2727 Fuller Road Ann Arbor, MI 48105
The Emery
Volume 3 Issue 2 October 2017
The Student Publication of Huron High School
News Briefs
Huron student hit at crosswalk near Huron Julie Heng | Staff Writer UPDATE: The Huron student hit while crossing Huron Parkway on bike was released from the hospital and is now recovering. The crash occurred before school on Oct 12, and the injuries sustained by the student included a sprained ankle and bruises. School administrators including Principal Dr. Janet Schwamb continue to stress the importance of safety by both pedestrians and drivers, especially “near and around schools and in areas where there is significant pedestrian traffic.” There are increased risk factors for accidents, especially in the dark where visibility is limited. Having the right of way does not always guarantee cars will stop. Principal Marcus Edmondson insists the protocol of going to the crosswalk and pushing the button for flashing lights is paramount. “Safety is the biggest thing. Kids need to always use the crosswalks and wait for the cars to stop,” Edmondson explains.
Julie Heng | Staff Writer Several protesters set up graphic anti-abortion signs at Huron High School’s Huron Parkway entrance after school Oct 11. The protesters cited their cause as wanting to educate high schoolers against abortion and assist unplanned teenage pregnancies with alternative support methods. Students and parents have expressed concern with the gruesome images next to the high school, which featured bloody mutilated fetuses. “Obviously the pictures are hard to look at,” one protester said of the signage and handout pamphlets. “They share the story of the victims.” A similar protest hosted by the group “Created Equal” which advocates “against ageism” was held outside Ypsilanti High School’s campus Oct 10. Both events were held on public space right next to the school’s property line, where such gatherings are legally allowed. Created Equal has been hosting anti-abortion demonstrations throughout the Midwest, which included protests at the University of Michigan and Eastern Michigan University Oct 10 and 11.
Last week people gathered just outside the property of Huron to raise awareness for anti-abortion. Seniors Sara Soroka and Sophia Gibson talked with the demonstrators. Photo taken by Jacob Heninberg
Domino’s stops delivery to the high school George white | Staff Writer During the second week of school, the Plymouth Road Domino’s Pizza location stated it would no longer deliver to Huron High School during lunch. Many pizza-less students speculated on what prompted this new development. According to the location’s General Manager, Luke Page, the Huron administration had instructed them to stop the services. “I don’t remember, and that word was just passed to me, I never spoke with [an administrator] directly,” Page said. The Huron administration has disputed this claim, however it is uncertain why it was introduced. “The statement from Domino’s is not accurate,” said Huron Principal Dr. Janet Schwamb. “No administrator at Huron High-School has communicated this to Domino’s at any time.” Page stated that 30-35 percent of lunch deliveries to Huron are returned. “I don’t want to make that call, but it’s impacting my business pretty heavily,” Page said. “I was barely breaking even if not losing money at times.”
The Domino’s delivery location for Huron at 2601 Plymouth Rd, Ann Arbor, MI 48105, who has stopped delivering to Huron High School. Photo taken by George White.
The Huron Girls’ Varsity volleyball team kneels for the National Anthem in their game against Saline on Oct. 4. Photo taken by Shamim Wambere.
Huron joins in taking the knee Samantha Ruud | Staff Writer
Every movement starts with one person-- this one started with quarterback free agent Colin Kaepernick. When he played for the San Francisco 49ers, Kaepernick decided to take a knee during the National Anthem in support of the Black Lives Matter Movement to protest the treatment of people of color in the United States. He first kneeled on Aug. 14, at his first preseason game this season, but he didn’t gain attention until his third game. “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color,” Kaepernick told NFL media in an interview after the game, via NFL.com. “To me, this is bigger than football, and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder.” After that, more players joined in the protests, and Kaepernick opted out of his contract with the 49ers. He has still not been picked up by another team, and many people think it is because he kneeled for the Anthem. But the biggest upswing in the movement happened the weekend of Sept. 22. President Donald Trump tweeted that the NFL should “fire any sons of b****es”* who kneel for the National Anthem. Many players responded by taking a knee, locking arms, and sitting on the bench. Some teams stayed in the locker room to avoid being caught up in the politics. Most teams published statements ad-
Trump’s comments and their team’s dressing opinion felt on the issue. An MLB player
even took a knee for one game this weekend. Players from Huron, and other high schools around the country, have now started joining the protest. Freshman JV football player Brandon Rawls took a knee at Saturday’s game. He said he did it because he doesn’t agree with what Trump tweeted. “I think it was unfair,” Rawls said. “Everyone has the right to do what they want and feel how they want about certain subjects.” He has strong hopes for the movement. “I think that everybody should see that he is not the ____ for our people.” Some athletes on the women’s Swim and Dive team also decided to take a knee at some of the swim meets. “I’ve been thinking about how I can make a difference and show my opinion, and taking a knee seemed like a good way to show what I believe in,” senior swim captain Sophie Flott said. While there are many sides to this movement, senior Nathan Davis’ father, an Airman First Class veteran stationed in Tyndall AFB, Florida supports the rights of the first amendment. “It’s their right as Americans to peacefully protest. If people would just listen to what they are saying instead of telling them what to do, we might be able to come to a consensus. It’s not a slight toward America but a call to seriousness of situation of black men
being killed by bad cops. We have to remember that not all cops are bad, however we still must acknowledge there will always be some bad cops,” Davis’ father said. Athletic Director Dottie Davis said there is certainly no controversy at Ann Arbor Huron High School.
“We allow our athletes the freedom of speech, and it is their constitutional right,” said Davis. “So there is zero controversy, and we are behind our student athletes. It is up to each individual student athlete whether they want to kneel for the National Anthem.” *This word has been censored due to the context of this piece.
