Tolstoy, Leo - A Calendar of Wisdom

"'$)#"+ *% !&,#*( :7?BO J>EK=>JI JE DEKH?I> J>; IEKB MH?JJ;D 7D: I;B;9J;: <HEC J>; MEHB:rI I79H;: J;NJI 8O

HBK OKHNOKR JH7DIB7J;: <HEC J>; HKII?7D 8O

'F;J;H I;A?H?D

Boa leitura, Angelitaaaa!

I9H?8D;H

=UbX\] cb BYc Jc`ghcm <fca J\Y ;ggYbh]U` =UbX\]& Bci]g <]gW\Yf QM\YbR ? kUg dUgg]b[ h\fci[\ U gYjYfY Wf]g]g cZ gYYd h]W]ga UbX XciVh((( ? WUaY UWfcgg Jc`ghcm g Vcc_ J\Y A]b[Xca cZ =cX ?g M]h\]b Oci& UbX kUg XYYd`m ]adfYggYX Vm ]h( ? kUg Uh h\Uh h]aY U VY`]YjYf ]b j]c`YbWY( ?hg fYUX]b[ WifYX aY cZ am gWYdh]W]ga UbX aUXY aY U Z]fa VY`]YjYf ]b Qbcb' j]c`YbWYR( M\Uh \Ug UddYU`YX hc aY acgh ]b Jc`ghcm g `]ZY ]g h\Uh \Y dfUWh]gYX k\Uh \Y dfYUW\YX UbX fYW_cbYX bc Wcgh hcc [fYUh ]b \]g dif gi]h cZ hfih\( ( ( ( >Y kUg h\Y [fYUhYgh Udcgh`Y cZ bcb'j]c`YbWY h\Y dfYg Ybh U[Y \Ug dfcXiWYX( Dc cbY ]b h\Y MYgh VYZcfY \]a cf g]bWY \Ug kf]hhYb UbX gdc_Yb cb bcb'j]c`YbWY gc Zi``m cf ]bg]ghYbh`m UbX k]h\ giW\ dYbYhfUh]cb UbX ]bg][\h( ( ( Q>]gR fYaUf_UV`Y XYjY`cdaYbh cZ h\]g XcWhf]bY dihg hc g\UaY h\Y dfYgYbh'XUm bUffck UbX `cd'g]XYX ]bhYfdfY hUh]cb dih idcb ]h Vm h\Y jchUf]Yg cZ 7\]agU ]b h\]g `UbX cZ cifg( ( ( ( JfiY 7\]agU g\ci`X aYUb U Wcad`YhY ZfYYXca Zfca ]`` k]`` UbX Ub[Yf UbX \UhY UbX Ub cjYf Z`ck]b[ `cjY Zcf U``( <cf ]bWi`WUh]b[ h\]g hfiY UbX \][\Yf hmdY cZ 7\]agU Uacb[gh ig& Jc`ghcm g `]ZY k]h\ ]hg cWYUbx `]_Y `cjY g\ci`X gYfjY Ug U VYUWcb `][\h UbX U bYjYf' ZU]`]b[ gcifWY cZ ]bgd]fUh]cb( ( ( (

OKHNOKR JA ODB MB OEKJ YV .@GCIB@K JD ?FLBJH

"F;J;H I;A+H?D

J\]g kUg BYc Jc`ghcmrg `Ugh aU^cf kcf_( M]h\ ]h& \Y Zi`x Z]``YX U XfYUa \Y \UX bcif]g\YX Zcf U`acgh Z]ZhYYb mYUfg& h\Uh cZ sWc``YWh]b[ h\Y k]gXca cZ h\Y WYbhif]Yg ]b cbY Vcc_t aYUbh Zcf U [YbYfU` UiX]YbWY( Jc`ghcm dih U \i[Y Uacibh cZ YZZcfh ]bhc ]hg WfYUh]cb& dfYdUf]b[ h\fYY fYj]gYX YX]h]cbg VYhkYYb +3*. UbX +3+*( ?h kUg \]g ckb ZUjcf]hY YjYfmXUm fYUX]b[& U Vcc_ \Y kci`X hifb hc fY[i`Uf`m Zcf h\Y fYgh cZ \]g `]ZY( J\Y cf][]bU` ]XYU Zcf h\]g kcf_ UddYUfYX hc WcaY hc Jc`ghcm ]b h\Y a]X'+22*g( >]g Z]fgh fYWcfXYX YldfYgg]cb cZ h\Y WcbWYdh cZ - /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRPvs7 k]gY h\ci[\h Zcf YjYfm XUm cZ h\Y mYUf& Zfca h\Y [fYUhYgh d\]`cgcd\Yfg cZ U`` h]aYg UbX U`` dYcd`YtvWUaY ]b +22.( >Y kfchY ]b \]g X]Ufm cb CUfW\ +/ cZ h\Uh mYUf4 s? \UjY hc WfYUhY U W]fx W`Y cZ fYUX]b[ Zcf amgY`Z4 ;d]WhYhig& CUfWig 7ifY`]ig& BUc'Jni& 8iXX\U& FUgWU`& J\Y DYk JYghUaYbh( J\]g ]g U`gc bYWYggUfm Zcf U`` dYcd`Y(t ?b +22/& \Y kfchY ]b U `YhhYf hc \]g Ugg]ghUbh& Cf( 9\Yfh_cj5 s? _bck h\Uh ]h []jYg cbY [fYUh ]bbYf ZcfWY& WU`abYgg& UbX \Udd]bYgg hc Wcaaib]x WUhY k]h\ giW\ [fYUh h\]b_Yfg Ug IcWfUhYg& ;d]WhYhig& 7fbc`X& FUf_Yf(((( J\Ym hY`` ig UVcih k\Uh ]g acgh ]adcfx

hUbh Zcf \iaUb]hm& UVcih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY UbX UVcih j]fhiY( ((( ? kci`X `]_Y hc WfYUhY U Vcc_ ((( ]b k\]W\ ?

Wci`X hY`` U dYfgcb UVcih \]g `]ZY& UbX UVcih h\Y =ccX MUm cZ B]ZY(t J\Y dfcWYgg cZ Wc``YWh]b[ h\YgY h\ci[\hg hcc_ cjYf Z]Zx hYYb mYUfg( Jc`ghcm VY[Ub kf]h]b[ VYhkYYb :YWYaVYf +3*, UbX @UbiUfm +3*-( J\Yb ]b \]g `UhY gYjYbh]Yg& \Y \UX ZU``Yb gYf]cig`m ]``5 k\]`Y aYX]hUh]b[ UVcih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY UbX XYUh\& \Y kUg ]bgd]fYX hc VY[]b Wcad]`]b[ k\Uh \Y h\Yb WU``YX - BLVH ?KRXJKW IRU 1YHU\ 0D\& M\Yb \Y Z]bU``m gYbh h\Y Vcc_ hc \]g diV`]g\Yf& Jc`ghcm kfchY ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s? ZY`h h\Uh ? \UjY VYYb Y`YjUhYX hc [fYUh gd]f]hiU` UbX acfU` \Y][\hg Vm Wcaaib]WUh]cb k]h\ h\Y VYgh UbX k]gYgh dYcd`Y k\cgY Vcc_g ? fYUX UbX k\cgY h\ci[\hg ? gY`YWhYX Zcf am /LUFOH RI =HDGLQJ& t >Y kci`X cZhYb fYhifb ]b \]g X]Ufm hc aYX]hUhY idcb h\]g Vci_& fYdYUh]b[ jUf]Ubhg cZ sM\Uh WUb VY acfY dfYW]cig h\Ub hc Wcaaib]WUhY YjYfm XUm k]h\ h\Y k]gYgh aYb cZ h\Y kcf`X6t Jc`ghcm WUfYZi``m gY`YWhYX h\Y Wcbhf]Vihcfg hc h\]g jc`iaY& sUacb[ h\Y jYfm VYgh kf]hYfg&t Ug \Y fYdYUhYX hc \]g Wc``YU[iYg UbX Zf]YbXg( J\Ym fYdfYx gYbhYX U k]XY jUf]Yhm cZ d\]`cgcd\]WU` j]Ykg& Wi`hifU` VUW_x [fcibXg& UbX \]ghcf]WU` dYf]cXg4 s?h k]`` VY U V][ gifdf]gY hc h\Y fYUXYfg&t Jc`ghcm kfchY& sh\Uh hc[Yh\Yf k]h\ AUbh UbX ch\Yf ZUacig h\]b_Yfg& h\Ym k]`` Z]bX ]b am Vcc_ h\ci[\hg Vm BiWm CU`cfm& Ub ib_bckb ^cifbU`]gh Zfca h\Y Kb]hYX IhUhYg& Zfca EfY[cb(t J\Y Z]fgh YX]h]cb UddYUfYX ]b +3*. ibXYf h\Y h]h`Y ?KRXJKWV RI BLVH 9HQ& ?h gUk h\fYY YX]h]cbg Xif]b[ Jc`ghcmrg `]ZYh]aY& VYhkYYb +3*. UbX +3+*& YUW\ diVx `]g\YX k]h\ U X]ZZYfYbh giVh]h`Y4 ?KH BD\ RI 8LIH$ /LUFOH RI =HDGLQJ$ UbXS` BLVH ?KRXJKW IRU 1YHU\ 0D\& 8YhkYYb +3*. UbX +3*1& Jc`ghcm kcf_YX cb h\Y Yb`Uf[YX UbX Wcad`YhY`m fYj]gYX gYWcbX YX]h]cb& Zfca k\]W\ h\]g& ]hg Z]fgh ;b[`]g\ hfUbg`Uh]cb& ]g XfUkb( ?b a]X' 7i[igh +3*/ \Y kfchY h\Y ]bhfcXiWh]cb h\Uh Zc``ckg UbX bchYX ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s? \UjY fYj]gYX UbX Yb`Uf[YX am /DOHQc GDU$ bck ]h ]g hk]WY Ug V][( <cf hkc acbh\g ? X]X bch fYUX

Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY& bY]h\Yf bYkgdUdYfg bcf aU[Un]bYg& UbX ?

ZY`h gc [ccX( ((( ? VYWUaY acfY UbX acfY Ughcb]g\YX Vm h\Y ][bcfUbWY& UbX YgdYW]U``m Vm h\Y Wi`hifU`& acfU` ][bcx fUbWY cZ cif gcW]Yhm( ( ( ( 7`` cif YXiWUh]cb g\ci`X VY X]fYWhYX hc h\Y UWWiai`Uh]cb cZ h\Y Wi`hifU` \Yf]hU[Y cZ cif UbWYghcfg& h\Y VYgh h\]b_Yfg cZ h\Y kcf`X)" J\Y aU^cf X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb h\Y Z]fgh YX]h]cb "?KRXJKWV RI BLVH 9HQ# UbX h\Y gYWcbX "- /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRP# kUg h\Uh Jc`ghcm bck [fcidYX h\Y h\ci[\hg UWWcfX]b[ hc hcd]Wg Zcf U WYfhU]b XUm& kYY_& UbX acbh\( >Y kfchY cfj^ibY -& +3*.& ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s? Ua Vigm k]h\ hZYYEZW)Y RI =HDGLQJ& ((( ? WUbbch Xc Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY(((( ? \UjY gY`YWhYX h\ci[\hgSaX [fcidYX h\Ya ]bhc h\Y Zc``ckx ]b[ aU^cf hcd]Wg4 =cX& ?bhY``YWh& BUk& BcjY& :]j]bY DUhifY cZ CUb_]bX& <U]h\& JYadhUh]cbg& McfX& IY`Z' IUWf]Z]WY& ;hYfb]hm =ccX& A]bXbYgg& Kb]Z]WUh]cb cZ FYcx d`Y #k]h\ =cX$& FfUmYf& <fYYXca& FYfZYWh]cb& Mcf_& YhW(t Jc`ghcm UXXYX UVcih Y][\h \ibXfYX cZ \]g ckb h\ci[\hg& kf]hhYb Xif]b[ \]g aUbm mYUfg cZ aYX]hUh]cb& cf hU_Yb Zfca dfYj]cig X]Ufm Ybhf]Yg( >Y [YbYfU``m ghUfhYX YUW\ XUm k]h\ Ub cdYb]b[ h\ci[\h cZ \]g ckb& UXXYX eichYg Vm ch\Yf gcifWYg& UbX Z]b]g\YX YUW\ XUm k]h\ U W`cg]b[ h\ci[\h cZ \]g ckb( 7XX]h]cbU``m& \Y kfchY U g\cfh ghcfm& cf j][bYhhY& h\fYY hc hYb dU[Yg ]b `Yb[h\ Zcf h\Y YbX cZ YjYfm kYY_( ;UW\ ghcfm WcffYgdcbXYX hc h\Uh kYY_rg acfU`& d\]`cgcd\]WU`& cf fY`][]cig hcd]W5 \Y dfYdUfYX Z]Zhm'hkc ghcf]Yg ]b U`` UbX WU``YX h\Ya ?KH >XQGD\ =HDGLQJ >WRULHV& J\Y aU^cf]hm cZ h\YgY Z]Zhm'hkc ghcf]Yg kYfY kf]hhYb Vm Jc`ghcm YgdYW]U``m Zcf h\]g kcf_5 h\Y fYgh kYfY gY`YWhYX UbX UXUdhYX Zfca kf]h]b[g Vm F`Uhc& 8iXX\U& :cghcYjg_]& FUgWU`& BYg_cj& 9\Y_\cj& UbX ch\Yfg( Jc`ghcmrg dfcgY ghm`Y ]b h\YgY >XQc GD\ =HDGLQJ >WRULHV ]g jYfm X]ZZYfYbh Zfca h\Y gcd\]gh]WUx h]cb cZ \]g YUf`]Yf bcjY`g( J\YgY ghcf]Yg& k\]W\ kYfY `UhYf [fYUh`m UXa]fYX Vm FUghYfbU_ UbX Ic`n\Yb]hgmb& kYfY kf]hhYb ]b U W`YUf& g]ad`Y& U`acgh df]a]h]jY `Ub[iU[Y&

XYg][bYX& Ug h\Ym kYfY& Zcf U k]XY UbX [YbYfU` UiX]YbWY( ?b h\Ya& Jc`ghcm WcaV]bYX g]ad`]W]hm cZ Zcfa UbX d\]`cx gcd\]WU` XYdh\( 8YWUigY h\YgY ghcf]Yg X]X bch UddYUf ]b U`` YX]h]cbg& UbX VYWUigY h\Ym UfY Ug U k\c`Y ei]hY `cb[& h\Ym Xc bch UddYUf ]b h\]g YX]h]cb( Eb :YWYaVYf ,+& +3*.& UZhYf fYUX]b[ h\Y [U``Ym dfccZg cZ h\Y gYWcbX YX]h]cb WU``YX ?KH /DOHQGDU* ?KH /LUFOH RI =HDGLQJ IRU 1YHU\ 0D\$ Jc`ghcm kfchY ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s:if]b[ h\]g `Ugh XUm ? \UjY XYgWYbXYX Zfca h\Y gd]f]hiU` UbX acfU` \Y][\hg k\YfY ? kUg U`` h\]g h]aY k\Yb ? Wcaaib]WUhYX k]h\ h\Y VYgh UbX k]gYgh h\]b_Yfg cZ h\Y kcf`X k\Yb ? WfYx UhYX am /LUFOH RI =HDGLQJ& J\]g h]h`Y kUg W\Ub[YX ]b h\Y gYWcbX fYj]gYX YX]h]cb& diV`]g\YX ]b +3*/'+3*1& hc BLVH ?KRXJKWV E\ 9DQ\ BULWHUV RQ ?UXWK$ 8LMH$ DQG .HKDYLRU /ROOHFWHG DQG -UUDQJHG IRU 1YHU\ 0D\ RI WKH CHDU E\ 8HR ?ROVWR\& <fca ]hg Z]fgh diV`]WUh]cb& h\Y Vcc_ kUg U`kUmg dfYgYbh cb Jc`ghcmrg XYg_5 ]h VYWUaY \]g ZUjcf]hY Vcc_ Xif]b[ h\Y `Ugh Z]jY mYUfg cZ \]g `]ZY( ;jYfm XUm& Zfca +3*/ hc +3+*& \Y fYUX h\ci[\hg dfYgYbhYX ]b h\Y Vcc_ Zcf h\Y WcffYgdcbX]b[ XUm cZ h\Y mYUf& UbX \Y fYWcaaYbXYX h\Y gUaY \UV]h hc U`` \]g Zf]YbXg( Eb CUm +0&+3*2& \Y kfchY hc U aUb bUaYX =igYj4 s? WUbbch ibXYfghUbX \ck gcaY dYcd`Y WUb `]jY k]h\cih Wcaaib]WUh]b[ k]h\ h\Y k]gYgh dYcd`Y k\c YjYf `]jYX cb ;Ufh\6 ((( ? ZYY` jYfm \Uddm YjYfm XUm& VYWUigY ? fYUX h\]g Vcc_(t Jc`ghcm dfYdUfYX U h\]fX fYj]gYX& g\cfhYbYX& UbX g]ad`]x Z]YX YX]h]cb k\]W\ UddYUfYX ]b df]bh ibXYf h\Y bYk h]h`Y ?KH BD\ RI 8LIH ]b +3+*& h\Y `Ugh mYUf cZ \]g `]ZY( >Y k]g\YX hc aU_Y h\Y Vcc_ YUg]`m WcadfY\Ybg]V`Y Zcf YjYb h\Y g]ad`Ygh UbX `YUgh YXiWUhYX dYcd`YvdYUgUbhg UbX W\]`XfYb( Ccgh dfcVUV`m& Jc`ghcm WcadUfYX)? /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRP hc BDU DQG <HDFH k\Yb \Y kfchY h\Uh sJc WfYUhY U Vcc_ Zcf h\Y aUggYg& Zcf a]``]cbg cZ dYcd`Y ((( ]g ]bWcadUfUV`m acfY ]adcfhUbh UbX Zfi]hZi` h\Ub hc WcadcgY U bcjY` cZ h\Y _]bX k\]W\ X]jYfhg gcaY aYaVYfg cZ h\Y kYU`h\m W`UggYg Zcf U g\cfh h]aY& UbX h\Yb ]g ZcfYjYf Zcf[chhYb( J\Y fY[]cb cZ

h\]g Ufh cZ h\Y g]ad`Ygh& acgh k]XY`m UWWYgg]V`Y ZYY`]b[ ]g Ybcfacig& UbX ]h ]g Ug mYh U`acgh ibhciW\YX(t Eh\Yf YX]x h]cbg UddYUfYX ]b EXYggU UbX Ih( FYhYfgVif[ ]b +3++'+3+,( 7 =YfaUb Wf]h]WU` YX]h]cb #hfUbg`UhYX Vm ;( IW\a]Xh UbX 7( IW\_UfjUb& :fYgXYb4 HUf` HY]ggbYf& +3*1$ ]bW`iXYX h\Y gcifWYg cZ \]g biaYfcig eichYg( 7b YX]h]cb cZ - /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRP kUg diV`]g\YX ]b Higg]U ]b +3+,& Vih UZhYf h\Y Higg]Ub HYjc`ih]cb diV`]WUx h]cb kUg ZcfV]XXYb ibXYf h\Y Icj]Yh fY[]aY& VYWUigY cZ h\Y Vcc_rg gd]f]hiU` cf]YbhUh]cb UbX ]hg biaYfcig fY`]x []cig eichYg( M\Yb ]h kUg U[U]b diV`]g\YX ]b Higg]U& ]b +33/& UZhYf h\Y fYWYbh XYacWfUh]W fYZcfag& ]h Yb^cmYX hfYaYbXcig giWWYgg& gY``]b[ cjYf -**&*** Wcd]Yg( ?h \Ug bYjYf VYZcfY VYYb hfUbg`UhYX ]bhc ;b[`]g\( J\Y Z]fgh ;b[`]g\ hfUbg]U4]cb cZS` /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRP k]`` VY U fYU` X]gWcjYfm Zcf h\Y ;b[`]g\'gdYU_]b[ fYUXYf( 9fYUhYX Vm cbY cZ h\Y kcf`Xrg [fYUhYgh bcjY`]ghg UbX h\]b_Yfg hc fYdfYgYbh h\Y jYfm VYgh cZ h\Y kcf`Xrg gd]f]hiU` \Yf]hU[Y& ]h XfUkg cb h\Y [fYUhYgh kcf_g cZ fY`][]cb& d\]`cgcd\m& UbX `]hYfUhifY h\Y kcf`X \Ug mYh gYYb( ?h VY`cb[g Uacb[ h\Y jYfm VYgh WfYUh]cbg cZ \iaUb [Yb]ig& U kcf_ k\]W\ k]`` gYfjY ]hg fYUXYfg Ug U dfUWh]WU` gd]f]hiU` [i]XY cb \ck hc `]jY ]b dYUWY k]h\ cbYgY`Z UbX \ck hc `]jY U `]ZY Z]``YX k]h\ _]bXbYgg& gUh]gZUWh]cb& UbX \Udd]bYgg( Jc`ghcmrg cf][]bU` [cU` kUg h\Y XY`]jYfm cZ k]gXca hc h\Y k]XYgh dcgg]V`Y biaVYf cZ dYcd`Y& shc YbhYfhU]b a]``]cbg cZ fYUXYfg(t J\]g U]a fYaU]bg Ug WcadY``]b[ bck& ]b h\]g h]aY cZ ]bWfYUg]b[ gd]f]hiU` bYYX& Ug ]h kUg h\Yb(

EJOMKAP OEKJ

8O B;E JEBIJEO

? hcc_ h\Y h\ci[\hg Wc``YWhYX \YfY Zfca U jYfm `Uf[Y biax VYf cZ kcf_g UbX Wc``YWh]cbg( ? ]bX]WUhYX h\Y Uih\cf cZ YUW\ h\ci[\h VYbYUh\ ]h& h\ci[\ ? X]X bch aUf_ h\Y YlUWh gcifWY cf Vcc_ h]h`Y cf kcf_ Zfca k\]W\ ? hcc_ ]h( ?b gcaY WUgYg& ? hfUbg`UhYX h\YgY h\ci[\hg bch X]fYWh`m Zfca h\Y]f cf][]bU` gcifWYg& Vih Zfca U hfUbg`Uh]cb Zfca h\Y `Ubx [iU[Yg ]b k\]W\ h\Ym VYWUaY _bckb hc aY& gc gcaYh]aYg am hfUbg`Uh]cbg a][\h bch VY Wcad`YhY`m ]XYbh]WU` hc h\Y cf][]bU`g( M\Yb ? hfUbg`UhYX h\ci[\hg Vm =YfaUb& <fYbW\& cf ?hU`]Ub h\]b_Yfg& ? X]X bch ghf]Wh`m Zc``ck h\Y cf][]bU`& igiU``m aU_]b[ ]h g\cfhYf UbX YUg]Yf hc ibXYfghUbX& UbX ca]hh]b[ gcaY kcfXg( HYUXYfg a][\h hY`` aY h\Uh U eichY ]g bch h\Yb FUgWU` cf HciggYUi& Vih am ckb kcf_& Vih ? h\]b_ h\Uh h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ kfcb[ ]b WcbjYm]b[ h\Y]f h\ci[\hg ]b U acX]Z]YX Zcfa( J\YfYZcfY& ]Z gcaYcbY XYg]fYg hc hfUbg`UhY h\]g Vcc_ ]bhc ch\Yf `Ub[iU[Yg& ? kci`X `]_Y hc UXj]gY h\Ya bch hc `cc_ Zcf h\Y cf][]bU` eichYg Zfca h\Y ;b[`]g\ dcYh 9c`Yf]X[Y& gUm& cf h\Y =YfaUb d\]`cgcd\Yf AUbh& cf h\Y <fYbW\ kf]hYf HciggYUi& Vih hc hfUbg`UhY X]fYWh`m Zfca am kf]h]b[( 7bch\Yf fYUgcb gcaY cZ h\YgY h\ci[\hg aUm bch WcffYgdcbX hc h\Y cf][]bU`g ]g Uh h]aYg ? hcc_ U h\ci[\h Zfca U `Yb[h\m UbX Wcbjc`ihYX Uf[iaYbh& UbX ? \UX hc W\Ub[Y gcaY kcfXg UbX d\fUgYg Zcf

W`Uf]hm UbX ib]hm cZ YldfYgg]cb( ?b gcaY WUgYg ? YjYb YldfYgg h\Y h\ci[\h Ybh]fY`m ]b am ckb kcfXg( ? X]X h\]g VYWUigY h\Y difdcgY cZ am Vcc_ ]g bch hc []jY YlUWh& kcfX'Zcf'kcfX hfUbg`Uh]cbg cZ h\ci[\hg WfYUhYX Vm ch\Yf Uih\cfg& Vih hc igY h\Y [fYUh UbX Zfi]hZi` ]bhY``YWhiU` \Yfx ]hU[Y WfYUhYX Vm X]ZZYfYbh kf]hYfg hc dfYgYbh Zcf U k]XY fYUX]b[ UiX]YbWY Ub YUg]`m UWWYgg]V`Y& YjYfmXUm W]fW`Y cZ fYUX]b[ k\]W\ k]`` UfcigY h\Y]f VYgh h\ci[\hg UbX ZYY`x ]b[g( ? \cdY h\Uh h\Y fYUXYfg cZ h\]g Vcc_ aUm YldYf]YbWY h\Y gUaY VYbYjc`Ybh UbX Y`YjUh]b[ ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ ? \UjY YldYx f]YbWYX k\Yb ? kUg kcf_]b[ cb ]hg WfYUh]cb& UbX k\]W\ ?

YldYf]YbWY U[U]b UbX U[U]b& k\Yb ? fYfYUX ]h YjYfm XUm& kcf_]b[ cb h\Y Yb`Uf[YaYbh UbX ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\Y dfYx j]cig YX]h]cb( ÅHUY OYXZÀYÂÃ

7@KAE "*!)

DchY hc HYUXYf4 ?b U`` cZ h\Y Vcc_rg cf][]bU` Higg]Ub' `Ub[iU[Y YX]h]cbg& Jc`ghcm \][\`][\hYX cb YUW\ dU[Y h\Y cbY eichY h\Uh acgh giWW]bWh`m YldfYggYX h\Y XUmrg h\YaY( J\YgY eichYg \UjY VYYb ]hU`]W]nYX ]b h\]g YX]h]cb( ÅL B O B M N B G E M E J

YBGPVGSX Á 8YhhYf hc _bck U ZYk h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY [ccX UbX bYWYggUfm h\Ub aUbm h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY igY`Ygg UbX aYX]cWfY( M\Uh U [fYUh hfYUgifY WUb VY \]XXYb ]b U gaU``& gY`YWhYX `]VfUfm 7 WcadUbm cZ h\Y k]gYgh UbX h\Y acgh XYgYfj]b[ dYcd`Y Zfca U`` h\Y W]j]`]nYX Wcibhf]Yg cZ h\Y kcf`X& Zcf h\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg& WUb aU_Y h\Y fYgi`hg cZ h\Y]f ghiX]Yg UbX h\Y]f k]gXca UjU]`UV`Y hc ig( J\Y h\ci[\h k\]W\ h\Ym a][\h bch YjYb fYjYU` hc h\Y]f VYgh Zf]YbXg ]g kf]hhYb \YfY ]b W`YUf kcfXg Zcf ig& dYcd`Y Zfca Ubch\Yf WYbhifm( OYg& kY g\ci`X VY [fUhYZi` Zcf h\Y VYgh Vcc_g& Zcf h\Y VYgh gd]fx ]hiU` UW\]YjYaYbhg ]b cif `]jYg( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

J\YfY UfY hcc aUbm aYX]cWfY Vcc_g k\]W\ Yl]gh ^igh hc YbhYfhU]b mcif a]bX( J\YfYZcfY& fYUX cb`m h\cgY Vcc_g k\]W\ UfY UWWYdhYX k]h\cih XciVh Ug [ccX(

$ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWU

HYUX h\Y VYgh Vcc_g Z]fgh& ch\Yfk]gY mcir`` Z]bX mci Xc bch \UjY h]aY( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

?KH GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ UHDO PDWHULDO SRLVRQ DQG LQWHOOHFWXDO SRLVRQ LV WKDW PRVW PDWHULDO SRLVRQ LV GLVJXVWLQJ WR WKH WDVWH$ EXW LQWHOOHFWXDO SRLVRQ$ ZKLFK WDNHV WKH IRUP RI FKHDS QHZVSDSHUV RU EDG ERRNV$ FDQ XQIRUWXQDWHO\ VRPHWLPHV EH DWWUDFWLYH&

BGPVGSX Â EbY cZ h\Y kcfgh dfY^iX]WYg _bckb ]g \Y`X Vm h\Y aU^cfx ]hm cZ h\Y gc'WU``YX gW\c`Ufg cZ cif h]aY& k\c W`U]a h\Uh U dYfgcb WUb `]jY k]h\cih ZU]h\( J\fci[\cih h\Y WYbhif]Yg& ]b YjYfm U[Y& dYcd`Y \UjY kUbhYX hc _bck cf Uh `YUgh \UjY U jU[iY ]XYU UVcih h\Y gcifWY& h\Y VY[]bb]b[& UbX h\Y Z]bU` difdcgY cZ h\Y]f Yl]ghYbWY( HY`][]cb gUh]gZ]Yg h\]g fYei]fYaYbh& UbX aU_Yg W`YUf h\cgY WcbbYWx h]cbg k\]W\ ib]hY U`` dYcd`Y Ug Vfch\Yfg& fYjYU`]b[ hc h\Ya h\Uh h\Ym \UjY h\Y gUaY gcifWY cZ cf][]b& h\Y gUaY hUg_ Zcf h\Y]f `]jYg& UbX h\Y gUaY [YbYfU` Z]bU` [cU`( TTTTT

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y YggYbh]U` aYUb]b[ cZ YjYfm fY`][]cb ]g hc UbgkYf h\Y eiYgh]cb sM\m Xc ? `]jY& UbX k\Uh ]g am Uhh]hiXY hc h\Y `]a]h`Ygg kcf`X k\]W\ giffcibXg aY6t J\YfY ]g bch U g]bx [`Y fY`][]cb& Zfca h\Y acgh gcd\]gh]WUhYX hc h\Y acgh df]a]h]jY& k\]W\ XcYg bch \UjY Ug ]hg VUg]g h\Y XYZ]b]h]cb cZ h\]g Uhh]hiXY cZ U dYfgcb hc h\Y kcf`X( 7h h\Y \YUfh cZ U`` fY`][]cbg `]Yg U g]b[`Y ib]Zm]b[ hfih\( BYh FYfg]Ubg VYUf h\Y]f hUcj]Xg& @Ykg kYUf h\Y]f WUdg& 9\f]gh]Ubg VYUf h\Y]f Wfcgg& Cig`]ag VYUf h\Y]f g]W_`Y accb& Vih kY \UjY hc fYaYaVYf h\Uh h\YgY UfY U`` cb`m cihYf g][bg( J\Y [YbYfU` YggYbWY cZ U`` fY`][]cbg ]g `cjY hc mcif bY][\Vcf& UbX h\Uh h\]g ]g fYeiYghYX Vm CUbih& PcfcUghYf& 8iXX\U& CcgYg& IcWfUhYg& @Ygig& IU]bh FUi`& UbX Cc\UaaYX U`]_Y( v;M7B: <BK=;B

?KH OLIH RI D SHUVRQ ZLWKRXW IDLWK LV WKH OLIH RI DQ DQLPDO&

BGPVGSX Ã J\cgY k\c _bck h\Y fi`Yg cZ hfiY k]gXca UfY VUgYf h\Ub h\cgY k\c `cjY h\Ya( J\cgY k\c `cjY h\Ya UfY VUgYf h\Ub h\cgY k\c Zc``ck h\Ya( v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh eiYgh]cb hc _YYd VYZcfY cifgY`jYg Uh U`` h]aYg ]g h\]g4 :c kY Xc h\Y f][\h h\]b[6 :if]b[ h\]g g\cfh dYf]cX cZ h]aY k\]W\ kY WU`` cif `]ZY& Xc cif UWhg WcbZcfa hc h\Y k]`` cZ h\Y ZcfWY h\Uh gYbh ig ]bhc h\Y kcf`X6 :c kY Xc h\Y f][\h h\]b[g BKHQ ( DP LQ GLIILFXOW FLUFXPVWDQFHV$ 5 DVN 3RG WR KHOS PH& .XW LW LV P\ GXW\ WR VHUYH WKH 8RUG$ DQG QRW 4LV WR VHUYH PH& -V VRRQ DV 5 UHPHPEHU WKLV$ P\ EXUGHQ EHFRPHV OLJKWHU& MY \UjY hc Zi`Z]`` \cbYgh`m UbX ]ffYdfcUW\UV`m h\Y kcf_ XYgh]bYX Zcf ig( ?h XcYg bch aUhhYf k\Yh\Yf kY \cdY h\Uh kY k]`` VYWcaY Ub[Y`g gcaY XUm& cf VY`]YjY h\Uh kY \UjY cf][]bUhYX Zfca g`i[g( v@E>D HKIA?D

@igh ]aU[]bY h\Uh h\Y difdcgY cZ mcif `]ZY ]g mcif \Udd]x bYgg cb`mvh\Yb `]ZY VYWcaYg U WfiY` UbX gYbgY`Ygg h\]b[( Oci \UjY hc YaVfUWY k\Uh h\Y k]gXca cZ \iaUb]hm& mcif ]bhY``YWh& UbX mcif \YUfh hY`` mci4 h\Uh h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY ]g hc gYfjY h\Y ZcfWY h\Uh gYbh mci ]bhc h\Y kcf`X( J\Yb `]ZY VYWcaYg U WcbghUbh ^cm(

BGPVGSX Ä ;jYb ]Z kY Xcbrh kUbh hc& kY WUbrh \Y`d Vih ZYY` cif Wcbx bYWh]cb hc h\Y fYgh cZ aUb_]bX4 kY UfY WcbbYWhYX Vm ]bXighfm& Vm hfUXY& Vm Ufh& Vm _bck`YX[Y& UbX acgh ]adcfx hUbh`m& Vm cif Wcaacb acfhU`]hm( 7LQG SHRSOH KHOS HDFK RWKHU HYHQ ZLWKRXW QRWLFLQJ WKDW WKH\ DUH GRLQJ VR$ DQG HYLO SHRSOH DFW DJDLQVW HDFK RWKHU RQ SXUSRVH$ v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug \]g VifXYb( EbY WUbbch `]jY k]h\cih h\Y giddcfh cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y5 h\YfYZcfY kY \UjY hc giddcfh YUW\ ch\Yf k]h\ Wcbgc`Uh]cb& UXj]WY& UbX aihiU` kUfb]b[g( S<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

7`` h\Y W\]`XfYb cZ 7XUa UfY aYaVYfg cZ h\Y gUaY VcXm( M\Yb cbY aYaVYf giZZYfg& U`` h\Y ch\Yfg giZZYf Ug kY``( ?Z mci UfY ]bX]ZZYfYbh hc h\Y giZZYf]b[g cZ ch\Yfg& mci Xc bch XYgYfjY hc VY WU``YX U aUb( vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

J\Y \]ghcfm cZ aUb_]bX ]g h\Y acjYaYbh cZ \iaUb]hm hckUfX [fYUhYf UbX [fYUhYf ib]Z]WUh]cb(

BGPVGSX Ā IcaYh]aYg& h\Y XUaU[Y XcbY Vm cif kcfXg ]g cVj]cig UbX gcaYh]aYg ]h ]gbrh& Vih h\Y XUaU[Y ]g bch Ubm gaU``Yf cf cif bch VY]b[ UV`Y hc gYY h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c giZZYf Zfca cif kcfXg( 7 [ibg\ch kcibX aUm VY WifYX& Vih h\Y kcibX aUXY Vm U hcb[iY bYjYf \YU`g( vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

?Z Ubm aUb cZZYbX bih ]b kcfX& h\Y gUaY ]g U dYfZYWh aUb(((( ;jYb gc h\Y hcb[iY ]g U `]hh`Y aYaVYf& UbX VcUgh' Yh\ [fYUh h\]b[g( 8Y\c`X& \ck [fYUh U aUhhYf U `]hh`Y Z]fY _]bX`Yh\ v@UaYg -4,& /

M\Yb mci \YUf dYcd`Y gdYU_ UVcih h\Y j]W]cigbYgg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& Xc bch g\UfY ]b d`YUgifY Vm X]gWigg]b[ h\YgY ]ggiYg( M\Yb mci \YUf UVcih h\Y VUX XYYXg cZ dYcd`Y& Xc bch `]ghYb hc h\Y YbX UbX hfm hc Zcf[Yh k\Uh mci \UjY \YUfX( M\Yb mci \YUf UVcih h\Y j]fhiYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& fYaYaVYf h\Ya UbX hY`` h\Ya hc ch\Yfg( v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

:c `]ghYb hc X]gdihYg& Vih VY bch gc ]bjc`jYX ]b X]gdihYg mcifgY`Z( vD?AEB7? =E=EB

? gU]X& ? k]`` hU_Y \YYX hc am kUmg& h\Uh ? g]b bch k]h\ am hcb[iY( vFI7BCI -34+

.H DIUDLG WR GHVWUR\ WKH XQLW\ RI SHRSOH E\ VWLUULQJ EDG IHHOc LQJV DPRQJVW WKHP DJDLQVW DQRWKHU ZLWK \RXU ZRUGV&

BGPVGSX Ă ?hrg ]adcfhUbh hc ghf]jY hc Xc [ccX& UbX YjYb acfY ]adcfx hUbh hc ghf]jY hc UVghU]b Zfca Yj]`( 7VghYbh]cb g\ci`X VY U \UV]h ]b mcif `]ZY5 ]h g\ci`X gidx dcfh mci ]b mcif j]fhiYg( <cf \Y k\c ]g fYgc`ihY ]b [ccXx bYgg& h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ h\Uh \Y Wci`X bch cjYfWcaY( vB7E'JPK

Fih Uh `YUgh \U`Z cZ mcif YbYf[m ]bhc aU_]b[ mcifgY`Z ZfYY cZ Yadhm k]g\Yg& UbX jYfm gccb mci k]`` gYY h\Uh ]b gc Xc]b[ mci k]`` fYWY]jY aiW\ [fYUhYf Zi`Z]``aYbh UbX \Udd]bYgg( v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

=cX hYghg YjYfmcbY& cbY k]h\ kYU`h\& Ubch\Yf k]h\ dcjYfhm( 7 f]W\ aUb ]g hYghYX ]b k\Yh\Yf \Y kci`X YlhYbX Ub Ufa cZ giddcfh hc h\cgY k\c bYYX ]h5 U dccf aUb ]b k\Yh\Yf \Y kci`X VYUf U`` \]g giZZYf]b[g k]h\cih X]gWcbx hYbh UbX k]h\ cVYX]YbWY( vJ\Y J7BCK:

? k]`` WU`` h\Y f][\h [fcca \Y k\c WUb ghcd \]g fU[Y& k\]W\ [cYg Ug ZUgh Ug h\Y ZUghYgh W\Uf]ch( Eh\Yf dYcd`Y \UjY bc dckYf5 h\Ym ^igh \c`X h\Y fY]bg( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

:R PDWWHU KRZ PDQ\ WLPHV \RX DLP WR DFKLHYH YLFWRU\ RYHU \RXU SDVVLRQV$ GR QRW JLYH XS& 1YHU\ HIIRUW ZHDNHQV WKH SRZHU RI SDVVLRQ DQG PDNHV LW HDVLHU WR JDLQ YLFWRU\ RYHU LW&

BGPVGSX Å A]bXbYgg ]g bYWYggUfm ]b fY`Uh]cbg\]dg k]h\ dYcd`Y( ?Z mci ]fY bch _]bX hc U dYfgcb& mci UfY bch Zi`Z]``]b[ mcif aU^cf cV`][Uh]cb( Oci \UjY hc fYgdYWh YjYfm dYfgcb& bc aUhhYf \ck a]gYfx UV`Y cf f]X]Wi`cig \Y cf g\Y aUm VY( Oci g\ci`X fYaYaVYf h\Uh ]b YjYfm dYfgcb `]jYg h\Y gUaY gd]f]h k\]W\ `]jYg ]b ig( v7ZhYf 7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

0R QRW EH FUXHO RI KHDUW WR WKRVH ZKR DUH WHPSWHG$ EXW WU\ WR FRQVROH WKHP$ MXVW DV \RX ZRXOG OLNH WR EH FRPIRUWHG& T v<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

#+$ :c bch dcghdcbY Zcf hcacffck k\Uh mci WUb Xc hcXUm( #,$ :c bch ZcfWY Ubch\Yf dYfgcb hc Xc k\Uh mci WUb Xc Vm mcifgY`Z( #-$ Ff]XY Wcghg acfY h\Ub U`` h\Uh ]g bYWYggUfm" Zcf ZccX& Xf]b_& g\Y`hYf& cf XfYgg( #.$ MY giZZYf gc aiW\& h\]b_]b[ UVcih k\Uh Wci`X \UjY \UddYbYX& Vih bch UVcih k\Uh \Ug UWhiU``m \UddYbYX( #/$ ?Z mci `cgY mcif hYadYf& Wcibh id hc hYb VYZcfY mci Xc cf gUm Ubmx h\]b[( ?Z mci \UjYbrh WU`aYX Xckb& h\Yb Wcibh hc U \ibx XfYX5 UbX ]Z mci \UjY bch WU`aYX Xckb UZhYf h\]g& Wcibh id hc U h\cigUbX( v7ZhYf J>EC7I @;<<;HIED

J\Y _]bXYf UbX h\Y acfY h\ci[\hZi` U dYfgcb ]g& h\Y acfY _]bXbYgg \Y WUb Z]bX ]b ch\Yf dYcd`Y( A]bXbYgg Ybf]W\Yg cif `]ZY5 k]h\ _]bXbYgg amghYf]cig h\]b[g VYWcaY W`YUf& X]ZZ]Wi`h h\]b[g VYWcaY YUgm& UbX Xi`` h\]b[g VYWcaY W\YYfZi`(

BGPVGSX Ǻ 9\f]gh]Ub hYUW\]b[ ]g gc g]ad`Y h\Uh YjYb gaU`` W\]`XfYb WUb ibXYfghUbX ]hg aYUb]b[( J\cgY dYcd`Y WUbbch ibXYfx ghUbX ]h& UbX cb`m h\cgY& k\c kUbh hc gYYa UbX hc VY WU``YX 9\f]gh]Ubg k]h\cih VY]b[ fYU` 9\f]gh]Ubg( 8iXX\U gU]X& s7 aUb k\c ghUfhg hc `]jY Zcf \]g gci` ]g `]_Y U aUb k\c Vf]b[g U `UbhYfb ]bhc U XUf_ \cigY( J\Y XUf_x bYgg X]gUddYUfg Uh cbWY( Oci \UjY hc VY dYfg]ghYbh ]b h\]g& UbX mcif gci` k]`` \UjY h\]g `][\h(t 9\f]gh YldfYggYX U`` >]g hYUW\]b[g ]b >]g `Ugh WcaaUbXx aYbh4 sBcjY YUW\& ch\Yf& Ug ? `cjYX mci( ;jYfmcbY k]`` gYY h\Uh mci UfY am X]gW]d`Yg& ]Z mci `cjY YUW\ ch\Yf(t >Y X]X bch gUm& s?Z mci VY`]YjY&t Vih s?Z mci `cjY(t <U]h\ WUb W\Ub[Y k]h\ h]aY& VYWUigY cif _bck`YX[Y ]g WcbghUbh`m W\Ub[]b[( BcjY& cb h\Y WcbhfUfm& bYjYf W\Ub[Yg5 `cjY ]g YhYfbU`( Cm fY`][]cb ]g `cjY hc U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g( 5Q RUGHU WR IXOILOO /KULVWLDQLW\$ ZH KDYH WR GHVWUR\ LWV SHUYHUc VLRQV DQG UHVWRUH LWV SXULW\&

BGPVGSX Ą Abck`YX[Y ]g fYU` _bck`YX[Y cb`m k\Yb ]h ]g UWei]fYX Vm h\Y YZZcfhg cZ mcif ]bhY``YWh& bch Vm aYacfm( Eb`m k\Yb kY Zcf[Yh k\Uh kY kYfY hUi[\h Xc kY ghUfh hc \UjY fYU` _bck`YX[Y( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

7 WcbghUbh Z`ck cZ h\ci[\hg YldfYggYX Vm ch\Yf dYcd`Y WUb ghcd UbX XYUXYb mcif ckb h\ci[\h UbX mcif ckb ]b]x h]Uh]jY( ( ( ( J\Uh ]Sk\m WcbghUbh `YUfb]b[ gcZhYbg mcif VfU]b( ((( Ihcdd]b[ h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ mcif ckb h\ci[\hg hc []jY fcca Zcf h\Y h\ci[\hg Zfca ch\Yf Vcc_g fYa]bXg aY cZ I\U_YgdYUfYrg fYaUf_ UVcih \]g WcbhYadcfUf]Yg k\c gc`X h\Y]f `UbX ]b cfXYf hc gYY ch\Yf Wcibhf]Yg( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

7 h\ci[\h WUb UXjUbWY mcif `]ZY ]b h\Y f][\h X]fYWh]cb cb`m k\Yb ]h UbgkYfg eiYgh]cbg k\]W\ kYfY Ug_YX Vm mcif gci`( 7 h\ci[\h k\]W\ kUg Z]fgh VcffckYX Zfca gcaYcbY Y`gY UbX h\Yb UWWYdhYX Vm mcif a]bX UbX aYacfm XcYg bch fYU``m aiW\ ]bZ`iYbWY mcif `]ZY& UbX gcaYh]aYg `YUXg mci ]b h\Y kfcb[ X]fYWh]cb( =HDG OHVV$ VWXG\ OHVV$ EXW WKLQN PRUH& 8HDUQ$ ERWK IURP \RXU WHDFKHUV DQG IURP WKH ERRNV ZKLFK \RX UHDG$ RQO\ WKRVH WKLQJV ZKLFK \RX UHDOO\ QHHG DQG ZKLFK \RX UHDOO\ ZDQW WR NQRZ&

BGPVGSX ÁÀ J\Y VUg]g cZ U`` YXiWUh]cb ]g h\Y YghUV`]g\aYbh cZ cif fY`Ux h]cbg\]d hc h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U`` h\]b[g& UbX h\Y WcbW`ix g]cbg UVcih cif VY\Uj]cf k\]W\ aUm VY XfUkb Zfca h\]g( 8ih k\cgcYjYf g\U`` cZZYbX cbY cZ h\YgY `]hh`Y cbYg k\c VY`]YjY ]b aY& ]h kYfY VYhhYf Zcf \]a h\Uh U a]``ghcbY kYfY \Ub[YX UVcih \]g bYW_& UbX h\Uh \Y kYfY XfckbYX ]b h\Y XYdh\ cZ h\Y gYU( vC7JJ>;M +240'1

7g kY Vf]b[ id cif W\]`XfYb& kY \UjY hc fYaYaVYf h\Uh kY UfY WUfYhU_Yfg cZ h\Y ZihifY( 8m ]adfcj]b[ h\Y]f YXiWUx h]cb& kY ]adfcjY h\Y ZihifY cZ aUb_]bX& h\Y ZihifY cZ h\]g kcf`X( v7ZhYf ?CC7DK;B A7DJ

( WKLQN WKDW WKH PDMRU REOLJDWLRQ RI SDUHQWV DQG HGXFDWRUV LV WR JLYH FKLOGUHQ DQ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH GLYLQH EHJLQQLQJ WKDW H[LVWV ZLWKLQ WKHP& vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

HY`][]cig idVf]b[]b[ ]g h\Y VUg]g cZ U`` YXiWUh]cb(

BGPVGSX ÁÁ FYfZYWh]cb ]g ]adcgg]V`Y k]h\cih \ia]`]hm( sM\m g\ci`X ? ghf]jY Zcf dYfZYWh]cb& ]Z ? Ua U`fYUXm [ccX Ybci[\6t J\Y \][\Yf h\Y dcg]h]cb mci cWWidm Uacb[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& h\Y acfY \iaV`Y mci g\ci`X VY( CUbm dYcd`Y `]jY ]b \Y][\h UbX [`cfm& Vih h\Y amghYf]Yg cZ h\]g kcf`X WUb VY fYjYU`YX cb`m hc h\cgY k\c UfY \iaV`Y( :c bch gYY_ cih Wcad`]WUh]cb( JfYUh mcif Xihm k]h\ fYgdYWh( :c bch ghiXm k\Uh mci g\ci`X bch( CcfY h\]b[g \UjY U`fYUXm VYYb fYjYU`YX hc mci h\Ub mci WUb ibXYfghUbX( v<fca 7FE9HOF>7

J\Y Icb cZ aUb WUaY bch hc VY a]b]ghYfYX ibhc& Vih hc a]b]ghYf& UbX hc []jY \]g `]ZY Ug fUbgca Zcf aUbm( vC7JJ>;M ,*4,2

IcaY cZ mcif Zf]YbXg dfU]gY mci& UbX ch\Yfg V`UaY UbX Wf]h]W]nY mci5 VY W`cgYf hc h\cgY k\c V`UaY mci UbX Zifx h\Yf Zfca h\cgY k\c dfU]gY mci( vJ\Y J7BCK:

M\Yb Ub Uffck XcYg bch \]h ]hg hUf[Yh& h\Y aUf_gaUb V`UaYg \]agY`Z& bch Ubch\Yf dYfgcb( 7 k]gY aUb VY\UjYg ]b h\Y gUaY kUm( TTTTTTTTTT v9ED<K9?KI

=HPHPEHU DOO WKH EDG WKLQJV ZKLFK \RX KDYH GRQH$ DQG WU\ WF DYRLG GRLQJ EDG WKLQJV DJDLQ& =HPHPEHULQJ RQO\ \RXU JRRG GHHGV ZLOO LQWHUIHUH ZLWK \RXU GRLQJ JRRG LQ WKH IXWXUH&

BGPVGSX ÁÂ J\YfY UfY dYcd`Y k\c hU_Y fYgdcbg]V]`]hm Zcf aU_]b[ XYW]x g]cbg Zcf ch\Yfg UbX XYhYfa]b]b[ h\Y]f fY`Uh]cbg\]d hc =cX UbX hc h\Y kcf`X5 UbX h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y& h\Y cjYfx k\Y`a]b[ aU^cf]hm cZ h\Ya& k\c []jY h\]g Uih\cf]hm hc h\Y ch\Yfg& UbX V`]bX`m VY`]YjY ]b YjYfmh\]b[ h\Ym UfY hc`X( 8ch\ [fcidg cZ dYcd`Y Wcaa]h Ub YeiU` Wf]aY( MY UfY U`` `]_Y W\]`XfYb k\c Z]fgh fYdYUh h\Y ibeiYgh]cbx UV`Y shfih\t hc`X hc ig Vm cif [fUbXach\Yfg& h\Yb h\Y shfih\t hc`X hc ig Vm cif hYUW\Yfg& UbX h\Yb& k\Yb kY VYWcaY c`XYf& h\Y shfih\t hc`X hc ig Vm dfca]bYbh dYcd`Y( v7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

8YkUfY cZ ZU`gY dfcd\Yhg& k\]W\ WcaY hc mci ]b g\YYdrg W`ch\]b[& Vih ]bkUfX`m h\Ym UfY fUjYb]b[ kc`jYg( OY g\U`` _bck h\Ya Vm h\Y]f Zfi]hg( :c aYb [Uh\Yf [fUdYg cZ h\cfbg& cf Z][g cZ h\]gh`Yg6 ;jYb gc YjYfm [ccX hfYY Vf]b[Yh\ Zcfh\ [ccX Zfi]h5 Vih U Wcffidh hfYY Vf]b[Yh\ Zcfh\ Yj]` Zfi]h( 7 [ccX hfYY WUbbch Vf]b[ Zcfh\ Yj]` Zfi]h& bY]h\Yf WUb U Wcffidh hfYY Vf]b[ Zcfh\ [ccX Zfi]h( ;jYfm hfYY h\Uh Vf]b[Yh\ bch Zcfh\ [ccX Zfi]h ]g \Ykb Xckb& UbX WUgh ]bhc h\Y Z]fY( M\YfYZcfY Vm h\Y]f Zfi]hg mY g\U`` _bck h\Ya( vC7JJ>;M 14+/',*

7 aUb g\ci`X igY h\Uh gd]f]hiU` \Yf]hU[Y k\]W\ \Y \Ug fYWY]jYX Zfca h\Y k]gY UbX \c`m dYcd`Y cZ h\Y dUgh& Vih \Y g\ci`X hYgh YjYfmh\]b[ k]h\ \]g ]bhY``YWh& UWWYdh]b[ WYfhU]b h\]b[g UbX fY^YWh]b[ ch\Yfg( 1YHU\ SHUVRQ VKRXOG GHILQH IRU KLPVHOI KLV DWWLWXGH WR WKLV ZRUOG DQG WR /RG&

BGPVGSX ÁÃ <U]h\ ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY UbX h\Y UWWYdhUbWY cZ h\cgY Xih]Yg UbX fYgdcbg]V]`]h]Yg WcbbYWhYX hc ]h( BKR LV D JRRG PDQ, ;QO\ D PDQ ZKR KDV IDLWK LV JRRG& BKDW LV IDLWK , ?KLV LV ZKHQ \RXU ZLOO LV LQ FRQVHQW ZLWK WKH ZRUOG_V FRQVFLHQFH DQG WKH ZRUOG_V ZLVGRP& v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

MY g\ci`X Xc cb`m cbY h\]b[4 []jY cifgY`jYg ]bhc h\Y \UbXg cZ =cX& k\UhYjYf cif i`h]aUhY ZUhY( 7``ck h\Uh k\]W\ g\ci`X \UddYb hc \UddYb( M\Uh k]`` \UddYb k]`` VY [ccX( v>;DHO 7C?;B

J\Ym gUm h\Uh @iX[aYbh :Um k]`` WcaY UbX h\Uh =cX k]`` VY Zif]cig( 8ih U [ccX =cX WUbbch Vf]b[ Ubmh\]b[ Vih [ccX( :c bch VY UZfU]X4 h\Y YbX k]`` VY Zi`` cZ ^cm( vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

Oci g\ci`X bch kcffm hcc aiW\ UVcih k\Uh k]`` \UddYb UZhYf XYUh\( :Y`]jYf mcifgY`Z hc h\Y X]j]bY WfYUhifY UbX V`Ygg ]h4 mci _bck h\Uh ]h ]g `cjY& h\YfYZcfY& k\m g\ci`X mci VY UZfU]X6 M\Yb 9\f]gh X]YX& \Y gU]X& s<Uh\Yf ? XY`]jYf am gd]f]h ]bhc J\m \UbXg(t J\cgY k\c gUm h\YgY kcfXg& bch k]h\ h\Y]f hcb[iY Vih k]h\ U`` h\Y]f \YUfh& Xc bch bYYX Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY( ?Z am gd]f]h fYhifbg VUW_ hc ]hg <Uh\Yf& h\]g ]g h\Y VYgh d`UWY Zcf ]h& UbX bch\]b[ WUb VY VYhhYf( :cbrh h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUb Z]bX dYUWY Zcf mcif gci` k]h\cih ZU]h\(

BGPVGSX ÁÄ Oci g\ci`X `cjY cb`m cbY h\]b[ ]b mcifgY`Z& h\Uh k\]W\ ]g h\Y gUaY ]b U`` cZ ig( ?b `cj]b[ h\Uh k\]W\ ]g h\Y gUaY ]b U`` cZ ig& mci `cjY =cX( CUghYf& k\]W\ ]g h\Y [fYUh WcaaUbXaYbh ]b h\Y `Uk6 @Ygig gU]X ibh]` \]a& J\ci g\U`h `cjY h\Y BcfX h\m =cX k]h\ U`` h\m \YUfh& UbX k]h\ U`` h\m gci`& UbX k]h\ U`` h\m a]bX( J\]g ]g h\Y Z]fgh UbX [fYUh WcaaUbXaYbh( 7bX X]Y gYWcbX ]g `]_Y ibhc ]h& J\ci g\U`h `cjY h\m bY][\Vcf Ug h\mgY`Z( Eb h\YgY hkc WcaaUbXaYbh6 \Ub[ U`` h\Y `Uk UbX h\Y dfcd\Yhg( vC7JJ>;M ,,'-0'.*

<HRSOH OLYH E\ ORYH* ORYH RI \RXUVHOI LV WKH EHJLQQLQJ RI GHDWK+ ORYH RI RWKHU SHRSOH DQG RI 3RG LV WKH EHJLQQLQJ RI OLIH& =cX ]g `cjY( 7bX \Y k\c `]jYg ]b `cjY& `]jYg ]b =cX& UbX =cX `]jYg ]b \]a( ?Z kY `cjY cbY Ubch\Yf& =cX `]jYg ]b ig( v? @E>D& Zfca 9\UdhYf .

BcjY ]g bch U gcifWY& ]h ]g U WcbgYeiYbWY cZ cif ibXYfx ghUbX]b[ h\Y X]j]bY& gd]f]hiU` VY[]bb]b[ k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b U`` cZ ig(

BGPVGSX ÁĀ J\Y [fYUhYgh hfih\ cZ h\Y hYUW\]b[g cZ 9\f]gh ]g h\Y X]fYWh WcbbYWh]cb VYhkYYb U aUb #=cXrg gcb$ UbX =cX #>]g <Uh\Yf$( Oci Ug_ aYj k\Uh h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh ZYUhifY cZ 9\f]gh"g W\UfUWhYf kUg( ? k]`` UbgkYf mci4 ]h kUg \]g WcbZ]XYbWY ]b h\Y [fYUhbYgg cZ h\Y \iaUb gci`( >Y gUk ]b U dYfgcb h\Y fYZ`YWh]cb cZ =cXrg ]aU[Y& UbX& h\YfYZcfY& \Y `cjYX YjYfmx cbY& k\cYjYf U dYfgcb kUg& k]h\cih fY[UfX hc \]g `]ZY cf W\UfUWhYf5v v7ZhYf M?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

8ch\ dYcd`Y UbX bUh]cbg aigh [Yh f]X cZ dfY^iX]WYg( <YY` mcifgY`Z hU`_]b[ X]fYWh`m hc =cX4 Xcbrh fYUX h\Y Vcc_& fYUX mcif gci`5 h\Yb U gaU`` W\UdY` k]`` VYWcaY Ug V][ Ug h\Y \YUjYb`m XcaY ]hgY`Z( v7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

J\YfY UfY hkc kUmg cZ ibXYfghUbX]b[ =cX4 Y]h\Yf ]bhY`x `YWhiU``m cf gd]f]hiU``m& VUgYX cb ZU]h\ UbX acfU`]hm( J\Y ]bhY``YWhiU` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX ]g bch fYgc`ihY Ybci[\ UbX WUb VY giV^YWhYX hc XUb[Yfcig a]ghU_Yg5 gd]f]hiU` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX fYei]fYg acfU` UWh]cbg( J\]g ZU]h\ ]g Vch\ bUhifU` UbX gidYfbUhifU`( v7ZhYf ?CC7DK;B A7DJ

.HZDUH RI HYHU\WKLQJ ZKLFK SXWV DQ REVWDFOH EHWZHHQ \RX DQG 3RG&

BGPVGSX ÁĂ 2DOVH IDLWK LV WKH PDMRU FDXVH RI PRVW RI RXU PLVIRUWXQHV& J\Y difdcgY cZ U \iaUb `]ZY ]g hc Vf]b[ h\Y ]ffUh]cbU` VY[]bb]b[ cZ cif `]ZY hc U fUh]cbU` VY[]bb]b[( ?b cfXYf hc giWWYYX ]b h\]g& hkc h\]b[g UfY ]adcfhUbh4 #+$ hc gYY U`` ]ffUh]cbU`& ibk]gY h\]b[g ]b `]ZY UbX X]fYWh mcif UhhYbh]cb hc h\Ya UbX ghiXm h\Ya5 #,$ hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y dcgg]V]`]hm cZ U fUh]cbU`& k]gY `]ZY( J\Y aU^cf difdcgY cZ U`` hYUW\Yfg'S cZ aUb_]bX kUg h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y ]ffUh]cbU` UbX fUh]cbU` VY[]bb]b[g ]b cif `]ZY( MY g\ci`X VY fYUXm hc W\Ub[Y cif j]Ykg Uh Ubm h]aY& UbX g`ci[\ cZZ dfY^iX]WYg& UbX `]jY k]h\ Ub cdYb UbX fYWYdh]jY a]bX( 7 gU]`cf k\c gYhg h\Y gUaY gU]`g U`` h\Y h]aY& k]h\x cih aU_]b[ W\Ub[Yg k\Yb h\Y k]bX W\Ub[Yg& k]`` bYjYf fYUW\ \]g \UfVcf( v>;DHO =;EH=;

7WWYdh h\Y hYUW\]b[ cZ 9\f]gh Ug ]h ]g& W`YUf UbX g]ad`Y5 h\Yb mci k]`` gYY h\Uh kY `]jY Uacb[ V][ `]Yg(

BGPVGSX ÁÅ B]jY Zcf mcif gci`& UbX k]h\cih hfm]b[ cf YjYb ibXYfx ghUbX]b[ h\Uh mcirfY Xc]b[ ]h& mci k]`` Wcbhf]VihY hc h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ gcW]Yhm( M\m Xc mci hcfhifY mcifgY`Z6 Oci kUbh _]bXbYgg& Vih mci Xc bch _bck k\YfY hc Z]bX ]h( Abck h\Uh mci WUbbch UW\]YjY Ubmh\]b[ k]h\cih =cX(((( =cX ]g mcif cb`m BcfX& mcif cb`m aUghYf& UbX mci Xc bch bYYX Ubch\Yf( =cX k]`` aU_Y mci ZfYY( v<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

?h kci`X VY b4WY ]Z k]gXca \UX giW\ U eiU`]hm h\Uh ]h Wci`X Z`ck Zfca cbY aUb k\c ]g Zi`` cZ k]gXca hc Ubch\Yf aUb k\c \Ug bc k]gXca& ^igh Ug k]h\ hkc WcbbYWhYX jYggY`g kUhYf Z`ckg Zfca cbY jYggY` hc h\Y ch\Yf ibh]` h\Y kUhYf `YjY` ]g h\Y gUaY ]b Vch\ cZ h\Ya( J\Y dfcV`Ya ]g h\Uh hc cVhU]b k]gXca& mci aigh aU_Y Ub ]bXYdYbXYbh& gYf]cig YZZcfh cZ mcif ckb( 5I \RX FDQ WHDFK D SHUVRQ NLQGQHVV DQG ORYH$ KXW \RX GR QRW$ \RX ORVH D EURWKHU& v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

?adfcjY mcif ckb gci`& UbX VY WcbZ]XYbh h\Uh cb`m ]b gc Xc]b[ WUb mci Wcbhf]VihY hc h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\Y `Uf[Yf gcW]Yhm cZ k\]W\ mci UfY dUfh(

BGPVGSX ÁǺ 7 gW\c`Uf _bckg aUbm Vcc_g5 U kY``'YXiWUhYX dYfgcb \Ug _bck`YX[Y UbX g_]``g5 Ub Yb`][\hYbYX dYfgcb ibXYfghUbXg h\Y aYUb]b[ UbX difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY( J\YfY UfY U `]a]h`Ygg biaVYf cZ X]ZZYfYbh gW]YbWYg& Vih k]h\cih cbY VUg]W gW]YbWY& h\Uh ]g& k\Uh ]g h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY UbX k\Uh ]g [ccX Zcf h\Y dYcd`Y& U`` ch\Yf Zcfag cZ _bck`YX[Y UbX Ufh VYWcaY ]X`Y UbX \UfaZi` YbhYfhU]bx aYbh( MY `]jY U gYbgY`Ygg `]ZY& WcbhfUfm hc h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ `]ZY Vm h\Y k]gYgh dYcd`Y cZ U`` h]aYg( J\]g \UddYbg VYWUigY cif mcib[ [YbYfUh]cbg UfY YXiWUhYX ]b h\Y kfcb[ kUmv h\Ym UfY hUi[\h X]ZZYfYbh gW]YbWYg Vih h\Ym UfY bch hUi[\h h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY( ?KH RQO\ UHDO VFLHQFH LV WKH NQRZOHGJH RI KRZ D SHUVRQ VKRXOG OLYH KLV OLIH& -QG WKLV NQRZOHGJH LV RSHQ WR HYHU\RQH&

BGPVGSX ÁĄ IcW]Yhm WUb VY ]adfcjYX cb`m Vm gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY( >YUjYb UbX YUfh\ UfY YhYfbU`( J\Ym UfY YhYfbU` VYWUigY h\Ym Xc bch Yl]gh Zcf h\YagY`jYg( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U hfi`m \c`m dYfgcb XcYg bch `]jY Zcf \]agY`Z& UbX h\YfYZcfY \Y WUb VYWcaY YhYfbU`& UbX WUb UW\]YjY Ubmh\]b[( vB7E'JPK ?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH ODZ$ ERWK LQ \RXU SHUVRQDO DQG VRFLDO OLIH* LI \RX ZDQW WR LPSURYH \RXU VRXO$ \RX VKRXOG EH UHDG\ WR VDFc ULILFH LW& J\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ aUb WUb VY aYUgifYX Vm h\Y `YjY` cZ \]g ]bbYf ZfYYXca( J\Y acfY U dYfgcb VYWcaYg ZfYY Zfca \]g dYfgcbU`]hm& h\Y acfY ZfYYXca \Y \Ug(

BGPVGSX ÂÀ :YUh\ UbX V]fh\ UfY hkc `]a]hg& UbX gcaYh\]b[ g]a]`Uf ]g \]XXYb VY\]bX YUW\( M\Yb mci h\]b_ UVcih k\Uh k]`` \UddYb hc mcif gci` UZhYf XYUh\& h\]b_ U`gc UVcih k\Uh \UddYbYX hc mcif gci` VYZcfY mcif V]fh\( ?Z mci d`Ub hc [c gcaYk\YfY& h\Yb mci WUaY Zfca gcaYk\YfY( M\YfY Xc kY [c UZhYf XYUh\6 MY [c hc k\YfY kY WUaY Zfca( J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ k\]W\ WUb VY WU``YX cifgY`jYg ]b h\Uh `UbX5 h\YfYZcfY& kY Xc bch fYaYaVYf k\Uh \Ug \Udx dYbYX hc ig h\YfY( M\Yb U dYfgcb `YUXg U [ccX `]ZY& \Y ]g \Uddm Uh h\Y dfYgYbh acaYbh UbX \Y XcYg bch h\]b_ k\Uh k]`` \UddYb UZhYf h\]g `]ZY( ?Z \Y h\]b_g cZ XYUh\& \Y `cc_g Uh \ck kY`` h\]g `]ZY ]g `U]X cih& UbX \Y VY`]YjYg h\Uh UZhYf XYUh\ YjYfmh\]b[ k]`` VY Ug [ccX Ug ]h ]g bck( ?h ]g aiW\ VYhhYf hc VY`]YjY h\Uh YjYfmx h\]b[ k\]W\ =cX aU_Yg Zcf ig ]g [ccX h\Ub hc VY`]YjY ]b U`` h\Y d`YUgifYg cZ dUfUX]gY( BKHQ ZH GLH$ RXU VRXOV EHFRPH IUHH&

v7ZhYf >;H79B?JKI

7 dYfgcb g\ci`X bch h\]b_ hcc aiW\ UVcih k\Uh k]`` \Udx dYb UZhYf \]g `]ZY( <c``ck h\Y k]`` cZ h\cgY k\c gYbh ig ]bhc h\]g kcf`X5 h\Uh k]`` ]g ]b cif a]bXg UbX cif \YUfhg(

BGPVGSX ÂÀ J\Y acfY W`cgY`m U dYfgcb Zc``ckg \]g ]bhY``YWh UbX Wcbx hfc`g \]g dUgg]cbg& h\Y W`cgYf \Y WcaYg hc gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& hc `cjY cZ =cX UbX cZ \]g bY][\Vcf( MY kci`X h\]b_ U aUb ]bgUbY k\c& ]bghYUX cZ WcjYf]b[ \]g \cigY k]h\ U fccZ UbX dihh]b[ k]bXckg ]b \]g k]bXck ZfUaYg& [cYg cih ]b ghcfam kYUh\Yf& UbX gWc`Xg h\Y k]bX& h\Y fU]b& UbX h\Y W`ciXg( 8ih kY U`` Xc h\Y gUaY k\Yb kY gWc`X UbX V`UaY h\Y Yj]` ]b ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]bghYUX cZ Z][\hx ]b[ h\Y Yj]` k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b ig( ?h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc [Yh f]X cZ h\Y Yj]` ]bg]XY cZ ig& Ug ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc aU_Y U fccZ UbX k]bXckg Zcf cif \cigY( J\]g ]g dcgg]V`Y( 8ih ]h ]g bch dcgx g]V`Y Zcf ig hc XYghfcm Yj]` ]b h\]g kcf`X& ^igh Ug kY WUbbch cfXYf h\Y kYUh\Yf hc W\Ub[Y UbX h\Y W`ciXg hc X]gUddYUf( ?Z& ]bghYUX cZ hYUW\]b[ ch\Yfg& kY kci`X YXiWUhYSUbX ]adfcjY cifgY`jYg& h\Yb h\YfY kci`X VY `Ygg Yj]` ]b h\]g kcf`X& UbX U`` dYcd`Y kci`X `]jY VYhhYf `]jYg( :c bch VY YaVUffUggYX Vm mcif a]ghU_Yg( Dch\]b[ WUb hYUW\ ig VYhhYf h\Ub cif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Ya( J\]g ]g cbY cZ h\Y VYgh kUmg cZ gY`Z'YXiWUh]cb( vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

5W VHHPV WR XV WKDW WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW ZRUN LQ WKH ZRUOG LV WKH ZRUN ZKLFK LV YLVLEOH$ ZKLFK ZH FDQ VHH* EXLOGLQJ D KRXVH$ SORZLQJ WKH ODQG$ IHHGLQJ FDWWOH$ JDWKHULQJ IUXLWV+ DQG WKDW WKH ZRUN ZKLFK LV LQYLVLEOH$ WKH ZRUN GRQH E\ RXU VRXO$ LV QRW LPSRUWDQW& .XW RXU LQYLVLEOH ZRUN DW WKH LPSURYHPHQW RI RXU VRXO LV WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW ZRUN LQ WKH ZRUOG$ DQG DOO RWKHU YLVLEOH NLQGV RI ZRUN DUH XVHIXO RQO\ ZKHQ ZH GR WKLV PDMRU ZRUN&

BGPVGSX ÂÂ Dc YlWYdh]cbg cf gdYW]U` W]fWiaghUbWYg WUb ^igh]Zm h\Y aifXYf cZ U `]j]b[ dYfgcb( CifXYf ]g h\Y acgh ji`[Uf j]cx `Uh]cb cZ h\Y BUk cZ =cX Ug ]h ]g YldfYggYX ]b U`` fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[g UbX ]b U`` dYcd`Yrg WcbgW]YbWY( C]`]hUfm gYfj]WY aU_Yg dYcd`Y Wcffidh& VYWUigY h\Y a]`]x hUfm& ]b h]aY cZ dYUWY& UV]XYg ]b Wcad`YhY ]X`YbYggS h\Ym `UW_ Ubm igYZi` `UVcf& h\Ym UfY ZfYYX cZ h\Y cV`][Uh]cbg cZ giW\ kcf_( ?bghYUX& h\Ym WfYUhY bch]cbg cZ \cbcf cZ fY[]x aYbh& cf cZ VUbbYf& cf h\Y Wcad`YhY giV^i[Uh]cb cZ cbY dYfgcb Vm Ubch\Yf( M\Yb W]j]`]Ubg [Yh ]bhc h\YgY W]fWiaghUbWYg& h\Ym VYWcaY Ug\UaYX cZ giW\ U kUm cZ `]ZY( J\Y a]`]hUfm& cb h\Y WcbhfUfm& UfY dfciX cZ ]h UbX VcUgh cZ h\]g kUm cZ `]ZY& YgdYW]U``m Xif]b[ dYf]cXg cZ kUf( J\Ym gUm4 sMY UfY fYUXm hc f]g_ cif `]jYg Uh kUf& UbX h\YfYZcfY giW\ U WUfY`Ygg ^cmZi` `]ZY ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf ig& UbX kY \UjY h\Y f][\h hc `YUX ]h(t ?KH VDPH GLYLQH EHJLQQLQJ OLYHV LQ DOO SHRSOH$ DQG QR VLQJOH SHUVRQ RU JDWKHULQJ RI SHRSOH KDV WKH ULJKW WR GHVWUR\ WKLV FRQc QHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKH GLYLQH EHJLQQLQJ DQG D KXPDQ ERG\$ WKDW LV$ WR WDNH D KXPDQ OLIH&

BGPVGSX ÂÃ 7acb[ U`` g]bg& h\YfY ]g cbY k\]W\ Wcad`YhY`m cddcgYg h\Y aU^cf V`Ygg]b[ cZ \iaUb `]ZY& k\]W\ ]g mcif `cjY Zcf mcif Vfch\Yf4 h\YfY ]g bc kcfgY g]b h\Ub hc XYghfcm h\]g aU^cf ^cm cZ `]ZY& Vm ZYY`]b[ fU[Y UbX \UhfYX Zcf mcif Vfch\Yf( IYbYWU& U k]gY aUb Zfca HcaY& gU]X h\Uh k\Yb mci kUbh hc YgWUdY Zfca mcif fU[Y& k\Yb mci ZYY` h\Uh ]h [fckg& h\Y VYgh h\]b[ hc XU]g hc ghcd( :c bch Xc Ubmh\]b[4 Xc bch kU`_& Xc bch acjY& Xc bch gdYU_( ?Z mcif VcXm cf mcif hcb[iY acjYg Uh h\]g acaYbh& h\Yb mcif fU[Y k]`` [fck( HU[Y ]g jYfm \UfaZi` Zcf U`` dYcd`Y& Vih ]h ]g acgh \Ufax Zi` Zcf h\Y aUb k\c YldYf]YbWYg ]h( 7b Yj]` dYfgcb XUaU[Yg bch cb`m ch\Yfg Vih \]agY`Z(

v7ZhYf IE9H7J;ITTTTTTTT5

Ocif YbYam k]`` dUm mci VUW_ k]h\ fU[Y& k]`` aU_Y mci giZZYf& Vih h\Y V][[Ygh XUaU[Y hc mci k]`` VY WUigYX Vm h\Y fU[Y UbX \UhfYX Yl]gh]b[ ]b mcif \YUfh( DY]h\Yf mcif ZUh\Yf& bcf mcif ach\Yf& bcf U`` mcif ZUa]`m WUb aU_Y mci acfY [ccX h\Ub mcif \YUfh WUb k\Yb ]h Zcf[]jYg UbX Zcfx [Yhg ]hg UVigY( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

CRXU UDJH FDQQRW EH MXVWLILHG E\ DQ\WKLQJ& ?KH UHDVRQ IRU \RXU UDJH LV DOZD\V LQVLGH \RX&

!# "$ ÂÄ DcVcXm _bckg k\YfY h\Y \iaUb fUWY ]g [c]b[( J\Y \][\x Ygh k]gXca& h\Yb& ]g hc _bck k\YfY \RX g\ci`X [c4 hckUfX dYfZYWh]cb( 7 k]gY aUb gYY_g k]gXca5 U aUXaUb h\]b_g h\Uh \Y \Ug ZcibX ]h( vF;HI?7D FHEL;H8

p 5W LV QRW WKH SODFH ZH RFFXS\ ZKLFK LV LPSRUWDQW$ KXW WKH GLUHFWLRQ LQ ZKLFK ZH PRYH& vEB?L;H M;D:;BB >EBC;I

Ocif UWh]cbg g\ci`X VY XYhYfa]bYX bch Vm h\Y XYg]fY cZ h\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX mci& Vih Vm h\Y bYYXg cZ U`` aUb_]bX(

BGPVGSX ÂĀ J\YfY ]g U VUg]W _bck`YX[Y k\]W\ ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf YjYfm \iaUb VY]b[g ibh]` U dYfgcb \Ug UWei]fYX h\]g VUg]W _bck`YX[Y& U`` ch\Yf _]bXg cZ _bck`YX[Y k]`` VY \UfaZi` Zcf \]a( IcWfUhYg hc`X \]g ghiXYbhg h\Uh ]b [ccX gmghYag cZ YXiWUx h]cb& h\YfY ]g U WYfhU]b `]a]h mci g\ci`X bch [c VYmcbX( ?b [YcaYhfm& \Y gU]X& ]h ]g Ybci[\ hc _bck \ck hc aYUgifY h\Y `UbX k\Yb mci kUbh hc gY`` ]h cf Vim ]h& cf \ck hc g\UfY Ub ]b\Yf]hUbWY& cf hc X]j]XY kcf_ Uacb[ kcf_Yfg( >Y X]X bch `]_Y hcc aUbm gcd\]gh]WUhYX gW]YbWYg5 h\ci[\ \Y _bYk U`` cZ h\Ya( >Y gU]X h\Uh gcd\]gh]WUhYX _bck`YX[Y fYei]fYg Ub YlhfU YZZcfh h\Uh hU_Yg h\Y ghiXYbhrg h]aY Zfca h\Y acgh VUg]W UbX h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh \iaUb difgi]h4 acfU` dYfZYWh]cb( vN;DEF>ED

:]jYfh mcif [UnY Zfca h\Y kcf`X cZ `]Yg( :c bch hfigh mcif ZYY`]b[g( Eb`m ]b mcifgY`Z& cb`m ]b mcif ]adYfgcbU` gY`Z& WUb mci Z]bX h\Y YhYfbU`( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

5W LV EHWWHU WR NQRZ VHYHUDO EDVLF UXOHV RI OLIH WKDQ WR VWXG\ PDQ\ XQQHFHVVDU\ VFLHQFHV& ?KH PDMRU UXOHV RI OLIH ZLOO VWRS \RX IURP HYLO DQG VKRZ \RX WKH JRRG SDWK LQ OLIH+ EXW WKH NQRZOHGJH RI PDQ\ XQQHFHVVDU\ VFLHQFHV PD\ OHDG \RX LQWR WKH WHPSWDWLRQ RI SULGH$ DQG VWRS \RX IURP XQGHUVWDQGLQJ WKH EDVLF UXOHV RI OLIH&

BGPVGSX ÂĂ 7 f]W\ aUb WUbbch VY aYfW]Zi`( ?Z \Y VYWcaYg fYU``m aYfx W]Zi`& \Y k]`` ei]W_`m `cgY \]g f]W\Yg( Ihcd fcVV]b[ ch\Yfg VYZcfY mci []jY acbYm hc VY[[Ufg( M]h\ h\Y gUaY \UbX h\Uh kY fcV cbY dYfgcb& kY fYkUfX Ubch\Yf& []j]b[ hc h\Y dccf h\Y acbYm k\]W\ kY \UjY hU_Yb Zfca h\Y YjYb dccfYf( 8YhhYf bc W\Uf]hm h\Ub h\]g _]bX cZ W\Uf]hm( vI7?DJ @E>D 9>HOIEIJEC

J\Y VYgh YlUad`Y cZ h\Y WfiY`hm cZ h\Y f]W\ aUbrg `]ZY ]g \]g YZZcfh hc VYWcaY j]fhicig( .XW ZKRVR KDWK WKLV ZRUOG_V JRRG$ DQG VHHWK KLV EURWKHU KDYH QHHG$ DQG VKXWWHWK XS KLV ERZHOV RI FRPSDVVLRQ IURP KLP$ KRZ GZHOOHWK WKH ORYH RI 3RG LQ KLP , 9\ OLWWOH FKLOGUHQ$ OHW XV QRW ORYH LQ ZRUG+ QHLWKHU LQ WRQJXH+ EXW LQ GHHG DQG WUXWK& v? @E>D -4+1'+2

?b cfXYf hc `cjY bch k]h\ kcfX UbX hcb[iY& Vih ]b XYYX UbX hfih\& YjYfmcbY g\ci`X \Y`d h\cgY k\c Ug_ Zcf \Y`d& gc 9\f]gh gU]X( 8ih ]Z mci ghUfh []j]b[ hc U`` h\cgY k\c Ug_& YjYb ]Z mci UfY jYfm f]W\& jYfm gccb mci k]`` bch VY f]W\ UbmacfY(

BGPVGSX ÂÅ BcjY Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y []jYg U fYU` ZYY`]b[ cZ [ccX& UbX ]h ib]hYg mci k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX k]h\ =cX( - ZLVH PDQ ORYHV QRW EHFDXVH KH ZDQWV WR SURILW IURP LW EXW EHFDXVH KH ILQGV EOLVV LQ ORYH LWVHOI& :c bch fY[fYh h\Y dUgh( M\Uh ]g h\Y igY cZ fY[fYhg6 J\Y `]Y gUmg h\Uh mci g\ci`X fY[fYh( J\Y hfih\ gUmg mci g\ci`X VY Z]``YX k]h\ `cjY( Fig\ U`` gUX aYacf]Yg UkUm Zfca mci( :c bch gdYU_ cZ h\Y dUgh( B]jY ]b h\Y `][\h cZ `cjY& UbX U`` h\]b[g k]`` VY []jYb hc mci( vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

J\Ym Ug_YX U 9\]bYgY aUb& sM\Uh ]g gW]YbWY6t >Y gU]X& sIW]YbWY ]g _bck]b[ dYcd`Y(t J\Yb h\Ym Ug_YX& s7bX k\Uh ]g j]fhiY6t >Y UbgkYfYX& sL]fhiY ]g `cj]b[ dYcd`Y(t @igh Ug U ach\Yf dihg \Yf `]ZY Uh f]g_ hc [iUfX UbX gUjY \Yf cb`m W\]`X& gc YjYfm dYfgcb g\ci`X [iUfX UbX gUjY ]b \]ax gY`Z `cjY Zcf YjYfm `]j]b[ VY]b[( J\Y ZYUf`YggbYgg& WU`a& ]bbYf dYUWY& UbX ^cm k\]W\ UfY []jYb hc ig Vm `cjY UfY gc V][ h\Uh U`` ch\Yf h\]b[g ]b h\Y kcf`X WUbbch VY WcadUfYX k]h\ h\Ya& YgdYW]U``m Zcf h\Y dYfx gcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\Y fYU` V`Ygg]b[ cZ `cjY(

BGPVGSX ÂǺ <cf U dYfgcb hc _bck h\Y `Uk h\Uh aU_Yg \]a ZfYY& \Y aigh VY Y`YjUhYX Zfca U aUhYf]U` hc U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY( ? \UjY aUbm h\]b[g hc gUm UbX hc ^iX[Y cb mci4 Vih \Y h\Uh gYbh aY ]g hfiY5 UbX ? gdYU_ hc h\Y kcf`X h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ ? \UjY \YUfX cZ \]a( J\Ym ibXYfghccX bch h\Uh \Y gdU_Y hc h\Ya cZ h\Y <Uh\Yf( J\Yb gU]X @Ygig ibhc h\Ya& M\Yb mY \UjY `]ZhYX id h\Y Icb cZ aUb& h\Yb g\U`` mY _bck h\Uh ? Ua \Y& UbX h\Uh ? Xc bch\]b[ cZ amgY`Z5 Vih Ug am <Uh\Yf \Uh\ hUi[\h aY& ? gdYU_ h\YgY h\]b[g( v@E>D 24,0',2

s? UbX =cX UfY h\Y gUaY&t gU]X h\Y hYUW\Yf( ?Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh am gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ ]g =cX& mci UfY a]ghU_Yb( 8ih am fYU` gY`Z ]g W`cgY hc =cX& UbX hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y( ?b cfXYf hc ibXYfghUbX h\]g dUfh cZ amgY`Z& mci g\ci`X Y`YjUhY h\Y aUb ]bg]XY cZ mci( M\Yb mci Y`YjUhY h\Y aUb ]bg]XY cZ mci& h\Yb mci k]`` gYY h\Uh h\YfY ]g bc X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb \]a UbX Ubm ch\Yf dYfgcb cb YUfh\( ?h cb`m gYYag Ug ]Z kY X]ZZYf Zfca YUW\ ch\Yf( 7 Z`ckYf cb U V`cggca]b[ hfYY WUb h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g U gYdUfUhY VY]b[& Vih U`` Z`ckYfg UfY dUfhg cZ h\Y gUaY V`cggca]b[ cZ cbY Udd`Y hfYY& UbX h\Ym U`` WcaY Zfca cbY gYYX( BH OLYH D VKRUW SHULRG RI WLPH LQ WKLV ZRUOG$ EXW ZH OLYH LW DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH ODZV RI HWHUQDO OLIH& v7ZhYf >;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

IiVa]gg]cb hc h\Y `Uk WfYUhYX Vm aYb aU_Yg cbY U g`UjY5 cVYX]YbWY hc h\Y `Uk WfYUhYX Vm =cX aU_Yg cbY ZfYY(

BGPVGSX ÂĄ M]gXca ]g _bck]b[ h\Y difdcgY cZ `]ZY& UbX _bck]b[ \ck hc UW\]YjY ]h( Oci WUb UW\]YjY k]gXca ]b h\fYY kUmg( J\Y Z]fgh kUm ]g h\Y kUm cZ aYX]hUh]cb( J\]g ]g h\Y acgh bcV`Y kUm( J\Y gYWcbX kUm ]g h\Y kUm cZ ]a]hUh]cb( J\]g ]g h\Y YUg]Ygh UbX `YUgh gUh]gZm]b[ kUm( J\]fX`m& h\YfY ]g h\Y kUm cZ YldYf]YbWY( J\]g ]g h\Y acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h kUm( v9ED<K9?KI

?KH PHULW RI D PDQ LV QRW LQ WKH NQRZOHGJH KH SRVVHVVHV$ KXW LQ WKH HIIRUW KH PDGH WR DFKLHYH LW& v=EJJ>EB: ;F>H7?C B;II?D=

?Z mci kUbh hc ghiXm mcifgY`Zv`cc_ ]bhc h\Y \YUfhg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( ?Z mci kUbh hc ghiXm ch\Yf dYcd`Yv`cc_ ]bhc mcif ckb \YUfh( v<H?;:H?9> LED I9>?BB;H

Ocif gci` ]g Vch\ mcif ^iX[Y UbX mcif d`UWY cZ gUbWhiUfm( Ocif ckb gci` ]g mcif \][\Ygh ^iX[Y( vC7DK

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ ]b k\]W\ fYU` k]gXca WUbbch VY X]gx d`UmYX(

BGPVGSX ÃÀ M\Yb IcWfUhYg kUg Ug_YX k\YfY \Y WUaY Zfca& \Y gU]X h\Uh \Y kUg U W]h]nYb cZ h\Y kcf`X( >Y fY[UfXYX \]agY`Z Ug U W]h]nYb cZ h\Y ib]jYfgY( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

M\Yb dYcd`Y kUbhYX hc _]`` U VYUf ]b h\Y UbW]Ybh h]aYg& h\Ym \ib[ U \YUjm `c[ cjYf U Vck` cZ \cbYm( J\Y VYUf kci`X dig\ h\Y `c[ UkUm ]b cfXYf hc YUh h\Y \cbYm( J\Y `c[ kci`X gk]b[ VUW_ UbX \]h h\Y VYUf( J\Y VYUf kci`X VYWcaY ]ff]hUhYX UbX dig\ h\Y `c[ YjYb \UfXYf& UbX ]h kci`X fYhifb UbX \]h \]a \UfXYf ]b fYhifb( J\]g kci`X Wcbh]biY ibh]` h\Y `c[ _]``YX h\Y VYUf( FYcd`Y VY\UjY ]b h\Y gUaY kUm k\Yb h\Ym fYhifb Yj]` Zcf h\Y Yj]` h\Ym fYWY]jY Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 9Ubrh dYcd`Y VY k]gYf h\Ub VYUfg6 CRX VKRXOG UHVSRQG ZLWK NLQGQHVV WRZDUG HYLO GRQH WR \RX$ DQG \RX ZLOO GHVWUR\ LQ DQ HYLO SHUVRQ WKDW SOHDVXUH ZKLFK KH GHULYHV IURP HYLO& J\Y hfiY hYUW\]b[ cZ `cjY ]g ghfcb[5 ]h _]``g Yj]` VYZcfY Yj]` WUb [fck UbX VYWcaY dckYfZi`(

BGPVGSX ÃÁ Eb`m [fYUh`m ]bgc`Ybh dYcd`Y YghUV`]g\ U fY`][]cig `Uk k\]W\ ]g hc VY hU_Yb Zcf [fUbhYX Vm ch\Yfg& k\]W\ g\ci`X VY UWWYdhYX Vm YjYfmcbY cb ZU]h\& k]h\cih Ubm X]gWigg]cb cf XciVhg( M\m aigh dYcd`Y Xc h\]g6 M\Uh U ghfUb[Y h\]b[ CUbm gWcibXfY`g hfm hc X]g[i]gY h\Y]f X]fhm XYYXg Vm h\Y]f XYX]WUh]cb hc h\Y ]bhYfYghg cZ fY`][]cb& cf Vm h\Y]f \][\ acfU`g& cf Vm `cjY Zcf h\Y]f ach\Yf`UbX( v>;?DH?9> >;?D;

8ih VY bch mYh WU``YX HUVV]4 Zcf cbY ]g mcif CUghYf& YjYb 9\f]gh5 UbX U`` mY UfY VfYh\fYb( 7bX WU`` bc aUb mcif ZUh\Yf idcb h\Y YUfh\4 Zcf cbY ]g mcif <Uh\Yf& k\]W\ ]g ]b \YUjYb( DY]h\Yf VY mY WU``YX aUghYfg4 Zcf cbY ]g mcif CUgx hYf& YjYb 9\f]gh( vC7JJ>;M ,-42'+*

?KH HVVHQFH RI WKH WHDFKLQJ RI /KULVW LV WR IROORZ KLV FRPc PDQGPHQWV& ?KRVH ZKR MXVW UHSHDW$ `9\ 3RG$ 9\ 8RUGa ZLOO QRW JHW WR KHDYHQ+ RQO\ WKRVH ZKR IXOILOO 3RG_V ZLOO&

AJHSVGSX Á ?h ]g bch dcgg]V`Y hc Yld`U]b h\Y cf][]b cZ h\Y gd]f]hiU` Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U`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v7ZhYf C7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y \YUfh cZ h\Y aUhhYf ]g k\Yh\Yf kY VY`]YjY cf X]gVY`]YjY ]b h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ U gd]f]hiU` fYU`a( 7`` dYcd`Y UfY X]j]XYX ]bhc hkc [fcidg& h\cgY k\c UfY U`]jY UbX h\cgY k\c UfY XYUX5 ]b ch\Yf kcfXg& h\cgY k\c VY`]YjY UbX h\cgY k\c Xcbrh( 7b ibVY`]YjYf gUmg4 sM\Uh ]g gd]f]h ((( M\Uh ? UhY UbX k\Uh ? Yb^cmYX& h\]g ]g k\Uh ? dcggYgg& h\]g ]g aUhYf]U` UbX fYU` t 7bX giW\ U dYfgcb& k]h\cih h\]b_]b[ aiW\& hU_Yg WUfY cb`m cZ h\Y cihYf h\]b[g& UffUb[]b[ ]b cfXYf cb`m \]g ckb aYUb& X]fhm UZZU]fg5 \Y VYWcaYg U `]Uf& U gbcV& U g`UjY& UbX XcYg bch ZYY` Ubm \][\Yf bYYXg4 ZfYYXca& hfih\& UbX `cjY( IiW\ U dYfgcb _YYdg UkUm Zfca h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y ]bhY`x `YWh& VYWUigY ]b ZUWh \Y ]g XYUX& UbX h\]g `][\h []jYg `]ZY cb`m hc `]j]b[ h\]b[g& UbX \UfXYbg UbX fchg h\Y XYUX h\]b[g( v7B;N7D:H 7HA>7D=;BIAO

