyes. Because Ohio State’s conference loss was to Penn State, Penn State won the division the two teams are in and will be playing in the Big Ten championship Saturday night against Wisconsin, who won its division in the conference.

As the Playoff selection committee has indicated during its first two seasons in existence, conference championships matter for a team’s resume. All eight teams that have made it into the first two college football playoffs were their conference’s champion. The only controversy surrounding selection into the playoff happened two years ago, when the committee had to decide whether to give Ohio State, Baylor or TCU the final playoff spot. The committee ultimately choose Ohio State, who won their conference championship outright by beating Wisconsin 59-0 in the Big Ten championship that year. The conference Baylor and TCU are in, the Big 12, doesn’t have

a conference title game, so they were declared conference co-champions.

By making the decision to put Ohio State in that season’s playoff — which proved to be the right decision, as Ohio State went on to win the national championship — the committee sent the message that this is how they will determine who gets in when it comes to making tough decisions between similarly accomplished teams.

W hat makes this year’s situation so complicated is that Penn State has two losses to Ohio State’s one, but Penn State is the team with the chance to win the conference championship.

This raises the possibility that a two-loss Penn State or two-loss Wisconsin would be chosen for the playoff over a one-loss Ohio State, or the reverse — Ohio State is chosen over Wisconsin or Penn State despite losing to Penn State and not winning its conference’s championship.

If the committee makes the former decision, it will raise outcries that a superior team was left out of the playoff due to a technicality.

If the committee makes the latter decision, it will destroy the criteria it previously established to determine who gets in over who during its short three years of existence.

Further complicating the situation is one-loss Washington, who also sits right at the edge of a playoff berth and will compete in the Pac-12 championship Friday. Despite their one loss, the Huskies do not have a spot guaranteed even with a win Friday, at least according to many college football experts. They could be left out to fit Ohio State, Alabama, Clemson and the future Big Ten conference champion.

If Alabama, Clemson and Washington all win this weekend, the selection committee is going to have quite a predicament on its hands.

W hatever happens, this is the committee’s first real test. This weekend could provide us with an insight into the basis of how the committee is going to decide who gets into the College Football Playoff for years to come.

Associated Press

BOSTON — Kentavious Caldwell-Pope scored 25 points and Tobias Harris had 21 to lead balanced scoring that carried the Detroit Pistons to a 121-114 win over the Boston Celtics on Wednesday night.

Andre Drummond added 20 points and 17 rebounds, one night after he was ejected in the second quarter of a victory at Charlotte for a flagrant-2 foul.

Isaiah Thomas paced the Celtics with 27 points, and Kelly Olynyk scored a seasonhigh 19. Boston had won five of seven.

Marcus Morris had 20 points and Ish Smith 19 for

the Pistons, who had lost eight of their first nine road games before winning away from home on consecutive nights.

Detroit used a 9-0 spree midway through the fourth quarter to open a 103-95 edge with 5:08 to play after Boston went on an 11-0 run to take its first lead since early in the opening period. Morris and Harris each hit a 3-pointer during the Pistons’ spurt.

Detroit pushed its lead to 112-101 on Smith’s basket before Boston closed within four points in the final 30 seconds.

The Pistons were shooting over 55 percent midway through the third quarter and opened their biggest lead of the game, 90-80, on Jon

Leuer’s dunk.

Boston center Al Horford returned after missing Monday’s win at Miami due to the birth of his second child. He scored nine points.

Pistons: Coach Stan Van Gundy said G Reggie Bullock hasn’t gotten an appointment yet for a second opinion on the torn meniscus in his left knee.

Celtics: Coach Brad Stevens said there was no longer a limit on F Jae Crowder’s minutes in his sixth game back from a sprained left ankle. There was a limit when Crowder first returned. . G Marcus Smart went down to the floor hard early in the fourth, but walked slowly to the bench during a stoppage.

nba | KNICKS 106, TIMBERWOLVES 104

Porzingis scores 29 to defeat the Timberwolves Associated Press

MINNEAPOLIS — Kristaps Porzingis had 29 points and eight rebounds in a thrilling duel with Karl-Anthony Towns, helping the New York Knicks beat the Minnesota Timberwolves 106-104 on Wednesday night.

