The Independent Student Publication of the University at Buffalo WEEKEND EDITION v March 11, 2011 Vol. 60 No. 63 v ubspectrum.com
Sources: UB Ignores SUNY Guidelines ANDREW WIKTOR and LAUREN NOSTRO Editor in Chief and Senior News Editor The Presidential Search Committee may not be adhering to SUNY guidelines as it pursues UB’s 15th president. It has been speculated that the final candidates have already been recommended to SUNY; however, if true, UB would have violated step 10 of “The Search Process” section listed in the SUNY Guidelines for Conducting [a] Presidential Search. The step states that once finalists are selected, schools are required to schedule campus visits for each of the remaining candidates and are to publically announce the names of those left in the running. UB has taken neither of those steps. The committee, chaired by Jeremy Jacobs, has been searching for President John B. Simpson’s successor since Simpson announced his retirement on the first day of classes in late August. The current president was set to retire on Jan. 15; however, on Jan. 5, he announced he would “continue to serve as president for a limited period of time beyond Jan. 15th while the search process moves toward a conclusion,” in a stateJohn B. Simpson ment released to UB officials. Now, well into March, the UB community remains uninformed about the progress of the search. Sources have revealed – but officials have not confirmed – that the committee has narrowed its pool to two candidates who may have been recommended to SUNY: Vice Provost Satish Tripathi and another unknown individual from outside of the UB community. The ultimate decision rests with the SUNY Satish Tripathi Board of Trustees. Despite conjecture, the only comment that the university is willing to make is that it has no comment. On March 2, UB officials
released a statement saying, “It would not be appropriate for the university to comment on speculation regarding specific or potential candidates.” “The necessity for anonymity and confidentiality of the process was emphasized at every turn in that if someone is going to be a viable candidate and not be chosen, they will want to keep their position at another university,” said Joshua Boston, student representative of the UB Council. “We’re talking about provosts at other top universities, presidents at other universities, deans; people that have a lot at stake and would be extremely viable candidates, but at the end, would want to go back to their positions without the public knowing.” UB 2020 has put a strain on relations between SUNY and UB. It’s possible that SUNY may be hesitant to appoint a candidate, such as Tripathi, who shares the same vision for UB’s future as Simpson. “The relationship between UB and SUNY, since I’ve been here in 2006, has always been weak,” Boston said. “It’s been a poor relationship so far as [UB] following SUNY guidelines. I don’t think we pay particular attention to [the guidelines] but I’m not familiar with how the committee operated, as I’m on the council [and not on the search committee].” Last Friday, SUNY Chancellor Nancy Zimpher rejected both of the candidates that the Binghamton University Council Search Committee had proposed last December. Following an eight-month selection process, SUNY deliberated over the two recommended candidates for three months before throwing out both choices. Within the eight-month process, BU conducted open sessions for its five candidates over a two-week span in which 150-200 people attended, according to Pipe Dream, Nancy Zimpher Binghamton’s student newspaper. Students at UB would prefer such an open process. Mary Schwartzmyer, a freshman biology major, thinks the closed process is unfair to students who are paying tuition to attend the university. Akinsele Walker, a senior English major, thinks that students
should be involved. “We should be informed in the process of helping to elect or just [able] to give our opinion on who [we think] should be the next president,” Walker said. The last statement made by the Presidential Search Committee, issued on Jan. 20, stated how swiftly the selection process was moving.
Timeline Jan. 13, 2003 - President William R. Greiner announced his resignation as president. Greiner held the position of president since 1991. March 19, 2003* - Members of the
Presidential Search Advisory Committee for UB’s 14th President were announced. Jeremy Jacobs Jr., chairman of the University Council and the Presidential Search Advisory Committee, appointed 17 members on the committee. Greiner’s retirement was tentatively set for June 30.
Jacobs, the only person permitted to speak on behalf of the committee, is currently out of town and has consistently denied comment. Jacobs, however, was far more willing to speak in 2003 when he chaired the search committee that helped choose Simpson as UB’s 14th president. He frequently commented on election processes, but he wouldn’t comment on the candidates (see Timeline to the right).