J\Y X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb h\Y gd]f]hiU` fYU`a UbX h\Y aUhYx f]U` ]g YeiU``m W`YUf UbX cVj]cig& Vch\ Zcf U W\]`X UbX U k]gY aUb5 Zifh\Yf gdYWi`Uh]cbg UfY bch bYWYggUfm(

AJHSVGSX Â ?KHUH DUH WZR GLIIHUHQW VWDWHV RI KXPDQ H[LVWHQFH* ILUVW$ WR OLYH ZLWKRXW WKLQNLQJ RI GHDWK+ VHFRQG$ WR OLYH ZLWK WKH WKRXJKW WKDW \RX DSSURDFK GHDWK ZLWK HYHU\ KRXU RI \RXU OLIH& J\Y acfY mci hfUbgZcfa mcif `]ZY Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U` hc h\Y gd]f]hiU` XcaU]b& h\Y `Ygg mci VYWcaY UZfU]X cZ XYUh\( 7 dYfgcb k\c `]jYg U hfi`m gd]f]hiU` `]ZY \Ug bc ZYUf cZ XYUh\( M\Yb mci \UjY XciVhg UVcih k\Uh hc Xc& ^igh ]aU[]bY h\Uh mci a][\h X]Y Uh h\Y YbX cZ h\Uh gUaY XUm& UbX h\Yb U`` mcif XciVhg k]`` X]gUddYUf& UbX mci k]`` gYY W`YUf`m k\Uh mcif WcbgW]YbWY hY``g mci& UbX k\Uh ]g mcif hfiY dYfgcbU` k]g\( 7 aUb WcbXYabYX hc ]aaYX]UhY YlYWih]cb k]`` bch h\]b_ UVcih h\Y [fckh\ cZ \]g YghUhY& cf UVcih UW\]Yj]b[ [`cfm& cf UVcih h\Y j]Whcfm cZ cbY [fcid cjYf Ubch\Yf& cf UVcih h\Y X]gWcjYfm cZ U bYk d`UbYh( 8ih cbY a]bihY VYZcfY \]g XYUh\ U aUb aUm k]g\ hc Wcbgc`Y Ub UVigYX dYfgcb& cf \Y`d Ub c`X dYfgcb hc ghUbX id& cf hc dih U VUbXU[Y cb gcaYcbYrg ]b^ifm& cf hc fYdU]f U hcm Zcf U W\]`X(

AJHSVGSX Ã A]bXbYgg ]g Zcf mcif gci` Ug \YU`h\ ]g Zcf mcif VcXm4 mci Xc bch bch]WY ]h k\Yb mci \UjY ]h( - SHUVRQ EHFRPHV KDSS\ WR WKH VDPH H[WHQW WR ZKLFK KH RU VKH JLYHV KDSSLQHVV WR RWKHU SHRSOH& v@ ;H;CO'8;DJ>7C

J\Y k]`` cZ =cX Zcf ig ]g hc `]jY ]b \Udd]bYgg UbX hc hU_Y Ub ]bhYfYgh ]b h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yfg( v@E>D HKIA?D

BcjY ]g fYU` cb`m k\Yb U dYfgcb WUb gUWf]Z]WY \]agY`Z Zcf Ubch\Yf dYfgcb( 1-b`m k\Yb U dYfgcb Zcf[Yhg \]agY`Z Zcf h\Y gU_Y cZ Ubch\Yf& UbX `]jYg Zcf Ubch\Yf WfYUhifY& cb`m h\]g _]bX cZ `cjY WUb VY WU``YX hfiY `cjY& UbX cb`m ]b h\]g `cjY Xc kY gYY h\Y V`Ygg]b[ UbX fYkUfX cZ `]ZY( J\]g ]g h\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ h\Y kcf`X( Dch\]b[ WUb aU_Y cif `]ZY& cf h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& acfY VYUih]Zi` h\Ub dYfdYhiU` _]bXbYgg(

AJHSVGSX Ä 7 aUb ]g ZfYY cb`m k\Yb \Y `]jYg ]b hfih\& UbX h\Y hfih\ aUm VY dYfWY]jYX cb`m Vm h\Y ]bhY``YWh( ?Z mci h\fck gcaY bihg UbX Wcc_]Yg cb U fcUX& mci k]`` YjYbhiU``m gYY W\]`XfYb WcaY& d]W_ h\Ya id& UbX ghUfh hc Uf[iY UbX Z][\h Zcf h\Ya( 7Xi`hg kci`X bch Z][\h Zcf giW\ h\]b[g( 7bX YjYb W\]`XfYb kci`X bch d]W_ id h\Y bihgr Yadhm g\Y``g( <cf U k]gY aUb& h\Y kYU`h\& h\Y [`cfm& UbX h\Y fYkUfXg cZ h\]g kcf`X UfY `]_Y gkYYhg cf Yadhm g\Y``g cb U fcUX( BYh h\Y W\]`XfYb d]W_ h\Ya id UbX Z][\h Zcf h\Ya( BYh h\Ya _]gg h\Y \UbXg cZ h\Y f]W\ aYb& h\Y fi`Yfg& UbX h\Y]f gYfx jUbhg( <cf h\Y k]gY cbY& U`` h\YgY UfY Vih Yadhm g\Y``g( v;F?9J;JKI

- GLVWLQFWLYH IHDWXUH RI D WKLQNLQJ SHUVRQ LV VXEPLVVLRQ WR KLV IDWH$ DV RSSRVHG WR WKH VKDPHIXO VWUXJJOH ZLWK LW WKDW LV D FKDUc DFWHULVWLF IHDWXUH RI DQLPDOV& vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

MY UfY bch ZfYY ]b h\]g kcf`X& giVXiYX Vm cif dUgg]cbg UbX Vm h\Y Yach]cbg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y hc h\Y XY[fYY h\Uh kY Zcf[Yh h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ cif ]bhY``YWhg( ?Z kY fYU``m kUbh hc VYWcaY ZfYY& kY WUb VY gc cb`m h\fci[\ cif ]bhY``YWh(

AJHSVGSX Ā 7`` YjYbhg& k\Yh\Yf ]b h\Y `]jYg cZ \iaUb ]bX]j]XiU`g& cf \iaUb gcW]Yh]Yg& \UjY h\Y]f VY[]bb]b[g ]b h\ci[\h( J\YfYx ZcfY& hc Zi``m ibXYfghUbX ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX ch\Yf gcW]Yh]Yg& kY aigh `cc_ VYmcbX dfYj]cig YjYbhg hc h\Y h\ci[\hg k\]W\ [UjY f]gY hc h\Ya( FYf\Udg ]h ]g YjYb acfY ]adcfhUbh hc _bck k\Uh cbY g\ci`X bch h\]b_ UVcih h\Ub k\Uh cbY g\ci`X h\]b_ UVcih( Eif h\ci[\hg& XYdYbX]b[ cb k\Yh\Yf h\Ym UfY [ccX cf VUX& WUb Vf]b[ ig Y]h\Yf hc dUfUX]gY cf hc \Y``5 h\]g \Udx dYbg& bY]h\Yf ]b \YUjYb bcf ibXYf h\Y YUfh\& Vih \YfY& ]b h\]g `]ZY( vBK9O C7BEHO

- WKRXJKW VHHPV WR EH IUHH DQG LQGHSHQGHQW$ EXW D KXPDQ EHLQJ KDV VRPHWKLQJ VWURQJHU WKDQ WKRXJKW$ VRPHWKLQJ ZKLFK FRXOG JXLGH RXU WKRXJKWV& ?b cfXYf hc W\Ub[Y h\Y bUhifY cZ h\]b[g& Y]h\Yf k]h\]b mcifgY`Z cf ]b ch\Yfg& cbY g\ci`X W\Ub[Y& bch h\Y YjYbhg& Vih h\cgY h\ci[\hg k\]W\ WfYUhYX h\cgY YjYbhg(

JHSVGSX Ă IYliU` XYg]fY ]g h\Y acgh U``'Wcbgia]b[ cZ XYg]fYg( J\]g XYg]fY ]g bYjYf gUhYX& Zcf h\Y acfY ]h ]g gUh]gZ]YX& h\Y acfY ]h [fckg( LYfm cZhYb dYcd`Y UfY aUXY dfciX Vm h\Y]f Wcbhfc` cjYf h\Y]f ckb XYg]fYg& UbX Vm h\Y ZcfWY UbX dUgg]cb k]h\ k\]W\ h\Ym aUghYf h\Ya( M\Uh U ghfUb[Y XY`ig]cb 9DQ\ SHRSOH ZRUU\$ DQG VXIIHU$ EHFDXVH WKH\ KDYH EHHQ LQYROYHG LQ VR PDQ\ EDG WKLQJV LQ WKHLU OLYHV& 5Q WUXWK$ WKRXJK$ JRRG WKLQJV RIWHQ KDSSHQ LQ VSLWH RI RXU ZLVKHV$ DQG VRPHWLPHV HYHQ LQ RSSRVLWLRQ WR RXU ZLVKHV$ DQG RIWHQ DIWHU RXU H[FLWHPHQW DQG VXIIHULQJ RYHU XQZRUWK\ WKLQJV& HYaYaVYf \ck dUgg]cbUhY`m mci mYUfbYX ]b h\Y dUgh Zcf aUbm cZ h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ mci \UhY cf XYgd]gY bck( HYaYaVYf \ck aUbm h\]b[g mci `cgh hfm]b[ hc gUh]gZm mcif ZcfaYf XYg]fYg( J\Y gUaY h\]b[ Wci`X \UddYb bck& k]h\ h\Y XYg]fYg k\]W\ YlW]hY mci Uh dfYgYbh( Jfm hc hUaY mcif dfYgYbh XYg]fYg& WU`a h\Ya5 h\]g ]g acgh VYbYZ]W]U`& UbX acgh UW\]YjUV`Y(

AJHSVGSX Å FYfZYWh]b[ h\Y gY`Z ]g Vch\ Ub ]bbYf UbX Ub cihYf kcf_4 Oci WUbbch ]adfcjY mcifgY`Z k]h\cih Wcaaib]WUh]b[ k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& ]bZ`iYbW]b[ h\Ya& UbX VY]b[ ]bZ`iYbWYX Vm h\Ya( J\fYY hYadhUh]cbg hcfhifY dYcd`Y4 gYliU` XYg]fY& df]XY& UbX `igh Zcf kYU`h\( 7`` h\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ aUb_]bX WcaY Zfca h\YgY h\fYY WfUj]b[g( M]h\cih h\Ya& dYcd`Y kci`X `]jY ]b \Udd]bYgg( 8ih \ck WUb kY [Yh f]X cZ h\YgY hYff]V`Y ]``bYggYg6( Mcf_ cb mcifgY`Z UbX ]adfcjY mcifgY`Z5 h\]g ]g h\Y UbgkYf( IhUfh h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\]g kcf`X Zfca k]h\]b( v<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I '

`.H SHUIHFW$ DV \RXU KHDYHQO\ 2DWKHU /KULVW VDLG& ?KLV GRHV QRW PHDQ WKDW /KULVW DVNHG SHRSOH WR EH DV JRRG DV 3RG+ RQO\ WKDW HYHU\RQH VKRXOG VWULYH IRU SHUIHFWLRQ& FifY dYfZYWh]cb WUb VY ZcibX cb`m ]b =cX5 cbYrg `]ZY Wcbx g]ghg cZ VYWca]b[ W`cgYf hc =cX( 7bX k\Yb U dYfgcb _bckg h\Uh [ccX ]g [ccX UbX h\Uh Yj]` ]g Yj]`& h\Yb \Y cf g\Y [Yhg W`cgYf hc [ccX& UbX acjYg ZUfh\Yf Zfca Yj]`( v9ED<K9?KI

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY \UfaZi` hc mci h\Ub ]adfcj]b[ cb`m mcif aUhYf]U`& Ub]aU` g]XY cZ `]ZY( J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY VYbYZ]W]U`& Vch\ Zcf mci UbX Zcf ch\Yfg& h\Ub UWh]j]hm X]fYWhYX hc h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ mcif gci`(

AJHSVGSX Ǻ M\m Xc dYcd`Y `]_Y hc V`UaY ch\Yfg gc aiW\6 >Y k\c WUghg V`UaY cb Ubch\Yf dYfgcb ]g ei]W_ hc h\]b_ h\Uh \Y kci`X bch Xc h\Y jYfm gUaY h\]b[( ?h ]g h\Y gUaY k]h\ dYcd`Y k\c `]_Y hc `]ghYb hc h\Y ZUi`h'Z]bX]b[ cZ h\Y]f bY][\Vcfg( M\Yb hkc dYcd`Y \UjY U X]gdihY& Vch\ UfY hc V`UaY( 7bX h\YfYZcfY& U X]gdihY k]`` ghcd cb`m k\Yb Uh `YUgh cbY dYfx gcb ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh \Y cf g\Y ]g [i]`hm( 6XGJH QRW$ WKDW \H EH QRW MXGJHG& 2RU ZLWK ZKDW MXGJPHQW \H MXGJH$ \H VKDOO EH MXGJHG* DQG ZLWK ZKDW PHDVXUH \H PHWH$ LW VKDOO KH PHDVXUHG WR \RX DJDLQ& vC7JJ>;M (+" #

Ihcd V`Ua]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& UbX mci k]`` ZYY` k\Uh Ub U`Wcx \c`]W ZYY`g k\Yb \Y ghcdg Xf]b_]b[& cf k\Uh U gac_Yf ZYY`g k\Yb \Y ghcdg gac_]b[( Oci k]`` ZYY` h\Uh mci \UjY Vfci[\h fY`]YZ hc mcif gci`(

AJHSVGSX Ą J\Y aUhYf]U` Yj]` WUigYX Vm kUf ]g V][& Vih ]h ]g ]bWcadUfUx V`m gaU`` ]b WcadUf]gcb k]h\ h\Y dYfjYfg]cb cf h\Y ibXYfx ghUbX]b[ cZ [ccX UbX VUX k\]W\ \UddYbg Xif]b[ h\Y kUf& UbX k\]W\ ]g dih ]bhc h\Y gci`g cZ dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch h\]b_( - FKLOG PHHWV DQRWKHU FKLOG ZLWK D VPLOH$ GLVSOD\LQJ KLV IULHQGO\ DWWLWXGH DQG MR\& ?KLV VDPH EHKDYLRU OLYHV LQ DOO VLQ% FHUH SHRSOH& .XW YHU\ RIWHQ$ D PDQ IURP RQH QDWLRQ DOUHDG\ KDWHV D PDQ IURP DQRWKHU QDWLRQ$ DQG LV UHDG\ WR FDXVH KLP VXIIHULQJV DQG HYHQ GHDWK$ HYHQ EHIRUH KH PHHWV KLP& ?KRVH ZKR FUHDWH WKHVH IHHOLQJV LQ QDWLRQV FRPPLW D WHUULEOH FULPH J\Y acgh dckYfZi` kYUdcb _bckb ]g h\Y kYUdcb cZ V`Ygg]b[( J\YfYZcfY& U W`YjYf dYfgcb fY`]Yg cb ]h( >Y k]bg k]h\ dYUWY& bch k]h\ kUf( vB7E'JPK

MUf WfYUhYg U ghUhY ]b k\]W\ dckYf UbX [`cfm ]g Uh h\Y YbX hcc cZhYb fYWY]jYX Vm h\Y acgh ibXYgYfj]b[ UbX j]W]cig dYcd`Y(

AJHSVGSX ÁÀ J\Y \][\Yf h\Y cd]b]cb U dYfgcb \Ug cZ \]agY`Z& h\Y acfY ibghUV`Y ]g \]g dcg]h]cb5 h\Y `ckYf \Y acjYg ]b \]g gY`Zx YghYYa& h\Y Z]faYf \Y ghUbXg( Jc VY ghfcb[& mci \UjY hc VY `]_Y kUhYf4 ]Z h\YfY UfY bc cVghUW`Yg& ]h Z`ckg4 ]Z h\YfY ]g Ub cVghUW`Y ]h ghcdg5 ]Z U XUa ]g Vfc_Yb& h\Yb ]h Z`ck"g Zifh\Yf5 ]Z U jYggY` ]g geiUfY& h\Yb ]h \Ug U geiUfY Zcfa5 ]Z U jYggY` ]g fcibX& h\Yb ]h \Ug U fcibX Zcfa( 8YWUigY ]h ]g gc gcZh UbX Z`Yl]V`Y& ]h ]g h\Y acgh bYWx YggUfm UbX h\Y ghfcb[Ygh h\]b[( vB7E'JPK

J\Y acfY U dYfgcb UbU`mnYg \]g ]bbYf gY`Z& h\Y acfY ]bg][b]Z]WUbh \Y gYYag hc \]agY`Z( J\]g ]g h\Y Z]fgh `Yggcb cZ k]gXca( BYh ig VY \iaV`Y& UbX kY k]`` VYWcaY k]gY( BYh ig _bck cif kYU_bYgg& UbX ]h k]`` []jY ig dckYf( vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

MUhYf XcYg bch ghUm cb U acibhU]b'hcd& Vih Z`ckg ]bhc h\Y jU``Ym( ?b h\Y gUaY aUbbYf& fYU` j]fhiY XcYg bch fYaU]b k]h\ h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c kUbh hc VY \][\Yf h\Ub h\Y ch\Yfg5 Vih j]fhiY ghUmg cb`m k]h\ dYcd`Y k\c UfY \iaV`Y( v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

?U\ WR ILQG RXW \RXU SRWHQWLDO& -IWHU \RX NQRZ LW$ GR QRW EH DIUDLG WR XQGHUHVWLPDWH LW& .H FDXWLRXV QRW WR H[DJJHUDWH LW&

AJHSVGSX ÁÁ - SHUVRQ_V OLIH LV JRRG RQO\ WR WKH H[WHQW WKDW LW IXOILOOV WKH H[SHFWDWLRQV RI WKH ZLOO RI 3RG& ;j]`& ]b h\Y Zcfa cZ giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\& ]g YjYfmk\YfY UddUfYbh hc U dYfgcb k\c UWWYdhg h\Y `Uk cZ \]g aUhYf]U`& Ub]aU` Yl]ghYbWY Ug h\Y aU^cf `Uk cZ \]g `]ZY( Eb`m k\Yb U aUb `ckYfg \]agY`Z hc h\Y ghUhY cZ Ub Ub]aU` XcYg XYUh\ UbX giZZYf]b[ gWUfY \]a( J\Y cb`m fcUX cdYb Zcf \]a hc YgWUdY h\Uh ZYUf ]g h\Y fcUX cZ Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ h\Y `Uk cZ =cX& h\Y `Uk k\]W\ ]g YldfYggYX ]b `cjY( J\YfY ]g bc XYUh\ UbX bc giZZYf]b[ Zcf U aUb k\c `]jYg UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y `Uk cZ =cX^ 8Y Ug mci UfY& Ug mci \UjY hc VY& UbX h\Y fYgh ]g =cXrg Vig]x bYgg( v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ cif Xih]Yg UbX h\Y gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ cif dYfgcbU` d`YUgifYg UfY hkc X]ZZYfYbh h\]b[g( :ih]Yg \UjY h\Y]f ckb `Ukg& UbX YjYb ]Z kY hfm hc a]l cif Xih]Yg k]h\ cif d`YUgifYg& h\Ym k]`` gYdUfUhY h\YagY`jYg( v7ZhYf ?CC7DK;B A7DJ

MY _bck h\Y `Uk cZ =cX& Vch\ Ug ]h ]g dfYgYbhYX hc ig Vm h\Y X]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cbg cZ h\Y kcf`X UbX Ug cif ckb Wcbx gW]YbWY& k\Yb ]h ]g bch cVgWifYX Vm dUgg]cb UbX dfY^iX]WY& UbX kY WUb YUg]`m ibXYfghUbX h\Y Udd`]WUh]cbg cZ h\]g `Uk hc cif `]ZY& Zcf U`` fYU` [ccX ghYag Zfca ]hg fYei]fYaYbhg(

AJHSVGSX ÁÂ ?h ]g cVj]cig Zcf YjYfmcbY h\Uh XYUh\ YldYWhg ig U`` ]b h\Y `cb[ fib5 Vih bYjYfh\Y`Ygg kY `]jY cif `]jYg Ug ]Z h\YfY k]`` VY bc XYUh\( ?Z cb`m =cX ]g Uacb[ ig& UbX YhYfb]hm Yl]ghg& h\Yb YjYfmx h\]b[ ]g X]ZZYfYbh( MY WUb X]gh]b[i]g\ [ccX Zfca Yj]`& `][\h Zfca XUf_bYgg& UbX XYgdU]f X]gUddYUfg( v;H7ICKI

EbY cZ h\Y _Ym eiYgh]cbg kY ZUWY ]g k\Yh\Yf cif `]jYg YbX UZhYf XYUh\( M\Yh\Yf kY VY`]YjY ]b YhYfb]hm cf bch XYhYfx a]bYg cif UWh]cbg( J\YfYZcfY& ]h ]g WfiW]U` h\Uh kY XYhYfx a]bY k\Uh ]g acfhU` ]b ig& UbX k\Uh ]g YhYfbU`& UbX h\Uh kY W\Yf]g\ h\cgY h\]b[g YhYfbU`( Ccgh dYcd`Y Xc YlUWh`m h\Y cddcg]hY( v7ZhYf 8B7?I; F7I97B

?KH PRUH GHHSO\ \RX XQGHUVWDQG OLIH$ WKH OHVV \RX JULHYH RYHU WKH GHVWUXFWLRQ FDXVHG E\ GHDWK& M\UhYjYf bUaY mci []jY hc h\Y cf][]b cZ aUb& h\]g gd]f]x hiU` eiU`]hm cZ \iaUbg hc ibXYfghUbX& ZYY`& UbX Yl]gh& ]h ]g \c`m& ]h ]g X]j]bY& UbX& h\YfYZcfY& ]h g\ci`X VY YhYfbU`( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

AJHSVGSX ÁÃ HY`][]cb ]g U d\]`cgcd\m k\]W\ WUb VY ibXYfghccX Vm Ubmx cbY( - SHUVRQ FDQ SOHDVH 3RG RQO\ ZLWK WKH JRGOLQHVV RI KLV OLIH& 5I DQ RXWZDUGO\ IDLWKIXO SHUVRQ LV QRW JRRG$ FOHDU$ DQG KXPEOH LQ KLV OLIH$ WKHQ KH SUHVHQWV D ELJ OLH$ KH VHUYHV 3RG IDOVHO\& v7ZhYf ?CC7DK;B A7DJ

HY`][]cb ]g g]ad`Y k]gXca k\]W\ ]g X]fYWhYX hc h\Y \YUfh UbX ibXYfghccX Vm h\Y ]bhY``YWh( HY`][]cb WUb Yb`][\hYb d\]`cgcd\]WU` aYX]hUh]cbg5 d\]`cx gcd\]WU` aYX]hUh]cbg WUb ghfYb[h\Yb fY`][]cb( J\YfYZcfY& hfm hc Wcaaib]WUhY Vch\ k]h\ hfi`m fY`][]cig dYcd`Y UbX hfi`m [ccX d\]`cgcd\Yfg& U`]jY UbX XYUX(

BHSVGSX ÁÄ 7 \c`m gd]f]h `]jYg k]h\]b mci( @Ygig UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc \]a& LYf]`m& jYf]`m& ? gUm ibhc h\YY& ;lWYdh U aUb VY Vcfb U[U]b& \Y WUbbch gYY h\Y _]b[x Xca cZ =cX( v@E>D -4-

?bhY``YWh WUb VY Yb`][\hYbYX cb`m ]b U _]bX dYfgcb( 7 dYfx gcb WUb VY _]bX cb`m k\Yb \Y \Ug Ub Yb`][\hYbYX ]bhY``YWh( EbY \Y`dg h\Y ch\Yf( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

7 aYfW\Ubh aUff]YX U df]bWYgg& UbX \Y Vi]`h U dU`UWY Zcf \Yf& Vci[\h `ilif]cig XfYggYg Zcf \Yf& UbX Vfci[\h \Yf \ibXfYXg cZ gYfjUbhg hc aU_Y \Yf \Uddm( 8ih h\Y df]bWYgg kUg VcfYX( I\Y kUg a]gg]b[ gcaYh\]b[& UbX g\Y WcbghUbh`m h\ci[\h UVcih \Yf fcmU` cf][]b( J\ig ]h ]g k]h\ U \iaUb gci`4 mci WUb giffcibX ]h k]h\ U`` h\Y d`YUgifYg cb YUfh\& Vih ]h k]`` gh]`` VY a]gg]b[ ]hg \caY& h\Y VY[]bb]b[ k\]W\ ]g WU``YX =cX& h\Y d`UWY Zfca k\]W\ ]h \Ug cf][]bUhYX( v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

;jYb ]Z dYcd`Y Xc bch _bck k\Uh fYU` _]bXbYgg ]g& h\Ym bYjYfh\Y`Ygg \UjY ]h k]h\]b h\Ya( v9ED<K9?KI

3RG OLYHV LQ HYHU\ RQH RI XV& BKHQ D SHUVRQ UHPHPEHUV WKLV$ WKH WKRXJKW RI LW FDQ VDYH KLP IURP HYLO$ DQG KHOS KLP WR GR JRRG&

AJHSVGSX ÁĀ J\YfY ]g g]ad`]W]hm cZ bUhifY& UbX h\YfY ]g g]ad`]W]hm cZ k]gXca( 8ch\ cZ h\Ya Yjc_Y `cjY UbX fYgdYWh( ?KH JUHDWHVW WUXWK LV WKH PRVW VLPSOH RQH& M\Yb dYcd`Y gdYU_ ]b U jYfm Y`UVcfUhY UbX gcd\]gh]WUhYX kUm& h\Ym Y]h\Yf kUbh hc hY`` U `]Y& cf hc UXa]fY h\YagY`jYg( Oci g\ci`X bch VY`]YjY giW\ dYcd`Y( =ccX gdYYW\ ]g U`kUmg W`YUf& W`YjYf& UbX ibXYfghccX Vm U``( I]ad`]W]hm ]g h\Y WcbgYeiYbWY cZ fYZ]bYX Yach]cbg(

v@;7D :r7B;C8;HJ

McfXg WUb ib]hY dYcd`Y( J\YfYZcfY& hfm hc gdYU_ jYfm W`YUf`m& UbX hY`` cb`m h\Y hfih\& Zcf bch\]b[ WUb ib]hY dYcx d`Y acfY h\Ub hfih\ UbX g]ad`]W]hm(

<YVfiUfm +0 J\Y mcib[Yf UbX h\Y acfY df]a]h]jY U dYfgcb ]g& h\Y acfY \Y cf g\Y VY`]YjYg h\Uh `]ZY ]g aUhYf]U` UbX h\Uh ]h Yl]ghg cb`m ]b h\Y VcXm J\Y c`XYf UbX k]gYf U dYfgcb VYWcaYg& h\Y acfY \Y cf g\Y ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh U`` `]ZY cf][]bUhYg Zfca h\Y gd]f]h( Bcc_ Uh h\Y g_m& UbX Uh h\Y YUfh\& UbX h\]b_ h\Uh U`` h\]b[g dUgg( 7`` cZ h\Y acibhU]bg UbX f]jYfg mci gYY& UbX U`` h\Y Zcfag cZ `]ZY& UbX U`` WfYUh]cbg cZ bUhifY& U`` dUgg( J\Yb mci k]`` ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfih\5 mci k]`` gYY k\Uh fYaU]bg& k\Uh XcYg bch dUgg( v v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

HYaYaVYf h\Uh mci UfY bch acfhU`5 cb`m' mcif VcXm ]g acfhU`( M\Uh ]g U`]jY ]g bch mcif VcXm Vih h\Y gd]f]h `]j]b[ ]b mcif VcXm( 7b ibgYYb ZcfWY [i]XYg mcif VcXm& ^igh Ug Ub ibgYYb ZcfWY [i]XYg h\Y kcf`X( v7ZhYf C7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

- SHUVRQ FDQ XQGHUVWDQG KLV UHDO GHVWLQDWLRQ LQ OLIH RQO\ DIWHU KH PDQDJHV WR OLEHUDWH KLPVHOI IURP WKH VHQVXDO^ PDWHUc LDO ZRUOG&

AJHSVGSX ÁÅ 7`` dYcd`Y cZ h\Y kcf`X \UjY Ub YeiU` f][\h hc h\Y df]j]x `Y[Yg cZ h\]g kcf`X( ;eiU`]hm WUbbch VY fYUW\YX& Ug gcaY dYcd`Y h\]b_& cb`m Vm W]j]` aYUgifYg( ?h WUb VY fYUW\YX cb`m Vm `cjY cZ =cX UbX dYcd`Y& UbX h\]g `cjY WUb VY fYUW\YX& bch Vm W]j]` aYUx gifYg& Vih cb`m Ug h\Y fYgi`h cZ gd]f]hiU` `YUfb]b[( ?KH\ VD\ WKDW HTXDOLW\ LV QRW SRVVLEOH$ EHFDXVH VRPH SHRSOH ZLOO DOZD\V EH VWURQJHU RU VPDUWHU WKDQ RWKHUV& .XW LW LV H[DFWO\ EHFDXVH RI WKLV$ VDLG 8LFKWHQEHUJ$ SUHFLVHO\ EHFDXVH VRPH SHRSOH DUH VWURQJHU DQG VPDUWHU WKDQ RWKHUV$ WKDW WKH SULQFLSOH RI HTXDOLW\ LV QHFHVVDU\& ?KH DGYDQWDJHV RI WKH ULFK RYHU WKH SRRU GHPRQVWUDWH QRW RQO\ LQHTXDOLW\ RI IRUFH DQG LQWHOOHFW$ EXW LQHTXDOLW\ RI FLYLO ULJKWV& 9\f]gh fYjYU`YX hc \iaUb]hm h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ h\Y]f VYgh gY`jYg U`fYUXm _bYk4 h\Uh dYcd`Y UfY YeiU` VYWUigY h\Y gUaY gd]f]h `]jYg ]b U`` cZ h\Ya( ( ( ( BYUfb Zfca h\Y gaU`` W\]`XfYb& VY\UjY `]_Y W\]`XfYb& UbX hfYUh U`` dYcd`Y cb Ub YeiU` VUg]g& k]h\ `cjY UbX hYbXYfbYgg(

BACD CE FG FYfgcbU`]hm ]g U aUg_ k\]W\ X]g[i]gYg h\Y X]j]bY VY]b[ k\]W\ `]jYg ]b YjYfm dYfgcb( J\Y acfY cbY fY^YWhg dYfgcbx U`]hm& h\Y acfY h\]g X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[ ]g aUb]ZYghYX( Oci aigh `cjY cb`m =cX& UbX mci aigh \UhY cb`m mcifgY`Z( v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\YfYZcfY Xch\ am <Uh\Yf `cjY aY& VYWUigY ? `Um Xckb am `]ZY& h\Uh ? a][\h hU_Y ]h U[U]b( Dc aUb hU_Yh\ ]h Zfca aY& Vih ? `Um ]h Xckb cZ amgY`Z( ? \UjY dckYf hc `Um ]h Xckb& UbX ? \UjY dckYf hc hU_Y ]h U[U]b( J\]g WcaaUbXx aYbh \UjY ? fYWY]jYX cZ am <Uh\Yf( v@E>D +*4+1'+2

Eb`m h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c XYbm h\Y]f ckb dYfgcbU`]hm WUb ibXYfghUbX h\Y fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[( vJ\Y J7BCK:

>Y k\c kUbhg hc gUjY \]g gci`& k]`` `cgY ]h5 UbX \Y k\c kUbhg hc `cgY \]g `]ZY Zcf aY UbX h\Y bYk hYghUaYbh& k]`` gUjY ]h( vC7HA 24-/

J\cgY k\c Xc bch gYY h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ h\Y]f `]ZY ]b hYadcx fUfm h\]b[g& ]b h\Y]f bUaYg UbX VcX]Yg& h\cgY dYcd`Y _bck h\Y hfih\ cZ `]ZY( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

;QO\ ZKHQ ZH IRUJHW DERXW RXUVHOYHV$ ZKHQ ZH JHW RXW RI WKH WKRXJKWV RI RXUVHOYHV$ FDQ ZH IUXLWIXOO\ FRPPXQLFDWH ZLWK RWKHUV$ OLVWHQ WR WKHP$ DQG LQIOXHQFH WKHP&

AJHSVGSX ÁĄ 5W LV D VLQ QRW WR EH HQJDJHG LQ ZRUN$ HYHQ LI LW LV QRW QHFHVc VDU\ IRU \RX WR PDNH \RXU OLYLQJ ZLWK HYHU\GD\ ZRUN& EbY cZ h\Y VYgh UbX difYgh ^cmg ]g \Uj]b[ U fYgh UZhYf `UVcf(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

Mcf_ U`` h\Y h]aY( :c bch h\]b_ h\Uh kcf_ ]g U X]gUghYf Zcf mci& UbX Xc bch gYY_ dfU]gY cf fYkUfX Zcf mcif kcf_( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y acgh cihghUbX]b[ []Zhg WUb VY XYghfcmYX Vm ]X`YbYgg(

vC?9>;B :; CEDJ7?=D;

Dch\]b[ WUb aU_Y U dYfgcb ZYY` acfY bcV`Y h\Ub kcf_( M]h\cih kcf_& U dYfgcb WUbbch \UjY \iaUb X][b]hm( ?h ]g VYWUigY cZ h\]g h\Uh ]X`Y dYcd`Y UfY gc aiW\ WcbWYfbYX Vm h\Y gidYfZ]W]U`& cihYf YldfYgg]cb cZ h\Y]f ]adcfhUbWY5 h\Ym _bck h\Uh k]h\cih h\]g& ch\Yf dYcd`Y kci`X XYgd]gY h\Ya( M\Yb kY UWWYdh hfih\ UbX fYdYbh cif g]bg& kY ibXYfghUbX h\Uh bcVcXm WUb \UjY gdYW]U` f][\hg& UXjUbhU[Yg& cf df]j]x `Y[Yg ]b h\]g `]ZY( J\YfY ]g bc YbX cf `]a]h hc cif Xih]Yg UbX cV`][Uh]cbg( 7bX h\Y Z]fgh UbX h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh cV`][Ux h]cb Zcf ig ]g hc Z][\h k]h\ bUhifY Zcf cif `]ZY UbX Zcf h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

AJHSVGSX ÂÀ >iaUb_]bX [cYg cb k]h\cih ghcdd]b[( J\]g acjYaYbh ZcfkUfX ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf mci Ug Ub ]bX]j]XiU` Ug kY``( ?Z mci kUbh hc gYfjY =cX& mci g\ci`X VY U kcf_Yf Zcf h\Y gd]f]hiU` dfc[fYgg cZ \iaUb]hm( J\Y kUm cZ `]ZY cZ Ubm dYcd`Y XYdYbXg cb h\Y]f ZU]h\( <U]h\& k]h\ h]aY& VYWcaYg acfY g]ad`Y& acfY W`YUf& UbX W`cgYf hc h\Y fYU` hfih\& UbX ]b UWWcfXUbWY k]h\ h\Y g]ad`]x Zm]b[ UbX W`Uf]Zm]b[ cZ ZU]h\& dYcd`Y VYWcaY acfY UbX acfY Kb]hYX( ?Z mci h\]b_ ]h ]g YjYf kUffUbhYX hc ghcd cb h\Y dUh\ cZ Zifh\Yf ibXYfghUbX]b[& mci UfY jYfm ZUf Zfca h\Y hfih\( J\Y `]ZY k\]W\ kY fYWY]jYX kUg []jYb hc ig bch h\Uh kY a][\h ^igh UXa]fY ]h& Vih h\Uh kY g\ci`X YjYf `cc_ Zcf bYk hfih\ \]XXYb Zfca ig( v7ZhYf @E>D C?BJED

CUb_]bX aU_Yg dfc[fYgg k\Yb ]hg ZU]h\ dfc[fYggYg( 7bX ]Z h\YfY ]g Ubm dfc[fYgg ]b fY`][]cb& ]h ]g bch ]b h\Y X]gWcjx Yfm cZ gcaYh\]b[ bYk& Vih ]b h\Y dif]Zm]b[ cZ h\Y hfih\g k\]W\ \UjY VYYb fYjYU`YX UbX Yld`U]bYX hc ig( MY g\ci`X bch giVgh]hihY fYU` fY`][]cig dfc[fYgg k]h\ ch\Yf hmdYg cZ dfc[fYgg4 (hYW\b]WU`& gW\c`Uf`m& UbX Ufh]gh]W( J\YgY hYW\b]WU`& gW\c`Uf`m& UbX Ufh]gh]W UW\]YjYaYbhg WUb WYfhU]b`m WcYl]gh k]h\ fY`][]cig VUW_kUfXbYgg& Ug \UddYbg ]b cif h]aY( 5I \RX ZDQW WR VHUYH 3RG$ \RX VKRXOG ZRUN RQ WKH VLGH RI UHOLJLRXV SURJUHVV LQ WKH ILJKW DJDLQVW SUHMXGLFH$ WRZDUG D EHWc WHU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH FOHDU DQG SXUH UHOLJLRQ&

AJHSVGSX ÂÁ J\YfY kUg U h]aY k\Yb dYcd`Y UhY YUW\ ch\Yf( J\Ym bc `cb[Yf Xc gc& Vih h\Ym gh]`` YUh Ub]aU`g( J\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb acfY UbX acfY dYcd`Y k]`` Xfcd h\]g hYff]V`Y \UV]h( 5W LV D PLVWDNH WR EHOLHYH WKDW ZH QHHG REH\ QR PRUDO LQ RXU DWWLWXGH WR WKH DQLPDOV$ WKDW ZH KDYH QR PRUDO UHVSRQVLELOLc WLHV WR WKHP& ?KLV ZD\ OLHV FRPSOHWH YXOJDULW\ DQG UXGHQHVV& v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

J\Y _]``]b[ UbX YUh]b[ cZ Ub]aU`g ]g U dfY^iX]WY UWWYdhYX Vm h\cgY k\c h\]b_ h\Uh Ub]aU`g kYfY []jYb hc dYcd`Y Vm =cX hc YUh& gc h\Uh h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ kfcb[ ]b _]``]b[ h\Ya( J\]g ]g bch hfiY( ?h aUm VY kf]hhYb ]b gcaY Vcc_g h\Uh ]h ]g bch U g]b hc _]`` Ub Ub]aU`& Vih ]h ]g kf]hhYb ]b cif ckb \YUfhg acfY W`YUf`m h\Ub ]b Ubm Vcc_gvh\Uh kY g\ci`X hU_Y d]hm cb Ub]aU`g ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug kY Xc cb YUW\ ch\Yf( 7bX kY U`` _bck h\]g& ]Z kY Xc bch XYUXYb h\Y jc]WY cZ cif WcbgW]YbWY ]bg]XY cZ ig(

AJHSVGSX ÂÂ 7`` h\Uh ]g kf]hhYb UVcih =cX& UbX U`` h\Uh dYcd`Y gUm UVcih >]a& gh]`` ZU``g g\cfh cZ h\Y aUf_( 9YfhU]b h\]b[g& k\]W\ YjYfm dYfgcb WUb XQGHUVWDQG UVcih =cX& WUb bYjYf VY YldfYggYX& h\]b[g bYWYggUfm Zcf YjYfmcbY& UbX h\]b[g k\]W\ WUigY h\Y `cjY cZ =cX( v7ZhYf 7D=;BKI I?B;I?KI

7b ]bhY``YWh k\]W\ WUb VY ibXYfghccX ]g bch Ub YhYfbU` ]bhY``YWh5 U VY]b[ k\]W\ WUb VY bUaYX ]g bch Ub YhYfbU` VY]b[( vB7E'JPK

J\YfY ]g U ZcfWY k\]W\ fYg]XYg ]b U`` h\]b[g& k]h\cih k\]W\ h\YfY ]g bc \YUjYb UbX bc YUfh\( J\]g ZcfWY WUbbch VY dYfx WY]jYX( FYcd`Y hfm hc XYgWf]VY ]hg eiU`]h]Yg& hc []jY ]h X]ZZYfx Ybh bUaYg& giW\ Ug s]bhY``YWht cf s`cjY&t Vih h\Y VY]b[ ]hgY`Z \Ug bc bUaY( ?h ]g jYfm fYachY Zfca ig& UbX ]h ]g W`cgYgh hc ig( v7ZhYf B7E'JPK

3RG LV WKH OLPLWOHVV EHLQJ ZKLFK DFFHSWV RQO\ WUXWK&

vC7JJ>;M 7HDEB:

J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Ug_ k\YfY =cX ]g UfY WfUnm5 =cX ]g YjYfmk\YfY& ]b U`` cZ bUhifY UbX ]b h\Y gci` cZ YUW\ dYfgcb( J\YfY UfY aUbm X]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cbg& Vih h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY =cX( ?Z U dYfgcb WUbbch ibXYfghUbX \]agY`Z& \ck WUb \Y ibXYfghUbX =cX6 v?D:?7D M?I:EC

?Z mcif YmYg VYWcaY V`]bXYX Vm h\Y gib& mci Xc bch gUm h\Uh h\Y gib XcYg bch Yl]gh( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& mci g\ci`X bch gUm h\Uh =cX XcYg bch Yl]gh ]Z mcif ]bhY``YWh ]g `cgh ]b hfm]b[ hc ibXYfghUbX \]a( v7ZhYf 7D=;BKI I?B;I?KI

AJHSVGSX ÂÃ J\Y Yl]gh]b[ XYg][b cZ `]ZY WcffYgdcbXg bY]h\Yf hc h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ WcbgW]YbWY bcf hc h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ ]bhY``YWh( ?aU[]bY U Z`cW_ cZ d][Ycbg ]b U Wcfb Z]Y`X( ?aU[]bY h\Uh b]bYhm'b]bY cZ h\Ya& ]bghYUX cZ dYW_]b[ h\Y Wcfb h\Ym bYYX UbX ig]b[ ]h Ug h\Ym bYYX ]h& ghUfh hc Wc``YWh U`` h\Ym WUb ]bhc cbY V][ \YUd( ?aU[]bY h\Uh h\Ym Xc bch `YUjY " aiW\ Wcfb Zcf h\YagY`jYg& Vih gUjY h\]g V][ \YUd cZ Wcfb cb VY\U`Z cZ h\Y j]`Ygh UbX kcfgh ]b h\Y]f Z`cW_( ?aU[]bY h\Uh h\Ym U`` g]h ]b U W]fW`Y UbX kUhW\ h\]g cbY d][YcbS k\c geiUbXYfg UbX kUghYg h\]g kYU`h\( 7bX h\Yb ]aU[]bY h\Uh h\Ym fig\ Uh U kYU_ d][Ycb k\c ]g h\Y acgh \ib[fm Uacb[ h\Ya k\c XUfYgh hc hU_Y cbY [fU]b Zfca h\Y \YUd k]h\cih dYfa]gg]cb& UbX h\Ym dib]g\ \]a( ?Z mci WUb ]aU[]bY h\]g& h\Yb mci WUb ibXYfghUbX h\Y XUm'hc'XUm VY\Uj]cf cZ aUb_]bX( vM?BB?7C F7B;O

? gYY dYcd`Y Uf[i]b[ k]h\ YUW\ ch\Yf& dfYdUf]b[ X]ZZYfYbh hfUdg Zcf YUW\ ch\Yf& `m]b[ UbX VYhfUm]b[ YUW\ ch\Yf( ? WUbx bch gYY k]h\cih hYUfg h\Uh h\Y ZcibXUh]cbg cZ =ccX UbX ;j]` UfY Zcf[chhYb& cf ]b gcaY WUgYg Wcad`YhY`m ib_bckb( vJ>;E=D?I

<HRSOH DUH UDWLRQDO FUHDWXUHV& BK\ GR WKH\ VHHP FDSDEOH RI XVLQJ YLROHQFH VR PXFK PRUH HDVLO\ WKDQ UHDVRQ LQ WKHLU LQWHUDFWLRQV ZLWK HDFK RWKHU,

AJHSVGSX ÂÄ <cf U hfih\ hc VY \YUfX& ]h aigh VY gdc_Yb k]h\ _]bXbYgg( Jfih\ ]g _]bX cb`m k\Yb ]h ]g gdc_Yb h\fci[\ mcif \YUfh k]h\ g]bWYf]hm( Oci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh k\Yb U aYggU[Y mci WcbjYm hc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb ]g bch ibXYfghccX Vm \]a& Uh `YUgh cbY cZ h\Y Zc``ck]b[ h\]b[g ]g hfiY4 k\Uh mci \UjY gU]X ]g bch hfiY& cf mci \UjY WcbjYmYX ]h k]h\cih _]bXx bYgg( J\Y cb`m kUm hc hY`` h\Y hfih\ ]g hc gdYU_ k]h\ _]bXbYgg( Eb`m h\Y kcfXg cZ U `cj]b[ aUb WUb VY \YUfX( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

Jc hY`` h\Y hfih\ ]g h\Y gUaY Ug hc VY U [ccX hU]`cf& cf hc VY U [ccX ZUfaYf& cf hc kf]hY VYUih]Zi``m( Jc VY [ccX Uh Ubm UWh]j]hm fYei]fYg dfUWh]WY4 bc aUhhYf \ck \UfX mci hfm& mci WUbbch Xc bUhifU``m k\Uh mci \UjY bch XcbY fYdYUhx YX`m( ?b cfXYf hc [Yh UWWighcaYX hc gdYU_]b[ h\Y hfih\& mci g\ci`X hY`` cb`m h\Y hfih\& YjYb ]b h\Y gaU``Ygh cZ h\]b[g( BH OLH WR RWKHU SHRSOH VR RIWHQ WKDW ZH JHW XVHG WR LW$ DQG ZH VWDUW WR OLH WR RXUVHOYHV& v<H7D9E?I :; B7 HE9>;<EK97KB:

Jfih\ WUbbch aU_Y U dYfgcb ib_]bX& cf hcc gY`Z'UggifYX5 h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ hfih\ hY``]b[ UfY \ia]`]hm UbX g]ax d`]W]hm(

AJHSVGSX ÂĀ ?R SUD\ LV WR DFFHSW DQG WR UHPHPEHU WKH ODZV RI WKH OLPLWOHVV EHLQJ$ 3RG$ DQG WR PHDVXUH DOO \RXU GHHGVvSDVW$ SUHVHQW$ DQG IXWXUHbDFFRUGLQJ WR 4LV ODZV& 8YZcfY mci ghUfh dfUm]b[& Ug_ mcifgY`Z k\Yh\Yf Uh h\Uh acaYbh mci WUb WcbWYbhfUhY5 ch\Yfk]gY& Xc bch dfUm Uh U``( J\cgY k\c aU_Y U \UV]h cih cZ dfUmYf Xc bch dfUm g]bx WYfY`m( vJ\Y J7BCK:

?Z mci Ug_ Zcf giddcfh Zfca =cX& h\Yb mci k]`` `YUfb \ck hc Z]bX ]h ]b mcifgY`Z( >Y XcYg bch W\Ub[Y ig& Vih kY W\Ub[Y cifgY`jYg Vm [Yhh]b[ W`cgYf hc >]a( 7`` Ug_ Zfca >]a& Ug ]Z >Y g\ci`X \Y`d ig& Vih ]b h\Y YbX kY []jY h\YgY h\]b[g hc cifgY`jYg( v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

<fca h\Y UbW]Ybh h]aYg& ]h \Ug VYYb _bckb h\Uh dfUmYf ]g U \iaUb bYWYgg]hm( FYcd`Y igY X]ZZYfYbh f]hiU`g Xif]b[ dfUmYf& gdYW]U` UXXfYggYg ]b gdYW]U` W]fWiaghUbWYg& ]b gdYW]U` d`UWYg& ]b h\Y kUmg h\Ym dfYgYbh h\Y]f aYggU[Y hc =cX UbX Ug_ >]a hc VY _]bX( 8ih `Yh h\YfY VY h\]g WcbghUbh4 Xif]b[ U dfUmYf& Zcf[Yh UVcih U`` YlhYfbU` kcf`X`m h\]b[g UbX UXXfYgg h\Y X]j]bY dUfh cZ mcif gci`( KgY h\]g X]j]bY dUfh hc [U]b Wcaaib]WUx h]cb k]h\ h\Uh cZ k\]W\ ]h ]g U dUfh UbX k\Yb mci ZYY` mcifx gY`Z W`cgY hc =cX& mci XY`]jYf mcif gci` hc >]a& UbX g\ck >]a U`` mcif XYYXg UbX k]g\Yg( FfUmYf XcYg bch \UddYb UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ h\Y kcf`X& Vih UWWcfXx ]b[ hc h\Y X]j]bY dUfh cZ mcif gci`(

AJHSVGSX ÂĂ 7ZhYf U `cb[ WcbjYfgUh]cb& ghcd UbX hfm hc fYaYaVYf k\Uh mci \UjY ^igh X]gWiggYX( :cbrh VY gifdf]gYX ]Z aUbm h\]b[g& gcaYh]aYg YjYb YjYfmh\]b[ mci \UjY X]gWiggYX& kYfY aYUb]b[`Ygg& Yadhm& UbX hf]j]U`& UbX gcaYh]aYg YjYb VUX( 7 ghid]X dYfgcb g\ci`X _YYd g]`Ybh( 8ih ]Z \Y _bYk h\]g& \Y kci`X bch VY U ghid]X dYfgcb( vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

Eb`m gdYU_ k\Yb mcif kcfXg UfY VYhhYf h\Ub mcif g]`YbWY(

v7H78?9 FHEL;H8

<cf YjYfm h]aY mci fY[fYh h\Uh mci X]X bch gUm gcaYh\]b[& mci k]`` fY[fYh U \ibXfYX h]aYg h\Uh mci X]X bch _YYd mcif g]`YbWY( A]bX dYcd`Y UfY bYjYf ]bjc`jYX ]b Uf[iaYbhg& UbX h\cgY k\c `]_Y hc Uf[iY UfY bYjYf _]bX( Jfih\Zi` kcfXg UfY bch U`kUmg d`YUgUbh& UbX d`YUgUbh kcfXg UfY bch bYWYggUf]`m hfih\Zi`( SB7E'JPK 5I \RX ZDQW WR EH D FOHYHU SHUVRQ$ \RX KDYH WR OHDUQ KRZ WR DVN FOHYHUO\$ KRZ WR OLVWHQ DWWHQWLYHO\$ KRZ WR UHVSRQG TXLc HWO\$ DQG KRZ WR VWRS WDONLQJ ZKHQ WKHUH LV QRWKLQJ PRUH WR VD\& CUbm ghid]X h\]b[g UfY ihhYfYX Vm dYcd`Y k\cgY cb`m ach]jUh]cb ]g hc gUm gcaYh\]b[ cf][]bU`( vLEBJ7?H;

?Z mci \UjY h]aY hc h\]b_ VYZcfY mci ghUfh hU`_]b[& h\]b_& ?g ]h bYWYggUfm hc gdYU_6 M]`` k\Uh ? \UjY hc gUm \Ufa UbmcbY6

AJHSVGSX ÂÅ - FKDULW\ LV RQO\ WKHQ D UHDO FKDULW\ ZKHQ LW LQYROYHV VDFULILFH& Ocif [c`X UbX g]`jYf ]g WUb_YfYX5 UbX h\Y figh cZ h\Ya g\U`` VY U k]hbYgg U[U]bgh mci& UbX g\U`` YUh mcif Z`Yg\ Ug ]h kYfY Z]fY( v@7C;I /4-

?b acbYmv]b h\Y acbYm ]hgY`Z& ]b ]hg UWei]g]h]cb(& ]b ]hg dcggYgg]cbvh\YfY]g gcaYh\]b[ ]aacfU`( 7 hfi`m _]bX dYl!cb WUbbch VY f]W\( 7 f]W\ dYfgcb& k]h\x cih eiYgh]cb& ]g bch U _]bX cbY( v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

J\Yb gU]X @Ygig ibhc \]g X]gW]d`Yg& LYf]`m ? gUm ibhc mci& h\Uh U f]W\ aUb g\U`` \UfX`m YbhYf ]bhc h\Y _]b[Xca cZ \YUjYb( 7bX U[U]b ? gUm ibhc mci& ]h ]g YUg]Yf Zcf U WUaY` hc [c h\fci[\ h\Y YmY cZ U bYYX`Y& h\Ub Zcf U f]W\ aUb hc YbhYf ]bhc h\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX( vC7JJ>;M +34,-',.

AJHSVGSX ÂǺ -UW LV RQH RI WKH PHDQV RI XQLI\LQJ SHRSOH& ?Z VYUih]Zi` Ufh XcYg bch YldfYgg acfU` ]XYUg& ]XYUg k\]W\ ib]hY dYcd`Y& h\Yb ]h ]g bch Ufh& Vih cb`m YbhYfhU]baYbh( FYcd`Y bYYX hc VY YbhYfhU]bYX ]b cfXYf hc X]ghUbWY h\Yax gY`jYg Zfca X]gUddc]bhaYbh ]b h\Y]f `]jYg( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc ]aU[]bY h\Uh Ufh Wci`X X]Y& Vih ]h ]g bch dcgg]V`Y hc ]aU[]bY h\Uh fYU` Ufh Wci`X `]jY ]Z ]h VYWUaY U g`UjY cZ kYU`h\ h\Uh `Ui[\YX Uh h\Y dccf( 7fh ]g cbY cZ h\Y acgh dckYfZi` aYUbg cZ Wcbj]bW]b[ dYcx d`Y cZ Ubmh\]b[& Vch\ [ccX UbX VUX5 h\YfYZcfY& mci aigh VY jYfm WUfYZi` ]b ]hg igY( 7b Ufh]gh( ]g cbY cZ hkc h\]b[g4 \Y ]g Y]h\Yf U \][\ df]Ygh& cf U acfY cf `Ygg gaUfh YbhYfhU]bYf( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

CYX]hUh]cbg cf X]gWigg]cbg UVcih Ufh UfY h\Y acgh igY`Ygg dUgh]aYg _bckb( J\cgY k\c fYU``m _bck Ufh _bck h\Uh Ufh WUb gdYU_ kY`` k]h\ ]hg ckb `Ub[iU[Y& UbX h\Uh hc gdYU_ UVcih Ufh k]h\ kcfXg ]g igY`Ygg( Ccgh dYcd`Y k\c gdYU_ UVcih Ufh Xc bch ibXYfghUbX cf ZYY` fYU` Ufh(

AJHSVGSX ÂĄ Jc acjY& mci aigh _bck k\YfY hc [c& ]b hYfag Vch\ cZ YjYfmXUm ach]cb UbX cZ mcif k\c`Y `]ZY( ?b cfXYf hc `]jY U [ccX `]ZY& mci aigh _bck k\YfY `]ZY `YUXg( <HUIHFWLRQ LV RI 3RG& ?R ZLVK IRU SHUIHFWLRQ LV RI PDQ& v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

B]ZY ]g bch []jYb hc ig h\Uh kY a][\h `]jY ]X`m k]h\cih kcf_( Dc& cif `]ZY ]g U ghfi[[`Y UbX U ^cifbYm( =ccX g\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ Yj]`5 hfih\ g\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ ZU`gY\ccX5 ZfYYXca g\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ g`UjYfm5 `cjY g\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ \UhfYX( B]ZY ]g acjYaYbh& U kU`_ U`cb[ h\Y kUm cZ `]ZY hc h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ h\cgY ]XYUg k\]W\ ]``ia]bUhY ig& Vch\ ]b cif ]bhY``YWh UbX ]b cif \YUfhg& k]h\ X]j]bY `][\h( v7ZhYf =?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y ]XYU` ]g k]h\]b mci& UbX h\Y cVghUW`Y hc fYUW\]b[ h\]g ]XYU` ]g U`gc k]h\]b mci( Oci U`fYUXm dcggYgg U`` h\Y aUhYx f]U` Zfca k\]W\ hc WfYUhY mcif ]XYU` gY`Z( vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

MY g\ci`X VY`]YjY h\Uh h\Y [ccXbYgg k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b ig UbX ]b h\]g kcf`X k]`` VY Zi`Z]``YX( J\]g ]g h\Y aU^cf WcbX]x h]cb hc aU_Y ]h \UddYb(

CGSIL Á J\Y ZYUf cZ XYUh\ ]b aUb ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ \]g g]bg( J\Y acfY gd]f]hiU` U `]ZY U dYfgcb `YUXg& h\Y `Ygg \Y ]g UZfU]X cZ XYUh\( <cf U gd]f]hiU` dYfgcb XYUh\ aYUbg gYhh]b[ h\Y gd]f]h ZfYY Zfca h\Y VcXm( IiW\ U dYfgcb _bckg h\Uh h\Y h\]b[g k]h\ k\]W\ \Y `]jYg WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX( Eb`m h\cgY k\c Xc bch `]jY UfY bch UZfU]X cZ XYUh\( 5I DV >RFUDWHV VDLG$ GHDWK LV WKH VWDWH LQ ZKLFK ZH DELGH GXUc LQJ RXU VOHHS PDGH SHUPDQHQW$ ZH DOO NQRZ WKLV VWDWH$ DQG NQRZ WKHUH LV QRWKLQJ WHUULEOH LQ LW& -QG LI GHDWK LV D WUDQVIHU WR D EHWWHU OLIH$ DV PDQ\ SHRSOH WKLQN$ WKHQ GHDWK LV QRW HYLO EXW D EOHVVLQJ& MY g\ci`X [Yh fYUXm Zcf XYUh\& VYWUigY ]h k]`` WcaY& gccbYf cf `UhYf( J\Y VYgh h\]b[ hc Xc ]g hc `]jY U [ccX `]ZY( ?Z mci `]jY U [ccX `]ZY& mci g\ci`X bch VY UZfU]X cZ XYUh\(

CGSIL Â ?KH PRUH FORVHO\ D SHUVRQ XQLWHV ZLWK WKH ZLOO RI 3RG$ WKH ILUPHU WKLV SHUVRQ EHFRPHV LQ KLV DFWLRQV& M\Yb U hfUjY`Yf ghUfhg cb U hf]d U`cb[ U fcUX k\]W\ ]g ibXYf h\Y h\fYUh cZ fcVVYfg& \Y XcYg bch [c U`cbY( >Y kU]hg Zcf U Zf]YbX& gcaYcbY hc VY \]g YgWcfh& UbX h\Yb \Y Zc``ckg \]a UbX gc ]g dfchYWhYX Zfca fcVVYfg( 7 k]gY aUb `]jYg \]g `]ZY h\Y gUaY kUm( 8ih h\YfY UfY gc aUbm hfciV`Yg ]b h\]g kcf`X( >ck WUb kY ghUbX U`` cZ h\Ya6 M\Uh _]bX cZ U Zf]YbX cf YgWcfh k]`` kY Z]bX cb cif kUm& gc h\Uh kY aUm dUgg h\fci[\ cif `]jYg k]h\cih ZYUf6 M\YfY g\ci`X kY hifb6 J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY UbgkYf& cb`m cbY fYU` Zf]YbX( J\Uh ]g =cX( ?Z mci Zc``ck =cX YjYfmk\YfY& mci k]`` ghYYf W`YUf cZ hfciV`Y( Jc Zc``ck =cX ]g hc kUbh k\Uh >Y kUbhg& UbX bch hc kUbh k\Uh >Y XcYg bch kUbh( >ck hc UW\]YjY h\]g6 Oci \UjY hc ibXYfghUbX UbX Zc``ck >]g `Ukg( v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

:c bch k]g\ Zcf hcc aiW\& bcf h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y h\]b[g mci k]g\ Zcf UfY h\Y cb`m f][\h cf bYWYggUfm h\]b[g( Oci g\ci`X k]g\ cb`m Zcf h\cgY h\]b[g Zcf k\]W\ =cX k]g\Yg( v>;DH? 7C?;?(

J\Y f][\h dUh\ ]b `]ZY ]g jYfm bUffck& Vih ]h ]g ]adcfhUbh hc Z]bX ]h( Oci WUb ibXYfghUbX ]h& Ug kY`` Ug kY WUb ibXYfx ghUbX ]h& Ug U kU`_kUm cZ kccX Vi]`h UWfcgg U gkUad5 ]Z mci ghYd cZZ ]h& mci k]`` d`ib[Y ]bhc h\Y gkUad cZ a]gibx XYfghUbX]b[ UbX Yj]`( 7 k]gY aUb fYhifbg hc h\Y hfiY dUh\ Uh cbWY& Vih U kYU_ aUb d`ib[Yg Zifh\Yf UbX Zifh\Yf ]bhc h\Y gkUad& UbX ]h VYWcaYg acfY UbX acfY X]ZZ]Wi`h Zcf \]a hc [Yh cih(

CGSIL Ã M\Uh fYkUfX g\ci`X U [ccX XYYX Vf]b[ mci6 Eb`m h\Y ^cm mci fYWY]jY Vm dYfZcfa]b[ ]h( 7bX Ubm ch\Yf fYkUfX `YggYbg h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ h\]g ^cm( >Y k\c XcYg [ccX hc ch\Yfg aU_Yg h\Y V][[Ygh []Zh hc \]agY`Z( ÅHÁTWÁZ 7bbUYig IYbYWU

7 gU]bh dfUmYX hc =cX ]b h\Y Zc``ck]b[ kUm4 sE =cX& d`YUgY VY _]bX hc Yj]` dYcd`Y Ug aiW\ Ug mci UfY hc _]bX dYcx d`Y( A]bX dYcd`Y U`fYUXm ZYY` [ccX& VYWUigY h\Ym UfY _]bX(t vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

?Z mci Xc [ccX UbX Ug_ Zcf U fYkUfX& mci kYU_Yb h\Y ZcfWY cZ mcif [ccXbYgg( v<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

0R QRW OHW \RXU OHIW KDQG NQRZ ZKDW \RXU ULJKW KDQG LV GRLQJ& vC7JJ>;M 04-

M\Uh U ^cm ]h ]g hc Xc U [ccX XYYX 7bX h\]g ^cm ]g ghfcb[Ygh ]Z bc cbY _bckg h\Uh mci \UjY XcbY ]h(

CGSIL Ä ;Uh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]g U j]WY ^igh Ug VUX Ug aUbm ch\Yfg( MY cZhYb Xc bch bch]WY ]h ]b ch\Yfg& VYWUigY acgh cZ ig UfY giV^YWh hc ]h( J\YfY UfY g]bg U[U]bgh ch\Yfg& UbX g]bg U[U]bgh mcifgY`Z( Oci Wcaa]h g]bg U[U]bgh ch\Yfg k\Yb mci Xc bch fYgdYWh =cXrg gd]f]h ]b h\Ya5 mci Wcaa]h g]bg U[U]bgh mcifgY`Z k\Yb mci Xc bch fYgdYWh =cXrg gd]f]h ]b mcifgY`Z( EbY cZ h\Y acgh Wcaacb g]bg U[U]bgh mcifgY`Z ]g [`ihhcbm( 7 dYfgcb k\c cjYfYUhg WUbbch Z][\h `Un]bYgg5 UbX U `Unm aUb WUbbch Z][\h gYliU` X]gg]dUh]cb( 7`` gd]f]hiU` hYUW\x ]b[g ghUfh k]h\ fYghf]Wh]cbg& k]h\ Wcbhfc` cZ h\Y UddYh]hY( 3RG JDYH IRRG WR SHRSOH$ DQG WKH GHYLO JDYH FRRNV& IcWfUhYg& U k]gY aUb& hf]YX hc UVghU]b Zfca U`` ibbYWYggUfm h\]b[g( >Y gU]X h\Uh ZccX g\ci`X gYfjY mci ]b Z][\h]b[ mcif \ib[Yf& UbX bch ]b XYjY`cd]b[ gcd\]gh]WUhYX hUghYg& UbX \Y Ug_YX \]g ghiXYbhg hc Zc``ck \]g fi`Y( >Y fYa]bXYX \]g ghiXYbhg UVcih h\Y k]gY EXmggYig& k\ca 9]fWY& Ub Yj]` gcfWYfYgg& Wci`X bch giV^YWh hc \Yf aU[]W& VYWUigY \Y X]X bch YUh hc YlWYgg( 8ih h\Y aYaVYfg cZ \]g WfYk& \]g Zf]YbXg& kYfY hifbYX ]bhc U \YfX cZ d][g Vm \Yf Ug gccb Ug h\Ym fig\YX hc h\Y UVibXUbWY cZ gkYYh ZccX( Bcc_ Uh mcif acih\5 h\fci[\ ]h& k\Yb mci YUh hc YlWYgg& ]``x bYggYg YbhYf mcif VcXm( 8Y\UjY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh k\Yb mci Z]b]g\ mcif X]bbYf& mci kUbh hc YUh U `]hh`Y acfY( ;Uh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]g bch Wcbg]XYfYX hc VY U g]b Vm aUbm& VYWUigY ]h dfcXiWYg bc bch]WYUV`Y \Ufa( 8ih h\YfY UfY g]bg k\]W\ XYghfcm \iaUb X][b]hm& UbX YUh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]g cbY giW\ g]b(

CGSIL Ā ^igh Ug ]hrg Zc``m hc hfm hc `]Zh mcifgY`Z ]bhc h\Y U]f& mci g\ci`X bch dfU]gY mcifgY`Z hcc aiW\( M\Yb mci dfU]gY mcifgY`Z& mci dfcXiWY h\Y cddcg]hY YZZYWh ]b ch\Yfg& UbX UddYUf `ckYf ]b h\Y]f YmYg( 5I \RX ZDQW RWKHU SHRSOH WR VSHDN ZHOO RI \RX$ GR QRW VSHDN ZHOO RI \RXUVHOI& v8B7?I; F7I97B

7 aUb k\c dfU]gYg \]agY`Z XcYg bch gYY Ubmh\]b[ YlWYdh \]agY`Z UfcibX \]a( ?h ]g VYhhYf hc VY U V`]bX aUb h\Ub hc gYY cb`m mcifgY`Z UbX bcVcXm Y`gY( vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

>Y k\c U`kUmg `]ghYbg hc k\Uh ch\Yf dYcd`Y gUm UVcih \]a k]`` bYjYf Z]bX ]bbYf dYUWY( 7 Z`UhhYfYf gdYU_g \]g Z`UhhYfm VYWUigY \Y \Ug U `ck cd]bx ]cb cZ \]agY`Z UbX cZ ch\Yfg( v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

?Z mci kUbh hc dfYgYfjY mcif [ccX bUaY& Xc bch dfU]gY mcifgY`Z UbX Xc bch gc aiW\ Ug U``ck ch\Yfg hc dfU]gY mci(

CGSIL Ă BcjY cZ =cX ]g `cjY ]b ]hgY`Z5 ]h ]g `cjY Zcf h\Y gU_Y cZ `cjY( J\]g _]bX cZ `cjY ]g h\Y \][\Ygh V`Ygg]b[( ?h XcYg bch U``ck h\Y g`][\hYgh dcgg]V]`]hm cZ hfYUh]b[ YjYb U g]b[`Y WfYUhifY k]h\cih `cjY5 ]Z h\YfY ]g YjYb cbY dYfgcb k\ca mci Xc bch `cjY& h\Yb mci `cgY =cXrg `cjY UbX V`Ygg]b[( 8RYH RI \RXU QHLJKERU ZLWKRXW ORYH RI 3RG LV D SODQW ZLWKc RXW URRWV& CRX VKRXOG ORYH 3RGbWKLV ORYH LV D UHDO DQG ILUP ORYH& 5W GRHV QRW EHFRPH ZHDNHU$ RQO\ VWURQJHU$ DQG LW JLYHV JRRG WR WKRVH ZKR KDYH LW& IcaY gUm h\Uh mci g\ci`X VY UZfU]X cZ =cX( Dch hfiY5 mci \UjY hc `cjY =cX( >ck WUb mci `cjY h\cgY k\ca mci UfY UZfU]X cZ6 =cX ]g `cjY& UbX \ck WUb mci VY UZfU]X cZ `cjY6 Dc& mci g\ci`X bch ZYUf =cX& Vih `cjY >]a( 7bX ]Z mci `cjY =cX& h\Yb mci k]`` bch VY UZfU]X cZ >]a& cf Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY ]b h\Y kcf`X(

CGSIL Å F\mg]WU` kcf_& d\mg]WU` YlYfW]gY Zcf mcif VcXm& ]g U bYWYgx gUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY( 7 aUb WUb ZcfWY ch\Yfg hc Xc h\]b[g Zcf \]a& Vih \Y WUbbch ZfYY \]agY`Z Zfca h\Y bYWYgg]hm cZ \]g ckb d\mg]WU` kcf_( 7bX ]Z U aUb XcYg bch kcf_ Uh bYWYggUfm UbX [ccX h\]b[g& h\Yb \Y k]`` kcf_ Uh ibbYWYgx gUfm UbX ghid]X h\]b[g( Mcf_& h\Y dfcWYgg cZ kcf_ ]b ]hgY`Z& ]g h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[ Zcf ig& UbX ]hg fYkUfX g\ci`X VY cZ a]bcf ]adcfx hUbWY5 ]Z ]h ]g& mci d`YUgY mcif WfYUhcf& =cX( ?Z h\Y fYkUfX ]g cZ aU^cf ]adcfhUbWY Zcf mci& UbX h\Y kcf_ ]hgY`Z cZ a]bcf ]adcfhUbWY& h\Yb mci UfY h\Y g`UjY cZ h\Y fYkUfX UbX ]hg WfYUhcf& h\Y XYj]`& UbX YjYb h\Y `ckYgh UbX h\Y `YUgh Uacb[ U`` XYj]`g( v@E>D HKIA?D

7 ;ifcdYUb dfU]gYX h\Y UXjUbhU[Yg cZ aYW\Ub]nYX `UVcf hc U 9\]bYgY aUb4 sJ\]g ]bjYbh]cb fY`]YjYg U aUb Zfca h\Y bYYX Zcf d\mg]WU` kcf_(t 8ih h\Y 9\]bYgY aUb fYd`]YX& sF\mg]WU` kcf_ ]g [ccX( 8Y]b[ fY`]YjYX Zfca d\mg]WU` kcf_ k]`` VY Ub Ybcfacig X]gUghYf(t 1YHU\ SK\VLFDO ODERU PDNHV D PDQ PRUH QREOH& 5I \RX GR QRW WHDFK \RXU VRQ VRPH SK\VLFDO VNLOOV$ \RX WHDFK KLP WR URE RWKHUV& v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

M]h\cih YlYfW]gY cZ h\Y]f aigW`Yg& bY]h\Yf aUb bcf Ub]aU` WUb `]jY( Ic h\Uh h\]g YlYfW]gY aUm []jY mci ^cm UbX gUh]gZUWh]cb& Xc [ccX d\mg]WU` kcf_( J\]g ]g U`gc h\Y VYgh kUm hc gYfjY ch\Yfg(

CGSIL Ǻ FfUmYf ]g U h]aY hc fYa]bX mcifgY`Z cZ mcif Uhh]hiXY hc `]a]h`Ygg h\]b[g& hc =cX( J\fci[\ dfUmYf& mci YghUV`]g\ mcif Uhh]hiXY hc h\Y VY[]bx b]b[ cZ YjYfmh\]b[5 mci W`Uf]Zm mcif Uhh]hiXY hckUfX dYcx d`Y& mcif fY`Uh]cbg\]d k]h\ UbX mcif XiXYg hc h\Ya& UbX hc h\Y <Uh\Yf cZ U`` cZ ig( v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

?h ]g [ccX hc dfUm Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY YUW\ XUm( ?Z mci WUbbch Wc``YWh mcif h\ci[\hg& VYhhYf bch hc dfUm& VYWUigY mci g\ci`X U`kUmg dfUm k]h\ mcif \YUfh& bch g]ad`m fYdYUh kcfXg k]h\ mcif hcb[iY( 5W LV JRRG DQG QHFHVVDU\ WR SUD\ LQ VROLWXGH$ EXW LV DOVR JRRG WR SUD\ ZKHQ \RX DUH LQ WKH FURZG$ ZKHQ \RX DUH H[FLWHG RU LUULWDWHGbWR WKLQN DERXW \RXU VRXO DQG DERXW 3RG& :c bch h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUb d`YUgY =cX k]h\ dfUmYf( Oci k]`` d`YUgY =cX Vm giVa]hh]b[ hc >]a( FfUmYf ]g ^igh U fYa]bXYf Zcf mci cZ k\c mci UfY UbX k\Uh h\Y difdcgY cZ mcif `]ZY ]g(

CGSIL Ą MUf UbX 9\f]gh]Ub]hm UfY bch WcadUh]V`Y( MUf ]g cbY cZ h\Y kcfgh& acgh hYff]V`Y h\]b[g ]b h\]g kcf`X( BDU LQ WKLV ZRUOG FDQ KH VWRSSHG QRW K\ WKH UXOLQJ HVWDEOLVKc PHQW& EXW E\ WKRVH ZKR VXIIHU IURP WKH ZDU& ?KH\ ZLOO GR WKH PRVW QDWXUDO WKLQJ* VWRS REH\LQJ RUGHUV& J\Y UfaYX kcf`X UbX h\Y kUfg ]h kU[Yg k]`` VY XYghfcmYX cbY XUm& Vih bch Vm h\Y _]b[g cf h\Y fi`Yfg cZ h\]g kcf`X( MUf ]g dfcZ]hUV`Y Zcf h\Ya( MUf k]`` ghcd h\Y acaYbh h\Y dYcx d`Y k\c giZZYf Zfca kUf Zi``m ibXYfghUbX h\Uh ]h ]g Yj]`(

CGSIL ÁÀ J\Uh k\]W\ []jYg `]ZY ]g h\Y gUaY ]b U`` h\]b[g( 7`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg ZYUf dU]b UbX XYUh\( Jhm hc ibXYfghUbX mcifgY`Z ]b YjYfm `]j]b[ WfYUhifY4 Xc bch hcfhifY UbX Xc bch _]``( Ihcd giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\( 7`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg kUbh k\Uh mci kUbh5 U`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg dfU]gY h\Y]f `]jYg( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg \UjY h\Y gUaY X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[& U`` UfY ]b ib]hm MY UfY U`` aYaVYfg cZ cbY [fYUh VcXm( DUhifY WfYUhYX ig fY`UhYX hc YUW\ ch\Yf& Zfca h\Y gUaY aUhYf]U`& Zcf h\Y gUaY difdcgY( 8YWUigY cZ h\]g& gcaYx k\YfY k]h\]b U`` cZ ig ]g aihiU` `cjY Zcf YUW\ ch\Yf(

$ # !#" 7

DD7;KI I;D;97

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY f][\h dUh\kUm cZ `]ZY( IccbYf cf `UhYf& kY U`` k]`` aYYh YUW\ ch\Yf cb h\]g dUh\kUm( J\Y ibXYfghUbXx ]b[ cZ ]h ]g jYfm W`YUf`m ]bgWf]VYX ]b cif \YUfhg& UbX ]h ]g k]XY UbX YUgm hc Z]bX( 7h h\Y YbX cZ h\]g kUm ]g =cX& UbX >Y WU``g ig hc >]agY`Z( ?h ]g gc dU]bZi` hc kUhW\ dYcd`Y k\c a]gg h\]g kUm cZ `]ZY UbX [c U`cb[ h\Y ch\Yf dUh\kUm& h\Y kUm cZ XYUh\( v7ZhYf D?AEB7? =E=EB

1[SXQJH IURP \RXUVHOI DQ\WKLQJ ZKLFK LQWHUIHUHV ZLWK \RXU IHHOLQJ RI D VSHFLDO FRQQHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ \RXUVHOI DQG DOO OLYc LQJ FUHDWXUHV&

CGSIL ÁÁ <ccX ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf h\Y `]ZY cZ Ub ]bX]j]XiU`& UbX aUff]U[Y ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf h\Y `]ZY cZ \iaUb]hm( ?Z YUh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]g Yj]` Zcf Ub ]bX]j]XiU`& h\Yb YlWYgg ]b aUff]U[Y UbX gYliU`]hm WfYUhYg Yj]` Vch\ Zcf ]bX]j]XiU`g UbX Zcf \iaUb gcW]Yhm( - PDUULDJH LV D VSHFLDO REOLJDWLRQ EHWZHHQ WZR SHRSOH$ RI RSSRVLWH VH[HV$ WR KDYH FKLOGUHQ RQO\ ZLWK HDFK RWKHU& ?R EUHDN WKLV SDFW LV D OLH$ D GHFHSWLRQ$ DQG D FULPH& ?h ]g U [fYUh h\]b[ k\Yb hkc gci`g UfY ib]hYX hc giddcfh YUW\ ch\Yf ]b h\Y]f kcf_& ]b h\Y]f giWWYggYg UbX a]gZcfx hibYg& ibh]` h\Y `Ugh g]`Ybh a]bihYg cZ h\Y `Ugh [ccX'VmY( v=;EH=; ;B?EJ

J\Y F\Uf]gYYg U`gc WUaY ibhc \]a& hYadh]b[ \]a& UbX gUmx ]b[ ibhc \]a& ?g ]h `UkZi` Zcf U aUb hc dih UkUm \]g k]ZY Zcf YjYfm WUigY6 7bX \Y UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc h\Ya& >UjY mY bch fYUX& h\Uh \Y k\]W\ aUXY h\Ya Uh h\Y VY[]bb]b[ aUXY h\Ya aU`Y UbX ZYaU`Y& UbX gU]X& <cf h\]g WUigY g\U`` U aUb `YUjY ZUh\Yf UbX ach\Yf& UbX g\U`` W`YUjY hc \]g k]ZY4 UbX h\Ym hkU]b g\U`` VY cbY Z`Yg\6 M\YfYZcfY h\Ym UfY bc acfY hkU]b& Vih cbY Z`Yg\( M\Uh h\YfYZcfY =cX \Uh\ ^c]bYX hc[Yh\Yf& `Yh bch aUb dih UgibXYf( vC7JJ>;M +34-'0

J\Y ib]Z]WUh]cb cZ U aUb UbX U kcaUb Zcf h\Y Wcbh]biUx h]cb cZ \iaUb_]bX ]g U [fYUh UbX ]adcfhUbh XYYX Zcf YjYfm ]bX]j]XiU`& Ug kY`` Ug Zcf U`` aUb_]bX( Oci WUbbch Xc ]h Ug ]h d`YUgYg mci& cf Ug mci `]_Y ]h( Oci \UjY hc Xc ]h ]b h\Y kUm k\]W\ kUg h\ci[\h UbX gYh cih Vm h\Y k]gY UbX \c`m dYcx d`Y k\c \UjY `]jYX VYZcfY ig(

CGSIL ÁÂ J\Y XYYXg cZ U dYfgcb VYWcaY \]g `]ZY& VYWcaY \]g ZUhY( J\]g ]g h\Y `Uk cZ cif `]ZY( J\Y FYfg]Ubg \UjY giW\ U ZUV`Y4 7ZhYf XYUh\& U gci` Z`Yk ]bhc h\Y g_m& UbX aYh U hYff]V`Y kcaUb& U X]fhm UbX \cff]x V`Y UddUf]h]cb& k]h\ ZYghYfYX gcfYg X]gW\Uf[]b[ dig& k\c kUg [c]b[ ]b h\Y cddcg]hY X]fYWh]cb( sM\Uh UfY mci Xc]b[ \YfY6t Ug_YX h\Y gci`( sM\c UfY mci6t J\Y hYff]V`Y kcaUb UbgkYfYX& s? Ua mcif XYYXg(t 5W LV LPSRUWDQW QRW RQO\ WR WDON DERXW WKH JRRG OLIH EXW WR GR JRRG WKLQJV(v v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

DYjYf dcghdcbY U [ccX XYYX k\]W\ mci WUb Xc bck& VYWUigY XYUh\ XcYg bch W\ccgY k\Yh\Yf mci \UjY cf \UjYbrh XcbY h\Y h\]b[g mci g\ci`X \UjY XcbY( :YUh\ kU]hg Zcf bcVcXm UbX bch\]b[( ?h \Ug bY]h\Yf YbYa]Yg& bcf Zf]YbXg( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Yb mci UddYUfYX ]b h\]g kcf`X& mci Wf]YX& UbX U`` h\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX mci fY^c]WYX( Oci \UjY hc `]jY mcif `]ZY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh k\Yb mci `YUjY h\]g kcf`X& mci k]`` fY^c]WY& UbX U`` h\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX mci k]`` Wfm( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

Ocif dUgh XYYXg kY][\ \YUj]`m cb h\Y ZihifY X]fYWh]cb cZ mcif `]ZY5 Vih gcaYh]aYg& mci WUb W\Ub[Y h\]g X]fYWh]cb h\fci[\ h\Y YZZcfh cZ mcif gd]f]h(

CGSIL ÁÃ J\Y WcbX]h]cb cZ k]gXca ]g dif]hm5 h\Y WcbgYeiYbWY cZ k]gXca ]g h\Y dYUWY cZ mcif gci`( 7 aUb k\c Zc``ckg \]g k]g\Yg W\Ub[Yg \]g Uhh]hiXY k]h\ h]aY( LYfm gccb \Y ]g bch gUh]gZ]YX Ubm acfY k]h\ h\Y h\]b[g \Y XcYg( J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c \UjY bch\]b[ hc `cgY UfY jYfm f]W\(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

7 k]gY dYfgcb bYjYf Wcbg]XYfg \]agY`Z hc VY k]gY( 7bX U dYfgcb bYjYf Wcbg]XYfg \]agY`Z k]gY k\Yb \Y \Ug h\Y ]aU[Y cZ =cX VYZcfY \]a( BLVGRP LV OLPLWOHVV$ DQG WKH FORVHU \RX DSSURDFK LW$ WKH PRUH LPSRUWDQW LW EHFRPHV IRU \RXU OLIH& - SHUVRQ FDQ DOZD\V LPSURYH KLPVHOI&

CGSIL ÁÄ 8RYH EULQJV SHRSOH WR XQLILFDWLRQ& ?KH XQLYHUVDO LQWHOOHFW$ ZKLFK LV WKH VDPH IRU HYHU\RQH$ VXSSRUWV WKLV XQLILFDWLRQ& Bcc_ UfcibX( M\Uh Xc h\Y kcf`Xrg dYcd`Y h\]b_ UVcih ]h6 J\Ym h\]b_ UVcih YjYfmh\]b[ YlWYdh k\Uh ]g acgh ]adcfx hUbh( J\Ym h\]b_ UVcih XUbW]b[& aig]W& UbX g]b[]b[5 h\Ym h\]b_ UVcih \cigYg& kYU`h\& UbX dckYf5 h\Ym UfY ^YU`cig UVcih h\Y kYU`h\ cZ f]W\ dYcd`Y UbX _]b[g5 Vih h\Ym Xc bch h\]b_ Uh U`` UVcih k\Uh ]h aYUbg hc VY \iaUb( v7ZhYf 8B7?I; F7I97B

EbY cZ h\YT]bU^cf fYgdcbg]V]`]h]Yg cZ U dYfgcb ]g hc aU_Y h\Uh ]bhY``YWhiU` gdUf_ k\]W\ mci \UjY fYWY]jYX .fca \YUjYb ]``ia]bUhY h\Y kcf`X UfcibX mci( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

;jYfmh\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cb cZ h\Y X]j]bY ]bhY``YWh( 7`` h\Uh kY _bck& kY _bck h\fci[\ h\Y ]bhY``YWh( J\cgY k\c Xc bch VY`]YjY& dYcd`Y k\c gUm h\Uh mci g\ci`X bch Zc``ck mcif ]bhY``YWh& fYa]bX aY cZ h\cgY k\c gi[[Ygh h\Uh mci hifb Xckb h\Y cb`m `UbhYfb k\]W\ g\ckg mci h\Y kUm ]bhc h\Y XUf_bYgg(

CGSIL ÁĀ 8Y Z]``YX k]h\ `cjY Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y& ]bW`iX]b[ h\cgY k\c UfY ibd`YUgUbh cf \cgh]`Y hc mci( 7 fYU` hf]U` hc cbYrg `cjY ]g hc `cjY mcif YbYa]Yg( 5I \RX ORYH \RXU HQHPLHV$ \RX ZLOO KDYH QR HQHPLHV& J\Y acgh dYfZYWh Uacb[ aYb ]g \Y k\c `cjYg \]g bY][\x Vcf k]h\cih h\]b_]b[ UVcih k\Yh\Yf h\Y dYfgcb ]g [ccX cf VUX( vCE>7CC;:

8Y \iaV`Y UbX cddcgY X]gg]dUh]cb( ;jYb U h\]b gkcfX WUbbch Wih gU`h g]`_( Kg]b[ hYbXYf kcfXg UbX _]bXbYgg& mci WUb `YUX Ub Y`Yd\Ubh k]h\ U \U]f( vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

;jYfm h]aY mci UfY UVigYX Vm gcaYcbY UbX ZYY` Ub]acg]hm hckUfX \]a& fYaYaVYf h\Uh U`` dYcd`Y UfY W\]`XfYb cZ =cX( HY[UfX`Ygg cZ k\Yh\Yf h\]g dYfgcb ]g ibd`YUgUbh hc mci& mci g\ci`X bch ghcd `cj]b[ \]a Ug mcif Vfch\Yf& VYWUigY& Ug aiW\ Ug mci UfY& \Y ]g =cX"g gcb(

CGSIL ÁĂ CcXYfb gW]YbWY WUbbch ghiXm HYHU\WKLQJ5 k]h\cih VY]b[ giddcfhYX Vm fY`][]cb& gW]YbWY XcYg bch _bck k\Uh ]h g\ci`X ghiXm( HYU` k]gXca ]g bch h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ YjYfmh\]b[& Vih h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ k\]W\ h\]b[g ]b `]ZY UfY bYWYggUfm& k\]W\ UfY `Ygg bYWYggUfm& UbX k\]W\ UfY Wcad`YhY`m ibbYWYggUfm hc _bck( 7acb[ h\Y acgh bYWYggUfm _bck`YX[Y ]g h\Y _bck`x YX[Y cZ \ck hc `]jY kY``& h\Uh ]g& \ck hc dfcXiWY h\Y `YUgh dcgg]V`Y Yj]` UbX h\Y [fYUhYgh [ccXbYgg ]b cbYrg `]ZY( 7h dfYx gYbh& dYcd`Y ghiXm igY`Ygg gW]YbWYg& Vih Zcf[Yh hc ghiXm h\]g& h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh _bck`YX[Y( 7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg `]hh`Y `]_Yg hc hU`_& UbX cbY k\c _bckg aiW\ acgh`m _YYdg g]`Ybh( J\]g ]g VYWUigY U dYfgcb k\c _bckg `]hh`Y h\]b_g h\Uh YjYfmh\]b[ \Y _bckg ]g ]adcfhUbh& UbX kUbhg hc hY`` YjYfmcbY( 7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg aiW\ U`gc _bckg h\Uh h\YfY ]g aiW\ acfY \Y XcYgbrh _bck( J\Uhrg k\m \Y gdYU_g cb`m k\Yb ]h ]g bYWYggUfm hc gdYU_& UbX k\Yb \Y ]g bch Ug_YX eiYgh]cbg& \Y _YYdg \]g g]`YbWY( v7ZhYf @;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

5I DOO NQRZOHGJH ZHUH JRRG$ WKHQ SXUVXLW RI HYHU\ VRUW RI NQRZOHGJH ZRXOG KH XVHIXO& .XW PDQ\ IDOVH PHGLWDWLRQV DUH GLVJXLVHG DV JRRG DQG XVHIXO NQRZOHGJH+ WKHUHIRUH$ KH VWULFW LQ VHOHFWLQJ WKH NQRZOHGJH \RX ZDQW WR DFTXLUH&

CGSIL ÁÅ MY WUb ]adfcjY h\]g kcf`X cb`m Vm X]ghf]Vih]b[ h\Y hfiY ZU]h\ Uacb[ h\Y kcf`Xrg dYcd`Y( - VRFLHW\ FDQQRW OLYH ZLWKRXW D XQLWHG IDLWK DQG SXUSRVH& -OO VRFLDO DFWLYLW\ FDQQRW UHDOO\ LPSURYH RXU VRFLDO OLIH LI LW LV QRW EDVHG RQ WKH IRXQGDWLRQV HVWDEOLVKHG E\ UHOLJLRQ& S=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y Udcgh`Yg `]jYX ib]hYX& ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh h\Ym g\UfYX cbY \YUfh UbX gci`( ?Z h\Ym \UX bch& bc cbY hcXUm kci`X _bck UVcih 9\f]gh]Ub]hm( M\Yb gcaY dU[Ubg X]X bch UWWYdh 9\f]gh]Ub]hm& ]h kUg VYWUigY h\Ym X]X bch gYY Wcad`YhY ib]x Z]WUh]cb UbX `cjY Uacb[ 9\f]gh]Ubg( MY 9\f]gh]Ubg UfY hc V`UaY k\Yb ch\Yf dYcd`Y Xc bch UWWYdh h\Y 9\f]gh]Ub ZU]h\( v7ZhYf I7?DJ @E>D 9>HOIEIJEC

9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]b ]hg difY UbX g]bWYfY Zcfa kcf_g `]_Y XmbUx a]hY4 ]h V`ckg id c`X acibhU]bg UbX cdYbg id bYk& `]a]hx `Ygg \cf]ncbg( ?Z mci gYY h\Uh gcaY UgdYWh cZ mcif gcW]Yhm ]g VUX& UbX mci kUbh hc ]adfcjY ]h& h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY kUm hc Xc gc4 mci \UjY hc ]adfcjY dYcd`Y( 7bX ]b cfXYf hc ]adfcjY dYcd`Y& mci VY[]b k]h\ cb`m cbY h\]b[4 mci WUb VYWcaY VYhhYf mcifgY`Z(

CGSIL ÁǺ 8`Ua]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]g U`kUmg kfcb[& VYWUigY bc cbY _bckg k\Uh \Ug \UddYbYX UbX \UddYbg ]b h\Y gci` cZ Ubch\Yf dYfgcb( MY cZhYb aU_Y ^iX[aYbhg UVcih ch\Yf dYcd`Y( MY WU`` cbY dYfgcb _]bX& h\Y ch\Yf ghid]X& h\Y h\]fX Yj]`& h\Y Zcifh\ W`YjYf( 8ih kY g\ci`X bch Xc gc( 7 aUb W\Ub[Yg WcbghUbh`m5 \Y Z`ckg `]_Y U f]jYf& UbX YjYfm bYk XUm \Y X]Z' ZYfg Zfca k\Uh \Y kUg VYZcfY( >Y kUg ghid]X UbX VYWUaY W`YjYf5 \Y kUg Yj]` UbX VYWUaY _]bX Uh \YUfh5 UbX gc cb( Oci WUbbch ^iX[Y Ubch\Yf dYfgcb( J\Y acaYbh mci V`UaY \]a& \Y VYWcaYg gcaYcbY X]ZZYfYbh( ?Z mci kUbh hc WcffYWh mcif ZU]`]b[g& mci Xc bch \UjY h\Y h]aY hc kUghY ]b V`Ua]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( :HYHU EODPH \RXU QHLJKERU XQWLO \RX KDYH EHHQ LQ KLV SODFH& vJ\Y J7BCK:

<cf[]jY ch\Yf dYcd`Y Zcf aUbm h\]b[g& Vih Xc bch Zcf[]jY mcifgY`Z Ubmh\]b[( vFK8B?B?KI IOHKI

? _bck cZ amgY`Z h\Uh ? Xc bch k]g\ hc Xc Yj]`( ?Z ? Xc Yj]`& ]h ]g VYWUigY ? WUbbch fYghfU]b amgY`Z( ?h ]g h\Y gUaY k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y4 h\Ym igiU``m Xc Yj]` VYWUigY h\Ym WUbbch fYghfU]b h\YagY`jYg Zfca Yj]`( J\YfYZcfY& k\m Xc ? h\]b_ VUX`m cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y6 M\m g\ci`X ? V`UaY h\Ya6

CGSIL ÁĄ J\Y WfYUh]cb cZ h\Y kcf`X kci`X \UjY VYYb U jYfm VUX UWh kYfY ]h f][\h Zcf f]W\ dYcd`Y hc `]jY cZZ h\Y kcf_ cZ h\Y dccf& UbX mYh h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym kYfY h\Y VYbYZUWhcfg( 7 ghcbY ZU``g cb U dchvkcY hc h\Y dch5 U dch ZU``g cb U ghcbYvkcY hc h\Y dch5 ]b YjYfm WUgY& ]h ]g VUX Zcf h\Y dch( vJ\Y J7BCK:

