Issue 20

Page 1

Volume 118 Issue 20

The Record Horace Mann’s Weekly Newspaper Since 1903 Courtesy of East Wind West Wind

record.horacemann.org February 19th, 2021

Historians reframe mass incarceration Professors Elizabeth Hinton and Brandon Terry present in History Speaker Series Emma Colacino and Claire Goldberg Staff Writers

BLACKPINK IN YOUR AREA EWWW club members perform dances around school.

East Wind West Wind hosts annual Asia Night

Jiya Chatterjee and Rachel Baez Contributing Writers Last Thursday, East Wind West Wind (EWWW) held its first ever remote Asia Night, which featured Upper Division (UD) students and teachers participating in performances and presentations that celebrated Asian culture. “Asia Night is very much the entire essence of East Wind West Wind distilled into a single evening,” EWWW Co-President Rachel Zhu (12) said. “It’s a night of celebration and positivity — a kind of huge family gathering — that essentially embodies the kind of community that we’re trying to build in the school.” The event opened with a lively performance of “Gangnam Style” by 22 faculty and staff members, including EWWW advisor Jennifer Huang and English teacher Rebecca Bahr. While Huang was initially hesitant to participate, due to her camera shyness, she enjoyed filming it, and convinced Bahr to participate as well. The dance preceded nine other acts and presentations, including Zhu’s recitation of her original poem, “Second Generation Ruminations,”

which discussed her place as a second generation immigrant in America and how she felt being in such a “precarious position.” “The poem is about knowing, but not quite knowing, exactly what your parents have been through to get to the U.S., while also about living a kind of life that is affected by both a bitter sense of unbelonging but also a guilt that says, ‘Well, look at everything that went into bringing you here and giving you these opportunities,’” Zhu said. “I think it’s something a lot of students in our community can really relate to.” Following that, Olivia Coward (8) read an original poem she wrote about her grandfather, informing the attendees about the challenges that Asians go through in America. The rest of the night was filled with other acts including Ashley Chung’s (11) cover of Korean singer Taeyon’s “Can You Hear Me,” copresident Samantha Tsai’s (12) and Daphne Tsai’s (9) dance to the song “Naughty” by the South Korean duo Irene and Seulgi, a fashion show showcasing outfits from all across Asia, and a final dance to a K-pop medley featuring the entire club. The K-pop dance performance takes place almost every Asia Night; in fact, it was the performance that drew Tsai to join EWWW as an

underclassman. This year, she was in charge of the compilation of video performances. Around 70 members from across the school community virtually attended the performances on Thursday night on YouTube. “I went to Asia Night to support my friends in East Wind West Wind, and also to see the art the club had created,” Dalia Pustilnik (11) said. Upper Division Library Department Chair Caroline Bartels, who attended Asia Night, said the online format did not negatively affect the show or dilute the purpose of the event. Bartels was pleased that the students had the opportunity to share their cultures with the school, she said. Tomoko Hida (11) spent hours preparing for her two performances. For her first performance, Hida, along with Michael Shaari (11), prepared a presentation about an interview they had conducted with Japanese contemporary artist, Kiyo Hasegawa, as a part of ‘The Japan Periodical,’ an organization of which Hida is the vice-president. “We were able to present on Japanese culture, [which is] very integral to my identity,” she said. For her second act, Hida, along with the rest of Sinfonietta, the see Asia night on pg. 3

Debate team competes at annual Harvard tournament Danny Cornstein Contributing Writer This past weekend, 50 members of the school’s Debate Team participated in the 47th Annual Harvard Debate Tournament and debated against over 500 teams virtually. In Varsity Public Forum, two teams advanced to Triple-octafinals, the round of 64, and Sean Lee (10) and Maeve Goldman (9) earned their first bid to the Tournament of Champions, a final national championship. Five members of the team also earned speaker awards, and Co-President Emily Shi (12) finished third out of 497 varsity debaters. The team performed well this weekend, Co-President Annabelle Xing (12) said. In Novice Public Forum, the division for freshmen, eight teams qualified to Tripleoctafinals. Out of those teams, Grant Sheft (9), Daniel Pustilnik (9), Athena

