!"# <=>?@A'ABC<#! renewal of post-conflict transitioning districts
01',1&6-+,7*'-./01'8*+,91 0::.30&)'(3':-/6,&'6,;*
$%&'()*+,+'-./01,+2 !)320+'4,&(3.'4,15
Delft University of Technology !
!"#$%#$
A363:)31 !"#$%&'()( The Public Carpet - renewal of post-conflict transitioning districts "#$%#&'()%*+$(,-"#$.+)%/#$"00,1"&2$31$0(-'%&$'%4+ 50,%'$6!78 921:")$;%&31,$;%#< 321:")**%#<=/:"%'>&1: ?@7A7@B88CA@ )3(.+#3$#(:-+,$$DE!CCC!C FG&$5,&2%3+&3(,+H$I,-"#%):$"#.$J(%'.%#/$G&%+#&+) K+'43$I#%*+,)%3L$14$9+&2#1'1/LH$.+0",3:+#3$14$I,-"#%): &2"%,$14$G0"3%"'$M'"##%#/$N$G3,"3+/L$O$I,-"#$K+)%/# ,+)+",&2$/,1(0$P1:0'+Q$P%3%+) R%,)3$F+#31,$$ $ $ G+&1#.$F+#31,$$$$$ $ $ J1",.$14$UQ":%#+,)$.+'+/"3+$
S(%)"$P"'"-,+)+ T1-+,31$T1&&1 P2,%)3"#$*"#$U+)
FG&@$R%,)3$F+#31,$$
F",3"$T+'"3)$91,"#3+
$
!
!"# <=>?@A'ABC<#! renewal of post-conflict transitioning districts the case Prishtina, Kosovo
.+0",3:+#3$14
,+)+",&2$/,1(0$14
V%32$+Q3+#)%*+$"))%)3"#&+$14
Kosovo s Architecture Foundation
!"#$ism !
!"# N
!$%&&'&(
A31(*1(
T+)+",&2$0",3 5&<#1V'+./+:+#3) M,+4"&+$ $ $ 5-)3,"&3
8 Z 77
1.0 Introduction$ $ W#3,1.(&3%1#$
$
*+,$-./0'12.3$ $ R,":+V1,<$ T+'+*"#&+ U32%&"'$"00,1"&2 X-Y+&3%*+)
4+,$5.267'0$"%/%'0'8%$ 7B
M,1-'+:$G3"3+:+#3$
$ 6E 6A 68 68
9+,$:'('/.#&$:'(;7%($ $ Post-conflict conditions 92+1,L$1#$0(-'%&$'%4+ Post-conflict & Dodona G(,*+L
7C
$ @7 E@ E8 86
K+)%/#$0",3
Reflection part
5.0 Design Research$
$
<+,$=28#7;()28($ $
$
7.0 Reflection$
$
M,%1,%3%+)$&1#&+03 G0"3%"'$,+[(%,+:+#3)$ G1&%1\G0"3%"'$M"33+,#) K+)%/#$&1#3+#3 K+)%/#$W#3+,*+#3%1#) G0"3%"'$W#3+/,"3%1# 5&31,) 9%:+0'"# R%#"#&%"'$)%.+ M(-'%&$.1:"%# P1#.%3%1#)$14$0(-'%&$.+)%/# R+")%-%'%3L 500'%&"-%'%3L$%#$M,%)23%#"
8A 8C 8C 8Z C! C6 7!A 7!C 7!Z 77! 777 776 776
P1#&'()%1#)$
77A
Personal Reflection
77C
$
>+,$:'?'.'8#'($ $
$
9.0 Appendices$ $
$
S%3+,"3(,+$ W#3+,*%+V)
76E 76B
],%33+#$%#3+,*%+V)$ S1&"'$)(,*+L G(,*+L$,+)('3)
76C 7@8 7EE
$
7
6
B&513D6*89*2*1(+
92%)$FG&$32+)%)$%)$32+$,+)('3$14$32+$V1,<$W$2"*+$.1#+$.(,%#/$32+$'")3$L+",$"#.$"$2"'4$14$ :L$/,".("3%1#$41,$32+$:")3+,$14$I,-"#%):$"3$32+$K+'43$I#%*+,)%3L$14$9+&2#1'1/L>$92%)$ /,".("3%1#$0,1Y+&3$)3",3+.$")$0",3$14$32+$0,1/,":$^_"00L$P%3%+)`H$&1#.(&3%#/$,+)+",&2$ 1#$32+$[("'%3L$14$(,-"#$'%4+$"#.$%3)$'%*"-%'%3L>$92%)$"%:H$V2%&2$+*+,L-1.L$%)$.+)%/#%#/$41,$ in the end, has always been in my mind. My first mentor Marta helped me a great deal %#$"..%#/$32%)$41&()$"#.$+'+:+#3$31$:L$0,1Y+&3>$I#41,3(#"3+'L$)2+$&1('.$#13$&1#3%#(+$ as my mentor but I was very satisfied with Luisa stepping in. I believe the projects de\ *+'10:+#3$14$"$#+V$0(-'%&$,+"':$"#.$"&&1:0"#L%#/$)0"&+)$41,$32+$'1&"'$010('"3%1#)$ 0(-'%&$ '%4+$ %)$ &1#3,%-(3%#/$ 31$ 32+%,$ 2"00L$ '%*%#/$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ 32+$ '",/+,$ &%3L>$ 92+$ undefined borders and aim for bold ideas gave me the opportunity to explore my per\ )1#"'$%#3+,+)3)>$91/+32+,$V%32$:L$4")&%#"3%1#$41,$32+$V1,'.$-+L1#.$32+$-1,.+,)$14$92+$ a+32+,'"#.)$W$.%)&1*+,+.$"$4"#3")3%&$0'"&+b$M,%)23%#"$%#$c1)1*1>$92%)$)3",3+.$"$Y1(,#+L$ on a topic which has a broad range and several levels of difficulties and challenges. ]%321(3$ 32+$ 2+'0$ "#.$ )(001,3$ 14$ "$ #(:-+,$ 14$ 0+10'+$ 32+$ &1:0'+3%1#$ 14$ 32%)$ 32+)%)$ V1('.$#13$2"*+$-++#$01))%-'+>$R%,)3$"#.$41,+:1)3H$W$V1('.$,+"''L$'%<+$31$32"#<$:L$:+#\ 31,)H$S(%)"$"#.$T1-+,31>$S(%)"H$"$)3(.+#3$&"##13$V%)2$41,$"$:1,+$%#)0%,%#/$"#.$01)%\ 3%*+$0+,)1#$")$:+#31,>$d1(,$+#.'+))$0"3%+#&+H$)3%:('"3%#/$V1,.)$"#.$3+Q3)$"#.$)%:%'",$ &2","&3+,$2"*+$2+'0+.$:+$"$/,+"3$.+"'>$W$210+$L1($2"*+$+#Y1L+.$"''$32+$"43+,#11#)$ .%)&())%#/$V2"3$/,+"3$32%#/)$&1('.$2"00+#$%#$&%3%+)$V%32$&,"eL$&%,&(:)3"#&+)>$T1-+,31H$ ")$:L$)+&1#.$:+#31,$41,$2"'4$14$32+$0,1Y+&3H$32"#<$L1($41,$L1(,$/11.$".*%&+H$:"<%#/$ :L$0,1Y+&3$3"#/%-'+$"#.$,+"'%)3%&$"#.$)3%:('"3%#/$:+$31$'11<$41,$:1,+$"#.$132+,$01)\ )%-%'%3%+)> Important moments were the three trips to Kosovo. Absorbing and infiltrating in the '1&"'$(,-"#$&('3(,+$"#.$)0+#.%#/$V++<)$%#$32+$&%3L$2")$-++#$32+$-+)3$3+"&2+,$"-1(3$ V2"3$"$&%3L$3,"#)%3%1#)$31$"43+,$"$V",>$92%)$+Q0+,%+#&+$&1('.$#13$2"*+$2"00+#+.$V%321(3$ the great help of PRO Planning the office for urban research and KAF the Kosovo Ar\ &2%3+&3(,+$R1(#."3%1#>$J132$&1:0"#%+)$144+,+.$:+$"$0'"&+$31$V1,<H$/"*+$:+$"&&+))$ 31$32+%,$#+3V1,<$14$0,14+))%1#"')$"#.$+Q0+,3)$%#$M,%)23%#"$"#.$+#.'+))$3"'<)$"-1(3$32+$ '%*%#/$&1#.%3%1#)$%#$32+$&%3L>$ W$V1('.$'%<+$31$/%*+$)0+&%"'$32"#<)$31$;Y1''&"H$32+$:"#L$21(,)$32"3$)2+$2+'0+.$3,"#)'"3%#/$ 32+$)(,*+L$%#$5'-"#%"#H$&1#.(&3%#/$%#3+,*%+V)$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$"#.$"%.%#/$:+$%#$ '1&"'$&1#*+,)"3%1#)>$W$V%)2$31$+Q0,+))$:L$/,+"3$"00,+&%"3%1#$31$9I$K+'43$4,%+#.)b$U*"H$ S"(,"$"#.$S%)"$41,$32+%,$:"#L$:1:+#3)$'%)3+#%#/$31$:L$0,1Y+&3H$,+&1,.%#/$&1::+#3)$ .(,%#/$0,+)+#3"3%1#)$"#.$'13)$14$2"00L$&144++)$"#.$3+")>$FL$0",+#3)$.+)+,*+$"$)0+&%"'$ thanks, supporting me during the years at university and always being there in difficult 3%:+)>$S")3H$W$":$0",3%&('",'L$/,"3+4('$41,$32+$#+*+,$+#.%#/$)(001,3$"#.$01)%3%*+$+#+,/L$ of Mitch. You have helped me every day and got me through the most difficult of times. R%#"''LH$31$"''$14$L1(b$/1$1(3$32+,+$"#.$+Q0'1,+> 921:")$;%&31,$;%#< 5:)3+,.":H$32+$a+32+,'"#.) 6!32$14$50,%'$6!78
Figure 1: Green Market, Prishtina Figure 2: Ethographic museum, Prishtina M2131)$-L$"(321,
!
@
E
<.*;0&*
]2L$c1)1*1f$5)$9%:$g(."2$h6!!Ci$.+)&,%-+)b$j%4$'1&"3%1#$%)$"''$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$0,10+,3L$32+#$ /+1/,"02L$&1(#3)$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$0+10'+$"#.$&1(#3,%+)k>$c1)1*1$%)$"$3%#L$0'"&+$%#$U(,10+$ "#.$V")$32+$&+#3+,$14$"33+#3%1#$%#$7ZZZ>$5$.+*")3"3%#/$8C$."L)$14$a59X$-1:-%#/$%#$1,.+,$31$ +#.$32+$G+,-%"#$.%&3"31,%"'$,+/%:+$"#.$%3)$01V+,4('$01)%3%1#$%#$%3)$)1(32+,#$0,1*%#&+H$c1)1*1>$5$ .%)")3,1()$+#.$14$L+",)$14$(#,+)3$":1#/$32+$c1)1*1$5'-"#%"#)$"#.$G+,-%"#$41,&+)>$J132$0",3%+)$ 2"*+$2".$32+%,$)2",+$%#$32+$(#)"4+$"#.$&,%3%&"'$)%3("3%1#$%3$2".$3(,#+.$%#31>$S11<$"3$32+$:"0$V2L$ 32%)$"''$2"00+#+.$%#$32%)$",+"$"#.$V2L$32+$W#3+,#"3%1#"'$P1::(#%3L$#++.+.$31$)3+0$%#>$c1)1*1$ "#.$32+$,+)3$14$32+$]+)3+,#$J"'<"#)$",+$&1(#3,%+)$32"3$",+$)(,,1(#.+.$-L$32+$3+,,%31,L$14$3V1$ 14$32+$:1)3$%:01,3"#3$"#.$01V+,4('$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$1#$32+$0'"#+3>$X#$+*+,L$)%.+$14$32+$,+/%1#$%3$ %)$-1,.+,+.$-L$32+$U(,10+"#$I#%1#$"#.$a59X$"#.$%#$.%,+&3$)(,,1(#.%#/)$14$T())%">$G1$")$9%:$ g(."2$h6!!Ci$V,13+$%#$2%)$-11<b$c1)1*1H$V2"3$+*+,L-1.L$#++.)$31$<#1VH$c1)1*1$"#.$%3)$.%,+&3$ )(,,1(#.%#/)$",+$#13$Y()3$)1:+$0'"&+$1(3$32+,+$%#$32+$U(,10+`)$-"&<L",.H$-(3$,"32+,$)%3("3+.$%#$ 32+$%##+,$&1(,3L",.$14$U(,10+>$a1-1.L$V"#3)$3,1(-'+$32+,+$"#L:1,+>$ !"#$%&'%()*$#+,-$.&/#0*1#,23.--,'()#$.#%*1)&)-$,20$)#$+)#4+0.-#.5#6.-.708.#,*#$+)#90:)#.5# the war in 1999. Albanians returning, Serbs fleeing, unsecure situations among minorities and enormous number of 120.000 houses either destroyed or damaged. Most significant however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a"3%1#)$G+&(,%3L$P1(#&%'$,+)1'(3%1#$76EE$V")$0",3$14$32+$.+"'$ "43+,$-",/"%#%#/$-+3V++#$32+$T())%"#)$"#.$32+$5:+,%&"#)>$X#$g(#+$7!H$7ZZZH$32+$-1:-%#/$14$ d(/1)'"*%"$+#.+.$"#.$32+$G+,-%"#$",:L$V")$,+0'"&+.$-L$32+$a59X\'+.$cRXT$41,&+$"#.$32+$#+\ V'L$&,+"3+.$I#%3+.$a"3%1#)$W#3+,%:$5.:%#%)3,"3%1#$F%))%1#$%#$c1)1*1$hIaFWci$V2%&2$&":+$1(3$ 14$32+$T+)1'(3%1#$76EE$hI#%3+.$a"3%1#)$G+&(,%3L$P1(#&%'H$7ZZZi>$92%)$".:%#%)3,"3%1#$(#%3$/"%#+.$ 32+$Y(,%).%&3%1#$%#$c1)1*1$"#.$%3$2".$31$,+-(%'.$c1)1*1>$92+$"%:$14$32+$:%))%1#$V")$31$41,:$"$ j3,"#)%3%1#"'$".:%#%)3,"3%1#$V2%'+$+)3"-'%)2%#/$"#.$1*+,)++%#/$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$0,1*%)%1#"'$ .+:1&,"3%&$)+'4\/1*+,#%#/$%#)3%3(3%1#)$31$+#)(,+$&1#.%3%1#)$41,$"$0+"&+4('$"#.$#1,:"'$'%4+$41,$"''$ %#2"-%3"#3)$14$c1)1*1k$hI#%3+.$a"3%1#)$G+&(,%3L$P1(#&%'H$7ZZZi>$$R1,:+,$0,%:+$:%#%)3+,H$5/%:$ l+<($)0+"<)$"-1(3$32+$Ia$:%))%1#H$jV+$",+$32"#<4('$41,$32+$.%44+,+#&+$32+L$:".+$%#$c1)1*1$ -+3V++#$7ZZZ$"#.$6!!C>$92+L$,+-(%'.$32%)$)1&%+3L$"#.$.%.$%3$V+''>k$R"%'%#/)$14$32+$:%))%1#$V+,+$ the illegal building, which now is a general problem in Kosovo. The importance at first seemed ):"''+,$"#.$.%.$#13$/+3$32+$"33+#3%1#$V2%&2$%3$)21('.$2"*+$/133+#>$jR1,$3V1$1,$32,++$L+",)H$#1$ 1#+$&",+.$"-1(3$32"3$-(3$#1V$%3$2")$-+&1:+$"$2"-%3$"#.$"$-%/$0,1-'+:k$)"L)$l+<(> "((#,*#0((=#0#7)&/#,*$)&)-$,*F#(.40$,.*#0*1#.5#F&)0$#,23.&$0*4)#,*#.&1)&#$.#%*1)&-$0*1#3&.4)--)-# 0*1#4.*1,$,.*-#,*#$+)#05$)&20$+#.5#0#90&;#
Figure 3: Human scale development, 1980â&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Figure 4: Mother Theresa boulevard M2131)$-L$"(321,
!
B
B/+(.0&(
Unregulated development is one of the core problems in post conflict areas. Current rebuil\ .%#/$"#.$&%3L$0'"##%#/$4"&+$3,+:+#.1()$&2"''+#/+)$,+/('"3%#/$,"0%.$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$(,-"#$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ ,+)+,*%#/$ "#.$ 0,+)+,*%#/$ )0"&+$ 41,$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#>$ 92+$ '"33+,$ 1#+$ 2")$ -++#$143+#$.%),+/",.+.$%3)$%:01,3"#&+>$W3$2")$-++#$41(#.$32"3$0(-'%&$)0"&+$"#.$)1&%"'$0'"&+)$ ",+$0",3$14$32+$-")%&$#++.)$+)0&%"''L$%#$.+*+'10%#/$&1(#3,%+)>$W#3+/,"3%#/$32"3$0(-'%&$.%:+#)%1#$ within current contexts of post conflict conditions have great challenges. Those challenges ,+'"3+.$31$)1&%"'\&('3(,"'H$01'%3%&"'H$+&1#1:%&H$+#*%,1#:+#3"'$"#.$02L)%&"'\(,-"#$&1#3+Q3)> 92%)$ 32+)%)$ 41&()+)$ 1#$ K1.1#"H$ "$ #+%/2-1,211.$ %#$ &"0%3"'$ M,%)23%#"H$ c1)1*1>$ 92+$ #+%/2-1,\ hoods urban fabric changed rapidly in the aftermath of the conflict and the limited quality )0"&+)$",+$%#$.+&"L$"#.$"44+&3$'%*"-%'%3L$14$32+$",+">$W#$1,.+,$31$.+)%/#$h)0"3%"'i$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$41,$ 32+$M(-'%&$P",0+3$K1.1#"H$A$(,-"#$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)$",+$.+*+'10+.$32"3$"%:$31$&,+"3+$)L#+,/L$ on political, social and cultural level and 25 patterns of post-conflict development are found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`)$ 0(-'%&$ #+3V1,<b$ 32+$ "*"%'"-'+$)0"&+H$+#3,+0,+#+(,"'$)0%,%3H$3,"#)%3%1#$31$&1:41,3H$,"#/+$14$.+*+'10:+#3$"#.$)&"'+>$! 92+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$%#$K1.1#"$&"#$0,1*%.+$%#3+,+)3%#/$(,-"#$0,1/,":H$&1#3,%-(3+$31$32+$(,-"#$ [("'%3L$14$32+$",+"$"#.$&,+"3+$"$#+V$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$;",%1()$#+%/2-1,211.)$"#.$32+%,$0(-'%&$ space quality are challenged by the post conflict processes. The interventions proposed in for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key words - post conflict processes, unregulated development, public space network, social .%:+#)%1#H$(,-"#$.+)%/#H$M,%)23%#"H$c1)1*1
Figure 5: Remains of war destruction M2131)$-L$"(321,
!
!""#$%&'() *$+#,-&#./(.&+0(12345(64/#%(",27#//&2$45/(4$%(434%#8&3/
EFG'@1(.38-&(,31
!""#$%&'() *$+#,-&#./(.&+0(12345(64/#%(",27#//&2$45/(4$%(434%#8&3/
THE STREET m$K.%,-#60+* W#$"$&%3L$"$)3,++3$:()3$-+$)(0,+:+>$W3$%)$32+$ first institution of the city. The street is a ,11:$-L$"/,++:+#3H$"$&1::(#%3L$,11:H$32+$ V"'')$14$h"$&%3Li$V2%&2$-+'1#/$31$32+$.1#1,)H$ .+&%&"3+.$31$32+$&%3L$41,$&1::1#$()+>$W3)$&+%\ '%#/$%)$32+$)<L>$91."LH$)3,++3)$",+$.%)%#3+,+)3+.$ :1*+:+#3)$#13$"$"''$-+'1#/%#/$31$32+$21()+)$ 32"3$4,1#3$32+:>$G1H$L1($2"*+$#1$)3,++3)>$d1($ 2"*+$,1".)H$-(3$L1($.1#`3$2"*+$)3,++3)>
EFG'@1(.38-&(,31
towards livable cities
The transition of civil unrest towards armed conflicts in the contemporary world has causes one 1,$:1,+$14$32+$41''1V%#/b$32+$+:+,/+#&+$14$#"3%1#"'%):$"#.$32+$01'%3%&"'$'+/"&%+)$14$&1'1#%"\ lism and the Cold War; unresolved cultural, religious, or ethnic conflict; the enduring presence 14$%''+/%3%:"3+H$&1,,(03H$"(321,%3",%"#$1,$,+0,+))%*+$,+/%:+)$"#.H$:1)3$%:01,3"#3'LH$0+,)%)3+#3$ %#+[("'%3%+)$1*+,$"&&+))$31$&,%3%&"'$,+)1(,&+)$hM+.+,)+#H$6!!6i>$W3$%)$"$/'1-"'$02+#1:+#1#H$"#.$ since the WWII more than 140 armed conflicts have changed lives of hundreds of thousands of people (Volume, 2010). Conflicts set in motion processes as: migration and human displace\ :+#3H$.+)3,(&3%1#$14$32+$+#*%,1#:+#3H$32+$-,+"<.1V#$14$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#)H$4":%'L$'1))$"#.$ .%),(03%1#$14$."%'L$ '%4+H$ '"&<$ 14$ )2+'3+,$ "#.$ 411.$)21,3"/+)H$ 32+$ .%):"#3'%#/$ 14$ -")%&$ )+,*%&+)$ "#.$.+)3,(&3%1#$14$32+$'1&"'$%#4,")3,(&3(,+$"''$&1#3,%-(3+$31$+Q3,+:+$41,:)$14$)(44+,%#/$"#.$.%)"\ -%'%3L$hM+.+,)+#H$6!!6i>$X#&+$32+$&%*%'$)3,(//'+$%)$1*+,H$"$0+,%1.$14$,+-(%'.%#/H$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#H$ ,+&1#&%'%"3%1#$"#.$,+#+V+.$,+)%'%+#&+$)3",3)$hG(,%H$6!7Bi>$92%)$%)$"$&,%3%&"'$0+,%1.$.(+$31$32+$4"&3$ that in 44% of all post-conflict areas war restarts in the first 5 years (World bank, 2004), and in even more than half of the situations in the first 10 years (Collier et al., 2003). In the transition 31V",.)$"$2+"'32L$&1(#3,LH$32+$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$&1::(#%3L$0'"L)$:1,+$"#.$:1,+$"#$%:01,3"#3$,1'+$ due to the relocation of the conflicts towards the global south. Main focus of organizations can -+$.%*%.+.$%#31$0+"&+-(%'.%#/H$+:+,/+#&L$2+'0$"#.$'1#/\3+,:$.+*+'10:+#3$hg(##+$N$;+,<1\ ,+#H$6!!BiH$"#.$%#$32+$+#.H$",+$"%:+.$"3$0,+*+#3%#/$4(3(,+$*%1'+#&+H$)"3%)4L$-")%&$2(:"#$#++.)$ "#.$&,+"3+$)3,(&3(,+)$32"3$0,1:13+$'1#/\3+,:$)()3"%#"-'+$/,1V32$"#.$)1&%"'$)3"-%'%3L>$92+$)%\ 3("3%1#)$ %#$ 32+)+$ &1(#3,%+)$ ",+$ %#$ #++.$ 14$ )0+&%"'$ "33+#3%1#$ V2+#$ %3$ &1:+)$ 31$ .+*+'10:+#3$ )3,"3+/%+)>$I)("'$.+*+'10:+#3$)3,"3+/%+)$h:",<+3$1,%+#3"3%1#H$'%-+,"'%e"3%1#H$0,%*"3%e"3%1#H$+3&>i$ &"##13$Y()3$-+$%:0'+:+#3+.$V%32$32+$&1#.%3%1#)$321)+$&1(#3,%+)$",+$+:+,/%#/$4,1:>$W#$/+#+\ ral, focus has been largely on restoring economy, post-conflict humanitarian help, rebuilding .+3+,%1,"3+.$(,-"#$",+")$"#.$)(001,3%#/$32+$,+#+V+.$/1*+,#:+#3)>$R+V+,$"33+#3%1#$2")$-++#$ /%*+#$31$32+$0,1&+))+)$32"3$"&&1:0"#L$"$0+,%1.$14$%#)3"-%'%3LH$%#$(,-"#$3+,:)b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
7B
HFG'<.3/6*2'%(0(*2*1(
Figure 6: Wars of the World since 1945 ;1'(:+$$F"/"e%#+$6Ab$5,&2%3+&3(,+$14$M+"&+H$ K+&+:-+,$78H$$6!7!
78
HFG'<.3/6*2'%(0(*2*1(
Figure 7: Casulties in was ,+)1(,&2b$VVV>1#+V1,'.%#."3">1,/
Post-conflict circumstances The topic of post-conflict development and processes is a complex 1#+>$ W3$ %#*1'*+)b$ ,+)31,%#/$ 32+$ /1*+,#"#&+$ )L)3+:$ 1,$ +*+#$ -(%'.$ one from scratch, the influence and support of the international &1::(#%3LH$ ,+&1#)3,(&3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ -(%'.$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ 0,1*%\ .%#/$ )2+'3+,H$ +#)(,%#/$ "3$ '+")3$ -")%&$ #++.)$ 41,$ ,+3(,#%#/$ ,+4(/++)$ "#.$32+$1#+)$32"3$)3"L+.$-+2%#.H$,+&1#&%'%"3%1#$14$32+$)1&%+3LH$32+$ 2%/2$ ,%)<$ 14$ &1,,(03%1#$ V%32$ )(..+#'L$ #+V$ 01V+,)H$ ,+)31,%#/$ 32+$ +&1#1:L$ "#.$ +:0'1L:+#3$ 1001,3(#%3%+)H$ "#.$ 32+$ )1&%+3"'$ %))(+)$ 41,:+.$32,1(/2$L+",)$14$+32#%&$"#.$#"3%1#"'%)3%&$&'")2+)>$a1#+32+\ less, even if actual open warfare has come to an end, post-conflict .+*+'10:+#3$%)$)3%''$.+"'%#/$V%32$2%/2$,%)<)$14$,+3(,#%#/$1,$&2"#/+$ 14$*%1'+#&+$"#.$(#,+)3$hg(##+$N$;+,<1,+#H$6!!Bi>$K%44+,+#3$1,/"#%\ e"3%1#)$2"*+$2".$"$*",%+3L$14$,+")1#)$31$/%*+$'%33'+$"33+#3%1#$31$32+$ problem of post-conflict development. For example, as mentioned by Gert Junne, â&#x20AC;&#x153;organizations that specialize in conflict prevention and conflict resolution have seen their hopes shattered by war and may find it too early to work with a highly-traumatized population. _(:"#%3",%"#$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$,()2$%#$-(3$",+$#+%32+,$%#3+,+)3+.$%#$32+$ causes of the conflict nor in long-term development. Development organizations see these situations as an exception and may find the )%3("3%1#$311$(#)3"-'+$31$,+)(:+$32+%,$V1,<k>
of conflict but it does not mean that it is sufficient to address the 0,1-'+:$hP1''%+,$+3$"'>H$6!!@i>$K+*+'10:+#3$)3,"3+/%+)$)21('.$'11<$ different in countries facing a high risk of conflict and have uni\ [(+$-"&</,1(#.)>$W#$"..%3%1#H$132+,$1,$+Q3,"$01'%&%+)$"#.$:+")(,+)$ 2"*+$ 31$ -+$ 3"<+#$ V2%&2$ ",+$ #1,:"''L$ #13$ 0",3$ 14$ "$ .+*+'10:+#3$ )3,"3+/L>$ M1'%&%+)$ %#*1'*%#/$ 32+$ #+V$ &1\V1,<%#/$ )L)3+:$ -+3V++#$ '1&"'$"#.$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$"#.$32+$.+)%/#$14$01'%3%&"'$%#\ )3%3(3%1#)$hP1''%+,$+3$"'>H$6!!@i>$ K+*+'10:+#3$ %)$ :1,+$ 32"#$ Y()3$ '11<%#/$ "3$ +&1#1:%&$ /,1V32H$ .+\ *+'10:+#3$%)$"-1(3$%#&,+")%#/$"#.$%:0,1*%#/$)3"#.",.$'%*%#/$"#.$ [("'%3L$ 14$ '%4+$ 14$ "''$ 0+10'+$ %#$ .+*+'10%#/$ &1(#3,%+)>$ G(&2$ .+*+\ '10:+#3$%#&'(.+$%:0,1*+:+#3)$14$2+"'32H$+.(&"3%1#H$+#*%,1#:+#3H$ 01'%3%&"'$0",3%&%0"3%1#H$/+#+,"'$V+''\-+%#/H$+[("'%3L$"#.$)1&%"'$Y()3%\ &+$hg(##+$N$;+,<1,+#H$6!!Bi>$
Post-conflict development is highly related to the planning situa\ 3%1#$14$32+$)3"3+$1,$",+">$92+$(#%[(+$)%3("3%1#$%#$32+$&1(#3,L$V2%&2$ demands a tailor-made approach to planning, makes it difficult for "$ ,+".L$ 31$ ()+$ "00,1"&2$ 31$ 0'"##%#/$ %#$ &1(#3,%+)$ +:+,/%#/$ 4,1:$ conflict (Suri, 2015). Until now, planning in the aftermath of a con\ flict does not work the way it should. A range of circumstances are causing difficulties in order to create a solid base for the planning K+*+'10:+#3$)3,"3+/%+)$/+#+,"''L$()+.$%#$"#L$&1(#3,L$",+$%#*1'*%#/$ %#)3%3(3+)b$ 32+$ &1#3+Q3H$ %3`)$ (#0,+.%&3"-%'%3LH$ 32+$ *"&((:$ 14$ /1*+,\ :",<+3$ 1,%+#3"3%1#H$ '%-+,"'%e"3%1#H$ 0,%*"3%e"3%1#H$ V2%&2$ ",+$ )+'.1:$ #"#&+H$32+$-,+"<.1V#$14$%#)3%3(3%1#)$"#.$,('+$14$'"VH$32+$%:01))%-%\ enough in the transitional countries emerging from civil conflict (cf. '%3L$14$.%"'1/(+H$32+$"-)+#&+$14$3,()3>$5''$14$321)+$",+$,+[(%,+:+#3)$ F11,+H$ 6!!!i>$ U&1#1:%&$ .+*+'10:+#3$ %)$ &+#3,"'$ %#$ 32+$ ,+.(&3%1#$ 41,$"$V1,<%#/$0'"##%#/$0,1&+))$32"3$%)$3"<%#/$&",+$14$#++.)$14$"''$
7C
2016
1992
1989
1991 ‘91-’95
2015 ‘92-’95 2008
‘94-’96 / ’99-’09
2008
1999 2001 1997
2016
Conflicts in Europe in the last 30 years
unrest and conflicts between nations and nationalities
Armed conflicts Falling apart of larger territories Not recognizing independence of Kosovo
Figure 8: Conflicts in Europe in the last 30 years
&1#&+,#+.$hG(,%H$6!7Bi>$ Another difficulty involved around planning is the long list of ac\ tors active in post-conflict situations. Where it was mainly the state which was involved in planning and rebuilding after a conflict in 32+$ 0,+*%1()$ &+#3(,LH$ 41,$ +Q":0'+$ "43+,$ 32+$ .+)3,(&3%1#$ 14$ ]]WW>$ 91."LH$%3$%)$"$0(ee'+$14$0'"L+,)$%#*1'*%#/b$32+$^%#3+,#"3%1#"'$&1::(\ #%3L`H$ Ia$ "/+#&%+)H$ .1#1,$ &1(#3,%+)H$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ anX)H$ 0,%*"3+$ &1#3,"&31,)H$ #+3V1,<)$ "#.$ "))1&%"3%1#)H$ ,+'%/%1()$ 1,/"#%e"3%1#)H$ 41(#."3%1#)$"#.$,+)+",&2+,)>$92+)+$*",%+3L$14$"&31,)$2"*+$*",%1()$ "00,1"&2+)$"#.$%.+"')$"-1(3$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#$"#.$V2%&2$"&&1,.%#/$ 31$WGXP5TM$0,+)%.+#3$G2%0,"$G(,%$.1$#13$%#&'(.+$0'"##%#/> $ Post-conflict in European context FL$0+,)1#"'$4")&%#"3%1#$31$32%)$)(-Y+&3$%)$.,%*+#$-L$"$&1#)3"#3'L$)2%4\ 3%#/$/'1-"'$"33+#3%1#$1#$.+0,%*+.$"#.$*('#+,"-'+$",+")$",1(#.$32+$ V1,'.$")$1001)+.$31$32+$#+/'+&3$"#.$%/#1,"#&+$14$)%:%'",$0'"&+)$ -(3$1*+,)2".1V+.$-L$32+)+$/'1-"'$41&()+)>$W$.1$"&<#1V'+./+$32+$ 0,1-'+:)$"#.$&2"''+#/+)$%#$/'1-"'$&%3%+)$%#$P2%#"H$W#.%"$"#.$G1(\ 32\5:+,%&"$,+/",.%#/$32+$'%*%#/$&1#.%3%1#)$14$&%3%e+#)$14$%::+#)+$ '",/+$(,-"#$",+")>$K+)0%3+$32"3$32+$%/#1,"#&+$14$.+*+'10%#/$0'"&+)$ %#$U(,10+"#$&1#3+Q3)$",+$'",/+'L$1*+,'11<+.$hn",)3<"H$6!7!i>$S%*%#/$ circumstances are not on sufficient levels at every corner of the Eu\ ropean continent mainly due to conflicts and ongoing tensions on 32+$+&1#1:%&$"#.$01'%3%&"'$'+*+'>$5V",+#+))$14$32+$)%3("3%1#$%#$32+$ aftermath of a conflict or war is required. The period after a conflict and its rehabilitation is significant to the way a nation will prosper
7Z
in the future. The falling apart of Yugoslavia with as final conflict the Kosovo War is a very recent example of conflict in the European context. Post-conflict development processes need close exami\ #"3%1#$%#$1,.+,$31$(#.+,)3"#.$)%3("3%1#)$%#$32+$"43+,:"32$14$"$V",>$ 92+$:1)3$*%)("'$1#+$%)$32+$3,"#)41,:"3%1#$'+*+'$14$32+$(,-"#$.%:+#\ )%1#>$5$*",%+3L$14$%))(+)$,+'"3+.$31$32+$,+\+)3"-'%)2:+#3$14$"$)3"3+$ &"#$ -+$ 1-)+,*+.$ %#$ 32+$ 02L)%&"'$ +#*%,1#:+#3>$ F1)3$ 0,1:%#+#3'L$ %)$ 32+$ &'")2$ 14$ 32+$ %::+#)+$ ,"0%.$ (,-"#%):$ "#.$ 32+$ '"&<%#/$ &",+$ 41,$32+$,+\+)3"-'%)2:+#3$14$)1&%"'$%#4,")3,(&3(,+>$92+$+Q%)3%#/$)1&%"'$ .%:+#)%1#H$V2%&2$2")$-++#$"$#"3(,"'$"))+3$14$)1(32+,#$&('3(,+)H$%)$ suffering when it comes to finding its renewed place within the city. Post-conflict urban processes Migration flows after the conflict accelerated a free construction -11:$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ 21()+$ "''$ 32+)+$ ,+3(,#%#/$ ,+4(/++)H$ ,(,"'\(,-"#$ :%/,"3%1#$ "#.$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ "%.$ V1,<+,)>$ ]%321(3$ "$ /11.$ /1*+,\ #"#&+$ "#.$ 0'"##%#/$ )L)3+:$ .+*+'10:+#3$ &"##13$ 0,1&++.$ ")$ "$ )L)3+:$ 32"3$ )+,*+)$ 32+$ /,+"3+,$ )1&%+3"'$ /11.)>$ W#.%*%.("'%):$ V%''$ /+3$ 32+$ (00+,$ 2"#.$ "#.$ 0(-'%&$ +'+:+#3)$ V%''$ .+&,+")+$ %#$ [("'%3L$ 1,$+*+#$+Q%)3+#&+>$W#$M,%)23%#"H$c1)1*1H$32+$.1(-'%#/$14$%3)$010(\ '"3%1#$.+:"#.+.$&1#)3,(&3%1#$V2%&2$-+&":+$32+$:"%#$+&1#1:%&$ .,%*+,$14$32+$&1(#3,L>$W#$"$3%:+$"43+,$"$V",H$32+$&1(#3,L`)$+&1#1:%&$ characteristics are evident to not fall in renewed conflicts. A viscous &%,&'+$32"3$32+$&1(#3,L$V")$%#$41,$:"#L$L+",)>$92+$01'%3%&"'$(#)3"-'+$ situation could not do something significantly in the decreasing &1#.%3%1#)$14$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"3$32"3$3%:+>$91."LH$78$L+",)$"43+,$ the conflict the situation is in need of change. Change in public
Figure 9: Destruction of War, Kosovo 1999 ,+)1(,&2b$VVV>32%#<'%#<>&1:
01'%&LH$%#.%*%.("'$:%#.)+3)H$&1::(#"'$)+#)+$"#.$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#$14$ 32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$92+$V"L$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$&2"#/+.$32+$(,-"#$ 4"-,%&H$#1V$%#*1'*+)$:"#L$&2"''+#/+)$%#$1,.+,$31$,+\+)3"-'%)2$"$'%*"\ -'+$0(-'%&$+#*%,1#:+#3> Public life and domain in post-conflict areas 92+$+'+:+#3$32"3$%)$%:01,3"#3$%#$"$&%3L$%)$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$")$ S+V%)$F(:41,.$h7Z@Ci$:+#3%1#+.$"-1(3$&%3%+)b$j5$&%3L$%)$"$)1&%"'$ %#)3%3(3%1#$-+41,+$%3$%)$"$02L)%&"'$)3,(&3(,+k>$92"3$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$%)$ 32"3$1#+$32"3$0'"L)$"#$%:01,3"#3$4"&31,$%#$"$[("'%3"3%*+$'%4+>$W3$%)$#1V$ 32+$%))(+$14$21V$)0"&+$&"#$"."03$"#.$.+"'$31$32+)+$,"0%.$3,"#)41,\ mations occurring after a conflict and facilitate the public life for a )()3"%#"-'+$)1&%"'$4(3(,+> 5&&+))$31$".+[("3+$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$-")%&$)+,*%&+)$%)$"#$+))+#3%"'$ 2(:"#$,%/23$"#.$31$+#)(,+$32+$"*"%'"-%'%3L$14$32+)+$,+)1(,&+)$V2+\ ,+*+,$-(3$)0+&%"''L$%#$.+*+'10%#/$&1(#3,%+)H$32+$%:01,3"#&+$'"L)$%#$ 0,+)+,*%#/$"#.$0,13+&3%#/$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$,11:$41,$32+$4(3(,+>$ 92%)$V")$01%#3+.$1(3$31$-+$4(#.":+#3"'$41,$[("'%3L$(,-"#$'%4+$"&&1,\ .%#/$31$a+V$d1,<$I#%*+,)%3L$M,14+))1,$M"('$T1:+,$.(,%#/$32+$a+V$ P%3%+)$G(::%3$%#$6!7E$%#$K"''")H$9+Q")> W#$ c1)1*1H$ 32+$ +)3"-'%)2:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ F(#%&%0"'$ G0"3%"'$ M'"##%#/$ G(001,3$M,1/,":$hF(GMMi$%#$6!!B$2")$-++#$V1,<%#/$1#$&"0"&%3L$ -(%'.%#/$"#.$3,"%#%#/$14$0'"##+,)$%#$32+$.%44+,+#3$:(#%&%0"'%3%+)$"#.$ F%#%)3,L$ 14$ U#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ G0"3%"'$ M'"##%#/>$ W:0'+:+#3"3%1#$ 14$ Ia\_"-%3"3$ 14$ 32+$ 1-Y+&3%*+)$ 2".$ 32+$ "%:$ 31$ 0,1:13%#/$ 32+$ &1#\ &+03$14$%#&'()%*+H$)3,"3+/%&$"#.$"&3%1#\1,%+#3"3+.$)0"3%"'$"#.$(,-"#$ 0'"##%#/$ %#$ c1)1*1H$ -+)%.+)$ 32"3$ &%*%'$ )1&%+3L$ "#.$ '1&"'$ /1*+,#\ :+#3)$",+$-+&1:%#/$"V",+$14$32+$#++.$41,$0",3%&%0"31,L$0'"##%#/$ hIa\_5JW959H$ 6!7Ei>$ X#+$ 14$ 32+%,$ 0,1Y+&3)$ V")$ j9(,#%#/$ )0"&+)$ %#31$ 0'"&+)kH$ V2%&2$ "&<#1V'+./+.$ &2"#/+)$ %#$ )1&%+3LH$ #++.$ 41,$ /,+"3+,$)()3"%#"-%'%3L$"#.$0+10'+`)$%#&,+")+.$+Q0+&3"3%1#)$%#$,+'"\ 3%1#$31$#+V$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$32"3$&,+"3+$1001,3(#%3%+)$41,$&%3%e+#)$31$ +#Y1L$)1&%"'$'%4+$1(3)%.+>$92+$0,1Y+&3`)$"%:$V")$31$%#&,+")+$"V",+\
Figure 10: Migrating refugees, Kosovo 1999 ,+)1(,&2b$VVV>#11,41(#."3%1#>&1:
#+))H$-L$321)+$V21$/1*+,#$"#.$+&1#1:%&"''L$.+*+'10$32+$0'"&+H$14$ 32+$ [("'%3L$ "#.$ %:01,3"#&+$ 14$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+$ hIa\_5JW959H$ 6!77i>$ T+)+",&2$1#$.+*+'10%#/$&1(#3,%+)$%#&,+")%#/'L$)(//+)3)$32"3$[("\ '%3L$)3,++3)$",+$+*+#$:1,+$&,%3%&"'$31$V+''\-+%#/$14$32+$011,$"#.$32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+%,$ &1::(#%3%+)H$ V21$ 143+#$ .1$ #13$ 2"*+$ )0"\ &%1()$ 21:+)$ "#.$ /",.+#)$ 31$ ,+3,+"3$ 31$ h]1,'.$ J"#<H$ 6!7Bi>$ 92%)$ [("'%3L$)3,++3)$41&()$%)$2%/2'L$,+&1::+#.+.$31$-+$%:0'+:+#3+.$-L$ 0'"##%#/$"#.$(,-"#$.+*+'10:+#3$"/+#&%+)$"#.$)21('.$)++$0(-'%&$ )0"&+$"#.$32+$)3,++3$")$"$-")%&$#++.$hIa\_5JW959H$6!7@i>$n,+"3+,$ "V",+#+))$ 14$ 32+$ %:01,3"#&+$ 14$ [("'%3L$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+)$ %)$ /,1V%#/$ -(3$%:0'+:+#3"3%1#$V%321(3$0,1Y+&3)$")$32+)+$%)$)3%''$,",+>$U))+#3%"'$ ",+$%.+")$41,$32+$.+#)+$#+%/2-1,211.)$32"3$V+,+$"44+&3+.$32+$:1)3$ V%32$32+$(#,+/('"3+.$.+*+'10:+#3$"43+,$32+$V",> %&'$@.267'0$(%/%'0'8% Post-conflict individual development processes and city planning &%,&(:)3"#&+)$2"*+$&2"#/+.$32+$(,-"#$4"-,%&$14$",+")$%#$M,%)23%#"$ .,")3%&"''L>$ ]%32$ "$ 313"'$ #+/'+&3$ 31$ 32+$ )1&%"'$ .1:"%#$ "#.$ 0(-'%&$ '%4+H$ "#$ +))+#3%"'$ +'+:+#3$ %#$ (,-"#$ +#*%,1#:+#3"'$ 0,1)0+,%3L$ "#.$ "#$%:01,3"#3$%#/,+.%+#3$%#$32+$)1&%+3L`)$%#3+,"&3%1#H$&1::(#%&"3%1#$ "#.$ &12+)%1#>$ a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in the society is showing difficulties economic, environmental, so\ &%+3"'$ "#.$ &('3(,"'$ .%:+#)%1#)>$ W#$ 32"3$ )+#)+H$ c1)1*1$ %)$ )21V%#/$ &2","&3+,%)3%&)$14$"$.+*+'10%#/$&1(#3,L$%#$32+$32+:+$14$0(-'%&$'%4+H$ "V",+#+))$14$32+$[("'%3L$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$0'"&+$-,%#/$31$32+$(,-"#$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ /11.$ 0(-'%&$ 01'%&%+)$ "#.$ 0'"##%#/$ .+&%)%1#)$ %#$ ,+)+,*%#/$"#.$:"%#3"%#%#/$0(-'%&$/11.)>$ Figure 11: Kosovo in numbers
6!
Disrupted daily lifes and urban conditions in Kosovo in 1999
1.45 mil
848.100 760.000 350.000
250.000
United States Institute of Peace, 1999 United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees UNHCR, 1999 Municipality of Prishtina, 2015
50.000
`Estimated illigal buildings in Prishtina
25.000
Homeless refugees
Uninhabitable homes
Severly damaged homes
Returned Kosovars 1999
Total displaced people
Fled Refugees after bombing by NATO
Fled Refugees since 1998 war started
100.000
IFG'<.3J*&('K.02*D3.5
6@
IFG'<.3J*&('K.02*D3.5
!/)8$:'('/.#&$A;'(%)28 _1V$&"#$)0"3%"'$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$%:0,1*+$32+$[("'%3L$14$'%*%#/$%#$01)3$ conflict Dodona and how could those contribute to a cohesive )1&%1\)0"3%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3> (;6$.'('/.#&$B;'(%)28( 01. What is post-conflict development in Prishtina and how can 0(-'%&$01'%&%+)$,+"&3$1#$32"3f !6>$]2"3$+44+&3)$0(-'%&$'%4+f !@>$ ]2%&2$ ",+$ 32+$ )1&%"'\)0"3%"'$ ")0+&3)$ 32"3$ &2","&3+,%e+$ Post-Conflict Dodona? !E>$]2"3$",+$32+$)1&%"'\)0"3%"'$[("'%3%+)$"#.$013+#3%"')$14$M1)3\&1#\ flict Dodona? !B>$_1V$%)$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3$+*"'(+3+.$-L$32+$010('"3%1#f !A>$_1V$&"#$V+$.+)%/#$h)0"3%"'i$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$32"3$4"&%'%3"3+$0(-'%&$ life and serve the larger urban system in post-conflict Dodona? !8>$_1V$&"#$V+$"00'L$32+$1(3&1:+$14$32+$.+)%/#$31$132+,$01)3$ conflict situations?
3.1 RESEARCH APPROACH :"00%#/$"#.$."3"$"#"'L)%)H$1-)+,*"3%1#H$&1(#3%#/$"#.$3,"&<%#/>
The research approach has formed itself during the project. In: part A: exploration study G(-$[(+)3%1#)$1#+$N$3V1$&"#$-+$"#)V+,+.$32,1(/2$"$&1:-%#"3%1#$ 14$3+&2#%[(+)$32"3$41,:$"$&12+)%*+$)3(.L>$JL$'%3+,"3(,+$)3(.LH$%#3+,\ *%+V%#/$'1&"'$0,14+))%1#"')H$0,+41,:$1-)+,*"3%1#)$"#.$&1''+&3%#/$ :"0)$ "#.$ ."3"H$ "$ &1:0'+3+$ 0%&3(,+$ &"#$ -+$ 41,:+.>$ 92+$ "%:$ %)$ to create insights: to identify, define and illustrate relevant phe\ nomena, to explain specific characteristics and effects and (inter) relationships. Besides that, it defines the measures that need to -+$ 3"<+#$ V2%&2$ V%''$ -+$ )0"3%"''L$ "..,+))+.$ %#$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$"$.+)%/#>$5#$2L0132+)%)$%)$41,:+.$32"3$V%''$-+$()+.$31$.+*+\ '10$"$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$.+)%/#>$92+$3+&2#%[(+)$()+.$31$"#)V+,$)(-$ ,+)+",&2$[(+)3%1#)$1#+$N$3V1$",+$"$'%3+,"3(,+$)3(.LH$%#3+,*%+V%#/H$ :"00%#/$"#.$."3"$"#"'L)%)>
part C: development of a public domain design for Dodona G(-$[(+)3%1#$)%Q$&"#$-+$"#)V+,+.$-L$.+)%/#$,+)+",&2>$92+$1(3\ &1:+)$14$0",3$5b$32+$:+")(,+)$%#$32+$41,:$14$32+:+)$#++.$31$-+$ 3,"#)'"3+.$%#31$"#$)0"3%"'$"/+#.">$92+$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$"#"'L)%)$0,1*%\ .+)$32+$013+#3%"')$"#.$[("'%3%+)$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$P1:-%#%#/$ these will lead to a post-conflict design strategy, the priorities &1#&+03>$ 92%)$ V%''$ +*+#3("''L$ 01)%3%1#$ 32+$ )0"3%"'$ "/+#."$ 31$ 32+$ )1&%1\)0"3%"'$/,1(#.$%#$1,.+,$31$.+*+'10$"$.+)%/#>$92+$3+&2#%[(+)$ ()+.$31$"#)V+,$)(-$,+)+",&2$[(+)3%1#$)%Q$",+$%#3+,*%+V%#/H$.+)%/#H$ )%:('"3%#/$"#.$3+)3%#/> part D: reflecting and concluding. G(-$[(+)3%1#$)+*+#$&"#$'+".$31V",.)$4(,32+,$,+)+",&2$"#.$32+$"0\ 0'%&"-%'%3L$14$32+$0,1Y+&3$1(3&1:+)$"#.$01))%-'+$.+)%/#>$W3$%)$32+$ :1:+#3$32"3$%:0,1*+:+#3)$14$32+$0,1Y+&3$V%''$-+$2%/2'%/23+.$"#.$ :%))%#/$'%#<)$&"#$-+$"..,+))+.>$J+)%.+)$32"3H$%3$%)$V1,32$31$&2+&<$ 32+$0,1Y+&3)$1(3&1:+)$32"3$&"#$"..,+))$)%:%'",$0,1-'+:)$"#.$&2"'\ lenges in the field of public life and post-conflict processes. The techniques used to answer sub research question seven are reflec\ 3%#/$"#.$&1#&'(.%#/>
part B: analyzing Dodona on life - form - performance Sub questions three, four & five are answered through a method 32"3$41&()+)$1#$32+$,+'"3%1#)2%0)$-+3V++#$32+$)1&%"'$'%4+H$)0"3%"'$+#\ *%,1#:+#3$"#.$32+$'1&"'$+*"'("3+.$0+,41,:"#&+$14$32+$)1&%1\)0"\ 3%"'$ &1#.%3%1#)>$ 92+$ "#"'L)%)$ 14$ 32+$ '%4+$ "#.$ 32+$ 41,:$ &1:-%#+.$ ,+)('3$%#$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$[("'%3%+)$"#.$013+#3%"')$32"3$&"#$-+$()+.$%#$ 32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$.+)%/#>$92+$)(,*+L$%)$:"<%#/$&1#3"&3$V%32$ 32+$010('"3%1#$%#$1,.+,$31$.+*+'10$"$.+)%/#$32"3$3"<+)$&",+$14$32+$ ,+[(%,+:+#3)$14$32+$)1&%+3L>$92+$3+&2#%[(+)$()+.$31$"#)V+,$)(-$ research question three, four and five are interviewing and survey,
6E
01. What is post-conflict development in Prishtina and how can public policies react on that?
spatial requirements
02. What effects public life?
spatial requirements
03. Which are the social-spatial aspects that characterize Post-Conflict Dodona? 04. What are the social-spatial qualities and potentials of Post-conflict Dodona?
06. How can we design (spatial) interventions that facilitate public life and serve the larger urban system in post-conflict Prishtina?
spatial requirements
05. How is the urban environment evalueted by the population?
spatial requirements
Figure 12: Project Research Framework
6B
07. How can we apply the outcome of the design to other post conflict situations?
Fig. 12 Raising awareness of the conditions of public space in Kosovo. G1(,&+b$M+,%1.%&"'$:+/"e%#$c1)1*1$6>!H$W))(+$DBH$6!7@
Fig. 13 Symposium with international speakers about challenges and proC blems in post-conflict development Source: http://isocarp.org/post-conflict-planning-inclusive-resilient-cities/
3.2 RELEVANCE 5)$ +)3%:"3+.$ -L$ 32+$ ]_X$ h6!7AiH$ (,-"#$ 010('"3%1#$ V%''$ /,1V$ 31$ :1,+$32"#$B!o$%#$'+))$.+*+'10+.$&1(#3,%+)>$92%)$%)$+)0+&%"''L$+:+,\ /%#/$ %#$ c1)1*1$ V2+,+$ ,(,"'$ 0,1)0+&3)$ ",+$ &1#)%.+,"-'L$ '1V+,$ ")$ opposed to urban centers. The influx of people since the war has densified central neighborhoods unregulated and decreased the ratio of build to open space. Prishtina shows difficulties that an (,-"#$",+"$4"&+)$%#$32+$"43+,:"32$14$"$V",H$%4$+:02")%)$1#$32+$%:\ 01,3"#&+$14$)1&%+3"'$,+-(%'.%#/$%)$'"&<%#/>$92%)$%)$,+'+*"#3$31."L$V%32$ conflicts around the globe that soon will start rebuilding. social relevance$ \$ W#$ 32%)$ 0,1Y+&3$ 32+$ 02L)%&"'$ %))(+)$ "#.$ +32%&"'$ .%:+#)%1#$",+$*+,L$,+'"3+.$31$32+$)1&%+3"'$,+'+*"#&+>$92+$32,++$",+$ "44+&3%#/$+"&2$132+,>$92+$+44+&3)$14$(#,+/('"3+.$01)3\V",$.+*+'10\ :+#3H$ )0"3%"''L$ %#$ .+#)+$ 010('"3+.$ ",+")H$ ",+$ "44+&3%#/$ 32+$ '%*%#/$ &1#.%3%1#)$14$",+")>$5,1(#.$8Bo$h;p&<'+,H$6!!Ci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and the public domain is influencing the social life of the city. It is +*+#$#+&+))",L$31$#13+H$32"3$(#,+/('"3+.$.+*+'10:+#3$"44+&3)$32+$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ %#$ 0",3%&('",$ 32+$ 2+"'32$ %))(+$ ")$ ,+'"3+.$ 31$ 32+$ 2(:"#$-+%#/)>$92+$.+&,+")+$14$32+$)1&%"'$'%4+$&"#$'+".$31$%)1'"3%\ 1#$"#.$4++'%#/)$14$+Q&'()%1#>$JL$&,+"3%#/$(,-"#$&1#.%3%1#)H$V2%&2$ "."03$31$32+$0,%1,%3%+)$14$.+#)+$#+%/2-1,211.)$%#$"$3,"#)%3%1#$)1&%\ +3LH$#+V$%#4,")3,(&3(,+)$41,$32+$)1&%"'H$)()3"%#"-'+$"#.$2+"'32L$'%*%#/$ +#*%,1#:+#3$&"#$%#&,+")+$&%3L$'%4+> scientific relevance$\$I,-"#$0'"##%#/$%#$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#$14$01)3\&1#\
6A
flict situations has to put emphasis to its strategic and systematic V"L$14$%3)$()"/+H$%#$1,.+,$31$0'"L$"$,1'+$%#$32+$,+-(%'.%#/$"#.$,+\ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ )1&%+3L$ hn",)3<"H$ 6!7!q$ G(,%H$ 6!7Bi>$ 92"3$ ,1'+$ &"#$ 3"<+$ 0",3$ %#$ -(%'.%#/$ 0+"&+4('H$ ,+)%'%+#3H$ %#&'()%*+$ "#.$ ,+&1#\ ciling societies. In recent Post-conflict urban planning theory an %:01,3"#3$,+41&()$%)$)++#$31V",.)$,+-(%'.%#/$&%*%'$)1&%+3LH$32,1(/2$ 32+$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#H$-(%'.%#/H$"#.$(,-"#$0'"##%#/$14$32+$-(%'.$+#\ *%,1#:+#3$ hP2",'+)V1,32H$ 6!!8i>$ 92+$ (#.+,)3"#.%#/$ 14$ 32+$ (,-"#$ #",,"3%*+)H$)++%#/$&,%3%&"'$%))(+)$%#$32+$)1&%"'$'"#.)&"0+$"#.$-+%#/$ "V",+$14$+Q%)3%#/$4,()3,"3%1#)$14$32+$0")3H$",+$<+L$+'+:+#3)$31$3"<+$ in consideration after a conflict (Bevan, 2006; Ghandour, 2002 as &%3+.$%#$P2",'+)V1,32H$6!!8q$]11.)H$7ZZ8i>$92%)$0,1Y+&3$32+,+41,+$ 3+#.)$ 31$ +Q0'1,+$ 32+$ "'3+,+.$ (,-"#$ '"#.)&"0+$ "43+,$ 32+$ V",$ "#.$ 1-)+,*+$32+$)1&%"'$'"#.)&"0+H$%#$1,.+,$31$/"%#$#+V$<#1V'+./+$14$ )1&%"'$"#.$)0"3%"'$.,%*+,)$14$32+$(,-"#$",+">$5$-+33+,$(#.+,)3"#.%#/$ of post conflict processes and experimental methodology can lead 31$#+V$01))%-%'%3%+)$%#$32+$3,"#)%3%1#"'$'"#.)&"0+>
3.3 ETHICAL DIMENSION 92+$4(#&3%1#$14$32%)$0","/,"02$%)$31$.%)&'1)+$32+$#+&+))",L$&1#&+,#$ 41,$*"'(+)$"#.$#1,:)$,+'"3+.$31$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$92+$1-Y+&3%*+$%)$ 32+$+Q0'1,"3%1#$14$+32%&)$",1(#.$0(-'%&$)0"&+$r$32+$*"'(+$"#.$:1,"'$ status of our behavior and the position as urbanists in this field. The :"%#$41&()$V%''$-+$1#$32+$&1#3+:01,",L$:1,"'$)3"3()$14$32+$'1&"'%\ 3%+)$31V",.)$0(-'%&$)0"&+$"#.$%3)$&1#)+[(+#&+)> 92+$ +32%&)$ %#*1'*+.$ ",1(#.$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+$ ",+$ &1:0'+Q$ )L)3+:)$ V%32$"$*",%+3L$14$"&31,)H$&('3(,+$"#.$2%)31,%&"'$-"&</,1(#.)>$W#$32%)$ 0",3%&('",$ &1#3+Q3H$ 32+$ 1#+$ 14$ "$ .+#)+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ .+*+'10+.$ unregulated, the multiple bodies that share a confined physical )0"&+$ 41,:$ "$ )1&%"'$ +321)>$ M,14+))1,$ 14$ n+1/,"02LH$ 5)2$ 5:%#$ h6!!Ci$",/(+)$32"3$32+$)%3("3%1#$14$:('3%0'%&%3L$1,$)(,0'()$14$2(:"#)$ "#.$32+,+41,+H$"&3%1#)$"#.$:1*+:+#3)H$%#$"$'%:%3+.$)0"&+H$0,1.(\ &+$)1&%"'$+44+&3)>$G(,0'()$%#$32%)$)+#)+$:+"#)$32+$.%44+,+#3$()+)$14$
Fig. 14 Poor quality public domain in neighborhoods G1(,&+b$02131/,"02$-L$"(321,
Fig. 15 Quality spaces are limited to the center G1(,&+b$02131/,"02$-L$"(321,
.%44+,+#3$"&3"#3)$)0"&+H$V2%&2$&2"#/+)$&1#)3"#3'L>$T+'"3+.$31$32+$ context, the unclear policies and official rules, make this space an +*+#$:1,+$&1:0'+Q$)L)3+:>$W3)$)(,0'()$%#$)0"&+$r$32+$'1&"'%e"3%1#$ "#.$ +Q0+,%+#&+$ 14$ 32"3$ 0'"&+H$ %)$ -+)%.+)$ ):"''$ %:0"&3)$ 1#$ (,-"#$ 0(-'%&$&('3(,+$"$V21'+$)L)3+:$14$,2L32:)$14$%#*+#3%1#H$1,.+,$"#.$ &1#3,1'$ /+#+,"3+.$ -L$ :('3%0'%&%3L$ h5:%#H$ 6!!Ci>$ 92%)$ *%+V$ 14$ 5)2$ 5:%#$%#$,+'"3%1#$31$+32%&)H$%)$&1:%#/$4,1:$V,%3%#/)$14$0,"/:"3%)3)$")$ ]%''%":$g":+)$h6!!@i$"#.$32+1,%)3$14$0'(,"'%):$+Q0'1,%#/$32+$,+'"\ 3%1#"'$.L#":%&)$"#.$)+'4\,+/('"3%#/$0,10+,3%+)$14$&1:0'+Q$)L)3+:)$ hP1##1''LH$6!!Bq$K+'"#."H$6!!!H$6!!Ai>$_+$01%#3)$1(3$32"3$+32%&"'$ ()+)$"#.$"&3%*%3%+)$%#$0(-'%&$)0"&+$"00+",$^0,+\&1/#%3%*+'L$"#.$,+\ flexively rather than rational or consciously, guided by routines of #+(,1'1/%&"'$,+)01#)+$"#.$:"3+,%"'$0,"&3%&+H$,"32+,$32"#$-L$"&3)$14$ 2(:"#$ V%''`>$ W3)$ :%Q3(,+$ 14$ 32+$ &,1V.H$ 32+$ 2"00+#%#/)H$ 4(#&3%1#"'$ %#3+,0,+3"3%1#H$%3)$'%*"-%'%3L$"#.$*%3"'%3L$31/+32+,$",+$"$&1#)3,"%#+.$ /,1(0$14$"&3%1#$"#.$1,%+#3"3%1#$h5:%#H$6!!Ci>$5$&1#)3"#3$#+/13%"\ 3%1#$14$32+$)0"&+$%#$,+'"3%1#$31$132+,)$"#.$32+$%#.%*%.("'%):$%)$0",3$ 14$32%)$+32%&"'$.%:+#)%1#H$V2%&2$%)$.1:%#"3%#/$"#.$&1#3,1''%#/$32+$ 0(-'%&$)0"&+>$F1,"'$)3"#.",.)$"#.$*"'(+)$",+$(#.1(-3+.'L$%#4+&3+.$ by ethical influences originated from the past of citizens living the\ ,+>$92+$)1&%"'$+32%&)H$%3)$&1#)&%1()#+))$14$#++.$"#.$1,%+#3"3%1#$31$ 32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$%#$1,.+,$31$'%*+$31/+32+,$%)$"$0,1&+))$%#*1'*%#/$ "''$ "&3"#3)>$ 5&&1,.%#/$ 31$ 5:%#$ h6!!CiH$ 32+$ :%Q3(,+$ 14$ 32+$ &,1V.$ /+#+,"3+)$^)1&%"'$0"321'1/%+)$14$"*1%."#&+H$)+'4\0,+)+,*"3%1#H$%#31\ '+,"#&+$"#.$2",:`$0",3%&('",'L$%4$.%*+,)%3L$14$01V+,$"#.$+Q&'()%1#$%)$ 0'"L%#/$0",3$%#$32+$)0"&+>
-%'%3L$":1#/$32+$&%3%e+#)H$31V",.)$32+$)3,++3$V")$"$0",3$14$32+$."%'L$ '%*+)>$ I#V,%33+#$ ,('+)$ V+,+$ "'%*+$ ,+/",.%#/$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+$ ")$ "$ )0"&+$14$+*+,L1#+$"#.$&%3%e+#)$311<$&",+$14$%3>$92%)$&1#3%#(+.$%#$"$ '",/+$0",3$14$32+$6!32$&+#3(,L>$]%32$32+$&2"#/+$%#$)L)3+:H$32+$:(#%\ &%0"'%3L$-+&":+$,+)01#)%-'+$41,$32+$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$)3,++3)>$92+$ 0(-'%&$%)$#13$32+$0(-'%&$"#L:1,+$41,$&+,3"%#$#"3%1#"'%3%+)>$5$,+Y+&3%\ 1#$1,$+Q&'()%1#$14$"$/,1(0$14$0+10'+$-L$"$01V+,$32"3$%)$)(..+#'L$ 3,"#)41,:%#/$32+$0(-'%&$%#31$0,%*"3+>$5$.+&"L$%#$4,++.1:$%#$"$-")%&$ 41,:q$#13$"'1(.$"#L:1,+$31$"&3$"#.$()+$%#$32+$0(-'%&>$X*+,$3%:+H$ the value of public spaces becomes insignificant if you cannot take 0",3$%#$%3$"#.$32+$:1,"'$)3"#.",.)$3(,#$%#31$#+/"3%*+$1#+)$-+&"(\ )+$32+$0(-'%&$%#$32%)$&")+$,+0,+)+#3)$32+$+#+:L>$92%)$+Q0+,%+#&+H$ V2%&2$2")$-++#$"V4('$2")$&1#3%#(+.$(#3%'$31."LH$321(/2$32+$)L)3+:$ &2"#/+.$"#.$32+$0(-'%&$%)$0(-'%&$"/"%#>$W3$%)$32+$,+%#*+#3%1#$14$32+$ 0(-'%&$31$)+,*+$")$0(-'%&$41,$+*+,L1#+>
3.4 OBJECTIVES
92+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ 0,1Y+&3$ %)$ "%:%#/$ 31$ 0,1*%.+$ %#\ sights in conditions, processes and challenges that signifies post conflict situations. Important is the good understanding of the situ\ ation. Research of other post conflict areas is useful but the context :"<+)$32+$)%3("3%1#$(#%[(+>$W#$32"3$&")+H$#13$"''$/+#+,"'$)3,"3+/%+)$ "#.$"00,1"&2+)$&"#$-+$()+.>$5$3"%'1,\:".+$.+)%/#$0,1Y+&3$V%''$-+$ 32+$ /1"'$ 14$ 32+$ 0,1Y+&3>$ W3$ V%''$ )+",&2$ 41,$ )1'(3%1#)$ 41,$ 32+$ '%:%3+.$ )0"&+H$ /1*+,#:+#3"'$ "00,1"&2H$ )1&%1\)0"3%"'$ &1#.%3%1#)$ "#.$ /"0$ W#$1,.+,$31$0,1&++.$"#.$41,:$"$0,+&%)+$10%#%1#$"-1(3$+32%&)$14$0(\ %#$32+$0(-'%&$\$0,%*"3+$,+'"3%1#)2%0>$W3$"%:)$31$%#3+/,"3+$"$,+#+V+.$ blic space, local definition is in order. During interviews with rese\ 0(-'%&$)0"&+$#+3V1,<$32"3$144+,)$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$[("'%3L$0'"&+)$ archers in the field of urban planning and urban sociology, a better "#.$ +#&1(,"/+)$ 32+$ '1&"'$ )1&%+3L$ 31$ -+$ "&3%*+$ "#.$ 0",3%&%0"3+$ %#$ (#.+,)3"#.%#/$14$32+$)%3("3%1#$&"#$-+$&1:01)+.>$ 32"3$#+V$.1:"%#>$W3$%)$"-1(3$3"<%#/$&",+H$-+$"&3%*+$"#.$)21V$3,"#)\ 0",+#&L$ %#$ .1%#/$ V2%&2$ &"#$ ,+)('3$ %#$ "#$ %#&,+")+.$ )+#)+$ 14$ &%3%\ 92+$&1#3+:01,",L$,+'"3%1#$31$0(-'%&$)0"&+$2")$&2"#/+.$1*+,$3%:+>$ e+#)2%0$"#.$,+)31,+.$,+'"3%1#)2%0)>$92+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$.+)%/#$ F1,"'$ )3"#.",.)$ "#.$ "00,10,%"3+$ -+2"*%1,$ 31V",.)$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+$ &"#$%#$32+$+#.$-+$+*"'("3+.$"-1(3$%3)$()+4('#+))$%#$132+,$)%3("3%1#)>$ "#.$'%4+$V+,+$&1::1#$%#$32+$X331:"#$0+,%1.>$5$/+#+,"'$,+)01#)%\
68
!"#$%#$
LFG'C*+*0.&)'C*+-6(+
6Z
Map of Europe
Kosovoâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s location in the southern Balkan
Kosovo with mostly Albanians Recognizing independence of Kosovo Not recognizing independence of Kosovo Figure 16: Kosovo
@!
