presents...
2010 ELECTION GUIDE Compiled by Scott Girard and Ariel Shapiro
Two Milwaukee executives fight for the Governorship Scott Walker, R • Milwaukee County Executive since 2002 • Plans to repeal corporate income tax and eliminate red tape regulations, which he says drive corporations away from Wisconsin, and eliminate wasteful government spending • He said he plans for the UW System to run more like a businesses and give it more autonomy from the state, similar to what Chancellor Biddy Martin proposed • He is anti-abortion and supports only adult stem cell research • Previously denounced Arizona’s controversial immigration bill, and has since changed his position
Tom Barrett, D • Milwaukee Mayor since 2004 • Published a job creation plan including targeted tax cuts to small businesses and funding of infrastructure projects • He said education is important, but that the state budget deficit is too large to maintain current level of funding • Barrett is pro-choice and supports both adult and embryonic stem cell research • Supports clean energy jobs and the state’s goal of running 25 percent of Wisconsin’s energy use on alternative sources
Newcomer challenges three-term incumbent for his seat in the U.S. Senate Ron Johnson, R • Oshkosh plastics manufacturer • Says his business experience will be an asset in fixing the economy • Strongly disagrees with the healthcare bill passed earlier this year and plans to repeal it if elected • Says he would defer to President Obama on foreign policy issues • Wants to cut government spending and extend the Bush tax cuts • He is anti-abortion and against samesex marriage
Russ Feingold, D • U.S. Senator since 1992 • Supports the health care bill passed earlier this year • Only senator to vote against the Patriot Act • Supports a timeline for getting troops out of Afghanistan, and said the threat from Al-Qaeda is a global one that cannot be solved by ground troops • Helped write the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 with Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) • Supports same-sex marriage
Graphics by Natasha Soglin and Dylan Moriarty/the daily cardinal
Republican faces veteran Democrat in traditionally liberal 2nd Congressional District
Chad Lee, R • Mount Horeb businessman • Against government spending and plans to bring fiscal responsibility to the House of Representatives if elected • Would like to lower taxes on all citizens • Supports immigration reform, saying the law passed in Arizona this year is a step in the right direction • Would like to implement term limits for representatives, so they do not lose touch with citizens
Tammy Baldwin, D • U.S. Congresswoman since 1999 • Strong supporter of health-care bill passed earlier this year • Supports unlimited federal funding for all types of stem-cell research, believing it will bring important medical advances • Wants to raise the minimum wage • Supports reforming state tax laws that affect Wisconsin small businesses and farms • Pro-choice and supportive of same sex marriage • Wants to redeploy troops out of Iraq election guide page 2
“…the great state University of Wisconsin should ever encourage that continual and fearless sifting and winnowing by which alone the truth can be found.”
page two 2 • Tuesday, November 2, 2010
An independent student newspaper, serving the University of Wisconsin-Madison community since 1892 Volume 120, Issue 45
2142 Vilas Communication Hall 821 University Avenue Madison, Wis., 53706-1497 (608) 262-8000 • fax (608) 262-8100
News and Editorial edit@dailycardinal.com Editor in Chief Emma Roller Managing Editor Todd Stevens Campus Editor Kayla Johnson City Editor Maggie DeGroot State Editor Ariel Shapiro Enterprise Editor Alison Dirr Associate News Editor Beth Pickhard Opinion Editors Dan Tollefson Samantha Witthuhn Editorial Board Chair Hannah Furfaro Arts Editors Jacqueline O’Reilly Jon Mitchell Sports Editors Mark Bennett Parker Gabriel Page Two Editor Victoria Statz Life & Style Editor Stephanie Rywak Features Editor Madeline Anderson Photo Editors Danny Marchewka Ben Pierson Graphics Editors Caitlin Kirihara Natasha Soglin Multimedia Editors Eddy Cevilla Briana Nava Page Designers Claire Silverstein Joy Shin Copy Chiefs Anna Jeon Margaret Raimann Nico Savidge Kyle Sparks Copy Editors Hannah Giese, Jake Pearce, Jackie Pecquex, Rachel Sossaman, Duwayne Sparks, Paige Veach, Julia Welytok
Business and Advertising business@dailycardinal.com Business Manager Cole Wenzel Advertising Manager Mara Greenwald Accounts Receivable Manager Michael Cronin Billing Manager Lizzie Breckenfelder Senior Account Executive Taylor Grubbs Account Executive Alyssa Flemmer Dan Kaplan Rick Maturo Nick Bruno Carly Ettinger Matt Jablon Graphic Designer Jaime Flynn Web Director Eric Harris Marketing Director Erica Rykal Public Relations Manager Becky Tucci Events Manager Bill Clifford Art Director Jaime Flynn Copywriters Dustin Bui Bob Sixsmith The Daily Cardinal is a nonprofit organization run by its staff members and elected editors. It receives no funds from the university. Operating revenue is generated from advertising and subscription sales. The Daily Cardinal is published weekdays and distributed at the University of Wisconsin-Madison and its surrounding community with a circulation of 10,000. Capital Newspapers, Inc. is the Cardinal’s printer. The Daily Cardinal is printed on recycled paper. The Cardinal is a member of the Associated Collegiate Press and the Wisconsin Newspaper Association. All copy, photographs and graphics appearing in The Daily Cardinal are the sole property of the Cardinal and may not be reproduced without written permission of the editor in chief. The Daily Cardinal accepts advertising representing a wide range of views. This acceptance does not imply agreement with the views expressed. The Cardinal reserves the right to reject advertisements judged offensive based on imagery, wording or both. Complaints: News and editorial complaints should be presented to the editor in chief. Business and advertising complaints should be presented to the business manager. Letters Policy: Letters must be word processed and must include contact information. No anonymous letters will be printed. All letters to the editor will be printed at the discretion of The Daily Cardinal. Letters may be sent to opinion@ dailycardinal.com.
