The Harvard Crimson THE UNIVERSITY DAILY, EST. 1873 | VOLUME CXLVI NO. 15 | CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS | WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 13, 2019
EDITORIAL PAGE 4
NEWS PAGE 3
SPORTS PAGE 6
The struggle to create an Ethnic Studies program persists.
Harvard Business School Professor Emeritus Wick Skinner dies at age 94.
Women’s Hockey loses an overtime heartbreaker in the Beanpot final.
Univ. Sanctions Lawsuits Likely Won’t Be Dismissed Faces Title IX Filing By SANJANA L. NARAYANAN and SAMUEL W. ZWICKEL CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS
Legal experts say judges will likely not immediately dismiss two lawsuits alleging Harvard’s single-gender social group penalties are illegal. Lawyers for the University filed two motions to dismiss the suits — one in state court and the other in federal court — Friday evening. But according to analysts, Harvard’s arguments are unlikely to convince the judges to throw out the cases right away. The lawsuits, filed in December 2018, allege the College’s sanctions on single-gender social organizations constitute sex-based discrimination and infringe upon students’ freedom of association. In their initial complaints, the plaintiffs allege the policy violates the United States Constitution and federal anti-discrimination law Title IX, as well as the Massachusetts Constitution and the state’s Civil Rights Act. The social group policy, which took effect with the Class of 2021, prohibits members of single-gender Greek organizations and final clubs from holding campus leadership positions and athletic team captaincies, as well as receiving College endorsement for prestigious fellowships like the Rhodes.
By ALEXANDRA A. CHAIDEZ and AIDAN F. RYAN CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS
A transgender woman filed a lawsuit against Harvard and Title IX officer Brigid Harrington alleging the University violated Title IX law and Massachusetts laws by discriminating and retaliating against her after she reported an admissions officer for sexual harassment. The 15-page complaint — filed Jan. 22 at the United States District Court for Massachusetts — details several instances in 2017 when the plaintiff, dubbed “Jane Doe” throughout the document, said she was sexually harassed and discriminated against on the basis of her transgender status. The complaint alleges that shortly after she reported an admissions officer for sexually harassing her, she was denied admission to Harvard Business School and the Graduate School of Education. The lawsuit states the complainant faced “two express incidents of gender-based discrimination” that the “defendants failed to either investigate or act on.” It names the University, the Board of Overseers, the President and Fellows of Harvard College, and Office for Dispute Resolution investigator Brigid Harrington as defendants. Harrington declined to comment. The plaintiff lays out a series of demands in the suit, asking the University and Harrington to issue a “declaratory judgment” admitting they unlawfully retaliated against her in violation of Title IX and state law. Title IX is a federal law prohibiting institutions that receive federal funding from discriminating against people on the basis of gender. The complaint names several Massachusetts laws that Harvard allegedly violated, including laws that prohibit discrimination and retaliation on the basis of gender or sexuality. The plaintiff also asks to receive a “permanent injunction requiring Harvard to conduct
SEE TITLE IX PAGE 3
SANCTION ANALYSIS
MARGOT E. SHANG—CRIMSON DESIGNER
By ANDREA M. BOSSI and ANNIE C. DORIS CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS
Harvard students and employees joined thousands of marchers from across the country in Washington D.C. Tuesday to rally for the preservation of Temporary Protected Status, a program that provides some immigrants with temporary refuge in the United States if their home countries are affected by armed conflict or natural disaster. “I believe in the power of marches like this one. I don’t think Trump is really scared of 5,000 people showing up in D.C. It happens often for various issues,” Salma Abdelrahmam ’20, who traveled to D.C. for the march, said. “I think it’s
H UW STL
W
C
H M MIT
C C
B
C
C
UWM
U C
Y
MARGOT E. SHANG—CRIMSON DESIGNER
By MICHELLE G. KURILLA CRIMSON STAFF WRITER
Datamatch, a free matchmaking service run by the Harvard Computer Society, is now available to students at 14 schools. Program organizers expanded Datamatch’s reach
INSIDE THIS ISSUE
Harvard Today 2
SEE SANCTIONS PAGE 3
Harvard Affiliates March in DC for TPS more about what conversation this sparks. It’s easy to end TPS when no one knows what TPS is.” The march began at 10 a.m. with a press conference in front of the White House, where Representatives Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) and Ayanna Pressley (D-Mass.) spoke to attendees. Then, roughly 5,000 people marched toward Capitol Hill in the rain, ending their demonstration hours later in front of Congress, according to Harvard employee and attendee Julio Perez. Perez, who came to the United States from El Salvador and was granted TPS 18 years ago, is protected until this upcoming September or — potentially — March of 2020, if
MIN JIN LEE TALK
SEE TPS PAGE 3
Bestselling author and Radcliffe Institute Fellow Min Jin Lee gave a talk at the Radcliffe Institute Tuesday titled “Are Koreans Human?” AMANDA Y. SU—CRIMSON
