November 2013 - Volume 4 Issue 4

Page 1

The SSC’s Official Science Newspaper

e rrent November 2013

thecurrent@westernssc.ca

Volume 4 Issue 4

NEUROSCIENCE

Unraveling the mysteries of human echolocation

IN THIS ISSUE...

Research shows remarkable differences in the brains of blind echolocators Mathura Thiyagarajah Graphics & Images Editor

1. 2. 3. 4-5.

Bats and dolphins are often associated with their remarkable ability of echolocation, but seldom do people realize that humans can share this skill. Human echolocation has garnered more attention in the media in the last few years, due largely in part to the research of Dr. Lore Thaler, Dr. Stephen R. Arnott, and Western’s own Dr. Melvyn A. Goodale. They demonstrated that when people who are blind emit sounds – namely clicking noises – and listen to the echoes to sense their environments, they stimulate parts of the brain that would normally be involved in the visual system, in addition to the regular activation of the auditory areas. Dr. Goodale, Director of the Brain and Mind Institute and Canada Research Chair in Visual Neuroscience, explained that these areas get “co-opted for echolocation.” While human echolocation is not a new discovery, this development raises many questions for future research and our current understanding of the brain. The research was conducted by playing pre-recorded echoes for the echolocation experts (one early-blind and one late-blind) and two sighted participants in an MRI machine. The blind participants showed activation in the primary visual cortex and were able to perceive the objects from the echoes, while the sighted participants only showed activation in the auditory areas and failed to perceive the objects. Echolocation not only involves sensing distances from objects, but also plays a role in identification and motion detection. Daniel Kish, an echolocator with staggering precision, started making clicking noises before the age of two after his eyes were removed due to retinal cancer. He has perfected this skill

and shares his ability through his non-profit organization, World Access for the Blind, by training others in echolocation. While the precision that Daniel Kish displays is extraordinary, Dr. Goodale clearly specified, “These individuals are not of superhearing. Rather, they have learned to attend to very faint echoes that we have learned to ignore. We hear these echoes all the time when moving from room to room but we do not discern them because we are

supposed stigma that clicking noises could perpetuate. However, he countered, “As one of my blind colleagues told me, ‘As if using a cane or having a guide dog does not already mark you as different.’” There is still much to explore in the area of human echolocation and its link to the visual neural areas. Human echolocation in the blind is a testament to the adaptive capabilities of the brain and the untapped potential that it possesses. Dr. Goodale

Image Courtesy of static.environmental graffiti.com

concentrating on other sounds and the use of our visual system.” In fact, he divulged that Dr. Thaler herself had started to learn how to echolocate, though it is still unknown how much a person with sight can master echolocation. The effect of whether one loses sight early or later in life on echolocation ability is something Dr. Thaler is interested in exploring. “Echolocation in people who are blind provides us with the opportunity to study the effects of age on neuroplasticity,” Dr. Goodale explains. When asked how human echolocation could have escaped the public’s awareness, he speculated that it had stemmed from the aversion towards echolocation training in the blind community because of the

shared his view, “Understanding the brain is one of the most important questions in the 21st century. Captain Kirk always used to say that space was the final frontier. I actually think that the brain is the final frontier. I believe that understanding the brain might be more difficult than understanding the universe.” To read the published paper, check out: Thaler, L. Arnott, S.R. & Goodale, M.A. (2011). Neural correlates of natural human echolocation in early and late blind echolocation experts. PloS ONE, 6(5): e20162.

For more of Dr. Goodale’s interview, visit our blog at: thecurrentssc.wordpress.com

ASK DR. GOODALE Q: Which advancement in the field of neuroscience are you most grateful for?

6-7.

A: NEUROIMAGING. It has allowed us to combine neuroimaging with traditional studies on behavourial abilities and cognitive abilities.

Q: Have you ever been a participant in a study? A: Yes, I have done my bit and been in an fMRI machine. Q: How have you found that Western has changed from when you were a graduate student? A: It is a much bigger university now. There are more buildings where there used to be parking lots and football fields. There were no bars on campus so the closest place to buy a drink was at The Ceeps.

8.

Q: Any advice for the readers of The Current?

Image Courtesy of psychology.uwo.ca

A: Follow your passion and make sure that you explore as many opportunities as you can.

Image Courtesy of uwo.ca

The sole responsibility for the content of this publication lies with the authors. Its contents do not reflect the opinion of the University Students’ Council of the University of Western Ontario (“USC”). The USC assumes no responsibility or liability for any error, inaccuracy, omission or comment contained in this publication or for any use that may be made of such information by the reader.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.