Editorial Board Hannah Furfaro • Miles Kellerman Emma Roller • Nico Savidge S. Todd Stevens • Dan Tollefson Samantha Witthuhn
Board of Directors Jason Stein, President Emma Roller • Cole Wenzel Samuel Todd Stevens • Mara Greenwald Vince Filak • Janet Larson Alex Kusters • Jenny Sereno Chris Drosner • Melissa Anderson Ron Luskin • Joan Herzing © 2010, The Daily Cardinal Media Corporation ISSN 0011-5398
For the record Correction: In Monday’s PAVE column, guest columnist Kristina Nailen’s name was misspelled. The Cardinal regrets the error.
tODAY: sunny hi 52º / lo 36º
wedneSDAY: chance of rain hi 54º / lo 36º dailycardinal.com/page-two
If classic Disney movies were re-made today... wondering how some of the classic movies would be different if they were made with today’s influence. What would be the result if Dora andrew Lahr the Explorer met Mowgli from the spare me the Jungle Book? lahrcasm “The Jungle Book”: I think e all know that times Mowgli’s a good place to start. have changed since the Due to the political-correctness early days of our child- of our society, there’s no way hood. No one wears glasses with in hell that the loincloth-sportlenses a half an inch thick, wind suits ing Mowgli would have existed with purple, blue and orange pat- and he most definitely would terns, and our president isn’t banging not have resided in a jungle. His Monica Lewinski (as far as we know). best friend, Baloo the bear (the Well, I was thinking about all of goofy “Bear Necessities” singer my favorite things to watch on the who totally made the movie), one tube-TV in the basement of my would be a polar bear and would old house and I realized that until be really sickly-looking, possibly the age of three or four, roughly 90 near death, due to the ravages of percent of my entertainment reper- global climate change. toire consisted of Disney movies. As “The Little Mermaid”: My anyone ages 18-21 knows, these God, I don’t even know where weren’t just any Disney movies, I’m to start. There’s no way in hell talking about THE Disney movies; Ariel would be a full ginger in this the ones between “Snow White” day and age—she’d be bleached and “The Lion King,” before David blonde all the way. Or maybe she Spade came in and raped the whole would be of hispanic descent? operation with “The Emperor’s Anyway, the plot would be cenNew Groove.” tered around a catastrophic oil Excluding the lack of sublimi- spill that ravages Ariel’s part of the nal messages about sex, I got to ocean, putting a stop to her aspi-
W
rations of becoming fully human. Instead, her outlook would shift away from Eric and her other finless friends, toward regarding them with hate and malice. The spill would probably kill Sebastian, the King and Ursula, leaving Ariel and Flounder on a life or death vendetta against humans and offshore drilling platforms.
With the way doctors dole out pills these days, the crazy baboon, Rafiki, would most likely be medicated for his insanity.
“Peter Pan”: Peter Pan lives forever with a large group of dudes his age. Let’s face it, everyone knows the pan-flute-playing friend of Tinkerbell is/was gay, so the only difference in his character would be that he came out of the closet in front of the Lost Boys a few weeks before meeting Wendy. Needless to say, the raid on Captain Hook and his pirates the
next day probably felt a little different for all of them. Wendy would be IMing/texting/Facebooking, “lolz omfg can you picture that? ROFL!” instead of sewing when Peter came rapping on her window. Tinkerbell was definitely a slut in the original and she would still be a slut, just computer animated and with much less clothing. “The Lion King”: With the way doctors dole out pills these days, the crazy baboon, Rafiki, would most likely be medicated for his insanity and poor Simba would never find out that he was the son of the king of the jungle. He would be forced to live with Timon and Pumba and eat bugs for the rest of his life. Thankfully, with the veterinary technology of today, Mufasa just may have survived that slowmotion fall off a cliff into a large stampede of wildebeest. Any other ideas pertaining to re-creating modern day Disney classics should be sent to Andrew at aplahr@wisc.edu, because he’s working on creating these plots in his basement using a pirated animation program.
news
election guide from page 1
Two liberals duke it out for the 77th Assembly District Brett Hulsey • Dane County Board Supervisor since 1998 • Advocates for environmental issues, including the creation of green jobs, the use of cleaner energies like biomass and solar, and the cleaning up of Madison’s lakes • Devised a UW Protection Plan which would call for increased investment in the university • Favors the DREAM Act and providing driving cards for illegal immigrants • Although he was initially endorsed by current district Rep. Spencer Black, Black said he is reconsidering his vote after Hulsey misquoted him in campaign literature
Ben Manski • Madison attorney and Green Party activist • Like Hulsey, Manski is a strong supporter of environmental causes. He advocates for clean energy, green jobs, and an extensive, low impact mass transportation system • He has been dedicated to student issues since he himself attended UW-Madison. He is proposing ultimately eliminating tuition by increasing taxes on the upper class • Wants to see all Wisconsin residents receive equal rights under state law, including illegal immigrants
GOP Attorney General’s position tested by Democrat promising bipartisanship J.B. Van Hollen • Attorney General since 2007 • Committed to fighting voter fraud • Takes a hard line against illegal immigrants involved in crime • Supports the right to bear arms •Declined to represent Wisconsin in challenges brought against the state’s laws on domestic partnerships and stem cell research • During his term, he worked to update the DNA database, but his office ended up misplacing thousands of records in 2009
Scott Hassett • Madison trial attorney for 22 years and former Secretary of Department of Natural Resources • Is a staunch supporter of stemcell research • Pledges to put partisanship aside and represent the state no matter what the subject matter may be. • Said he will enforce environmental laws and hold polluters accountable • Unlike Van Hollen, he does not believe in immigration enforcement on the state level, as he sees it as a federal issue
Check out our news blog on dailycardinal.com for today’s election coverage.
Funds allocated to high-speed rail line The federal government and state transportation officials signed a deal this weekend locking in $810 million in transportation funds for the proposed highspeed rail line between Madison and Milwaukee, according to the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. The deal would allow Gov. Jim Doyle to deal with most of the contracts in the last weeks of his term, potentially thwarting Republican gubernatorial candidate Milwaukee County Executive Scott Walker’s plans to stop the construction of the rail line. Walker, the frontrunner for the governorship in many polls, has been an avid opponent of the project and calls it a waste of tax dollars.