Girls Swim and Dive team exercises their First Amendment right of Freedom of Speech by choosing whether or not to kneel for the National Anthem in their meet against Pinckney High School
What role does politics have in the classrooms today? Julie Heng | Staff Writer To say that the country has become polarized through politics may be a slight understatement. The United States’ atmosphere has become incredibly divisive since the change of agenda that resulted from the 2016 general election. In the aftermath, classrooms are expected to remain relatively unaffected, but politics always finds a way into everyday conversation. In some ways, given the assumption that schools prepare us for the future, having politics in the classroom can be a very beneficial opportunity, as it allows students to argumentatively debate the merits and consequences of various actions and beliefs. However, real life does not work out in the cookie-cutter way that many envision. In Ann Arbor, a city that overwhelmingly voted for the liberal ticket (Washtenaw County tallied 128,025 Clinton-Kaine votes compared to 50,335 Trump-Pence votes), it may be especially easy to align with one side. Students can often be quick to judge and bite, which can lead to even more exclusion for those with a minority opinion. Naturally, questions arise over where should the line be drawn. Is there room for teachers to lean towards one end of the political spectrum in class? Or should all political debates stay off the table altogether? One of Huron’s U.S. history teachers, Sarah Roldan-Dodson, sits at her desk at the front of her room, flanked by a bust of Lincoln and a large American flag. She mentions that political discussions in classrooms are not usually incited by teachers themselves, but they are more of a response to questions that the students themselves make, especially in her history classes. There, Roldan-Dodson explains, she makes an effort to emphasize making connections between events that have transpired in the past with what may be unfolding in the news. She went on to explain how several primary sources concerning Chinese exclusion and Japanese internment and how her students voluntarily draw
parallels with the current status of immigration, such as the travel ban or DACA. “[I]f we see something that has happened in the past [occur in the present], I think it is relevant to discuss.” Huron U.S. Government and Global Politics teacher Andrew Face agrees earnestly. “Current events should play a role because they help keep subject matter relevant to the students, which I think can engage students,” Face said. Of course, this is not to say that prejudice is completely removed on the part of the teacher. Even historical interpretations can vary based on political alignments, and many can argue the benefits or consequences of wars and legislation. More often than not, teachers incorporate politically-infused commentary, references, or opinions in lectures. Over Roldan-Dodson
are addressed and respected without any potential fistfights brewing between students. Whatever the method, the key here is to ensure that no one’s integrity or dignity is intentionally attacked. There is no place for students to feel vulnerable or at risk. “[T]he teacher’s role is to act as a facilitator and a mediator and to ensure that students are focusing on the issue and not making it become personal,” Face said. “School is a safe environment for students to engage in civic dialogue in the real world.” However, “the teacher holds the power in the classroom, and, if they pick a side, those who do not agree can sometimes (if outnumbered) have a harder time expressing their ideas,” senior Soham Naik said. H e believes the teacher’s ultimate role is to point out as many ideas as possible and sometimes play devil’s advocate to stimulate students in discussion. “What we sometimes forget is that there are others who don’t follow the same political ideology as we do. Just because our political outlooks do not coincide doesn’t mean any of us is more correct,” Naik added. This is also the general consensus given by experts in the education field. Schools constantly face a struggle regarding what skills students should be taught and what concepts they should instead personally explore and formulate. Diana E. Hess is the co-author of The Political Classroom: Evidence and Ethics in Democratic Education and the Dean of the School of Education at the University of
“
We’ll be reading a primary source, and a student will connect it to modern day—so [politics is] brought out by the conversation in class
“
Anti-abortion protesters gather outside Huron
60 percent of polled students notice occasional political references made by teachers in class. “[N]early everywhere you look, there is politics, even in classes that have nothing to do with it,” freshman Josh Cullen noted. He firmly believes that the place for politics is only in social studies classes and that teachers have one goal: to make “the conversations proper, not a scream fest.” However, politics does inevitably find a way into science labs and ELA lectures. Another solution, proposed by sophomore Dante Bailey. The best method of prevention, he argues, would be to have the teacher not have the class discuss these topics out loud. Rather, they could strictly belong on opinion-based surveys and essays. This way, all viewpoints
Wisconsin-Madison. In an nprEd interview, she explains about several conclusions made about politics in the classroom. In her book, based on a study she conducted from 2005 to 2009, she studied the political leanings and behaviors of 21 teachers in 35 schools. The one important thing for teachers to remember, according to Hess, is to not “give students the impression that there’s a political view that they should be working toward.” “[E]ven though there can be really good ethical reasons for teachers to share [their views], in a very polarized time, that sharing can be misinterpreted….That being said, we have no evidence from the study of teachers who were actively and purposely trying to indoctrinate kids to a particular point of view,” Hess said. In conclusion, “this feeling that the public seems to have that teachers by definition are trying to push their political views on students is just false.” One needs to recognize that most teachers who add political-leaning references do so unconsciously, not to provoke hostility. One must realize that teachers, after all, are human and maintain their own grounds when it comes to political beliefs. They may be very vocal about their beliefs, but it’s not to alienate those with other perspectives. Many say they would welcome an intellectual debate as to why a different outlook makes more sense. Students do generally want to engage in political discussion, especially as it pertains to a developing world stage in which they are growing up. The role of politics in the classroom is not meant to divide. Politics can be used as a tool in order to better the communication between those with different beliefs and engage lively debates that better us as free-speaking citizens of the United States. Roldan-Dodson sums it up. “Sometimes I think politicians could actually learn a lot from the students,” she concluded. “I think [students] bring far more mature answers and discussions to the table… and they support each other.”