Carmelo Anthony capped a quiet night with a game-winning 18-footer over Andrew Wiggins with 2.3 seconds to play, helping the Knicks avoid what would have been an epic collapse in the fourth quarter.

Towns had a career-high 47 points and 18 rebounds for the Wolves, who tied the game in the final minute after trailing by 17 with 7:30 to play.

But Porzingis threw Gorgui Dieng aside for a putback slam and Anthony tipped the inbounds pass on Minnesota’s final possession to thwart the comeback.

Brandon Jennings scored 12 points off the bench and Porzingis had a big block against his friend and draft classmate Towns to help the Knicks weather the loss of Joakim Noah, who sat out with a sprained left ankle.

New York made 13 3-pointers to Minnesota’s four.

After the Timberwolves lost to Utah on Monday, a despondent Towns vowed to do more to help his team win. He came out a man on fire, scoring 22 points on 8-for-8 shooting and grabbing seven rebounds in the first quarter.

Porzingis held his own, banking in jumpers and swatting shots left and right. The two young stars rarely guarded each other, but Towns did go at Porzingis late in the second quarter, rising up to try to dunk on him only to have the Latvian emphatically stuff him for Towns’ first missed shot in 11 attempts.

Porzingis made 11 of 20 shots and three 3-pointers, scoring 10 in the fourth to hold off Towns and the Wolves.

Knicks: Anthony had 14 points on 5-for-16 shooting. ... SG Courtney Lee only played eight minutes because of a sprained left ankle. ...

Coach Jeff Hornacek said F Lance Thomas, who has not played yet because of a sore left ankle, had a good workout during shootaround and will practice on Friday in the hopes of playing in the next game or two.

Timberwolves: Wiggins had

19 points, seven rebounds and four assists. ... Towns’ 22 points in the first quarter were two off of Chauncey Billups’ franchise record of 24. ... G/F Brandon Rush was inactive with a sore big toe that has bothered him for much of the season.

The Bulls made the playoffs all five seasons with coach Tom Thibodeau leading Derrick Rose and Noah.

Rose and Noah were two players Thibodeau, now with Minnesota, deeply respected for their competitive drive and determination.

“You don’t realize what you have with him until he’s not around,” Noah said. “He used to tell me that when I played for him because we used to butt heads all the time. He’s definitely one of the tops in the business.”

Sacramento mayor and former NBA star Kevin Johnson met with Wolves owner Glen Taylor before the game.

Taylor also is a part-owner of the Minnesota United soccer team that will debut in the MLS in 2017. Johnson sat with United’s primary owner Bill McGuire as he continues investigating bringing an MLS team to Sacramento.

The Observer accepts classifieds every business day from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. at the Notre Dame office, 024 South Dining Hall. Deadline for next-day classifieds is 3 p.m. All classifieds must be prepaid. The charge is 5 cents per character per day, including all spaces. The Observer reserves the right to edit all classifieds for content without issuing refunds.

Contact Michael Ivey at mivey@hcc-nd.edu.

The views expressed in this Sports Authority are those of the author and not necessarily those of The Observer.

For Rent EDDY COMMONS CONDO — 2BR 2BA $1799 MO SUSAN (954) 665-4075

“This is my winter song to you,/The storm is coming soon,/It rose in from the sea,/My voice, a beacon in the night,/ My words will be your light,/To carry you to me./Is love a lie?/Is love alive?/Is

love a lie?/Is love.../They say that things just cannot grow,/Beneath the winter snow,/Or so I have been told./They say we’re buried far,/Just like a distant star,/I simply cannot hold.”-Leslie Odom Jr.

10

Sports

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

Hockey Continued from page 12

larger rink size opens up room in the offensive zone for what has been an inconsistent Notre Dame attack this season, it also poses its share of challenges offensively.