“This is just raw political power at its worst,” Walker told the MJS. “This is why the Doyle administration is corrupt and unwilling to listen to taxpayers.” However, Cari Anne Renlund, executive assistant to state Transportation Secretary Frank Busalacchi, defended the decision to the MJS. “We are merely trying to get the money obligated so the work can begin,” Renlund said. “These are stimulus dollars. The goal of it was to get people working.” The Madison-Milwaukee route would be part of a larger rail network connecting to Chicago and potentially the Twin Cities. —Ariel Shapiro
Polls show Republican gains may promise slow two years Republican control of the U.S. House of Representatives and gains in the U.S. Senate may stall both parties’ legislative agendas in the next congressional term. Polls show that the GOP could gain 40 to 50 seats in the House and narrowly miss gaining control of the Senate. According to UW-Madison political science professor Barry Burden, this may be more because of disillusionment with Democrats than approval of Republicans. “Both the Republicans and the Democrats are in the dumps,” Burden said. “In fact, in a lot of polls, Republicans are less liked than the Democrats are. This is sort of funny. It’s a wave or a surge for one party, but it’s not a party that’s especially well liked.” The likely election results
could spell disarray for both parties’ legislative agendas. The president’s veto and Republican Senate filibuster could result in a congressional stalemate. According to Burden, Republicans may be able to nibble away at Obama’s health-care reform act, but will be unable to achieve a full-scale repeal. Burden predicts that Republicans will focus on maintaining Bush’s tax cuts, preventing more stimulus funding, and fighting the administration on energy policy. The results could also shake up Democrat and Republican leadership. House Minority Leader John Boehner would assume Speaker of the House despite some in-party opposition, Burden said, while Democrats may punish current speaker Nancy Pelosi for the loss. —Patrick Tricker
dailycardinal.com/news
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
l
news
3
Body discovered in Monona Bay A body found near the Brittingham Boathouse on Monona Bay Monday morning was identified by Dane County Acting Coroner Barry Irmen as a man reported missing from the night before, according to police. Forty-year-old Mark Sobrilsky, who used a wheelchair, was reported missing by his roommate around midnight. Sobrilsky was found dead in the water at 7:25 a.m. Police attempted to track him down early Monday morning by
tracing the last use of his laptop’s portable WiFi card to Frances Street. However, Sobrilsky’s body was found by a passerby who spotted his abandoned wheelchair by the lake. The MPD and the Dane County Coroner’s Office are continuing to investigate the incident. From preliminary findings, they determined it does not seem as though there was any criminal activity involved with Sobrilsky’s death.
Chancellor Martin returns to China Matt Marheine/the daily cardinal
The Faculty Senate discussed a campus evaluation proposal to review campus services Monday.
Faculty Senate discusses campus evaluation proposal The UW-Madison Faculty Senate discussed a new proposal to review the productivity of various campus services Monday. The proposal, recommended by the University Committee, requests an evaluation of the campus by an external consultant. The consultant would observe how the university is structured and would suggest different structures to make it more efficient. The proposed evaluation aims to identify ways to improve services that support research and teaching methods
on campus. The Lectures Committee also reviewed 65 guest lectures that were given on campus in 2009-’10. The total annual expenditures for the lectures were approximately $61,000. Various funds support these university-wide lectures. The Lectures Committee discussed the William K. Fitch Fund, which has a balance of $171,000, but has not been used to fund guest lectures due to special restrictions on the fund. “This fund specifically has stated that the money is to be
used for prominent business people to give lectures on the American free-enterprise system,” Professor Sandra Ward said. “We have rarely had a request for a lecture that fit that bill.” The fund board has been asked to change the criteria for using the fund in order to provide more lectures that fit the description of the fund. The fund board rejected the motion. “[The fund is] worded just they way they want it,” Ward said. —Molly Reppen
UW-Madison Chancellor Biddy Martin is visiting China for a second time this year to promote collaboration between the university and China with a new focus on economic development. During her trip, Martin will visit Beijing, Hong Kong and Taipei. In Taipei, Martin will attend several meetings including one with Chinese Vice President Vincent Stew and another with the American Chamber of Commerce in Taipei. In Beijing, Martin will meet with Chinese Vice Minister of Education Hao Ping and several Wisconsin corporations working in China.
She will also speak at the Beijing Forum, which is an annual meeting of international leaders in social science and humanities. Martin will also update the Beijing Sports University about Chinese Olympians who are studying at UW-Madison, meet with UW alumni and visit two Chinese universities. Martin visited Beijing, Tianjin, Hangzhou and Shanghai last spring to enhance the university’s reputation in Asia. The university encourages students to follow Martin’s trip on her Twitter or Facebook accounts.
SSFC passes increased budgets for GUTS, SLP By Alison Bauter The Daily Cardinal
The Student Services Finance Committee approved budget increases for the Greater University Tutoring Services and Student Leadership Program Thursday. The committee also held budget hearings for Promoting Awareness, Victim Empowerment and Wisconsin Student Lobby. After motioning to strike $500 from GUTS’ technology budget, the SSFC voted to approve the GUTS budget at $166,398.91 by an 8-0-1 margin. The budget for SLP was approved at $69,786. PAVE, a student group focusing on sexual violence awareness and prevention requested a 6.52 percent budget
increase from $68,967 this year to $82,616 for 2011-’12. PAVE Chair Claire Peterson said the largest increase was to raise PAVE peer facilitators’ salaries in efforts to “really customize” student workshops. “We’re not changing much on our budget because PAVE has been successful,” Peterson said. “Ninety percent of the increase would be toward peer facilitator budget.” SSFC representative Cale Plamann said he thought the PAVE budget was “largely in line,” but he questioned the honorarium for some of the group’s programming. “It’s more than we’ve been paying other comparable groups,” Plamann said. WSL requested a 5.8 percent budget decrease after failing to use
$11,000, a third of the previous year’s budget. Their requested 2011-’12 budget would total $61,811, approximately $4,000 less than their 2010-’11 allocation. Under the WSL proposal, staff salary allocation would increase despite the budget decrease. The increase caused some SSFC members to question whether the staff salary raise could be justified, given that the group spent only 71 percent of last year’s budget. “There may be actual elimination of positions and reduction in hours. In fact, there almost has to be,” Plamann said. The SSFC will vote on PAVE and WSL’s proposals Thursday, and will also hear budget proposals from Sex Out Loud and SPILL.
$26k Rolex watch thief, getaway driver arrested after chase A 17-year-old man and his getaway driver were arrested Friday after the man allegedly stole a $26,000 Rolex watch on State Street. Detroit natives involved in the alleged theft were Ronald Parker who was arrested for theft and Fernando Hall, 21, who was arrested for being the driver of the get-away vehicle.
A store employee showed Parker the watch at Goodman’s Jewelers on State Street. The jewelry store employee chased the suspect after he left the store with the watch, according to the police report. Madison Police Department foot patrol officers in the area also became involved in the chase.
The suspect allegedly dropped the Rolex, which an officer recovered, behind Bethel Lutheran Church. Eventually police caught the suspect several blocks away as he got into the getaway vehicle. The suspect and the driver of the vehicle were then arrested, Madison Police spokesperson Joel DeSpain said in a statement.
Dancing queen arrested after kicking security guard A Madison woman was arrested Sunday night for dancing in the aisle during a Gogol Bordello concert and punching a security guard in the face. Private security guards at the Overture Center called for Madison police after 26-year-old concertgoer Lisa Matejka became “unruly,” according to the police incident report.
The woman allegedly went beyond a check point to get into the dance area of the Capitol Theater in the Overture Center. In order to get into this area the woman needed a wristband, which she did not have, police said. “When confronted by security, the woman kicked one staff member in the leg several times and punched another in the face,” Madison Police
Department spokesperson Joel DeSpain said in a statement. The Madison woman allegedly continued to resist arrest as the police officers removed her from the building. “One officer quoted her as saying, ‘I’m going to keep on fighting you. I just wanted to dance. Are you going to refund my $30 ticket back?’” DeSpain said in the statement.