LFG'C*+*0.&)'C*+-6(+
Bu
75
%
lg
Illy
ria
ns
&
Da
Ro
M
rd a
m
ni
an
s
an
oe
em
sia
pi
re
4th c. BC.
160 BC.
Bu
lg
Su
pe
rio
ar
By ian
za
em
pi
r
0
87
re
nt
Se ine
O
tto
rb
em
em
pi
pi
re
850
ian
1018
re
ian
nd
in
em
pi
re
1346
1455
ce
Se
Au
to
rb
sa
pr ov
m
an
ar
of
ia
Au
an
str o-
d
Se
Hu
rb
ia
Ki
ng
25
ng
%
ar
M
on
ian
s
1912
serbs majority
te
do
Re
ne
gr o
1914
m
pu
of
Yu g
os
1918
bl
ic
lav
Al ia
no
of
ba
m
ou
Yu g
ni
a
sp
os
1929
Se
ro v
lav
ia
in
ce
rb
in
Yu g
ia
1941 1945
os
UN
-a
&
M
lav
on
ia
te
Ko
dm
so
in
ne
gr o
1974
ist
ra
vo
tio
n
1989
in
de
pe
nd
en
1999
ce
2008
albanians majority serbian re-colonisation
Figure 17: Kosovo timeline
4.1 POST CONFLICT CONDITIONS V%321(3$ '(&<>$ 543+,$ 32+$ :(,.+,$ 14$ R,"#e$ R+,.%#"#3$ %#$ #+%/2-1\ ,%#/$G","Y"*1$,+)('3+.$%#$32+$]]WH$c1)1*1$3+,,%31,L$V")$&'1)+$31$ the center of the conflict and got hit severely in the war. In the +#.$32+$-%,32$14$d(/1)'"*%"$")$"$#+V$c%#/.1:$%#&'(.%#/$G+,-%"H$ F1#3+#+/,1H$ J1)#%"H$ P,1"3%"H$ G'1*+#%"$ "#.$ F"&+.1#%"$ :".+$ c1)1*1$0",3$14$32+$G+,-%"#$)3"3+>$c1)1*1$,+:"%#+.$0",3$14$G+,\ -%"$")$"$0,1*%#&+$%#$32+$0+,%1.$14$d(/1)'"*%"$(#3%'$%#$7Z8E$32+$ 0,1*%#&+$V")$/,"#3+.$"(31#1:L$"#.$)3",3+.$31$2"*+$"$*1%&+$1#$ 4+.+,"'$'+*+'>$S"3+,H$V%32$32+$d(/1)'"*%"#$V",)$"#.$32+$4"''$14$32+$ 4+.+,"3%1#$%#31$)+0","3+$&1(#3,%+)H$G+,-%"$3"<+)$c1)1*1$"#.$%3)$ '+".+,$F%'1)+*%&$.%&3"3+)$32+$#"3%1#>$92+$)%3("3%1#$14$32+$5'-"\ #%"#)$'%*%#/$%#$c1)1*1$V1,)+#+.$"#.$%#$32+$L+",)$-+41,+$32+$V",$ %#$7ZZZ$)+*+,"'$/,1(0)$14$c1)1*1\5'-"#%"#)$+:+,/+.$"#.$'+.$ 31$32+$41(#.%#/$14$32+$c1)1*1$S%-+,"3%1#$5,:LH$32+$I)23,%"$l'%\ ,%:3",+$+$c1)1*s)$hIPci>$]%32$32+%,$'%:%3+.$&"0"&%3LH$32+L$3,%+.$ 31$.,+V$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$"33+#3%1#$31$32+$)%3("3%1#$14$5'-"#%"#)$%#$ Kosovo. The intensity of unrest and small conflicts worsened, .+)0%3+$ 14$ )3,1#/$ +441,3)$ 14$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ 1,/"#%e"3%1#)>$ 5)$ 14$ 1998, the conflicts became a military struggle and with it the .+3+,%1,"3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ '%*%#/$ &1#.%3%1#)$ 14$ 32+$ &%*%'%"#$ 010('"3%\ 1#>$92+$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$&1::(#%3L$"#.$32+$a59XH$%#3+,*+#+.$-L$ "33+:03%#/$32+$0",3%+)$31$#+/13%"3+$-L$32,+"3$14$:%'%3",L$%#3+,\ *+#3%1#>$]2+#$32+$T":-1(%''+3$"/,++:+#3$V")$,+Y+&3+.$-L$32+$ G+,-)$ %#$ F",&2$ 7ZZZH$ 32+$ "33"&<$ 14$ 32+$ a59X$ 1#$ 32+$ G+,-%"#$ 01V+,)$)++:+.$32+$1#'L$V"L$1(3>$]%321(3$4(''$(#.+,)3"#.%#/$14$ 32+$2%)31,L$32+$7ZZZ$&'")2$V")$"$.%)"/,++:+#3$"-1(3$31$V21:$ c1)1*1$3+,,%31,L$-+'1#/)$31>$
Preceding the conflict \$W#$1,.+,$31$(#.+,)3"#.$V2"3$0,+'(.+.$ 32+$ *%1'+#3$ &'")2$ -+3V++#$ 3V1$ #"3%1#)$ %#$ 7ZZZ$ V2%&2$ '+.$ 31$ "$ V",$1*+,$32+$,+/%1#$-132$#"3%1#)$)2",+.$%#$G1(32\U")3+,#$U(,1\ 0+H$"$)21,3$2%)31,%&"'$1*+,*%+V$&"#$0,1*%.+$32+$#+&+))",L$%#41,\ :"3%1#>$J132$)%.+)H$G+,-)$"#.$5'-"#%"#)$&1#)%.+,$32+$c1)1*1$ /,1(#.)$31$-+$32+$1,%/%#$14$32+%,$#"3%1#"'$%.+#3%3L>$92+)+$*%+V)$ 1#$-132$1,%/%#)$."3+$-"&<$31$32+$+",'L$E32$&+#3(,L$JP$"#.$7632$ &+#3(,L>$ 5'-"#%"#$ #"3%1#"'%)3)$ &1#)%.+,$ 32+%,$ .+)&+#3$ 4,1:$ 32+$ W''L,%"#)$ "#.$ 32+%,$ '1&"3%1#$ 14$ '%*%#/$ %#$ 32+$ E32$ &+#3(,L$ JP>$ 1#$ 31."L`)$c1)1*1$/,1(#.)>$U*+#3("''LH$:+#3%1#+.$")$5'-"#%"#)$%#$ 32+$7632$&+#3(,LH$-(3$32+%,$+Q"&3$0'"&+$14$1,%/%#$%)$)3%''$.%)0(3+.>$ R,1:$32+$01%#3$14$*%+V$14$32+$G+,-%"#$#"3%1#"'%)3)H$c1)1*1$3+,,%\ 31,L$%)$)++#$")$32+$-%,320'"&+$14$32+%,$X,321.1Q$P2(,&2$"#.$32+$ :+.%+*"'$ G+,-%"#$ )3"3+>$ _%)31,%&"'$ :1#")3+,%+)$ "#.$ 1,321.1Q$ churches, such as the Gračanica Monastery, Patriarchate of Peć and Visoki Dečani dating back as earliest as the 12th and 13th &+#3(,L$",+$)++#$")$%:01,3"#3$-(%'.%#/)$%#$32+$G+,-%"#$X,321\ dox Church. It comes down to an complex and difficult histo\ ,L$ -+3V++#$ 32+$ 3V1$ #"3%1#"'%)3)$ 41,$ "$ 4(''$ (#.+,)3"#.%#/>$ ]2L$ .%.$%3$'")3+.$(#3%'$32+$7ZZ!)$-+41,+$%3$,+)('3+.$%#31$32+$c1)1*1$ ]",>$92%)$%)$-+&"()+$%#$2%)31,L$32+$3+,,%31,L$14$c1)1*1$2")$-++#$ 1&&(0%+.$-L$"$*",%+3L$14$#"3%1#)>$5)$+",'%+)3$-+%#/$0",3$14$32+$ W''L,%"#)$"#.$K",."#%"#)H$32+#$32+$JLe"#3%#+$+:0%,+$,('+.$1*+,$ 32+$",+"H$"43+,$32"3$G'"*%&$:%/,"3%1#)$4,1:$32+$#1,32$)+33'+.$%#$ c1)1*1$"#.$F+312%Y">$J132$)31,%+)$14$32+$5'-"#%"#)$"#.$G+,-)$ ",+$+*+#$:1,+$.%)0(3+.$V2+#$32+$-L$32+$-"33'+$14$32+$-'"&<-%,.$ field against the Turks in 1389. The Ottoman empire ruled over 32+$",+"$41,$B!!$L+",)$"#.$'+43$"$,%&2$:",<$1#$32+$",+">$J+)%.+)$ 1,321.1Q$ &2(,&2+)$ 32+$ ",+"$ %)$ :"%#'L$ .1:%#"3+.$ -L$ F1)[(+)$ "#.$:1)3$%#2"-%3"#3)$",+$F()'%:>$92+$M+,%1.$14$32+$6!32$&+#3(\ ry is marked by extensive conflicts over territory and power not Y()3$%#$32+$G1(32+,#$J"'<"#)$-(3$%#$32+$'",/+,$U(,10+"#$&1#3%\ nent. Nevertheless, considerable more conflicts took place in 32+$ J"'<"#>$ W#$ 32+$ 0,+4"&+$ 14$ 32+$ ]]WH$ 3V1$ J"'<"#$ V",)$ 311<$ 0'"&+>$R%,)3H$32+$X331:"#$+:0%,+$V")$41,&+.$1(3$14$32+$3+,,%31,L$ 14$c1)1*1$-L$32+$G+,-)$"#.$F1#3+#+/,%#)H$)+&1#.H$32+$"33+:03$ 14$ 32+$ 5'-"#%"#)$ 31$ :"<+$ c1)1*1$ 0",3$ 14$ 5'-"#%"#$ 3+,,%31,L$
The conflict$\$92+$c1)1*1$]",$")$21V$V+$,+:+:-+,$%3H$%)$32+$ 8C\."L$-1:-",.:+#3$14$G+,-%"H$%#&'(.%#/$c1)1*1$"#.$F1#3+\ #+/,1>$ 92+$ 0+,%1.$ "43+,$ 32+$ 4"%'(,+$ 14$ T":-1(%''+3$ "/,++:+#3$ in march of 1999, with the NATO intervening is only the final 0",3$14$32+$'1#/$)3,(//'+$-+3V++#$32+$G+,-)$"#.$5'-"#%"#\c1\ )1*",>$ 92+$ 0,1'1/(+$ 31$ 32%)$ 3,"/%&$ :1:+#3$ %#$ c1)1*1$ 2%)31,Lb$ the preceding year of conflict between the Kosovo Liberation 5,:L$hcS5iH$32+$I)23,%"$l'%,%:3",+$+$c1)1*s)$hIPciH$"#.$G+,-%\ "#$R1,&+)>$9V1$<+L$+*+#3)$V+,+$31$&2"#/+$+*+,L32%#/$%#$c1)\ @7
serbia
1.850.000 est.
1.61 mil Mitrovice / Mitrovica
montenegro
Prishtina
Peje / Pec
35.000 18.000
8.000
Gjilan / Gnjilane GjakovĂŤ / Dakovica
Ferizaj / Urosevac
Prizren
Gorani
Roma,Ashkali, Egyptians
Turks
27.000
Bosniaks
Serbs
Albanians
146.000
macedonia albania Map of Kosovo
Split of nationalities
0
Fig. 18 Demographics Kosovo
Kosovo-Albanians
50 km
Kosovo-Serbs
Fig. 19 Kosovoâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s divided landscape
_+,%3"/+$c1)1*1
_+,%3"/+$c1)1*1
"#.$3,()3>$92+$0'"&+:+#3$14$c1)1*1$(#.+,$32+$&1#3,1'$14$"$0,1\ *%)%1#"'$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ ".:%#%)3,"3%1#$ V%32$ Ia$ +#3+,%#/$ V%32$ "$ #(:-+,$")$2%/2$")$6!!!$+:0'1L++)H$0"%.$-L$]+)3+,#$)3"#.",.)$ 4,1:$ :1#+L$ )+3$ ")%.+$ 41,$ "%.$ .%.$ #13$ 4+'3$ V+''$ -L$ 32+$ '1&"')>$ 92+)+$ )"'",%+)$ 3,%//+,+.$ ,+#3)$ )<L,1&<+3%#/$ %#$ M,%)23%#">$ S")3H$ 32+$&2"#/+$4,1:$-+%#/$"$0,1*%#&+$14$G+,-%"$31$"$)+0","3+$",+"$ '+43$ :"Y1,$ /"0)$ %#$ ".:%#%)3,"3%*+$ &"0"&%3%+)$ "#.$ 132+,$ 0+10'+$ V+,+$)(..+#'L$+[(%00+.$V%32$01V+,>$P1,,(03%1#$V")$"#.$%)$"$ *+,L$ &1::1#$ +'+:+#3$ %#$ c1)1*1>$ I#&'+",$ ,+'"3%1#)$ -+3V++#$ /1*+,#:+#3$ "#.$ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ &1:0"#%+)$ /"*+$ 01V+,$ 31$ 32+$ large firms. For a time, the construction industry was the largest 0'"L+,$1#$32+$+&1#1:%&$:",<+3>$92+$%#&"0"&%3%+)$14$32+$/1*+,\ #:+#3$ "#.$ :(#%&%0"'$ %#)3%3(3%1#)$ :".+$ 4,++$ V"L$ 41,$ "''\,1(#.$ .+*+'10:+#3$%#$32+$0,%*"3+$)+&31,$"#.$)+&1#.$4"%'(,+$14$0'"#)$ %#$32+$L+",)$"43+,$32+$V",$+Q3+#.+.$32%)$0+,%1.$14$(#&'+",$(,-"#$ "#.$,+/%1#"'$.+*+'10:+#3>$S")3H$32+$0+,%1.$14$/,+"3$100,+))%\ 1#$-L$32+$G+,-%"#$,+/%:+$-+3V++#$32+$7ZZ!`)$"#.$32+$-+/%#\ #%#/$14$32+$V",$2")$&"()+.$.":"/+$31$32+$5'-"#%"#$)1&%+3L$%#$ 32+%,$4++'%#/$14$&1::1#$)+#)+$1,$&",+$41,$32+$0(-'%&>$
1*1H$321)+$1#$01'%3%&"'$"#.$)3,"3+/%&"'$'+*+'>$R%,)3H$32+$%#$7ZZB$ "/,++.$K"L31#$0+"&+$"/,++:+#3$32"3$+#.+.$32+$J1)#%"#$]",>$ 92+$,+&1/#%3%1#$14$J1)#%"$")$"$)+0","3+$)3"3+$-L$32+$U(,10+"#$ I#%1#$3(,#+.$1(3$31$-+$"$2(/+$3,"(:"$41,$32+$c1)1*1`)$5'-"\ #%"#)>$ 92+$ K"L31#$ "/,++:+#3$ .%.$ #13$ :+#3%1#$ c1)1*1$ "3$ "''$ "#.$)11#$32+$,+"'%e"3%1#$14$0+"&+4('$,+)%)3"#&+$V1('.$#13$/+3$ c1)1*1$%3)$%#.+0+#.+#&+$4,1:$G+,-%">$G+&1#.H$32+$)(..+#$4"''$ 14$5'-"#%"$%#$&1:0'+3+$"#",&2L$"''$31$.1$V%32$32+$/1*+,#:+#3"'$ supported financial pyramid, results in a leaving behind a great #(:-+,$14$",:1,%+)$-L$32+$:%'%3",L$"#.$)+&(,%3L$41,&+)>$G(..+#\ 'L$ "$ '",/+$ #(:-+,$ 14$ V+"01#)$ -+&":+$ "*"%'"-'+$ 31$ 32+$ -"33'+$ 14$32+$c1)1*1$5'-"#%"#)$hg(."2H$6!!Ci>$92+)+H$"#.$"$)+,%+)$14$ 132+,$ +*+#3)$ :".+$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ 0,+&",%1()$ "#.$ 32+$ %#3+,#"3%\ 1#"'$ &1::(#%3L$ %#3+,*+#+.>$ I#41,3(#"3+'LH$ V2+#$ 32+$ ^3"'<)`$ %#$ R,"#&+$ 4"%'+.$ 32+$ a59X$ .%.$ #13$ )++$ "#132+,$ 103%1#$ 32+#$ 31$ %#3+,*+#+$V%32$:%'%3",L$41,&+)>$X#$F",&2$6E$7ZZZH$32+$-1:-%#/$ )3",3+.H$4"&31,%+)$"#.$:%'%3",L$-")+)$V+,+$2%3$-(3$(#41,3(#"3+'L$ :"#L$&%*%'%"#)$'1)3$32+%,$'%*+)$311> The actual destruction \$ In the aftermath of a war or conflict several processes emerge. Returning refugees find their ways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
W#$ 32+$ 41''1V%#/$ 0"/+)$ 32+)+$ 0,1&+))+)$ "43+,$ 32+$ V",$ V%''$ -+$ .+)&,%-+.$%#$:1,+$.+3"%'>$92+$&1#.%3%1#)$"43+,$32+$V",$"''$&1#\ 3,%-(3+$31$32+$&1#3+:01,",L$011,$[("'%3L$14$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$ %3)$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$M(-'%&$'%4+$%#$M,%)23%#"$%)$"&3%*+$"#.$)1&%"'$"#.$ #1V"."L)$ )++<)$ 41,$ :1,+$ &1:41,3"-'+$ 0'"&+)>$ 92+$ )1&%+3L$ %)$ )'1V'L$/+33%#/$-"&<$1#$3,"&<$"#.$%)$,"0%.'L$&"3&2%#/$(0$V%32$32+$ ]+)3+,#$)3L'+$14$'%*%#/$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$-+2"*%1,$"#.$#++.)>$ a+*+,32+'+))H$32+$,+[(%,+.$)0"&+)$"#.$[("'%3"3%*+$/11.$(,-"#$ &1#.%3%1#)$ 41,$ 32%)$ 31$ 2"00+#$ #13$ "*"%'"-'+>$ 92%)$ %)$ +)0+&%"''L$ "$ )+,%1()$ 0,1-'+:$ %#$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.)$ 32"3$ 2"*+$ )++#$ -%/$ urban changes in the aftermath of the conflict. For that matter, 32+$ .%44+,+#3$ 0,1&+))+)$ "#.$ )%3("3%1#)$ "43+,$ 32+$ V",$ ",+$ -+%#/$ ,+)+",&2+.$1#$32+%,$%:0"&3$1#$32+$[("'%3L$14$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#\ :+#3>$ 92+$ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ -11:H$ 4"%'(,+$ 14$ ".:%#%)3,"3%*+$ 0'"#\ #%#/$"#.$0'"#)H$32+$&2"#/+$14$+&1#1:L$"#.$32+$%#2+,%3+.$"*+,\ )%1#$31$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$",+$32+$%:01,3"#3$4"&31,)$32"3$2"*+$ '+.$31$32+$.+3+,%1,"3%1#$14$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$%3)$.1:"%#>$92+%,$ %:0"&3$1#$32+$)0"3%"'$1,/"#%e"3%1#$V%''$-+$,+*%+V+.$"#.$0,+'%\ minary conclusions will be drawn. Those conclusions are first )3+0)$%#$.+*+'10%#/$0,%1,%3%+)$41,$32+$/1*+,#:+#3$32"3$%#&,+")+$ 32+$ [("'%3L$ 14$ 32+$ (,-"#$ &1#.%3%1#)>$ 921)+$ )3,"3+/%&$ 0,%1,%3%+)$ 14$32+$0(-'%&$-1.%+)$#++.$31$41&()$1#$-(%'.%#/$0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$ ,+'"3%1#)2%0)$ "#.$ %#3+/,"3+$ 32+$ V21'+$ )1&%+3L$ %#$ 32+$ ,+#+V+.$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#>$ 92+L$ #++.$ 31$ -+$ %#3,1.(&+.$ %#$ 4(3(,+$ 01'%&L$ :"<%#/$"#.$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$14$32+$+#3%,+$&%3L$"#.$41,$32+$'1&"'$ #+%/2-1,211.)>
W#$ "''$ 14$ c1)1*1$ -(3$ +Q0'%&%3'L$ %#$ &"0%3"'$ M,%)23%#"H$ c1)1*1$ 5'\ -"#%"#)$)"V$32+$:",&2%#/$14$32+$a59X\'+.$cRXT$3,110)$hc1\ )1*1$ R1,&+i$ ")$ "#$ "&3$ 14$ '%-+,"3%1#>$ 5$ #+V'L$ 41(#.$ )+#)+$ 14$ 4,++.1:$ 1,$ %#.+0+#.+#&+$ V")$ 02L)%&"''L$ +Q0,+))+.$ %#$ "#$ %:\ :+.%"3+$:".#+))$14$&1#)3,(&3%1#$h;1&<'+,H$6!!Ai>$5#$+,(03%1#$ 14$&1#)3,(&3%1#$14$21()%#/$"#.$"0",3:+#3)$V")$"$+Q0,+))%1#$14$ 32"3$ )(..+#$ 4,++.1:>$ G+&1#.H$ 32+$ '1#/$ 100,+))%1#$ 14$ d(/1\ )'"*%"$"#.$G+,-%"$'"3+,$3,%//+,+.$"$'",/+$"&3$14$*%1'+#&+$"/"%#)3$ G+,-%"#$1,321.1Q$&2(,&2+)$"#.$:1#")3+,%+)$%#$c1)1*1>$W#$32+$ 0+,%1.$-+3V++#$7ZZZ$"#.$6!!EH$7BB$&('3(,"'$%#)3%3(3%1#)$V+,+$ .+)3,1L+.$-L$5'-"#%"#$"&3%*%)3)>$T%13)$%#$6!!E$-L$5'-"#%"#$211\ '%/"#)$ '+43$ :"#L$ .+".$ "#.$ %#Y(,+.$ G+,-)$ h;1&<'+,H$ 6!!Ai>$ 92+$ 01'%3%&"'$)%3("3%1#$V")$"')1$#13$1#+$32"3$V")$)0,+".%#/$)3"-%'%3L$ @6
housing shortage
international aid workers
construction boom
repatriated refugees
economic migrants 300.000
150.000
PRISHTINA 1999
PRISHTINA 2017
Fig. 20 Post Conflict challenges
%#2"-%3"#3)$ V%32$ )"*%#/)$ %#*+)3+.$ %#$ 21()%#/$ 41,$ 32+%,$ 4":%'%+)$ "#.$32+$#+V$:%/,"#3)$%#$21()%#/$%#$1,.+,$31$)3",3$"$#+V$'%4+$%#$ M,%)23%#">$92+$)1&%"''L$.%)".*"#3"/+.$1,$*('#+,"-'+$V+,+$'+43$31$ &10+$V%32$32+%,$0,1-'+:)$1#$32+%,$1V#>$91."LH$41,$+Q":0'+$1#'L$ "$2"#.4('$14$)1&%"'$0,1Y+&3)$"#.$21()%#/$%#%3%"3%*+)$",+$0,1*%.+.$ &1:%#/$4,1:$32+$/1*+,#:+#3>$W#$M,%)23%#"$32"3$&1:+)$.1V#$31$ 7ZC$"0",3:+#3)>
D&'$#28(%.;#%)28$6220$\$T"0%.$010('"3%1#$/,1V32$%#$&%3%+)$%)$ characteristic of post-conflict situations (Vockler, 2006). Migra\ tion flows towards cities and particularly to Prishtina include ,+0"3,%"3+.$ ,+4(/++)H$ ,(,"'$ 31$ (,-"#$ :1*+:+#3$ "#.$ +)3"-'%)2\ :+#3$14$32+$'",/+$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$&1::(#%3L$/+#+,"3+.$"$21()%#/$ shortage. In the conflict period over 200.000 refugees went 31$]+)3+,#$U(,10+$"#.$:(&2$&":+$-"&<$"43+,$32+$V",$.(+$31$ ,+*1<+.$ ")L'(:$ -L$ 21)3%#/$ &1(#3,%+)>$ ]2"3$ 32+L$ 41(#.$ V+,+$ .+)3,1L+.$*%''"/+)$"#.$31V#)$"#.$:"#L$.+&%.+.$31$:%/,"3+$31$ 32+$-%//+,$&%3%+)$V2%&2$2".$-++#$)"*+.$:1)3'L$.(,%#/$32+$V",$ "#.$",+$144+,%#/$-+33+,$0,1)0+&3)>$5''$32+)+$#+V$,+)%.+#3)$2".$ to find a way to settle in the city which led in situations to con\ flicts. The high demand for housing in the city accelerated the &1#)3,(&3%1#$14$-(%'.%#/)>$92+$,+)('3$V")$"$&1#)3,(&3%1#$-11:$ 31$21()+$"''$32+)+$#+V&1:+,)$%#$M,%)23%#">$92+$.%,+&3$"43+,:"32$ ,+/",.%#/$32+$/1*+,#:+#3$"#.$".:%#%)3,"3%*+$%#)3%3(3%1#)$V+,+$ (#"-'+$,+/('"3+$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$.(+$31$%#&"0"&%3%+)$"#.$V+,+$ .L)4(#&3%1#"'>$92%)$&1#)3,(&3%1#$-11:$V2%&2$0,1&++.+.$+*+#\ tually without permits and sufficient standards has resulted in a .,")3%&$&2"#/+$14$+Q%)3%#/$(,-"#$4"-,%&$14$M,%)23%#">$F('3%)31,L$ 21()%#/$ "0",3:+#3)$ 0100+.$ (0$ +*+,L$ ."L$ %#$ M,%)23%#"H$ ):"''$ 21()+)$ )(..+#'L$ .%)"00+",+.$ "#.$ :".+$ V"L$ 41,$ :"Q%:%e%#/$ )3,(&3(,"'$*1'(:+H$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$:(#%&%0"'$'"#.$V")$3"<+#$ 31$-(%'.$"#.$"3$:1:+#3)$32+$&%3L$Y()3$1#+$-%/$&1#)3,(&3%1#$)%3+>$ I#%[(+$ &1#)3,(&3%1#)$ -+3V++#$%#*+)31,)H$&1#)3,(&3%1#$ &1:0"\ #%+)$ "#.$ 0,10+,3L$ "#.$ '"#.$ 1V#+,)$ 31/+32+,$ .1:%#"3+.$ 32+$ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ )+&31,$ "#.$ ,"0%.'L$ (,-"#$ ",+")$ &2"#/+.>$ W#3+#3%\ ons were clear: maximizing profit from selling and renting out new property and investing those profits in new construction.
5)$c"%$;1&<'+,$:+#3%1#)H$32+$)01#3"#+1()H$(#&1#3,1''+.$(,-"#$ .+*+'10:+#3$V")$31$,+/('"3+$%3)+'4>$G+'4\,+/('"3%1#H$2+$V,%3+)H$ %)$+))+#3%"''L$.+3+,:%#+.$-L$+"&2$14$32+$%#.%*%.("'$0",3%+)$.+\ "'%#/$ V%32$ 1#+$ "#132+,$ %#$ &1#)3,(&3%1#)$ 0,1Y+&3)>$ 5''$ 32+)+$ %#\ 3+,+)3)$ .1$ #13$ .%,+&3'L$ )+,*+$ 32+$ %#3+,+)3)$ 14$ 32+$ )1&%+3L$ ")$ "$ V21'+>$92%)$%)$&'+",'L$)++#$%#$32+$313"'$#+/'+&3$14$0(-'%&$"44"%,)>$ W3$ %)$ :"%#'L$ '+.$ -L$ %#.%*%.("'$ %#3+,+)3)$ V2%&2$ 3+#.$ 31$ '+".$ 31$ conflicts with neighbors. The negative results are very obvious %#$",+")$V2+,+$32+$/1*+,#:+#3$)21('.$2"*+$%#3+,*+#+.$V%32$"&\ &(,"3+$0'"##%#/$"#.$,+/('"3%1#)$4,1:$32+$-+/%##%#/b$)(00'L%#/$ "$4(#&3%1#%#/$3+&2#%&"'$"#.$)1&%"'$%#4,")3,(&3(,+H$"#.$,+)+,*%#/$ "#.$ :"%#3"%#%#/$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+$ "#.$ 0'"&+)$ 32"3$ )(001,3$ 0(-'%&$ ."%'L$'%4+>$ P1:0",%#/$&%3L$)%3("3%1#)$-+41,+$32+$V",$"#.$32+$,"0%.$.+*+\ '10:+#3$L+",)$"43+,$%#.%&"3+)$32"3$32+$1*+,-(%'.%#/$14$32+$&%3L$ "#.$+Q0+#.%#/$%#41,:"'$+./+)$2")$&2"#/+.$32+$",+"$41,$8Bo$ (Vรถckler, 2008, p. 39). It was not the actual conflict that chan\ ged the city but rather the post-conflict processes that led to .+)3,(&3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 0'"&+$ h;p&<'+,H$ 6!!CH$ 0>$ E6i>$ W3$ V")$ "$ &1#3%\ #("3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ .+)3,(&3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ &%3L$ V2%&2$ 2".$ %3)$ 1,%/%#$ %#$ 32+$ d(/1)'"*%"#$ 0+,%1.$ V2+#$ 32+$ :1.+,#%)3%&$ &1#&+03)$ V+,+$ "00'%+.$ "#.$ 2%)31,%&$ 0'"&+)$ ")$ 32+$ 31V#$ -"e"",$ "#.$ ,+'%/%1()$ -(%'.%#/)$2".$31$:"<+$V"L$41,$#+V$%.+")>
F1#+L$V")$0,%:",%'L$%#*+)3+.$%#$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$)+&31,$"#.$%3$ )11#$-+&":+$32+$:1)3$%:01,3"#3$0",3$14$32+$+&1#1:L>$R(#.)$ 41,$ 32%)$ &":+$ 0",3%"''L$ 4,1:$ 32+$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ .1#1,)$ 1,$ 4,1:$ 32+$+)3%:"3+.$E!!>!!!$c1)1*1\5'-"#%"#$.%")01,">$T+'"3%*+)$14$ c1)1*1$ 5'-"#%"#)$ '%*%#/$ %#$ V+)3+,#$ &1(#3,%+)>$ 92"3$ +&1#1:L$ V")$ 31$ )2,%#<$ ")$ )11#$ ")$ 32+$ 21()%#/$ )21,3"/+$ V")$ .+&'%#%#/$ "#.$ 0'"#)$ 41,$ 132+,$ )+&31,)$ 14$ 32+$ +&1#1:L$ V+,+$ #13$ :".+>$ 91."LH$c1)1*1$2")$1#+$14$32+$'1V+)3$0+,$&"0%3"$%#&1:+)$%#$G1(\ 32\U")3+,#$U(,10+$h]1,'.$J"#<H$6!7Ei>$92%)$2")$'+.$31$"$V"*+$14$ +&1#1:%&$:%/,"#3)$31V",.)$]+)3+,#$U(,10+$hc1)1*1$G3"-%'%3L$ W#%3%"3%*+H$6!7Ei>
W3$%)$01))%-'+$31$%.+#3%4L$32,++$.%44+,+#3$.%,+&3%1#)$32+$.+*+'10\ ment after the war took. The specific circumstances and con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a+%/2-1,)$/+#+,"''L$<#1V$+"&2$132+,$"#.$1#'L$)01,".%&$
Everyone except the socially disadvantaged were able to profit "#.$-+$0",3$14$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$-11:$"#.$32+$,+"'\+)3"3+$)+&\ 31,>$P1#)3,(&3%1#$&1:0"#%+)H$'"#.$"#.$-(%'.%#/$1V#+,)H$41,+%/#$ %#*+)31,)H$)<%''+.$'"-1,+,)H$-(%'.+,)$1V#%#/$:"3+,%"')$V+,+$+#\ /"/+.$%#$32+$#+V$+&1#1:L$14$M,%)23%#">$J+)%.+)$32"3H$32+$'1&"'$ @@
Map of Prishtina
Informal & unregulated development 1999-2013
Extentions of the urban environment Private densification of the urban fabric Investors densification of the urban fabric Parasite development
Fig. 21 Unregulated development in Prishtina
@E
Fig. 22 Urban extentions
Fig. 23 Private densification
Fig. 24 Investors densification
Fig. 25 Urban parasites
conflicts have occurred. For those areas, no plans existed and )(00'L$14$-")%&$%#4,")3,(&3(,+$V")$#13$"*"%'"-'+>$M(-'%&$":+#%\ 3%+)$",+$/+#+,"''L$'"&<%#/H$)(&2$")$0(-'%&$3,"#)01,3$"#.$0"*+.$ ,1".)> 92%)$ 3L0+$ 14$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 2")$ +#'",/+.$ 32+$ -1(#.",%+)$ 14$ (,\ -"#$ M,%)23%#"$ .,")3%&"''L>$ S"3+,H$ V%32$ 32+$ )3,"3+/%&$ 0'"#)$ 32"3$ V+,+$ 41,:+.$ 32+)+$ ",+")$ V+,+$ .+)%/#+.$ ")$ (,-"#$ +Q3+#)%1#)$ V%32$1#'L$"0",3:+#3$-(%'.%#/)$14$E\7!$)31,%+)$"#.$.%.$#13$%#&'(\ .+$4":%'L$21:+)>
.+&,+")+$0(-'%&$)0"&+$"#.$)"4+$)3,++3$'%4+> 92+$ )+&1#.$ &")+$ %)$ :"Q%:%e%#/$ 32+$ 0,10+,3L$ (0$ 31$ %3)$ 0",&+'$ '%:%3)$-L$%#*+)31,)$V2%&2$",+$#13$0",3$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$&1:\ munity. The intentions are only profit by maximizing its proper\ 3L$*"'(+$"#.$.1$#13$&",+$41,$0(-'%&$",+")$"#.$+Q%)3%#/$#+%/2-1\ ring properties. Generally, the ground floors can be used for commercial purposes while the upper floors are for office space 1,$ "0",3:+#3)>$ 92+)+$ -(%'.%#/)$ ",+$ :1,+$ 1,$ '+))$ "&&1,.%#/$ 31$ ITM`)H$%#&'(.%#/$"$0+,:%3H$-(3$32+L$)21V$'%:%3+.$&",+$41,$)1&%"'$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+H$"0",3:+#3$)%e+$"#.$)%.+V"'<)>
92+$)+&1#.$3L0+$14$.+*+'10:+#3$2"00+#+.$V%32%#$32+$&%3L$"#.$ densified the urban fabric enormously. Within this develop\ :+#3$ 32+,+$ ",+$ 3V1$ V"L)b$ +#'",/+:+#3$ 14$ -(%'.%#/)$ .1#+$ -L$ 32+$ 1V#+,$ 14$ 32+$ '"#.$ "#.$ +#'",/+:+#3$ 14$ -(%'.%#/)$ .1#+$ -L$ %#*+)31,)$32"3$-1(/23$32+$'"#.>$92+$0",&+')$2"*+$"',+".L$-++#$ .%*%.+.$%#31$):"''+,$0'13)$"#.$32+$",+")$",+$:1,+$"33,"&3%*+$.(+$ to existing infrastructure. The intention is to gain as much profit -L$:"Q%:%e%#/$-(%'.%#/)$(0$31$0'13$)%e+)>
The last type of development is urban densification on top and sides of existing building. The municipality was allowing flat ,114)$ 31$ &2"#/+$ %#31$ 0%3&2+.$ ,114)$ V%32$ "#$ +Q3+#)%1#$ 14$ 1#+$ floor. In practice, up to four floors have been added to buil\ .%#/)>$ G:"''$ +Q3+#)%1#)$ 1#$ )%.+)$ "#.$ -"'&1#%+)$ ",+$ 143+#$ %''+\ /"'$"#.$-(%'.$V%321(3$0+,:%3)>$92+)+$+Q3+#)%1#)$",+$/+#+,"''L$ :".+$ 1#$ 41,:+,$ G1&%"'%)3$ "0",3:+#3$ -'1&<)$ V2%&2$ 2"*+$ -++#$ 0,%*"3%e+.$.(,%#/$32+$3,"#)%3%1#$31V",.)$"$:",<+3$+&1#1:L>$92%)$ 41,:$ %)$ :1)3'L$ 0+,41,:+.$ 1#$ '",/+$ :1.+,#%)3%&$ 2%/2$ ,%)+$ -(%'\ .%#/)$%#$32+$)1(32$14$32+$&%3L>$
In the first case, the owner had a permit for a single-family house but extends this development up to 6-7 floors. It is "')1$ 01))%-'+$ 32"3$ :('3%0'+$ '"#.$ 1V#+,)$ V1,<$ 31/+32+,$ V2+#$ constructing a building. Eventually the final buildings exceed maximum gross floor size for the site and the number of floors aloud by the regulatory neighborhood plans. The ground floor is usually designed for commercial purposes. Conflicts arise be\ 3V++#$ 0,10+,3L$ 1V#+,)$ .(+$ 31$ -'1&<+.$ )(#'%/23$ "#.$ .%)3"#&+$ 31$ +Q%)3%#/$ 0,10+,3%+)>$ S"&<$ 14$ &",+$ 41,$ +Q%)3%#/$ (,-"#$ 4"-,%&)$ "#.$ 2%)31,%&"'$ .1$ #13$ +Q%)3$ "#.$ +Q3+#)%1#)$ 1#$ 0(-'%&$ /,1(#.)$
92+$&1,+$%))(+$*%)%-'+$%#$32+$-(%'.$+#*%,1#:+#3$31."L$%)$32+$#+\ /'+&3$14$%:01,3"#&+$,+'"3+.$31$-(%'.%#/$)3"#.",.)$"#.$,+/('"3%\ 1#)H$&1#&+,#%#/$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$"43+,$32+$V",>$92+$(#&1#3,1'\ '+.$(,-"#$.+*+'10:+#3$0+,:%33+.$'"#.1V#+,)$31$:"Q%:%e+$32+$ *"'(+$14$32+%,$'"#.$%#$%##+,$&%3L$",+")>$P'+",'L$%)$32+$%#.%*%.("'$ interests and conflict with one another and this eventually will "44+&3$0,10+,3L$*"'(+>$G+&1#.H$&",+$"#.$'"&<$31V",.)$32+$)3,++3H$ @B
!"#$%&'()*+)!&"(,$"-. 1400
1800
Ottoman Architecture
1900
1950
West European influence
1960
International style
1970
Social Realism
1980
Brutalism
1990
2000
2010
Turbo Architecture Tu Internationalism Inte Non - vernacular or regional style
Kosovo War Kos
Fig. 26 Architecture timelime including contemporary free architecture
0(-'%&$ )0"&+)$ "#.$ 2%)31,%&$ *"'(+$ .%.$ #13$ +Q%)3>$ J(%'.%#/)$ 2"*+$ -++#$ &1#)3,(&3+.$ (0$ 31$ "#.$ 1*+,$ 32+$ 0'13$ '+*+'$ 3"<%#/$ )0"&+$ 4,1:$)3,++3)$"#.$)%.+V"'<)>$92+$)3,++3)$",+$"$&2"13%&$:%Q3(,+$14$ ()+)$"#.$32+$*",%+3L$14$4"&".+)$"#.$)0"&+)$%#$4,1#3$:"<+$32%)$"#$ undefined place. Within the city limits, self-regulation and un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
G,.Y"#$g1*"1*%&$]+%))$&"'')$%3H$&"#$-+$41(#.$+*+,LV2+,+$%#$32+$ V+)3+,#$ J"'<"#$ ,+/%1#)>$ _+$ &"'')$ %3$ "$ :%)2\:")2$ 14$ )3L'+)$ "#.$ ,+4+,+#&+)$31$^3,".%3%1#`$-(3$32"3$3,".%3%1#$&1:+)$4,1:$+')+V2+\ ,+$ #1V>$ W3$ %)$ %:%3"3%#/$ )3L'+)$ 14$ -(%'.%#/)$ )++#$ %#$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ :+.%"$%#$"$V"L$.+:1#)3,"3%#/$:1.+,#%3L$-(3$#13$32+$:1.+,#$ ",&2%3+&3(,+$32"3$c1)1*1$"#.$132+,$J"'<"#$,+/%1#)$+Q0+,%+#&+.$ %#$32+$0,+*%1()$&+#3(,L$.(,%#/$32+$G1&%"'%)3$d(/1)'"*%"$0+,%1.>$ W3$%)$"#$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$)3L'+$32"3$,+Y+&3)$+*+,L32%#/$32"3$%)$3,".%3%1#$ "#.$,+/%1#"'$",&2%3+&3(,+>$X'.$M,%)23%#"H$V2%&2$%)$3L0%&"''L$21(\ )%#/$2%)31,%&$21()+)$1,$)%#/'+\)31,L$21()+)$2"*+$:".+$V"L$41,$ overbuilt enormous high-rise office and commercial buildings. 5.103+.$)3L'+)$")$&'"))%&"'H$1,%+#3"'H$4,++\)3L'+$&1:%#/$4,1:$32+$ US, Dubai mixed with structures that have no specific style at "''$:"<+$32+$)3,++3)$14$M,%)23%#"$"$(#%[(+$0'"&+>$W3$%#&1,01,"3+)$ 210+$31$-+&1:+$0",3$14$32+$:1.+,#$V+)3+,#$&('3(,+$h;1&<'+,H$ 6!!A$0>$B6i>
92+$'")3$+'+:+#3$14$)+'4\,+/('"3%1#$"#.$(#&1#3,1''+.$.+*+'10\ :+#3$%)$:"L-+$+*+#$32+$:1)3$*%)%-'+$1#+b$32+$)3L'+$14$32+$-(%'\ .%#/)>$ 92+$ )3L'+$ 14$ -(%'.%#/)$ 32"3$ -+'1#/$ 31$ "#$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ (,-"#$ &('3(,+$ :",<+.$ -L$ :+.%"$ V2%&2$ 0,+)+#3+.$ $ 32+$ ^/11.$ '%4+`$ 4,1:$ "''$ 1*+,$ 32+$ V1,'.>$ 92+$ #+V$ ^9(,-1$ 5,&2%3+&3(,+`$ $ ")$
All these elements have changed the urban profile of the city. It %)$-")%&"''L$32+$.+,+/('"3+.$)%3("3%1#$32"3$,+)('3+.$%#$32+$%#41,\ :"'%e"3%1#$14$(,-"#$)0"&+>$ @A
Fig. 27 Strategic Plan 2020
Fig. 28 Urban development plan 2012-2020
F(#%&%0"'%3L$14$M,%)23%#"H$6!!E
F(#%&%0"'%3L$14$M,%)23%#"H$6!77
Failure of administrative plans - 92+$ (#,+/('"3+.$ .+*+'10\ :+#3$ "#.$ :"#L$ %''+/"'$ &1#)3,(&3%1#)$ V+,+$ "$ :"33+,$ 14$ 4"%'(,+$ 14$ ".:%#%)3,"3%*+$ 0'"#)$ "#.$ %#)3%3(3%1#"'$ %#&"0"&%3L>$ 92+$ &")+$ of Kosovo as a post-conflict situation had an extra dimension %#$ 32+$ 41,:$ 14$ "$ .L)4(#&3%1#"'$ "#.$ V+"<$ /1*+,#"#&+$ )L)3+:>$ K%,+&3'L$"43+,$32+$V",H$32+$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$&1::(#%3L$.+&%.+.$31$ 0'"&+$ c1)1*1$ (#.+,$ 32+$ &1#3,1'$ 14$ "$ 0,1*%)%1#"'$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ ".:%#%)3,"3%1#>$ ]%32$ 32+$ +)3"-'%)2:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ IaFWc$ hI#%3+.$ a"3%1#)$W#3+,%:$5.:%#%)3,"3%1#$F%))%1#$%#$c1)1*1i$"%:+.$"3$41\ ,+)++%#/$32+$#+V$#"3%1#$V%32$"$j3,"#)%3%1#"'$".:%#%)3,"3%1#$V2%\ '+$+)3"-'%)2%#/$"#.$1*+,)++%#/$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$0,1*%)%1#"'$ .+:1&,"3%&$)+'4\/1*+,#%#/$%#)3%3(3%1#)$31$+#)(,+$&1#.%3%1#)$41,$ "$0+"&+4('$"#.$#1,:"'$'%4+$41,$"''$%#2"-%3"#3)$14$c1)1*1k$hI#%\ 3+.$a"3%1#)$G+&(,%3L$P1(#&%'H$7ZZZi>$92+$&2"#/+$14$-+%#/$0",3$ 14$ d(/1)'"*%"$ "#.$ '"3+,$ G+,-%"$ ")$ "$ 0,1*%#&+$ 14$ "$ '",/+,$ )3"3+$ towards a new control of UN mission has been a difficult one. W#$32+$d(/1)'"*%"#$0+,%1.H$32+$&%3L$V")$(#.+,$J+'/,".+$&1#3,1'$ "#.$0'"#)$V+,+$:".+$:1)3'L$1(3)%.+$c1)1*1>$543+,$32+$V",$32+$ G+,-%"#$+:0'1L++)$%#$:1)3$0",3)$14$32+$/1*+,#:+#3"'$%#)3%3(\ 3%1#)$'+43H$"$'",/+$%#&"0"&%3L$14$32+$%#)3%3(3%1#"'$)L)3+:$V")$32+$ ,+)('3>$ 92+$ :%))%1#$ 14$ 32+$ IaH$ "%:%#/$ "3$ /%*%#/$ 32+$ #+V$ )3"3+$ "$ 3,"#)%3%1#"'$ ".:%#%)3,"3%1#H$ V2+#$ %#$ 32+$ :+"#3%:+$ 0+,41,:$ &"0"&%3L$ -(%'.%#/$ 41,$ "$ 4(3(,+$ .+:1&,"3%&$ /1*+,#:+#3$ V2%&2$ would be self-sufficient in organizing the country, has been a &1:0'+Q$0,1&+))>$91/+32+,$V%32$32+$Ia$32+$XGPU$h1,/"#%e"3%1#$ 41,$G+&(,%3L$"#.$P1\10+,"3%1#$%#$U(,10+i$"#.$32+$UI$hU(,10+"#$ I#%1#i$32+$/1"'$V")$31$)3,(&3(,+$"$0,1*%)%1#"'$)+'4\/1*+,#:+#3$ hM,1*%)%1#"'$W#)3%3(3%1#)$14$G+'4\n1*+,#:+#3$r$MWGni>$5',+".L$%#$ 6!!6$+'+&3%1#)$32+$"(321,%3L$1*+,$32+$&1(#3,L$V")$3,"#)4+,,+.$31$ 32+$MWGn>$a+*+,32+'+))H$32+$IaFWc$)3"L+.$"#.$)3%''$2".$'13$14$ influence the years after.