?KH SOHDVXUHV RI WKH ULFK DUH RIWHQ DFTXLUHG E\ WKH WHDUV RI WKH SRRU& MYU`h\ ]g WfYUhYX Vm h\Y WcbWYbhfUh]cb cZ \iaUb `UVcf5 igiU``m cbY dYcd`Y dfcXiWY `UVcf& UbX ch\Yfg WcbWYbhfUhY ]h( J\]g ]g WU``YX sh\Y X]j]g]cb cZ `UVcft Vm WcbhYadcfUfm k]gY dYcd`Y( J\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ kfcb[ k]h\ h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ h\]g kcf`X& VYWUigY h\Y f]W\ dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym UfY h\Y VYbYZUWx hcfg cZ h\Y dccf& Vih ]b ZUWh h\cgY f]W\ UfY ZYX UbX XfYggYX Vm h\Y kcf_ cZ h\YgY dccf UbX `]jY ]b `ilifm WfYUhYX Zcf h\Ya Vm h\Y dccf(

CGSIL ÂÀ J\cgY k\c `]jY UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y k]`` cZ =cX WUbbch VY gYbg]h]jY hc h\Y ^iX[aYbhg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( Oci g\ci`X h\]b_ ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh YjYfmVcXm Wci`X `cc_ ]bhc mcif gci` UbX gYY k\Uh ]g hfUbgd]f]b[ h\YfY( ÅHÁTWÁZ 7bbUYig IYbYWU

B]jY ]b h\Y cdYb(

v7K=KIJ; 9ECJ;

?h ]g bch [ccX hc \]XY mcif VUX XYYXg& Vih]h ]g YjYb kcfgY hc Z`Uibh h\Ya ]b h\Y cdYb UbX hc VY dfciX cZ h\Ya( Jc ZYY` g\UaY ]b h\Y WcadUbm cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]g [ccX& Vih ]h ]g YjYb VYhhYf hc YldYf]YbWY g\UaY k\Yb mci UfY U`cbY k]h\ mcifgY`Z( 0R QRW KLGH DQ\WKLQJ IURP RWKHU SHRSOH ZKHQ WKH\ DVN \RX$ KXW GR QRW ERDVW DERXW EDG WKLQJV LI \RX DUH QRW DVNHG DERXW WKHP& Oci WUb \]XY gcaY h\]b[g Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Y& Vih mci WUbx bch \]XY Ubmh\]b[ Zfca =cX( <cf bch\]b[ ]g gYWfYh& h\Uh g\U`` bch VY aUXY aUb]ZYgh5 bY]h\Yf Ubm h\]b[ \]X& h\Uh g\U`` bch VY _bckb UbX WcaY hc `][\h( vBKA; 24+1

B]jY mcif `]ZY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci bY]h\Yf \]XY bcf \UjY U k]g\ hc X]gd`Um mcif `]ZY hc dYcd`Y(

CGSIL ÂÁ MY _bck cif `]ZY Ug ]h Yl]ghg cb`m \YfY& ]b h\]g kcf`X5 h\YfYZcfY& ]Z cif `]ZY ]g hc \UjY Ubm aYUb]b[& ]h g\ci`X VY \YfY ]b h\]g kcf`X( :c bch k]g\ Zcf XYUh\ ^igh VYWUigY mcif `]ZY ]g \UfX( 7`` h\Y VifXYbg cb mcif g\ci`XYfg k]`` \Y`d mci Zi`Z]`` mcif XYgh]bm( J\Y cb`m kUm hc [Yh f]X cZ mcif VifXYbg ]g hc `]jY mcif `]ZY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci Zi`Z]`` mcif XYgh]bm( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

HYU` `]ZY ]g ZcibX cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh( ?Z dYcd`Y hY`` mci h\Uh mci g\ci`X `]jY mcif `]ZY dfYdUf]b[ Zcf h\Y ZihifY& Xc bch VY`]YjY h\Ya( MY `]jY ]b h\]g `]ZY& UbX kY _bck h\]g `]ZY cb`m& UbX h\YfYZcfY U`` cif YZZcfhg g\ci`X VY X]fYWhYX hckUfX h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\]g `]ZY( Dch mcif `]ZY ]b [Ybx YfU` Vih YjYfm \cif cZ h\]g `]ZY g\ci`X VY `]jYX ]b h\Y VYgh kUm mci _bck \ck( B]ZY ]g bY]h\Yf giZZYf]b[ bcf d`YUgifY& Vih h\Y Vig]bYgg k\]W\ kY \UjY hc Xc& UbX k\]W\ kY \UjY hc Z]b]g\ \cbx Ygh`m& id hc cif `]ZYrg YbX( v7B;N?I :; JE9GK;L?BB;

?KLV ZRUOG$ RQO\ WKLV ZRUOG$ LV WKH SODFH RI RXU ZRUN$ DQG DOO RXU IRUFHV$ DOO RXU HIIRUWV$ VKRXOG EH GLUHFWHG WRZDUG WKLV OLIH&

CGSIL ÂÂ ?Z hfih\ aU_Yg cif `]ZY YUg]Yf& h\Yb ]h ]g VYhhYf hc UWWYdh h\Y hfih\ h\Ub hc \]XY Zfca ]h( Eif `]ZY WUb VY W\Ub[YX& Vih h\Y hfih\ WUbbch VY W\Ub[YX4 ]h k]`` U`kUmg fYaU]b h\Y hfih\& UbX ]h k]`` YldcgY ig( MY g\ci`X `]jY cif `]jYg Ug ]Z YjYfmcbY Wci`X gYY ig& Ug ]Z h\Y acgh gYWfYh WcfbYfg cZ cif gci` kYfY cdYb hc h\Y g][\h cZ ch\Yfg( M\m g\ci`X kY \]XY Ubmh\]b[6 Oci WUbbch \]XY Ubmh\]b[ Zfca =cX( 7`` X]j]bY UbX \iaUb `YUfb]b[ WUb VY giaaUf]nYX ]b cbY hfih\vh\Uh kY UfY aYaVYfg cZ cbY V][ VcXm( DUhifY ib]hYX ig ]b cbY V][ ZUa]`mTUbX kY g\ci`X `]jY cif `]jYg hc[Yh\Yf& \Y`d]b[ YUW\ ch\Yf( v7ZhYf HÁTWÁZ 7DD7;KI I;D;97

>HHN WKH WUXWK* LW DOZD\V VKRZV XV ZKDW ZH VKRXOG GR$ ZKDW ZH VKRXOG QRW GR$ DQG ZKDW ZH VKRXOG VWRS GRLQJ&

CGSIL ÆǼ ?KH HDUWK$ WKH DLU$ DQG WKH VXQ EHORQJ WR DOO RI XV+ WKH\ FDQQRW EH PDGH REMHFWV RI SURSHUW\& MY UfY U]` j]g]hcfg ]b h\]g kcf`X( M\YfYjYf mci [c ]b h\]g kcf`X& hc h\Y bcfh\& hc h\Y gcih\& hc h\Y kYgh& cf hc h\Y YUgh& h\YfY k]`` U`kUmg VY U aUb kU]h]b[ hc hY`` mci& sJ\]g ]g am dfcdYfhm( =Yh cih cZ \YfY t M\Yb mci j]g]h ch\Yf Wcibhf]Yg ]b h\Y kcf`X UbX mci WcaY VUW_& mci k]`` gYY W\Uh h\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y d]YWY cZ ZfYY `UbX k\YfY mcif k]ZY WUb []jY V]fh\ hc mcif W\]`X& k\YfY mci WUb ghcd UbX ghUfh kcf_]b[ cb h\Y `UbX& UbX k\YfY mcif W\]`XfYb WUb Z]bX fYgh Zcf mcif VcbYg Uh `]ZYrg YbX( v7ZhYf <( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

?Z mci `YUjY U aUb cb `UbX k\]W\ ]g gcaYcbY Y`gYrg dfcdx Yfhm UbX hY`` \]a h\Uh \Y ]g U Wcad`YhY`m ZfYY aUb UbX WUb kcf_ Zc] \]agY`Z& ]hrg Ug ]Z mci Xfcd \]a ]b h\Y a]XX`Y cZ h\Y 7h`Ubh]W UbX hY`` \]a h\Uh \Y ]g ZfYY hc [c Ug\cfY( v>;DHO =;EH=;

J\cgY k\c ckb `UbX ]b Uacibhg `Uf[Yf h\Ub h\Uh k\]W\ ]g bYYXYX hc ZYYX h\Y]f ckb ZUa]`]Yg WUb VY hfYUhYX Ug VY]b[ [i]`hm cZ WUig]b[ h\Y dcjYfhm cZ aUbm ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

CGSIL ÂÄ ;QO\ WKH SHUVRQ ZKR IXOILOOV 3RG_V ODZ FDQ XQGHUVWDQG 3RG& ?KH PRUH FORVHO\ KH IXOILOOV 3RG_V ODZ$ WKH EHWWHU KH XQGHUc VWDQGV 3RG& J\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y VY`]YjYf k\c Zfca h]aY hc h]aY \Ug bch \UX gcaY \Yg]hUh]cbg UVcih h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX( 8ih h\YgY acaYbhg cZ \Yg]hUh]cb UfY bch \UfaZi`( Eb h\Y WcbhfUfm& h\Ym `YUX ig hc U VYhhYf ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX( IYY_]b[ =cX k]h\ mcif gci` ]g U dfcWYgg h\Uh \Ug `]a]h`Ygg g]XYg UbX UgdYWhg( CcgYg gU]X hc =cX& sM\YfY WUb ? Z]bX mci6t =cX gU]X& q ?Z mci UfY `cc_]b[ Zcf aY& mci \UjY U`fYUXm ZcibX aY(t J\Ym Ug_YX U k]gY aUb& s>ck Xc mci _bck h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg6t >Y fYd`]YX& s?g ]h bYWYggUfm hc \UjY U hcfW\ ]b cfXYf hc gYY h\Y gib6t MY Xc bch \UjY Ybci[\ kcfXg hc Yld`U]b k\Uh =cX ]g& Vih kY _bck k]h\cih kcfXg h\Uh >Y Yl]ghg( v7H78?9 M?I:EC

@Ykg Wcbg]XYf ]h U g]b hc ghUhY h\Y bUaY cZ =cX U`ciX( J\Ym UfY f][\h4 =cX ]g gd]f]h& UbX YjYfm bUaY ]g aUhYf]U` UbX bch gd]f]hiU`(

CGSIL ÆĆ :if]b[ cif `]jYg kY \Y`d YUW\ ch\Yf4 gcaYh]aYg kY \Y`d ch\Yf dYcd`Y& gcaYh]aYg kY UfY \Y`dYX Vm ch\Yfg( 8ih h\Y kcf`X ]g ZcfaYX gc h\Uh igiU``m gcaY dYcd`Y acgh`m \Y`d ch\Yfg& UbX gcaY acgh`m fYWY]jY h\Y]f \Y`d( -V \RX DFTXLUH REMHFWV$ DQG \RX XVH WKHP$ \RX VKRXOG NHHS LQ PLQG WKDW WKH\ DUH WKH SURGXFWV RI SHRSOH_V ZRUN& BKHQ \RX GDPDJH RU GHVWUR\ WKHVH REMHFWV$ \RX GDPDJH RU GHVWUR\ WKH WRLO$ DQG WKLV SDUW RI WKH OLIH$ RI RWKHU SHRSOH& Bcc_ Uh U`` cZ mcif _bck`YX[Y Ug U []Zh& Ug U aYUbg cZ \Y`dx ]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 7 ghfcb[ UbX k]gY dYfgcb igYg \]g []Zhg hc giddcfh ch\Yf dYcd`Y( @E>D HKIA?D

>Y`d g\ci`X VY aihiU`( CcfYcjYf& h\cgY k\c UWWYdh \Y`d UbX Ugg]ghUbWY Zfca h\Y]f Vfch\Yfg g\ci`X dUm h\Ya VUW_& bch cb`m k]h\ acbYm& Vih k]h\ `cjY& fYgdYWh& UbX [fUh]hiXY(

CGSIL ÂĂ J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh W\Ub[Y h\Uh WUb cWWif ]b U dYfgcbrg `]ZY ]g U W\Ub[Y ]b \]g ZU]h\( ?bX]j]XiU`g X]Y& Vih h\Y k]gXca h\Ym \UjY cVhU]bYX ]b h\Y]f `]jYg XcYg bch X]Y k]h\ h\Ya( CUb_]bX _YYdg U`` h\]g k]gXca& UbX U dYfgcb igYg h\Y k]gXca cZ h\cgY k\c `]jYX VYZcfY \]a( J\Y YXiWUh]cb cZ aUb_]bX fYa]bXg aY cZ h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ h\Y UbW]Ybh dmfUa]Xg& ]b h\Uh YjYfmcbY k\cS `]jYg dihg Ubch\Yf ghcbY ]b h\Y ZcibXUh]cb( MY UfY hYadcfUfm j]g]hcfg ]b h\]g kcf`X5 UZhYf kY UfY YXix WUhYX& kY UfY WU``YX hc X]ZZYfYbh d`UWYg& UbX kY dUgg UkUm( 8ih h\Y [YbYfU` YXiWUh]cb cZ aUb_]bX [cYg cb& jYfm g`ck`m Vih k]h\cih ]bhYffidh]cb( v7ZhYf =?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

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

CGSIL ÂÅ J\Y acfY U dYfgcb VY`]YjYg ]b =cX& h\Y `Ygg \Y ]g UZfU]X cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( :c bch XYgdU]f( :c bch VY X]gUddc]bhYX ]Z mci gYY h\Uh mci WUbbch UWWcad`]g\ U`` h\Y [ccX k\]W\ mci kci`X `]_Y hc UWWcad`]g\( ?Z mci ZU``& hfm hc ghUbX id5 hfm hc cjYfWcaY h\Y cVghUW`Y VYZcfY mci( =Yh hc h\Y \YUfh cZ h\Y aUhhYf& hc h\Y YggYbWY cZ h\]b[g( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\cgY k\c ZYUf dYcd`Y Xc bch ZYUf =cX5 h\cgY k\c ZYUf =cX Xc bch ZYUf dYcd`Y( >Y k\c ]g bch UZfU]X cZ Ubmh\]b[& UbX k\c ]g fYUXm hc []jY \]g `]ZY Zcf U f][\hYcig WUigY& ]g aiW\ ghfcb[Yf h\Ub \Y k\ca ch\Yf dYcd`Y ZYUf UbX k\c \Ug h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]b \]g dckYf( 8RRN IRU WKH EHWWHU PHQ DPRQJ WKRVH ZKR DUH GHVSLVHG& :c k\Uh mci h\]b_ ]g bYWYggUfm& UbX Xc bch YldYWh fYkUfX( HYaYaVYf h\Uh U ghid]X dYfgcb ]g U VUX ^iX[Y cZ W`YjYf XYYXg( Oci kUbh hc gUjY mcifgY`Z Zfca h\Y dckYf cZ ch\Yf dYcx d`Yv[]jY mcifgY`Z hc h\Y dckYf cZ =cX( ?Z mci gYY mcifx gY`Z Ug VY]b[ ]b h\Y dckYf cZ =cX& h\Yb dYcd`Y WUbbch Xc Ubmh\]b[ hc mci(

CGSIL ÂǺ M]gXca WUb VY UW\]YjYX Vm ]bbYf kcf_& h\fci[\ gc`]hUfm Wcaaib]WUh]cb k]h\ mcifgY`Z5 ]h U`gc WUb VY UW\]YjYX k\Yb mci Wcaaib]WUhY k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( B]ghYb UbX VY UhhYbh]jY& Vih Xc bch gdYU_ hcc aiW\5 UbX k\Yb mci UfY Ug_YX U eiYgh]cb& UbgkYf Vf]YZ`m( :c bch VY Ug\UaYX hc UWWYdh h\Uh gcaYh]aYg mci Xc bch _bck Ub UbgkYf hc k\Uh mci kYfY Ug_YX( :c bch [Yh ]bhc Ub Uf[i' aYbh ^igh Zcf h\Y gU_Y cZ Uf[iaYbh5 UbX Xc bch VcUgh( vIK<? M?I:EC

Oci WUb j]Yk mcif ckb XfUkVUW_g cb`m h\fci[\ h\Y YmYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

? \UjY `YUfbYX aUbm h\]b[g Zfca am hYUW\Yfg5 ? \UjY `YUfbYX aUbm h\]b[g Zfca am Zf]YbXg5 UbX ? \UjY `YUfbYX YjYb acfY Zfca am ghiXYbhg( vJ\Y J7BCK:

?Z mci gYY U \c`m aUb& h\]b_4 \ck Wci`X ? VYWcaY `]_Y \]a6 ?Z mci gYY U X]gg]dUhYX aUb& h\]b_4 Xcbrh ? \UjY h\Y gUaY j]WYg6 v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

HYU` `cjY ]g bch ]b kcfXg Vih ]b XYYXg& UbX cb`m `cjY WUb []jY mci fYU` k]gXca( BKHQ \RX DUH LQ FRPSDQ\$ GR QRW IRUJHW ZKDW \RX KDYH IRXQG RXW ZKHQ \RX ZHUH WKLQNLQJ LQ VROLWXGH+ DQG ZKHQ \RX DUH PHGLWDWLQJ LQ VROLWXGH$ WKLQN DERXW ZKDW \RX IRXQG RXW E\ FRPPXQLFDWLQJ ZLWK RWKHU SHRSOH&

CGSIL ÂĄ ?Z gcaYh]aYg mci ZYY` h\Uh ]b gd]hY cZ U`` mcif k]g\Yg hc [U]b hf]iad\ cjYf mcif dUgg]cbg& h\Ym [U]b j]Whcfm cjYf mci& Xc bch h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUbbch WcbeiYf h\Ya Uh U``( Oci \UjY cb`m dfcjYb h\Uh mci kYfYbrh UV`Y ĄǺ h\]g cbY h]aY( 7 [ccX [fcca XcYg bch Xfcd \]g fY]bg k\Yb \Y WUbx bch ghcd \]g \cfgYg Uh cbWY Vih hf]Yg U[U]b hc di`` h\Y fY]bg& UbX YjYbhiU``m h\Y \cfgYg ghcd( Ic ]Z mci Wci`X bch fYg]gh h\Y hYadhUh]cbg cbWY& Wcbh]biY mcif Z][\h& UbX ]b h\Y YbX bch mcif dUgg]cb Vih mci k]`` [U]b h\Y j]Whcfm( ?U\ WR EH WKH PDVWHU RYHU JUHHG$ VORWK$ OHFKHU\$ DQG UDJH& 7 j]Whcfm cjYf cbYgY`Z ]g U V][[Yf UbX U VYhhYf j]Whcfm h\Ub U j]Whcfm cjYf h\cigUbXg cZ dYcd`Y ]b U gWcfY cZ VUhh`Yg( J\cgY k\c \UjY UW\]YjYX j]Whcfm cjYf ch\Yf dYcd`Y WUb VY XYZYUhYX ]b ZihifY VUhh`Yg& Vih h\cgY k\c \UjY UW\]YjYX j]Whcfm cjYf h\YagY`jYg VYWcaY j]Whcfg ZcfYjYf( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 dUgg]cb ]b U dYfgcbrg \YUfh ]g `]_Y U gd]XYfrg kYV( 7h h\Y VY[]bb]b[ ]h ]g Ub U`]Yb j]g]hcf5 h\Yb ]h VYWcaYg U fY[i`Uf [iYgh5 h\Yb ]h VYWcaYg aUghYf cZ h\Y \cigY( v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

>Y k\c \Ug UW\]YjYX j]Whcfm cjYf \]agY`Z \Ug fYU` dckYf( v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

7VghYbh]cb WUbbch VY UW\]YjYX Uh cbWY& Vih ]h g\ci`X VY U dfcWYgg& UbX U WcbghUbh YZZcfh( J\Y `]ZY cZ U dYfgcb k\c aU_Yg h\]g YZZcfhg X]fYWhYX bch hc h\Y WU`a]b[ cZ \]g dUgx g]cbg Vih hc h\Y aUghYfm cZ h\Ya( J]aY UbX dYfg]ghYbWY \Y`d mci ]b h\YgY YZZcfhg(

CGSIL ÃÀ J\Y hfih\ ]g bch cb`m U ^cm& ]h ]g Ub ]bghfiaYbh ]b WcbZ`]Wh aiW\ acfY dckYfZi` h\Ub j]c`YbWY( ?KHQ FDPH <HWHU WR KLP$ DQG VDLG$ 8RUG$ KRZ RIW VKDOO P\ EURWKHU VLQ DJDLQVW PH$ DQG 5 IRUJLYH KLP, 6LOO VHYHQ WLPHV, 6HVXV VDLWK XQWR KLP$ 5 VD\ QRW XQWR WKHH$ @QWLO VHYHQ WLPHV* EXW$ @QWLO VHYHQW\ WLPHV VHYHQ& vC7JJ>;M +24,+',,

?Z mci kUbh hc XYacbghfUhY gcaY hfih\ hc mcif `]ghYbYfg& Xc bch VY ]ff]hUhYX& UbX Xc bch gUm ib_]bX cf UVig]jY kcfXg( v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

?Z mci bch]WY gcaYcbY ]b Yffcf& h\Yb WcffYWh h\]g dYfgcb UbX \]g a]ghU_Y ]b U \iaV`Y kUm( ?Z \Y XcYg bch `]ghYb hc mci& V`UaY mcifgY`Z cb`m5 cf& YjYb VYhhYf& Xc bch V`UaY UbmVcXm& Vih Wcbh]biY hc VY \iaV`Y( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

?Z mci \UjY dUfhYX Zfca U dYfgcb& UbX \Y kUg bch gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ mci& cf X]X bch U[fYY k]h\ mci k\Yb mci kYfY f][\h& \Y ]g bch hc V`UaY& Vih dfcVUV`m ]h ]g mci k\c UfY hc V`UaY& VYWUigY mci kYfY bch _]bX Ybci[\ k]h\ h\]g aUb(

CGSIL ÃÁ Jc fYdYbh aYUbg hc g\ck mcif j]WYg UbX kYU_bYggYg hc U``( HYdYbhUbWY aYUbg hU_]b[ fYgdcbg]V]`]hm Zcf U`` cZ h\Y VUX h\]b[g mci \UjY XcbY& dif]Zm]b[ mcif gci`& UbX dfYdUf]b[ hc UWWYdh [ccXbYgg( M\Yb U _]bX aUb XcYg bch UWWYdh \]g a]ghU_Yg UbX hf]Yg U`kUmg hc ^igh]Zm \]agY`Z& \Y VYWcaYg Ub ib_]bX aUb( 0R \RX KDYH TXDOLWLHV ZKLFK FDQ EH FULWLFL]HG DQG LPSURYHG, ?U\ WR DGPLW WKDW WKLV LV VR$ DQG WR ILQG WKHVH TXDOc LWLHV RXW E\ \RXUVHOI Dch\]b[ WUb aU_Y U dYfgcbrg gci` gcZhYf h\Ub h\Y ibXYfx ghUbX]b[ cZ \]g ckb V`UaY& UbX bch\]b[ WUb aU_Y cbY \UfXYf h\Ub h\Y XYg]fY U`kUmg hc VY f][\h( v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

J\cgY k\c WcjYf h\Y]f c`X g]bg k]h\ dfYgYbh'XUm [ccX XYYXg fYa]bX aY cZ h\Y accb`][\h k\]W\ ]``ia]bUhYg h\]g XUf_ kcf`X cb U W`ciXm b][\h( v :>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 aUb k]`` U`kUmg ibXYfghUbX \]g g]bg Ug kY`` Ug \]g `]a]hg ]b h\]g `]a]h`Ygg kcf`X(

RSMN Á IW]YbWY WUb VY X]j]XYX ]bhc Ub ]bZ]b]hY biaVYf cZ X]gW]x d`]bYg& UbX h\Y Uacibh cZ _bck`YX[Y h\Uh WUb VY difgiYX ]b YUW\ X]gW]d`]bY ]g `]a]h`Ygg( J\Y acgh Wf]h]WU` d]YWY cZ _bck`YX[Y& h\Yb& ]g h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ k\Uh ]g YggYbh]U` hc `YUfb UbX k\Uh ]gbrh( 7 \i[Y Uacibh cZ _bck`YX[Y ]g UWWiai`UhYX Uh dfYgYbh( Iccb cif UV]`]h]Yg k]`` VY hcc kYU_& UbX cif `]jYg hcc g\cfh& hc ghiXm h\]g _bck`YX[Y( MY \UjY jUgh hfYUgifYg cZ _bck`YX[Y Uh cif X]gdcgU` Vih UZhYf kY ghiXm h\Ya& kY cZhYb Xc bch igY h\Ya Uh U``( ?h kci`X VY VYhhYf bch hc \UjY h\]g VifXYb& h\]g ibbYWYggUfm _bck`YX[Y& k\]W\ kY Xc bch fYU``m bYYX( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

Jcc jcfUW]cig fYUX]b[& VY[ib Uh hcc YUf`m Ub U[Y& Z]``g cif a]bXg k]h\ ibX][YghYX aUhYf]U`( Eif aYacfm WUb VYWcaY h\Y aUghYf cZ cif ZYY`]b[g UbX cif ZUhY5 UbX k\Yb ]h XcYg& Ub ]bhY``YWhiU` YZZcfh ]g fYei]fYX hc fY]bZcfWY cif ZYY`]b[g k]h\ df]aYjU` ]bbcWYbWY& hc Z]bX cifgY`jYg Ua]Xgh h\Y Xighm \YUdg cZ ZcfY][b h\ci[\hg UbX j]Ykdc]bhg& ]b cfXYf hc ghUfh ZYY`]b[ Vm cifgY`jYg& UbXv? Ua fYUXm hc gUmv]b cfXYf hc `]jY cb cif ckb( v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

.HZDUH RI IDOVH NQRZOHGJH& -OO HYLO FRPHV IURP LW& Abck`YX[Y ]g `]a]h`Ygg( J\YfYZcfY& h\YfY ]g U a]bigWi`Y X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb h\cgY k\c _bck U `ch UbX h\cgY k\c _bck jYfm `]hh`Y(

RSMN Â J\Y cb`m fYU` `]ZY ]g cbY `]jYX W`cgY hc =cX( J\]g XcYg bch \UddYb Vm ]hgY`Z5 mci aigh aU_Y Ub YZZcfh hc aU_Y h\]g \UddYb& UbX h\]g YZZcfh k]`` Vf]b[ mci ^cm( 7 \UV]h ]g bYjYf [ccX& YjYb U \UV]h cZ Xc]b[ [ccX XYYXg( =ccX XYYXg& UZhYf h\Ym VYWcaY \UV]hg& UfY bc `cb[Yf UWhg cZ j]fhiY( HYU` [ccX ]g UW\]YjYX cb`m k]h\ YZZcfh( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

M\Yb mci WUffm mcif VifXYb& mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh ]h ]g [ccX Zcf mci hc \UjY ]h( CU_Y h\Y VYgh cZ h\]g VifXYb UbX hU_Y Zfca ]h YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf mcif ]bhY`x `YWhiU` `]ZY& Ug mcif ghcaUW\ hU_Yg Zfca ZccX YjYfmh\]b[ bYWYggUfm Zcf mcif Z`Yg\& cf Ug Z]fY Vifbg Vf][\hYf UZhYf mci dih gcaY kccX cb ]h( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

.H DWWHQWLYH WR ZKDW \RX GR+ QHYHU FRQVLGHU DQ\WKLQJ XQZRUWK\ RI \RXU DWWHQWLRQ& v9ED<K9?KI

Id]f]hiU` YZZcfh UbX h\Y ^cm h\Uh WcaYg Zfca ibXYfghUbX]b[ `]ZY [c \UbX ]b \UbX `]_Y d\mg]WU` YlYfh]cb UbX fYgh( M]h\x cih d\mg]WU` YlYfh]cb& h\YfY ]g bc ^cm ]b fYgh5 k]h\cih gd]fx ]hiU` YZZcfh& h\YfY WUb VY bc ^cmZi` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ `]ZY(

RSMN Ã M\Yb ? X]Y& cb`m cbY cZ hkc h\]b[g WUb \UddYb4 Y]h\Yf h\]g YggYbWY k\]W\ ? ibXYfghUbX Ug amgY`Z k]`` hfUbgZcfa ]b hc U X]ZZYfYbh VY]b[& cf ? k]`` ghcd VY]b[ U gYdUfUhY ]bX]j]XiU` UbX VYWcaY U dUfh cZ =cX( ;]h\Yf dcgg]V]`]hm ]g [ccX( :YUh\ ]g h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\]g VcXm k]h\ k\]W\ ? ibXYfx ghUbX h\Y kcf`X ]b h\]g `]ZY( ?h ]g h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y [`Ugg h\fci[\ k\]W\ ? `cc_ Uh h\Y kcf`X( 7bX kY Xc bch _bck k\Yh\Yf h\]g [`Ugg k]`` VY fYd`UWYX Vm Ubch\Yf5 cf k\Yh\Yf h\Y YggYbWY k\]W\ `cc_g h\fci[\ h\Y k]bXck k]`` ]bhY[fUhY k]h\ h\Y kcf`X( MY WUbbch _bck h\]g( J\YfY ]g U WYfhU]b `]a]h hc h\Y Uddfcdf]UhY `Yb[h\ cZ Ubm h]aY ]b h\]g kcf`X( @igh Ug h\Y Zfi]hg UbX jY[YhUV`Yg UfY `]a]hYX Vm h\Y gYUgcbg cZ h\Y mYUf& YjYfmh\]b[ g\ci`X \UjY ]hg VY[]bb]b[& ]hg `]ZY& UbX ]hg YbX]b[& UZhYf k\]W\ ]h g\ci`X dUgg UkUm( M]gY dYcd`Y k]``]b[`m giVa]h hc h\]g cfXYf( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

7`` h\Uh ? _bck UVcih =cX Vf]b[g aY hc h\Y Zc``ck]b[ WcbW`ig]cb4 U`` h\Uh >Y X]X Zcf ig kYfY h\Y VYgh h\]b[g dcgg]V`Y( v7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

CRX VKRXOG OLYH \RXU OLIH VR WKDW \RX DUH QRW DIUDLG RI GHDWK& DQG DW WKH VDPH WLPH GR QRW ZLVK WR GLH&

RSMN B]ZY g\ci`X UbX WUb VY `]a]h`Ygg ^cm( B]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g bch U jU`Y cZ hYUfg& bch U hf]U`& Vih U h\]b[ h\Uh gifdUggYg cif ]aU[]bUh]cb( B]ZY Wci`X VY `]a]hx `Ygg ^cm& ]Z kY kci`X cb`m hU_Y ]h Zcf k\Uh ]h ]g& ]b h\Y kUm ]h ]g []jYb hc ig& 7 dYfgcbrg ibZf]YbX`m Uhh]hiXY hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y aU_Yg `]ZY ib\Uddm& Vch\ Zcf h\Uh dYfgcb UbX Zcf h\cgY k\c gifx fcibX \]a( 7 Zf]YbX`m accX UbX `cj]b[ Uhh]hiXY UfY Ug Ub c]` k\]W\ `iVf]WUhYg h\Y k\YY`g cZ `]ZY& aU_]b[ h\Ya acjY YUg]`m UbX gacch\`m( ?U\ WR OLYH \RXU OLIH DQG EH KDSS\ ZLWK\ RXU GHVWLQ\$ DFTXLUc LQJ LQQHU SHDFH E\ ORYH DQG JRRG GHHGV& vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y gYWfYh cZ \Udd]bYgg6 ;b^cm gaU`` d`YUgifYg(

vI7CK;B IC?B;I

:c bch gYY_ d`YUgifY YjYfmk\YfY& Vih U`kUmg VY fYUXm Z]bX ]h( v@E>D HKIA?D

7 hfi`m k]gY aUb ]g U`kUmg ^cmZi`( J\Y VYgh kUm hc `]jY ^cmZi``m ]g hc VY`]YjY h\Uh `]ZY kUg []jYb Zcf ^cm( M\Yb ^cm X]gUddYUfg& `cc_ Zcf mcif a]ghU_Y(

RSMN Ā ?h ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h hc Ujc]X kcf_]b[ ]b `]ZY k]h\cih Y]h\Yf g]bx b]b[& Wcaa]hh]b[ j]c`YbWY& VY]b[ U dUfhm hc j]c`YbWY& cf Vm Z`UhhYf]b[ UbX d`YUg]b[ h\Y U[Ybhg cZ j]c`YbWY( 8Y]b[ dccf ]g VYhhYf h\Ub `]j]b[ ]b `ilifm UbX gYfj]b[ h\Y f]W\( :c bch ghUbX Uh h\Y Xccf cZ U f]W\ aUb Ug_]b[ Zcf ZUjcfg ]Z mci \cdY hc `YUX U [ccX `]ZY(

v?D:?7D FHEL;H8 ppp

7 XfYgg dfYgYbhYX hc mci Ug U []Zh Vm h\Y _]b[ aUm VY VYUih]Zi`& Vih mcif ckb g]ad`Y XfYgg ]g VYhhYf( :]ZZYfYbh aYU`g Zfca h\Y hUV`Yg cZ h\Y f]W\ aUm VY [ccX& Vih U `cUZ cZ g]ad`Y VfYUX Zfca mcif ckb hUV`Y U`kUmg hUghYg aiW\ VYhhYf( uvCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

Jc h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch kcf_ h\Y `UbX& h\Y gc]` gUmg4 ]Z mci Xc bch kcf_ aY& Vm Udd`m]b[ d\mg]WU` `UVcf k]h\ Vch\ cZ mcif \UbXg& h\Yb mci k]`` ghUbX ]b Zfcbh cZ h\Y Xccfg cZ ch\Yfg Ug_]b[ Zcf \Y`d5 mci k]`` U`kUmg VY ZUhYX hc igY h\Y `YZhcjYfg cZ h\Y f]W\( vPEHE7IJ;H

CRX ZLOO ILQG WKDW SHRSOH XQZLOOLQJ WR ZRUN ZLOO HLWKHU WDNH DGYDQWDJH RI RWKHUV RU EH KXPLOLDWHG E\ WKHP&

RSMN Ă FYcd`Y ]bjc`jY h\YagY`jYg ]b Wcibh`Ygg UWh]j]h]Yg k\]W\ h\Ym Wcbg]XYf hc VY ]adcfhUbh& Vih h\Ym Zcf[Yh UVcih cbY UWh]j]hm k\]W\ ]g acfY ]adcfhUbh UbX bYWYggUfm h\Ub Ubm ch\Yf& UbX k\]W\ ]bW`iXYg U`` ch\Yf h\]b[g4 h\Y ]adfcjYx aYbh cZ h\Y]f gci`( ?KH ELJJHVW KDSSLQHVV LV ZKHQ DW WKH HQG RI WKH \HDU \RX IHHO EHWWHU WKDQ DW WKH EHJLQQLQJ v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

s8Y dYfZYWh& Ug mcif <Uh\Yf ]b \YUjYb ]g dYfZYWh(t J\]g aYUbg h\Uh mci g\ci`X hfm hc Z]bX h\Y dfYgYbWY cZ h\Y >c`m Id]f]h ]b mcif gci`( Jc ]adfcjY cifgY`jYg& hc acjY hckUfX h\Uh [cU`& dYfZYWh]cb& h\Uh dihg bc `Ygg U XYaUbX cb ig Zcf VY]b[ ibUhhU]bUV`Y& fYei]fYg gc`]hiXY& fYacjU` Zfca h\Y WcbWYfbg cZ YjYfmXUm `]ZY( 7bX mYh WcbghUbh gc`]hiXY fYbXYfg gY`Z']adfcjYaYbh ]adcgg]V`Y& ]Z bch dc]bh`Ygg( 7 VU`UbWY aigh VY ghfiW_ VYhkYYb aYX]hUh]b[ ]b gc`]hiXY UbX h\Yb Udd`m]b[ h\]g hc mcif YjYfmXUm `]ZY(

RSMN Å Jc fYdUm Yj]` k]h\ [ccXbYgg ]g YUg]Yf& k]gYf& UbX acfY bUhx ifU` h\Ub hc fYdUm Yj]` k]h\ Yj]`( HYdUm Yj]` k]h\ [ccXbYgg( vJ\Y J7BCK:

7bX k\Yb h\Ym kYfY WcaY hc h\Y d`UWY& k\]W\ ]g WU``YX 9U`jUfm& h\YfY h\Ym WfiW]Z]YX \]a& UbX h\Y aU`YZUWhcfgS cbY cb h\Y f][\h \UbX& UbX h\Y ch\Yf cb h\Y `YZh( J\Yb gU]X @Ygig& <Uh\Yf& Zcf[]jY h\Ya5 Zcf h\Ym _bck bch k\Uh h\Ym Xc( vBKA; ,-4--'-.

/RQTXHU UDJH ZLWK KXPLOLW\$ FRQTXHU HYLO ZLWK JRRGQHVV$ FRQTXHU JUHHG ZLWK JHQHURVLW\$ DQG FRQTXHU OLHV ZLWK WUXWK& v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

M\Yb kY hfYUh cif bY][\Vcfg Ug h\Ym XYgYfjY hc VY hfYUhYX& kY aU_Y h\Ya YjYb kcfgY5 k\Yb kY hfYUh h\Ya Ug ]Z h\Ym kYfY k\c kY k]g\ h\Ym kYfY& kY ]adfcjY h\Ya( Sv@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

J\cgY k\c hU_Y ^cm ]b fYdUm]b[ Ub Yj]` k]h\ [ccXbYgg k]`` U`kUmg hfm hc YldYf]YbWY h\]g ^cm U[U]b(

RSMN Ǻ FYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]Z h\Ym WU`` aUgg aifXYf skUf&t h\Yb aUgg aifXYf k]`` ghcd VY]b[ U aifXYf& U Wf]aY( EbY WUb XYbm 9\f]gh ]b jUf]cig kUmg4 cbY WUb V`Ugd\YaY fiXY`m& cf acW_ \]g [fYUhbYgg( 8ih giW\ kUmg UfY bch XUbx [Yfcig5 fY`][]cb ]g hcc dfYW]cig Zcf dYcd`Y& UbX h\]g acW_x Yfm WUbbch W`YUjY h\Ya Zfca ]h( 8ih h\YfY ]g Ubch\Yf kUm hc XYbm 9\f]gh4 h\]g ]g k\Yb mci WU`` >]a mcif aUghYf& UbX mci W`U]a hc Zc``ck >]g WcaaUbXaYbhg& Vih mci giddfYgg Ubm ZfYY h\ci[\h Vm eich]b[ \]g kcfXg& UbX X]gx [i]gY U`` ghid]X]h]Yg& U`` a]ghU_Yg& UbX U`` g]bg cZ h\Y dYcd`Y ]b \]g bUaY( J\]g gYWcbX kUm ]g h\Y hfi`m XUb[Yfcig cbY( vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

?h ]g bch hfiY h\Uh U kUf U[U]bgh U ZcfY][b bUh]cb WUb VY gUWfYX( ?h ]g bch hfiY h\Uh h\Y YUfh\ kUbhg V`ccX( J\Y YUfh\ kUbhg difY kUhYf Zfca h\Y g_m Zcf ]hg f]jYfg& difY XYk Zfca ]hg W`ciXg& Vih bch V`ccX( MUf ]g WifgYX Vm =cX& Ug UfY h\cgY k\c dUfh]W]dUhY ]b ]h( v7B<H;: :; L?=DO

-QG EHFDXVH ODZOHVVQHVV LV LQFUHDVHG$ PRVW SHRSOH_V ORYH ZLOO JURZ FROG& HUh\Yf& ]h ]g mcif Wf]aYg h\Uh gYdUfUhY mci Zfca =cX& UbX ]h ]g mcif g]bg h\Uh aU_Y \]a \]XY \]g ZUWY gc h\Uh \Y k]`` bch \YUf mci( <cf mcif \UbXg UfY ghU]bYX k]h\ V`ccX& mcif Z]b[Yfg k]h\ [i]`h5 mcif `]dg gdYU_ ZU`gY\ccX& UbX mcif hcb[iY ihhYfg XYWY]h( v?I7?7> /34,'-

CifXYf ]g U`kUmg U Wf]aY& bc aUhhYf k\ca& UbX \ck ]h ]g ^igh]Z]YX(

RSMN Ą BcjY cZ [ccXbYgg UbX ZU]h\ ]b ]aacfhU`]hm UfY ]bgYdUfUV`Y( DcVcXm WUb gUm h\Uh \Y _bckg k\Uh h\Y UZhYf`]ZY k]`` VY( Eif VY`]YZg UfY VUgYX bch cb `c[]WU` dfccZg Vih cb acfU` cbYg UbX h\YfYZcfY ? WUbbch gUm h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg UbX ? Ua ]aacfhU`& Vih ? WUb gUm h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg UbX h\Uh am sgY`Zt ]g ]aacfhU`( J\]g aYUbg h\Uh am ZU]h\ ]b =cX ]g gc W`cgY`m WcbbYWhYX k]h\ am bUhifY h\Uh h\]g ZU]h\ WUbbch VY gYdUx fUhYX Zfca aY( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

J\Y Ub]aU` VY[]bb]b[ X]gUddYUfg& h\Y jY]` ]g hU_Yb Zfca h\Y ZihifY& h\Y XUf_bYgg X]gdYfgYg( ?h ]g h\Yb h\Uh kY ZYY` cif ]aacfhU`]hm( v7ZhYf I7?DJ C7HJ?D

MY `]jY ]b h\]g kcf`X `]_Y U W\]`X k\c YbhYfg U fcca k\YfY U W`YjYf dYfgcb ]g gdYU_]b[( J\Y W\]`X X]X bch \YUf h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ h\Y gdYYW\& UbX \Y `YUjYg VYZcfY h\Y YbX5 UbX h\YfY UfY WYfhU]b h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y \YUfg Vih XcYg bch ibXYfx ghUbX( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& h\Y [fYUh gdYYW\ cZ =cX ghUfhYX aUbm& aUbm WYbhif]Yg VYZcfY kY ghUfhYX `YUfb]b[& UbX ]h k]`` Wcbh]biY Zcf aUbm WYbhif]Yg UZhYf kY hifb hc Xigh( MY \YUf cb`m dUfh cZ ]h& UbX kY Xc bch ibXYfghUbX h\Y V][[Ygh dUfh cZ k\Uh kY \YUf& Vih bYjYfh\Y`Ygg& U V]h jU[iY`m& kY ibXYfghUbX gcaYh\]b[ [fYUh& gcaYh\]b[ ]adcfhUbh( 5I \RX WUXO\ ORYH JRRGQHVV "3RG#$ WKHQ \RX FDQQRW KDYH GRXEWV LQ \RXU LPPRUWDOLW\&

RSMN ÁÀ J\Y \c`m gd]f]h k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b dYcd`Y ]g `]VYfUhYX acfY UbX acfY( J\]g k]`` W\Ub[Y cif Yl]gh]b[ kcf`X cfXYf( HYU` gW]YbWY g\ckg ig \ck hc Udd`m cif fY`][]cig ZU]h\ hc cif cihYf `]jYg( 7fh g\ckg ig \ck hc Udd`m ]h hc cif ZYY`]b[g ?KH IXUWKHU DQ\ SXUSRVH WKH IDVWHU ZH VKRXOG ZRUN WRZDUG LW& v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y `cb[Yf ? `]jY& h\Y acfY h\]b[g ? aigh Wcad`YhY(

vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

J\Y acfY kY ibXYfghUbX cif X]j]bY bUhifY& h\Y acfY ]hg fi`Yg g\ci`X VY Zi`Z]``YX ]b cif UWh]cbg(

RSMN ÁÁ ;jYfmh\]b[ ]g WcbbYWhYX acfY W`cgY`m ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` kcf`X h\Ub ]b h\Y aUhYf]U` kcf`X( ;jYfm `]Y Vf]b[g ai`h]d`Y `]Yg& YjYfm WfiY`hm Vf]b[g acfY WfiY`hm( LYfm cZhYb dYcd`Y UfY dfciX cZ h\Y dif]hm cZ h\Y]f Wcbx gW]YbWY cb`m VYWUigY h\Y]f aYacfm ]g hcY g\cfh( vP7D?P7: H7<7;PIAO

:fcd UZhYf Xfcd& kUhYf Z]``g h\Y jYggY`5 ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\cgY k\c kUbh hc VY [ccX& VYWcaY Z]``YX k]h\ [ccXbYgg( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

CUbm cZ cif j]WYg Yl]gh cb`m VYWUigY h\Ym UfY giddcfhYX Vm ch\Yf j]WYg5 h\YfYZcfY& ]Z kY XYghfcm cif aU^cf j]WYg& aUbm ch\Yfg k]`` X]gUddYUf Uh cbWY& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug VfUbW\Yg ZU`` k\Yb mci Wih h\Y hfib_ cZ U hfYY( v8B7?I; F7I97B

.H DWWHQWLYH WR WKH DSSHDUDQFH RI HYLO& ?KHUH LV DQ LQQHU YRLFH LQ \RXU VRXO ZKLFK DOZD\V WHOOV \RX DERXW DSSURDFKLQJ HYLO& CRX IHHO XQSOHDVDQW$ \RX IHHO DVKDPHG& .HOLHYH LQ WKLV YRLFH+ VWRS DQG VHHN WR LPSURYH \RXUVHOI$ DQG WKHQ \RX ZLOO GHIHDW HYLO&

RSMN ÁÂ 7h U WYfhU]b `YjY` cZ gY`Z'UkUfYbYgg& U dYfgcb ibXYfghUbXg gcaYh\]b[ gidYfbUhifU` ]b \]agY`Z( =cX Yl]ghg VYWUigY kY Yl]gh( Oci WUb WU`` ]h Ubm ch\Yf bUaY& Vih h\YfY ]g bc XciVh h\Uh h\Y gidYf]cf `]ZY k\]W\ WfYUhYX ig Yl]ghg( 7bX mci WUb WU`` h\Y gcifWY cZ h\]g `]ZY =cX& cf []jY ]h Ubm ch\Yf bUaY( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

3RG H[LVWV RQO\ IRU WKRVH ZKR ORRN IRU 4LP& >WDUW ORRNLQJ* \RX ZLOO ILQG 4LP LQ \RX DQG \RXUVHOI LQ 4LP& Bcc_]b[ Zcf =cX ]g `]_Y di``]b[ U bYh ]b h\Y kUhYf( M\Yb mci di`` h\Y bYh& ]h ]g \YUjm UbX Zi`` cZ kUhYf& UbX mYh k\Yb mci di`` ]h cih& h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ ]b ]h( M\Yb mci gYY_ =cX k]h\ mcif ]bhY``YWh UbX mcif UWh]cbg& =cX Yl]ghg ]b mci& UbX Ug gccb Ug mci XYW]XY h\Uh mci \UjY ZcibX =cX& UbX ghcd UbX VYWcaY gUh]gZ]YX& mci \UjY `cgh \]a( v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

?h ]g gifdf]g]b[ h\Uh ? Wci`X bch gYY U jYfm g]ad`Y hfih\4 VY\]bX UbX UVcjY h\]g kcf`X UbX cif `]jYg& h\YfY ]g gcaYx cbY k\c _bckg k\m h\]g kcf`X Yl]ghg UbX k\m kY Yl]gh ]b h\]g kcf`X( 7bX cif `]jYg UfY Ug ViVV`Yg ]b Vc]`]b[ kUhYf& k\]W\ UddYUf& f]gY hc h\Y gifZUWY& dcd& UbX X]gUddYUf( J\Y ib]hm cZ U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g Yl]ghg ]b h\]g kcf`X k\YfY YjYfmVcXm UbX YjYfmh\]b[ ei]Yh`m gYY_g =cX( ?h ]g cb`m ibVY`]Yj]b[ Uh\Y]ghg k\c gYY YhYfbU` g]`YbWY( v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

@igh VYWUigY U dYfgcb XcYg bch ibXYfghUbX =cX& \Y \Ug bc f][\h hc XfUk h\Y WcbW`ig]cb h\Uh =cX XcYg bch Yl]gh(

RSMN ÁÃ MY ibXYfghUbX h\Y X]j]bY& gd]f]hiU` VY[]bb]b[ cZ cif `]ZY Vch\ k]h\ cif ]bhY``YWh UbX k]h\ cif `cjY( 7 aUb ]g k]gY k\c XcYg h\fYY h\]b[g4 Z]fgh& \Y XcYg Vm \]agY`Z h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y UXj]gYg ch\Yfg hc Xc5 gYWx cbX`m& \Y XcYg bch Xc Ubmh\]b[ h\Uh WcbhfUjYbYg h\Y hfih\5 UbX h\]fX`m& \Y ]g dUh]Ybh k]h\ h\Y kYU_bYggYg cZ h\cgY k\c giffcibX \]a( 3UHDW WKRXJKWV FRPH GLUHFWO\ IURP WKH KHDUW& ÅHÁT XY LUijYbUf[iYg

?bjYgh][UhY YjYfmh\]b[4 VY`]YjY cb`m ]b h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ Yl]gh ]b UWWcfXUbWY k]h\ ]bhY``YWh( 7 W`YjYf dYfgcb WUbbch VY Yj]`( 7 _]bX dYfgcb ]g U`kUmg W`YjYf( ?adfcjY mcif _]bXbYgg Vm YlYfW]g]b[ mcif ]bhY`x `YWh& UbX ]adfcjY mcif ]bhY``YWh Vm YlYfW]g]b[ mcif _]bX x bYgg UbX `cjY(

RSMN ÁÄ MY WUbbch \cdY hc cVhU]b Ubm gcfh cZ dYfZYWh]cb ]b U gcW]x Yhm k\]W\ ]g X]j]XYX ]bhc hkc dUfhg4 f]W\ dYcd`Y k\c fi`Y h\Y kcf`X UbX dccf dYcd`Y k\c cVYm h\Y]f cfXYfg( MY WUaY hc ghfUb[Y WcbW`ig]cbg ]b h\]g kcf`X4 kY gUm h\Uh kY `]jY ]b gcW]Yhm Vih Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY kY `]jY `cbY`m `]jYg( vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

?Z h\YfY UfY a]``]cbU]fYg& h\YfY g\ci`X VY dUidYfg(

v>;DHO =;EH=;

5I \RX KDYH DQ LQFRPH ZLWKRXW ZRUNLQJ KDUG$ WKHQ VRPHRQH ZRUNHG KDUG ZLWKRXW UHFHLYLQJ DQ LQFRPH& vC7?CED?:;I

?h ]g kcfgY hc VY Ub cddfYgg]jY aUghYf h\Ub Ub cVYX]Ybh g`UjY( ;lWYgg]jY kYU`h\ ]g kcfgY h\Ub dcjYfhm(

RSMN ÁĀ J\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ cif bch]cbg WUbbch VY _bckb hc ig& VYWUigY h\Ym f]dd`Y cihkUfX `]a]h`Ygg`m ]b U `]a]h`Ygg kcf`X( Eif YZZcfhg hc dYbYhfUhY h\Y amghYfm cZ =cX UfY Zih]`Y( ?h ]g Ybci[\ hc Zc``ck h\Y X]j]bY `Uk( TuvJ\Y J7BCK:

7 gU]bh `]jYg k]h\ \]g ]bbYf `]ZY5 \Y XYb]Yg cihYf `]ZY&

vB7E'JPK

Eif acgh ]adcfhUbh UWh]cbg UfY h\cgY WcbgYeiYbWYg k\]W\ kY k]`` bch gYY( 3UHDW GHHGV KDYH YHU\ UHPRWH FRQVHTXHQFHV&

v@E>D HKIA?D

?Z mci WUb gYY U`` cZ h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ mcif UWh]cbg& h\Yb mcif UWh]cbg UfY cZ bc igY(

RSMN ÁĂ Jc UWWYdh h\Y X][b]hm cZ Ubch\Yf dYfgcb ]g Ub Ul]ca( ?h \Ug bch\]b[ hc Xc k]h\ giVXi]b[& giddcfh]b[& cf []j]b[ W\Ufx ]hm hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y( J\Y gaU``Ygh XYhU]` WUb VYbYZ]h h\Y ghfYb[h\Yb]b[ cZ W\Ufx UWhYf( :c bch gUm h\Uh gaU`` XYhU]`g UfY bch ]adcfhUbh5 cb`m U dYfgcb k]h\ \][\ acfU`g WUb gYY h\Y]f ]adcfhUbWY( IcaY cZ h\Y acgh fY`][]cig dYcd`Y ]b Higg]U \UjY Ub ]bhYfx Ygh]b[ \UV]h4 h\Ym aU_Y U `ck Vck hc dYfgcbg hc k\ca h\Ym UfY ]bhfcXiWYX Zcf h\Y Z]fgh hibY( J\Ym gUm h\Ym Xc h\]g hc UW_bck`YX[Y h\Y X]j]bY gd]f]h h\Uh YjYfm dYfgcb \Ug k]h\]b \]agY`Z( J\]g ]g bch U k]XYgdfYUX hfUX]h]cb& Vih ]hg ZcibXUh]cbg UfY jYfm XYYd( - PDQ LV KXPEOH& 4H FDQ KDUGO\ VD\* 5 H[LVW$ 5 FDQ WKLQN&

v7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

7 dYfgcb g\ci`X _bck h\Uh \Y dYfZcfag hfiY W\Uf]hm bch ]b Zfcbh cZ ch\Yf dYfgcbg& Vih VYZcfY h\Y YhYfbU` `Uk cZ =cX(

RSMN ÁÅ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g h\Y ghiXm cZ h\Y X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[ ]b U dYfgcb( 9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g U jYfm g]ad`Y h\]b[4 `cjY ch\Yf dYfgcbg& Ug mci `cjY =cX( 8Y Ug dYfZYWh Ug mcif ZUh\Yf ]b \YUjYb( B]jY ]b h\Y gd]f]h cZ =cX& aU_]b[ h\Y VYgh h\]b[g& ]b h\Y VYgh dcgg]V`Y kUm& Zcf h\Y VYgh difdcgYg( ;jYb U gaU`` W\]`X WUb ibXYfghUbX h\YgY ]XYUg& UbX YjYb U [fYUh a]bX WUbbch ]adfcjY idcb h\Ya( vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

BLWKRXW WKH FOHDU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH PHDQLQJ RI RQH_V OLIH$ ZLWKRXW IDLWK$ D SHUVRQ FDQ DW DQ\ PLQXWH GHQ\ JRRG DQG VWDUW ZRUVKLSLQJ HYLO& 7 dYfgcb WUbbch \UjY Wcad`YhY ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY( 7 dYfgcb WUb cb`m _bck ]hg X]fYWh]cb( J\Y YggYbWY cZ U`` fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[g ]g `cjY( M\Uh ]g gdYx W]U` ]b 9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g hYUW\]b[g UVcih `cjY& h\Y W`YUf UbX YlUWh ghUhYaYbh cZ h\Y aU^cf WcbX]h]cb cZ `cjY4 bcbfYg]gx hUbWY hc Yj]` UbX j]c`YbWY( ?Z mci kUbh hc VY ei]Yh UbX ghfcb[& kcf_ UbX ]adfcjY mcif ZU]h\(

RSMN ÁǺ M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]g bch h\Y eiUbh]hm cZ mcif _bck`YX[Y& Vih ]hg eiU`]hm( Oci WUb _bck aUbm h\]b[g k]h\cih _bckx ]b[ h\Uh k\]W\ ]g acgh ]adcfhUbh( 5JQRUDQFH LQ LWVHOI LV QHLWKHU VKDPHIXO QRU KDUPIXO& :RERG\ FDQ NQRZ HYHU\WKLQJ& .XW SUHWHQGLQJ WKDW \RX NQRZ ZKDW \RX DFWXDOO\ GR QRW NQRZ LV ERWK VKDPHIXO DQG KDUPIXO& J\YfY UfY hkc hmdYg cZ ][bcfUbWY& h\Y difY& bUhifU` ][bcx fUbWY ]bhc k\]W\ U`` dYcd`Y UfY Vcfb& UbX h\Y ][bcfUbWY cZ h\Y gc'WU``YX k]gY( Oci k]`` gYY h\Uh aUbm Uacb[ h\cgY k\c WU`` h\YagY`jYg gW\c`Ufg Xc bch _bck fYU` `]ZY& UbX h\Ym XYgd]gY g]ad`Y dYcd`Y UbX g]ad`Y h\]b[g( 8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y hfih\ g\ci`X cZhYb cjYfWcaY h\cigUbXg cZ cVghUW`Yg& ibh]` ]h ]g UWWYdhYX( v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

J\Y gW\c`Uf k\c h\]b_g Vih XcYg bch WfYUhY ]g `]_Y h\Y W`ciX k\]W\ XcYg bch []jY fU]b( v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

LU[iY UbX Wcad`Yl hYfa]bc`c[m kUg WfYUhYX Vm ZU`gY gW\c`Ufg( HYU`& hfih\Zi` _bck`YX[Y XcYg bch bYYX jU[iY hYfag(

RSMN 7 aUb k\c XcYg bch ibXYfghUbX h\Y VYbYZ]h cZ giZZYf]b[ XcYg bch `]jY U W`YjYf UbX hfiY `]ZY( CUb_]bX \Ug bYjYf UW\]YjYX [fYUhbYgg Vih h\fci[\ giZx ZYf]b[( v<( HE8;HJ':; B7C;DD7?I

M]h\cih giZZYf]b[& gd]f]hiU` [fckh\ WUbbch \UddYb( IiZ' ZYf]b[ cZhYb UWWcadUb]Yg XYUh\& Vih giZZYf]b[ ]g U`gc U igYZi`& VYbYZ]W]U` WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY( ?h ]g gU]X h\Uh =cX `cjYg h\cgY k\c YldYf]YbWY giZZYf]b[( HY`][]cb []jYg U dYfgcb h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ \]g Yl]ghYbWY UbX \]g XYgh]bUh]cb( v7D7JEB; <H7D9;

- SHUVRQ ZKR OLYHV D VSLULWXDO OLIH FDQQRW KHOS KXW VHH WKDW VXIIHULQJ EULQJV KLP FORVHU WR 3RG& >HHQ LQ WKLV OLJKW$ VXIIHUc LQJ ORVHV LWV ELWWHU VLGH DQG EHFRPHV EOLVV&

RSMN ÂÀ <cf U dYfgcb k\c `YUXg U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY Vf]b[g U V`]gg h\Uh ZUf hfUbgWYbXg h\Y d`YUgifY cZ U dYfgcb k\c `]jYg Vm h\Y gY`Z']bXi`[Ybh gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ \]g Ub]aU` dUgg]cbg( >Y k\c ]g _]bX XcYg [ccX Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 7bX ]Z U dYfx gcb giZZYfg k\]`Y \Y XcYg _]bX XYYXg& \Y VYWcaYg Ub YjYb VYhhYf dYfgcb( v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

>Y h\Uh `cjYh\ ZUh\Yf cf ach\Yf acfY h\Ub aY ]g bch kcfx h\m cZ aY4 UbX \Y h\Uh `cjYh\ gcb cf XUi[\hYf acfY h\Ub aY ]g bch kcfh\m cZ aY( vCUhh\Yk "!+$(

J\YfY ]g bc \][\Yf V`Ygg]b[ Zcf U dYfgcb h\Ub hc Xc W\Uf]x hUV`Y kcf_ Zcf h\Y VYbYZ]h UbX kY``'VY]b[ cZ ch\Yfg( vBK9O C7BEHO

@igh Ug Z]fY V`ckg cih WUbX`Yg& [ccX XYYXg Zcf h\Y VYbYZ]h cZ ch\Yfg XYghfcm U gY`Z]g\ `]ZY( ?KH GDUN VSRW LQ WKH VXQOLJKW WKDW IDOOV RQ XV LV WKH VKDGRZ FUHDWHG E\ RXU RZQ SHUVRQDOLWLHV& BH OLYH IRU RXUVHOYHV RQO\ ZKHQ ZH OLYH IRU RWKHUV& 5W PD\ VHHP VWUDQJH$ EXW WU\ LW$ DQG \RX ZLOO VHH LW IURP \RXU RZQ H[SHULHQFH&

RSMN ÂÁ ?b h\Y ZihifY& h\Y cfXYf cZ h\Y gcW]U` `]ZY cZ h\Y 9\f]gh]Ub kcf`X k]`` VY W\Ub[YX Vm h\Y fYd`UWYaYbh cZ j]c`YbWY UbX ]hg ZYUfg k]h\ `cjY UbX V`Ygg]b[( J\ig ? WcaaUbX mci& hc `cjY cbY Ubch\Yf(

v@E>D +/4+1'+3

?h ]g U a]ghU_Y hc h\]b_ h\Uh h\YfY UfY h]aYg k\Yb mci WUb" gUZY`m UXXfYgg U dYfgcb k]h\cih `cjY( Oci WUb kcf_ k]h\ cV^YWhg k]h\cih `cjYvWihh]b[ kccX& VU_]b[ Vf]W_g& aU_x ]b[ ]fcbvVih mci WUbbch kcf_ k]h\ dYcd`Y k]h\cih `cjY( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug mci WUbbch kcf_ k]h\ VYYg k]h\cih VY]b[ WUih]cig& mci WUbbch kcf_ k]h\ dYcd`Y k]h\cih VY]b[ a]bXZi` cZ h\Y]f \iaUb]hm( ?h ]g h\Y eiU`]hm cZ dYcd`Y Ug ]h ]g cZ VYYg4 ]Z mci UfY bch jYfm WUih]cig k]h\ h\Ya& h\Yb mci \Ufa Vch\ mcifgY`Z UbX h\Ya( ?h WUbbch VY ch\Yfx k]gY& VYWUigY aihiU` `cjY ]g h\Y aU^cf `Uk cZ cif Yl]ghYbWY( Kbh]` ? WUb gYY h\Uh h\Y aU^cf WcaaUbXaYbh cZ 9\f]ghv `cjY mcif YbYa]Ygv]g VY]b[ Zi`Z]``YX& ? k]`` Wcbh]biY hc VY`]YjY h\Uh aUbm dYcd`Y UfY bch fYU` 9\f]gh]Ubg& Vih cb`m dfYhYbX hc VY 9\f]gh]Ubg( v=EJJ>EB: ;F>H7?C B;II?D=

J\Y kcfgh a]ghU_Y k\]W\ kUg YjYf aUXY ]b h\]g kcf`X kUg h\Y gYdUfUh]cb cZ dc`]h]WU` gW]YbWY Zfca Yh\]Wg( vF;H9O 8OII>; I>;BB;O

CRX VKRXOG OLYH VR WKDW LW LV SRVVLEOH WR FUHDWH WKH NLQJGRP RI ORYH RQ HDUWK& CRX VKRXOG OLYH D OLIH EDVHG QRW RQ YLROHQFH EXW RQ ORYH&

RSMN ÂÂ ?KH JUHDWHVW NQRZOHGJH LV VHOI%NQRZOHGJH& 4H ZKR XQGHUc VWDQGV KLPVHOI ZLOO XQGHUVWDQG 3RG& @Ygig Wf]YX UbX gU]X( >Y h\Uh VY`]YjYh\ cb aY& \Y`]YjYh\ bch cb aY& Vih cb \]a h\Uh gYbh aY( 7bX \Y h\Uh gYYh\ aY gYYh\ \]a h\Uh gYbh aY( ? Ua WcaY U `][\h ]bhc h\Y kcf`X& h\Uh k\cgcYjYf VY`]YjYh\ cb aY g\ci`X bch UV]XY ]b XUf_x bYgg( 7bX ]Z Ubm aUb \YUf am kcfXg& UbX VY`]YjY bch& ? ^iX[Y \]a bch4 Zcf ? WUaY bch hc ^iX[Y h\Y kcf`X& Vih hc gUjY h\Y kcf`X( >Y h\Uh fY^YWhYh\ aY& UbX fYWY]jYh\ bch am kcfXg& \Uh\ cbY h\Uh ^iX[Yh\ \]a4'h\Y kcfX h\Uh ? \UjY gdc_Yb& h\Y gUaY g\U`` ^iX[Y \]a ]b h\Y `Ugh XUm( <cf ? \UjY bch gdc_Yb cZ amgY`Z5 Vih h\Y <Uh\Yf k\]W\ gYbh aY& \Y [UjY aY U WcaaUbXaYbh& k\UhS? g\ci`X gUm& UbX k\Uh ? g\ci`X gdYU_( 7bX ? _bck h\Uh h\]g WcaaUbXaYbh ]g `]ZY YjYf`Ugh]b[4 k\UhgcYjYf ? gdYU_ h\YfYZcfY& YjYb Ug h\Y <Uh\Yf gU]X ibhc aY& gc ? gdYU_( O4928 "#+%% &!

M]h\cih dif]hm cZ gci`& \ck WUb mci gUm& ? k]`` [`cf]Zm =cX6 J\Uh `][\h& `]_Y U acfb]b[ ghUf& k\]W\ `]jYg ]b h\Y \YUfh cZ YjYfm dYfgcb& h\]g `][\h ]g cif gU`jUh]cb( vM787D7 FKH7D7& ?D:?7D M?I:EC

7 dYfgcb WUb hfUbgZcfa \]g dYfgcbU`]hm& \]g ]bbYf gY`Z& Zfca h\Y XcaU]b cZ giZZYf]b[ UbX giVXi]b[ ]bhc h\Y XcaU]b k\]W\ ]g U`kUmg ghYUXm UbX ^cmZi`& h\Uh ]g& h\Y XcaU]b cZ ibXYfghUbX]b[ \]g gd]f]hiU` UbX X]j]bY YggYbWY(

RSMN ÂÃ HYU` [ccXbYgg ]g U`kUmg g]ad`Y( I]ad`]W]hm ]g gc UhhfUWh]jY UbX gc dfcZ]hUV`Y h\Uh ]h ]g ghfUb[Y h\Uh gc ZYk dYcd`Y `YUX hfi`m g]ad`Y `]jYg( 0R QRW VHHN KDSSLQHVV HOVHZKHUH& 3LYH WKDQNV WR 3RG$ ZKR PDGH QHFHVVDU\ WKLQJV VLPSOH$ DQG FRPSOLFDWHG WKLQJV XQQHFHVVDU\&

v=H;=EHO IAELEHE:7 "'"

Ccgh cZ cif gdYbX]b[ ]g XcbY hc ZcfkUfX cif YZZcfhg hc `cc_ `]_Y ch\Yfg( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

;jYfm [fYUh h\]b[ ]g XcbY ]b U ei]Yh& \iaV`Y& g]ad`Y kUm5 hc d`ck h\Y `UbX& hc Vi]`X \cigYg& hc VfYYX WUhh`Y& YjYb hc h\]b_vmci WUbbch Xc giW\ h\]b[g k\Yb h\YfY UfY h\ibx XYf UbX `][\hb]b[ UfcibX mci( =fYUh UbX hfiY h\]b[g UfY U`kUmg g]ad`Y UbX \iaV`Y( Dc cbY `cc_g `Ygg g]ad`Y h\Ub h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Ufh]Z]x W]U``m ghf]jY hc gYYa gc( 7fh]Z]W]U` g]ad`]W]hm ]g h\Y acgh ibd`YUgUbh cZ U`` Ufh]Z]W]U` h\]b[g(

RSMN ÂÄ ?b Ubm ghfi[[`Y hfiY VfUjYfm `]Yg k]h\]b h\cgY k\c _bck h\Uh =cX ]g h\Y]f U``m( !BKDWHYHU KDSSHQV& GR QRW ORVH IDLWK& :RWKLQJ KDG FDQ KDSc SHQ WR \RX DV D KXPDQ EHLQJ& J\YgY h\]b[g ? \UjY gdc_Yb ibhc mci& h\Uh ]b aY mY a][\h \UjY dYUWY( ?b h\Y kcf`X mY g\U`` \UjY hf]Vi`Uh]cb4 Vih VY cZ [ccX W\YYf5 ? \UjY cjYfWcaY h\Y kcf`X( v@E>D +04--

;jYfmh\]b[ ]g ]bXYZ]b]hY& a]ghm& UbX hfUbg]Ybh5 cb`m j]fhiY ]g W`YUf& UbX ]h WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm Ubm ZcfWY( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

Eb`m U dYfgcb k\c fYbcibWYg \]g dYfgcbU`]hm VYWcaYg hfi`m dckYfZi`( 7g gccb Ug cbY XYb]Yg \]g dYfgcbU`]hm& ]h ]g bch \Y Vih =cX k\c UWhg h\fci[\ \]a( EbWY idcb U h]aY& U HcaUb YadfYgg `cgh \Yf dfYW]cig ^YkY`fm( ?h kUg UbbcibWYX UWfcgg h\Y Yad]fY h\Uh k\cYjYf ZcibX \Yf `cgh ghcbYg VYZcfY h\]fhm XUmg kci`X fYWY]jY U V][ fYkUfX& Vih Ubm k\c fYhifbYX h\Y ^YkY`fm UZhYf h\]fhm XUmg kci`X VY YlYWihYX( IUaiY`& U @Yk]g\ fUVV]& ZcibX h\Y dfYW]cig ghcbYg& Vih \Y fYhifbYX h\Ya UZhYf h\]fhm XUmg \UX dUggYX( s>UjY mci VYYb UVfcUX6t h\Y HcaUb YadfYgg Ug_YX \]a( sDc& ? kUg Uh \caY(t sCUmVY mci X]X bch _bck k\Uh kUg dfcW`U]aYX6t sDc& ? _bYk&t gU]X IUaiY`( sJ\Yb k\m X]X mci bch fYhifb h\YgY h\]b[g VYZcfY h\Y Yld]fm cZ h\Y h\]fhm XUmg6 Dck mci \UjY hc VY YlYWihYX(t s? kUbhYX hc g\ck mci h\Uh ? fYhifbYX mcif `cgh ^YkY`fm& bch VYWUigY cZ ZYUf cZ mcif dib]g\aYbh& Vih VYWUigY cZ ZYUf cZ =cX(t

RSMN

!

7 dYfgcb WUb ibXYfghUbX \]agY`Z Ug U aUhYf]U` cf U gd]f]x hiU` VY]b[( M\Yb mci ibXYfghUbX mcifgY`Z Ug U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[& h\Yb mci UfY ZfYY( M\Uh ]g s`cjY cZ =cX&t ]Z ]h ]g bch h\Y YZZcfh hc UXX dUfh cZ mcifgY`Z hc h\Y \][\Yf WfYUh]jY Z`ck cZ YbYf[m ]b h\]g kcf`X6 :]j]bY ZcfWY Yl]ghg ]b YjYfmh\]b[& Vih h\Y [fYUhYgh aUb]x ZYghUh]cb cZ ]h ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g ]b \iaUb]hm& UbX ]b cfXYf hc dih ]h hc kcf_& cbY aigh ibXYfghUbX ]h UbX UWWYdh ]h( 5I D SHUVRQ GRFV QRW EHOLHYH KLPVHOI FDSDEOH RI GRLQJ WKH EHVW WKLQJV LQ WKH ZRUOG$ WKHQ KH VWDUWV WR FUHDWH WKH ZRUVW WKLQJV& ? _bck h\Uh h\Y g_m _bckg YjYfmh\]b[& UbX h\Uh ]hg `Ukg UfY WcbghUbh( ? _bck h\Uh ]h gYYg YjYfmh\]b[& ]h [Yhg ]bhc YjYfmh\]b[& UbX ]h ]g dfYgYbh ]b YjYfmh\]b[( J\Y \YUjYbg WUb [Yh ]bhc h\Y XYdh\g cZ U`` \iaUb \YUfhg ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh h\Y XUm`][\h WUb `][\hYb U XUf_ fcca( MY g\ci`X hfm hc fYZ`YWh h\]g \YUjYb`m `][\h( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

RSMN ÂĂ J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX ]g UWWYgg]V`Y hc YjYfmVcXm5 h\Y Wcad`YhY ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y YggYbWY cZ =cX ]g bch UWWYgg]V`Y hc Ubm dYfgcb( 7`` h\Y bUh]cbg cZ h\Y kcf`X bUaY UbX fYgdYWh =cX( :]Zx ZYfYbh dYcd`Y []jY \]a X]ZZYfYbh bUaYg& UbX dih X]ZZYfYbh W`ch\Yg cb \]a5 Vih h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY =cX ibXYf U`` h\YgY X]ZZYfYbh aUb]ZYghUh]cbg( v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

<U]h\ ]b =cX ]g Ug bUhifU` hc aYb Ug h\Y]f UV]`]hm hc kU`_ cb hkc ZYYh( J\]g ZU]h\ WUb VY acX]Z]YX& UbX ]h WUb YjYb X]gUddYUf ]b gcaY ]bX]j]XiU`g5 Vih Ug U fi`Y& ]h ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf ]bhY``YWhiU` `]ZY ]b gcW]Yhm( v7ZhYf =;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

J\YfY UfY gcaY ghUhYaYbhg k\]W\ WUbbch VY ZUh\caYX4 =cX Yl]ghg cf \Y XcYg bch Yl]gh5 h\Y gci` Yl]ghg ]b h\Y VcXm& cf kY Xc bch \UjY U gci`5 h\Y kcf`X kUg WfYUhYX cf h\Y kcf`X kUg bch WfYUhYX( v8B7?I; F7I97B

8LYH LQ 3RG$ OLYH WRJHWKHU ZLWK 3RG$ E\ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ 4LP LQ \RX$ DQG GR QRW WU\ WR GHILQH 4LP ZLWK ZRUGV&

RSMN

"

7 VUX accX ]g cZhYb h\Y fYUgcb Zcf V`Ua]b[ ch\Yfg5 Vih jYfm cZhYb V`Ua]b[ ch\Yfg WUigYg VUX ZYY`]b[g ]b ig4 h\Y acfY kY V`UaY ch\Yfg& h\Y kcfgY kY ZYY`( EbY cZ cif acgh Wcaacb UbX k]XYgdfYUX dfY^iX]WYg ]g h\Uh YjYfm dYfgcb \Ug U Z]lYX& gdYW]U` W\UfUWhYf]gh]W& h\Uh h\YfY UfY _]bX dYcd`Y UbX Yj]`& W`YjYf dYcd`Y UbX ghid]X dYcd`Y& UbX Wc`X cf \ch dYcd`Y( 8ih dYcd`Y UfY bch `]_Y h\]g5 kY WUb gUm UVcih U dYfgcb cb`m h\Uh \Y ]g acfY cZhYb _]bX h\Ub Yj]`& acfY cZhYb W`YjYf h\Ub ghid]X& acfY cZhYb Wc`X h\Ub \ch( MY U`kUmg X]j]XY dYcd`Y `]_Y h\]g& Vih ]h ]g bc `Ygg kfcb[v ?Z h\YfY ]g Ub]acg]hm VYhkYYb hkc dYcd`Y& Vch\ UfY hc V`UaY( 7bm biaVYf mci ai`h]d`m Vm nYfc& \ckYjYf V][& k]`` YeiU` nYfc( ?Z h\YfY ]g Ub]acg]hm& h\Yb& ]h ]g h\Y Ub]x acg]hm cZ hkc dYcd`Y hckUfX YUW\ ch\Yf& UbX ]h Yl]ghg ]b Vch\ cZ h\Ya( ?U\ WR XQGHUVWDQG DQG UHPHPEHU WKDW D SHUVRQ DOZD\V WULHV WR GR ZKDW LV EHVW IRU KLPVHOI& -QG LI KH LV ULJKW ZKHQ KH GRHV WKH EHVW WKLQJ IRU KLPVHOI LW LV JRRG+ EXW LI KH LV PLVWDNHQ$ LW LV EDG$ EHFDXVH VXIIHULQJ ZLOO IROORZ DIWHU VXFK PLVWDNHV& 5I \RX UHPHPEHU WKLV$ WKHQ \RX ZLOO QHYHU EH XSVHW E\ DQ\ERG\$ \RX ZLOO QHYHU UHSURDFK DQ\ERG\$ DQG \RX ZLOO QHYHU EH DQ HQHP\ WR DQ\ERG\& v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

?Z mci UfY `]j]b[ k]h\ Ubch\Yf dYfgcb& aU_Y Ub U[fYYaYbh h\Uh Ug gccb Ug Y]h\Yf cZ mci ghUfhg hc V`UaY h\Y ch\Yf& mci k]`` YbX h\Y Uf[iaYbh(

RSMN ÂǺ Mcf_ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ \Udd]bYgg( <]fgh& ZUjcf]hY UbX ZfYY kcf_5 gYWcbX`m& h\Y d\mg]WU` kcf_ k\]W\ UfcigYg mcif UddYh]hY UbX UZhYfkUfX []jYg mci hfUbei]` UbX gcibX g`YYd( CUbiU` `UVcf XcYg bch YlW`iXY ]bhY``YWhiU` UWh]j]hm& Vih ]adfcjYg ]hg eiU`]hm UbX YjYb \Y`dg ]h( /RQVWDQW LGOHQHVV VKRXOG KH LQFOXGHG LQ WKH WRUWXUHV RI KHOO$ EXW LW LV$ RQ WKH FRQWUDU\$ FRQVLGHUHG WR EH RQH RI WKH MR\V RI SDUDGLVH& 9>7HB;I :; CEDJ;IGK?;K

M\Yb U dYfgcb gYhg hc kcf_& YjYb ]Z ]h ]g h\Y acgh ibeiU`x ]Z]YX& df]a]h]jY& g]ad`Y kcf_& h\Y \iaUb gci` WU`ag Xckb( 7g gccb Ug U dYfgcb ghUfhg hc kcf_& U`` h\Y XYacbg `YUjY \]a UbX WUbbch UddfcUW\ \]a( 7 aUb VYWcaYg U aUb( vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

Mcf_ ]g bYWYggUfm( ?Z mci kUbh U [ccX X]gdcg]h]cb cZ mcif gd]f]h& kcf_ ibh]` mci VYWcaY h]fYX( 8ih bch JEE aiW\( Dch ibh]` mci VYWcaY Yl\UighYX( 7 [ccX gd]f]hiU` X]gdcx g]h]cb WUb VY XYghfcmYX Vm YlWYgg]jY kcf_ Ug kY`` Ug Vm ]X`YbYgg(

RSMN ÂĄ 7 dYfgcb WUb Zi`Z]`` \]g difdcgY ]b `]ZY YeiU``m Ug kY`` ]b ]``x bYgg Ug ]b \YU`h\( ?Z kY aYX]hUhY idcb h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ `]ZY UZhYf XYUh\& h\Yb U`` ]``bYggYg kci`X gYYa hc VY hU_]b[ ig W`cgYf hc h\Y acjYaYbh Zfca cbY `]ZY hc Ubch\Yf& U hfUbgZYf acfY XYg]fx UV`Y h\Ub ibXYg]fUV`Y( :if]b[ h\YgY dU]bg kY WUb ibXYf ghUbX UbX Yld`U]b Zcf cifgY`jYg k\Uh k]`` \UddYb hc ig&" UbX dfYdUfY Zcf h\Y bYk ghUhY cZ cif bYlh Yl]ghYbWY( KgiU``m dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc gYfjY =cX UbX \iaUb]hm cb`m k\Yb mci UfY \YU`h\m( J\]g ]g bch hfiY( LYfm cZhYb ]h ]g hc h\Y WcbhfUfm( 9\f]gh gYfjYX =cX UbX U`` aUb_]bX k\Yb \Y giZZYfYX cb h\Y Wfcgg& UbX YjYb h\Yb \Y Zcf[UjY h\cgY k\c _]``YX \]a( ;jYfm dYfgcb WUb Xc `]_Yx k]gY( Oci WUbbch gUm k\]W\ ghUhY ]g VYhhYf& U \YU`h\m cf ]`` ghUhY& ]b h\Y gYfj]WY cZ =cX UbX \iaUb_]bX( 2RU \RXUVHOI$ DQG IRU \RXUVHOI RQO\$ LW LV QHFHVVDU\ WR KDYH KHDOWK DQG SRZHU& .XW WR VHUYH 3RG LW LV QRW QHFHVVDU\$ DQG VRPHWLPHV HYHQ WKH RSSRVLWH LV WUXH& LYfm cZhYb& k\Yb ? \UjY XYU`h k]h\ hYfa]bU``m ]`` dYcd`Y& ? \UjY `YUfbYX h\Uh h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[ ]g bch \]X]b[ h\Y UddfcUW\]b[ XYUh\ Zfca h\Y dUh]Ybh& Vih cb h\Y WcbhfUfm& Yld`U]b]b[ hc \]a \]g ckb X]j]bY& gd]f]hiU` bUhifY& k\]W\ [fckg ]b \]a UbX k\]W\ WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm XYUh\( ?``bYggYg U`acgh U`kUmg XYghfcm cbYrg d\mg]WU` dckYf& UbX h\Ym fY`YUgY h\Y dckYf cZ cbYrg gci`( <cf U dYfgcb k\c WcbWYbhfUhYg \]g WcbgW]cigbYgg ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` XcaU]b& ]``bYggYg Xc bch X]a]b]g\ \]g [ccXbYgg& Vih cb h\Y Wcbx hfUfm& h\Ym ]bWfYUgY ]h(

RSMN ÃÀ ?h gYYag h\Uh ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Y hc `]jY k]h\cih X]gWcjYf]b[ h\Y difdcgY cZ mcif `]ZY( 7bX h\Y Z]fgh h\]b[ k\]W\ U dYfx gcb g\ci`X Xc ]g hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY( 8ih h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y k\c Wcbg]XYf h\YagY`jYg hc VY YXix WUhYX UfY dfciX h\Uh h\Ym \UjY fYUW\YX giW\ U [fYUh \Y][\h h\Uh h\Ym WYUgY hc WUfY UVcih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ Yl]ghYbWY( ?KH UHDO SXUSRVH RI RXU H[LVWHQFH LV WR XQGHUVWDQG WKLV OLPLWc OHVV OLIH H[LVWLQJ LQ WKLV ZRUOG& 7 dYfgcb aUm bch _bck h\Y difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY& Vih \Y g\ci`X _bck KRZ hc `]jY( 7 kcf_Yf Uh U V][ d`Ubh aUm bch bYWYggUf]`m _bck h\Y difdcgY cZ \]g `UVcf& Vih ]Z \Y ]g U [ccX kcf_Yf& \Y g\ci`X _bck \ck hc Xc kY`` k\Uh \Y g\ci`X Xc( ;jYfm `]j]b[ VY]b[ \Ug gYbgcfm cf[Ubg k\]W\ fYjYU` hc ]h ]hg d`UWY ]b h\Y kcf`X( <cf U \iaUb& h\Y df]aUfm gYbgY ]g h\Y ]bhY``YWh( ?Z mci Xc bch _bck mcif d`UWY ]b h\Y kcf`X UbX h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ mcif `]ZY& mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh h\YfY ]g gcaYx h\]b[ hc V`UaY5 UbX ]h ]g bch h\Y gcW]U` gmghYa& cf mcif ]bhY``YWh& Vih h\Y kUm ]b k\]W\ mci X]fYWhYX mcif ]bhY``YWh(

CGX Á >Y k\c gYYg \]g `]ZY Ug U dfcWYgg cZ gd]f]hiU` dYfZYWh]cb XcYg bch ZYUf YlhYfbU` YjYbhg( 7Vi =Ub]ZU_\ X]YX ]b U df]gcb ]b 8U[\XUX ]b k\]W\ \YrX VYYb dih Vm 9U`]d\ U`'CUbgif Zcf fYZig]b[ hc UWWYdh h\Y hYUW\]b[ cZ AUUX( EbWY& VYZcfY \]g XYUh\& k\Yb h\]g ZUacig gd]f]hiU` hYUW\Yf fYWY]jYX U \YUjm V`ck Zfca U [iUfX& \Y hc`X h\Y aUb k\c \]h \]a& s? Wci`X fYbXYf mci Ub ]b^ifm UZhYf mci \UjY XcbY Ub ]b^ifm hc aY( + Wci`X Wcad`U]b hc h\Y 9U`]d\& Vih ? k]`` bch Wcad`U]b( ?b am dfUmYfg& ? Wci`X hY`` =cX UVcih h\]g cZZYbgY k\]W\ mci \UjY XcbY hc aY& Vih ? k]`` fYZfU]b Zfca h\]g( :if]b[ h\Y XUm cZ h\Y <]bU` @iX[aYbh ? Wci`X Ug_ X]j]bY fYjYb[Y Zcf mcif UWh& Vih YjYb ]Z h\]g XUm WcaYg hcXUm& UbX YjYb ]Z ? _bYk h\Uh am dfUmYf kci`X VY \YUfX& YjYb h\Yb ? kci`X YbhYf dUfUX]gY cb`m k]h\ mci(t vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

:c bch h\]b_ h\Uh WcifU[Y `]Yg cb`m ]b Vc`XbYgg UbX dckYf( J\Y \][\Ygh WcifU[Y ]g h\Y WcifU[Y hc VY \][\Yf h\Ub mcif fU[Y UbX hc `cjY U dYfgcb k\c \Ug cZZYbXYX mci( vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

/ULWLFL]H \RXUVHOI$ EXW GR QRW IHHO GHVSHUDWH DERXW LW&

v;F?9J;JKI

M\Uh ? hY`` mci ]b XUf_bYgg& h\Uh gdYU_ mY ]b `][\h4 UbX k\Uh mY \YUf ]b h\Y YUf& h\Uh dfYUW\ mY idcb h\Y \cigYx hcdg( 7bX ZYUf bch h\Ya k\]W\ _]`` h\Y VcXm& Vih UfY bch UV`Y hc _]`` h\Y gci`4 Vih fUh\Yf ZYUf \]a k\]W\ ]g UV`Y hc XYghfcm Vch\ gci` UbX VcXm ]b \Y``( vCUhh\Yk +*4,1',2

CGX Â FYcd`Y jYfm cZhYb Xc bch UWWYdh h\Y hfih\& VYWUigY h\Ym Xc bch `]_Y h\Y Zcfa ]b k\]W\ h\Y hfih\ ]g dfYgYbhYX hc h\Ya( J\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U eiUffY` ]g `]_Y U Z`ccX k\]W\ VfYU_g h\fci[\ U XUa( 7g gccb Ug ]h fig\Yg h\fci[\& mci WUbbch ghcd ]h( vJ\Y J7BCK:

;QH VKRXOG DYRLG GLVSXWHV+ ZKHQ DILUH EHFRPHV WRR ELJ$ LW LV GLIILFXOW WR TXHOO LW& :if]b[ Ub Uf[iaYbh& aU_Y mcif kcfXg jYfm gcZh& UbX mcif \YUfh \UfX( :c bch hfm hc `Ug\ cih Uh mcif cddcbYbh& Vih hfm hc Wcbj]bWY \]a( v=;EH=; M?BA?DI

?Z mci _bck h\Y hfih\& cf ]Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh mci _bck h\Y hfih\& hfm hc dUgg ]h cb hc h\Y ch\Yfg& Ug g]ad`m Ug mci WUb& U`cb[ k]h\ h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY Zcf h\cgY dYfgcbg hc k\ca mci dUgg ]h(

CGX J\Y `]ZY cZ @Ygig 9\f]gh ]g jYfm ]adcfhUbh Zcf ig Ug Ub YlUad`Y cZ U `]ZY cZ cbY k\c Wci`X bch gYY h\Y Zfi]hg cZ \]g kcf_ Xif]b[ \]g `]ZYh]aY( /OHYHU SHRSOH VWXG\ LQ RUGHU WR NQRZ PRUH& @QGHVHUYLQJ SHRSOH VWXG\ WR EH PRUH NQRZQ& v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?b cfXYf hc fYUW\ gd]f]hiU` dYfZYWh]cb& mci g\ci`X Z]fgh cZ U`` hU_Y WUfY cZ h\Y dif]hm cZ mcif gci`( J\]g WUb VY fYUW\YX k\Yb h\Y \YUfh `cc_g Zcf hfih\& UbX ghf]jYg Zcf k\c`YbYgg& UbX XYdYbXg cb hfiY _bck`YX[Y( v9ED<K9?KI

?Z mci kci`X `]_Y hc _bck \ck hc fYWc[b]nY U dfcd\Yh& `cc_ hc \]a k\c []jYg mci h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ mcif ckb \YUfh( vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug cb`m cbY difdcgY4 hc Z]bX dYfZYWh]cb ]b [ccXbYgg( J\YfYZcfY& cb`m h\Uh _bck`YX[Y ]g bYWYggUfm k\]W\ `YUXg ig hc h\]g(

CGX Ä ;jYfm h\ci[\h k\]W\ ]g YldfYggYX Vm kcfXg ]g U ZcfWY& UbX h\]g ZcfWY ]g `]a]h`Ygg( =ccX h\ci[\hg k\]W\ cf][]bUhY Zfca h\Y \YUfhg cZ aYb UfY Ug igYZi` Ug [ccX YlUad`Yg( ÅHÁTWÁZ 7bbUYig IYbYWU

Ihfcb[ h\ci[\hg k\]W\ UfY YldfYggYX ]b U dckYfZi` kUm U]X h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ `]ZY( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

- WKRXJKW LV DQ LQWHOOHFWXDO DQG YLWDO HQHUJ\ RI OLIH$ DQG LW FDQ KH HLWKHU D FXUVH RU D EOHVVLQJ$ GHSHQGLQJ RQ LWV TXDOLW\& vBK9O C7BEHO

Jfih\ YldfYggYX ]b kcfXg ]g h\Y [fYUhYgh ZcfWY h\YfY ]g ]b h\Y `]jYg cZ dYcd`Y( MY Xc bch ibXYfghUbX h\]g ZcfWY Wcax d`YhY`m& VYWUigY ]hg WcbgYeiYbWYg UfY bYjYf gYYb Uh cbWY( KgY [ccX h\ci[\hg cZ k]gY dYcd`Y5 ]Z mci WUbbch WfYUhY g]a]`Uf _]bX UbX k]gY h\ci[\hg& h\Yb Uh `YUgh Xc bch X]gx hf]VihY h\Y ZU`gY h\ci[\hg YldfYggYX Vm mci UbX Vm ch\Yfg(

CGX Ā HY`][]cig hYUW\]b[& h\Uh ]g& h\Y Yld`UbUh]cb cZ h\Y difdcgY UbX aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY& g\ci`X VY h\Y VUg]g cZ Ubm YXiWUh]cb( FYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g bc Wf]aY hc `]Y hc W\]`XfYb& UbX h\Uh hc `]Y hc W\]`XfYb ]g bch fYU``m jYfm kfcb[& Vih YjYb gcaYx h]aYg bYWYggUfm( 8ih ]h ]g W`YUf h\Uh k]h\ W\]`XfYb mci g\ci`X VY YgdYW]U``m WUfYZi` UbX \cbYgh UVcih k\Uh mci gUm hc h\Ya( CRX VKRXOG DOZD\V EH WUXWKIXO$ HVSHFLDOO\ ZLWK D FKLOG& CRX VKRXOG DOZD\V GR ZKDW \RX KDYH SURPLVHG KLP$ RWKHUZLVH \RX ZLOO WHDFK KLP WR OLH& v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

CUb& k\cgY hYUW\Yf ]g bUhifY& g\ci`X bch VY U d]YWY cZ kUl cb k\]W\ Ub Y`YjUhYX ]aU[Y cZ gcaY dfcZYggcf ]g hc VY WUfjYX( v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

:c bch gUm hc U W\]`X k\ca mci hYUW\ h\Uh h\YfY ]g U Z]bU` hfih\& ]Z mci Xc bch VY`]YjY ]b gcaYh\]b[ Wcad`YhY`m& cf ]Z mci \UjY gcaY XciVhg( Jc Xc giW\ U h\]b[ ]g U [fYUh Wf]aY(

CGX Ă 9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g ]g gc bUhifU` hc ig h\Uh kY WUb VYWcaY ]bgYbg]h]jY hc h\Y]f giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\ cb`m h\fci[\ hfUX]h]cbg cf \mdbcg]g( 9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g ]g gc W`cgY`m WcbbYWhYX k]h\ _]bXx bYgg h\Uh mci WUb hfi`m gUm h\Uh U dYfgcb WUbbch VY _]bX ]Z \Y ]g WfiY` hc Ub]aU`g( 9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g WcaYg Zfca h\Y gUaY gcifWY Ug WcadUgg]cb hckUfX dYcd`Y( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

<YUf =cX& Xc bch hcfhifY Ub]aU`g( BYh h\Ya gYfjY mci& UbX `Yh h\Ya fYgh k\Yb h\Ym UfY h]fYX5 dfcj]XY Ybci[\ ZccX UbX Xf]b_ Zcf h\cgY WfYUhifYg k\]W\ WUbbch gdYU_( SCE>7CC;:

- SHUVRQ LV QRW KLJKHU WKDQ RWKHU DQLPDOV EHFDXVH KH FDQ PHUFLOHVVO\ WRUWXUH WKHP& EXW EHFDXVH KH FDQ WDNH SLW\ RQ WKHP& v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

:c bch U``ck mcif W\]`XfYb hc _]`` ]bgYWhg5 h\]g ]g h\Y Z]fgh ghYd U`cb[ U fcUX k\]W\ WUb `YUX hc h\Y _]``]b[ cZ dYcd`Y( vFOJ>7=EH7I

CGX Å 7 dYfgcb k\c hf]Yg hc Z]bX [ccX cihg]XY \]agY`Z& Y]h\Yf ]b h\]g `]ZY cf ]b h\Y cbY hc WcaY& ]g aU_]b[ U a]ghU_Y( ? kYbh U`cb[ U`` h\Y YUfh\& gYUfW\]b[ Zcf U [i]X]b[ `][\h( ? kYbh U`` cjYf k]h\cih fYgh& Uh b][\h UbX Xif]b[ h\Y XUm& UbX h\Yb ? \YUfX Zfca U dfYUW\Yf& k\c cdYbYX h\Y hfih\ hc aY& h\Uh h\Y UbgkYf ]g ]bg]XY am gci`& UbX h\Uh h\Y `][\h k\]W\ ? kUg `cc_]b[ Zcf YjYfmk\YfY ]b h\Y kcf`X ]g ]bg]XY aY( v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?KHUH DUH QR FRLQFLGHQFHV$ HLWKHU LQ OLIH RU LQ RQH_V IDWH& PDQ FUHDWHV KLV RZQ GHVWLQ\& v78;B L?BB;C7?D

Oci Y]h\Yf aU_Y Yj]` Zcf mcifgY`Z& cf mci YgWUdY g]b UbX dif]Zm mcifgY`Z5 mci UfY VUX cf Yj]`& cf mci UfY difY5 UbX bcVcXm WUb gUjY mci YlWYdh Zcf mcifgY`Z( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

Ocif VcXm ]g U W]hm k\]W\ ]g Zi`` cZ [ccX UbX Yj]`5 UbX mci UfY h\Y _]b[ cZ h\]g W]hm UbX mcif ]bhY``YWh ]g mcif VYgh WcibgY`cf( vI7?DJ BKA;

J\Y \Udd]bYgg cf ib\Udd]bYgg cZ U aUb XcYg bch XYdYbX idcb h\Y Uacibh cZ dfcdYfhm cf [c`X \Y ckbg( >Udd]bYgg cf a]gYfm ]g ]b cbYrg gci`( 7 k]gY aUb ZYY`g Uh \caY ]b YjYfm Wcibhfm( J\Y k\c`Y ib]jYfgY ]g h\Y \caY cZ U bcV`Y gci`( v:;CE9H?JKI

Dch\]b[ WUb []jY U aUb ghfYb[h\ k\Yb \Y ]g `cc_]b[ Zcf gU`jUh]cb ch\Yf h\Ub \]g ckb YZZcfh(

CGX Ǻ J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY UhhfUWh]jY h\Ub \iaV`YbYgg UbX _]bXbYgg( 8ih mci g\ci`X bch gYY_ _]bXbYgg k\]W\ UXjYfx h]gYg ]hgY`Z( 7 k]gY aUb gU]X hc Ubch\Yf aUb k\c kUg W\Ug]b[ \]a& s?Z mci \UjY Ubm [f]YjUbWY U[U]bgh aY& hY`` aY bck& VYZcfY kY YbhYf h\Y W]hm& ch\Yfk]gY ch\Yf dYcd`Y k]`` \YUf ]h UbX h\Ym k]`` UhhUW_ mci(t v;=OFJ?7D M?I:EC

8ih \Y h\Uh ]g [fYUhYgh Uacb[ mci& `Yh \]a VY Ug h\Y mcib[Yf5 UbX \Y h\Uh ]g W\]YZ& Ug \Y h\Uh Xch\ gYfjY( <cf k\]W\ ]g [fYUhYf& \Y h\Uh g]hhYh\ Uh aYUh& cf \Y h\Uh gYfjYh\6 ]g bch \Y h\Uh g]hhYh\ Uh aYUh6 Vih + Ua Uacb[ mci Ug \Y h\Uh gYfjYh\( vBKA; ,,4,0',1

J\Y f]jYfg UbX gYUg UfY h\Y aUghYfg cZ h\Y jU``Ymg UWfcgg k\]W\ h\Ym Z`ck( J\]g ]g VYWUigY h\Ym UfY `ckYf h\Ub h\Y jU``Ymg( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U dYfgcb k\c kUbhg hc VY \][\Yf h\Ub ch\Yf dYcd`Y g\ci`X VY `ckYf h\Ub h\Ym5 ]Z \Y kUbhg hc [i]XY dYcd`Y& \Y g\ci`X VY VY`ck h\Ya( vB7E'JPK

- ZLVH PDQ ZDV WROG WKDW KH ZDV FRQVLGHUHG WR KH D KDG SHUc VRQ& 4H DQVZHUHG$ `5W LV JRRG WKDW WKH\ GR QRW NQRZ HYHU\c WKLQJ DERXW PH$ EHFDXVH RWKHUZLVH WKH\ FRXOG VD\ ZRUVH WKLQJV DERXW PH& t Jfm hc Ujc]X aU_]b[ ^iX[aYbhg UVcih mcifgY`Z& YgdYW]U``m Vm WcadUf]b[ mcifgY`Z k]h\ ch\Yfg( 9cadUfY mcifgY`Z cb`m k]h\ dYfZYWh]cb(

CGX Ą B]ZY ]g WcbghUbh W\Ub[Y5 ]h ci[\h hc Wcbg]gh cZ kYU_Yb]b[ h\Y aUhYf]U` UbX ]bWfYUg]b[ h\Y gd]f]hiU` g]XY cZ cif Yl]ghYbWY( IYY_ hc `YUfb WcbghUbh`m k\]`Y mci `]jY5 Xc bch kU]h ]b h\Y ZU]h\ h\Uh c`X U[Y Vm ]hgY`Z k]`` Vf]b[ k]gXca( vIEBED

ALUWXH DOZD\V ODVWV ORQJHU WKDQ RWKHU TXDOLWLHV$ DQG LW DOZD\V VWDUWV IURP WKH EHJLQQLQJ& v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

J\Y _]bXbYgg cZ U XcjY ]g bch j]fhiY( 7 XcjY ]g bch acfY j]fhicig h\Ub Ub YU[`Y( L]fhiY VY[]bg cb`m k\Yb h\YfY ]g Ub YZZcfh( ?Z =cX kUbhYX hc& \Y Wci`X \UjY aUXY ig cbY bUh]cb& Vih \Y hYghg ig( M\YfYjYf mci [c& ]b U`` d`UWYg& hfm Ug aiW\ Ug mci WUb hc VY _]bX& hc VY [ccX& UbX h\Yb h\Y XUm k]`` WcaY k\Yb =cX k]`` ib]hY U`` cZ ig( vJ\Y AEH7D

MY WUbbch ghcd cb h\Y kUm hc gY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb( 7g gccb Ug mci bch]WY h\Uh mci \UjY U V][[Yf ]bhYfYgh ]b h\Y cihYf kcf`X h\Ub ]b mcifgY`Z& h\Yb mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh h\Y kcf`X acjYg VY\]bX mci( Eb`m gd]f]hiU` h\]b[g Yl]gh ]b fYU`]hm& UbX h\Y aUhYf]U` kcf`X ]g cb`m Ub ]``ig]cb( ?Z jci kUbh hc gUjY mcif gci`& Zcf[Yh UVcih mcif WcaZcfh(

CGX ÁQ ?UXO\$ RQO\ WKRVH WKLQJV ZKLFK DUH VSLULWXDO DUH UHDO& ?KRVH WKLQJV ZLQFK FDQ EH VHHQ DQG IHOW DUH RQO\ DQ LOOXVLRQ& B]ZY ]g []jYb hc ig bch cb`m Zcf d`YUgifYg(

vD?AEB7? =E=EB

Dc aUb WUb gYfjY hkc aUghYfg5 Zcf Y]h\Yf \Y k]`` \UhY h\Y cbY& UbX `cjY h\Y ch\Yf5 cf Y`gY \Y k]`` \c`X hc h\Y cbY& UbX XYgd]gY h\Y ch\Yf( OY WUbbch gYfjY =cX UbX aUaacb( vC7JJ>;M 04,.

