Dashboard Inaccuracies

Page 1

Emerson College’s student newspaper since 1947 • berkeleybeacon.com

Thursday, Oct. 8, 2020 • Volume 74, Issue 6

@berkeleybeacon // @beaconupdate

EMERSON COVID-19 DASHBOARD RIDDLED WITH INACCURACIES, MISSING METRICS Andrew Brinker

The day’s update to the dashbord was correct. That means, according to The Beacon’s records, there were no reporting errors in any metrics on the dashboard (positive tests, positivity rate, cumulative tests, cumulative positive tests, isolation numbers, quarantine numbers.)

Beacon Staff

A review of Emerson’s reported COVID-19 data reveals severe shortcomings in the college’s dashboard, which intends to provide insight into the virus’ presence in the community. The regularly updated dashboard has been riddled with reporting and mathematical errors, a Beacon investigation found. In addition, it is missing several metrics two public health experts said are crucial to painting an accurate picture of the virus’ spread at Emerson. “As a general principle, it’s concerning if the numbers are bouncing around, because then you have to question well, why were they?” Dr. Michael Siegel, a professor of community health sciences at Boston University, said in an interview. “Which one is correct? And why were they wrong in the first place? What’s going on?” Cases at Emerson have remained low since the college’s reopening in August. As of publication, the college reported 19 positive tests out of 23,781 tests administered between Aug. 6 and Oct. 7. The reported positivity rate sits at .08 percent. (All students must be tested weekly; faculty and staff were given the choice to opt-in to weekly tests.) Other New England schools, like Boston College and Providence College, by contrast, have Dashboard, Pg. 2

The day’s update to the dashboard had at least one reporting error. Reporting errors include: 1) over- or underreporting cumulative tests, 2) incorrect isolation metrics, 3) adding positive tests without updating the cumulative test number, 4) mislabeling metrics, 5) incorrect dates. The Beacon did not track all metrics on the dashboard on this day, or the date is in the future.

Every day the dashboard contained errors.from Sept. 9 to Oct. 7.

The college does not update the dashboard on the weekends.

Diti Kohli / Beacon Staff

Proposed federal DHS rule to limit international students’ time in U.S.

Gregg Winik (right), NBA Commissioner Adam Silver (left) and former NBA comissioner David Stern at 1988 NBA finals

Courtesy NBA Entertainment

Director of OISA Andrea Popa Hongyu Liu / Beacon Correspondent

Charlie McKenna & Alec Klusza

Beacon Staff & Beacon Correspondent A newly proposed U.S. Department of Homeland Security rule could limit the ability of international students to stay in the U.S. for more than four years during their planned course of study. Proposed on Sept. 25, the rule would curtail the current Duration of Status policy, which allows international students to enter the U.S. and stay until the completion of their academic studies so long as they maintain legal status with the federal government. The current policy also allows for students to take “optional practice training” in their field for up to one year after graduation. If enacted, the new rule would instead impose a two to four year limit on students’ academic pursuits, a harsh limit for students who may need more time to graduate or are enrolled in a program longer than four years. Students would be able to apply for an extension on their D/S but must pay a fee and wait over a year for a response, Director of the Office of International Student Affairs Andrea Popa said in an interview. DHS said the rule will serve as a barrier to visa fraud, and to those who

may overstay or otherwise defy the conditions of entry to the U.S as Immigrants would then be subject to a review by the U.S. Immigration Service. However, Popa said the college verifies students are maintaining legal status every semester. “They’re concerned for the potential for visa abuse and for students to stay here for years and years without direct inspection is what they’re concerned about,” she said. “I don’t think they’re giving enough credence to the fact that students do have to be reporting to their own schools… it’s not that they stay in the U.S.without inspection, it’s that they stay in the U.S without inspection from an immigration officer.” The policy will include a fouryear transition period for current visa holders, meaning it may not affect the international students already enrolled in college, 14 percent of Emerson’s total student population. Future students may be discouraged from studying in the U.S. The policy will also take months for DHS to finalize. International Students, Pg. 3

Emerson alum behind acclaimed ‘Last Dance’ NBA docuseries Lucia Thorne Beacon Staff

While documenting Michael Jordan’s last season with the Chicago Bulls in the late 1990s, Gregg Winik ‘84 and the rest of the NBA Entertainment film crew joked that the footage would become either a “great documentary” or “the greatest set of home movies ever assembled.” At the 72nd annual Primetime Emmy Awards, the former proved to be true. The Last Dance, the 2020

sports docuseries chronicling Jordan’s career and final season, won the Emmy for Outstanding Documentary or Nonfiction Series. The Emmy win represented 22 years of hard work and perseverance from Winik, an Emerson alum and executive producer of the show, and his crew. The Last Dance is currently available for streaming on Netflix and the ESPN app. Winik’s dedication to the project and a lifelong passion for sports production are evident from the praise the show has received.

INSIDE THIS EDITION

Scooby Doo, Pg. 7

FSL organizations navigate online platforms during recruitment Pg. 7 Three students on their social lives during COVID-19 Pg. 4 In this sexual desert, opt for masturbation Pg. 5 Scooby Doo takes over Little Building Pg. 7 Two men’s soccer players join forces in new podcast Pg. 8

“The audience reacted to it, the sports world reacted to it, and obviously the awards shows have now reacted to it, and it came out great,” Winik said in a phone interview. Winik grew up in the suburbs of New York City and came from a family with a background in filmmaking, so he quickly learned he wanted to be a part of the industry. He was also surrounded by sports, since his father was a sports cinematographer and director who owned an independent sports production company. Greg Winnick, Pg. 6

19 positive

COVID-19 tests

23,700+ tests administered .08% positivity rate


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.