The Spectrum Volume 61 Issue 39

Page 1

Vol. 61 NO. 39

ubspectrum.com

Monday, December 5, 2011

Intervarsity Christian Fellowship Suspended SA Senate to investigate legality of club’s constitution

Steven Jackson's controversial resignation from the Intervarsity Christian Fellowship has sparked an SA investigation.

LUKE HAMMILL

Senior News Editor

The Student Association suspended the Intervarsity Christian Fellowship until further notice on Friday, and two days later, the SA Senate created an investigative committee to determine whether the club is in violation of the law and university policy by requiring its executive board members to sign a faith-based agreement. The suspension came after The Spectrum reported that sophomore history and French major Steven Jackson felt pressured to resign as treasurer of the Intervarsity Christian Fellowship (IVCF) – a national, student-led, evangelical ministry with a UB chapter – because his homosexuality didn’t sit well with the group’s executive board and staff. “All peripheral privileges afforded to Student Association clubs are revoked for Intervarsity Christian Fellowship until further notice,” wrote SA Treasurer Sikander Khan in a Friday letter to the IVCF’s executive board. The SA Senate decided on Sunday afternoon not to lift the suspension after a plea from Jackson himself on behalf of the club. (Jackson is also the speaker of the SA Assembly.) Jackson is still a member of the club, and he attended a club event on Friday night. SA Senator Travis Nemmer read a prepared statement from Jackson to those assembled in a Knox lecture hall for the meeting, which had unusually high attendance due to the IVCF issue. Many IVCF members were present, as well as numerous other concerned students from

the LGBT community and other groups. “I believe the article in Friday’s Spectrum was wholly accurate,” Jackson’s statement read. “Had my [sexual] orientation not come up, I do not believe that this would be happening right now...If [the IVCF’s requirement to sign a faith-based agreement] is illegal, I do not blame Intervarsity. I blame the Student Association for failing to properly review club constitutions and inform clubs of their legality.” Later in his statement, Jackson asked the Senate to lift the suspension. “I understand that [IVCF] is currently suspended, which means we cannot do events that we were promised space for as an SA club...My plea to the Senate: do not punish the majority, the general membership, for an unfortunate mistake [pressuring me to resign] by a minority, the executive board,” Jackson’s statement read. The Senate, though, did not lift the suspension, instead choosing to leave that decision to the SA’s executive board, which suspended IVCF in the first place. As a result, the IVCF will miss a club event scheduled for Tuesday, unless the SA executive board decides to lift the suspension before then, which is unlikely. Legal or Illegal? The Senate investigative committee was created Sunday to gather information this week and recommend to the Senate at next week’s meeting (this coming Sunday at 3 p.m., room to be announced) what action it should take toward IVCF.

Meg Kinsley /// The Spectrum

IVCF’s requiring its executive board members to sign a faith-based agreement could result in the Senate mandating that IVCF abolish the policy, imposing financial sanctions upon IVCF, suspending IVCF further, derecognizing IVCF altogether, or some combination of the above, according to a letter from SA lawyer Joshua Korman to SA President JoAnna Datz. “SA clubs – even religiously focused clubs – may not deny membership or participation on the basis of a student not professing a belief in a particular faith advocated by that club, and may not require students to sign a statement of commitment to pray and participate in a local church,” Korman’s letter reads. The committee will consist of Special Interests and Special Hobbies (IVCF’s club council) coordinator Adam Zimnicki, SA Vice President Meghan McMonagle, People of Color coordinator Anabel Casanova, and on-campus senator Daniel Ovadia. Zimnicki will chair the committee, which has the ability to decide to add members. It will likely add someone from the Student-Wide Judiciary. At Sunday’s meeting, Timothy Stewart of UB’s Campus Ministries Association (CMA), which also recognizes IVCF, expressed interest in involvement in the SA committee’s investigation, as CMA will also have to make decisions regarding IVCF. “The committee is going to attempt to get the most unbiased, factual statements about [IVCF] and the issues brought forth,” Zimnicki said. To facilitate that, the SA has added to

