.org
the
ranger Serving San Antonio College since 1926
An independent forum of free voices
Volume 88 Issue 12 • Feb. 14, 2013
210-486-1773 • Single copies free
PENNY WISE
R.T. Gonzalez
For a direct link to theranger.org, download a qr reader from the app store today
/readtheranger
/therangervideo
Students vote on doubling activity fee
Private vs. federal loans Students who apply for loans can get money to help pay for college and living expenses. A private loan is provided by private banks or credit unions, which may offer more money than a federal loans processed by the U.S. Department of Education. When students apply for private loans, banks recommend they have co-signers to ensure someone will be liable if the student does not pay. Some banks, like Wells Fargo, do not require students to be U.S. citizens to apply if they have a cosigner who is, said Joel Rodriguez, a personal banker at Wells Fargo. A student without established credit will also need a co-signer. Banks like to see students who are financially stable and will be able to pay the bank back, Rodriguez said. Rodriguez said that even if students could afford to pay back the loan in a lump sum, he recommended paying back in increments because it will show borrowers understand the responsibility of making payments. Some banks, such as Wells Fargo and Discover Bank, offer discounts on loan interest for making payments on time and take off percentages for applying for automatic loan payments. Though federal loans do not offer discounts, federal lenders take off 0.25 percent of loans when students apply for automatic payments. An adviser in the financial services office at this college, Belinda Gonzales, recommends students apply for federal loans over private loans because they tend to have lower interest rates. FAFSA offers students two types of direct loans — subsidized and unsubsidized. Subsidized loans by the federal government are awarded to students who show financial need, and interest does not accrue until six months after they graduate. Unsubsidized loans do not require the student to show financial need, but interest does accrue while the student is in school and after they graduate. Students who apply for federal loans must have applied for financial aid through FAFSA and fill out the federal direct loan request on the Alamo Colleges website at http://mywebdev. alamo.edu/fa/internal-test. Visit the financial aid office in Room 101 of Fletcher Administration Center or call 210-486-9282.
@therangerSAC
Committee approves student trustee seat. By T. L. Hupfer
thupfer@student.alamo.edu
and family and asked the judge to deny the request that would give same-sex couples the same rights as heterosexual married couples. Neel Lane, attorney for the plaintiffs, argued it is harmful to family and children to deny same-sex couples the rights married couples receive in time of need without having to file (wills, power of attorney, divorce rights) for them. In 1996, the U.S. Congress passed an act known as DOMA Defense of Marriage Act. DOMA states, “No state, territory or possession of the United States, or Indian tribe, shall be required to give effect to any public act, record, or judicial proceeding a relationship between persons of the same sex that is treated as a marriage under
Students at the five district colleges will get to vote on whether they support paying a $1 per semester fee to fund study-abroad scholarships and doubling the student activity fee. Dr. Adelina S. Silva, vice chancellor for student success survey, discussed the survey at meetings of the Academic Accountability and Student Success committees of the board of trustees Tuesday. On Sept. 17, the board voted unanimously to support the $1 international education fee if a majority vote from students from all five colleges supports it. However, the name changed to the study-abroad scholarship fee to be clearer on the fee’s purpose. The fee is estimated to generate $150,000 a year and eligible students could receive up to $1,000 in study abroad scholarships. The $1 per semester credit hour rise on the student activity fee increase was discussed in a Nov. 8 committee meeting. Students currently pay $1 per semester hour. If the fee doubles, a full-time student taking 12 hours would pay $24 each semester. The student activity fee funds activities and other items deemed worthy by a Student Activity Fee Committee at each college.
See STALLS, Page 4
See FEE, Page 5
Attorney Neel Lane, bottom right, answers questions from the media Wednesday outside the John H. Wood Jr. U.S. Courthouse. The plaintiffs Cleopatra De Leon, Nicole Dimetman, Vic Holmes and Mark Phariss are together in the top center after the court adjourned. M.J. Callahan
Same-sex marriage case stalls in verdict By M.J. Callahan, Bleah B. Patterson, Pam Paz sac-ranger@alamo.edu A crowd of about 30 gathered Wednesday outside the John H. Wood Jr. U.S. Courthouse awaiting the verdict of a court case that could overturn Texas’ constitutional prohibition of marriage between same-sex couples. U.S. District Judge Orlando Garcia did not immediately rule in the case of Nicoles Dimetman and her spouse, Cleopatra De Leon, who were married in Massachusetts in 2009, and Vic Holmes and his life partner, Mark Phariss, both of Plano, who want to marry. The plaintiffs were asking the court to prohibit the state from enforcing its ban on same-sex marriage while this case winds it way through the courts.