DAnny Marchewka/the daily cardinal
The Center for Investigating Healthy Minds at the Waisman Center will research how meditation affects the brain.
Healthy Minds center opens Monday The Center for Investigating Healthy Minds, a center funded partially by the Dalai Lama, held its grand opening at the Waisman Center Monday. Attendees included UW Foundation President Mike Knetter, provost Paul DeLuca and a few Tibetan monks, who played an essential role in the center’s founding. The Dalai Lama donated $50,000 to the center earlier this academic year in support of the center’s research. The center’s director, Richard Davidson, said the center is focused on contemplative neuroscience, a study the center hopes will become mainstream. According to Davidson, contemplative neuroscience is “training the mind and nourishing the heart in ways that we think will change the brain for the better and enable us to go forth with positive qualities of the mind like compassion and kindness.” The center includes a meditation room for individuals
and aims at enhancing parts of the mind that prevent problems such as fear and anxiety. Mel Charbonneau, the center’s director of communications and marketing, said she hopes to spread awareness about the center and encourages students to volunteer at the center or simply check it out. “Our hope with the center is to engage the student community here on campus,” Charbonneau said. “It’s really important that we reach out to the students here.” —Jessica Phan
opinion ✔ Lack of student interest in Iraq war is shocking 4
l
miles kellerman opinion columnist
T
oday, the hotly contested midterm elections of 2010 will finally come to an end. Job creation, economic recovery and social issues such as gay marriage and abortion have taken center stage in an election season characterized by absurd spending and Republican advantage. One issue, however, has found itself uncharacteristically absent from debate: the ongoing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. This absence is no accident. In an election characterized by economic recovery, incumbents are happy to avoid the enormous cost of the war, while challengers simultaneously shy away from delving into the complexities of our presence in the Middle East. But the lack of attention paid to Iraq and Afghanistan is more than just an electoral trend. Never before in the history of our country has a war been so absent from our collective conscience. Despite the fact that the war in Afghanistan is now the longest war in U.S. history, the average Wisconsin student is more likely to know the words to Justin Bieber’s “Baby” than the fact that 47 U.S. troops died in the month of September. So why do the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan inspire less outrage in comparison to past U.S. conflicts? It would prove futile to compare the current situation with the scale and uncertainty of World War II. But why do we as a society, and more specifically college students, not protest as we did during Vietnam? Both have proven horrendously unpopular, reflected poorly upon our leaders and resulted in devastating civilian casualties. Yet the bombing of Sterling Hall in 1970 in protest of the Vietnam War is a level of activism unthinkable by today’s standards. Perhaps it’s a numbers game. As of Oct. 3, the Washington Post reports 5,710 military casualties
to date in the collective Iraq and Afghanistan wars. The Vietnam War resulted in over 58,000 military casualties. The recent release of classified military documents by WikiLeaks suggests a civilian death toll upwards of 100,000 in Iraq, compared to rough estimates of three million during the Vietnam War. Others might attribute our lack of attention to the media. While coverage of the war was all-encompassing during the early years. A study by The Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in Journalism found that by 2008 news stories dedicated to the war had dropped by 15 percent. In an interview with PBS News hour, Majorie Miller of the Los Angeles Times explained, “There’s definitely a weariness. This is a story that people want to go away, and so we are constantly looking for new and interesting ways to tell the story and keep people engaged.”
Perhaps the greatest reason that college students have failed to pay attention is the lack of a draft.
While the media holds certain responsibilities to inform the public, we must also realize that they are businesses. Despite their agenda-setting power when it comes to deciding what are important issues, their coverage is dependent on what sells. The fact that we as a public need journalists like Miller to keep us engaged is symbolic of how confused our perception of war has become. Ironically, the enormous amount of available information on Iraq is what’s deterring our attention. Media coverage made the war just another reality show whose ratings continue to drop with every new season. Perhaps the greatest reason that college students have failed to pay attention is the lack of a draft. During the Vietnam War, students’ lives were profoundly impacted by
the fact that so many of those around them were being sent to Vietnam. While college-student status temporarily protected them from the draft, the consequences of a failed class could mean military service. Vietnam coverage dominated the news, whose depictions of soldiers’ coffins and the horrors of war brought about unprecedented public outrage. The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, in stark contrast, are fully supported by volunteer service men and women. Furthermore, private military contractors in Afghanistan now outnumber U.S. troops. Students’ lives, unless directly related to someone serving overseas, are rarely impacted by the war. This of course is not to suggest a lack of support, only to recognize that the conflict in the Middle East has lost interest among the general population. This lack of interest, perhaps a result of the war’s longevity, is unprecedented in our history. While Vietnam dominated the lives of our parents, Iraq and Afghanistan have become side notes of an ongoing news story that never seems to end. The scale, length and media coverage of the war sets it apart from Vietnam, but there’s no denying that our efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan are just as controversial. We invaded Iraq on the false promises of Weapons of Mass Destruction, and many have connected our invasion with a need for oil. Despite the promises of the Obama administration to end our involvement, recently exposed connection between Iran and our enemies suggest quite the opposite. Why these circumstances fail to capture our attention is hard to pinpoint, especially in light of UW-Madison’s traditionally political student body. The bombing of Sterling Hall during Vietnam was symbolic of student frustration expressed in a horribly wrong manner. But we must also remember that our lack of interest and understanding can be just as dangerous. Miles Kellerman is a sophomore with an undecided major. Please send all feedback to opinion@dailycardinal.com.
Find your polling place: DISTRICT 4:
—Doyle Administration Building: 545 W. Dayton St. —Fire Station No. 1: 316 W. Dayton St. —Madison Area Technical College: 211 N. Carroll St. —Madison Public Library: 201 W. Mifflin St.
DISTRICT 5:
—Eagle Heights Community Center: 611 Eagle Heights —First Congregational Church: 1609 University Ave. —Holt Commons: 1640 Kronshage Dr.
DISTRICT 8:
dailycardinal.com/opinion
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
—Gordon Commons: 717 W. Johnson St. —Porchlight, Inc.: 306 N Brooks St. —UW Memorial Library: 728 State St. —UW Memorial Union: 800 Langdon St.
For district identification and polling locations visit: cityofmadison.com/election/voter/Where.cfm
2010 Midterm Election Ballot The Daily Cardinal’s Editorial Board endorses the selected candidates in Wisconsin’s midterm election.
