Volume 16 Issue 11
“To acquire wisdom, one must observe” www.brandeishoot.com
Brandeis University’s Community Newspaper · Waltham, Mass.
Senator rescinds proposal to de-charter The Brandeis Hoot
By Thalia Plata staff
Class of 2019 Senator Kent Dinlenc formally introduced a proposal to de-charter The Brandeis Hoot at the senate meeting held this past Sunday. This proposal was rescinded late on Thursday night, April 11 in a Facebook post by Dinlenc. Dinlenc’s nine-page proposal to the senate states “...as important as the presence of an indepen-
dent student-run newspaper is on campus, Brandeis already has one in existence: The Justice.” In his proposal Dinlenc claims that The Hoot “...blatantly violates the Duality of Purpose amendment.” The amendment in question, found in the bylaws in Article VIII Section 2, clause C, states: “In order to be eligible for accreditation, a prospective club must…. Not duplicate the purpose or goals of an existing club. If the prospective club’s operations, impact, and student appeal would substantively be the same
as that of an existing club, then it should not be accredited. A group has duality of purpose if it has duality of operations, impact, and appeal. Collectively, this standard is called Duality of Purpose.” Dinlenc, in his capacity as Senate Co-Chair of the Sustainability Committee (SenSus), met separately with editorial staff from both newspapers in mid-March to discuss sustainability. Dinlenc was a staff writer for the Justice’s arts section but denies this being a factor in his proposal, stating at the senate meeting, “I criti-
PHOTO BY RYAN SPENCER/THE HOOT
FIRE ON DARTMOUTH STREET
‘I Am Proud’ celebrates students By David Cohen staff
The student leadership board of the Student Support Services Program (SSSP) arranged a celebratory event to commemorate students and faculty for their academic dedication to the community this past Tuesday. The event featured student talks, awards and other forms of recognition. Agnele Sewa ’20 and Karekin Johnson ’19, both current board
members of SSSP, opened the night, explaining the program’s history of being federally funded through the department of education to provide low-income first generation students with the support they need to achieve academic success. SSSP Director Elena Lewis then took the stage to show her delight, saying the students’ “presence gives us strength and legitimacy to the work that we do.” After a brief remark of gratitude by new Dean of Arts and Sciences Dorothy Hodgson, SSSP student
Billy Chau ’19 entered the stage to share his journey at Brandeis. Chau explained how his history as a hardworking student was put to the test at Brandeis. A local native from the Bronx, he explained how his high school did not offer certain support programs that SSSP does, so his chemistry classes obstructed his sense of worth as a student. Through SSSP, however, he slowly gained the skills to succeed in his classes and esSee SSSP, page 5
Canceled campus play progresses off-campus years later By Ryan Spencer editor
“Buyer Beware,” a play which was originally meant to be performed on the Brandeis campus in Fall 2017 but was canceled following controversy and concerns over its content, is “in development” for performance elsewhere, according to the playwright Michael Weller ’65.
Weller, a Brandeis alum, first drafted the play after he had a chance to visit campus as part of his receiving the 2017 Creative Arts Award from Brandeis. He used interviews with students and research in the Brandeis archives to help inform the play about a Brandeis student who discovers comedian and free speech icon, Lenny Bruce, in the university archives and becomes inspired to do
Inside This Issue:
News: Union to hold elections Ops: Timeline of the history of The Hoot Features: Spanish books added to library Sports: Virginia wins March Madness
EDITORIAL: Thank you for supporting The Hoot
a comedy routine of his own. At the time, he was excited to write the play for college theater “because it would be a chance to write for a very large cast,” but, in newer drafts of the play, what once was an 11-person cast has since shrunk to become more commercially viable, he said. An updated script of the play was read several weeks ago in
Letter from Hoot Alumni Dear Brandeis University Student Union Senators, As both alumni of the University as well as passionate believers in democracy and free speech, we are profoundly disturbed by reports of a Union Senator’s proposal (link here) to decommission The Brandeis Hoot. Given The Hoot’s invaluable contributions to due process and transparency across the University during nearly 15 years of operations, as well as the antidemocratic precedent such a questionably motivated proposal would incur, we as alumni strongly urge the Union to vote against this course of action. Founded in 2005, The Brandeis Hoot has been Brandeis University’s independent student newspaper for nearly a decade and a half, and has spearheaded national reporting such as President Jimmy Carter’s book “Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid,” the attempted sale of donated artwork for the Rose Art Museum, the removal of Palestinian artwork from the Goldfarb Museum, racist behavior by Brandeis men’s basketball coach Brian Meehan, and much more. To say that The Hoot’s coverage is somehow redundant — or even worse, somehow detrimental — to the campus’ ongoing health is not an argument that stands to reasonable review. On any metric you choose to review, The Brandeis Hoot also is a model of sustainability and responsible fiscal spending. Over the last four years, The Hoot has never once broken $25,000 annually printing nearly two dozen issues per year, and has remained financially consistent with its spending every year — nearly half of any other publications on campus. Additionally, when this proposal was first introduced — as an environmentally based proposal, rather than a hastily composed “duality of purpose” argument — The Hoot had already pledged to reduce printing numbers, thereby reducing the publication’s financial and environmental impact further. Yet looking at this proposal on its alleged merits — if one wishes to decommission The Hoot based on duality of titles, one may wish to decommission numerous other groups who have competing titles such as “president,” “treasurer” or “secretary.” A line-by-line comparison of any organization on campus obviously fails any test of scrutiny, but the idea of multiple journalistic outlets on campus being redundant is a fallacy that is dangerous to public transparency and the principles of social justice that Brandeis values so deeply. The Hoot’s independent, community-based approach stands in sharp contrast to any other publication, and the introduction of multiple voices to the campus journalism ecosystem has only benefited the campus. And anyone viewing this proposal should ask themselves whether decommissioning The Hoot would bring any positive value to the University, or if this proposal would only succeed as a strike against free speech, transparency and social justice. Furthermore, the source of this proposal gives us deep concerns as to the motivations behind it. Beyond the antidemocratic sentiments behind such action, it is worrisome that the proposing senator has submitted this proposal just 48 hours after the publication of an article titled “Survey Circulates About Environmental Impact of Student Newspapers” (Thalia Plata, The Brandeis Hoot, April 5, 2019). In said article, the proposing Senator was reported to have released a survey about the campus’ newspapers on behalf of the Senate Sustainability Committee, when in fact he had not received the group’s authorization to act on its behalf. Furthermore, the proposing Senator himself admitted he did not communicate with key group members for his survey, adding “I changed my mind due to the unethical nature of [a fellow committee member’s] position,” alleging a conflict of interest. Yet the article also discloses that while this particular Senator is a contributor to The Justice — the entity which he recommends absorb The Hoot — he believes he has no bias in pursuing this course of action. While The Justice has since asked the proposing Senator to resign as of this writing, as fellow learned students of the University, it does not require a staggering leap of logic to see the double standard at play here. The timing of this proposal is concerning and frankly disquieting to us as alumni. While See ALUMNI, page 7
See BUYER BEWARE, page 6
Track & Field
Page 5 Page 15 Men’s place third, women’s fifth. Page 16 Page 8 SPORTS: PAGE 9 Page 10
April 12, 2019
The Bacchae Dionysus seeks revenge. ARTS: PAGE 17