The Guardsman, Vol. 158, Issue 4. City College of San Francisco

Page 1

THE GUARDSMAN

VOL. 158, ISSUE 4, OCT. 1 - OCT. 14, 2014 | CITY COLLEGE OF SAN FRANCISCO | SINCE 1935 | WWW.THEGUARDSMAN.COM | @SFBREAKINGNEWS | IG: THEGUARDSMAN | FREE

INSIDE

People of California vs. ACCJC

Commission violates law

Superior Court Judge Curtis Karnow agrees with U.S. Department of Education that the commission failed to form a complete evaluation team during City College investigation By Santiago Mejia

@santiagomejia santiago@theguardsman.com

The Guardsman

New bike law Automobiles must leave space for passing bicyclists » Story on page 3

Campus artwork Masterpieces at Ocean campus right under your nose » Story on page 5

Ferguson shooting Mike Brown, Trayvon Martin, Alejandro Nieto... police brutality is nothing new » Story on page 6

The Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges violated federal law, ruled Superior Court Judge Curtis Karnow on Sept. 19. The 40-page ruling was made following a Sept. 10 hearing requested by both parties for summary adjudication. Karnow stated he has the power to restore the status of City College’s accreditation prior to the challenged issues, but any relief the People of California are entitled to will have to wait for the scheduled Oct. 27 trial. “Trials are usually needed only when there are important disputes about the facts. If there aren’t any, parties may ask the court to decide issues without a trial,” Karnow said. “So these parties brought motions for summary adjudication, by which they hope to show that (1) there are no disputed facts for a trial, and (2) the law requires me to find in their favor.” Out of the 22 issues presented by both parties, Karnow found one undisputable issue by the People that fulfills the motion for summary adjudication. The issue was the commission failed to have more than one academic on the 2013 evaluation team, violating federal law. The other 21 issues will be battled out in the Oct. juryless trial in front of Karnow. The 2013 evaluation team members were hand picked by the commission, was in charge of evaluating City College’s progress towards reaching accrediting standards. The team reported their findings and sent recommendations to the commission. The commission’s policy states it will “include educators, academics, administrators and members of the public on evaluation teams.” But it does not state how many of each are required on a team. At first, Karnow was uncertain if the commission broke the law. “What’s enough academics? 1, 2, 3, 5? I don’t know, nobody’s addressed this,” Karnow said. Karnow decided the commission broke the law after Deputy City Attorney Tom Lakritz, representing the People, brought Karnow’s attention to a letter from the U.S. Department of Education sent last year to the commission’s president. The DOE said one academic was not enough. Additionally, the DOE noted that the evaluation teams sent to City College included a “large number of administrators in comparison to the number

Superior Court Judge Curtis Karnow deliberates during a Sept.9 hearing. (Illustration by Olivia Wise/Contributor)

of faculty members.” Additionally, commission members were found participating in the evaluation teams, but the commission’s policy does not state its own members may serve on the teams.

Karnow filed an injunction earlier this year preventing the commission from terminating City College’s accreditation pending the outcome of the trial. City Attorney Dennis Herrera,

representing the People of California, filed the lawsuit against the commission in Aug. 2013. Herrera claimed the commission unlawfully decided to terminate City College’s accreditation.

Campus News Briefs Arming campus officers surfaces once again Arming City College police to ensure campus safety is seriously being considered, college officials said. Currently, City College is one of two community colleges that don’t arm their officers, reported the San Francisco Examiner. The other college is Pasadena Community College. The idea to arm officers surfaced at a listening session on Sept. 5 when the discussion turned to public safety and whether campus police were well trained and equipped to respond to criminals with weapons on campus. At that point, Chancellor Art Tyler said it might be time for a conversation about whether to arm campus police, reported the Examiner. “One of the things that perhaps we should do is have a discussion through the participatory governance process to determine whether or not we should continue the way we are and whether or not that unarmed

status for our police officers is satisfactory,” he said. Although trained and licensed by state law to use firearms, City College police instead carry two types of batons and pepper spray, which has been the case at least since the agency transitioned from a security department in 2001, the Examiner reported. If arming City College police gets the green light, Police Chief Andre Barnes told the San Francisco Examiner, it will involve 28 sworn officers.

New law requires more transparency of ACCJC California’s 112 community colleges must be more transparent, thanks to legislation recently signed into law. Gov. Jerry Brown signed into law Assembly Bill 1942 on Sept. 24 that require an accrediting agency to report accreditation decisions to the Legislature, such as last summer’s vote by the Accrediting Commission for Community and

Junior Colleges to revoke City College of San Francisco’s accreditation. Additionally, the Board of Governors will be required to review the accreditation status of community colleges within a particular district to determine if the district is meeting the minimum conditions mandated by the board for accreditation, reported the San Francisco Examiner. Authored by Assemblyman Rob Bonta, D-Oakland, and co-authored by San Francisco’s Democratic assemblymen Tom Ammiano and Phil Ting, AB 1942 was unanimously supported by both the Senate and Assembly. “In signing my AB 1942, Governor Brown has reinforced the importance of having a transparent and fair accreditation process for community colleges in California,” Bonta said in a statement to the San Francisco Examiner. “These new requirements will help guarantee access to affordable, high-quality education for millions of California students.” Briefs continued on page 2


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
The Guardsman, Vol. 158, Issue 4. City College of San Francisco by The Guardsman - Issuu