The National Newspaper of St. Vincent and the Grenadines
FRIDAY,
MAY 26, 2017
VOLUME 111, No.21
www.thevincentian.com
EC$1.50
Ali Gibson (centre) –convicted murder – being led away to the her Majesty’s Prison, from which he will return to know his fate. between August 11 and 13, 2005. THE PROSECUTION will be Their case rested entirely on seeking the death penalty in the circumstantial evidence, as case of convicted murderer Ali there was no evidence as to Gibson, 39, of Diamond. anybody seeing who killed Crown Counsel Karim Duke. Nelson gave the High Court The evidence included DNA notice of this Wednesday analysis done at the United afternoon, after a 12-member States Federal Bureau of jury, comprised of 11 women Investigations (FBI) Laboratory and one man, found Gibson in Quantico, Virginia. guilty of murdering 21-year-ld FBI DNA expert Eric Lakeitha Duke, 12 years ago. Pokorak testified via video link The jury took close to three from the United States last hours to return the verdict. week Tuesday, May 16. The matter has been In his closing arguments on adjourned to today (Friday) for Tuesday, Crown Counsel Karim mitigation. Nelson used the rope issue as The nude body of Duke, a an analogy for his case. He, Diamond resident at the time however, noted that while the of her death, was discovered in rope that strangled Duke had bushes on a pasture at two strands, the prosecution’s Diamond on the morning of rope had three. August 13, 2005. A two-strand He went on to explain that rope was tightly bound around on the first strand, witnesses her neck. Cosmore Glasgow and Maureen An autopsy showed that she Daniel, both Diamond was strangled. residents, testified that they The prosecution’s case was were at Daniel’s gate at that Duke was sexually Diamond when they saw assaulted and killed sometime Gibson walking about 25 ft. behind Duke around 8:30 pm on August 12, 2005. It was the Left: The prosecution - led by last time Duke was seen alive. Karim Nelson – has given notice On the second strand, of its intention to seek the ultimate Nelson pointed out that, based punishment. by HAYDN HUGGINS
on the expert’s testimony, Gibson’s semen was found in Duke’s vagina, and thirdly, Duke’s blood was found on the pants Gibson was wearing at the time of his arrest on August 13, 2005. The defence’s case was that Gibson was not the killer. While Gibson’s lawyer Euchrista Bruce-Lyle did not challenge the results of the DNA analysis, she took issue with the way the samples and other items were collected, packaged and stored in St. Vincent and the Grenadines, prior to them being taken to the FBI laboratory in the United States. She indicated that there was a possibility that they could have been mixed up, contaminated or tampered with, and therefore, the jury could not be sure that the samples allegedly taken from Gibson were indeed his. She noted that none of the doctors who collected the samples gave evidence to verify anything, and that there was no other evidence to corroborate that of the investigator, Selwyn Jack, a retired Sergeant of the Royal St. Vincent and the Grenadines
Maudlin Shearman, the murder victim’s sister, must have felt that justice was served. Police Force (RSVGPF). However, Nelson had said in his arguments what was important was that there was continuity in the chain of custody. He pointed out that the samples and other items were packaged, labelled, stored and ultimately taken to the FBI laboratory in the U.S. He added that what was shown in Court and identified by Jack were also identified by Pokorak as being the samples submitted for analysis. Continued on Page 3.