Rem (9), and Rizaa Fazal (9) advanced to octafinals, the round of 16. “The tournament allowed me to meet new people from around the world while also becoming closer to my fellow HM peers, especially those I do not have classes with,” Sheft said. Attending national tournaments such as Harvard’s allows the team to build camaraderie, Brett Karpf (11) said. In preparation for the Harvard tournament, teams have been researching the benefits and harms of urbanization in West Africa since winter break. For novices, the preparation process included research, drills, and practice debates, Pustilnik said. The team felt confident entering the event, given the preparations, Lola Stern (9) said. “Without the help of the seniors and juniors, we would not have been able to do so well,” she said. Debaters prepared arguments that both supported and opposed the

urbanization of West Africa. One of Pustilnik and Sheft’s main arguments was that urbanization leads to widespread education, which is one of the greatest solutions to mass poverty. However, the duo said that one of the downsides to urbanization in West Africa was that people residing in rural areas — a large portion of the West African population — would be neglected as resources would be funneled to urban development. Usually, the team would travel together and stay at the same hotel, but this year, the debaters competed from home, which made it difficult to keep track of debaters and judges, Xing said. To keep everyone together, Co-President Sam Chiang (12) created a “Debate Check,” mimicking the school’s Symptom Check, to ensure that members of the team were ready to debate. The hardest part of debating online see Debate on pg. 3

Guest speakers Professor Elizabeth Hinton and Professor Brandon Terry discussed the rise of mass incarceration in the sixth installment of the Upper Division (UD) speaker series: “How did we get here?: Race and the Rise of Mass Incarceration” on Thursday night. The event was moderated by Eli Scher (12), Nya Marshall (12), and History teacher Dr. Lauren Meyer. Professor Hinton, who is one of the leading experts on criminalization and policing in the U.S., is an Associate Professor in the Department of History and the Department of African American Studies at Yale University, according to the Speaker Series website. Professor Brandon Terry is an Assistant Professor of African and African American Studies and Social Studies at Harvard University, where he earned his BA from and graduated magna cum laude. Terry also earned his PhD in Political Science and African American Studies from Yale University. In the event, Hinton described mass incarceration as part of a historical tendency in the U.S., where new forms of incarceration emerge every time the bounds of citizenship are expanded to marginalized groups, she said. “Just as we dismantled Jim Crow laws and passed the voting rights act in the 1960s, Johnson declared the War on Crime,” she said. The War on Crime, part of Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society program, birthed mass incarceration by creating a role for the federal government in funding prisons and policing, she said. Backlash against movements for racial justice enabled federal policy makers to turn ordinary street crime into national security threats, fueling the carceral state, Terry said. “Policy makers took an ordinary mugging and treated it as if a Black person was trying to overthrow the government,” he said. “This was really the start of militarizing the police and treating standard street violence with over the top military responses.” In expanding the lens of mass incarceration back to the 1960s to include Johnson’s War on Crime, Hinton reveals how both liberalism and conservatism played a crucial role in creating the rise of mass incarceration, history teacher Dr. Lauren Meyer said. The bipartisan dimension of mass incarceration demonstrates how it is the result of a structural inequality, rather than bad policies, Hinton said. The speakers also explored the relationship between violent and nonviolent expressions of protests, and how one depends on the other. Terry spoke about Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and his ardent defense of non-violence. “Oftentimes King’s power depends on this delicate dance between the violence of the oppressive order and the violence of

Black folks defending themselves,” Terry said. “He’s trying to walk a narrow tightrope of keeping those at bay, while transforming the society through this practice of reconciliatory demonstration.” This narrative clearly contradicted the traditional narrative taught in school that violent protests are bad, Sasha Snyder (12) said. “The speakers seemed to imply that nonviolent protest relies on violence as a threat,” she said. “I think this is a provocative idea, which I had not really considered, but the more I thought about it the more it made sense.” This portrayal of MLK brought more nuance to the conversation of criminal justice, Ericka Familia (12) said. “They showed how MLK really paved the way for people to be able to defend the dignity of ordinary Black people who found themselves on the wrong side of the law, because he encouraged breaking laws of an unjust social system.” Hinton also addressed Black community members’ calls for more policing. Hinton discussed a term she coined as “selective hearing” where out of all the demands made by Black communities, the only policies put into place are the punitive ones such as harsher sentencing. Walker McCarthy (11) had not considered how politicians could either unintentionally misinterpret the demands of a community, or intentionally misinterpret the demands of a community based on their own political interest and goals, he said. Black community members’ call for more policing is often a last ditch effort for order, Hinton said. “By the 1980s, communities [of color] had suffered from disinvestment in their local municipalities that the police were the last institution standing,” she said. “If your son is addicted to crack cocaine and is posing a threat to you, you don’t have the option to seek treatment. If you’re in danger, the only social service provided to you as a poor person of color is calling the police.” Marshall was interested to hear about Terry’s answer to this question, which explained that over time, mass incarceration has become a more taxing process with longer sentencing, she said. However, Terry explained that Black community members can call the police on members of their community or family without understanding the consequences of incarceration. “When people call on the police for their own families, they are not expecting to sentence their family to a lifetime of poverty,” he said. This example stood out to Scher because it captured how Black people can run out of options due to systemic inequalities. “Regardless of how you stand on these issues, Terry showed how incarceration acts on poor Black communities in a way that makes you ready to fight for change.”


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Issue 20 by The Horace Mann Record - Issuu