Please check the candidates you are in support of for Statewide and Congressional office:
Wisconsin Governor Candidates: Tom Barrett (Democrat)
Scott Walker (Republican)
Jim Langer (Independent)
James James (Common Sense Party)
U.S. Senate Candidates: Russ Feingold (Democrat)
Ron Johnson (Republican)
Robert Taylor (Constitution Party)
House 2nd District Candidates: Tammy Baldwin (Democrat)
Chad Lee (Republican)
State Assembly District 77 Candidates:
Brett Hulsey (Democrat)
David Redick (Republican)
Ben Manski (Green Party)
David Olson (Constitution Party)
Attorney General Candidates: Scott Hassett John Van Hollen
Please check in favor or against the following referenda: Should the Wisconsin Legislature enact legislation allowing residents with debilitating medical conditions to acquire and possess marijuana for medical purposes if supported by their physician?
Yes
No
Should MATC be granted $133.8 million for construction and expansion projects through property tax increases?
Yes No
arts
dailycardinal.com/arts
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
l
5
Little to ‘Nothing’ to dislike about N.E.R.D.’s latest album By Ben Siegel
Nothing contains a few less experimental songs. “Party People” feaDespite consisting of one of tures a rapid-fire appearance by the music industry’s consistently T.I., but is relatively forgettable. successful hip-hop/pop production Pharrell’s simple and usually catchy teams, the Neptunes, N.E.R.D.’s lyrics become borderline irritating group work has never topped the when sung over a beat that sounds charts. Ten years and three studio like it was made on an out-of-tune albums have not given the trio of keytar. Like much of N.E.R.D’s Pharrell Williams, Chad Hugo and less creative and more repetitive Shay Haley much radio play. In fact, work, “Party People” is the type of the highest chart position of any of song that sounds better at a high their songs came in 2004 with energy performance than it ever “She Wants To Move” hitting fifth will on headphones. on the U.K. singles chart. While The album’s first single, “HotN.E.R.D.’s albums have been more n-fun” is slightly less migrainesuccessful than their singles (with inducing. The track features a In Search Of… (2002) and Fly memorable guest performance or Die (2004) both reaching gold from Nelly Furtado, which is status) the three another example CD REVIEW Grammys and of a track seemtwo Billboard ingly made for R&B/Hip-Hop a live show. It’s Awards sitting possible that on a shelf in the the band itself Neptunes’ studio understands the are better indicanature of their tors of the group’s music, as much Nothing excellent producof the music was N.E.R.D. tion and arrangefirst introduced ment skills. And at venues like it’s these skills that are the high MTV’s Spring Break concert series points of their new album, Nothing. long before being leaked online. Musically, the band has always N.E.R.D. is most frequently been experimental, and Nothing is criticized for their lyrics, which no different. According to Rolling usually come off as painfully simStone, the band was inspired by ple compared to the sophisticasounds of the ’60s and groups like tion of their production. However, The Doors and The Beach Boys. Nothing hits its highest note on “Victory” and “Help Me” are most “God Bless Us All,” a song that feain tune with this era, the latter tures lyrics about something other sounding like a re-imagined James than festivities and females, two Bond film score with moody gui- N.E.R.D. topical mainstays. The tar and 808 drumbeats. Pharrell’s song resonates socially conscious typically reedy falsetto comes off lines like, “you are brown in this as stirringly haunting, as the front- world that’s black and white, lil’ man gives arguably his best vocal bruh / You were made to amaze performance of the album. and bring change, lil’ bruh.” With “Hypnotize U,” the Daft a strong jazz and almost gospel-like Punk-engineered single, combines influence this song is as uplifting as European techno and psychedelic its background trumpet is resonatdrumbeats, along with Pharrell’s ing. A crown jewel of an experimesmerizing warble resulting mental album, this song finds in something that can only be N.E.R.D.’s vocal and songwriting described as groovy. ability equalling, if not surpassing, To appeal to commercially- its prodigious and innovative style minded record label executives, of production.
THe Daily Cardinal
Photo Courtesy Fox Searchlight Pictures
Hilary Swank and Sam Rockwell star as the Waters siblings in “Conviction,” a true story of perseverance.
Stand by this ‘Conviction’ By Kalie Riemer The Daily Cardinal
In 1983, Kenny Waters was convicted of the murder of Katharina Brow in Ayer, Massachusetts. In the 18 years that followed, Kenny’s sister, Betty Anne Waters, dedicated her life to fighting for his freedom. Determined to free her brother from what she believed a wrongful conviction, Betty Anne went through college and law school in order to eventually exonerate her brother. This remarkable true story of personal sacrifice is illustrated in Tony Goldwyn’s “Conviction.” The film’s plot, as adapted by screenwriter Pamela Gray, jumps between scenes from before and after Kenny’s conviction. Many of these scenes are short, revealing just enough to convey the necessary points. Scenes of Kenny and Betty Anne as children illustrate the development of their close relationship. Raised by a neglectful mother, they frequently got themselves in trouble until their separation into foster homes. Betty Anne’s separation from her husband is implied only by a scene of them arguing and his later absence from her household, leaving much to the interpretation of the audience.
Given the inspirational nature of the story, the movie could easily slip into the category of a Hallmark channel tear-jerker. Goldwyn, however, refrains from this by keeping the effects simple. The audience is neither distracted by dramatic music nor left impatient from drawn-out scenes. Instead, Goldwyn lets the actors bring the story to life, with Hilary Swank and Sam Rockwell putting on commendable performances as the Waters siblings. Swank portrays the delicate resolve of Betty Anne with depth and emotion. For much of the film, her character has a quiet strength. Her unwavering loyalty to her brother and her belief in his innocence keeps her forging through every obstacle imaginable. Although Betty Anne is skilled at maintaining her composure, she is not immune to letting her emotions get to her, particularly when it comes to family. These moments in the film allow Swank to display her phenomenal acting talent. The strained smile she puts on for her sons as she sends them off with her ex-husband could make any mother’s heart ache, and her livid reaction to questions of her brother’s
innocence resonates with anyone who has had to defend a family member. Rockwell, whose character is less prominently featured than Swank’s, also delivers a realistic performance in his presentation of the pompous and wild Kenny. In the various scenes where Kenny loses his temper, Rockwell conveys anger so believably the audience is inclined to believe that his character is capable of murder. However, Kenny’s love for his family is evidenced by his uncontrollable excitement when Betty Anne passes the bar exam. Supporting actresses Minnie Driver and Juliette Lewis add to the already exemplary acting in “Conviction.” Minnie Driver plays Betty Anne’s friend, Abra, whose sarcasm provides an occasional reprieve from the intensity of the film. Lewis portrays a witness, and though her appearance in the film is minimal, she is perfect for the ditsy role. The story behind this film is already powerful, but when paired with Goldwyn’s brilliant directing and a strong cast, it becomes all the more compelling. “Conviction” reminds us of the rewards of hard work and the power of familial love.
