Volume 8 Number 17
www.thebrandeishoot.com
Brandeis University’s Community Newspaper • Waltham, Mass.
September 23, 2011
Dual CA role presents conflicts of interest Community living unclear on standards By Josh Kelly Staff
Roaming residence halls at quiet hours, community advisors are a major authority in upholding alcohol-re-
lated policies for social gatherings on campus. They fulfill a responsibility shared by university police—to prevent illegal underage drinking—but face the inherent dilemma of walking into parties and dorms with loud noise full of their friends and classmates. Brandeis lays out its core alcohol policy in the Rights and Responsibilities Handbook, stating “Brandeis
University upholds and supports local, state, and federal laws with regard to alcohol beverages.” “At the university we have some responsibility to enforce state and local laws … It would not be responsible for us to have policies that weren’t aligned with the laws that are in place for the city and state … We could sit here and debate for hours about the legal drinking age … It’s not really
for us to decide,” Senior Director of Community Living Jeremy Leiferman said. Leiferman described the duties of the community advisor by explaining that it is not strictly about breaking up parties despite those perceptions from the student body. “If a student has registered a party, See ADVISORS, page 5
Broken promise, loss for transparency in forgotten student vote By Alex Schneider Editor
More than a year after administrators solicited student opinions for three options to replace the now-demolished Kalman Science Building, The Hoot has confirmed that administrators consider the construction project to be complete. Instead of the proposed four-season garden, sand volleyball court or hybrid concept incorporating elements of both, the space, which sits between Gerstenzang and KosowWolfson-Rosensweig science buildings, is now filled by a parking lot, with room for 22 cars, including only two handicap spaces. The outdated website for Brandeis capital projects lists the “Science Complex Renewal Project Interim Landscape/Hardscape” as a “current project” to be “completed in Spring 2010,” but the plan for the project has gone unfulfilled, with the student vote, which supported the hybrid plan, effectively void. Senior Vice President for Administration Mark Collins told The Hoot that the construction of the Shapiro Science Complex displaced muchneeded parking, explaining the installation of the parking lot. He further cited handicap-parking considerations in the decision to install a parking lot close to the science complex. Collins, who was not involved in the initial voting process, commented on the difficulty of planning
a construction project based on a voting procedure. “I think that until you have a plan in place for the site, I think it’s difficult—it’s pie in the sky.” Contacted early Thursday, Casey Russo, assistant project manager in the Office of Capital Projects, confirmed that the project was in fact considered finished by the administration. That decision, unlike the original unprecedented student vote, was never communicated with students or even formally announced. Former Student Union President See TRANSPARENCY, page 5
photo by alex schneider/the hoot; graphic from website of office of capital projects
‘put up a parking lot’ (Top) The Shapiro Science Complex parking lot built in lieu of a
proposed four-season garden or sand volleyball court; (Bottom) The proposed hybrid concept.
Skip option fails to fill vacant seats By Jon Ostrowsky Editor
The student body elected senators to the Student Union Thursday with 18 percent turnout, but even with a new skip option in voting, three of the five seats on the Judiciary were left vacant due to abstain votes. Three other senate seats were also left vacant and a new election date will be announced soon, Union Secretary Todd Kirkland said. This election marked the debut of a new “skip” option available to students during the voting process. Unlike the “abstain” option, the skip option does not hurt the candidates but it still gives students the opportunity to demonstrate their right not to vote. “We’re going to further evaluate what we do with the skip option,” said Union President Herbie Rosen ’12 in an interview early Friday morning following the election results. The following students won seats: Evyn Rabinowitz as Senator at Large; Sneha Walia ’15 and Daniel Novak ’15 as Class of 2015 Senators; Theodore Choi ’13 and Sarah G. Kim ’13 as class of 2013 Senators; Melissa Donze ’12 as Class of 2012 Senator; Jenny Lau ’14 to the Alumni Association Representative seat; Lisa Purdy ’14 and Rohan Bhatia ’14 to the Brandeis Sustainability Fund Representative seats; Kelsey Dean ’14 as the Castle Quad Senator; Jeremy Goodman ’14 as the East Quad Senator; Paul Lee ’13 to the F-Board Racial Minority seat; Gaili Gordon to the Judiciary; Dean Kaplan ’15 as Massell Quad Senator; Charlotte Franco ’15 as North Quad Senator; Rachel Goutman as Off Campus Senator; Boris Osipov as Ridgewood Quad Senator; Jacklyn Gil ’14 as Rosenthal Quad Senator; James Polite as TYP Senator; Benjamin Beutel as Village Quad Senator See UNION, page 4
Brandeis students protest Davis execution By Connor Novy Staff
photo by nafiz “fizz ” ahmed/the hoot
louis brandeis statue
The Troy Davis trial had captivated media for weeks and, finally, has come to a close. Students who felt there was more than a shadow of a doubt of Davis’ innocence due to the physical evidence and recanting of witness testimonies (and even a confession by someone else) protested his execution with duct tape gags and a vow of silence. The night of the execution, Brandeisians were repeatedly refreshing news pages, waiting for some news of the Supreme Court’s decision. After it was announced that the appeal was rejected, some students wore tape over their mouths and refused to speak in protest of the Supreme Court decision. From the Brandeis Protest for Troy Davis Facebook, “Although hope is lost for Troy Davis, we, as a community, can still effect change, and promote justice.” Sentenced to death in 1991 for the shooting
of Savannah, Ga., off-duty police officer Mark McPhail, his appeals were rejected by the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, in a two to one ruling. The dissenting judge, Rosemary Barkett, wrote, “To execute Davis, in the face of a significant amount of proffered evidence that may establish his actual innocence, is unconscionable and unconstitutional.” One of the few witnesses that did not recant his testimony was the other prime suspect in the case. He also was the person to initially inform the police of Davis’ professed guilt. Troy Davis was executed on Sept. 21 at 11 p.m. He had had three previous sentences— each time he appealed, he was sentenced to death over again. The Supreme Court reviewed the case for an entirety of three hours Wednesday night, and though the decision disappointed supporters, it is significant that the justices spent as much time as they did reviewing a death penalty case. He has become a martyr of the anti-death penalty cause. Amnesty International wrote,
“The state of Georgia shamefully executed Troy Davis … but our fight to abolish the death penalty lives on.” They collected more than 700,000 signatures in less than a week, and the other organizations that bastioned Davis have had similar success. The ACLU and NAACP contributed their support, along with numerous public figures, including President Jimmy Carter. Many students at Brandeis consider the Davis trial to be a “legal lynching” and evidence of the “racism inherent in the system.” “It’s disgusting because there was so much evidence against his guilt,” Sneha Walia ’15 said. “The death penalty should never be allowed. No one should have the power to play God.” Currently, the organizers of the protest are talking to the administration about organizing a rally to memorialize Troy Davis and the tragedy of the death penalty. “What happened tonight in Georgia constitutes an absolute failure of the justice system,” said the protest organizers, who urged Brandeisians, as members of an “activist school,” to show support.