The Harvard Crimson - Volume CXLIX, No. 13

Page 1

The Harvard Crimson THE UNIVERSITY DAILY, EST. 1873

|

VOLUME CXLIX, NO. 13 |

CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS

|

WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 9, 2022

LETTER PAGE 6

SPORTS PAGE 8

SPORTS PAGE 8

A response from 73 faculty members to the Comaroff letter

Women’s hockey claim 2022 Beanpot title with victory over Boston College

Midfielder Fred Asare-Konadu gives back to youth in Florida

Suit: Harvard Ignored Harassment Claims HUPD Advisory Board Meets By ISABELLA B. CHO and ARIEL H. KIM CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS

Three graduate students filed a lawsuit against Harvard on Tuesday alleging the school ignored years of sexual harassment and retaliation by professor John L. Comaroff, who was placed on unpaid leave last month. The suit, filed by three graduate students in the Anthropology Department, alleges that Harvard mishandled Title IX complaints and allowed Comaroff to intimidate students who threatened to report him, including the plaintiffs. The suit — filed by Margaret G. Czerwienski, Lilia M. Kilburn, and Amulya Mandava — charges that Comaroff committed physical and verbal sexual harassment, including unwanted kissing and groping. In the 65-page filing, the students took sharp aim at Harvard, which they allege “watched” as Comaroff retaliated against accusers and “allowed its investigatory process to be used in service of Professor Comaroff’s campaign of professional blacklisting.” The lawsuit alleges that Comaroff subjected Kilburn “to a pattern of gender-based ha­

rassment and assault continuing from 2017 until at least April 2019 using threats, intimidation, and coercion.” He also allegedly “threatened, intimidated, and coerced” Mandava and Czerwienski for warning others about his sexual misconduct “with the goal of inducing them to stop their speech and opposition to his sexual harassment and gender discrimination.” The suit, filed in federal court, charges that Harvard knew of Comaroff’s alleged misconduct when it hired him in 2012 and failed to act after repeated reports of verbal and physical harassment. It also accuses the University of refusing to take action against Comaroff until the press reported on the harassment allegations. Comaroff, who is not named in the suit, denies the allegations of misconduct. In a statement Tuesday, Comaroff’s lawyers — Norman S. Zalkin, Ruth K. O’Meara-Costello ’02, and Janet E. Halley — wrote that he “categorically denies ever harassing or retaliating against any student.” Harvard spokesperson Rachael Dane declined to comment.

“This is a case about Harvard’s decade-long failure to protect students from sexual abuse and career-ending retaliation.”

At its first meeting of 2022, the board discussed campus safety and police transparency. By SARAH M. GIRMA and BRANDON L. KINGDOLLAR CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS

The Lieber trial resulted in the highest-profile conviction to date by the Department of Justice’s China Initiative, a controversial program launched under the Trump administration targeting those suspected of “trade secret theft” and “economic espionage.” The initiative has faced criticism for alleged prosecutorial misconduct and a disproportionate focus on individuals of Chinese heritage. Prosecutors dropped a similarly high-profile case under the China Initiative against Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor Gang Chen on Jan. 20, less than a month after Lieber’s conviction. Chen faced some of the same felony charges as Lieber. Lieber’s attorneys identified the charges against Chen as one example of “a string of hollow prosecutions” brought forward under the China Initiative, a program they criticized as “flawed.”

The Harvard University Police Department Advisory Board discussed redefining campus safety and working toward greater department transparency at its first meeting of the semester last Wednesday. The board, which first convened last March, was established after an external review concluded the University’s private police force required major departmental reforms to bring transparency and campus engagement. The external review also prompted the creation of a Reimagining Community Safety working group, which includes two HUPD Advisory Board members as well as faculty, staff, and administrators from across the University. “The University should engage in a community-driven, stakeholder-informed process of defining what ‘public safety’ is at Harvard and re-imagining how it can best be achieved,” the review suggested. At its meeting Wednesday, the HUPD Advisory Board provided feedback on an early draft of the working group’s plan to hold a series of forums focusing on three core features of campus safety. These areas include physical safety; belonging and ideological safety; and mental, social, and emotional safety, according to Annabella Morabito, the newest member of the board. Currently, the board consists of thirteen members, including professors, students, and administrators. Noah A. Harris ’22 – who was previously president of the Harvard Undergraduate Council – is the only undergraduate serving on the board.