?b h\Y `cb[ fib& h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY giV^YWh kcfh\m cZ ghiXm& UbX h\]g ]g h\Y X]ZZYfYbh Zcfag cZ hfUbgZcfaUh]cb cZ h\Y gd]f]h( 7`` ch\Yf giV^YWhg UbX ghiX]Yg WUb VY Vfci[\h hc h\YgY VUg]W h\]b[g( v>;DH? 7C?;B

? WUb gYbX am h\ci[\hg hc aUbm X]ZZYfYbh dYcd`Y Uh cbWY5 h\Ym k]`` Wfcgg h\Y gYUg UbX h\Ym k]`` [c hc X]ZZYfYbh `UbXg ]Z h\YfY ]g =cXrg k]``& UbX h\Y dckYf cZ `cjY UbX k]gXca( Cm h\ci[\hg Vm h\YagY`jYg UfY U gd]f]hiU` dckYf5 h\Ym WUb Yl]gh Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY ]b h\cigUbXg cZ d`UWYg( Cm VcXm& \ckYjYf& WUb cb`m Yl]gh Uh cbY d`UWY Uh cbY h]aY( vBK9O C7BEHO

?h gYYag hc ig h\Uh h\Y acgh W`YUf& ibXYfghUbXUV`Y& UbX cVj]cig`m Yl]gh]b[ h\]b[g UfY bch U`` h\YfY ]g( J\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ Y`gY4 ibW`YUf& ib_bckb& WcbhfUX]Whcfm& UbX bcbYl]ghYbh(

CGX ÁÁ J\Y acj]b[ ZcfWY cZ U`` dYfZYWh]cb& Vch\ Zcf ]bX]j]XiU`g UbX Zcf k\c`Y bUh]cbg& ]g bch h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ k\Uh Yl]ghg ]b h\]g kcf`X& Vih h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ k\Uh WUb VY UW\]YjYX( J\Y kYU_Yf am \UbXg& h\Y acfY YZZcfh ? g\ci`X aU_Y hc UW\]YjY dYfZYWh]cb( `CRX PXVW EH DV SHUIHFW DV \RXU IDWKHU LQ KHDYHQ& a ?KH SHUIHFWLRQ RI WKH KLJKHVW NLQGQHVV LV WKH JRDO IRU ZKLFK DOO PDQNLQG VWULYHV& /KULVWLDQ OHDUQLQJ DERXW SHUIHFWLRQ LV D WRRO IRU DOO PDQNLQG& 7 dYfgcb k\c gU]`g ZUf Zfca h\Y g\cfY WUb gYY gcaY g\cfYx `]bYg cf W`]ZZg( 8ih k\Yb gU]`cfg [c fYU``m ZUf UkUm Zfca h\Y g\cfY& h\Ym WUb VY [i]XYX cb`m Vm h\Y ghUfg \][\ id ]b h\Y g_m& UbX h\Y WcadUgg k\]W\ ]bX]WUhYg h\Y]f X]fYWh]cb& UbX Vch\ h\YgY h\]b[g UfY []jYb hc ig( Dc aUhhYf \ck `ck U dYfgcb aUm ZU``& \Y k]`` U`kUmg VY UV`Y hc gYY h\Uh dYfZYWh]cb hckUfX k\]W\ \Y g\ci`X acjY(

CGX ÁÂ B]ZY ]g h\Y WcbghUbh UddfcUW\ hc XYUh\5 h\YfYZcfY& `]ZY WUb VY V`]gg cb`m k\Yb XYUh\ XcYg bch gYYa hc VY Ub Yj]`( MY gUm gcaYh]aYg& s>YfY ? k]`` `]jY ]b h\Y fU]bm gYUgcb& h\YfY ? k]`` `]jY ]b h\Y giaaYf(t Ic U WfUnm aUb XfYUag& VYWUigY \Y XcYg bch h\]b_ UVcih XYUh\( 8ih h\Yb XYUh\ WcaYg& UbX ]h hU_Yg U`` dYcd`Y k]h\ ]h4 h\Y aUb k\c ]g Vigm& UbX \Y k\c ]g WcbWYfbYX k]h\ gcaYh\]b[& UbX \Y k\c ]g [fYYXm& UbX \Y k\c ]g UVgYbh'a]bXYX( DY]h\Yf mcif gcb& bcf mcif ZUh\Yf& bcf ZUa]`m cf Zf]YbXg WUb \Y`d mci k\Yb XYUh\ WcaYg( 7 k]gY aUb& cbY k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\]g& `cc_g Zcf h\Y kUm k\]W\ `YUXg hc WU`abYgg( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 aUb WcaYg ]bhc h\Y kcf`X k]h\ \]g \UbXg dig\YX ]bhc Z]ghg& Ug ]Z \Y kUbhg hc gUm& s7`` h\]g kcf`X ]g a]bY(t 7 aUb `YUjYg h\]g kcf`X k]h\ \]g dU`ag cdYb& Ug ]Z hc gUm& sBcc_& ? hU_Y bch\]b[ k]h\ aY(t vJ\Y J7BCK:

CRX VKRXOG OLYH \RXU OLIH DV LI \RX DUH UHDG\ WR VD\ JRRG%E\H WR LW DW DQ\ PRPHQW$ DV LI WKH WLPH OHIW \RX LV VRPH SOHDVDQW VXUSULVH& vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Ocif `]ZY ]g U gaU`` ghfYhW\ cZ ib`]a]hYX h]aY( Ic \UjY U [ccX `cc_ Uh ]h& UbX aU_Y h\Y VYgh cZ ]h( vI7?:'8;D'>7C;:

HYaYaVYf& mci Xc f]ch `]jY ]b h\Y kcf`X& mci cb`m dUgg h\fci[\ ]h(

CGX ÁÃ 1YHU\ SHUVRQ VKRXOG GHFLGH TXHVWLRQV RI OLIH DQG GHDWK IRU KLPVHOI& 7 k]gY aUb gYhg fYei]fYaYbhg cb`m Zcf \]agY`Z5 Ub ibk]gY aUb aU_Yg fYei]fYaYbhg Zcf ch\Yfg( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

7 gci` XcYg bch `YUfb5 ]h g]ad`m fYaYaVYfg k\Uh ]h _bYS U`` h\Y h]aY( v:7K: ;B =7<<;H

7 k]gY aUb U`kUmg Z]bXg gcaY giddcfh Zcf \]agY`Z ]b YjYfmh\]b[& VYWUigY \]g []Zh ]g ]b cVhU]b]b[ [ccXbYgg Zfca YjYfmh\]b[( v@E>D HKIA?D

Dch\]b[ k]`` Vf]b[ mci dYUWY YlWYdh mcifgY`Z(

vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

Eb`m h\Y hfih\ k\]W\ kUg UWei]fYX Vm mcif ckb h\]b_]b[& h\fci[\ h\Y YZZcfhg cZ mcif ]bhY``YWh& VYWcaYg U aYaVYf cZ mcif ckb VcXm& UbX cb`m h\]g hfih\ fYU``m VY`cb[g hc ig( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

CGX ÁÄ J\Y gci` _bckg YjYfmh\]b[( Dc bYk h\]b[ WUb gifdf]gY ]h( Dch\]b[ WUb VY V][[Yf h\Ub ]h( BYh ch\Yfg VY UZfU]X& Vih h\Y gci` ]g bch UZfU]X cZ Ubmh\]b[( ?h `]jYg UWWcfX]b[ hc ]hg ckb `Ukg( ?h ]g V][[Yf h\Ub gdUWY UbX c`XYf h\Ub h]aY( ?h []jYg WcifU[Y U[U]bgh U`` h\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ `]ZY( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

3RG OLYHV LQ DOO SHRSOH$ EXW QRW DOO SHRSOH OLYH LQ 3RG$ DQG WKLV LV WKH VRXUFH RI WKHLU VXIIHULQJV& - ODPS FDQQRW EXUQ ZLWKRXW ILUH$ DQG D SHUVRQ FDQQRW OLYH ZLWKRXW 3RG& vJ>; =EIF;B E< IH? H7C7AH?I>D7& U Vcc_ cZ >?D:K?IC

:c mci h\]b_ h\Uh UbmVcXm WUb XUaU[Y mcif gci`6 J\Yb k\m UfY mci gc YaVUffUggYX6 ? `Ui[\ Uh h\cgY k\c h\]b_ h\Ym WUb XUaU[Y aY( J\Ym Xc bch _bck k\c ? Ua& h\Ym Xc bch _bck k\Uh ? h\]b_& h\Ym WUbbch YjYb hciW\ h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY fYU``m a]bY UbX k]h\ k\]W\ ? `]jY( v;F?9J;JKI

7`` h\]b[g ]b h\Y kcf`X VY`cb[ hc aY( '9fYUh]cb UbX XYghfiWh]cb \UddYb UWWcfX]b[ hc am k]``( J\Y dfYgYbh kcf`X ]g ^igh U g\Y``& UbX ? Ua h\Y mc`_( vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

J\Y ]bhY``YWh eiYgh]cbg& \ck UbX k\m6 J\Y XcjY XcYg bch Ug_& ]h gUmg4 ? Ua `cjY( ?h []jYg gUh]gZUWh]cb k]h\cih Ug_]b[ eiYgh]cbg( 2HDU QRERG\ DQG QRWKLQJ& ?KDW ZKLFK LV WKH PRVW SUHFLRXV PDWWHU LQ \RX FDQ EH GDPDJHG E\ QR RQH DQG E\ QRWKLQJ&

CGX ÁĀ Jfih\ ]g bch j]fhiY& Vih h\Y `UW_ cZ j]WYg( J\Y acgh Wcaacb UbX h\Y acgh k]XY`m igYX XYWY]h ]g h\Y k]g\ hc XYWY]jY bch ch\Yf dYcd`Y& Vih mcifgY`Z( 7bX h\]g _]bX cZ `]ZY ]g h\Y acgh \UfaZi`( ?KHUH DUH WKRXVDQGV RI ZD\V ZKLFK OHDG WR GHFHSWLRQ$ DQG WKHUH LV RQO\ RQH ZD\ ZKLFK OHDGV WR WKH WUXWK& v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

FYcd`Y g\ci`X Zc``ck cb`m h\Y ]bX]gdihUV`Y hfih\(

v9ED<K9?KI

Jfih\Zi`bYgg ]g h\Y cb`m fYU` WiffYbWm k\]W\ W]fWi`UhYg YjYfmk\YfY( v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

BYh ig VY hfih\Zi`( J\]g ]g h\Y amghYfm cZ f\Yhcf]W UbX j]fhiY& h\]g ]g h\Y V][[Ygh amghYfm& h\]g ]g h\Y \][\Ygh UW\]YjYaYbh ]b Ufh UbX h\Y aU^cf `Uk cZ `]ZY( v>;DH? 7C?;B

EbY cZ h\Y acgh Wcaacb a]ghU_Yg ]g hc h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUb `]jY k]h\cih hfih\( J\Y ]bbYf UbX cihYf WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ YjYb h\Y gaU``Ygh `]Yg UfY igiU``m acfY \UfaZi` h\Ub h\cgY gaU`` ibd`YUgUbh h\]b[g k\]W\ fYgi`h Zfca hY``]b[ h\Y hfih\ X]fYWh`m(

CGX ÁĂ >iaUb]hm \Ug bYjYf `]jYX UbX WUbbch `]jY k]h\cih fY`][]cb( HY`][]cb ]g h\Y bYWYgg]hm UbX df]aY WcbX]h]cb cZ h\Y `]ZY cZ Ub ]bhY``YWhiU` dYfgcb( J\Y ghfcb[Yf h\Y fY`][]cig ZYY`]b[ ]g& h\Y VYhhYf cbY ibXYfx ghUbXg k\Uh ]g UbX k\Uh g\ci`X VY h\Y [i]XY cZ U`` cbYrg UWh]cbg( ?h ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h Ybci[\ hc d`i[ mcif YUfg ]b U V][ \U`` Zi`` cZ XUbW]b[ dYcd`Y5 bck ]aU[]bY h\Uh mci UfY ]b Ub Ugm`ia( <cf cbY k\c XYghfcmg ]b \]agY`Z \]g fY`][]cig WcbgW]YbWY& U`` cZ h\Y fY`][]cig UWh]j]hm cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y k]`` dfcXiWY U g]a]`Uf ]adfYgg]cb( 8ih ]h ]g XUb[Yfcig hc h\]b_ h\Uh mci UfY acfY W`YjYf h\Ub h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ fY`][]cig aUb_]bX( v>;DH? 7C?;B

FYcd`Y cZhYb gUm h\Uh fY`][]cb `cgYg ]hg dckYf Ua]Xgh \iaUb]hm( J\]g ]g bch hfiY& UbX h\]g WUbbch VY hfiY( J\]g \UddYbg VYWUigY h\Y dYcd`Y k\c h\]b_ gc cVgYfjY cb`m U gaU`` [fcid cZ dYcd`Y& UbX h\YfY UfY U`kUmg WYfhU]b dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch \UjY fY`][]cig ZYY`]b[g( 5I D SHUVRQ KDV SUREOHPV$ WKHUH FDQ EH RQO\ RQH URRW FDXVH* ODFN RI IDLWK& ?KH VDPH LV WUXH ZLWKLQ KXPDQ VRFLHWLHV DV D ZKROH&

CGX ÁÅ ?KH JUHDWHVW MR\$ DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH ZRUNV RI 2UDQFLV -VVLVL$ LV WKDW \RX FDQ HQGXUH HYHU\WKLQJ$ \RX FDQ HYHQ VXIIHU VODQGHU DQG SK\VLFDO SDLQ$ DQG DW WKH HQG \RX DUH DEOH WR IHHO QR DQLc PRVLW\ WRZDUG WKHVH VXIIHULQJV$ EXW \RX IHHO MR\$ EHFDXVH \RX KDYH IDLWK+ VXFK MR\ FDQQRW EH GHVWUR\HG$ HLWKHU E\ HYLO SHRSOH RU E\ \RXU RZQ VXIIHULQJ& J\Y eiU`]hm cZ U fYU``m j]fhicig dYfgcb ]g hc VY ib_bckb& hc dYcd`Y& cf hc VY a]gibXYfghccX Vm dYcd`Y& Vih bch hc VY X]gUddc]bhYX Vm h\]g( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

M\Yb h\Ym V`UaY mci UbX gWc`X mci UbX X]gWigg mci& h\Yb mci g\ci`X fY^c]WY5 k\Yb h\Ym dfU]gY mci UbX UXa]fY mci& h\Yb mci g\ci`X VY gUX( B]VY` UbX U ZU`gY fYdihUh]cb k\]W\ mci WUb XYghfcm ]g h\Y VYgh gW\cc` cZ [ccXbYgg( J\Y V`Ua]b[ UbX Wf]h]W]ga cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]g VUX( 8ih Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY ]h ]g ibXYfghUbXUV`Y& UbX ]h ]g jU`iUV`Y Ug h\Y cb`m hYgh cZ mcif `cjY Zcf =cX UbX mcif bY][\Vcf(

7@N ") EbY WUbbch gUm h\Uh h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y X]j]bY YggYbWY cZ mcif gci` []jYg mci dckYf& Zcf h\]g ibXYfx ghUbX]b[ fU]gYg mci hc h\Uh `YjY` k\]W\ hfUbgWYbXg Ubm bch]cbg cZ ZcfWY cf kYU_bYgg UbX h\YfYZcfY cZ dckYf( >YUjYb ]g W`cgYf hc h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c dif]Zm h\Y]f gci`g( J\cgY k\c \UjY cb`m h\Y _bck`YX[Y fYWY]jYX Vm cif Z]jY gYbgYg Xc bch _bck h\Y YggYbWY cZ h\]b[g( J\Y fYU` _bck`x YX[Y ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh h\YfY ]g U \][\Yf gd]f]hiU` ZcfWY( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

FYcd`Y aUm Ug_ mci& sM\m Xc mci _bck =cX6t Oci g\ci`X fYgdcbX& s8YWUigY \Y ]g ]b am \YUfh(t Bcc_ Uh h\Y YggYbWY cZ `]ZY& bch k]h\ h\Y YmYg ]b mcif \YUX& Vih k]h\ h\Y YmYg cZ mcif \YUfh( 9Ub mci _bck mcifgY`Z& ]Z mci Xc bch _bck =cX6 J\Y fYU` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcifgY`Z ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX( vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

BKR FDQ KDUP \RX$ ZKR FDQ KH PRUH SRZHUIXO WKDQ \RX$ LI \RX DUH XQLWHG ZLWK 3RG, -QG FDQ GR WKLV&

CGX ÁĄ J\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ U` ZU]h\g ]g h\Y gUaY( ?h cb`m gYYag h\Uh dYcd`Y UfY Vigm k]h\ hfUXY& k]h\ aU_]b[ U[fYYaYbhg& bY[ch]Uh]cbg UbX kUfg& gW]YbWY UbX h\Y Ufhg( J\YfY ]g ]b ZUWh cb`m cbY h\]b[ k\]W\ dYcd`Y Xc5 h\]g ]g hc gYUfW\ Zcf h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y acfU` `Uk Vm k\]W\ h\Ym `]jY( 7bX h\]g ibXYfghUbX]b[ ]g bch cb`m h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh Vih h\Y cb`m fYU` WcbWYfb Zcf U`` \iaUb_]bX( 7 M]gYaUb kUg Ug_YX& s?g h\YfY U g]b[`Y kcfX k\]W\ mci WUb Zc``ck h\fci[\cih U`` mcif `]ZY6t 7bX h\Y k]gY aUb UbgkYfYX& sJ\YfY ]g giW\ U kcfX( J\]g ]g VKX&a 7bX h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ h\]g kcfX ]g& s?Z kY Xc bch kUbh WYfhU]b h\]b[g hc VY XcbY hc ig& kY g\ci`X bch Xc giW\ h\]b[g hc ch\Yfg(t v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

CRX VKRXOG EHKDYH LQ VXFK D ZD\ WKDW \RX FDQ VD\ WR HYHU\c ERG\$ `.HKDYH DV 5 GR&a v7ZhYf ?CC7DK;B A7DJ

J\Y fYU``m hfiY UbX ibW\Ub[]b[ `Uk& h\Uh `Uk k\]W\ []jYg ig hfiY X]fYWh]cb UbX k\]W\ ZcfV]Xg ig hc Xc VUX h\]b[g& ]g h\Y ]bhY``YWh cZ U \][\Yf& gidYf]cf VY]b[( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

M\Yb mci W`Ug\ k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& fYaYaVYf h\Y `Uk cZ fYW]dfcW]hm( Oci g\ci`X Xc hc ch\Yfg h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ mci kUbh XcbY hc mci( J\]g g\ci`X VYWcaY mcif kUm cZ `]ZY(

CGX ÂÀ <cf U dYfgcb& Zcf Ub Ub]aU`& ]bXYYX Zcf Ubm `]j]b[ VY]b[& h\YfY ]g bY]h\Yf `c[]W bcf aYUb]b[ ]b h\Y kcfX sZfYYXcat VYWUigY U`` cif `]jYg UfY `]a]hYX Vm aUbm WcbghfU]bhg( 7bX mYh ]Z U dYfgcb ibXYfghUbXg \]agY`Z Ug U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[& \Y WUbbch YjYb gdYU_ UVcih bch VY]b[ ZfYY4 h\Y ]XYU cZ bch VY]b[ ZfYY WUbbch VY Udd`]YX hc h\Y bch]cbg cZ ]bhY``YWh& WcbgW]YbWY& UbX `cjY( HYaYaVYf h\Uh mcif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcif ]bbYf gY`Z \c`Xg h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ mcif `]ZY& UbX ]h aU_Yg mci ZfYY ]Z mci Xc bch ZcfWY ]h hc gYfjY mcif Z`Yg\( J\Y \iaUb gci` k\]W\ ]g Yb`][\hYbYX Vm ibXYfghUbX]b[ UbX ZfYYX Zfca dUgg]cbg& UbX `]h k]h\ h\Y X]j]bY `][\h& ghUbXg cb U Z]fa ZcibXUh]cb( -QG \H VKDOO NQRZ WKH WUXWK$ DQG WKH WUXWK VKDOO PDNH \RX IUHH& v@E>D 24-,

;j]` XcYg bch Yl]gh ]b aUhYf]U` bUhifY Vm ]hgY`Z& Vih Yj]` Yl]ghg Zcf YjYfm dYfgcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg [ccXbYgg& UbX k\c \Ug h\Y ZfYYXca cZ W\c]WY VYhkYYb [ccX UbX VUX( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

MY ibXYfghUbX jYfm W`YUf`m h\Uh hc VY U dYfgcb k]h\ \][\ acfU`g ]g hc VY U dYfgcb k]h\ U `]VYfUhYX gci`( J\cgY k\c UfY X]gUddc]bhYX cf WcbWYfbYX cf UZfU]X& cf k\c UfY ]bjc`jYX ]b dUgg]cbg& WUbbch ZfYY h\Y]f gci`g( v9ED<K9?KI

FYcd`Y k\c XYbm ZfYYXca fYa]bX aY cZ V`]bX dYcd`Y k\c XYbm Wc`cfg( J\Ym Xc bch _bck h\Y bUhifY cZ ZfYYXca(

CGX ÂÁ ?b cfXYf hc `]jY ]b [ccXbYgg& hfm Xc]b[ ]h( CRX VKRXOG FHOHEUDWH HDFK QHZ GD\ ZLWK D JRRG DFWLRQ& D JRRG GHHG& ?KLV LV WKH EHVW ZD\ WR VWDUW D QHZ GD\& DcVcXm \Ug Ubm ]XYU UVcih k\Uh [ccXbYgg ]g& ibh]` h\Ym ghUfh Xc]b[ ]h(

v>7HH?;J C7HJ?D;7K

=cXrg `cjY k]`` [c Zfca \YUjYb hc h\cgY k\c []jY hc h\Y dccf( 7 XciV`Y V`Ygg]b[ k]`` [c hc h\cgY k\c& k\]`Y Xc]b[ h\]g& aYYh h\Y dccf UbX hYbXYf`m gUm s[ccX'VmYt hc h\Ya( vJ\Y J7BCK:

M\Yb mci Xc U [ccX XYYX& VY [fUhYZi` h\Uh mci \UjY \UX h\Y W\UbWY hc Xc ]h( Oci aigh _bck Z]fa`m UbX ZYY` XYYd`m h\Uh mci g\ci`X XYX]WUhY YjYfm XUm hc h\Y [ccX cZ mcif ZY``ckg& Xc]b[ YjYfmh\]b[ mci WUb Zcf h\Ya( Oci \UjY hc Xc ]h UbX bch hU`_ UVcih ]h( v@E>D HKIA?D

?Z mci WUbbch hYUW\ mcifgY`Z hc gYY_ dcgg]V]`]h]Yg Zcf Xc]b[ [ccX UbX hc Xc [ccX Uh YjYfm dcgg]V`Y cWWUg]cb& h\Yb Uh `YUgh Xc bch a]gg U W\UbWY hc Xc [ccX(

CGX ÂÂ J\Y [fYUhYgh W\Ub[Yg ]b h\Y kcf`X UfY aUXY g`ck`m UbX [fUXiU``m& bch k]h\ Yfidh]cbg UbX fYjc`ih]cbg( J\Y gUaY h\]b[g \UddYb ]b cbYrg gd]f]hiU` `]ZY( 7`` [fYUh h\ci[\hg UfY `]j]b[ h\ci[\hg& UbX h\Ym WUb [fck UbX VY W\Ub[YX( 7bX h\Ym W\Ub[Y UbX [fck Ug U hfYY& UbX bch Ug U W`ciX( v@E>D HKIA?D

-OO UHDOO\ JUHDW WKLQJV DUH KDSSHQLQJ LQ VORZ DQG LQFRQVSLFXc RXV ZD\V& J\Y dfcWYgg cZ `]ZY g\ci`X VY h\Y V]fh\ cZ U gci`( J\]g ]g h\Y \][\Ygh U`W\Yam& UbX h\]g ^igh]Z]Yg cif dfYgYbWY cb YUfh\( J\]g ]g cif WU``]b[ UbX cif j]fhiY( v>;DH? 7C?;B

Eif `]ZY ]g ibWYUg]b[ kcbXYf& [fckh\& UbX XYjY`cdaYbh(

vBK9O C7BEHO

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY \UfaZi` Zcf mcif ]bbYf dYfZYWh]cb h\Ub h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh mci UfY Xc]b[ kY``( J\Y kUm hc \Udd]bYgg& h\Y kUm hc fYU` acfU` ]adfcjYaYbh& acjYg gc ]bj]g]V`m& gc ]bWcbgd]Wicig`m& h\Uh U dYfgcb WUb gYY \]g giWWYggYg cb`m UZhYf [fYUh& `Yb[h\m dYf]cXg cZ h]aY( ?Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh mci UfY acj]b[ hckUfX dYfZYWh]cb UbX mci bch]WY h\]g& h\Yb mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh mci UfY a]gx hU_Yb& h\Uh mci \UjY ghcddYX UbX UfY acj]b[ VUW_kUfX(

CGX ÂÃ MY g\ci`X VY gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ h\Y gaU`` h\]b[g ]b `]ZY( J\Y `Ygg kY bYYX& h\Y `Ygg hfciV`Y kY WUb \UjY( ?h ]g U [fYUh \Udd]bYgg hc \UjY k\Uh mci XYg]fY5 Vih ]h ]g Ub YjYb [fYUhYf \Udd]bYgg bch hc kUbh acfY h\Ub mci U`fYUXm \UjY( vC;D;:;CKI

M\c ]g U k]gY aUb6v>Y k\c ghiX]Yg U`` h\Y h]aY( M\c ]g ghfcb[6v>Y k\c WUb `]a]h \]agY`Z( M\c ]g f]W\6v>Y k\c ]g \Uddm k]h\ k\Uh \Y \Ug(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

:DWXUH QHHGV VPDOO WKLQJV$ KXW \RXU LPDJLQDWLRQ QHHGV PXFK& <fca d`YUgifYg UddYUf gUXbYgg UbX ZYUf( >Y k\c ]g ZfYY Zfca d`YUgifYg XcYg bch \UjY Y]h\Yf ZYUf cf gUXbYgg( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

J\Y ]b]h]U` ^cm cb VYWca]b[ ZfYY ]g VYhhYf h\Ub VY]b[ U _]b[5 ]h ]g acfY VYUih]Zi` h\Ub [c]b[ hc \YUjYb5 ]h ]g acfY ]adcfhUbh h\Ub WcaaUbX]b[ k\c`Y kcf`Xg( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

J\Y [fckh\ cZ mcif XYg]fYg ]g bch h\Y kUm hc dYfZYWh]cb& Ug aUbm dYcd`Y h\]b_( Jc h\Y WcbhfUfm& h\Y acfY U dYfgcb `]a]hg \]agY`Z& h\Y VYhhYf \Y WUb ibXYfghUbX \]g \iaUb X][b]hm& UbX h\Y acfY ZfYY& h\Y acfY VfUjY \Y VYWcaYg& UbX acgh ]adcfhUbh`m& h\Y acfY WUdUV`Y cZ gYfj]b[ =cX UbX ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

CGX ÂÄ BcjY ]g cbY cZ h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ =cX ]b aUb( J\Y difdcgY cZ `]ZY ]g hc YldfYgg `cjY ]b U`` ]hg aUb]ZYghUx h]cbg( ?b cfXYf hc VY \Uddm& mci g\ci`X `cjYv`cjY k]h\ gY`Z' gUWf]Z]WY& `cjY U`` UbX YjYfmh\]b[& UbX gdfYUX U bYhkcf_ cZ `cjY YjYfmk\YfY( Dc aUhhYf k\c [Yhg ]bhc h\]g bYh& WUhW\ h\Ya U`` UbX Z]`` h\Ya k]h\ `cjY( ;jYfmcbY WUb fYWU`` U acaYbh& ib]jYfgU` hc U``& dYf\Udg Zfca YUf`m W\]`X\ccX& k\Yb mci kUbhYX hc `cjY YjYfmcbY UbX YjYfmh\]b[vmcif ZUh\Yf& mcif ach\Yf& mcif Vfch\x Yfg& Yj]` dYcd`Y& U Xc[& U WUh& [fUggvUbX mci kUbhYX YjYfmcbY hc ZYY` [ccX& YjYfmcbY hc ZYY` \Uddm5 UbX YjYb acfY& mci kUbhYX hc Xc gcaYh\]b[ gdYW]U` gc h\Uh YjYfmx cbY kci`X VY \Uddm& YjYb hc gUWf]Z]WY mcifgY`Z& hc []jY mcif `]ZY gc h\Uh YjYfmcbY g\ci`X ZYY` \Uddm UbX ^cmZi`( J\]g ZYY`]b[ ]g h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY& UbX ]h aigh VY fYhifbYX hc& Zcf ]h ]g h\Y `]ZY cZ YjYfm dYfgcb( -Q\WKLQJ \RX GR VKRXOG KH ILOOHG ZLWK ORYH&

CGX ÂĀ Oci g\ci`X VY WUfYZi` bch hc Zc``ck VUX YlUad`Yg( M\Yb mci \YUf mcif bY][\Vcf g`UbXYf]b[ ch\Yfg& hfm hc ghcd \]a( v<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

J\YfY ]g bc kcfgY \Ufa Zcf U dYfgcb k]h\ U ghfcb[ ]bhY`x `YWh h\Ub h\Y hYadhUh]cb hc aU_Y k]hhm fYaUf_g h\Uh V`UaY UbX acW_ \]g bY][\Vcfg( CU_]b[ ^c_Yg UbX V`Ua]b[ UbX acW_]b[ ch\Yfg ]g `]_Y WcjYf]b[ U XYUX VcXm k]h\ U b]WY gUiWY UbX dfYgYbh]b[ ]h Ug U aYU`( M]h\cih h\Y gUiWY& mci kci`X hifb UkUm& Vih k]h\ ]h& mci Z]bX mci WUb YUg]`m YUh h\]g X]ghUghYZi` aYU`( :HYHU OLVWHQ WR WKRVH ZKR EODPH RWKHUV DQG VSHDN ZHOO DERXW \RX& Oci \UjY hc h\]b_ UVcih k\Uh mci gUm5 cb`m h\Yb k]`` mci ZYY` ei]Yh UbX _]bX UbX Z]``YX k]h\ `cjY( J\Y acfY mci UfY ]ff]hUhYX& h\Y acfY YlW]hYX mci VYWcaY& h\Y acfY WUfY mci aigh YlYfW]gY bch hc g]b k]h\ mcif kcfXg Vm UVig]b[ ch\Yfg(

CGX ÂĂ ?KH PDQQHU RI RQH_V GHDWK FDQ KH LQ DFFRUG ZLWK WKH PDQQHU RI RQH_V OLIH$ DQG WKHUHIRUH LW FDQ EH D PRUDO DFWLRQ& -Q DQLc PDO VLPSO\ GLHV$ EXW D KXPDQ VKRXOG UHWXUQ KLV VRXO WR LWV FUHDWRU& v>;DH? 7C?;?

9\f]ghrg [fYUhYgh kcfXg kYfY gU]X ]aaYX]UhY`m VYZcfY \]g XYUh\& k\Yb \Y Zcf[UjY \]g dYfgYWihcfg& k\c X]X bch ibXYfghUbX k\Uh h\Ym X]X( J\Y kcfXg UbX UWh]cbg cZ U Xm]b[ dYfgcb \UjY [fYUh dckYf cjYf dYcd`Y& UbX h\ig ]h ]g ]adcfhUbh Vch\ hc `]jY U [ccX `]ZY UbX hc X]Y ]b U [ccX kUm( 7 [ccX XYUh\ hU_Yg UkUm h\Y g]bg cZ U VUX `]ZY( :if]b[ h\Y a]bihYg cZ XYUh\& U dYfgcb WUb gYY U WUbX`Y& ]b h\Y `][\h cZ k\]W\ \Y fYUXg h\Y Vcc_ cZ U `]ZY Z]``YX k]h\ dfcV`Yag& `]Yg& Yj]`g& UbX a]gZcfhibYg( 7bX& ]b h\Y a]bihYg cZ Xm]b[& h\]g WUbX`Y `][\hg id U`` h\Y kcf`X k]h\ U jYfm Vf][\h UbX W`YUf `][\h& UbX Vf][\hYbg id U`` h\Y WcfbYfg cZ U dYfgcbrg `]ZY& YjYb h\cgY WcfbYfg k\]W\ kYfY U`kUmg Wcjx YfYX k]h\ XUf_bYgg5 UbX h\Yb ]h aU_Yg gcaY g`][\h bc]gY& UbX h\Y `][\h [cYg Xckb UbX X]gUddYUfg ZcfYjYf( M\Yb mci [Yh fYUXm hc X]Y& Xc bch kcffm UVcih h\Y igiU` h\]b[g& `]_Y Zc``ck]b[ f]hiU`g cf hU_]b[ WUfY cZ YjYfmXUm Vig]bYgg( 8Y dfYdUfYX gc h\Uh mci WUb X]Y ]b h\Y VYgh kUm dcgg]V`Y( KgY U`` h\Y a][\hm ]bZ`iYbWY cZ h\cgY dckYfZi` ghfcb[ a]bihYg cZ XYUh\& k\Yb U dYfgcb Yl]ghg dUfh]U``m ]b h\Y ch\Yf kcf`X& UbX \]g kcfXg UbX XYYXg \UjY gdYW]U` dckYf cjYf h\cgY k\c fYaU]b ]b h\]g kcf`X(

CGX ÂÅ LYfm cZhYb& U`` cZ h\Y UWh]j]hm cZ h\Y \iaUb a]bX ]g X]fYWhYX bch ]b fYjYU`]b[ h\Y hfih\& Vih ]b \]X]b[ h\Y hfih\( J\Y dchYbh]U` cZ h\Y \iaUb a]bX hc UWh h\]g kUm ]g cif aU^cf gcifWY cZ hYadhUh]cb( J\Y Wcifh ^ifm \Ug& Ug ]hg fU]gcb XrYhfY& h\Y hUg_ cZ dfYgYfjx ]b[ gcW]Yhm Ug ]h Yl]ghg bck& UbX h\YfYZcfY& ]h dYfgYWihYg UbX YlYWihYg h\cgY k\c ghUbX \][\Yf h\Ub h\Y [YbYfU` `YjY` cZ gcW]Yhm& UbX ]h gYfjYg h\cgY k\c UfY `ckYf h\Ub h\Y [YbYfU` `YjY`( 7 aUb WUbbch Xc YjYfmh\]b[5 Vih h\]g WUbbch VY Ub YlWigY Zcf Xc]b[ VUX h\]b[g( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

? `cjY dYUgUbhg UbX ZUfaYfg5 h\Ym UfY bch gW\c`Uf`m Ybci[\ bcf YXiWUhYX Ybci[\ hc hY`` gcd\]gh]WUhYX `]Yg( v9>7HB;I :; CEDJ;IGK?;K

5I \RX VHH WKDW DQ DFWLRQ LV H[SODLQHG E\ D YHU\ VRSKLVWLFDWHG UHDVRQLQJ$ WKHQ \RX FDQ KH VXUH WKDW WKLV DFWLRQ LV KDG& ?KH GHFLVLRQV RI WKH FRQVFLHQFH DUH DOZD\V VWULFW DQG VLPSOH&

CGX ÂǺ <cf h\Y dU[Ub kcf`X& U aUbrg f]W\bYgg ]bX]WUhYg \]g [`cfm UbX ]adcfhUbWY5 ]b U hfi`m 9\f]gh]Ub kcf`X& h\Y [fYUh kYU`h\ cZ U aUb ]g Ub ]bX]WUh]cb cZ \]g kYU_bYgg UbX `]Yg( FYcd`Y UfY gc ]bjc`jYX ]b h\Y]f aUhYf]U` ]bhYfYghg h\Uh k\Yb h\Ym `cc_ Uh h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ h\Y \iaUb gci`& UbX Uh difY fY`Uh]cbg\]dg VYhkYYb dYcd`Y& h\Ym `cc_ Uh h\Ya Zfca h\Y dc]bh cZ j]Yk cZ \ck hc ]adfcjY h\Y]f aUhYf]U` kY``'VY]b[( HYgdYWhUV]`]hm ]g cZhYb aYUgifYX Vm cbY"g kYU`h\& UbX bch Vm \]g fYU` ]bbYf gd]f]hiU` jU`iY( 7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

J\Y dcggYgg]cb cZ [fYUh kYU`h\ ]g U gW\cc` cZ df]XY& Wfix Y`hm& gY`Z'UXa]fUh]cb& UbX X]gg]dUh]cb( J\Y `UW_ cZ gYbg]h]j]hm Uacb[ f]W\ dYcd`Y ]g bch Ug WfiY` Ug h\Y]f WcadUgg]cb( v7ZhYf @;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

CRX VKRXOG QRW UHVSHFW SRRU SHRSOH WRR PXFK$ EXW \RX VKRXOG WDNH SLW\ RQ WKHP& - ULFK SHUVRQ VKRXOG QRW EH SURXG RI KLV ZHDOWK+ KH VKRXOG EH DVKDPHG RI LW&

CGX ÂĄ B]ZY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ U \c`m gd]f]h ]b mcifgY`Z5 U \c`m gd]f]h k\]W\ ]g dih ]bhc gcaY `]a]hg( ?KH RQO\ FOHDU DQG ILQDO WUXWK LV WKH WUXWK RI FRQVFLHQFH&

vH;D; :;I97HJ;I

KbXYf am ZYYh& h\YfY ]g Wc`X ZfcnYb YUfh\5 UfcibX aY \i[Y hfYYg UfY ghUbX]b[5 UVcjY am \YUX ]g h\Y Zc[[m Wi`XS g_m( ? ZYY` am VcXm& ? ZYY` am a]bX cWWid]YX k]h\ jUf]cig h\ci[\hg( 7bX Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY ? _bck h\Uh U`` h\YgY h\]b[g& U`` h\]g ZfcghYX Wc`X YUfh\& UbX h\Y hfYYg& UbX h\Y g_m& UbX am VcXm& UbX am h\ci[\hg& h\]g ]g U`` WfYUhYX Vm W\UbWY& h\]g ]g U hYadcfUfm kcf`X& h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ am Z]jY gYbgYg( J\Y kcf`X WfYUhYX Vm aY Yl]ghg cb`m VYWUigY ? Ua dUfh cZ ]h& UbX h\YfYZcfY& ? gYdUfUhY amgY`Z Zfca h\Y kcf`X( ? _bck h\Uh ? Wci`X X]Y& Vih h\Y kcf`X k]`` bch X]gUddYUf( :YUh\ k]`` aU_Y gcaY W\Ub[Yg ]b aY& UbX k\]`Y ? k]`` bch VY Wcad`YhY`m XYghfcmYX& ? k]`` VYWcaY Ubch\Yf VY]b[& gYdUfUhY Zfca h\]g kcf`X( Dck& Uh dfYgYbh& ? ibXYfx ghUbX amgY`Z5 h\Yb& gcaYh\]b[ X]ZZYfYbh U`hc[Yh\Yf k]`` \UddYb hc am ]bbYf gY`Z( 7bX h\YfY WUb VY U `]a]h`Ygg biax VYf cZ giW\ VY]b[g& k\]W\ Yl]gh gYdUfUhY`m Zfca h\]g kcf`X( Eif `]ZY ]g cif `]a]hYX ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g YhYfbU` UbX `]a]h`Ygg gd]f]h k\]W\ _bckg bc WcbghfU]bhg ]b h]aY UbX gdUWY UbX k\]W\ ]g bch VcibX Vm Ubm gdUh]U` cf h]aY`m YjYbhg( J\Y \iaUb WcbgW]YbWY ]g U X]j]bY WcbgW]YbWY(

CGX ÃÀ Eif `UbX& `]_Y cif W\UfUWhYf& WUbbch VY h\Y cV^YWh cZ Vimx ]b[ UbX gY``]b[( 8Y\]bX h\Y Vim]b[ UbX gY``]b[ cZ YUfh\ ]g h\Y \]XXYb dfcWYgg cZ Vim]b[ UbX gY``]b[ U dYfgcbU`]hm( ;Ufh\ ]g h\Y [fYUh []Zh k\]W\ bUhifY [UjY hc dYcd`Y& UbX h\Y V]fh\ cZ YjYfm dYfgcb ]b h\]g kcf`X g\ci`X []jY \]a h\Y f][\h hc dcggYgg h\]g YUfh\( 7bX h\]g f][\h g\ci`X VY Ug bUhifU` Ug h\Y f][\h cZ U dYfgcb hc \UjY h\Y VfYUgh cZ \]g ach\Yf( v@;7D <H7D9E?I C7HCEDJ;B

7 dYfgcb ]b cif gcW]Yhm WUbbch g`YYd k]h\cih dUm]b[ Zcf h\Y d`UWY k\YfY \Y g`YYdg5 \Y \Ug h\Y f][\h hc \UjY ZfYY U]f cf kUhYf cf gib`][\h cb`m k\Yb \Y ]g cb h\Y fcUX( J\Y cb`m f][\h \Y \Ug ]g hc kU`_ U`cb[ h\]g fcUX5 ibh]` \Y VYWcaYg h]fYX& cf \Y WUbbch kU`_& \Y \Ug hc Wcbh]biY kU`_]b[( J\Y VcX]Yg cZ aYb UbX kcaYb& UbX YjYb acfY ]adcfx hUbh`m& h\Y]f W\]`XfYb& g\ci`X bch VY Vci[\h UbX gc`X( Ic hcc h\Y kUhYf& h\Y `UbX UbX U]f& VYWUigY h\YgY h\]b[g UfY bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cbg cZ h\]g Yl]ghYbWY( v@E>D HKIA?D

<HRSOH VWULYH LQ WKLV ZRUOG$ QRW IRU WKRVH WKLQJV ZKLFK DUH WUXO\ JRRG$ KXW IRU WKH SRVVHVVLRQ RI PDQ\ WKLQJV ZKLFK WKH\ FDQ FDOO WKHLU SURSHUW\&

CGX ÃÁ 7 dYfgcb k\c ]g bch igYX hc `ilifm& Vih k\c UWei]fYX `ilifm ei]hY Vm W\UbWY& cZhYb dfYhYbXg& ]b cfXYf hc VYWcaY acfY ]adcfhUbh ]b \]g ckb YmYg UbX ]b h\Y YmYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& h\Uh `ilifm ]g bUhifU` Zcf \]a& h\Uh \Y ]g bch gifdf]gYX Vm ]h& h\Uh \Y bY[`YWhg ]h( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm U ghid]X dYfgcb dfYhYbXg h\Uh \Y ]g VcfYX k]h\ `]ZY&UbX h\Uh \Y WUb Z]bX gcaYh\]b[ acfY ]bhYfYgh]b[( ?KH MR\ RI \RXU VSLULW LV WKH LQGLFDWLRQ RI \RXU VWUHQJWK&

vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

Oci aigh VY`]YjY ]b h\Y dcgg]V]`]hm cZ \Udd]bYgg ]b cfXYf hc VY \Uddm( JU_Y Zfca U dYfgcb k\c Zc``ckg h\Y X]j]bY `Uk YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y h\]b_ cZ Ug WcaZcfh UbX kYU`h\& UbX bYjYfh\Y`Ygg giW\ U dYfgcb k]`` fYaU]b \Uddm( 7 dYfgcb k\c \Ug gdc]`YX \]g ghcaUW\ k]`` Wf]h]W]nY \]g aYU]g gUm]b[ h\Uh h\Y ZccX ]g VUX5 h\Y gUaY h\]b[ \UddYbg k]h\ dYcd`Y k\c UfY bch gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ h\Y]f `]jYg ]b h\]g kcf`X( MY Xc bch \UjY h\Y f][\h hc VY ib\Uddm k]h\ cif `]ZY( ?Z ]h gYYag hc ig h\Uh kY UfY bch gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ `]ZY& kY g\ci`X gYY h\]g Ug U fYUgcb hc VY ibgUh]gZ]YX k]h\ cifgY`jYg(

BVPJ Á .HWWHU WR GR QRWKLQJ WKDQ WR GR KDUP& MY cZhYb fYZigY hc dUfh]W]dUhY ]b h\Y ]bbcWYbh ^cmg cZ `]ZY VYWUigY kY UfY hcc Vigm k]h\ gcaYh\]b[ kY ZYY` kY \UjY hc Xc( MY g\ci`X UWWYdh h\YgY acaYbhg& VYWUigY h\Y gkYYh UbX ^cmZi` [UaY ]g gcaYh]aYg acfY ]adcfhUbh UbX bYWYggUfm h\Ub acgh ch\Yf h\]b[g( LYfm cZhYb h\Y Vig]bYgg k\]W\ Vigm dYcd`Y W`U]a hc VY Xc]b[ ]g bch ]adcfhUbh Uh U``( UbX gcaYh]aYg ]h kci`X VY VYhhYf `YZh ibXcbY( 9fiY` dYcd`Y UfY Vigm U`` h\Y h]aY& Ug ]Z hc Z]bX ^igh]Z]WUx h]cb Zcf h\Y WfiY`hm cZ h\Y]f XYU`]b[g( ?h ]g U Wcaacb a]gWcbWYdh]cb hc h\]b_ h\Uh d`YUgifYg UbX ^cmg UfY ib]adcfhUbh UbX gcaYh]aYg Yj]`5 Ug Zcf YlUad`Y& ?g`Ua& cf UbW]Ybh c`X Efh\cXcl 9\f]gh]Ub]hm& cf Fif]x hUb]ga kci`X \UjY ]h( F`YUgifY ]g Ug ]adcfhUbh Ug kcf_& UbX ]g h\Y fYkUfX cZ kcf_( Mcf_ WUbbch `Ugh YbX`Ygg`m& UbX h\Y bYWYggUfm fYgh g\ci`X igiU``m WcbW`iXY k]h\ gcaY dYf]cX cZ d`YUgifY( F`YUgifYg UfY cb`m VUX ]b h\YgY h\fYY WUgYg4 k\Yb kY \UjY hc aU_Y ch\Yf dYcd`Y kcf_ Zcf ig VYWUigY ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Y Zcf ig hc gUh]gZm cif XYg]fY Zcf d`YUgifYg& k\Yb kY d`Ub WcadYh]h]jY [UaYg hc XYhYfa]bY k\c k]`` \UjY h\Y VYgh cf h\Y acgh d`YUgifYg& UbX k\Yb d`YUgifYg UfY U``ckYX cb`m Zcf gY`YWhYX dYcd`Y( 8ih ]Z h\YgY Yj]`g UfY Ujc]XYX& h\Yb d`YUgifY& YgdYW]U``m Zcf mcib[ dYcd`Y& ]g bch Ub Yj]`& Vih U [ccX( Mcf_ UbX d`YUgifY g\ci`X VY U`hYfbUhYX& cbY UZhYf h\Y ch\Yf5 h\Ym Z]`` cif `]jYg k]h\ ^cm& h\ci[\ bch YjYfm kcf_ UbX YjYfm d`YUgifY WUb Xc h\]g(

BVPJ Â <cf k\cgcYjYf YlU`hYh\ \]agY`Z g\U`` VY UVUgYX5 UbX \Y h\Uh \iaV`Yh\ \]agY`Z g\U`` VY YlU`hYX( vBKA; +.4++

7 dYfgcb k\c ghUbXg cb \]g h]dhcYg WUbbch ghUbX `cb[& UbX U dYfgcb k\c ]g hcc dfciX cZ \]agY`Z WUbbch gYh U [ccX YlUad`Y( vB7E'JPK""

4H ZKR LV ORRNLQJ IRU ZLVGRP LV DOUHDG\ ZLVH+ DQG KH ZKR WKLQNV WKDW KH KDV IRXQG ZLVGRP LV D VWXSLG PDQ& v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

Dc YlhYf]cf ZcfWY WUb aU_Y mci \iaV`Y( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY kUm hc VY \iaV`Y4 Xc bch h\]b_ UVcih mcifgY`Z& Vih UVcih \ck mci WUb gYfjY =cX UbX ch\Yfg(

BVPJ Ã BKHWKHU WKH\ NQRZ LW RU QRW$ DOO FUHDWXUHV DUH LQVHSDUDEO\ FRQQHFWHG& ? k]`` bYjYf gYY_ cf UWWYdh aYfY`m am ckb dYfgcbU` gU`jUx h]cb& ? Xc bch kUbh hc fYWY]jY gUh]gZUWh]cb Vm amgY`Z5 U`kUmg UbX YjYfmk\YfY ? `]jY UbX kcf_& ? k]`` \cdY UbX ghf]jY Zcf h\Y ib]jYfgU` gU`jUh]cb cZ U`` dYcd`Y UbX U`` WfYUx hifYg ]b h\Y kcf`X( Kbh]` U`` \UjY VYYb gUjYX UbX ZfYYX& ? k]`` bch UVUbXcb h\]g kcf`X cZ g]b& gUXbYgg& UbX ghf]ZY( v7D9?;DJ 9>?D;I; M?I:EC

KbXYfghUbX h\Uh mci UfY dUfh cZ U [fYUh gd]f]hiU` Vfch\Yfx \ccX5 h\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ W\YYf]b[ UbX gcch\]b[ ]b h\Y h\ci[\h k\]W\ k]`` aU_Y mci WU`a UbX gUh]gZ]YX( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

>iaUb]hm \Ug VY[ib hc ibXYfghUbX h\Uh kY k]`` U`` f]gY cf ZU`` hc[Yh\Yfvh\Uh kY UfY VcibX hc[Yh\Yf& Ug kY `]jY hc[Yh\Yf( FYcd`Y UfY `]ghYb]b[ acfY UbX acfY hc h\Y jc]WY k\]W\ gdYU_g h\]g ]bg]XY cZ ig( vBK9O C7BEHO

?bX]j]XiU` [ccXbYgg UbX ]bX]j]XiU` Yj]` Vch\ \UjY h\Y dckYf hc gdfYUX [ccXbYgg cf Yj]` h\fci[\cih h\Y kcf`X(

BVPJ Ä :iY hc h\Y WiffYbh X]ghcfh]cb& dYfjYfg]cb& UbX ZU`gY ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm& cif `]jYg \UjY VYWcaY kcfgY h\Ub h\cgY cZ dU[Ubg( 7 aUb g\ci`X VY U gYfjUbh& UbX \Y g\ci`X aU_Y U W\c]WY cZ k\cgY gYfjUbh \Y ]g4 ]Z \Y ]g h\Y gYfjUbh cZ \]g dUgg]cbg& h\Yb \Y ]g U gYfjUbh cZ ch\Yf \iaUb VY]b[g& Vih ]Z \Y ]g h\Y gYfjUbh cZ \]g ]bbYf X]j]bY gd]f]h& h\Yb \Y ]g U gYfjUbh cZ =cX U`cbY( ?h ]g VYhhYf hc \UjY U gidYf]cf aUghYf( J\Y gU`jUh]cb cZ aUb_]bX XYdYbXg idcb ]bXYdYbXYbh h\]b_Yfg X]fYWh]b[ h\Y]f h\ci[\hg f][\h`m( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

?KH PRUH UHVSHFW WKDW GLIIHUHQW REMHFWV$ FXVWRPV$ RU ODZV DUH JLYHQ$ WKH PRUH DWWHQWLYHO\ \RX KDYH WR TXHVWLRQ WKH ULJKW WKHVH WKLQJV KDYH WR WKLV UHVSHFW& Kdfcch]b[ h\Y Yl]gh]b[ Yj]`g cZ h\]g `]ZY WUb VY[]b cb`m Vm aU_]b[ cif fY`][]cbg cdYb& gc h\Uh YjYfm g]b[`Y \iaUb VY]b[ ]b h\Y kcf`X WUb fYjYU` fY`][]cig `]ZY UbX WUb X]gWigg UbX WfYUhY UbX X]gWcjYf fY`][]cig hfih\(

BVPJ Ā ?Z kY gUm h\Uh h\Y cihYf kcf`X Yl]ghg cb`m Ug kY gYY ]h& kY XYbm h\Uh h\YfY UfY ch\Yf VY]b[g& k]h\ gYbgYg X]ZZYfYbh Zfca cif ckb( M\Yb ? WUgh am [UnY cb cV^YWhg& ? hfm hc WcffY`UhY h\Y]f cih`]bYg k]h\ ]XYUg h\Uh U`fYUXm Yl]gh ]b am \YUX( ? k]`` gYY k\]hY cb h\Y \cf]ncb& UbX ? k]`` h\]b_& J\YfY ]g U k\]hY W\ifW\ ]b h\Y X]ghUbWY( :c kY bch []jY YjYfmh\]b[ kY gYY ]b h\]g kcf`X U dfYYl]gh]b[ Zcfa Zfca cif ]aU[]bUh]cb& Vfci[\h Vm ig Zfca cif dfYj]cig `]ZY6 MY WUb gYY h\Uh U`` cZ h\Y kcf`Xrg cV^YWhg Yl]gh ]b hkc kUmg4 ]b fY`Uh]cb hc h\Y]f d`UWY UbX h]aYvVm ibXYfghUbXx ]b[ h\Uh h\Ym Yl]gh ]b =cX UbX kYfY WfYUhYX Vm h\Y gUaY :]j]bY DUhifY k\]W\ YjYfo" gd]f]hiU` h\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X VYUfg ]b fY`Uh]cb hc YhYfb]hm v7ZhYf 8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

5Q UHDOLW\$ WKH RXWHU ZRUOG LQ LWVHOI LV QRW DV ZH VHH LW$ DQG WKXV HYHU\WKLQJ PDWHULDO LQ WKLV ZRUOG WV LQVLJQLILFDQW& BKDW LV LPSRUWDQW WKHQ, ?KDW WKLQJ ZKLFK H[LVWV HYHU\ZKHUH$ DW DOO WLPHV$ DQG IRU DOO SHRSOH* WKH GLYLQH VSDUN$ WKH VSLULWXDO URRW RI RXU OLYHV&

BVPJ Ă 7b Yj]` XYYX bch cb`m XYghfcmg h\Y gci` Vih cZhYb fYhifbg hc Vf]b[ Yj]` cb h\Y Yj]`XcYf J\Y [fYUhYgh j]fhiY ]g hc Xc bc Yj]`& YjYb hc mcif YbYa]Yg( ?Z mci fYgdYWh mcifgY`Z& mci k]`` bch Wcaa]h Yj]`& YjYb ]b h\Y g`][\hYgh kUm( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Yb mci"`` h\fck U VU`` id ]b h\Y U]f& ]h XcYgbrh ghUm h\YfY Vih fYhifbg hc h\Y YUfh\5 `]_Yk]gY U`` mcif [ccX cf VUX UWh]cbg k]`` fYhifb hc mci ]b Ubch\Yf Zcfa& UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y XYg]fY cZ mcif \YUfh& bc aUhhYf k\]W\ dUh\ mci hU_Y( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

-Q HYLOGRHU LV KDSS\ ZKLOH WKH HYLO LV QRW \HW ULSH$ KXW ZKHQ LW LV ULSH DQG UHDG\$ KH ZLOO XQGHUVWDQG ZKDW HYLO LV$ DQG KLV HYLO ZLOO UHWXUQ WR KLP OLNH GXVW WKURZQ DJDLQVW WKH ZLQG& DY]h\Yf ]b h\Y g_m bcf ]b h\Y YUfh\ bcf ]b h\Y XYdh\ cZ acibhU]bg& bcf Ubmk\YfY ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g h\YfY U d`UWY k\YfY cbY WUb YgWUdY h\Y fYgi`hg cZ g]b( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

- SHUVRQ ZKR EURRGV RQ UHYHQJH RQO\ ZRUVHQV KLV ZRXQGV& 4LV LQMXULHV ZRXOG KHDO LI KH ZRXOG UHIUDLQ& v<H7D9?I 879ED

I]bb]b[ ]g Ug XUb[Yfcig Ug ]ff]hUh]b[ U k]`X VYUgh( ?b acgh WUgYg ]b h\]g kcf`X& Yj]` fYhifbg hc h\Y Yj]`XcYf ]b h\Y kcfgh UbX fiXYgh Zcfa(

BVPJ Å 9U`abYgg UbX \ia]`]hm dfcj]XY d`YUgifYg k\]W\ UfY bch UWWYgg]V`Y hc h\Y gY`Z]g\ UbX h\Y dfciX( J\Y dfYfYei]g]hY cZ U [ccX `]ZY ]g dYUWY VYhkYYb dYcd`Y& UbX h\Y aU^cf cVghUW`Y hc dYUWY ]g df]XY( 7 dYfgcb g\ci`X VY \iaV`Y& dfYdUfYX hc VY ZU`gY`m UWWigYX& fYUXm Zcf YjYfmh\]b[5 cb`m h\Yb WUb \Y Vf]b[ dYUWY ]bhc \]g fY`Uh]cbx g\]dg UbX ]bhc h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yfg( 9caY ibhc aY& U`` mY h\Uh `UVcf UbX UfY \YUjm `UXYb UbX ? k]`` []jY mci fYgh( JU_Y am mc_Y idcb mci& UbX `YUfb cZ aY5 Zcf ? Ua aYY_ UbX `ck`m ]b \YUfh4 UbX mY g\U`` Z]bX fYgh ibhc mcif gci`g( <cf am mc_Y ]g YUgm& UbX am VifXYb ]g `][\h( vC7JJ>;M ++4,2'-*

Ff]XY XYZYbXg ]hgY`Z& UbX bch cb`m ]hgY`Z Vih ch\Yf g]bg& UbX ]h \UhYg \ia]`]hm& gc ]h fY^YWhg h\Y WifY& UbX \]XYg UbX ^igh]x Z]Yg h\Y g]b( J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ g]b \Ug U dcg]h]jY ]bZ`ix YbWY cb U dYfgcb5 ]h ]g YjYb acfY igYZi` h\Ub U [ccX XYYX& k\]W\ WUb ]bWfYUgY df]XY( .H VWULFW LQ MXGJLQJ \RXUVHOI DQG JHQWOH LQ MXGJLQJ RWKHUV$ DQG \RX ZLOO KDYH QR HQHPLHV& v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

:c bch VY UZfU]X hc VY \ia]`]UhYX ]Z mci WUb UWWYdh h\]g k]h\ \ia]`]hmvmci k]`` VY fYdU]X aUbm h]aYg ]b h\Y gd]fx ]hiU` V`Ygg]b[g k\]W\ UfY WcbbYWhYX k]h\ VY]b[ \iaV`Y(

BVPJ Ǻ BLWKRXW WUXWK WKHUH LV QR NLQGQHVV+ ZLWKRXW NLQGQHVV WKH WUXWK FDQQRW KH WROG& 7bX k\m WU`` mY aY& BcfX& BcfX& UbX Xc bch h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ ? gUm6 M\cgcYjYf 9caYh\ aY& UbX \YUfYh\ am gUm]b[g& UbX XcYh\ h\Ya& ? k]`` g\Yk mci hc k\ca \Y ]g `]_Y4 >Y ]g `]_Y U aUb k\]W\ Vi]`h Ub \cigY& UbX X][[YX XYYd& UbX `U]X h\Y ZcibXUh]cb cb U fcW_4 UbX k\Yb h\Y Z`ccX UfcgY& h\Y ghfYUa VYUh jY\YaYbh`m idcb h\Uh \cigY UbX Wci`X bch g\U_Y ]h4 Zcf ]h kUg ZcibXYX idcb U fcW_( 8ihS\Y h\Uh \YUfYh\& UbX XcYh\ bch& ]g `]_Y U aUb h\Uh k]h\cih U ZcibXUh]cb Vi]`h Ub \cigY idcb h\Y YUfh\5 U[U]bgh k\]W\ h\Y ghfYUa X]X VYUh jY\YaYbh`m& UbX ]aaYx X]UhY`m ]h ZY``5 UbX h\Y fi]b cZ h\Uh \cigY kUg [fYUh( vBKA; 04.0'.3

7`kUmg fYgdcbX hc \UhfYX k]h\ _]bXbYgg( J\Y acgh X]ZZ]x Wi`h YbhYfdf]gYg UfY YUg]Ygh Uh h\Y]f ]bWYdh]cb& UbX h\Y [fYUhYgh cZ YbhYfdf]gYg \UjY \iaV`Y cf][]bg( 9cbZfcbh X]ZZ]Wi`h]Yg k\]`Y h\Ym UfY gh]`` YUgm& h\Yb& UbX hUW_`Y U V][ h\]b[ k\Yb ]h ]g gh]`` gaU``( vB7E'JPK

J\YfY UfY hkc dUh\g k\]W\ `YUX hc j]fhiY4 h\Y Z]fgh ]g hc VY hfih\x Zi` UbX ^igh& UbX h\Y gYWcbX ]g hc Xc bc Yj]` hc `]j]b[ VY]b[g( vC7DK

:]g[i]g]b[ mcifgY`Z Ug U _]bX dYfgcb ]g kcfgY h\Ub VY]b[ bU_YX`m aYUb(

BVPJ Ą 9\f]gh]Ub gcW]Yhm& Ug ]h bck Yl]ghg& XcYgbrh Zc``ck 9\f]gx h]Ub `Uk ]b ]hg fYU` aYUb]b[( 7`acgh YjYfm YZZcfh cZ h\Y \iaUb a]bX ]g X]fYWhYX& bch hckUfX `][\hYb]b[ h\Y kcf_ cZ h\Y `UVcfYf& Vih hckUfX aU_]b[ acfY d`YUgUbh h\Y ]X`YbYgg cZ h\Y `Y]gifYX( ?Z U dYfgcb Wci`X `cc_ Uh cif kcf`X Zfca U X]ghUbWY \Y kci`X gYY gc aiW\ ghid]X]hm UbX \UhfYX h\Uh \Y kci`X dfcVUV`m Wfm( MY Xc gc aUbm Zibbm UbX ghid]X UbX ]adcjYf]g\YX \UhYZi` XYYXg( EbY dYfgcb \ibhg k]`X Ub]x aU`g UbX VYWcaYg Ub Ub]aU` \]agY`Z5 Ubch\Yf ZYYXg Xcbx _Ymg UbX \cfgYg hc WUffm `cUXg& UbX XYgd]gYg dYcd`Y k\c X]Y cZ \ib[Yf( Eh\Yf dYcd`Y gdYbX U [fYUh XYU` cZ acbYm hc WfYUhY \i[Y \cigYg UbX Xc bch\]b[ hc \Y`d h\Y \caYx `Ygg( IcaY dYcd`Y gYY_ cb`m dfcZ]hg& ch\Yfg gdYbX cb`m Zcf X]gg]dUh]cb& UbX ch\Yfg ghYU`( ?b U`` cZ h\YgY YlWYggYg& U`` cZ h\]g Wf]a]bU` VY\Uj]cf& kY gYY dYcd`Y k\c cb`m kUbh hc hU_Y WUfY cZ h\YagY`jYg& k]h\cih U h\ci[\h UVcih k\Uh ]g acgh bYWYggUfm ]b h\]g kcf`X( vI7?DJ @E>D 9>HOIEIJEC

?h XYZ]Yg h\Y `Ukg cZ bUhifY Zcf U W\]`X hc fi`Y Ub UXi`h& cf U Zcc` hc [i]XY U k]gY aUb( B]_Yk]gY& ]h ]g U[U]bgh h\Y `Uk cZ bUhifY h\Uh U gaU`` [fcid cZ dYcd`Y g\ci`X VY cjYf]bXi`[YX k\Yb U \i[Y& \ib[fm WfckXrg acgh VUg]W bYYXg UfYbrh aYh( ?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH WKLQJ LQ WKLV ZRUOG ZKLFK LV ZRUWK GHGLFDWc LQJ DOO \RXU OLIH& ?KLV LV FUHDWLQJ PRUH ORYH DPRQJSHRSOH DQG GHVWUR\LQJ KDUULHUV ZKLFK H[LVW EHWZHHQ WKHP&

BVPJ ÁÀ J\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ ]b h\Y gci` k\]W\ WUbbch X]Y& k\]W\ WUbbch VY UZZYWhYX Vm XYUh\( >Y k\c XYZYUhg ch\Yfg ]g ghfcb[5 \Y k\c XYZYUhg \]agY`Z ]g dckYfZi`& UbX \Y k\c _bckg k\Yb \Y X]Yg h\Uh \Y k]`` bch VY XYghfcmYX ]g YhYfbU`( ÅH KĂOSP

FYcd`Y UfY Vcfb UbX `]jY cb`m Ug aUb]ZYghUh]cbg& cf d]YWYg cZ =cX5 h\YfYZcfY h\Ym WUbbch VY Wcad`YhY`m XYghfcmYX( J\Ym WUb X]gUddYUf Zfca VYZcfY cif YmYg& Vih h\Ym WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX( EbY dYfgcb kUg k]h\]b am g][\h Zcf U `cb[ h]aY5 Ubch\Yf kYbh cih cZ am g][\h jYfm ei]W_`m5 Vih ?

WUbbch gUm h\Uh h\Y Z]fgh dYfgcb Yl]ghYX acfY UbX h\Y gYWx cbX `Ygg( ?h XcYgbrh aUhhYf k\Yh\Yf U aUb dUggYg'Vm am k]bXck ei]W_`m cf g`ck`m( ? _bck XYZ]b]hY`m h\Uh h\]g aUb Yl]ghYX ]b h\Y h]aY VYZcfY ? gUk \]a UbX h\Uh \Y k]`` Yl]gh ]b h\Y h]aY UZhYf \Y \Ug X]gUddYUfYX Zfca am g][\h( >Y k\c _bckg h\Uh h\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ h\]g `]ZY ]g gd]f]h ]g cih cZ XUb[Yf( M\Yb \Y W`cgYg h\Y [UhYg cZ \]g gYbgYg Uh h\Y YbX cZ \]g `]ZY& \Y \Ug bc hfciV`Yg( v7ZhYf B7E'JPK

=HDO OLIH H[LVWV RXWVLGH WLPH DQG VSDFH+ WKHUHIRUH$ GHDWK FDQ FKDQJH WKH PDQLIHVWDWLRQ RI OLIH LQ WKLV ZRUOG$ KXW LW FDQQRW GHVWUR\ OLIH LWVHOI Jfm hc `]jY k]h\ h\Y dUfh cZ mcif gci` k\]W\ ibXYfghUbXg YhYfb]hm& k\]W\ ]g bch UZfU]X cZ XYUh\( 7bX h\Uh dUfh cZ mcif gci` ]g `cjY(

4MIC "" 7`` aUhYf]U` W\Ub[Yg ]b cif YjYfmXUm `]ZY UfY gaU`` ]b Wcax dUf]gcb k]h\ h\cgY ]b cif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY( J\YfY Wci`X VY U W\Ub[Y ]b ZYY`]b[g UbX UWh]cbg& h\YfY Wci`X VY U W\Ub[Y ]b h\ci[\hg UbX ]XYUg( ?b cfXYf hc W\Ub[Y mcif h\ci[\hg UbX ]XYUg& mci g\ci`X WcbWYbhfUhY mcif WcbgW]cig a]bX cb mcif gd]f]hiU` fYei]fYaYbhg( ;jYfm h\ci[\h U dYfgcb XkY``g idcb& k\Yh\Yf \Y YldfYggYg ]h cf bch& Y]h\Yf XUaU[Yg cf ]adfcjYg \]g `]ZY( vBK9O C7BEHO

?R YDQTXLVK VLQ& \RX PXVW DFFHSW WKDW WKH URRW RI HDFK VLQ LV LQ D EDG WKRXJKW& BH DUH DOO RQO\ WKH FRQVHTXHQFHV RI ZKDW ZH WKLQN& v8K::>7

MY fY[fYh `cg]b[ U difgY Zi`` cZ acbYm& Vih U [ccX h\ci[\h k\]W\ \Ug WcaY hc ig& k\]W\ kYrjY \YUfX cf fYUX& U h\ci[\h k\]W\ kY g\ci`X \UjY fYaYaVYfYX UbX Udd`]YX hc cif `]ZY& k\]W\ Wci`X \UjY ]adfcjYX h\Y kcf`XvkY `cgY h\]g h\ci[\h UbX dfcadh`m Zcf[Yh UVcih ]h& UbX kY Xc bch fY[fYh ]h& h\ci[\ ]h ]g acfY dfYW]cig h\Ub a]``]cbg(

BVPJ ÁÂ >XIIHULQJ LV WKH QHFHVVDU\ FRQGLWLRQ IRU VSLULWXDO DQG SK\VLFDO JURZWK& HYU``m& fYU``m ? hY`` mci& mci k]`` Wfm& UbX mci k]`` ZU``& UbX h\Y kcf`X k]`` \Y [`cf]Z]YX( Oci k]`` VY gUX& UbX mcif gUXx bYgg k]`` VYWcaY ^cm( 7 kcaUb ]g ]b dU]b k\Yb g\Y []jYg V]fh\ hc U W\]`X& UbX UZhYf h\Y V]fh\ g\Y XcYgbrh fYaYaVYf& UbX g\Y ]g ^cmZi`( v@E>D +04,*',+

LYfm cZhYb kY gUm h\Uh kY Xcbrh `]_Y giZZYf]b[& h\Uh kY \UjY hcc aiW\ giZZYf]b[& Vih giZZYf]b[g& U`` _]bXg cZ giZZYfx ]b[g& UfY U`kUmg [ccX Zcf ig( IcaYh]aYg& kY YjYb gYY h\Uh ]h ]g igYZi` hc giZZYf4 W\]`XfYb giZZYf k\Yb h\Ym [fck& cf k\Yb ]h ]g bYWYggUfm h\Uh h\Ym W`YUb Ub ]b^ifm Z]``YX k]h\ Z]`h\( MY WUbbch gYY h\Y igYZi`bYgg cZ acfU` giZZYf]b[g& Vih h\cgY giZZYf]b[g& hcc& aU_Y ig VYhhYf UbX W`cgYf hc =cX( MY [fck h\ig4 MY WcaY W`cgYf hc =cX UbX =cX WcaYg W`cgYf hc ig Ug cif k]`` VYWcaYg ib]hYX k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

Oci g\ci`X `cc_ ]b giZZYf]b[ Zcf h\Y gYYXg cZ mcif ZihifY gd]f]hiU` [fckh\& cf h\Y V]hhYfbYgg cZ giZZYf]b[ k]`` VY gYjYfY(

BVPJ ÁÃ ?bhY``YWh ]g h\Y eiU`]hm h\Uh aU_Yg ig X]ZZYfYbh Zfca Ub]aU`g( 8iXX\U gU]X4 s?b aYX]hUh]cb& ]b gdYYW\& ]b `]ZY& ]b ghiX]Yg& ? bYjYf Zcf[Yh UVcih h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[4 h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ h\Y ]bhY``YWh(t J\Y acfU` UbX h\Y ]bhY``YWhiU` UfY U`kUmg ]b \Ufacbm( ?Z U gY`Z'WcbZ]XYbh aUb hU`_g hc U k]gY aUb& \Y k]`` bch ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfih\& ^igh Ug U gdccb k]`` bch ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfih\ k\Yb ]h [Yhg ]bhc h\Y acih\( v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

5 FDQQRW FDXVH DQ\ LPSURYHPHQW LQ DQ\RQH H[FHSW ZLWK WKH KHOS RI WKH JRRGQHVV DQG NLQGQHVV ZKLFK DOUHDG\ LV LQKHUHQW LQ WKLV SHUVRQ& v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

FYcd`Y gdc]` h\Y]f `]ZY k\c bY[`YWh h\Y]f ]bhY``YWh UbX gUm h\Uh ]h WUbbch [i]XY h\Ya( ?bhY``YWh ]g h\Y gUaY ]b U`` dYcd`Y& UbX Wcaaib]WUh]cb ]g VUgYX cb ]bhY``YWh5 h\YfYZcfY YjYfm aUb aigh WcffYgdcbX hc ]hg fYei]fYaYbhg(

BVPJ ÁÄ M\Yb mci aU_Y Ub YZZcfh bch hc V`UaY ch\Yf dYcd`Y& jcif `]ZY VYWcaYg aiW\ YUg]Yf& Vih jYfm ZYk dYcd`Y aU_Y h\]g gaU`` YZZcfh( ?b h\Y `]jYg cZ h\Y gU]bhg& h\YfY ]g h\Y ghcfm cZ h\Y \Yfa]h k\c gUk ]b \]g XfYUa U acb_ k\c \UX X]YX `cb[ U[c& UbX k\c \UX VYYb fUh\Yf kYU_ ]b \]g `]ZY( J\Y acb_ kUg ]b Ub YgdYW]U``m `cjY`m UbX \cbcfYX dUfh cZ dUfUX]gY( J\Y \Yfa]h Ug_YX& >ck kYfY mci [fUbhYX h\]g d`UWY& k]h\ U`` mcif kYU_bYggYg6t UbX h\Y acb_ UbgkYfYX h\Uh ]h kUg VYWUigY \Y \UX bYjYf V`UaYX& bch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb ]b \]g `]ZY( J\YfYZcfY h\ci Ufh ]bYlWigUV`Y& E aUb& k\cgcYjYf h\ci Ufh h\Uh ^iX[Ygh4 Zcf k\YfY]b h\ci ^iX[Ygh Ubch\Yf& h\ci WcbXYabYgh h\mgY`Z5 Zcf h\ci h\Uh ^iX[Ygh XcYgh h\Y gUaY h\]b[g( vHEC7DI ,4+

?KH PRUH VWULFWO\ DQG PHUFLOHVVO\ \RX MXGJH \RXUVHOI$ WKH PRUH MXVW DQG NLQG \RX ZLOO KH LQ WKH MXGJPHQW RI RWKHUV& v9ED<K9?KI

:c bch [`cf]Zm ]b V`Ua]b[ UbX XYgd]g]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 7 _]bX dYfgcb g\ci`X \]XY h\Y g\UaY cZ ch\Yfg& YjYb h\cgY k\c \UjY \UfaYX \]a( :c bch fYaYaVYf cbY k\c fYdYbhg \]g ZcfaYf g]bg( vJ\Y J7BCK:

Kb`Ygg mci mcifgY`Z UfY g]b`Ygg& Xc bch gUm U g]b[`Y kcfX UVcih h\Y g]bg cZ ch\Yfg& Vih VY ei]Yh( ?Z mci aU_Y ]h U \UV]h bch hc V`UaY ch\Yfg& mci k]`` ZYY` h\Y [fckh\ cZ h\Y UV]`]hm hc `cjY ]b mcif gci`& UbX mci k]`` gYY h\Y [fckh\ cZ [ccXbYgg ]b mcif `]ZY(

BVPJ ÁĀ Jc `cjY =cX aYUbg hc `cjY h\Y \][\Ygh dcgg]V`Y [ccX k\]W\ kY WUb ]aU[]bY ]b U`` h\]b[g( FYcd`Y cZhYb gUm& s? Xc bch ibXYfghUbX `cjY cZ =cX5 k\Uh ]g `cjY cZ =cX6t ?h kci`X VY acfY YlUWh hc gUm& sWUbbch ibXYfghUbX `cjY ]b h\]g kcf`X k]h\cih `cjY cZ =cX(t HYU` `cjY cZ =cX ]g U acfU` ZYY`]b[ VUgYX cb U W`YUf ibXYfx ghUbX]b[ cZ >]g \][\& gidYf]cf VY]b[5 `cjY cZ =cX Wcx ]bW]XYg k]h\ `cjY cZ j]fhiY& hfih\& UbX _]bXbYgg( v"M?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

7 dYfgcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\Y `Uk Vih k\c ]g ZUf Zfca h\Y `cjY cZ =cX ]g `]_Y U VUb_ cZZ]W]U` k\c \Ug _Ymg Zcf h\Y ]bg]XY cZ \]g Vi]`X]b[ Vih bch h\Y _Ym Zcf h\Y Zfcbh Xccf( vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\Y WcaaUbXaYbhg cZ =cX g\ci`X VY Zc``ckYX VYWUigY cZ `cjY cZ =cX& bch VYWUigY cZ ZYUf cZ =cX( vJ\Y J7BCK:

5I \RX ORYH D SHUVRQ ZLWKRXW ORYLQJ 3RG$ ZKLFK LV WKH JRRGc QHVV LQVLGH RI KLP$ WKHQ \RX SODQW WKH VHHGV IRU IXWXUH GLVDSc SRLQWPHQWV DQG VXIIHULQJV ZLWK WKLV ORYH& J\cgY k\c gUm h\Uh h\Ym `cjY =cX Vih X]g`]_Y h\Y]f bY][\x Vcfg UfY `m]b[ hc dYcd`Y5 h\cgY k\c `cjY h\Y]f bY][\Vcfg Vih Xcbrh `cjY =cX UfY `m]b[ hc h\YagY`jYg( Eb`m dYfZYWh]cb ]g kcfh\ Wcad`YhY `cjY( ?b cfXYf hc ZYY` Wcad`YhY `cjY& kY WUb Y]h\Yf XY`iXY cifgY`jYg h\Uh gcaY ]adYfZYWh cV^YWh cZ cif `cjY ]g sdYfZYWh]cbt cf kY WUb `cjY dYfZYWh]cb& k\]W\ ]g =cX(

BA CD J\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ gcW]Yhm WUb VY UW\]YjYX cb`m Vm h\Y acfU` ]adfcjYaYbh cZ ]bX]j]XiU`g( MY `]jY ]b Ub YdcW\ cZ X]gW]d`]bY& Wi`hifY& UbX W]j]`]nUh]cb& Vih bch ]b Ub YdcW\ cZ acfU`]hm( ?b h\Y dfYgYbh ghUhY& kY WUb gUm h\Uh h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZ h\Y dYcd`Y [fckg& UbX mYh h\Y ib\Udd]bYgg cZ h\Y dYcd`Y ]bWfYUgYg Ug kY``( >ck WUb kY aU_Y dYcd`Y \Uddm k\Yb h\Ym UfY bch YXiWUhYX hc \UjY \][\ acfU`g6 J\Ym Xc bch VYWcaY k]gY( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?KHUH FDQ EH RQO\ RQH ZD\ WR ILJKW WKH JHQHUDO HYLO RI OLIH* LW LV LQ WKH PRUDO$ UHOLJLRXV$ DQG VSLULWXDO SHUIHFWLRQ RI \RXU RZQ OLIH&

BVPJ ÁÅ J\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ kUf UbX dfYdUfUh]cbg Zcf kUf VYUf `]hx h`Y fY`Uh]cb hc h\Y fYUgcbg []jYb hc Yld`U]b kUf4 h\Y fYU` fYUgcbg UfY igiU``m gc ]bg][b]Z]WUbh h\Uh h\Ym UfY bch YjYb kcfh\ X]gWigg]cb& UbX h\Ym UfY Wcad`YhY`m ib_bckb hc h\cgY k\c X]Y( J\Y aUXbYgg cZ WcbhYadcfUfm kUf ]g ^igh]Z]YX Vm XmbUgh]W ]bhYfYgh& Wcaacb bUh]cbU`]ga& ;ifcdYUb Yei]`]Vf]ia& cf UaV]h]cbg( ?Z h\YfY UfY UaV]h]cbg ]b dYcd`Y& h\]g ]g U jYfm ghfUb[Y kUm hc gighU]b ]h& k]h\ U`` h\Y Wf]aYg k\]W\ \UddYb hc dYcd`Y Xif]b[ kUf4 XYghfiWh]cb cZ \caYg& d`ibXYf& UbX aUgg aifXYf( v7D7JEB; <H7D9;

Oci Ug_ aY& ]g ]h bYWYggUfm Zcf W]j]`]nYX dYcd`Y hc aU_Y kUf6 7bX ? hY`` mci bch cb`m ]g ]h sU`fYUXmt ibbYWYggUfm& Vih ]h kUg bYjYf bYWYggUfm& UbX bch gcaYh]aYg Vih U`kUmg ]h XYghfcmg h\Y bcfaU` XYjY`cdaYbh cZ \iaUb]hm& XYghfcmg ^igh]WY& UbX ghcdg dfc[fYgg( v=7BIJED CE>A

;QO\ GXULQJ D SHULRG RI ZDU GRHV LW EHFRPH REYLRXV KRZ PLOOLRQV RI SHRSOH FDQ EH PDQLSXODWHG& <HRSOH$ PLOOLRQV RI SHRSOH$ DUH ILOOHG ZLWK SULGH ZKLOH GRLQJ WKLQJV ZKLFK WKRVH VDPH SHRSOH DFWXDOO\ FRQVLGHU VWXSLG$ HYLO$ GDQJHURXV$ SDLQIXO$ DQG FULPLQDO$ DQG WKH\ VWURQJO\ FULWLFL]H WKHVH WKLQJVbEXW FRQWLQXH GRLQJ WKHP& J\Y fYUgcbg k\]W\ [cjYfbaYbhg []jY Zcf kUfg UfY U`kUmg gWfYYbg& VY\]bX k\]W\ `]Y Wcad`YhY`m X]ZZYfYbh fYUgcbg UbX ach]jYg(

BVPJ ÁǺ KbXYfghUbX]b[ cif Xihm dfcj]XYg ig k]h\ h\Y ibXYfx ghUbX]b[ cZ cif X]j]bY gci`( 7bX& hcc& h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ cif X]j]bY gci` []jYg ig h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ Xihm( ?KHUH LV LQ RXU VRXO VRPHWKLQJ WKDW& LI ZH VHH LW DV LW LV DQG JLYH LW WKH SURSHU DWWHQWLRQ$ ZLOO DOZD\V JLYH XV JUHDW SOHDc VXUH+ WKLV VRPHWKLQJ LV WKH PRUDO GLVSRVLWLRQ RU TXDOLW\ ZKLFK ZDV JLYHQ WR XV DW RXU FUHDWLRQ& v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

FYcd`Y WUb fYUW\ \YUjYb`m ^cm4 h\cgY difY cbYg k\c UfY Z]``YX k]h\ h\Y XYg]fY Zcf U [ccX `]ZY fYWY]jY d`YUgifYg ]b h\Y]f VcXm& ]b h\Y]f aUhYf]U` `]ZY( M\Yb mcif a]bX UbX mcif \YUfh UfY difY& h\Yb h\Y X]j]bY k]`` VY cdYbYX Zcf mci( v8H7>C?D ?D:?7D M?I:EC

?Z mcif \YUfh ]g Z]``YX k]h\ j]fhiY& h\Yb mci k]`` Z]bX \Udd]x bYgg UbX VYUihm( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

J\Y jc]WY cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY ]g h\Y jc]WY cZ =cX(