5',+".L$ %#$ 6!!!H$ 32+$ .%,+&31,$ 14$ 32+$ 0'"##%#/$ "/+#&LH$ T+Q2+0$ S(&%$ ,+&1/#%e+.$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ ")$ 0,1-'+:"3%&$ "#.$ 3,%+.$ 31$ +)\ 3"-'%)2$ "$ .1&(:+#3$ 31$ ,+/('"3+$ 32+$ %''+/"'$ .+*+'10:+#3H$ ")$ "$ ,+"&3%1#$2+$V")$:(,.+,+.>$IaFWc$,+/('"3%1#$6!!!OB@$"&<#1V\ '+./+.$ 32%)$ %))(+$ -(3$ %#&"0"&%3%+)$ "#.$ 32+$ L+3$ #1#\1,/"#%e+.$ c1)1*1$01'%&+$41,&+$4"%'+.$%#$,+/('"3%#/$32+$%''+/"'$&1#)3,(&3%1#$ "#.$31$+#41,&+$-(%'.%#/$&1.+)$h;p&<'+,H$6!!CH$0>$E@i>$F1,+1*+,H$ plans had to be drawn first to establish a legal basis. W#$ 32+$ 0+,%1.$ -+3V++#$ 7ZZZ$ "#.$ 6!!@$ 32+$ *"&((:$ 14$ )0"3%"'$ 0'"#)$"#.$'"V)$2")$-++#$.%)")3,1()$41,$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3$ 14$ M,%)23%#">$ W3$ %)$ *+,L$ &'+",$ #1VH$ 32"3$ 0'"##%#/$ "#.$ /11.$ /1\ vernance after a conflict is essential. Irreversible situations now &,+"3+$+Q&+))%*+$0,1-'+:)$,+/",.%#/$32+$(,-"#$[("'%3L>$U*+#3(\ "''L$32+$jI,-"#$G3,"3+/%&$M'"#$6!6!k$V")$:".+$%#$6!!E$%#$Y()3$"$ 4+V$:1#32)>$5#$(#,+"'%)3%&$0'"#$-")+.$(01#$(#,+'%"-'+$%#41,:"\ 3%1#H$")$0,1*+.$-L$32+$U(,10+"#$G3"-%'%3L$W#%3%"3%*+$h6!!Ai$V2%&2$ :".+$ &'+",$ 32"3$ B!!>!!!$ %#2"-%3"#3)$ V")$ 3V%&+$ 32+$ ":1(#3$ '%*%#/$ %#$ M,%)23%#">$ 53$ 32+$ 01%#3$ V2+#$ 32%)$ 0'"#$ V")$ :".+H$ %3$ )21('.$ 2"*+$ 41&()+.$ 1#$ "&3("'$ )%3("3%1#)$ 32"3$ 2"00+#+.$ ,"\ 32+,$32"#$0,101)%#/$"$V1,'.'L$/,+"3$*%)%1#>$a1$)3,"3+/L$%#$32+$ â&#x20AC;&#x153;Strategic Planâ&#x20AC;? was specified regarding problems concerning .+)3,1L%#/$2%)31,%&$+'+:+#3)H$)"4+3L$14$-(%'.%#/)H$V"3+,$)(00'L$ "#.$ V")3+V"3+,$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+$ "#.$ )1&%"'$ 0,1-'+:)$ ,+'"3+.$ 31$ 32+$(#,+/('"3+.$.+*+'10:+#3> J")+.$ 1#$ 32+$ )3,"3+/%&$ 0'"#H$ V2%&2$ 2".$ #1$ '+/"'$ -%#.%#/$ "#.$ V")$ #13$ .+3"%'+.$ "3$ "''H$ ):"''+,$ ,+/('"31,L$ 0'"#)$ 41,$ .%44+,+#3$ #+%/2-1,211.)$ V+,+$ .+*+'10+.>$ J")+.$ 1#$ "$ V,1#/$ &+#)()$ "#.$%#.%*%.("''L$4,1:$+"&2$132+,H$32+L$V+,+$"$&1:0'+3+$4"%'(,+>$ R"%'(,+$.(+$31$"-)+#&+$14$"$F(#%&%0"'$K+*+'10:+#3$M'"#$hFKMi$ "#.$"#$I,-"#$K+*+'10:+#3$M'"#$hIKMi$V2%&2$V+,+$,+[(%,+.$"&\ &1,.%#/$31$32+$S"V$1#$G0"3%"'$M'"##%#/$h6!!@i>$G+&1#.H$.(+$31$ "-)+#&+$14$".:%#%)3,"3%*+$1,.%#"#&+)$"#.$"00,1*+.$&1#)3,(&\ tion regulations (Hasimja, 2012). These plans found difficulties 1#$32+$/,1(#.$V2+#$,+)+,*%#/$)0"&+$41,$0(-'%&$":+#%3%+)$"#.$ )0"&+)$41,$0(-'%&$'%4+>$J+)%.+)$32+$)3,++3)H$#1$'"#.$V")$1V#+.$ -L$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ 31$ /+#+,"3+$ 0(-'%&$ 4"&%'%3%+)>$ a1$ ,+"'$ 0(\ -'%&$ )3"#.",.)$ V+,+$ %#&'(.+.$ %#$ 32+$ 0'"#)$ "#.$ -+)%.+)$ 32"3H$ implementation of public projects had difficulties, related to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
92+$+Q%)3%#/$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"#)$."3%#/$4,1:$32+$d(/1)'"*$0+\ ,%1.$ V+,+$ +Q%)3%#/$ 1#$ 0"0+,$ -(3$ '+43$ '",/+'L$ ")%.+$ .(,%#/$ 32%)$ 0+,%1.>$ 92+$ ,+'+")+$ 4,1:$ 32+$ d(/1)'"*%"#$ .1:%#"3%1#$ :".+$ those plans insufficient. A vacuum of a period with no planning %#)3,(:+#3$%#$&2",/+$"#.$)1H$#1$'+/"'$-%#.%#/$.1&(:+#3$/"*+$ 4,++.1:$ 31$ 0,10+,3L$ .+*+'10+,)$ %#$ 32+$ V%.+)3$ )+#)+$ 14$ 32+$ V1,.>$53$32"3$3%:+H$%3$V")$#13$+*+#$01))%-'+$31$/+3$"$0+,:%3$41,$ "$ .+*+'10:+#3>$ G+&1#.H$ 0,10+,3L$ 1V#+,)2%0$ V%32%#$ M,%)23%#"$ had many difficulties caused by unclear legal status of property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
Ko
so
vo
Ko pr ov
so
in
ce
vo
Fi
rs
be
co
of
Se
rb
ia
St
at
e
in
Re
pu
bl
ic
of
at
pa
m
es
Sp
tS
Au
to
tia
no
lP
m
lan
ou
Yu g
os la
via
of
De
fa
Ko
so
vo
pl
an
os
ni
ng
La
w
Pr es
id
te s p cto rL ro se aw vin lf-G on ce ov Sp in ern at Yu m ial go ent Pl an sla is ni i via nit ng iat ed
1974
v
an
Es
go
la
af
1946
Centralized-directive planning 1947-1952
ial
Ru
Yu g
d
m
va
en
tM
ici
pa
ld
ec
lg
se
ev
te
Be
ilo
un
el
el
de
:s
m
pr es
id
ra
vic
op
d
tri
p
di
ss
ol
rig
ve
ht
en
tp
lan
en
fs
st
he
so
fa
s
1977
The decentralized and socialist self-management planning from 1953 to 1967
to
el
Ko
fp
ro c
ut
so
on
vo
om
la
go
y
ta bl UN i UN shm M M en Re IK r IK t o xh eg re f M ep ul so a lut inis Luc tio iio ter i re n y 12 of co 44 en - P vi ro vis io
ve
im
1987
ed
K
re p
rn
ub
m
lic
en
t
1989
1990
Democratized polycentric planning model from 1967 to 1990
Dictorial Regim
Period
Period
1990 - 1999
1947 - 1965
Planning Activities
Period
Planning Activities
1965 - 1974
Central commend planning
Level of self governing & planning
1992
Planning Activities
- controlled development - urban growth / city limits - public interst over private - focus on technical solution
New system of voluntary planning â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;social self-management planningâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; - communication & coordination of different bodies at all levels by agreements and commitments - no hierarchical approval system
Planning Documents - Regulations - Detailed plans
Planning Documents - Top down Master Plan as goal - Formulations (landuse) - Regulatory and Detailed plans - bottom-up driven (5y)
Period 1974 - 1990
Planning Activities Decentralized - Provincial level / local planning - spatial planning at the provincial government level - municipal and urban planning - regulatory & detailed urban planning
Planning Documents
Central Planning - Serb (topdown control) - Exclusion of Albanian process - (planning activities o towards the goals of not linking with the r - superficial
Planning Documen
- Land use plans - Development scenar - Regulative plans
- Spatial Plan Kosovo - Regional spatial plans - General urban plans - Regulatory plans - Detailed urban plans
Fig. 29 Kosovo and Planning since 1946
W#$6!77H$32+$I,-"#$M'"#$6!76\6!6!$V")$%#3,1.(&+.>$92+$0'"#)$ are not very specific and clear. The urban development plan %#.%&"3+)$32+$)3,"3+/%+)$V%32%#$32+$(,-"#$-1(#.",%+)$"#.$",+$)+\ 0","3+.$%#$):"''+,$,+/('",$0'"#)$41,$+"&2$#+%/2-1,211.>$92+,+$ ",+$.%44+,+#3$0,1-'+:)$#1V$-+&"()+$+*+#$32%)$I,-"#$.+*+'10\ :+#3$ 0'"#$ %)$ #13$ 2",:1#%e+.$ V%32$ "&3("'$ )%3("3%1#$ "#.$ "&3("'$ ,+/('"31,L$0'"#)$%#$)1:+$0'"&+)>
.%#/H$ 3,"%#%#/$ "$ *+,%3"-'+$ ",:L$ 14$ 0'"##+,)$ V21$ ",+$ #1V$ +:\ -+..+.$"&,1))$#"3%1#"'$"#.$'1&"'$/1*+,#:+#3$%#)3%3(3%1#)$32+,+$ hG(,%H$ 6!7Bi>$ 92+$ "%:$ V")$ 31$ 3+"&2$ 32+:$ 21V$ 31$ .1$ 0'"##%#/H$ %>+>$ 31$ 0,+0",+$ 321)+$ 0'"#)H$ V2%'+$ &,+"3%#/$ 32+$ &1#.%3%1#)$ 31$ )(001,3$32+%,$%:0'+:+#3"3%1#>$I#41,3(#"3+'LH$32+$+:02")%)$1#$ 32+$0,1&+))$:+"#3$32"3$.+*+'10:+#3$0,1&++.+.$"0"&+$%#$32+$ :+"#3%:+H$ "#.$ &2"#/+.$ 32+$ 4"&+$ 14$ c1)1*1`)$ 31V#)H$ #+V'L$ emerged from conflict, in an irreparable manner â&#x20AC;&#x201C; illegal con\ )3,(&3%1#)$&1*+,%#/$32+$2%'')%.+)H$-(%'.%#/$:"3+,%"'$.+013)$"#.$ 4(+'$)3"3%1#)$"-(33%#/$32+$2%/2V"L)H$2(/+$V",+21()+)$.133%#/$ 32+$'"#.)&"0+>
]%32$ 32+$ #+V$ S"V$ 1#$ G0"3%"'$ M'"##%#/$ 6!7@H$ "$ t1#%#/$ F"0$ %)$ %#3,1.(&+.$")$"#$%#)3,(:+#3$-+3V++#$32+$FKM$"#.$IKMOITM>$ W3$%#.%&"3+)$"$#+V$)L)3+:H$32%)$:+"#)$32"3$32+$,+&+#3$I,-"#$K+\ velopment plan 2012-2020 was replaced immediately after fi\ #%)2%#/>$92%)$V")$"3$32+$3%:+$)3%''$%#$0,1/,+))$"#.$#13$"00,1*+.H$ ,+'%"#&+$%)$)3%''$1#$32+$1'.$0'"#)$"#.$S"V$14$6!!@>$5$313"'$#+V$ )L)3+:H$ V%32$ %3)$ 1,%/%#$ %#$ 5:+,%&"#$ )0"3%"'$ 0'"##%#/H$ 32"3$ #1V$ #++.)$(#.+,)3"#.%#/$"#.$"$V"L$14$()%#/>
W#$ )1:+$ ",+")H$ V2+,+$ )3,++3)$ ",+$ )3%''$ )%:%'",$ %#$ '"L1(3$ 31$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 7ZB!`)H$ 32+$ -(%'.%#/$ -11:$ "#.$ .+#)%3L$ .1+)$ #13$:"3&2$V%32$32+$&"0"&%3%+)$14$32+$)3,++3)>$92+$#",,1V$)3,++3)H$ V2%&2$",+$32+$4+V$,+:",<"-'+$)(,*%*+.$+'+:+#3)$41,:$32+$2%)31\ ric periods, have great difficulties related to increased car de\ 0+#.+#&LH$"$V%.+$*",%+3L$14$()+)$"#.$/%*%#/$0+.+)3,%"#)$)0"&+$ 41,$ )"4+$ V"'<)>$ 92+$ ()+$ 14$ &",$ "#.$ %3)$ 4(#&3%1#$ 31$ 32+$ c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e+$%)$#13$32+$,+"'$0,1-'+:H$%3$2")$:1,+$ "$ /+1/,"02%&"'$ %))(+$ V%32$ 32+$ #(:-+,$ 14$ )3++0$ 2%'')$ "#.$ 32+$
92+)+$0,1&+))+)$&1#3%#(+.$(#3%'$32+$S"V$%#$6!7@$&":+$32"3$0(3$ "$21'.$1#$32+)+$&1#)3,(&3%1#)>$W#$"$3%:+4,":+$14$7@$L+",)$:1,+$ 1,$'+))$32+,+$V")$#1$,+/('"3%1#$"#.$)3"#.",.)$1#$&1#)3,(&3%1#>$ 92+$ S"V$ 1#$ '+/"'%e"3%1#$ %)$ :".+$ "#.$ V%''$ '+/"'%e+$ "':1)3$ "''$ %''+/"'$-(%'.%#/)$-(%'.$"43+,$32+$V",>$92+$S"V$0,1*%.+)$'1V$)3"#\ .",.)$"#.$.1+)$#13$.+:"#.$".Y()3:+#3$14$-(%'.%#/)$%#$1,.+,$ 31$ %#&,+")+$ )3,++3H$ )(#$ "#.$ "%,H$ )"4+3L$ 0,1-'+:)$ ,+'"3+.$ 31$ 32+$ -(%'.%#/)>$ 92+$ &2"''+#/+$ #1V$ %)$ 21V$ 31$ 0,1&++.$ 4(,32+,$ V%32$ 32+$0,1&+))+)$%#$32+$-(%'.$+#*%,1#:+#3$32"3$+Q%)3>$ 92+$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ &1::(#%3L$ 2")$ "')1$ .1#+$ %3)$ -%3H$ :1)3'L$ '+.$ -L$ Ia\_5JW959>$ W#$ c1)1*1H$ Ia\_5JW959$ ,"#$ )(&&+))%*+$ 0,1\ /,":)$ 32"3$ 41&()+.$ 1#$ %#)3%3(3%1#"'$ ,+41,:$ "#.$ &"0"&%3L\-(%'\ @C
on
N
ew
Sp
at
ial
pl
20
an
ni
ng
La
w og 00/ an d niz 53 m ir. ed - co un & pr ici pl ob nce pa St on ann lem rne ra ld tig al d i ev Ad ng - atic wi ic el Ko m 37 illi th Ur op i i g ba l m so nist de al d liga e n nt Pl vo ratio cen ev l de p an e t lan W n Ko ralis lopm velo 20 s a p 20 ar so tio en m vo n en s t t
1999
2000
ns of planning
Reconstruction & emergency acitivities â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;shelter programsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; - Limited regulatory planning activities
rio
In
de
pe
nd
en
ce
2003
ov
er
nm
La Dr w af on ts leg of St op ali Reg Ur sa u on ba tio la n t un De La n & ory co ve tre Pl w nt lo o at an ro n pm lle Sp ing s b en d i a a t tP de ial lliga sed l lan ve o Pl an dev n U lo 20 pm e ni 12 ng lop DP e -2 m /11 nt 02 en t 0
2008
en
t-
2011
2013
Dr
2013
af
tin
g
M
un
ici
pa
lZ
on
in
g
M
ap
sa
2014
sl
eg
al
do
cu
m
en
t
20??
Democrized central - local planning
1999 - 2002
Planning Activities
nts
vo
G
Period
bian government
orientated f sustainability / real context)
so
ty
UN administration provisional government together with new local government - Decentralized
me of Serbia
s
2003
Ko
Ci
Planning Documents Applicible planning law from 1987 and limited respect for made plans
Period 2002 - 2012
Planning Activities
Period
Decentralized - Central & local planning - strategic planning at the central level - municipal & urban planning - regulatory planning
Planning Activities
Planning Documents Central level: - Spatial plan of Kosovo - Spatial plans for special areas Local level: - Municipal Dev. Plan - Urban Dev. Plan - Regulatory Plans
2012 -
Decentralized planning process - centrally approved plans - strategic planning at central level - municipal planning, zoning - land use plans, regulatory planning
Planning Documents Central level: - Spatial plan of Kosovo - Zoning map, spatial plans for special areas Local Level: - Municipal Dev. Plan - Zoning map - Detailed Reg. Plan
0+.+)3,%"#$"&&+))%-%'%3L$%#$"$02L)%&"'$)+#)+>$92+$0+.+)3,%"#$2")$ '%:%3+.$)0"&+$31$()+$4,++'L$V%321(3$&1#&+,#$14$)"4+3L$,+'"3+.$31$ heavy traffic, the quality of pavements, obstacles on ground "#.$4"u".+$"#.$/+#+,"'$'+*+'$14$"33,"&3%*+#+))$14$32+$0'"&+>
53$ 32+$ :1:+#3H$ V%32$ 32+$ (0&1:%#/$ #+V$ )L)3+:$ V%32$ e1#%#/$ :"0)$ "#.$ #+V$ 0'"#)$ 1#$ :(#%&%0"'$ "#.$ '1&"'$ '+*+'H$ 32+$ 3")<$ %)$ 32+,+$31$.+)%/#$0'"#)$.+,%*+.$4,1:$"&3("'$)%3("3%1#)$"#.$(,-"#$ +#*%,1#:+#3"'$ #++.)>$ ;",%1()$ 0,1-'+:)$ "#.$ &2"''+#/+)$ #++.$ "#)V+,)H$-(3$:1,+$%:01,3"#3$%)$32+$&2"#/+.$"33%3(.+$"#.$3,"#)\ 0",+#&L$ 14$ 32+$ /1*+,#:+#3$ "-1(3$ 32+$ 0'"#)$ "#.$ )3,"3+/%+)>$ U*+#3("''LH$%3$%)$32+$'1&"'$&%3%e+#$V21$2")$31$.+"'$V%32$32+$.+&%)%\ 1#)$1#$&+#3,"'H$:(#%&%0"'$"#.$'1&"'$'+*+'>$5$,+#+V+.$01'%&L$31\ V",.)$32+$[("'%3L$14$(,-"#$'%4+$#++.)$31$-+$%#&1,01,"3+.>$R,1:$ /1*+,#:+#3"'$ '+*+'H$ 32+$ V%''$ "#.$ &",+$ 41,$ "$ [("'%3L$ (,-"#$ +#\ *%,1#:+#3$2")$31$-+$&'+",>$F"#L$)+&31,)$14$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#\ :+#3$ 2"*+$ -++#$ #+/'+&3+.$ "#.$ %/#1,+.$ %#$ 0'"#)$ "#.$ 01'%&L>$ 92+$ +#*%,1#:+#3H$ 2+,%3"/+H$ &('3(,+H$ )1&%"'$ .%:+#)%1#)H$ 0(-'%&$ 4"&%'%3%+)H$"&&+))%-%'%3L$"#.$:1-%'%3LH$'1&"'$h%#41,:"'i$+&1#1:%+)H$ [("'%3L$ +.(&"3%1#$ "#.$ )0"&+$ "#.$ )3,1#/$ '1&"'$ ,+0,+)+#3"3%1#$ "#.$ 3,"#)0",+#&L$ ",+$ 32+:+)$ 32"3$ .+)0+,"3+'L$ #++.$ "33+#3%1#$ "#.$0",3$14$32+$0'"##%#/$0,1&+))>
W#$c1)1*1H$32+$+)3"-'%)2:+#3$14$32+$F(#%&%0"'$G0"3%"'$M'"##%#/$ G(001,3$M,1/,":$hF(GMMi$%#$6!!B$2")$-++#$V1,<%#/$1#$&"0"&%3L$ -(%'.%#/$"#.$3,"%#%#/$14$0'"##+,)$%#$32+$.%44+,+#3$:(#%&%0"'%3%+)$ "#.$F%#%)3,L$14$U#*%,1#:+#3$"#.$G0"3%"'$M'"##%#/>$W:0'+:+#3"\ 3%1#$14$Ia\_"-%3"3$14$32+$1-Y+&3%*+)$2".$32+$"%:$31$0,1:13%#/$ 32+$&1#&+03$14$%#&'()%*+H$)3,"3+/%&$"#.$"&3%1#\1,%+#3"3+.$)0"3%"'$ "#.$ (,-"#$ 0'"##%#/$ %#$ c1)1*1H$ -+)%.+)$ 32"3$ &%*%'$ )1&%+3L$ "#.$ '1&"'$/1*+,#:+#3)$",+$-+&1:%#/$"V",+$14$32+$#++.$41,$0",3%&%\ 0"31,L$0'"##%#/$hIa\_5JW959H$6!7Ei>$X#+$14$32+%,$0,1Y+&3)$V")$ j9(,#%#/$ )0"&+)$ %#31$ 0'"&+)kH$ V2%&2$ "&<#1V'+./+.$ &2"#/+)$ %#$ )1&%+3LH$ #++.$ 41,$ /,+"3+,$ )()3"%#"-%'%3L$ "#.$ 0+10'+`)$ %#&,+\ ")+.$+Q0+&3"3%1#)$%#$,+'"3%1#$31$#+V$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$32"3$&,+"3+$ 1001,3(#%3%+)$41,$&%3%e+#)$31$+#Y1L$)1&%"'$'%4+$1(3)%.+>$92+$0,1\ Y+&3`)$"%:$V")$31$%#&,+")+$"V",+#+))H$-L$321)+$V21$/1*+,#$"#.$ +&1#1:%&"''L$.+*+'10$32+$0'"&+H$14$32+$[("'%3L$"#.$%:01,3"#&+$ 14$0(-'%&$)0"&+$hIa\_5JW959H$6!77i>$n,+"3+,$"V",+#+))$14$32+$ %:01,3"#&+$14$[("'%3L$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$%)$/,1V%#/$-(3$%:0'+:+#\ 3"3%1#$ V%321(3$ 0,1Y+&3)$ ")$ 32+)+$ %)$ )3%''$ ,",+>$ T+&+#3$ +Q":0'+)$ ",+$32+$0+.+)3,%"#%e%#/$14$F132+,$92+,+)"$J1('+*",.H$#+V$0"\ *+:+#3)$",1(#.$0",3$14$32+$&+#3+,H$,+#1*"3%1#$14$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$ ",1(#.$,+'%/%1()$-(%'.%#/)$"#.$):"''$/,++#$)0"&+)$%#$)+'+&3+.$ #+%/2-1,211.)>$ G3,(&3(,"'$ "#.$ )3,"3+/%&$ *%)%1#)$ 1#$ 4"&%'%3"3%1#$ 14$0(-'%&$'%4+$32,1(/21(3$32+$&%3L$",+$)3%''$)3+0)$31$3"<+>$U))+#3%"'$ ",+$%.+")$41,$32+$.+#)+$#+%/2-1,211.)$32"3$V+,+$"44+&3+.$32+$ :1)3$V%32$32+$(#,+/('"3+.$.+*+'10:+#3$"43+,$32+$V",>
U)32+,$ P2",'+)V1,32$ h6!!8iH$ 5))1&%"3+$ M,14+))1,$ "3$ 32+$ T1L"'$ Melbourne Institute of Technology, researched many conflict "44+&3+.$ 0'"&+)$ %#$ 32+$ 0,+*%1()$ .+&".+>$ G2+$ %#.%&"3+)$ "$ #+\ cessary shift in post-conflict urban planning, by making the 0'"##%#/$ 0,1&+))$ "#$ %#)3,(:+#3$ 41,$ +)3"-'%)2%#/$ 0+"&+$ "#.$ ,+-(%'.%#/$ "$ )()3"%#"-'+$ )1&%+3L>$ W3$ %)$ ,+-(%'.%#/$ 14$ 32+$ -(%'.$ +#*%,1#:+#3$V%32$+:02")%)$1#$32+$)1&%"'$'%4+$31$,+&1#&%'+>$W3$%)$ 32+$)2%43$31V",.)$32+$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#$14$32+$)1&%+3L>$W#$1,.+,$31$ "&2%+*+$32%)H$)2+$01%#3)$1(3$32,++$0,%#&%0'+)$32"3$&"#$/(%.+$32+$ 0'"##%#/$ 0,1&+))$ 31V",.)$ "#$ %:0,1*+:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ %#$ "$:1,+$)3,"3+/%&$V"L$V%32$'1#/$3+,:$+)3"-'%)2%#/$4(#.":+#3)>$ @Z
‘Free’ market economy - M1)3\7ZZZ$9(,-1$O$4")3$(,-"#%):H$V%32$ %3)$ 3L0%&"'$ )+'4\,+/('"3%1#$ 0,1&+))$ %)$ #13$ Y()3$ "#$ +'+:+#3$ ,+)('\ 3%#/$4,1:$32+$"&&+'+,"3+.$1*+,-(%'.$&%3L$0'"##%#/$V%32$%3)$41(#\ ."3%1#)$ %#$ '"&<$ 14$ )3"3+$ ,+/('"3%1#)>$ W3$ %)$ "')1$ 32+$ ,+)('3$ 14$ 32+$ specific economic situation. A major change in the economic )L)3+:$%)$+[("''L$,+)01#)%-'+$41,$32+$%#41,:"'$V"L$32+$.+*+'10\ :+#3$ 0,1&+))$ 2"00+#+.>$ 92+$ 1'.$ 0'"##+.$ G1&%"'%)3$ +&1#1:L$ 3,"#)41,:+.$%#31$"$:",<+3$+&1#1:L>
The following principles are described here briefly. $ M1'%3%&"'$"#.$U32#%&$&1''"-1,"3%1#\$U)3"-'%)2%#/$"$4,":+$41,$&1'\ '"-1,"3%1#$-+3V++#$.%44+,+#3$"&31,)$%)$+))+#3%"'$%#$0'"##%#/$)%3(\ ations in general. In the case of post-conflict planning, this col\ '"-1,"3%1#$%)$+*+#$:1,+$&,%3%&"'$.(+$31$.%44+,+#3$+32#%&$/,1(0)$ '%*%#/$%#$&'1)+$0,1Q%:%3L$31$+"&2$132+,>$F%#1,%3%+)H$4,1:$.%44+,+#3$ -"&</,1(#.)$2"*+$*",%1()$+32%&"'$)3"#.",.)$"#.$#1,:)>$I#.+,\ )3"#.%#/$14$32+$.%44+,+#3$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$%)$+))+#3%"'$%#$"*1%.%#/$ new conflicts. The political power, which normally presents the :"Y1,$+32#%&$/,1(0H$)21('.$"&3$31$32+$#++.)$14$"''$&1#&+,#+.>$ W3$")<)$0,14+))%1#"')$31$)++<$,+'"3%1#$V%32$^#1#\)0"3%"'`$+Q0+,3)$ in order to tackle other problem fields by reconstruction the )0"3%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3>
Market economy is described by the following definition of The 5:+,%&"#$_+,%3"/+$a+V$K%&3%1#",L$14$&('3(,"'$'%3+,"&Lb ^5#$ +&1#1:L$ %#$ V2%&2$ 32+$ /,+"3+,$ 0",3$ 14$ 0,1.(&3%1#H$ .%)3,%\ -(3%1#H$"#.$+Q&2"#/+$%)$&1#3,1''+.$-L$%#.%*%.("')$"#.$0,%*"3+\ 'L$1V#+.$&1,01,"3%1#)$,"32+,$32"#$-L$32+$/1*+,#:+#3H$"#.$%#$ V2%&2$/1*+,#:+#3$%#3+,4+,+#&+$%#$32+$:",<+3$%)$:%#%:"'`>
M(-'%&$&1#)('3"3%1#$\$K+:1&,"3%&$0'"##%#/$2")$")$&1,+$+'+:+#3H$ %#*1'*%#/$"#.$+#/"/%#/$32+$0(-'%&$%#$32+$0'"##%#/$0,1&+))>$92+$ 0(-'%&$%)$32+$1#+$,+&1/#%e%#/$32+$0,1-'+:)$"#.$#++.)$"#.$V2"3$ )21('.$ 2"*+$ 0,%1,%3L>$ ^J1331:\(0`$ 0,1&+))+)$ ",+$ 32+,+$ 31$ )++$ 32+$+))+#3%"'$#++.)$14$)1&%+3L$"#.$31$&,+"3+$"$'+/%3%:"3+$)()3"%\ #"-'+$ 0'"#>$ W#*1'*%#/$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ "#.$ :"<%#/$ 32+:$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ 0'"##%#/$0,1&+))H$&,+"3+)$"$-")%)$41,$"$)(&&+))4('$%:0'+:+#3"\ 3%1#$"#.$'1#/$3+,:$4(#&3%1#%#/$14$"$0,1Y+&3>
92+$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ %#3+,*+#%#/$ ".:%#%)3,"3%1#$ )(001,3+.$ #+1'%\ -+,"'$+&1#1:%&$0,%#&%0'+)$"43+,$32+$V",$%#$7ZZZH$32"3$+Q0+,%+#\ &+.$V+"<$41,:"'$)3,(&3(,+)$.(+$31$32+$1,/"#%e"3%1#$0,1&+))+)$14$ 321)+$#+V$)3"3+$%#)3%3(3%1#)>$92%)$3,%//+,+.$"#$+&1#1:L$+))+#\ 3%"''L$.1:%#"3+.$-L$%#41,:"'$#+3V1,<)$14$'1&"'$%#*+)31,)>$W3$V")$ only in the first few years that Kosovo was experiencing growth -L$32+$+Q0"#.%#/$+&1#1:L>$_1V+*+,H$32+$+&1#1:L$.+0+#.+.$ (01#$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$.1#1,)$"#.$32+$c1)1*1\5'-"#%"#$.%")01,">$ 91."LH$ )3%''$ :"#L$ 4":%'%+)$ )(,*%*+$ 1#$ )(001,3$ 14$ 32+$ .%")01,"$ '%*%#/$%#$]+)3+,#$U(,10+>$5#$+)3%:"3+.$E!!>!!!$\$8!!>!!!$c1\ )1*1\5'-"#%"#)$'%*+$%#$&1(#3,%+)$'%<+$n+,:"#LH$GV%3e+,'"#.$"#.$ Austria, that is between one fifth to one third of the population. According to estimates from the Kosovar Ministry of finance "#.$U&1#1:LH$3,"#)4+,,+.$:1#+L$4,1:$.%")01,"$&1(#3)$41,$(0$ 31$B!o$14$32+$21()+$21'.$%#&1:+)$%#$c1)1*1$%#$6!!6>
M%'13$ 0,1Y+&3)$ \$ R1,$ 32+$ '")3$ +'+:+#3H$ P2",'+)V1,32$ %)$ )"L%#/b$ j92+$)(&&+))4('$:+,/%#/$14$32+1,L$V%32$0,"&3%&+$%#$32+$01)3\,+\ covery field is a rare phenomenon, an enormous gap still exists -+3V++#$ "&".+:%&$ &,%3%[(+)$ "#.$ "#L$ *%)%-'+$ %:0,1*+:+#3$ 14$ 32+%,$ 02L)%&"'$ +#*%,1#:+#3k>$ 5$ &1(#3+,"&3%1#$ %)$ 32+$ %#3,1.(&\ 3%1#$ 14$ 0%'13$ 0,1Y+&3)$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ -,%./+$ 32+$ /"0$ -+3V++#$ 32+$ "&".+:%&$ &,%3%[(+)$ "#.$ 32+$ "&3("'$ )%3("3%1#>$ W3$ &"#$ -,%#/$ 32+$ 0'"##%#/$0,1&+))$31$"#$1(3&1:+$"#.$3+)3$%3H$-+)%.+)$32"3$%3$&"#$ -+$"$)21V&")+$31$32+$0(-'%&>
F1#+L$V")$:1)3'L$%#*+)3+.$%#$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$)+&31,$h;1+&<+,H$ 6!!Ai>$G11#$:"#L$0+10'+$V"#3+.$31$0",3%&%0"3+$%#$32%)$+&1#1\ my and tried to gain some profit or at least an income out of it.
The second expert on post-conflict development is Gert Jun\ #+$h6!77q$6!!BiH$M,14+))1,$"3$32+$I#%*+,)%3L$14$5:)3+,.":>$_+$ +Q0'"%#)$ 32"3$ 32+$ 41&()$ 41,$ 32+$ (,-"#$ .+*+'10:+#3$ )21('.$ -+$ "%:+.$"3$4"&%'%3"3%#/$32+$)1&%+3L$%#$1,.+,$31$&,+"3+$)1&%"'$&12+)%\ 1#>$92+$.+*+'10:+#3$0,1&+))$%#$32+$"43+,:"32$%)$&2","&3+,%e+.$ -L$"$:"%#'L$0,%*"3+$.+*+'10:+#3$V%32$"#$%#.%*%.("'$0+,)0+&3%*+$ %#$:%#.H$32%)$%)$.(+$31$01'%3%&"'$,+\+)3"-'%)2:+#3$14$32+$/1*+,#\ :+#3"'$%#)3%3(3%1#)$V2%&2$2"*+$-++#$)+*+,+'L$.":"/+.>$g(##+$ h6!77i$:"<+)$&'+",$32"3$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3$)21('.$,+41&()$ 1#$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$32"3$&"#$-+$&2"##+'+.$V%32$0)L&2%&"'$ 0'"&+:+#3$ 14$ -(%'.%#/)$ "#.$ )0"&+)>$ ]2%&2$ :+"#)$ 32"3$ )0"3%"'$ 0'"##%#/$ 1#$ 32+$ ):"''$ )&"'+$ 2")$ "$ '13$ 31$ .1$ V%32$ 32+$ 0'"##%#/$ 0,1&+))H$"'321(/2$#13$"'V"L)$.%,+&3'L$2")$"$*%)%-'+$02L)%&"'$4+\ ature. Besides that, in the spatial organization of post-conflict ",+")$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+)$ "#.$ -(%'.%#/)$ ",+$ 143+#$ '"&<%#/$ %#$ (,-"#$ areas in the aftermath of a conflict. Rebuilding and construction 3"<+)$)0"&+)$32"3$-+41,+$V+,+$()+.$-L$32+$0(-'%&$"#.$V+,+$0",3$ 14$ 32+$ )1&%"'$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+$ 14$ 32+$ &%3L>$ 5$ 4+V$ 14$ 2%)$ *%)%1#)$ 1#$ the urban landscape of a post-conflict area are concrete spatial %.+")> $ F"<+$0'"&+)$"."03"-'+$\$5$:1,+$:('3%0(,01)+$14$-(%'.%#/)$",+$ (,/+#3$%#$1,.+,$31$"."03$31$32+$&2"#/%#/$)1&%+3L$"#.$)21('.$-+$ 0(3$1#$32+$"/+#."$14$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$%#*1'*+.$%#$)(001,3%#/$&%\ ties after conflict. The character of an urban area in contempo\ ,",L$41,:H$%)$32+$,"0%.$&2"#/%#/$14$0,%1,%3%+)$"#.$#++.)H$V2%&2$ need to be accommodated. A flexible use of new buildings and )0"&+)$&1#)3,(&3+.$%)$%#$1,.+,> K+)3,(&3%1#$01))%-%'%3%+)$\$92+$.+)3,(&3%1#$32"3$2")$3"<+#$0'"&+$ "')1$/%*+)$01))%-%'%3%+)$41,$#+V$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$V2+,+$0+10'+$&"#$ %#3+,"&3>$G++$32+$"'3+,+.$'"#.)&"0+$")$"#$1001,3(#%3L$41,$4(3(,+$ new social systems and cherish places that at first sight seem difficult to change. F('3%'"L+,$%#&'()%*+$#+3V1,<$\$92+$:('3%'"L+,$+:-+..+.#+))$14$ (,-"#$"#.$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$%)$#+&+))",L$31$-,%#/$31/+32+,$ 32+$ %#.%*%.("'$+441,3)$14$"&31,)$"#.$%.+"')>$W#&'(.+$32+$&2"#/+.$:('\ 3%&('3(,"'$)1&%+3L$%#31$32+$.%44+,+#3$'"L+,)$14$32+$(,-"#$)L)3+:>
92%)$ .+*+'10:+#3H$ V2%&2$ U.V",.$ S(33V"<$ &"''$ ^9(,-1$ P"0%3"\ '%):`H$ &"#$ -+$ &2","&3+,%e+.$ -L$ "$ 3L0+$ 14$ &"0%3"'%)3$ +&1#1:%&)$ aiming for pure efficiency and maximum profit on a global sca\ '+>$ 92+$ .+,+/('"3%1#$ &1,,+)01#.)$ 31$ 32+$ ,%)%#/$ +:+,/+#&+$ 14$ ‘informality,’ happening specifically in the labor sector, which "."03)$31$#+V$&1#.%3%1#)>$ W#$32+$.%,+&3$"43+,:"32$"#.$'")3%#/$(#3%'$32+$/1*+,#:+#3"'$.+\ &%)%1#$31$)310$"''$&1#)3,(&3%1#$%#$6!7@H$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$)+&31,$ gave a majority of the Kosovars a chance to achieve financial /"%#>$92+$.+&%)%1#$%#$6!7@$2")$%#&,+")+.$32+$#(:-+,$14$(#+:\ 0'1L:+#3$ V2%&2$ ,1)+$ 31V",.)$ @Bo$ "#.$ +*+#$ (0$ 31$ A!o$ V%32$ L1(#/$".('3)$h]1,'.$J"#<H$6!!!\6!7EH$Ia\2"-%3"3H$6!7Ai>$92%)$ %)$"$)+,%1()$%))(+$"#.$+&1#1:%&$:%/,"3%1#$%)$*+,L$0,+)+#3$32+)+$ ."L)$ hRUGH$ 6!7Bi>$ W#$ 32"3$ &")+H$ %3$ -+&1:+)$ "$ :1,"'$ 310%&H$ %:\ 0,1*%#/$)%3("3%1#)$%#$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3$1,$%/#1,+$"#.$'+3$ &1#)3,(&3%1#)$&1#3%#(+$V2%&2$/%*+$+:0'1L:+#3$31$"$'",/+$0",3$ 14$)1&%+3L> Public aversion / lack of care \$ 92+$ )%3("3%1#$ ,+/",.%#/$ 32+$ (,-"#$ &1#.%3%1#)$ %#$ "..%3%1#$ 31$ 32+$ 0,+*%1()'L$ :+#3%1#+.$ post-conflict processes and situations is also socially embed\ .+.$ %#$ 32+$ )L)3+:>$ W#$ 1,.+,$ 41,$ 0'"##%#/$ 0,1&+))$ "#.$ 01'%&%+)$ 31$ "&2%+*+$ 01)%3%*+$ 1(3&1:+$ 32+L$ #++.$ 31$ -+$ "."03+.$ 31$ 32+$ specific social context. This social context: the behavior of peo\ 0'+$V%32%#$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3H$32+$)1&%"'$"#.$&1::(#"'$,+)\ 01#)%-%'%3L$%)$V1,32$:+#3%1#%#/>$92+$'",/+'L$%#.%*%.("'$0,1&+)\ )+)$")$1001)+.$31$"$0,1&+))$32"3$%#&1,01,"3+)$32+$)1&%+3L$")$"$ V21'+H$-(3$:"%#'L$32+$"33%3(.+$31V",.)$32+$0(-'%&$1,$&1::(#"'$ %)$%#2+,%3+.$4,1:$32+$0+,%1.$%#$32+$7ZZ!)>$92+$0+,%1.$-+3V++#$ 7ZZ7$"#.$7ZZZH$G+,-%"$&1#.(&3+.$"#$"':1)3$.%&3"31,%"'$,+/%:+>$ 92%)$&1#3"%#+.$)3,%&3$,('+)$"#.$,+)3,%&3%1#)$41,$"''$c1)1*1\5'-"\ #%"#)$,+/",.%#/$32+$0+,41,:"#&+$%#$32+$0(-'%&$)+&31,>$W#$"#$%#\ 3+,*%+V$V%32$U'%e"$_1Q2"H$3+"&2+,$"3$32+$I#%*+,)%3L$14$M,%)23%#"H$ )2+$+Q0'"%#)$32+$)%3("3%1#$)2+$"#.$2+,$4":%'L$"#.$V%32$2+,$:"#L$ 132+,)$+Q0+,%+#&+.$%#$32"3$0+,%1.>
E!
STRENGTHS
Young cosmopolitan population Entrepreneurial spirit & variation of buissines Rich cultural background Unique urban landscape Adaption to transitions
WEAKNESSES
Mobility of the society Unemployment rate Lack of environmental protection Unstructured streetproďŹ les§ Public Policies
01. Governmental Integration & Co-operation
02. Public Accessibility
03. Community & Society Interplay renewed public focus 04. Environmental & Cultural facilitation
Geographical walkability Possibilities in renewal of public grounds Attraction of the urban core New networks of local economy
OPPORTUNITIES
05. Knowledge & Economic Stimulation
Social hertiage Unstable public government Untransparent policy making Uncorrect population census Public care and social behaviour
06. Historical and contemporary Identity
THREATS
Fig. 30 SWOT- results
Fig. 31 The renewed public policy
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
%#$"$:1,+$&1::(#%3L$)+#)+$"#.$,+)01#)%-%'%3L$41,$)(,,1(#.%#/$ &1#.%3%1#)>
92+$0(-'%&H$"#.$)1$32+$)3,++3)$V+,+$#13$)++#$")$32+%,)$"#.$#13$ 1(,)$ "#L:1,+>$ 92%)$ V")$ )++#$ ")$ 32+$ )3"3+H$ G+,-%"$ "#.$ )1$ 32+$ +#+:L>$W#$32+$&1#3+:01,",L$&%3LH$32%)$%)$#13$32+$&")+$"#L:1,+$ -(3$32+)+$144+#)%*+$%.+")$"-1(3$32+$0(-'%&$",+$#13$/1#+>$92+L$ .1$#13$&",+$"-1(3$32+)+$)0"&+)>$W3$%)$"$2"-%3H$"$-,1<+#$'%#<$14$ 0(-'%&$"#.$32+$&1''+&3%*+$/11.$%)$#13$32+,+>$92%)$%)$)3%''$*+,L$*%)%\ -'+$%#$0",3)$14$M,%)3%#">$d1($V%''$)++$0+10'+$3"<%#/$&",+$14$)0"&+$ not further then their threshold. They define it, wall it, put up 4+#&+)>$G1H$L1($2"*+$"''$32+)+$#%&+$)013)$1,$%)'"#.)$%#$M,%)23%#"$ "#.$%#$-+3V++#$"$'13$14$(#V"#3+.$)0"&+)>$_1V$&"#$V+$&2"#/+$ 32+$)%3("3%1#$41,$0+10'+$31$10+#$32+%,$:%#.$"#.$&2"#/+$"$'%33'+$ 14$32+%,$-+2"*%1,$"#.$-+&1:+$:1,+$10+#$31$32+$0(-'%&f$U*+,L\ -1.L$&1#3,%-(3+)$31$32"3$%#$.%44+,+#3$V"L)H$-(3$%4$L1($.1$#132%#/$ "3$'+")3$.1$#13$.+)3,1L$%3$1,$'%33+,>$92%)$%)$"#$(,-"#$:+#3"'%3L$"#.$ 32%)$)21('.$-+$,+)2"0+.$-%3$-L$-%3$+Q0'"%#)$U'%e"$_1Q">
92+$41''1V%#/$)%Q$32+:+)$#++.$31$-+$"..,+))+.$V%32%#$32+$.+\ *+'10:+#3$14$32+$.+)%/#$"#.$V%32%#$32+%,$,+"&2$",+$14$)(-)3"#\ tial influence regarding the public life and realm of a neigh\ -1,211.>$
5#$%:01,3"#3$4"&31,$%#$32%)$41,$32+$4(3(,+$%)$32+$,+\+)3"-'%)2%#/$ 14$32+$0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$,+'"3%1#)2%0>$92+$3,"#)0",+#&LH$0(-'%&$01\ '%&%+)$"#.$/+#+,"'$)3"3+$,+)01#)%-%'%3L$-+'1#/$%#$"#$4(3(,+$)3,"3+\ /L$"#.$0'"##%#/$&1#&+03>$n1*+,#:+#3$"#.$0(-'%&$-1.%+)$#++.$ 31$ .+:1#)3,"3+$ 32+%,$ ,+#+V+.$ %#3+,+)3$ %#$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ "#.$ 32+$ quality urban environment first, but this needs to be taken to 32+$#+%/2-1,211.)$1#$"$'1&"'$)&"'+>$ Conclusion towards the public goods focus M,1&+))+)$%#$32+$"43+,:"32$2"*+$&2"#/+.$32+$(,-"#$4"-,%&$.,")\ 3%&"''L$ %#$ M,%)23%#">$ 92+$ #+/"3%*+$ +44+&3)$ ",+$ &2"''+#/%#/$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$14$"$&%3L$31V",.)$"$'%*"-'+$"#.$:"L-+$+*+#$)()\ 3"%#"-'+$ 4(3(,+>$ 92+$ 0,1-'+:)$ 31$ 3"&<'+$ 2"*+$ /,1V#$ 1*+,$ 32+$ L+",)$"#.$)1'(3%1#)$31$&2"#/+$32+$)%3("3%1#$2"*+$$-++#$:%#%:"'>$ P'+",$%)$32"3$4,1:$"''$)%.+)$14$32+$)1&%+3L$"$&2"#/+$%)$%#$1,.+,$ 31$ 0,+*+#3$ 4(,32+,$ .+&,+")+$ 14$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ "#.$ :"%#3+#"#&+$ "3$'+")3$14$)(,*%*+.$2%)31,L>$F+"#V2%'+H$"00,+&%"3%1#$14$32+$0+\ ,%1.$ )21('.$ :"<+$ 0+"&+$ V%32$ 32+$ 0")3>$ W3$ 41,:+.$ 32+$ &%3L$ ")$ %3$ %)H$ V2%&2$ %)$ "$ [("'%3L$ 311>$ R,1:$ 32%)$ )3(.LH$ 0,%1,%3%+)$ V%32%#$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ 4,1:$ "#$ 01'%&L$ "#.$ /1*+,#"#&+$ '+*+'$ &"#$ 2+'0$ &2"#/+$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ %#$ 32+$ 4(3(,+>$ 92+)+$ V%''$ /(%.+$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$.+)%/#$"#.$",+$3+)3+.$1#$32+$)%3("3%1#$14$ K1.1#"$#+%/2-1,211.>
92+$0(-'%&$'%4+$41&()$2")$32+$41''1V%#/$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)b n1*+,#:+#3"'$%#3+/,"3%1#$N$P1\10+,"3%1# M(-'%&$"&&+))%-%'%3L$N$:1-%'%3L c#1V'+./+$N$+&1#1:%&$)3%:('"3%1# P1::(#%3L$N$G1&%+3L$%#3+,0'"L _%)31,%&"'$N$4(3(,+$W.+#3%3L U#*%,1#:+#3"'$N$P('3(,"'$4"&%'%3"3%1# 92+)+$ %3+:)$ )21('.$ -+$ <+L$ 41&()$ 32+:+)$ .(+$ 31$ 32+%,$ .%,+&3$ ,+'"3%1#$31$0(-'%&$.1:"%#)$14$"#$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3>$92+%,$%:\ 0'+:+#3"3%1#O%#3+/,"3%1#$V%32%#$32+$(,-"#$",+")$&"#$-+$")$"&\
92+$ 4":%'L$ -")+.$ 3,".%3%1#)$ %)$ "$ V+''\)2"0+.$ )L)3+:$ -(3$ '"&<)$ E7
tual physical design or either a first step in the change of the 0'"##%#/$01'%3%&"'$'"#.)&"0+$V1,<%#/$1#$32+$0(-'%&$/,1(#.)> Governmental integration & Co-operation 92+$0'"##%#/$"#.$.+*+'10:+#3$.+0",3:+#3$1#$:(#%&%0"'$"#.$ (,-"#$ )&"'+$ %)$ %#$ #++.$ 14$ 32%#<%#/$ %#$ "$ &1\10+,"3%*+$ V"L>$ 92+$ 01. 0,%*"3%e+.$0,1&+))+)$14$32+$0")3$78$L+",)$2"*+$:".+$"$/"0$-+\ Governmental 3V++#$32+$)1&%+3L$"#.$32+$)3"3+>$X#$32+$(,-"#$)&"'+$"$*",%+3L$ Integration & Co-operation 14$01'%&L$"#.$)0"3%"'$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$#++.$32+$2"00+#$%#$1,.+,$31$ .+&,+")+$32+$/"0)$"#.$011,$)%3("3%1#)$41,$%3)$%#2"-%3"#3)$V2+#$ %3$&1:+)$31$'%*"-%'%3L$14$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3>$910%&)$")$)1&%"'$ "#.$&('3(,"'$4,"/:+#3"3%1#H$'%:%3+.$3,"#)0",+#&L$%#$01'%&L$:"\ 02. <%#/$"#.$(,-"#$.+*+'10:+#3H$011,$(,-"#$.%)3,%&3$&1\10+,"3%1#$ Public Accessibility "#.$ %#3+/,"'$ 32%#<%#/$ "#.$ .+&%)%1#$ :"<%#/>$ G:"''+,$ .+&%)%1#$ :"<%#/$'+*+')$1#$#+%/2-1,211.$'+*+'$#++.$31$-+$,+0,+)+#3+.$ '1&"''L$"#.$V1,<$1#$%#3+/,"3%1#$14$-1,.+,%#/$",+")>$$F1,+1*+,H$ 32+$/1*+,#:+#3)$1-Y+&3%*+$)21('.$V1,<$31V",.)$/+#+,"3%#/$"$ 01. 03. &12+)%*+$)0"&+> Governmental Community & Society Interplay Integration & Co-operation Public accessibility & mobility 92+$.+&,+")%#/$[("'%3L$'+*+'$14$0(-'%&$"&&+))%-%'%3L$"#.$:1-%'%3L$ renewed public focus .+:"#.)$"$,+#+V+.$0'"#$"#.$)3,"3+/L$41,$32+$&%3L$31$3,"#)%3%1#$ 01.02. 31V",.)$"$0(-'%&$4,%+#.'L$)0"&+>$M2L)%&"'$"&&+))$31$)3,++3)H$-(%'\ 04. Governmental Public Accessibility .%#/)$"#.$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$%)$14$011,$[("'%3L>$J'1&<%#/$"&&+))$.(+$ Environmental & Cultural facilitation Integration & Co-operation 31$ &",$ 0",<%#/H$ )3"%,)$ 1#$ )%.+V"'<)$ "#.$ -,1<+#$ 0"*+:+#3)$ .1$ #++.$ "$ )3,"3+/L>$ R(#&3%1#"'$ "&&+))$ 31$ )+,*%&+)$ "#.$ (3%'%3%+)$ 1#$ V"'<%#/$.%)3"#&+$#++.$-+33+,$,+0,+)+#3"3%1#>$n+#+,"'$:1-%'%3L$ 01. 14$"''$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$%)$.+)%,+.> 02.03. Governmental 05. Public Accessibility Community & Society Interplay Integration & Co-operation Knowledge & Economic Stimulation Community & Society interplay In a drastically changed social situation and 01. a recent conflict Governmental renewed:1,+$ public/,1(0)$ focus .+:"#.)$ %#3+,*+#%#/$ %#$ -+3V++#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ :"<+$ Integration & Co-operation 02. "$0'"#$31$:1*+$41,V",.>$UQ3+#)%*+$0,1/,":)$)21('.$"'V"L)$-+$ 03. Public 04.Accessibility 0",3$ 14$ 01'%&L$ %#$ )(&2$ )%3("3%1#)>$ G3,+#/32+#%#/$ 32+$ 14$Society Interplay 01. Community 06. )+#)+$ & Environmental & Cultural facilitation &1::(#%3L$"#.$32+$4++'%#/$14$-+'1#/%#/$%)$(,/+#3>$92+$%#.%*%\ Governmental Historical and contemporary Identity .("'$.+*+'10:+#3$2")$.+&,+")+.$32%)$%))(+>$G3%:('"3%1#$14$3,%\ Integration & Co-operation 02. "#/('"3%1#$1#$"$&,1))\#+%/2-1,211.$'+*+'$-(3$")$V+''$1#$):"'\ renewed public focus Public Accessibility '+,$)&"'+)$&"#$+#2"#&+$"$:('3%\)1&%"'$&1::(#%3L>$ 03. 04. Community & Society Interplay 05. 02. Environmental & Cultural facilitation Environmental Cultural facilitation Knowledge &&Economic Stimulation Public 5&&+))$ 31$ 2+"'32L\#1#\-(%'.$ ",+")$ )(&2$ ")$ 0",<)$ "#.$Accessibility /",.+#)$ 03. renewed public focus V%32%#$32+$(,-"#$4"-,%&$&"#$/%*+$"$)+#)+$14$4,++$-,+"32%#/>$UQ%)\ Community & Society Interplay 3%#/$0'"&+)$#++.$,+*%3"'%e"3%1#$"#.$4(,32+,$32+$+Q3+#)%1#$14$321\ )+$)0"&+$V%32%#$32+$4"-,%&>$92+$&1:0+#)"3%1#$14$32+$1*+,-(%'.$ 04. 05.31$ &,+"3+$ "$ "#.$ )1'%.$ /,1(#.)$ Environmental & Cultural facilitation 06. renewed public focus #++.$ 31$ -+$ "..,+))+.$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 03. Knowledge & Economic Stimulation '%*"-'+$ 4"-,%&>$ X#$ &('3(,"'$ /,1(#.)H$ :1,+$ )0"&+$ %)$Historical %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ contemporary Community &and Society Interplay Identity 0+,41,:$32+$)1&%+3%+)$"))+3)$"#.$2%)31,L>$a+V$"&3%*%3%+)$&"#$+#\ 04. ,%&2$32+$'1&"'$'%4+> Environmental & Cultural facilitation renewed public focus 05. Knowledge & economic stimulation 06. Knowledge & Economic Stimulation 04. W#$1#+$14$32+$011,+)3$&1(#3,%+)$14$U(,10+H$32+$+&1#1:L$1#$32+$ Historical and contemporary Identity Environmental ):"''+)3$ )&"'+$ #++.$ 31$ -+$ )(001,3+.>$ J+)%.+)$ 32"3H$ 32+$ (0&1\& Cultural facilitation 05. :%#/$V1,<41,&+$#++.$31$-+$0,+0",+.$41,$32+$0,14+))%1#"'$'%4+>$ & Economic Stimulation G(001,3%#/$ 32+$ %#41,:"'$ "#.$ :%&,1$ +&1#1:L$Knowledge -L$ <#1V'+./+H$ )0"&+)$"#.$#+3V1,<)$&"#$+#2"#&+$32+$0(-'%&$'%*"-%'%3L>$P1\V1,\ 06. <%#/$ 0'"&+)$ "#.$ )3(.+#3\0,14+))%1#"'$ #+3V1,<)$05. &"#$ )3%:('"3+$ Historical and contemporary Identity #+%/2-1,211.$+&1#1:%+)> Knowledge & Economic Stimulation 06. Historical & future Identity Historical and contemporary Identity ]%32$ 32+$ )+*+,"'$ 3,"#)%3%1#)$ 1*+,$ 32+$ L+",)`$ %.+#3%3L$ %)$ "$ 0,1\ blem. The image of post-conflict places is not attracting most 14$ 32+$ 010('"3%1#>$ 5$ ,+#+V+.$ 32%#<%#/$ "#.$ :",<+3%#/$ 14$ 32+$ 06. (#%[(+$ (,-"#$ '"#.)&"0+$ "#.$ '%4+$ &"#$ 3,"#)41,:$ 32+$ #+/"3%*+$ Historical and contemporary Identity *%+V$14$32+)+$'1&"3%1#)>$J+)%.+)$32"3H$%3$&,+"3+)$"$)+#)+$14$-+\ '1#/%#/$31$"$0'"&+$V2%&2$32+L$",+$0,1(.$14>$92+$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$ "#.$ '%4+$ &"#$ )2"0+$ "$ #+V$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ "#.$ %3)$ ,+&1/#%e"-'+$ '+*+'>$T+0+3%3%1#$14$+'+:+#3)H$-")%&$)2"0+)$"#.$&1'1,)$"#.$&'+",$ *%)%1#$&"#$"33,"&3$+*+,L-1.L$V%32%#$32+$0,1&+))> 92+)+$A$32+:+)$V%''$/(%.+$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$.+)%/#$"#.$ V%''$-+$3,"#)'"3+.$%#31$"$)0"3%"'$"/+#."$V2%&2$&"#$-+$%:0'+:+#\ 3+.$V%32%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.> Fig. 32 Developed strategic themes
E6
Require quality of public space
Passive optional activities
Acitve optional activities
Improvement of public space Disregard quality of public space Car invasion Necessary activities 1880
1890
1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
General line of development of Public Life in Europe Estimated developent of Public Life in Kosovo
Fig. 33 Development of public life since 1880 "."03+.$4,1:$a+V$PW3L$S%4+H$hn+2'H$6!!Ai
4.2 PUBLIC THEORY
V")$41,$&+#3(,%+)$%#$32+$2%)31,%&$&%3%+)$hn+2'$N$G*",,+H$6!7@i>$ K(,%#/$32+$C!`)$"#.$Z!`)H$32+$)3(.%+)$-+&":+$"$)3,"3+/%&$ 311'$V2+#$h,+i.+*+'10%#/$&%3%+)>$U*+#$321(/2H$32+$,%)+$14$32+$ %#.%*%.("'$",&2%3+&3$"#.$%3)$%&1#%&$-(%'.%#/)$'+43$32+$)0"&+$ -+3V++#$32+$-(%'.%#/)$(#31(&2+.H$%#$"$#(:-+,$14$&%3%+)$0(-'%&$ )0"&+$0'"##%#/$V")$#1V$0",3$14$32+$&%3%+)$01'%&%+)>$M,+)+#3$ ."LH$)3(.%+)$14$0(-'%&$'%4+$",+$+))+#3%"'$%#$0'"##%#/$/11.$&%3%+)>$ W#&'(.%#/$.%,+&3'L$32+$&%3%e+#)$%#$0,1Y+&3)$31."LH$-,%#/)$32+$0(\ -'%&$'%4+$)3(.%+)$&'1)+,$31$32+$)1&%+3LH$V2+#$32+L$",+$%#*1'*+.$%#$ 32+$3,"#)41,:"3%1#$0,1&+))>$]%32$:1,+$0+10'+$'%*%#/$%#$&%3%+)H$ <#1V'+./+$"-1(3$32+$'%4+$"#.$%#3+,"&3%1#)$V%32$)0"&+$%#$&%3%+)$ %)$0,%1,%3L$%#$:"<%#/$/11.$'%*%#/$0'"&+)$41,$+*+,L1#+H$+)0+&%"'\ 'L$%#$32+$.+*+'10%#/$&1(#3,%+)$hn+2'$N$T1/+,)H$6!7@i>
Renewed public policy? - Post-conflict development pro\ &+))+)$%#$32+$-(%'.$+#*%,1#:+#3$)21V$"$&'+",$#+/'+&3$41,$32+$ 0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$/11.$0'"##%#/$%#)3,(:+#3)$41,$+)3"-'%)\ 2%#/$)1&%"'$%#4,")3,(&3(,+$"#.$0(-'%&$)+,*%&+)>$921)+$&%3%+)$ and specific certain neighborhoods, exposed to unregulated developments with solely economic reasons, show difficult )%3("3%1#)$%#$(,-"#$'%*%#/$+#*%,1#:+#3>$92%)$,"%)+)$32+$[(+)3%1#$ 14$21V$31$%:0'+:+#3$"#.$V2%&2$[("'%3%+)$"$,+#+V+.$)1&%"'$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+$)21('.$2"*+$31$&10+$V%32$1#/1%#/$.+*+'10:+#3$ 0,1&+))+)f$G3,"3+/%+)$&1#&+,#%#/$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$&1#&+03)$&"#$ 0(3$+:02")%)$1#$32+$%:01,3"#&+$14$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$"#.$ %3)$0,1)0+&3)$41,$"$#+%/2-1,211.$"#.$32+$'",/+,$&%3L>$92()H$ 32+$:"%#$"%:$14$32%)$&2"03+,$%)$31$%#*+)3%/"3+$32+$013+#3%"'$14$ the “public life” concepts in post-conflict urban design. It is a )+",&2$%#31$"00'%&"-%'%3L$14$32+$&1#&+03)H$V2%&2$",+$"%:+.$"3$ %:0,1*%#/$[("'%3L$14$(,-"#$'%*%#/H$")$"$.,%*%#/$41,&+$%#$,+-(%'\ ding a cohesive sense in a dense post conflict area.