March 28, 2003* - Speculations arose
The process of electing Simpson in 2003 is similar to the current finding of UB’s 15th president, with the exception of the controversy surrounding Scott Nostaja’s illegitimate appointment as interim president.
July 1, 2003* - Greiner announced he would remain in office past his intended date of June 30, 2003. There was no word of the progress of the Presidential Search Advisory Committee at this time.
On Aug. 30, 2010, Jacobs announced that Scott D. Nostaja, UB’s senior vice president and chief operations officer, would serve as interim president following Simpson’s retirement, in a press release. This appointment also did not follow SUNY guideScott Nostaja lines, which state that Zimpher must recommend an interim president to the SUNY Board of Trustees before he can be appointed. Nostaja later asked that his name not be recommended to the Board of Trustees. “The council recommended, with Jacobs, to elect Nostaja as interim,” Boston said. “SUNY’s reaction and the faculty’s reaction at UB was a poor one; there was no public discourse about it, it was all in one day – Simpson’s retiring, [Nostaja] as interim.” Boston assumes that if UB is following SUNY guidelines, that it must be close to the end of the process since Simpson decided to stay at his post until the end of the search. g
E-mail: news@ubspectrum.com
that Provost Elizabeth Capaldi would be appointed UB’s 14th President. Greiner was unsure of the exact date of his retirement at this time.
Aug. 27, 2003* - The process of accepting applications was nearly culminated, according to Jeremy Jacobs. Information on the candidates was kept confidential at this point. Jacobs said the search committee did not have to follow SUNY guidelines that state finalists’ names are to be announced to the public when finalists are scheduled to visit the campus. Sept. 24, 2003* - Coverage of the search by The Buffalo News stated that the selection had been narrowed to between three and five candidates. The coverage also stated that a new president could be chosen as early as the next meeting of the SUNY Board of Trustees on Oct. 28, 2003. Jacobs could not confirm the rumor but stated that there was an “element of truth in it,” according to The Spectrum.
Oct. 17, 2003* - Dr. John B. Simpson was announced as UB’s 14th President during a press conference. Simpson was expected to take office on Jan. 1, 2004, pending a ‘nearcertain’ approval from the SUNY Board of Trustees. Jan. 1, 2004 takes office.
*These dates are when the story was reported in The Spectrum. Actual dates are not confirmed.
Buffalo Small Press Book Fair Connects Readers of All Ages and Genres LESLIE TUNMOREStaff Writer
Courtesy of Chris Fritton
The Buffalo Small Press Book Fair will showcase local vendors, artists, and writers through a variety of genres.
ARTS & LIFE :: 4–5, 7 DAILY DELIGHTS :: 6 CLASSIFIEDS :: 6 SPORTS :: 8
FRI
OPINION :: 3
SAT
NEWS :: 2
WEATHER
SUN
INSIDE
g g k
80%
40%
30%
H: 38 L: 32 H: 39 L: 31 H: 34 L: 20
7
While no promises can be made for bikini weather and beach trips for those staying in Buffalo during the break, there will be an opportunity for members of the community who share a common love for books to come together.
LIFE UB Offers Support to Veterans PAGE 4
- President John B. Simpson
ARTS The WONDER YEARS PAGE 5
The Buffalo Small Press Book Fair is a oneday event that brings a variety of people including authors, poets, zine-sters, and bookmakers to the same place and encourages the sharing of creative ideas. The event, which is free to the public, will be held at the Karpeles Manuscript Library Museum on Porter Avenue in Downtown Buffalo on March 19, from noon to 6 p.m. “The book fair really is an egalitarian space that brings a diverse group of artists and authors together to share their ideas and what they’re making,” said Chris Fritton, the organizer of the Buffalo Small Press Book Fair.
Continued on Page 2
ARTS A WEEK IN INK PAGE 7