Vinpages 08 11 13 e reader

Page 1

The National Newspaper of St. Vincent and the Grenadines

FRIDAY,

NOVEMBER 8, 2013

VOLUME 107, No.45

by HAYDN HUGGINS DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (DPP) Colin Williams has appealed Chief Magistrate Sonya Young’s decision to dismiss criminal charges against two police officers, in connection with the shooting of one of their colleagues at Rose Place, Kingstown, last December 5. According to information reaching THE VINCENTIAN, the DPP has appealed the Chief Magistrate’s decision to uphold no case submissions on charges of wounding, negligence and conspiracy against Sergeant Julius Morgan, and on charges of negligence and conspiracy against Constable Orlando Collins. The DPP has also appealed the Chief Magistrate’s decision to dismiss charges of unlawful discharge of firearm and excessive force in relation to Morgan, and wounding, unlawful discharge of firearm and excessive force in respect of Collins. The no case submissions were made in writing by Attorney Ronald Marks, representing Morgan, and Duane Daniel, defending Collins, following the Left: THE VINCENTIAN understands that DPP Colin Williams will claim that the Chief Magistrate erred in fact and in law.

www.thevincentian.com

close of the prosecution’s case June 25. The Chief Magistrate ruled October 25 that she had dismissed the other charges after considering all the evidence. She had reserved her decision on those charges following closing written submissions by the DPP and the defence. THE VINCENTIAN understands that the DPP has appealed on the ground that the Chief Magistrate erred in fact and in law in arriving at her decision. The appeal was filed October 31.

EC$1.50

Sergeant Julius Morgan, one of the two police officers whose fate still hangs in the balance.

No appeal against Forde’s acquittal Morgan and Collins, both of the Criminal Investigation Department (CID), had been charged jointly with Constable Adrian Forde, also of the CID, on the conspiracy matter, but Forde was acquitted at the close of the prosecution’s case June 25. The Chief Magistrate had concluded there was no evidence to support the charge against Forde, after she upheld his lawyer Kay Bacchus-Browne’s objection to a report Forde had given to the police, being admitted into evidence. The DPP has not appealed this decision. He had agreed, at the trial, that, once the report was not in evidence, the case against Forde would fall.

Sonya Young, Chief Magistrate, had reserved her decision on the matter after receiving written submission from both sides. Forde had given the report shortly after the incident. Bacchus-Browne objected to its admission on the basis that witness statements are not put into evidence. Continued on Page 3.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.