]%32$32+$+Q0,+))%1#$14$n1,.1#$P(''+#`)$h7ZA7i$"-1(3$32+$ multifaceted city, inspired by the traditional city, signifies the 1001)%3+$.%,+&3%1#$14$V2+,+$01)3\V",$0'"##%#/$V")$/1%#/$31>$ _%)$-11<$V")$"$:"#%4+)3$14$[("'%3%+)$14$32+$3,".%3%1#"'$2%)31\ ,%&$&%3L$'"L1(3>$_1V$&"#$0'"##%#/$14$#+V$#+%/2-1,211.)$-+$ 3,"#)41,:+.$31V",.)$32+$%.+"$14$32+$2(:"#$")$&+#3,"'$+'+:+#3$ "/"%#$14$"$32,%*%#/$(,-"#$",+"f
Origin of the concept \$W#$32+$0+,%1.$31V",.)$32+$7ZA!`)$"$ &,%3%&%):$",1)+$",1(#.$32+$V1,'.$,+'"3+.$31$.+)%/#$"#.$0'"#\ #%#/$14$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3>$F1.+,#%)3%&$%.+"')$14$32"3$3%:+$ V+,+$&,%3%&%e+.$41,$%3)$#+/'+&3)$14$'%4+$%#$32+$&%3L>$a1-1.L$)++:$ 31$3"<+$&",+$14$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$"#.$32+$%#3+,"&3%1#$-+3V++#$'%4+$ "#.$)0"&+>$W#3+,+)3$V")$%#$.+)%/#%#/$/11.$:1-%'%3L$0,1/,":)H$ /,+"3$'"#.)&"0+)$"#.$0",<)$"#.$-(%'.%#/)$-L$%:01,3"#3$",&2%\ 3+&3)>$92+$'",/+$0%&3(,+$V")$'11<+.$"3$-(3$V2"3$2"00+#+.$"3$ 32+$2(:"#$)&"'+$V")$(#<#1V#$hn+2'$N$G*",,+H$6!7@i>$W3$V")$ #13$Y()3$0,14+))%1#"')$32"3$&,%3%&%e+.$32+$'"&<%#/$'%*"-%'%3L$"#.$ *%3"'%3L$14$#+V$",+")$-(3$"')1$32+$,+)%.+#3)$-+/"#$31$2"*+$ "$)3,1#/$10%#%1#>$5:1#/$&,%3%&)$V+,+$,+)+",&2+,)$32"3$V+,+$ %#3+,+)3+.$%#$V2"3$V+`,+$.,%*%#/$41,&+)$41,$,%&2$0(-'%&$'%4+$"#.$ (,-"#$)0"&+)>$5&&1,.%#/$31$32+:H$32+$:1#131#1()$-(%'.%#/)H$ 4,"/:+#3+.$4(#&3%1#)$14$&%3%+)$"#.$32+$)&"'+$V+,+$.+&,+")%#/$ )3,++3$'%4+$%#$32+$#+V$.+*+'10:+#3)>$92+$'%4+$-+3V++#$-(%'\ .%#/)$2".$-++#$41,/133+#H$%3$V")$%/#1,+.$.(+$31$32+$41&()$1#$ &",)H$'",/+$)&"'+$:")3+,0'"#)$"#.$%.+"')$"#.$,"3%1#"'%e%#/$32+$ 0,1&+))+)$%#$32+$&%3L>$92%)$&,%3%&%):$)3",3+.$-L$P":%''1$G%33+$ %#$32+$+#.$14$32+$7Z32$&+#3(,LH$V2+#$G%33+$01%#3+.$1(3$V2"3$ 32+$[("'%3%+)$14$32+$3,".%3%1#"'$&%3L$V+,+$"#.$/"*+$&,%3%&%):$31$ 32+$,"3%1#"'$0'"##%#/$31$-+$31$)3,"%/23$"#.$41,:"'>$_+$V")$#13$ .%,+&3'L$41&()+.$1#$0(-'%&$'%4+$)3(.%+)$-(3$.%.$:".+$&'+",$32+$ %:01,3"#&+$14$&,+"3%#/$)0"&+$41,$0+10'+$hG%33+H$7CCZi>$
X*+,$3%:+$.%44+,+#3$:+"#%#/)$"#.$310%&)$2"*+$Y1%#+.$32+$ )&10+$14$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$)3(.%+)>$a+V$&%,&(:)3"#&+)$"#.$ &2"#/%#/$2(:"#$0,%1,%3%+)$2"*+$+#'",/+.$32+$#13%1#$.(+$31$ %#&,+")+.$&",$.+0+#.+#&LH$#+V$3+&2#1'1/%+)H$*",%+3%+)$14$ &('3(,"'$10%#%1#)$"#.$(,-"#$:%/,"3%1#>$W3$2")$"'V"L)$-++#$32+$ "%:$41,$0(-'%&$'%4+$)3(.%+)$31$:"<+$#13%1#$14$32+$%:01,3"#&+$ 14$32+$)3(.L$14$2(:"#$-+2"*%1,$")$%:01,3"#3$")$)3(.L$02L)%&"'$ urban environment (Gehl & Svarre, 2013, p. 13). The first to :"#%4+)3$2+,)+'4$"#.$2+,$-+'%+*+)$V")$g"#+$g"&1-)$h7ZA7i>$_+,$ 0,13+)3$"/"%#)3$32+$.+&,+")%#/$'%4+$14$2(:"#)$&"()+.$-L$32+$ &",$"#.$%3)$"&&+))%-%'%3L$32,1(/21(3$32+$&%3LH$(#%3+.$"$'13$14$*1%\ &+)$%#$a+V$d1,<$P%3L>$_+,$V,%33+#$:"#%4+)3H$32+$.+"32$"#.$'%4+$ 14$/,+"3$5:+,%&"#$&%3%+)$h7ZA7iH$:".+$&'+",$%#$V2%&2$%#2(:"#+$ &%,&(:)3"#&+)$0'"&+)$V2+,+$&2"#/%#/>$G%#&+$32+#$2+,$*%)%1#)$ V+,+$()+.$")$4(#.":+#3$31$:"#L$132+,$,+)+",&2+,)$%#3+,+)3+.$ %#$0(-'%&$'%4+$32,1(/21(3$32+$L+",)> 92+$0(-'%&$'%4+$#13%1#$2")$"$V%.+$*",%+3L$14$310%&)$"#.$ &1#&+03)>$5&&1,.%#/$31$32+1,LH$4(#.":+#3"'$+'+:+#3)$",+$ %#3+,"&3%1#$h5'+Q"#.+,H$7Z88q$n+2'H$7ZC8q$g>$g"&1-)H$7ZA7q$ G+##+33H$7Z88q$]2L3+H$7ZC!-iH$.%*+,)%3L$14$4(#&3%1#)$"#.$ )0"&+)$h500'+L",.H$7ZC7q$5>$J>$g"&1-)H$7ZCBq$g>$g"&1-)H$7ZA7q$ F",&()$N$R,"#&%)H$7ZZ!iH$2(:"#$)&"'+$hn+2'H$7ZC8q$g>$g"&1-)H$ 7ZA7q$9%--"'.)H$6!!6i$H$.+#)%3L$14$010('"3%1#$h500'+L",.$N$ g"&1-)H$7ZC6q$g>$g"&1-)H$7ZA7i$H$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$hn+2'H$7ZC8q$ g>$g"&1-)H$7ZA7q$MMGH$6!!!i$H$"&3%*%3%+)$N$()+)$hn+2'H$7ZC8q$ 9%--"'.)H$6!!6iH$&%3%e+#)$+#/"/+:+#3$h500'+L",.$N$g"&1-)H$ 7ZC6q$g>$g"&1-)H$7ZA7q$MMGH$6!!!i>$g(./%#/$32+$'+*+'$14$[("'%3L$ 14$0(-'%&$'%4+$14$"$#+%/2-1,211.H$%)$'11<%#/$&,%3%&"'$"3$32+$)3"3+$ "#.$)%3("3%1#$14$32+$2(:"#$-+%#/$%#$,+'"3%1#$31$)0"&+$"#.$ -(%'.%#/)>$5,+$&%3%e+#)$"-'+$31$0+,41,:$"#.$"&3$#"3(,"''L$"#.$ feeling the comfort that they usually find in private domains.
Since the 1960’s the field of public life studies started to .+*+'10$&,%3%&"'$+'+:+#3)$41,$/11.$2(:"#$'%4+$%#$&%3%+)>$92+$ -+/%##%#/$V+,+$)3"3+:+#3)$14$&,%3%&)$1#$32+$*",%+3L$14$(#\ 2(:"#$V"L)$32+$&%3L$V")$+*1'*%#/$"#.$0,+)+#3%#/$32+$41&()$ 01%#3)$32"3$V1('.$'+".$31$-+33+,$2(:"#$'%4+>$92%)$V")$32+$)3",3$ 14$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$)3(.%+)$V%32$V1,<)$14$g"#+$g"&1-)H$g"#$n+2'H$ P2,%)3102+,$5'+Q"#.+,$"#.$]%'%":$_>$]2L3+$[(+)3%1#%#/$V2"3$ V")$#++.+.$31$%#3,1.(&+$'%4+$%#$32+$#+V$#+%/2-1,211.)$")$ E@
@E
@B
@A
Fig. 34 Attractive spaces, City Park 5.)(&%)8/ M2131$-L$"(321, Fig. 35 & 36 Jane Jacobs ideals are alive
*%)%-'+>$P1::+,&%"'$"&3%*%3%+)$'%<+$:",<+30'"&+)$V+,+$'%:%3+.H$ 32+)+$V+,+$:1,+$143+#$0,+)+#3$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.)H$V2%&2$ .+&,+")+.$32+$*%3"'%3L$14$&+#3+,)>$
5)$g"#+$g"&1-)$h7ZA7i$)"%.b$j32+,+$%)$#1$'1/%&$32"3$&"#$-+$ )(0+,%:01)+.$1#$32+$&%3Lq$0+10'+$:"<+$%3H$"#.$%3$%)$31$32+:H$ not to buildings, that we must fit our plansâ&#x20AC;?. People will use )0"&+$"#.$%3$)21('.$-+$"&&+))%-'+$31$.%44+,+#3$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$ "#.$&%3%e+#)$4,1:$.%44+,+#3$&('3(,+)$hS1VH$6!!!i>$92%)$)0"&+$ %#$.+#)+$0'"&+)$&1:+)$:1)3'L$.1V#$31$32+$)3,++3$hn+2'$N$ T1/+,)H$6!7@i>$92+$)3,++3$%#$:1)3$&")+)$%)$"$:('3%0(,01)+$ 0'"&+$V2+,+$&",H$0+.+)3,%"#H$-%<+,H$"#.$132+,)$",+$)2",%#/$ 32+$)0"&+>$W:01,3"#3$%)$32+$0"&+$%#$V2%&2$+*+,L32%#/$2"0\ 0+#)$%#$1,.+,$31$+)3"-'%)2$"$'%*+'L$)3,++3$)&"0+>$R")3$:1*%#/$ traffic is decreasing street-crossing friendships and sense of )3,++3$&1::(#%3L$h500'+L",.H$7ZC7q$9%--"'.)H$6!!6i>$n+#+\ ,"3%#/$)"4+$)3,++3)$41,$+*+,L-1.L$%)$%#$1,.+,$31$#(,3(,+$32+$ 2+3+,1/+#+1()$&1+Q%)3+#&+$"#.$.%*+,)%3L$14$0+10'+$%#$)0"&+$ hF"."#%01(,H$6!!@i>$W3$%)$32+$,+'"3%1#)$-+3V++#$32+$0(-'%&$"#.$ 0,%*"3+$)02+,+)$32"3$&,+"3+$"$)"4+$0'"&+$hF"."#%01(,H$6!!@iH$ 1,$")$g"#+$g"&1-)$&"'')$%3b$^+L+)$1#$32+$)3,++3`>$92%)$%)$32+$ ground floor edges of buildings and its functions that make ,+'"3%1#$01))%-'+$"#.$",+$0",3$14$32+$"33,"&3%1#$14$32+$0'"&+$ h5'+Q"#.+,H$7Z88q$n+2'H$7ZC8q$G+##+33H$7Z88i>$$J+)%.+)$32+$ .%44+,+#3$+./+)H$*",%+3L$14$.+3"%')$+Q0+,%+#&+.$%#$32+$)3,++3H$ 32+$)3"L%#/$01))%-%'%3%+)$&1(#3$41,$32+$":1(#3$14$0+10'+$32"3$ ()+)$32+$)0"&+$h5'+Q"#.+,H$7Z8Zq$]2L3+H$7ZC!-i>$$]%''%":$_>$ ]2L3+$h7ZC!"i$,+&1/#%e+.$32+$41''1V%#/$,+'"3+.$31$32+$":1(#3$ 14$0+10'+$%#$)0"&+b$^]2"3$"33,"&3)$0+10'+$:1)3H$%3$V1('.$"0\ 0+",$%)$#13$32+$02L)%&"'H$+#*%,1#:+#3"'H$+&1#1:%&"'$)3"3+$14$"$ 0'"&+H$%3$%)$132+,$0+10'+`>$92%)$&"#$"001%#3$()$31V",.)$&,+"3%#/$ )+#)+$14$&1::(#%3L$"#.$/%*%#/$0+10'+$)0"&+$31$%#3+,"&3$V%''$ %#&,+")+$32+$":1(#3$14$0+10'+$"#.$&,+"3+$"V",+#+))$14$32+$ %:01,3"#&+$14$"$)0"&+$31$%#3+,"&3>$92+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$14$"$ )0"&+$%)$"$&,%3%&"'$+'+:+#3$41,$)0"&+)$%#$1,.+,$31$41)3+,$)1&%"'$ )+#)+$14$0'"&+>$W3$%)$32+$31'+,"#&+$"#.$,+)01#)%-%'%3L$31$"''$32+$ )1&%"'$/,1(0)$%#$1,.+,$31$-+&1:+$"$0(-'%&$)0"&+$41,$0(-'%&$ '%4+$h5>$J>$g"&1-)H$7ZCBq$MMGH$6!!!i>$P%3%e+#)$+#/"/+:+#3$ "#.$()%#/$0",3%&%0"31,L$)3,"3+/%+)$&"#$2+'0$31$-(%'.$32+$)+#)+$ 14$&1::(#%3L$"#.$0'"&+>$W#*1'*%#/H$"&3%*"3%#/$"#.$%#41,:%#/$ '1&"'$,+)%.+#3)$"#.$)3"<+21'.+,)H$&"#$"#.$%)$#+&+))",L$31$ 3,"#)41,:$)0"&+)$%#31$0'"&+)$14$[("'%3L$hg>$g"&1-)H$7ZA7q$MMGH$ 6!!!iH$%3$%)$-+&1:%#/$"V",+$14$32+$#++.)$"#.$0,%1,%3%+)$14$32+$ ()+,)$h5'+Q"#.+,H$7Z88q$n+2'H$7ZC8i>$S")3H$%#$32+$4")3\&2"#/%#/$ )1&%+3%+)$"#.$#++.)$14$0+10'+H$"$&+,3"%#$'+*+'$14$"."03"-%'%3L$ "#.$+Q":%#%#/$14$32+$2(:"#$0,1&+))+)$%)$#+&+))",L$31$&,+"3+$ )0"&+)$32"3$&"#$+*1'*+$1*+,$3%:+$hn+2'$N$G*",,+H$6!7@i>$92+$ temporary use of spaces and level of flexibility of buildings is #1V$*+,L$0,+)+#3$V%32$4")3$3,"#)41,:%#/$)1&%+3%+)>$
j92+$W.+1'1/%&"''L$&2",/+.$:1#(:+#3"'%3L$14$32+$&+#3,"'$ )[(",+)H$.+&1,"3+.$41,$32+$0,10+,$j&+'+-,"3%1#)k$14$32+$P1:\ :(#%)3$M",3L`)$/'1,%1()$'+".+,)2%0H$)311.$%#$)3",<$&1#3,")3$V%32$ 32+$"-(#."#&+$14$.+)1'"3+H$(#<+:03H$"#.$(#.%44+,+#3%"3+.$ 10+#$)0"&+$&2","&3+,%e%#/$32+$:"Y1,%3L$14$32+$(,-"#$'"#.)\ &"0+$%#$32+$)1&%"'%)3$&%3L>$I#.+,$32+)+$&%,&(:)3"#&+)H$)1&%"'$ %#3+,"&3%1#$,+:"%#+.$32+$1#'L$*%"-'+$4(#&3%1#$14$0(-'%&$)0"&+k$ hG3"#%'1*H$6!!8i 92+$0(-'%&$)0"&+$V")$"$&1#3,1''+.$)0"&+$.(,%#/$32+$G1&%"'%)3$ 3%:+>$M(-'%&$/"32+,%#/)$"#.$"&3%*%3%+)$32"3$V1('.$)0+"<$"-1(3$ %3+:)$#13$%#$'%#+$V%32$32+$G1&%"'%)3$G1&%+3L$V+,+$#13$"''1V+.>$ a1$4,++.1:$14$)0++&2$"#.$1(3%#/)$"/"%#)3$32+$)3"3+$&1('.$ 2"00+#$%#$0(-'%&$)0"&+>$S"3+,$%#$32+$)1&%"'%)3$)3"3+H$0(-'%&$ )0"&+)$V+,+$()+.$41,$0(-'%&$.+:1#)3,"3%1#)$"/"%#)3$:1)3'L$ 32+$/1*+,#:+#3>$W#$M,%)23%#"$"'1#+H$'",/+$.+:1#)3,"3%1#)$V+,+$ %#$7ZC7H7ZC6H$7ZCCH7ZCZH7ZZ!$hnY%#1''%H$6!7Bi>$ 92+$0+,%1.$-+3V++#$7ZZ!$"#.$32+$V",$%#$7ZZZ$V")$"$0",3%&('",$ difficult one. The Serbian government used an authoritarian V"L$14$,('%#/$%#$G+,-%"#$'"#.)>$W#$c1)1*1$32%)$&":+$.1V#$31$ 32+$-"#%)2%#/$14$5'-"#%"#)$4,1:$"''$%#)3%3(3%1#)$"#.$-L$:"<%#/$ "''$32+$)1&%"''L$1V#+.$&1:0"#%+)$)3"3+$1V#+.$'",/+$#(:-+,)$ -+&":+$(#+:0'1L+.>$W#$32%)$0+,%1.H$5'-"#%"#$'%4+$2"00+\ #+.$%#$32+$0,%*"3+$0,+:%)+)H$%#&'(.%#/$)&211')H$."L&",+H$"#.$ :+.%&"'$)+,*%&+>$92+$0(-'%&$'%4+$&2"#/+.$'1&"3%1#H$"#.$V")$ :1)3'L$2"00+#%#/$%#)%.+$0+10'+`)$21()+)$"#.$&"4v`)$1V#+.$-L$ 5'-"#%"#)>$92%)$,+)('3+.$%#$"#$"*+,)%1#$31$32+$0(-'%&'L$1V#+.$ )3,++3)$"#.$)0"&+)$"#.$"$)3",3$14$"$#+V$V"L$14$0(-'%&$'%4+>$ 91."LH$32%)$,+)('3)$%#$"$/,+"3$&('3(,+$",1(#.$&144++$"#.$32+$&14\ 4++21()+$")$"$0'"&+$41,$"''$)1,3)$14$/"32+,%#/)>$W#$32%)$0+,%1.H$ 32+$'%:%3+.$&1#)3,(&3%1#$32"3$2"00+#+.$V")$1#$0,%*"3+$'"#.)H$ %#$32+$41,:$14$):"''$+Q3+#)%1#)$1#$0,%*"3+$'"#.$41,$-()%#+))+)$ hnY%#1''%H$6!7Bi>$W#$"$V"LH$31."L$32%)$"*+,)%1#$%)$)3%''$2"00+#%#/>$ 92+$'"&<$14$&",+$41,$32+$0(-'%&$)0"&+$)++:)$'%<+$"$.+)&+#3$ 4,1:$32+$%.+"$32"3$%3$%)$)3"3+$1V#+.$"#.$#1$,+)01#)%-%'%3L$41,$%3$ %)$#++.+.>$ G%#&+$32+$V",$+#.+.$"$#+V$3,"#)%3%1#$0+,%1.$)3",3+.H$V2+,+")$ 3,"#)%3%1#$%#$32+1,L$%)$:1)3'L$"$01'%3%&"'$32%#/H$%#$c1)1*1$32%)$ %#&'(.+)$"')1$+&1#1:%&H$)1&%"'$"#.$3,"#)41,:"3%1#)$14$(,-"#$ :1,021'1/L$hnY%#1''%H$6!7Bi>$92+$#"3(,+$14$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$ "43+,$G1&%"'%):$%)$3,"#)41,:%#/$4(#&3%1#"''L$"#.$)1&%"''L>$92+$ new market economy has introduced a new energy reflecting &'+",'L$%#$32+$0,%*"3+$%#%3%"3%*+)$%#$32+$(,-"#$4"-,%&$"#.$0(-'%&$ )0"&+>$W#$)1:+$&")+)H$&1::+,&%"'%e"3%1#$14$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$V")$ %#$4"*1,$14$32+$0(-'%&$%#3+,+)3$-(3$:1)3'L$32+$0,%*"3%e"3%1#$2")$ #13$-++#$/11.$41,$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$%#$/+#+,"'>$5&&1,.%#/$31$c%,%'$ G3"#%'1*$h6!!8iH$32+$&2"#/+)$%#$01)3\)1&%"'%)3$3,"#)41,:"3%1#$ 14$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$",+$2",:+.$"#.$)(44+,%#/$.(+$31$0,%*"3%e"3%\ 1#$"#.$&1::+,&%"'%e"3%1#>$92+$3,"#)41,:"3%1#$14$)3,++3)$"#.$ 0(-'%&$01'%&%+)$2")$#13$-++#$01)%3%*+$41,$32+$0(-'%&$)0"&+)>$
W#$32+$G1&%"'%)3$&1(#3,%+)H$'",/+$0",3)$14$32+$(,-"#$'"#.$V")$ 0(-'%&'L$1V#+.>$92+$)3"3+$V")$32+$1V#+,$14$)3,++3)H$-(%'.%#/)$ "#.$4"&%'%3%+)>$92+$0(-'%&$)0"&+$%#$G1&%"'%)3$&1(#3,%+)$2")$ /,+"3$,"#/+$14$'"#.$%#$0(-'%&$()+H$.%44+,+#3$)0"&+$.%)3,%-(3%1#$ "#.$#+3V1,<)$"#.$132+,$4(#&3%1#"'$.%:+#)%1#H$")$1001)+.$ 31$V+)3+,#$U(,10+"#$0(-'%&$)0"&+$hG3"#%'1*H$6!!8i>$W#$1,.+,$ 31$.+*+'10$)3,++3)$"#.$0(-'%&$)0"&+)H$+Q0,10,%"3%1#$14$'"#.$ 2"00+#+.$%#$32+$#":+$14$32+$0(-'%&$#++.$hnY%#1''%H$6!7Bi>$ W#)3%3(3%1#"'$-(%'.%#/)H$1#$0(-'%&$'"#.H$4"&+.$32+$10+#$)0"&+)>$ 5$)3,1#/$'%#<$-+3V++#$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$"#.$32+$/1*+,#:+#3$V")$ EE
Fig. 37 Limited public spaces in the city
W#$32+$&")+$14$c1)1*1H$32%)$2")$#13$2"00+#+.$%#$32"3$+Q3+#3H$ "'321(/2$#1$0'"##%#/$,+/('"3%1#)$"#.$'"V)$1#$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$ give definitions to public space (Gjinolli, 2015). In this way, se\ '+&3+.$#+%/2-1,211.)$)(44+,$32+$":1(#3$14$10+#$)0"&+$.(+$31$ #1$,+/('"3%1#)H$)3"#.",.)$"#.$0(-'%&$,%/23)H$V2%&2$%)$#13$%#$'%#+$ with the EU regulation that defines what public space means hU(,10+"#$P1::%))%1#H$6!!@i>
%)$#+&+))",L>$G+&1#.H$+Q0'1,"3%1#$14$&1#3+:01,",L$+32%&"'$ *%+V)$"#.$0")3$*%)%1#)$14$"*+,)%1#$31$32+$^0(-'%&`$",+$%#$1,.+,>$ P,+"3%#/$[("'%3L$)0"&+)$"#.$0(-'%&$-1.%+)$%#$0,1*%.%#/$)3,++3$ '%4+$&"#$1#'L$-+$"$)(&&+))$)31,L$%4$"$,+#+V+.$&1::(#"'$)+#)+$ %)$41,:+.$"#.$"$/+#+,"'$"V",+#+))$14$32+$,+)01#)%-%'%3%+)$")$ "#$(,-"#$&%3%e+#>$92%,.H$"00,1"&2%#/$32+$310%&$4,1:$"$0(-'%&$ '%4+$)3(.%+)$&1#&+03H$&"#$0(3$+:02")%)$1#$,+*%+V%#/$32+$(,-"#$ situation from a different angle. Reflecting the strengths and V+"<#+))$14$32+$(,-"#$",+"$"/"%#)3$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$&1#&+03)$ "#.$%3)$&1,,+)01#.%#/$0,10+,3%+)$0,1*%.+)$"$&1:0'+3+'L$#+V$ *%+V$1#$32+$"&3%1#)$31$3"<+>$S")3H$"#.$:1)3$%:01,3"#3$%)$.1#`3$ (#.+,+)3%:"3+$32+$+Q%)3%#/$0(-'%&$-1.%+)$"#.$32+%,$)3,+#/32)>$ In difficult times, human beings are the most innovative and &,+"3%*+$%#$1,.+,$31$41,+)++$32+%,$#++.)$%#$'%4+>$92+$0,%*"3+$0(\ -'%&$'%4+$32"3$+Q%)3+.$%#$32+$L+",)$-+41,+$32+$V",H$0+10'+$&":+$ (0$V%32$&,+"3%*+$%.+")$31$'%*+$"$'%4+$")$#1,:"'$")$01))%-'+>
5)$+Q0'1,+.$%#$32%)$&2"03+,H$32+$)3"3+$14$4"&%'%3"3%1#$14$32+$ 0(-'%&$'%4+$h4"&%'%3%+)H$)0"&+)H$"&&+))%-%'%3LH$[("'%3LH$%#*1'*+:+#3i$ is largely overlooked in the aftermath of the conflict. Even 321(/2H$#+V$01'%3%&"'$"00,1"&2+)$",+$"%:+.$"3$%:0,1*+:+#3H$ 32+$02L)%&"'$)%3("3%1#$%#$.,":"3%&$)%3("3%1#)$:"<+)$32%)$%:0,1\ *+:+#3$"$/,+"3$&2"''+#/+>$R%,)3H$")$U)32+,$P2",'+)V1,32$h6!!8i$ 01%#3)$1(3H$%3$%)$:1,+$32"#$Y()3$0,1*%.%#/$#+V$)0"&+)$41,$0(-'%&$ '%4+H$%3$%)$32+$0,1&+))$31V",.)$32+)+$#+V$)0"&+)$32"3$#++.)$"$ .%44+,+#3$41&()>$W#$1,.+,$31$&,+"3+$[("'%3L$)0"&+)H$&1''"-1,"\ 3%1#H$&1#)('3"3%1#$"#.$)21V&")%#/$01))%-%'%3%+)$31$32+$0(-'%&$ EB
Fig. 38 Dodona neighborhood situation, 1961 )1(,&+b$M1+3%&$F+:1,%+)$14$M,%)23%#"H$6!!Z
EA
@Z
E!
E7
E6
Fig. 39,40,41,42 Dodona neighborhood in 1961 )1(,&+b$M1+3%&$F+:1,%+)$14$M,%)23%#"H$6!!Z
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b$M1+3%&$ :+:1,%+)$ 14$ M,%)23%#"$ ",+$ )21V%#/$ K1.1#"$ #+%/2-1,211.$ %#$ 7ZA7>$I#0"*+.$)3,++3)H$,+'%/%1()$-(%'.%#/)H$*+,#"&('",$",&2%3+&\ 3(,+$ -(3$ :1)3'L$ "$ [(%+3$ "3:1)02+,+>$ 92+)+$ %:"/+)$ ",+$ 31."L$ "':1)3$.%)"00+",+.$"#.$1#'L$"$2"#.4('$14$32+)+$-(%'.%#/)$2")$ survived the process of development after the conflict. The nar\ ,1V$)3,++3)$,+:"%#$%#$32+$&1#3+:01,",L$)%3("3%1#$-(3$V+,+$-(%'3$ 41,$32+$"-1*+$)3,++3)&"0+>
History of Dodona - ]%32%#$ 32+$ X331:"#$ 0+,%1.$ 32+$ &%3L$ 14$ M,%)23%#"$ +Q0+,%+#&+.$ "$ #"3(,"'$ 1,/"#%&$ /,1V32H$ '%<+$ )1$ :"#L$ 2%)31,%&$ &%3%+)$ %#$ U(,10+>$ 92%)$ 0+,%1.$ +#.+.$ %#$ 7Z76>$ 5,1(#.$ 32+$ %:01,3"#3$ -(%'.%#/)$ '%<+$ 32+$ :1)[(+H$ -"3221()+$ "#.$ -"\ e",$32+$)+33'+:+#3$.+*+'10+.>$92+$/,"#.$:1)[(+$14$M,%)23%#"$ '1&"3+.$1#$+")3$&1,#+,$14$32+$41,:+,$-"e",H$41,:)$32+$#1,32+,#$ -1,.+,$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$M",3)$14$32"3$-"e",$V+,+$'1&"3+.$%#$ K1.1#"$-(3$.(,%#/$32+$A!`)$:1.+,#%e"3%1#$32+$-"e",$2")$-++#$ .+)3,1L+.>$92+$3+,,"%#$14$32+$-"e",$0",3$%#$32+$#1,32\V+)3$&1,\ #+,$ 14$ K1.1#"$ %)$ #1V$ "#$ +:03L$ )0"&+$ ()+.$ 41,$ 0",<%#/>$ 92+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ K1.1#"$ &1##+&3+.$ 32+$ 2%)31,%&$ &+#3+,$ %#$ 32+$ #1,32$V%32$32+$)1(32+,#$*%''"/+)$14$32+$&%3L>$X#$c+':+#.%$)3,++3H$ in the heart of the neighborhood the largest river flowed, which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
Fig. 43 Dodona, Prishtina
EC
Fig. 44 Dodona neighborhood Urban Regulatory Plan, 2006 F(#%&%0"'%3L$14$M,%)23%#"H$6!!A
/,++#+,L$ "#.$ 3,++)$ :"<+$ %3$ "$ 213$ ",+"$ V%321(3$ 0'"&+)$ 14$ )2"\ .%#/$ %#$ 32+$ )(::+,>$ G[(",+)H$ 0",<)H$ 4,1#3$ L",.)H$ 0'"e"`)H$ &'+",$ sidewalks make it difficult to spend time in the neighborhood V2%&2$%)$#13$0",3$14$#+&+))",L$"&3%*%3%+)>$92+$&144++21()+)$"#.$ %3)$&('3(,+$",+"$0",3$14$32+$/+#+,"'$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$31."L>$P'+",$ 0'"##%#/$)L)3+:)$"#.$/11.$0(-'%&$/1*+,#"#&+$2")$-++#$'%:%\ 3+.$%#$32+$0")3$L+",)$")$&"#$-+$)++#$%#$132+,$#+%/2-1,211.)$14$ Prishtina. Difficult situations have emerged due to the historical '"L1(3$14$32+$)3,++3)$V2%&2$2"*+$#13$-++#$.+*+'10+.$"#.$&2"#\ ged in order to provide adequate access and safe traffic flows. Pedestrians have many difficulties walking properly through the #+%/2-1,211.>
Dodona and post conflict development processes - 91."LH$ 1#'L$'%:%3+.$2%)31,%&$[("'%3%+)$14$32+$1'.$#+%/2-1,211.$&"#$-+$ )++#>$ 92+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 0,1&+))+)$ .%.$ &2"#/+$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,\ 211.$&1:0'+3+'L>$X&&")%1#"''L$L1($&"#$2"*+$"$/'%:0)+$14$32+$ 1'.$21()+)$V%32%#$32+$-'1&<)$-+2%#.$2%/2$,%)+$"0",3:+#3$-(%'\ .%#/)>$92+$2+",3$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.H$c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
X001)%3+$14$32+$011,$&1#.%3%1#)$14$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#H$"*"%'"-'+$ 0(-'%&$)0"&+)H$/,++#+,L$"#.$#"3(,"'$+'+:+#3)H$/11.$"&&+))$"#.$ V"'<"-%'%3L$ 14$ K1.1#"H$ %)$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ '%4+>$ U*+#$ 321(/2$ )0"&+)$ .1$#13$:++3$32+$-")%&$[("'%3L$'+*+')H$'%4+$%)$-()3'%#/>$]%32$ 32+$ availability of diverse shops, offices and restaurants, Dodona is "#$"33,"&3%*+$",+"$41,$*%)%3%#/$"#.$'%*%#/>$5$2%/2$*",%+3L$14$.V+'\ '%#/)$144+,$)0"&+$31$'%*+$41,$0+10'+$41,$*",%1()$-"&</,1(#.)>$
543+,$32+$V",H$K1.1#"$")$&+#3,"'$",+"$+Q0+,%+#&+.$"$'",/+$%#\ &1:+$14$0+10'+$"#.$:"#L$.+*+'10:+#3)>$92+$41,:+,$&('3(,"'$ :%Q+.$#+%/2-1,211.$%)$#1V$1#'L$%#2"-%3+.$-L$'%:%3+.$#(:-+,)$ of minority groups. Those groups that could not profit from the new building economy. The densification process and con\ )3,(&3%1#$ -11:$ %)$ 31."L$ +Q0+,%+#&+.$ ")$ "$ V%'.$ *",%+3L$ 14$ ",\ &2%3+&3(,+$ )3L'+)H$ 1*+,-(%'.$ 0'13)H$ '"&<%#/$ )(#'%/23$ 31$ ):"''+,$ 21()+)H$ .":"/+.$ 0"*+:+#3)H$ V%'.$ 0",<%#/$ 14$ &",)H$ 1&&(0%+.$ public property, safety situations, low electricity wires, difficul\ ties for disabled people, many properties for rent, unfinished &1#)3,(&3%1#)$"#.$"-"#.1#+.$-(%'.%#/)>$92+$V21'+$#+%/2-1,\ 211.$&"##13$-+$/%*+$32+$'"-+'$"33,"&3%*+$")$"$0'"&+$"#.$'%*"-'+$ )0"&+>$K+)0%3+$32"3H$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$2")$"$,%&2$-()%#+))$"#.$ &1::+,&%"'$ .%:+#)%1#>$ F"#L$ .%44+,+#3$ )210)$ "#.$ &1:0"#%+)$ ",+$-")+.$%#$K1.1#"$")$V+''$")$:('3%0'+$:1)[(+)H$)&211')H$32+\ "3+,)>$P144++21()+)$"#.$):"''$,+)3"(,"#3)$&1:0'+3+$32+$0,%*"\ te sector of ground floors. Public services and organizations ",+$ '"&<%#/>$ 5$ #+%/2-1,211.$ -(%'.%#/$ 1,$ &1::(#%3L$ ",+"$ %)$ #13$"*"%'"-'+>$F1)3$)3,%<%#/$%)$32+$0'"&+$V2+,+$&2%'.,+#$2"*+$31$ 0'"L$"#.$1#$V2%&2$-+#&2$32+$+'.+,'L$&"#$2"*+$,+)3>$92+$'%:%3+.$
R%/>$EE$)21V)$32+$(,-"#$,+/('"31,L$0'"#$14$6!!A>$W3$V")$:".+$ %#$"43+,$32+$)3,"3+/%&$(,-"#$0'"#$14$6!!E>$5)$:+#3%1#+.$-+41,+H$ 32"3$0'"#$&1#)%)3+.$:1)3'L$(310%"#$%.+")$"#.$4"%'+.$%#$144+,%#/$ )1'(3%1#)$31$32+$0,1-'+:)$"#.$&2"''+#/+)$"3$32"3$3%:+>$],%3%#/$ a spatial plan on local scales is difficult if there are no quality /(%.+'%#+)$144+,+.$-L$0'"##%#/$".:%#%)3,"3%1#$"#.$(,-"#$0'"#)>$ 92+$,+/('"31,L$0'"#$.%.$"&<#1V'+./+$32+$0,+))%#/$)%3("3%1#$,+\ /",.%#/$32+$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$4"&%'%3%+)$-(3$.%.$#13$&,+"3+.$"#L$ )1'(3%1#$31$32+$0,1-'+:>$92+$0'"#$V")$1#'L$)21V%#/$32+$(,-"#$ )%3("3%1#$"3$32"3$3%:+> W#$ 32+$ 41''1V%#/$ 0"/+)H$ 32+$ "#"'L)%)$ 14$ K1.1#"$ %)$ .+)&,%-+.>$ 92+$:"0)$14$32+$02L)%&"'$+#*%,1#:+#3$e11:$%#$1#$.%44+,+#3$31\ 0%&)$32"3$3,L$31$+Q0'"%#$32+$,"0%.'L$&2"#/+.$(,-"#$)%3("3%1#>$W#$ "..%3%1#H$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$%)$&1:0",+.$V%32$32+$,+:"%#%#/$0(\ -'%&$/,1(#.)$"#.$'%:%3+.$+&1'1/%&"'$'+*+'$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>
EZ
Historical Building Development Heritage Pre-1999 development Demolished 1999 - 2013
Figure 45 Historic buildings and houses Pre-War build
Historic & pre-war building development \$ K1.1#"$ 2")$ /,1V#$2%)31,%&"''L$")$)1(32+,#$+Q3+#)%1#$14$32+$2%)31,%&$&+#3+,>$ P(,*+.$)3,++3)$"#.$"''+L)H$1#+\)31,L\0%3&2+.$,114$21()+)H$"#.$ %#)3%3(3%1#"'$ "#.$ /1*+,#:+#3"'$ -(%'.%#/)$ V+,+$ 32+$ '",/+)3$ ,+\ 0,+)+#3$ K1.1#"`)$ 2%)31,%&"'$ -"&</,1(#.>$ 92+$ :"0$ )21V)$ 32"3$ "#$+)3%:"3+.$6@!$-(%'.%#/)$2"*+$.%)"00+",+.$)%#&+$32+$+#.$14$ 32+$V",>$92%)$&1(#3)$41,$"':1)3$B!o$14$32+$313"'$0,+\V",$21()%#/$ "#.$-(%'.%#/)>$92+$:%..'+$",+"$&2"#/+.$:1)3$*%)%-'+$%#$3+,:)$ 14$ .+)3,1L+.$ -(%'.%#/)>$ 92+$ #1,32\V+)3$ &1,#+,$ .%)0'"L)$ 32+$ .+)3,1L+.$0",3$14$K1.1#"`)$0",3$14$32+$X331:"#$0+,%1.$J"e",> F1,+$31V",.)$32+$+")3$)%.+$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.H$)3,++3)$2"*+$
0",3'L$ )"*+.$ 32+%,$ %:"/+$ 14$ -(%'.%#/)>$ 92+$ :%))%#/$ +'+:+#3$ %)$ 32+$+Q"&3$'1&"3%1#$14$2%)31,%&$21()+)H$32+$0+,%1.$V%32%#$32+$G1\ &%"'%)3$ 3%:+H$ "$ V"*+$ 14$ :1.+,#%):$ "',+".L$ &2"#/+.$ #+%/2-1,\ 211.)$"#.$32+%,$2%)31,%&$%:"/+>$G%:%'",$31$32+$#+V$&+#3+,$"#.$ -1('+*",.$F132+,$92+,+)"H$V2%&2$%)$"$&+#3,"'$",+"$-(%'.$%#$32+$ B!`)$"#.$A!`)>$]"'<%#/$32,1(/2$K1.1#"H$%::+.%"3+'L$)21V)$%3)$ ,".%&"'$ &2"#/+$ -(3$ 32+$ 2%)31,%&$ -(%'.%#/)$ &"#$ -+$ )++#$ +*+,L\ V2+,+$%#$-+3V++#>$92+$:1)3'L$011,$&1#.%3%1#)$")<$41,$"$:(#%\ &%0"'$)3,"3+/L$%#$1,.+,$#13$31$'1)+$32+$,+:"%#%#/$0,+\V",$-(%'\ .%#/)$V%32$2%)31,%&$*"'(+>$92+$+32#1/,"02%&$:()+(:$%)$"$/11.$ +Q":0'+$14$3,"#)41,:%#/$2%)31,%&"'$-(%'.%#/)$%#$"$0(-'%&$0'"&+> B!
Post-ConďŹ&#x201A;ict Building Development Heritage Pre-1999 development 1999 - 2006 development Post - 2006 development 2013 - under construction
Figure 46 Building development process after the conflict, Dodona
Post-war building development \$92+$&2"#/+$31V",.)$"$4,++$ market economy and the migration flows that pressured all #+%/2-1,211.)$%#$M,%)23%#"$,+'"3+.$31$#+V$&1#)3,(&3%1#>$K1.1\ #"H$.(+$%3)$&+#3,"'$'1&"3%1#H$0,%*"3%e+.$0",&+')$"#.$'",/+$&2"#/+$ %#$+32#%&$010('"3%1#H$V")$"44+&3+.$")$1#+$14$32+$:1)3$)+*+,+'L>$ 92+$:"0$%#.%&"3+)$-(%'.%#/$.+*+'10:+#3$.%,+&3'L$"43+,$32+$V",H$ .+*+'10:+#3$%#$32+$)+&1#.$0+,%1.$"#.$32+$1#/1%#/$&1#)3,(&\ 3%1#$ (#3%'$ 32+$ 21'.$ %#$ 6!7@>$ 92%)$ &2"#/+$ 14$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 2")$ .,")3%&"''L$3,"#)41,:+.$32+$(,-"#$4"-,%&$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$ Buildings on plots have been maximized, floors have been ad\ .+.$V%321(3$0+,:%3H$32+$)'10+$.+:"#.)$):"''$)3"%,)$V2%&2$143+#$
",+$0'"&+.$1#$0(-'%&$/,1(#.)H$)(#'%/23$2")$-++#$3"<+#$"V"L$41,$ #+%/2-1,%#/$0'13)H$0'13)$2"*+$-++#$&1##+&3+.$31$-(%'.$'",/+,$ property, mixture of international styles and unfinished facades ",+$%#3+,+)3%#/$-(3$&1#4()%#/H$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$)%.+V"'<)$2"*+$ .%)"00+",+.H$V+"<$&1#.%3%1#$1,$4(''L$0",<+.$.(,%#/$32+$."L$-L$ *%)%31,)>$5''$:"<+$"$&2"13%&$)3,++3)&"0+$"#.$"$*+,L$&,1V.+.$"#.$ .+#)+$)%3("3%1#>$92+$+",'%+,$:+#3%1#+.$#",,1V$2%)31,%&"'$)3,++3)$ do not have the capacity for this type of densification. The #(:-+,$14$&",)$()+.$V%32%#$32+$&%3L$%)$0(33%#/$0,+))(,+$1#$32+$ )"4+3L$"#.$[("'%3L$14$32+$)3,++3)>$92%)$%)$0",3%&('",$&,%3%&"'$,+'"3+.$ 31$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$V2%&2$&'+",'L$.1$#13$+Q%)3$"#L:1,+$%#$K1.1#"> B7
Build number of stories 1 + pitched roof 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
+650 Geographical heights
+600
North
+620
+610
+630
+640
Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 47 Build and Geographical heights
Stories build in Dodona \$92+$+Q&+))%*+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$ post-conflict years have changed Dodona from a pitched single )31,L$"#.$):"''$:1.+,#$21()%#/$#+%/2-1,211.$%#31$"$2%/2$,%)+$ ,+)%.+#3%"'$ ",+"$ V%32$ :"#L$ :1,+$ 0+10'+$ '%*%#/$ 32+#$ -+41,+>$ W3$ %)$+")L$31$%.+#3%4L$32+$",+")$V%32$'1V$,%)+$21()%#/H$V2%&2$2"*+$ <+03$32+%,$)1,3$14$%.+#3%3L>$X32+,$",+")$)21V$&'+",$:+.%(:$)%e+$ "#.$2%/2$,%)+$.+*+'10:+#3>$921)+$.+*+'10:+#3$2"*+$+:+,/+.$ in between the pre-conflict development but there are areas V%32$ "':1)3$ #+V$ .+*+'10:+#3>$ J+)%.+)$ 32+)+$ #+V$ .+*+'10\ ment, which has up to eleven floors, it is also the size of the .+*+'10:+#3>$ F('3%0'+$ 0",&+')$ 2"*+$ -++#$ &1:-%#+.$ %#$ 1,.+,$
31$.+*+'10$"$'",/+,$-(%'.%#/H$)1:+3%:+)$%#$)3,"#/+$41,:)$"#.$ )%3("3%1#)>$ 92+$ )'10+$ 14$ 32+$ 2%''$ 1#$ V2%&2$ K1.1#"$ %)$ '1&"3+.$$ demands specific solutions for the entrance of properties. The )'10+$ "3$ )1:+$ 01%#3)$ %)$ (0$ 31$ C:$ 2+%/23$ .%44+,+#&+$ 1#$ 7!!:$ '+#/32>$I0$31$32+$#1,32$32%)$)'10+$.+&,+")+)$"#.$(0$31$32+$+")3$ %3$%#&,+")+)$V%32%#$32+$P%3L$M",<>
B6
Public spaces and parks greenery & sidewalks
Public parks Private & Institutional gardens Undefined green space Pedestrian spaces Childerns playground
12/34 ()*+,-.*/ $
# $ -0
%$ $ -0
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 48 Public space and green areas
Public grounds of Dodona \$ K1.1#"$ %)$ "$ *+,L$ .+#)+$ #+%/\ 2-1,211.$ "#.$ &+#3,"''L$ '1&"3+.$ %#$ 32+$ &%3L>$ W3)$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ "#.$ )0"&+)$ .1$ )3,+3&2$ 4(,32+,$ 32+#$ Y()3$ 32+%,$ 1V#$ %#2"-%3"#3)>$ 92+$:"0)$)21V)$&'+",'L$32+$'%:%3+.$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$'"&<%#/$ /,++#+,L$ V%32%#$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.>$ 92+$ 011,$ 0'"##%#/$ )%3("\ tion has been difficult for the quality and quantity of public )0"&+)$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$92+$0",<$%)$"#$+Q&+''+#3$+)&"0+$14$ 32+$-(%'.$",+"$-(3$32+)+$[("'%3%+)$)21('.$-+$+*+#$&'1)+,$31$32+$ ,+)%.+#3)>$ J+)%.+)$ 32+$ P%3L$ M",<H$ '%:%3+.$ /,++#$ %#$ 32+$ 41,:$ 14$ 3,++)$&"#$-+$41(#.H$32+$&1(0'+$14$/,++#$)0"&+)$1#$32+$:"0$",+$ +%32+,$0,%*"3+$1,$011,'L$:"%#3"%#+.>$F1)3$&,%3%&"'$32+$)%3("3%1#$
41,$32+$0+.+)3,%"#)H$011,$[("'%3L$)%.+V"'<)H$%#41,:"'$0",<%#/$1#$ )%.+V"'<)$"#.$0,%*"3+$1-Y+&3)$")$)3"%,)$",+$-'1&<%#/$)"4+$:1*+\ :+#3)>$ R1&()%#/$ 1#$ &2%'.,+#H$ V2%&2$ &"#$ -+$ 41(#.$ 32,1(/21(3$ 32+$#+%/2-1,211.H$2"*+$'%:%3+.$)0"&+$31$0'"L>$92+$)3,++3)$",+$ #13$1,/"#%e+.$")$)(&2$"#.$#13$144+,$"#L$)"4+$)0"&+$41,$&2%'.,+#>$ W4$L1($'+"*+$32+$P%3L$M",<$1(3H$32+$":1(#3$14$0(-'%&$)0"&+$%#$32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ %)$ '1V$ "#.$ 14$ 011,$ [("'%3L>$ W#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ &2"#/+$ 32%)$ )%3("3%1#$ "$ *",%+3L$ 14$ #+V$ &1#.%3%1#)$ ",+$ #++.+.$ )(&2$ ")b$ )3,1#/+,$/1*+,#"#&+H$&'+",$"#.$"&&(,"3+$0'"#)H$&1\V1,<%#/$"#.$ transparency of municipality and local offices, involvement of 32+$'1&"'$010('"3%1#$"#.$&2"#/+.$)+33%#/$14$%#2"-%3"#3)> B@
Fig. 49 Physical context mapping
BE
Fig. 50 Timelaps analysis notes
Figure 51 Programme analysis map
For this analysis 3 types of angles can be identified: the soci\ "'H$ 32+$ )0"3%"'$ "#.$ 32+$ &1:01)%3%1#>$ 92+$ )1&%"'$ "#/'+$ %)$ &1:\ 01)+.$ 14$ 32+$ 41''1V%#/$ :"0)b$ 3%:+\'"0)+$ :"0)H$ _w/+,)3,"#.$ :1*+:+#3$:"0)$"#.$"&3%*%3L$:"0>$92+)+$:"0)$3,L$31$%.+#3%4LH$ 32,1(/2$1-)+,*"3%1#H$3,"&<%#/$"#.$3,"&%#/H$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$ 14$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.>$ 92+$ )0"3%"'$ "#/'+$ %)$ &1:01)+.$ 14b$ 0,1\ /,":$ :"0H$ 0(-'%&#+))$ :"0$ "#.$ 10+##+))$ :"0>$ 92+)+$ :"0)$ try to identify the ground floor activeness of the neighborhood "#.$%3)$4(#&3%1#"'$"#.$()+,$4,%+#.'L$",+")>$S")3H$32+$:"0)$"3$32+$ beginning of this chapter try to identify the main post-conflict &2","&3+,$ "#.$ &1#.%3%1#)$ 14$ 32+$ 02L)%&"'$ +#*%,1#:+#3>$ 92+)+$ :"0)$ ",+$ 32+$ &1:01)%3%1#$ :"0)$ '%<+b$ +,-$.&,40(# 0*1# 1)7)(.3Q 2)*$#203-=#'%,(1,*F#0*1#F).F&03+/$:"0)$"#.$/,++#$"#.$0(\ -'%&$)0"&+$:"0)>$92+)+$'")3$/,1(0$2")$"',+".L$-++#$)21V+.$%#$ 32+$-+/%##%#/$14$32+$&2"03+,>$92+$)1&%"'$"#.$)0"3%"'$:"0)$",+$ 0,+)+#3+.$%#$32+$41''1V%#/$0"/+)>$92+$,+)('3$14$32+)+$:"0)$%)$"$ &,1))$:"00%#/$:+321.$%#$1,.+,$31$%.+#3%4L$32+$)0"3%"'$[("'%3%+)$ "#.$ 013+#3%"')$ 14$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.>$ J(3$ "')1$ 31$ %.+#3%4L$ 0,1\ blems and challenges in the form of patterns of post conflict .+*+'10:+#3$0,1&+))+)>
Method of Analysing$\$K(,%#/$32%)$,+)+",&2H$)3,1#/$%:01,3"#&+$ is given to the field of analysis. A fundamental concept of the ,+)+",&2$%)H$")$J+,#",.1$G+&&2%$)"%.H$!(Z%&'0*,-$,40#-,#50#4.,#3,)Q 1,>$32"3$:+"#)$32"3$(,-"#%):$%)$1#'L$01))%-'+$1#$4113H$)1$32"3$ observations and fieldwork are strongly necessary. The field\ V1,<$41&()+)$1#$32+$02L)%&"'$3,"&+)$"#.$1#$32+$+#*%,1#:+#3"'$ -+2"*%1,$14$()+,)$ht+%)+'H$g>$6!!Ai>$92%)$:+321.$%)$%#3+#.+.$31$ â&#x20AC;&#x153;systematically look at physical surroundings to find reflectiQ .*-#.5#3&)7,.%-#04$,7,$/>$ht+%)+'H$g>$6!!Ai$"#.$31$j)L)3+:"3%&"''L$ V"3&2$0+10'+$()+$32+%,$+#*%,1#:+#3)b$%#.%*%.("')H$0"%,)$14$0+1\ 0'+H$):"''$/,1(0)$"#.$'",/+$/,1(0)k$"#.$31$(#.+,)3"#.$ !+.9# 0# 3+/-,40(# )*7,&.*2)*$# -%33.&$-# .&# ,*$)&5)&)-# 9,$+# ')+07,.&-# $0:,*F#3(04)#9,$+,*#,$>$ht+%)+'H$g>$6!!Ai>$ K1.1#"$"#.$132+,$#+%/2-1,211.)$%#$M,%)23%#"H$2"*+$-++#$:"0\ 0+.$ #13$ ")$ "&&(,"3+$ "#.$ 0+,%1.%&"''L$ ")$ %#$ 92+$ a+32+,'"#.)>$ K(,%#/$32+$0,1&+))$14$"#"'L)%)$32+$:1)3$(0$31$."3+$:"0$."3+)$ -"&<$31$6!!A$:".+$-L$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$41,$32+$(,-"#$,+/('"31,L$ 0'"#$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$5$.+3"%'+.$:"0$%)$,+[(%,+.$%#$1,.+,$ 31$0+,41,:$"#"'L)%)$1#$32+$*+,L$'1&"'$)&"'+>$]%32$32%)$<#1V'+./+$ the first part of this analysis is a clear identification of the physi\ &"'$+#*%,1#:+#3$"#.$&1#.%3%1#)>$]%32$."L)$14$:"00%#/$"#.$1-\ )+,*%#/$32+$)%3("3%1#$1#$32+$)3,++3$"#.$32+$#+V$.+*+'10:+#3)$ "43+,$6!!A$"$:1,+$0,+&%)+$:"0$2")$-++#$&1:01)+.>$]%32$32%)$ ,+)+",&2$ 14$ 32+$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ 32+$ "#"'L)%)$ 14$ 32+$ )1&%"'\)0"3%"'$ &1::1#$/,1(#.$&"#$-+$.1#+>$]%32$32+$,+)+",&2$1#$01)3\&1#\ flict processes, it is becoming clear that the relation between the social and spatial element is an interesting field of research. W#.%*%.("'$:%#.)$"#.$'"&<$14$&1::(#"'$%#%3%"3%*+)$"#.$310\.1V#$ -(3$011,$0'"##%#/$&,+"3+)$"#$%#3+,+)3%#/$",+"$14$)3(.L>$W#$1,.+,$ 31$.+*+'10$"$.+)%/#$V2%&2$%)$41&()+.$1#$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#H$%3$%)$ #+&+))",L$31$1-)+,*+$&'1)+'L$32+$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3$"#.$ 32+$ 0'"&+$ V2+,+$ %3$ 2%3)$ +"&2$ 132+,b$ 32+$ &1::1#$ /,1(#.>$ 92%)$ 3L0+$14$)3(.L$e11:)$%#$1#$32+$)3,++3$)&"'+$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$ "#.$0,+41,:)$,+)+",&2$14$32+$)1&%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3$14$32+$#+%/2\ -1,211.$"#.$&1:-%#+)$32%)$V%32$%3)$)0"3%"'$&1#.%3%1#)>$
Social angle: 9%:+$S"0)$:"0) _w/+,)3,"#.$:1*+:+#3$:"0) 5&3%*%L$:"0 Spatial angle: M,1/,"::+$:"0 M(-'%&#+))$:"0 X0+##+))$:"0 Composition angleb K+*+'10:+#3$:"0 J(%'.%#/$'"L+,)$:"0 n,++#$"#.$G0"&+$:"0
BB
Place & Timelaps Analysis
Social groups at locations at different moments
Children Teenagers Young adults <35
06
Adults > 35 Elderly
Hetrogeneus places Hetrogeneus spaces Homogeneus places
07
Homogeneus spaces Moments of the day (10 min) 05
7.30 - 9.30
11.30 - 13.30
14.30 - 16.30
17.30 - 19.30
03
01. City Park entrance 08
68
40
92
72
02. Gustav Meyer square
04
30
60
68
58
03. Kelmendi street - â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Mosqueâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; 160
92
182
190
04. Agim Ramadani crossing
01
146
114
232
190
02
05. Kelmendi street - pedestrian alley 72
82
152
32
06. Elena Gijka school 144
126
196
98
07. Rrustem Hyseni crossing 74
78
90
92
08. Mustafe Kruja crossing 09
52
56
66
98
09. Rrustem Statovci - taxi stand 112 162 78
86
10. Adrian Krasniqi - local businesses 94
10
182
114
60
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 52 Time laps analysis map
Time Laps analysis map Dodona \$92%)$:"0$.+)&,%-+)$32+$01\ )%3%1#$14$*",%1()$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$1#$7!$'1&"3%1#)$14$)0+&%"'$%#3+\ ,+)3$ %#$ K1.1#">$ X#$ E$ :1:+#3)$ 14$ 32+$ ."L$ 0+10'+$ 2"*+$ -++#$ 1-)+,*+.$41,$7!$:%#>$92+$%#3+#)%3L$14$2(:"#$"&3%*%3L$%)$:"00+.$ "#.$32+$:1,+$2+3+,1/+#+1()$1,$21:1/+#1()$&2","&3+,$14$32+$ 0'"&+)$ ",+$ .%)&1*+,+.>$ X-)+,*%#/$ .%44+,+#3$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)$ &"#$ &,+"3+$ "$ &'+",$ 0%&3(,+$ 14$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.)$ )1&%"'$ "&3%*%3L>$ JL$ &211)%#/$7!$'1&"3%1#)$V2%&2$",+$,+'"3+.$31$"#$"33,"&3%1#$01%#3$ 32+$#+%/2-1,211.)$"&3%*+$0'"&+)$",+$:"00+.>$X32+,$",+")$",+$ 14$ '+))$ %:01,3"#&+H$ '1V$ "&3%*%3L$ 1,$ &"##13$ )21V$ #(:-+,)$ 32"3$ are significant to work with. The analysis is of 5 social groups
#":+'Lb$&2%'.,+#H$L1(#/)3+,)H$L1(#/$".('3)$h67\@BiH$".('3)$h@B\ BBi$ "#.$ +'.+,'L>$ 92+$ *+,L$ L1(#/$ 010('"3%1#$ h"*>$ 68$ L+",)i$ 14$ c1)1*1$ &"#$ -+$ 3,"&+.$ -"&<$ %#$ 32+$ .%*%)%1#$ 14$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)$ %#$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.>$ U'.+,'L$ "#.$ P2%'.,+#$ ",+$ #13$ ,+0,+)+#3+.$ well in the neighborhood and only occur on specific areas: the &%3L$0",<$"#.$",1(#.$32+$0,%:",L$)&211'>$543+,$32%)$1-)+,*"3%1#$ %#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.H$"$.%*%)%1#$%)$:".+$-+3V++#$"$)0"&+$"#.$ "$0'"&+>$5$^)0"&+`$%)$Y()3$"#$10+#$",+"$V2+,+$0+10'+$.1$1&&(,$ but which are not specifically designed for its users today and ^0'"&+)`$",+$:1,+$.+)%/#+.$")$"#$",+"$14$-+'1#/%#/$31$%3)$()+,)>$
BA
Hägerstrand Movement mapping
Historic old town
crossings of the neighborhood by various social groups
Children Teenagers Young adults <35 Adults > 35 Elderly
10 min
9 min 8 min
Vellusha 7 min
6 min
5 min
4 min
3 min
2 min
1 min
Center
Center
City Park
University Faculties
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 53 Explanation of Hagerstrand map Dodona
Hägerstrand Tracking map Dodona \$9,"&<%#/$"#.$3,"&%#/$,1(\ 3+)$14$0+10'+$&"#$/%*+$%#)%/23$%#$&21)+#$)3,++3)$"#.$)3,++3)$'+43$ ")%.+>$92+$:"0$)21V)$32+)+$,1(3+)$14$%#.%*%.("')$41,$"$0+,%1.$14$ 7!$:%#>$W3$)21V)$32+$3%:+H$"$0+,)1#$%)$)0+#.%#/$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,\ 211.$"#.$%4$)%.+$"&3%*%3%+)$",+$2"00+#%#/$'%<+$:"<%#/$)310)>$X#$ .%44+,+#3$:1:+#3)$14$32+$."L$"$0+,)1#$4,1:$+*+,L$)1&%"'$/,1(0$ %)$41''1V+.$1#$%3)$V"L$32,1(/2$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$G1:+$0+10'+$ 2"*+$K1.1#"$")$32+%,$h3+:01,",Li$.+)3%#"3%1#$-(3$:1)3$14$32+:$ ",+$1#$32+%,$V"L$31V",.)$",+")$",1(#.$K1.1#"$"#.$",+$()%#/$ 32+$#+%/2-1,211.$31$/+3$32+%,$)21,3'L>$W#$32+$"-1*+$)21V#$:"0H$ %)$32+$_w/+,)3,"#.$%)$+Q0'"%#+.>$W$2"*+$41''1V+.$"$0+,)1#$1#$%3)$
V"L$32,1(/2$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$W$0'"&+.$:L)+'4$1#$"$01)%3%1#$ 1#$32+$+./+$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$%#$1,.+,$31$41''1V$)1:+-1.L$ 32"3$&":+$4,1:$1#+$14$32+$41''1V%#/$",+")b$G,$/#[0&:=#+,-$.&,40(# 4)*$)&=#20,*#4,$/#'.%()70&1=#%*,7)&-,$/#4023%-#.&#*),F+'.&,*F# \)((%-+0#0&)0;$92+$/,"02$)21V)$32+$,1(3+$32+$0+,)1#$3"<+)$"#.$ 32+$*+,3%&"'$"Q+)$32+$0+,%1.$14$7!$:%#>$W#$:"#L$&")+)$32+$0+,)1#$ )0+#.)$'+))$32+#$7!$:%#$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$92%)$%)$.(+$31$32+$ '%:%3+.$)%e+$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$
B8
Hägerstrand Movement mapping
crossings of the neighborhood by various social groups
Children Teenagers Young adults <35 Adults > 35 Elderly
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 54 Hagerstrand map ‘morning time laps’ 3,"&<%#/$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$-+3V++#$8>@!$\$Z>@!
Hagerstrand Tracking map Dodona (morning) \$ 92%)$ :"0$ %)$ 32+$ ,+)('3$ 14$ 32+$ :1,#%#/$ 0+,%1.$ 3,"&<%#/$ 14$ .%44+,+#3$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)>$X#$32+%,$V"L$31$V1,<$1,$)&211'H$0+10'+$&,1))$32+$#+%/\ 2-1,211.$"#.$()%#/$32+$)21,3+)3$,1(3+)$31$32+$.+)3%#"3%1#>$G1\ :+3%:+)$"$)21,3$)310$%#$"$-"<+,L$%)$.1#+>$5$*",%+3L$14$)3,++3)$%)$ ()+.$"#.$.+)3%#"3%1#$&"#$-+$%#$"#.$-+L1#.$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$
BC
Hägerstrand Movement mapping
crossings of the neighborhood by various social groups
Children Teenagers Young adults <35 Adults > 35 Elderly
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 55 Hagerstrand map ‘lunch time laps’ 3,"&<%#/$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$-+3V++#$77>@!$\$7@>@!
Hagerstrand Tracking map Dodona (lunchtime) \$92%)$:"0$%)$ 32+$ ,+)('3$ 14$ 32+$ '(#&23%:+$ 0+,%1.$ 3,"&<%#/$ 14$ .%44+,+#3$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)>$ P'+",$ %)$ 32"3$ 0+10'+$ :"<+$ )310)$ 1#$ 32+%,$ V"L$ 31$ 32+$ .+)3%#"3%1#>$ n1%#/$ %#$ "$ )(0+,:",<+3H$ V"'<%#/$ (0$ "#.$ .1V#$ "$ street to a specific shop or crossing the mosque area and stop 41,$"$0,"L+,$-+41,+$&1#3%#(%#/$32+%,$V"L$32,1(/2$32+$#+%/2-1,\ 211.>$
BZ
Hägerstrand Movement mapping
crossings of the neighborhood by various social groups
Children Teenagers Young adults <35 Adults > 35 Elderly
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 56 Hagerstrand map ‘afternoon time laps’ 3,"&<%#/$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$-+3V++#$7E>@!$\$7A>@!
