FEBRUARY 2012
CELEBRATING 132 YEARS AS CANADA’S PREMIER HORTICULTURAL PUBLICATION
VOLUME 62 NUMBER 02
The fruits of deregulation are spinning out of reach How to harness an unwieldy reform process KAREN DAVIDSON Of all the issues facing horticulture, the relationship with governments is proving to have ever greater importance. Ted McMeekin, Ontario’s new agriculture minister may have his facts right about agriculture being neck and neck with the auto industry as an economic driver, but the stone cold reality is that his ministry’s budget represents only one per cent of the provincial total. And that meager portion is about to be sliced again. “We have to reinvent the delivery of government services,” he told the recent annual general meeting of the Ontario Fruit and Vegetable Growers’ Association (OFVGA) in a barely veiled preview of the cuts to come. That’s not good news for horticulture that generates $1.5 billion in market receipts (2010 OMAFRA), second only to dairy that generates $1.78 billion. The language is code for more userpay services, in some instances, thousands of dollars for permits and reviews. Repeatedly, the issues that came to the floor of OFVGA’s annual meeting concerned relationships with various provincial ministries beyond agriculture: finance, natural resources, environment, transportation. A minor one is the no-travel policy outside the province that’s preventing horticulture specialists from attending knowledge transfer
INSIDE Food safety lessons from U.S. cantaloupe
Page 5
OFVGA AGM highlights
Page 14
Focus: Crop protection
Page 26
www.thegrower.org P.M. 40012319
Up in the air. That’s the state of the Ontario government budget as everyone waits for looming cuts. Agriculture minister Ted McMeekin (centre) visits with Mac James, (L) Leamington potato grower and new chair of the Ontario Fruit and Vegetable Growers’ Association. They are joined by Ray Duc, (R) Niagara-on-the-Lake grape grower and new vice-chair. Photo by Denis Cahill.
meetings in Gatineau, Quebec – a quick car ride from Ottawa. More substantially, the industry is grappling with regulatory burdens
on handling washwater in vegetable operations and rainwater from the roofs of greenhouses. As Bob Seguin, executive
director, George Morris Centre, so astutely identified in a recent paper, growers feel a kinship with the Greek mythological figure of
Tantalus. A mere mortal, he was greatly favoured by the gods. CONTINUED ON PAGE 3
OFA seeks moratorium on wind turbines KAREN DAVIDSON Wind turbines, symbols of the greening of Ontario’s energy, have only served to polarize rural communities. That’s why the Ontario Federation of Agriculture (OFA), the province’s umbrella farm organization, has called for a freeze on wind turbines until questions can be answered on pricing, health and nuisance issues. “We are hearing very clearly from our members that the wind turbine situation is coming to a head – seriously dividing rural communities and even jeopardizing farm succession planning,” says OFA president Mark Wales. “The onus is on our provincial government to ensure the interests of rural Ontarians are protected.
OFA is speaking up to clearly outline the issues that must be addressed right now.”
“
We are hearing very clearly from our members that the wind turbine situation is coming to a head.” ~ Mark Wales, President OFA
The timing couldn’t be more critical as a review of the Feedin-Tariff (FIT) pricing scheme is expected this spring. Wales was to meet energy minister Chris Bentley in late January to discuss how to resolve these key issues.
In a position paper, OFA stated that it has worked with the provincial government since 2007 to clarify regulations, while cautioning farmers on the pitfalls of wind leases and initial enticements of lucrative pricing. Now that many farmers have committed, particularly on the shores of Lake Erie and the Shelburne area, the provincial government is looking to lower prices. OFA says that municipalities would be better positioned to plan for wind farms and to study whether current minimum 550metre setbacks from houses are sufficient. Under the current Green Energy Act, municipalities have no jurisdiction over where turbines will be constructed. While the province’s objective is to pioneer green energy – and
indeed it leads all other Canadian provinces with 2,000 megawatts of wind power capacity -- the economics don’t support the business case. The federation says that the electricity can’t always be stored because it’s produced at non-peak times and is exported at a loss. Ironically, the province has halted any offshore development in the Great Lakes pending further study, while shovels are in the ground for new wind turbines on land. At press time, the federation’s website posed the question: OFA has taken a stand on industrial wind turbine development. Are you happy with the new position? More than 90 per cent of respondents agreed, representing 607 votes.