its Senate webpage (www.sa.buffalo.edu/ legislation) a form that allows for anyone to provide the committee with information or viewpoints pertaining to the investigation. The committee will have to decide whether IVCF – as a recipient of $6,000 in public funds via the university’s mandatory student activity fee – violated legal and/or university anti-discrimination policy by requiring elected executive board members to sign the faith-based agreement. Article 7.B.2 of UB’s Student Code of Conduct reads, “Any organization with restrictive membership clauses which discriminates on the basis of race, religion, sex (except as exempted by Federal Regulations), sexual orientation, disability, age, creed, National Origin, or veteran status will not obtain or maintain University registration/recognition.” But IVCF only requires its executive board members, who are elected by the group at large, to sign the faith-based agreement. IVCF and its defenders maintain that since anyone can become a member, the policy does not also apply to becoming a leader of such an organization. University officials disagree. In an email, Elizabeth Lidano of Student Affairs responded to the following question: “[IVCF] makes only elected officers sign the agreement. Is that OK, or is that also discriminatory, in the university’s view?” “It is also discriminatory,” Lidano said. “There cannot be any type of restrictive membership in a recognized club.”

The Cycle Never Ends

Staff Writer

After three frustrating hours, Joe Malak, a freshman biomedical science major and resident of Governors Complex, took his laundry out of the dryer only to see that his clothing was imprinted with a pattern of dark brown, small hexagons. Laundry around campus is a growing frustration amongst students living in residence halls across UB.

With over 4,350 loads done each day, according to Residential Building Services Manager Ken Kern, problems are bound to arise. After discovering he had over $200 worth of damage to his clothing, Malak had to file a negligence form in hopes of being compensated for the damages. But he didn’t have receipts to prove the price of his garments and therefore could not be reimbursed. “I was angry because I had some expensive pieces of clothing in the machine,” Malak said. “If someone could tell me how to do my laundry better, then I

“[Christian Legal Society v. Martinez] merely holds that a university can require that clubs comply with an “all-comers” policy for members and leaders so long as it consistently and equally enforces that policy. [UB] does not have an all-comers policy for leaders.” Regardless of the legal interpretation, Lidano’s statement indicates that the university will not allow IVCF to require its leaders to sign the faith-based agreement. (It’s worth noting that the university might act separately from SA.) When asked what IVCF would do if it were told that it must abolish the policy or lose SA funding, Van Bennekom said he couldn’t comment, as he’d have to discuss the matter with both his fellow executive board members and his national organization. The IVCF Constitution The Buffalo IVCF’s constitution –

Continued on Page 2

would. But I am just a college kid trying to get his clothes clean using terrible laundry machines.”

Courtesy of Ken Kern - Residential Building Services Manager

Many students, like Malak, are used to having parents do their laundry for them. College is often times the first place students must do their own washing and drying.

Empty your pockets. Machine pumps may be clogged up with small items such as loose change, bobby pins, and other such small objects.

The lack of laundry experience may be the root of the frustration behind the broken machines, according to Phil Tucciarone, a sophomore chemical engineering major and residential advisor in Governors Complex. He believes that students are to blame for the problems that arise while doing their laundry.

Ladies, the use of lingerie bags is recommended. Loose bra wires will clog the pumps.

“The machines are very different from home dryers where you could just turn it on high for an hour and let it go,” Tucciarone said. “People are also just asses in college. If someone breaks a machine, [his or her] first inclination is not to fix the problem; it’s to get out of there. It’s just [students] not respecting the environment they live in and taking it for granted.”

RACHEL KRAMER

Korman’s letter indicates that the decision applies. IVCF’s national organization does not. IVCF outreach coordinator Quinten Hall-Lochmann Van Bennekom provided his national organization’s stance on the matter via email:

Tips for Proper Washing Machine Operation

UB students are frustrated over the campus’ many laundry issues

UB students are frustrated with the faulty laundry facilities and the lack of respect that occurs in the dorm laundry rooms. Meg Kinsley /// The Spectrum

Whether or not IVCF broke the law will depend, among other things, upon interpretations of Christian Legal Society v. Martinez, a 2010 Supreme Court decision that upheld UC Hastings College of the Law’s “all-comers” policy, which barred all university-funded groups from blocking membership or participation based on a student’s status or beliefs. (And “participation” likely includes running for an elected position and holding that position.)