BVPJ ÁĄ Ocif WcbgW]YbWY ]g mcif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcif gd]f]hiU` cf][]bg5 cb`m k\Yb mci dcggYgg giW\ UkUfYbYgg k]`` ]h VY U fYU` [i]XY ]b mcif `]ZY( J\YfY UfY hkc X]ZZYfYbh VY]b[g k]h\]b mci& cbY k\]W\ ]g V`]bX UbX gYbgiU`& UbX Ubch\Yf k\]W\ WUb gYY UbX ]g gd]f]x hiU`( J\]g gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ ]g WU``YX WcbgW]YbWY UbX WUb VY WcadUfYX k]h\ h\Y bYYX`Y cZ U WcadUgg k\]W\ dc]bhg Uh [ccXbYgg Uh cbY YbX& UbX Uh h\Y ch\Yf& Yj]`( MY WUbbch dYfx WY]jY h\]g WcadUgg ibh]` kY ghfUm Zfca [ccXbYgg& Vih Ug gccb Ug kY Xc gcaYh\]b[ VUX& h\Yb kY ZYY` h\]g di`` UkUm Zfca h\Y X]fYWh]cb cZ [ccXbYgg ]b `]ZY( =cX [UjY ig h\Y WcbgW]cigbYgg cZ aUb_]bX Ug U k\c`Y& Ug kY`` Ug cif ckb WcbgW]cigbYgg Ug ]bX]j]XiU`g5 k]h\ h\Y \Y`d cZ h\YgY hkc h\]b[g& Ug k]h\ hkc k]b[g kY WUb Z`m \][\Yf UbX WcaY W`cgYf hc =cX UbX hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfih\( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

E\& WcbgW]YbWY4 mci UfY h\Y XYUh\`Ygg jc]WY cZ \YUjYb& UbX U hfiY [i]XY UbX ^iX[Y cZ [ccXbYgg( Oci aU_Y U dYfx gcb fYgYaV`Y =cX( v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

Ocih\ ]g h\Y h]aY cZ dUgg]cbg UbX ]bZUhiUh]cbg& UbX mYh `]gx hYb bck hc h\Y jc]WY cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY UbX UWWYdh ]h Ug h\Y [fYUhYgh Uih\cf]hm( 7`kUmg Ug_ mcifgY`Z& Xc am UWh]cbg Wc]bW]XY k]h\ am WcbgW]YbWY6 7bX Xc bch VY UZfU]X hc Uff]jY Uh aYUb]b[g X]ZZYfYbh Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Yrg( vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

<YUf U`` h\Uh ]g bch UWWYdhYX Vm mcif WcbgW]YbWY(

BVPJ ÂÀ J\YfY kUg U h]aY k\Yb dYcd`Y UhY \iaUb Z`Yg\ UbX ZcibX bch\]b[ kfcb[ ]b ]h5 YjYb bck h\YfY UfY giW\ k]`X dYcd`Y( FYcd`Y ghcddYX YUh]b[ \iaUb aYUh& `]hh`Y Vm `]hh`Y5 bck h\Ym WYUgY hc YUh h\Y aYUh cZ Ub]aU`g `]hh`Y Vm `]hh`Y& h\ci[\ ]h \Ug hU_Yb h]aY( .XW WKH WLPH ZLOO FRPH ZKHQ SHRc SOH ZLOO KDYH WKH VDPH GLVJXVW IRU WKH PHDW RI DQLPDOV DV WKH\ QRZ KDYH IRU KXPDQ IOHVK& v7ZhYf 7BF>EDI; B7C7HJ?D;

?h ]g hYff]V`Y hc h\fck `]hh`Y W\]`XfYb hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y Ug ZcibX`]b[g& hc cf[Ub]nY [`UX]Uhcfgr Z][\hg& hc hcfhifY df]gx cbYfg& UbX hc Xc ch\Yf giW\ ibW]j]`]nYX XYYXg( ?b h\Y ZihifY& h\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb ]h k]`` VY ibUWWYdhUV`Y hc _]`` Ub]aU`g UbX hU_Y h\Y]f XYUX VcX]Yg Ug mcif ZccX( v:H( @E>7DD =;EH= LED P?CC;HC7DD

:c bch fU]gY mcif \UbX U[U]bgh mcif Vfch\Yf& UbX Xc bch gd]`` h\Y V`ccX cZ Ubm `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg k\c `]jY cb h\]g YUfh\& bY]h\Yf \iaUb VY]b[g bcf dYhg bcf k]`X Ub]aU`g bcf V]fXg( ?b h\Y XYdh\ cZ mcif gci` gcaY X]j]bY jc]WY ghcdg mci Zfca gd]``]b[ h\]g V`ccX( J\YfY ]g `]ZY ]b ]h( Oci WUbbch fYhifb h\]g `]ZY( v7BF>EDI; B7C7HJ?D;

?b cif h]aY& h\Y _]``]b[ cZ Ub]aU`g Zcf d`YUgifY cf ZccX ]g U`acgh U Wf]aY& UbX \ibh]b[ UbX YUh]b[ aYUh UfY bch ^igh hf]j]U` h\]b[g& Vih VUX UWh]cbg& k\]W\ `]_Y Ubm ch\Yf VUX UWh]cbg `YUX hc aUbm ch\Yf UWh]cbg k\]W\ UfY kcfgY(

BVPJ ÂÁ ?KH PLVHU\ RI WKH XQLQWHOOHFWXDO OLIH EULQJV XV WR WKH QHHG IRU DQ LQWHOOHFWXDO OLIH& 8YZcfY& ? `]jYX ]b g]b& UbX ? gUk h\Uh h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y UfcibX aY `]jYX ]b h\Y gUaY kUm( B]_Y U fcVVYf& ? _bYk ? kUg ib\Uddm UbX ? giZZYfYX& UbX h\Uh dYcd`Y UfcibX aY kYfY ib\Uddm UbX h\Ym giZZYfYX5 UbX ? X]Xbrh gYY Ubm kUm cih cZ h\]g g]hiUh]cb YlWYdh Zcf gi]W]XY cf XYUh\( B]ZY gYYaYX hYff]V`Y hc aY( 7bX h\Yb ? \YUfX h\Y kcfXg cZ 9\f]gh UbX + ibXYfghccX h\Ya( 7bX `]ZY WYUgYX hc gYYa Ub Yj]`& UbX ]bghYUX cZ XYgdYfUh]cb ? ZY`h U \Udd]bYgg Zcf `]ZY k\]W\ gifdUggYg YjYb XYUh\( MY WUb ibXYfghUbX k]gXca ]b h\fYY kUmg4 Z]fgh& Vm aYX]x hUh]cb5 h\]g ]g h\Y acgh bcV`Y kUm( IYWcbX`m& Vm VY]b[ ]bZ`iYbWYX Vm gcaYcbY cf Zc``ck]b[ gcaYcbY5 h\]g ]g h\Y YUg]Ygh kUm( J\]fX ]g h\Y kUm cZ YldYf]YbWY5 h\]g ]g h\Y acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h kUm( v9ED<K9?KI

M\Yb mci giZZYf& h\]b_ bch cb \ck mci WUb YgWUdY giZZYfx ]b[& Vih WcbWYbhfUhY mcif YZZcfhg cb k\Uh _]bX cZ ]bbYf acfU` UbX gd]f]hiU` dYfZYWh]cb h\]g giZZYf]b[ fYei]fYg( 7`` h\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ aUb_]bX Wc``YWh]jY`m UbX ]bX]j]Xix U``m UfY bch igY`Ygg5 h\Ym Vf]b[ dYcd`Y UbX ]bX]j]XiU`g UbX bUh]cbg ]b X]ZZYfYbh kUmg W`cgYf hc h\Y difdcgY k\]W\ ]g gYh VYZcfY h\Ya4 h\Y UddYUfUbWY cZ =cX& Zcf YjYfm dYfgcb ]b \]agY`Z& UbX ]b U`` aUb_]bX(

BVPJ ÂÂ J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY hfiY fY`][]cb Zcf U`` cZ aUb_]bX( J\Y X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb fY`][]cbgvk\Uh U ghfUb[Y YldfYgx g]cb( 9YfhU]b`m h\YfY WUb VY X]ZZYfYbh ZU]h\g& UbX VY`]YZg ]b \]ghcf]WU` YjYbhg k\]W\ UfY dUggYX Zfca cbY [YbYfUh]cb hc Ubch\Yf hc ghfYb[h\Yb fY`][]cb5 ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\YfY WUb VY X]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cig Vcc_gvh\Y IihfUg& LYXUg& AcfUb& YhW( 8ih h\YfY WUb VY cb`m cbY fY`][]cb& UbX ]h ]g fYU` Zcf U`` h]aYg( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

BH FDQ EHOLHYH LQ D WKLQJ$ ZH FDQ NQRZ WKDW LW H[LVWV$ HYHQ LI ZH FDQQRW XQGHUVWDQG LW ZLWK RXU LQWHOOHFW$ RU H[SODLQ LW ZLWK ZRUGV& ?Z mci UfY U Cig`]a& [c UbX `]jY Ug U 9\f]gh]Ub5 ]Z mci UfY U 9\f]gh]Ub `]jY Ug U @Yk5 ]Z mci UfY 9Uh\c`]W& `]jY Ug Ub Efh\cXclvk\UhYjYf fY`][]cb mci \UjY& \c`X h\Y gUaY fYgdYWh Zcf dYcd`Y cZ X]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cbg( ?Z mcif gdYYW\ hc[Yh\Yf XcYg bch UfcigY cf YlW]hY mci hc ]bX][bUh]cb UbX ]Z mci WUb ZfYY`m Wcaaib]WUhY k]h\ h\Ya& mci \UjY UW\]YjYX dYUWY( ?h ]g gU]X h\Uh h\Y cV^YWh cZ YjYfm fY`][]cb ]g h\Y gUaY4 U`` dYcd`Y `cc_ Zcf `cjY& UbX U`` h\Y kcf`X ]g U d`UWY cZ `cjY( J\Yb k\m g\ci`X kY gdYU_ UVcih h\Y X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb h\Y Cig`]a W\ifW\ UbX h\Y 9\f]gh]Ub W\ifW\6 v?IB7C?9 M?I:EC

:c bch ZYUf \Yg]hUh]cbg Vih ghiXm h\Y X]ZZYfYbh ZU]h\g UbX fY`][]cbg ]bhY``YWhiU``m(

BVPJ ÂÃ Eb`m \Y k\c UWWYdhg h\Uh h\Y YggYbWY cf aYUb]b[ cZ \]g `]ZY ]g bch aUhYf]U` Vih gd]f]hiU` WUb VY ZfYY( 7 g`UjY k\c ]g \Uddm k]h\ \]g ghUhY ]g U g`UjY hk]WY cjYf& VYWUigY bch cb`m \]g VcXm Vih \]g gci` ]g Ybg`UjYX( * =cX& k\]`Y ? ghUm cb h\]g YUfh\ ? kUbh hc VY h\Uh k\]W\ ? Ua(

v;F?9J;JKI

FYUWY ]g U [fYUh V`Ygg]b[ ]Z ]h WUb VY fYUW\YX& Vih ]Z dYUWY ]g fYUW\YX Vm g`UjYfm& ]h VYWcaYg U a]gZcfhibY UbX bch U V`Ygg]b[( FYUWY ]g h\Y ZfYYXca k\]W\ ]g VUgYX cb h\Y UWWYdx hUbWY cZ YjYfm dYfgcbrg f][\hg& UbX g`UjYfm ]g h\Y bY[Uh]cb cZ f][\hg& UbX cZ \iaUb X][b]hm( J\YfYZcfY& kY g\ci`X gUWx f]Z]WY YjYfmh\]b[ hc UW\]YjY dYUWY& Vih YjYb acfY& hc [Yh f]X cZ g`UjYfm( v7ZhYf C7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

HYaYaVYf h\Uh mci UfY acfY ZfYY ]Z mci W\Ub[Y mcif cd]b]cb UbX Zc``ck h\cgY k\c \UjY WcffYWhYX mcif a]gx hU_Yg& h\Ub ]Z mci UfY ghiVVcfb UVcih mcif a]ghU_Yg( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY fYU` _bck`YX[Y4 h\Uh k\]W\ \Y`dg ig hc VY ZfYY( ;jYfm ch\Yf hmdY cZ _bck`YX[Y ]g aYfY UaigYaYbh( vL?I>DK FKH7D7& ?D:?7D M?I:EC

?KHUH LV QR PLGGOH ZD\* HLWKHU KH D VODYH RI SHRSOH RU RI 3RG&

BVPJ ÂÄ KbXYfghUbX]b[ cf a]bXZi`bYgg cZ XYUh\ hYUW\Yg cbY hc W\ccgY h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY Wcad`YhY cf Wci`X VY Wcax d`YhYX5 UbX h\cgY h\]b[g UfY h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh( Oci Wci`X X]Y jYfm ei]W_`m5 Vih mYh mci \UjY h]aY hc f]X mcifgY`Z cZ mcif dUgg]cbg( 8Y \iaV`Y hc YjYfmcbY( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

- ZLVH SHUVRQ WKLQNV PRUH DERXW OLIH WKDQ DERXW GHDWK&

v8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

J\YfY ]g bc XYUh\ Zcf h\Y gd]f]h5 h\YfYZcfY& U dYfgcb k\c `]jYg U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY ]g ZfYYX Zfca XYUh\( :c mci kcffm UVcih h\Y acaYbh k\Yb mci X]Y6 Eif `]ZY ]g cb`m U acaYbh ]b YhYfb]hm( J\]b_ UbX mci k]`` gYY h\Uh mci \UjY YhYfb]hm VY\]bX mci UbX VYZcfY mci& UbX VYhkYYb h\YgY hkc \i[Y UVmggYg& k\Uh X]ZZYfYbWY XcYg ]h aU_Y k\Yh\Yf mci `]jY h\fYY XUmg cf h\fYY WYbhif]Yg6 vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

M\YbYjYf mci Ug_ k\Yh\Yf mci g\ci`X VY\UjY ]b h\]g kUm cf h\Y ch\Yf& Ug_ mcifgY`Z& k\Uh kci`X mci Xc ]Z mci _bYk h\Uh mci Wci`X X]Y h\]g YjYb]b[& UbX bcVcXm kci`X Z]bX cih UVcih mcif UWh]cb6 :YUh\ gdifg dYcd`Y hc Z]b]g\ h\Y]f UZZU]fg5 Uacb[ U`` UWh]cbg& h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY hmdY k\]W\ ]g Wcad`YhY& UbX h\Uh ]g `cjY k\]W\ gYY_g bc fYkUfX(

BVPJ ÂĀ ?h ]g jYfm igYZi` hc bch]WY h\Y ]adfYgg]cb k\]W\ cif `]ZY UbX XYYXg aU_Y idcb ch\Yf dYcd`Y( Oci g\ci`X `]jY gc h\Uh ch\Yf dYcd`Y h\]b_ kY`` cZ mci UbX mci h\]b_ kY`` cZ mcifgY`Z( vBK9O C7BEHO

J\Y jYfm g\cfhWca]b[g k\]W\ aU_Y ch\Yfg X]ZZ]Wi`h UbX ibVYUfUV`Y aYUb `Ygg ]b mcifgY`Z( Oci Xc bch gYY h\Ya& UbX k\Yb mci gdYU_ cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y \Uj]b[ h\YgY XfUkx VUW_g& mci Xc bch bch]WY h\Uh mci UfY XYgWf]V]b[ mcifgY`Z( v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

J\Y g]ad`Ygh& ei]W_Ygh& UbX gifYgh aYUbg hc VYWca]b[ _bckb Ug U j]fhicig dYfgcb ]g hc kcf_ cb mcifgY`Z& hc UWhiU``m VY j]fhicig( ;lUa]bY YUW\ j]fhiY& UbX mci k]`` gYY h\Uh h\Ym U`` kYfY UW\]YjYX k]h\ kcf_ UbX YlYfW]gY( vIE9H7J;I

EbY aUb _YYdg g]`YbWY& UbX dYcd`Y X]gWigg \]a( 7bch\Yf gdYU_g U `ch& UbX dYcd`Y X]gWigg \]a( 7 h\]fX gdYU_g U `]hx h`Y& UbX dYcd`Y X]gWigg \]a( J\YfY ]g bc giW\ h\]b[ Ug U dYfgcb k\c ]g bch VY]b[ X]gWiggYX cf gWc`XYX( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

:c mci WU`` U dYfgcb \Uddm ]Z \Y Z]bXg \]g ghfYb[h\ ]b \]g W\]`XfYb cf ]b \]g Zf]YbXg& cf ]b ch\Yf h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY ]adYfaUbYbh6 ?b cbY gYWcbX& \]g dfcgdYf]hm WUb VY fi]bYX( IYY_ bc ch\Yf giddcfh h\Ub mcif ]bbYf gY`Z UbX =cX( v:;CEIJ>;D;I

:HYHU WU\ WR MXVWLI\ \RXU GHHGV&

BVPJ ÂĂ BcjY dfcj]XYg U dYfgcb k]h\ h\Y difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY( ?bhY`x `YWh g\ckg \]a h\Y aYUbg hc UW\]YjY h\Uh difdcgY( ?b h\Y gW\YaY cZ h\Y kcf`X& U dYfgcb ]g bc acfY h\Ub U d]bY WcbY& cf U kYU_ \YfV& cf U V]h cZ gkUad [fUgg& Vih \Y ]g U [fUgg k\]W\ dcggYggYg gcaY ]bhY``YWh( v8B7?I; F7I97B

9DQ GLIIHUV IURP RWKHU DQLPDOV RQO\ LQ KLV LQWHOOHFW+ VRPH SHRSOH WU\ WR GHYHORS LW DQG RWKHUV QHJOHFW LW$ MXVW DV WKH\ WU\ WR UHMHFW WKRVH RWKHU TXDOLWLHV ZKLFK GLIIHUHQWLDWH WKHP IURP WKH DQLPDOV& v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

? dfU]gY 9\f]gh]Ub]hm VYWUigY ]h XYjY`cdg& ghfYb[h\Ybg& UbX Y`YjUhYg am ]bhY``YWhiU` bUhifY( vM?BB?7C ;BBB;HO 9>7DD?D=

?Z U dYfgcb `UW_g ]bhY``YWh& \Y WUb bch X]gh]b[i]g\ VUX Zfca [ccX& UbX gc \Y WUb bY]h\Yf hfi`m gYY_ bcf hfi`m \UjY fYU` [ccXbYgg(

BVPJ ÆĈ 7 [ccX `]ZY ]g []jYb cb`m hc h\cgY k\c aU_Y YZZcfhg hc UW\]YjY ]h( ?b cfXYf hc \UjY U [ccX `]ZY& mci g\ci`X bch VY UZfU]X cZ Ubm [ccX XYYXg( Oci g\ci`X \UjY bc `Ygg dckYf cf ghfYb[h\ Zcf gaU`` UWhg h\Ub Zcf h\Y V][[Ygh UbX [fYUhYgh [ccX XYYX( 5Q RUGHU QRW WR SRXU RXW D YHVVHO IXOO RI ZDWHU$ \RX VKRXOG KROG LW HYHQO\& 5QRUGHU WR KDYH D UD]RU VKDUS$ \RX VKRXOG VKDUSHQ LW& ?KH VDPH VKRXOG KDSSHQ ZLWK \RXU VRXO LI \RX DUH ORRNLQJ IRU UHDO JRRGQHVV& vB7E'JPK

?Z h\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ [fYUh ]b mci& ]h k]`` bch UddYUf cb mcif Z]fgh WU``( ?h k]`` bch UddYUf UbX WcaY hc mci YUg]`m& k]h\cih Ubm kcf_ UbX YZZcfh( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

7g_& UbX ]h g\U`` VY []jYb mci5 gYY_& UbX mY g\U`` Z]bX5 _bcW_& UbX ]h g\U`` VY cdYbYX ibhc mci4 Zcf YjYfm cbY h\Uh Ug_Yh\ fYWY]jYh\5 UbX \Y h\Uh gYY_Yh\ Z]bXYh\5 UbX hc \]a h\Uh _bcW_Yh\ ]h g\U`` VY cdYbYX( vC7JJ>;M 141'2

Jfm hc `]jY U [ccX `]ZY ]b UWWcfX k]h\ h\Y j]fhiYg h\Uh UfY gYh VYZcfY mci( FYf\Udg h\]g ]g U X]ZZ]Wi`h h\]b[& Vih k]h\ h]aY ]h VYWcaYg acfY UbX acfY ^cmZi`( ?Z mci bYYX [ccXbYgg& Zc``ck =cXrg `Uk( 7bX hc Zc``ck h\Y `Uk cZ =cX ]g dcgg]V`Y cb`m Vm aU_]b[ Ub YZZcfh( Dch cb`m ]g h\]g YZZcfh fYkUfXYX k]h\ U \Uddm `]ZY& Vih YjYb h\Y YZZcfh ]hgY`Z []jYg h\Y V][[Ygh V`Ygg]b[ cZ `]ZY(

BVPJ ÂǺ J\Y ZUa]`m fY`Uh]cbg\]d ]g cb`m [ccX UbX Z]fa UbX []j]b[ cZ j]fhiY hc dYcd`Y k\Yb ]h [cYg VYmcbX ZUa]`m UbX ]g U`gc fY`][]cig& UbX U`` h\Y aYaVYfg cZ h\Y ZUa]`m VY`]YjY ]b cbY =cX UbX >]g `Uk( Eh\Yfk]gY& h\Y ZUa]`m ]g h\Y gcifWY bch cZ d`YUgifY Vih cZ giZZYf]b[( EbY cZ h\Y acgh Wcaacb Yld`UbUh]cbg Zcf VUX XYYXg ]g h\Y ZUa]`m bUaY( FYcd`Y ghYU`& aU_Y Vf]VYg& Xc aUbm ch\Yf bUghm h\]b[g ]b `]ZY& U`` cZ k\]W\ WUb VY Yld`U]bYX Vm h\Y]f `cjY Zcf h\Y]f ZUa]`m( 2DPLO\ ORYH LV D VHOILVK IHHOLQJ$ DQG WKHUHIRUH LW FDQ MXVWLI\ KDG$ XQZRUWK\ DFWLRQV& 7bX ]h kUg hc`X \]a Vm WYfhU]b& k\]W\ gU]X& J\m ach\Yf UbX h\m VfYh\fYb ghUbX k]h\cih& XYg]f]b[ hc gYY h\YY( 7bX \Y UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc h\Ya& Cm ach\Yf UbX am VfYh\fYb UfY h\YgY k\]W\ \YUf h\Y kcfX cZ =cX& UbX Xc ]h( O6=50 )+#! #"

>Y h\Uh `cjYh\ ZUh\Yf cf ach\Yf acfY h\Ub aY ]g bch kcfx h\m cZ aY4 UbX \Y h\Uh `cjYh\ gcb cf XUi[\hYf acfY h\Ub aY ]g bch kcfh\m cZ aY( O7,<<20? "!+$(

?b ZUa]`m `cjY& ]b h\Y acfU` \][\ aYUb]b[& h\YfY ]g bch\x ]b[ [ccX cf VUX& ^igh Ug ]b gY`Z'`cjY( 8ch\ UfY bUhifU`( BcjY cZ mcif ZUa]`m& Ug kY`` Ug cZ mcifgY`Z& k\Yb ]h gifdUggYg ]hg `]a]hg& WUb VY U j]WY& Vih ]h WUb bYjYf VY U j]fhiY& VYWUigY ]hrg U bUhifU` ZYY`]b[(

BVPJ ÂĄ :YdfYgg]cb ]g U ghUfY cZ h\Y gci` ]b k\]W\ mci WUb gYY bc gYbgY Y]h\Yf ]b mcif ckb `]ZY cf ]b h\Y `]ZY cZ h\Y kcf`X( J\]g ghUhY ]g bch cb`m dU]bZi` Zcf h\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX mci& Vih ]h WUb ]bZ`iYbWY h\Ya& UbX U hfi`m [ccX dYfgcb XYU`g k]h\ h\]g ibd`YUgUbhbYgg k\Yb \Y ]g U`cbY( M\Yb mci \UjY VUX gd]f]hg cf UfY ]b U `ck accX& cf mci UfY ]ff]hUhYX& mci g\ci`X VY gc ]b gc`]hiXY( M\Yb YjYfmh\]b[ mci gYY UddYUfg ]b XUf_& [`ccam g\UXYg& UbX gYYag VU`YZi`& UbX mci kUbh hc hY`` ch\Yfg cb`m VUX UbX ibd`YUgUbh h\]b[g& Xc bch hfigh mcif dYfWYdh]cbg( JfYUh mcifgY`Z Ug h\ci[\ mci kYfY Xfib_( JU_Y bc ghYdg UbX UWh]cbg ibh]` h \]g ghUhY \Ug X]gUddYUfYX( Oci g\ci`X bYjYf ZYY` XYdfYggYX( 7 aUb g\ci`X U`kUmg ZYY` \Uddm5 ]Z \Y ]g ib\Uddm& ]h aYUbg \Y ]g [i]`hm( E 8RUG$ KHOS PH WR KH DOZD\V KDSS\ DQG WR UHMRLFH IROORZLQJ DQG IXOILOOLQJ \RXU ZLOO& 8ch\ cif d\mg]WU` giZZYf]b[g UbX dYf]cXg cZ XYdfYgg]cb UfY dUfh cZ cif `]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X& UbX kY g\ci`X dUh]Ybh`m kU]h ibh]` h\Ym UfY cjYf& cf cif `]ZY ]g cjYf(

BVPJ ÃÀ 7g gccb Ug U dYfgcb Ug_g \]agY`Z h\Y eiYgh]cb& s>ck Xc ? `]jY am `]ZY ]b h\Y VYgh kUm6t h\Yb U`` ch\Yf eiYgh]cbg UfY UbgkYfYX( HYU` `]j]b[ hU_Yg d`UWY bch ]b h\Y XcaU]b cZ cihkUfX W\Ub[Y& Vih ]b h\Y ]bbYf XcaU]b k\YfY W\Ub[Yg WUb \UfX`m VY cVgYfjYX& ]b cif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY( 7bX @Ygig UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc \Yf& CUfh\U& CUfh\U& h\ci Ufh'WUfYZi` UbX hfciV`YX UVcih aUbm h\]b[g4 8ih cbY h\]b[ ]g bYYXZi`4 UbX CUfm \Uh\ W\cgYb h\Uh [ccX dUfh& k\]W\ g\U`` bch VY hU_Yb UkUm Zfca \Yf( vBKA; +*4.+'.,

5QVWHDG RI VDYLQJ KXPDQLW\& HYHU\ SHUVRQ VKRXOG VDYH KLP c VHOI v7B;N7D:;H >;HP;D

J\Y acfY dYcd`Y VY`]YjY h\Uh ch\Yfg WUb ]adfcjY h\Y]f `]jYg& h\Y g`ckYf Ubm ]adfcjYaYbh k]`` cWWif(

@i`m + J\Y \iaUb gci` ]g X]j]bY( 1YHU\ WUXWK KDV LWV RULJLQ LQ 3RG& BKHQ LW LV PDQLIHVWHG LQ D PDQ$ WKLV LV QRW EHFDXVH LW FRPHV IURP KLP$ EXW EHFDXVH KH KDV VXFK D TXDQWLW\ RI WUDQVSDUHQF\ WKDW KH FDQ UHYHDO LW& v8B7?I; F7I97B

M\Yb UZhYf h\Y fU]b& kUhYf Z`ckg Zfca h\Y fccZ h\fci[\ d]dYg& ]h gYYag hc ig h\Uh kUhYf Z`ckg cih cZ h\YgY d]dYg& Vih ]b fYU`]hm& ]h ZU``g Zfca h\Y g_m( J\Y gUaY d\YbcaYbcb WUb VY gYYb k]h\ h\Y fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[g hUi[\h hc ig Vm \c`m dYcd`Y( ?h gYYag hc ig h\Uh h\]g hYUW\]b[ WcaYg Zfca h\Ya& Vih ]b fYU`]hm& h\YgY hYUW\]b[g WcaY Zfca =cX( vJ>; =EIF;B E< IH? H7C7AH?I>D7

7 dYfgcbrg difdcgY cb h\]g YUfh\ ]g hc VY ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ YhYfb]hm( ?h ]g cb`m h\Yb h\Uh h\Y ib]jYfgU` Z`ck cZ `cjY UbX ]bhY``YWh WUb VY W\UbbY`YX h\fci[\ h\]g dYfgcb& Ug ]Z h\fci[\ U W`YUf dUh\kUm( vBK9O C7BEHO

B]ZY ]g []jYb hc ig ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug U W\]`X ]g []jYb hc U bUbbm& gc h\Uh ]h WUb VY fU]gYX hc aUhif]hm( AYYd mcifgY`Z ]b dif]hm& ZUf Zfca Yj]`& gc h\Uh X]j]bY dckYf aUm WcaY h\fci[\ mci( 7bX ]b h\]g Z`ck cZ X]j]bY dckYf h\fci[\ mci& h\YfY ]g [fYUh V`]gg(

BVNX Â J\YfY ]g bc ch\Yf XcaU]b k\YfY h\Y kcfXg cZ cif `Ubx [iU[Y UfY gc a]gigYX Ug ]b h\Y Wf]h]W]ga cZ Ufh& YgdYW]U``m cZ ZU`gY Ufh( 7 kcf_ cZ Ufh aU_Yg U [fYUh ]adfYgg]cb cb ig cb`m k\Yb ]h []jYg ig gcaYh\]b[ k\]W\& YjYb k]h\ U`` h\Y YZZcfhg cZ cif ]bhY``YWh& kY WUbbch ibXYfghUbX Wcad`YhY`m(

v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7KI%&vT

7fh \Ug giW\ Ub ]adUWh cb dYcd`Y h\Uh aUbm ghfUb[Y h\]b[g WUb \UddYb ]b h\Y]f gci`g4 amghYf]Yg VYWcaY W`YUfYf5 cdUeiY h\]b[g VYWcaY Yj]XYbh5 Wcad`]WUhYX h\]b[g VYWcaY g]ad`Y5 k\Uh ]g dfcVUV`Y VYWcaYg bYWYgx gUfm( 7 fYU` Ufh]gh U`kUmg g]ad`]Z]Yg( v7ZhYf >;DH? 7C?;B

=HPHPEHU WKDW \RX FDQQRW GR DQ\WKLQJ ZRQGHUIXO GULYHQ E\ FRPSHWLWLRQ+ \RX FDQQRW GR DQ\WKLQJ QREOH IURP SULGH& v@E>D HKIA?D

J\YfY UfY hkc jYfm W`YUf ]bX]WUh]cbg cZ fYU` gW]YbWY UbX fYU` Ufh4 h\Y Z]fgh ]bbYf g][b ]g h\Uh U gW\c`Uf cf Ub Ufh]gh kcf_g bch Zcf dfcZ]h& Vih Zcf gUWf]Z]WY& Zcf \]g WU``]b[5 h\Y gYWcbX& cihYf g][b ]g h\Uh \]g kcf_g UfY ibXYfghUbXUV`Y hc U`` dYcd`Y( HYU` gW]YbWY ghiX]Yg UbX aU_Yg UWWYgg]V`Y h\Uh _bck`YX[Y k\]W\ dYcd`Y Uh h\Uh dYf]cX cZ \]ghcfm h\]b_ ]adcfhUbh& UbX fYU` Ufh hfUbgZYfg h\]g hfih\ Zfca h\Y XcaU]b cZ _bck`YX[Y hc h\Y XcaU]b cZ ZYY`]b[g( 9fYUh]b[ Ufh ]g bch Ug Y`YjUhYX U h\]b[ Ug aUbm dYcd`Y [iYgg& Vih WYfhU]b`m ]h ]g U igYZi` UbX _]bX h\]b[ hc Xc& YgdYW]U``m ]Z ]h Vf]b[g dYcd`Y hc[Yh\Yf UbX UfcigYg _]bX ZYY`]b[g ]b h\Ya(

BVNX Ã 7 dYfgcb ]g Ybg`UjYX hc h\Y YlhYbh \Y VY`]YjYg h\Uh \]g `]ZY \Ug cb`m U d\mg]WU` VY[]bb]b[( Dch\]b[ WUb VY XcbY k]h\cih ZU]h\( >Yg]hUh]cb WUb _]`` U dYfgcb& cf ]h WUb XYghfcm k\c`Y bUh]cbg( M\m ]g ]h gc X]ZZ]x Wi`h hc []jY `]VYfUh]cb hc dYcd`Y6 8YWUigY k\Yb dYcd`Y Xc bch \UjY U XYYd ZU]h\ h\Ym UfY bch Wcad`YhY`m gifY UVcih h\Y]f f][\hg( v<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

J\Ym gUm h\Uh h\Y \][\Ygh [ccX ]g ZfYYXca( 7bX ]Z ZfYYXca ]g [ccXbYgg& h\Yb \ck WUb U ZfYY dYfgcb VY ib\Uddm6 ?Z mci gYY U dYfgcb k\c ]g bch \Uddm mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh \Y ]g bch U ZfYY aUb5 \Y ]g U g`UjY cZ gcaYh\]b[( ?b cfXYf hc VY Wcad`YhY`m ZfYY& mci g\ci`X VY fYUXm hc []jY hc =cX U`` h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ mci \UjY fYWY]jYX Zfca \]a( Oci g\ci`X VY fYUXm hc ib]hY mcif k]`` k]h\ h\Uh cZ =cX( v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

M\Yb mci \UjY bc ZfYYXca& h\Yb mcif `]ZY VYWcaYg h\Y `]ZY cZ Ub Ub]aU`( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

>iaUb X][b]hm UbX ZfYYXca UfY cif WcbghUbh bYWYgg]h]Yg( Ic& `Yh ig _YYd h\Ya k]h\ ig& cf `Yh ig X]Y k]h\ X][b]hm( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

5I \RX IHHO WKDW \RX DUH QRW IUHH$ ORRN IRU WKH UHDVRQ LQVLGH \RX&

#%$& Fib]g\aYbh ]g U bch]cb h\Uh \iaUb_]bX [fUXiU``m cihx [fckg( 7 dYfgcb \Ug XcbY Yj]`& gc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb& cf U [fcid cZ dYcd`Y& ]b cfXYf hc Z][\h h\]g Yj]`& WUbbch h\]b_ cZ Ubmx h\]b[ VYhhYf h\Ub hc WfYUhY Ubch\Yf Yj]`& k\]W\ h\Ym WU`` dib]g\aYbh( ;jYfm dib]g\aYbh ]g VUgYX& bch cb `c[]W cf cb h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ ^igh]WY& Vih cb h\Y XYg]fY hc k]g\ Yj]` cb h\cgY k\c \UjY XcbY Yj]` hc mci cf hc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb( 9Ud]hU` dib]g\aYbh ]g U jYfm W`YUf dfccZ h\Uh cif gcW]Yhmrg cf[Ub]nUh]cb ]g ZUf Zfca VY]b[ U 9\f]gh]Ub cbY( ;jYfmh\]b[ UVcih cif dfYgYbh gmghYa cZ dib]g\aYbhg UbX UVcih U`` Wf]a]bU` `Uk k]`` VY h\ci[\h cZ Vm ZihifY [YbYfUx h]cbg ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh kY h\]b_ cZ WUbb]VU`]ga cf \iaUb gUWf]Z]WY hc UbW]Ybh dU[Ub [cXg( s>ck X]X h\Ym bch gYY h\Y igY`YggbYgg UbX WfiY`hm cZ h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ h\Ym X]X6t cif XYgWYbXUbhg k]`` gUm UVcih ig( ?R SXQLVK RWKHUV LV OLNH SXWWLQJ PRUH ZRRG LQ WKH ILUH& 1YHU\ FULPH DOUHDG\ KDV SXQLVKPHQW LQ LWVHOI DQG LW LV PRUH FUXHO DQG PRUH MXVW WKDQ WKH SXQLVKPHQW FUHDWHG E\ SHRSOH& MY g\ci`X fYaYaVYf h\Uh h\Y XYg]fY hc dib]g\ ]g dUfh cZ U jYfm `ck Ub]aU` ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ g\ci`X VY giddfYggYX& UbX k\]W\ g\ci`X bch VY U dUfh cZ cif fYU`]hm(

4MGN & Ic`cacb UbX @cV _bYk UbX gdc_Y k]gY`m UVcih h\Y igYx `YggbYgg cZ \iaUb `]ZY( J\Y Z]fgh kUg h\Y \Udd]Ygh& h\Y gYWx cbX h\Y ib\Udd]Ygh cZ U`` aYb( EbY _bYk h\Y jUb]hm cZ d`YUgifY5 h\Y ch\Yf& h\Y fYU`]hm cZ a]gZcfhibY( v8B7?I; F7I97B

<c``ck h\Y VYgh kUm cZ `]ZY mci dcgg]V`m WUb& UbX \UV]h k]`` aU_Y h\]g kUm gi]hUV`Y UbX d`YUgUbh Zcf mci( J\]g ]g h\Y X]j]bY `Uk cZ `]ZY4 h\Uh cb`m j]fhiY ghUbXg Z]fa( 7`` h\Y fYgh ]g bch\]b[( vFOJ>7=EH7I

?Z mci ZYUf kcYg UbX a]gZcfhibYg& h\Yb mci UfY U`fYUXm ib\Uddm( J\cgY k\c ZYUf a]gZcfhibYg igiU``m XYgYfjY h\Ya( v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

>Udd]bYgg UbX WU`abYgg UfY bY]h\Yf ]bg]XY ig bcf cihg]XY ig( J\Ym UfY ]b =cX& k\c ]g Vch\ ]bg]XY UbX cihg]XY ig( 'TTTTT

v8B7?I; F7I97B

1YHU\WKLQJ LV IURP 3RG+ WKHUHIRUH$ HYHU\WKLQJ LV JRRG& 1YLO LV JRRGQHVV ZKLFK ZH GLG QRW XQGHUVWDQG EHFDXVH RI RXU VKRUWVLJKWHGQHVV& M\Yb cbY ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh _]bX cZ Yj]` k\]W\ ]g ]b \]g XYYXg& h\Yb U`` ch\Yf a]gZcfhibYg hc k\]W\ \Y WUb VY giVx ^YWhYX UfY bch\]b[ Ug WcadUfYX k]h\ h\Y d`YUgifY UbX ZfYYXca \Y WUb h\Yb YldYf]YbWY(

BVNX Ă DY]h\Yf h\Y XYgWf]dh]cbg cZ kUf bcf ]hg hYff]V`Y WfiY`h]Yg UbX UhfcW]h]Yg WUb ghcd dYcd`Y Zfca dUfh]W]dUh]b[ ]b ]h( EbY fYUgcb Zcf h\]g ]g h\Uh Vm j]Yk]b[ h\Y UhfcW]h]Yg cZ kUf& YjYfmcbY WcaYg hc ibXYfghUbX h\Uh ]Z giW\ U hYff]V`Y h\]b[ WUb Yl]gh UbX VY UWWYdhYX Vm dYcd`Y& h\Yb h\YfY aigh VY gcaY fYUgcb Zcf ]hg Yl]ghYbWY( 7 k]hbYgg fYWcibhYX \]g YldYf]YbWY ]b J\Y Higg]Ub' @UdUbYgY kUf& k\Yb \Y kUg cb h\Y iddYf XYW_ cZ h\Y ADQDJ VUhh`Yg\]d Xif]b[ U @UdUbYgY UhhUW_( ?h kUg U hYff]V`Y g][\h( ;jYfmk\YfY h\YfY kUg V`ccX& d]YWYg cZ Z`Yg\& VcX]Yg k]h\ \YUXg hcfb UkUm& h\Y gaY`` cZ V`ccX gc ghfcb[ ]h aUXY YjYb h\Y acgh hci[\ UbX \UfXYgh aYb X]nnm( J\Y UfacfYX WUbbcb hckYf giZZYfYX acgh cZ U``( 7 g\Y`` Yld`cXYX cb hcd cZ ]h UbX _]``YX U mcib[ cZZ]WYf k\c kUg h\Y W\]YZ cZ h\Y g\]drg Ufh]``Yfm( Eb`m cbY h\]b[ kUg `YZh cZ h\Y dccf aUb5 ]h kUg \]g Z]gh& h\Y \UbX k\]W\ \Y`X h\Y ]bghfiaYbh( Jkc cZ Zcif gU]`cfg k\c ghccX bYlh hc h\Y]f WcaaUbXYf kYfY hcfb ]bhc d]YWYg& UbX h\Y ch\Yf hkc \UX hYff]V`Y ]b^if]Yg5 UZhYfx kUfXg Vch\ \UX h\Y]f `Y[g UadihUhYX& UbX h\Yb h\Y fYaU]bg cZ h\Y]f `Y[g kYfY Wih cZZ U[U]b Wcad`YhY`m( J\Y WcaaUbx XYf cZ h\Y VUhh`Yg\]d \UX U gaU`` ]b^ifm ]b \]g \YUX& ]b h\Y hYad`Yg( <]`h\& hYff]V`Y ]``bYggYg& \ib[Yf& Z]fY& XYghfiWh]cb& Yj]`vh\]g ]g a]`]hUfm [`cfm& h\]g ]g kUf( v>;DH? >7H:K?D =7H:K;D

MUf ]g bck acfY hYff]V`Y h\Ub Uh Ubm dYf]cX ]b \iaUb \]ghcfm( v=KO :; C7KF7II7DJ

?KH WLPH KDV FRPH WR WDON DERXW WKH HYLOV RI ZDU& 5W LV QRW WUXH WKDW WKH H[LVWHQFH RI ZDUV SURYHV WKHLU QHFHVVLW\& ?KH KLVWRU\ RI PDQNLQG VD\V WKDW VXFK WKLQJV VKRXOG QRW KDSSHQ&

BVNX Å ?R GHQ\ 3RG LV WR GHQ\ \RXUVHOI DV D VSLULWXDO DQG LQWHOOHFc WXDO EHLQJ& ? _bck =cX UbX gci` bch Vm h\Y]f XYZ]b]h]cb& Vih ]b Ubch\Yf kUm Ybh]fY`m( Ihf]j]b[ hc XYZ]bY =cX XYghfcmg h\]g _bck`YX[Y ]b aY( ? _bck h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg& h\Uh am gci` Yl]ghg5 h\]g _bck`YX[Y ]g W`YUf hc aY VYWUigY ? kUg []jYb ]h( ? \UjY bch h\Y g`][\hYgh XciVh UVcih h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX& ]Z ? Ug_4 M\Uh Ua ?6 M\c Ua ?6 Cm `Y[g UfY bch aY5 am Ufag UfY bch aY5 am \YUX ]g bch aY5 am ZYY`]b[g UfY bch aY5 YjYb am h\ci[\h ]g bch aY( J\Yb k\Uh Ua ?6 ? Ua amgY`Z& ? Ua am gci`( Dc aUhhYf k\]W\ g]XY ? UddfcUW\ h\]g eiYgh]cb& ? ]bYj]hUV`m WcaY hc =cX( J\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ am `]ZY ]g =cX& h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ am Yl]ghYbWY ]g =cX( J\Y gUaY k]h\ h\Y gci`( ?Z ? kUbh hc _bck h\Y hfih\& ? _bck h\Uh Uh h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U`` ]g am gci`5 ]Z ? kUbh hc ibXYfx ghUbX am ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY UbX bYWYgg]hm Zcf [ccXbYgg& h\Yb ? U[U]b Z]bX h\Y gcifWY cZ h\]g ]b am gci`( =cX Yl]ghg( MY g\ci`X bch dfcjY h\]g5 hc XYbm =cX ]g aUXbYgg( =cX `]jYg ]b am WcbgW]YbWY& ]b h\Y WcbgW]YbWY cZ U`` \iaUb]hm& ]b U`` cif ib]jYfgY& UbX kY hU`_ hc =cX ]b h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh acaYbhg cZ gUXbYgg cf ^cm( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

B]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X [cYg UWWcfX]b[ hc gcaYVcXmrg k]``v gcaYcbY dYfZcfag gdYW]U` UWh]cbg idcb U`` `]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X& UbX hciW\Yg U`` cif `]jYg( J\Uh k\]W\ dYfZcfag h\YgY UWh]cbg ]g k\Uh kY WU`` =cX(

BVNX Ǻ J\Uh ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ gc`jYg U`` cZ h\Y WcbhfUX]Wh]cbg cZ \iaUb `]ZY UbX []jYg cbY h\Y [fYUhYgh V`]gg ]g _bckb hc U`` dYcd`Y4 h\]g ZYY`]b[ ]g `cjY( FUm VUX dYcd`Y k]h\ mcif [ccXbYgg5 Z][\h h\Y]f \UhfYX k]h\ mcif _]bXbYgg( ;jYb ]Z mci Xc bch UW\]YjY j]Whcfm cjYf ch\Yf dYcd`Y& mci k]`` WcbeiYf mcifgY`Z( v>Ybf] IEBH

BcjY XYghfcmg XYUh\ UbX aU_Yg ]h Yadhm5 ]h []jYg aYUb]b[ hc gYbgY`Ygg h\]b[g5 Zfca ib\Udd]bYgg& `cjY aU_Yg fYU` \Udd]bYgg( 2LUH SXULILHV HYHU\WKLQJ LQ WKH PDWHULDO ZRUOG+ ORYH SXULILHV HYHU\WKLQJ LQ WKH VSLULWXDO ZRUOG& v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y `Ygg `cjY U dYfgcb \Ug& h\Y acfY \Y giZZYfg( ?Z mci UfY ]b U X]ZZ]Wi`h g]hiUh]cb& U `ck accX& ]Z mci UfY UZfU]X cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX cZ mcifgY`Z& ]Z mci UfY hcfx aYbhYX& h\Yb hY`` mcifgY`Z4 s? k]`` `cjY YjYfmcbY k\ca ? aYYh ]b h\]g `]ZY(t Jfm hc Zc``ck h\]g fi`Y5 UbX mci k]`` gYY h\Uh YjYfmh\]b[ k]`` Z]bX ]hg kUm& UbX YjYfmh\]b[ k]`` gYYa g]ad`Y& UbX mci k]`` bc `cb[Yf \UjY XciVhg cf ZYUfg(

BVNX Ą FYcd`Y a]ghU_Yb`m h\]b_ h\Uh j]fhiY `]Yg ]b h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ aUbm h\]b[g( M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]g bch h\Y eiUbh]hm Vih h\Y eiU`]hm cZ _bck`YX[Y( IcWfUhYg h\ci[\h h\Uh ghid]X]hm kUg ]bWcadUh]V`Y k]h\ k]gXca& Vih \Y bYjYf gU]X h\Uh ][bcfUbWY kUg ghid]X]hm( vN;DEF>ED

MY `]jY ]b h\Y U[Y cZ d\]`cgcd\m& gW]YbWY& UbX ]bhY``YWh( >i[Y `]VfUf]Yg UfY cdYb Zcf YjYfmcbY( ;jYfmk\YfY kY \UjY gW\cc`g& Wc``Y[Yg& UbX ib]jYfg]h]Yg k\]W\ []jY ig h\Y k]gXca cZ h\Y dYcd`Y Zfca aUbm dfYj]cig a]``Ybb]U( 7bX k\Uh h\Yb6 >UjY kY VYWcaY k]gYf Zcf U`` h\]g6 :c kY VYhx hYf ibXYfghUbX cif `]ZY& cf h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ cif Yl]ghYbWY6 :c kY _bck k\Uh ]g [ccX Zcf cif `]ZY6 v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

HYUX]b[ hcc aiW\ ]g \UfaZi` hc mcif ]bXYdYbXYbWY cZ h\ci[\h( J\Y [fYUhYgh h\]b_Yfg ?rjY aYh Uacb[ gW\c`Ufg UfY dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch fYUX hcc aiW\( =;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

0R QRW IHDU WKH ODFN RI NQRZOHGJH$ IHDU IDOVH NQRZOHGJH& -OO HYLO LQ WKLV ZRUOG FRPHV IURP IDOVH NQRZOHGJH& Abck`YX[Y Vcfb ]b Uf[iaYbh UbX X]gWigg]cb ]g hc VY XciVhYX(

BVNX ÁÀ ?b h\Y kcf`X hcXUm& fYU` ZU]h\ \Ug ]b acgh WUgYg VYYb fYd`UWYX Vm diV`]W cd]b]cb( FYcd`Y Xc bch VY`]YjY ]b =cX& Vih h\Ym VY`]YjY ]b aUbm a]bcf h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY hUi[\h Vm ch\Yf dYcd`Y( FYcd`Yrg a]gZcfhibYg UfY WUigYX bch VYWUigY h\Ym Xc bch _bck h\Y]f Xih]Yg& Vih VYWUigY h\Ym a]gibXYfghUbX h\Y]f Xih]Yg( =cX []jYg U W\c]WY hc YjYfm gci` VYhkYYb hfih\ UbX dYUWY( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

2DLWK LV QRW DFKLHYHG E\ D PDMRULW\ RI YRWHV& J\Y aU^cf fYUgcb Zcf h\Y Yj]` h\Uh Yl]ghg hcXUm ]g h\Y UVgYbWY cZ ZU]h\ ]b dYcd`Y cZ cif h]aY(

BVNX ÁÁ Jfi`m j]fhicig ]g h\Y dYfgcb k\c []jYg \]g `cjY hc h\Y kYU_( <RZHU LV JLYHQ WR D SHUVRQ$ QRW WR RSSUHVV WKH ZHDN$ KXW WR VXSSRUW DQG WR KHOS WKH ZHDN& v@E>D HKIA?D

=]jY hc YjYfm aUb h\Uh Ug_Yh\ cZ h\YY5 UbX cZ \]a h\Uh hU_Yh\ UkUm h\m [ccXg Ug_ h\Ya bch U[U]b( 7bX Ug mY kci`X h\Uh aYb g\ci`X Xc hc mci& Xc mY U`gc hc h\Ya `]_Yk]gY( vBKA; 04-*'-+

;jYfm _]bX h\]b[ ]g U j]fhiY( Jc []jY kUhYf hc U h\]fghm dYfx gcb& cf hc d]W_ id U ghcbY Zfca U fcUX& cf hc Wcbj]bWY mcif bY][\Vcfg UbX Zf]YbXg h\Uh h\Ym g\ci`X VY j]fhicig& cf hc g\ck U hfUjY`Yf \]g kUm& cf hc ga]`Y `cc_]b[ ]bhc mcif bY][\Vcfrg ZUWYvU`` h\]g ]g j]fhiY( vCE>7CC;:

?Z U f]W\ dYfgcb Wci`X VY hfi`m j]fhicig& h\Yb \Y kci`X ghcd VY]b[ f]W\ jYfm ei]W_`m(

BVNX ÁÂ J\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ `cjY ]g ]b YUW\ dYfgcbrg ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y ib]hm cZ h\Y X]j]bY gdUf_ k\]W\ `]jYg ]b U`` dYcd`Y( 7`` h\Uh Vf]b[g ib]Z]WUh]cb hc dYcd`Y ]g [ccXbYgg UbX VYUihm5 U`` h\Uh Vf]b[g gYdUfUh]cb Uacb[ h\Ya ]g Yj]`( 7]` dYcd`Y _bck h\]g4 ]h ]g Z]fa`m ]bgWf]VYX cb cif \YUfhg( ;jYfm [ccX cf W\Uf]hUV`Y UWh]cb& YjYfm ibdfcZ]hUV`Y Ugg]gx hUbWY k\]W\ giddcfhg ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]b bYYX& k\Yb kY WcaY hc ]hg cf][]bg UbX ZcibXUh]cbg& VYWcaYg U amghYf]x cig UbX ibYld`U]bUV`Y h\]b[& VYWUigY ]h WcaYg cih cZ h\Y amghYf]cig ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y ib]hm cZ U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g& UbX ]h WUb VY Yld`U]bYX Vm bch\]b[ Y`gY( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

BH DUH VHSDUDWH EHLQJV$ LW VHHPV$ EXW LQ RXU LQQHU OLIH ZH DUH FORVHO\ FRQQHFWHG ZLWK DOO OLYLQJ WKLQJV& MY WUb ZYY` gcaY cZ h\Y j]VfUh]cbg cZ h\]g gd]f]hiU` kcf`X5 gcaY cZ h\Ya \UjY bch fYUW\YX ig mYh& Vih h\Ym UfY acjx ]b[& Ug h\Y j]VfUh]cbg cZ `][\h Zfca h\Y X]ghUbh ghUfg UfY acj]b[ UWfcgg h\Y ib]jYfgY5 h\Ym acjY& h\ci[\ h\Ym UfY bch mYh j]g]V`Y hc cif YmYg(

BVNX ĄǼ J\Y H[LVWLQJ RUGHU RI WKLQJV FDQ KH LPSURYHG& M]gY Wcbgiadh]cb ]g aiW\ acfY Wcad`]WUhYX h\Ub k]gY dfcXiWh]cb( M\Uh Z]jY dYcd`Y k]`` dfcXiWY& cbY dYfgcb WUb jYfm YUg]`m WcbgiaY& UbX h\Y eiYgh]cb Zcf YUW\ ]bX]x j]XiU` UbX Zcf YjYfm bUh]cb ]g bch \ck UfY kY hc dfcXiWY& Vih \ck cif dfcXiWhg UfY hc VY WcbgiaYX( v@E>D HKIA?D

Oci WUb hcfhifY dYcd`Y5 mci WUb hfYUh h\Ya Ug ]Z h\Ym kYfY Ub]aU`g5 mci WUb UVigY h\Ya ]b U`` kUmg5 mci WUb _]`` h\Ya Ug ]Z h\Ym kYfY giaaYf Z`]Yg( 8ih dYcd`Y k]`` fYaU]b ZfYY ]b h\Y \][\Ygh gYbgY VYWUigY h\Ym \UjY YhYfbU` gci`g( v@E>D HKIA?D

?b cfXYf hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y `Uk cZ =cX Ug kY ibXYfghUbX ]h& U ^c]bh YZZcfh aigh VY aUXY Vm aUbm dYcd`Y( J\Yb& aUmVY g`ck`m& kY k]`` acjY hc Ub ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g X]j]bY `Uk(

BVNX ÁÄ =cXrg _]b[Xca ]g h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh Uacb[ aUb_]bX cZ =cXrg k]``& UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y aYUgifY ]b k\]W\ ]h ]g fYjYU`YX hc ig( ?b h\Y `]ZY cZ h\Y kcf`X& h\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg `cc_ `]_Y cbY mYUf( J\YfYZcfY& kY g\ci`X kcf_ \UfX Uh h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ YhYfb]hm& UbX kY g\ci`X kU]h Zcf h\Y XUm k\Yb fY`][]cb k]`` Yb`][\hYb h\]g kcf`X Wcad`YhY`m( J\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX cb YUfh\ ]g h\Y Z]bU` difdcgY UbX XYg]fY cZ \iaUb_]bX( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?b fY`][]cig gYfj]WYg kY g\ci`X ibXYfghUbX& bch h\Y f]hix U`g& bch ibbUhifU` h\]b[g k\]W\ WUb VY dYfZcfaYX cb`m Vm U df]Ygh5 ]b fY`][]cb& kY g\ci`X ibXYfghUbX `cjY Zcf =cX UbX Zcf cif bY][\Vcf( v7B;N7D:H 7HA>7D=;BIAS

?KH NLQJGRP RI 3RG LV LQVLGH XV+ WKHUHIRUH ORRN IRU WKH NLQJc GRP RI 3RG LQVLGH \RX DQG WKH UHVW ZLOO WDNH FDUH RI LWVHOI$ LQ WKH EHVW SRVVLEOH ZD\&

BVNX ÁĀ Cm aUhYf]U` `]ZY ]g giV^YWh hc giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\& UbX bc YZZcfh cZ a]bY WUb fY`YUgY aY Zfca giZZYf]b[ cf XYUh\( Cm gd]f]hiU` `]ZY ]g giV^YWh bY]h\Yf hc giZZYf]b[ bcf XYUh\( J\YfYZcfY& gU`jUh]cb Zfca giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\ `]Yg ]b cb`m cbY h\]b[4 ]b h\Y hfUbgZYf cZ am WcbgW]cig sgY`Zt Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U` hc h\Y gd]f]hiU`( J\Y kUm hc ibXYfghUbX h\]g kcf`X ]g hc ibXYfghUbX mcif ]bbYf gY`Z( M]h\ h\Y \Y`d cZ `cjY& UbX Vm j]fhiY cZ h\Y `cjY cZ ch\Yfg& kY ibXYfghUbX ch\Yf VY]b[g4 dYcd`Y& Ub]aU`g& d`Ubhg& ghcbYg& \YUjYb`m VcX]Yg5 UbX kY ibXYfghUbX h\Y Uhh]hiXYg cZ h\YgY VY]b[g hc h\YagY`jYg5 UbX h\YgY Uhh]x hiXYg WfYUhY h\Y k\c`Y kcf`X Ug kY _bck ]h( J\Y kUm hc ibXYfghUbX]b[ ]g VUgYX cb `cjY& cb ib]Z]WUh]cb k]h\ U`` ch\Yf WfYUhifYg ]b h\Y kcf`X( CHW QRW 9\ ZLOO$ EXW ?KLQH EH GRQH&

vBKA; ,,4.,

J\Y YggYbWY cZ `cjY cZ =cX ]g ]b h\Y XYg]fY cZ h\Y gci` Zcf ]hg WfYUhcf& Zcf ib]hm k]h\ h\]g \][\Yf `][\h( vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\]g YhYfbU` VY[]bb]b[ ]b mci \Ug U`kUmg Yl]ghYX& ]h Yl]ghg bck& UbX ]h k]`` U`kUmg Yl]gh4 ]hg h]aY k]`` bYjYf YbX( vJ>; 8H7>C?DrI M?I:EC

J\Uh k\]W\ kY ibXYfghUbX Ug h\Y \Udd]bYgg cf ib\Udd]bYgg cZ cif Ub]aU` sgY`Zt XYdYbXg cb h\Y \][\Ygh gd]f]hiU` k]``(

BVNX ÁĂ Dch\]b[ WUb giddcfh ]X`YbYgg VYhhYf h\Ub Yadhm W\UhhYf( FYcd`Y kci`X VY VYhhYf hc _YYd g]`Ybh UbX bch gdYU_ h\Y Vcf]b[& Yadhm h\]b[g h\Ym fcih]bY`m gUm hc YbhYfhU]b h\YagY`jYg( >ck WUb h\Ym YbXifY ]h6 J\Y dYfgcb k\c gdYU_g aiW\ k]`` gY`Xca Zi`Z]`` U`` \]g kcfXg ]b \]g UWh]cbg( 7 k]gY dYfgcb ]g U`kUmg kUfm `Ygh \]g kcfXg gifdUgg \]g UWh]cbg( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

2LUVW WKLQN$ WKHQ VSHDN& >WRS ZKHQ WROG sHQRXJK& t - SHUVRQ LV KLJKHU WKDQ DQ DQLPDO EHFDXVH RI KLV DELOLW\ WR VSHDN$ EXW KH LV ORZHU WKDQ DQ DQLPDO LI KH FDQQRW SURSHUO\ XVH WKLV DELOLW\& vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

J\cgY dYcd`Y gdYU_ acgh k\c Xc bch \UjY aiW\ hc gUm( ?Z mci kUbh hc ghcd U dYfgcb Zfca Ub UWh]cb& Ug_ \]a hc gdYU_ acfY cb h\Y hcd]W( J\Y acfY dYcd`Y gdYU_& h\Y `Ygg XYg]fY h\Ym \UjY hc UWh( vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

J\Y `Ygg mci gdYU_& h\Y acfY mci k]`` kcf_(

BVNX ÁÅ J\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ UbW]Ybh gcW]Yh]Yg kUg j]c`YbWY( J\Y VUg]g cZ cif WcbhYadcfUfm gcW]Yhm ]g k]gY WcbWcfX& h\Y bY[Uh]cb cZ j]c`YbWY( OY \UjY \YUfX h\Uh ]h \Uh\ VYYb gU]X& 7b YmY Zcf Ub YmY& UbX U hcch\ Zcf U hcch\4 8ih ? gUm ibhc mci& J\Uh mY fYg]gh bYh Yj]`4 Vih k\cgcYjYf g\U`` ga]hY h\YY cb h\m f][\h W\YY_& hifb hc \]a h\Y ch\Yf U`gc( vC7JJ>;M /4-2'-3

>Y k\c ]g fYU``m g_]``Zi` ]b Wcaaib]WUh]b[ k]h\ dYcd`Y ]g igiU``m U \iaV`Y UbX ei]Yh dYfgcb( J\]g ]g WU``YX h\Y j]fhiY cZ bcbfYg]ghUbWY( J\]g ]g WU``YX \Ufacbm k]h\ >YUjYb( B7E'JPK

IcaY dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Y hc fi`Y ch\Yf dYcx d`Y k]h\cih j]c`YbWY( 7bX gc h\Ym Xc hc dYcd`Y Ug ch\Yf dYcd`Y Xc k]h\ \cfgYg& k\Yb h\Ym V`]bX h\Y]f YmYg gc h\Uh h\Ym k]`` acfY cVYX]Ybh`m kU`_ ]b U W]fW`Y( 2RU ZKDW SXUSRVH LV D PDQ_V LQWHOOHFW LI \RX DUH JRLQJ WR LQIOXHQFH KLP RQO\ ZLWK YLROHQFH, ?b U`` WUgYg& k\Yb dYcd`Y igY j]c`YbWY& mci g\ci`X hfm hc Wcbj]bWY h\Ya bch hc( Oci g\ci`X hfm hc Udd`m k]gY& Wcbx j]bW]b[ Uf[iaYbhg& UddYU`]b[ bch hc h\Y YjYfmXUm kcf`X& Vih hc h\Y]f \][\Yf gd]f]hiU` ibXYfghUbX]b[( J\Yb& k\Yb mci giWWYYX& mci k]`` \UjY h\Y Wcad`YhY gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY(

BVNX ÁǺ FYcd`Y VY`]YjY ]b YhYfbU` `]ZY VYWUigY h\Ym VY`]YjY h\Uh `]ZYrg VY[]bb]b[ ]g gd]f]hiU`& UbX h\YfYZcfY YhYfbU`( ?b cif gci` ]g h\Y g][b cZ YhYfb]hm(

vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DDJD9

Eif V][[Ygh XYg]fY ]g hc `]jY ZcfYjYf( 8ih k\Yb kY UfY ZfYYX Zfca h\]g VcXm& kY k]`` bch k]g\ hc WcaY VUW_( ?g h\YfY giW\ U W\]`X k\c& cbWY Vcfb& kci`X `]_Y hc fYhifb hc h\Y kcaV cZ \]g ach\Yf6 ?g h\YfY U aUb k\c& ZfYYX Zfca df]gcb& kci`X `]_Y hc fYhifb hc ]h6 ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U dYfx gcb g\ci`X bch VY UZfU]X UVcih h\Y ZihifY `]VYfUh]cb Zfca \]g VcXm& ]Z \Y ]g bch WcbbYWhYX hcc W`cgY`m k]h\ h\]g aUhYx f]U` `]ZY( vJUV`Yg cZ h\Y 8UV]Xg& U Cig`]a gYWh Zfca FYfg]U

7 dYfgcb ]g bch UZfU]X hc X]Y cb`m UZhYf \Y ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh \Y kUg bYjYf Vcfb& h\Uh \Y U`kUmg Yl]ghYX& Yl]ghg Uh dfYgYbh& UbX k]`` U`kUmg Yl]gh( 7 dYfgcb k]`` VY`]YjY ]b \]g YhYfb]hm k\Yb \Y ibXYfx ghUbXg h\Uh \]g `]ZY ]g bch U kUjY& U dYf]cX cZ h]aY& Vih h\Y YhYfbU` acjYaYbh k\]W\ ]g aUb]ZYghYX ]b h\]g `]ZY cb`m Ug U kUjY( ?KRVH ZKR EHOLHYH WKDW WKHLU OLIH KDV QRW EHJXQ ZLWK WKHLU ELUWK DQG ZLOO QRW HQG ZLWK GHDWK ILQG LW PXFK HDVLHU WR OLYH D JRRG OLIH WKD#L WKRVH ZKR GR QRW XQGHUVWDQG RU EHOLHYH WKLV&

BVNX ÁĄ =HDOO\ WUXH$ JRRG$ DQG JUHDW WKLQJV DUH DOZD\V VLPSOH& J\Y `Ub[iU[Y cZ hfih\ ]g U`kUmg g]ad`Y(

ÅHÁTWÁZ 7DD7;KI I;D;97

LYfm cZhYb h\Y g]ad`Ygh UbX `YUgh YXiWUhYX dYcd`Y WUb YUgx ]`m UbX ibWcbgW]cig`m ibXYfghUbX h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY k\]`Y h\Y acgh gW\c`Uf`m dYcd`Y `UW_ h\]g UV]`]hm& VYWUigY h\Ym \UjY VYYb hcc YXiWUhYX hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y g]ad`Y h\]b[g h\Uh UfY VUg]W hc U`` dYcd`Y( J\Y W`YUfYgh UbX g]ad`Ygh bch]cbg UfY U`acgh U`kUmg Wcbx WYU`YX Vm gcd\]gh]WUhYX aYX]hUh]cbg( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

?Z mci kUbh hc Z]bX Ub YlUad`Y hc Zc``ck& mci g\ci`X `cc_ Uacb[ g]ad`Y& \iaV`Y Zc`_( J\YfY ]g fYU` [fYUhbYgg cb`m ]b h\cgY k\c Xc bch UXjYfh]gY h\YagY`jYg& UbX k\c Xc bch ibXYfghUbX h\YagY`jYg Ug [fYUh(

BVNX ÂÀ J\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ WcadUgg]cb Zcf ch\Yf `]j]b[ VY]b[g fYa]bXg aY cZ h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ dU]b ]b cif VcXm( @igh Ug mci WUb VYWcaY `Ygg gYbg]h]jY hc dU]b ]b mcif VcXm k]h\ h]aY& mci WUb VYWcaY `Ygg WcadUgg]cbUhY hc ch\Yfg( ?KH ILUVW FRQGLWLRQ WR EULQJLQJ UHOLJLRQ LQWR \RXU OLIH LV PDQc LIHVWLQJ ORYH DQG SLW\ WRZDUG DOO OLYLQJ FUHDWXUHV& v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g ]g W`cgY`m WcbbYWhYX k]h\ W\UfUWx hYf hmdY( Oci WUb gUm k]h\ WcbZ]XYbWY h\Uh \Y k\c ]g WfiY` hc Ub]aU`g WUbbch VY U _]bX aUb( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

;jYfm aifXYf ]g hYff]V`Y( 8ih acgh hYff]V`Y ]g h\Y aifXYf ]b k\]W\ mci kUbh hc YUh h\Y WfYUhifY mci \UjY _]``YX& k\Yb mci _]`` Zcf h\Y gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ mcif ghcaUW\( vC?A>7?B =EB:IJ;?D

M\Yb h\Y giZZYf]b[ cZ Ubch\Yf WfYUhifY WUigYg mci hc ZYY` dU]b& Xc bch giVa]h hc h\Y ]b]h]U` XYg]fY hc Z`YY Zfca h\Y giZZYf]b[ cbY& Vih cb h\Y WcbhfUfm& WcaY W`cgYf& Ug W`cgY Ug mci WUb hc \]a k\c giZZYfg& UbX hfm hc \Y`d \]a(

4MGN #" BcjY ]g h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cb cZ h\Y X]j]bY bUhifY k\]W\ Yl]ghg UVcjY h]aY( BcjY ]g bch cb`m U kUm cZ `]ZY& ]h ]g Ub UWh]cb X]fYWhYX hckUfX h\Y [ccXbYgg cZ ch\Yfg( J\YfY ]g bc `cjY ]b h\Y ZihifY( BcjY WUb Yl]gh cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh acaYbh( 7 aUb k\c XcYg bch aUb]ZYgh `cjY ]b h\Y dfYgYbh XcYg bch `cjY Uh U``( .H NLQG HYHQ LI WKH ZRUOG EODPHV \RX& 5W LV EHWWHU WKDQ WKH FRQYHUVH ZKHQ D SHUVRQ LV SUDLVHG E\ RWKHUV EXW FRQWLQXHV WR EH EDG& J\Y DYk JYghUaYbh fYZ`YWhg U jYfm g]ad`Y ZU]h\4 ZU]h\ ]b =cX UbX fYgdYWh Zcf >]a( ?h ]g h\Y gUaY ]b Zc``ck]b[ h\Y `Uk5 h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY `Uk4 `cjY mcif bY][\Vcf( v8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

9YfhU]b`m& ]h ]g dU]bZi` hc fYWU`` U`` h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ mci Wci`X \UjY XcbY ]b h\Y dUgh Vih X]X bch4 gcaY W\Uf]hm& Zcf YlUad`Y5 U h]aY mci XYb]YX hc h\cgY k\c YldYWhYX \Y`d Zfca mci5 cf k\Yb mci V`cW_YX h\Y ^cmZi` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ Wcad`Yh]b[ Ub UWh]cb mci g\ci`X \UjY Z]b]g\YX(

BVNX ÂÂ 2DLWK LV QRW WUXH IDLWK LI ORYH LV QRW LQ KDUPRQ\ ZLWK LW& J\Y Xccf hc \YUjYb ]g cdYbYX hc mci hc h\Y gUaY YlhYbh mci kUbh ]h( =Yh f]X cZ mcif hfciV`Yg UbX dfcV`Yag& UbX X]fYWh mcif gci` hc gd]f]hiU` h\]b[g( 8Y UhhYbh]jY& UbX Zi`Z]`` mcif Xihm k]h\cih h\]b_]b[ UVcih h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYgSOci g\ci`X bch [i]XY YjYbhg& Vih VY [i]XYX Vm YjYbhg( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Uh Xch\ ]h dfcZ]hS am VfYh\fYb& h\ci[\ U aUb gUm \Y \Uh\ ZU]h\& UbX \UjY bch kcf_g6 9Ub ZU]h\ gUjY \]a6 ?Z U Vfch\Yf cf g]ghYf VY bU_YX& UbX XYgh]hihY cZ XU]`m ZccX& UbX cbY cZ mci gUm ibhc h\Ya& :YdUfh ]b dYUWY& VY mY kUfaYX UbX Z]``YX5 bchk]h\ghUbX]b[ mY []jY h\Ya bch h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY bYYXZi` hc h\Y VcXm5 k\Uh Xch\ ]h dfcZ]h6 ;jYb gc ZU]h\& ]Z ]h \Uh\ bch kcf_g& ]g XYUX& VY]b[ U`cbY( ((( OY gYY h\Yb \ck h\Uh Vm kcf_g U aUb ]g ^igh]Z]YX& UbX bch Vm ZU]h\ cb`m(((( <cf Ug h\Y VcXm k]h\cih h\Y gd]f]h ]g XYUX& gc ZU]h\ k]h\cih kcf_g ]g XYUX U`gc( v@7C;I ,4+.'+2& ,.& ,0

7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg h\Y `Uk Vih XcYg bch Zi`Z]`` ]h fYa]bXg aY cZ cbY k\c d`ckg h\Y `UbX Vih XcYg bch dih gYYX ]b ]h( v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?Z U dYfgcb ]g bch ]b U \iffm hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y ibXYfghUbXg Ug h\Y `Uk cZ =cX& h\Yb \Y VY`]YjYg bY]h\Yf ]b h\Y `Uk& bcf ]b =cX(

BVNX ÂÃ 1IIRUW LV WKH QHFHVVDU\ FRQGLWLRQ RI PRUDO SHUIHFWLRQ& J\cgY k\c h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym WUb `]jY U \][\ gd]f]hiU` `]ZY k\cgY VcX]Yg UfY Z]``YX k]h\ ]X`YbYgg UbX `ilif]Yg UfY a]gx hU_Yb( J\Y VcXm ]g h\Y Z]fgh ghiXYbh cZ h\Y gci`(

v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

Dch\]b[ acfY WUb VY Wcbg]XYfYX Ug fYU` aYf]h Zcf U dYfgcb h\Ub \]g YZZcfh( Eb`m ]b \]g YZZcfh ]g U dYfgcb g\ckb ]b \]g fYU` `][\h( vJ\Y AEH7D

?Z mci kYfY UVigYX& aU_Y Ub YZZcfh hc `cjY h\cgY k\c \UjY UVigYX mci( ?Z mci \UjY UVigYX gcaYcbY& aU_Y Ub YZZcfh hc WcffYWh h\Y Yj]` k\]W\ mci WfYUhYX(

BVNX ÂÄ BKHQ RQH XQGHUVWDQGV OLIH_V ODZ$ RQH PDQLIHVWV WKH SDUW RI 3RG ZKLFK OLYHV LQVLGH KLP& ;jYfm aUb& Zfca h\Y _]b[ hc h\Y dccfYgh dUidYf& g\ci`X gYY_ \]g ckb dYfZYWh]cb& VYWUigY cb`m gY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb ]adfcjYg aUb_]bX( v9ED<K9?KI

?b h\Y `cb[ fib& dYcd`Y UW\]YjY cb`m h\Uh k\]W\ h\Ym \UjY gYh Ug [cU`g Zcf h\YagY`jYg5 h\YfYZcfY& gYh h\Y \][\Ygh dcgx g]V`Y [cU`g Zcf mcifgY`Z( J\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ h\Y `Uk cZ [ccXbYgg \Ug bch\]b[ ]b Wcaacb k]h\ YjYfmXUm aUhYf]U` dfcgdYf]hm( IcaYh]aYg aUhYf]U` dfcgdYf]hm UbX acfU` [ccXbYgg W`Ug\ ]b WcbZ`]Wh( J\YgY giZZYf]b[g `YUX hc h\Y \][\Ygh Y`YjUh]cb cZ gd]f]h(

BVNX ÂĀ IcaYh]aYg kY WUbbch gYY Ubm WcbbYWh]cb VYhkYYb cif giZZYf]b[ UbX cif g]b( Vih h\]g WcbbYWh]cb XYZ]b]hY`m Yl]ghg( s? kUg fYdU]X k]h\ Yj]` Zcf h\Y [ccXbYgg k\]W\ ? \UjY XcbY(t 8ih ]Z mci `cjY h\cgY Zcf k\ca mci X]X [ccX& h\Yb mci \UjY U`fYUXm fYWY]jYX mcif fYkUfX( J\YfYZcfY& U`` h\Uh mci Xc k]h\ `cjY& mci Xc Zcf mcifgY`Z( J\Y fYkUfX Zcf j]fhiY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y [ccX XYYX( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

8RRN IRU WKH FDXVHV RI WKH HYLO IURP ZKLFK \RX VXIIHU LQ \RXUc VHOI >RPHWLPHV WKLV HYLO LV WKH GLUHFW FRQVHTXHQFH RI \RXU DFWLYLW\+ VRPHWLPHV LW KDSSHQV DIWHU D OHQJWK\ SHULRG RI WUDQVc IRUPDWLRQ RI DQ HYLO ZKLFK \RX FRPPLWWHG ORQJ DJR& .XW WKH VRXUFH LV DOZD\V LQ \RX$ DQG VDOYDWLRQ IURP LW OLHV LQ FKDQJHV LQ \RXU DFWLRQV$ \RXU ZD\ RI OLIH&

BVNX ÂĂ ?b YjYfm ZU]h\& cb`m k\Uh ]g gd]f]hiU` ]g hfiY( 3RG LV D VSLULW$ DQG WKRVH ZKR ZRUVKLS 4LP PXVW ZRUVKLS LQ VSLULW DQG WUXWK& v@ E>D .4,.

?Z mci Xc bch VY`]YjY h\Uh Uh ]hg VY[]bb]b[& mcif `]ZY WUaY Zfca gd]f]h& k\m UfY mci `cc_]b[ Zcf ]h Y`gYk\YfY& h\]b_x ]b[ h\Uh mci WUb Z]bX gd]f]h ]b ch\Yf d`UWYg6 >Y k\c VY\UjYg ]b h\]g kUm ]g `]_Y h\Y aUb k\c Vifbg U `UbhYfb ]b Vf][\h gib`][\h( :c bch VY UZfU]X hc [Yh f]X cZ h\]b[g k\]W\ X]ghfUWh mcif UhhYbh]cbvYjYfmh\]b[ aUhYf]U`& YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ WUb VY gYYb cf WUb VY ZY`h( J\Y acfY mci dif]Zm h\Y gd]f]hiU` WcfY cZ mcif ZU]h\& h\Y Z]faYf mcif ZU]h\ k]`` VY(

BVNX ÂÅ Abck`YX[Y ]g U hcc`& bch U difdcgY( FYcd`Y _bck `]hh`Y& VYWUigY h\Ym hfm hc ibXYfghUbX h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY bch cdYb hc h\Ya Zcf ibXYfghUbX]b[4 =cX& YhYfb]hm& gd]f]h5 cf h\cgY k\]W\ UfY bch kcfh\ h\]b_x ]b[ UVcih4 \ck kUhYf VYWcaYg ZfcnYb& cf U bYk h\Ycfm cZ biaVYfg& cf \ck j]figYg WUb hfUbga]h ]``bYggYg( >ck hc `]jY mcif `]ZY ]g h\Y cb`m fYU` _bck`YX[Y( FYcd`Y k\c h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[ ]b `]ZY ]g _bck`YX[Y fYa]bX aY cZ U VihhYfZ`m k\c Z`]Yg ]bhc h\Y Z`UaY cZ U WUbX`Y& UbX ]b gc Xc]b[ Vifbg& UbX Ylh]b[i]g\Yg h\Y `][\h( J\Y h]h`Y gW\c`Uft gi[[Yghg h\Uh U dYfgcb \Ug [cbY hc gW\cc`& UbX h\Uh \Y ghiX]YX& Vih ]h XcYg bch aYUb h\Uh \Y \Ug UWei]fYX Ubm hfi`m ]adcfhUbh _bck`YX[Y( v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

?KH SXUSRVH RI OLIH LV WKH IXOILOOPHQW RI WKH ODZ RI 3RG$ QRW WKH DFTXLVLWLRQ RI HYHU PRUH NQRZOHGJH&

4MGN #) HYdYbhUbWY U`kUmg dfYWYXYg dYfZYWh]cb( ?h ]g gUX h\Uh dYcx d`Y h\]b_ fYdYbhUbWY ]g ibbYWYggUfm( ?h ]g XUb[Yfcig hc gYY h\Y WUigY cZ Yj]` Ug `m]b[ cihg]XY cifgY`jYg5 Zcf h\Ya fYdYbhUbWY VYWcaYg ]adcgg]V`Y( O1:0/0:3.5 ?3663,7 :9-足0:<;余986

:RW WR DFFHSW \RXU PLVWDNHV LV WR LQFUHDVH WKHP& ? \UjY U VifXYb cb am gci` :if]b[ U`` am `cb[ `]ZY& ? X]X bch aU_Y UbmcbY \Uddm& bY]h\Yf am Zf]YbXg& bcf am ZUax ]`m& bcf YjYb amgY`Z( ? \UjY XcbY aUbm Yj]` h\]b[g( ((( ? kUg h\Y WUigY cZ h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ h\fYY V][ kUfg( 7Vcih 2**&*** dYcd`Y kYfY _]``YX VYWUigY cZ aY cb h\Y VUhh`Yx Z]Y`Xg& UbX h\Y]f ach\Yfg& Vfch\Yfg& UbX k]Xckg Wf]YX Zcf h\Ya( 7bX bck h\]g ghUbXg VYhkYYb aY UbX =cX( O9<<9 >98 -足3;余7,:.5

Oci g\ci`X `]jY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci WUb WcbZ]XY Ubmx h\]b[ cb mcif a]bX(

BVNX ÂĄ J\Y acfY ]adcfhUbh gcaYh\]b[ ]g ]b mcif `]ZY& h\Y acfY \UfaZi` ]h WUb VY Zcf mci ]b h\Y ZihifY ]Z mci UVigY ]h( J\Y a]gZcfhibYg UbX kcYg cZ dYcd`Y cZhYb WcaY Zfca h\Y UVigY cZ h\Y acgh dfYW]cig hcc` cZ cif `]ZY4 ]bhY``YWh( 3RG JDYH KLV VSLULW+ KLV LQWHOOHFW+ WR XV$ VR WKDW ZH FDQ XQGHUc VWDQG KLV ZLOO DQG IXOILO LW+ KXW ZH PLVXVH LW DQG DSSO\ WKLV $VSLULW IRU WKH IXOILOOPHQW RI RXU RZQ ZLOO& M\Yb h\Y ]bhY``YWh VYWcaYg h\Y g`UjY cZ j]WYg UbX dUgx g]cbg& h\Y giddcfhYf cZ `]Yg& ]h VYWcaYg bch cb`m U dYfjYfx g]cb& Vih Ub ]``bYgg& UbX kY WUbbch gYY h\Y X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb hfih\ UbX ZU`gY\ccX& [ccX UbX Yj]`& j]fhiY UbX j]WY(" vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

M\Yb U dYfgcb hf]Yg hc Udd`m \]g ]bhY``YWh hc h\Y eiYgh]cb sM\m Xc ? Yl]gh ]b h\]g kcf`X6t \Y VYWcaYg X]nnm( J\Y \iaUb ]bhY``YWh WUbbch Z]bX h\Y UbgkYfg hc giW\ eiYgx h]cbg( M\Uh XcYg h\]g aYUb6 J\]g aYUbg h\Uh cif ]bhY``YWh ]g bch []jYb hc ig hc Z]bX U gc`ih]cb Zcf h\]g eiYgh]cb( Eif ]bhY``YWh WUb cb`m UbgkYf h\Y eiYgh]cb4 s>ck g\U`` ? `]jY6t 7bX h\Y UbgkYf ]g g]ad`Y4 sMY g\ci`X `]jY gc Ug hc Vf]b[ [ccX hc U`` dYcd`Y(t J\Y difdcgY cZ h\Y ]bhY``YWh ]g hc fYjYU` h\Y hfih\5 h\YfYx ZcfY ]h ]g U \UfaZi` a]gWcbWYdh]cb hc dYfjYfh h\Y hfih\ k]h\ ]bhY``YWhiU` YZZcfhg(

6XO\ )' Eb`m h\cgY k\c _bck h\Y]f kYU_bYggYg WUb VY hc`YfUbh cZ h\Y kYU_bYggYg cZ h\Y]f bY][\Vcfg( Cm W\]`XfYb& ]Z gcaYcbY UVigYg mci k]h\ kcfXg& Xc bch dUm aiW\ UhhYbh]cb5 VY ei]Yh Uh mcif dfUmYf& UbX Ug_ mcif Zf]YbXg hc gYhh`Y h\Y X]gdihY UbX Z]bX dYUWY VYhkYYb mci UbX h\cgY k\c \UjY UVigYX mci( O<EC <,67=/

J\Y aUb k\c WUbbch Zcf[]jY XYghfcmg U Vf]X[Y k\]W\ \Y k]`` \UjY hc Wfcgg& VYWUigY YjYfm dYfgcb bYYXg Zcf[]jYbYgg( O0/?,:/ 20:-­0:<

-OPRVW DOZD\V$ ZKHQ ZH ORRN GHHS LQWR RXU VRXOV$ ZH FDQ ILQG WKHUH WKH VDPH VLQV ZKLFK ZH EODPH LQ RWKHUV& 5I ZH GR QRW ILQG D SDUWLFXODU VLQ LQ RXU VRXO$ WKHQ ZH VKRXOG ORRN PRUH FORVHO\$ DQG ZH ZLOO ILQG HYHQ ZRUVH VLQV WKHUH& 7 XYYd f]jYf ]g bch hfciV`YX ]Z mci h\fck U ghcbY ]bhc ]h( ?Z U fY`][]cig dYfgcb ]g \ifh Vm Wf]h]W]ga& h\Yb \Y ]g bch U f]jYf Vih U g\U``ck dcc`( <cf[]jY ch\Yfg& UbX h\Yb mci k]`` fYWY]jY Zcf[]jYbYgg( O7=;;632 =/ /38 ;;,,/3

?Z kY WUb dih cifgY`jYg ]bhc h\Y d`UWY cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& kY `YggYb cif df]XY(

BVNX ÃÁ 5I /KULVWLDQV ZRXOG IROORZ WKH ODZ$ WKHUH ZRXOG KH QR ULFK DQG QR SRRU& 7bX& VY\c`X& cbY WUaY UbX gU]X ibhc \]a& =ccX CUghYf& k\Uh [ccX h\]b[ g\U`` ? Xc& h\Uh ? aUm \UjY YhYfbU` `]ZY6((( @Ygig gU]X ibhc \]a& ]Z h\ci k]`h VY dYfZYWh& [c UbX gY`` h\Uh h\ci \Ugh& UbX []jY hc h\Y dccf& UbX h\ci g\U`h \UjY hfYUgifY ]b \YUjYb4 UbX WcaY UbX Zc``ck aY( O7,<<20? "*+"' #"

7 f]W\ dYfgcb WUb VY ]bgYbg]h]jY UbX Wcad`YhY`m ]bX]ZZYfx Ybh hc h\Y kcYg cZ ch\Yfg( vJ\Y J7BCK:

MYU`h\ fYa]bXg aY cZ aUbifY ]b h\Y Z]Y`X( M\Yb ]h ]g ]b U V][ d]`Y ]h aU_Yg U VUX gaY``( 8ih k\Yb ]h ]g X]ghf]VihYX YjYfmk\YfY UWfcgg h\Y Z]Y`X& ]h aU_Yg h\Y gc]` ZYfh]`Y( 7 dYfgcb aigh Wcad`YhY`m W`cgY \]g YmYg cb \]g acfU`g& h\Uh ]b U 9\f]gh]Ub gcW]Yhm gc Z]``YX k]h\ dYcd`Y ]b bYYX& h\YfY UfY ch\Yf dYcd`Y k\c UfY gc dfciX hc \UjY [fYUh kYU`h\(

VKVTU Á J\Y ]bhY``YWh WUb `]VYfUhY U dYfgcb5 h\Y `Ygg cZ Ub ]bhY``YWx hiU` `]ZY cbY \Ug& h\Y `Ygg `]VYfUhYX cbY ]g( ?Z mci k]g\ hc Xc bc Yj]` h\Yb h\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y [ccX XYYX k\]W\ mci WUbbch Xc( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

7 k]gY dYfgcb `]jYg ]b UWWcfXUbWY k]h\ \]g XYg]fYg& VYWUigY \Y kUbhg cb`m h\Uh k\]W\ ]g UhhU]bUV`Y( IiW\ U dYfx gcb ]g ZfYY( :]c[YbYg gU]X& s7 k]gY aUb VYWcaYg ZfYY k\Yb \Y ]g fYUXm hc X]Y Uh Ubm acaYbh(t >Y kfchY hc h\Y FYfg]Ub _]b[& sOci WUbbch Ybg`UjY hfi`m ZfYY dYcd`Y& ^igh Ug mci WUbbch Ybg`UjY U Z]g\( Oci aUm WUdhifY h\Ya& Vih mci WUbx bch ZcfWY h\Ya hc gYfjY5 h\Ym dfYZYf hc X]Y Ug WUdh]jYg( Ic& k\Uh kci`X ]h dfcZ]h mci hc ]adf]gcb h\Ya6t J\]g ]g U gdYYW\ cZ U fYU``m ZfYY aUb& U aUb k\c fYWc[b]nYg \]g ckb ZfYYXca( v;F?9J;JKI

MY \UjY WfYUhYX U kUm cZ `]ZY k\]W\ ]g WcbhfUfm hc aUb_]bXrg acfU` UbX d\mg]WU` bUhifY& UbX mYh kY kUbh hc VY ZfYY k\]`Y `]j]b[ h\]g _]bX cZ `]ZY( 2UHHGRP FDQQRW EH DFKLHYHG E\ ORRNLQJ IRU LW$ EXW LQ ORRNLQJ IRU WUXWK& 2UHHGRP VKRXOG QRW EH D SXUSRVH$ EXW& D FRQVHc TXHQFH& <fYYXca WUbbch VY [fUbhYX hc mci Vm ch\Yfg( ;UW\ dYfx gcb WUb `]VYfUhY cb`m \]aY`Z(

VKVTU Â ?Z mci UfY U aUhYf]U` VY]b[& h\Yb XYUh\ ]g h\Y YbX cZ YjYfmx h\]b[( 8ih ]Z mci UfY U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[& h\Yb h\Y VcXm `]a]hg mcif gd]f]hiU` VY]b[& UbX XYUh\ ]g cb`m U W\Ub[Y( Eif VcXm `]a]hg h\Y gd]f]hiU` X]j]bY gdUf_ k\]W\ kY WU`` cif gci`( ?b h\Y kUm h\Uh U jYggY` []jYg Zcfa hc h\Y `]ei]X cf [Ug k\]W\ ]g dih ]bhc ]h& cif VcXm []jYg Zcfa hc cif gd]f]hiU` "VY]b[( ?Z h\Y jYggY` ]g Vfc_Yb& h\Uh k\]W\ kUg ]b ]hbc `cb[Yf fYhU]bg h\Y Zcfa ]h \UX UbX Z`ckg cih( :cYg ]h fYWY]jY U bYk Zcfa6 ?g ]h ib]hYX k]h\ ch\Yf VY]b[g6 MY _bck bch\]b[ cZ h\]g( 7ZhYf XYUh\ h\Y gci` VYWcaYg gcaYh\]b[ X]ZZYfYbh& gcaYh\]b[ ]bXYgWf]VUV`Y( :YUh\ ]g cbY ghYd ]b U Wcbh]bicig XYjY`cdaYbh( vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

Eif `Ugh XUm XcYg bch Vf]b[ XYghfiWh]cb& cb`m U W\Ub[Y( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

:YUh\ ]g U `]VYfUh]cb cZ h\Y gci` Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U` dYfgcbx U`]hm ]b k\]W\ ]h Yl]ghYX ]b h\]g kcf`X( 2RU WKRVH ZKR OLYH D VSLULWXDO OLIH$ WKHUH LV QR GHDWK&

VKVTU Ǽ MY YldYWh fYkUfXg Zcf [ccXbYgg& UbX dib]g\aYbhg Zcf h\Y VUX h\]b[g k\]W\ kY Xc( EZhYb& h\Ym UfY bch ]aaYX]UhY`m Zcfh\Wca]b[( 8ch\ Yj]` UbX [ccX Yl]gh ]b h\Y `]ZY cZ h\Y gd]f]h& h\ci[\& k\]W\ ]g cihg]XY h]aY& UbX h\ci[\ kY aUm bch gYY W`YUf ]bX]WUh]cbg cZ fYkUfX cf dib]g\aYbh& bYjYfx h\Y`Ygg& kY ZYY` fYkUfX cf dib]g\aYbh k]h\ cif WcbgW]YbWY( Oci g\ci`X VY ]b U \iffm hc Xc [ccX kcf_g& YjYb gaU`` cbYg& UbX hc Ujc]X g]b( EbY [ccX h\]b[ `YUXg hc Ubch\Yf& UbX cbY g]b WUigYg Ubch\Yf( J\Y fYkUfX Zcf j]fhiY ]g j]fhiY& UbX h\Y dib]g\aYbh Zcf j]WY ]g acfY j]WY( vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\Y kcfgh dib]g\aYbh ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh mci ZU]`YX hc dfcdYf`m igY h\cgY [ccX h\]b[g k\]W\ kYfY []jYb hc mci( :c bch YldYWh U V][ dib]g\aYbh( J\YfY WUb VY bc \UfXYf dib]g\aYbh h\Ub h\]g fYacfgY( CRX VHHN WKH FDXVH RI HYLO$ DQG LW LV RQO\ LQ \RXUVHOI& v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

:c]b[ [ccX ]g h\Y cb`m gifY dUh\ hc V`]gg( :c bch YldYWh gcaY hUb[]V`Y fYkUfX mcif UWh]cbg UfY h\Y]f ckb fYkUfX( ?b bch h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUb \cdY hc Ujc]X Yj]` UWhg& Zcf mcif dib]g\aYbh U`fYUXm Oci UfY a]ghU_Yb ]Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y kUg WUigYX Vm Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY(

Zcf mcif [ccXbYgg5 h\Y gUaY kUm& Xc dib]g\aYbh cZ mcif `]Yg ]b mcifgci`( dU]b ]b mcif gci`

VKVTU Ä IY`Z'UVbY[Uh]cb ]g bch h\Y fY^YWh]cb cZ mcif Ybh]fY gY`Z& ^igh h\Y fY^YWh]cb cZ mcif Ub]aU` VY]b[( ;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug k]h\]b \]agY`Z h\Y WUdUV]`]hm hc ibXYfx ghUbX h\Y `]ZY cZ U`` \iaUb]hm( J\]g WUdUV]`]hm ]g \]XXYb XYYd ]b h\Y gci`& Vih ]h Yl]ghg& UbX gccbYf cf `UhYf& U dYfgcb k]`` Z]bX ]h( v;:M7H: 97HF;DJ;H

