02-17-12 Vol. 33 No. 26

Page 1

WWW.THELEAVEN.COM | NEWSPAPER OF THE ARCHDIOCESE OF KANSAS CITY IN KANSAS | VOL. 33, NO. 26 FEBRUARY 17, 2012

BATTLE LINES DRAWN Archbishop Naumann pans president’s ‘fix’

K

By Joe Bollig Leaven staff

ANSAS CITY, Kan. — On Feb. 10, President Barack Obama offered a policy change to a birth control mandate in his health care reform plan. Some have called the policy change a compromise, while others called it an accommodation. The bishops called it unacceptable. “We were not consulted in advance,” said the bishops in a U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops statement. “Today’s proposal continues . . . to threaten government coercion of religious people and groups to violate their deeply held convictions.” Among the bishops who vigorously oppose the mandate is Archbishop Joseph F. Naumann. He gave The Leaven an opportunity to sit down with him and have a conversation about his concerns about the mandate.

Q.

You said in your initial reaction to President Obama’s Feb. 10 press conference that his announcement gave you “a glimmer of hope.” Has your assessment changed?

A.

When I said glimmer of hope, I meant the glimmer was that the president was saying what had been promulgated on Jan. 20 wasn’t necessarily the final decision. He seemed to understand, at least, [that] what had been proposed was not acceptable. As I understand it, and we still don’t have adequate details on what the president is actually proposing, but from what I understand of his so-called accommodation, it isn’t adequate.

Q. It still has problems? A. It has numerous problems, the most fundamental problem being

that the insurance providers for reli-

President Barack Obama unveiled a compromise on the federal mandate on contraceptive coverage on Feb. 10 with Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius. Obama outlined a plan that would allow religious employers not to offer such services to their employees but would compel insurance companies to do so. Cardinal-elect Timothy Dolan (far right) of New York said that U.S. bishops do not see the White House as truly willing to accommodate their concerns over infringements on religious freedom. Likewise, Archbishop Joseph F. Naumann has spoken out against the mandate, saying there are still numerous problems with it. gious institutions would be required to provide these so-called services. That seems to be [what others] have called an “accounting gimmick,” because it’s impossible not to believe that the insurance providers are going to pass this cost back to their clients, the church. There is no such thing as free services. Someone has to pay for these. The idea that so long as the insurance company is the one paying for it, but we’re being mandated to purchase insurance that provides this, it’s still a problem. I don’t think the accommodation is really an accommodation.

Q. The concerns about free-

dom of religion and conscience remain?

A.

Right now, this is still an attack on freedom of conscience. It doesn’t do anything for entities that would be insured by a self-insurance program as we are here at the archdiocese. We are our own insurance carrier, so this doesn’t do anything in those circumstances. In other circumstances, it creates an appearance of something that is different, but there is no substantive difference. It also does nothing to protect individuals who object because of con-

science. In effect, it would exclude any practicing Catholic [from] being involved in health insurance, because they’ll have to provide these so-called preventive services.

Q.

Do you see the mandate as ideologically driven?

A.

I think it’s a very serious assumption that underlies these policies. . . . women’s fertility and pregnancy are treated as a disease. See “ARCHBISHOP” on page 4

LENTEN REGULATIONS

All Catholics 14 years of age and older are obliged to abstain from meat on Ash Wednesday, Feb. 22, and all Fridays of Lent. Catholics 18 to 59 years of age are obliged to fast on Ash Wednesday and Good Friday — a fast consisting of one normal meal and two lesser meals, with no eating in between. It is also recommended that Catholics find opportunities throughout the Lenten season to complement their fasts with prayer, reception of the sacraments of reconciliation and the Eucharist, and positive works of charity.

CONFESSION

The sacrament of reconciliation will once again be made available at most churches in the archdiocese from 6-7 p.m. every Wednesday of Lent.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
02-17-12 Vol. 33 No. 26 by The Leaven - Issuu