“Just my experience of having been in international hockey for all those years is that there’s so much room out there, you get lost,” Jackson said.

Jackson also said the team has emphasized getting inside the face-off dots in recent weeks, but on the larger ice surface he believes that will be especially important.

“If you play outside the dots too much, you’re not going to generate a lot of offense,” Jackson said. “You have to offensively still have to try to play inside the dots. And defensively, you can’t get stretched out outside the dots.”

Defending on the big ice also takes an added amount of discipline because offenses have an easier time controlling the puck in the zone, and Jackson said maintaining a presence inside the dots will also be crucial in front of Irish junior netminder Cal Petersen.

“Our defense is fairly mobile, so as long as they don’t get trapped [outside the dots] stepping up on people or getting caught outside the dot with a couple forwards,” Jackson said. “ … We have a rule that you’re not supposed to have more than one guy outside the dots defensively. And that happens occasionally when forwards are back checking, but the defense has to read it and back off more towards the middle.”

Petersen has played well statistically in net for the Irish this season, posting a 2.25 goals against average and a .917 save percentage, but Jackson said the team’s captain still hasn’t reached top form this season.

“I don’t think he’s given us his best games yet,” Jackson said.

“He’s had a few really good games for us, but I think there’s more there. We’ve seen it in the past.”

Jackson added that the team has hung Petersen out to dry far too often this season.

“We’ve put him in some very awkward situations,” Jackson said. “When we make a breakdown, we make a good one where they’re getting a really good scoring chance. Not like every once in a while, we’ll give up an occasional breakaway or 2-on-1, but we give up doozies. We’ve given up some 2-on-0s where our defense will get trapped or just make a bad play, and all of a sudden they’re getting a great scoring chance.”

The Minutemen were dismal last season, finishing 8-24-4 overall and just 2-16-4 in Hockey East play, while losing 22 of their final 24 games. Notre Dame accounted for two of those losses, as the Irish were victorious 3-1 and 5-1 in a series sweep at Compton Family Ice Arena.

Jackson said while the team’s record this year doesn’t reflect it, UMass has already shown improvement under first-year head coach Greg Carvel.

“Greg Carvel is a really good coach, and they play a pretty much North American-style, NHLstyle game there on the Olympic sheet,” Jackson said. “We had our hands full with them last year, and they’re always a competitive team. “ … They had a tough finish last year, and I think they’ve rebounded to get off to a reasonably decent start this year. They’re competitive in every game; they’re not winning every game, but they’re not getting beat badly every game.

That’s for sure.”

The Irish square off with the Minutemen in Amherst, Massachusetts, on Friday night at 6:05 p.m. while the opening faceoff Saturday evening is at 7:05 p.m.

Contact Zach Klonsinski at zklonsin@nd.edu

ANN CURTIS | The Observer

Junior goaltender Cal Petersen stares down a loose puck during a 4-1 Irish win over UMass Lowell on Nov. 18 at Compton Family Ice Arena.

MICHAEL YU | The Observer

Irish sophomore forward Andrew Oglevie controls the puck alongside junior forward Connor Hurley during Notre Dame’s 3-3 overtime tie against Penn State on Oct. 21 at Compton Family Ice Arena.

Oglevie Continued from page 12

Bjork. Oglevie himself credited a lot of this improvement and success to his offseason work as well as the support of his coaches and teammates.

“I got a lot stronger over the offseason,” Oglevie said. “Other than that, it’s just been working on the little things, and I have to give a lot of credit to my linemates and coaches trusting me, putting me in more positions to make plays with being on the power play and penalty kill. It’s this along with my linemates helping me out and hard work over the offseason.”

Oglevie especially credits the talk he had with head coach Jeff Jackson over the offseason, which helped him to understand why building up strength was so important in his development.

“He talked to me before the season and told me he wanted me to play on the inside more because I was more of a perimeter player

last year,” Oglevie said. “I don’t think that was me necessarily wanting to be a perimeter player.