J\Y [fYUhYgh V`]gg U dYfgcb WUb _bck ]g h\Y ghUhY cZ Wcax d`YhY ZfYYXca UbX \Udd]bYgg h\Uh WUb WcaY cb`m h\fci[\ gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY UbX `cjY( :Ybm mcif dYfgcbU`]hm& UbX mci k]`` WcaY hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y \][\Ygh [ccX ]b `]ZY4 `cjY( =HDO OLIH VWDUWV ZLWK VHOI%VDFULILFH& vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

J\Y acfY U dYfgcb []jYg hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y& UbX h\Y `Ygg \Y Ug_g Zcf \]agY`Z& h\Y VYhhYf Zcf \]a( J\Y `Ygg \Y []jYg hc ch\Yfg& UbX h\Y acfY \Y kUbhg Zcf \]agY`Z& h\Y kcfgY Zcf \]a( Eif WcbhYadcfUf]Yg h\]b_ ]h h\Y fYjYfgY(

VKVTU Ć <cf h\Y acgh dUfh& ZU`gY UbX \UfaZi` cd]b]cbg UfY X]ghf]Vx ihYX UbX giddcfhYX Vm ]bZ`iYbWY( MY UfY hcc `]_Y`m hc UWWYdh h\Y j]Ykg UbX h\ci[\hg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y k]h\cih hfm]b[ hc ]bjYgh][UhY h\Ya XYYdYf UbX Zifh\Yf cifgY`jYg( Kb]adcfhUbh dYcd`Y UfY h\cgY k\c UWWYdh ch\Yf dYcd`Yrg h\ci[\hg k]h\cih XYjY`cd]b[ h\Ya h\YagY`jYg( Ocif h\ci[\h ]g YUg]`m ]bZ`iYbWYX Vm h\Y dfYgYbWY cZ Ubch\Yf gci`5 U dYfgcb WUb VY Wcad`YhY`m ZfYY cb`m k\Yb \Y ]g U`cbY( Dch\]b[ ]g acfY \UfaZi` h\Ub U VUX YlUad`Y gYh Vm ch\x Yfg( J\Ym Vf]b[ ]bhc cif `]ZY bch]cbg k\]W\ bYjYf kci`X \UjY cWWiffYX hc ig k]h\cih Ub YlUad`Y( 0R QRW DOORZ \RXUVHOI WR EH LQIHFWHG E\ WKH PRRG RU VSLULW RI WKRVH ZKR DEXVH \RX+ GR QRW VWHS RQWR WKHLU SDWK& vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

7 dYfgcb WUb YUg]`m [fck UWWighcaYX hc `]j]b[ U `]Y& YgdYx W]U``m ]Z \Y gYYg YjYfmcbY UfcibX \]a `]j]b[ ]b h\Y gUaY kUm( <U`gY ]XYUg k\]W\ [U]b WiffYbWm WUb YUg]`m VY fYWc[b]nYX Vm h\Y `ciX ZUbZUfY k]h\ k\]W\ h\Ym UfY UWWcadUb]YX( HYU` hfih\ XcYg bch bYYX Ubm cihYf YaVY``]g\aYbhg( J\Y dcgg]V]`]hm cZ ]bZ`iYbW]b[ ch\Yfg WUigYg U dYfgcb k]h\ \][\ acfU`g hc VY acfY ghf]Wh UVcih \]g kcfXg UbX UWh]cbg k\]W\ Wci`X ]bZ`iYbWY ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

VKVTU Ă J\Y ]bhY``YWh ]g h\Y cb`m Z]h [i]XY Zcf \iaUb `]ZY( J\Y `][\h cZ h\Y VcXm ]g h\Y YmY4 h\YfYZcfY k\Yb h\]bY YmY ]g g]b[`Y& h\m k\c`Y VcXm U`gc ]g Zi`` cZ `][\h5 Vih k\Yb h\]bY YmY ]g Yj]`& h\m VcXm U`gc ]g Zi`` cZ XUf_bYgg( JU_Y \YYX h\YfYx ZcfY h\Uh h\Y `][\h k\]W\ ]g ]b h\YY VY bch XUf_bYgg( vBKA; ++4-.'-/

7 aUb k\c `]jYg Ub ]bhY``YWhiU` `]ZY ]g `]_Y U aUb k\c WUfx f]Yg U `UbhYfb ]b Zfcbh cZ \]a hc `][\h \]g kUm( IiW\ U dYfgcb k]`` bYjYf WcaY hc U XUf_ d`UWY& VYWUigY h\Y `][\h cZ \]g ]bhY``YWh acjYg VYZcfY \]a( J\YfY ]g bc ZYUf cZ XYUh\ ]b h\]g _]bX cZ `]ZY& VYWUigY h\Y `UbhYfb k\]W\ acjYg VYZcfY mci `][\hg mcif kUm hc mcif `Ugh a]bihY& UbX mci Zc``ck ]h hc h\Y YbX Ug WU`a`m UbX ei]Yh`m Ug mci \UjY U`` cZ mcif `]ZY( >RPH SHRSOH OLYH DQG DFW DFFRUGLQJ WR WKHLU RZQ WKRXJKWV$ DQG VRPH DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH WKRXJKWV RI RWKHUV+ WKLV LV D FUXFLDO GLVWLQFWLRQ EHWZHHQ SHRSOH&

VKVTU Ĉ LUb]hm \Ug bc `]a]hg( 7 dYfgcb Z]``YX k]h\ jUb]hm ]g gc ]bjc`jYX k]h\ \]agY`Z h\Uh h\YfY ]g bc fcca ]bg]XY \]a Zcf UbmcbY cf Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY( vF7D

7g fi`Yg [c& sOci g\ci`X VY\UjY ^igh Ug ch\Yf dYcd`Y VY\UjYt ]g Uacb[ h\Y acgh XUb[Yfcig5 ]h U`acgh U`kUmg fYgi`hg ]b mcif VY\Uj]b[ VUX`m( v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

CRX FRXOG FKRRVH QR ZRUVH ZD\ WR JXLGH \RXU OLIH WKDQ WR IROc ORZ WKH RSLQLRQV RI RWKHU SHRSOH& M\Yb kY dfU]gY ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]h ]g h\Ym `cc_ `]_Y ig5 cZhYb hc fYgdYWh \]a cb h\Y gUaY `YjY` Ug cbYgY`Z(

VYWUigYkY h\]b_ h\Uh U dYfgcb aYUbg hc dih v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

HYU` j]fhiY bYjYf `cc_g VUW_ cb ]hg g\UXck& ZUaY( v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

?hrg bch k]gY hc VY ]bhYfYghYX ]b ZUaY UbX h\Y UddfYW]Uh]cb cZ ch\Yfg& VYWUigY bc hkc dYcd`Yrg cd]b]cbg UVcih k\Uh ]g [ccX UfY h\Y gUaY(

VKVTU Ǻ ?KH RSLQLRQ RI D UHYHUHG ZULWHU RU WKLQNHU FDQ KDYH D GHHS LQIOXHQFH RQ VRFLHW\+ LW FDQ DOVR EH D ELJ REVWDFOH WR XQGHUc VWDQGLQJ UHDO WUXWK& :]j]bY hfih\ aUm VY fYjYU`YX ]b h\Y gdYYW\ cZ W\]`XfYb& cf ]b h\Y fUj]b[g UbX b][\haUfYg cZ aUXaYb5 cf ]b h\Y cfX]x bUfm WcbjYfgUh]cbg cZ g]ad`Y dYcd`Y( 7bX kYU_ UbX ZU`gY h\ci[\hg aUm VY ZcibX ]b Vcc_g k\]W\ \UjY WcaY hc VY Wcbg]XYfYX [fYUh& cf YjYb gUWfYX( CUbm ghUhYaYbhg k\]W\ UfY UWWYdhYX Ug hfih\ VYWUigY h\Ym \UjY VYYb dUggYX Xckb hc ig Vm hfUX]h]cb `cc_ `]_Y hfih\ cb`m VYWUigY kY \UjY bYjYf hYghYX h\Ya& bYjYf h\ci[\h UVcih h\Ya ]b U acfY dfYW]gY kUm( <cf h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ aUb_]bX& fY`][]cb ]g U \UV]h& cf& acfY dfYW]gY`m& hfUX]h]cb ]g h\Y]f fY`][]cb( J\ci[\ ]h gYYag ghfUb[Y& ? h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y Z]fgh ghYd hc acfU` dYfZYWh]cb ]g mcif `]VYfUh]cb Zfca h\Y fY`][]cb ]b k\]W\ mci kYfY fU]gYX( Dch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb \Ug WcaY hc dYfZYWh]cb YlWYdh Vm Zc``ck]b[ h\]g kUm( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

7 h\ci[\h k\]W\ ]g YldfYggYX ]b h\Y E`X JYghUaYbh& cf ]b h\Y DYk JYghUaYbh& cf ]b h\Y AcfUb cf ]b h\Y ?bX]Ub X]j]bY Vcc_ h\Y KdUb]g\UXg& XcYg bch VYWcaY U hfih\ VYWUigY ]h ]g YldfYggYX ]b U Vcc_ k\]W\ ]g Wcbg]XYfYX hc VY \c`m( ?Z kY h\]b_ h\Uh YjYfm kcfX ]b YjYfm \c`m Vcc_ ]g hfiY& h\Yb kY \UjY WfYUhYX Ub ]Xc`( 7bm ]adcfhUbh h\ci[\h& bc aUhhYf k\YfY ]h WcaYg Zfca& g\ci`X VY X]gWiggYX5 UbX YjYfm h\ci[\h& bc aUhhYf k\c gU]X ]h& g\ci`X VY []jYb UhhYbh]cb(

VKVTU Ċ J\Y aU^cf]hm cZ Yj]`g dYcd`Y Wcaa]h UfY h\Y fYgi`h& bch cZ Ub Yj]` k]``& Vih cZ h\Y X]ggYa]bUh]cb cZ Yj]` h\ci[\hg k\]W\ dYcd`Y UWWYdh UbX Zc``ck ibWf]h]WU``m( CUhYf]U` fYgi`hg UfY h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ ibgYYbTZcfWYg4 Ub Ufh]``Yfm g\Y`` h\Uh WcaYg hc ig kUg g\ch Zfca Ub ibgYYb WUbbcb Uh Ub ib_bckb h]aY( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U`` ]adcfx hUbh YjYbhg cf][]bUhY ]b U h\ci[\h( v>;DH? 7C?;B

Eif UWh]cbg UfY bY]h\Yf Ug [ccX bcf Ug j]W]cig Ug cif XYg]fYg( BK9 :; LUijYbUf[iYg

?KLQN RQO\ JRRG WKRXJKWV$ DQG ZLWK WLPH WKH\ ZLOO EHFRPH JRRG GHHGV& J\ci[\hg k\]W\ WfYUhY Yj]` UWh]cbg UfY aiW\ kcfgY h\Ub h\Y UWhg h\YagY`jYg( Oci WUb ghcd Xc]b[ U VUX h\]b[& UbX fYdYbh& UbX bch fYdYUh ]h( 8ih VUX h\ci[\hg UfY fYdYUhYX U[U]b UbX U[U]b& UbX WUigY ch\Yf VUX UWh]cbg5 VUX h\ci[\hg Zc``ck cbY UZhYf Ubch\Yf( J\]b_ [ccX h\ci[\hg& UbX mcif h\ci[\hg k]`` VY hifbYX ]bhc [ccX UWh]cbg( ;jYfmh\]b[ VY[]bg ]b h\ci[\h( =i]X]b[ mcif h\ci[\hg ]g cbY cZ h\Y _Ymg hc gY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb( ?Z mci giZZYf a]gZcfhibYg ]b mcif `]ZY& `cc_ Zcf h\Y]f WUigY& bch ]b mcif UWh]cbg& Vih ]b h\Y h\ci[\hg k\]W\ ]bgd]fYX h\Ya& UbX hfm hc ]adfcjY h\cgY h\ci[\hg( ?Z mci UfY ]bgd]fYX Vm Ub YjYbh ]b mcif `]ZY& `cc_ Zcf ]hg cf][]bg ]b mcif dfYj]cig h\ci[\hg k\]W\ WUigYX h\Y YjYbh(

VKVTU ÁÀ Oci aU_Y mcif XYW]g]cbg ]b h\Y dfYgYbh& UbX h\Y dfYgYbh Yl]ghg cih cZ h]aY5 ]h ]g U h]bm acaYbh k\YfY hkc dYf]x cXgvh\Y dUgh UbX h\Y ZihifYvaYYh( ?b h\Y dfYgYbh mci UfY U`kUmg ZfYY hc aU_Y mcif W\c]WY( 7 k]gY aUb kUg Ug_YX k\Uh kUg h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h]aY& dYfgcb& UbX h\]b[ ]b `]ZY( >Y UbgkYfYX& sJ\Y acgh ]adcfx hUbh h]aY ]g h\Y dfYgYbh h]aY& VYWUigY Uh h\]g h]aY U dYfgcb \Ug dckYf cjYf \]agY`Z( J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh dYfgcb ]g h\Y cbY k]h\ k\ca mci XYU` Uh dfYgYbh& VYWUigY h\YfY ]g bc [iUfUbhYY h\Uh mci k]`` YjYf VY UV`Y hc XYU` k]h\ Ubm ch\Yf dYfgcb ]b h\]g kcf`X( J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[ ]g hc `cjY h\]g dYfgcb& VYWUigY YjYfmcbY ]g gYbh ]bhc h\]g kcf`X k]h\ h\Y gc`Y difdcgY cZ `cj]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(t Eb`m k\Yb kY igY YjYfm a]bihY cZ cif `]ZY k]`` kY _bck h\Uh kY UfY YhYfbU`( v>7HH?;J C7H>D;7K

7 acgh XUb[Yfcig hYadhUh]cb ]g h\Y hYadhUh]cb hc dfYx dUfY hc `]jY& ]bghYUX cZ `]j]b[( J\Y ZihifY XcYg bch VY`cb[ hc mci( J\YfYZcfY& fYaYaVYf hc `]jY h\Y VYgh kUm mci _bck QRZ& J\Y cb`m dYfZYWh]cb bYWYggUfm ]g dYfZYWh]cb ]b `cjY& k\]W\ WUb VY fYUW\YX cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh( ?hrg k\m kY WUaY ]bhc h\]g kcf`X( ?KH SUHVHQW LV WKH PRPHQW LQ ZKLFK WKH GLYLQH QDWXUH RI OLIH LV UHYHDOHG& 8HW XV UHVSHFW RXU SUHVHQW WLPH+ 3RG H[LVWV LQ WKLV

VKVTU ÁÁ - SHUVRQ GLHV DV KH OLYHV KLV VSLULWXDO OLIH$ DORQH& M\Uh mci Xc& mci dcggYgg( Oci aigh VY`]YjY h\Uh YhYfbU` [ccXbYgg Yl]ghg h\Uh ]g k]h\]b mci& UbX h\Uh ]h [fckg UbX XYjY`cdg Ug `cb[ Ug mci `]jY( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

Oci U`cbY d`Ub hc Wcaa]h U g]b& mci U`cbY d`Ub hc Xc Yj]`5 UbX mci U`cbY WUb YgWUdY g]b UbX dif]Zm mcif h\ci[\hg( Eb`m mcif ]bbYf gY`Z WUb XUab mci& UbX cb`m mcif ]bbYf gY`Z WUb gUjY mci( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 dYfgcb aUm Ug_ =cX cf ch\Yf dYcd`Y Zcf \Y`d& Vih cb`m \]g [ccX `]ZY WUb \Y`d \]a& UbX h\]g \Y aigh Xc cb \]g ckb( ;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug U XYdh\ hc \]g ]bbYf `]ZY& Ub YggYbWY h\Uh WUbbch VY Yld`U]bYX( IcaYh]aYg mci kUbh hc Yld`U]b h\]g YggYbWY hc dYcd`Y& Vih mci k]`` gYY h\Uh ]h ]gbrh dcgg]V`Y hc Yld`U]b ]h hc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb gc h\Uh \Y ibXYfghUbXg( >YbWY h\Y bYYX Zcf mcif ckb W\UbbY` cZ Wcaaib]WUx h]cb k]h\ =cX( ;ghUV`]g\ h\]g W\UbbY` UbX Xc bch gYY_ Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY(

VKVTU ÁÂ J\Y VifXYb& h\Y Wfcgg& k\]W\ YjYfm aUb \Ug hc WUffm Yl]ghg cb hkc d`UbYg4 U `cb[Yf jYfh]WU` d`UbY& k\]W\ ]g h\Y k]`` cZ =cX5 UbX U aiW\ g\cfhYf& \cf]ncbhU` d`UbY&k\]W\ ]g U aUbrg ckb k]``( ?Z mci cf]Ybh mcif k]`` gc h\Uh ]h dUfU`x `Y`g h\Y X]fYWh]cb cZ =cXrg k]``& h\Yb mcik]`` \UjY bc Wfcgg hc WUffm& bc VifXYb( HYU` \Udd]bYgg WUb VY Vi]`h cb`m Vm \Ufacb]n]b[ mcif `]ZY k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX( vBK9O C7BEHO

4H ZKR LV QRW ZLWK 9H LV DJDLQVW 9H+ DQG KH ZKR GRHV QRW JDWKHU ZLWK 9H$ VFDWWHUV& vBKA; ++4,-

?Z mci kUbh hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y k]`` cZ =cX& U`` k]`` VY [ccX5 ]Z mci kUbh hc Zi`Z]`` mcif ckb k]``& UbX ]h XcYg bch Wc]bW]XY k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX& U`` k]`` VY Yj]`( J\Y cb`m kUm hc _bck =cX UbX hc VY`]YjY ]b YhYfb]hm ]g hc ib]hY mcif ckb k]`` k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX(

VKVTU ĄǼ Jc VY k]gY& mci aigh Zc``ck mcif ]bhY``YWh& YjYb h\ci[\ giW\ U kUm cZ `]ZY ]g cZhYb UhhUW_YX( J\Y \YUjYbg Xc bch UddfcjY k\Yb kY g]b& UbX h\Y YUfh\ XcYg bch UddfcjY k\Yb kY UfY j]fhicig( vJ\Y J7BCK:

:c bch VY ]bhYfYghYX ]b h\Y eiUbh]hm cZ dYcd`Y k\c fYgdYWh UbX UXa]fY mci& Vih ]b h\Y]f eiU`]hm( ?Z VUX dYcd`Y X]g`]_Y mci& gc aiW\ h\Y VYhhYf( ' ,vBiW]ig 7bbUYig IYbYWU

4XPDQ LQWHOOHFW$ LV D GLYLQH ODPS$ DQG LWV OLJKW$ SHQHWUDWHV WR WKH GHSWK RI WKLQJV& v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

Oci g\ci`X bch VY idgYh Vm h\Y g][\h cZ k]gXca VY]b[ Wf]h]W]nYX( M]gXca kci`X bch VY fYU` k]gXca ]Z ]h X]X bch fYjYU` h\Y ghid]X]hm cZ U VUX `]ZY& UbX dYcd`Y kci`X bch VY dYcd`Y ]Z h\Ym YbXifYX h\]g fYjY`Uh]cb k]h\cih Wf]h]W]ga(

VKVTU ÁÄ FYcd`Y \UjY VYWcaY hcc UWWighcaYX hc h\Y igY cZ ZcfWY( B]ZY k]h\cih j]c`YbWY gYYag ]adcgg]V`Y Zcf h\Ya hc ]aU[]bY( Jkc kUmg Yl]gh hc [i]XY \iaUb UWh]j]hm( EbY ]g hc ZcfWY U dYfgcb hc UWh U[U]bgh \]g k]g\Yg5 h\Y ch\Yf ]g hc [i]XY U dYfx gcbrg k]g\Yg& hc dYfgiUXY \]a k]h\ fYUgcb]b[( EbY ]g h\Y kUj cZ j]c`YbWY4 ]Z( ]g igYX Vm ][bcfUbh dYcd`Y& UbX ]h `YUXg hc Wcad`YhY X]gUddc]bhaYbh( J\Y ch\Yf ]g giddcfhYX Vm YldYf]YbWY& UbX ]g U`kUmg giWWYggZi`( v78H7>7C 9EC8

!BLWKRXW$ IDLWK LQ 3RG$ \RX FDQ IRUFH SHRSOH WR DFW&$ KXW& \RX FDQQRW$ FRQYLQFH WKHP& CRX FDQ EHFRPH D W\UDQW&$ EXW& QRW& D WHDFKHU& v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

FYcd`Y UfY k]gY VY]b[g5 h\Ym dcggYgg h\Y UV]`]hm hc `]jY UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y X]WhUhYg cZ h\Y]f ]bhY``YWh& UbX gccbYf cf `UhYf& h\Ym k]`` Yjc`jY Zfca U ghUhY cZ j]c`YbWY hc U ghUhY cZ Wcad`YhY \Ufacbm UbX ibXYfghUbX]b[( 7bX YjYfm UWh cZ j]c`YbWY aU_Yg h\]g h]aY acfY X]ghUbh Zfca hcXUm(

VKVTU ĄĆ -OO RWKHU DUJXPHQWV DJDLQVW PHDW HDWLQJ$ QR PDWWHU KRZ VWURQJ WKH\ DUH$ DUH PHDQLQJOHVV LQ UHODWLRQ WR WKH IDFW WKDW$ DQLPDOV KDYH WKH VDPH OLIH VSLULW WKDW$ H[LVWV LQ XV& MY g\ci`X ZYY` h\Uh Vm hU_]b[ Ub Ub]aU` `]ZYkY Wcaa]h gcaYh\]b[ W`cgY hc gi]W]XY( Dc ch\Yf Uf[iaYbh U[U]bgh aYUh YUh]b[ ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf h\cgY k\c \UjY h\]g ]bbYf ZYY`]b[( ;Uh]b[ U `ch cZ aYUh WUb aU_Y mcif VcXm ghfcb[Yf& Vih ]h kYU_Ybg mcif a]bX( vFBKJ7H9>

?h ]g jYfm ]adcfhUbh bch hc _]`` W\]`XfYbrg bUhifU` hUghY Vm ZcfW]b[ h\Ya hc VYWcaY aYUh YUhYfg& bch cb`m Zcf h\Y]f \YU`h\& Vih Zcf h\Y gU_Y cZ h\Y]f W\UfUWhYf( MY Xc bch _bck h\Y fYUgcb& Vih kY _bck h\Uh dYcd`Y k\c YUh U `ch cZ aYUh UfY igiU``m WfiY`( v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

MY WUbbch W`cgY cif YmYg hc h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c YUh aYUh Zcf h\Y gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ h\Y]f dUadYfYX hUghYg( J\Y `c[]WU` Uf[iaYbhg U[U]bgh aYUh YUh]b[ UfY bch ghfcb[ Ybci[\( Bc[]W ]g [ccX& Vih ]b gcaY WUgYg ]h ZU``g g\cfh( 8ih _bck h\]g4 h\Y acfY WcadUgg]cb U dYfgcb g\ckg ch\Yf `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg& h\Y _]bXYf UbX VYhhYf \Y ]g( Jc _]`` Ub]x aU`g& k\Yh\Yf Zcf gdcfh cf Zcf ZiY`& ]g jYfm WfiY`(

VKVTU ÁĂ MY UfY gd]f]hiU``m WcbbYWhYX cb U`` g]XYg& bch cb`m k]h\ dYcd`Y Vih k]h\ U`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg( IcaYcbY hc`X aY cbWY h\Uh YjYfm dYfgcb \Ug Ub Y`YaYbh cZ [ccX UbX Ub Y`YaYbh cZ VUX k]h\]b \]a& UbX h\Uh Y]h\Yf h\Y [ccX cf h\Y VUX WUb VY aUb]ZYghYX UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y dYfgcbrg accX( MY dcggYgg k]h\]b ig hkc X]ZZYfYbh kUmg cZ ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\]g kcf`X( EbY ]g h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ VY]b[ X]j]XYX& X]ghUbWYX& UbX U`]YbUhYX Zfca YUW\ ch\Yf5 ]b h\]g ghUhY& U`` h\]b[g gYYa [`ccam hc ig( MY ZYY` bch\]b[ YlWYdh ^YU`cigm& ]bX]ZZYfYbWY& UbX \UhfYX( ? kci`X `]_Y hc WU`` h\Y cddcg]hY kUm cZ ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ ib]jYfgU` ib]Z]WUh]cb( ?b h\]g ghUhY& U`` dYcd`Y gYYa jYfm W`cgY hc ig& UbX U`` UfY YeiU` Uacb[ h\YagY`jYg( J\]g ghUhY& h\YfYZcfY& UfcigYg WcadUgg]cb UbX `cjY ]b ig( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

-OO SHRSOH KDYH WKH VDPH RULJLQ$ DUH KRXQG$ K\ WKH VDPH ODZ$ DQG ZHUH FUHDWHG IRU WKH VDPH SXUSRVH& J\YfYZcfY& kY g\ci`X \UjY cbY ZU]h\& cbY difdcgY hc cif UWh]cbg& cbY VUbbYf ibXYf k\]W\ kY `]jY UbX Z][\h( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

MY g\ci`X U`kUmg hfm hc Z]bX h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ Xc bch gYdUfUhY ig Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Y Vih k\]W\ ib]hY ig( Jc kcf_ U[U]bgh YUW\ ch\Yf& hc VYUb[fm UbXhifb mcif VUW_ cb YUW\ ch\Yf& ]g hc kcf_ U[U]bgh bUhifY( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Jfm hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y ib]hm cZ U`` `]j]b[ h\]b[g( Jfm hc gYfjY UbX giZZYf k]h\ U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g(

VKVTU ÁÅ A]bXbYgg ]g U bYWYggUfm UXX]h]cb hc YjYfmh\]b[( 7]` h\Y VYgh eiU`]h]Yg cZ aUb_]bX UfY aYUb]b[`Ygg UbX kcfh\`Ygg k]h\cih _]bXbYgg& UbX YjYb h\Y kcfgh j]WYg WUb VY YUg]`m Zcf[]jYb k]h\ _]bXbYgg( J\YfY ]g U bUhifU` _]bXbYgg k\]W\ WcaYg Zfca cif YlhYfbU` Uhhf]VihYg& Zfca cif ]b\Yf]hUbWY& UiX]YbWY& [ccX cf VUX ]bX]x [Ygh]cb& giWWYgg& YhW( J\]g _]bX cZ _]bXbYgg ]g jYfm d`YUgUbh& Vch\ Zcf h\Y dYfgcb k\c YldYf]YbWYg ]h UbX Zcf h\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX \]a( 7bX h\YfY ]g Ubch\Yf hmdY cZ _]bXbYgg k\]W\ WcaYg Zfca ]bbYf gd]f]hiU` kcf_( J\]g _]bXbYgg ]g `Ygg UhhfUWh]jY& Vih U`h\ci[\ h\Y Z]fgh _]bXbYgg WUb YUg]`m W\Ub[Y cf VY hfUbgZcfaYX ]bhc \UhfYX& h\Y gYWcbX _]bX cZ _]bXbYgg k]`` bYjYf X]gUddYUf UbX k]`` WcbghUbh`m [fck( J\Y [ccXbYgg k\]W\ mci Xc []jYg mci d`YUgifY& Vih bch gUh]gZUWh]cb( Dc aUhhYf \ck aiW\ [ccXbYgg mci Xc& mci g\ci`X k]g\ hc Xc acfY UbX acfY( v9ED<K9?KI

7LQGQHVV LV WKH PDMRU TXDOLW\ RI WKH VRXO& 5I D SHUVRQ LV QRW NLQG$ LW LV EHFDXVH KH ZDV VXEMHFWHG WR VRPH OLH$ SDVVLRQ$ RU WHPSWDWLRQ ZKLFK YLRODWHG KLV QDWXUDO VWDWH&

VKVTU ÁǺ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g hfiY VYWUigY ]h WUb UbgkYf h\Y acgh X]gx hUbh& UVghfUWh eiYgh]cbg& UbX Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY& ]h WUb gc`jY U`` dfUWh]WU` ]ggiYg cZ `]ZY Ug kY``( ?h YghUV`]g\YX h\Y _]b[x Xca cZ =cX ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ YjYfm ]bX]j]XiU`& UbX ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ \iaUb]hm ]b [YbYfU`( 9\f]gh kUg gYbh hc h\]g kcf`X hc Vf]b[ [ccX bYkg( J\]g kUg \]g aU^cf kcf_( 8ih Xc h\Ym hYUW\ h\]g h\]b[ ]b \]g bUaY6 >Y kUbhYX hc W\Ub[Y g`UjYfm ]bhc ZfYYXca( ?g h\]g hUi[\h ]b \]g bUaY6 MYfYh\Ym Zi`Z]``YX& h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y kUbhYX hc Zi`Z]``6 :]Xdccf dYcd`Y \YUf h\Y [ccX bYkg6 >UjY h\Y Vfc_Yb \YUfhg VYYb WifYX6 9Ub h\Y V`]bX dYcd`Y gYY6 >UjY U`` h\Y g\UW_`Yg VYYb hU_Yb Zfca h\Y df]gcbYfg6 7fY h\Y ]baUhYg gYh ZfYY6 Dc( 9\f]gh ]g gh]`` cb \]g Wfcgg& kU]h]b[ Zcf \]g Udcgh`Yg( J\Ym g\ci`X WcaY Ug gccb Ug dcgg]V`Y& VYWUigY h\Y giZZYf]b[ ]g hYff]V`Y& UbX \]g YmYg UfY h]fYX cZ `cc_]b[ hc h\Y YUgh UbX kU]h]b[ Zcf h\Y gibf]gY cZ h\Y h]aY cZ h\Y `cfX( v<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

=HOLJLRQ LV WUXH QRW EHFDXVH LW ZDV WDXJKW E\ WKH VDLQWV$ EXW& WKH VDLQWV WDXJKW$ LW& EHFDXVH LW& LV WUXH& v=EJJ>EB: ;F>H7?C B;II?D=

Eb`m fY`][]cb XYghfcmg Y[c]ga UbX gY`Z]g\bYgg& gc h\Uh cbY ghUfhg hc `]jY `]ZY bch cb`m Zcf \]agY`Z( Eb`m fY`][]cb XYghfcmg h\Y ZYUf cZ XYUh\& cb`m fY`][]cb []jYg ig h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY& cb`m fY`][]cb WfYUhYg YeiU`]hm Uacb[ dYcx d`Y& cb`m fY`][]cb gYhg U dYfgcb ZfYY Zfca cihYf dfYggifYg( MY aigh VY`]YjY h\cgY gd]f]hiU` XcWhf]bYg k\]W\ dfcj]XY U jYfm g]ad`Y UbX dfUWh]WU` [i]XY Zcf YjYfm cbY cZ ig(

VKVTU ÁĄ B]ZY ]g WcbghUbh acjYaYbh& UbX h\YfYZcfY [ccXbYgg ]b `]ZY ]g bch U WYfhU]b ghUhY& Vih h\Y X]fYWh]cb cZ acjYaYbh( J\]g X]fYWh]cb ]g bch ]b gYfj]b[ mcifgY`Z& Vih =cX( IcaY dYcd`Y gYY_ [ccXbYgg ]b dckYf& ch\Yfg ]b gW]x YbWY& ch\Yfg ]b X]gg]dUh]cb( J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c UfY fYU``m W`cgY hc [ccXbYgg ibXYfghUbX h\Uh fYU` [ccXbYgg Zcf cbY ]g k\Yb U`` dYcd`Y \UjY h\]g [ccXbYgg UbX g\UfY ]h Uacb[ h\YagY`jYg( v8B7?I; F7I97B

4DSSLQHVV LV D WKLQJ ZKLFK D SHUVRQ ZLVKHV RQO\ IRU KLPVHOI JRRGQHVV LV D WKLQJ ZKLFK D SHUVRQ ZLVKHV IRU KLPVHOI DQG IRU RWKHUV& 4DSSLQHVV FDQ KH DFKLHYHG E\ VWUXJJOH+ JRRGQHVV$ RQ WKH FRQWUDU\$ E\ EHLQJ KXPEOH& HYU` [ccXbYgg ]g hc gYfjY =cX( Oci g\ci`X Xc [ccXbYgg k]h\cih W\ccg]b[ hc k\ca( =ccX h\]b[g& cbWY XcbY& k]`` bYjYf X]gUddYUf& YjYb ]Z mci Zcf[Yh UVcih h\Ya( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY kUm hc VY \Uddm& UbX h\]g ]g U gifY kUm4 hc Xc [ccXbYgg UbX hc g\UfY h\]g [ccXx bYgg k]h\ ch\Yfg(

VKVTU ÂÀ 7bmcbY k\c ]g Yb[U[YX ]b fYU``m ]adcfhUbh h\]b[g ]g jYfm g]ad`Y VYWUigY \Y XcYg bch \UjY h]aY hc WfYUhY ibbYWYgx gUfm h\]b[g( ;jYfm XYg]fY UVUhYg& UbX YjYfm j]WY [fckg UZhYf ]h ]g gUh]gZ]YX( v>;DH? 7C?;B

;jYfm bYk XYg]fY ]g h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U bYk k]g\& h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U bYk aUXbYgg( vLEBJ7?H;

F`YUgifY& `ilifmvh\YgY h\]b[g mci WU`` \Udd]bYgg& Vih ? h\]b_ h\Uh hc k]g\ bch\]b[ ]g h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZ =cX& UbX k\Yb mci k]g\ hc \UjY cb`m gaU`` h\]b[g& h\Yb mci aU_Y mcifgY`Z W`cgYf hc h\]g X]j]bY UbX \][\ \Udd]bYgg( vIE9H7J;I

DUhifY fYei]fYg gaU`` h\]b[g5 h\Y Yl]gh]b[ `Uk fYei]fYg aUbm YlWYgg]jY h\]b[g( '''''BK9?KI 7bbUYig IYbYW7h

<HRSOH FDQ OLYH ZLWKRXW QHHG DQG ZLWKRXW MHDORXV\ RQO\ ZKHQ WKH\ OHDG D OLIH RI PRGHUDWLRQ&

VKVTU ÂÁ 7 Zfi]hZi` dfUmYf ]g h\Y YghUV`]g\aYbh ]b mcif WcbgW]cig a]bX cZ h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ `]ZYrg aYUb]b[& UbX mci WUb YldYf]YbWY h\]g ghUhY Xif]b[ h\Y VYgh a]bihYg cZ mcif `]ZY( FfUmYf ]g ibXYfghccX Ug Ub ]bbYf ZcfaU` fY`][]cig gYfj]WY& U gYfj]WY hc Ug_ UbX UW\]YjY gcaY WcadUgg]cb Zcf mcifgY`Z Zfca h\Y \][\Yf ZcfWY5 h\]g ]g U a]gWcbWYdh]cb( Eb h\Y ch\Yf \UbX& h\Y XYg]fY cZ cif \YUfhhc d`YUgY =cX k]h\ U`` cif UWh]cbgvh\]g ]g h\Y gd]f]h cZ fYU` dfUmYf k\]W\ g\ci`X U`kUmg Yl]gh ]b ig( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

8Uh k\Yb mY dfUm& igY bch jU]b fYdYh]h]cbg& Ug h\Y\YUh\Yb Xc4 Zcf h\Ym h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym g\U`` VY \YUfX Zcfh\Y]f aiW\ gdYU_]b[( 8Y bch mY h\YfYZcfY `]_Y ibhc h\Ya4 Zcf mcif <Uh\Yf _bckYh\ k\Uh h\]b[g mY \UjY bYYX cZ& VYZcfY mY Ug_ \]a( 7ZhYf h\]g aUbbYf h\YfYZcfY dfUm mY4 Eif <Uh\Yf k\]W\ Ufh ]b \YUjYb& >U``ckYX VY h\m bUaY(((( vCUhh\Yk 041'3

;QH KRXU RI KRQHVW$ VHULRXV WKLQNLQJ LV PRUH SUHFLRXV WKDQ ZHHNV VSHQW LQ HPSW\ WDONV& Oci g\ci`X dfUm YjYfm \cif( J\Y acgh bYWYggUfm UbX h\Y acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h Zcfa cZ dfUmYf ]g hc fYaYaVYfv]b gd]hY cZ h\Y biaYfcig X]ghfUWh]cbg cZ `]ZYvmcif cV`][Uh]cbg hc =cX& hc \]g `Uk( Oci VYWcaY gWUfYX& mci VYWcaY idgYh& mci VYWcaY YaVUffUggYX& mci VYWcaY hcc ]bjc`jYX cf X]ghfUWhYX Vm gcaYh\]b[( 8ih mci g\ci`X U`kUmg fYaYax VYf k\c mci UfY UbX k\Uh mci g\ci`X Xc(J\]g ]g k\Uh U fYU` dfUmYf g\ci`X VY UVcih( J\]g ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h ]b h\Y VY[]bx b]b[& Vih k]h\ h]aY mci WUb kcf_ UbX WfYUhY h\]g \UV]h(

$!$"#

?h ]g XUb[Yfcig hc X]ggYa]bUhY h\Y ]XYU h\Uh cif `]ZY ]g difY`m h\Y dfcXiWh cZ aUhYf]U` ZcfWYg UbX h\Uh ]h XYdYbXg Ybh]fY`m cb h\YgY ZcfWYg( J\YfY UfY bc dYcd`Y k\c WUb acfY WcbZigY h\Y bch]cbg cZ [ccX UbX Yj]` h\Ub h\Y gW\c`Ufg cZ cif h]aY( J\Y]f gW]YbWY aU_Yg [ccX dfc[fYgg ]b h\Y ghiXm cZ h\Y aUhYf]U` kcf`X& "Vih ]b h\Y ]bbYf& gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ \iaUb]hm& ]h VYWcaYg Ub ibbYWYggUfm UbX gcaYh]aYg \UfaZi` h\]b[( <U`gY gW]YbWY UbX ZU`gY fY`][]cb YldfYgg h\Y]f Xc[aUg ]b \][\`m Y`YjUhYX `Ub[iU[Y hc aU_Y g]ad`Y dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym UfY amghYf]cig& ]adcfhUbh& UbX UhhfUWh]jY( 8ih h\]g amghYf]cig `Ub[iU[Y ]g bch U g][b cZ k]gXca( J\Y k]gYf U dYfgcb ]g& h\Y g]ad`Yf h\Y `Ub[iU[Y \Y igYg hc YldfYgg \]g h\ci[\hg( vBK9O C7BEHO

?KH WHDFKLQJ DERXW$ \RXU LQQHU OLIH LV WKH PRVW$ XVHIXO RQH& ?b cif h]aY gW]YbWY \Ug ghUfhYX hc []jY X]d`caUg Zcf ]X`YbYgg( J\Y fYU` difdcgY cZ gW]YbWY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y hfih\ cZ h\]g `]ZY( ?hg ZU`gY difdcgY ]g h\Y ^igh]Z]WUh]cb cZ Yj]` ]b h\]g kcf`X( J\YgY UfY h\Y ^iX]W]U` gW]YbWYg& dc`]h]WU` gW]YbWYg& UbX YgdYW]U``m h\Yc`c[m& h\Y gW]YbWY cZ fY`][]cb(

VKVTU ÆǼ ?Z dYcd`Y kYfY Wcad`YhY`m j]fhicig& h\Ym kci`X bYjYf ghYd Ug]XY Zfca h\Y hfih\( 7bX h\]g ]g h\Y WcbXYabUh]cb& h\Uh `][\h ]g WcaY ]bhc h\Y kcf`X& UbX aYb `cjYX XUf_bYgg fUh\Yf h\Ub `][\h& VYWUigY h\Y]f XYYXg kYfY Yj]`( <cf YjYfm cbY h\Uh XcYh\ Yj]` \UhYh\ h\Y `][\h& bY]h\Yf WcaYh\ hc h\Y `][\h& `Ygh \]g XYYXg g\ci`X VY fYdfcjYX( 8ih \Y h\Uh XcYh\ hfih\ WcaYh\ hc h\Y `][\h& h\Uh \]g XYYXg aUm VY aUXY aUb]ZYgh& h\Uh h\Ym UfY kfci[\h ]b =cX( v@E>D -4+3',+

:cbrh VY UZfU]X cZ U dYfgcb ]b Ubm dcg]h]cb& ]b `ck cf \][\ ghUbX]b[& k\Yh\Yf \Y ]g U gW\c`Uf cf Ub ][bcfUbh dYfgcb( ?Z mci fYgdYWh U`` dYcd`Y& mci g\ci`X `cjY U`` dYcd`Y& UbX ZYUf bc cbY( vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

J\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ Ubm [ccX h\]b[ k\]W\ mci \UjY XcbY ]b mcif `]ZY k]`` X]Y Ug gccb Ug mci ghYd Ug]XY Zfca h\Y hfih\( J\Y \][\ gd]f]h k\]W\ `]jYg ]b mci UbX k\]W\ ]g ib]hYX k]h\ mci ]g `cc_]b[ U`` h\Y h]aY Zcf [ccX UbX Yj]`( vC7DK

Jfih\ WUb VY ibXYfghccX cb`m Vm kU]h]b[ UbX kUhW\]b[& UbX k\Yb mci [Yh cbY hfih\& hkc acfY k]`` UddYUf VYZcfY mci( v@E>D HKIA?D

?KH WUXWK LV KDUPIXO RQO\ WR HYLOGRHUV& ?KRVH ZKR GR JRRG ORYH WKH WUXWK&

VKVTU ÂÄ FYcd`Y acjY& ]bWcbgd]Wicig`m Vih WYUgY`Ygg`m& hckUfX h\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX& k\]W\ k]`` VY UW\]YjYX Vm ib]Z]WUh]cb ]b `cjY( ;jYfm g]b[`Y ]bX]j]XiU` dYfgcb& Ug kY`` Ug U`` aUb_]bX hc[Yh\Yf& k]`` W\Ub[Y& UbX k]`` [c cb hc \][\Yf ghU[Yg k]h\cih'ghcdd]b[ ]b h\Y]f XYjY`cdaYbh& h\Y `]a]h cZ k\]W\ ]g =cX \]agY`Z( 7bX h\]g h]aY ]g Wca]b[( '<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

Dc& h\Y kcfX cZ U``'dckYfZi` =cX \Ug bch VYYb hc`X Wcax d`YhY`m( 7bX \]g h\ci[\h \Ug bch VYYb ibXYfghccX Wcax d`YhY`m ]b U`` ]hg XYdh\( >Y WfYUhYX UbX \Y WfYUhYg& UbX \Y k]`` WfYUhY& Zcf aUbm YhYfbU` WYbhif]Yg UZhYf ig5 h\]g h\Y \iaUb a]bX WUbbch YaVfUWY( '=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

? Ua WcaY hc gYbX Z]fY cb h\Y YUfh\5 UbX k\Uh k]`` ?& ]Z ]h VY U`fYUXm _]bX`YX6 IiddcgY mY h\Uh ? Ua WcaY hc []jY dYUWY cb YUfh\6 ? hY`` mci& DUm5 Vih fUh\Yf X]j]g]cb( 'BKA; +,4.3&/+

?KH FRQVWDQW VWUXJJOH EHWZHHQ IOHVK DQG VSLULW ZLOO QHYHU EH ILQLVKHG& ?KLV VWUXJJOH LV HWHUQDO DQG WKH HVVHQFH RI OLIH& ?KH SXUSRVH RI OLIH LV ORYLQJ$ WKH SHQHWUDWLRQ RI HYHU\WKLQJ ZLWK ORYH& 5W LV WKH VORZ DQG JUDGXDO FKDQJH IURP HYLO WR JRRG$ LW LV WKH FUHDWLRQ RI WKH UHDO OLIH$ WKH OLIH ILOHG ZLWK ORYH& J\Y \iaUb kcf`X ]g U`kUmg cb h\Y kUm hc dYfZYWh]cb& UbX h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g dfcWYgg cZ dYfZYWh]cb ]g cbY cZ aUb_]bXrg V][[Ygh ^cmg& UbX h\]g ^cm ]g UWWYgg]V`Y hc YjYfm dYfgcb(

VKVTU ÆĆ Mcf_ ]g h\Y WcbX]h]cb cZ Yl]ghYbWY ]b h\Y aUhYf]U`& d\mg]x WU` kcf`X( ?Z HcV]bgcb \UX bch kcf_YX& \Y kci`X \UjY ZfcnYb hc XYUh\ UbX X]YX Zfca \ib[Yf& UbX YjYfmVcXm WUb gYY h\]g( Ic `UVcf ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb Zcf h\Y gd]f]x hiU` `]ZY Ug kY``& Vih bch U`` dYcd`Y WUb gYY h\]g W`YUf`m& h\ci[\ ]h ]g Ug cVj]cig Ug h\Y bYWYgg]hm cZ d\mg]WU` `UVcf Zcf h\Y VcXm( ?Z Ubm kci`X bch kcf_& bY]h\Yf g\ci`X \Y YUh( v?? J>;II7BED?7DI -4+*

5I \RX DUH GRLQJ QRWKLQJ$ LW PHDQV \RX DUH GRLQJ EDG WKLQJV& J\cgY k\c Xc bch\]b[& Xc VUX h\]b[g( J\cgY k\c Xc bch\]b[& \UjY aUbm UggcW]UhYg UbX giddcfhYfg( J\Y VfU]b cZ U `Unm UbX ]X`Y dYfgcb ]g h\Y ZUjcf]hY ghcdd]b[ d`UWY cZ h\Y XYj]`( DUhifY XcYg bch ghcd ]b U`` _]bXg cZ ]X`YbYgg(

]hgXYjY`cdaYbh&

UbX ]h YlYWihYg

v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

Oci g\ci`X bYjYf VY Ug\UaYX cZ Ubm kcf_& YjYb h\Y `ckx Ygh UbX X]fh]Ygh& Vih mci g\ci`X VY Ug\UaYX cb`m cZ h\Y X]fh]Ygh acfU` ghUhY& h\Uh ]g h\Y ]X`YbYgg cZ mcif VcXm& k\]W\ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm fYgi`h cZ h\Y Wcbgiadh]cb cZ h\Y `UVcf cZ ch\Yfg(

VKVTU ÂĂ 6XVWLFH LV DFKLHYHG QRW LQ VWULYLQJ IRU MXVWLFH$ KXW& ZLWK ORYH& ?b cfXYf hc \]h h\Y aUf_& mci g\ci`X U]a ZUfh\Yf h\Ub ]h ghUbXg& gc mci k]`` UW\]YjY ]h5 ]b cfXYf hc VY ^igh& mci g\ci`X aU_Y U gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY& VY ib^igh hc mcifgY`Z( Dch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb WUb VY Wcad`YhY`m ^igh ]b U`` \]g XYYXg& Vih U ^igh dYfgcb WUb VY Wcad`YhY`m X]ZZYfYbh Zfca Ub ib^igh cbY k]h\ \]g YZZcfhg& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug U hfih\Zi` aUb ]g X]ZZYfYbh Zfca U `]Uf& k]h\ \]g YZZcfhg hc gdYU_ cb`m hfih\( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY `Uk cZ `]ZY k\]W\ ]g fYU``m dfYW]cig4 h\ci[\ mci aYYh U`` h\Y h]aY k]h\ ]b^igh]WY& fYaU]b \iaV`Y( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Oci WUbbch VY Wcad`YhY`m ^igh( EbY h]aY mci Xc hcc `]hx h`Y& h\Y ch\Yf h]aY mci Xc hcc aiW\( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY kUm bch hc g]b U[U]bgh ^igh]WY5 U`kUmg hc W\Ub[Y h\]b[g& hc ]adfcjY h\]b[g& hc aU_Y h\Ya VYhhYf(

VKVTU ÆĈ J\Y VYgh UbX h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh cV^YWh Zcf YjYfm dYfgcb ]g \]g ]bbYf gY`Z& \]g gd]f]hiU` VY]b[( 7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg U`` gW]YbWYg Vih XcYg bch _bck \]ax gY`Z ]g U dccf UbX ][bcfUbh dYfgcb( >Y k\c XcYg bch _bck Ubmh\]b[ YlWYdh Zcf \]g ]bbYf gd]f]hiU` gY`Z ]g Ub Yb`][\hx YbYX dYfgcb( BKHQ \RX IHHO WKH GHVLUH IRU SRZHU$ \RX VKRXOG VWD\ LQ VROLc WXGH IRU VRPH WLPH& v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

J\Y kUm hc ZUaY [cYg h\fci[\ h\Y dU`UWYg& h\Y kUm hc \Udd]bYgg [cYg h\fci[\ h\Y aUf_Yhg& h\Y kUm hc j]fhiY [cYg h\fci[\ h\Y XYgYfhg( v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

7 dYfgcb U`kUmg \Ug U d`UWY hc VY gUZY Zfca U`` cZ \]g a]gx ZcfhibYg& UbX h\]g d`UWY ]g \]g gci`( ?Z mci Wci`X cb`m _bck k\c mci UfY& U`` mcif hfciV`Yg kci`X gYYa ihhYf`m ibbYWYggUfm UbX hf]j]U`(

VKVTU ÂǺ 2DLWK LV WKH IRXQGDWLRQ RQ ZKLFK DOO HOVH UHVWV+ LW LV WKH URRW RI DOO NQRZOHGJH& J\YfY UfY hkc hmdYg cZ ZU]h\ ]b h\]g kcf`X( J\Y Z]fgh ]g ZU]h\ ]b h\]b[g ch\Yf dYcd`Y gUm& ZU]h\ ]b dYcd`Y5 h\YfY UfY aUbm jUf]Yh]Yg cZ h\]g hmdY cZ ZU]h\( J\Y gYWcbX ]g ZU]h\ ]b =cX5 h\]g hmdY cZ ZU]h\ ]g ibjUfm]b[& UbX ]h ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf U`` 'dYcd`Y( <U]h\ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm dfcdYfhm cZ h\Y gci`( <YY` h\Y YggYbx h]U` aYUb]b[`YggbYgg cZ h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY kY``'_bckb hc mci& UbX h\Y [fYUhbYgg cZ h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY ib_bckb Vih ]adcfhUbh( 9`YUjY hc h\Y hYUW\]b[g cZ 9\f]gh Wcad`YhY`m& UbX `Yh [c cZ ch\Yf hYUW\]b[g& ^igh Ug U gU]`cf fYUXg \]g WcadUgg& h\ci[\ ch\Yf g][bg UfcibX \]a a][\h WcbhfUX]Wh ]h( FYcd`Y k\c VY`]YjY h\Ym Xc bch \UjY ZU]h\ UfY kfcb[5 h\Ym g]ad`m Xcbrh fYU`]nY ]h& cf Xcbrh kUbh ]h& cf WUbbch YldfYgg ]h(

VKVTU ÆĊ 5I LQ KLV VRXO$ D SHUVRQ XQGHUVWDQGV 3RG$ KH XQGHUVWDQGV KLV FRQQHFWLRQ WR DOO WKH ZRUOG!V SHRSOH& :c bch VY dfciX& bc aUhhYf k\Uh \][\ dcg]h]cb mci cWWidm ]b `]ZY( ?b mci UbX ]b aY UbX ]b YjYfm" ch\Yf dYfgcb `]jYg h\Y gUaY =cX& h\Y gUaY `]ZY ZcfWY5 mci `cc_ Xckb cb aY ]b jU]b5 kY UfY U`` YeiU` VY]b[g( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

? Ua Z]``YX k]h\ U [fYUh h\ci[\h4 h\Uh cZ h\Y [fYUhbYgg cZ am gci`& ]hg ib]hm k]h\ =cX( Cm gci` ]g bch ib]hYX k]h\ =cX ]b giVa]gg]cb& Vih h\fci[\ ]hg UV]`]hm hc ibXYfghUbX >]a& UbX h\fci[\ >]a& hc VY YhYfbU`( v>;DH? 7C?;B

MY UfY U`` W\]`XfYb cZ h\Y gUaY ZUh\Yf& UbX ]h ]g ibbUhifU` bch hc `cjY cif Vfch\Yfg(

VKVTUT ǼǺ J\cgY k\c UfY cb hcd cZ h\Y acibhU]b WUb gYY h\Y gibf]gY gccbYf h\Ub h\cgY k\c `]jY ]b h\Y jU``Ym( Ic& hcc& k]h\ h\cgY k\c UW\]YjY gd]f]hiU` \Y][\hg4 h\Ym WUb gYY h\Y \YUjx Yb`m gibf]gY gccbYf h\Ub h\cgY k\c `]jY U aUhYf]U` `]ZY( 8ih h\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb h\Y gib k]`` f]gY gc \][\ ]b h\Y g_m h\Uh YjYfmcbY k]`` gYY ]h( BH g\ci`X \cdY h\Uh h\Y XUm k]`` WcaY k\Yb U`` dYcd`Y dYfWY]jY h\Uh h\Y `]ZY cZ U aUb ]g [fYUh cb`m ]b ]hg gYfj]WY hc \]g Vfch\Yfg& Zcf \Y ]g ib]hYX k]h\ h\Ya Vm =cX( v;:M7H: 8HEMD

FckYfZi` ZcfWYg UfY Uh kcf_ ]b h\]g kcf`X( Dc cbY WUb ghcd h\Ya( MY gYY h\Y]f g][bg ]b U bYk ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ fY`][]cb& U bYk fYgdYWh Zcf dYcd`Y& U bYk ZYY`]b[ cZ Vfch\x Yf\ccX( vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

7g gccb Ug h\Y \][\Yf ]XYU` ]g dih VYZcfY ig& U`` ZU`gY ]XYU`g k]`` ZUXY UkUm Ug h\Y ghUfg ZUXY UkUm k\Yb h\Ym aYYh h\Y

VKVTU ǼĄ 7bm kcf_ cZ ZU`gY Ufh dfU]gYX Vm Wf]h]Wg ]g U Xccf h\fci[\ k\]W\ s\mdcWf]hYg cZ Ufht YbhYf cif a]bXg( J\Y WfYUh]cb UbX gU`Y cZ acgh Ufh hcXUm ]g difY dfcgh]hix h]cb( J\Y WcadUf]gcb ]g hfiY ]b YjYfm XYhU]`( HYU` Ufh WUb cb`m fUfY`m VY WfYUhYX YjYb Vm U fYU` Ufh]gh5 `]_Y U W\]`X ]b U ach\Yfrg kcaV& ]h ]g h\Y f]dYbYX Zfi]h cZ \]g df]cf `]ZY( <U`gY Ufh& h\ci[\& WUb VY WYUgY`Ygg`m dfcXiWYX Vm WfUZhgx aYb& UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y X]WhUhYg cZ U aUf_Yh( B]_Y U ZU]h\Zi` k]ZY k\c `cjYg \Yf \igVUbX& fYU` Ufh XcYg bch bYYX Ubm YlWYgg XYWcfUh]cb5 `]_Y U dfcgh]hihY& ZU`gY Ufh XYaUbXg hc VY XYWcfUhYX( JfiY Ufh WcaYg cih cZ Ub Ufh]ghrg if[Ybh bYYX hc YldfYgg h\Y ZYY`]b[g h\Uh \UjY ZcfaYX ]bg]XY \]a& ^igh Ug U ach\Yf bYYXg hc []jY V]fh\ hc \Yf VUVm( <U`gY Ufh UbgkYfg cb`m hc dfcZ]h( HYU` Ufh Vf]b[g bYk ZYY`]b[g ]bhc cif `]ZY& Ug U kcaUb Vf]b[g U bYk dYfgcb ]bhc h\Y kcf`X( <U`gY Ufh Wcffidhg4 ]h aU_Yg U dYfgcb X]gg]dUhYX& X]ghfUWhg \]a& kYU_Ybg \]g gd]f]hiU` dckYf( ;jYfmcbY aigh ibXYfx ghUbX h\]g& ]b cfXYf h\Uh h\Ym g\ib h\Y hYff]V`Y dfc`]ZYfUx h]cb cZ h\]g X]fhm& X]gg]dUhYX hmdY cZ Ufh k\]W\ ]g& cb ]hg ZUWY& dfcgh]hih]cb( CRX FDQQRW VHOO \RXU WDOHQW$ \RXU JHQLXV+ DV VRRQ DV \RX GR$ \RX DUH D SURVWLWXWH& CRX FDQ VHOO \RXU ZRUN$ EXW& QRW& \RXU VRXO& v@E>D HKIA?D

Kbh]` h\Ym h\fck h\Y acbYm W\Ub[Yfg cih cZ h\Y hYad`Y cZ Ufh& ]h k]`` bYjYf VY U fYU` hYad`Y( 8ih h\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb h\YgY gU`YgaYb k]`` VY gYbh UkUm Zfca h\Y hYad`Y cZ Ufh(

FJRUJOHJS Á Ic`X]Yfg k\c ghUbX ]X`Y ]b U g\Y`hYf Xif]b[ U VUhh`Y Ug fYx ]bZcfWYaYbhg k]`` hfm hc ]bjc`jY h\YagY`jYg ]b U`acgh Ubm UWh]j]hm ]b cfXYf hc X]ghfUWh h\YagY`jYg Zfca h\Y ]adYbX]b[ XUb[Yf( ?h gYYag hc aY h\Uh dYcd`Y k\c kUbh hc gUjY h\Yax gY`jYg Zfca `]ZY VY\UjY `]_Y h\YgY gc`X]Yfg4 gcaY X]ghfUWh h\YagY`jYg k]h\ jUb]hm& gcaY k]h\ WUfXg& dc`]h]Wg& `Ukg& kcaYb& [UaV`]b[& \cfgYg& \ibh]b[& k]bY& cf ghUhY UZZU]fg( ?h ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h hc ]aU[]bY k\Uh kcbXYfZi` W\Ub[Yg kci`X cWWif hc \iaUb `]jYg ]Z dYcd`Y kci`X ghcd dc]gcb]b[ h\YagY`jYg k]h\ VfUbXm& k]bY& hcVUWWc& UbX Xfi[g( J\Ym gUm h\Uh h\YfY ]g cbY fY`][]cig gYWh h\Uh Uh h\Y YbX cZ h\Y]f [Uh\Yf]b[g h\Ym hifb Xckb h\Y `][\hg UbX \UjY Ub cf[m( ?b cif gcW]Yhm& dYcd`Y k\c dUfh]W]dUhY ]b WcbghUbh X]gg]dUh]cbg hifb Xckb h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y ]bhY``YWh k]h\ UXX]Wh]jY h\]b[g giW\ Ug Xfi[g& U`Wc\c`& UbX hcVUWWc( 9DNLQJ \RXUVHOI DGGLFWHG LV QRW D FULPH$ EXW LW LV D SUHSDUDc WLRQ IRU FULPH& IcaY dYcd`Y gUm& s?h ]g bch ]adcfhUbh ]Z mci Xf]b_ cf gac_Y(t ?Z ]h ]g cZ bc ]adcfhUbWY& h\Yb k\m bch ^igh ghcd& ]Z mci _bck h\Uh mci \Ufa mcifgY`Z UbX& k]h\ mcif YlUax d`Y& ch\Yfg6

FJRUJOHJS Â J\Y W`cgYf dYcd`Y UfY hc h\Y hfih\& h\Y acfY hc`YfUbh h\Ym UfY cZ h\Y a]ghU_Yg cZ ch\Yfg( J\cgY k\c Xcbrh VY`]YjY ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` ZcibXUh]cbg cZ h\Y]f ZU]h\& k\c cb`m dUm `]d gYfj]WY hc h\Y cihYf g\Y`` cZ h\Y]f fY`]x []cig f]hiU`g& WUbbch VY hc`YfUbh cZ ch\Yfg( ?KHUH LV RQH KDUG DQG IDVW UXOH ZH PXVW DOZD\V UHPHPEHU* LI D JRRG HQG FDQ KH DFKLHYHG RQO\ WKURXJK KDG PHDQV$ HLWKHU LW LV QRW JRRG DIWHU DOO$ RU LWV WLPH KDV QRW \HW FRPH& ?bhc`YfUbh UbX dckYf'\ib[fm df]Yghg UbX dUghcfg Vf]b[ UVcih h\Y bY[Uh]cb cZ fY`][]cb( vM?BB?7C M7H8KHJED

KbVY`]YjYfg WUb VY YeiU``m ]bhc`YfUbh Ug h\cgY k\c VY`]YjY k]h\ WfiXY& df]a]h]jY ibXYfghUbX]b[( v@;7D <H7D9; :K9BEI

7 fYU` hfih\& U fYU` ZU]h\& bYYXg bY]h\Yfkcf`X`m giddcfh bcf Ub cihYf [`Uacif& bcf XcYg ]h bYYX hc VY ZcfWYZi``m ]bhfcXiWYX hc ch\Yfg( =cX \Ug h]aY5 Zcf >]a h\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg dUgg Ug cbY( J\cgY k\c ZYY` h\Y bYYX hc gdfYUX h\Y]f ZU]h\ h\fci[\ j]c`YbWY UbX ZcfWY Y]h\Yf `UW_ ZU]h\ ]b =cX& cf ]b h\YagY`jYg(

FJRUJOHJS Ã =cX WUbbch VY ibXYfghccX Vm h\Y \iaUb ]bhY``YWh& cb`m ZY`h Vm h\Y \iaUb \YUfh( MY cb`m _bck h\Uh \Y Yl]ghg& UbX fY[UfX`Ygg cZ k\Yh\Yf kY kUbh ]h cf bch& kY _bck h\]g Zcf gifY( J\Y ]bhY``YWh ]g `]_Y U `][\h h\Uh WcaYg h\fci[\ U hfUbg`ix WYbh [`Ugg4 ? gYY ]h& UbX h\ci[\ ? Xc bch _bck k\YfY ]h WcaYg Zfca& ? _bck h\Uh ]h Yl]ghg( MY WUb gUm h\Y gUaY UVcih =cX( 8Y`]YjY ]b =cX& gYfjY >]a& Vih Xcbrh hfm hc ibXYfghUbX >]g YggYbWY( Oci k]`` [Yh bch\]b[ Zfca mcif dU]bZi` YZZcfhg YlWYdh X]gUddc]bhaYbh UbX ZUh][iY( :c bch YjYb ghf]jY hc Z]bX cih k\Yh\Yf \Y Yl]ghg cf bch& ^igh gY]jY \]bf Ug ]Z \Y XcYg& Ug ]Z \Y ]g dfYgYbh YjYfmk\YfY( Dch\]b[ Y`gY ]g bYWYggUfm( vF>?B;CED

Dc cbY YlWYdh =cX WcadfY\YbXg h\Y gYWfYh cZ h\Y [fYUh VY[]bb]b[5 bc cbY WUb ghYd cihg]XY \]agY`Z( vEC7H A>7OO7C

MY WUb ibXYfghUbX h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX k]h\ cif ]bhY`x `YWh cb`m k\Yb kY ibXYfghUbX cif Wcad`YhY XYdYbXYbWY cb \]a& Ug ]Z kY \UjY h\Y gUaY ZYY`]b[ Ub ]bZUbh ibXYfx ghUbXg k\Yb \]g ach\Yf \c`Xg \]a( 7 VUVm XcYg bch _bck k\c ZYYXg \]a& k\c kUfag \]a& k\c hU_Yg WUfY cZ \]a& Vih \Y ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh h\YfY LV gcaYcbY k\c XcYg h\]g& UbX YjYb \Y `cjYg h\Y ZcfWY ]b k\cgY dckYf \Y fYghg( 0R QRW EH DODUPHG LI WKH QRWLRQ RI 3RG LV QRW FOHDUO\ H[SUHVVHG WR \RX& ?KH PRUH FOHDUO\ LW LV H[SUHVVHG$ WKH IXUWKHU LW LV IURP WKH WUXWK$ IURP LWV IRXQGDWLRQ&

FJRUJOHJS Ä =HDO JRRGQHVV LV QRW VRPHWKLQJ WKDW FDQ KH DFTXLUHG LQ DQ LQVWDQW$ KXW RQO\ WKURXJK FRQVWDQW HIIRUW$ EHFDXVH UHDO JRRGc QHVV OLHV LQ FRQVWDQWO\ VWULYLQJ IRU SHUIHFWLRQ& J\Y Zc``ck]b[ kcfXg kYfY WUfjYX cb h\Y VUh\fcca cZ h\Y _]b[ @]bl'>Ub[4 sHYbYk mcifgY`Z Wcad`YhY`m YjYfm XUm& UbX ghUfh]b[ UZfYg\& Zfca h\Y VY[]bb]b[(t v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

J\Y ^cifbYm cZ h\Y k]gY hc j]fhiY ]g Ug U ^cifbYm hc U fYachY `UbX& cf h\Y UgWYbh cZ U \][\ acibhU]b( FYcd`Y k\c hfUjY` hc U ZUfUkUm d`UWY ghUfh k]h\ U g]b[`Y ghYd& UbX h\cgY k\c W`]aV U \][\ acibhU]b ghUfh Zfca h\Y Vchhca( v9ED<K9?KI

7bX @Ygig gU]X ibhc \]a& Dc aUb& \Uj]b[ dih \]g \UbX hc h\Y d`ck& UbX `cc_]b[ VUW_& ]g Z]h Zcf h\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX( vBi_Y 340,

Ihf]jY Zcf [ccXbYgg k]h\cih Ubm YldYWhUh]cbg Zcf fUd]X cf bch]WYUV`Y giWWYgg( Oci k]`` bch gYY h\Y fYgi`hg cZ mcif YZZcfhg& VYWUigY h\Y Zifh\Yf mci dfc[fYgg& h\Y \][\Yf h\Y ]XYU` cZ dYfZYWh]cb hckUfX k\]W\ mci ghf]jY f]gYg( J\Y YZZcfh cZ ghf]j]b[ Zcf [ccXbYgg& h\Y dfcWYgg ]hgY`Z& ^igh]Z]Yg cif `]jYg(

FJRUJOHJS Ć Oci g\ci`X hYUW\ ch\Yfg k]h\ U [ccX YlUad`Y& Vih ]Z mci fYUW\ k]h\ Yj]`& h\Yb mci Xc bch hYUW\& Vih XYghfcm( J\Yb WUaY FYhYf hc \]a& UbX gU]X& BcfX& \ck cZh g\U`` am Vfch\Yf g]b U[U]bgh aY& UbX ? Zcf[]jY \]a6 h]`` gYjYb h]aYg6 @Ygig gU]h\ ibhc \]a& ? gUm bch ibhc h\YY& Kbh]` gYjYb h]aYg4 Vih& Kbh]` gYjYbhm h]aYg gYjYb( ÅI OODBQ ĄČÄÆĄĂÆÆ

>LQIXO SHRSOH KDG RQFH DFFHSWHG WKHLU ULJKW WR SXQLVK RWKc HUVbDQG PRVW RI RXU PLVIRUWXQHV VWDUWHG IURP WKLV& ?Z mci h\]b_ gcaYcbY ]g [i]`hm cZ kfcb[]b[ mci& Zcf[]jY \]a( ?Z mci \UjY bYjYf Zcf[]jYb h\Y [i]`hm VYZcfY& mci k]`` YldYf]YbWY U bYk ^cm4 h\Y ^cm cZ Zcf[]j]b[( Fib]g\aYbh ]g U`kUmg WfiY`& U`kUmg dU]bZi`( J\Y 7aYf]WUb ?bX]Ubg \UX bc `Ukg& bc dib]g\aYbhg& UbX bc [cjYfbaYbh( J\Ym cVYmYX h\Y acfU` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ [ccX UbX Yj]` h\Uh ]g dUfh cZ YjYfm \iaUb bUhifY( ÅODKI N FBCCBMNKJ

J\Y ghfcb[Ygh dfccZ h\Uh ]b h\Y bUaY cZ sgW]YbWYt kY difx giY ibkcfh\m UbX gcaYh]aYg YjYb \UfaZi` h\]b[g ]g h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ U gW]YbWY cZ dib]g\aYbh& k\]W\ ]b ]hgY`Z ]g cbY cZ h\Y acgh ][bcfUbh UbX cZZYbg]jY hmdYg cZ UWh]cb _bckb hc aUb& U jYgh][Y cZ h\Y `ckYgh `YjY` cZ \iaUb XYjY`cdaYbh& `ckYf h\Ub h\Uh cZ U W\]`X cf U aUXaUb(

FJRUJOHJS Ă <HRSOH MXPS EDFN DQG IRUWK LQ SXUVXLW RI SOHDVXUHV RQO\ EHFDXVH WKH\ VHH WKH HPSWLQHVV RI WKHLU OLYHV PRUH FOHDUO\ WKDQ WKH\ GR WKH HPSWLQHVV RI ZKLFKHYHU QHZ HQWHUWDLQPHQW DWWUDFWV WKHP& v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y h\]b[g kY Xc hc aU_Y cif `]ZY acfY WcaZcfhUV`Y fYa]bX aY cZ Ub cghf]W\ k\c \]XYg \]g \YUX ]b cfXYf bch hc gYY \]g YbYa]Yg( MY VY\UjY YjYb kcfgY h\Ub Ub cghf]W\( ?b cfXYf hc UW\]YjY gcaY XiV]cig eiYgh]cbUV`Y ZihifY& kY XYZ]b]hY`m XYghfcm cif `]ZY ]b h\Y W`YUf`m XYZ]bYX dfYgYbh h]aY( FYcd`Y hcXUm Zcc`]g\`m hfm hc VY`]YjY h\Uh U`` h\Y kcf`Xrg gYbgY`YggbYgg UbX WfiY`hmvh\Y f]W\bYgg cZ h\Y ZYk& h\Y [fYUh dcjYfhm cZ h\Y aUbm& h\Y j]c`YbWY UbX kUfZUfYv \UddYbg cihg]XY h\Y]f ckb `]jYg UbX XcYg bch ]bhYfZYfY k]h\ h\Ya UbX h\Y]f kUm cZ `]ZY( 7 a]gWcbWYdh]cb fYaU]bg U a]gWcbWYdh]cb& YjYb k\Yb ]h ]g g\UfYX Vm h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ h\Y dYcd`Y(

FJRUJOHJS Ĉ ?Z `]ZY ]g [ccX& h\Yb XYUh\ k\]W\ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm dUfh cZ "`]ZY& ]g [ccX Ug kY``( HYU` `]ZY Yl]ghg cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh( J\Y ZihifY \Ug bcx aYUb]b[( J\Y difdcgY cZ fYU` `]ZY ]g hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y `Uk cZ =cX& k\]W\ Yl]ghg YhYfbU``m4 ]h U`kUmg Yl]ghYX& ]h Yl]ghg bck& UbX ]h U`kUmg k]`` Yl]gh( :c bch Vch\Yf UVcih k\Uh k]`` \UddYb gcaYXUm& gcaYx k\YfY& ]b h\Y ZUf UkUm X]ghUbWY& ]b U ZihifY h]aY5 h\]b_ UbX VY jYfm UhhYbh]jY hc k\Uh \UddYbg bck& \YfY& ]b h\]g d`UWY( v@E>D'HKIA?D

7g gccb Ug mci [c ]bhc h\Y ZihifY cf h\Y dUgh& mci [c UkUm Zfca =cX& UbX mci ZYY` `cbY`m& XYgYfhYX& UbX Ybg`UjYX( ?KH IXWXUH GRHV QRW UHDOO\ H[LVW& 5W LV FUHDWHG E\ XV LQ WKH SUHVHQW& J\YfY ]g U WcbX]h]cb ]b k\]W\ U dYfgcb ZYY`g \]agY`Z h\Y UfW\]hYWh cZ \]g `]ZY( ?h cWWifg k\Yb \Y WcbWYbhfUhYg U`` \]g YZZcfhg UbX U`` \]g ]bhY``YWh cb h\Y dfYgYbh acaYbh(

FJRUJOHJS Ǻ 7h h\Uh h]aY @Ygig UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X& ? h\Ub_ h\YY& E <Uh\Yf& BcfX cZ \YUjYb UbX YUfh\& VYWUigY h\ci \Ugh \]X h\YgY h\]b[g Zfca h\Y k]gY UbX dfiXYbh& UbX \Ugh fYjYU`YX h\Ya ibhc VUVYg( ;jYb gc& <Uh\Yf4 Zcf gc ]h gYYaYX [ccX ]b h\m g][\h( vC7JJ>;M +.4,/',0

?KH ZRUOG ZRXOG KH D WHUULEOH SODFH ZLWKRXW QHZERUQ FKLOc GUHQ$ ZKR EULQJ ZLWK WKHP LQQRFHQFH$ DQG WKH KRSH RI PDQ_V IXUWKHU SHUIHFWLRQ& ^ v@E>D HKIA?D

9\]`X\ccX ]g V`YggYX Vm \YUjYb VYWUigY ]h Vf]b[g U d]YWY cZ dUfUX]gY ]bhc h\Y WfiY`h]Yg cZ `]ZY( 7`` h\YgY h\cigUbXg cZ YjYfmXUm V]fh\g UfY ZfYg\ UXX]h]cbg cZ ]bbcWYbWY UbX dif]hm& k\]W\ Z][\h U[U]bgh h\Y YbX cZ aUb_]bX& UbX U[U]bgh cif gdc]`YX bUhifY& UbX U[U]bgh cif Wcad`YhY ]aaYfg]cb ]bhc g]b( v>;DH? 7C?;B

E BcfX cif BcfX& \ck YlWY``Ybh ]g YUfh\ k\c \Ugh gYh h\m [`cfm UVcjY h\Y acih\ cZ VUVYg UbX giW_`]b[g ghfYb[h\ VYWUigY cZ h\]bY YbYa]Yg& gh]`` h\Y YbYam UbX h\Y UjYb[Yf(

h\m bUaY ]b U`` h\Y h\Y \YUjYbg( Eih cZ \Ugh h\ci cfXU]bYX h\Uh h\ci a][\hYgh vFI7BCI 24+',

M\Uh h]aY Wci`X VY VYhhYf h\Ub W\]`X\ccX& UbX k\Uh j]fhiYg Wci`X VY VYhhYf h\Ub ]bbcWYbh ^cmZi`bYgg& UbX h\Y bYYX Zcf `cjY6 J\Ym UfY h\Y difYgh aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ `]ZY( Oci g\ci`X fYgdYWh YjYfm dYfgcb& Vih mci g\ci`X fYgdYWh U W\]`X UVcjY U``& UbX bch XYghfcm h\Y ]bbcWYbh dif]hm cZ \]g gci`(

FJRUJOHJS Ą J\Y _bck`YX[Y kY bck UWWYdh Ug gW]YbWY ]bhYfZYfYg k]h\ acfY h\Ub ]h giddcfhg h\Y [ccXbYgg cZ \iaUb `]ZY( 7ghfcbcam& aYW\Ub]Wg& d\mg]Wg& W\Ya]ghfm& UbX U`` ch\Yf gW]YbWYg hc[Yh\Yf UbX X]ZZYfYbh`m& U`` ghiXm h\Y dUfh]Wi`Uf g]XYg cZ `]ZY& Vih h\Ym Xc bch WcaY hc Ubm WcbW`ig]cb UVcih h\Y gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ aUb_]bX( IW]YbWY Zi`Z]``g ]hg difdcgY& bch k\Yb ]h Yld`U]bg h\Y fYUx gcbg Zcf h\Y XUf_ gdchg cb h\Y gib& Vih k\Yb ]h ibXYfx ghUbXg UbX Yld`U]bg h\Y `Ukg cZ cif ckb `]ZY& UbX h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ j]c`Uh]b[ h\YgY `Ukg( v@E>D HKIA?D

:R PDWWHU KRZ JUHDW RXU NQRZOHGJH PD\ KH$ LW FDQQRW KHOS XV IXOILOO RXU OLIH_V PDMRU SXUSRVHbRXU PRUDO SHUIHFWLRQ&

FJRUJOHJS ÁÀ J\Y jc]WY cZ WcbgW]YbWY aU_Yg bc a]ghU_Yg( ?h kUbhg& bch h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ h\Y Ub]aU` gY`Z& Vih ]hg XYb]U` cf gUWf]Z]WY( 7 9\f]gh]Ub k\c XcYg bch _bck k\YfY \Y [cYg #@c\b -42$& cf k\Uh ]g []jYb hc \]a Vm =cX #@c\b -4-.$& XcYg bch _bck \]g `]ZYrg fYU` difdcgY( v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

7g cif gY`Z']bhYfYgh X]a]b]g\Yg& cif Ubl]Yh]Yg X]gUddYUf& UbX h\Yb WcaYg ei]Yh UbX Z]fa ^cm& k\]W\ U`kUmg X]ZZigYg ig k]h\ U [ccX gd]f]hiU` X]gdcg]h]cb UbX U W`YUf Wcbx gW]YbWY( ;jYfm [ccX XYYX \Y`dg hc _]bX`Y h\]g ZYY`]b[ cZ ^cm k]h\]b ig( J\Y Y[c]gh ZYY`g `cbY`m& giffcibXYX Vm h\fYUhYb]b[ UbX U`]Yb YjYbhg5 U`` \]g XYg]fYg UfY gib_ ]b \]g ckb WcbWYfbg( 7 _]bX dYfgcb `]jYg ]b U kcf`X cZ VYbYZ]x WYbh YjYbhg& k\cgY [ccXbYgg aUhW\Yg \]g ckb( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

7 dYfgcb k\c `]jYg cb`m Zcf h\Y WcbWYfbg cZ \]g VcXm aUm VYWcaY `cgh ]b h\Y `UVmf]bh\ cZ Ub Ub]aU` UbX gYbgiU` `]ZY& k\]`Y h\Y gci` k]`` U`kUmg Z]bX hfih\5 ]h k]`` Z]bX h\Y kUm( vBK9O C7BEHO

?KH YRLFH RI \RXU FRQVFLHQFH FDQ DOZD\V KH VLQJOHG RXW DERYH WKH QRLVH RI \RXU RWKHU ZLVKHV$ EHFDXVH LW DOZD\V ZDQWV VRPHWKLQJ VHHPLQJO\ XVHOHVV$ VHHPLQJO\ VHQVHOHVV$ VHHPLQJO\ LQFRPSUHKHQVLEOH$ EXW DW WKH VDPH WLPH VRPHWKLQJ DFWXDOO\ EHDXWLIXO DQG JRRG$ ZKLFK FDQ EH DFKLHYHG RQO\ WKURXJK HIIRUW&

FJRUJOHJS ÁÁ J\Y fYU` ZU]h\ UhhfUWhg dYcd`Y cZ ]hgY`Z bch VYWUigY ]h dfca]gYg [ccXbYgg hc h\cgY k\c VY`]YjY& Vih VYWUigY ]h ]g h\Y cb`m YgWUdY& bch cb`m Zfca U`` h\Y dfcV`Yag UbX hfcix V`Yg UbX a]gZcfhibYg cZ cif `]ZY& Vih U`gc Zfca h\Y ZYUf cZ XYUh\( 5I \RX NQRZ WKDW \RX ODFN IDLWK$ NQRZ DOVR WKDW \RX DUH LQ RQH RI WKH PRVW GDQJHURXV VLWXDWLRQV LQ WKLV ZRUOG D SHUVRQ FDQ KH LQ& ?h ]g VUX bch hc \UjY gcaYh\]b[ Zcf k\]W\ mci UfY fYUXm hc X]Y( Bcc_ Uh h\Y WUigYg cZ h\Y a]gZcfhibYg Zfca k\]W\ aUb_]bX giZZYfg( Fig\ VYmcbX h\Y cVj]cig WUigYg hc h\Y fcch WUigYg& UbX mci k]`` ]bYj]hUV`m Z]bX h\Uh h\Y acgh VUg]W& h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh WUigY cZ YUW\ UbX YjYfm cbY cZ \iaUb]hmrg dfcV`Yag ]g h\Y kYU_bYgg cZ ZU]h\ h\Uh WcaYg Zfca U ZU`gY Uhh]hiXY hc h\Y kcf`X UbX ]hg cf][]b( IU`jUh]cb `]Yg bch ]b f]hiU`g UbX bch ]b U dUfh]Wi`Uf WfYYX& Vih ]b U W`YUf ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ mcif `]ZY(

FJRUJOHJS ÁÂ CRX FDQQRW VHUYH ERWK JRG DQG WKH GHYLO& 9HUHO\ WHQGLQJ WR WKH JURZWK RI \RXU ZHDOWK KDV QRWKLQJ WR GR ZLWK WKH UHTXLUHc PHQWV RI WKH WUXO\ VSLULWXDO OLIH& ?h gYYag hc aY h\Uh h\Y c`X dfY^iX]WY h\Uh kYU`h\ Vf]b[g \Udd]bYgg \Ug VY[ib hc VY X]gWfYX]hYX( J\Y `cjY cZ [fYUh kYU`h\ WcaaYbXg mci& s8f]b[ aY mcif gci` Ug U gUWf]Z]WY&t UbX dYcd`Y k]`` Xc gc( vI7?DJ @E>D 9>HOIEIJEC

;lWYgg]jY XfYgg dfYjYbhg h\Y VcXm Zfca acj]b[ ZfYY`m( ;lWYgg]jY kYU`h\ ]bhYfZYfYg k]h\ h\Y acjYaYbhg cZ cif gci`( v:;CEIJ>;D;I

J\Y XYg]fY Zcf kYU`h\ WUb bYjYf VY gUh]gZ]YX( J\cgY k\c \UjY ]h UfY YlW]hYX Vm h\Y k]g\ hc \UjY acfY& UbX mYh acfY( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

:c bch ZYUf dcjYfhm& Vih VYkUfY kYU`h\( ?Z cb`m dYcd`Y k\c gYY_ kYU`h\ Wci`X W`YUf`m gYY k\Uh h\Ym kci`X `cgY Vm \Uj]b[ ]h& h\Ym kci`X dih h\Y gUaY Uacibh cZ YZZcfh ]bhc [Yhh]b[ f]X cZ h\]g kYU`h\ Ug h\Ym bck dih ]bhc UWei]f]b[ ]h(

FJRUJOHJS ĄǼ 7 k]gY aUb XcYg bch k]g\ hc W\Ub[Y \]g g]hiUh]cb& VYWUigY \Y _bckg h\Uh ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y `Uk cZ =cX& h\Y `Uk cZ `cjY& ]b YjYfm g]hiUh]cb( 7 k]gY aUb `cc_g Zcf YjYfmh\]b[ ]bg]XY cZ \]agY`Z5 U aUXx aUb gYY_g Zcf YjYfmh\]b[ ]b ch\Yfg( v9ED<K9?KI

? bYjYf Wcad`U]b UVcih am ZUhY( EbWY& ? X]X bch g\cYg& UbX ? Wcad`U]bYX hc =cX( ? kYbh ]bhc W\ifW\ U \YUjm \YUfh UbX ]b h\Y W\ifW\ ? gUk U aUb k]h\cih ZYYh( Ic ? h\Ub_YX =cX h\Uh \Y \UX []jYb aY Vch\ UbX h\Uh am cb`m dfcV`Ya kUg h\Uh h\Ym kYfY ibg\cX(

\UjY k]h\ Vch\ ZYYh&

'CKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

7 k]gY aUb ]bbUhY`m _bckg \ck hc UWh k]h\cih gYUfW\]b[& VYWUigY \Y \Ug h\Y X]j]bY k]h\]b \]agY`Z( J\Y Zifh\Yf mci gYUfW\ UbX gYY_& h\Y `Ygg mci _bck( 'B7E'JPK

Oci g\ci`X hfYUh mcif h\ci[\hg h\Y kUm mci hfYUh mcif gY`Z& UbX hfYUh mcif k]g\Yg h\Y kUm mci hfYUh mcif W\]`XfYb( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

Jfm hc YghUV`]g\ Ub ]bbYf g]`YbWY ]b mcifgY`Z& U Wcad`YhY g]`YbWY cZ mcif `]dg UbX mcif \YUfh( J\Yb mci k]`` \YUf \ck =cX gdYU_g hc ig& UbX mci k]`` _bck \ck hc Zi`Z]`` >]g k]``( ?KH PRUH XSVHW D SHUVRQ LV ZLWK RWKHU SHRSOH$ DQG ZLWK FLUc FXPVWDQFHV$ DQG WKH PRUH VDWLVILHG KH LV ZLWK KLPVHOI$ WKH IXUc WKHU KH LV IURP ZLVGRP &

FJRUJOHJS ÁÄ L]c`YbWY ]g \UfaZi` VYWUigY ]h ]g igiU``m XfYggYX ]b kYU`h\& UbX ]h h\YfYZcfY UfcigYg gcaY fYgdYWh Zcf h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ g\ci`X UfcigY X]g[igh( FYcd`Y k\c \UjY dckYf UfY gifY h\Uh ]h ]g cb`m j]c`YbWY h\Uh [i]XYg dYcd`Y& UbX gc h\Ym igY j]c`YbWY hc giddcfh h\Y Yl]gh]b[ cfXYf( 8ih h\Y Yl]gh]b[ cfXYf ]g bch VUgYX cb j]c`YbWY& Vih cb diV`]W cd]b]cb( 7 dYfgcb ]g bch WfYUhYX Y]h\Yf hc giVXiY ch\Yfg& cf hc Zc`x `ck h\Y cfXYfg cZ ch\Yfg( FYcd`Y UfY WcffidhYX Vm Vch\ kUmg cZ VY\Uj]cf( ?b h\Y Z]fgh h\Ym UggiaY hcc aiW\ ]adcfhUbWY& ]b h\Y gYWcbX& hcc `]hh`Y fYgdYWh( ?b Vch\ kUmg h\YfY ]g jYfm `]hh`Y X][b]hm( vL?9JEH 9EDI?:;H7DJ

Eif `]ZY kci`X VYWcaY kcbXYfZi` ]Z kY Wci`X gYY U`` h\Y X]g[igh]b[ h\]b[g k\]W\ Yl]gh ]b ]h( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

IiVXi]b[ dYcd`Y h\fci[\ j]c`YbWY ]g bYjYf ^igh]WY( v8B7?I; F7I97B

>Y k\c XYdYbXg cb j]c`YbWY VY\UjYg kfcb[`m( J\Y aU_Yf cZ VYUih]Zi` gdYYW\Yg ]g bch k]gY& cb`m \Y k\c ]g ZfYY Zfca \UhfYX UbX ZYUf ]g hfi`m k]gY( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

-OO YLROHQFH LV FRQWUDU\ WR ORYH* GR QRW SDUWLFLSDWH LQ YLROHQFH&

FJRUJOHJS ÁĀ J\Y V][[Ygh cVghUW`Yg hc ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Y hfih\ UfY `]Yg X]g[i]gYX Ug hfih\( ?b fYU` `]ZY ]``ig]cbg WUb cb`m hfUbgZcfa cif `]ZY Zcf U acaYbh& Vih ]b h\Y XcaU]b cZ h\ci[\hg UbX h\Y ]bhY``YWh& a]gWcbWYdh]cbg aUm VY UWWYdhYX Ug hfih\ Zcf h\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg& UbX aU_Y U `Ui[\]b[ghcW_ cZ k\c`Y bUh]cbg& aihY h\Y bcV`Y k]g\Yg cZ aUb_]bX& aU_Y g`UjYg Zfca dYcx d`Y UbX `]Y hc h\Ya( J\YgY a]gWcbWYdh]cbg UfY h\Y YbYa]Yg k]h\ k\]W\ h\Y k]gYgh aYb ]b h\Y \]ghcfm cZ aUb_]bX hfm hc ghfi[[`Y( J\Y ZcfWY cZ h\Y hfih\ ]g [fYUh& Vih ]hg j]Whcfm ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h( >ckYjYf& cbWY mci fYWY]jY h\]g j]Whcfm& ]h WUb bYjYf VY hU_Yb Zfca mci( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

?KH H[SRVXUH RI D OLH LV DV YDOXDEOH WR D FRPPXQLW\ DV D FOHDUO\ H[SUHVVHG WUXWK& <fYY]b[ U dYfgcb Zfca a]gWcbWYdh]cbg& ZU`gY hfih\g& UbX `]Yg XcYg bch hU_Y Ubmh\]b[ Zfca \]a5 ]h []jYg \]a gcaYx h\]b[ ]adcfhUbh( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

J\Y dfc[fYgg cZ aUb_]bX ]g ]b fYjYU`]b[ cVghUW`Yg k\]W\ UfY \]X]b[ Zfca ig(

FJRUJOHJS ÁĂ :ciVhg Xc bch XYghfcm hfih\5 h\Ym ghfYb[h\Yb ]h( 0LVEHOLHI LV QRW ZKHQ D SHUVRQ EHOLHYHV RU GRHV QRW EHOLHYH LQ VRPHWKLQJ& 5W LV ZKHQ KH SURSKHVLHV WKRVH WKLQJV LQ ZKLFK KH GRHV QRW EHOLHYH& v>7HH?;BC7HJ?D;7K

Oci k]`` \UjY acaYbhg ]b k\]W\ mci bc `cb[Yf VY`]YjY ]b" h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ h\Y gd]f]hiU` X]aYbg]cb cZ `]ZY( Bcc_ Uh h\YgY acaYbh/pUg YjYbhg ]b h\Y XYjY`cdaYbh cZ mcif ZU]h\( 7 dYfgcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\Y gd]f]hiU` bUhifY cZ `]ZY aUm gh]`` Uh gcaY dc]bh VYWcaY UZfU]X cZ XYUh\& igiU``m Zcf U g\cfh dYf]cX cZ h]aY& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh mci WUb gYY Ug mci kUhW\ U gWYbY Uh h\Y h\YUhYf UbX Zcf[Yh h\Uh mci UfY kUhW\]b[ U d`Um& UbX VYWcaY gWUfYX Vm k\Uh mci UfY gYY]b[ Ug ]Z ]h kYfY fYU`( Ic ]h ]g ]b fYU` `]ZY4 ]b acaYbhg cZ gY`Z'XY`ig]cb& U fY`]x []cig dYfgcb Zcf[Yhg h\Uh k\Uh \UddYbg ]b \]g d\mg]WU` `]ZY WUbbch ]bhYfZYfY k]h\ k\Uh \UddYbg ]b \]g gd]f]hiU` ]]ZY( ?b h\YgY dYf]cXg& k\Yb mcif gd]f]hg \UjY ZU``Yb& mci \UjY hc hfYUh mcifgY`Z Ug Ub ]`` aUb( 7 k]gY aUb \Ug XciVhg YjYb ]b \]g VYgh acaYbhg( HYU` hfih\ ]g U`kUmg UWWcadUb]YX Vm \Yg]hUh]cbg( ?Z ? Wci`X bch \Yg]hUhY& ? Wci`X bch VY`]YjY( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

>Y k\c \Yg]hUhYg ]g bch X]ghUbWYX Zfca =cX5 ]h ]g \Y k\c VY`]YjYg ib\Yg]hUh]b[`m ]b gcaYcbY Y`gYrg kcfX h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg cf XcYg bch Yl]gh k\c ]g ZUf Zfca =cX(

FJRUJOHJS ÁÅ J\Y ]bX]j]XiU` ckbYfg\]d cZ `Uf[Y UfYUg cZ `UbX ]g Ug ib^igh Ug h\Y ckbYfg\]d cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( Oci WUbbch gUm h\Uh h\Y Yl]gh]b[ `Ukg fY[UfX]b[ h\Y dcgx gYgg]cb cZ `UbX UfY `UkZi`( L]c`YbWY& Wf]aY& UbX dckYf \UjY h\Y]f gcifWY ]b h\YgY `Ukg( v>;H8;HJ IF;D9;H

Ff]jUhY ckbYfg\]d cZ `UbX WUaY hc VY& bch cih cZ Ubm bUhx ifU` fY`Uh]cbg\]dg VYhkYYb dYcd`Y& Vih h\fci[\ fcVVYfm( v>;DHO =;EH=;

?KH LQMXVWLFH RI RZQLQJ ELJ SLHFHV RI ODQG DV SULYDWH SURSHUW\$ OLNH DQ\ RWKHU LQMXVWLFH$ LV QHFHVVDULO\%OLQNHG ZLWK PDQ\ RWKHU LQMXVWLFHV ZKLFK DUH XVHG WR SURWHFW LW&

FJRUJOHJS ÁǺ B]ZYrg YggYbWY `]Yg& bch ]b mcif VcXm& Vih ]b mcif Wcbx gW]YbWY( J\Y X]j]bY gdUf_ `]jYg ]b U`` cZ ig& UbX dYfdYhiU``m ghf]jYg hckUfX ]hg cf][]b( ÅHP EPN

7bbUYig IYbYWU

M\Yb mci gYY h\Uh YjYfmh\]b[ UfcibX mci ]g ]adYfaUx bYbh& h\Yb mci k]`` dYfWY]jY ch\Yf& dYfaUbYbh UbX YhYfbU` h\]b[g( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

Oci WUbbch gYY h\Y gci`& Vih cb`m h\Y gci` WUb hfi`m gYY h\Y YggYbWY cZ h\]b[g( vJ\Y J7BCK:

5 FDOO VSLULW WKDW SDUW RI PDQ ZKLFK KDV LQGHSHQGHQW H[LVWHQFH DQG JLYHV XV WKH XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI OLIH& vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

BYh mcif gd]f]hiU` g]XY [i]XY mcif aUhYf]U` g]XY& UbX bch h\Y ch\Yf kUm UfcibX( ?b cfXYf hc ]adfcjY \]g ghUhY& U dYfx gcb g\ci`X ghf]jY Zcf gd]f]hiU` bch d\mg]WU` dYfZYWh]cb(

FJRUJOHJS ÁĄ Dch\]b[ WUb Yb`][\hYb dYcd`Yrg `]jYg UbX YUgY h\Y]f Vifx XYbg acfY h\Ub h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh h\Ym g\ci`X gYfjY =cX( =HOLJLRXV GLVEHOLHI DQG QHJOHFW LV D JUHDW HYLO$ EXW SUHMXGLFH DQG OLHV DUH HYHQ ZRUVH& vFBKJ7H9>KI

B]ZY ]g g\cfh( :c bch Zcf[Yh UVcih h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[g ]b cif `]ZY& `]j]b[ Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX Xc]b[ [ccX Zcf h\Ya( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y Icb cZ aUb WUaY bch hc VY a]b]ghYfYX ibhc& Vih hc a]b]ghYf& UbX hc []jY \]g `]ZY Ug U fUbgca Zcf aUbm( vC7JJ>;M ,*4,2

FUm [ccXbYgg Zcf Yj]`( MY g\ci`X VY `]_Y hfYYg h\Uh []jY Zfi]hg hc h\cgY k\c h\fck ghcbYg Uh h\Ya( Oci g\ci`X UWWYdh mcifgY`Z& bch Ug U aUghYf& Vih Ug U gYfx jUbh& UbX h\Yb U`` mcif VUX ZYY`]b[g& mcif Ubl]Yhm& U`Ufa& ibWYfhU]bhm& UbX X]ggUh]gZUWh]cb k]`` VY W\Ub[YX ]bhc WU`ax bYgg UbX dYUWY( Oci k]`` VY Z]``YX ]bg]XY k]h\ U W`YUf j]g]cb cZ mcif difdcgY& UbX k]h\ U [fYUh ^cm5

FJRUJOHJS ÂÀ 7`` [ccX h\]b[g WUb VY UW\]YjYX cb`m k]h\ YZZcfh( .DG WKLQJV DUH HDV\ WR GR$ JRRG WKLQJV DUH GRQH RQO\ ZLWK ZRUN DQG HIIRUW& v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

;bhYf Vm h\Y bUffck [UhY5 Zcf h\Y [UhY ]g k]XY& UbX h\Y kUm ]g VfcUX h\Uh `YUXg hc XYghfiWh]cb& UbX aUbm UfY h\cgY k\c YbhYf Vm ]h( <cf h\Y [UhY ]g gaU``& UbX h\Y kUm ]g bUfx fck h\Uh `YUXg hc `]ZY& UbX ZYk UfY h\cgY k\c Z]bX ]h( vC7JJ>;M 14+-'+.

