The Murray State News April 17, 2015
TheNews.org
Vol. 89, No. 28
FIRST STEP
Editor’s Note: The Murray State News changed the name of the woman and decided to not name the alleged perpetrator or any other students involved.
Amanda Grau Staff writer
agrau1@murraystate.edu
It took Lily Smith two days to fully understand she had been raped. She said as she stood in the shower thinking about the events of Nov. 7, 2014, she wished the hot water running over her head were acid, eating away flesh and memories. “If I didn’t ask for this, then what does that make it? The shock of the word ‘rape’ hit me,” Smith said. It took another three days for her to gather the courage to come forward about what happened. A saga of unreturned phone calls and email chains ensued, during which she learned the Murray State administrator assigned to guide her through the judicial process is the adviser to the accused rapist’s fraternity. Colby Bruno, a case advocate with Victim Rights, said that’s a conflict of interest. “This is just an objectively wrong thing to do,” Bruno said. “He oversees the process. He can make it more or less difficult or spend time not getting back to her.” Victim Rights, an advocate group based in Boston, Mass., and Portland, Ore., provides free legal aid for sexual assault victims. However, the group was not involved in this case. After 51 emails spanning six months, Smith got a judicial hearing, scheduled to take place behind closed doors April 20. The man accused by Smith declined to be interviewed.
On Nov. 12, Smith decided she needed to speak with authorities about the alleged rape. But when she went to the Women’s Center, ready to recount the events of Nov. 7, she was greeted by a student worker and a clipboard of paperwork. Smith said she wasn’t mentally stable. She couldn’t fill out the paperwork. Smith was told Abigail French, Women’s Center director and a counselor trained to take on sexual assault cases, was the only person who could see her, but was unavailable at the time. Smith moved to the Counseling Center, where she was told her case would be put in a file to be discussed at the weekly meeting. Someone would be in touch the following week. A delay was the last thing she said she wanted. “I’m in the trenches,” Smith said. Having to “hang tight for a week” was a big ask, she said. In the mean time, she was directed to the Title IX office. The office, though, is not easy to find in Wells Hall. The Title IX office also is known as the Office of Equal Opportunity (its name on the Wells Hall directory marquee) and as the IDEA office, which stands for Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. A student must follow signs to the IDEA office through the subterranean first floor of Wells Hall. It’s hidden for a reason, said Camisha Duffy, Murray State’s Title IX coordinator. “People are coming forward and we don’t want the office to be a public place,” Duffy said. Once she found the office, Smith retold her story to three University officials: Duffy, Mike Young, interim associate vice president of Student Affairs, and Duffy’s secretary. Murray State’s process for handling sexual assault complaints divides cases between Duffy and Young. Employee-to-student sexual assaults are handled by Duffy, and student-to-student cases are handled by Young. Students who come forward about a sexual assault can first report it to different authorities, such as a residential adviser or the police. But that point of contact often serves only as an entry way to Murray State’s judicial process, as Smith found out. After a debriefing with Duffy and Young, Smith was given the option to move forward with criminal charges. Smith decided to talk to the police. Because the assault took place off campus the case fell under the jurisdiction of the Murray Police Department. The tall, male officer entered the Title IX office in uniform. Smith was left alone with him to
‘It had taken over my life.’ How one traumatic night for a student became a six-month struggle with Murray State.
see TAKEN OVER, 2A
TIMELINE OF EVENTS
Smith seeks help
Smith leaves Smith meets with message Young to discuss for Young University action 6th
12th
Young emails Smith before leaving town 3rd
24th
DEC.
NOV. 20th
7th
The alleged rape occurred
Graphic by Taylor McStoots/The News
INSIDE
Smith finds out Young is adviser for accused rapist’s fraternity
MARCH
Young Smith tells her meets to not with give up Robertson hope
4th
18th
Smith tells adviser she doesn’t want to work with Young
20th
11th
13th
12th
Young’s last contact until 2nd Feb. 3 Smith emails Duffy about not hearing from Young
Registrar’s Office confirms receiving Smith’s withdrawal
8th
FEB.
Early Dec.
Smith meets with Murray Police detective
WHAT’S
JAN.
Smith leaves Murray without packing
Date of judicial hearing
APRIL
25th
Smith files official grievance against accused rapist
16th
Smith receives confirmation that withdrawal has been processed Graphic by Mary Bradley/The News
TIME CAPSULE
OUR VIEW
WOMEN’S TENNIS
ALL CAMPUS SING
SGA collects items for new time capsule, 6A
Cum laude GPA change is abrupt, but good, 4A
Team stays No. 1 and heads to OVC tournament, 1B
The tradition takes to Lovett’s steps for another year, 5B