SEE LIEBER PAGE 4

SEE HUPD PAGE 4

“The results have been devastating: Professor Comaroff and his enablers have destroyed the educational opportunities and careers of countless students.”

SEE COMAROFF PAGE 3

CAMILLE G. CALDERA—CRIMSON DESIGNER

Lieber Files Motion for New Trial By ISABELLA B. CHO and BRANDON L. KINGDOLLAR CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS

Harvard professor Charles M. Lieber — pictured here in December 2021 — has requested a retrial after being found guilty of lying about his ties to a Chinese recruitment program. MAYESHA R. SOSHI—CRIMSON PHOTOGRAPHER

Attorneys for Harvard professor Charles M. Lieber filed a motion Monday for an acquittal or new trial, over a month after he was convicted in federal court on six felony counts. Lieber was found guilty in a December trial of two counts of lying to federal officials about his involvement with the China-sponsored Thousand Talents Program. The renowned nanoscientist was also convicted of four tax-related offenses. Calling their client’s conviction a “manifest injustice,” Lieber’s lawyers wrote in a memorandum that Lieber’s statements to investigators were “warped by the government.” They also reiterated a previous call to suppress statements the chemist made in a post-arrest FBI interview. The government has until March 7 to register opposition to the defense’s request.

Shelters Hold Steady Students Protest Despite Omicron By JULIA J. HYNEK and KALEIGH M. KUDDAR CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS

A lmost two years after the pandemic’s start, Cambridge homeless shelters have held steady operations amid the spread of the Omicron variant. Local shelters, including Harvard Square Homeless Shelter and Y2Y Harvard Square, have successfully implemented Covid-19 protocols in accordance with public health guidelines, limiting transmission among staff and guests through the spike in Omicron cases this winter. Harvard Square Homeless Shelter and Y2Y Harvard Square practice social distancing, mask-wearing, and regular disinfection, which are measures the institutions have maintained since the early days of the pandemic. Both shelters are staffed by student volunteers through the Phillips ­

INSIDE THIS ISSUE

Harvard Today 2

Brooks House Association. Jim Stewart, the director of First Church Shelter — a Cambridge shelter that serves men experiencing homelessness — said handwashing, masking, and rapid testing have largely limited infections. “We’ve tried to be consistent all the way through, we went, at the beginning of the pandemic, 10 months without any infections,” Stewart said. At HSHS, volunteers are required to be vaccinated against Covid-19, according to HSHS administrative director Henry N. Lear ’23-’24. “We ask everyone to be masked at all times. All our volunteers need to be vaccinated,” Lear, a Crimson magazine editor, said. “We don’t require our guests to be vaccinated. Certainly, we encourage it and do what we can to connect people to vaccine resources, but it’s not

SEE SHELTERS PAGE 5

News 3

Editorial 6

Hummus Company By ELLA L. JONES and MONIQUE L. VOBECKY CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS

Harvard Out of Occupied Palestine held a rally in Harvard Yard Tuesday to call on the University to stop serving Sabra hummus in its dining halls due to the company’s ties to the Israeli Defense Forces. Protesters gathered around the John Harvard Statue and chanted phrases like “Don’t buy products laced with hate, Sabra funds a racist state.” HOOP organizers delivered speeches to a crowd of roughly 20 protesters and spectators. HOOP is a campaign, spearheaded by the Harvard College Palestine Solidarity Committee, ­

SEE HUMMUS PAGE 3

Sports 8

Students gathered in front of Massachusetts Hall on Tuesday to protest Harvard’s use of Sabra products in their dining halls. J. SELLERS HILL—CRIMSON PHOTOGRAPHER

TODAY’S FORECAST

SUNNY High: 41 Low: 24

VISIT THECRIMSON.COM. FOLLOW @THECRIMSON ON TWITTER.

happy meal


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.