Datamatch Sends Love to More Campuses
B C
Plaintiffs in the Massachusetts case are the international parent group of sorority Alpha Phi, Harvard’s newly reinstated chapter of Alpha Phi, and a management company for chapters of sorority Delta Gamma. In the federal suit, the plaintiffs are the international organizations for two sororities, Kappa Alpha Theta and Kappa Kappa Gamma; the parent groups for two fraternities, Sigma Alpha Epsilon and Sigma Chi; Harvard’s chapter of Sigma Alpha Epsilon; and three anonymous College students who are also members of all-male social clubs. Sean P. Callan, an attorney at Fraternal Law Partners, said he thinks it would be “difficult” for the judges in both cases to dismiss the suits at this stage. Harvard argued in its Friday filings that the international Greek organizations do not have standing to bring the suits because they are speaking on behalf of their members. Callan, though, said he believes the courts will need more information to evaluate the University’s claims, so the cases will likely proceed. “I think that the arguments that Harvard’s advancing are inherently fact-driven, and I don’t think that just on the face of these pleadings, that we can say that these plaintiffs have not
from last year, when the service was available at four colleges and universities. HCS, which launched the program in 1994 exclusively for Harvard College students, also offered Datamatch to students at Brown University, Columbia University, and Wellesley College in 2018.
News 3
Editorial 4
Datamatch’s efforts to partner with campus satirical publications was critical for its expansion, according to co-Supreme Cupid Russell F. Pekala ’19, who helps oversee the program at the College. “We wanted to pair with people that would want to do the stuff we were unable to on the ground at those schools, which included writing school-specific questions, getting the word out about Datamatch, getting people excited about it,” Pekala said. “That’s why we kind of targeted organizations similar to Satire V at other schools.” This Valentine’s Day, Datamatch will share the love on thirteen other campuses, in addition to Harvard: Boston College, Brown University, Carleton College, the University of Chicago, the Claremont Colleges, Columbia University, Cornell University, Harvey Mudd College, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Wellesley College, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Washington University in St. Louis, and Yale University. Michael Dizon, a student at
Sports 6
Washington University in St. Louis, worked alongside two other students to lead Datamatch’s efforts on his campus. Dizon wrote in an email that he enjoyed launching the service on campus. “At first I became really apprehensive about taking on what felt like a massive task… and I wanted to decline the offer until next year, when I had more time to prepare,” he wrote. “But I had a long call with Russell Pekala, and I remember him saying, ‘As long as you would have fun running this, we would have fun supporting it.’ So I started to have fun with it.” Pekala said the support Harvard Datamatch organizers have given to students at other schools has helped them bring the program to their campuses. Harvard organizers have overseen the service’s matchmaking algorithm, provided students with materials to help with publicity, and helped them send mass emails to other undergraduates, he said. Brow n Universit y ’s
SEE VALENTINE PAGE 3
TODAY’S FORECAST
Whitehead Appointed New Head of Library By ALEXANDRA A. CHAIDEZ and AIDAN F. RYAN CRIMSON STAFF WRITERS
Martha Whitehead, the vice provost for digital strategy and university librarian at Queen’s University in Ontario, has been named as the next leader of the Harvard University Library system, the University announced Tuesday. Whitehead’s appointment comes months after former University Librarian Sarah E. Thomas announced her retirement last year. She led the system for five years. “I am thrilled to be joining Harvard, where the library and the University’s mission are so interwoven, and where there is such a rich legacy to build upon,” Whitehead said in a press release. “I’m honored to be entrusted with leading the library forward during this complex period in the information realm.” Her selection comes after an international search conducted by a committee comprising University faculty members,
CLOUDY High: 43 Low: 26
administrators, and library leaders. The search process also included two town-hall meetings. University Provost Alan M. Garber ’76 and Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences Claudine Gay wrote in an email to University affiliates that they are “delighted” that Whitehead will take the helm of the Harvard Library. “The library is one of Harvard’s greatest jewel,” Garber said in a separate press release. “Martha recognizes that it is a uniquely valuable resource to our students, researchers, other members of the Harvard community, and to the world. She is singularly qualified to take this institution to the next level.” At Queen’s University, Whitehead led strategic planning initiatives and oversaw organizational changes, including fostering digital research infrastructure and implementing new information systems, according to the release.
SEE LIBRARY PAGE 3
VISIT THECRIMSON.COM. FOLLOW @THECRIMSON ON TWITTER.
quesadilla slices