Hagerstrand Tracking map Dodona (afternoon) \$ 92%)$ :"0$ %)$ 32+$ ,+)('3$ 14$ 32+$ "43+,#11#$ 0+,%1.$ 3,"&<%#/$ 14$ .%44+,+#3$ )1\ &%"'$ /,1(0)>$ W#$ 32%)$ 0%&3(,+$ %3$ %)$ &'+",$ 32"3$ :"#L$ 0+10'+$ &,1))$ 32+$-()L$c+':+#.%$)3,++3>$92"3$)3,++3$%)$0,1-"-'L$32+$1#+$:1)3$ 0+10'+$<#1V$14H$32%#<%#/$14$K1.1#"$"#.$32+,+41,+$"$&'+",$01%#3$ 14$ 1,%+#3"3%1#$ 31/+32+,$ V%32$ 32+$ '1&"'$ :1)[(+$ 0'"&+.$ 1#$ 32+$ -()L$&1,#+,>$
A!
Hägerstrand Movement mapping
crossings of the neighborhood by various social groups
Children Teenagers Young adults <35 Adults > 35 Elderly
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 57 Hagerstrand map ‘afternoon time laps’ 3,"&<%#/$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$-+3V++#$78>@!$\$7Z>@!
Hagerstrand Tracking map Dodona (evening) \$ 92%)$ :"0$ %)$ 32+$ ,+)('3$ 14$ 32+$ +*+#%#/$ 0+,%1.$ 3,"&<%#/$ 14$ .%44+,+#3$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)>$ a+V$ ,1(3+)$ ",+$ &'+",$ "#.$ '+))$ )310)$ ",+$ :".+$ %#$ 32+$ +*+#%#/>$$
A7
Flows of street users
crossings of the neighborhood by various social groups
Pedestrians 372
Moterized traffic 96
24
users per hour
84
216
120
144
72
264 312
144
0 576
264 180
252
792
72
276
2310
36
96
276
48 12
96
24
108 36
216
970
108 36
108
288
12
192
84 168 48
336
48 468
456
60 360
600 192
492
36
120
24 468
384
420
192 132
492
300 168
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 58 Flows of traffic and pedestrians Dodona
-721($0/@$- Counting flows of traffic and pedestrian provides %#)%/23$1#$2+"*%'L$:131,%e+.$,1".)$"#.$[(%+3$)3,++3)>$P1(#3%#/$ 1#$,()2$21(,$32+$)3,++3$"&3%*%3L$0,1*%.+)$%#)%/23$14$%#3+#)%3L$14$ street use. Most streets are open to all traffic even though the streets have narrow profiles and unclear scenes. Nevertheless, "$'",/+$#(:-+,$14$)3,++3)$)++$4+V$&",)$0+,$21(,$"#.$",+$/11.$ )3,++3)$41,$0+.+)3,%"#$()+>$92+$:"%#$)3,++3)$")$c+':+#.%$)3,++3$ and the inner ring road have both motorized traffic and pedes\ 3,%"#)$-(3$)0"&+$%)$143+#$'%:%3+.$41,$"''$32+)+$()+,)$"#.$&,1))%#/)$ ",+$-()L>$
A6
Active places
Social groups at locations at different moments
Window shopping Religious activities Socializing spaces Childrens playing area Walking / exercizing Parking Informal parking informal street vendors Outdoor terraces informal playing areas informal free sitting BUS waiting places
carwash/gasstation
BUS
Taxi
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 59 Activity map Dodona
Activity map Dodona \$ 92+$ :"0$ )21V)$ 32+$ *",%1()$ "&3%*%3%+)$ 14$32+$010('"3%1#>$92+$:"%#$01%#3)$14$"&3%*%3L$",+$32+$)2100%#/$ ",+"$14$32+$%##+,$,%#/$,1".$"#.$)3,+3&2+)$%#31$c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
Programme of groundďŹ&#x201A;oors
various groups of services, commercial and institutions
Housing Vacancies Offices Shops OfďŹ ce buildings Institutional building Private office Embassy Services Hair salon Travel agency Medical practice Bank Private parking / petrol Laundry / Tailor Physical health Car service Public services School Religious building Social service / NGO Museum Kindergarten School for driving Retail Clothing shop Footwear shop Pharmacy Beauty shop General retail shop Art gallery & shop Food & Leisure Restaurant Local eatery Fast food Coffee house Hotel Theater
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 60 Programme map Dodona
Programme map Dodona \$ 92+$ :"0$ )21V)$ 32+$ +Q3+#)%*+$ broad network of ground floor use in Dodona. Many different 0,%*"3+$ &1:0"#%+)H$ ,+3"%'+,)H$ )+,*%&+$ )210)$ :"<+$ K1.1#"$ "$ .+)3%#"3%1#$41,$"$,"#/+$14$)2100+,)$"#.$*%)%31,)>$X#$32+$132+,$ 2"#.H$32+$0(-'%&$)+&31,$"#.$)+,*%&+)$",+$/+#+,"''L$'"&<%#/$"#.$ a great part of ground floor spaces are vacant. Besides that, )1:+$%#3+,+)3%#/$)3,++3)$'%<+$32+$1#+$)(,,1(#.%#/$32+$0",<$14\ fers limited active ground floors. Most interesting are Kelmendi )3,++3H$32+$%##+,$,%#/$,1".$"#.$32+$'1&"'$)210)$%#$32+$)1(32$14$ 32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$
AE
Publicness of the groundďŹ&#x201A;oors programme Openness towards the public
Limited entrance Certain groups With door restrictions Payment for consuming Public service Limited control on entrance Housing Vacancies Offices Shops Construction site
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 61 Publicness map Dodona
Publicness map Dodona - The publicness of the ground floor research places the variety of groundfloor in groups of public entrance. The blue and green groundfloors are open to most 0+10'+$ "#.$ ",+$ 4(#&3%1#"''L$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ 14$ 32+$ neighborhood. On the other many groundfloors are offices or 1#'L$10+#$31$&+,3"%#$0+10'+$"#.$2"*+$)3,%&3$+#3,"#&+$01'%&%+)>$ S")3H$%#$&+,3"%#$)3,++3)$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$%)$'%:%3+.$31$32+$)3,++3$ .(+$31$:"#L$*"&"#&%+)$"#.$&1#)3,(&3%1#$)%3+)>
AB
Openness of groundďŹ&#x201A;oor facades Openness towards the public
Housing Vacancies Under construction Closed wall - limited windows Inactive Semi open Fences in/out interaction Active facede
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Figure 61 Openness map Dodona
Openness map Dodona \$92+$:"0$%#.%&"3+)$32+$3L0+$14$4"&".+$ of the groundfloor which is closing off the public domain from 32+$0,%*"3+$",+")>$92%)$:"0$.1+)$#13$'11<$"3$32+$4"&".+$")$)3L'+$ 1,$%4$321)+$",+$%#$/11.$&1#.%3%1#$-(3$1#'L$31$32+$10+##+))$14$ 32+$4"&".+>$J'%#.$V"'')$.1$2"*+$"$#+/"3%*+$+44+&3$1#$%3)$0(-'%&$ )(,,1(#.%#/)$ "#.$ .1$ #13$ 144+,$ "#$ "33,"&3%*+$ )3,++3$ )&"0+>$ 92+$ :"0$)21V)$&'+",'L$32+$:"#L$%#"&3%*+$"#.$-'%#.$4"&".+)$V2%&2$ "#.$32+$'%:%3+.$#(:-+,$14$"33,"&3%*+$)3,++3)>$
AA
"2#)/7$/8/7E()(
"@/%)/7$/8/7E()(
06
07
05
03
08
04
01
BUS
02
09
Taxi
10
North
North
Scale bar
Scale bar 0
0
North
20 m
100 m
20 m
North
100 m
20 m
0
9%:+$'"0)$:"0
F1*+:+#3$:"0
5&3%*%3L$:"0
G0"&+$013+#3%"')$:"0
20 m
0
100 m
M,1/,"::+$:"0
‘Potentials’ translation
0
Scale bar
Scale bar
100 m
Scale bar
North
North
Scale bar 0
20 m
20 m
100 m
100 m
M(-'%&#+))$:"0
X0+##+))$:"0
‘Qualities’ translation
G1&%"'$"33,"&31,)$:"0
G1&%"'$"&3%*%3L$:"0
G0"3%"'$.%*+,)%3L
Figure 62 Method of socio-spatial common ground
Socio-Spatial common ground \$]%32%#$32+$3,"#)'"3%1#H$)1&%"'$ :"0)$ "#.$ )0"3%"'$ :"0)$ ",+$ :+,/+.$ 31/+32+,$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ (#\ .+,)3"#.$)1&%"'$)%3("3%1#$r$32+$&1::(#%3L$%.+#3%3L$",+")$r$32+$ .%*+,)%3L$14$32+$",+"$r$V2+,+$32+$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$%#3+,3V%#+$r$"#.$ 32+$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$013+#3%"')$14$32+$)0"&+> R1,$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ .+)%/#H$ [("'%3%+)$ "#.$ 013+#3%"')$ &"#$-+$()+.$%#$&,+"3%#/$)L#+,/L$-+3V++#$32+$)1&%"'$"#.$)0"3%"'$ +#*%,1#:+#3>$x("'%3%+)$#++.$31$-+$/%*+#$)0"&+$"#.$-+$+#2"#\ &+.$ "#.$ 013+#3%"')$ ",+$ 01))%-%'%3%+)$ 41,$ "$ 4(3(,+$ 3,"#)41,:"3%\ 1#$"#.$,+#+V"'$14$32+$",+">$JL$&1:-%#%#/$32+)+$:"0)$)L#+,/L$ %)$ ,+)+",&2+.$ -+3V++#$ 32+$ )1&%"'$ "#.$ )0"3%"'$ "#/'+>$ W#$ 1,.+,$
31$ 0'"&+$ +*+,L32%#/$ 32+$ &1:01)%3%1#$ :"0)$ :",<$ 32+$ 02L)%&"'$ ",+"$"#.$0'"&+)>$W#$32+$41''1V%#/$0"/+)$32+$41(,$013+#3%"'$"#.$ [("'%3L$ :"0)$ ",+$ )21V#$ #":+'Lb$ -304)# 3.$)*$,0(-# 203=# -.4,0(# 0$$&04$.&-# 203=# -.4,0(# 04$,7,$/# 203# 0*1# -30$,0(# 1,7)&-,$/# 203;# 92+)+$:"0)$",+$0",3$14$"#$+Q0'1,"3%*+$,+)+",&2$%4$32%)$"00,1"&2$ &"#$/%*+$"#)V+,)$"-1(3$32+$)1&%"'\)0"3%"'$&1::1#$/,1(#.$"#.$ provide insight in the patterns of a post conflict neighborhood. 92%)$"00,1"&2$"%:)$31$)21V&")+$32+$'1&"'$0"33+,#)$32"3$&"#$-+$ identified through this research. In order to use this method as "$ /11.$ -")+$ 41,$ .+)%/#$ ,+)+",&2$ :1,+$ +Q3+#)%*+$ ."3"$ %)$ #++\ .+.> A8
Space Potentials
potentials of spaces of the neighborhood
Vacancies under construction Open space related to business Strategic open spaces used for parking Traffic intensive road
Possible street drivers Strategic streets as backbone Possible corner attraction Strategic corner space Outdoor space related to particular buildings Underused open space
Figure 63 Spatial Potentials map Dodona
Spatial Potentials Dodona \$P1:-%#%#/$32+$&1:01)%3%1#$:"0)$ 14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$V%32$)+'+&3+.$)1&%"'$"#.$)0"3%"'$:"0)$0,1\ *%.+)$ %#)%/23$ %#$ 32+$ )0"3%"'$ 013+#3%"')$ 14$ 32+$ ",+">$ P1:-%#%#/$ 32+$3%:+\'"0)+$:"0)H$:1*+:+#3$:"0)$"#.$0,1/,":$:"0$)0"\ &+)$ V%32$ 013+#3%"'%3%+)$ 41,$ 4(3(,+$ 0(-'%&$ 4(#&3%1#$ "#.$ &1::1#$ use. The dense neighborhood with at first sight limited space 41,$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+)H$ .1+)$ 2"*+$ "$ *",%+3L$ 14$ )0"&+)$ )(%3"-'+$ 41,$ 0(-'%&$()+>$92%)$:"0$0,1*%.+)$%:01,3"#3$%#41,:"3%1#$41,$4(3(,+$ .+*+'10:+#3$14$0(-'%&$.+)%/#>$W3$-+&1:+)$&'+",$32"3$%4$32+$0(\ -'%&$.1:"%#$V"#3)$31$+Q0"#.$#+V$%##1*"3%*+$32%#<%#/$%)$,+[(%\ ,+.$31$3,"#)41,:$32+)+$)0"&+)$%#31$0(-'%&$0'"&+)> AC
Social Attractors
attracion areas of the neighborhood
Social attractor Attractor High value street Attractor Corner space Attractor Attractive spaces
Figure 64 Social Attractors Dodona
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
'%:%3+.>$W4$)1&%"'$"&3%*%3%+)$3"<+$0'"&+$%#$32+$0",<H$%3$%)$$:1)3'L$1#$ '1&"'$%#%3%"3%*+>$X#'L$41,$&2%'.,+#$"$-")%&$0'"L/,1(#.$%)$0,1*%.+.$ -(3$ )++%#/$ 32+$ P%3L$ M",<$ ")$ 32+$ '",/+,$ /,++#$ *+#(+$ V%32%#$ 32+$ &%3L$'%:%3)$%3)$14$011,$[("'%3L>$92+$"&&+))%-%'%3L$"#.$*%)%-%'%3L$%)$"$ 0,1-'+:$"#.$#++.$31$-+$%:0,1*+.>$J(3$32+$M",<$"33,"&3)$0+10\ '+$"#.$2")$013+#3%"'$")$"$)1&%"'$"33,"&31,$V%32%#$32+$)&"'+$14$32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$-(3$"')1$%#$32+$'",/+,$&1#3+Q3>
AZ
Social Activity
active areas of the neighborhood
high frequency use Pedestrian spaces Indoor extensions of public groundfloor vacancies Concentration activity Homogeneus places Homogeneus spaces Heterogeneus place Heterogeneus space under construction
Figure 65 Social activity map Dodona
Social Activity map Dodona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
41,$%)$()+)>$a+*+,32+'+))$32+$:"0$)21V)$*",%1()$",+")$V%32$%#3+\ ,+)3%#/$)1&%"'$"&3%*%3L$-(3$%#&,+")+.$[("'%3L$14$0'"&+$%)$.+)%,+.>$ a+Q3$ 31$ 32%)$ :"0$ "$ :1,+$ %#3+#)%*+$ ,+)+",&2$ %)$ ,+[(%,+.$ "-1(3$ '1&"'$-+2"*%1,$"#.$)1&%"'$#+3V1,<)>
8!
Spatial Diversity
Diverse build development of the neighborhood
Pre-1999 strict for business Pre-1999 family housing & business Commercial urban streets Post-1999 Family housing & business Commercial residential streets Post-1999 Apartments & business Poor high urban streets Park oriented streets
Spatial Diversity of Dodona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`$4++'%#/$14$32+$)0"&+>$
Figure 66 Spatial diversity of Dodona
87
Patterns of Dodona \$ 92+$ *",%+3L$ 14$ &1::1#$ /,1(#.$ :"0)$ "#.$ 32+$ :+321.$ 14$ ,+)+",&2%#/$ 32+$ )1&%1\)0"3%"'$ .%:+#)%1#$ of the neighborhood identifies patterns of Dodona. These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
patterns of post conďŹ&#x201A;ict
spatial design poten
01. crossing social groups 02. community identity 03. traffic intensive road 04. urban park 05. existing commercial street 06. potential attractors space 07. dense urban development 08. mixed commercial streets 09. residential areas 10. residual spaces between buildings 11. abandoned buildings 12. space under construction 13. building under construction 14. strategic open spaces uesed for parking 15. underused open space 16. inner block space 17. space related to specific buildings 18. vacancies 19. social attractor 20. attractors corner 21. activity concentration points 22. enclosed green 23. variety facades 24. build diversity 25. diverse street profiles 26. public facility
01. crossing social group 02. community identity 03. traffic intensive road 04. urban park 05. existing commercial 06. potential attractors s 07. dense urban develo 08. mixed commercial s 09. residential areas 10. residual spaces betw 11. abandoned building 12. space under constru 13. building under cons 14. strategic open space 15. underused open spa 16. inner block space 17. space related to spe 18. vacancies 19. social attractor 20. attractors corner 21. activity concentratio 22. enclosed green 23. variety facades 24. build diversity 25. diverse street profile 26. public facility
Fig. 67 Patterns of Dodona
4.4 THE PUBLIC SURVEY Objective of a survey$\$a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
92+$0(-'%&$)(,*+L$%#&'(.+.$[(+)3%1#)$%#$32+$41''1V%#/$32+:+)b y$ y$ y$ y$ y$
n+#+,"'$[(+)3%1#)$14$32+$'%*%#/$)%3("3%1# x(+)3%1#)$1#$32+$[("'%3L$14$(,-"#$'%4+ U*"'("3%1#$14$32+$)"3%)4"&3%1#$V%32$32+$02L)%&"'$&1#3+Q3 UQ0'1,"3%1#$14$32+$'1&"'$0(-'%&$'%4+ x(+)3%1#)$"-1(3$32+$(,-"#$#++.)
W#$1,.+,$31$/"%#$%#41,:"3%1#$"-1(3$(,-"#$[("'%3%+)$"#.$&1#.%3%\ 1#)$4,1:$"$,"#/+$14$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$32+$)(,*+L$V")$3,"#)'"3+.$%#$ 5'-"#%"#$-L$;Y1''&"$M1.*1,%&"$V21$%)$"#$%#.+0+#.+#3$",&2%3+&3$ V1,<%#/$%#$M,%)23%#">$W#$1,.+,$31$,+"&2$"$V%.+$*",%+3L$14$%#2"-%\ 3"#3)H$4,1:$V1,<%#/$&'"))$31$+'.+,'L$31$.%44+,+#3$+32%&"'%3%+)$V+$ :".+$ &1#3"&3$ V%32$ 32+$ )1$ &"''+.$ jJ")<%)2$ S1<"'+k$ ]21$ %)$ 32+$ '1&"'$ #+%/2-1,211.$ ,+0,+)+#3"3%*+>$ W#$ 32+1,L$ "$ -,"#&2$ 14$ 32+$ '1&"'$ /1*+,#:+#3$ V21$ %)$ "001%#3+.$ 31$ 1*+,)++$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,\ 211.$"#.$)(001,3$32+$'1&"'$)1&%+3L>$]%32$2%)$2+'0H$"$V%.+$,"#/+$ 14$%#2"-%3"#3)$V")$,+"&2+.$V%32$32+$)(,*+L>$W#$32+1,L$"$)(,*+L$ #++.)$ "$ :%#%:(:$ ":1(#3$ 14$ ,+)01#.+#3)$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ )21V$ "$ ,+'%"-'+$4,":+$14$,+)('3)$%#$0,"&3%&+$V+$,+"&2+.$6B$%#2"-%3"#3)>$ 92+$'%:%3+.$3%:+H$.+3"%'+.$&1#3+#3$14$32+$)(,*+L$"#.$32+$&('3(\ ral settings of performing a survey made it difficult to reach a '",/+,$ #(:-+,$ 14$ ,+)%.+#3)>$ a+*+,32+'+))H$ 32+$ )(,*+L$ ,+)('3+.$ %#$"$,%&2$+Q0+,%+#&+$14$-132$:+$"#.$;Y1''&"H$V2+#$/1%#/$.11,$ 31$.11,$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$W3$%)$"$/11.$V"L$31$/+3$%#$&1#3"&3$ V%32$L1(,$&1#3+Q3$"#.$%#&,+")+$32+$(#.+,)3"#.%#/$14$32+$2(:"#$ -+2"*%1,>$92+$,+)('3)$14$32+$)(,*+L$)21V$"#$%#%3%"'$*%+V$14$'1&"'$ 10%#%1#)$"#.$#++.$31$-+$)++#$")$%#3+,+)3%#/$01%#3)$14$*%+V$,"\ ther than use it as official academic research.
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`)$0",3%&%0"3%1#$"#.$%#&,+")%#/$32+$,+)('3)$ 14$32+$,+)+",&2>$J+33+,$(#.+,)3"#.%#/$&"#$",%)+$%4$32+$)(,*+L$%)$ .1#+$%#$-%//+,$#(:-+,)>$$ 86
What would you like to have in the streets / Dodona neighborhood? Çfarë dëshironi të keni në rrugët/lagjen tuaj Dodona?
THE PUBLIC SURVEY written and visual questionnaire on urban conditions and public needs
Delft University of Technology
Thomas Victor Vink translated in Albanian by Vjollca Podvorica
Fig. 68 Survey of Dodona’s urban quality
Clear street use Qartësi për përdoruesin
Streetcrossing paths Kalim për këmbësorë
Parking spaces Vende parkimi
Community gardens / urban farming Kopshte të komunite t / fermat urbane
7 votes
8 votes
19 votes
10 votes
Places with shading Strehim
Urban greenery Gjelbërim
Pedestrian zones Zonat e këmbësorëve
Places for sitting / relaxing Vende për të ulur / çlodhur
4 votes
15 votes
13 votes
14 votes
Spaces for meeting friends Hapësira për të takuar miq
Places for children Vende për fëmijë
Street markets Tregjet rrugë
Social activities Aktivitete sociale
7 votes
12 votes
2 votes
15 votes
Fig. 69 Visual survey of Dodona’s needs
!"#$%&'(%)#*$%$'%"#+,%'*%$",%-$.,,$-%/% 0'1'*#%2*%&'(.%*,23"4'."''15 ?@A
67,#.%-$.,,$%(-,%
?EA
8$.,,$9.'--2*3%:#$"-
BCA
;#.<2*3%-:#9,-
D?A
6'==(*2$&%3#.1,*-%/%(.4#*%>#.=2*3
;7#9,-%)2$"%-"#12*3
FGA
KEA
H.4#*%3.,,*,.&
EKA
;,1,-$.2#*%I'*,-
KFA
;7#9,-%>'.%-2$$2*3%/%.,7#J2*3
?@A
8:#9,-%>'.%=,,$2*3%>.2,*1-
;7#9,-%>'.%9"271.,*
8$.,,$%=#.<,$-
8'92#7%L9$2+2$2,-
ECA
%MA
KEA
Fig. 70 Visual survey results
Fig. 71 Participants of the questionnaire
8@
What you want to have on the streets / Dodona in your neighborhood? 95,7%
Amount of public green spaces
91,4%
Street safety
Accessibility by foot
82,7%
Visually pleasent streets and buildings
82,7%
Conditions of surrounding buildings
82,7%
78,5%
Accessibility by public transport
69,6%
Close proximity to public space
65,1%
Variety of program and functions Mix of cultures & people (ethnic, elderly, children, etc.)
56,5%
Amount of people living close to each other to interact with
52,2%
Public services and community buildings
43,4%
Accessibility by car
Figure 72: Important elements in a quality of urban life \$ ]2"3$ %)$ 32+$ %:01,3"#&+$14$32+$41''1V%#/$h(,-"#i$0,10+,3%+)$"#.$&1#.%3%1#)$%#$L1(,$.%\ ,+&3$'%*%#/$+#*%,1#:+#3f$92+$,+)('3)$)21V$32"3$32+$":1(#3$14$h0(-'%&i$/,++#$ "#.$ /,++#$ )0"&+)$ %)$ "#$ %:01,3"#3$ [("'%3L$ 14$ (,-"#$ +#*%,1#:+#3)$ "#.$ 32+$ "&&+))%-%'%3L$-L$&",$'+")3$%:01,3"#3>$
34,8%
30,4%
Places for social interaction
Figure: 55 Evaluation of the satisfaction with the physical context
Opportunities to use green space are good
63%
Social interaction possibilities are good
63%
The organization of space is comfortable
52,1%
Quality space is provided to pursue your choice of activities
47,8%
Opportunities to use public spaces are good
43,5%
39,1%
Enough space to spend time outside Living conditions are up to good standards
36,9%
Walking is a pleasant activity in Dodona (functional speaking)
30,3%
The size of the buildings is at appropriate sizes
23,9%
It is pleasant to move around on foot (physical speaking)
23,9%
21,7%
The look of buildings is pleasant Open and build-up areas are well-balanced There is enough space & distance between buildings
Figure 73: Evaluation of the satisfaction with the physical context \$92%)$ .%"/,":$+Q0'"%#)$32+$'1&"'$)"3%)4"&3%1#$V%32$32+$02L)%&"'$&1#3+Q3>$K%44+,+#3$ ":+#%3%+)$2"*+$-++#$+*"'("3+.$%#$1,.+,$31$&"'&('"3+$'1&"'$)"3%)4"&3%1#>$M+1\ 0'+$%#$32%)$&")+$",+$:1)3$01)%3%*+$"-1(3$01))%-%'%3%+)$31$()+$/,++#$)0"&+$"#.$ '+")3$01)%3%*+$"-1(3$32+$":1(#3$14$)0"&+$'+43$-+3V++#$-(%'.%#/)>
17,3%
4,3%
8E
What are possible reasons for leaving Dodona related to the public life (more answers possible)
56%
52% 39%
39%
35%
30%
30%
22%
I participate in public gatherings
I am interested in making new friends in the neighborhod
I invite friends & family to come to my neighborhood
I meet friends & family in the neighborhood
I meet with friends in public places
I try to make contact when am outside
I engage in social activities
I spend free time outside in my neighborhood
I feel part of community in my neighborhood
17%
Figure 74: Exploration of the local @;67)#$7)?'$\$92%)$):"''$+Q0'1,"3%1#$%)$ "$ )3",3$ 31V",.)$ (#.+,)3"#.%#/$ V2"3$ '1&"'$0(-'%&$'%4+$&1#)%)3)$14>$
How satisfied would you say you are on a scale from 0-10 with your current place of living?
26%
Figure 75: Satisfaction with place of living - How satisfied would you )"L$L1($",+$1#$"$)&"'+$4,1:$!\7!$V%32$ L1(,$&(,,+#3$0'"&+$14$'%*%#/f$X*+,"''H$ V2"3$ %)$ 32+$ )"3%)4"&3%1#$ '+*+'$ 14$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.f
17% 13%
9%
9%
13%
9%
4% 0% 1
2
3
4
5
0% 6
7
8
9
10
Figure: 58 Reasons for leaving Dodona neighborhood
30%
22%
Accessibility of the neighborhood by car
Accessibility of the neighborhood by foot
9%
Scarce facilitation of public spaces
Scarce amout of green amenities
Level of housing conditions
9%
Opportunities to interact with neighbors
22%
Level of street safety (crime, accidetns)
30%
Other
26%
Crowdedness of the neighborhood
35%
35%
Figure 76: Reasons for leaving DoC dona \$]2"3$",+$01))%-'+$,+")1#)$41,$ '+"*%#/$K1.1#"$,+'"3+.$31$32+$0(-'%&$ '%4+$h:1,+$"#)V+,)$01))%-'+i>$
Use of the survey in the project$\$92+$1(3&1:+)$14$32+$)(,*+L$ 3+''$ ()$ V2"3$ (,-"#$ &2","&3+,%)3%&)$ ",+$ %:01,3"#3$ "#.$ ",+$ '+))$ %:01,3"#3$ 31$ 41&()$ 1#$ "#.$ V2%&2$ +'+:+#3)$ ",+$ +*"'("3+.$ ")$ %:0+,4+&3$ "#.$ )21('.$ -+$ ".Y()3+.>$ W3$ "')1$ %#)0%,+)$ 31$ .+*+'10$ "$.+)%/#$)'%/23'L$.%44+,+#3$32+#$W$V1('.$.1$41,$"$.%44+,+#3$0'"&+$ 32"3$2")$"$.%44+,+#3$)1&%1\&('3(,"'$-"&</,1(#.>$W3$%)$/11.$31$3"<+$ %#$&1#)%.+,"3%1#$32+$10%#%1#$14$32+$0(-'%&$-+&"()+$%#$32+$+#.$ 32+L$ ",+$ 32+$ +Q0+,3)$ 1#$ '%*%#/$ &1:41,3$ %#$ 32+%,$ .%,+&3$ +#*%,1#\ :+#3>$ K(,%#/$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ 0,1&+))H$ W$ V%''$ 0+,%1.%&"''L$ 3+)3$ 32+$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ V%32$ 32+$ #++.)$ "#.$ 0,%1,%3%+)$ 14$ 32+$ 0(-'%&>$ 92%)$ )21('.$"'V"L)$-+$.1#+$.(,%#/$"$.+)%/#$0,1Y+&3$31$:L$10%#%1#>$$ 5'321(/2$ 32+$ #(:-+,$ 14$ ,+)01#.+#3)$ %)$ ):"''$ 32+$ %#41,:"3%1#$ 32"3$%)$&1''+&3+.$.1+)$/%*+$()$#+V$<#1V'+./+$1#$32+$'1&"'$)"\ 3%)4"&3%1#>$F"#L$"#)V+,)$1#$0(-'%&$[(+)3%1#)$%#$32+$)(,*+L$",+$ #13$.%,+&3'L$)(,0,%)%#/$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$V2"3$%)$"#.$V2"3$%)$#13$ %:01,3"#3$ %#$ "$ [("'%3L$ #+%/2-1,211.$ -(3$ V%32$ 32+$ <#1V'+./+$ 14$ 32+$ %#.%*%.("'$ .+*+'10:+#3$ %#$ 32+$ 0")3$ L1($ V1('.$ +Q0+&3$
'+))$%#3+,+)3$%#$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$92%)$%)$32"#$"$01)%3%*+$,+)('3H$ V2%&2$ :"<+)$ &'+",$ 32"3$ %#2"-%3"#3)$ 14$ M,%)23%#"$ .1$ #13$ .%44+,$ 32"3$:(&2$4,1:$%#2"-%3"#3)$4,1:$V+)3+,#$&%3%+)>$92+L$.1$V"#3$ "$&1:41,3"-'+$"#.$)"4+$#+%/2-1,211.$V%32$0'+#3L$14$/,++#+,LH$ )0"&+$31$-,+"32$"#.$0'"&+)$31$:++3\(0$V%32$4,%+#.)$"#.$4":%'L>$ 92%)$ "')1$ &":+$ 1(3$ 14$ 32+$ %#3+,*%+V)$ V%32$ '1&"'$ 0,14+))%1#"')$ V2+#$ V+$ V+,+$ 3"'<%#/$ "-1(3$ 32+$ &1#3+:01,",L$ 010('"3%1#`)$ #++.)$"#.$.+)%,+)$41,$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$F1)3$%:01,3"#3$+'+\ :+#3$14$32%)$)(,*+L$%)$32+$#++.$41,$%#&1,01,"3%1#$14$32+$0(-'%&$ %#$ "#L$ 4(3(,+$ .+&%)%1#>$ 92+$ '%33'+$ )"3%)4"&3%1#$ V%32$ 32+$ 02L)%&"'$ +#*%,1#:+#3$"#.$%3)$&1#.%3%1#)$%)$&,%3%&"'$"#.$#++.)$"$)3,"3+/L$ 31$ &2"#/+$ %3>$ ]%32%#$ 32%)$ 0,1Y+&3$ "#.$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ design I will try to influence the different interventions by the #+V$<#1V'+./+$4,1:$32+$)(,*+L>$53$32+$+#.$14$32+$.+)%/#$02"\ )+$W$V%''$+*"'("3+$32+$.+)%/#$31/+32+,$V%32$32+$)(,*+L$,+)('3)$%#$ 1,.+,$31$)++$%4$%3$2")$V1,<+.$&12+,+#3$V%32$32+$'1&"'$"#)V+,)>
8B
!"#$%#$
MFG'N*+,91'C*+*0.&)
88
MFG'N*+,91'.*+*0.&)
strategic public themes
spatial agenda
+
socio-spatial analysis Dodona
priority concept
Patterns
design interventions
spatial integration Fig. 77 Design Research Framework
The public carpet design is developed for Dodona, a post-conflict affected neighborhood in central Prish\ tina. The starting point of the public carpet design is the conclusion from the post conflict conditions (see 0"/>$E6iH$"#.$32+$"%:$14$,+#+V%#/$32+$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$&1::1#$/,1(#.$%#31$"$,%&2$0(-'%&$,+"':$32"3$#+3V1,<)$ "''$'+*+')$14$)1&%+3L$"#.$10+#)$(0$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$31$#+%/2-1,%#/$",+")>$92+$.+*+'10:+#3$"#.$.+)%/#$14$ h)0"3%"'i$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$32"3$%#3+/,"3+$%#$32+$(,-"#$'"L1(3$14$K1.1#"$"#.$)3",3$32+$3,"#)%3%1#$14$32+$#+%/2-1,\ 211.$31V",.)$"$:1,+$'%*"-'+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3$41,$%3)$,+)%.+#3)$"#.$-+L1#.$",+$32+#$32+$:"%#$.+)%/#$3")<>$ In order to develop and design interventions for Dodona I use the design research framework, see fig. 59. W$)3",3+.$V%32$32+$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$"#"'L)%)$14$K1.1#"$"#.$0","''+'$V1,<+.$1#$32+$)3,"3+/%&$0(-'%&$32+:+)>$W$()+$ 32+$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)$%#$&1:-%#"3%1#$V%32$32+$"#"'L)%)$14$K1.1#"$31$)+",&2$41,$)L#+,/%+)$"#.$01))%-%'%3%+)$ 41,$K1.1#">$92+$0,%1,%3L$&1#&+03$%)$.+*+'10+.$%#$1,.+,$31$0'"&+$32+$)0"3%"'$,+[(%,+:+#3)$%#31$0"33+,#)$14$ post-conflict. It organizes the design interventions into 3 groups which stand for the line of designing. The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by the elements that influence the interventions.
5.1 PRIORITIES CONCEPT 92+$0,%1,%3%+)$&1#&+03$%)$)+,*+)$")$32+$-")+$14$32+$.+)%/#$0,1Y+&3>$92+$&1#&+03$%)$/(%.%#/$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$ of the design. In the situation and with the conditions of a post conflict affected neighborhood there is a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level has a sufficient base then the second and third level of the design can develop as part of that first le\ vels public network. Whereas the first level is already owned by public bodies like the municipality or state, 32+$)+&1#.$'+*+'$%)$)0"&+$32"3$%)$%#$0,%*"3+$1,$(#<#1V#$1V#+,)2%0$"#.$32+$32%,.$'+*+'$)0"&+$32"3$%)$"$/+#+,"'$ /11.$"#.$)1$#++.)$+Q3+#)%*+$&1#)('3"3%1#>$92+$)+&1#.$'+*+'$%)$3,"#)41,:%#/$)0"&+)$%#$1,.+,$31$+#'",/+$32+$ limited public space network create in the first level. The third level is adding elements to public and private .1:"%#$V2%&2$V%''$%#&,+")+$32+$[("'%3L$14$32+$)0"&+$"#.$&,+"3+$('3%:"3+$)L#+,/L$-+3V++#$)1&%"'$"#.$)0"3%"'$ .%:+#)%1#)$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$W#$"..%3%1#H$%3$"%:)$31$&,1))$#+%/2-1,211.$-1,.+,)$"#.$)1&%"'$)+/,+/"3%1#$ %3$-,%#/)$V%32$%3>$92+$&1#3+#3$"#.$0'"&+:+#3$14$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$&1:+)$4,1:$32+$'1&"'$41(#.$0"33+,#)$"#.$ /+#+,"'$:(#%&%0"'$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)$1#$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$.+*+'10:+#3>$]%32%#$32+$&1#&+03$321)+$V%''$)+,*+$")$ 32+$-")+$41,$32+$4(3(,+$.+)%/#$%#3+,*+#3%1#)> 8C
MAXIMUM
DESIRED
MINIMUM
DODONA
Post conflict conditions & situations
Renewal of exisiting public domain & space - new public network New public domain and spaces Establishing a public-private relationship Creating social-spatial synergy Transformation of (semi)-private spaces extending the new public network
Adding new public buildings & elements as part of the new public network
Fig. 78 Strategic spatial agenda
8Z
gs
parking
gs
01. Governmental Integration & Co-operation
01. public policies for livability
02. district borders as centers
03. stakeholder meetings
04. pilot projects
05. Local office & broader representation
02. Public Accessibility
06. organization of streets
07. safe pedestrian routes
08. public transport routes
09. clear public service network
10. shared spaces street users
03. Community & Society Interplay
11. supply micro places
12. multi user spaces
13. various activities provided
14. shared front yard design
15. communial building & space
16. clear & visible access to parks
17. organization of cultural events
18. urban greenery & gardens
19. managment and maintenance
20. cultural moving spaces
21. supporting incubators
22. co-sharing of groundfloors
23. mixed student / proffessonal
24. adaptable business units
25. outdoor commercial space
26. streets support the unique building styles
27. Repetiton elements for recognizing networks
28. advanced legalisation process
29. marketing strategy
30. attraction signs
spatial design potential 01. crossing social groups 02. community identity 03. traffic intensive road 04. urban park 05. existing commercial street 06. potential attractors space 07. dense urban development 08. mixed commercial streets 09. residential areas 10. residual spaces between buildings 11. abandoned buildings 12. space under construction 13. building under construction 14. strategic open spaces uesed for parking 15. underused open space 16. inner block space 17. space related to specific buildings 18. vacancies 19. social attractor 20. attractors corner 21. activity concentration points 22. enclosed green 23. variety facades 24. build diversity 25. diverse street profiles 26. public facility
04. Environmental & Cultural facilitation
05. Knowledge & Economic Stimulation
06. Historical and contemporary Identity
Physical Interventions
Fig. 79 Patterns of post conflict
Public Policy & Organizational activities
Fig. 80 Patterns of post conflict
5.2 SOCIO-SPATIAL PATTERNS
5.3 SPATIAL AGENDA
Through extensive research of the post conflict situation in Dodo\ #"$#+%/2-1,211.>$5$'%)3$14$0"33+,#)$%)$32+$,+)('3$14$32"3$,+)+",&2$ 32"3$ .+)&,%-+$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.`)$ )1&%1\)0"3%"'$ &1#.%3%1#>$ 921)+$ 0"33+,#)$",+$01)%3%*+$1,$#+/"3%*+$+'+:+#3)$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$ "#.$ ",+$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#>$ 5)$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$32+$.+)%/#H$7!$&,%3%&"'$0"33+,#)$",+$&21)+#>$921)+$)21V$)0"3%"'$ .+)%/#$013+#3%"'$%#$1,.+,$31$&,+"3+$"$,+#+V+.$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$ )2"0+$"$0(-'%&$)0"&+$#+3V1,<$-(3$"')1$31$0,1*%.+$/11.$)0"&+$41,$ 32+$+Q%)3%#/$)1&%"'$[("'%3%+)>$921)+$7!$0"33+,#)$",+b$32+$(,-"#$0",<H$ "-"#.1#+.$-(%'.%#/)H$)0"&+$(#.+,$&1#)3,(&3%1#H$-(%'.%#/)$(#.+,$ &1#)3,(&3%1#H$ (#.+,()+.$ 10+#$ )0"&+H$ %##+,$ -'1&<$ )0"&+H$ )0"&+$ related to specific buildings, vacancies, attractors corners, diver\ se street profiles and public facility. These patterns will be the '1&"3%1#)$ 41,$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ "#.$ -+&1:+$ 32+$ 02L)%&"'$ 0(-'%&$#+3V1,<>$92+L$",+$%#$011,$&1#.%3%1#H$2"*+$'%:%3+.$&1##+&\ tion with the public domain, are difficult to enter or create unat\ 3,"&3%*+$ ",+")$ %#$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.>$ ]%32%#$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+$.+)%/#$32+)+$0"33+,#)$V%''$-+$,+#+V+.H$3,"#)41,:+.$1,$"..+.$ ")$0",3$14$"$[("'%3L$0(-'%&$)0"&+$#+3V1,<>$R1,$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$ 32+)+$)0"&+)$")$0",3$14$32+$#+V$0(-'%&$.1:"%#H$32+$&1#3+#3$#++.)$ 31$ -+$ "..+.$ 31$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ 4,":+V1,<>$ R,1:$ 32+$ ,+)+",&2H$ #+V$ )3,"3+/%&$32+:+)$2"*+$-++#$41,:('"3+.$%#$1,.+,$31$"..$32+$,%/23$ +'+:+#3)$31$32+$#+V$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$921)+$2"*+$"$)0"3%"'$&1#3+#3$ "#.$32"3$#++.)$31$-+$%#3+/,"3+$%#$32+$.+)%/#$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$%#$1,.+,$ 31$/%*+$32+$.+)%/#$:+"#%#/>$W#$32+$+#.H$32+$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$&1::1#$ /,1(#.$14$32+$",+"$#++.)$+:-,"&+.$"#.$)2"0+$"$[("'%3L$)0"&+>
92+$ )0"3%"'$ "/+#."$ %)$ 32+$ &1#3+#3$ 14$ 32+$ )3,"3+/%&$ 32+:+)$ 32"3$ 2"*+$-++#$41,:+.$32,1(/2$+Q3+#)%*+$,+)+",&2$14$M,%)3%#"`)$/1*+,\ #"#&+$"#.$0'"##%#/$)%3("3%1#>$92+$A$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)H$32"3$2"*+$ -++#$ 41,:('"3+.$ 1#$ 0>$ EE$ 14$ 32+$ ,+01,3H$ ",+$ 32+$ 1-Y+&3%*+)$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L`)$ )0"3%"'$ 0'"##%#/$ .+0",3:+#3$ )21('.$ 2"*+$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$,+#+V$"#.$3,"#)41,:$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$)0"&+)$%#31$[("\ '%3L$",+")>$92+$A$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)$",+b$S.7)&*2)*$0(#E*$)F&0$,.*# ]#G.Q.3)&0$,.*=#[%'(,4#"44)--,',(,$/=#G.22%*,$/#]#<.4,)$/#E*$)&Q 3(0/=#^*7,&.*2)*$0(#]#G%($%&0(#504,(,$0$,.*=#6*.9()1F)#]#^4.*.Q 2,4#<$,2%(0$,.*#0*1#_,-$.&,40(#0*1#4.*$)23.&0&/#E1)*$,$/>$92+)+$ 32+:+)$",+$"''$41&()+.$1#$"$-+33+,$0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$,+'"3%1#)2%0$"#.$ %:0,1*+:+#3$14$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$)0"&+)>$92+$)0"3%"'$"/+#\ ."$ ",+$ 32+$ 01'%&L$ &2"#/+)H$ 1,/"#%e"3%1#"'$ "&3%1#)$ "#.$ 02L)%&"'$ +'+:+#3)$,+'"3+.$31$32+$.%44+,+#3$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)>$U*+,L$32+:+H$ %#&'(.+)$"$*",%+3L$14$)1&%"'\)0"3%"'$,+[(%,+:+#3)$%#$1,.+,$31$%:0,1\ *+$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$%3)$)0"&+)>$J+)%.+)$32"3H$%3$"%:)$41,$"#$ %:0,1*+:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ ,+'"3%1#)2%0$ -+3V++#$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ %#)3%3(3%1#)$ "#.$ 0,%*"3+$ &1:0"#%+)$ "#.$ 1,/"#%e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e%#/$32+$,+#+V+.$0(-'%&$41&()>$ C!
MINIMUM INTERVENTIONS
Str ee
rge
Cro
La
ssi
06. organization of streets
07. safe pedestrian routes
10. shared spaces street users
14. shared front yard design
ba Ur
s
ce
pa
ns
ts
11. supply micro places
ng
s
16. clear & visible access to parks
26. streets support the unique building styles
27. Repetiton elements for recognizing networks
18. urban greenery & gardens
DESIRED INTERVENTIONS
Ab
an
do
ne
d
Inn
er
blo
ck
sp
ace
Un
Va ca
ed
ish
ďŹ n
s
n
tio
uc
str
n co
nci
17. organization of cultural events
21. supporting incubators
22. co-sharing of groundfloors
23. mixed student / proffessonal
24. adaptable business units
25. outdoor commercial space
es
12. multi user spaces
20. cultural moving spaces
18. urban greenery & gardens
13. various activities provided
MAXIMUM INTERVENTIONS
ral r ltu to Cu nnec o c
02. district borders as centers
15. communal building & space
30. attractive power
12. multi user spaces
Fig. 81 Content of the Priorities concept
5.4 DESIGN CONTENT 92+$"&3("'$.+)%/#$&1#3+#3$14$32+$.+)%/#$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$%)$"$&1:-%\ #%#/$32+$)0"3%"'$"/+#."$V%32$32+$7!$&,%3%&"'$0"33+,#)$14$01)3$&1#\ flict and position them in the priorities concept. Connecting the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b$+)3"-'%)2%#/$"$,+'"3%1#)2%0$-+3V++#$32+$0,%*"3+$.1:"%#$"#.$ '1&"'$)1&%+3L$"#.$32+$0(-'%&$-1.%+)$14$32+$&%3L>$W3$%)$+Q3,+:+'L$%:\ C7
01,3"#3$%#$32%)$+#*%,1#:+#3$31$&,+"3+$/11.$&1##+&3%1#)$-+3V++#$ -132$%#$1,.+,$31$&2"#/+$32+$0,+*%1()$0+,%1.$14$%#.%*%.("'%):>$5$ ,+#+V+.$)+#)+$14$&1::(#%3L$"#.$&%3%e+#)2%0$%)$32+$('3%:"3+$/1"'$ V%32%#$32%)$0,1Y+&3> Within the first level, the minimum, 3 interventions are develo\ 0+.>$X#$0(-'%&$/,1(#.)$"$*",%+3L$14$)0"3%"'$"/+#."$01%#3)$V%''$-+$ %#3+/,"3+.$"#.$,+#+V$32+$+Q%)3%#/$)0"&+>$]%32%#$32+$.+)%,+.$'+*+'H$ )0"3%"'$"/+#."$01%#3)$&"#$-+$"..,+))+.$"#.$+#,%&2$32+$0(-'%&$#+3\ V1,<>$X#$32+$:"Q%:(:$'+*+'H$"..%#/$"$#+V$0(-'%&$-(%'.%#/$&"#$ -+&1:+$32+$&1##+&3%#/$0(-'%&$+'+:+#3$-+3V++#$#+%/2-1,211.)$ "#.$%3)$&1#3+#3$"$&1:-%#"3%1#$14$0(-'%&$)+,*%&+)>$
5.5 DESIGN INTERVENTIONS
3+,:)$:"<+$)0"&+$41,$+#Y1L%#/$32+$)3,++3$")$"$0'"&+>$W3$%)$32+$1,\ /"#%e"3%1#$14$32+$)3,++3)$%#$1,.+,$31$)+,*+$%3)$0(,01)+$%#$/+#+,"'$ 3+,:)b$"$)0"&+$41,$:1*+:+#3$-(3$4(,32+,$.(+$31$&1#.%3%1#)$14$32+$ '",/+,$&1#3+Q3$"#.$&1#.%3%1#)$14$'%:%3+.$0(-'%&$)0"&+b$")$"$0'"&+>$ W#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ .1$ )1H$ ,+0+3%3%1#$ %)$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ &"':$ 32+$ .%)1,.+,+.$ )3,++3)>$ X#$ 32+$ 132+,$ )%.+H$ #+V$ #+3V1,<)$ 14$ &1::(#%3L$ )3",3$ "3$ that same street. Providing space for the direct ground floor func\ 3%1#$ 1,$ 21:+$ 10+#)$ (0$ 32+$ -1,.+,$ -+3V++#$ 0(-'%&$ "#.$ 0,%*"3+>$ T+)+,*+.$ 0+,)1#"'%e+.$ )0"&+$ W$ V%''$ &"''$ 32"3H$ 32+$ )0"&+$ -+3V++#$ 32+$ -(%'.%#/$ "#.$ 32+$ )%.+V"'<>$ a+%/2-1,)$ V%32$ )%:%'",$ 321(/23)$ &"#$)2",+$32%)$)0"&+$"#.$.+*+'10$31/+32+,>$92+$)%e+$14$32+$)0"&+$ .+0+#.)$ ,"32+,$ 1#$ 32+$ 01)%3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ -(%'.%#/>$ F%#%:(:$ )%e+)$ for traffic and sidewalk are reserved. Last, with growing space on profiles, small micro places can exist. From a small flower bed to 0(-'%&$-+#&2+)$",1(#.$"$3,++>$
The design concept helped me to define the design interventions V2%&2$ V%''$ &2"#/+$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ %#$ "#$ ",+"$ "44+&3+.$ -L$ 32+$ urban transitioning processes after a conflict. These interventions ",+$1,/"#%e+.$%#$32,++$&"3+/1,%+)>$R%,)3H$32+$0(-'%&$-")%&)$V2%&2$%)$ 32+$,+#+V"'$14$32+$011,$&1#.%3%1#$14$32+$+Q%)3%#/$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$ 92+)+$2"*+$32,++$(,-"#$+'+:+#3)b$'",/+$(,-"#$)0"&+)H$)3,++3)$"#.$ &1,#+,)>$92+$.+)%,+.$%)$32+$)3+0$(0$%#$1,.+,$31$+#'",/+$32+$'%:%3+.$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#>$ W3$ %)$ .%44+,+#3$ .(+$ 31$ %3)$ 1V#+,H$ :1)3'L$ "$ 0,%*"3+$ &1:0"#L$1,$%3$%)$(#<#1V#$"#.$.(+$%3)$0,1&+))$31$:"<+$%3$0",3$14$ 32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#b$3,"#)41,:"3%1#>$W#&'(.+.$%#$32%)$&"3+/1,Lb$%##+,$ block space, unfinished construction / left behind buildings and *"&"#&%+)>$S")3H$32+$:"Q%:(:$&"3+/1,L$%)$32+$3L0+b$"..%#/$)0"&+$ 31$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$92%)$&"#$-+$4,++'L$%#3+,0,+3+.>$W$&211)+$#1V$ 32"3$%3$V%''$-+$"..%#/$"$-(%'.%#/$14$V%32$0(-'%&$0(,01)+$-(3$%3$&"#$ "')1$ -+$ :"<%#/$ ",3$ %#$ 32+$ ,+)%.("'$ )0"&+)$ -+3V++#$ -(%'.%#/)$ 1,$ +Q3+#.%#/$32+$0",<$%#$3+,:)$14$*+,3%&"'$"#.$,114310$/",.+#)>
03. The concrete crossing 92+$ &1,#+,)$ "#.$ &,1))%#/)$ ",+$ /+#+,"''L$ "$ &2"13%&$ "))+:-'L$ 14$ uses, users, traffic, attractions and building typology. The corner #1V$"''$0"*+.H$:1)3'L$")02"'3$"#.$32+$&'1)+,$L1($/+3$31$32+$&1,#+,$ the more space for cars and motorized traffic. This is not what a &1,#+,$1,$&,1))%#/$)21('.$-+>$W3$%)$%#$/+#+,"'$3+,:)$"$,%)<%+,$",+"$ 14$32+$)3,++3)$"#.$)1$.+&,+")+$%#$)0++.$%)$"&&+03+.>$92+$&1,#+,)$ "#.$&,1))%#/)$V%''$-+$+%32+,$3,"#)41,:+.$%#$0'"&+)$V%32$)3,%&3$+./+)$ for dividing traffic from all other uses or the corner will transform %#31$"$)[(",+H$"$0'"&+$V2+,+$32+$&",$%)$/(+)3$"#.$32+$)0"&+$%)$()+.$ 4,++,>$W#$-132H$:1,+$)0"&+$%)$32+,+$41,$0+.+)3,%"#)H$&1,#+,$"33,"&\ 3%1#)H$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$/,++#+,L>$92+$&1,#+,$-+&1:+)$"$0'"&+>
0)8)0;0 !7>92+$%)1'"3+.$+&1'1/%&"'$O$&%3L$)0"&+ !6>$K%)1,.+,+.$)3,++3)&"0+ !@>$92+$&1#&,+3+$&,1))%#/ desired !E>92+$%##+,$-'1&<$N$P1,#+,$*1%.) !B>$92+$)'++0%#/$&1#)3,(&3%1#$N$"-"#.1#+.$0(-'%&$-(%'.%#/) !A>M'"##+.$*"&"#&%+)
desired 04. The inner block & corner voids JL$ :+"#)$ 14$ 2%)31,LH$ 32+$ 1,%/%#"'$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ K1.1#"$ 2")$ -++#$,+'"3+.$31$132+,$3L0+)$(,-"#$"#.$",&2%3+&3(,"'$3L01'1/L>$G++$ "00+#.%Q$7$%#3+,*%+V$V%32$U'%e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`)$ 0'"L/,1(#.)>$ 92+$)"4+$"#.$)+&(,+.$+#*%,1#:+#3$%)$/11.$41,$):"''$)&"'+$0'"&+)>
maximum !8>92+$)1&%"'O&('3(,"'$&1##+&31, )`$&0 ?BC;#E*7,-,'()#3%'(,4#-)&7,4)#Q#30&$#.5#2,*,2%2D ?BO;#P+)#&)-,1%0(#-304)-#]#4.*4&)$)#N%*F()#Q#30&$#.5#20`,2%2D
0)8)0;0 01. The Isolated ecological/attraction space UQ%)3%#/$(,-"#$)0"&+)$V%32$"$0(-'%&$1,$)+:%0(-'%&$4(#&3%1#$#++.$31$ -+$+#2"#&+.$")$&'+",$0'"&+)$41,$32+$+#3%,+$&1::(#%3L>$]%32$32+%,$ )%e+$"#.$)3,"3+/%&$'1&"3%1#)$1#$-1,.+,)$14$.%44+,+#3$.%)3,%&3)$32+%,$ 013+#3%"')$")$&1::1#$)2",+.$)0"&+$#++.$3,"#)41,:"3%1#$%#$1,.+,$ to function properly. It is also the first step in the state-community .%"'1/(+$%#$/%*%#/$[("'%3L$)0"&+$31$32+$)1&%+3L$"#.$+#2"#&+$32+$ '"&<%#/$&1::(#%&"3%1#$-+3V++#$-132>$92+$41''1V%#/$".Y()3:+#3)$ 32,1(/2$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ &1:0'+:+#3$ 32+$ "%:$ 31$ 10+#$ (0$ +Q%)3%#/$ )0"&+)$"#.$&2"#/+$32+:$%#31$0'"&+)$V2+,+$"$/,+"3$*",%+3L$14$32+$ community will find their needs when it comes to public spaces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
05. The sleeping construction & abandoned public buildings W#$6!7@H$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$14$M,%)23%#"$0(3$1#$21'.$1#$&1#)3,(&3%1#>$ This means today, that many buildings are unfinished and left to V"%3$41,$"$0'"#$32"3$%#&1,01,"3+)$32+%,$-(%'.%#/>$I#3%'$32+#H$32+)+$ )1:+3%:+)$('3,"$'",/+$"0",3:+#3$2%/2\,%)+$&"#$-+&1:+$0",3$h3+:\ 01,",Li$14$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$X,/"#%e"3%1#$14$+*+#3)H$",3$)21V)H$ :++3%#/)H$ /",.+#%#/H$ )1&%"'$ "&3%*%3%+)$ +3&>$ &1('.$ 2"*+$ 32"3$ 0'"&+$ ()+.>$ 92%)$ %)$ %::+.%"3+'L$ +44+&3%#/$ 32+$ '%*+'L$ '+*+'$ 14$ 32+$ )3,++3$ ,+'"3+.$31$32+$-(%'.%#/>$G1:+$)1,3$14$3,"#)%3%1#$%)$%#$1,.+,$-+3V++#$ 32+$)3,++3$"#.$32+$#+V$0(-'%&$)0"&+> 06.Planned vacancies The many vacancies of ground floors are almost designed. The 1V#+,$ 14$ 32+$ -(%'.%#/$ %)$ ):",3$ +#1(/2$ 31$ ,+)+,*+$ 32+$ /,1(#.$ floors for other use then residential but forgets to design speci\ fically for that. This result sometimes in very large vacant spaces. a+V$+&1#1:%+)$&"#$2"*+$"$)3",3$2+,+H$"#$%#&(-"31,$&"#$)(001,3$ )3",3\(0)H$:++3%#/)$-+3V++#$0,14+))%1#"')$"#.$)3(.+#3)$&"#$0,+\ 0",+$32+:$41,$32+$4(3(,+$:",<+3$"#.$/%*+$)0"&+$31$-132$%#$32+%,$ #++.$41,$V1,<$)0"&+>
02. Disordered streetscape 92+$ )3,++3)$ "#.$ (,-"#$ 0"33+,#$ %#$ 32+$ #1,32+,#$ 0",3$ 14$ K1.1#"$ 2"*+$-++#$"#$+Q0"#)%1#$1,$#"3(,"'$/,1V$14$32+$2%)31,%&"'$&+#3+,$%#$ the north. The narrow streets show clearly difficult situations with 32+$&1#3+:01,",L$()+)$"#.$%#3+#)%3L>$U*+#$321(/2$32+$#+%/2-1,\ 211.$%)$1#$"$&'1)+$.%)3"#&+$31$:1)3$14$M,%)3%#"`)$4(#&3%1#)$32+$&",$ %)$"$V+''\()+.$3,"#)01,3"3%1#$.+*%&+>$92+$&2"#/%#/$-(%'.%#/$0'%#32H$ 32+$.%*+,)+$",&2%3+&3(,"'$)3L'+)H$-(%'.%#/$[("'%3L$&",$0",<%#/$-+2"\ vior and the narrow street profile and condition make the streets '11<$ (#1,/"#%e+.$ "#.$ 4",$ 4,1:$ 0'+")"#3$ 0'"&+)>$ 92+$ 0+.+)3,%"#$ 2")$'%:%3+.$)0"&+$41,$V"'<%#/H$0(-'%&$3,"#)01,3$'%#+)$.1$#13$,+"&2$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.H$ /,++#+,L$ "#.$ #"3(,"'$ +'+:+#3)$ .1$ #13$ +Q%)3H$ 0'"&+)$41,$)3"L%#/$",+$#13$4"&%'%3"3+.H$"&&+))$31$-(%'.%#/)$.(+$31$ %3)$'1&"3%1#$1#$"$)'10+$0(3)$1-Y+&3)$")$)3"%,)$1#$0(-'%&$/,1(#.)>$ 92+$ 41&()$ 41,$ )3,++3)$ V2%&2$ 2"*+$ .%44+,+#3$ &1#.%3%1#)H$ 0(,01)+)H$ intensity of traffic, sizes, will be on shaping a coherent space. In -")%&$ 3+,:)H$ /%*+$ 32+$ ()+,)$ "&&+))$ 31$ 32+$ )0"&+)$ "#.$ %#$ [("'%3L$
maximum 07.The social/cultural connector 92+$&1##+&31,$%)$"$#+V$-(%'.%#/$V2%&2$-'+#.)$#"3(,"''L$%#$V%32$32+$ environment but is very specific and will be seen. It is the indoor/ 1(3.11,$)0"&+$41,$"''$)1&%"'O&('3(,"'$/"32+,%#/)$"''$41,$32+$0(-'%&$ .1:"%#>$W3$%)$)3,"3+/%&"''L$'1&"3+.$1#$+./+)$14$.%)3,%&3)$"#.$&1#\ #+&3)$)+*+,"'$)1&%"'$/,1(0)>
C6
Isolated & limited accesibility
Large urban spaces
07. safe pedestrian routes
10. shared spaces street users
27. Repetiton elements for recognizing networks
18. urban greenery & gardens
16. clear & visible access to parks
Disorderd & limited walkability 06. organization of streets
07. safe pedestrian routes
10. shared spaces street users
26. streets support the unique building styles
27. Repetiton elements for recognizing networks
18. urban greenery & gardens
14. shared front yard design
Streets 11. supply micro places
Chaotic & unsafe places 07. safe pedestrian routes
10. shared spaces street users
11. supply micro places
27. Repetiton elements for recognizing networks
Corners
Underused & informalized 22. co-sharing of groundfloors
12. multi user spaces
18. urban greenery & gardens
13. various activities provided
Inner block spaces
Underused & informalized 17. organization of cultural events
12. multi user spaces
15. communal building & space
Unfininished & Abandoned 20. cultural moving spaces
13. various activities provided
Unattractive & waste of indoor space 21. supporting incubators
22. co-sharing of groundfloors
23. mixed student / proffessonal
24. adaptable business units
25. outdoor commercial space
20. cultural moving spaces
Vacancies
Limited public buildings & attractions 02. district borders as centers
15. communal building & space
12. multi user spaces
30. attractive power
Cultural Connector
Fig. 82 Design Interventions
C@
Mosque
Heritage compound
shared urban square
Museum
Mosque
Ministery
public square
Mosque
community garden
Islamic college Community square
Community square
urban farm
new plaza
new plaza
terraces Kinder’’garten’’
improved playgrounds
improved sportsfield
new plaza
new plaza
Urban Park k
sunbeds
Spatial integration of design interventions picknick places
running routes
coffee terraces
devided into 3 levels of priority
Minimum Isolated public places
social activities
Disordered streets Concrete crossings
new plaza
Desired Inner block voids Unfinished construction Abandoned buildings architecture faculty
Commercial vacanies
Shared faculty gardens
architecture faculty
architecture faculty
Office vacancies Maximum Cultural connector
Fig. 83 Spatial integration of the project ”The Public Carpet Dodona “
5.6 SPATIAL INTEGRATION R%/>$C@$)21V)$32+$)0"3%"'$%#3+/,"3%1#$14$32+$0(-'%&$&",0+3$%#3+,\ *+#3%1#)$%#$K1.1#"$#+%/2-1,211.>$92+$8$.+)%/#$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$ 14$32+$0(-'%&$&",0+3$K1.1#"$",+$)21V%#/$32+$#+V$0(-'%&$#+3\ V1,<$"#.$.1:"%#>$W#$32+$41''1V%#/$0"/+)$32+$.%44+,+#3$'"L+,)$14$ 32+$.+)%/#$",+$)21V#$%#.%*%.("''L>$92+$.+)%/#$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$",+$ )21V#$ "#.$ +Q0'"%#+.$ "#.$ )+'+&3+.$ 0'"&+)$ )21V$ 32+$ 01))%-'+$ #+V$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ "#.$ )0"&+)>$ 92+L$ ",+$ )21V%#/$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ %#3+,*+#3%1#$%#$:1,+$.+3"%'$"#.$3,L$31$+Q0'"%#$32+$(,-"#$[("'%\
3L$"#.$%:0"&3$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#$2")$1#$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3>$ ]%32$ &1''"/+$ %:"/+)$ V%32%#$ 32+$ +Q%)3%#/$ )%3("3%1#$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ 3,%+)$31$%#.%&"3+$32+$01)%3%*+$&2"#/+$%3$-,%#/)$31$32+$)0"&+$"#.$ 21V$%3$&,+"3+)$"$0'"&+$41,$"#.$V%32$%3)$,+)%.+#3)$"#.$*%)%31,)>
CE
01.The isolated space
03. The concrete crossing
05. Sleeping construction
02. Disorderd streetscape
,9+$G88'.$672#3$(@/#'(
06.Planned vacancies
Fig. 84 Design Interventions visible in actual context
CB
Mosque
Heritage compound
shared urban square
Museum
Mosque
Ministery
public square
Mosque
Islamic college Community square
Isolated public place
‘AA
01A new plaza
‘AA
water elements
improved terraces
improved playgrounds
improved playgrounds
01D ‘AA
improved sportsfield
new plaza
01B new plaza
‘AA water elements
‘AA
‘AA
Urban Park k
sunbeds
picknick places
running routes
coffee terraces
social activities
01C new plaza
‘AA
architecture faculty
Shared faculty gardens
architecture faculty
architecture faculty
Fig. 85 Overview of large urban spaces as public places
!)*'@+360(*8':-/6,&':60&*
JL$ 32+%,$ )%e+$ "#.$ '1&"3%1#H$ 32+L$ V%''$ "33,"&3$ "#.$ )+,*+$ 32+$ %#\ 3+,$#+%/2-1,211.$)&"'+>$W#$32+$0,%1,%3%+)$&1#&+03$32+)+$)0"&+)$ come first because of their existing quality. Within the concept, 32+L$ .+:"#.$ '%:%3+.$ 3,"#)41,:"3%1#$ "#.$ .1$ )+,*+$ ")$ 0%'13$ 41,$ 32+$ +#3%,+$ 0(-'%&$ &",0+3$ 0,1Y+&3>$ 92+$ )0"&+)$ ",+$ .%*%.+.$ %#31$ 0(-'%&'L$1V#+.$"#.$)+:%\0,%*"3+$%#)3%3(3%1#"'>$]%32$%#&,+")%#/$ 32+$[("'%3L$14$0(-'%&$0'"&+)$"#.$"..$32+$)+:%\0,%*"3+$0'"&+)$31$ 32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$32+$0,1Y+&3$2")$%3)$0(-'%&$2(-)$,+"'%e+.>$92+L$ V%''$ -+$ 0(-'%&H$ /,++#$ "#.$ )"4+$ '1&"3%1#)$ 41,$ "$ *",%+3L$ 14$ ()+,)$ "#.$0,1/,":)>
]%32%#$32+$.+)%/#$4,":+V1,<$"#.$&1#&+03H$32+$'",/+$(,-"#$)0"\ ces are the first to be renewed. Their potential, location, size "#.$ +Q%)3%#/$ "33,"&3%1#$ ",+$ -")+$ 41,$ 32+$ #+V$ 0(-'%&$ #+3V1,<>$ 53$ 32+$ :1:+#3H$ 32+L$ ,+0,+)+#3$ 32+$ #1#\-(%'.$ )0"&+)$ 14$ &1#\ )%.+,"-'+$ )%e+$ -(3$ V%32$ 011,$ "&&+))%-%'%3LH$ *%)%-%'%3LH$ 0,1/,":H$ 0(-'%&$'+*+'$"#.$'"&<$14$-+'1#/%#/>$921)+$)0"&+)$&"#$)+,*+$")$ .,%*+,)$"#.$0(-'%&$2(-)$V%32%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$92+L$)21('.$ 0,1*%.+$)0"&+$"#.$0,1/,":$41,$"$-,1".$,"#/+$14$)1&%"'$/,1(0)>$ CA
CA
i
+Q%)3%#/$)%3("3%1#
%#&,+")+$"&&+)$01%#3) "#.$,1(3+)
&,+"3+$3,"#)%3%1#$e1#+) "#.$:"<+$*%)%-'+
Fig. 86 concept for entire park â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;s placemaking Fig. 87 exisiting situation location 01A Fig. 88 exisiting situation location 01B Fig. 89 exisiting situation location 01C Fig. 90 exisiting situation location 01D
"..$0,1/,"::+$ "#.$4(#&3%1#)
!75
C8
!7J
CC
!7P
CZ
!7K
Z!