I think it was just harder for me to get on this inside and play in those gritty areas of the ice.

“Now, it’s easier for me to get to the front of the net and win puck battles and stuff like that with the added strength. It makes me want to go to the net more, knowing I can do it, so I think it was big, just building that confidence and getting me that extra strength to propel me into those areas.”

The improvement in the sophomore’s play has not gone unnoticed by Jackson, who credits a lot of Oglevie’s improvement and rapid development to his newfound confidence.

“I think the biggest thing is confidence. His strength has improved, which helps build confidence, and he got off to a good start, which gave him even more confidence,” Jackson said. “We always knew he had some playmaking ability, and we’ve tried to encourage him to play inside the Paid Advertisement

dots a little more, and I think because of his additional strength, he’s been able to do that.”

Looking forward to the rest of the season, Oglevie will look to continue his hot start, and that starts this weekend with a matchup against fellow a Hockey East program, UMass. He said he realizes the team will need to be focused in against the Minutemen, and that starts with his work on the power play.

“Coach has been stressing that we need to get the power play going again because we’ve been kind of lacking the last few games,” Oglevie said. “I’d say as a power play goal, we want to make sure to get on the board this weekend and have some success there, and obviously as a team goal, we want to go out there and try to get two wins and come back here to focus on [Boston College] so we can go have a good Christmas break.”

Contact Alex Bender at abender@nd.edu

Sports

ndsmcobserver.com | thursday, december 1, 2016 | The Observer

Please recycle The Observer.

Paid Advertisement

W Bball Continued from page 12

Disterhoft and sophomore for ward Megan Gustafson — who were the only Hawkeyes in double figures with 18 and 16 points, respectively — led the comeback effort.

McGraw particularly praised the play of Gustafson, who also grabbed 11 rebounds in the game.

“I thought that Megan Gustafson was phenomenal. She really played well,” McGraw said. “She had a great game — a double-double — [and] really hurt us.

We didn’t have an answer for her. Tried trapping her in the first half, got a couple of turnovers but overall, she was really a tougher matchup than I expected.”

But the stretch had just as much to do with the Notre Dame’s poor play as it did Iowa’s resiliency, McGraw added.

“Pretty much ever ything [went wrong],” she said. “I don’t think we were doing anything well. We weren’t containing the ball, we weren’t guarding, and we weren’t boxing out. We weren’t making lay ups, we weren’t making good decisions — we just couldn’t wait for the buzzer to go off. We just wanted the game to be over. At least, that’s what it looked like.”

From that 2:37 mark in the third on, however, the Irish

11

regained control of the contest and ended it on a 23-10 run to bring the game to its 73-58 final.

Junior for ward Brianna Turner led the Irish offensively in the game with 15 points. The Irish made it a point at various times throughout the game to get the ball inside and give Turner scoring chances, but McGraw said she felt her team still has to learn to take advantage of all the opportunities to score inside, especially when teams have been playing Turner more physical as of late.

“I think we had a little more team speed,” McGraw said.

“We do like to drive the ball, and we were tr ying to drive it a little bit more. I thought we shot too many 3s today, and tr ying to throw the ball inside — I thought [Turner] was open, [senior for ward Kristina Nelson] was open.

We’re just not good at looking in right now.”

Now off to a 7-0 start, Notre Dame will have a few days off before taking on Valparaiso on Sunday at Purcell Pavilion. The following game next Wednesday, however, will mark the biggest game of the season so far for the topranked Irish when they host No. 2 Connecticut.

Notre Dame and Valparaiso tip-off at 1 p.m. Sunday at Purcell Pavilion.

Contact Ben Padanilam at bpadanil@nd.edu

Paid Advertisement

ANNA MASON | The Observer

Sophomore guard Marina Mabrey squares up for a shot during Notre Dame’s 67-36 victory over Fordham on Nov. 14 at Purcell Pavilion.