Garcia said gay people are free to marry, just not someone of the same sex. He said his ruling isn’t important because he realizes either way, the decision will be appealed and taken to the U.S. Supreme Court. He did say when his ruling would be forthcoming. Chuck Smith, executive director of Equality Texas, worries the reason the judge is taking time to consider his verdict isn’t for the benefit of the people, but because he realizes he’ll be remembered based on the decision he makes and he wants to protect his legacy. Inside the courtroom Michael Murphy, assistant solicitor general from the Texas attorney general’s office, argued Texas needs to preserve a traditional view of marriage
Learning Framework to benefit training firm Cost of Covey training increases to $3.5 million, according to a town hall presentation. By Bleah B. Patterson
bpatterson13@student.alamo.edu
In Monday’s town hall meeting called by this college’s Faculty Senate, a slide presentation detailed the history of a core change that has faculty across the district protesting. The presentation provided fuel to the faculty fire. Included was the widespread announcement that the Alamo Colleges will serve as a guinea pig for Franklin Covey Co., to expand its market from K-12 into higher education. Representatives of Franklin Covey met twice in the fall with the Student Academic Success Council, co-chaired by Dr. Robert Vela, vice president for academic and student success, and Dr. Cynthia MendiolaPerez, associate vice chan-
cellor for student and program development. The district is collaborating with Franklin Covey, the company behind “Seven Habits of Highly Effective People” by Stephen Covey and its extensive line of training and planning materials. Covey intends to release a textbook specifically for EDUC 1300, Learning Framework, that will be required for every student taking the course. “I can’t help but think that there’s a skunk in the woodpile when I hear all of this information,” Faculty Senate Secretary Lisa Black said. Beginning in fall 2014, the Covey Training and Counseling Institute will be using the Alamo Colleges course EDUC 1300 as a model to market to other institutions implementing similar
courses, Chancellor Bruce Leslie wrote in a response to a protest from Northwest Vista College faculty. Throughout a two-year discussion, faculty members across the district have opposed implementing the course in the core curriculum in place of a humanities class, but the NVC protest centered on Leslie’s circumventing the normal process. In the meeting Monday, senate President Dawn Elmore said, “Everyone in here has been Covey-ized. Covey is all about process. If you expect our students to follow the process, then, we, too, must follow the process.” She continued, “How can we not have an intelligent dialogue just because we may not agree?” Writing center Director Jane Focht-Hansen was among the nearly 100 people in attendance. “Where’s the evidence?”
she asked, “I want to see evidence that this will be successful for college students. I want to know this will work.” “That’s because there isn’t (any),” Elmore responded. During this conversation, NVC Faculty Senate member Neil Lewis turned to NVC humanities Instructor Carlos Lopez to say “assimilation.” He referred to numerous decisions Leslie has presented to the board of trustees since his arrival in November 2006 that are aimed at forcing five individual colleges into one. Under Leslie, the five colleges now share common course descriptions, developmental education offerings, degree plans unless unique to a college, and core curriculum. Sharing student learning outcomes and textbook selections are in progress. “The burden of proof
needs to be on the other side,” English and reading Chair Mike Burton said. “We need to know if it’s successful, and unfortunately, that evidence doesn’t exist.” The presentation also indicated a five-fold increase to $3.5 million in the amount the college district has spent so far on Covey training materials. Black questioned the level of forethought put into the core change decision. “It’s like whiplash around here; I feel like I need to be wearing a neck brace.” English Professor Alex Bernal said, “The chancellor is so insistent that employers want students with leadership skills and that they don’t need English and history students, but every employer I’ve ever met is looking for critical thinkers and people with reading skills — at least any employer I’ve ever met, in my limited experience.”