The isolated ecological space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
C8
,HF Z7
New entrance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;stairsâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;
micro places
commercial space
public place
crossing
19.5 meter city park entrance
public domain
personalized space
4.5 meter
19 meter
public domain
!75
Z6
,HI
Fig. 91 section 01A - New stairway and entrance point to City Park from the north Fig. 92 Impression of entrance and surrounding corner as place Fig. 93 section 01B - improved entrance as place of belonging on the east side
Z@
left over spaces transformed as part of public domain
renewed entrance as place
micro places
new park entrance
local street
13 meter
public domain
CC
park neighbhorhood square
10 meter
7.5 meter
public domain
,H= ZE
Fig. 94 section 01C - New square and entrance to the city park from the south Fig. 95 Impression of main entrance and connection with surrounding crossing Fig. 96 section 01D - improved main entrance as place of belonging
New programmes of public places
transformation of park entrance functions
non public office micro places
city park
local entrepreneur
personalized space
main road
3.5 meter
public domain
park entrance square
park
16 meter
24.5 meter
public domain
ZB
!7K
,HJ
ZA
Medical practise
city park entrance
City Park
personalized space
roundabout
5 meter
public domain
park entrance square
8.25 meter
29.5 meter
public domain
CZ
04 - pedestrian zone
‘AA
‘AA ‘AA
m 02 -
‘AA
ain
‘BB
et
stre
‘AA
‘AA ‘BB
ard
lev
ou
-b
03 al
oc
-l
01
‘AA
st e re
t
‘AA
‘BB
‘BB
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Fig. 97 Overview of 4 street typologies as public places
!)*'N,+3.8*.8':-/6,&'/0&5/31*
144+,$/11.$V"'<"-%'%3L$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$"#.$.1$#13$&,+"3+$ )L#+,/L$ -+3V++#$ 32+$ %#.%*%.("'$ .+*+'10:+#3)$ "#.$ 0,10+,3%+)$ "#.$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ )3,++3)>$ W#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ &2"#/+$ 32%)H$ 32+$ #+V$ 0,1\ files offer place for traffic but more important enough space 41,$)%.+V"'<)H$(,-"#$/,++#$"#.$4"&%'%3%+)$"#.$)0"&+$41,$&,+"3%#/$ 0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$)L#+,/L>$92+$)3,++3)$%#$K1.1#"$",+$.%*%.+.$%#31$ E$3L01'1/%+)$32"3$)+,*+$")$-")%)$41,$"''$32+$)3,++3)>$5''$)3,++3)$+Q\ &+03$32+$0+.+)3,%"#$e1#+)$2"*+$32+$@$-+41,+$:+#3%1#+.$)0"&+)$ included in their profile (fig.98) The interesting and challenging part of the design of the profiles is the nonlinear building lines. In some cases, the profiles are very small and sometimes very
]%32%#$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$#+V$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<$"#.$[("'%\ 3L$0(-'%&$.1:"%#H$32+$)3,++3)$0'"L$"#$%:01,3"#3$,1'+>$92+L$",+$ &1##+&3%#/$ 32+$ #+V$ 0(-'%&$ 0'"&+)$ .+)&,%-+.$ %#$ 32+$ 0,+*%1()$ %#3+,*+#3%1#$ V%32$ 32+$ '1&"'$ %#2"-%3"#3)$ "#.$ &1:0"#%+)>$ 92+L$ "')1$ &1##+&3$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ %#$ 32+$ '",/+,$ )L)3+:$ 14$ &%3L>$ Very important in the renewal of the street profiles is the clear separation of (motorized) traffic and pedestrians. At the mo\ ment, the street profiles are unorganized spaces which do not Z!
ZC Boulevard
Neighborhood Main Street
Local street
Pedestrian zone
macro places
micro places
Personalized space
micro places
minimum sidewalks
Personalized space
Personalized space
micro places
minimum sidewalks
Personalized space
Personalized space
minimum sidewalks
Personalized space
Personalized space
J1('+*",.
ZZ
a+%/2-1,211.$:"%#$)3,++3
7!!
S1&"'$1#+\V"L$)3,++3
7!7
M+.+)3,%"#$e1#+
7!6
plaza
Personalized space
Fig. 98 Steettypologies Fig. 99,100,101,102 existing situations
wide within 1 street. A basis profile is creating good space to even the smallest profile. The boulevards$ ",+$ ,+'"3%*+'L$ V%.+$ )3,++3)$%#$V2%&2$"')1$%)$)0"&+$41,$0",<%#/$"#.$:%&,1$)1&%"'$0'"\ &+)>$ 92+$ )3,++3$ 144+,)$ V%32%#$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ #+3V1,<$ +Q3,"$ 2(-)$ 14$ for social activity when the profile allows. The neighborhood 0/)8$ (%.''%( have similar traffic intensity but smaller profiles. In this case, a asymmetric profile is made which allows at least /11.$)%.+V"'<)$"#.$(,-"#$/,++#+,L$"3$1#+$)%.+$14$32+$)3,++3>$ These first two streets are main routes in the public network "#.$ 32+,+41,+$ #++.$ 31$ %#&'(.+$ (,-"#$ /,++#$ "#.$ 0(-'%&$ :%&,1$ 0'"&+)$31$/(%.+$0+.+)3,%"#)$1#$32+%,$V"L$31$32+$0",<)$"#.$#+V$
0'"e")>$D&'$72#/7$(%.''%($",+$3,"#)41,:+.$%#31$1#+\V"L$)3,++3)>$ These see fewer traffic and pedestrians in the current situation. The change of profile need to activate the streets on the local )&"'+$-L$0,1*%.%#/$/11.$V"'<V"L)$"#.$%#3+,+)3%#/$0+,)1#"'%e+.$ )0"&+)$1,$4,1#3$L",.)>$92%)$&2"#/+$&"#$%#3+/,"3+$32+:$%#$32+$'",\ /+,$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<$"#.$%#&,+")+$%3)$"33,"&3%*+$01V+,>$S")3H$%&'$ pedestrian zones$",+$32+$(0/,".+$14$+Q%)3%#/$0+.+)3,%"#$",+")H$ %#&'(.%#/$#+V$,1(3+)$V%32%#$32+$(,-"#$-'1&<)$"#.$&2"#/%#/$)+\ '+&3+.$'1&"'$)3,++3)$%#31$0+.+)3,%"#$",+")>$92+)+$V%''$2"*+$)0"&+$ ,+)+,*+.$41,$0+,)1#"'%e+.$)0"&+H$V"'<%#/$e1#+)$"#.$)0"&+$41,$ /,++#+,LH$0'"L/,1(#.)$"#.$)%33%#/$0'"&+)> Z7
7!@
,4$\$a+%/2-1,211.$:"%#$
KFF
7!E
KII
micro places
micro places commercial space commercial space
offices
commercial space
housing parking
personalized space
main road
2m
personalized space
personalized space
main road
8.4 meter
2m
public domain
9.5 meter
personalized space
4.5 meter
20.5 meter
public domain
7!B
,4$\$a+%/2-1,211.$:"%#$
Fig. 103 Section 1:500 smallest street profile on the boulevard ‘AA Kelmendi street Fig. 104 Section 1:500 micro place on widest street profile ‘BB Kelmendi street Fig. 105 Impression neighborhood main street Fig. 106 Section 1:500 assymmetric street profile ‘AA on Rrustem Hyseni street
7!A
KFF
office
commercial space
main street personalized space
public domain
personalized space
1.5 m public domain
2.75 m 9,25 meter
Z6
,*$\$S1&"'$1#+\V"L$)3,++3)
Fig. 107 Section 1:500 smallest profile on one way street â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;AA on Svetozar Markoviq str. Fig. 108 Section 1:500 personalized space on street profile â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;BB on Svetozar Markovic str. Fig. 109 Section 1:500 new pedestrian zones with functions and program Fig. 110 Impression of new pedestrian zones
7!8
KFF
7!C
KII
micro places
office
local business
shared street
shared street
personalized space
public domain
1,25 m
1,25 m
shared personalized space public domain
public domain
2m
4,5 meter
3.5 m
public domain
7.5 meter
,9$\$M+.+)3,%"#$e1#+)
KFF
7!Z
offices
New programmes of public places
housing
micro places specialized shops
coffee & eatery
personalized space
outdoor room
personalized space
9.5 meter
9.5 meter
public domain
77!
Z@
concrete crossing â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;AA
01 â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;AA
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Fig. 111 Overview of 2 types of crossings as public places
!)*'A31&.*(*'&.3++,19
V%''$ -+$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ #+3V1,<>$ 92+$ &,1))%#/)$ 2"*+$ 6$ 3L\ pologies. On traffic intensive corners the corners will become places and on crossing with fewer traffic the crossing will be .+)%/#$")$"$)2",+.$)[(",+>$92+$&",$V%''$-+$/(+)3$"#.$32+$+#3%,+$ )[(",+$V%''$-+$0",3$14$32+$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<>$
92+$'")3$%#3+,*+#3%1#$%#$32+$:%#%:(:$'+*+'H$32+$&,1))%#/)$3"<+$ "#$%:01,3"#3$,1'+>$92+)+$",+$%#$/+#+,"'$"#.$"43+,$32+$)1&%1\)0"\ 3%"'$"#"'L)%)$0'"&+)$14$%#3+,+)3>$533,"&3%*+$4(#&3%1#)$'%<+$,+'%/%1()$ -(%'.%#/)H$ )&211')$ "#.$ &144++$ 0'"&+)$ "33,"&3$ %#2"-%3"#3)$ "#.$ 0"))%#/$ 0+.+)3,%"#)>$ G3,++3$ &,1))%#/)$ .1$ 2"*+$ "$ 2%/2+,$ '+*+'$ 14$(#)"4+3L$"#.$#++.$31$-+$.+)%/#$&",+4(''L>$92+$&,1))%#/)$V%''$ include similar as the streets clear space for pedestrians, traffic "#.$0+,)1#"'%e+.$)0"&+$%#$4,1#3$14$32+$-(%'.%#/)>$921)+$)0"&+)$ ZE
776
P,1))%#/
77@
corner typology 01 \$&1,#+,$0'"&+)
77E
KFF
shared corner place
shared corner place
Local Coffeehouse
Commercial
Crossing shared space
personalized space
public domain 10.5 meter
7 m public domain 24 meter
Kelmendi crossing \$ 92+$ &,1))%#/$ 14$ c+':+#.%$ )3,++3$ "#.$ F",<1*%&$ )3,++3$ %)$ 32+$ :1)3$ %:01,3"#3$ "#.$ -()%+)3$ &,1))%#/$ %#$ 32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$92+$*",%+3L$14$4(#&3%1#)$"#.$'1&"3%1#$%#$32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ "33,"&3$ :"#L$ 0+.+)3,%"#)$ "#.$ %)$ 1#$ ,1(3+$ &1#\ #+&3%#/$ 32+$ %##+,$ ,%#/$ ,1".$ V%32$ 32+$ +")3+,#$ #+%/2-1,211.)>$ The design creates clear spaces for car traffic on the corner -(3$ :1,+$ )0"&+$ %)$ /%*+#$ 31$ 32+$ 0+.+)3,%"#`)$ V"'<"-%'%3L$ %#&'(\ .%#/$&,1))V"'<)>$W#$"..%3%1#$31$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#H$/11.$)0"&+$ %)$ /%*+#$ 31$ 32+$ )(,,1(#.%#/$ 4(#&3%1#)$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ &,+"3+$ "$ '%4+$ "3:1)02+,+>$$
ZB
Fig. 112 impression of new crossing Fig. 113 existing situation Fig. 114 Section 1:500 micro corner places related to corner specifics
Abandoned public buildings
‘AA
03 ‘AA
Sleeping pin pi in construction site in
01
‘AA
‘AA
Unfinished buildings
02 ‘AA
‘AA
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Fig. 115 Overview various construction sites and abandoned municipaly buildings since 2013
!)*'+6**:,19'&31+(.-&(,31'O' 0/01831*8':-/6,&'/-,68,19
heless, these sites remain unfinished and through their uncom\ 0'+3+.$)3"3+$1,$'",/+'L$4+#&+.$#13$01)%3%*+$41,$32+$.%,+&3$(,-"#$ [("'%3L>$W#$32"3$)":+$",+"H$"$#(:-+,$14$"-"#.1#+.$-(%'.%#/)$%#$ 011,$)3"3+$",+$+[("''L$V"%3%#/$"#$(#&'+",$4(3(,+>$92+$:(#%&%0\ "''L$ 2"*+$ &'"%:+.$ #13$ 31$ 2"*+$ ",+")$ V%32%#$ 32+%,$ 1V#+,)2%0$ 31$ .+*+'10$")$0",3$14$"$#+V$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$-(3$32+L$:1)3$&+,3"%#'L$ .1>$ ]%32%#$ 32%)$ .+)%,+.$ %#3+,*+#3%1#$ '+*+'$ #+V$ ",+")$ ",+$ 32+,+$ 31$-+$41(#.$32"3$&1('.$-+&1:+$0",3$14$32+$#+V$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<$ "#.$.1:"%#$-L$3,"#)41,:%#/>$92+)+$32,++$%#.11,O1(3.11,$0(\ -'%&O0,%*"3+$)0"&+$32"3$&(,,+#3'L$",+$(#.+,()+.$&1('.$-+$"..+.$ h3+:01,",Li$31$32+$0(-'%&$V%32$:('3%0'+$4(#&3%1#)>
G%#&+$ 6!7@$ #1$ (#"(321,%e+.$ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ &"#$ &1#3%#(+$ V%32%#$ 32+$&%3L$'%:%3)$14$M,%)23%#">$92+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$.%.$0(3$"$21'.$1#$ 32"3$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ 0,+*+#3$ 4(,32+,$ .+&"L$ 14$ 32+$ (,-"#$ +#*%,1#\ :+#3>$92+$",+")$(#.+,$&1#)3,(&3%1#$",+$#1V$"V"%3%#/$32+$(,-"#$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 0'"#)$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ &1#3%#(+$ &1#)3,(&3%1#>$ 92%)$ %)$ )3%''$"#$1#/1%#/$0,1&+))$.(+$31$32+$#+V$)L)3+:$32"3$#++.)$31$ -+$%#&1,01,"3+.$%#$32+$:(#%&%0"'$0'"##%#/$4,":+V1,<>$a+*+,3\ ZA
unfinished construction 01 \$:%&,1$)3,++3$)0"&+
77A
â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;AAâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; new micro economics
temporary micro space
local coffee & fruits
one-way street temporary public gardens
personalized space
3.5 meter public domain
public domain 13.5 meter 7.5 meter
778
unfinished construction 02\$'",/+$"0",3:+#3$-(%'.%#/
UNFINISHED BUILDING
KFF
Concerts? Art & culture? Urban farming?
Communial meetings?
temporary macro space the public carpet
specialized shops
temporary public place
temporary public place
crossing
34 meter
personalized space
3.75 meter
public domain
19 meter
public domain
abandoned public building 03\$&1::(#"'$-(%'.%#/
77C
KFF
micro indoor-outdoor place
enlarging with inner block space community center
shared neighbor space
the public carpet
new public building
Fig. 116 Section 1:500 tempoC rary use of an sleeping construcC tion forming an urban farm Fig. 117 Section 1:500 tempoC ./.E$0;7)%?;8#%)28/7$#200;8)%E$ use of building in construction Fig. 118 Section 1:500 new use of public abandoned building as #200;8)%E$#'8%'.
local square
shared public space
25 meter public domain
18 meter public domain
8 meter
#28(%.;#%)28$ ()%'($ \$ K%44+,+#3$ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ )%3+)$ ",+$ '1&"3+.$ %#$K1.1#">$R,1:$):"''$)%#/'+$21()+$)&"'+$0",&+')$(0$31$'",/+$ "0",3:+#3$-'1&<$)%e+)>$W#$32%)$.+)%/#H$"$'1&"'$)%3+$V%32$#13$:1,+$ 32"#$"$*%+V$&1#&,+3+$&1'(:#)$%)$3,"#)41,:+.$41,$3+:01,",L$0+\ ,%1.$ %#31$ "$ '1&"'$ 0,1.(&3%*+$ L",.$ V%32$ ):"''$ /'"))$ 21()+>$ 92%)$ &"#$2"00+#$-L$%#%3%"3%*+$14$"$'1&"'$/,1&+,L$)210$32"3$V%)2+)$31$ 0,1.(&+$ :1,+$ )()3"%#"-'+$ 1,$ "$ /,1(0$ 14$ ,+)%.+#3)$ 32"3$ V1('.$ &1\V1,<$32+$)0"&+>$JL$.1%#/$)1$32+$.%,+&3$0(-'%&$)3,++3$%#&,+\ ")+)$%3)$"33,"&3%*+$01V+,$"#.$#(:-+,$14$0+10'+$%#$32+$)3,++3>$
14$ 0(-'%&$ -(%'.%#/)$ "#.$ &+#3+,)$ 41,$ 0(-'%&$ /"32+,%#/)$ 32,1(/\ hout the year, unfinished apartment buildings could (tempo\ ,",Li$ 3,"#)41,:$ %#31$ &+#3+,)$ 41,$ "$ *",%+3L$ 14$ 0(-'%&$ &1::(#"'$ 4(#&3%1#)>$]%32$-")%&$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$")$"#$+#3,"#&+$)3"%,)H$)"4+3L$ :+")(,+)$V%32%#$"#.$"."03"-'+$%#3+,%1,)$32+$",+"$&1('.$3,"#)\ 41,:$%#$)21,3$3%:+$%#$"$&1::(#%3L$&+#3+,>$ abandoned historic buildings \$ I0/,".%#/$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ -(%'\ .%#/)$")$):"''$%#.11,$&1::(#"'$&+#3+,)$1,$)(001,3$&+#3+,)$41,$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)$ 31$ /"32+,$ /%*+)$ )0"&+$ 31$ 32+$ 0(-'%&>$ W::+.%"3+$ )(,,1(#.%#/)$&"#$-+&1:+$32+$1(3.11,$3,"#)%3%1#$)0"&+`)>
unfinished apartment buildings \$]%32$32+$'%:%3+.$"*"%'"-%'%3L$ Z8
Inner block spaces ‘AA
01
community garden
‘AA
Community square
urban farm
Kinder’’garten’’
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Fig. 119 Overview neighborhood inner block space for new public domain extentions
@11*.'/63&5'O'&3.1*.'73,8+
)0"&+)$ ",+$ #1V$ 32+$ *1%.)$ 14$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ V%32$ '%:%3+.$ %#41,:"'$ ()+$ "#.$ '1V$ [("'%3L>$ ]%32%#$ 32+$ .+)%,+.$ %#3+,*+#3%1#$ '+*+'H$01))%-'+$0(-'%&$",+"$+Q3+#)%1#$",+$41(#.$V2%&2$&1('.$-+$ 3,"#)41,:+.$"#.$-+&1:+$0",3$14$32+$#+V$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<>$92+$ %##+,$ -'1&<$ )0"&+)$ ",+$ 1#+$ 14$ 32+:>$ 9,"#)41,:%#/$ 32+:$ 1#$ "$ '1V$ )&"'+$ %#$ &1::(#%3L$ /",.+#)H$ 01&<+3$ 0",<)H$ 0'"L/,1(#.)H$ or squares the new public network will enrich and infiltrate V%32%#$ 32+$ ):"''+,$ h)+:%$ 0,%*"3+i$ )0"&+)$ 14$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.>$ a+V$'1&"'$0'"&+)$14$-+'1#/%#/$&"#$",%)+$"#.$,+#+V$)3,++3)$32"3$ 2"*+$'%:%3+.$[("'%3L$"#.$"33,"&3%*+$01V+,>$J+)%.+)$32"3H$%3$10+#)$ (0$"$#+V$",+"$31$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$144+,)$#+V$,1(3+)$41,$
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h:%#1,%3%+)i>$92+)+$ ZC
76!
Fig. 120 Existing urban farm in Prishtina-West Fig. 121 Existing situation of unused spaces Fig. 122 Impression of new community farm Fig. 123 Section 1:500 micro place 01 community urban farming possibility
767
766
8A
)88'.$672#3$,H$\$&1::(#%3L$(,-"#$4",:%#/$+Q":0'+
76@
KFF gardening
new micro economics micro-macro community spaces
the public carpet
urban farm shop
backyard/porch space
community place â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;multi levels of publicnessâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;
2.5 m personalized space
backyard/porch space
2.5 m personalized space 45 meter
0",3%&('",'L$ 0+.+)3,%"#)>$ K+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+)+$ )0"&+)$ %)$ 2%/\ 2'L$,+'"3+.$31$32+$'1&"'$)%3("3%1#>$5$:1,+$0(-'%&$",+"$)(&2$")$"$ 01&<+3$0",<$%)$+")%+,$31$.+)%/#$%4$32+$*1%.$%)$#13$,+'"3+.$31$"#L$ #+%/2-1,$"#.$"$)+:%0(-'%&$",+"$%)$"00,+&%"3+.$%4$'1&"'$,+)%.+#3)$ 2"*+$32+%,$-"&<L",.$1*+,)++%#/$32+$)0"&+>$W#$32+$.+)%/#H$'1&"'$ 0",3%&%0"3%1#$"-1(3$32+$4(#&3%1#$"#.$32+$'+*+'$14$%#3%:"&L$#++.)$ 31$-+$,+)+",&2+.$%#$1,.+,$41,$32+$)0"&+$31$-+&1:+$"$)(&&+))>
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e+$ %3$ ")$ "$ &1::(#%3L$ (,-"#$ 4",:>$ J+)%.+)$ 32"3H$%3$10+#)$(0$#+V$,1(3+)$32,1(/2$32+$-'1&<>$92%)$#+V$)0"&+$ 144+,)$#+V$,+'"3%1#)$"#.$-,%#/)$0+10'+$31/+32+,>
community garden/farm \$92+$'1&"'$"3:1)02+,+$"3$32%)$%##+,$ -'1&<$)0"&+$)(,,1(#.+.$-L$'1&"'H$:1)3'L$0,+\V",$21()+)$&1('.$ -+$ &2"#/+.$ %#$ "$ )2",+.$ 0,1.(&3%*+$ /",.+#>$ 92+$ %#3%:"&L$ 14$ ZZ
Vacancies
02 ‘AA
‘AA AA ‘AA
‘AA
01 ‘AA
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Fig. 124 Overview of office and shops vacancies as of summer 2016
<6011*8'40&01&,*+
+*+,L$ -()%#+))>$ ]%32$ 10+#%#/$ (0$ 321)+$ *"&"#&%+)$ 0+,:"#+#3$ 1,$ 3+:01,",L$ 31$ '1&"'$ -()%#+))+)H$ )3(.L%#/$ )3(.+#3)H$ 010\(0$ )31,+)H$ ")$ +Q01)%3%1#$ 2"''$ 1,$ ")$ %#&(-"31,$ &"#$ %#&,+")+$ )3,++3$ [("'%3%+)$ "#.$ "33,"&3$ "$ .%*+,)+$ 010('"3%1#>$ F1)3$ %:01,3"#3H$ ")$ 0",3$14$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$"#.$/1*+,#:+#3$-1.%+)$%)$.+&,+")%#/$ 32+$ 010('"3%1#)$ (#+:0'1L:+#3$ ,"3+)>$ JL$ )(001,3%#/$ :%&,1$ -()%#+))+)H$ 4"&%'%3"3%#/$ )3(.+#3\+Q0+,3)`$ #+3V1,<)$ "#.$ 0,1*%\ .%#/$"."03"-'+$V1,<$)3"3%1#)$"#.$-()%#+))$(#%3)H$#+V$&,+"3%*+)$ "#.$(#+:0'1L+.$&"#$%#&,+")+$32+%,$01)%3%1#$1#$32+$:",<+3>$S1V$ ,+#3)$"#.$"."03"-'+$%#3+,%1,$.+)%/#)$&"#$10+#\(0$.11,)$41,$"$ *",%+3L$14$:%&,1$+&1#1:%&)>$
Vacancies of groundfloors can have a negative impact on an "&3%*+$ )3,++3$ '%4+$ "#.$ "33,"&3%#/$ 0+10'+$ 31V",.)$ "#$ ",+">$ 92+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 0",3%&('",$ '",/+$ 2%/2$ ,%)+$ -(%'.%#/)$ %#$ 32+$ )+\ &1#.$2"'4$"43+,$32+$V",$2"*+$&1#)%.+,"-'L$:1,+$*"&"#&%+)>$92+\ )+$'",/+$)0"&+)$2"*+$"$'%:%3+.$0'"##%#/$.(+$31$32+$4"&3$32"3$32+$ upper residential floors were the priority. Those floors generate income and not particularly the public groundfloors. Limited 0'"##%#/$ "#.$ .+)%/#%#/$ :"<+$ 321)+$ )0"&+)$ #13$ "33,"&3%*+$ 31$ 7!!
76B Fig. 125 Impression of PoP-up store and spaces Fig. 126 Section of temporary commercial space use Fig. 127 Change of space uses Fig. 128 Section 1:500 adaptable space use as econoC mic stimulator and networking Fig. 129 Change of space use
76A
vacancies 01 - commercial groundfloor space
768
KFF temporary extends of indoor uses
l
PARK
PEDESTRIANS
active wal
STORE
CLEAR ROADWAY PARK&PLACE
WALL
POP-UP SHARED FRONT
micro places
PARKING
OBSTACLES
Pop-up store
PARK
TRAFFIC
VACANCY
PEDESTRIANS
Adaptable vacancy uses
active STREET
main road personalized space
5 meter
park
shared public space
2,5 meter public domain
3,5 meter 11 meter
vacancies 02 - office groundfloor space
76C
76Z
KFF
expositions? Courses?
one-way street adaptable space
community place ‘multi levels of publicness’
shared in/out space
public domain 14 meter
DEAD STREET
VOID
CAR ORIENTED
adaptable incubator space
the public carpet
active STREET
network station
CLEAR ROADWAY
studying student-proffesional meetings
RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL INCUBATOR
PEDESTRIANS
RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL VACANCY
Start-up support
SHARED FRONT
networking? business units?
1.5 m public domain 7 meter
@2@C;@$(%2.'$\$92+$:"#L$&1::+,&%"'$*"&"#&%+)$&1('.$-+$3+:\ 01,",L$21()%#/$4(#&3%1#)$V2%&2$2"*+$"$*+,L$0(-'%&$#"3(,+>$R1,$ +Q":0'+H$ 010\(0$ )31,+)$ 32"3$ 144+,$ )0"&+)$ 31$ '1&"'$ +#3,+0,+\ #+(,)$ 31$ )21V&")+$ 32+%,$ 0,1.(&3)>$ 92+)+$ #+V$ ^0(-'%&`$ ,11:)$ have front door spaces as indicated within the street profile %#3+,*+#3%1#$ 31$ -,%./+$ 32+$ -1,.+,$ 14$ 32+$ 4"&".+>$ W#$ "..%3%1#H$ and in areas where the profile offers space, outdoor temporary )31,+$+'+:+#3)$&"#$-+$0'"&+.$%#$32+$0(-'%&>$5)$+Q":0'+$14$32+$ pop-up store design in fig. 126 is located in front of the parkV"''$ "#.$ 3+:01,",L$ 32+$ 0",<%#/$ '13$ &1('.$ -+&1:+$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ store. It activates locally the street profile and creates micro 0'"&+)>$
knowledge incubator \$5$)+&1#.$+&1#1:%&$3+:01,",L$0(-'%&$ intervention is using vacant office groundfloors as incubators. R,1:$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3LH$32+)+$)0"&+)$&1('.$)(001,3$):"''$-()%\ #+))+)$"#.$32+$:%&,1$+&1#1:L>$92+)+$%#&(-"31,)$&1('.$"33,"&3$ 0,14+))%1#"')$ "#.$ )3(.+#3)$ "#.$ 2+'0$ 32+:$ V%32%#$ 32+%,$ &",++,$ "#.$144+,$)0"&+$41,$#+V$#+3V1,<)$"#.$&1\V1,<%#/>$92+)+$^.+".`$ )3,++3)$ -+&1:+$ #+V$ "33,"&3%1#)$ +)0+&%"''L$ %4$ "/"%#$ 32+$ 4,1#3$ .11,$)0"&+)$",+$()+.$")$0",3$14$32+$#+V$0,1/,":>$W4$32+$'1&"'$ 4"-,%&$144+,)$1(3.11,$)0"&+)$41,$3+:01,",L$()+H$32+)+$&1('.$-+$ 3,"#)41,:+.$")$0",3$14$32+$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<$"#.$4(#&3%1#$")$1(3\ .11,$ V1,<)0"&+)>$ a+V$ '1&"'$ )3,++3$ "33,"&3%1#)$ &"#$ )3",3$ 2+,+> ",%)+$2+,+> 7!7
Cultural connector
new plaza
‘BB
01
ac
tiv es
active stre
tre e
t
‘AA
et
‘AA
new plaza
new plaza
terraces
Cultural
‘BB ‘B B
Boulevard
improved playgrounds new plaza
improved sportsfield new plaza
Urban Park k
sunbeds
picknick places
running routes
coffee terraces
social activities
new plaza
North Scale bar 0
20 m
100 m
Fig. 130 Plan of cultural connector and spaces within Dodona
!)*'A-6(-.06'A311*&(3.
-(3$ :1)3'L$ "..%#/$ "$ :1,+$ %#3+,+)3%#/$ 0,1/,":$ 1,$ 4(#&3%1#>$ W3$ %)$ "-1(3$ +#,%&2%#/$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ #+3V1,<)$ .1:"%#>$ W3$ %)$ "%:+.$ "3$ %#&,+")%#/$32+$"33,"&3%*+$01V+,$"#.$%:"/+$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$ but certainly also the networks infiltration within the urban fa\ -,%&$"#.$&,1))$-1,.+,$&"0"&%3%+)$14$32+$.+)%/#>$W#$32%)$4")+$32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$%)$)++#$")$01))%-'+$)1&%"'\&('3(,"'\+#*%,1#:+#3"'$ "33,"&3%1#$ V2%&2$ %)$ 144+,%#/$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ "#$ %:"/1$ "#.$ %.+#3%3L>$]%32%#$32%)$'+*+'H$"$*",%+3L$14$&,+"3%*+)$"#.$%##1*"3%*+$ %.+")$)21('.$/+3$,11:$31$+Q0'1,+$01))%-'+$#+V$*%-,"#3$"..%#/`)$ 31$32+$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<>$R1''1V%#/$%#3+,*+#3%1#$^32+$&('3(,"'$&1#\ #+&31,`$%)$"$01))%-'+$%#3+,*+#3%1#>$W3)$%#3+/,"3%1#$V%32%#$32+$(,\
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
existing park slope & wall
building placement & front square
continuation of park blv to street level
planting roof park & new stairway
Fig. 131 Project Intervention concept
GREEN MARKET
CULTURAL BLV MOTHER THERESA BLV
UNIVERSITY CAMPUS
Fig. 132 Overview of the interventions within the urban public domain of spaces
-"#$4"-,%&$"#.$")$0",3$14$32+$):"''+,$"#.$'",/+,$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<$ %)$ +Q0'"%#+.$ %#$ %:"/+)>$ a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
0",<$%#$32+$#1,32$)%.+>$92+$.+)%/#$0'"&+)$31$-(%'.%#/)$1#$-132$ )%.+)$14$32+$-1('+*",.$"#.$10+#\(0$31$32+$)3,++3$"#.$0",<$)%.+$ V%32$%#.11,$&('3(,"'$4"&%'%3%+)>$X#$32+$-1('+*",.$)%.+H$32+$-"&<\ -1#+$&(3)$32+$-(%'.%#/$%#$3V1$"#.$144+,)$%#)%.+$%#$32+$-(%'.%#/>$ 5-1*+$ 32+$ 0",<$ &1#3%#(+)$ ")$ #1,:"'$ V2%&2$ &,+"3+)$ #+V$ 0",<$ )0"&+)$ "#.$ *%+V01%#3)>$ 92+$ -(%'.$ "..%3%1#)$ ",+$ :('3%4(#&3%1\ #"'$ &('3(,"'$ )0"&+)$ ()%#/$ 32+$ +Q%)3%#/$ V"''$ V%32$ #+V$ 10+#%#/)$ 41,$'%/23>$X#$32+$0",<$)%.+$32%)$%)$"$3,"#)0",+#3$/'"))$V"''$32"3$ %#3+/,"3+)$32+$%#.11,$V%32$32+$,+#+V+.$)[(",+$%#$32+$0",<>$92+$ )[(",+$10+#)$(0$32+$0",<$1#$32+$V+)3+,#$"#.$+")3+,#$)%.+$31$ 32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$ 7!@
Cultural boulevard and building$
KFF
7@@ Moviescreen Dodona theater
Cultural NGO?
Concerts?
Exhibitions?
Park BLV
the public carpet
the public carpet
socio-cultural connector
socio-cultural connector
public building
Park boulevard
Local Tailor
public building
personalized space
street
75 meter
3.25 meter
public domain
public domain 40 meter
20 meter
Cultural building and spaces within the City Park
KII
Park Boulevard
the public carpet
socio-cultural connector
public building
80 meter
public domain
7!E
7@E
7@B
Park Boulevard
outdoor terraces
outdoor terraces
playground
50 meter
child domain
7!B
Fig. 133 Section 1:500 â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;AA of cultural conC nector and cultural boulevard Fig. 134 Impression of new public domain Fig. 135 Section 1:500 â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;BB of new building and additional public spaces within the existing City Park
.6)'+($6=!.
*+,+*-*$.$/0)12) !3#$40'5($6'/07$)802() &"+($%-1B#.06=$&
PRO Kosovo center for
!'0D.)..06 ;-'%)$/')106
PA W
PLANNNG
!"#$%$&'($)*
Urban Research
!"#$%&'( )&*(+#,-%.( $+)./
$#%10&10')$1# 1#-%$)*-(./.(
$%&'(##)*&' #(+',+-".' +&/&.&+"$)(.
%1!&'# %1!!"#
(1%'(-$#$)$')$/.6-;-+"$(,-.#/$01#!.#)-107'#$A')$1#6 @0$6=)$#'-&1&"(')$1#
Prishtina Architecture week
$#='+$)'#)6->1,1#'
!"#$%&
C11&.0'
%'()"*)'(%+'& ,-./01.23
61%$'(-23456 &0$/').-1B#.06=$& %1!!"#$)*-+"$(,.06
+"$(,-.#/$01#!.#)-23456
61%$1<%"()"0'(-$#6)$)")$1#6 1B#.06-18-6&'%.6
0.#"B'(-188'%',.6
&$(1)-&01F.%)6-<-6=1B%'6.-0.#.B.,-81%"6G-0.(')$1#6-;-$#).#)$1#6
!"#$%&'((&) ; 9$#$6)0*-18?#80'6)0"%)"0.
)0'#6&'0.#%* ;-%1<1&.0')$1# 9.,$')$#7
',/$6.
!"#$%$&'($)*
71/.0#!.#)
(1%'(-%1!!"#$)* &"+($%-)0'#6&10)-%1!&'#$.6
!"#$%$&'($)*
$#80'6)0"%)"0.-.#7$#..06
PRO Kosovo center for
PLANNNG
Urban Research
$%&'(##)*&' #(+',+-".' +&/&.&+"$)(.
',/$6. $#='+$)'#)6->1,1#'
61%$'(E%"()"0'( 23456
#.$7=+10=11,-,.&'0)!.#)
%1!!"#$)*-+"$(,.06
"0+'#-0.6'0%=-;-,.6$7#
61%$'(E%"()"0'( 23456
!?#$:<'7(')
.%1(17*-;-.#/$01#!.#) '7.#%$.6-
!"#$%$&'($)*
',/$6.
61%$'(-6.0/$%.6-$#6)$)")$1#6
#.$7=+10=11,-,.&'0)!.#)
'%)$/')$#7-%1!!"#$)*
61%$1<%"()"0'(-$#6)$)")$1#6
(1%'(-%1!!"#$)*
5.7 COLLABORATION, COMMUNITY BUILDING & RENEWING STATE-SOCIETY RELATIONSHIPS 5$ :%Q$ 14$ 0(-'%&$ )3"<+21'.+,)$ "#.$ 0,%*"3+$ )3"<+21'.+,)H$ '1&"'$ and non-local stakeholders and specific and general stakehol.+,)$ ",+$ %#*1'*+.$ %#$ 32+$ .%44+,+#3$ .+)%/#$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ 41,$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$&",0+3$0,1Y+&3$K1.1#">$5''$32+$)3"<+21'.+,)$",+$.+0+#\ .+#3$1#$+"&2$132+,$"#.$32+$,+'"3%1#)2%0)$-+3V++#$32+$)3"<+21'\ .+,)$.%44+,>$W#$/+#+,"'H$32+$,1'+$14$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$,+'"3+)$31$32+$ 01'%3%&"'$ &1#3+Q3$ h,+/('"3%1#)$ "#.$ 32+$ '"#.$ ()+$ 0'"#$ 41,$ +Q":\ 0'+i$"#.$32+$)1&%"'$&1#3+Q3$h,"%)%#/$"V",+#+))H$41)3+,%#/$0",3%\ &%0"3%1#$"#.$"''1V%#/$%#%3%"3%*+)$31$V1,<$%#$32+$",+"$41,$+Q":\ ple). Besides these, the municipality and the local office within 32+$#+%/2-1,211.$",+$"%:%#/$31$"&2%+*+$-+33+,$&%3%e+#)2%0$"#.$ )+#)+$14$-+'1#/%#/$14$32+$010('"3%1#H$)21V%#/$32+$010('"3%1#$ 32+%,$ ,+#+V+.$ &",+$ "#.$ 41&()$ 31V",.)$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ "#.$ +)3"-'%)2%#/$ "$ ,+'"3%1#)2%0$ V%32$ %3)$ %#2"-%3"#3)>$ W#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ .1$ )1H$"$0,1Y+&3$anX$#++.$31$-+$+)3"-'%)2+.$")$:+.%"31,$-+3V++#$ 32+$:(#%&%0"'%3LH$'1&"'$%#2"-%3"#3)H$132+,$)3"<+21'.+,)$"#.$32+$ 0,1Y+&3$3+":>$W3$%)$"#$%#.+0+#.+#3$1,/"#%e"3%1#$V2%&2$"%:)$31$ ,+0,+)+#3$ "''$ %#3+,+)3)>$ 92+$ '1&"'$ 010('"3%1#)$ #++.$ 31$ -+$ "'\ V"L)$ %#*1'*+.$ %#$ 32+$ .%44+,+#3$ 0,1Y+&3)>$ 92+%,$ )2",+$ "#.$ 0",\ 3%&%0"3%1#$ %)$ &,(&%"'$ %#$ 32+$ )(&&++.%#/$ 14$ 32+$ )+*+,"'$ 0,1Y+&3)>$$ 92%)$%)$#13$Y()3$&'+",$.(+$31$32+$4"&3$32"3$41,$+Q":0'+$32+$4,1#3$ L",.$0+,)1#"'%e+.$)0"&+)$#++.$"$4(#&3%1#$-(3$:1,+$%:01,3"#3'L$ 32+%,$&2"#/+$14$-+2"*%1,$"#.$-+'1#/%#/$31$"$'",/+,$&1::(#%3L$
V%32%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$#++.)$31$-+$)1'*+.>$X32+,$"&31,)$V%''$ be involved more related to specific project. Examples are the :%#%)3,L$ 14$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+H$ 0(-'%&$ 3,"#)01,3$ &1:0"#%+)H$ &('3(,"'$ %#)3%3(3%1#)H$ '1&"'$ -()%#+))+)H$ '"#.$ "#.$ 0,10+,3L$ 1V#+,)>$ S")3H$ 32+$ /,1(0$ 32"3$ #++.)$ 31$ .+"'$ V%32$ ,+#+V%#/$ "#.$ )(001,3%#/$ #+V$,+'"3%1#)2%0)$"#.$#+3V1,<)H$,+)+",&2$32+$*",%+3L$14$#++.)$ "#.$ -+2"*%1,$ 14$ '1&"'$ )1&%+3L$ "#.$ 1,/"#%e"3%1#$ 14$ -,1".$ 0",\ 3%&%0"3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 010('"3%1#>$ 92+)+$ )1&%"'$ "#.$ &('3(,"'$ anX`)$ ",+$"%:+.$"3$&12+)%*+$)1&%+3L$"#.$)3,+#/32+#$32+$&1::(#%3%+)$ 4++'%#/$14$-+'1#/%#/$"#.$&%3%e+#)2%0>$ ]%32%#$ 32+$ :%#%:(:$ .+)%/#$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)H$ 32+$ )3"3+$ 1V#)$ 32+$ '"#.$ V+,+$ .+"'%#/$ V%32$ h+Q&+03$ 32+$ )+:%\0,%*"3+$ 10+#$ )0"&+)$ ,+'"3+.$31$-(%'.%#/)i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anX$%)$32+$1#+$31$&,+"3+$)L#+,/L$"#.$32+$0(-'%&$%#)3%\ 7!A
.6)'+($6=!.#)-18-$#,.&.#,.#)-!.,$')$#7-234
; !"#$%$&'($)*
%1!&'#$.6-; %1!!"#$)*
BC%+DCB$.$2<EF<'&)
C11&.0')$1#
!=#$>020721() 9$#$6)0*-18:%1#1!$%6-; .!&(1*!.#)
!"#$%$&'($)*
.%1#1!$%6
(1%'(-+"6$#.66-6.%)10
"#$/.06$)$.6
$##1/')$1#-$#$)$')$/.6 $#='+$)'#)6->1,1#'
C11&.0')$1#
%1!!"#$)*-+"$(,$#7
!@#$+77('$/;<2A$)802()
$)* !"#$%$&'($)*
6"&&10)$#7-23456
(1%'(-$#$)$')$/.6
!"#
'70$%"()"0.-;./$01#!.#)'(-107'#$A')$1#6
(1%'(-%1!!"#$)*
$%&'(##)*&' #(+',+-".' +&/&.&+"$)(.
!"#$%&'( )&*(+#,-%.( $+)./
$#='+$)'#)6->1,1#'
06. Unfinished & Abandoned
%1!!"#$)*-+"$(,$#7
C11&.0')$1#
*GH+*-*$.$0&&'02&1I() !"#$%$&'($)*
$#='+$)'#)6->1,1#'
!9#$:6;&6'0;$:<77(2&<' Kosovo - Prishtina Office
%1#6)0"%)$1#-%1!&'#$.6
$#).0#')$1#'(-!.,$')106
61%$'(-23456 %1!!"#$)*-+"$(,.06 $#='+$)'#)6->1,1#'
!" #$
!%&'%()& "*(+'),*-#+'./%'-$/(0*(1
!"#$%$&'($)* %1!!"#$)*-+"$(,$#7
(1%'(-%1!!"#$)*
%"()"0.-6.%)10
!"#!$% (1%'(-$#$)$')$/.6
3(3%1#)$)21('.$144+,$)1:+32%#/$%#$,+3(,#>$ 92+$ :"Q%:(:$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ V%''$ %#*1'*+$ "$ -,1".$ ,"#/+$ 14$ )3"\ keholders and reflections and evaluations will be part of the #+V$ .+)%/#)>$ W#$ 32+$ &")+$ 14$ 32+$ 01))%-'+$ &('3(,"'$ &1##+&31,H$ (#.+,)3"#.%#/$ 14$ 32+$ '1&"'$ #++.)H$ +*"'("3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 0,+*%1()$ 3V1$%#3+,*+#3%1#$'+*+')$"#.$'",/+,$(,-"#$*%)%1#$"#.$&%3L$.+*+\ '10:+#3$#++.)$31$-+$%#&1,01,"3+.>$92+$%#*1'*+:+#3$14$32+$'",\ /+,$0(-'%&H$&,1))$-1,.+,$,+0,+)+#3"3%*+)$"#.$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$"#.$ )(001,3%#/$&1:0"#%+)$1#$32%)$'+*+'$%)$,+[(%,+.>$M",3$14$32%)$'+*+'$ %)$"')1$)'%/23$.%44+,+#3$"00,1"&2$#":+'Lb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no general relationship to define. Nevertheless, in every de)%/#$%#3+,*+#3%1#$%3$%)$14$/,+"3$%:01,3"#&+$32"3$32+$)3"<+21'.+,)$ &1::(#%&"3+H$&1\&,+"3+$"#.$&1''"-1,"3+>$
$ 7!8
61%$1<%"()"0'(-$#6)$)")$1#6
%"()"0'(-$#6)$)")$1#6
!"#$%&'()*+',-$."/(
!J#$K'((7$6'/07$;07L)208(
!M#$'()1L60;$L()157$)802(
Fig. 136 Involved Actors
!"#$%$&'( )*!'$#
!G# B)&0(%)*')+,-12138-+8(,-1H,:0-0+,+0%)
!6# 789-0:1;::'<<090-0+=
!E# F0<+%(0:,-1,)A1:%)+'*5%(,(=1.A')+0+=
!"#$%&'($
:%)<8-+,+0%)121'I5-%(,+0%)
*0)0*8*10)+'(&')+0%)<141589-0:1%@)'(<J05<1%H1<5,:'
)*+,!-.+/.012("&.3$!,+*4.'35.&+##13"!6.
!"#1K,(/'18(9,)1<5,:'< 012("&.+,3$*%-"0 ('/:-/,&('# >*/,/-#-='(,*>,&"+($%,"/+'#,5&'%-5
&$(*0,&/*?-%0
)-.-(*&$#: !"#$%$&'( )*!'$#
$#,%**&-/'0$*#, )-.-(*&$#: ').'#%-), %*#)$0$*#5
/-'%0$*#
-#/$%6!-#0
!"#1K,(/'18(9,)1<5,:'< %$#".0*"7'!$.+,3$*%-"0 /-'%0$*#
)-.-(*&$#:
5!'((,&/*?-%05
#-:*0$'0$*#5
5!'((,&/*?-%05
/-'%0$*#
/-'%0$*#
project
PA W
5!'((,&/*?-%05
&'/0,*>,*#-,)-5$:#,50/'0-:8,'#),'$!
NGO
Prishtina Architecture week
!6#1C+(''+< )-.-(*&$#: #-:*0$'0$*#5
/-'%0$*# &/*?-%0,)-.-(*&!-#0
&$(*0,&/*?-%0 0-50,>'5-, #-=,&/*>$()-5$:#
('/:-/,&('# >*/,/-#-='(,*>,50/--0,&/*>$(-5 -.'("'0$#:
)-.-(*&!-#0,*>, &-/5*#'($;-),5&'%-5,'#),/-('0$*#5
-E0-#)$#:
!D#13%()'(< &$(*0,&/*?-%0 )-.-(*&$#: #-:*0$'0$*#5
/-'%0$*# &/*?-%0,)-.-(*&!-#0
0-50,>'5-, #-=,%*/#-/ )-5$:#
('/:-/,&('# >*/,/-#-='(,*>,%*/#-/5 -.'("'0$#:
)-.-(*&!-#0,*>, &-/5*#'($;-),5&'%-5,'#),/-('0$*#5
-E0-#)$#:
$#6'+$0'#05,7*)*#'
)-.-(*&$#:
$##*.'0$*#,$#$0$'0$.-5
PRO Kosovo center for
PLANNNG
Urban Research
-.'("'0$*#5 @AB @CB @DB
"#$.-/5$0$-5
!"#$%&&'(#$ &%)$*)+,-$ )#.#-#),!'%-
#-:*0$'0$*#5 5*%$'(,12345 %*!!"#$08,+"$()-/5
!"#$%&
%'()"*)'(%+'& ,-./01.23
+"$(),-#.$/*#!-#0,12345
&/*?-%0,)-.-(*&!-#0
5*%$*<%"(0"/'(,$#50$0"0$*#5 *=#-/5,*>,5&'%-5
!" #$
').'#%-), &('##$#:,>*/ 0/'#5>*/!$#: &/$.'0-,5&'%-5 $#0*,-E0-#0$*#5 *>,&"+($%,)*!'$#
!>#1.) &$(*0, &/*?-%0
!E#1; )-.-(*&$#:
&$(*0, &/*?-%0
06. U
56*/0-#,0$!-
!%&'%()& "*(+'),*-#+'./%'-$/(0*(1
)-.-(*&$#:
%"(0"/-,5-%0*/
&$(*0, &/*?-%0
0
)-.-(*&$#:
(*%'(,$#$0$'0$.-5,9,+"$(),-#.$/*#!-#0,*/:'#$;'0$*#5
!G#1L
&$(*0, &/*?-%0
0 Kosovo - Prishtina Office
$#0-/#'0$*#'(,!-)$'0*/5
%*#50/"%0$*#,%*!&'#$-5
5.8 TIME PLAN STRATEGY R1,$32+$0,1Y+&3$32+$3%:+$4,":+$%)$)+3$%#$E$e1#+)>$W#%3%"3%1#$4"&+H$ is the moment the municipality ant its local neighborhood offi&+$-,%#/)$32+$A$)3,"3+/%&$32+:+)$31$32+$0(-'%&$3"-'+>$92+$4")+$%)$ +Q0'1,%#/$ %.+")H$ 0,%1,%3%+)$ "#.$ &2"''+#/+)$ "#.$ &1#)('3%#/$ V%32$ all the stakeholders, financers and actors. As a mixed and di*+,)+$ /,1(0$ 32+$ 41,:"3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 0,1Y+&3$ anX$ %)$ +)3"-'%)2+.$ V2%&2$V%''$)+",&2$41,$)L#+,/L$-+3V++#$"''$)3"<+21'.+,)$"#.$32+%,$ 10%#%1#)$%#$1,.+,$41,$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$.+)%/#$31$"&2%+*+$ -,1".$ )"3%)4"&3%1#>$ 92%)$ anX$ %)$ 32,1(/21(3$ 32+$ 0,1Y+&3$ "&3%*+$ ")$ :+.%"31,H$ &,+"3%#/$ "$ -,1".$ %#*1'*+:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ "#.$ overseeing the outcomes of the design and their local reflec3%1#$ -L$ 32+$ ()+,)>$ 92+L$ ,+01,3$ 31$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ "#.$ ".*%)+$ 32+:$"-1(3$32+$)3,"3+/%+)$"#.$&2"#/+)$.(,%#/$32+$0,1Y+&3>$W#$ 1,.+,$31$)'1V'L$)3,+#/32+#$32+$0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$,+'"3%1#)2%0$,+/(\ '",$:++3%#/)$"3$"$'1&"'$0'"&+$-,%#/)$32+$)3"<+21'.+,)$",1(#.$32+$ table in the specific area.