Only fill washers about halfway. Overfilling the washing machines will not cause clothes to wash properly, nor provide proper draining of the water used by the machine. Use HE (High Efficiency) soap. The front load washers are energy efficient and ecologically friendly. They utilize less water and as such the use of HE soap is required.

But many students, like Zach Korman, a freshman undecided major, have experiences with doing laundry before coming to college and still encounter issues.

Do not use 3-in-1 washer/dryer sheets. These have been known to break down and cause additional clogging issues for both washers and dryers.

“At the time [I was doing laundry] only two out of four machines worked [in the Spaulding Quad, building one],” Korman said. “I ended up putting my clothes in a broken machine twice, because they smelled after the first round. When I went to dry them, I ended up with brown burnt stains on one of my favorite t-shirts.”

Do not use more soap than is required. Overfilling the soap dispenser will cause excessive “sudsing,” and may not provide proper rinse.

Kern has been the services manager for 10 years and said he doesn’t know how a dryer would be able to burn clothing. They all have a safety feature that prevents the inside from getting too hot.

Wait for the “cycle complete” indicator light to turn off before attempting to open the door. Even though the machine is not spinning, the cycle is not complete until it returns to proper temperature. Opening the door early will cause the door and/or lock to break.

Continued on Page 2

Former CAS Dean Steps in as Interim Provost

REBECCA BRATEK and NATALIE LICATA

Following the departure of Harvey Stenger, Dr. Bruce McCombe has agreed to fill the position of interim provost.

said. “There are problems you can solve in the lab or on the computer, but being an administrator at that level, you deal with a bunch of problems. I never knew what was going to happen when I came to work. If you view that it is your job to help solve problems, then it is really rewarding.”

For an estimated six months, McCombe will be taking on the responsibilities of the interim provost, such as setting goals for and overseeing all academic activity at the university.

McCombe was born in the small town of Sanford, Maine and attended Bowdoin College before going on to earn his Ph.D in solid-state physics from Brown University in 1966.

“There’s always a learning process when you walk into a new job,” McCombe said. “You need to work yourself into whatever kinds of projects are going on.”

After obtaining his doctorate, McCombe went on to accept a position at the Naval Research Laboratory in Washington, D.C. There, he occupied various positions until he became the superintendent of the Electronics Technology Division in 1979. He spent two years in this position before accepting a professorship at UB.

News Editor and Staff Writer

Administrative positions are nothing new to McCombe. Since his arrival to UB in 1982, he has served the university not only as an associate professor of physics, but also as dean of the Graduate School, and most recently, dean of the College of Arts and Sciences (CAS). “If you’re a physicist, you solve problems,” McCombe

McCombe is an internationally known scholar, and he focuses his research in basic physics, applications of semiconductor nanostructures, and spin effects in semiconductors. He has authored and co-authored more than 220 articles as a fellow of the American

Physical Society.

McCombe also likes to play basketball to get away from the science world, despite his growing age. Apart from serving as dean of the Graduate School and dean of CAS, McCombe has served as associate chair and chair of the physics department, co-director of the Center for Electronic and Electro-Optic Materials, and vice provost for graduate education, among other positions. After five years in CAS, McCombe stepped down on July 1, 2011. The college teaches about 80 percent of all credit hours of all freshmen and deals with twothirds of all undergraduate students; CAS is unavoidable at this university, according to McCombe. Over the course of seven years, CAS hired over 300 faculty members – including younger faculty members and many more women – to add to the strength and diversity of the college’s faculty, according to McCombe. He attributes this success to UB2020.

I N S I D E “It was a very good vision for the university,” Mc-

Continued on Page 2

Weather for the Week:

d

Monday: Rain- H: 44, L: 33 Tuesday: AM Rain/Snow/Showers- H: 35, L: 30 Wednesday: Partly Cloudy- H: 37, L: 30

Bruce McCombe, former dean of the College of Arts and Sciences, will replace Harvey Stenger as interim provost. Alexa Strudler /// The Spectrum

Opinion * 3 Arts * 4 & 5 Classifieds / Daily Delights * 7 Sports * 8


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.