J\Y kUm hc hfiY _bck`YX[Y XcYg bch [c h\fci[\ gcZh [fUgg WcjYfYX k]h\ Z`ckYfg( Jc Z]bX ]h& U dYfgcb aigh W`]aV ghYYd acibhU]bg( v@E>D HKIA?D

Bcc_ Zcf h\Y hfih\5 ]h kUbhg hc VY ZcibX( v8B7?I; F7I97B

7 dYfgcb Wf]Yg cih Zfca dU]b k\Yb \Y hU_Yg id \UfX d\mgx ]WU` kcf_ UZhYf U dYf]cX cZ ]X`YbYgg( 7bm fYgh Zfca h\Y ghfi[[`Y Zcf gd]f]hiU` ]adfcjYaYbh Vf]b[g h\Y gUaY dU]b(

FJRUJOHJS ÂÁ J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh UbX bYWYggUfm YldfYgg]cb cZ ZfYYXca ]g hc []jY mcif h\ci[\h U gdYW]Z]W X]fYWh]cb( BRUN WRZDUG WKH SXULILFDWLRQ RI \RXU WKRXJKWV& BLWKRXW KDG WKRXJKWV \RX ZLOO KH LQFDSDEOH RI EDG GHHGV& v9ED<K9?KI

;jYfmh\]b[ ]g ]b \YUjYbrg dckYf& YlWYdh Zcf cif W\c]WY cZ k\Yh\Yf hc gYfjY =cX cf cifgY`jYg( MY WUbbch dfYjYbh V]fXg Zfca Z`m]b[ cjYf cif \YUXg& Vih kY WUb _YYd h\Ya Zfca aU_]b[ bYghg cb hcd cZ cif \YUXg( I]a]`Uf`m& VUX h\ci[\hg gcaYh]aYg UddYUf ]b cif a]bX& Vih kY WUb W\ccgY k\Yh\Yf kY U``ck h\Ya hc `]jY h\YfY& hc WfYUhY U bYgh Zcf h\YagY`jYg& UbX hc VfYYX Yj]` XYYXg( vC7HJ?D BKJ>;H

?h ]g U g]b& bch cb`m hc Xc VUX h\]b[g& Vih YjYb hc h\]b_ UVcih VUX h\]b[g( 'PEHE7IJ;H

FJRUJOHJS ÂÂ <U]h\ ]b h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ YhYfb]hm ]g cif YlW`ig]jY`m \iaUb eiU`]hm( J\Y gci` XcYg bch `]jY ]b h\Y VcXm Ug ]b U \cigY& Vih Ug ]b U hYbh& U d`UWY cZ hYadcfUfm XkY``]b[( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\c Vfci[\h aY ]bhc h\]g kcf`X6 7WWcfX]b[ hc k\cgY WcaaUbX Xc ? Z]bX amgY`Z Uh h\]g YlUWh d`UWY& Xif]b[ h\]g dUfh]Wi`Uf h]aY6 B]ZY ]g h\Y fYaYaVfUbWY cZ U jYfm g\cfh XUm kY gdYbh j]g]h]b[ h\]g kcf`X( v8B7?I; F7I97B

CcfhU` dYcd`Y WUbbch `]jY `cb[5 kY \UjY cb`m U ZYk acaYbhg( 8ih cif gci` XcYg bch U[Y( ?h VY`]YjYg ]b YhYfbU` h\]b[g& UbX ]h k]`` `]jY Zcf U`` YhYfb]hm( vJEH?9B?:JI

:YUh\ ]g h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y VcX]`m cf[Ubg k]h\ k\]W\ ? gYY am kcf`X Xif]b[ am `]ZY5 h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y [`Ugg h\fci[\ k\]W\ ? `cc_ Uh h\]g kcf`X( J\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\]g [`Ugg XcYg bch aYUb h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y YmY ]hgY`Z( ;XU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI HWHUQLW\ LV WKH YRLFH RI 3RG ZKR OLYHV ZLWKLQ XV&

FJRUJOHJS ÆǼ :R PDWWHU ERZ ELJ PDQNLQG_V VWRUH RI NQRZOHGJH VHHPV WR PH LQ FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK RXU SUHYLRXV LJQRUDQFH$ LW LV RQO\ DQ LQILQLWHO\ VPDOO SDUW RI DOO SRVVLEOH NQRZOHGJH& IcWfUhYg X]X bch \UjY h\Y kYU_bYgg cZ aUbm gW\c`Ufg& h\Y XYg]fY hc _bck UVcih U`` dcgg]V`Y h\]b[g& hc `YUfb h\Y cf]x []bg UbX Yld`UbUh]cbg cZ h\]b[gvk\Uh h\Y Icd\]ghg WU`` sh\Y bUhifY cZ h\]b[gtvUbX hc ibWcjYf h\Y cf][]bg cZ h\Y WY`Ygh]U` VcX]Yg( IcWfUhYg gU]X& s?g ]h hfiY h\Uh dYcd`Y UfY gc WcbWYfbYX k]h\ h\YgY YUfh\`m h\]b[g6 FYcd`Y kfcb[`m h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym g\ci`X _bck YjYfmh\]b[( J\Ym h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym WUb XYgd]gY h\Y acgh bYWYggUfm UbX ]adcfhUbh Z]Y`Xg cZ _bck`YX[Y& UbX dYbYhfUhY h\Y amghYf]Yg h\Uh Xc bch VY`cb[ hc ig(t vN;DEF>ED

Dch cb`m ]g fYU` gW]YbWY bch \cgh]`Y hc fY`][]cb& ]b ZUWh fYU` gW]YbWY U`kUmg giddcfhg ]h( v@E>D HKIA?D

Abck`YX[Y ]g `]a]h`Ygg& UbX h\Y acgh gW\c`Uf`m UbX YXiWUhYX dYfgcb ]g Ug ZUf Zfca hfiY _bck`YX[Y Ug Ub ibYXiWUhYX dYUgUbh( v@E>D HKIA?D

MY WUbbch ]aU[]bY h\Y gWcdY cZ cif ][bcfUbWY& ^igh Ug U V`]bX aUb WUbbch ]aU[]bY XUf_bYgg ibh]` \Y WUb gYY( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g VYhhYf hc _bck `Ygg h\Ub bYWYggUfm h\Ub hc _bck acfY h\Ub bYWYggUfm( :c bch ZYUf h\Y `UW_ cZ _bck`YX[Y& Vih hfi`m ZYUf ibbYWYggUfm _bck`YX[Y k\]W\ ]g UWei]fYX cb`m hc d`YUgY jUb]hm(

FJRUJOHJS ÂÄ ?h kci`X VY dcgg]V`Y hc YUh aYUh ]Z ]h kYfY ^igh]Z]YX Vm Ubm gYf]cig Wcbg]XYfUh]cbg( 8ih ]h ]gbrh5 UbX aYUh YUh]b[ ]g g]ax d`m U VUX h\]b[ h\Uh Yl]ghg k]h\cih Ubm ^igh]Z]WUh]cb Uh U``( BKDW QDWXUH RI VWUXJJOH IRU H[LVWHQFH RU NLQG RI PDGQHVV IRUFHV \RX WR VKHG EORRG ZLWK \RXU KDQGV LQ RUGHU WR HDW DQLc PDOV, BK\ GR WKLV$ LI \RX KDYH DOO WKH FRPIRUWV RI OLIH, vFBKJ7H9>

?Z ]h kYfY bch gc V`]bX`m UWWYdhYX Ug U dUfh cZ cif Wighcag UbX hfUX]h]cbg& \ck Wci`X Ubm gYbg]h]jY dYfgcb UWWYdh h\Y h\ci[\h h\Uh ]b cfXYf hc ZYYX cifgY`jYg kY g\ci`X _]`` giW\ U \i[Y biaVYf cZ Ub]aU`g& ]b gd]hY cZ h\Y ZUWh h\Uh cif YUfh\ []jYg ig gc aUbm X]ZZYfYbh hfYUgifYg Zfca d`Ubhg6 J\YfY ]g U V][ X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb& cb h\Y cbY \UbX& U dYfx gcb k\c XcYg bch \UjY UWWYgg hc Ubm ZccX YlWYdh aYUh& UbX cb h\Y ch\Yf& Ub YXiWUhYX dYfgcb cZ hcXUm k\c `]jYg ]b U Wcibhfm k\]W\ \Ug jY[YhUV`Yg UbX a]`_ ]b UVibXUbWY& UbX k\c ]g ]bghfiWhYX U[U]bgh aYUh YUh]b[( J\Y YXiWUhYX dYfgcb g]bg [fYUh`m ]Z \Y Wcbh]biYg hc VY\UjY ]b U kUm \Y _bckg ]g kfcb[(

FJRUJOHJS ÆĆ Mcf_ ]g bch U j]fhiY& Vih ]h ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ U j]fhicig `]ZY( >iff]YX kcf_ XcbY ]b ]ff]hUh]cb UhhfUWhg h\Y ibZUjcfUV`Y UhhYbh]cb cZ ch\Yfg( HYU` kcf_ ]g U`kUmg ei]Yh& WcbghUbh& UbX ]bWcbgd]Wicig( 5W LV QRW HQRXJK WR KH D KDUGZRUNLQJ SHUVRQ& ?KLQN* ZKDW GR \RX ZRUN DW, v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

<cf YjYfm ]X`Y dYfgcb& h\YfY ]g Ubch\Yf dYfgcb k\c kcf_g hcc aiW\( <cf YjYfm dYfgcb k\c YUhg hc YlWYgg& h\YfY ]g Ubch\Yf dYfgcb gcaYk\YfY k\c ]g \ib[fm4 CiW\ cZ h\Y UWh]j]hm cZ ]X`Y dYcd`Y k\c dfYhYbX h\Uh h\Ym UfY Vigm k]h\ kcf_ ]g aYfY`m YbhYfhU]b]b[5 ]h ^igh UXXg U VifXYb hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y( J\]g WUb VY gU]X cZ U`` `ilif]Ubh YbhYfhU]baYbhg(

FJRUJOHJS ÂĂ 7`` hfiY k]gXca UbX U`` hfiY ZU]h\ UfY W`YUf`m YldfYggYX ]b h\Y gUaY acfU` `Uk( 7`` h\Y kcf`X ]g giV^YWh hc cbY `Uk& UbX U`` h\]b_]b[ VY]b[g \UjY h\Y gUaY VUg]W ]bhY``YWh( J\YfYZcfY& U`` k]gY aYb g\UfY h\Y gUaY ]XYU cZ dYfZYWh]cb( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y acfY ? XYX]WUhY am h]aY hc hkc h\]b[g& h\Y acfY h\Ym Z]`` am `]ZY k]h\ YjYf']bWfYUg]b[ d`YUgifY( J\Y Z]fgh ]g h\Y g_m UVcjY aY& UbX h\Y gYWcbX ]g h\Y acfU` `Uk k]h\]b aY( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?KHUHIRUH DOO WKLQJV ZKDWVRHYHU \H ZRXOG WKDW PHQ VKRXOG GR WR \RX$ GR \H HYHQ VR WR WKHP* IRU WKLV LV WKH ODZ DQG WKH SURSKHWV& vC7JJ>;M 14+,

CcfU` `Uk ]g gc cVj]cig UbX W`YUf h\Uh YjYb dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch _bck h\Y `Uk \UjY bc YlWigY Zcf j]c`Uh]b[ ]h( J\Ym \UjY cb`m cbY fYWcifgY4 hc XYbm h\Y]f ]bhY``YWh& k\]W\ h\Ym Xc(

FJRUJOHJS ÂÅ 8`Ua]b[ ch\Yfg ]g Ub YbhYfhU]baYbh k\]W\ gcaY dYcd`Y `]_Y UbX WUbbch fYghfU]b h\YagY`jYg Zfca( M\Yb mci gYY U`` h\Y \Ufa h\]g V`Ua]b[ WUigYg& mci gYY h\Uh ]h ]g U g]b bch hc ghcd dYcd`Y Zfca dfUWh]W]b[ h\]g YbhYfhU]baYbh( ?Z mci kUbh hc V`UaY aY& mci g\ci`X bch VY k]h\ aY( Oci g\ci`X VY ]bg]XY aY( v7:7C C?9A?;M?9P

?UXWK LV DFKLHYHG WKURXJK GLVFXVVLRQ$ KXW WKH ZLVHU PDQ VWRSV WKH DUJXPHQWV& Eif [fYUhYgh ]adYfZYWh]cbg UfY ]b cif ]bbYf j]g]cb( MY UfY gc g\cfhg][\hYX h\Uh kY WUbbch gYY VUX h\]b[g ]b ch\Yfg& Vih kY WUbbch Z]bX VUX h\]b[g ]b cifgY`jYg Ug kY``( v;:M7H: 8HEMD

7g gccb Ug mci ghUfh V`Ua]b[ U dYfgcb& ghcd mcifgY`Z( HYaYaVYf bch hc gUm gcaYh\]b[ VUX UVcih gcaYcbY& YjYb ]Z mci _bck ]h hc VY hfiY& UbX YgdYW]U``m ]Z mci UfY bch WYfhU]b Vih UfY cb`m fYdYUh]b[ [cgg]d(

FJRUJOHJS ÂǺ Ccgh dYcd`Y UWh& bch UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y]f aYX]hUh]cbg& UbX bch UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y]f ZYY`]b[g& Vih Ug ]Z \mdbch]nYX& VUgYX cb gcaY gYbgY`Ygg fYdYh]h]cb cZ dUhhYfbg( CRX VKRXOG EH EUDYH HQRXJK WR XVH \RXU RZQ LQWHOOHFW$ LQ OLIH DQG LQ \RXU HGXFDWLRQ& v?CC7DK;B AUbh

?Z& Uacb[ h\Y aUbm jc]WYg k\]W\ gdYU_ ]b am gci`& ?

Wci`X cb`m fYWc[b]nY am gci`rg hfiY jc]WY& h\Yb ? kci`X bYjYf aU_Y a]ghU_Yg& UbX bYjYf Xc Yj]`( J\]g ]g k\m ]h ]g bYWYggUfm hc _bck mcifgY`Z( ?Z mci gYY h\Uh mci UfY bch VY\Uj]b[ UWWcfX]b[ hc mcif ]bbYf XYg]fYg& Vih VYWUigY cZ gcaY cihYf ]bZ`iYbWY& ghcd UbX Wcbg]XYf k\Yh\Yf k\Uh Xf]jYg mci ]g [ccX cf VUX(

FJRUJOHJS ÆĊ McfgY h\Ub U`` h\Y hfciV`Yg UbX \cffcfg cZ kUf ]g h\Y dYfx jYfg]cb cZ a]bXgYh WUigYg( 7fa]Yg Yl]gh UbX h\Y Wcgh cZ kUf Yl]ghg& UbX dYcd`Y aigh kfYgh`Y hc Z]bX Yld`UbUh]cbg Zcf k\Uh Yl]ghg( MUf WUbbch VY Yld`U]bYX k]h\ h\Y ]bhY``YWh& gc hc ^igh]Zm ]h& dYcd`Y WfYUhY ]bhY``YWhiU` dYfjYfg]cbg( 5V WKHUH DQ\WKLQJ PRUH DEVXUG WKDQ D SHUVRQ KDYLQJ D ULJKW WR NLOO PH EHFDXVH ZH OLYH RQ WZR RSSRVLWH EDQNV RI WKH ULYHU$ DQG RXU NLQJV TXDUUHO ZLWK HDFK RWKHU , v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb dYcd`Y k]`` ibXYfghUbX h\Y ghix d]X]h]Yg cZ kUf( T v9>7HB;I H?9>;

;ifcdYUb Wcibhf]Yg \UjY UVcih Zcif a]``]cb dYcd`Y gYfjx ]b[ ]b h\Y Ufam( Jkc h\]fXg cZ h\Y]f ViX[Yh UfY gdYbh cb a]`]hUfm gdYbX]b[( v=KIJ7L; :; CEB?D7H?

:c bch hfm hc ^igh]Zm kUf cf h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ h\Y a]`]hUfm( ?Z mci hfm hc Udd`m `c[]WU` h\ci[\h hc Yld`U]b h\]b[g h\Uh UfY Yj]`& h\Y YZZcfh k]`` cb`m dfYjYbh mcif ]bhY``YWh UbX dc]x gcb mcif \YUfh(

FJRUJOHJS ÃÀ J\Y acfY `cbY`m U dYfgcb ]g& h\Y acfY W`YUf`m \Y WUb \YUf h\Y jc]WY cZ =cX( J\Y k]`` hc UWWcad`]g\ mcif [ccX ]bhYbh]cbg XYdYbXg cb k\Yh\Yf mci jc]WY h\Ya( Oci fYaYaVYf h\Y h\]b[g cZ k\]W\ mci gdc_Y ]b mcif mcih\ Ug ]Z h\Ym kYfY Z`ckYfg h\Uh mci hcfY cih cZ U Z`ckYf VYX UbX h\fYk UkUm& UbX h\Yb gUk `m]b[ cb h\Y YUfh\& ZUXYX ]bhc h\Y X]fh( ?b h\Y ]adcfhUbh eiYgh]cbg cZ `]ZY& kY UfY U`kUmg U`cbY( Eif XYYdYgh ]bbYf h\ci[\hg WUbbch VY ibXYfghccX Vm ch\x Yfg( J\Y VYgh dUfh cZ h\Y XfUaU h\Uh [cYg cb XYYd ]b cif gci` ]g U acbc`c[iY& cf& VYhhYf hc gUm& U jYfm g]bWYfY Wcbx jYfgUh]cb VYhkYYb =cX& cif WcbgW]YbWY& UbX cifgY`Z( v>;DH? 7C?;B

?HPSRUDU\ VROLWXGH IURP DOO WKLQJV LQ WKLV OLIH$ WKH PHGLWDc WLRQ ZLWKLQ \RXUVHOI DERXW WKH GLYLQH$ LV IRRG DV QHFHVVDU\ IRU \RXU VRXO DV PDWHULDO IRRG LV IRU \RXU ERG\&

EIUQHJS Á 7 gU[Y ]g bch UZfU]X cZ `UW_ cZ _bck`YX[Y4 \Y ]g bch UZfU]X cZ \Yg]hUh]cbg& cf \UfX kcf_& Vih \Y ]g UZfU]X cZ cb`m cbY h\]b[vhc dfYhYbX hc _bck h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y XcYg bch _bck( Oci g\ci`X ghiXm acfY hc ibXYfghUbX h\Uh mci _bck `]hh`Y( vC?9>;B :<( CEDJ7?=D;

DYjYf VY Ug\UaYX hc UXa]h k\Uh mci Xc bch _bck( v7H78?9 FHEL;H8

<XW HYHU\WKLQJ WR WKH WHVW$ KROGIDVW WR WKDW ZKLFK LV JRRG& v? J>;II7BED?7DI /4,+

HYU` k]gXca WcaYg& bch Zfca _bck]b[ k\Uh ]g [ccX UbX k\Uh g\ci`X VY XcbY& Vih Zfca _bck]b[ k\]W\ ]g h\Y VYhx hYf h\]b[ UbX k\]W\ ]g h\Y kcfgY& UbX h\YfYZcfY& k\Uh g\ci`X VY XcbY UbX k\Uh g\ci`X VY XcbY `UhYf( Jc VY k]gY cbY aigh ghiXm Vch\ [ccX UbX VUX h\ci[\hg UbX UWhg& Vih cbY g\ci`X ghiXm h\Y VUX Z]fgh( Oci g\ci`X Z]fgh _bck k\Uh ]g QRW W`YjYf& k\Uh ]g QRW ^igh& UbX k\Uh ]g QRW bYWYggUfm hc Xc(

EIUQHJS Â HY`][]cb ]g h\Uh k\]W\ hY``g U dYfgcb k\c \Y ]g UbX k\Uh h\Y bUhifY cZ h\Y kcf`X ]b k\]W\ \Y `]jYg ]g MY g\ci`X hYUW\ cif W\]`XfYb h\cgY df]bW]d`Yg h\Uh UfY Wcaacb hc U`` fY`][]cbgv8iXX\]gh& Cig`]a& 9\f]gh]Ub& @Yk]g\& UbX gc cb& h\Uh ]g& Zcf h\Y acfU` gW]YbWY cZ `cjY UbX h\Y ib]Z]WUh]cb cZ U`` dYcd`Y( 9RVW SHRSOH GR QRW OLVWHQ WR 3RG EXW DGRUH KLP& 5W LV EHWWHU QRW WR DGRUH EXW WR OLVWHQ& CcfU` hYUW\]b[ ]g bch Wcad`YhY ]Z ]h ]g bch fY`][]cig& Vih fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[ ]g igY`Ygg ]Z ]h ]g bch VUgYX cb acfU`]hm& h\Uh ]g& ]Z ]h XcYg bch `YUX hc U [ccX `]ZY(

EIUQHJS Ã 8][ kYU`h\ k]`` bch []jY mci gUh]gZUWh]cb( J\Y acfY mcif kYU`h\ [fckg& h\Y acfY mcif fYei]fYaYbhg [fck k]h\ ]h( 5W LV GLIILFXOW LI QRW LPSRVVLEOH WR ILQG VRPH UHDVRQDEOH OLPLW IRU DFTXLULQJ PRUH DQG PRUH SURSHUW\& v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

Oci g\ci`X UWei]fY h\Y _]bX cZ kYU`h\ k\]W\ WUbbch VY ghc`Yb Zfca mci Vm h\]YjYg& k\]W\ dYcd`Y ]b dckYf WUbbch hU_Y Zfca mci& k\]W\ k]`` ghUm k]h\ mci YjYb UZhYf mcif XYUh\& bYjYf X]a]b]g\]b[ UbX bYjYfX]gUddYUf]b[( J\]g kYU`h\ ]g mcif gci`( v?D:?7D FHEL;H8

J\YfY UfY hkc kUmg bch hc giZZYf Zfca dcjYfhm J\Y Z]fgh ]g hc UWei]fY acfY kYU`h\( J\YgYWcbX ]g hc `]a]h mcif fYei]fYaYbhg( J\Y Z]fgh ]g bch U`kUmg k]h\]b cif dckYf& Vih h\Y gYWcbX ]g U`kUmg ]b cif dckYf(

EIUQHJS Ä HYU` `cjY fYZYfg bch ^igh hc `cjY Zcf U dUfh]Wi`Uf dYfgcb Vih hc h\Y gd]f]hiU` ghUhY cZ `cj]b[ YjYfmcbY( Jc `cjY aYUbg hc `]jY k]h\]b h\Y `]jYg cZ h\cgY k\ca mci `cjY( 0R QRW IRUFH RWKHUV WR ORYH \RX* MXVW ORYH RWKHUV$ DQG \RX ZLOO KH ORYHG& 7 \c`m dYfgcb"g `]jYg ]b h\Y kcf`X& Vih \Y ]g WcbWYfbYX acgh cZ U`` UVcih \]g Uhh]hiXY hc dYcd`Y( >Y WUb ZYY` U`` dYcd`Y& UbX \Y WUb gYbgY U`` dYcd`Y& UbX U`` dYcd`Y hifb h\Y]f YUfg UbX YjYg hc \]a( vB7E'JPK

M]h\cih `cjY bch\]b[ WUb Vf]b[ mci [ccXbYgg& UbX YjYfm UWh]cb ]bgd]fYX k]h\ `cjY& YjYb ]Z ]h gYYag gaU`` UbX ib]ax dcfhUbh& k]`` Vf]b[ mci gcaY Zfi]hg UZhYfkUfX( v<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

HY`][]cb ]g h\Y \][\Ygh Zcfa cZ `cjY( vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

J\Y acfY U dYfgcb YldfYggYg \]g `cjY& h\Y acfY dYcd`Y `cjY \]a5 UbX h\Y acfY dYcd`Y `cjY \]a& h\Y YUg]Yf ]h ]g Zcf \]a hc `cjY ch\Yfg( ?b h\]g kUm& `cjY ]g YhYfbU`(

EIUQHJS Ć Ocif gd]f]h aigh WcbghUbh`m UggYfh ]hgY`Z VYWUigY mcif VcXm ]g WcbghUbh`m YlYfh]b[ ]hgY`Z( 7g gccb Ug mci ghcd kcf_]b[ Uh mcif gd]f]h& h\Yb mcif VcXm k]`` \UjY Wcad`YhY dckYf cjYf mci( M\Uh ]g bch W`YUf g\ci`X VY W`YUfYX id( M\Uh ]g bch YUgm hc Xc g\ci`X VY XcbY k]h\ [fYUh dYfg]ghYbWY( v9ED<K9?KI

MY giZZYf Zfca cif j]WYg& UbX hfm hc ghfi[[`Y k]h\ h\Ya& UbX h\Y fYUgcb Zcf h\]g ghfi[[`Y ]g h\Uh kY UfY bch dYfZYWh( 8ih cif gU`jUh]cb ]g ]b h\]g ghfi[[`Y k]h\ j]WYg& UbX ]Z =cX kYfY hc hU_Y UkUm cif UV]`]hm hc Z][\h cif j]WYg& h\Yb kY kci`X VY `YZh k]h\ h\Ya ZcfYjYf( v8B7?I; F7I97B

7 [ccX h\]b[ ]g U`kUmg XcbY k]h\ Ub YZZcfh& UbX k\Yb h\Y YZZcfh ]g fYdYUhYX gYjYfU` h]aYg& h\Yb U [ccX h\]b[ VYWcaYg U \UV]h( 0R QRW GHWHVW DQ\ DFWLRQ ZKLFK KHOSV \RX WR DFKLHYH JRRG$ RU HYHQ PRUH LPSRUWDQWO\bZKLFK FDQ SUHYHQW \RX IURP GRLQJ HYLO&

EIUQHJS Ă ?``bYgg g\ci`X VY j]YkYX Ug U bUhifU` WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY( DY[`YWh]b[ mcif \YU`h\ WUb dfYjYbh mci Zfca gYfj]b[ dYcd`Y& UbX hcc aiW\ UhhYbh]cb hc mcif VcXm UbX ]hg \YU`h\ WUb Vf]b[ h\Y gUaY fYgi`hg( ?b cfXYf hc Z]bX h\Y a]XX`Y kUm& mci g\ci`X hU_Y WUfY cZ mcif VcXm cb`m hc h\Y YlhYbh h\Uh Xc]b[ gc \Y`dg mci hc gYfjY ch\Yfg& UbX XcYg bch ghcd mci Zfca gYfj]b[ h\Ya( Dc ]``bYgg WUb dfYjYbh U dYfgcb Zfca k\Uh \Y \Ug hc Xc( ?Z mci WUbbch kcf_& h\Yb []jY mcif `cjY hc dYcd`Y( ?``bYggYg cZ h\Y a]bX UfY aiW\ acfY XUb[Yfcig h\Ub ]``x bYggYg cZ h\Y VcXm( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

0R QRW EH DIUDLG$ RI LOOQHVV$ DQG GR QRW WKLQN WKDW EHLQJ LOO IUHHV \RX IURP \RXU PRUDO UHTXLUHPHQWV&

EIUQHJS Ĉ Oci WUb WU`` =cX Vm jUf]cig bUaYg& mci WUb Ujc]X \]g bUaY U`hc[Yh\Yf& Vih mci WUbbch Ujc]X UWWYdh]b[ \]g Yl]gx hYbWY( Dch\]b[ Yl]ghg \YfY ]Z =cX XcYg bch Yl]gh( 7`` ? _bck ? _bck VYWUigY h\YfY ]g =cX& UbX ? _bck >]a VYWUigY >Y []jYg aY h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ YjYfmh\]b[( BYh ig h\]b_ UVcih =cX& fYaYaVYf >]a& UbX hU`_ hc >]a Ug cZhYb Ug kY WUb( v;F?9J;JKI

3RG LV QRW DQ LGRO+ KH LV DQ LGHDO ZKLFK ZH VKRXOG VWULYH IRU LQ RXU HYHU\GD\ OLIH& vBK9O C7BBEHO

?h ]g jYfm ]adcfhUbh hc fYaYaVYf =cX& bch bYWYggUf]`m k]h\ kcfXg& Vih ]b h\Y gYbgY cZ VY]b[ UkUfY cZ >]a Zc`x `ck]b[ mcif UWh]cbg& giddcfh]b[ h\Ya cf Wf]h]W]n]b[ h\Ya( Higg]Ub dYUgUbhg \UjY U gUm]b[4 s:c mci fYaYaVYf =cX6t

EIUQHJS Ǻ Eb`m dYcd`Y k\c \UjY bYjYf h\ci[\h UVcih `]ZYrg acgh ]adcfhUbh ]ggiYg WUb VY`]YjY h\Uh YjYfmh\]b[ ]g dcgg]V`Y Zcf h\Y \iaUb ]bhY``YWh( J\YfY UfY h\fYY hmdYg cZ dYcd`Y( <]fgh& h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch VY`]YjY ]b Ubmh\]b[5 h\Yb& h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y k\c VY`]YjY cb`m ]b h\cgY hYUW\]b[g h\Ym kYfY Vfci[\h id hc VY`]YjY( <]bU``m& h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y k\c VY`]YjY ]b h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ h\Ym ibXYfghUbX k]h\ h\Y]f \YUfhg& UbX h\]g `Ugh [fcid cZ dYcd`Y ]g h\Y k]gYgh UbX acgh fYgc`ihY( 7`` VY[]bb]b[g UfY amghYf]Yg& h\Y amghYfm cZ WfYUh]cb( v>;DH? 7C?;B

9cbhYadcfUfm gW]YbWY WUbbch hYUW\ mci UVcih =cX UbX >]g j]fhiYg( J\Y gW]YbWYg WUbbch aU_Y mci j]fhicig& Vih h\Ym \Y`d mci cb mcif kUm(

$ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWU

0R QRW SUHWHQG WR XQGHUVWDQG VRPHWKLQJ WKDW \RX GR QRW& 5W LV RQH RI WKH ZRUVW SRVVLEOH WKLQJV WR GR&

EIUQHJS Ą 7 dYfgcb k\c WcaYg ]bhc Ub ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y `]ZY cZ \]g gd]f]hiU` gY`Z WUbbch ZYUf Yj]`& Y]h\Yf ]b `]ZY cf ]b XYUh\( ?KDW ZKLFK LV KRUQ RI WKH IOHVK LV IOHVK+ DQG WKDW ZKLFK LV KRUQ RI WKH >SLULW LV VSLULW& CUfjY` bch h\Uh ? gU]X ibhc h\YY& OY aigh VY Vca U[U]b( J\Y k]bX V`ckYh\ k\YfY ]h `]ghYh\& UbX h\ci \YUfYgh h\Y gcibX h\YfYcZ& Vih WUbgh bch hY`` k\YbWY ]h WcaYh\& UbX k\]h\Yf ]h [cYh\4 gc ]g YjYfm cbY h\Uh ]g Vca cZ h\Y Id]f]h( v@c\b -40'2

J\Y gci`g cZ k]gY dYcd`Y `cc_ hc h\Y ZihifY ghUhY cZ h\Y]f Yl]ghYbWY5 U`` cZ h\Y]f h\ci[\hg UfY WcbWYbhfUhYX hckUfX YhYfb]hm( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

J\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y gci` h\Uh WUb VY [ccX k]h\cih =cX( vBiW]ig 7DD7;KI I;D;97

IU`jUh]cb ]b U`` h\]b[g `]Yg ]b h\Y]f gd]f]hiU`]hm( ;j]` WUbbch hciW\ U dYfgcb k\c _bckg \]g gd]f]hiU`]hm(

EIUQHJS ÁÀ 7 aUb ]g Vch\ Ub Ub]aU` UbX U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY( 7g Ub Ub]aU`& U aUb ]g UZfU]X cZ XYUh\5 Ug U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ \Y XcYg bch YldYf]YbWY XYUh\( 5Q WKH ODVW PRPHQWV EHIRUH GHDWK$ WKH VRXO OHDYHV WKH ERG\& 5W XQLWHV ZLWK WKH OLPLWOHVV$ WLPHOHVV$ DQG HWHUQDO VRXO DQG WUDQVIRUPV LQWR DQRWKHU IRUP$ ZH NQRZ QRW ZKLFK& -IWHU GHDWK$ RXU ERG\ LV OHIW EHKLQG$ DQG LW EHFRPHV RQO\ DQ REMHFW IRU REVHUYDWLRQ& :YUh\ aUf_g U W\Ub[Y& ]h aUf_g h\Y X]gUddYUfUbWY cZ h\Y XkY``]b[ d`UWY cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY( J\Y WcbgW]YbWY ]hgY`Z WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm XYUh\& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug h\Y W\Ub[Y cZ U h\YUhYf gYh WUbbch XYghfcm U gdYWhUhcf( FYf\Udg mci ZYUf h\Y W\Ub[Yg h\Uh XYUh\ k]`` Vf]b[6 8ih U g]a]`Uf [fYUh W\Ub[Y U`fYUXm \UddYbYX Uh h\Y h]aY cZ mcif V]fh\& UbX bch\]b[ VUX WUaY cih cZ ]h(

EIUQHJS ÁÁ Ccgh dYcd`Y UfY dfciX& bch cZ h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfcigY fYgdYWh& Vih cZ h\cgY k\]W\ UfY ibbYWYggUfm& cf YjYb \UfaZi`4 ZUaY& dckYf& UbX kYU`h\( J\YfY ]g bc kcfgY gWcibXfY` h\Ub \Y k\c& k\Yb VY `cc_g UfcibX \]agY`Z Uh ch\Yf dYcd`Y& WUb U`kUmg Z]bX Ub YjYb kcfgY gWcibXfY` h\Ub \]agY`Z5 UbX h\YfYZcfY& WUb VY ei]hY gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ \]agY`Z( 7 dYfgcb k\c `cjYg \]agY`Z \Ug h\Y UXjUbhU[Y cZ \Uj]b[ jYfm ZYk WcadYh]hcfg( ?KHUH LV QR ZLVGRP LQ KH ZKR WKLQNV WKDW KH LV ZLVH& 7 gY`Z]g\ dYfgcb ]g U`kUmg `]a]hYX( 7bX cbY ]g WcbbYWhYX k]h\ h\Y ch\Yf4 \Y ]g gY`Z]g\ VYWUigY \Y ]g `]a]hYX5 \Y ]g `]a]hYX VYWUigY \Y ]g gY`Z]g\( 7 dfciX dYfgcb ]b]h]U``m WUigYg ch\Yf dYcd`Y hc h\]b_ h\Uh \Y \Ug acfY ]adcfhUbWY h\Ub \Y UWhiU``m \Ug& Vih k\Yb h\]g ]bZ`iYbWY X]gUddYUfg& Ug ]h U`kUmg XcYg& \Y VYWcaYg cb`m h\Y cV^YWh cZ ^c_Yg(

EIUQHJS ÁÂ -Q\ GHSDUWXUH IURP DFFHSWHG WUDGLWLRQV DQG FXVWRPV UHTXLUHV D ODUJH DQG VHULRXV HIIRUW$ EXW WUXH XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI QHZ WKLQJV DOZD\V UHTXLUHV VXFK DQ HIIRUW& 7 gcW]Yhm gUmg hc U aUb4 sJ\]b_ Ug kY h\]b_&'VY`]YjY ]b k\Uh kY VY`]YjY& YUh UbX Xf]b_ k\Uh kY YUh UbX Xf]b_& UbX XfYgg ]b h\Y kUm kY XfYgg(t vBK9O C7BEHO

Oci g\ci`X VY\UjY Ug mci h\]b_ ]g [ccX& Vih bch Zc``ckx ]b[ h\Y UXj]WY cZ h\Y WfckX( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

?h ]g VUX hc ]ff]hUhY dYcd`Y Vm ghYdd]b[ VUW_ Zfca h\Y]f Wighcag UbX hfUX]h]cbg& Vih ]h ]g YjYb kcfgY hc XYbm h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY UbX ]bhY``YWh Vm Zc``ckx ]b[ h\Y Wighcag cZ h\Y WfckX(

EIUQHJS ĄǼ 7 ghUhY gmghYa& bc aUhhYf k\Uh _]bX cZ ghUhY gmghYa ]h ]g& ZibWh]cbg Uh U ZUf fYacjY Zfca h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ 9\f]gx h]Ub]hm( ?b h\cgY Wcibhf]Yg k\YfY k]gY dYcd`Y UfY ]b dckYf& h\Y]f giV^YWhg Xc bch bch]WY h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ h\Y]f fi`Yfg( vB7E'JPK

IhUhY j]c`YbWY WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm XYWfYY& cb`m Vm hfih\ UbX `cjY( CUmVY ghUhY j]c`YbWY kUg bYWYggUfm Zcf dfYj]cig [YbYfUh]cbg5 aUmVY ]h ]g YjYb bYWYggUfm bck& Vih dYcd`Y g\ci`X WcbWY]jY cZ U _]bX cZ ZihifY [cjYfbaYbh ]b k\]W\ j]c`YbWY k]`` bch VY bYWYggUfm( CRX VKRXOG OLYH LQ VXFK D ZD\ WKDW YLROHQFH LV QRW QHFHVVDU\ IRU \RX&

EIUQHJS ÁĂ =cX ]g ]b U`` cZ ig& UbX ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y Zcf U`` cZ ig hc Z]bX UbX ibXYfghUbX \]a h\YfY( Jc _bck mcifgY`Z ]g hc X]gWcjYf h\Y [ccX h\Uh `]Yg k]h\]b( 3RG LV FORVH WR XV$ KH LV ZLWK XV* WKH GLYLQH VSLULWLV LQVLGH RI XV& 5I KH ZHUH QRW$ WKH SRZHU WR KH JRRG ZRXOG EH EH\RQG RXU UHDFK& - SHUVRQ FDQQRW EH JRRG ZLWKRXW 3RG&

$ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWU

?Z mci UfY [c]b[ h\fci[\ U \UfX h]aY& kcf_ \UfXYf hc ibXYfghUbX =cX5 Ug gccb Ug mci ibXYfghUbX >]a& U`` X]ZZ]x Wi`h h\]b[g k]`` VYWcaY YUgm& UbX mci k]`` ZYY` `cjY UbX ^cm( ?Z U dYfgcb XcYg bch ZYY` U X]j]bY ZcfWY k]h\]b \]agY`Z& h\]g XcYg bch aYUb h\Uh U X]j]bY ZcfWY XcYg bch Yl]gh ]b \]a& Vih h\Uh \Y \Ug bch mYh `YUfbYX \ck hc fYWc[b]nY ]h(

EIUQHJS ÁÅ ?Z h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y UbX h\YfY ]g =cX& h\Yb h\YfY UfY fY`Ux h]cbg\]dg VYhkYYb =cX UbX dYcd`Y( J\YgY fY`Uh]cbg\]dg UfY W\Ub[]b[ k]h\ h]aY& UbX aUb_]bXrg fY`][]cig WcbWYdh]cbg UfY WcbghUbh`m Yjc`j]b[& WcbghUbh`m ]adfcj]b[& VYWca]b[ acfY W`YUf UbX YUg]`m ibXYfghccX k]h\ h\Y dUggU[Y cZ h]aY( =HOLJLRXV FRQVFLHQFH RI PDQNLQG LV QRW ULJLG$ LW LV FKDQJLQJ DOO WKH WLPH$ EHFRPLQJ SXUHU DQG FOHDUHU& =cX ]g gd]f]h UbX dUfh cZ h\]g gd]f]h `]jYg ]bg]XY aY UbX []jYg gYbgY hc am `]ZY( J\YfY ]g aiW\ [ccX hc VY `YUfbYX Zfca h\Y AcfUb& Zfca h\Y 8iXX\]ghg& Zfca 9cbZiW]ig& Zfca h\Y E`X JYghUaYbh& Zfca h\Y ?bX]Ub KdUb]g\UXg& UbX Zfca h\Y DYk JYghUx aYbh( 8ih h\Y W`cgYf U fY`][]cig h\]b_Yf cf d\]`cgcd\Yf ]g hc ig ]b h]aY& h\Y acfY \Y WUb \Y`d ig XfUk Zfca h\YgY hYUW\]b[g ]b h\Y `][\h cZ cif dfYgYbh'XUm `]jYg(

EIUQHJS ÁǺ J\Y dUgh bc `cb[Yf Yl]ghg5 h\Y ZihifY \Ug bch mYh WcaY5 h\YfY ]g cb`m h\Y dfYgYbh( 7bX cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh WUb h\Y X]j]bY bUhifY cZ h\Y ZfYY \iaUb gci` VY aUb]ZYghYX( J\Yb @Ygig gU]X ibhc h\Ya& OYh U `]hh`Y k\]`Y ]g h\Y `][\h k]h\ mci( MU`_ k\]`Y mY \UjY h\Y `][\h& `Ygh XUf_bYgg WcaY idcb mci4 Zcf \Y h\Uh kU`_Yh\ ]b XUf_bYgg _bckYh\ bch k\]h\Yf \Y [cYh\( v@E>D +,4-/

;jYfmcbY _bckg h\Uh cif \UV]hg UfY ]adfcjYX UbX ghfYb[h\YbYX h\fci[\ h\Y]f YlYfW]gY( ?b cfXYf hc VY U [ccX kU`_Yf& mci bYYX hc kU`_ U `ch5 ]b cfXYf hc VY U ghfcb[ fibbYf& mci bYYX hc fib ZfYeiYbh`m5 ]b cfXYf hc VY U dYfWYdh]jY fYUXYf& mci ci[\h hc fYUX Ug aiW\ Ug mci WUb( J\Y gUaY ]g hfiY cZ mcif gci`4 ]Z mci VYWcaY Ub[fm& mci aigh _bck h\Uh mci bch cb`m dYfZcfa Yj]`& Vih mci U`gc WfYUhY Ub Yj]` \UV]h& UbX mci ]bWfYUgY mcif dchYbh]U` Zcf Zifh\Yf Yj]`( v;F?9J;JKI

5I \RX ZDQW WR GR D JRRG GHHG$ GR LW QRZ& ?KH WLPH ZLOO SDVV$ DQG \RX ZLOO QRW KDYH WKH FKDQFH DJDLQ&

EIUQHJS ÁĄ J\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY ]g fYjYU`YX hc h\cgY k\c UfY fYUXm hc UWWYdh h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ k]`` VY fYjYU`YX( 7bX ]h ]g \Y k\c \Ug U`fYUXm XYW]XYX h\Uh \Y k]`` UWWYdh h\Y hfih\ Ug ]h ]g& UbX bch h\Y hfih\ ]hgY`Z& k\]W\ k]`` W\Ub[Y h\Y kUm cZ `]ZY \Y \Ug VYYb UWWighcaYX hc( BKR DP 5, BKDW VKRXOG 5 GR, BKDW VKRXOG ( EHOLHYH LQ DQG ZKDW VKRXOG 5 KRSH IRU, 7`` cZ d\]`cgcd\m ]g ]b h\YgY eiYgx h]cbg& gU]X h\Y d\]`cgcd\Yf B]W\hYbVYf[( 8ih Uacb[ U`` h\YgY eiYgh]cbg& h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh cbY ]g h\Uh k\]W\ ]g ]b h\Y a]XX`Y( ?Z U dYfgcb _bckg k\Uh \Y g\ci`X Xc& \Y k]`` ibXYfghUbX YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ \Y g\ci`X _bck( BRH WR WKH SHRSOH ZKR ORRN ZLWKRXW XQGHUVWDQGLQJ$ ZKR GR QRW NQRZ WKHLU IRXQGDWLRQV& v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

;jYfm V]fX U`kUmg _bckg k\YfY hc aU_Y \Yf bYgh( 7bX ]Z g\Y _bckg \ck UbX k\YfY hc aU_Y \Yf bYgh& h\]g aYUbg h\Uh g\Y _bckg \Yf difdcgY ]b `]ZY( 7bX k\m XcYg aUb& k\c ]g h\Y k]gYgh Uacb[ U`` WfYUhifYg& bch _bck h\Uh k\]W\ Ubm V]fX _bckg& h\Uh ]g& \]g difdcgY ]b `]ZY6 v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

J\Y fYU` aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY ]g bch dcgg]V`Y hc YaVfUWY& ]Z mci UfY `cc_]b[ Zcf h\Y ib]jYfgU` aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY( 7bX Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY ]h ]g gc g]ad`Y h\Uh ]h WUb VY Yld`U]bYX hc Zcc`g UbX hc ]bZUbhg k\Yb k\Uh hc _bck ]g k\Uh mci g\ci`X Xc Ug Ub ]bX]j]XiU`(

EIUQHJS ÂÀ J\Y `]ZY cZ aUb ]g Z]``YX k]h\ ]bhY``YWh cb`m k\Yb h\Y Zi`x Z]``aYbh cZ mcif Xihm ]g ibXYfghccX( MY U`` _bck Zcf gifY h\Uh XYUh\ kU]hg Zcf ig( MY Xc bch _bck k\Yb& ^igh Ug kY Xc bch _bck k\YfY kY WUaY Zfca( v>;DHO =;EH=;

L]fhiY ]g U gYfj]WY k\]W\ U dYfgcb g\ci`X Xc Zcf \]agY`Z( ?Z h\YfY kYfY bc \YUjYb UbX bc =cX k\c fi`YX h\]g kcf`X& YjYb h\Yb j]fhiY kci`X VY h\Y bYWYggUfm `Uk cZ `]ZY( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

BKHQ \RX DSSURDFK D PDQ$ \RX VKRXOG WKLQN QRW DERXW KRZ KH FDQ KHOS \RX$ EXW KRZ \RX PLJKW VHUYH DQG KHOS KLP& MY \UjY h\Y bYWYggUfm `Uk Zcf U`` cif UWh]cbg& UbX h\]g `Uk WUbbch VY fYghf]WhYX Vm Ubm dckYf( J\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ h\]g `Uk ]g dcgg]V`Y YjYb ]b df]gcb& UbX ibXYf h\Y h\fYUh cZ hcfx hifYg UbX XYUh\( Bcc_ Zcf U _]bX `]ZY k\]W\ ]g ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX& UbX h\Yb mci k]`` Zi`Z]`` h\Y Xihm cZ mcif `]ZY(

EIUQHJS ÂÁ ?b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug h\Y ghcfa hfciV`Yg UbX aiXX]Yg h\Y kUhYfg& gc hcc dUgg]cbg hfciV`Y cif gci`g UbX ]bhYfZYfY k]h\ cif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g `]ZY( FYcd`Y k]h\ [fYUh UbX kcbXYfZi` gci`g UfY U`kUmg ei]Yh UbX \Uddm( J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch \UjY gd]f]hiU`]hm UfY U`kUmg ib\Uddm( v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

:c bch VY WcbWYfbYX hcc aiW\ k]h\ k\Uh k]`` \UddYb( ;jYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ \UddYbg k]`` VY [ccX UbX igYZi` Zcf mci( v;F?9J;JKI

7 dYfgcb k]`` ibXYfghUbX \]g d`UWY ]b h\Y kcf`X cb`m k\Yb \Y ibXYfghUbXg \]g gci`( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

=HDO SRZHU LV QRW LQ PRPHQWDU\ GHVLUHV$ EXW LQ FRPSOHWH FDOPQHVV& 9cad`YhY cihYf WU`abYgg ]g ]adcgg]V`Y( 8ih k\Yb h\YfY UfY gcaY WU`a dYf]cXg& kY g\ci`X UddfYW]UhY h\Ya UbX aU_Y h\Ya `Ugh `cb[Yf( J\]g ]g h\Y h]aY k\Yb igYZi` h\ci[\hg UddYUf5 h\Ym VYWcaY ghfcb[Yf UbX [i]XY ig ]b `]ZY(

EIUQHJS ÂÂ CU_Y gifY h\Uh mci Xc bch [cgg]d UVcih mcif Vfch\Yf( ?LPH SDVVHV$ EXW WKH ZRUGV ZKLFK \RX VD\ ZLOO UHPDLQ& Jc ghcd mcif hcb[iY Zfca hU`_]b[ hcc aiW\ ]g U g][b cZ [fYUh j]fhiY( J\Y \iaUb gci`& bch Vm ]hgY`Z& Vih Vm gcaY dckYf& ]g dig\YX W`cgYf UbX W`cgYf hc hfih\ UbX [ccXbYgg& UbX h\Y VYhhYf kY ibXYfghUbX h\]g& h\Y acfY \iaV`Y kY k]`` VY( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

?Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g bYWYggUfm hc ^iX[Y mcif bY][\Vcf& h\Yb gUm h\]g `cc_]b[ X]fYWh`m ]bhc \]g YmYg& UbX gUm h\]g ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci Xc bch WfYUhY Ub]acg]hm(

EIUQHJS ÆǼ 9cbgW]YbWY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[ k\]W\ `]jYg ]b ig( 9cbgW]YbWY ]g h\Y fYU` ^iX[Y VYhkYYb [ccX UbX VUX& Wcbx gW]YbWY ]g k\Uh aU_Yg U dYfgcb g]a]`Uf hc =cX& UbX Wcbx gW]YbWY ]g h\Y [fYUhYgh UXjUbhU[Y cZ \iaUb bUhifY( M]h\cih WcbgW]YbWY h\YfY kci`X VY bch\]b[ h\Uh kci`X fU]gY ig UVcjY h\Y Ub]aU`g& UbX dYcd`Y kci`X acjY Zfca cbY `]Y hc Ubch\Yf( v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

?KH SXUSRVH RI \RXU OLIH LV QRW WR GR DV WKH PDMRULW\ GRHV$ EXW WR OLYH DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH LQQHU ODZ ZKLFK \RX XQGHUVWDQG LQ \RXUVHOI 0R QRW DFW DJDLQVW \RXU FRQVFLHQFH RU DJDLQVW WUXWK& 8LYH OLNH WKLV$ DQG \RX ZLOO IXOILOO WKH WDVN RI \RXU OLIH& vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Oci WUbbch Z][\h k]h\ h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ WcbgW]YbWY( J\YgY UfY h\Y fi`Yg cZ =cX& UbX ]h ]g VYhhYf hc giVa]h hc h\Ya(

EIUQHJS ÂÄ 5I WKH IRXQGDWLRQV RI RXU OLIH ZHUH QRW RI WKH VDPH QDWXUH LQ DOO RI XV$ WKHQ ZH ZRXOG QRW KH DEOH WR H[SODLQ WR HDFK RWKHU WKRVH IHHOLQJV RI FRPSDVVLRQ ZKLFK ZH UHDOO\ H[SHULHQFH& 9cadUgg]cb YldfYggYX ]b fYgdcbgY hc fU[Y ]g h\Y gUaY Ug kUhYf Zcf Z]fY( M\Yb mci UfY ]b U fU[Y& hfm hc ZYY` WcadUgx g]cb Zcf h\Y ch\Yf dYfgcb& UbX h\Yb mcif fU[Y k]`` X]gUddYUf( v7ZhYf 7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

J\YfY UfY aUbm dYcd`Y k\c UfY acfY ib\Uddm h\Ub mci( J\]g aYggU[Y WUbbch VY U fccZ ibXYf k\]W\ mci aUm `]jY& Vih ]h k]`` VY Ybci[\ cZ U fccZ ibXYf k\]W\ mci aUm \]XY Zfca ghcfag( Oci \]XY Zfca mcif a]gZcfhibYg( 8ih ]Z mci _bYk k\Uh ch\Yf dYcd`Y giZZYfYX& h\Yb mci kci`X bch Wcad`U]b UVcih mcif ckb( vIEBED

HYU` WcadUgg]cb VY[]bg cb`m k\Yb mci dih mcifgY`Z ]b h\Y d`UWY cZ h\cgY k\c giZZYf& UbX mci ZYY` fYU` giZZYf]b[(

IYdhYaVYf ,/ 7 dYfgcb WUb ibXYfghUbX \]g difdcgY ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug \Y ibXYfghUbXg \]g X][b]hm( Eb`m U fY`][]cig dYfgcb WUb ibXYfghUbX \]g difdcgY ]b `]ZY( 7 _]b[ Ug_YX U \c`m aUb& s:c mci fYaYaVYf UVcih aY6t J\Y \c`m aUb UbgkYfYX& sOYg& ? h\]b_ UVcih mci& k\Yb ?

Zcf[Yh UVcih =cX(t vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

BH IXOILOO WKH ODZ RI 3RG ZKHQ ZH IHHO WKH OLYHV RI RWKHUV DV RXU RZQ OLIH& v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y ZfYYXca cZ U dYfgcb ]g U [fYUh h\]b[& UbX YjYb h\Y ZfYYXca cZ U k\c`Y bUh]cb VY[]bg Zfca h\Y ZfYYXca cZ U

g]b[`Y ]bX]j]XiU`( Oci g\ci`X fYgdYWh ZfYYXca ]b mcifgY`Z& UbX ]b mcif bY][\Vcf& UbX ]b U`` dYcd`Y( Eb`m \Y k\c ibXYfghUbXg \]agY`Z Ug U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ WUb ibXYfghUbX h\Y gd]f]hiU` X][b]hm cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( IiW\ U dYfgcb k]`` bch `ckYf \]agY`Z k]h\ Ubm UWh k\]W\ ]g bch kcfh\m cZ U gd]f]hiU` dYfgcb(

EIUQHJS ÂĂ <cf h\Y acfU`& gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& h\Y ]adcfhUbWY cZ h\]b[g ]g aYUgifYX bch Vm h\Y]f aUhYf]U` jU`iY& Vih Vm h\Y]f `YjY` cZ [ccXbYgg( J\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y kUbh hc Xc gcaYh\]b[ ibigiU` UbX X]ZZ]Wi`h ]b cfXYf hc ]adfcjY h\Y]f `]jYg& Vih 'h\Ym kci`X VY VYhhYf hc dif]Zm h\Y]f k]g\Yg& UbX ]adfcjY h\Y]f ]bbYf gY`jYg( J\Y gYWcbX h\]b[g UfY aiW\ acfY ]adcfhUbh h\Ub h\Y Z]fgh( v7ZhYf <H7D9E?I <;D;BED

- SHUVRQ XQGHUVWDQGV KLPVHOI QRW WKURXJK WKRXJKWV$ EXW ZLWK DFWLRQV& 5W LV RQO\ WKURXJK PDNLQJ DQ HIIRUW WKDW D SHUVRQ ZLOO XQGHUVWDQG KLV ZRUWK& v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

Jc acjY mcifgY`Z Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U hc h\Y gd]f]hiU` aYUbg hc Xc cb`m gd]f]hiU` h\]b[g( Cm aUhYf]U` VcXm di``g am ]bbYf gY`Z hc ]hgY`Z& Vih ? hfm hc gYdUfUhY am gd]f]hiU` gY`Z Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U` VcXm( J\ci[\ ? igY am VcXm& ? `]jY k]h\]b am gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& k\]W\ ]g am fYU` `]ZY(

EIUQHJS ÆĈ HYU` fY`][]cb WUbbch VY cddcgYX hc ]bhY``YWh( :c bch VY`]YjY h\Uh ]b fY`][]cb mci WUbbch hfigh mcif ]bhY``YWh( J\Y ZcfWY cZ cif ]bhY``YWh aigh giddcfh h\Y ZcibXUh]cbg cZ YjYfm fYU` ZU]h\( vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

?Z =cX& h\Y cV^YWh cZ cif ZU]h\& ]g \][\Yf h\Ub cif ibXYfx ghUbX]b[& UbX ]Z mci Xc bch ibXYfghUbX >]a& ]h XcYg bch aYUb h\Uh mci g\ci`X bch igY mcif ]bhY``YWh hfm]b[ hc ibXYfghUbX >]a( T v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

M\]`Y mY \UjY `][\h& VY`]YjY ]b h\Y `][\h& h\Uh mY aUm VY h\Y W\]`XfYb cZ `][\h( J\YgY h\]b[g gdU_Y @Ygig& UbX XYdUfhYX& UbX X]X \]XY \]agY`Z Zfca h\Ya( v@E>D +,4-0

5Q RUGHU WR XQGHUVWDQG WKH WUXWK$ \RX VKRXOG QRW VXSSUHVV \RXU LQWHOOHFW& ;Q WKH FRQWUDU\$ \RX VKRXOG SXULI\ \RXU LQWHOc OHFW$ H[HUFLVH LW$ DQG LQWHOOHFWXDOO\ WU\ DQG WHVW HYHU\WKLQJ ZKLFK ZH FDQ SRVVLEO\ SXW WR WKH WHVW&

EIUQHJS ÂǺ FU]b ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ cif VcXm& UbX giZZYf]b[ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ cif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& Zfca V]fh\ hc XYUh\( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Oci g\ci`X kY`WcaY YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ \UddYbg hc mci Zfca V]fh\ hc XYUh\& VYWUigY h\Y Yl]ghYbWY UbX h\Y difx dcgY cZ h\Y kcf`X ]g ]b h\YgY WUgYg( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Eb`m ]b h\Y ghcfa WUb mci gYY h\Y Ufh cZ h\Y fYU` gU]`cf5 cb`m cb h\Y VUhh`YZ]Y`X WUb mci gYY h\Y VfUjYfm cZ U gc`X]Yf( J\Y WcifU[Y cZ U g]ad`Y dYfgcb WUb VY gYYb ]b \ck \Y WcdYg k]h\ h\Y X]ZZ]Wi`h UbX XUb[Yfcig g]hiUh]cbg ]b `]ZY( v:7D?;B 79>?DIAO

?KRVH WKLQJV ZKLFK ZH FDOO KDSSLQHVV DQG WKRVH ZKLFK ZH FDOO XQKDSSLQHVV DUH XVHIXO IRU XV$ HVSHFLDOO\ ZKHQ ZH VHF WKHP DV RSSRUWXQLWLHV WR WW\ RXUVHOYHV& J\Y `Y[YbX UVcih h\Y kUbXYf]b[ @Yk k\c kUg giZZYf]b[ h\Y dib]g\aYbh cZ YhYfbU` `]ZY ]g jYfm hfiY( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& h\YfY ]g U `Y[YbX UVcih U aUb k\c kUg dib]g\YX Vm VY]b[ []jYb U `]ZY k]h\cih Ubm giZZYf]b[(

EIUQHJS ÆĊ J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY ]adcfhUbh h\Ub Ub YlUad`Y( ?h `YUXg ig hc Xc [ccX XYYXg k\]W\ kci`X VY ]adcgg]V`Y k]h\cih h\]g YlUad`Y( J\YfYZcfY& ]Z kY igY X]gg]dUhYX cf dUgg]cbUhY cf WfiY` dYcd`Y Ug YlUad`Yg& ]h XYghfcmgpcif gci`( J\Y WcbhfUfm ]g U`gc hfiY( ?KRVH ZKR GR QRW WKLQN LQGHSHQGHQWO\ DUH XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI VRPHERG\ HOVH ZKR WKLQNV IRU WKHP& 5I \RX JLYH \RXU WKRXJKWV WR VRPHERG\ HOVH$ LW LV D P RUH VKDPHIXO VODYHU\ WKDQ LI \RX JLYH \RXU ERG\ WR VRPHRQH WR SRVVHVV& ?Z mci XYg]fY hc Zc``ck gcaYcbY Ug Ub YlUad`Y& Ug aUbm ch\Yf dYcd`Y Xc& Z]fgh ghcd UbX h\]b_ k\Yh\Yf ]h ]g kcfh\x k\]`Y hc Zc``ck h\]g [YbYfU` YlUad`Y( J\cgY k\c UfY bch UZfU]X cZ hfi`m hYff]V`Y h\]b[g Zc``ck ZU`gY YlUad`Yg UbX h\cgY dYcd`Y Zc``ck h\Y dUh\ hc XYghfiWh]cb( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

;j]` ]bZ`iYbWY WUb VY XYghfcmYX cb`m Vm [ccX ]bZ`iYbWY( 7bX h\Y kUm hc fYWY]jY U [ccX ]bZ`iYbWY ]g hc \UjY U [ccX `]ZY(

EIUQHJS ÃÀ 7 gYbgY cZ gY`Z']adcfhUbWY gc \][\ h\Uh ]h gifdUggYg U`` `]a]hg ]g U aYbhU` ]``bYgg WU``YX PDQLD JUDQGLRVD& FYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY j]c`UhYg mcif ZfYYXca( J\cgY dYcd`Y Xc bch _bck h\Uh gUWf]Z]WY []jYg ig Wcax d`YhY ZfYYXca& UbX ZfYYg ig Zfca cifgY`jYg& Zfca h\Y g`Ujx Yfm cZ cif X]gg]dUh]cb( ;XU SDVVLRQV DUH WKH PRVW WHUULEOH W\UDQWV$ DQG ZH FDQ KH WKH VODYH RI WKHP& ;QO\^WHOI%VDFULIFH FDQ IUHH XV IURP WKLV VODYHU\& `wmci hYUW\ ch\Yfg \ck aUbm ]bgYWhg Yl]gh ]b h\]g kcf`X& cf k\Yb mci `cc_ Uh h\Y gdchg cb h\Y gib& cf k\Yb mci kf]hY Ub cdYfU cf U bcjY`vkY Xc h\YgY h\]b[g Zcf X]ZZYfx Ybh difdcgYg( 8ih hc hYUW\ dYcd`Y [ccXbYgg ]g XcbY cb`m Zcf h\Y difdcgY cZ gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY& gYfj]WY hc ch\Yfg& UbX mci WUbbch YldfYgg h\]g hYUW\]b[ k]h\cih gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY( 9\f]gh [UjY \]g `]ZY cb h\Y Wfcgg Zcf U [fYUh difdcgY& bch ]b jU]b( 7bX U gUWf]Z]WY cf giZZYf]b[ ]g bYjYf ]b jU]b& UbX ]h k]`` hf]x iad\ cjYf YjYfmh\]b[(

EIUQHJS ÃÁ Dch\]b[ WUb ]bhYfZYfY k]h\ h\Y [fckh\ cZ hfih\ ]b h\Y kcf`X4 bch\]b[ YlWYdh h\Y k]g\ hc gUjY c`X dfY^iX]WYg( FYcd`Y gUm h\Uh =cX WfYUhYX aUb_]bX UZhYf \]g ]aU[Y( J\]g aYUbg h\Uh aUb WfYUhYX =cX UZhYf \]g ]aU[Y( v=;EH=; B?9>J;DH;H=

'?Z kY VY`]YjY ]b h\Y h\]b[g kY kYfY hUi[\h& h\YfY ]g [ccXx bYgg UbX Yj]` Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY( v>;DHO =;EH=;

>iaUb]hm g`ck`m Vih WYUgY`Ygg`m acjYg ZcfkUfX hc h\Y VYhx hYf UbX VYhhYf ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ h\]g `]ZY( 7acb[ h\Y acgh hYff]V`Y `]Yg cZ U`` ]g hc hYUW\ ZU`gY ZU]h\ hc W\]`XfYb( 0LVUHVSHFW IRU WUDGLWLRQV KDV QRW FDXVHG HYHQ RQH WKRXVDQGWK SDUW RI WKH JUHDW HYLO ZKLFK ZDV FDXVHG E\ WKH ROG SUHMXGLFHV$ WUDGLWLRQV$ FXVWRPV$ DQG LQVWLWXWLRQV ZKLFK VKRXOG QRW H[LVW DW SUHVHQW&

DQWJOHJS Á 7 aUb k\c Wcbg]XYfg \]agY`Z h\Y aUghYf cZ \]g ckb `]ZY WUb bYjYf VY \iaV`Y& VYWUigY \Y h\]b_g h\Uh \Y \Ug bc cV`][Uh]cb hc UbmcbY( J\Y aUb k\c Wcbg]XYfg gYfj]WY hc =cX hc VY h\Y difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY ]g U`kUmg \iaV`Y& VYWUigY \Y ZYY`g h\Uh \Y \Ug bYjYf Zi`Z]``YX \]g cV`][Uh]cbg( 7bX h\Y Udcgh`Yg gU]X ibhc h\Y BcfX& ?bWfYUgY cif ZU]h\( 7bX h\Y BcfX gU]X& ?Z mY \UX ZU]h\ Ug U [fU]b cZ aighUfX gYYX& mY a][\h gUm ibhc h\]g gmWUa]bY hfYY& 8Y h\ci d`iW_YX id& UbX VY h\ci d`UbhYX ]b h\Y gYU5 UbX ]h g\ci`X cVYm mci( 8ih k\]W\ cZ mci& \Uj]b[ U gYfx jUbh d`ck]b[ cf ZYYX]b[ WUhh`Y& k]`` gUm ibhc \]a Vm UbX Vm& k\Yb \Y ]g WcaY Zfca h\Y Z]Y`X& =c UbX g]h Xckb hc aYUh6 7bX k]`` bch fUh\Yf gUm ibhc \]a& CU_Y fYUXm k\YfYk]h\ ? aUm gid& UbX []fX h\mgY`Z& UbX gYfjY aY& h]`` ? \UjY YUhYb UbX Xfib_Yb5 UbX UZhYfkUfX h\ci g\U`h YUh UbX Xf]b_6 :ch\ \Y h\Ub_ h\Uh gYfjUbh VYWUigY \Y X]X h\Y h\]b[g h\Uh kYfY WcaaUbXYX \]a6 ? hfck bch( Ic `]_Yk]gY mY& k\Yb mY g\U`` \UjY XcbY U`` h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY WcaaUbXYX mci& gUm& MY UfY ibdfcZ]hUV`Y gYfjUbhg4 kY \UjY XcbY h\Uh k\]W\ kUg cif Xihm hc Xc( vBKA; +14/'+*

Jfi`m _]bX dYcd`Y Zcf[Yh h\Y [ccX h\]b[g h\Ym \UjY XcbY ]b h\Y dUgh( J\Ym UfY gc ]bjc`jYX ]b h\Y h\]b[g h\Ym Xc bck h\Uh h\Ym Zcf[Yh h\Y h\]b[g h\Ym \UjY XcbY VYZcfY( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

?KH EHWWHU D SHUVRQ NQRZV KLPVHOI$ WKH VPDOOHU DQG OHVV VLJc QLILFDQW KH VHHPV WR KLPVHOI$ DQG WKH KLJKHU KH HOHYDWHV KLPc VHOI WRZDUG 3RG& vJ>EC7I 7 A;CF?I

DQWJOHJS Â 7 XYYX XcbY cb`m hc UW\]YjY [`cfm ]g U`kUmg VUX& bc aUhx hYf k\Uh WcbgYeiYbWYg ]h \Ug( 7 XYYX ach]jUhYX YeiU``m Vm h\Y XYg]fY hc UW\]YjY [ccXbYgg UbX hc UW\]YjY [`cfm ]g ]bX]ZZYfYbh( 7 XYYX ]g hfi`m [ccX cb`m k\Yb ]hg ach]jUh]cb ]g hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y `Uk cZ =cX( ?Z mci WUfY hcc aiW\ UVcih VY]b[ dfU]gYX& ]b h\Y YbX mci k]`` bch UWWcad`]g\ Ubmh\]b[ gYf]cig( FYcd`Y \UjY X]ZZYfx Ybh jU`iYg( Oci aUm gUm& s? kUbh [ccX dYcd`Y hc jU`iY aY&t Vih mci _bck mci k]`` fYgdYWh cb`m h\cgY k\c dfU]gY mcif UWh]cbg( MY UfY bch gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ cif fYU` `]ZY( MY kUbh hc `]jY Ub ]aU[]bUfm `]ZY& U `]ZY ]b k\]W\ kY gYYa X]ZZYfYbh ]b h\Y YmYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y h\Ub kY UfY ]b fYU`]hm( v8B7?I; F7I97B

8HW WKH MXGJPHQWV RI RWKHUV KH WKH FRQVHTXHQFH RI \RXU GHHGV$ QRW WKHLU SXUSRVH& Jc `]jY cb`m Zcf =cX& mci g\ci`X Xc [ccX kcf_g k\]W\ bc cbY k]`` YjYf X]gWcjYf( :c gc& UbX mci k]`` YldYf]YbWY U gdYW]U` ^cm(

DQWJOHJS Ǽ J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY fYU` `Uk& h\Y `Uk cZ =cX& k\]W\ ]g h\Y gUaY Zcf U`` cZ aUb_]bX( >iaUb `Uk WUb VY jU`]X cb`m k\Yb ]h ]g ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ h\Y `Uk cZ =cX( J\Y Z]fgh UbX acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h cVghfiWh]cb hc h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ h\Y `Uk cZ =cX ]g h\Y ZUWh h\Uh cif gcW]Yhmrg Yl]gh]b[ `Ukg UfY Wcad`YhY`m cddcgYX hc h\]g `Uk( ?KRVH KXPDQ ODZV DUH JRRG ZKLFK DUH EDVHG RQ WKH ODZ RI 3RG& ?KRVH KXPDQ ODZV DUH EDG ZKLFK FRQWUDGLFW WKH ODZV RI 3RG+ ZH VKRXOG FKDQJH WKHVH ODZV& v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

?b cfXYf hc ghiXm h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh eiYgh]cbg cZ `]ZY& YjYfmcbY g\ci`X XYghfcm h\Y dfY^iX]WYg UbX `]Yg k\]W\ kYfY WfYUhYX Vm dfYj]cig WYbhif]Yg ]b fY`Uh]cb hc U`` gYf]x cig eiYgh]cbg ]b `]ZY( J\Y `Uk cZ =cX WcbhfUX]Whg \iaUb `Uk( Ic k\Uh g\ci`X kY Xc6 I\ci`X kY \]XY h\Y `Uk cZ =cX UbX dfcW`U]a \iaUb `Uk6 FYcd`Y \UjY XcbY h\]g Zcf U`acgh b]bYhYYb WYbhif]Yg& UbX h\Y WcbhfUX]Wh]cb VYWcaYg ghfcb[Yf UbX ghfcb[Yf( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY gc`ih]cb4 hc fYd`UWY h\Y Yl]ghx ]b[ `Ukg k]h\ h\Y `Uk cZ =cX(

DQWJOHJS Ä :YVUhYg WcbWYU` h\Y hfih\ acfY cZhYb h\Ub h\Ym fYjYU` ]h( HYU` hfih\ g\ci`X VY fYjYU`YX ]b gc`]hiXY( M\Yb ]h ]g fYjYU`YX& ]h VYWcaYg W`YUf hc mci h\Uh mci WUb UWWYdh ]h k]h\cih Ubm Uf[iaYbh cf X]gWigg]cbg( 4H KDV SRZHU ZKR FDQ NHHS VLOHQW LQ DQ DUJXPHQW$ HYHQ WKRXJK KH LV ULJKW& Oci g\ci`X UVghU]b Zfca Uf[iaYbhg( J\Ym UfY jYfm ]``c[]x WU` kUmg hc Wcbj]bWY dYcd`Y( Ed]b]cbg UfY `]_Y bU]`g4 h\Y ghfcb[Yf mci \]h h\Ya& h\Y XYYdYf ]bg]XY h\Ym [c( v:;9?CKI @KD?KI @KL;D7B?I

?Z mci `]jY U`cbY& h\]b_ UVcih mcif ckb g]bg5 ]Z mci UfY ]b gcW]Yhm& Zcf[Yh UVcih h\Y g]bg cZ ch\Yfg( v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

J\Y acfY if[Ybh`m mci kUbh hc gdYU_& h\Y acfY `]_Y`m ]h ]g h\Uh mci k]`` gUm gcaYh\]b[ Zcc`]g\(

DQWJOHJS Ć J\ci[\h ]g h\Y [`cf]Z]WUh]cb cZ hfih\5 h\YfYZcfY& VUX h\ci[\hg UfY h\cgY k\]W\ \UjY bch VYYb h\ci[\h h\fci[\ hc h\Y YbX( ?b cfXYf h\Uh U `Uad WUb []jY [ccX `][\h& mci g\ci`X dih ]h ]b U d`UWY dfchYWhYX Zfca h\Y k]bX( ?Z h\Y `][\h ]g ]b h\Y k]bX& h\Yb ]h k]`` `YUjY `cb[& hfYaV`]b[ g\UXckg( Ic hcc k]`` VUX h\ci[\hg Xfcd g\UXckg cb h\Y k\]hY gifZUWY cZ mcif gci`( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

1VWDEOLVK \RXU SXUSRVH ZKHQ \RX DUH DORQH DQG ZLWKRXW WHPSWDWLRQV& v@;H;CO 8;DJ>7C

CYX]hUh]cb ]g h\Y kUm hc YhYfb]hm5 `][\h\YUfhYXbYgg ]g h\Y kUm hc XYUh\( J\cgY k\c aYX]hUhY bYjYf X]Y5 h\cgY k\c UfY `][\h\YUfhYX fYa]bX aY cZ XYUh\( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

Oci WUbbch gYbX UkUm U VUX h\ci[\h k\Yb ]h UddYUfg ]b mcif a]bX& Vih mci WUb WfYUhY ch\Yf h\ci[\hg k\]W\ k]`` kYU_Yb cf XYghfcm h\]g VUX h\ci[\h( <cf YlUad`Y& ? aUm ]aU[]bY h\Uh mcif Zf]YbX cf bY][\Vcf \Ug gcaY XfUkVUW_& UbX ? aUm bch VY UV`Y hc VUb]g\ h\]g h\ci[\h& Vih k\Yb ?

WcbWYbhfUhY cb h\Y h\ci[\hh\Uh Wf]h]W]n]b[ Ubch\Yf dYfx gcb ]g VUX VYWUigY ? Ua bch dYfZYWh& UbX \Y \Ug h\Y gUaY =cX k]h\]b \]a Ug ? \UjY k]h\]b aY& h\Yb ? WUbbch ghcd `cj]b[ h\]g dYfgcb(

DQWJOHJS Ă 8`Ua]b[ mcif bY][\Vcf ]g \UfaZi`& Vch\ Zcf mci UbX Zcf ch\Yfg( OYghYfXUm Uh U dUfhm& k\Yb U [iYgh gU]X [ccX'VmY UbX XYdUfhYX& YjYfmcbY k\c kUg `YZh ghUfhYX hc g`UbXYf \]a( J\Y gUaY h\]b[ \UddYbYX hc h\Y gYWcbX dYfgcb k\Yb \Y `YZh& UbX hc U`` h\Y [iYghg& cbY UZhYf Ubch\Yf& Ug h\Ym `YZh( J\Y `Ugh [iYgh gU]X& sBYh aY ghUm \YfY UbX gdYbX h\Y b][\h( ? gUk h\Uh U`` h\Y dYcd`Y k\c `YZh giZZYfYX UbX ? Ua UZfU]X Zcf amgY`Z(t .H VWULFW WR \RXUVHOI$ DQG IRUJLYH RWKHUV$ DQG WKHQ \RX ZLOO KDYH QR HQHPLHV& v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

? cbWY aYh Ub c`X aUb k\c gdc_Y jYfm g`ck`m& dUig]b[ Zcf gYjYfU` gYWcbXg VYhkYYb \]g kcfXg( >Y X]X h\]g VYWUigY \Y kUg UZfU]X hc g]b k]h\ \]g kcfXg( BYh ig Zcf[]jY YUW\ ch\Yf( ?Z kY WUb Zcf[]jY YUW\ ch\Yf& h\Yb kY WUb `]jY ]b dYUWY( 7 kcfX ]g Ub YldfYgg]cb cZ h\ci[\hg5 h\ci[\hg UfY h\Y YldfYgg]cb cZ X]j]bY ZcfWY( J\YfYZcfY& kcfXg g\ci`X Wcfx fYgdcbX hc cif hfiY aYUb]b[( IdYYW\ WUb VY ]bX]ZZYfYbh& Vih ]h g\ci`X bch VY Ub YldfYgg]cb cZ Yj]`(

DQWJOHJS Ĉ Oci WUb `cc_ Uh `]ZY Ug XYUh\& UbX XYUh\ Ug Ub UkU_Yb]b[( ? WUbbch ghcd h\]b_]b[ h\Uh ? kUg XYUX VYZcfY ? kUg Vca& UbX Uh am XYUh\ ? k]`` fYhifb hc h\Y gUaY ghUhY( v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

? Xc bch fY[fYh h\Uh ? kUg Vca \YfY UbX h\Uh ? `]jYX dUfh cZ am `]ZY \YfY& VYWUigY ? `]jYX ]b U kUm h\Uh ? h\]b_ kUg igYx Zi`( M\Yb h\Y YbX WcaYg& ? k]`` `YUjY am `]ZY ]b h\Y gUaY kUm& Ug ]Z ? `YUjY Ub ]bb UbX bch am \caY& VYWUigY ? h\]b_ h\Uh am ghUm ]b h\]g `]ZY ]g hYadcfUfm UbX h\Uh XYUh\ ]g cb`m U hfUbgZYf hc Ubch\Yf ghUhY( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

;jYb ]Z ? Yff ]b gUm]b[ h\Uh h\Y gci` ]g YhYfbU`& bYjYfh\Y`Ygg ? Ua \Uddm h\Uh ? aUXY h\]g a]ghU_Y( 7bX k\]`Y ? Ua U`]jY& bch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb WUb hU_Y UkUm h\]g UggifUbWY k\]W\ []jYg aY Wcad`YhY WU`abYgg UbX [fYUh gUh]gZUWh]cb( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

BH DVN WKH ZURQJ TXHVWLRQ ZKHQ ZH VD\$ `BKDW ZLOO KDSSHQ DIWHU GHDWK,a BKHQ ZH VSHDN DKRXW WKH IXWXUH$ ZH VSHDN RI WLPH$ KXW ZKHQ ZH GLH$ ZH OHDYH WLPH EHKLQG&

DQWJOHJS Ǻ MY WcaY hc U f][\h ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ cif `]ZY ]b fY`Uh]cb hc =cX ]b h\Y gUaY kUm kY ibXYfghUbX cif fY`Uh]cb hc h\Y kcf`X UbX hc ]hg h\]b[g( M]h\cih WcbgW]YbWY& kY kci`X bYjYf _bck Ubmh\]b[ UVcih =cX( J\Y eiYgh]cb ]g k\Yh\Yf h\Y ]bhY``YWhiU` cbY& k]h\cih h\Y \YUfh& WUb ibXYfghUbX =cX( J\Y hfih\ ]g h\Uh ]Z cif \YUfh ibXYfghUbXg =cX cif ]bhY``YWh k]`` h\Yb ghUfh hc gYY_ >]a( v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

J\Y VUg]W ZcibXUh]cb cZ h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX ]g ]bg]XY cZ ig& vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

7 [ccX kcf_Yf dfcVUV`m XcYg bch _bck h\Y XYhU]`g cZ h\Y `]ZY cZ \]g aUghYf( Eb`m U `Unm kcf_Yf hf]Yg hc Xc bch\]b[ YlWYdh Z]bX cih acfY UVcih \]g aUghYfrg kUm cZ `]ZY& hUghYg& UbX dfYZYfYbWYg ]b cfXYf hc d`YUgY \]a( J\Y gUaY ]g hfiY cZ U dYfgcbrg Uhh]hiXY hc =cX( ?h ]g ]adcfhUbh hc UWWYdh >]a Ug mcif aUghYf UbX hc _bck k\Uh >Y kUbhg mci hc Xc( ? aUm bYjYf _bck h\Y UbgkYfg hc h\Y eiYgh]cbg sM\Uh ]g >Y6t UbX s>ck XcYg >Y `]jY6t ? k]`` bYjYf Z]bX cih VYWUigY ? Ua bch YeiU` hc >]a( ? Ua >]g kcf_Yf& bch >]g aUghYf( 1YHU\ SHUVRQ XQGHUVWDQGV 3RG LQ GLIIHUHQW ZD\V$ EXW SHRSOH IXOILOO 4LV ZLOO LQ WKH VDPH ZD\&

DQWJOHJS Ą IY`Z'UXa]fUh]cb ]g h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ df]XY( Ff]XY ]g X]gg]x dUhYX gY`Z'UXa]fUh]cb( J\cgY k\c Xc bch \UhY h\Y]f ckb gY`Z]g\bYgg& h\Y]f d`UWx ]b[ cZ h\YagY`jYg \][\Yf h\Ub h\Y fYgh cZ h\Y kcf`X& UfY V`]bX& VYWUigY h\]g UWh]cb WcbhfUX]Whg h\Y hfih\( v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y `][\hYf UbX `Ygg XYbgY U giVghUbWY ]g& h\Y `Ygg gdUWY ]h cWWid]Yg( J\Y eiU`]h]Yg k\]W\ U dfciX dYfgcb Uhhf]VihYg hc \]agY`Z WUb VY WcadUfYX hc h\]g( J\YfY UfY aUbm dYcd`Y k\c W`U]a hc VY hYUW\Yfg cZ ch\Yfg k\c g\ci`X h\YagY`jYg VY hUi[\h Z]fgh cZ U``( v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?KH PRVW LPSRUWDQW WKLQJ LQ OLIH LV WKH SDWK WR SHUIHFWLRQ$ DQG ZKDW NLQG RI SHUIHFWLRQ FDQ H[LVW LI D SHUVRQ LV SURXG DQG VDWc LVILHG ZLWK KLPVHOI,

DQWJOHJS ÁÀ <fca h\Y Z]fgh acaYbh h\Y aYaVYfg cZ U fY`][]cig [Uh\Yfx ]b[ gU]X& sJ\Y >c`m Id]f]h ]g Uacb[ ig(t k\Yb h\Ym W`U]aYX h\Y]fg h\Y \][\Ygh Uih\cf]hm UVcjY U`` ch\Yf Uih\cf]h]Yg& k\Yb h\Ym UWWYdhYX h\Y fYgi`hg cZ h\Y]f ckb aYX]hUh]cb Ug acfY kcfh\m h\Ub h\Y X]j]bY gdUf_ h\Uh Yl]ghg ]b YjYfm dYfgcb #h\Uh ]g& h\Y ]bhY``YWh UbX h\Y WcbgW]YbWY$& Zfca h\]g h]aY& U [fYUh `]Y cf][]bUhYX& U `]Y k\]W\ XYWY]jYg h\Y VcXx ]Yg UbX gci`g cZ aUbm dYcd`Y& k\]W\ \Ug XYghfcmYX a]``]cbg cZ \iaUb VY]b[g& UbX k\]W\ Wcbh]biYg ]hg hYff]V`Y kcf_( ?b +02,& U :f( BYmhcb& U fYgdYWhYX W]h]nYb cZ ;b[`UbX k\c kfchY U Vcc_ Wf]h]W]n]b[ U V]g\cd& kUg dih cb hf]U` UbX gYjYfY`m dib]g\YX( <]fgh \Y kUg \Ufg\`m VYUhYb& h\Yb cbY YUf kUg Wih UkUm( 7ZhYf gYjYfU` XUmg \Y kUg VYUhYb U[U]b& h\ci[\ h\Y ]b^if]Yg cb \]g VUW_ \UX bch \YU`YX5 h\Yb h\Ym Wih cZZ \]g gYWcbX YUf& UbX hcfY cZZ \]g bcgY( J\]g kUg XcbY ]b h\Y bUaY cZ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm( vH7D:7BB J>EC7I :7L?:IED

9\f]gh bYjYf ZcibXYX Ubm W\ifW\& bYjYf WfYUhYX Ubm ghUhY& bYjYf dUggYX Ubm `Uk& bYjYf YghUV`]g\YX Ubm [cjYfbaYbh cf ch\Yf Uih\cf]hm( >Y kUbhYX hc dih h\Y `Uk cZ =cX ]bhc h\Y \YUfhg cZ dYcd`Y& hc aU_Y h\Ya gY`Z'[cjYfbYX( v>;H8;HJ D;MJED

5I WKHUH LV D WUXH FKXUFK$ WKH SHRSOH ZKR DUH LQVLGH LW FDQQRW VHH LW IURP WKH RXWVLGH&

DQWJOHJS ÁÁ CcfU` dYfZYWh]cb ]g h\Y ]adcgg]V`Y [cU`& Vih acj]b[ hc ]h ]g h\Y `Uk cZ \iaUb `]ZY( IcaY dYcd`Y gUm& sCUb ]g gY`Z]g\& [fYYXm& UbX X]gg]dUhYX& UbX WUbbch VY _]bX hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y(t J\]g ]g bch hfiY MY WUb VY [ccX( <YY` ]b mcif \YUfh h\Y _]bX cZ dYfgcb mci g\ci`X VY5 h\]g ZYY`]b[ k]`` []jY mci dckYf( 7 kcaUb UWW]XYbhU``m XfcddYX U dfYW]cig dYUf` ]bhc h\Y gYU& UbX g\Y ghUfhYX hc gWccd cWYUb kUhYf k]h\ U gdUXY& cbY Wid UZhYf Ubch\Yf( 7 gYU'gdf]hY WUaY hc \Yf UbX gU]X& sM\Yb k]`` mci ghcd gWccd]b[ id kUhYf6t J\Y kcaUb gU]X& sM\Yb ? \UjY hU_Yb U`` h\Y kUhYf Zfca h\Y gYU& UbX fYhf]YjYX am dYUf` Zfca h\Y Vchhca(t J\Yb h\Y gYU'gdf]hY fYhf]YjYX h\Y dYUf` UbX fYhifbYX ]h hc \Yf( ;XWHU FRQVHTXHQFHV DUH QRW LQ RXU SRZHU WR FRQWURO+ LW LV RQO\ SRVVLEOH WR PDNH DQ HIIRUW$ DQG LQQHU FRQVHTXHQFHV DOZD\V IROORZ IURP RXU HIIRUW&

DQWJOHJS ÁÂ J\Y `UbX ]g h\Y [YbYfU` UbX YeiU` dcggYgg]cb cZ U`` \iaUbx ]hm& UbX h\YfYZcfY WUbbch VY h\Y dfcdYfhm cZ ]bX]j]XiU`g( Cm ]bhY``YWh hYUW\Yg aY h\Uh `UbX WUbbch VY gc`X( v8B79A >7MA

?KH ODQG VKDOO QRW KH VROG IRU HYHU* IRU WKH ODQG LV PLQH+ IRU \H DUH VWUDQJHUV DQG VRMRXUQHUV ZLWK PH& vB;L?J?9KI ,/4,-

Jc VY \cbYgh& h\Y YUfh\ \Ug hkc aUghYfg4 h\Y Z]fgh ]g U`a][\hm =cX UbX h\Y gYWcbX UfY \]g gcbg5 U`` h\Y dYcd`Y k\c \UjY kcf_YX UbX k]`` kcf_ cb ]h( vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

7`` dYcd`Y& Zfca h\Y Z]fgh& UbX k]h\cih Ubm ^iX]W]U` UWh& g\ci`X dcggYgg h\Y YUfh\( J\Ym g\ci`X VY UV`Y hc `]jY k\YfY bUhifY UbX W\UbWY \UjY Vfci[\h h\Ya( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

J\Y dcggYgg]cb cZ `UbX Ug dfcdYfhm ]g cbY cZ h\Y acgh ibbUhifU` Wf]aYg h\YfY ]g( MY WUbbch gYY h\Y \cffcf cZ h\]g Wf]aY VYWUigY ]b cif kcf`X ]h ]g UWWYdhYX Ug `Uk(

DQWJOHJS ĄǼ IY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb g\ci`X VY cbYrg df]aUfm ach]jUh]cb( ?Z mci UfY hfih\Zi` hc mcifgY`Z& mci k]`` bYjYf VY gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ mcifgY`Z( 7 dYfgcb g\ci`X U`kUmg XYjY`cd \]g UV]`]hm hc Xc [ccXbYgg( CU_Y mcifgY`Z VYhhYf5 h\]g g\ci`X VY YjYfm dYfgcbrg [cU`( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?KH ILUVW UXOH RI DFKLHYLQJ JRRGQHVV LV WKLV* WKLQN RQO\ DKRXW VHOI%SHUIHFWLRQ$ DQG GR VR ZLWKRXW WKRXJKW WR EHLQJ SUDLVHG E\ RWKHUV& v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

>Y k\c acjYg Zfca Xc]b[ VUX XYYXg hc Xc]b[ [ccX XYYXg Yb`][\hYbg h\]g kcf`X `]_Y h\Y accb Wca]b[ cih Zfca VY\]bX h\Y W`ciXg( J\]g ]g h\Y VYgh h\]b[ ]b h\Y kcf`X5 h\]g ]g h\Y Z]fgh ghYd hckUfX X]j]b]hm( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

J\cgY k\c `]jY `]ZY ]b dYfZYWh]cb `cc_ cb`m ZcfkUfX5 h\cgY k\c \UjY ghcddYX acj]b[ ZcfkUfX `cc_ VUW_ cb h\Y]f UW\]YjYaYbhg( :]ggUh]gZUWh]cb ]g U bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ ]bhY``YWhiU` `]ZY( ?h ]g cb`m h\]g X]ggUh]gZUWh]cb h\Uh dig\Yg mci hc kcf_(