'1&"'$ 010('"3%1#$ %3)$ )"3%)4"&3%1#$ "#.$ -+2"*%1,$ V%32%#$ "''$ 32+$ 0,1Y+&3)$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ "#.$ /1*+,#:+#3$ #++.$ 31$ )21V$ 32+%,$ ,+#+V+.$&",+$"#.$,+)01#)%-%'%3L$41,$"$[("'%3L$+#*%,1#:+#3>$32+\ ,+41,+H$"''$0,1Y+&3)$",+$%#%3%"3+.$-L$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$V%32$%::+\ .%"3+$%#*1'*+:+#3$14$32+$'1&"'$010('"3%1#>$W#$32+$^.+*+'10%#/`$ 0+,%1.$ 32+)+$ "&31,)$ "#.$ 132+,$ )3"<+21'.+,)$ ",+$ %#*1'*+.$ %#$ "$ :%&,1$0,1Y+&3>$92+$^0%'13$0,1Y+&3`$%)$32+$32"3$1(3&1:+$32"3$V%''$ 3+)3$ 32+$ 0",3%&('",$ 0,1Y+&3>$ 5)$ +Q":0'+H$ "$ ):"''$ )3,++3$ "#.$ %3)$ profile is renewed in a temporary project and evaluated by the #+%/2-1,211.$ %#$ 32+$ ()+.$ "00,1"&2$ "#.$ 01))%-'+$ 1(3&1:+>$ P2"#/+)$&"#$-+$:".+$"#.$"$0+,:"#+#3$'",/+,$0,1Y+&3$&"#$-+$ .+*+'10+.>$92+$+*"'("3%1#)$14$32+$0,1Y+&3$&"#$"')1$-+$()+.$%#$ "$ )+&1#.$ '"L+,$ 0,1Y+&3>$ 5)$ +Q":0'+H$ 32+$ +*"'("3%1#)$ 14$ "$ #+V$ street profile are very important in developing the pilot proY+&3$ 41,$ "$ ,+#+V+.$ &1,#+,>$ ]%32$ 32%)$ "00,1"&2H$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ #+V$ #+3V1,<$ %)$ )'1V+,$ -(3$ 32%)$ :('3%\"&31,$ %#*1'*+:+#3$ "#.$)3,"3+/%&$0'"##%#/$"00,1"&2$&"#$%#%3%"3+$.+)%,+.$#+3V1,<)$ "#.$&1''"-1,"3%1#$"#.$144+,)$3%:+)$31$.1$)1>$92+$0,1Y+&3$&"#$-+$ &1#)%.+,+.$")$"$,+*+,)+.$0L,":%.q$"$)1'%.$"#.$/11.$"00,1"&2$ "3$ 32+$ )3",3$ &1#3%#(+)$ %#$ "$ )3,(&3(,+.$ )L)3+:$ 32,1(/21(3$ 32+$ 0,1Y+&3$"#.$"&&+'+,"3+)$32,1(/2$)%:%'",$0,1Y+&3)$2"00+#%#/$)%\ :('3"#+1()'L>$M,+)+#3%#/$32+$1*+,"''$%.+")$"#.$0,1Y+&3)$"3$32+$ -+/%##%#/$ &"#$ )21V$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3%+)$ ,+#+V+.$ 0(-'%&$ %#3+#\ 3%1#)$"#.$+*+#$"&3%*"3+$0",3)$14$32+$0,1Y+&3$)11#+,$1#&+$32+L$ #13%&+$32+%,$01)%3%*+$"33%3(.+$"#.$1(3&1:+>$
92+$:1)3$%:01,3"#3$"%:)$14$32%)$0,1Y+&3$",+$,+#+V%#/$32+$0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$")$"$&1::(#%3L$-L$.+*+'10%#/$.+)%/#)$%#$4"*1,$14$32%)$ 0(-'%&$ ,+"':>$ G0"&+)$ "#.$ 0'"&+)$ %#$ V2%&2$ "$ *",%+3L$ 14$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)$4++'$&1:41,3"-'+$"#.$4++'$"33"&2+.$31>$W3$%)$32+$&,+"3%#/$ 14$"$)1\&"''+.$&%3%e+#)2%0$"#.$)+#)+$14$-+'1#/%#/$31$32+$#+%/2\ -1,211.>$92%)$%)$-+%#/$'1#/$'1)3$"#.$#++.$%#3+,*+#3%1#$%#$1,.+,$ 31$&,+"3+$32%)$#+%/2-1,211.$0(-'%&$&1::(#%3L>$ ]%32$ 32%)$ %#$ :%#.H$ <#1V%#/$ %3)$ 2%)31,L$ "#.$ +*"'("3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 7!C
#5
('/:-/,&('# >*/,/-#-='(,*>,50/--0,&/*>$(-5 )-.-(*&!-#0,*>, &-/5*#'($;-),5&'%-5,'#),/-('0$*#5
-E0-#)$#:
('/:-/,&('# >*/,/-#-='(,*>,%*/#-/5 -E0-#)$#:
)-.-(*&!-#0,*>, &-/5*#'($;-),5&'%-5,'#),/-('0$*#5
#5
#:
#:
#:
#:
A'<0('A10)+'(&')+0%)<1415(0&,+'1%@)'(<J05< !G#1L,:,):0'< &$(*0, &/*?-%0
0-!&*/'/8,"5-
0-50$#:
&-/!'#-#0,"5-.'("'0-
!>#1.))'(9-%:M1<5,:'< &$(*0, &/*?-%0
!"(0$&(8,0*,!*/-,5&'%-5,9,#-=,(*%'(,%*!!"#$0$-5 /->(-%0
!E#1;9,)A%)'A1589-0:1980-A0)/< &$(*0, &/*?-%0
)-.-(*&,'5,&-/!'#-#0,%*!!"#$08,+"$()$#: /->(-%0
06. Unifinished constructions &$(*0, &/*?-%0
&$(*0, &/*?-%0
0-50$#:
0-50$#:
50/'0-:8,>*/,"5-, $#,06-,>"0"/-
&$(*0, &/*?-%0
*,I0*8*10)+'(&')+0%)<1589-0:45(0&,+'1%@)'(<J05
&'/0,*>,#-= "/+'#,&('#
0-50$#:
!N#1C%:0,-138-+8(,-13%))':+%( -.'("'09,(-'/# #-:*0$'0$*#5
7-5$:#$#: $#,%*(('+*/'0$*# =$06,/'#:-,*>
&/*?-%0,)-.-(*&!-#0
&/-5-#0
7-.-(*&!-#0,%*##-%0*/,5&'%-
0-50$#:,-.'("'0$#:,/->(-%0$#:,$!&/*.$#:, 0*:-06-/,=$06,"5-/5,
Fig. 137 timeplan of the design interventions
5.9 THE FINANCIAL SIDE
land and property investors
R1,+%/#$"%.$%)$3L0%&"'$41,$)%3("3%1#)$'%<+$32+$1#+$14$c1)1*1>$S%\ :%3+.$+&1#1:%&"'$:+"#)$"#.$/+#+,"'$+&1#1:%&"'$'+*+')$14$32+$ &1(#3,L$",+$0,1-'+:"3%&$%#$3,"#)%3%1#$31V",.)$"$)3"-'+$"#.$)"4+$ +#*%,1#:+#3>$R%#"#&%"'$)(001,3%#/$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3%+)$%)$32+,+41\ re unlikely to disappear soon after the conflict. When possible, )(001,3$14$'1&"'$:%#%)3,%+)$"#.$'1&"'$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$-(3$%#$:1)3$ &")+)$ V%32$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$ )01#)1,)$ '%<+$ +:-"))L`)H$ 41(#."3%1#)$ "#.$ 32+$U(,10+"#$%#)3%3(3%1#)>$92+$0,1Y+&3$0,101)"'$V%''$ #++.$ %#3+,#"3%1#"'$)(001,3$311H$-(3$")$1001)+.$31$:"#L$%#3+,#"3%1\ #"'$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$%3$#++.$31$-+$'1&"'$%#%3%"3+.$"#.$.+*+'10+.>$ 5.*%)+$/%*+#$-L$32+$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$&1::(#%3L$%#*1'*+.H$)(001,\ 3%#/$ :(#%&%0"'%3%+)$ %#$ 1V%#/$ #+V$ 0,10+,3%+)H$ )01#)1,%#/$ '1&"'$ projects but most important investing financial means. With 0%'13$ 0,1Y+&3)$ "3$ 32+$ -+/%##%#/$ 32+$ :"%#$ )01#)1,$ -(3$ 41,$ 32+$ '",/+,$0,1Y+&3)$'1&"'$:%#%)3,%+)$"#.$'",/+$&1:0"#%+)$)21('.$-+$ %#*1'*+.>$92%)$%)$%:01,3"#3$%#$0,+)+#3%#/$32+$'1&"'$+&1#1:L$")$ "$0(-'%&'L$%#*1'*+.$0",3$14$)1&%+3L$"#.$41,$32+$'1&"'$/1*+,#:+#3$ to become clearer about their financial means and destinati1#)>$S")3H$%#$/+#+,"'$32+$%#*1'*+:+#3$14$32+$'1&"'$+#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$010('"3%1#$%)$.+&%)%*+$31$32+$&1:0'+3%1#$14$32+$0,1Y+&3>$W#$ most cases, it will not be financial but by involvement and ac3%*+$0",3%&%0"3%1#$%3$%)$32+$:1)3$%:01,3"#3$0,%&+'+))$)(001,3$"#.$ V%321(3$%3$"#L$0,1Y+&3$&"##13$)(&&++.>
municipality
neighborhood department
ďŹ nancial investors
examples
municipality M Ministry of Culture, Youth Cu and Sports an
socio-cultural institutions
land owners
construction companies & property developers
cultural buildings
Mi Ministry of Ag Agriculture, Forestry and Fo Ru Rural Development
Ministry of Mi Infrastructure Inf
i i i ministeries
National sponsors
knowledge investors examples
local
Kosovo - Prishtina Office
CH wB
International organizations & funds
Cultural Heritage without Borders
national Governments
Kosovo - Prishtina Office
international
European sponsors
Fig. 138 investors needed for the design project
$ 7!Z
Activities in the new public domain Working activities
Leisure activities
Urban activities
Social activities
Community activities
Sports activities
Fig. 139 Activities in the new public domain
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e+.$ 4,1#3$ L",.)H$ %3$ "''1V)$ 0+10'+$ 31$ .+*+'10$ #+V$ "&\ 3%*%3%+)$1,$:1*+$'1&"3%1#$14$+Q%)3%#/$1#+)H$32"3$()+.$31$2"00+#$ 1#$ 0,%*"3+$ 3+,,"%#>$ R1,$ %3)$ ,+)%.+#3)H$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ "#.$ %3)$ 01))%\ -%'%3%+)$144+,$)0"&+)$32"3$%#&,+")+$1(3.11,$"&3%*%3%+)>$W3$"%:)$31$ )2"0+$ "$ )+#)+$ 14$ &1::(#%3L$ "#.$ &%3%e+#)2%0>$ 92+$ (#.+,'L%#/$ 321(/23$ %)$ 31$ .+*+'10$ )0"&+)$ 32"3$ :%Q$ .%44+,+#3$ "&3%*%3%+)$ "#.$
)1&%"'$/,1(0)>$a+V$%#3+,"&3%1#)$"#.$#+3V1,<)$&"#$/,1V$-L$0,1\ *%.%#/$ )0"&+$ 41,$ *",%1()$ "&3%*%3%+)$ 10+,"3%#/$ V%32%#$ 32+$ )":+$ .1:"%#>$U*+#3("''L$32+$.+)%/#$3,%//+,)$32+$%#2"-%3"#3)$31$3"<+$ "&3%*+$ 0",3%&%0"3%1#$ %#$ .+*+'10%#/$ 32+%,$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ 0+,\ )1#"'%e+$%3>
77!
World
Entrepereurial active society
search for comfort & quality urban life
Conditions that contribute to Public Carpet Dodona Available space
Scale
Diverse Development
Fig. 140 Conditions that contribute
5.11 CONDITIONS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROJECT definitely belong to this society and will increase participation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e+#)$ ",+$ )++<%#/$ :1,+$ &1:\ 41,3$ "#.$ /11.$ 0(-'%&$ 0'"&+)>$ W##1*"3%*+$ "#.$ 4(3(,+$ 32%#<%#/$
91$&1#&'(.+$32+$B$&1#.%3%1#)$"#.$&2","&3+,%)3%&)$32"3$&1#3,%-(\ 3+$31$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$14$0(-'%&$&",0+3$K1.1#"$",+b$"*"%'"-'+$ )0"&+H$ +#3,+0,+#+(,%"'$ )1&%+3LH$ )+",&2$ 41,$ &1:41,3H$ )3"/+)$ 14$ .+*+'10:+#3$"#.$)&"'+> 777
5.12 FEASIBILITY OF THE INTERVENTIONS As I discussed in the previous paragraph, there are five con\ .%3%1#)$1,$&2","&3+,%)3%&)$14$K1.1#"$32"3$&1#3,%-(3+$31$32+$.+\ *+'10:+#3$%#31$"$0(-'%&$)0"&+$#+3V1,<$"#.$.1:"%#b$"*"%'"-'+$ )0"&+H$ +#3,+0,+#+(,%"'$ )1&%+3LH$ )+",&2$ 41,$ &1:41,3H$ )3"/+)$ 14$ development and scale. In this section I will reflect on the seven %#3+,*+#3%1#)$%#$,+'"3%1#$31$32+)+$&1#.%3%1#)$"#.$32+$4+")%-%'%3L$ 14$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)>$R%,)3$14$"''H$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$&"#$1#'L$V1,<$ %4$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$"#.$/1*+,#:+#3$V1,<$1#$"$:1,+$3,"#)0",+#3$ "#.$10+#$V"L$14$/1*+,#"#&+>$P,(&%"'$41,$32+$.+)%/#$%#3+,*+#3%\ 1#)$%)$32+$0",3%&%0"3%1#$14$32+$)3"<+21'.+,)H$V2%&2$"3$32%)$01%#3$ %)$'%:%3+.$"#.$%#.%*%.("'$-L$#"3(,+>$92+$&"0"&%3L$14$32+$:(#%&%\ pality is limited, especially financial terms.
06. Vacancies - Vacant ground floors of buildings will always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e+#)2%0$ "#.$ &,+"3%#/$ 0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$ ,+'"3%1#)2%0)>$ 92+$ P('\ 3(,"'$ &1##+&31,$ %)$ "#$ "..%3%1#$ 1#$ 32+$ 01)%3%*+$ &2"#/+$ V%32%#$ 32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$"$0(-'%&$/+)3(,+>$92+$*",%1()$"&3%*%3%+)$ "#.$#+V$4(#&3%1#)$V%32%#$32+$0(-'%&$&",0+3$",+$+*"'("3+.$"#.$ reflected on in order to compose the cultural connector. The building, that ask a great financial contribution will be a com\ 0'+Q$ 0,1&+))>$ a+*+,32+'+))H$ W$ -+'%+*+$ %3$ )21V)$ %3)$ &1#3,%-(3%1#$ 31$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ "#.$ '",/+,$ )&"'+)$ V2+#$ %3$ &1:+)$ 31$ 14\ 4+,%#/$ )0"&+$ 41,$ :"#L$ )1&%"'$ /,1(0)$ "#.$ %3)$ 0'"&+$ V%32%#$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$.1:"%#>
01. The isolated public places \$ 92+$ '",/+$ (,-"#$ )0"&+)$ %#$ "#.$)(,,1(#.%#/$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$)21V$.%44+,+#3$&1#.%3%1#)>$ G1:+$ ",+$ %#$ 0,%*"3+$ 1V#+,)2%0H$ )1:+$ ",+$ 0(-'%&'L$ 1V#+.$ -(3$ 2"*+$'%:%3+.$"&&+))%-%'%3L$"#.$132+,)$",+$%#$41,:"'%e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h'%:%3+.i$)1&%"'$/,1(0)>$W4$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$1,$32+$0(-'%&$ %#)3%3(3%1#$ 1V#)$ 32+$ '"#.H$ ,+"'%e"3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 0'"#$ &"#$ 2"00+#$ without difficult and expensive negotiations. The effect of the .+)%/#$ &"#$ V1,<$ 1#$ :1,+$ 32"#$ Y()3$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ )&"'+>$ W#$"..%3%1#H$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#$%)$&1:01)+.$14$"$)+,%+)$14$:%&,1$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$V2%&2$%#.%*%.("''L$)21V%#/$*"'(+$31$32+$,+#+V+.$ 0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$
5.13 APPLICABILITY IN PRISHTINA W#$ 32%)$ 0","/,"02H$ W$ ()+$ 32+$ 0,101)+.$ .+)%/#$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)H$ &1#.%3%1#)$14$K1.1#"$#+%/2-1,211.$"#.$32+$4+")%-%'%3L$14$32+$ 0,1Y+&3$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ 31$ ,+)+",&2$ )21,3'L$ %3$ "00'%&"-%'%3L$ V%32%#$ 32+$V%.+,$&1#3+Q3$14$32+$&%3L>$5)$.+)&,%-+.$%#$&2"03+,$E>7H$K1\ dona is not the only area affected by post conflict develop\ :+#3H$ -(3$ %#$ 132+,$ ",+")$ .%44+,+#3$ <%#.)$ 14$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 311<$ 0'"&+>$92+$&2"''+#/+)$"#.$&1#.%3%1#)$14$32+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3$ 2"*+$"$.%44+,+#3$&1#3+Q3>$W#$32%)$0,1Y+&3H$32+$&")+$)3(.L$#+%/2\ -1,211.$ V")$ "$ .+#)+$ "#.$ &+#3,"'$ ",+"$ V%32$ (#%[(+$ 0,1-'+:)$ "#.$&2"''+#/+)>$$92+$'%:%3+.$":1(#3$14$4,++$10+#$)0"&+H$2%/2$ frequency car traffic and location close to the city center of M,%)23%#"$,+)('3+.$%#$%#$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$41&()+.$1#$0,1*%.%#/$-")%&$ 0(-'%&$ ":+#%3%+)$ "#.$ 3,"#)41,:%#/$ (#.+,()+.$ )0"&+)$ %#31$ 0(\ -'%&$",+")>$W#$1,.+,$31$()+$32+)+$0,101)+.$%#3+,*+#3%1#)H$W$V%''$ reflect on their applicability in other areas that changed during the period after the conflict. Those areas have different pro\ -'+:)$"#.$&2"''+#/+)$-(3$V%32$)%:%'",$011,$[("'%3L$)0"&+)$"#.$ '1V$'+*+'$&%3%e+#)2%0>$92+$:"0$)21V)$.%44+,+#3$#+%/2-1,211.)$ in Prishtina that have been affected by post conflict develop\ ment. Briefly I mention the situation and reflect on the possible ()+$14$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$%#$32+$*",%1()$&1#3+Q3)>$
02. The disordered streets \$92+$%#3,1.(&3%1#$14$32+$%#3+,*+#\ 3%1#$41,$32+$*",%1()$)3,++3)$+44+&3)$32+$+#3%,+$#+%/2-1,211.>$W3$ asks a great deal of stakeholder participation and financial me\ "#)>$a+*+,32+'+))H$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#$-+&1:+$4+")%-'+$,+'"3+.$31$ "''$32+$&1#.%3%1#)$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$92+$011,$&1#.%3%1#)$"3$ 32+$:1:+#3$#++.$31$&2"#/+$"#.$3(,#%#/$32+$)3,++3)$%#31$/11.$ 0'"&+)$%)$32+$.,%*%#/$41,&+$"#.$:1)3$%:01,3"#3$%#3+,*+#3%1#$41,$ K1.1#">$$ ,*+$ D&'$ #28#.'%'$ #2.8'.($ \$ ]%32%#$ 32+$ %#3+,*+#3%1#$ 41,$ 32+$ &,1))%#/$:"#L$.%44+,+#3$)3"<+21'.+,)$#++.$31$-+$%#*1'*+.>$92+$ &,1))%#/)$%#$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#$&2"#/+$32+$+Q%)3%#/$)0"&+$41&()+.$ on primarily traffic area into a space combining traffic, human :1*+:+#3)$"#.$:%&,1$0'"&+>$92+$'"33+,$3V1$V%''$/+3$:1,+$)0"&+$ and the first one needs the adapt a great deal. The interventi\ 1#$V%''$-+$4+")%-'+$32,1(/2$32+$"*"%'"-'+$)0"&+H$+#3,+0,+#+(,%"'$ )0%,%3H$)+",&2$41,$&1:41,3>$
92+$.+*+'10:+#3$"43+,$32+$V",$%#$32+$(,-"#$0+,%02+,L$2"00+\ #+.$1#$0,%*"3+$'"#.)>$92+L$(,-"#%e+.$",+")$0,+*%1()'L$()+.$"#.$ 4(#&3%1#%#/$")$"/,%&('3(,"'$'"#.)>$921)+$",+")$2".$#13$-++#$%#$ "#L$(,-"#$,+/('"31,L$0'"#$"#.$)1$,1".$"#.$)3,++3$&1#.%3%1#)$",+$ minimum. Often streets are not paved, no traffic signs placed "#.$)%.+V"'<)$.1$#13$+Q%)3>$W#$"$)+#)+$32%)$%)$#13$,+"''L$"$0,1\ -'+:$ -+&"()+$ 32+$ "3:1)02+,+$ %)$ '1&"'$ "#.$ )3,++3)$ .1$ 143+#$ 2"*+$"$.+".$+#.>$5)$1001)+.$31$K1.1#"H$)+,*%&+)$"#.$)210)$ ",+$'%:%3+.>$X#&+$%#$"$V2%'+$32+$21()+$1V#+,$3,"#)41,:+.$2%)$ ground floor into a micro shop. Part of the urban domain, im\ 0,1*+:+#3)$ 1#$ &1''+&3%*+$ )1&%"'$ "#.$ 3+&2#%&"'$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+)$ ",+$ #++.+.>$ a+*+,32+'+))H$ 32+$ -")%&$ .+)%/#$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ &"#$ "')1$-+$"00'%+.$%#$32%)$&1#3+Q3>$a+Q3$31$32"3H$32+L$#++.$31$-+$ %#$%#&1,01,"3+.$%#$32+$#+",-L$#+%/2-1,211.$.+*+'10:+#3$)3,"\ 3+/L$"#.$0'"#)>$
04. the sleeping construction and abandoned buildings \$ This intervention, using unfinished building and construction )%3+)$ 3+:01,",L$ "#.$ ,+#1*"3%#/$ "-"#.1#+.$ -(%'.%#/)$ %)$ &1:\ 0'+Q>$R%,)3H$32+$(#&'+",$4(3(,+$14$0'"#)$"#.$(,-"#$.+&%)%1#)$.1+)$ #13$/%*+$()$"$3%:+$)&"'+$41,$32+$()+$14$32+$)0"&+)>$G+&1#.H$32+$ 0,%*"3+$ 1V#+,)2%0$ %#&,+")+)$ 32+$ #+/13%"3%1#)$ 3%:+>$ 92%,.H$ 32+$ )"4+3L$ 14$ 32+$ )0"&+$ 41,$ &1::1#$ ()+$ %)$ (#&'+",>$ S")3H$ 32+$ (#\ <#1V#$)+",&2$41,$&1::(#%3L$"#.$%3)$*"'(+$":1#/$32+$)1&%+3L$%)$ '%:%3+.>$a+*+,32+'+))H$"''$&1#.%3%1#)$32"3$K1.1#"$144+,)$&1('.$ :"<+$32%)$%#3+,*+#3%1#$"#$%#3+,+)3%#/$)3+0$31$3"<+>$W3$144+,)$#+V$ "#.$%##1*"3%*+$()+$14$)0"&+$"#.$%)$10+#$31$*",%1()$"&3%*%3%+)>$ ,M+$G88'.$672#3$(@/#'($\$92+$%#3+,*+#3%1#$41,$(#()+.$"#.$'+43$ 1*+,$)0"&+$%)$*+,L$*"'("-'+$V%32%#$32+$'",/+,$0(-'%&$)0"&+$#+3\ V1,<>$W3$144+,)$%3)$,+)%.+#3)$#+V$1(3.11,$)0"&+)$"#.$10+#)$(0$ 32+$01))%-%'%3L$41,$#+V$,+'"3%1#)2%0)$"#.$&1::(#%3L$-(%'.%#/> The unknown ownership and direct surrounding is the difficult +'+:+#3$%#$32%)$%#3+,*+#3%1#>$_+,+$%3$%)$"-1(3$-(%'.%#/$32"3$,+'"\ 3%1#)2%0$"#.$144+,$)0"&+$%#$,+3(,#>$92+$+#3,+0,+#+(,%"'$)0%,3$"#.$ "*"%'"-'+$ )0"&+$ :"<+$ 32%)$ %#3+,*+#3%1#$ 4+")%-'+$ "#.$ %:01,3"#3$ %#$+Q3+#.%#/$32+$#+3V1,<$-+L1#.$32+$:%#%:(:$%#3+,*+#3%1#)>
92+$ #+%/2-1,211.)H$ )%:%'",$ ")$ K1.1#"$ ",+$ %#$ 32+$ #1,32$ "#.$ +")3$14$32+$&%3L$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$&"#$-+$()+.$%#$32%)$",+">$a+\ *+,32+'+))H$ K1.1#"`)$ .+#)%3L$ %)$ 2%/2+,$ "#.$ "33,"&3)$ :1,+$ *%\ )%31,)>$92+$0",<$0'"L)$"$'",/+$,1'+$%#$32%)>$R1,$32+$132+,$#+%/2\ -1,211.)H$"$)%:%'",$"33,"&3%1#$1,$'",/+,$10+#$)0"&+$1,$/,++#+,L$ )21('.$-+$0",3$14$32+$)3,"3+/L$"#.$.+)%/#>$W3$#++.)$31$2"*+$"$ 776
Map of Prishtina
Variety of neighborhoods
urban periphery dense neighborhoods central district student district socialist highrise high classe residential business & Industrial 0
villlages
2km
Fig. 141 Post conflict Prishtina
&1::(#%3L$ &+#3,"'$ )0"&+$ V2%&2$ )+,*+)$ 32+$ ."%'L$ 0(-'%&$ #++.)$ 14$%3)$,+)%.+#3)>$
0","3+$[("'%3L$",+")$V%321(3$)+,*%#/$32+$'",/+,$0(-'%&$#+3V1,<>$ 92+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$%#$32%)$0,1Y+&3$"&3$1#$32+$'%:%3+.$-")%&$[("'%3L$ 14$32+$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$0'"&+)>$W#$32+$&+#3+,H$32+$&1##+&3%1#$ -+3V++#$32+$0(-'%&$"#.$0,%*"3+$%)$+[("''L$'%:%3+.>$G1:+$",+")$ ",+$ *+,L$ "&3%*+$ "#.$ )21V$ "$ /11.$ 0'"&+$ .+)%/#$ -(3$ )3%''$ :"#L$ ",+")$&1('.$()+$32+$0,101)+.$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$41,$:"<%#/$32+$&+#\ 3+,$"')1$0'"&+$14$-+'1#/%#/>$a13$Y()3$")$'+%)(,+$.%)3,%&3>
92+$ )1&%"'%)3$ 2%/2$ ,%)+$ ",+")$ %#$ 32+$ )1(32$ ",+$ 4"&%#/$ .%44+,+#3$ 0,1-'+:)>$ U#1(/2$ )0"&+$ %)$ 0,1*%.+.H$ )3,++3)$ ",+$ ,+'"3%*+'L$ 14$ /11.$[("'%3L$"#.$32+,+$%)$:1,+$)0"&+$41,$*",%1()$)1&%"'$/,1(0)>$ 92+$ #+%/2-1,211.)$ ",+$ :1)3'L$ ,+)%.+#3%"'$ "#.$ 4(#&3%1#)$ ",+$ &+#3,"'$'1&"3+.$%#$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$5#$"&3%*+$)3,++3$'%4+$%)$'%\ :%3+.$"#.$:"#L$)0"&+)$+:03L>$92+$,+'"3%1#$-+3V++#$32+$-(%'\ .%#/$"#.$32+$)(,,1(#.%#/$)0"&+$%)$#13$V+''$.+)%/#+.>$5$):"''$ amount of micro businesses appeared on the ground floors but most ground floors are blind walls. The approach used in this 0,1Y+&3$,+'"3+.$31$)(001,3$#+V$-()%#+))+)$"#.$)3",3\(0)H$()+.$ .+)%/#$3+&2#%[(+)$41,$-,%#/%#/$31/+32+,$.%44+,+#3$"&3%*%3%+)$"#.$ %##1*"3%*+$()+$14$'+43$14$)0"&+)$&1('.$-+$"$V"L$31$,+#+V$32+)+$ #+%/2-1,211.)$311>$
92+$ ",+")$ 14$ 32+$ (#%*+,)%3L$ "#.$ )3(.+#3$ .%)3,%&3$ 2"*+$ .%*+,)+$ (,-"#$4"-,%&>$92+$(#%*+,)%3L$&":0()H$V2%&2$%)$&+#3,"''L$'1&"3+.$ %)$ :"%#3"%#+.$ 011,'L>$ W#\41,:"'%e"3%1#$ 14$ )0"&+H$ 011,$ [("'%3L$ 14$ *+,L$ 013+#3%"'$ /,++#$ ",+")$ "#.$ '%:%3+.$ "33,"&3%1#$ 14$ .%*+,\ )+$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$&1('.$()+$32+$0,101)+.$%.+")$%#$32+$0,1Y+&3>$ I)%#/$32+$"&3%*+$L1(#/$010('"3%1#$%#$&,+"3%#/$"#$"&3%*+$0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$ V2%&2$ %)$ %#3+,+)3%#/$ 41,$ 32+$ '",/+,$ &1#3+Q3$ &"#$ :"<+$ 32%)$ ",+"$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ (,-"#$ 0(-'%&$ .1:"%#>$ W#$ "..%3%1#H$ %3$ &"#$ -+&1:+$"#$%:01,3"#3$+'+:+#3$%#$+Q3+#.%#/$32+$'"#.)&"0+$"#.$ +&1'1/L$%$32+$1*+,-(%'.$&%3L>
92+$&+#3,"'$",+"$%)$"',+".L$%#$3,"#)%3%1#$31V",.)$"$:1,+$[("'%\ 3"3%*+$0'"&+>$92+$0+.+)3,%"#%e%#/$14$F132+,$92+,+)"$-1('+*",.$ was the first step providing place for its residents and even on "$#"3%1#"'$)&"'+>$92+$"33,"&3%*+$01V+,$14$32+$&+#3+,$%)$+#1,:1()$ "#.$.(,%#/$32+$."L$:"#L$*%)%3$32+$",+">$W3$%)$"$0'"&+$41,$)1&%"'$ %#3+,"&3%1#$"#.$'+%)(,+>$92+$132+,$)%.+$%)$32+$.%,+&3$-"&<L",.$14$ 32+$-1('+*",.H$%3$%)$,+)%.+#3%"'$V%32$:%Q+.$()+$",+")>$92+$"':1)3$ (#\M,%)23%#"$ '%<+$ [("'%3L$ 14$ 32+$ -1('+*",.$ %)$ 32+$ 1001)%3+$ 14$ :"#L$#+%/2-1,%#/$)3,++3)>$92+L$",+$#13$%#3+,+)3%#/H$.",<$0'"&+)$ "#.$#13$"33,"&3%*+>$W#$/+#+,"'H$32+$&+#3+,$%)$"$&1:01)%3%1#$14$)+\
W#$/+#+,"'H$32+$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$",+$3"%'1,$:".+$41,$32+$&1#3+Q3$14$ K1.1#"$ -(3$ .1$ 144+,$ 01))%-%'%3%+)$ %#$ ()%#/$ %3$ %#$ .%44+,+#3$ &1#\ 3+Q3)>$92+$"00,1"&2$"#.$)3,"3+/L$41,$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$%)$/11.$ 41,$32+$+#3%,+$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3H$32+$0",3%&('",$"&3%1#)$)21('.$ -+$ 41&()+.$ 1#$ 32+$ '1&"'$ 0,1-'+:)>$ 92+$ +)3"-'%)2:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ ,+'"3%1#)2%0$-+3V++#$32+$0(-'%&$"#.$0,%*"3+$%)$%#$0'"&+$41,$+*+,L$ #+%/2-1,211.>
77@
PFG'A31&6-+,31+
PFG'A31&6-+,31+
I#,+/('"3+.$ "#.$ %#41,:"'$ .+*+'10:+#3$ ",+$ 1#+$ 14$ 32+$ &1,+$ 0,1\ blems in post conflict areas. Current rebuilding and city planning 4"&+$3,+:+#.1()$&2"''+#/+)$,+/('"3%#/$,"0%.$.+*+'10:+#3$14$32+$ (,-"#$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ ,+)+,*%#/$ "#.$ 0,+)+,*%#/$ )0"&+$ 41,$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$.1:"%#>$92+$'"33+,$1#+$2")$-++#$143+#$.%),+/",.+.$%3)$%:\ 01,3"#&+>$ W3$ 2")$ -++#$ 41(#.$ 32"3$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+$ "#.$ )1&%"'$ 0'"&+)$ ",+$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ -")%&$ #++.)H$ +)0+&%"''L$ %#$ .+*+'10%#/$ &1(#3,%+)>$ W#3+/,"3%#/$ 32"3$ 0(-'%&$ .%:+#)%1#$ V%32%#$ &(,,+#3$ &1#3+Q3)$ 14$ 01)3$ conflict conditions has great challenges. This thesis focused on the 41''1V%#/$[(+)3%1#b How can spatial interventions improve the quality of living in post conflict Dodona and how could those contribute to a coC hesive socio-spatial environment. W#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ "#)V+,$ 32%)$ :"%#$ ,+)+",&2$ [(+)3%1#H$ )+*+#$ ,+)+",&2$ questions were defined to contribute to a final answer. The first ,+)+",&2$[(+)3%1#$,+'"3+.$31$32+$&1#.%3%1#)$"#.$)%3("3%1#)$32"3$32+$ post conflict development processes have caused in Prishtina. Pris\ 3%#"`)$(,-"#$4"-,%&$&2"#/+.$,"0%.'L$"#.$V%32$+#1,:1()$&1#)+[(+#\ &+)$41,$32+$01)%3%1#$14$32+$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$0",<)>$W3$2")$-+&1:+$ &'+",$32"3$%3$%)$"$&1:-%#"3%1#$14$.%44+,+#3$&%,&(:)3"#&+)$32"3$&"()+.$ 41,$32+$.+3+,%1,"3%1#$14$32+$(,-"#$[("'%3L>$W#$/+#+,"'H$32%)$3,"#)%3%1#$ &"#$-+$'%)3+.$1#$32+$2+".%#/b$%#.%*%.("'%):>$92%)$:+"#3$41,$32+$&1#\ .%3%1#)$14$32+$&1::1#$/,1(#.)$"#.$0(-'%&$/11.)$31$.+&,+")+$%#$ [("'%3L$"#.$143+#$+*+#$31$.%)"00+",>$F"#L$01%#3$%#$32+$.%,+&3%1#$14$ 32+$/1*+,#:+#3$"#.$:(#%&%0"'%3L$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$32+$011,$&1#.%\ 3%1#)$14$32+$0(-'%&$/,1(#.)$"#.$/11.)>$92+$,+)('3$14$)+'4\/1*+,#%#/$ as a new in depended country has not yet reflected in improved the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c1)1*1$.(,%#/$32%)$0,1Y+&3$32+$/+#+,"'$1-)+,*"3%1#$%)$32"3$M,%)23%#"$ %)$&"3&2%#/$(0$[(%&<'L$%#$32+$/'1-"''L$)+",&2$41,$&1:41,3$"#.$/11.$ (,-"#$0'"&+)>$5)$0,14+))1,$R'1,%#"$g+,'%($:+#3%1#+.$.(,%#/$32+$%#\ 3+,*%+VH$32+$c1)1*1$"#.$M,%)23%#"$010('"3%1#$%#$0",3%&('",$)21V$2%/2$ '+*+')$14$"."03"-%'%3L$"#.$,+)%'%+#&+>$92,1(/2$:('3%0'+$3,"#)%3%1#)$%#$ 32+$0")3$A!\8!$L+",)$'%*%#/$V%32$(#&+,3"%#3%+)$%)$0",3$14$."%'L$'%4+$-(3$ this does not influence their need for an active public life. The â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;out\ /1%#/`$&('3(,"'$&2","&3+,%)3%&)$0,1*%.+$M,%)23%#"$V%32$"$-()L$"':1)3$ &1):101'%3"#$*%-+$"#.$"3:1)02+,+>$P'+",$%)$32"3H$",+")$32"3$2"*+$ -++#$&2"#/+.$%#$4"*1,$14$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$'%<+$F132+,$92+,+)"$)3,++3$ 2"*+$+*+#$32+$01V+,$31$"&3$1#$#"3%1#"'$)&"'+)>$92"3$)1&%"'$.%:+#\
77A
)%1#$ %)$ *+,L$ %:01,3"#3$ %)$ ."%'L$ '%*+)$ 14$ %#2"-%3"#3)>$ a+*+,32+'+))H$ )+0","3%1#$14$.%44+,+#3$)1&%"'$/,1(0)$%)$2"00+#%#/$"#.$32+$'1&"3%\ 1#$"#.$01)%3%1#$14$.%44+,+#3$:%#1,%3L$/,1(0)$")$0",3$14$32%)$)1&%+3L$ need to be enhanced. While studying post conflict processes and 0(-'%&$'%4+$32+1,%+)$)L)3+:)$32+$)1&%"'H$+&1#1:%&H$01'%3%&"'H$&('3(,"'$ "#.$+#*%,1#:+#3"'$&1#3+Q3)$",+$&,(&%"'$31$(#.+,)3"#.>$92%)$32+)%)$ aimed to develop spatial interventions for post conflict Dodona, a #+%/2-1,211.$%#$32+$+")3$14$M,%)23%#">$92+$.+&,+")+$14$0",3%&('",'L$ 32+$)0"3%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3$2")$+44+&3$1#$"$[("'%3L$0(-'%&$'%4+>$W#$1,.+,$ 31$(#.+,)3"#.$32+$'1&"'$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$")0+&3)$32"3$&2","&3+,%e+$32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$"#$+Q3+#)%*+$"#"'L)%)$2")$-++#$.1#+>$W3$"%:)$31$(#\ .+,)3"#.$32+$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$&1::1#$/,1(#.$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>$$ JL$1-)+,*%#/$&'1)+'LH$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$32+$-+41,+$:+#3%1#+.$ characteristics were confirmed. Different social groups are more or less present but facing difficulties in performing their choice 14$ "&3%*%3%+)>$ 92+$ )0"&+$ %#$ 32+$ )3,++3)H$ V2%&2$ ",+$ 32+$ 1#'L$ 0(-'%&$ ",+")$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.$.1$#13$144+,$[("'%3L$)0"&+$41,$"$'1&"'$ &21%&+$14$()+>$92+$&",$.1:%#"3+)$32+$)3,++3$)&+#+$"#.$%)$3"<+#$%#$ "''$"*"%'"-'+$)0"&+>$W3$%)$0",3'L$32+$)0"3%"'$.+)%/#$1,$'"&<$14$32"3$%)$ &"()%#/$ 4,++$ ()+$ -(3$ "')1$ 32+$ :+#3"'%3L$ "#.$ -+2"*%1,$ %#$ 32+$ 0(\ -'%&>$92+$"#"'L)%)$%)$3,"#)4+,,+.$%#31$"#$1*+,*%+V$14$0"33+,#)$14$K1\ .1#">$x("'%3%+)H$013+#3%"')$"#.$&2"''+#/+)$144+,$"#$%#)%/23$%#$32+$ "*"%'"-'+$(#.+,()+.$)0"&+)H$"&3%*+$"#.$.+".$",+")$"#.$&(,,+#3'L$ 144+,+.$01))%-%'%3%+)$41,$"&3%*%3%+)>$T+)+",&2$)21V)$32"3$32+,+$%)$"$ /"0$-+3V++#$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$"#.$0,%*"3+$.1:"%#>$92+$V"L$0+10'+$ "&3$ "#.$ &",+$ 41,$ 32+%,$ 1V#$ 0,10+,3L$ %)$ *+,L$ .%44+,+#3$ 4,1:$ 32+%,$ -+2"*%1,$%#$32+$0(-'%&$&1::1#$)0"&+)>$92+$'+*+'$14$-+'1#/%#/$31$ 32+$#+%/2-1,211.$"#.$"$)+#)+$14$&%3%e+#)2%0$%)$:%))%#/>$92"3$'1&"'$ (#.+,)3"#.%#/$2")$-++#$/%*+#$)0"&+$%#$32+$0,1Y+&3>$W#*1'*%#/$32+$ 010('"3%1#$%#$0'"##%#/$"#.$.+&%)%1#$:"<%#/$%)$,"32+,$%:01,3"#3>$ c#1V'+./+$14$'1&"'$)"3%)4"&3%1#$V%32$32+$&(,,+#3$(,-"#$&1#.%3%1#)$ "#.$#++.)$"#.$0,%1,%3%+)$"&&1,.%#/$32+$%#2"-%3"#3)$&1#3,%-(3+.$31$ 32+$.+)%/#>$G0"3%"'$%#3+,*+#3%1#)$#++.$31$%:0,1*+$'1&"'$'%*+)>$W#2"\ -%3"#3)$:".+$&'+",$32+%,$&1#&+,#)$"-1(3$32+$)0"3%"'$1,/"#%e"3%1#$ "#.$011,$[("'%3L$14$32+$0(-'%&$",+")>$5$&'+",$#++.$41,$&1:41,3$V")$ 01%#3+.$1(3>$ 5$ .+)%/#$ ,+)+",&2$ 4,":+V1,<$ %)$ .+*+'10+.$ 31$ .+)%/#$ h)0"3%"'i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b$32+$%)1'"3+.$0(-'%&$ )0"&+)H$32+$.%)1,.+,+.$)3,++3H$&1#&,+3+$&,1))%#/H$%##+,$-'1&<$)0"\
ces, unfinished construction and abandoned buildings, vacancies "#.$32+$&('3(,"'$&1##+&31,>$5''$+#2"#&+$32+$'1&"'$[("'%3%+)$"#.$()+$ 32+$013+#3%"')$14$32+$)0"3%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3>$92+$)0"3%"'$"/+#."$32"3$ defines the strategic themes is integrated in the design interven\ 3%1#)$")$V+''$")$32+$#++.)$14$32+$'1&"'$)1&%+3L>$92+$.+)%/#$)21V+.$ that there are five conditions that contribute to the development 14$ K1.1#"`)$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+$ #+3V1,<$ N$ [("'%3L$ (,-"#$ .1:"%#b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e+#)2%0$"#.$"&3%*+$0(-'%&\0,%\ vate networks. The feasibility of the interventions has reflected. R%#"#&%"'$ &"0"&%3L$ 14$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ %)$ '%:%3+.$ "#.$ )01#)1,%#/$ -L$ h%#3+,i\#"3%1#"'$ .1#1,)$ "3$ 32%)$ 01%#3$ %)$ #+&+))",L>$ W#$ "..%3%1#H$ 32+$"&3%*+$0",3%&%0"3%1#$14$%#2"-%3"#3)H$anX`)H$"#.$132+,$)3"<+21'\ .+,)$%)$&,(&%"'$31$32+$0,1Y+&3>$S")3H$32+$&1::%3:+#3$"#.$,+#+V+.$ 0(-'%&$&",$14$32+$0(-'%&$-1.%+)$%)$+))+#3%"'>$92+$0,1Y+&3)$0'"##%#/$ "#.$3%:+$)&"'+$0,101)+)$"$.+3"%'+.$"00,1"&2$31$,+"'%e+$32+$%#3+,\ *+#3%1#)>$]%32$32+$()+$14$0%'13$0,1Y+&3)$41,$+*+,L$%#3+,*+#3%1#H$32+$ 1(3&1:+)$&"#$-+$+*"'("3+.$"#.$-+$&,%3%&%e+.$-L$"''$)3"<+21'.+,)$%#$ 1,.+,$31$%:0,1*+$0+,:"#+#3$"&3%1#)>$W#$"..%3%1#H$321)+$%#3+,*+#3%\ ons can be reflected upon their applicability in different contexts. M,%)23%#"$2")$*",%1()$#+%/2-1,211.)$32"3$2"*+$-++#$"44+&3+.$-L$ the post conflict processes. The design interventions are tailor made for Dodona, but it is worth reflecting their possible use in 132+,$#+%/2-1,211.)>$W3$)21V)$32"3$%#$#+%/2-1,211.)H$0(-'%&$)0"\ &+)$)21V$)%:%'",$&1#.%3%1#)>$5."03$32+$0(-'%&$"00,1"&2$31$321)+$ )%3("3%1#)$&"#$%:0,1*+$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$&1#.%3%1#)$311>$ 92+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ %#3+,*+#3%1#)$ )21V$ 32"3$ "$ ,+#+\ V+.$0(-'%&$)0"&+$#+3V1,<$&"#$-+$%#3+/,"3+.$%#$"$#+%/2-1,211.$ affected by post conflict processes. It can contribute to an inte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e+.>
778
7.0 Reflection
7.0 Reflection
92+$310%&$14$32%)$/,".("3%1#$0,1Y+&3$%)$/"%#%#/$%:01,3"#&+$#1V"\ ."L)>$;",%1()$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$"#.$%#)3%3(3%1#)$",+$0(33%#/$0,+))(,+$1#$ 32+$+))+#3%"')$14$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3)$V%32$/'1-"'$,+)+",&2$1#$%#3,%#\ )%&$*"'(+)$14$&%3%+)>$W#$32+)+$,+)+",&2$0,1Y+&3)$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$ of rebuilding after a civil strife or conflict is pointed as important but neglected in significantly. This project is inspired by the general %#3+,+)3$%#$*",%1()$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3)$"#.$-"&</,1(#.)$14$)1&%+3L$ "#.$ 32+%,$ (,-"#$ 0,%#3$ %#$ &%3%+)>$ c1)1*1$ /13$ V%32%#$ :L$ *%)%1#$ "#.$ 41&()$.(+$31$%3)$*+,L$(#%[(+$&%,&(:)3"#&+)$"#.$'%:%3+.$3%:+$0"))+.$ since the conflict. It could show through research its situations as a post conflict place within the European context, which we know /+#+,"''L$14$32+$)3"3+$0'"##+.$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#$14$41,$+Q":0'+$T13\ terdam as post-conflict rebuilding process. The main context I refer 31$%)$32+$1*+,"''$)%3("3%1#$14$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3)$.+)&,%-+.$")$(,-"#$ areas in transition, accelerated by a conflict. More and more places see figures on p. 16-19 will reach the point of somehow of the post conflict period and the challenges that it brings.
'+*+')$3,%+)$31$,+"''L$31(&2$32+$#+&+))",L$"#.$-")%&$#++.)$14$0(-'%&$ life first. It works as system on multiple levels in order to enhance 0(-'%&$'%4+>$
W$ )3",3+.$ V%32$ "$ '%3+,"3(,+$ )3(.L$ 1#$ 0(-'%&$ '%4+$ "#.$ 0","''+'$ 1#$ post- conflict situations. This combination of understanding both )'1V+.$ .1V#$ 32+$ 0,1Y+&3)$ 0,1&+))>$ J132$ ",+$ +Q3+#)%*+$ 0",3)$ 14$ ,+)+",&2$ "#.$ %#*1'*+$ *",%1()$ 132+,$ .1:"%#)H$ '%<+$ 32+$ )1&%"'$ +#\ *%,1#:+#3H$+&1#1:LH$2%)31,LH$&('3(,+H$%#)3%3(3%1#"'$"#.$%#3+,#"3%1\ #"'$)L)3+:)>$92+$'"&<$14$."3"$"#.$:"0)$V")$%#&,+")%#/$32+$#++.$ 41,$)+'4\1,/"#%e"3%1#>$W#$1,.+,$31$&'+",$:%#.)$"#.$/"%#$-+33+,$.%,+&3$ (#.+,)3"#.%#/H$ )+*+,"'$ )21,3+,$ "#.$ '1#/+,$ 3,%0)$ V+,+$ :".+>$ W#\ 3+,*%+V)$V%32$*",%1()$)3"<+21'.+,)H$,+)+",&2+,)$"#.$0,14+))%1#"')$ slowly made the story clearer. The story of conflict related places %)$143+#$"$&1:0'+Q$1#+H$#13$+*+#$:+#3%1#%#/$32+$0,1&+))$14$(,\ -"#$ .+*+'10:+#3>$ 5)$ )++#$ %#$ 32+$ ,+)+",&2H$ 32+$ (,-"#$ 4"-,%&$ 14$ K1.1#"$#+%/2-1,211.$"#.$32+$'",/+,$(,-"#$&1#3+Q3$&2"#/+.$3,+\ mendously, which indicates so many other issues and conflicts on 92+$:"%#$,+)+",&2$[(+)3%1#$14$32%)$/,".("3%1#$0,1Y+&3$%)b$_1V$&"#$ ",&2%3+&3(,"'H$&1#)3,(&3%1#H$%#4,")3,(&3(,+$"#.$+#*%,1#:+#3"'$'+*+')$ spatial interventions improve the quality of living in post conflict V2%&2$&1('.$#13$"''$-+$"#)V+,+.> K1.1#"$"#.$21V$&1('.$321)+$&1#3,%-(3+$31$"$&12+)%*+$)1&%1\)0"\ 92+$ 0,1Y+&3$ ()+)$ M,%)23%#"$ ")$ "$ &")+$ )3(.L$ %#$ 32+$ 310%&)$ 14$ 01)3$ 3%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3f 92+$[(+)3%1#$%)$.%*%.+.$%#31$)(-$[(+)3%1#)$32"3$%#.%*%.("''L$"#)V+,$ conflict development and public life, and the approach of the so\ elements of the main question. Questions on post-conflict tran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c1)1*1>$ 2+,+$",+$3"%'1,$:".+H$32+)+$",+$"$&1:-%#"3%1#$14$&,+"3%*+$32%#<%#/$ Much written about post conflict, rebuilding its physical, etc. but V%32$<#1V'+./+$14$/+#+,"'$0(-'%&$'%4+$.+)%/#$+Q":0'+)>$92+L$2"*+$ 0,"&3%&"'$(,-"#$%.+")$"-1(3$):"''$%:0,1*+:+#3)O$)3,"3+/%&$.+)%/#) been influenced by the satisfaction and evaluation of the urban "#.$ %#3+/,"3+.$ 0'"#)$ ",+$ #13$ :(&2$ .+*+'10+.$ L+3>$ 92+,+41,+H$ W$ +#*%,1#:+#3$14$32+$'1&"'$010('"3%1#$%#$32+$)(,*+LH$/+#+,"'$Ia\2"\ 32%#<$32"3$32+$0,1Y+&3$,+"''L$&1#3,%-(3+)$31$32+$V%.+,$)1&%"'$&1#3+Q3$ -%3"3$0,%#&%0'+)$1#$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$)3,++3)>$R(,32+,$"#.$-,1".+,$ 14$)()3"%#"-'+$,+#+V"'$"#.$'%*"-%'%3L$14$01)3$V",$.+*+'10:+#3$0,1\ ,+)+",&2$ &"#$ 0,1*%.+$ 132+,$ )1'(3%1#)$ 4,1:$ V1,'.'L$ .+)%/#)$ +')+\ &+))+)>$_1V+*+,H$32%)$0,1Y+&3$#++.)$)1:+$:1,+$%#$.+032$,+)+",&2$ where in which post conflict processes were tackled. "#.$ 3+)3%#/$ 31$ ,+"''L$ (#.+,)3"#.$ 32+$ %:0"&3$ 14$ 32+$ )1'(3%1#)$ "#.$ 32+$.+)%/#>$J+)%.+)$32"3H$32+$0,1Y+&3$'+"*+)$",+")$(#31(&2+.$V%32%#$ JL$"$'%3+,"3(,+$,+*%+VH$132+,$,+)+",&2$.1&(:+#3"3%1#H$0+,)1#"'$1-\ 32+$ )1&%"'$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ '%<+$ )1&%"'$ 21()%#/$ "#.$ 1,/"#%e"3%1#"'$ "&\ )+,*"3%1#)$"#.$%#3+,*%+V)$V%32$'1&"'$0,14+))%1#"')$"#.$)3"<+21'.+,)$ 3%*%3%+)$ %#$ 32+$ &1::(#%3L$ -(%'.%#/$ "#.$ )1&%"'$ )3(.%+)$ ",+">$ X32+,$ W$41(#.$32+$&2"''+#/+)$%#$.+)%/#%#/$,+#+V+.$0(-'%&$'%4+$%#$K1.1#"$ :1,+$)0"3%"'$%))(+)$32"3$2"*+#`3$-++#$,+)+",&2+.$"3$32+$:1:+#3$%)$ -(3$%#$/+#+,"'$"''$#+%/2-1,211.)$14$M,%)23%#">$92+#$W$*%)%3+.$M,%)2\ 32+$011,'L$0(-'%&$3,"#)01,3$)%3("3%1#H$32+$&1#.%3%1#)$14$32+$*",%1()$ tina again for 2,5 months to do the fieldwork and interviewing. An 21()%#/$)3L'+)$"#.$%3)$01))%-'+$(0/,".+$"#.$%#3+/,"3%1#$V%32%#$32+$ +Q3+#)%*+$0",3$14$32+$,+)+",&2$"#.$"%:$%)$"-1(3$32+$+Q%)3%#/$[("\ )3,++3$"#.$'")3H$32+$0",<%#/$)%3("3%1#$"#.$&",\()+$-+2"*%1,$14$32+$)1\ '%3L$14$32+$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$"#.$)1&%"'$+#*%,1#:+#3H$-(3$0",3%&('",'L$ ciety. The design and the project is focusing firstly on the spatial re\ gaining local knowledge on situations and absorbing specifics of quirements of places and the search for these within the conflicted post conflict characteristics in the local context. In collaboration (,-"#$4"-,%&>$92%)$%)$(#.+,)311.$-L$()%#/$02L)%&"'$%#.%&"31,)$()+.$%#$ with urban research company: PRO Planning and the office for public life studies to reflect the existing situation. They contribute I,-"#$ T+/+#+,"3%1#$ "#.$ c1)1*1`)$ 5,&2%3+&3(,+$ R1(#."3%1#$ #+V$ 31$(#.+,)3"#.%#/$14$32+%,$)1&%"'$%:0"&3$%#$"#$(,-"#$+#*%,1#:+#3>$ #+3V1,<)$ :".+$ %3$ 01))%-'+$ 31$ (#.+,)3"#.$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ :1,+$ %#$ 92+$ M,%1,%3L$ &1#&+03$ 14$ :%#%:(:\.+)%,+.\:"Q%:(:$ %#3+,*+#3%1#$ .+032$"#.$:".+$%3$01))%-'+$31$&'1)+'L$"-)1,-$32+$#+%/2-1,211.>
76!
92+$.+)%/#$.+*+'10:+#3$32,1(/2$32+$,+)+",&2$)3",3+.$31$+*1'*+>$ 5$ '%)3$ 14$ &2"''+#/+)$ #++.$ 31$ -+$ 3"&<'+.$ 32,1(/2$ 32+$ .+)%/#$ 4,1:$ 32+$,+)+",&2$0+,)0+&3%*+>$J+)%.+)$32"3H$32+$:%#.$14$32+$%#.%*%.("'$ designer and with that specific aims and ideals chanced the direc\ 3%1#$14$32+$.+)%/#$)1:+21V>$92+$(,-"#$4++'%#/$"#.$)+#)+$14$32+$ 0,1-'+:)$10+#+.$(0$#+V$0",3)$14$32+$#+%/2-1,211.b$32+$2%)31,L$ 14$ 0(-'%&$ '%4+$ %#$ 32+$ 100,+))+.$ 0+,%1.$ %#$ ^Z!)H$ 32+$ (#%[(+#+))$ 14$ the self-organization and the rich street profiles that were created "#.$32+$+#3,+0,+#+(,%"'$"#.$10+#$&2","&3+,%)3%&)$14$32+$010('"3%1#>$ 92+$ .+)%/#$ -+&":+$ :1,+$ 32"#$ Y()3$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ "$ -+33+,$ )3,++3$1,$)[(",+$%3$/13$"$)+#)+$14$"&3%*%):$"#.$V%32$32"3$)3"3+:+#3)$ "-1(3$ 0'"##%#/$ [(+)3%1#)H$ )3"3+\&1::(#%3L$ ,+'"3%1#)H$ )+'4\1,/"#%\ e"3%1#$ "#.$ ,%&2#+))$ 14$ "''$ 0'"&+)$ %#$ 32+$ V1,'.$ .+)0%3+$ %3)$ '1&"3%1#$ "#.$+&1#1:%&"'$)3"3+> 92+$ .+)%/#$ #1VH$ %)$ /,1V%#/$ 31V",.)$ "$ #+3V1,<$ '",/+,$ 32"#$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.$ %3)+'4>$ $ X#$ 1#+$ )%.+H$ %3$ %#&,+")+)$ 3,%"#/('"3%1#$ "#.$ &,1))%#/)$ 14$ *",%1()$ /,1(0)$ "#.$ 1#$ 32+$ 132+,$ )%.+$ %3$ &"#$ 0,1*%.+$ )1'(3%1#)$1#$32+$):"''+)3$)&"'+)>$$92+$,+'"3%1#$V%32$L1(,$#+%/2-1,$ "-1(3$)2",%#/$4,1#3$L",.$)0"&+)$41,$103%:"'$1(3&1:+)$%#$32+$0(-'%&$ .1:"%#$%)$"')1$)1:+$3L0+$14$3,%"#/('"3%1#>$a+V$0(-'%&$0'"&+)$V%32%#$ 32+$ '",/+,$ #+3V1,<$ ",+$ %#&,+")%#/$ 32+$ 0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$ &1::(#%&"\ 3%1#H$ -(3$ :1)3$ %:01,3"#3$ /,1V%#/$ 32+$ )+#)+$ 14$ 32+$ 0(-'%&$ ,+"':b$ )0+#.%#/$ 3%:+$ 1(3)%.+$ "#.$ %#&,+")%#/$ 32+$ )1&%"'$ +#*%,1#:+#3H$ "$ 4++'%#/$14$&%3%e+#)2%0>$W#$"..%3%1#H$%3$%)$%:01,3"#3$41,$32+$&1::(#%3L$ 31$-+$%#*1'*+.$%#$32+$0,1&+))>$5)$.+)&,%-+.$%#$32+$.+)%/#$,+)+",&2H$ :1)3$ %:01,3"#3$ %)$ 32+$ 0",3%&%0"3%1#$ "#.$ &1::(#%&"3%1#$ -+3V++#$ 32+$0(-'%&$"#.$0,%*"3+$0",3)$14$32+$)1&%+3L> W#$/+#+,"'H$32+$"%:$14$32+$0,1Y+&3b$&,+"3%#/$"$)1&%1\)0"3%"'$&1::1#$ /,1(#.$"#.$"$,+#+V+.$0(-'%&$.1:"%#$&1('.$-+$3+)3+.$+')+V2+,+>$$ The case of Dodona, is not unique as a post conflict development process. However, the design interventions are very specific to the '1&"'$ &1#3+Q3$ "#.$ &2"''+#/+)>$ 92+$ *%)%1#$ "#.$ %.+"$ 1#$ 32+$ 132+,$ hand are more general for post conflict situations. It is worth gene\ ,"3%#/$-")%&$0,%#&%0'+)$1(3$14$32%)$0,1Y+&3$32"3$V2%&2$&"#$-+$32+$)3",3$ of strategies for other post conflict situations.