It’s a bird! It’s a plane! No, it’s...just another superhero remake David Cottrell cott-rell it on the mountain
T
his week nerds of all kinds across the Web rejoiced as Christopher Nolan revealed the title of his next Batman film— “The Dark Knight Rises,” set for release on July 20, 2012. Although Nolan has said it won’t feature the Riddler or Mr. Freeze, it’s a good bet it will be a phenomenal film, if its predecessors are any indication. Superheroes have been an integral part of our country’s zeitgeist over the last hundred years. I would even venture to draw a parallel between the way our culture holds the stories of classic superheroes like Spiderman, Batman and Superman to the way Ancient Rome and Greece held their myths of great heroes. Perhaps Homer was merely the Stan Lee of ancient Greece. After all, despite often being relegated as purely nerdy subject matter, the
classic mythos of these characters are known almost universally in the United States. My mom has never read a comic book in her life, but she could tell you exactly how Peter Parker got his Spidey sense and probably name a few of his more prominent foes. Thus, superheroes have played their role in our film history as well. The Christopher Reeve “Superman” movies are iconic pieces of film history in their own right. And the first Tim Burton “Batman” movie broke numerous box-office records when it opened in 1989. But then in the ’90s the later Joel Schumacher “Batman” movies bombed critically and financially, and studios shunned superhero movies as box office poison. Things changed again when CGI (computer generated imagery) progressed and became a staple in the film industry. Suddenly, fantastical tales of superheroes, which would have been impossibly challenging to film before, became feasible. What could only have been portrayed in cartoons and comics previously could now be visualized in live-action film.
In 2002, after being stuck in development hell for decades, Sam Rami’s first “Spiderman” film was released to a box-office bonanza. It was the first film to ever pass $100 million in a weekend and even today is still the 24th highest grossing film of all time. The superhero genre had been revitalized and we are now living in the resulting superhero renaissance. But how long until we burn out on superheroes and the studios are sent searching for new summer tentpoles? Next year is set to be bubbling over with superhuman action. In January we’ll see Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg (co-writers of “Superbad” and “Pineapple Express”) take on a classic in “The Green Hornet.” Then over the summer we get: “Green Lantern” with Ryan Reynolds and Blake Lively; “Captain America: The First Avenger” co-written by Joss Whedon; “Thor” with Chris Hemsworth and Natalie Portman; and “X-Men: First Class” directed by Matthew Vaughn (KickAss) and featuring a cavalcade of stars such as Kevin Bacon, January Jones, and James McAvoy.
And the studios aren’t stopping there. They have plans for dozens more superhero film adaptations in the next four years. After last summer’s indie hit “(500) Days of Summer,” director Marc Webb is set to helm a new Spiderman reboot starring Andrew Garfield (“The Social Network”) and Emma Stone. Mark Neveldine and Brian Taylor, the duo behind “Crank” and its sequel, are directing “Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance.” In an interesting choice, Darren Aronofsky, director of “The Wrestler,” will be taking on “X-Men Origins: Wolverine 2” next year. Then there’s the inevitable “Iron Man 3” to come. Zach Snyder (director of “300” and “Watchmen”) has a new take on Superman, “The Man of Steel,” with a script by Christopher Nolan and David Goyer (co-writers of “The Dark Knight”). To top it all off, Adrien Brody has been interested in getting an adaption of “Ant-Man” rolling, whoever Ant-Man is. With all of that on the horizon, the question isn’t so much whether audiences will get sick of superheroes, but when they will. Marvel and Disney
might be in for a rude awakening if public interest wanes before they can even get their mega-Frankenstein film “The Avengers” out in 2012. Spiderman and Batman are iconic heroes that everyone knows, comic book nerd or not. But Thor? Green Lantern? How many people will line up at midnight to see them? I highly doubt these will have anywhere close to the pull bigger names have had. How far down the superhero notoriety list can studios go before average folks stop showing up? Matthew Vaughn, director of the superhero movies “X-Men: First Class” and “Kick-Ass 2: Balls to the Wall” said in an interview this summer, “I’ve always wanted to do a big-budget superhero film and I think we’ve kind of crossed the Rubicon with superhero films ... The genre is going to be dead for a while because the audience has just been pummeled too much.” But which superhuman cinematic punch is going to be one punch too many? Have you had enough of Superhero movies as well? E-mail David at dcottrell@wisc.edu.
comics 6
l
Bad Parenting... Male hippos will attack young hippos in the water, but not on land. dailycardinal.com/comics
Tuesday, November 2, 2010 Finding Christmas merchandise in stores now
Today’s Sudoku
Evil Bird
By Caitlin Kirihara kirihara@wisc.edu
© Puzzles by Pappocom
Branching Out
By Brendan Sullivan bsullivan3@wisc.edu
Solution, tips and computer program available at www.sudoku.com.
Fill in the grid so that every row, every column and every 3x3 box contains the digits 1 through 9.