DQWJOHJS ÁÄ J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh _bck`YX[Y ]g h\Uh k\]W\ [i]XYg h\Y kUm mci `YUX mcif `]ZY( ?h ]g \UfaZi` hc YUh ]Z mci UfY bch \ib[fm( ?h ]g YjYb kcfgY hc \UjY gYl ]Z mci `UW_ XYg]fY( 8ih YjYb acfY \UfaZi` ]g hc hfm hc h\]b_ k\Yb mci Xc bch k]g\ hc& cf hc VY Yb[U[YX ]b aYUb]b[`Ygg ]bhY``YWhiU` UWh]j]hm( CUbm dYcd`Y Xc gc k\Yb h\Ym kUbh hc ]adfcjY h\Y]f dcg]h]cb( Ocif k]`` ]g bch [ccX ibh]` mci \UjY W\Ub[YX h\Y \UV]hg cZ mcif ]bhY``YWh& UbX h\Ym k]`` ]adfcjY cb`m k\Yb h\Ym Zc`x `ck h\Y YhYfbU` `Ukg cZ `]ZY( vBK9?KI 7bbUYig IYbYWU

;QO\ WKRVH ZKR KDYH UHDO NQRZOHGJH NQRZ ZKDW WR GR& v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]b _bck`YX[Y ]g bch eiUbh]hm& Vih eiU`x ]hm( ?h ]g ]adcfhUbh hc _bck k\Uh _bck`YX[Y ]g g][b]Z]WUbh& k\Uh ]g `Ygg gc& UbX k\Uh ]g hf]j]U`(

DQWJOHJS ĄĆ J\Y ^cm cZ kYU`h\ ]g ]bWcbghUbh( BKHUHYHU \RXU KHDUW LV$ WKHUH ZLOO KH \RXU WUHDVXUH& ?KH KHDUW RI D SHUVRQ ZKRVH PDMRU WUHDVXUH LV ZHDOWK LV EXULHG LQ ILOWK& ?g ]h hfiY h\Uh dYcd`Y kYfY WfYUhYX hc Wc``YWh acfY UbX acfY [c`X6 Dc( =cX WfYUhYX dYcd`Y UZhYf >]g ckb ]aU[Y5 >Y WfYUhYX mci gc h\Uh mci Wci`X Zi`Z]`` \]g k]``( vI7?DJ @E>D 9>HOIEIJEC

M\m g\ci`X U dYfgcb VY f]W\6 M\m g\ci`X \Y \UjY YldYbx g]jY \cfgYg& f]W\ W`ch\Yg& kcbXYfZi` fccag& UbX h\Y `Y]gifY hc j]g]h diV`]W d`UWYg cZ YbhYfhU]baYbh6 8YWUigY \Y XcYg bch \UjY Ybci[\ h\ci[\hg hc UWWcadUbm \]g ]bhY``YWh( =]jY h\]g dYfgcb h\Y ]bbYf kcf_ cZ \]g ]bhY``YWh& UbX \Y k]`` VY \Udd]Yf h\Ub h\Y f]W\Ygh aUb( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

<cf h\cgY k\c `]jY U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& kYU`h\ ]g bch cb`m ibbYWYggUfm Vih ibWcaZcfhUV`Y( ?h ghcdg h\Y XYjY`cdx aYbh cZ cbYrg fYU` `]ZY(

DQWJOHJS ÁĂ <U]h\ UbgkYfg h\cgY eiYgh]cbg hc k\]W\ h\Y ]bhY``YWh WUbx bch Z]bX UbgkYfg& Vih k\]W\ aigh VY Ug_YX( ?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH WUXH UHOLJLRQ$ WKRXJK WKHUH DUH PDQ\ GLIIHUc HQW IDLWKV& v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g cb`m ZU]h\ k\]W\ WfYUhYg h\Y dckYfZi` Wcbj]Wh]cbg& h\Y YbYf[m& UbX h\Y ib]hm k\]W\ WUb WifY gcW]Yhm( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

MY \UjY cb`m cbY g]b`Ygg [i]XY& U ib]jYfgU` gd]f]h k\]W\ [Yhg ]bhc U`` cZ ig h\ci[\ kY UfY U]` ]bX]j]XiU`g& UbX k\]W\ []jYg ig h\Y if[Y hc Xc U`` h\Uh ]g bYWYggUfm( J \Yf gUaY gd]f]h k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b U hfYY UbX dig\Yg ]h hc [fck ghfU][\h UbX hc dfcXiWY gYYXg Yl]ghg ]b ig& if[Yg ig hc VY W`cgYf hc =cX& UbX Vf]b[g ig W`cgYf hc YUW\ ch\Yf( M\Yb U dYfgcb ]g U`]jY& \Y VY`]YjYg5 h\Y W`cgYf \]g ZU]h\ ]g hc h\Y hfih\& h\Y \Udd]Yf \]g `]ZY( J\Y Zifh\Yf Zfca h\Y hfih\ \]g ZU]h\ ]g& h\Y acfY ib\Uddm \Y ]g( M]h\cih ZU]h\ \Y XcYg bch `]jY5 \Y X]Yg U dfYaUhifY XYUh\ cf Y`gY _]``g \]agY`Z(

DQWJOHJS ÆĈ MY giZZYf Zfca h\Y dUgh& UbX kY gdc]` cif ZihifY VYWUigY kY bY[`YWh h\Y dfYgYbh( J\Y VYgh h\Y ZihifY WUb cZZYf ]g XfYUag( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY h\]b[ k\]W\ fYU``m Yl]ghg4 h\Y dfYgYbh( 8Y UhhYbh]jY hc h\Y dfYgYbh( Eb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh h]aY WUb kY ibXYfghUbX YhYfb]hm( v7ZhYf @E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

@VH \RXU ERG\$ \RXU YHVVHO$ WRGD\+ WRPRUURZ LW FDQ EH EURNHQ& vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\YfY ]g bc dUgh UbX bc ZihifY5 bc cbY \Ug YjYf YbhYfYX h\cgY hkc ]aU[]bUfm _]b[Xcag( J\YfY ]g cb`m h\Y dfYgYbh( :c bch kcffm UVcih h\Y ZihifY& VYWUigY h\YfY ]g bc ZihifY( B]jY ]b h\Y dfYgYbh UbX Zcf h\Y dfYgYbh& UbX ]Z mcif dfYgYbh ]g [ccX& h\Yb ]h ]g [ccX ZcfYjYf( ?Z mci \UjY X]ZZ]Wi`h h]aYg& ]Z mci giZZYf Zfca h\Y `cgg cZ `cjYX cbYg cf Zfca ZYUfg UVcih h\Y ZihifY& fYaYaVYf h\Uh `]ZY Yl]ghg cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh UbX X]fYWh U`` mcif h\ci[\hg UbX aYacf]Yg hc h\]g dfYgYbh( 7`` mcif Ub[i]g\ UVcih h\Y dUgh UbX mcif kcff]Yg UVcih h\Y ZihifY k]`` X]gUddYUf& UbX mci k]`` ZYY` ZfYYXca UbX \Udd]bYgg(

DQWJOHJS ÁǺ Oci WUbbch aYUgifY [ccX Vm Y]h\Yf h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ bYYX cf gUWf]Z]WY& Vih cb`m Vm h\Y Wcaaib]WUh]cb k]h\ =cX k\]W\ ]g YghUV`]g\YX VYhkYYb h\Y []jYf UbX h\Y fYWY]jYf( 8LIH DORQH LV QRW JRRG& 3RRGQHVV H[LVWV RQO\ LQ D SURSHU$ YLUc WXRXV OLIH&

$ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWU

?h ]g bch U j]fhiY& Vih U _]bX cZ XYWY]hZi` g]a]`]hiXY& hc Zi`x Z]`` cif Xihm Zcf h\Y difdcgY cZ ]hg fYkUfX( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

7`` dYcd`Y VYWcaY W`cgYf& acfY cf `Ygg& hc cbY cZ hkc cddcg]hY `]a]hg4 cbY ]g `]ZY cb`m Zcf cbYgY`Z& UbX h\Y ch\Yf ]g `]ZY cb`m Zcf =cX( ? WU`` h\]g `]ZY U \Uddm cbY ]b k\]W\ ? Xc cbY [ccX XYYX UZhYf Ubch\Yf& k]h\ bc ]bhYfjU`g VYhkYYb h\Ya( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

BH GR JRRG RQO\ ZKHQ ZH GR QRW QRWLFH ZKDW ZH GR$ ZKHQ ZH IRUJHW RXUVHOYHV DQG OLYH RQO\ LQ RWKHUV&

DQWJOHJS ÁĄ 7 aUhYf]U` Yj]` XcbY Vm U dYfgcb XcYg bch fYhifb hc h\Y Yj]`XcYf& Vih h\Y Yj]` ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ kUg WfYUhYX Vm h\Y g]bx Zi` XYYX k]`` ZYghYf ]b \]g gci` UbX gccbYf cf `UhYf aU_Y \]a giZZYf( ?Z ]b h\Y acfb]b[ U dYfgcb kUbhg hc Xc Yj]` ibhc ch\Yfg& Yj]` k]`` fYhifb hc \]a Vm b][\hZU``( v?D:?7D M?I:EC

?KH HYLOGRHU KDUPV KLPVHOI ILUVW$ EHIRUH KH KDUPV RWKHUV& vI7?DJ 7K=KIJ?D;

;jYfm aUb VYWcaYg k\Uh \Y hYUW\Yg ch\Yfg hc VY( J\cgY k\c [U]b j]Whcfm cjYf h\YagY`jYg k]`` [U]b j]Whcfm cjYf ch\Yfg( ?h ]g acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h hc UW\]YjY j]Whcfm cjYf cbYgY`Z( ;jYfm aUb \Ug dckYf cb`m cjYf \]agY`Z( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

J\YfY ]g bc aUhYf]U` [ccXbYgg k\]W\ WUb fYghcfY h\Y gci` UZhYf h\Y XUaU[Y XcbY Vm h\Y Yj]` k\]W\ mci WfYUhY(

DQWJOHJS ÂÀ HYaYaVYf4 J\cgY k\c giZZYf h\fci[\ hc h\Y YbX k]`` VY gUjYX( LYfm cZhYb U dYfgcb VYWcaYg XYgdYfUhY cf YjYb ghcdg ]b \]g difdcgY k\Yb cb`m U gaU`` YZZcfh ]g bYYXYX hc UW\]YjY ]h( 8ih VYkUfY cZ aYb4 Zcf h\Ym k]`` XY`]jYf mci id hc h\Y WcibW]`g& UbX h\Ym k]`` gWcif[Y mci ]b h\Y]f gmbU[c[iYg5 7bX mY g\U`` VY Vfci[\h VYZcfY [cjYfbcfg UbX _]b[g Zcf am gU_Y& Zcf U hYgh]acbm U[U]bgh h\Ya UbX h\Y =Ybh]`Yg( 8ih k\Yb h\Ym XY`]jYf mci id& hU_Y bc h\ci[\h \ck cf k\Uh mY g\U`` gdYU_4 Zcf ]h g\U`` VY []jYb mci ]b h\Uh gUaY \cif k\Uh mY g\U`` gdYU_( <cf ]h ]g bch mY h\Uh gdYU_& Vih h\Y Id]f]h cZ mcif <Uh\Yf k\]W\ gdYU_Yh\ ]b mci( vC7JJ>;M A\ +1',*

H][\h WUbbch VY XYZYUhYX& VYWUigY ]h ]g XcbY bch Vm mcif k]`` Vih UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y YhYfbU` `Ukg cZ =cX( vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

FYfgYWih]cb UbX giZZYf]b[ UfY h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cbg cZ h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ 9\f]gh]Ub `Uk( FYfgYWih]cb ]g dfYW]cig VYWUigY ]h fYjYU`g k\Yh\Yf U dYfgcb `]jYg k]h\ fYU` ZU]h\( 0R QRW VHHN ORYH LQ RWKHU SHRSOH$ DQG GR QRW FRPSODLQ DERXW WKH DEVHQFH RI WKHLU ORYH IRU \RX& >RPH SHRSOH ORYH ZURQJ$ QRW ULJKW+ WKHUHIRUH$ WW\ WR SOHDVH 3RG$ UDWKHU WKDQ SHRSOH&

DQWJOHJS ÂÁ J\YfY ]g bc XYYX ]b h\]g `]ZY gc ]adcgg]V`Y h\Uh mci WUbbch Xc ]h( Ocif k\c`Y `]ZY g\ci`X VY `]jYX Ug Ub \Yfc]W XYYX( ;jYfm h]aY mci kU_Y id UbX Ug_ mcifgY`Z& sM\Uh [ccX h\]b[g Ua ? [c]b[ hc Xc hcXUm6t fYaYaVYf h\Uh& k\Yb h\Y gib [cYg Xckb Uh gibgYh& ]h k]`` hU_Y U dUfh cZ mcif `]ZY k]h\ ]h( v?D:?7D FHEL;H8

?KH YLUWXH RI D SHUVRQ LV PHDVXUHG QRW E\ KLV RXWVWDQGLQJ HIIRUWV$ KXW E\ KLV HYHU\GD\ EHKDYLRU& v8B7?I; F7I97B

? Ua h\Y hcc` k]h\ k\]W\ =cX kcf_g( Cm j]fhiY ]g hc dUfx h]W]dUhY ]b h\]g kcf_& UbX ? WUb Xc gc ]Z ? _YYd h\Y ]bghfix aYbh k\]W\ ]g []jYb hc aY& bUaY`m am gci`& ]b ]aaUWi`UhY WcbX]h]cb( 7`` h\]b[g& YjYb h\Y acgh Wcad`]WUhYX h\]b[g& VYWcaY g]ad`Y UbX W`YUf ]Z mci gYdUfUhY h\Ya Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX d`UWY h\Ya VYZcfY =cX Zcf ^iX[aYbh( Eh\Yf h\Ub cif gYfj]WY hc =cX& U`` cif UWh]cbg& k\Yh\Yf kY Wcbg]XYf h\Ya ]adcfhUbh cf bch& UfY Wcad`YhY`m hf]jx ]U`( MY aUm bch _bck k\Uh h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ cif UWh]cbg k]`` VY& Vih kY _bck k\Uh kY g\ci`X Xc(

DQWJOHJS ÂÂ J\Y acfY Vigm mci UfY k]h\ h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ mcif ]bbYf `]ZY& h\Y acfY UWh]jY mci VYWcaY ]b gcW]U` `]ZY& \Y`dx ]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 5W LV DV ZURQJ IRU RQH SHUVRQ WR UXOH PDQ\ DV LW LV IRU PDQ\ WR UXOH RQH& vLB7:?C?H 9>;HJAEL

M\Uh ]g hfih\6 <cf h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y& hfih\ ]g h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ WcibhYX jchYg( vJ>EC7I" 97HBOB;

M\Yb ? g]h cb h\Y gYUg\cfY UbX `]ghYb hc h\Y kUjYg VYUh]b[ cb h\Y gUbX& ? ZYY` ZfYY Zfca Ubm cV`][Uh]cb& UbX ? h\]b_ h\Uh U`` h\Y dYcd`Y cZ h\Y kcf`X WUb W\Ub[Y h\Y]f Wcbgh]hix h]cbg k]h\cih aY( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

DYjYf Vi]`X& Vih U`kUmg d`Ubh4 ]b h\Y WUgY cZ h\Y Z]fgh& bUhifY k]`` ]bhYfZYfY UbX XYghfcm h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ mcif kcf_& Vih ]b h\Y WUgY cZ h\Y gYWcbX& bUhifY k]`` \Y`d mci& WUig]b[ [fckh\ ]b YjYfmh\]b[ mci d`UbhYX( J\Y gUaY h\]b[ \UddYbg ]b mcif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY4 h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ h\Y YhYfbU` `Ukg cZ \iaUb bUhifY k]`` [fck& Vih h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ WcffYgdcbX hc h\Y hYadcfU` k]g\Yg cZ dYcd`Y k]`` bch(

DQWJOHJS ÆǼ J\Y eiYgh]cb cZ `]ZYrg aYUb]b[ ]gU X]ZZ]Wi`h dfcV`Ya k\]W\ WUbbch VY gc`jYX( Ic& hcc& ]g h\Y eiYgh]cb& sM\m X]X =cX gYbX ig ]bhc h\]g kcf`X6t 8ih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY VYWcaYg jYfm g]ad`Y k\Yb U dYfgcb Ug_g \]agY`Z& sM\Uh g\ci`X 1 Xc6t Ocif `]ZY aUm VY Wih g\cfh Uh Ubm h]aY5 h\YfYZcfY& mcif `]ZY g\ci`X \UjY U XYYd difdcgY& U g][b]Z]WUbWY h\Uh k]`` bch XYdYbX cb k\Yh\Yf ]h ]g g\cfh cf `cb[( ?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH ZD\$ LI \RX ZDQW WR OLYH ZLWKRXW XQGHUc VWDQGLQJ WKH PHDQLQJ RI \RXU OLIH* WR EHFRPH DGGLFWHG WR WREDFFR$ DOFRKRO$ DQG GUXJV$ DQG WR OLYH LQ WKH ZRUOG RI SHUc PDQHQW HQWHUWDLQPHQW& J\]g kcf`X ]g bch U ^c_Y Vih fUh\Yf U d`UWY Zcf U hf]U`& U kUm ghUh]cb hc U VYhhYf& YhYfbU` kcf`X( Eif difdcgY ]g hc aU_Y ]h U VYhhYf UbX acfY ^cmcig d`UWY hc `]jY& Zcf h\cgY k\c `]jY k]h\ ig UbX h\cgY k\c WcaY UZhYf ig( Eif gci`rg dYfZYWh]cb ]g cif `]ZYrg difdcgY5 Ubm ch\Yf difx dcgY& _YYd]b[ XYUh\ ]b a]bX& \Ug bc giVghUbWY(

DQWJOHJS ÂÄ >Y`d]b[ ch\Yfg hU_Yg h\Y Zcfa bch cb`m cZ d\mg]WU` U]X& Vih cZ gd]f]hiU` giddcfh Zcf mcif bY][\Vcf( Ihcd V`Ua]b[ mcif bY][\Vcf UbX fYgdYWh \]g \iaUb X][b]hm( :c bch h\]b_ h\Uh mci UfY [YbYfcig VYWUigY mci []jY mcif YlWYgg kYU`h\ hc U dccf dYfgcb( HYU` [YbYfcg]hm fYei]fYg h\Uh mci( []jY h\]g dYfgcb U d`UWY ]b mcif \YUfh& v<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

>Y ]g j]fhicig k\c XcYg bch dUm Ubm UhhYbh]cb hc `]VY` UbX Yj]` gdYYW\( Oci g\ci`X VY hfih\Zi`4 mci g\ci`X Ujc]X kfUh\5 mci g\ci`X []jY hc h\cgY k\c Ug_& VYWUigY h\Ym Ug_ Zcf gaU`` h\]b[g( Oci k]`` VYWcaY \c`]Yf Vm Zc``ck]b[ h\YgY h\fYY dUh\g( v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

BLWK KXPEOHQHVV$ NLQGQHVV$ DQG VHOI%VDFULILFH$ \RX ZLOO WDNH WKH ZHDSRQ IURP DQ\ HQHP\& -Q\ ILUH GLHV LI WKHUH LV LQVXIILc FLHQW ZRRG& v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

Jfm bch hc \]XY h\Y g\UaYZi` aYacf]Yg cZ mcif g]bg ]b XUf_ WcaYfg( Eb h\Y WcbhfUfm& _YYd h\Ya W`cgY hc mci UbX fYaYaVYf h\Ya& VYZcfY mci ^iX[Y mcif bY][\Vcf(

DQWJOHJS ÆĆ MUf ]g aifXYf( Dc aUhhYf \ck aUbm dYcd`Y [Yh hc[Yh\Yf hc Wcaa]h aifXYf cf k\Uh h\Ym WU`` h\YagY`jYg& aifXYf ]g h\Y kcfgh g]b ]b h\Y kcf`X( <HRSOH RI SODQHW 1DUWK DUH RQ D YHU\ ORZ OHYHO RI GHYHORSPHQW& 1YHU\ GD\ LQ WKH QHZVSDSHUV \RX UHDG WKH QHZV DERXW PLOLWDU\ WUHDWLHV$ DERXW WKH SUHSDUDWLRQV IRU ZDU$ IRU PDVV PDQVODXJKc WHU& <HRSOH GR QRW XQGHUVWDQG WKDW WKH OLIH RI HDFK PDQ LV KLV RZQ SHUVRQDO SULYDWH SURSHUW\& v97C?BB; <B7CC7H?ED

J\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y bck ibXYfghUbX bch cb`m h\Y igYx `YggbYgg& Vih U`gc h\Y ghid]X]hm UbX WfiY`hm cZ Ubm kUf( Kbh]` giW\ h]aY Ug dYcd`Y fY^YWh h\Y dckYf cZ [cjYfbaYbh hc [cjYfb& hc hUl& hc `Y[]g`UhY& UbX hc dib]g\& kUf k]`` bYjYf ghcd( MUf ]g h\Y WcbgYeiYbWY cZ h\Y [cjYfbaYbhrg dckYf(

DQWJOHJS ÂĂ @igh Ug cbY WUbX`Y `][\hg Ubch\Yf UbX WUb `][\h h\cigUbXg cZ ch\Yf WUbX`Yg& gc cbY \YUfh ]``ia]bUhYg Ubch\Yf \YUfh UbX WUb ]``ia]bUhY h\cigUbXg cZ ch\Yf \YUfhg( 8YkUfY cZ h\cgY k\c kUbh hc Wcbj]bWY mci h\Uh ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Y hc ghf]jY Zcf [ccX ^igh VYWUigY ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Y hc fYUW\ dYfZYWh]cb( v@E>D HKIA?D

=ccX Vcc_g UfY U [ccX ]bZ`iYbWY( =ccX Ufh ]g U [ccX ]bZ`iYbWY( FfUmYf ]g Ub ]bZ`iYbWY Ug kY``( 8ih h\Y ghfcb[Ygh ]bZ`iYbWY ]g h\Y YlUad`Y cZ U [ccX `]ZY( 7 [ccX `]ZY VYWcaYg U V`Ygg]b[ Zcf dYcd`Y& bch cb`m Zcf h\cgY k\c `]jY [ccX `]jYg Vih h\cgY k\c WUb gYY& _bck& UbX ibXYfghUbX giW\ `]jYg( 5W LV GLIILFXOW WR EULQJ SHRSOH WR JRRGQHVV ZLWK OHVVRQV$ EXW LW LV HDV\ WR GR VR E\ H[DPSOH& ÅHP EPN 7bbUYig IYbYWU

8YkUfY cZ [fcidg cZ dYcd`Y k\c UfY \UfaZi` Zcf mcif gci`( Jfm hc Ujc]X h\Ya( Oci g\ci`X dfU]gY [ccX WcadUbm UbX gYY_ ]h(

DQWJOHJS ÆĈ ?Z U dUgg]cb YaVfUWYg mci& mci g\ci`X fYaYaVYf h\Uh h\]g dUgg]cbUhY XYg]fY ]g bch U dUfh cZ mcif gci`& Vih U XUf_ Wcjx Yf]b[ k\]W\ g\ihg cih h\Y hfiY eiU`]h]Yg cZ mcif gci`( Oci g\ci`X VY U `UbhYfb Zcf mcifgY`Z( :fUk W`cgY hc h\Y `][\h k]h\]b mci UbX gYY_ bc ch\Yf g\Y`hYf( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

- SHUVRQ_V VRXO PD\ EH FRPSDUHG WR D WUDQVSDUHQW EDOO ZKLFK LV OLW IURP WKH LQVLGH ZLWK LWV RZQ OLJKW& ?KLV IODPH LV QRW RQO\ WKH VRXUFH RI DOO OLJKW DQG WUXWK$ EXW LW LOOXPLQDWHV HYHU\WKLQJ DURXQG \RX& 5Q WKLV VWDWH$ WKH VRXO LV IUHH DQG KDSS\& ;QO\ LI LW EHFRPHV DGGLFWHG WR DQ\WKLQJ RXWVLGH \RX ZLOO LW EHFRPH WURXEOHG$ GDUNHQHG$ DQG LPSHQHWUDEOH& 0LVWUDFWLRQV REVWUXFW WKH OLJKW ZKLFK VKRZV \RX WKH ZD\& vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y gci` ]g U a]ffcf ]b k\]W\ mci WUb gYY h\Y fYZ`YWh]cb cZ X]j]bY ]bhY``YWh( v@E>D HKIA?D

7g gccb Ug mci ZYY` dUgg]cb& hfm hc ZYY` ]b mcifgY`Z h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcif X]j]bY bUhifY( 7g gccb Ug mci dYfx WY]jY h\Uh mcif X]j]bY bUhifY ]g ]bUWh]jY UbX h\Uh mci UfY dcggYggYX Vm dUgg]cbg& Z][\h k]h\ h\YgY dUgg]cbg(

DQWJOHJS ÂǺ B]ZY ]g bch XYghfcmYX& cb`m W\Ub[YX& Vm XYUh\( J\Y ZihifY ]g cb`m Ub ]``ig]cb ]bZYffYX Zfca cif dfYgYbh ghUhY( M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]g bch h\Y `Yb[h\ cZ `]ZY& Vih h\Y XYdh\ cZ `]ZY( M\Uh ]g acgh ]adcfhUbh ]g bch hc aU_Y `]ZY `cb[Yf& Vih hc hU_Y mcif gci` cih cZ h]aY& Ug YjYfm giV`]aY UWh XcYg( Eb`m h\Yb XcYg mcif `]ZY VYWcaY Zi`Z]``YX( 7bX Xc bch Ug_ mcifgY`Z eiYgh]cbg UVcih h]aY( @Ygig X]X bch Yld`U]b U h\]b[ UVcih h\Y YhYfb]hm cZ `]ZY& Vih \]g ]bZ`iYbWY Vfci[\h dYcd`Y hc h\Y YhYfbU`( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

2DLWK LQ WKH HWHUQLW\ LV JLYHQ WR XV QRW LQ PHGLWDWLRQ$ KXW LQ OLIH& ?h ]g bch fYUgcb]b[ k\]W\ k]`` Wcbj]bWY mci cZ h\Y bYWYgx g]hm cZ `]ZY UZhYf XYUh\& Vih YlUad`Y4 k\Yb mci kU`_ jYfm W`cgY hc U dYfgcb& \UbX ]b \UbX& UbX h\]g dYfgcb X]gUdx dYUfg ]bhc Ub UVmgg& RYHU WKHUH$ ghcd ]b Zfcbh cZ h\Y UVmgg UbX hfm hc `cc_ k]h\]b ]h( J\Y `YjY` cZ ZYUf mci ZYY` UVcih XYUh\ ]g h\Y `YjY` cZ mcif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ `]ZY( J\Y `Ygg mci ZYUf XYUh\& h\Y acfY mci dcggYgg ZfYYXca& hfUbei]``]hm& UbX Ub ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y [fYUhbYgg cZ mcif gd]f]h UbX h\Y ^cm cZ `]ZY( J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ YhYfb]hm ]g dUfh cZ h\Y bUhifY cZ h\Y \iaUb gci`(

DQWJOHJS ÆĊ 7 kcfX ]g Ub UWh]cb( :c bch gUm kcfXg mci Xc bch ZYY`& `Ygh mcif gci` VY V`UW_x YbYX k]h\ XUf_bYgg( v<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

Ocif YbYa]Yg WUb VY acfY igYZi` hc mci h\Ub mcif Zf]YbXg& VYWUigY mcif Zf]YbXg WUb cZhYb dUfXcb mcif kYU_bYggYg& Vih mcif YbYa]Yg bch]WY h\Ya UbX UhhfUWh mcif UhhYbh]cb hc h\Ya( :c bch bY[`YWh h\Y cd]b]cb cZ mcif YbYa]Yg( - ZLVH PDQ GRHV QRW MXGJH D SHUVRQ IRU KLV ZRUGV$ EXW DW WKH VDPH WLPH GRHV QRW QHJOHFW DQRWKHU SHUVRQ V ZRUGV$ HYHQ ZKHQ WKHVH ZRUGV DUH SURQRXQFHG E\ DQ XQZRUWK\ SHUVRQ& v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

7 dYfgcbrg hcb[iY ]g U hcc` k\]W\ ]g giZZ]W]Ybh hc hfUbga]h h\Y ]XYUg WfYUhYX Vm h\Y \iaUb a]bX( 8ih ]b h\Y XcaU]b cZ hfiY UbX XYYd ZYY`]b[g& cif hcb[iY ]g kYU_( vB7@EI AEIIKJ>

DYjYf ]g h\YfY U g]b[`Y ]bghUbWY k\Yb U `]Y WUb VY ^igh]Z]YX(

DQWJOHJS ÃÀ M\Yb U \iaV`Y dYfgcb Zcf[Yhg \]agY`Z& \Y ]g ib]hYX k]h\ =cX( FYcd`Y k\c hfm hc ZcfWY W]fWiaghUbWYg VYWcaY h\Y]f g`UjYg( J\cgY k\c igY h\Ya VYWcaY h\Y]f aUghYfg( vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X acfY hYbXYf UbX acfY d`]x UV`Y h\Ub kUhYf& mYh \UfX UbX f][]X h\]b[g WUbbch fYg]gh ]h( MYU_bYgg XYZYUhg ghfYb[h\& hYbXYfbYgg XYZYUhg f][]X]hm( ;jYfmcbY _bckg h\]g `Uk& Vih bc cbY UWhg idcb ]h( J\Y kYU_Ygh ]b h\Y kcf`X [U]b j]Whcfm cjYf h\Y ghfcb[Ygh5 h\YfYZcfY& h\YfY ]g U [fYUh UXjUbhU[Y ]b \ia]`]hm UbX g]`YbWY( Eb`m U ZYk dYcd`Y ]b h\]g kcf`X UfY hfi`m \iaV`Y( BUc'Jni ?KH PRUH KXPEOH D SHUVRQ LV$ WKH IUHHU DQG VWURQJHU KH LV&

JIJOHJS Á 7 kcaUb XcYg bch X]ZZYf Zfca U aUb ]b \Yf W\]YZ a]gg]cb( J\]g a]gg]cb ]g hc gYfjY =cX( J\Y X]ZZYfYbWY ]g ]b h\Y aYh\cX cZ h\]g gYfj]WY( J\ci[\ h\Y a]gg]cb cZ U kcaUbrg `]ZY ]g h\Y gUaY Ug h\Uh cZ U aUbrg `]ZY UbX h\Y gYfj]WY hc =cX ]g Zi`Z]``YX Vm h\Y gUaY aYUbg& bUaY`m `cjY& Zcf h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ kcaYb h\Y aYh\cX cZ h\]g gYfj]WY ]g acfY gdYW]Z]W h\Ub Zcf aYb( J\]g ]g h\Y V]fh\ UbX idVf]b[]b[ cZ bYk kcf_Yfg Zcf h\Y BcfX h\fci[\cih `]ZY( ?Z U kcaUbrg _]bXbYgg ]g VcibX`Ygg& h\Yb \Yf fU[Y WUb U`gc \UjY bc `]a]hg( 7 [ccX k]ZY ]g h\Y VYgh []Zh Zcf U \igVUbX& UbX Ub Yj]` k]ZY ]g U hYff]V`Y i`WYf Zcf U aUb( vJ\Y J7BCK:

?KH PRUH EHDXWLIXO D ZRPDQ LV$ WKH PRUH KRQHVW VKH VKRXOG EH EHFDXVH LW LV RQO\ WKURXJK KRQHVW\ WKDW VKH FDQ GHDO ZLWK DOO WKH HYLO DQG GDPDJH ZKLFK KHU EHDXW\ FDQ SURGXFH& v=EJJ>EB: ;F>H7?C B;II?D=

?h ]g bch igiU``m \igVUbXg k\c W\ccgY h\Y]f k]jYg& Vih k]jYg k\c W\ccgY h\Y]f \igVUbXg( ?b cfXYf hc Z]bX U VYhx hYf ZUh\Yf Zcf \Yf W\]`XfYb& U kcaUb aigh _bck [ccX UbX Yj]`( J\YfYZcfY& kcaYb g\ci`X \UjY U [ccX YXiWUh]cb Z]fgh cZ U``( J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY bUhifU` Zcf U kcaUb h\Ub gY`Z' gUWf]Z]WY( Dch\]b[ WUb VY acfY ibd`YUgUbh ]b \Yf h\Ub gY`Z]g\bYgg(

JIJOHJS Â s:c bch _]``t4 h\YgY kcfX fYZYf bch ^igh hc h\Y _]``]b[ cZ U dYfgcb& Vih hc h\Y _]``]b[ cZ Ubmh\]b[ k\]W\ ]g U`]jY( J\]g WcaaUbXaYbh kUg kf]hhYb ]b h\Y dYcd`Yrg \YUfhg YjYb VYZcfY ]h kUg \YUfX cb Ch( I]bU]( M\UhYjYf Uf[iaYbhg h\Ym igY U[U]bgh jY[YhUf]Ub]ga& aYb WUbbch dfYjYbh h\YagY`jYg Zfca ZYY`]b[ WcadUgg]cb UbX X]g[igh Uh _]``]b[ g\YYd& Wckg& cf W\]W_Ybg( Ccgh dYcd`Y kci`X fUh\Yf ghcd YUh]b[ aYUh h\Ub _]`` h\YgY Ub]aU`g h\YagY`jYg( ?KH PRUH SHRSOH EHFRPH HGXFDWHG DQG WKH PRUH RXU SRSXODc WLRQ JURZV$ WKH PRUH SHRSOH ZLOO PRYH IURP HDWLQJ DQLPDOV %WR HDWLQJ SODQWV& HYUX]b[ UbX kf]h]b[ Xc bch YXiWUhY ]Z h\Ym Xc bch \Y`d dYcd`Y hc VYWcaY _]bXYf hc U`` Ub]aU`g( v@E>D HKIA?D

J\Y ghid]X]hm& `Uk`YggbYgg& UbX \Ufa& Vch\ d\mg]WU` UbX acfU`& cZ aYUh YUh]b[ ]g gc W`YUf h\Uh aYUh YUh]b[ ]g bch giddcfhYX Vm fYUgcb]b[ Vih Vm c`X hfUX]h]cbg UbX dfY^ix X]WYg( MY g\ci`X bch YjYb Uf[iY UVcih h\Y UVgYbWY cZ `c[]W ]b YUh]b[ aYUh5 ]h ]g gY`Z'Yj]XYbh(

0HFHPEHU ) 7fh ]g h\Y UWh]j]hm k\YfYVm U dYfgcb aU_Yg U WcbgW]cig UhhYadh hc igY h\Y dUfh]Wi`Uf aYUbg Uh \]g X]gdcgU` hc hfUbga]h \]g ZYY`]b[g hc ch\Yfg gc h\Uh h\Ym ZYY` h\Ya Ug ]bhYbgY`m Ug \Y XcYg( ?b U hfiY WfYUh]cb cZ Ufh& h\YfY ]g bch cb`m bc VcfXYf VYhkYYb h\Y kcf_ cZ Ufh UbX h\Y Ufh]gh& Vih U`gc VYhkYYb h\Y kcf_ UbX h\Y ch\Yf dYcd`Y k\c YldYf]YbWY ]h( J\Y aU^cf UhhfUWh]cb cZ fYU` Ufh `]Yg ]b h\]g ib]Z]WUh]cb( - QHZ ZRUN RI DUW VKRXOG EULQJ D QHZ HPRWLRQ LQ RXU OLIH& ;aYfgcb gU]X h\Uh aig]W \Y`dg dYcd`Y hc Z]bX h\Y [fYUhx bYgg ]b h\Y]f gci`g( J\Y gUaY WUb VY gU]X UVcih Ubm Zcfa cZ Ufh( 9cbhYadcfUfm Ufh]ghg UbX gW\c`Ufg Xc bch Zi`Z]`` UbX WUbx bch Zi`Z]`` h\Y]f XYgh]b]Yg& VYWUigY h\Ym \UjY hfUbgZcfaYX h\Y]f Xih]Yg ]bhc h\Y]f f][\hg(

JIJOHJS Ä ?h ]g bch gU]X Vm W\UbWY h\Uh h\Y YggYbWY cZ X]j]bY `Uk ]g hc `cjY =cX UbX mcif bY][\Vcf( DY][\Vcfg WcaY UbX [c& Vih =cX Yl]ghg U`kUmg( J\YfYZcfY& U aUb WUb Zi`Z]`` h\]g `Uk k\Yb \Y ]g U`cbY ]b U XYgYfh& cf k\Yb \Y ]g ]b df]gcb( >Y WUb `cjY =cX UbX =cXrg aUb]ZYghUh]cbg YjYb ]b \]g h\ci[\hg& aYacf]Yg& UbX ]aU[]bUh]cb( HYaYaVYf h\Uh h\Y gd]f]h cZ =cX Yl]ghg ]b YjYfm dYfgcb& h\Y gUaY gd]f]h h\Uh []jYg mci `]ZY( J\YfYZcfY mci g\ci`X bch cb`m `cjY Vih fYgdYWh h\Y gci` cZ YjYfm dYfgcb Ug U \c`m d`UWY( TT ? Xc bch [f]YjY h\Uh U dYfgcb X]Yg& h\Uh \Y `cgYg \]g acbYm& \]g YghUhY& cf U`` \]g dfcdYfhm& U`` h\Uh WUb VY`cb[ hc U aUb( 8ih ]h ]g U [fYUh d]hm k\Yb U dYfgcb `cgYg \]g [fYUhYgh dcgx gYgg]cb& \]g \iaUb X][b]hm( v;F?9J;JKI

0R QRW GR DQ\WKLQJ$ HLWKHU DPRQJ RWKHUV RU DORQH$ ZKLFK LV RSSRVHG E\ \RXU FRQVFLHQFH& ?b cif h]aY& dYcd`Y Zcf[Yh h\Uh Z]fgh cZ U`` h\Ym g\ci`X fYgdYWh h\Y \iaUb VY]b[ ]b h\YagY`jYg( vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

8YmcbX \]g Xihm hc \]g bY][\Vcf& YjYfm dYfgcb \Ug Ub cV`][Uh]cb hc \]agY`Z& Ug hc h\Y Icb cZ =cX(

JIJOHJS Ć J\Y `cb[Yf aUb_]bX Yl]ghg& h\Y acfY `]VYfUhYX ]h VYWcaYg Zfca dfY^iX]WY UbX h\Y acfY W`YUf`m ]h dYfWY]jYg h\Y `Uk cZ `]ZY( Eifg ]g h\Y U[Y cZ Wf]h]W]ga( HY`][]cb UbX `Uk hfm hc YgWUdY Zfca Wf]h]W]ga& fY`][]cb Vm gUm]b[ h\Uh ]h ]g X]j]bY UbX `Uk Vm g\ck]b[ h\Uh ]h ]g dckYfZi`( 8ih gcaY gigd]W]cbg Uf]gY Zfca h\]g YgWUdY& VYWUigY kY WUb fYgdYWh cb`m h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ ghUbX id ]b ZfYY UbX diV`]W hf]U`( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

>WXG\ HYHU\WKLQJ$ DQG SXW LQWHOOHFW ILUVW& vFOJ>7=EH7I

:c bch VY UZfU]X cZ h\Y kUm mcif ]bhY``YWh WU``g ]bhc eiYgx h]cb c`X ghcf]Yg UbX `Y[YbXg( J\Y difY ]bhY``YWh WUbbch XYghfcm Ubmh\]b[ k]h\cih fYd`UW]b[ ]h k]h\ h\Y hfih\4 h\]g ]g cbY cZ ]hg YggYbh]U` eiU`]h]Yg(

JIJOHJS Ă MY \UjY a]gWcbWYdh]cbg bch VYWUigY kY h\]b_ ]``c[]WU``m Vih VYWUigY kY `]jY cif `]jYg VUX`m( ?[bcfUbWY WUbbch `YUX hc Yj]`& a]gWcbWYdh]cbg `YUX hc Yj]`( ?hrg bch k\Uh dYcd`Y Xc _bck& ]hrg k\Uh h\Ym dfYhYbX h\Uh h\Ym Xc( v@ ;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

;jYfm a]gWcbWYdh]cb ]g U dc]gcb5 h\YfY UfY bc \Ufa`Ygg a]gWcbWYdh]cbg( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

EbY cZ h\Y Yj]` dfcdYfh]Yg cZ aUb ]g h\Uh \Y `cjYg cb`m \]agY`Z UbX kUbhg [ccXbYgg cb`m Zcf \]agY`Z( 8ih kcY hc \]a k\c `cjYg cb`m \]agY`Z v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y Z][\h VYhkYYb h\Y gd]f]hiU` UbX aUhYf]U` ]bbYf bUhifY [cYg cb ]b YjYfmcbY( J\ig& U`` dYcd`Y \UjY a]gWcbWYdx h]cbg& UbX aUbm k]`` U`kUmg a]ghU_Y h\Ya Zcf h\Y hfih\( ?R IHHG WKH KXQJU\$ WR FORWKH WKH QDNHG$ WR YLVLW WKH LOO LQ WKH KRVSLWDObWKHVH DUH DFWV RI PHUF\$ KXW WKHUH LV RQH FKDULWDEOH GHHG ZKLFK FDQQRW EH FRPSDUHG WR WKHP* WR IUHH \RXU EURWKHU IURP PLVFRQFHSWLRQ&

JIJOHJS Ĉ B]ZY Wcbg]ghg cZ biaYfcig ]bj]g]V`Y& ]adYfWYdh]V`Y W\Ub[Yg& W\Ub[Yg h\Uh VY[Ub Uh V]fh\ UbX YbX k]h\ XYUh\( ?h ]g bch dcgg]V`Y Zcf ig \iaUbg hc cVgYfjY h\Ya U``( Jfi`m& hfi`m& ? gUm hc mci& ib`Ygg U [fU]b cZ k\YUh ZU``g ]bhc h\Y YUfh\ UbX X]Yg& ]h fYaU]bg Vm ]hgY`Z U`cbY5 Vih ]Z ]h X]Yg& ]h VYUfg aiW\ Zfi]h( >Y k\c `cjYg \]g `]ZY `cgYg ]h& UbX \Y k\c \UhYg \]g `]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X g\U`` _YYd ]h hc `]ZY YhYfbU`( ?E>D +,4,.',/

B]ZY ]g W\Ub[]b[ U`` h\Y h]aY& UbX cb`m h\Y ][bcfUbh Xc bch `cc_ ]bhc h\Y XYdh\ cZ h\]b[g( vBK9O C7BEHO

M\m UfY mci gc UZfU]X cZ W\Ub[Y6 Dch\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X WUb VY XcbY k]h\cih W\Ub[Y( Eb`m cbY fi`Y g\ci`X fYaU]b WcbghUbh4 Xc bch Xc Ubmh\]b[ ]b\iaUbY hc ch\Yfg( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

;jYfmh\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X V`ccag& [fckg& UbX fYhifbg hc ]hg fcchg( HYhifb]b[ hc cbYrg fcchg aYUbg VYWca]b[ ib]hYX k]h\ bUhifY5 VYWca]b[ ib]hYX k]h\ bUhifY ]bjc`jYg YhYfx b]hm( J\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ mcif VcXm \c`Xg bc XUb[Yf ]b ]hgY`Z( vB7E'JPK

0HDWK LV D FKDQJH WR D IRUP ZLWK ZKLFK RXU VSLULW LV XQLWHG& CRX VKRXOG QRW FRQIXVH WKH IRUP ZLWK WKRVH WKLQJV ZLWK ZKLFK LW LV XQLWHG&

JIJOHJS Ǻ ?h gYYag gc YUgm hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y `Uk cZ =cX h\Uh ]g YldfYggYX ]b h\Y 9\f]gh]Ub hYUW\]b[& Vih kY UfY gh]`` gc ZUf Zfca h\]g Zi`Z]``aYbh ?KH ODZ RI ULJKW OLYLQJ LV QRW LPPHGLDWHO\ FOHDU WR WKH ZLVH PDQ$ KXW LW EHFRPHV PXFK FOHDUHU ZKHQ KH IROORZV LW& ?KH ODZ RI ULJKW OLYLQJ LV LPPHGLDWHO\ FOHDU WR WKH RUGLQDU\ SHUc VRQ$ EXW LW EHFRPHV OHVV REYLRXV ZKHQ KH WULHV WR IROORZ LW& v9ED<K9?KI

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY YhYfbU` `Uk( ?h XcYg bch W\Ub[Y UbX ]h [cjYfbg U`` dYcd`Y Uh U`` h]aYg( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

JIJOHJS Ċ 9DQ_V SXUSRVH LV WR VHUYH DOO PDQNLQG$ QRW WR VHUYH RQO\ RQH PDQ ZKLOH GRLQJ KDUP WR RWKHUV& <cf U 9\f]gh]Ub& h\Y `cjY cZ cbYrg ach\Yf`UbX WUb VY Ub cVghUW`Y hc h\Y `cjY cZ cbYrg bY][\Vcf( Bcgh gci`g YgWUdY h\Y]f `cgg cZ Wcbhfc` ]b dUhf]ch]ga( v:H( I7CK;B @E>DIED

FUhf]ch]ga ]g bch U j]fhiY( IUWf]Z]W]b[ mcif `]ZY Zcf Ub ]bgh]x hih]cb k\]W\ YaVcX]Yg dfY^iX]WY WUbbch VY mcif Xihm( FYcd`Y Xc aUbm VUX h\]b[g Zcf gY`Z]g\ fYUgcbg5 h\Ym Xc kcfgY h\]b[g Zcf h\Y]f ZUa]`]Yg( 8ih h\Ym Xc h\Y kcfgh ]b h\Y bUaY cZ dUhf]ch]ga& UbX h\Ym UfY aUXY dfciX Vm h\YgY Wf]aYg4 gdm]b[& ibXi`m \YUjm hUl Wc``YWh]b[& gUWf]Z]W]b[ `]jYg& UbX kU[]b[ kUfg( Bcj]b[ mcif Wcibhfm UbX `cj]b[ mcif ZUa]`m UfY Vch\ j]fhiYg h\Uh WUb VYWcaY j]WYg k\Yb h\Ym VYWcaY cjYfx k\Y`a]b[ UbX XUaU[Y mcif `cjY Zcf mcif bY][\Vcf(

JIJOHJS ÁÀ EbY cZ h\Y kcfgh h\]b[g dcgg]V`Y ]g hc Zc``ck h\Y fi`Y4 s8Y `]_Y YjYfmcbY& Zc``ck h\Y WfckX(t McY hc h\Y kcf`X VYWUigY cZ ]hg ghiaV`]b[ V`cW_ <cf ]h ]g ]bYj]hUV`Y h\Uh ghiaV`]b[ V`cW_g WcaY& Vih kcY hc h\Uh aUb h\fci[\ k\ca h\Y ghiaV`]b[ V`cW_ WcaYg 7bX ]Z mcif \UbX cf mcif Zcch WUigY mci hc ghiaV`Y& Wih ]h cZZ UbX h\fck ]h Zfca mci5 ]h ]g VYhhYf Zcf mci hc YbhYf `]ZY Wf]dd`YX cf `UaY h\Ub \Uj]b[ hkc \UbXg UbX hkc ZYYh& hc VY WUgh ]bhc h\Y YhYfbU` Z]fY( vC7JJ>;M +241'3

EbY cZ h\Y aU^cf cVghUW`Yg ]adYX]b[ Ubm dcg]h]jY ZihifY W\Ub[Y ]b cif `]jYg ]g h\Uh kY UfY hcc Vigm k]h\ cif Wifx fYbh kcf_ cf UWh]j]hm( BYj] ei]h \]g hUl'kcf_& FYhYf ghcddYX Z]g\]b[ Uh U `U_Y& FUi` WYUgYX VY]b[ U df]Ygh( J\Ym U`` `YZh h\Y]f ^cVg VYWUigY h\Ym h\ci[\h ]h kUg bYWYggUfm( v@E>D HKIA?D

?Z U dYfgcbrg \UbX ]g bch XUaU[YX& h\Yb ]h WUb k]h\ghUbX h\Y V]hY cZ U dc]gcbcig gbU_Y( ?hg dc]gcb dcgYg bc XUb[Yf hc U \YU`h\m \UbX( ;j]` ]g \Ufa`Ygg Zcf \]a k\c ]g bch Ub Yj]`XcYf( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

2DOVH VKDPH LV WKH GHYLO_V IDYRULWH HPRWLRQ+ LW LV HYHQ ZRUVH WKDQ IDOVH SULGH& <ULGH FDQ VXSSRUW HYLO$ EXW IDOVH VKDPH VWRSV JRRGQHVV& v@E>D HKIA?D

J\YfY ]g bc Yj]` ]b h\Y kcf`X ]hgY`Z( 7`` Yj]` Yl]ghg ]b cif gci`g& UbX WUb VY XYghfcmYX(

JIJOHJS ÁÁ Dch\]b[ ]g acfY ^cmZi` h\Ub h\Y `UVcf cZ U ZUfaYf h]``]b[ h\Y gc]`( ?KH EHVW IRRG LV WKH IRRG \RX RU \RXU FKLOGUHQ PDNH E\ \RXUc VHOI vCE>7CC;:

J\cgY k\c dfcj]XY Zcf h\Y]f ckb ZccX Vm h\YagY`jYg XYgYfjY acfY fYgdYWh h\Ub h\cgY k\c W`U]a hc VY fY`]x []cig( vJ\Y J7BCK:

Mcf_]b[ cb h\Y `UbX UbX aU_]b[ mcif ckb VfYUX ]gbrh bYWYggUfm Zcf U`` dYcd`Y& Vih bc hmdY cZ kcf_ ]g acfY ]adcfhUbh Zcf \iaUb]hm& UbX bc hmdY cZ kcf_ cZZYfg U [fYUhYf XY[fYY cZ ]bXYdYbXYbWY UbX [ccX(

JIJOHJS ÁÂ A]bXbYgg XYZYUhg YjYfmh\]b[ UbX WUb bYjYf VY XYZYUhYX( CRX FDQ VWDQG ILUP LQ D ILJKW DJDLQVW HYHU\WKLQJ H[FHSW NLQGQHVV& v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7Kv

?h ]g bch h\Y V`Ua]b[ cZ Yj]` Vih h\Y [`cf]Zm]b[ cZ [ccXbYgg h\Uh WfYUhYg \Ufacbm ]b cif `]ZY( vBK9O C7BEHO

?Z U [ccX UWh]cb \Ug Ub i`hYf]cf WUigY& h\Yb ]h ]g bch hfi`m [ccX( ?Z ]h YldYWhg fYkUfX& ]h ]g bch hfi`m [ccX( =ccX h\]b[g UfY VYmcbX fYUgcb UbX WcbgYeiYbWY( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh Z]fYkcf_g UbX hcfW\Yg WUbbch VY gYYb ]b h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y gib& h\Y VYgh ]bhY``YWh UbX h\Y [fYUhYgh VYUihm WUbbch VY gYYb ]b h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y _]bXbYgg cZ U g]b[`Y \YUfh( v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

J\Y acgh hYbXYf d`Ubhg WUb dig\ h\Y]f kUm h\fci[\ h\Y \UfXYgh fcW_g& UbX ]h ]g h\Y gUaY k]h\ _]bXbYgg( Dch\]b[ WUb ghcd U hfi`m _]bX UbX g]bWYfY dYfgcb( v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

J\Y dYfgcb XcYg bch Yl]gh hc k\ca mci WUbbch Xc [ccX( vBK9?KI 7bbUYig IYbYWU

MY Xc [ccX hc dYcd`Y bch ]b \cdY cZ fYkUfX& Vih VYWUigY kY gYY h\Y X]j]bY gd]f]h k]h\]b YjYfmcbY( J\Y VYgh UbX YUg]Ygh kUm hc h\kUfh Yj]` ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g hc fYgdcbX hc ]h k]h\ _]bX kcfXg& fYhifb Ub Yj]` UWh]cb k]h\ [ccX(

JIJOHJS ĄǼ ?UXH IDLWK LV IDLWK RQO\ LI WKH DFWLRQV RI \RXU OLIH DUH LQ KDUc PRQ\ ZLWK LW DQG QHYHU FRQWUDGLFW LW& :if]b[ h\Y XUm mci g\ci`X VY\UjY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci WUb g`YYd Uh b][\h ]b dYUWY5 UbX ]b mcif mcih\ mci g\ci`X VY\UjY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci WUb `]jY ]b mcif c`X U[Y ]b dYUWY( v?D:?7D FHEL;H8

J\cgY k\c \UjY kYU_ ZU]h\ h\YagY`jYg WUbbch UfcigY ZU]h\ ]b ch\Yfg( vB7E'JPK

J\cgY k\c []jY gYWcbX d`UWY hc =cX ]b h\Y]f \YUfhg Xc bch []jY >]a U d`UWY Uh U``( v@E>D HKIA?D

MY WUb bYjYf Zi``m ibXYfghUbX h\Y Z]bU` difdcgY cZ \iaUb `]ZY( 7 WcbghfiWh]cb kcf_Yf k\c kcf_g Uh U WcbghfiWh]cb g]hY WUb \UjY bc ]XYU cZ h\Y Z]bU` Zcfa cf [YbYfU` XYg][b cZ h\Y `Uf[Y ghfiWhifY \Y Vi]`Xg& Vih \Y WUb _bck h\Uh \Y ]g kcf_x ]b[ cb gcaYh\]b[ [ccX& gcaYh\]b[ VYUih]Zi`& W`YjYf& UbX bYWYggUfm& Vch\ Zcf \]a UbX Zcf h\Y kcf`X( J\]g ]g ZU]h\( :c bch VY`]YjY ]b kcfXg& mcifg cf ch\Yfgr5 VY`]YjY ]b h\Y XYYXg(

JIJOHJS ÁÄ 7 dYfgcb k\c VYWcaYg W`cgY hc =cX ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh =cX `]jYg k]h\]b \]a( 7b[Y`ig& U amgh]WU` dcYh cZ h\Y gYjx YbhYYbh\ WYbhifm& gU]X& s+ gYY =cX k]h\ h\Y gUaY YmY k]h\ k\]W\ >Y gYYg aY(t v>;DH? 7C?;B

?KH VRXO RI D SHUVRQ LV WKH ODPS RI 3RG& vJ\Y J7BCK:

FYcd`Y Xc bch _bck k\Uh =cX `cc_g `]_Y Vih h\Ym `]jY ]b >]a UbX >Y ]b h\Ya( vIK<? M?I:EC5 U amgh]WU` gYWh ]b ?IB7C

J\cgY k\c WUb fU]gY h\Y]f h\ci[\hg hc \YUjYb k]`` U`kUmg \UjY W`YUf XUmg& VYWUigY h\Y gib U`kUmg g\]bYg UVcjY h\Y W`ciXg( ?Z mci UfY [bUkYX Vm XYg]fY cf ZYUf mci aigh bch VY`]YjY ]b =cX& k\c ]g Z]``YX k]h\ `cjY& UbX k\c Yl]ghg ]b mci( ?Z mci VY`]YjY ]b >]a& mci _bck h\Uh mci bYYX bch k]g\ Zcf Ubmh\]b[ VYWUigY h\Y k]g\Yg cZ =cX U`kUmg WcaY hfiY5 UbX mci bYYX bYjYf VY UZfU]X cZ Ubmh\]b[& VYWUigY =cX ZYUfg bch\]b[( J\Y bUhifY cZ U gci` ]g gc amghYf]cig h\Uh bc aUhhYf \ck \UfX kY hfm hc ibXYfghUbX ]h& kY k]`` bYjYf VY UV`Y hc XYZ]bY ]h( v>;H79B?JKI

BKDWHYHU PD\ KDSSHQ WR \RX$ \RX ZLOO QHYHU KH XQKDSS\ LI \RX XQGHUVWDQG \RXU XQLILFDWLRQ ZLWK 3RG&

JIJOHJS ĄĆ ;QO\ PLVFRQFHSWLRQV QHHG WR EH VXSSRUWHG E\ HODERUDWH DUJXPHQWV& ?UXWK FDQ DOZD\V VWDQG DORQH& 7`` [ccXbYgg ]g Ug bch\]b[ WcadUfYX hc h\Y [ccXbYgg cZ hfih\5 U`` gkYYhg UfY Ug bch\]b[ WcadUfYX hc h\Y gkYYhbYgg cZ hfih\( J\Y V`]gg cZ hfih\ gifdUggYg U`` ch\Yf ^cmg ]b h\Y kcf`X( v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 dYfgcb WUbbch VY Wcad`YhY`m hfih\Zi` U`` h\Y h]aY& VYWUigY X]ZZYfYbh ZcfWYg UbX Ugd]fUh]cbg Z][\h k]h\]b \]a& 'UbX gcaYh]aYg \Y WUbbch YldfYgg h\Ya& YjYb hc \]agY`Z( C]gWcbWYdh]cbg Yl]gh cb`m Zcf U Z]b]hY dYf]cX cZ h]aY& Vih fYU` hfih\ fYaU]bg Ug ]h U`kUmg kUg& UZhYf U`` hf]W_g& gcd\]gag& UbX `]Yg \UjY k]h\YfYX UkUm( BYUfb k\Uh hc Xc& h\]b_& UbX gUm h\Y hfih\ Uh U`` h]aYg( Eb`m k\Yb mci ghUfh hc `YUfb h\]g WUb mci ibXYfghUbX \ck ZUf kY UfY Zfca fYU` hfih\( B]Yg UfY U`kUmg \UfaZi` hc U`` `]j]b[ h\]b[g( Dc dYfgcb ]g k]h\cih g]b5 bc dYfgcb ]g Wcad`YhY`m hfih\x Zi`( ?h ]g bch h\Uh cbY dYfgcb ]g j]fhicig UbX hfih\Zi` UbX Ubch\Yf ]g g]bZi` UbX XYWY]hZi`5 fUh\Yf ]hrg h\Uh cbY dYfgcb ghf]jYg hc acjY hckUfX hfih\ UbX j]fhiY UbX h\Y ch\Yf XcYg bch(

JIJOHJS ÁĂ Eb`m h\Y gdfYUX cZ `cjY VYhkYYb dYcd`Y WUb ]adfcjY h\Y Yl]gh]b[ gcW]U` ghfiWhifY( BcjY []jYg aYUb]b[ hc \iaUb `]ZY( J\]g kY \UjY _bckb g]bWY Ubh]ei]hm( 8ih k\Uh ]g `cjY6 CUbm k]gY dYcd`Y h\fci[\cih h\Y U[Yg \UjY hf]YX hc gc`jY h\]g eiYgh]cb( ?Z mci fU]gY dYcd`Y hc dfU]gY cb`m kYU`h\& dckYf& UbX [`cfm& h\Yb bUhifU``m h\Ym k]`` dfU]gY cb`m h\YgY h\]b[g( ?Z mci fU]gY dYcd`Y hc `cjY h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY& h\Ym k]`` ghUfh hc `]jY ]b `cjY( vC;;'J;;& U ghiXYbh cZ 9ED<K9?KI

;QO\ RQH FOHDU TXDOLW\ PDUNV DQ DFWLRQ DV HLWKHU JRRG RU HYLO* 5I LW LQFUHDVHV WKH DPRXQW RI ORYH LQ WKH ZRUOG$ LW LV JRRG& 5I LW VHSDUDWHV SHRSOH DQG FUHDWHV DQLPRVLW\ DPRQJ WKHP$ LW LV KDG& J\Y h]aY ]g Wca]b[& U h]aY cZ WcbWcfX& \Ufacbm& Zcf[]jYx bYgg& UbX `cjY( :YdYbX cb ]h( MY aigh Xc YjYfmh\]b[ ]b cif dckYf hc Vf]b[ h\]g h]aY W`cgYf& UbX hc ghcd h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ XY`Um ]hg Uff]jU`(

JIJOHJS ÁÅ Eif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ cifgY`jYg Ug X]gWfYhY VY]b[g gYdUx fUhY Zfca YUW\ ch\Yf [fckg cih cZ WcbX]h]cbg cZ cif `]ZY ]b h]aY UbX gdUWY( J\Y `Ygg kY ZYY` h\]g gYdUfUh]cb& h\Y acfY kY ZYY` cif ib]Z]WUh]cb k]h\ U`` ch\Yf `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg& h\Y `][\hYf cif `cUX& UbX h\Y acfY ^cmZi` cif `]ZY k]`` VY( <cf h\Y VcXm ]g bch cbY aYaVYf& Vih aUbm(((( 7bX ]Z cbY aYaVYf giZZYfg& U`` h\Y aYaVYfg giZZYf k]h\ ]h5 ]Z cbY aYaVYf ]g \cbcfYX& U`` h\Y aYaVYfg fY^c]WY k]h\ ]h( v? 9EH?DJ>?7DI +,4+.& ,0

7 gaU`` VfUbW\ Wih cZZ Zfca U V][ `]aV ]g gYdUfUhYX Zfca h\Y k\c`Y hfYY( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm k\Yb U dYfgcb ]g ]b Ub Uf[iaYbh k]h\ Ubch\Yf dYfgcb& \Y ]g gYdUfUhYX Zfca U`` \iaUb]hm( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

=cX WfYUhYX \YUjYb UbX YUfh\& Vih h\Ym `UW_YX h\Y UV]`]hm hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZ h\Y]f Yl]ghYbWY( J\Yb =cX aUXY WfYUhifYg k\c Wci`X ibXYfghUbX h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZ h\Y]f Yl]ghYbWY& UbX k\c Wci`X WfYUhY U g]b[`Y VcXm Zfca U`` cZ ]hg h\]b_]b[ dUfhg( 7`` dYcd`Y UfY aYaVYfg cZ h\]g cbY VcXm5 ]b cfXYf hc VY \Uddm& h\Ym g\ci`X `]jY ]b \Ufx acbm k]h\ h\Y k]`` h\Uh [cjYfbg ]hg `]ZY( MY g\ci`X `]jY ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ h\]g [fYUh gci` UbX `cjY ]h acfY h\Ub kY `cjY cifgY`jYg( v8B7?I; F7I97B

BH PDQLIHVW LQ ORYH RXU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH XQLW\ RI RXU EHLQJ ZLWK RWKHUV$ DQG LQ VR GRLQJ ZH PDNH RXU OLIH JUHDWHU& ?KH PRUH ZH ORYH$ WKH ZLGHU$ ODUJHU$ DQG PRUH MR\IXO RXU OLIH EHFRPHV&

JIJOHJS ÁǺ CUb_]bX acjYg WYUgY`Ygg`m hckUfX dYfZYWh]cb& bch cZ YjYfm dYfgcbrg UWWcfX& Vih h\fci[\ h\Y YZZcfhg h\Uh gcaY dUfh]Wi`Uf ]bX]j]XiU`g aU_Y hckUfX h\Y]f dYfgcbU` dYfZYWh]cb( J\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX k]`` VY WfYUhYX Vm h\YgY ]bX]j]XiU` YZZcfhg( :c bch VY YaVUffUggYX Vm U`` mcif VUX XYYXg& Vm U`` mcif a]gZcfhibYg( :c bch VY YaVUffUggYX& Vih Z][\h WYUgYx `Ygg`m& VfUjY`m& UbX k]h\cih \Yg]hUh]cb& VYWUigY h\Y _]b[x Xca cZ =cX k]`` WcaY( v<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

MY \YUf cZhYb h\Uh h\YfY ]g bc igY ]b kcf_]b[ hc ]adfcjY cif `]ZY& hc Z][\h Yj]`& cf hc YghUV`]g\ ^igh]WY& VYWUigY dfc[fYgg k]`` cWWif Vm ]hgY`Z( ?aU[]bY h\Uh U VcUh Z`cUhg U`cb[ U f]jYf( ?aU[]bY h\Uh h\cgY k\c \UjY gUh Vm h\Y cUfg UbX fckYX h]fY`Ygg`m \UjY ghcddYX UbX [cbY Ug\cfY5 UbX h\Uh h\Y hfUjY`Yfg k\c fYaU]b ]b h\Y VcUh Xc bch Vch\Yf hc hU_Y id h\Y cUfg UbX dig\ h\Y VcUh Zifh\Yf& Vih h\]b_ h\Uh ]h k]`` hfUjY` Vm ]hgY`Z& Ug VYZcfY& ]bhc h\Y ZihifY( B]ZY \Ug bc aYUb]b[ k]h\cih difdcgY( Jc `UW_ difdcgY ]g hc XYbm h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX UbX hc UXa]h h\Uh cif `]ZY ]g Ub Yj]`& ghid]X^c_Y( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

-OO RXU KLVWRU\ SURYHV WKDW 3RG PD\ KH XQGHUVWRRG$ QRW E\ UHDVRQLQJ$ EXW E\ VXEPLVVLRQ WR 4LP DQG REH\DQFH WR 4LV ODZV& ;QO\ E\ GRLQJ WKLV FDQ ZH XQGHUVWDQG 4LV ZLOO RQ HDUWK& v@E>D HKIA?D

;jYfm dYfgcb g\ci`X aU_Y U gaU`` YZZcfh& YjYb h\Y gaU``x Ygh YZZcfh& hc ]adfcjY h\Y [YbYfU` kY``'VY]b[ cZ \iaUb]hm(

Z JIJOHJS ÁĄ =HDO JRRGQHVV LV LQ \RXU KDQGV& 5W IROORZV D JRRG SHUVRQ DV D VKDGRZ IROORZV LWV REMHFW& ;jYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ WUb aU_Y ig VYhhYf UbX \Udd]Yf kUg []jYb hc ig Vm =cX( ?Z cif WcbgW]YbWY ]g W`YUf& h\Yb bch\x ]b[ WUb \Ufa ig( v;F?9J;JKI

J\Ym k\c \UjY XYW]XYX hc XYX]WUhY h\Y]f `]jYg hc gd]f]hiU` dYfZYWh]cb k]`` bYjYf VY X]ggUh]gZ]YX cf ib\Uddm& VYWUigY& U`` h\Uh h\Ym kUbh ]g ]b h\Y]f dckYf( v8B7?I; F7I97B

>Udd]bYgg& difY \Udd]bYgg& ]g U j]fhiY ]b ]hgY`Z( v8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

J\Y [fYUhYf h\Y YZZcfh U dYfgcb aU_Yg hc UW\]YjY d`YUgifY& h\Y `Ygg dcgg]V`Y ]h ]g Zcf \]a hc dcggYgg fYU` [ccXbYgg& cf `cjY( J\Ym k\c gUm h\Uh Xc]b[ [ccX WUigYg h\Ya ib\Udd]bYgg Y]h\Yf Xcbrh VY`]YjY ]b =cX cf UfYbrh Xc]b[ gcaYh\]b[ h\Uh ]g hfi`m [ccX(

JIJOHJS ÂÀ J\Y fYU` difdcgY cZ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g cVj]cig hc U``& UbX ]h ]g ghfcb[Yf h\Ub h\Y `]Yg k\]W\ hfm hc dYfjYfh ]h( MY g\ci`X gYdUfUhY h\Y fY`][]cb h\Uh kUg hUi[\h Vm @Ygig Zfca h\Y fY`][]cb k\cgY giV^YWh ]g @Ygig( J\Yb kY k]`` ibXYfghUbX h\Y fYU` aYUb]b[ cZ h\Y DYk JYghUaYbh UbX Zc``ck ?h( v>;DH? 7C?;B

? gYY U bYk fY`][]cb VUgYX cb aihiU` hfigh& k\]W\ UddYU`g hc cif XYYdYgh gY`jYg& UbX k\]W\ hYUW\Yg h\Uh U dYfgcb g\ci`X `cjY [ccXbYgg k]h\cih fYkUfX& UbX h\Uh h\Y X]j]bY Yl]ghg ]b YjYfmcbY( ?b X]ZZYfYbh kUmg UbX ]b X]ZZYfYbh hcb[iYg& U`` \iaUb]hm fYdYUhg h\Y kcfXg cZ h\Y BcfXrg dfUmYf& sBYh h\m _]b[Xca WcaY cb YUfh\ Ug ]h ]g ]b \YUjYb(t v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

0R QRW WKLQN WKDW \RX ZLOO SHUVRQDOO\ VHH WKH FRPLQJ RI WKH NLQJGRP RI 3RG& .XW KDYH QR GRXEW WKDW LW ZLOO FRPH VRRQ* LW LV FRPLQJ FORVHU DQG FORVHU$ ZLWKRXW KHVLWDWLRQ&

JIJOHJS ÂÁ 7h h\Y \][\Ygh `YjY` cZ WcbgW]cigbYgg& Ub ]bX]j]XiU` ]g U`cbY( IiW\ gc`]hiXY WUb gYYa ghfUb[Y& ibigiU`& YjYb X]ZZ]x Wi`h( <cc`]g\ dYcd`Y hfm hc YgWUdY ]h Vm aYUbg cZ jUf]cig X]gg]dUh]cbg ]b cfXYf hc [Yh UkUm Zfca h\]g \][\ dc]bh& hc gcaY dc]bh `ckYf& Vih k]gY dYcd`Y fYaU]b Uh h\]g \][\ dc]bh& k]h\ h\Y \Y`d cZ dfUmYf( =cX kUbhg ig hc Zi`Z]`` \]g k]`` \YfY cb YUfh\& ]b cif `]jYg( 8ih `]ZYrg ]bhYfYghg UbX dUgg]cbg X]ghfUWh ig Zfca h\]g YjYfm a]bihY( M\Yb kY ibXYfghUbX h\]g& kY WUb []fX cifgY`jYg k]h\ h\Y d\mg]WU` YldfYgg]cb cZ cif Uhh]hiXY hc =cX& dfUmYf( 7 dYfgcbU`]hm ]g U `]a]hUh]cb UbX& h\YfYZcfY& =cX& Ug kY ibXYfghUbX >]a& ]g bch U dYfgcbU`]hm( FfUmYf ]g cif UXXfYgg hc =cX UbX mYh \ck WUb kY UXXfYgg cbY k\c \Ug bc dYfgcbU`]hm6 ? UXXfYgg =cX Ug ]Z >Y kYfY U dYfgcb& h\ci[\ ? _bck ]h ]g bch gc( 7 dYfgcb Vif]YX ]b U XYYd a]bY& ZfYYn]b[ Zfca h\Y Wc`X ]b XYYd ]WY& Xm]b[ Zfca \ib[Yf U`cbY cb h\Y cdYb gYU& kUghx ]b[ UkUm ]b gc`]hiXY ]b U df]gcb WY``& cf g]ad`m Xm]b[ Uh \caY& XYUZ UbX V`]bXv\ck Wci`X h\]g dYfgcb `]jY cih h\Y fYaU]bXYf cZ \]g `]ZY ]Z dfUmYf X]X bch Yl]gh6 4RZ JRRG D SHUVRQ IHHOV ZKHQ$ H[KDXVWHG IURP VWULYLQJ IRU JRRGQHVV LQ KLV HYHU\GD\ OLIH$ KH VWUHWFKHV RXW KLV KDQGV WR 3RG& v8B7?I; F7I97B

EbY WUb `]jY k]h\cih dfUmYf Y]h\Yf k\Yb \Y ]g dcggYggYX Vm \]g dUgg]cbg cf k\Yb \]g `]ZY ]g Wcad`YhY`m XYX]WUhYX hc =cX( 8ih Zcf U dYfgcb k\c ]g Z][\h]b[ \]g dUgg]cb UbX mYh ZUf Zfca Zi`Z]``]b[ \]g Xihm& dfUmYf ]g U bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY(

JIJOHJS ÂÂ Dch\]b[ gYYag hc W\YW_ h\Y bch]cb h\Uh h\Y kUm hc ]adfcjY W]j]`]nUh]cb ]g UZZYWhYX Vm W\Ub[]b[ ]hg cihYf Zcfag( J\]g bch]cb ]g ZU`gY& UbX XfUkg h\Y UWh]j]hm cZ hcc aUbm dYcd`Y UkUm Zfca YZZcfh h\Uh hfi`m WUb ]adfcjY cif `]jYg( 9]j]`]nUh]cb ]g Z]fgh cZ U`` U acfU` h\]b[( M]h\cih hfih\& fYgdYWh Zcf Xihm& `cjY cZ bY][\Vcf& j]fhiY& YjYfmh\]b[ ]g XYghfcmYX( J\Y acfU`]hm cZ U gcW]Yhm ]g U`cbY h\Y VUg]g cZ W]j]`]nUh]cb( v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y dfcdYf X]fYWh]cb cZ aUbrg h\ci[\h ]g bch hckUfX h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ bYk `Ukg Zcf [cjYfbaYbh& Vih hckUfX h\Y UWWYdhUbWY cZ YjYfm dYfgcbrg acfU` X][b]hm( v;:CKD: O7J;I

IcW]U`]ga& k\Yb WcadUfYX k]h\ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm& ]g U fUh\Yf a]bcf& gYWcbXUfm eiYgh]cb UVcih h\Y aUhYf]U` bYYXg cZ h\Y kcf_]b[ W`Ugg( ?h ghUbXg cihg]XY h\Y VUg]W eiYgh]cbg cZ \iaUb `]ZY( v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

MY g\ci`X& Z]fgh cZ U``& ibXYfghUbX h\Uh kY UfY U`` W\]`XfYb cZ h\Y gUaY ZUh\Yf& UbX kY g\ci`X Zi`Z]`` h\Y gUaY [YbYfU` `Uk4 `]jY bch Zcf cifgY`jYg& Vih hc \Y`d ch\Yfg VY \Uddm( v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

BKHQ ZH DFFHSW IDOVH DQG YLROHQW ODZV DQG VXEPLW WR WKHP$ ZH FDQ QHLWKHU HVWDEOLVK WUXWK QRU FRPEDW OLHV LQ WKLV ZRUOG&

JIJOHJS ÆǼ M]gXca ]g ibXYfghUbX]b[ \ck YhYfbU` hfih\ WUb VY Udd`]YX hc `]ZY( IcWfUhYg kUg h\Y Z]fgh k\c Vfci[\h d\]`cgcd\m Zfca \YUjYb& X]ghf]VihYX ]h Uacb[ h\Y dYcd`Y& UbX Ybh]WYX h\Ya hc ghiXm h\Y gW]YbWY cZ `]ZY& \iaUb acfU`g& UbX h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ [ccX UbX Yj]`( >FLHQFH LV VHOGRP FRQQHFWHG ZLWK ZLVGRP& - VFKRODUO\ SHUc VRQ NQRZV PDQ\ XQQHFHVVDU\ WKLQJV& - ZLVH SHUVRQ NQRZV IHZ WKLQJV$ EXW DOO WKDW KH NQRZV LV QHFHVVDU\ ERWK IRU KXPDQLW\ DQG IRU KLPVHOI& >Y k\c ibXYfghUbXg \]g gci` k]`` ibXYfghUbX h\Y X]j]bY gdUf_ k]h\]b \]agY`Z( vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

M]gY dYcd`Y WUbbch VY giZZ]W]Ybh`m YXiWUhYX& UbX YXix WUhYX dYcd`Y WUbbch VY giZZ]W]Ybh`m k]gY( vB7E'JPK

J\Y [ccXbYgg []jYb hc ig Vm k]gXca WcadUfYg hc U`` ch\Yf _bck`YX[Y ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh ]b U XYgYfh& U jYggY` Z]``YX k]h\ kUhYf WcadUfYg hc acibhU]bg cZ [c`X(

JIJOHJS ÂÄ IhUfh]b[ Zfca YUf`m W\]`X\ccX5 Ug kY U[Y kY ZYY` h\Y [fckh\ cZ cif gd]f]hiU` dckYf UbX h\Y X]a]bih]cb cZ cif d\mg]WU` dckYf( E`XYf dYcd`Y k\c `]jY gd]f]hiU` `]jYg YjYf k]XYb h\Y]f gd]fx ]hiU` \cf]ncbg& UbX YjYf YldUbX h\Y]f WcbgW]YbWYg( E`XYf dYcd`Y k\c `]jY cb`m U XU]`m fcih]bY VYWcaY acfY UbX acfY ghid]X cjYf h\Y mYUfg( vJ\Y J7BCK:

EbY VYWcaYg c`XYf ]b cfXYf hc VYWcaY _]bXYf5 h\YfY ]g bc a]ghU_Y k\]W\ ? \UjY bch U`fYUXm aUXY( v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

J\Y [fckh\ UbX XYjY`cdaYbh cZ h\Y gci` ]g acfY ]adcfx hUbh h\Ub dckYf UbX [`cfm( v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y [fckh\ cZ cif d\mg]WU` YbYf[m dfYdUfYg ig Zcf gd]f]x hiU` kcf_& Zcf gYfj]b[ =cX UbX aUb_]bX5 h\]g kcf_ ghUfhg k\Yb cif VcXm VY[]bg hc ZUXY UkUm( 3URZ VSLULWXDOO\ DQG KHOS RWKHUV WR GR VR+ LW LV WKH PHDQLQJ RI OLIH& JYff]V`Y ]g h\Y g]hiUh]cb cZ h\cgY k\c WUbbch dYfWY]jY gd]f]hiU` [fckh\ ]b h\YagY`jYg( J\Ym WUb gYY cb`m d\mg]WU` `]ZY& k\]W\ k]`` X]gUddYUf ]b h]aY( M\Yb mci ibXYfghUbX mcif gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ UbX `]jY k]h\ ]h& h\Yb ]bghYUX cZ XYgdU]f]b[ mci ibXYfghUbX h\Y ^cm h\Uh WUb bYjYf VY XYghfcmYX& k\]W\ U`kUmg [fckg(

JIJOHJS ÆĆ A]bXbYgg UbX j]fhiY WcaY Zfca h\Y \YUfh& UbX g\ci`X VY dYfZcfaYX k]h\cih h\ci[\h Zcf h\Y cd]b]cb cZ ch\Yfg& cf cZ ZihifY fYkUfXg( ALUWXH DQG FKDULW\ VWDUW DW KRPH& 5I \RX KDYH WR JR VRPHc ZKHUH WR GLVSOD\ LW$ WKHQ LW LV QRW YLUWXH& 7gg]ghUbWY []jYb hc h\Y dccf Vm h\Y f]W\ ]g hcc cZhYb ^igh U [YghifY cZ dc`]hYbYgg& bch fYU` W\Uf]hm( 9\Uf]hm ]g [ccX cb`m k\Yb ]h WcaYg Ug U gUWf]Z]WY5 cb`m h\Yb Xc h\cgY k\c fYWY]jY" h\Y aUhYf]U` []Zh fYWY]jY h\Y gd]f]hiU` []Zh hcc( ?Z ]h ]g bch U gUWf]Z]WY Vih U X]gW\Uf[Y cZ YlWYgg& ]h WUb cb`m ]ff]hUhY h\cgY k\c fYWY]jY ]h(

JIJOHJS ÂĂ /KLOGKRRG LV WKH SHULRG LQ ZKLFK XQGHUO\LQJ FRQYLFWLRQV DUH IRUPHG& ?KHUHIRUH$ WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW SDUW RI HGXFDWLRQ LV WKH VHOHFWLRQ RI WKH WKLQJV RI ZKLFK D FKLOG VKRXOG KH FRQc YLQFHG& JU`_]b[ UbX fYUgcb]b[ XcYg bch YjYb \UjY cbY h\cigUbXh\ h\Y ]bZ`iYbWY U hfiY YlUad`Y \Ug( 7`` `Yggcbg UVcih \ck hc VY\UjY UfY kcfh\`Ygg k\Yb W\]`XfYb gYY h\Y cddcg]hY ]b fYU` `]ZY( M\Uh igY ]g ]h Zcf W\]`XfYb k\Yb dYcd`Y cb`m gdYU_ UVcih [ccXbYgg& Vih dYfZcfa VUX XYYXg ]b fYU`]hm6 v=KIJ7L IJHKL;

J\Y ghfcb[ XYg]fY Zcf U d`YUgUbh UbX ]XYU` `]ZY ]g U W\]`Xrg kcfgh a]gZcfhibY( ?h ]g WfiW]U` h\Uh W\]`XfYb g\ci`X _bck \ck hc kcf_ Zfca Ub YUf`m U[Y( v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g ]adcfhUbh hc hYUW\ W\]`XfYb _]bXbYgg UbX g]ad`]W]hm ]b `]ZY UbX kcf_( 7`` cZ W\]`XfYbrg acfU` UbX gd]f]hiU` YXix WUh]cb g\ci`X VY giddcfhYX Vm mcif ckb [ccX YlUad`Y( Oci g\ci`X `]jY j]fhicig`m& cf Uh `YUgh hfm hc Xc gc5 h\Y giWx WYgg cZ mcif [ccX `]ZY k]`` YXiWUhY mcif W\]`XfYb(

JIJOHJS ÂÅ 7`` h\Uh kY gYY UbX _bck XcYg bch Yl]gh ]b fYU`]hm& VYWUigY ]h ]g h\Y dfcXiWh cZ cif `]a]hYX UV]`]hm hc ibXYfghUbX fYU`]hm( ?bghYUX cZ gUm]b[ h\Uh h\Y kcf`X ]g fYZ`YWhYX ]b cif ]bhY``YWh& VYhhYf hc gUm h\Uh cif ]bhY``YWh ]g fYZ`YWhYX ]b h\Y kcf`X( v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

E`X ZcfhfYggYg UfY XYghfcmYX& acbiaYbhg hc _]b[g UfY XYac`]g\YX& c`X U[Y fUjU[Yg cif VcX]Yg( Eb`m h\Y hYUW\x ]b[g cZ _]bXbYgg UfY bYjYf fi]bYX cf UZZYWhYX Vm U[Y( -V VRRQ DV D SHUVRQ ILQG\ ORRNV DW KLPVHOI DV RQO\ D SK\VLFDO ERG\$ WKHQ KH VHHV DQ XQVROYHG SX]]OH$ D FRQWUDGLFWLRQ WKDW FDQQRW EH XQUDYHOHG& ?b cfXYf hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfiY YggYbWY cZ U h\]b[ kY aigh hfUbgZcfa h\Y d\mg]WU` ]bhc h\Y gd]f]hiU`(

JIJOHJS ÂǺ IW]YbWY ]g j]hU``m ]adcfhUbh k\Yb ]h ]g \UfbYggYX hc fYjYU` h\Y `Uk cZ \iaUb `]ZY( ?b cfXYf hc UWWYdh h\Y ]adcfhUbWY cZ gW]YbWY& kY aigh dfcjY h\Uh h\]g UWh]j]hm ]g igYZi`( IW]Ybh]ghg igiU``m XYacbx ghfUhY h\Uh h\Ym UfY Xc]b[ gcaYh\]b[ UbX h\Uh aUmVY gcaYx h]aY& gcaYXUm& h\]g Wci`X VY igYZi` Zcf dYcd`Y ]b h\Y ZihifY( J\Y ib]jYfgY ]g `]a]h`Ygg& UbX ]adcgg]V`Y Zcf UbmcbY hc ibXYfghUbX( J\YfYZcfY& kY WUbbch Wcad`YhY`m ibXYfghUbX h\Y `]ZY cZ cif ckb VcXm( v8B7?I; F7I97B

>FLHQFH a LV QRW TXLWH WKH FRQFHSW ZKLFK SHRSOH XVH WKLV ZRUG WR LGHQWLI\+ LW LV WKH KLJKHVW$ PRVW LPSRUWDQW$ PRVW QHFHVVDU\ REMHFW RI RXU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ&

JIJOHJS ÆĊ -V ORQJ DV WKHUH LV YLROHQFH$ WKHUH ZLOO KH ZDU& ;QH FDQQRW GHIHDW YLROHQFH ZLWK PRUH YLROHQFH$ RQO\ ZLWK QRQUHVLVWDQFH WR DQG QRQSDUWLFLSDWLRQ LQ LW& vB;JKHDE

?Z am gc`X]Yfg ghUfhYX h\]b_]b[& bch U g]b[`Y gc`X]Yf kci`X fYaU]b ]b am Ufam( v<H;:;H?9A ??

J\Y k]`X ]bgh]bWh cZ a]`]hUfm aifXYf \Ug XYjY`cdYX ]b \iaUb]hm cjYf h\Y WcifgY cZ h\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg& UbX \Ug VYWcaY fcchYX ]b cif VfU]bg( MY aigh \cdY h\Uh cif gcW]x Yhm k]`` VY UV`Y hc f]X ]hgY`Z cZ h\]g hYff]V`Y Wf]aY( M]h\ h]aY ? ibXYfghUbX h\Y Ufam WcXY h\Uh X]WhUhYg h\Uh U gYf[YUbh ]g U`kUmg f][\h k\Yb \Y UXXfYggYg U gc`X]Yf& h\Uh U `]YihYbUbh ]g U`kUmg f][\h k\Yb \Y UXXfYggYg U gYf[YUbh& UbX gc cb id hc [YbYfU`g UbX aUfg\U`g& YjYb k\Yb U dYfgcb gUmg h\Uh hkc h]aYg hkc YeiU`g Z]jY( ?Z mci Xc bch cVYm mcif gidYf]cf& mci UfY dib]g\YX Vm XYUh\& cf mYUfg ]b df]gcb( v;:M7H: ;AC7D

MUfg WUb VY ghcddYX cb`m ]Z dYcd`Y UfY fYUXm hc VY dYfgYx WihYX Zcf bch dUfh]W]dUh]b[ ]b h\Ya( J\]g ]g h\Y cb`m kUm

JIJOHJS ÃÀ J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y ZfUhYfb]hm UbX YeiU`]hm cZ U`` dYcd`Y VYWcaYg acfY UbX acfY dcdi`Uf Uacb[ aUb_]bX( :c kY ibXYfghUbX cif gd]f]hiU` ZfUhYfb]hm6 :c kY ibXYfx ghUbX h\UhkY cf][]bUhYX Zfca cbY X]j]bY <Uh\Yf k\cgY ]aU[Y kY WUffm ]b cifgY`jYg UbX Zcf k\cgY dYfZYWh]cb kY ghf]jY6 >UjY kY UWWYdhYX h\Uh h\YfY ]g h\Y gUaY X]j]bY `]ZY ]b U`` dYcd`Y& Ug kY`` Ug ]b cifgY`jYg6 7bX h\Uh h\]g aU_Yg U bUhifU` UbX ZfYY VcbX Uacb[ dYcd`Y6 vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

BH FDQ ORYH QHLWKHU WKRVH ZKRP ZH IHDU QRU WKRVH ZKR IHDU XV& vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

<Ua]`m UbX ach\Yf`UbX UfY Vih hkc W]fW`Yg h\Uh UfY dUfh cZ h\Y k]XYf W]fW`Y h\Uh ]g \iaUb]hm( J\cgY k\c hYUW\ acfU`x ]hm UbX k\c `]a]h cbYrg Xih]Yg cb`m hc ZUa]`m UbX Wcibhfm hYUW\ U gY`Z]g\bYgg k\]W\ ]g XUb[Yfcig Zcf U`` cZ ig( J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ cbYrg ib]hm k]h\ U`` cZ \iaUb]hm WcaYg Zfca h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[ ]b ig U``& UbX []jYg U`` cif [fYUhYgh [ccX( JfiY fY`][]cb WfYUhYg h\]g ibXYfghUbX]b[& UbX X]ZZYfYbh dfY^iX]WYg ]bhYfZYfY k]h\ ]hvdfY^iX]WY cZ ghUhY& bUh]cb& UbX W`Ugg(

JIJOHJS ǼĄ J\Y dUgh XcYg bch Yl]gh( J\Y ZihifY \Ug bch VY[ib( J\Y dfYgYbh ]g Ub ]bZ]b]hY`m gaU`` dc]bh ]b h]aY ]b k\]W\ h\Y U`fYUXm bcbYl]ghYbh dUgh aYYhg h\Y ]aa]bYbh ZihifY( 7h h\]g dc]bh& k\]W\ ]g h]aY`Ygg& U dYfgcbrg fYU` `]ZY Yl]ghg( sJ]aY dUggYg Vm t kY gUm( J]aY XcYg bch Yl]gh5 cb`m kY acjY( v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

?LPH LV EHKLQG XV$ WLPH LV EHIRUH XV$ EXW LQ WKH SUHVHQW WKHUH LV QR WLPH& ] Wcbg]gh cZ gd]f]h UbX VcXm( J]aY UZZYWhg h\Y VcXm& Vih h\Y `]ZY cZ h\Y gd]f]h \Ug bc aYUb]b[ Y]h\Yf ]b h\Y dUgh cf ]b h\Y ZihifY( 7`` ]hg `]ZY ]g WcbWYbhfUhYX ]b h\Y dfYgYbh( vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

:]j]bY gd]f]h ]g YhYfbU`& ]h Yl]ghg cih cZ h]aY( B]a]h`Ygg h]aY UbX gdUWY UfY X]j]XYX ]bhc gaU``& `]a]hYX dUfhg hc VY igYX Vm `]a]hYX VY]b[g( v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y gci` ]g dih ]bhc cif VcXm& gc h\Uh ]h WUb ibXYfghUbX h\Y bch]cb cZ XUhY UbX h]aY( ?h WcbhYad`UhYg h\]g ZUWh UbX WU``g ]h sbUhifY(t v8B7?I; F7I97B

J]aY XcYg bch Yl]gh( J\YfY ]g cb`m U gaU`` UbX ]bZ]b]hY dfYgYbh& UbX ]h ]g cb`m ]b h\]g dfYgYbh h\Uh cif `]ZY cWWifg( J\YfYZcfY& U dYfgcb g\ci`X WcbWYbhfUhY U`` \]g gd]f]hiU` ZcfWY cb`m cb h\]g dfYgYbh(

=UbX\] cb BYc Jc`ghcm <fca J\Y ;ggYbh]U` =UbX\]& Bci]g <]gW\Yf QM\YbR ? kUg dUgg]b[ h\fci[\ U gYjYfY Wf]g]g cZ gYYd h]W]ga UbX XciVh((( ? WUaY UWfcgg Jc`ghcm g Vcc_ J\Y A]b[Xca cZ =cX ?g M]h\]b Oci& UbX kUg XYYd`m ]adfYggYX Vm ]h( ? kUg Uh h\Uh h]aY U VY`]YjYf ]b j]c`YbWY( ?hg fYUX]b[ WifYX aY cZ am gWYdh]W]ga UbX aUXY aY U Z]fa VY`]YjYf ]b Qbcb' j]c`YbWYR( M\Uh \Ug UddYU`YX hc aY acgh ]b Jc`ghcm g `]ZY ]g h\Uh \Y dfUWh]gYX k\Uh \Y dfYUW\YX UbX fYW_cbYX bc Wcgh hcc [fYUh ]b \]g dif gi]h cZ hfih\( ( ( ( >Y kUg h\Y [fYUhYgh Udcgh`Y cZ bcb'j]c`YbWY h\Y dfYg Ybh U[Y \Ug dfcXiWYX( Dc cbY ]b h\Y MYgh VYZcfY \]a cf g]bWY \Ug kf]hhYb UbX gdc_Yb cb bcb'j]c`YbWY gc Zi``m cf ]bg]ghYbh`m UbX k]h\ giW\ dYbYhfUh]cb UbX ]bg][\h( ( ( Q>]gR fYaUf_UV`Y XYjY`cdaYbh cZ h\]g XcWhf]bY dihg hc g\UaY h\Y dfYgYbh'XUm bUffck UbX `cd'g]XYX ]bhYfdfY hUh]cb dih idcb ]h Vm h\Y jchUf]Yg cZ 7\]agU ]b h\]g `UbX cZ cifg( ( ( ( JfiY 7\]agU g\ci`X aYUb U Wcad`YhY ZfYYXca Zfca ]`` k]`` UbX Ub[Yf UbX \UhY UbX Ub cjYf Z`ck]b[ `cjY Zcf U``( <cf ]bWi`WUh]b[ h\]g hfiY UbX \][\Yf hmdY cZ 7\]agU Uacb[gh ig& Jc`ghcm g `]ZY k]h\ ]hg cWYUbx `]_Y `cjY g\ci`X gYfjY Ug U VYUWcb `][\h UbX U bYjYf' ZU]`]b[ gcifWY cZ ]bgd]fUh]cb( ( ( (