12

The observer | thursday, december 1, 2016 | ndsmcobserver.com

ND WOMEN’s BASKETBALL | ND 73, IOWA 58

Irish start, finish strong in win over Hawkeyes

By BEN PADANILAM Associate Sports Editor

No. 1 Notre Dame overcame poor second and third quarters to top Iowa, 73-58, in its ACC/Big Ten Challenge game Wednesday night in Iowa Cit y, Iowa.

From the 1:52 mark in the first quarter to the 2:37 mark of the third quarter, the Hawkeyes (5-3) outscored the Irish, 39-27, and turned a 14-point Notre Dame lead into a two-point margin.

However, the Irish (7-0) used a strong start and finish to propel themselves to v ictor y, despite what Irish head coach Muffet McGraw described as an unsatisfactor y performance.

“I thought that we looked really sluggish,” McGraw said. “We were kind of going through the motions. We got out to a little bit of an early lead, and I think we just rela xed. I didn’t think we brought our intensit y on defense — lot of fundamental mistakes. … We didn’t play as I wanted to, but I felt we

did enough good things at the end to w in the game.”

The opening and closing quarters would prove to be critical for the Irish in the w inning effort. Notre Dame was in control of the game early, starting the contest on a 21-7 run and ending the first quarter leading 23-15.

Its defense forced nine Iowa turnovers in the period, and sophomore guard Marina Mabrey led the offensive effort, scoring all nine of her points in the period. Irish head coach Muffet McGraw credited the defensive effort for propelling the team to its early lead.

“Defense — I mean we got turnovers right off the bat,” McGraw said. “ … They were just a little off, maybe, to start the game, and I thought, defensively, we were better.”

However, the Hawkeyes fought their way back into the game during the middle stretch of play, as Iowa’s duo of senior guard A lly see ND WBBALL PAGE 11

ANNA MASON | The Observer

Junior forward Brianna Turner extends for a layup during Notre Dame’s 67-36 victory over Fordham on Nov. 14 at Purcell Pavilion. Turner is averaging 13.3 points while shooting 57.9 percent from the field.

HOCKEY

Oglevie, Notre Dame set to take on UMass Irish to face Minutemen on Olympic-sized rink

Oglevie emerges as offensive threat in his second season

By ZACH KLONSINSKI

By ALEX BENDER

Assistant Managing Editor

Sports Writer

No. 12 Notre Dame resumes Hockey East play this weekend with a series against Massachusetts on the Olympicsized ice at Mullins Center.

Instead of the usual NHLsized rink that’s 85 feet wide, Olympic-sized ice sheets add another 15 feet in width. Notre Dame’s Compton Family Ice Arena has two sheets of ice: Lefty Smith Rink, the main ice sheet for the Irish (7-5-2, 3-21 Hockey East), is NHL-sized, while an Olympic sheet lies adjacent to the main arena specifically for weeks when Notre Dame prepares for teams like the Minutemen (3-7-2, 1-5-1). “[The larger ice surface] is a factor, and that’s why we’re fortunate we can practice on an Olympic ice sheet this week,” Irish head coach Jeff Jackson said during media availability Wednesday afternoon.

Jackson added that while the

In a season in which the offensive output hasn’t quite been where No. 12 Notre Dame would like it to be, sophomore forward Andrew Oglevie has held up his end in what has been a year of rapid development for the young talent.

A Fullerton, California, native, Oglevie has made seen a quick ascension to being one of Notre Dame’s best offensive weapons as he continues to put together an impressive resume early on in his collegiate career.

As a freshman, Oglevie played in 31 games during which he scored five goals — including two game winners — and added four assists for a total of nine points. In just 14 games this season, he has already blown past last year’s total for six goals along with nine assists. His mark of 14 points good enough for second on the team so far, trailing only fellow forward and junior Anders

see HOCKEY PAGE 10

MACKENZI MARINOVICH | The Observer

Irish sophomore forward Andrew Oglevie surveys the ice during Notre Dame’s 4-2 loss to UConn on Oct. 27 at Compton Family Ice Arena. Oglevie is second on the team in points with 15.

see OGLEVIE PAGE 10