Eatin’ Cake
By Dylan Moriarty graphics@dailycardinal.com
Crustaches
By Patrick Remington premington@wisc.edu
Today’s Crossword Puzzle
Hot Sauce
By Oliver Buchino buchino@wisc.edu
Answer key available at www.dailycardinal.com
TIME FOR A HOMER 1 6 11 14 15 17 18 19 21 22 23 24 28 29 30 34 37 40 41 42 43 44 46
ACROSS Phantom’s haunt Feeling of hostility Clerical garment Second airing of a TV show Transfer to the next column, in math Precipice part Travel plan “Cher” or “Madonna,” e.g. Emblem of Great Britain America’s bird Roly-___ Leads, as a band Space between teeth Top-of-the-line Person enslaved by another Reiner of “All in the Family” Life insurance policy provision Letters on an ambulance Hangout for pinball wizards Work on movie clips Word to end a card game Take to the cleaners Wife who survived Henry VIII
48 Follow as a consequence 51 Certain enveloping glow 52 Rare baseball event 57 Cheap lodging 59 Give up, as one’s rights 60 Tend to a dull pencil again 61 Mid-sail 62 Versified salute 63 “Do you understand?” 64 Calendar periods DOWN 1 Planets, per poets 2 Beautiful and graceful girl 3 “___ go bragh!” 4 Ladder level 5 Low sock 6 Serving perfectly, in tennis 7 Present at birth 8 Sooty dirt 9 Fish-eating eagle 10 Bread or booze type 11 Be useful to 12 Bad ___ Brown of song 13 ___ Mawr 16 Lowest of decks 20 EST word 23 Tree type common in Hawaii
24 Vanish gradually 25 Word with “elbow” or “rumpus” 26 Liability 27 Bird’s beak 28 Elated 31 Inebriated one’s utterance 32 Ribosome component 33 Word on a dipstick 34 Amusement park thrill 35 Suffix with “narc” 36 Storage unit 38 Secluded habitat 39 Word suggesting a name change 43 Place for peaks and valleys 45 Wiggle room 46 Whimpered 47 Was mentioned, as a name 48 Spew lava 49 Certain JapaneseAmerican 50 Tuckered out 51 Hendrix hairdo 52 Moved quickly 53 Spread in a spread 54 Maggie Simpson’s sister 55 State with confidence 56 Thumbs-up votes 58 Witchlike character
Washington and the Bear
By Derek Sandberg kalarooka@gmail.com
sports
dailycardinal.com/sports
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
l
7
Men’s Basketball
soccer from page 8
Bo with many decisions yet to be made
best games of the season Monday night, scoring two goals and adding one assist. The junior midfielder found herself involved in all of the Badgers goals. Head coach Paula Wilkins had nothing but praise for Nosbusch. “I thought she could have a couple more,” Wilkins said. “I think when she raised her level there in the first half, it really made a difference.” Having a good day of her own, junior keeper Michele Dalton was on top of her game, earning her 11th shutout of the season. After a relatively quiet first half for Dalton, she found herself needing to make some big, and at the time acrobatic, saves in the second half to keep her clean sheet bid alive. “I thought she [Dalton] did a great job,” Wilkins said. “I think getting those opportunities and making those saves, it builds some confidence going into the post season.” The win was an emotional one for the team in a few different ways. It was the last conference game for the Wisconsin seniors, and to be able to get the win at home was a big motivating factor from the opening kickoff. “It was the last conference game for the seniors and we really wanted to play hard for them,” Kodee Williams said. With the win, the Badgers moved to 7-1-2 Big Ten and 10-4-4 overall. As it stands now, Wisconsin sits at the top of the Big Ten standings. The Badgers need either a tie or loss by both Penn State and Ohio State when those teams play Michigan and Michigan State, respectively, later this week to win the team’s first Big Ten title since 1996. Expecting to earn a NCAA bid regardless though, the team is hoping for a home field reward in that tournament. “Hopefully we get a home bid so we can play at home and keep the momentum going,” Williams said. The team will learn their NCAA tournament fate when those selections are announced on Nov. 8.
By Max Sternberg the daily cardinal
Despite returning three starters and 12 letterwinners from last year’s 24-9 squad, much of the pre-season focus has been on the newcomers to badger basketball. Still, No. 24 Wisconsin is faced with the task of finding replacements for two of their three AllBig Ten selections from last season, guards Jason Bohannon and Trevon Hughes. Although junior guard Jordan Taylor, a starter toward the latter part of last year, is likely to be tapped for the starting point, the race for the second guard vacancy is wide open. One player in the mix is freshman Josh Gasser. A former high school quarterback, the 6'3" Port Washington, Wis. native has impressed coach Bo Ryan throughout preseason workouts and into the early practice and scrimmage slate. “Josh Gasser is not 18, or 19. He’s 21, 22,” Ryan said. “The way he sees the floor is maturing.” While coach Ryan has certainly been impressed by the leadership experience and floor sense of Gasser, he also noted that another freshman, Ben Brust, has been off the charts in his displays of athleticism. Seen by many as a Bohannon-type player, the former Iowa recruit and late Badger pickup has quickly become another potential option as Ryan and the badger coaching staff try to fill the gaping hole in that final guard spot. “Ben Brust is the fastest guy coming off screens that I’ve ever coached,” Ryan said. “I’ve had some guys with a little bit of speed, but he’s like a bullet.” Though the second guard spot is the obvious question mark heading into Saturday’s exhibition opener, the other newcomers are sure to play a pivotal role in supporting a cast of big men that includes returning starters, seniors Keaton
Nankavil and Jon Leuer. One of the biggest questions among this group is the status of freshman Evan Anderson. The 7-foot Stanley, Wis. native was thought to be leaning toward redshirting, but coach Ryan was quick to note that Anderson’s work in practice has gotten him to a level where that route is no longer a foregone conclusion. The final piece of the freshman puzzle, 6'8" freshman Duje Dukan, remains a work in progress with tremendous upside. Although this diverse set of newcomers look poised to blend in well with the noted culture
of badger basketball, there is sure to be a learning curve, especially on the defensive end of the floor. “The biggest thing all four of them have to learn is what we do defensively,” Ryan said. “You can always go to a playground, to the open gyms, and you’re fine. Defense is what’s gonna make the difference.” As the season looms on the horizon, Wisconsin basketball is right on the brink of the national scene, a position this program has grown accustomed to throughout Bo Ryan’s tenure.
Lorenzo zemella/cardinal file photo
Jordan Taylor, who played in all 33 games last season, averaging 10 points per contest, will be key in replacing departing guards, Jason Bohannon and Trevon Hughes this year.
sports 8
l
dailycardinal.com/sports
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
Football
Badgers ready to get back to work after bye
Boilermakers pose next big test for Badgers By Ted Porath the daily cardinal
In his weekly press conference on Monday, football head coach Bret Bielema discussed the Badgers’ state as a team, as well as the team’s upcoming game against Purdue. Bielema began by addressing the injuries accrued in the Badgers’ previous game against Iowa. Bielema expects that all players who were injured against Iowa, including senior tight end Lance Kendricks and freshman running back James White, to play on Saturday.
Bielema then addressed how he plans to get his team focused again coming off a bye week. “To me, the very important thing is to stay fresh,” Bielema said. “As coaches, idle time is sometimes a time when coaches can get overly creative and do things that are out of their norm … just stick with the plan, I think that’s what we’ll do.” Wisconsin is now ranked No. 7 in both the AP Top 25 and the USA Today Poll. Additionally, the team is ranked No. 9 in the BCS rankings. With the possibility of a BCS bowl looming, many fans are wondering how Bielema is keeping his team focused for their next opponent each week. “If we don’t take care of our business this week, it’s all for naught,” Bielema said. “I think this group probably gets that bet-
Kyle bursaw/cardinal file photo
While Purdue’s defensive line has been a force all season, the Badger front four, featuring J.J. Watt, has brought chaos to opponents as well.
