Volume 9 Number 13
www.thebrandeishoot.com
Brandeis University’s Community Newspaper • Waltham, Mass.
April 27, 2012
Student questions univ response to alleged rape case Title IX compliance in doubt By Jon Ostrowsky Editor
Alleging she was raped by a Heller School student at their off-campus apartment nearly a dozen times from October 2010 through January 2011, an undergraduate student now on medical leave said the university cared more about closing the case than listening to her story and protecting her safety.
Advisers for both students doubted whether Brandeis sufficiently fulfilled its legal obligation to conduct a campus investigation following the complaints, according to emails sent last May to Scot Bemis, the university’s Title IX coordinator. The facts of the case are fogged in a he-said, she-said story. But a yearlong investigation supported with several documents and emails obtained by The Hoot reveal an administration more fearful of lawsuits than student concerns and officials more willing to defer questions than to answer them directly. “The school was more interested in
protecting its image than removing the hostile environment for me. They were afraid of being sued [by my alleged assailant],” she said. “I think they did not care about my safety at all.” The Hoot interviewed her multiple times since May but has withheld her name and his to protect privacy. The paper’s attempts to contact him were unsuccessful. University officials declined to comment, citing federal privacy laws. It was a case of his word against hers. She said her assailant and his friend currently enrolled at the Heller School repeatedly threatened
and sexually assaulted her. He filed a criminal complaint that she threatened to kill him, a claim she denies. In response to the rape allegations, he provided a Word document of instant messages to university police showing her aggressive pursuit of him. She said the Word document was heavily edited and falsified. Although the student conduct board found him responsible for nine of 11 code violations in Rights and Responsibilities, including section 3.1, which prohibits sexual contact without consent and an appeals comSee ASSAULT, page 2
Policy change needed
S
exual assault on college campuses rarely makes the news. There’s no wonder as to why: Cases are often difficult to prove and many aren’t even reported. When assaults are reported, they often devolve into a he-said, shesaid back-and-forth. That doesn’t mean sexual assault isn’t happening. When it does, we must pay attention. In this case, administrators acted in a manner inconsistent with federal law, community standards and social justice. They gave this student the run-around, threatened her with suspension, ignored See EDITORIAL, page 3
Breaking the silence on mental illness and attempted suicide By Tali Singer Staff
an early commencement Jesse Beal MA’12 and Alwina Bennett embrace at the graduation ceremony.
photo by nate rosenbloom/the hoot
LGBTQ grads recognized at ‘Lavender’ awards By Alana Blum staff
Sporting shades of lavender, the graduating members of Brandeis’ LGBTQ family paraded into the Intercultural Center lounge amid cheers and cello music on Tuesday. With
excitement and nostalgia, Brandeis commenced its first Lavender Graduation. Lavender Graduation is a ceremony specifically set aside for the graduating members of the LGBTQ community and their allies. It celebrates the contributions and accomplishments
Kirkland ’13 takes presidency By Connor Novy Editor
Todd Kirkland ’13 was elected Student Union president last Friday, edging out Dillon Harvey ’14 by a narrow margin of less than 100 votes. This is the first year in many that the race has been so close, due both to low voter turnout, 32.85 percent, down from 44 percent last year and 50 percent the year prior to that. The straight decline in voter turnout and the increase in candidacy narrowed margins all around, steep change from the landslide victory of last year’s president, Herbie Rosen ’12. Changes to the constitution are imminent in the face of a number of
this community has achieved for the past four years. The LGBTQ and ally community at Brandeis appreciates the recogniSee LAVENDER, page 5
August 31, 2010, was one of the most frightening nights of my life. When my roommate, Lily NagyDeak, left our suite, I had no idea that a few hours later we would receive frantic phone calls from her friends that something was wrong. Did we know where Lily was? Soon thereafter, there was a loud knock on our door from the campus police. But it wasn’t until I walked through the door of Lily’s room—she had left it open—that I finally pieced it together. That’s when another roommate and I found it, sitting on her desk: a suicide note. Thankfully, we got a call later that evening that Lily had been found; she was alive and safe. The police stopped by the suite again, and this time they emerged with a large Ziploc bag filled with assorted bottles of pills. When Lily returned to campus after her hospital stay, we never spoke about her suicide attempt. A yearand-a-half later, I spoke with Lily via Skype and she told me her side of the story. She told me not only about
that one August day, but also about how she has lived with bipolar disorder. Lily could have chosen to speak anonymously, but she felt that doing so would defeat her whole purpose: to combat the stigma and silence surrounding mental illness. Below is an excerpt from my conversation with Lily. To hear her full story listen to the extended podcast version at www.thebrandeishoot. com. Hearing Lily’s voice conveys her story in a way that words on a page cannot. Tali Singer: What was your first encounter with mental illness? Lily Nagy-Deak: I think my first encounter was actually my own experience. I remember it was sort of jarring, because my freshman year, I described what I going through and how I was feeling, and a friend of mine said to me, “Isn’t that just bipolar?” And I looked at him, and I was like, “What? No, I don’t have that. That’s something serious. What are you talking about?” […] Ironically, he turned out to be right. See MENTAL ILLNESS, page 2
Designing the knuckle sandwich with food art
amendments, which Rosen sent to the student body this past week. The seven amendments include eliminating a student-elected alumni association position because, according to the dossier explaining the amendments, “the truth is that the position is largely ineffective if the representative is not a member of Future Alumni of Brandeis (FAB) … We want to ensure efficiency and better, stronger representation of students towards the Alumni.” Kirkland is largely concerned with the efficiency of the Student Union. As president, he plans to eliminate a number of unfilled positions on See ELECTION, page 7
campus center studio Kelsey Elvelrum ‘12 displays her food art display in the Shapiro Campus Center.
photo by ingrid schulte/the hoot
inside this issue:
Amendments
Culture X
A war story
Editor critiques the proposals for constitutional changes.
Our review of the annual display of dance, music and spoken word.
Hoot editor tells grandfather’s story surviving WWII.
Impressions , p. 13
Arts, Etc. , p. 16
Features. , p. 10