The National Newspaper of St. Vincent and the Grenadines
FRIDAY,
JANUARY 27, 2017
by HAYDN HUGGINS SENIOR PROSECUTOR Adolphus Delpleche has described as “unethical and unfortunate”, a news conference the police High Command held on Wednesday, January 18, to highlight a recent major firearms and ammunition seizure, and to display the guns and ammunition seized. “In my opinion, putting the exhibits (guns and ammo) on display to the public should not have happened before the matter is ventilated in a Court of Law”, Delpleche added during an interview with THE VINCENTIAN on Tuesday. The Prosecutor noted that, while that news conference was being held, there were persons detained in connection with the matter, with a strong possibility of them being
VOLUME 111, No.04
charged. Delpleche, however, explained that in a summary matter as the one in question, the holding of such a news conference and the displaying of exhibits, may not be as damaging as if the matter would have been tried on indictment. The Senior Prosecutor, who heads the Summary Division in the DPP’s Office, pointed out that in a trial on indictment, the tribunal of fact is the jury which comes from the public at large while in a summary trial the tribunal of fact comes from the bench who is the magistrate. Delpleche’s comments came four days after Chief Magistrate Rechanne Browne stated that it was “most unfortunate”, when events like
www.thevincentian.com
the January 18 news conference occur. She described the nature of such activities as a poor reflection of those who should know better. Browne cautioned, that matters cannot be tried in public since there is Court of Law, and a person is presumed innocent until proven guilty. She added that the issue of pre-trial publicity is a very sensitive and serious matter. Browne’s comments were in response to those made by attorney Grant Connell, during bail application submissions on behalf of his clients Randy Shallow and Friekesha Douglas, a Lowmans Hill couple who was appearing before the Serious Offences Court last Friday,
EC$1.50
Senior Prosecutor Adolphus Delpleche had initially withheld comments on the matter, but made no bones about his position when he did choose to comment. conference. “If you haven’t seen the exhibits, look them here,” he told The Magistrate, and held Chief Magistrate Rechanne up a copy of last Friday’s Browne had prior to (January 20) publication of Delpleche’s comments, declared the public display of THE VINCENTIAN newspaper front page article, the exhibits as “most captioned ‘Cache of weapons, unfortunate”. ammo discovered’, and picturing the guns and January 20, charged on eight ammunition seized. counts of possession in The article carried an connection with the said extensive report on the news firearms and ammunition conference held by the seizure. Commissioner. Their appearance came two The Senior Prosecutor had days after the news conference declined to comment on the was held. issue, at the hearing last Connell highlighted the Friday, saying, “I will remain issue of pre-trial publicity, silent”. referring to the news But he told THE VINCENTIAN on Tuesday, Left: The exhibits were when asked why he declined displayed at a news to comment, “I thought it was conference hosted by the the prudent thing not to COP (Ag) Reynold Hadaway comment then, because I in the company of Assistant needed time to think through Commissioner with the matter”. responsibility for Crime When contacted on Frankie Joseph (right) and Wednesday, Commissioner of Insp. Hawkins Nanton Police Renold Hadaway –Officer in Charge of SVGPF declined to comment on the Complaints and PR issue. Department.