ter than years past, that the reason they’re in the position they’re in is they’ve taken it one week at a time. We didn’t talk about Ohio State till we got to Ohio State. We didn’t talk about Iowa till we got to Iowa. It’s the same reason we’re gonna carry forward that thinking with Purdue.” Bielema also covered the team’s upcoming game this weekend against Purdue. The Boilermakers (2-2 Big Ten, 4-4 overall) come into this game on a two game losing streak, with losses to Ohio State and Illinois by a combined score of 93-10. Purdue is known to have a solid front four, led by senior defensive end and NFL prospect Ryan Kerrigan. Kerrigan has totaled 49 total tackles so far, with 7.5 sacks and 18.5 tackles for loss. “Still to this day, I think that Ryan Kerrigan, their defensive end, is one of the premiere players in our league,” Bielema said. “Their d-line really plays hard. Bruce Gaston, their starting defensive end, we wanted him bad. We really recruited him hard.” Purdue runs a spread offense, a system that places the quarterback in the shotgun with 3, 4 or 5 receiver sets. The Badgers have not faced this type of offense this year, but Bielema believes that the key to beating Purdue will be the same key to beating Ohio State or Iowa. Bielema said that some things, like tackling, will be even more critical this week. “Defensively, we’ve got to tackle well, probably now more than ever because in spread offenses they create one on one spacing, so that’s a big difference in this game,” Bielema said. This game will be the 77th meeting between Wisconsin and Purdue, with Wisconsin leading the series 39-29-8. Wisconsin has won the last four meetings between the teams, winning the last two by a combined score of 61-3.
Women’s Soccer
Matt marheine/the daily cardinal
Junior Laurie Nosbusch contributed to all three goals Monday night, scoring two and adding an assist to a Kodee Williams score.
Wisconsin in first place following 3-0 victory Team now awaits PSU, OSU play later this week By Matthew Kleist the daily cardinal
As the Wisconsin women’s soccer team took the field Monday night, it was an emotional moment for some. In their last regular season game of the year, the Badgers hosted the Wildcats of Northwestern. From the opening whistle, the UW women were locked in. The Badgers came out hot from the start, pressuring the Wildcat defense by relentlessly attacking the box. It didn’t take long for one of their attacks to produce results either. Wisconsin’s first goal would come in the 19th minute on a beautiful series of passes in and around the box. After a heads up play, sophomore midfielder Alev Kelter hooked up with junior forward Laurie Nosbusch. With a well played ball into the box, freshman
midfielder Kodee Williams controlled the ball and put it past the Northwestern keeper. Continuing the assault on Northwestern’s back line, Wisconsin would find themselves in a good position just five minutes after scoring the first goal. Delivering a great cross into the box, freshman midfielder Catie Sessions was able to find the head of Nosbusch who would drive the ball to the back of the net, increasing the Wisconsin lead to two. And not to outdo herself, Nosbusch would find the net once more in the game to solidify Wisconsin’s lead over the Wildcats. The goal coming in the 30th minute on a right place, right time play. Sophomore midfielder Monica Lam-Feist crossed the ball into the box finding the feet of junior midfielder Leigh Williams. Williams shot would be blocked, but not cleared. Capitalizing on the free ball, Nosbusch knocked it home for her second of the game. Nosbusch would play one of her soccer page 7
Boise State deserves more respect than the voters, computers are giving the Broncos this season Ryan Evans compelling evandence
W
hat the BCS and college football, as a whole, is doing to the Boise State Broncos is sickening. It appears like the computers are perfectly happy with screwing over Boise State week after week, much like the AP voters before them. When the preseason polls were released, the Boise State Broncos sat proudly at the number two spot, which was the highest preseason ranking ever for a non-automatic BCS qualifying conference team. Bronco Nation rejoiced thinking that maybe this would be the year that they would finally have the opportunity to prove their mettle on the biggest stage of all: the BCS National Title Game in Glendale, Arizona. But so far this year it is apparent that the voters, or computers,
or whoever, is going to do their best to keep the Broncos out of the title game, which, in my mind, is extremely unfair. Boise State has evolved from that cute little underdog that knocked off Oklahoma in the 2006 Fiesta Bowl, into one of college football’s premier powers, and a team that is as worthy and capable as any other team in the country to play in the BCS title game. Some argue that that is because their conference is extremely weak, so when they go undefeated in conference play, it really isn’t that big of an accomplishment. So what does Boise do to combat that? They load their nonconference schedule with big name schools to try and make a statement. They’ve played Oregon, Oregon State, Virginia Tech and still win on a regular basis, and recently set up a future series with Michigan State. Not to mention they have knocked off Oklahoma and TCU in bowl games. They beat Oregon, now ranked No.1 in the country, just last season. The Broncos have been willing to lay
any hope of a national title appearance on the line in the early weeks of their season, and they have come away from those games unscathed. They try to schedule more but a funny thing happens: no one wants to play them. None of the big boy schools want to take the risk of playing the smurf turf squad, in fear of their own national title hopes will going right out the window. Then people argue that Boise State doesn’t play anyone. Well guess what? They have tried but college football is scared of the Broncos, scared of what they can do to the established hierarchy of college football. They opened this season by playing on the road against a Virginia Tech team that was, at the time, the No.10 team in the country. They won that game on a late game drive led by quarterback Kellen Moore in an extremely hostile environment. It was a fantastic ending to a great game, and for any other team it would have been a signature win that the BCS computers love to see.
But, Virginia Tech lost the next week to Division I-AA foe James Madison, and it was Boise State that suffered the consequences. The AP voters dropped Boise State from No. 2 to No. 3 in the AP poll that week, despite the Broncos being on bye. So, they were dropped in the rankings solely based on Virginia Tech’s loss. Its like these people look for any reason to discredit the Broncos. The injustice continued as soon as the BCS rankings were released. As top-ranked teams fell by the wayside the first two weeks of the poll, Boise State remained at the number three spot in the polls as team after team leapfrogged them to occupy the number one and two spots, despite the fact that Boise State was still winning, and winning impressively at that. And now, in the most recent BCS rankings released on Sunday maybe the biggest travesty to date has occurred. Despite yet another Bronco victory, the BCS computers allowed the TCU Horned Frogs to move into the No. 3 spot, bumping Boise State
down to No. 4. Are you kidding me? It is one thing for automatic BCS qualifying schools to pass Boise State, but now they’re letting other BCS buster schools pass them; a BCS buster that Boise defeated in last year’s Fiesta Bowl no less. The latest rankings also have Utah sitting at No.5, as if they’re setting up another drop for Boise. If the BCS is letting TCU jump over the Broncos, it’s not screwing them over solely because they come from a non-AQ conference. There is just something about Boise State that the computers don’t like, and for the life of me I cannot figure out what it is. Boise State is fighting an uphill battle that it cannot possibly win, no matter, it seems, how well they do. This team can line up with the best in the country, I truly believe that, but it seems they will never get the opportunity to prove it and instead will continue to get the shaft from a chance at college football glory. Think a No. 4 ranking is fair? E-mail Ryan at rmevans2@wisc.edu.