GET PHYSICAL: Learn about community through Walks with Talks and More A2
Seeing potential Crestwood softball coach thinks team can take next step FRIDAY, MARCH 21, 2014
| Serving South Carolina since October 15, 1894
75 cents
B1
Jury: Johnson is guilty Clarendon man gets life in 2011 double murder BY JIM HILLEY jim@theitem.com (803) 774-1211 “Your family asks for mercy,” Circuit Court Judge Jeffrey Young told Justin Johnson shortly after a jury found him guilty in the shotgun murders of 9-month-old Jayden Caraway and the child’s great-grandmother, Maxine Caraway, in a Manning residence on April 6, 2011. “You were shown mercy when the solicitor did not seek the death penalty in this case. “I will show you the same mercy you showed Jayden and Maxine Caraway,” the judge said before Johnson received three consecutive life sentences plus 30 years. Johnson was also found guilty of kidnapping, burglary and the possession of a weapon in the commission of a violent crime. The jury found him not guilty of the attempted murder of Jayden’s mother, Kaisha Caraway. “In a civil society, we are ingrained to protect and give aid to the young and the elderly,” Young said. “To have a baby sitting in a high chair gunned down by your hand is absolutely beyond understanding. “It is my intention to sentence you to the maximum, and I have done that,” Young said. “It is my intention to use the law of South Carolina to make sure you never walk among the citizens of this state again.” Few who attended Johnson’s trial will forget the image of baby Jayden Caraway slumped over in his high chair, his short life ended by a 12-gauge shotgun blast through his right eye, or the photos of Maxine Caraway, sprawled on her back next to her car, hair curlers spread in the grass by the force of the shot that took her life. The jury found that the victims were killed by Johnson after he and Kaisha Caraway argued over access to money in his bank account and allegations Jayden was not his son. Before the sentencing, public defender Scott Robinson echoed what the prosecution had said at the beginning of the trial. “There are no winners here; everybody has lost,” he said. “Promising young people are either dead or facing prison.” “This is not the Justin Johnson anybody knew; it was an
Justin Johnson’s mother, above, is consoled after Johnson was found guilty Thursday in the slayings of 9-month-old Jayden Caraway and the child’s great-grandmother, Maxine Caraway. Kaisha Caraway, center at left, mother of Jayden Caraway, watches as Justin Johnson, right, is asked if he wants to make a statement by the judge. The jury found Johnson not guilty of the attempted murder of Kaisha Caraway. PHOTOS BY MATT WALSH / THE SUMTER ITEM
SEE VERDICT, PAGE A3
What makes a pedophile? BY BRISTOW MARCHANT bmarchant@theitem.com (803) 774-1272 The school choir teacher is accused of having sex with one of her students. A pastor faces charges he took advantage of his young parishioners. An older boy is accused of criminal sexual conduct by a younger relative. All of these cases have
VISIT US ONLINE AT
the
.com
made news in the Sumter area in the past month. What is going on? Why would adults in a trusted position risk their freedom, their career, their reputation, to commit a sexual act on a child? Those are the questions that flash through any layman’s mind when he or she hears
CONTACT US Information: 774-1200 Advertising: 774-1237 Classifieds: 774-1234 Delivery: 774-1258 News and Sports: 774-1226
SEE PEDOPHILE, PAGE A6
Supreme Court may take up Virginia sex registry case BY SAM HANANEL The Associated Press WASHINGTON — She was a 24-year-old swimming instructor who had a sexual affair with a male student under 16. The woman was convicted
DEATHS, B7 Dorothy L. Wilson Emma D. Moore Lillian P. Holliday Julia J. Boyd Sammie Lee Oliver
Tara D. Graham Tyrus Archie Richard Jenkins Jr. Annie Lee T. Johnson William L. James
in Virginia in 1993 of unlawful sex with a teenager and served 30 days in jail. She was listed on the state’s sex offender registry and could have tried to get her name removed at some point but didn’t.
SEE SEX REGISTRY, PAGE A8
WEATHER, A8
INSIDE
NOW THIS IS MORE LIKE IT
3 SECTIONS, 22 PAGES VOL. 119, NO. 133
Sunshine and clouds today; partly cloudy tonight HIGH 74, LOW 49
Classifieds C1 Opinion A7 Comics C5 Television B8 Lotteries A8