767
QFG'C*;*.*1&*+
QFG'C*;*.*1&*+
Literture References 5/#+VH$g>$5>$h6!!Bi>$G0"&+b$M'"&+>$W#$M>$P'1<+$N$T>$g12#)31#$hU.)>iH$G0"&+)$14$/+1/,"02%&"'$321(/23b$K+&1#)3,(&3%#/$2(:"#$/+1/,"02L`)$-%#",%+)$h00>$C7\ZAi>$S1#.1#b$G"/+> 5'+Q"#.+,H$P>$h7Z88i>$5$M"33+,#$S"#/("/+b$91V#)H$J(%'.%#/)H$P1#)3,(&3%1#b$XIM$IG5> 5'+Q"#.+,H$P>$h7Z8Zi>$92+$9%:+'+))$]"L$14$J(%'.%#/b$XQ41,.$I#%*+,)%3L$M,+))> 5:%#H$5>$h6!!Ci>$P1''+&3%*+$&('3(,+$"#.$(,-"#$0(-'%&$)0"&+>$P%3LH$76h7iH$B\6E>$ 500'+L",.H$K>$h7ZC7i>$S%*"-'+$G3,++3)b$I#%*+,)%3L$14$P"'%41,#%"$M,+))> 500'+L",.H$K>H$N$g"&1-)H$5>$J>$h7ZC6i>$91V",.$5#$I,-"#$K+)%/#$F"#%4+)31>$g1(,#"'$14$32+$5:+,%&"#$M'"##%#/$5))1&%"3%1#H$@6>$ J+*"#H$T>$h6!!Ai>$92+$.+)3,(&3%1#$14$:+:1,Lb$5,&2%3+&3(,+$"3$V",>$S1#.1#b$T+"<%31#$J11<)> P2",'+)V1,32H$U>$h6!!8i>$5,&2%3+&3)$)21('.$"&3z$;1'(:+$\$P%3%+)$I#-(%'.H$5,&2%)H$76\7B>$ P1::%))%1#H$U>$h6!!@i>$U(,10+"#$P1::1#$W#.%&"31,)>$F%'"#b$5:-%+#3+$W3"'%"$T+)+",&2$W#)3%3(3+> P1##1''LH$]>$h6!!Bi>$M'(,"'%):>$K(,2":b$K(<+$I#%*+,)%3L$M,+))> T+)1'(3%1#$76EEH$GOTUGO76EE$P>R>T>$h7ZZZi> P,+))V+''H$9>$h6!!Ei>$M'"&+b$5$G21,3$W#3,1.(&3%1#b$]%'+L> P(''+#H$n>$h7ZA7i>$92+$P1#&%)+$91V#)&"0+b$5,&2%3+&3(,"'$M,+))> K+'"#."H$F>$h6!!!i>$5$921()"#.$d+",)$14$a1#\S%#+",$_%)31,L>$a+V$d1,<b$t1#+> K1#14,%1H$9>$5>$h6!7!i>$n,1(#.$t+,1$"#.$M'"&+\F"<%#/$5(321,%3Lb$92+$P1#)+,*"3%*+$F+3"021,)$%#$ZO77$R":%'%+)`$j9"<+$J"&<$32+$F+:1,%"'k$T2+31,%&>$]+)3+,#$g1(,#"'$14$P1::(#%&"3%1#H$8Eh6iH$ 7B!\7AZ>$.1%b7!>7!C!O7!B8!@77!!@A7EEZ6 UGW>$h6!!Ai>$I310%"#$*%)%1#)H$n1*+,#"#&+$R"%'(,+)$%#$c1)1*1`)$P"0%3"'>$T+3,%+*+.$4,1:$M,%)23%#"b$2330bOOVVV>+)%V+->1,/O RUG>$h6!7Bi>$92+$c1)1*1$91,,+#3$31$UI$\$M+10'+H$,+")1#)$"#.$V"L)>$M,%)23%#" $ Garstka, G. J. (2010). Post-conflict urban planning: The regularization process of an informal neighborhood in Kosova/o. elsevier, Habitat International(34), 86-95. n+2'H$g>$h7ZC8i>$S%4+$J+3V++#$J(%'.%#/)b$I)%#/$M(-'%&$G0"&+$h)%Q32$+.>i>$a+V$d1,<b$W)'"#.$M,+))> n+2'H$g>H$N$T1/+,)H$T>$h6!7@i>$P%3%+)$41,$M+10'+b$W)'"#.$M,+))> n+2'H$g>H$N$G*",,+H$J>$h6!7@i>$_1V$31$G3(.L$M(-'%&$S%4+>$P10+#2"/+#b$W)'"#.$M,+))> n2"#.1(,H$F>$h6!!6i>$J(%'.%#/$")$)1&%"'$0,"&3%)+>$W#$]>$U>$X`T+%''L$hU.>iH$5,&2%3+&3(,"'$+.(&"3%1#$31."L$\$P,1))$&('3(,"'$0+,)0+&3%*+>$S"()"##+b$P1:0",3:+#3)> $ nY%#1''%H$W>$h6!7Bi>$M(-'%&$G0"&+$%#$c1)1*1$\$9,"#)41,:"3%1#$92,1(/2$_%)31,L>$hK1&31,"'iH$n,"e$I#%*+,)%3L$14$9+&2#1'1/LH$n,"e>$$ $ _":.%H$a>$h6!7!i>$92+$M'"&+:"<+,`)$n(%.+$31$J(%'.%#/$P1::(#%3Lb$U",32)&"#> _")%:Y"H$K>$h6!76i>$M,1-'+:)$.(,%#/$32+$W:0'+:+#3"3%1#$14$32+$I,-"#$T+/('"31,L$M'"#)$%#$c1)1*1>$M"0+,$0,+)+#3+.$"3$32+$7)3$W#3+,#"3%1#"'$P1#4+,+#&+$1#$5,&2%3+&3(,+$N$I,-"#$K+)%/#H$5'-"#%">$ 2330bOOVVV>%&"(.>+01<">+.(>"' _1''1V"LH$S>H$N$_(--",.H$M>$h6!!7i>$M+10'+$"#.$M'"&+b$92+$UQ3,"1,.%#",L$n+1/,"02%+)$14$U*+,L."L$S%4+b$M,+#3%&+$_"''> g"&1-)H$5>$J>$h7ZCBi>$n,+"3$G3,++3)b$F%3$M,+))> g"&1-)H$g>$h7ZA7i>$92+$K+"32$"#.$S%4+$14$n,+"3$5:+,%&"#$P%3%+)b$;%#3"/+$J11<)> g":+)H$]>$h6!!@i>$U))"L)$%#$T".%&"'$U:0%,%&%):>$a+V$d1,<b$K1*+,$M(-'%&"3%1#)> g(."2H$9>$h6!!Ci>$c1)1*1b$]2"3$U*+,L1#+$a++.)$31$c#1VTnb$XQ41,.$I#%*+,)%3L$M,+))> Junne, G. (2011) Junne discusses the immediate and long-term challenges of post-conflict situations/Interviewer: NAI. The Good Cause. Junne, G., & Verkoren, W. (2005). Postconflict Development: Meeting New Challenges: Lynne Rienner Publishers. S"#+H$T>$U>$h7ZZEi>$x("'%3L$14$'%4+$"#.$x("'%3L$14$M+,)1#)>$5$#+V$T1'+$41,$/1*+,#:+#3f$M1'%3%&"'$92+1,LH$66hh6iiH$67Z\6B6> $ S1:-",.H$F>$h6!7Ei>$P1#)3,(&3%#/$1,.%#",L$0'"&+)b$0'"&+:"<%#/$%#$(,-"#$%#41,:"'$)+33'+:+#3)$%#$F+Q%&1>$M,1/,+))$%#$M'"##%#/H$ZEH$7\BE>$ S1VH$G>$F>$h6!!!i>$X#$32+$M'"e"b$92+$M1'%3%&)$14$M(-'%&$G0"&+$"#.$P('3(,+b$I#%*+,)%3L$14$9+Q")$M,+))> F"&c+#e%+H$5>$h6!7Ei>$M'"&+:"<%#/$"#.$M'"&+\'+.$K+*+'10:+#3b$5$#+V$M",".%/:$41,$P%3%+)$14$32+$R(3(,+>$M'"&+:"<%#/$T+)1(,&+)>$ F"."#%01(,H$5>$h6!!@i>$M(-'%&$"#.$M,%*"3+$G0"&+)$14$32+$P%3Lb$9"L'1,$N$R,"#&%)> F","#)H$T>$]>$h6!!@i>$I#.+,)3"#.%#/$+#*%,1#:+#3"'$[("'%3L$32,1(/2$[("'%3L$14$'%4+$)3(.%+)b$32+$6!!7$K5G$"#.$%3)$()+$14$)(-Y+&3%*+$"#.$1-Y+&3%*+$%#.%&"31,)>$S"#.)&"0+$"#.$I,-"#$M'"##%#/H$ ABh7r6iH$8@\C@>$ $ F","#)H$T>$]>H$N$G3%:)1#H$T>$h6!77i>$5#$X*+,*%+V$14$x("'%3L$14$I,-"#$S%4+>$W#$]>$T>$F","#)$N$g>T>$G3%:)1#$hU.)>iH$W#*+)3%/"3%#/$x("'%3L$14$I,-"#$S%4+b$92+1,LH$F+321.)H$"#.$U:0%,%&"'$T+)+",&2$ h00>$7\6Zi>$K1,.,+&23b$G0,%#/+,$a+32+,'"#.)> F",&()H$P>$P>H$N$R,"#&%)H$P>$h7ZZ!i>$M+10'+$0'"&+)b$.+)%/#$/(%.+'%#+)$41,$(,-"#$10+#$)0"&+b$;"#$a1)3,"#.$T+%#21'.> F")'1VH$5>$_>$h7ZE@i>$5$32+1,L$14$2(:"#$:13%*"3%1#>$M2L&21'1/%&"'$T+*%+VH$B!hhEiiH$@8!\@ZA>$
76E
F1#3/1:+,LH$P>$h6!7@i>$_"00L$P%3Lb$9,"#)41,:%#/$X(,$S%*+)$92,1(/2$I,-"#$K+)%/#b$K1(-'+."L$P"#"."> F(''%/"#H$n>H$P",,(32+,)H$g>H$N$P"2%''H$F>$h6!!Ei>$I,-"#$x("'%3L$14$S%4+$"#.$M(-'%&$M1'%&Lb$5$G(,*+L$P1#3,%-(3%1#)$31$U&1#1:%&$5#"'L)%)$h;1'>$;1'(:+$6AAH$00>$86Z\C!6ib$U')+*%+,> F(:41,.H$S>$h7Z@Ci>$92+$&('3(,+$14$&%3%+)b$_",&1(,3H$J,"&+$"#.$&1:0"#L>$ a"3%1#)H$I>$h6!7Bi>$G()3"%#"-'+$K+*+'10:+#3$n1"')>$T+3,%+*+.$4,1:$2330)bOO)()3"%#"-'+.+*+'10:+#3>(#>1,/O a())-"(:H$F>$h7ZZ@i>$a1#$,+'"3%*+$*%,3(+)b$5#$5,%)313+'%"#$500,1"&2>$W#$F>$G>$a())-"(:H$5>$hU.>iH$92+$[("'%3L$14$'%4+$h00>$E6\6AZi>$_+')%#<%b$I#%3+.$a"3%1#)$I#%*+,)%3L> MMG>$h6!!!i>$_1V$31$3(,#$0'"&+)$",1(#.>$a+V$d1,<b$M,1Y+&3$41,$M(-'%&$G0"&+)$W#&> M('"H$J>$h6!7@i>$K%))+&3%#/$M,%)23%#">$92+$&"03%3"'$%)$"$&%3L$-L$#":+$-(3$"$e1:-%+$%#$)0%,%3>$c1)1*1$6>!H$M(-'%&$G0"&+H$BB\A8> T+'02H$U>$h7Z8Ai>$M'"&+$"#.$0'"&+'+))#+))b$M%1#> TL"#H$T>H$N$K+&%H$U>$h6!!7i>$X#$_"00%#+))$"#.$_(:"#$M13+#3%"')b$5$T+*%+V$14$T+)+",&2$1#$_+.1#%&$"#.$U(."%:1#%&$]+''\J+%#/>$5##("'$T+*%+V$14$M)L&21'1/LH$B6h7iH$7E7\7AA>$.1%b.1%b7!>77EAO "##(,+*>0)L&2>B6>7>7E7 G&2#++<'132H$S>$_>H$N$G2%-'+LH$T>$n>$h7ZZBi>$M'"&+:"<%#/b$32+$",3$"#.$0,"&3%&+$14$-(%'.%#/$&1::(#%3%+)b$]%'+L> G+##+33H$T>$h7Z88i>$92+$R"''$14$M(-'%&$F"#b$P":-,%./+$I#%*+,)%3L$M,+))> G%33+H$P>$h7CCZi>$K+,$G3w.3+-"($#"&2$)+%#+#$<{#)3'+,%)&2+#$n,(#.)w3e+#b$T"#.1:$_1()+> M,1Y+&3$41,$M(-'%&$G0"&+)$h6!7Bi>$I,-"#$K+)%/#$"#.$M'"&+:"<%#/>$W#$T>$9>$S+n"3+)$N$R>$G31(3$hU.)>iH$92+$P%3L$T+".+,$h00>$BB7\AE7ib$9"L'1,$N$R,"#&%)> G3"#%'1*H$c>$h6!!8i>$92+$M1)3\G1&%"'%)3$P%3L>$I,-"#$R1,:$"#.$G0"&+$9,"#)41,:"3%1#)$%#$P+#3,"'$"#.$U")3+,#$U(,10+$"43+,$G1&%"'%):>$K1,.,+&23b$G0,%#/+,$a+32+,'"#.)> Suri, S. N. (2015). In-conflict/Post-Conflict: A role for planning in building peaceful, inclusive and resilient cities? Retrieved from http://isocarp.org/post-conflict-planning-inclusive-resilient-cities/ "&&+)$."3+b$7B\76\6!7B 9%--"'.)H$R>$h6!!6i>$F"<%#/$M+10'+\R,%+#.'L$91V#)b$W:0,1*%#/$32+$M(-'%&$U#*%,1#:+#3$%#$91V#)$"#.$P%3%+)b$9"L'1,$N$R,"#&%)> Ia\_5JW959>$h6!77i>$9(,#%#/$G0"&+)$%#31$M'"&+)>$M,%)23%#"H$,+3,%+*+.$4,1:b$2330bOOVVV>(#2"-%3"3\<1)1*1>1,/$ Ia\_5JW959>$h6!7@i>$G3,++3)$")$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$.,%*+,)$14$(,-"#$0,1)0+,%3L>$a"%,1-%H$,+3,%+*+.$4,1:b$2330bOOVVV>(#2"-%3"3>1,/ Ia\_5JW959>$h6!7Ei>$F(#%&%0"'$G0"3%"'$M'"##%#/$G(001,3$M,1/,"::+$%#$c1)1*1$hF(GMMi>$M,%)23%#"H$,+3,%+*+.$4,1:b$2330bOOVVV>(#2"-%3"3\<1)1*1>1,/ IaKM>$h6!7Bi>$G()3"%#"-'+$K+*+'10:+#3$n1"')>$T+3,%+*+.$4,1:b$2330bOOVVV>(#.0>1,/O)()3"%#"-'+.+*+'10:+#3/1"')6!7B $ ;++#21*+#H$T>$h6!!!i>$92+$41(,$x("'%3%+)$14$'%4+b$X,.+,%#/$&1#&+03)$"#.$F+")(,+)$14$32+$/11.$'%4+>$g1(,#"'$14$_"00%#+))$G3(.%+)H$7hh7iiH$7\@Z>$ ;++#21*+#H$T>$h6!!@i>$_+.1#%):$"#.$_"00%#+))>$g1(,#"'$14$_"00%#+))$G3(.%+)H$EhEiH$E@8\EB8> ;p&<'+,H$c>$h6!!Ci>$M,%)23%#"$%)$U*+,LV2+,+b$9(,-1$I,-"#%):$b$32+$543+,:"32$14$"$P,%)%)b$5,&2%)>$J+,'%# ]_X>$h6!7Ai>$n'1-"'$_+"'32$X-)+,*"31,L$hn_Xi$."3">$I,-"#$M10('"3%1#$n,1V32>$T+3,%+*+.$4,1:$2330bOOVVV>V21>%#3O/21O(,-"#|2+"'32O)%3("3%1#|3,+#.)O(,-"#|010('"3%1#|/,1V32|3+Q3O+# ]2L3+H$]>$_>$h7ZC!"i>$92+$G1&%"'$S%4+$14$G:"''$I,-"#$G0"&+)b$P1#)+,*"3%1#$R1(#."3%1#> ]2L3+H$]>$_>$h7ZC!-i>$92+$)1&%"'$'%4+$14$):"''$(,-"#$)0"&+)$};%.+1~>$IG> ]11.)H$S>$h7ZZ8i>$T".%&"'$,+&1#)3,(&3%1#>$5,&2%3+&3(,"'$M,+))>$ ]1,'.J"#<>$h6!!!\6!7Ei>$c1)1*1$K+*+'10:+#3>$$T+3,%+*+.$g"#(",L$CH$6!7A$2330bOOVVV>V1,'.-"#<>1,/O ]1,'.J"#<>$h6!7Bi>$M(-'%&$)0"&+)$\$#13$"$j#%&+$31$2"*+k$-(3$"$-")%&$#++.$41,$&%3%+)>$,+3,%+*+.$g"#(",L$CH$6!7A$2330bOOVVV>V1,'.-"#<>1,/O-'1/) Figures Interviews K(<"/Y%#$J"<%Y"H$M2.$&"#.%."3+$F"))"&2()+33)$W#)3%3(3+$14$9+&2#1'1/Lb$7B$G+03+:-+,$6!7BH$K+'43|J1)31#$\G<L0+ G".%Y+$c+':+#.%H$Ia\_"-%3"3$c1)1*1H$(,-"#$0'"##+,b$B$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$'1&"'$&144++21()+H$M,%)23%#" Rudina Qerimi, Pro Planning, Kosovo Center for Urban Research: 6 November 2015, local office, Pristhina Lumnije Gashi, Pro Planning, Kosovo Center for Urban Research: 6 November 2015, local office, Pristhina Drita Nushi, Pro Planning, Kosovo Center for Urban Research: 6 November 2015, local office, Pristhina ;Y1''"$P"<"H$G3(.+#3$5,&2%3+&3(,+H$M,%)23%#"$I#%*+,)%3Lb$8$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$",1(#.$M,%)23%#" M,144>$R'1,%#"$g+,'%(H$I#%*+,)%3L$14$M,%)23%#"$O$5,&2%)$W#3+,*+#3%1#)H$anXb$Z$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$I#%*+,)%3L$14$M,%)23%#"H$M,%)23%#" n+",."$K+:%,"YH$F(#%&%0"'%3L$14$M,%)23%#"H$I,-"#$M'"##%#/$.+0",3:+#3b$Z$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$F(#%&%0"'%3L$-(%'.%#/H$M,%)23%#" S("#$a()2%H$M'"##%#/$.%,+&31,H$W#)3%3(3+$14$G0"3%"'$M'"##%#/b$Z$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$n1*+,#"#&+$J(%'.%#/H$M,%)23%#" J+<%:$T":<(H$5,&2%3+&3H$c1)1*1$5,&2%3+&3(,+$R1(#."3%1#b$78$R+-,(",%$6!7AH$S1&"'$&144++21()+H$M,%)23%#" U'%e"$_1Q2"H$I,-"#$M'"##+,H$I#%*+,)%3L$14$M,%)23%#"b$78$g(#+$6!7AH$S1&"'$P144++21()+H$M,%)23%#"
76B
RFG'B::*18,&*+
APPENDIX 1 Interviews with local based professionals and academics
Proff. Florina Jerliu University of Prishtina Archis Interventions, NGO $
$
$
$
Z$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$M,%)23%#"
-72.)8/|$$P%3%+)$%#$.+$J"'<"#)$",+$&%3%+)$%#$3,"#)%3%1#$"#.$3,"#)%3%1#$ %)$32+%,$)3"3+$14$",3$h2%/2+)3$'+*+'$14$.+*+'10:+#3i>$W#$32+$0+,%1.$14$ A!$L+",)$32+,+$2")$"'V"L)$-++#$3,"#)%3%1#$/1%#/$1#>$92+,+$V")$#1$ )3+".L$.+*+'10:+#3$32"3$&1('.$/,1VH$"3$'+")3$41,$6$/+#+,"3%1#)$%#$ "$,1VH$31$,113$%#$32"3$0+,%1.>$_"00L$&%3%+)H$32"3$%)$V2"3$32+$J"'<"#$ &%3%+)$",+H$32+,+$#13$-1,+.$-(3$%#$3,"#)%3%1#>$ Interviewer_ Compared this place to a place that is in conflict out\ )%.+$32+$J"'<"#$V2"3$V1('.$-+$32+$.%44+,+#&+$V%32$M,%)3%#"f$ -72.)8/|$$W3$%)$"$&('3(,"'$.%44+,+#&+H$#13$%#$3+,:)$",&2%3+&3(,"'$14$)0"\ 3%"'$&2","&3+,%)3%&)$-(3$%#$32+$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#H$#13$32+$01'%3%&"'$")\ 0+&3>$W3$%)$()("''L$32+$0$\1'%3%&)$14$V",$32"3$%)$32+$)":+$,+/",.'+))$14$ V2"3$32+$1(3&1:+$"#.$32+$%.+"$-+2%#.$%3$%)>$W$32%#<$%3$.+0+#.)$1#$ 32+$&('3(,+$14$32+$0+10'+H$32"3$)1&%"'$.%:+#)%1#$"#.$.+0+#.)$1#$ 21V$32"3$0",3$14$&%3%e+#)$",+$"-'+$"#.$&"0"-'+$31$,+&"'%-,"3+$"43+,$ 32+$ V",>$ c1)1*1$ "#.$ -+&"()+$ M,%)23%#"$ %#$ 32+$ J"'<"#)$ %)$ "$ &%3L$ %#$ 3,"#)%3%1#$)%#&+$"$'1#/$3%:+$%3$2")$#1$0,1-'+:)$31$,+&"'%-,"3+H$"#.$ 32%)$2"00+#)$%#$'+3$)"L$@$."L)$"43+,$32+$V",> ]+$",+$2"00L$+*+#$%4$V+$2"*+$%''+/"'$-(%'.%#/)$",1(#.$-+&"()+$V+$ find places of complement. Content and aesthetics are not binary 31$"$2"00L$&%3L$'%4+>$921)+$",+$#13$#+&+))",%'L$#++.+.$31/+32+,H$31$ 2"*+$"$2"00L$'%4+$V%32%#$32+$&%3L>$5+)32+3%&)$.1$#13$)"3%)4L$32+$+#3%,+$ V+''\-+%#/> Interviewer_ Can the urban environment be of influence on the V+''\-+%#/$14$32+$M,%)23%#"$&%3%e+#)f -72.)8/_ It can definitely be. Letâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s start from the little things. The 0",<)$ "#.$ 0(-'%&$ /,++#$ V%32%#$ 32+$ &%3L>$ 92%)$ &2"#/+.$ ,+&+#3'L$ 31\ V",.)$ "$ -+33+,$ )%3("3%1#>$ W3$ %)$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ 0'"##%#/$ 0,1&+))$ #1V>$ G1$ %#$ /+#+,"'$ 32+)+$ "+)32+3%&$ +'+:+#3)H$ 32+)+$ '%33'+$ +'+:+#3)$ &"#$ :"<+$0+10'+$2"00%+,$-(3$V%''$%3$:"<+$"$&%3L$2"00%+,$")$"$V21'+f$ X#+$32%#/$%)$32"3$#1$V",$41,$32+$(0&1:%#/$.+&".+)$V%''$-+$/11.$ for the city. A time towards more stability. The adjustment of firstly (,/+#3$"#.$%::+.%"3+$#++.)$14$(,-"#$)3,(&3(,+)$"#.$"+)32+3%&)$14$ 32+$-(%'.%#/)>$F"L-+$%#$32+$4(3(,+$32+$".Y()3:+#3$14$(,-"#$3,".%\ 3%1#)H$ #13$ %#4,")3,(&3(,"'$ -(3$ "+)32+3%&)H$ 21V$ -(%'.%#/)$ ",+$ -+%#/$ 0'"##+.$+3&>$S%33'+$:1.+')$",+$)21V%#/$32"3$'1&"'$0+10'+$",+$.1%#/$ V+''$ -L$ '11<%#/$ "3$ 32+$ '%33'+$ 0'"&+)H$ 32+$ &144++21()+)H$ 32+$ -11<\ )210)H$32+$.%44+,+#3$V1,'.$32"3$/1+)$V%32$%3$-+2%#.$32+$V"'')>$92%)$%)$ "$*+,L$L1(#/$/+#+,"3%1#$32"3$%)$0'"&%#/$32+:$)+'4`)$32+,+>$M+,2"0)$ 32+$L1(32$%)$#13$,+"''L$'%<%#/$V2"3$%)$2"00+#%#/$1(3)%.+$"#.$",+$#13$ satisfied in how their outside world looks like. It is designed to suit 32+$ L1(#/+,>$ ]2"3$ "-1(3$ 32+$ 132+,$ /+#+,"3%1#)H$ %3$ %)$ 32+$ 1(3)%.+$ 32"3$V+$2"*+$31$32%#<$"-1(3f Interviewer|$]2"3$%)$5,&2%)$W#3+,*+#3%1#)$.1%#/$#1Vf$ -72.)8/|$G1&%"'$&"0"-%'%3LH$"(.%3H$%))(+)H$&%3%+)$%#$3,"#)%3%1#H$21V$32+$ 0,1&+))$%)$/1%#/H$%3$%)$#1V$0",3$14$32+$#"3%1#"'$'"VH$32+$)1&%"'$&1:\ 01#+#3)$ %)$ 0",3$ #1V$ 31$ -+$ 3"&<'+.$ ,+)01#)%-%'%3L$ 14$ &%3%e+#)>$ a13$ 32"3$2+"*%'L$%#*1'*+.$"#L:1,+>$F1)3$14$32+%,$"%:$%)$.1#+>$92+$)1&%"'$ &1:01#+#3$14$&%3%+)$#1V$2")$31$-+$3"<+#$&",+$14>$92+$,+)01#)%-%'%3L$ 14$&%3%e+#)$31V",.)$0'"##%#/>$
Interviewer|$]2"3$%)$32+$0+,&+03%1#$1#$0'"##%#/$"#.$V2"3$2"0\ 0+#+.$%#$32+$0")3$(#3%'$0,+)+#3$."Lf$ -72.)8/|$$W3$%)$/+33%#/$-+33+,$-(3$32%)$3"<+)$3%:+>$P1:0,+2+#)%1#$ 14$ 32+$ 0'"##%#/$ )L)3+:$ %)$ /,1V%#/H$ V2%&2$ %)$ "$ /11.$ 32%#/>$ K(+$ 31$ 32+$ 4"&3$ 32"3$ c1)1*1$ 2")$ -++#$ %#$ &1#3%#(1()$ 3,"#)%3%1#H$ 4,1:$ G1&%"'%)3$ )3"3+H$ G+,-%"#$ K%&3"31,)2%0$ V%32$ F%'1)+*%&$ 31$ T(/1%):$ which brought democracy. Since 1945 and 1974, difficult periods 14$3,"#)%3%1#$.%.$0(3$0,+))(,+$1#$c1)1*1>$92+)+$@$4"&+)$14$3,"#)%\ 3%1#$#+*+,$"'1(.$41,$,+&1*+,L$1#$32+$)1&%"'$"#.$(,-"#$'+*+'>$]2"3$ 2"00+#+.$ V%32$ 32+$ 02L)%&"'$ )3"3+$ %)$ #13$ )"L%#/$ 32"3$ :(&2H$ V2"3$ V")$-(%'.$%#$d(/1)'"*%"$%#$c1)1*1$V")$*+,L$4,"/:+#3+.$"#.$#13$ ,+'"3+.$1,$&1#&+,#+.$V%32$32+$&1#3+Q3>$F1.+,#$",&2%3+&3(,+$"#.$ (,-"#$0'"##%#/$V")$#13$"'V"L)$*+,L$&1#&+,#+.$V%32$32+$&1#3+Q3>$ Urban blocks were not finished as it happened elsewhere, only the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e+#)$ 31."Lf$ ]"3+,H$ )+V"/+H$ +'+&3,%&%3LH$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+$ "#.$"$'"&<$14$:1#+L$31$&,+"3+$32+)+$:%))%#/$+'+:+#3)>$92+)+$%)\ )(+)$)21('.$-+$)3%''$1#$32+$310$14$32+$31$.1$'%)3$14$32+$/1*+,#:+#3>$ This, with care for the city. Utilize these places first in order for the :"Y1,%3L$31$2"*+$"&&+))>$W#$32%)$3%:+$"43+,$32+$V",$32+$&+#3+,$-+\ &":+$.+#)+,>$92%)$-+&"()+$32+$4(,32+,$"V"L$32+$'%:%3+.$"&&+))$31$ 4"&%'%3%+)>$92+,+$V")$#1$(,-"#$:"#"/+:+#3H$32+$'"&<%#/$&1#.%3%1#)$ "#.$32+$(#.+,)3"#.%#/$14$(,-"#$0'"##%#/$-L$32+$0(-'%&$:".+$32+$ situation very difficult. Little by little, first quantity then more qua\ '%3L$%)$&1:%#/>$W3$%)$32"3$#+V$/+#+,"3%1#)$32"3$V%''$32%#<$14$32+$0(-'%&$ /11.>$J(3$32+$#+V$/+#+,"3%1#)$#++.$"$&1::1#$)+#)+>$92+$1#+$ V21$.1#`3$,+:+:-+,$32+$0")3$V%''$-+$32%#<%#/$14$32+$0(-'%&$/11.> Interviewer|$]2"3$".*%&+$V1('.$L1($/%*+$%#$1,.+,$31$2%3$32+$+)\ )+#&+$14$32+$0,1-'+:$"#.$&2"''+#/+)$%#$"$0,1Y+&3f -72.)8/|$ G++$ 32+$ )%3+$ 4,1:$ "$ 0+,)1#"'$ 0+,&+03%1#>$ P2+&<$ )"3%)\ 4"&3%1#$'+*+')$14$32+$'1&"'$)1&%+3L$"#.$V1,<)$14$anX`)>$]2"3$",+$ 41,$+Q":0'+$32+$0,1:%)+)$14$32+$:"Y1,$"#.$32+$&2+&<$(0$"43+,$A$ :1#32)$"-1(3$'1&"'$)"3%)4"&3%1#>$M,1*%)%1#$14$0(-'%&$)+,*%&+)$%)$#13$ #+&+))",%'L$01'%3%&"'$+'+:+#3$1#'L>$n1$1(3$31$2"*+$"$3"'<$31$0+10'+$ "#.$-+$10+#$31$"$*",%+3L$14$)"3%)4"&3%1#$"#.$32+$0",3$%#$-+3V++#>$ Eventually freezing to death is energy efficient too and running water for 24h ad day is also happiness. Make a stratification of a )1,3$14$*('#+,"-%'%3L$:"0$"-1(3$)1&%"'$%#&'()%1#$"#.$)1&%"'$0",3%&%\ 0"3%1#>$921)+$0",3)$&"#$'+3$L1($,+&,+"3+$1,$".Y()3$31$32+$[("'%3L$14$ V2"3$L1($"..$%#$3+,:)$14$)"3%)4"&3%1#>$U*+,L32%#/$%)$1&&(0%+.$-L$ &",)$1,$)1:+32%#/$+')+$)1$&2%'.,+#$2"*+$#1$32%#/$31$.1$1,$0'"&+$ to play in the neighborhood. How you appreciate life is the first "#.$32+#$32+$)(,,1(#.%#/$"#.$V2+,+$L1($V"#3$31$/1>$R,++.1:$%)$ 32+,+H$-(3$V2"3$2"00+#)$"43+,f$]2"3$%)$%:01,3"#3$"43+,f
76C
U*+,L32%#/$2")$-++#$,+&+#3$.+*+'10:+#3)>$]2"3$V%''$2"00+#$%4$V+$ ,+:"%#$4,++$%)$#13$+*+#$"#$%))(+$"#L:1,+H$-(3$V2"3$%)$#+Q3$32+#f$W4$ V+$#13$,+/,+))H$%3$)21('.$0,1/,+))$'%<+$-")%&$#++.)$14$&1::1#$'%4+$ -(3$"43+,$32"3f$T+/",.'+))$14$V2"3$%3$:+"#)$31$32+$,+)3$14$32+$V1,'.H$ V2+#$#1$V",$&1:+)$"/"%#$/'1-"'%e"3%1#$"#.$32+$:",<+3$+&1#1:L$ V%''$ 2%3$ c1)1*1$ 311>$ W4$ 32+$ 4,++$ :",<+3$ +&1#1:L$ :",/%#"'%e+)$ 32+$ :"Y1,%3L$ 32+#$ 32%)$ V%''$ 2"*+$ "44+&3$ 1#$ c1)1*1$ V%321(3$ .1(-3>$ 92+$ +&1#1:L$%)$%:01,3"#3>$W#$c1)1*1$32+,+$%)$#1$0,1.(&3%1#H$#132%#/$ %)$0,1.(&+.$%#$c1)1*1H$%3$2")$"'V"L)$-++#$)+3$%#$32+$-%//+,$&2"%#$ 14$ 0,1.(&3%1#>$ F(&2$ 14$ 321)+$ 0'"&+)$ ",+$ #13$ ()+.$ "#L:1,+$ "#.$ 2"*+$ #1$ 4(#&3%1#$ "3$ 32+$ :1:+#3>$ 5$ '%:%3+.$ ":1(#3$ 14$ '1&"'$ 0,1\ .(&3)$%)$0,1.(&+.$%#$):"''$)+33%#/)>$J(3$+*+#3("''L$32+$)L)3+:$.1+)$ #13$&",+$"-1(3$32+$)1&%+3L`)$-"e",H$):"''$-()%#+))+)$"#.$&1::(#%3L$ -()%#+))+)$V2%&2$:+"#)$"$'13$14$)+'4\,+/('"3%1#$"#.$-+%#/$%#41,:"'$ +'+:+#3$ 14$ +&1#1:L>$ 92%)$ %)$ 0",3$ 14$ 32+$ &('3(,+$ 14$ 32+$ )1&%+3LH$ "$ '1&"'$[("'%3Lf Interviewer|$]2"3$%)$32+$%:"/+$14$32+$M,%)32%#"$P%3Lf -72.)8/|$ 92+$01'%3%&"'$-1,.+,$%)$10+#$#1V$"#.$32+#$%3$V%''$&1:+H$ 32+$ &1##+&3%1#)$ V%''$ /,1V$ V2%&2$ V%''$ 2+'0$ 32+$ %:"/+$ 14$ M,%)32%#"$ "#.$c1)1*1$")$"$V21'+>$a1V$32+$%.+#3%3L$%)$32+$0,1-'+:>$92+,+$%)$ #1$4113-"''$3+":H$V+$0'"L$41,$5'-"#%">$]+$#++.$"$&'+"#$%.+#3%3L$14$ V21$V+$",+H$"$)3L'+>$a+*+,32+'+))H$M,%)23%#"$2")$"$)1,3$14$&1):101\
'%3"#$%.+#3%3L$-(3$32"3$%)$#13$)%:%'",$31$32+$,+)3$14$c1)1*1>$5#$:1,+$ 10+#$"#.$%#3+/,"3+.$"00,1"&2$32"3$)++)$"#.$32%#<)$"-1(3$32+$&%3L$ 32,1(/2$ 32+$ +L+)$ 14$ 32+$ &%3%e+#)$ %)$ #++.+.>$ X0+#$ &1:0+3%3%1#)H$ +Q2%-%3%1#)$ +*+#$ %4$ %3$ %)$ 1#'L$ 41,$ 32+$ )"<+$ 14$ "V",+#+))$ 14$ V2"3$ %)$ /1%#/>$ 92%)$ &"#$ 10+#$ (0$ 32+$ )L)3+:>$ W3$ )21('.$ -+$ 10+#$ 41,$ "$ *",%+3L$14$)1'(3%1#)$%#)3+".$%3$%)$*+,L$)3,"%/2341,V",.$"#.$.+0+#\ .%#/$ 1#$ 01'%&%+)$ 32"3$ ",+$ 0(,+'L$ 01'%3%&"'>$ R1,$ "$ '1#/$ 3%:+$ c1)1\ *",$2"*+$-++#$'%*%#/$1#$32+$:",/%#)H$'%*%#/$1#$32+$+./+)H$)1&%"''LH$ )0"3%"''LH$01'%3%&"''LH$V2%&2$2")$31$-+$&1#)1'%."3+.>$a+V$-1,.+,)H$ )L)3+:)H$#+3V1,<)$"#.$32%#<%#/$%#$32+:"3%&$0'"##%#/$"#.$:('3%'"L\ +,+.$"00,1"&2+)>$9"'<$%#$#+3V1,<)$"#.$3,"#)41,:$32+:$%#$)0"3%"'$ 0'"#)H$"3$32+$:1:+#3$%3$.+0+#.)$"$'13$1#$32+$'",/+,$)&"'+$V2"3$V%''$ 2"00+#$ %#$ 32+$ 4(3(,+$ V%32$ c1)1*1>$ a13$ #+&+))",%'L$ 32+$ &+#3+,$ %)$ :1,+$V"#3+.$32+#$32+$0+,%02+,L$V2+#$,+&"'%-,"3+.$#+V$-1,.+,)H$ #+3V1,<)$"#.$)L)3+:)$",+$:".+>$a+V$%.+")$)21('.$-+$+*"'("3+.$ "#.$3+)3+.$"-1(3$32+$4(3(,+H$32+$)3"/+$14$(3%'%e%#/$+*+,L32%#/>$J(3$ #+V$)3,(&3(,+)$",+$)<+03%&"'>$n+3$,%.$14$32+$)3(0%.$0'"#)H$-+&"()+$ 32+$0,1-'+:$V")$#13$32+$(#,+/('"3+.$.+*+'10:+#3$-(3$32+$011,$ plans and unfinished level of planning. Take care of minimum )3"#.",.)H$"-1(3$)(#'%/23$V2+#$.+*+'10%#/$1#$1#+$)%.+$-(3$"3$32+$ )":+$3%:+$V+$V"#3$31$<++0$32+$1'.$)3,++3)$"#.$(,-"#$3%))(+$14$32+$ &%3L>$5$#++.$41,$"."03"3%1#$14$32+$'"V$1#$'"#.$%)$%#$1,.+,>$U*+#3(\ "''L$%3$%)$#1,:"'$31$/,1V$+*+#$"3$32+$):"''$'+*+'>$W3$"''$.+0+#.)$1#$ 32+$&('3(,+)>
Dukagjin Bakija Phd candidate Massachusetts Institute of Technology $
7B$G+03+:-+,$6!7BH$K+'43|J1)31#$\G<L0+
",1(#.$%3$V")$41&()%#/$1#$V2"3$32+L$&"''$%3$2%/2+,$0,%1,%3L$%))(+)H$ '%<+$")02"'3H$0,1*%.+$"&&+))H$+:0'1L:+#3H$"33,"&3%#/$-()%#+))H$%#\ Dukagijn|$ $ 53$ &+#3,"'$ )3"3+$ '+*+'$ 32+,+$ %)$ 32+$ F%#%)3,L$ 14$ +#*%,1#\ *+)3:+#3H$"#.$32"3$V")$32+%,$+Q&()+>$J(%'.$V2"3+*+,$L1($V"#3$V%32$ :+#3$"#.$0'"##%#/$V%32$%3`)$%:0'+:+#3%#/$W#)3%3(3+$14$)0"3%"'$0'"#\ L1(,$'"#.$"#.$21V$4,1:$2%/2\,%)+$"#.$'1V\,%)+$31$4,1#3$14$32+$0'13$ #%#/>$ 92+$ &+#3,"'$ '+*+'$ 0'"##%#/$ %)$ &1*+,%#/$ :"#L$ +'+:+#3)$ '%<+$ 1,$&+#3,"'$%#$32+$0'13>$ +&1#1:LH$ .+*+'10:+#3H$ 31(,%):$ +3&>$ J+3V++#$ 32%)$ '+*+'$ "#.$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'$'+*+'$32+,+$%)$#1$%#3+,:+.%"3+$)3+0$1#$,+/%1#"'$'+*+'>$92+$ P1:0'+3+$ &2"1)$ V%32$ #1$ ,+/('"3%1#)$ (#3%'$ 6!7!$ V")$ 32+$ ,+)('3>$ '1&"'$'+*+'$,+0,+)+#3)$"$:(#%&%0"'$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$41,$(,-"#$"#.$ 92+,+$V")$"$&1#)3"#3$32,1V%#/$-"&<$"#.$41,32$"-1(3$32+$,+)01#\ rural parts. The plans are not very specific and clear. The urban )%-%'%3L$-+3V++#$'1&"'$"#.$&+#3,"'$/1*+,#:+#3>$92+,+$V+,+$)+*+,"'$ .+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$%#.%&"3+)$32+$)3,"3+/%+)$V%32%#$32+$(,-"#$-1(#\ "33+:03)$31$)310$32+$%#41,:"'$-(%'.%#/)$-+%#/$-(%'.H$32+L$.%.$,+\ .",%+)$"#.$",+$)+0","3+.$%#$):"''+,$,+/('",$0'"#)$41,$+"&2$#+%/2\ &1,.%#/$4,1:$"%,H$"#.$:".+$"$'%#+$4,1:$#1V$1#$L1($&"##13$-(%'.$ -1(,211.>$92"3$(,-"#$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$2")$-++#$,+0'"&+.$-L$32+$ "#L$4(,32+,$%''+/"''L$-+&"()+$%3$V%''$#13$-+$'+/"'%)+.>$_1V+*+,H$32"3$ 5:+,%&"#$e1#%#/$:"0$"43+,$32+$6!76$#+V$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$'"V>$5$ V")$#+*+,$%:01)+.$"#.$:1,+$,+&+#3'L$%#$6!7B$V+$2"*+$"$'"V$'+\ #+V$)L)3+:$"#.$0'"#)$",+$)3%''$(#.+,$&1#)3,(&3%1#$V2%&2$:"<+)$32+$ /"'%)"3%1#H$V2%&2$%)$"$&+#3,"'$'+*+'$%#%3%"3%*+$%#3+/,"3%#/$+*+,L32%#/$ 32"3$V")$-(%'.$V%32%#$32+$'+/"'$)L)3+:$14$c1)1*1$)1$31$:"<+$32+$ process of development very inefficient these days. %#41,:"'$ 41,:"'>$ _1V+*+,H$ V%32$ )1:+$ -")%&$ &1#.%3%1#)>$ 92+$ 1#'L$ Interviewer_ Informal development happend after the conflict, &1#.%3%1#)$32+L$:".+$V+,+b$L1($2"*+$31$-(%'.$%#$L1(,$1V#$'"#.$ 21V$.%.$32%)$0,1&+))$V1,<f$ "#.$%4$%3$%)$"$0(-'%&$'"#.$L1($2"*+$31$'+/"'%)+$%3H$V2%&2$%)$2",.+,>$W4$ L1($2"*+$"$0,%*"3+$'"#.$32+#$32+$&2"#/+)$",+$*+,L$/11.$31$/+3$%3$ Dukagijn|$$]+$V+,+$0",3$14$G+,-%"$"#.$d(/1)'"*%"$(#3%'$7ZZZH$"43+,$ '+/"'%)+.$*+,L$+")%'L>$ 32"3$c1)1*1$-+&":+$0",3$14$32+$I#%3+.$a"3%1#)$".:%#%)3,"3%1#>$92+$ &1(#3,L$ V")$ 3%,+.$ "#.$ .1#+$ V%32$ "''$ 32+$ '+/%)'"3%1#$ 14$ G+,-%"$ "#.$ 92"3$V")$32+$)%3("3%1#$(0$31$#1V$"#.$#1V$%#$:"Y1,$&%3%+)$'%<+$M,%)2\ d(/1)'"*%"$ "#.$ V"#3+.$ "$ 4,+)2$ )3",3>$ c1)1*1$ +#3+,+.$ V%32$ #1$ '+\ 3%#"$V+$2"*+$)3,1#/$'1&"'$/1*+,#:+#3$"#.$32+L$2"*+$:"#"/+.$31$ gislation in 1999. The United Nations came and the first thing they /+3$ %3$ (#.+,$ &1#3,1'$ "#.$ %#41,:"'$ -(%'.%#/)$ -(%'.$ 2"*+$ )3100+.$ )3",3+.$ V")$ .,"V%#/$ '+/%)'"3%1#H$ 21V$ 31$ :"<+$ %#)3%3(3%1#)H$ V2"3$ )%#&+$)%Q$:1#32)>$92+$&1#&+,#$V")$32"3$%3$'+.$"':1)3$31$)1&%"'$(#\ <%#.$14$'"V)$",+$#++.+.>$ ,+)3$-L$32+$0+10'+$32"3$V1,<+.$%#$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$-()%#+))$-+\ &"()+$32+L$V+,+$"&&1::1."3%#/$'1&"'$4":%'%+)$-L$V1,<%#/$%#$32+$ W#$6!!@$c1)1*1$2".$"$'"V$1#$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$-+&"()+$%3$2".$0,%\ &1#)3,(&3%1#$)+&31,>$]2+,+$.1$L1($.,"V$32+$'%#+H$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$ 1,%3L$.(+$31$32+$'",/+$:%/,"3%1#$4,1:$,(,"'$31$(,-"#$",+")H$"$'13$14$ .+*+'10:+#3H$V2+#$1#$32+$1#+$2"#.$L1($:"<+$0+10'+$011,$"#.$ :1*+:+#3)$%#$32+$01)3$V",>$92+$010('"3%1#$:1*+:+#3)$V+,+$"$,+\ 1#$32+$132+,$2"#.$L1($V"#3$31$&1#3,1'$%3f$ )('3$14$'"&<$14$%#4,")3,(&3(,+$1,$)+V"/+$%#$32+$,(,"'$",+")$"#.$'%:%3+.$ :1-%'%3L>$G1$0+10'+$.+&%.+.$31$:1*+$31$(,-"#$",+")> What you find in the policy documents and in different materials, 92+,+$V+,+$#13$+#1(/2$21()+)$31$"&&1::1."3+$"''$32+)+$0+10\ )21V)$32"3$32+$%:0'+:+#3"3%1#$14$32+$'+/%)'"3%1#$2")$)(44+,+.$"#.$ '+H$)1$0+10'+$)3",3+.$31$-(%'.$%#41,:"''L$"#.$V2+,+*+,$32+L$&1('.$ W$-'":+$:1)3$32+$"-)+#&+$14$2"*%#/$32+$%#)3,(:+#3)$%#$0'"&+$31$ -(%'.>$92"3$&1#3%#(1()$"3$32+$:1:+#3$-(3$%#$"$'+))+,$.":"/%#/$.+\ +#)(,+$32+$%:0'+:+#3"3%1#>$d1($&1('.$#13$.1$"#L32%#/$V,1#/$%4$ /,++>$JL$6!!@$V+$2".$"$'"V$1#$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$32"3$/"*+$32+$'1&"'$ L1($V+,+$#13$41''1V%#/$32+$'"VH$%:01,3"#3$0+10'+$&1('.$.1$V2"\ /1*+,#:+#3$32+$"(321,%3L$31$&1#3,1'$32+$.+*+'10:+#3)$%#$32+$",+"> 3+*+,b$%/#1,%#/$32+$'+/%)'"3%1#> _1V+*+,H$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 0,1&+))$ V")$ )3%''$ ,%)%#/$ (#3%'$ 6!7!>$ W3$ V")$ )(0+,$ 0,1-'+:"3%&H$ 32+$ '1&"'$ /1*+,#:+#3$ "#.$ "''$ 32+$ 0+10'+$ Interviewer|$]2"3$%)$32+$0'"##%#/)L)3+:$%#$)21,3f
76Z
Gearda Demiraj !;8)#)@/7)%E$2?$5.)(&%)8/ Urban Planning department $
$
$
$
Z$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$M,%)23%#"
Interviewer|$ $ ]2"3$ %)$ 32+$ ,1'+$ 14$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ "#.$ %3)$ 0'"&+$ Interviewer|$$$]+,+$0,%*"3+$%#%3%"3%*+)$1,$%#41,:"'$.+*+'10:+#3)$ +*+,LV2+,+$/1%#/$1#f V%32%#$32+$/1*+,#:+#3"'$%#)3%3(3%1#)$"#.$V%32%#$M,%)323%#"f Gearda|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ifferent ideas and needs about the plan made it difficult to make "$/11.$)3,"3+/%&$0'"#>$W#$6!77$32+$-%/$:")3+,$0'"#$41,$32+$&%3L$V")$ :".+$V2%&2$%)$#13$%#$&1''"-1,"3%1#$V%32$32+$1'.$0'"#)>$5$,+#+V+.$ )3,"3+/L$%#$1,.+,$31$,+*%3"'%e+$32+$&%3L>$J(3H$"43+,$32%)$32+$#+V$'"V$ 1#$ (,-"#$ 0'"##%#/$ -+&":+$ %#$ &2",/+$ 4,1:$ 6!7@>$ 5$ #+V$ '"V$ &1\ :+)$ 1(3$ V2%&2$ )3"3+.$ 32"3$ 32+$ 6!77$ (,-"#$ 0'"#$ %)$ #13$ "*"%'"-'+$ "#L:1,+$"#.$32+$e1#%#/$0'"#$)3,"3+/L$V")$%:01)+.$4,1:$IG$")$"$ #+V$%#)3,(:+#3>$92+$0'"#$V")$)(001)+.$31$-+$41,$"$3%:+$0+,%1.$14$ 7B\6!$L+",)$"#.$V%32$32+$#+V$'"V$"#.$32+$%.+"$"-1(3$32+$e1#%#/$ :"0$)3,"3+/L$%3$%)$1#'L$%#$01V+,$(#3%'$32%)$e1#%#/$:"0$%)$,+".L>$92%)$ 0+,%1.$%)$#1V$/1%#/$1#$41,$6$L+",)$%#$.,"43%#/$32%)$1#+>$92%)$)3%''$ didnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t start as well for the final voting about this planning strategy. 92+$".:%#%)3,"3+$0",3$%)$#13$1(3$L+3H$%3$%)$"$V1,<$%#$0,1/,+))$)3%''>$53$ 32+$:1:+#3$V+$2"*+$"$F")3+,$0'"#$1,$FKM$"#.$,+/('"31,L$0'"#)>$ 92+)+$ ",+$ "*"%'"-'+$ -(3$ ",+$ )3%''$ *"'%.$ -(3$ 1#'L$ 41,$ "$ 0+,%1.$ 14$ B$ L+",)$V2+#$,+*%)%1#$%)$#++.+.>$5''$14$32+:$",+$#13$*+,L$/11.>$92+$ )%3("3%1#$ %)$ .%44+,+#3$ 4,1:$ 32+$ 0'"#)$ "3$ 32+$ :1:+#3$ "#.$ )1$ %#$ #1$ &")+$*+,L$V1,<"-'+>$d1($2"*+$31$,+*%+V$32+:$"#.$32%)$2")$-(./+3$ #++.+.>$ 92%)$ %)$ #++.+.$ 4,1:$ /1*+,#:+#3$ "#.$ 2")$ 31$ -+$ .1#+>$ I#3%'$32+$e1#%#/$:"0$%)$%#$V1,<$V+$,+*%)+$321)+$,+/('"31,L$0'"#)$ -(3$V%32$0,1-"-'L$#13$"#$+*+#3("'$"&3%1#$V%32%#$%3>$G1$32%)$:+"#)$ )0+#.%#/$:1#+L$1#$)1:+32%#/$V2%&2$V%''$#13$-+$14$"$'+/"'$.1&(\ :+#3$"#L:1,+$'"3+,>$ M","''+'$ V%32$ 32%)$ 0'"##%#/$ )%3("3%1#$ %)$ 32+$ '+/"'%e"3%1#$ 0,1&+))>$ U*+,L32%#/$L1($)++$2+,+$",1(#.$V")$41,:+,$'"#.$V2%&2$2"00+#+.$ %#$32+$0")3$7B$L+",)$V2%&2$%)$#13$#1,:"'$-(3$%3$2"00+#+.$+*+,L\ V2+,+$%#$32+$J"'<"#)$-(3$%#$"$:1,+$+Q3,+:+$&")+$%#$M,%)23%#"H$")$ in Post-Conflict areas. It is not chaos but it is rough. So at this :1:+#3$32+$3%:+$%)$"-1(3$V"%3%#/$(#3%'$"$#+V$)L)3+:$%)$%#$0'"&+$%#$ 1,.+,$31$.+*+'10$#+V$0'"#)$"#.$)3,"3+/%+)$%#$32+$&%3L>$92+$".:%\ nistrative parts of the law. The strategies which clarifiy the law. As )11#$")$32+$e1#%#/$:"0$)3,"3+/L$%)$%#$&2",/+H$32+$41,:+,$FKM$V%''$ change or needs clarification about its purpose and role still. This %)$%#$,+"'%3L$"$'%33'+$:+))L$%#$0'"##%#/$"#.$)3,"3+/%+)> Interviewer|$$]2"3$%)$%#*1'*+.$%#$.,"43%#/$:(#%&%"0'$.+*+'10:+#3$ 0'"#)$1,$)1$&"''+.$FKM)f Gearda|$$P%3%e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a1V$L1($2"*+$31$3"<+$32+:$%#$&1#)%.+,"3%1#$V2+#$ :"<%#/$0'"#)>
Gearda|$W3$.%.$#13$2"00+#$+*+,LV2+,+$%#$32+$&%3L>$92+$V+)3$0",3$ 14$ 32+$ &%3L$ "#.$ -+L1#.$ 32+$ ,"%'V"L$ 3,"&<$ V")$ +:03L$ '"#.>$ 92+,+$ V")$"$&'+",+,$%.+"$"-1(3$%3>$W#$)1:+$",+")$L1($&1('.$-(%'.$V%32$&,%\ 3+,%"`)H$#13$:+#3%1#%#/$"-1(3$32+$/11.$1,$-".$0",3$14$32+$&,%3+,%"`)$ -(3$"3$'+")3$32+,+$V+,+$,('+)$"#.$L1($'%*+.$(0$31$321)+$L1($&1('.$ -(%'.$L1(,$-(%'.%#/>$F1)3$14$32+$3%:+$32+L$2".$"''$32+$,('+)$"#.$ 0+,:%3)$-(3$.(,%#/$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$32+L$+#'",/+.$32+$-(%'.%#/$1,$ &2"#/+.$4"&".+)$1,$:".+$+Q3,"$'+*+')>$92"3`)$V2L$32+$&,%3+,%"`)$"#.$ 32+$0+,:%))%1#$V")$32+,+$-(3$32+L$&2"#/+.$%3$"43+,$32%)>$ Interviewer|$$]2L$.%.$32+$%#41,:"'$.+*+'10:+#3$2"00+#+.$+*+#$ 321(/2$+Q%)3%#/$0'"#)$V+,+$%#$&2",/+f Gearda|$a1$ 1#+$ %)$ -(%'.%#/$ V%321(3$ 0+,:%))%1#H$ 41,$ +*+,L$ ):"''$ 32%#/$32+L$",+$&1:%#/$31$")<$"00,1*"'>$G1:+3%:+)$L1($&"#$/%*+$ 32+:$ 0+,:%))%1#$ "&&1,.%#/$ 31$ 32+$ '"V)$ "#.$ ,+/('"3%1#)>$ G1:+\ 3%:+)$L1($Y()3$&"#`3$.1$%3>$92+$)":+$'"V)$",+$)3%''$"#.$V+,+$"&3%*+H$ #132%#/$ &2"#/+.$ :(&2$ "-1(3$ 32"3$ -+)%.+)$ 32%)$ 0",3$ %#$ 32+$ V+)3$ V2+#$,+*%+V%#/$32+$0'"#>$W#$/+#+,"'H$"&&1,.%#/$31$,+/('"3%1#)$"#.$ 0'"#)$32+L$V+,+$#13$:(&2$&2"#/+.$"#.$V+,+$%#$01V+,>$92+$0,1\ -'+:$%)$32"3$321)+$,('+)$"#.$,+/('"3%1#)$V+,+$#13$41''1V+.>$a13$ )3100+.$")$V+''$V2+#$&1#3,1'$V")$32+,+H$%4$32+,+$V")$&1#3,1'>$W#$ some cases, it was not a sufficient enough plan or corruption was /1%#/$ 1#H$ 32+$ %#)0+&3%1#$ .%.#`3$ )310$ V2"3$ V")$ /1%#/$ 1#>$ W3$ %)$ "$ :%Q$V2"3$V")$/1%#/$1#>$W#$"$)+#)+$%3$%)$#1,:"'$%#$"$)%3("3%1#$"43+,$ a conflict or war that you have to reconstruct or build your own 21()+$"/"%#>$K%44+,+#3$,+")1#)$"-1(3$32+$:1*+:+#3)$31V",.)$32+$ city after the conflict that put pressure on the building stock and 32+$":1(#3$14$21()%#/$&1#)3,(&3%1#)>$92%)$%)$"$0'"&+$%#$3,"#)%3%1#>$ At that moment after the conflict there was a need for housing and not an awareness or a sufficient level of responsibility about 32+$+#*%,1#:+#3H$)"4+3L$14$&1#)3,(&3%1#)H$0(-'%&$)0"&+$+3&>$W4$#1$ 1#+$V")$&2+&<%#/$V2"3$L1($.1$L1($&"#$.1$0(,)(+$L1(,$1V#$%.+\ ")H$,+/",.'+))$32+$%.+")$"#.$,('+)$32"3$",+$%#$&2",/+>$J+41,+$32+$ conflict everything was different. Normal permissions and rules V+,+$41''1V+.>$543+,$32+$V",$.%44+,+#3$#++.)$V+,+$(,/+#3$"#.$%#$ 32%)$V"L$#13$,+"''L$3"&<'+.$"3$32+$3%:+$14$+:+,/+#&+>$92+$0,1-'+:$ )1$%4$'"V)$"#.$,+/('"3%1#)$",+$#13$)1$)3,%&3$.%44+,+#3$%#3+,0,+3"3%1#$ %)$2"00+#%#/>$92%)$V1('.$2"00+#$+*+,LV2+,+$%#$32+$V1,'.$%#$32%)$ &")+>$ 5$ :%Q$ 14$ 0+10'+$ V21$ '+".>$ ]21$ 31$ '%)3+#$ "3f$ W::+.%"3+'L$ "43+,$32+$V",$J")<%#$R+:%'$32+$:1.+,#%)3%&$",&2%3+&3$3,%+.$31$:"<+$ "$:")3+,0'"#$41,$32+$(#%*+,)%3L$&":0()>$a132%#/$V")$32+,+$"3$32+$ -+/%##%#/>$W3$%)$32+$)%3("3%1#$%#$"''$c1)1*1$#13$1#'L$M,%)23%#">$92+L$ .%.#`3$ "#"'Le+$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ "3$ 32"3$ 3%:+$ "#.$ V2"3$ V")$ #++.+.>$ 5$:%Q3(,+$14$'+".+,)$14$W#3+,#"3%1#"'$1,/"#%e"3%1#)$31/+32+,$V%32$ '1&"'$/1*+,#:+#3$'+.$31$32%)$)%3("3%1#> Interviewer|$$]")$32+%,$"$0'"#$41,$"3$'+")3$-")%&$,+/("'"3%1#)f Gearda|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c1)1*1$2".$#1$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$'"V$"#.$)0"\ tial and urban plans. In 2004 this finally came. So there was a gap
7@!
14$E$L+",)$V%321(3$(,-"#$.%,+&3%1#)$"#.$)3,"3+/%+)$-+&"()+$32+$+Q%)\ ting plans from before the war were ignored and insufficient for the #+V$)3"3+$14$c1)1*1>$U*+,L$+Q0+,3$"3$32"3$:1:+#3$2".$"#$10%#%1#$ "-1(3$ 32+$ .%,+&3%1#$ c1)1*1$ #++.+.$ 3"<+>$ 53$ 32+$ 3%:+$ V%32%#$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$"#.$%#$32+$I,-"#%):$.+0",3:+#3$32+,+$V+,+$+Q0+,3)$ V1,<%#/$4,1:$1(3)%.+$c1)1*1>$92+L$.,"43+.$V1,<%#/$0'"#)$41,$32+$ moment and no spatial plans with proper visions. The first plan 32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$:".+$"43+,$32+$V",$V")$32+$)3,"3+/%&$0'"#$6!6!$%#$ 6!!E>$J")+.$1#$32"3$0'"#$32+L$)3",3+.$31$.,"43$32+$,+/('"31,L$0'"#)$ 41,$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.)>$ 92+$ 0,1-'+:$ V")$ 32"3$ 32+$ )3,"3+/%&$ 0'"#$ 6!6!$ 2".$ #1$ '+/%)'"3%*+$ -")+H$ %3$ .%.#`3$ .+,%*+$ 4,1:$ "#L$ '"V>$ 92%)$ 0'"#$ V")$ :".+$ -L$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ 14$ M,%)23%#"$ V%32$ )(0+,*%)%1#$ 14$ 1(3)%.+$ +Q0+,3)>$ 543+,$ 32+$ '"V$ "#.$ )1:+$ ,+/('"31,L$ 0'"#)H$ 32+$ (,-"#$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$V")$:".+$-(3$32"3$)21('.$2"*+$-++#$32+$ first and most important document for municipalities in the field 14$(,-"#$0'"##%#/$"#.$)3,"3+/L$"#.$&":+$1#'L$%#$6!7@>$92%)$V")$"$ :%)3"<+>$]+$2"*+$.%44+,+#3$0,1-'+:)$#1V$-+&"()+$+*+#$32%)$I,-"#$ .+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$%)$#13$2",:1#%e+.$V%32$"&3("'$)%3("3%1#$"#.$"&3(\ "'$,+/('"31,L$0'"#)$%#$)1:+$0'"&+)>$92%)$%)$32+$)%3("3%1#$#1V$"#.$"3$ 32+$:1:+#3$V+$",+$V"%3%#/$41,$32+$e1#%#/$:"0)$31$2"*+$&'+",$41,:)$ 32"3$.+,%*+.$4,1:$#+V$'"V$1#$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$%#$6!76>$92+$e1#%#/$ :"0$&"#$-+$&1:0",+.$31$32+$(,-"#$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$1,$FKM>$92+$ :"<%#/$14$32+$e1#%#/$:"0$.+0+#.)$:1)3$1#$32+$+Q0+,3)$4,1:$IG$ "#.$21V$32+L$&"#$-+$"00'%+.$31$32+$c1)1*1$)%3("3%1#>$W3$#++.)$"$ &+,3"%#$'+*+'$14$.+3"%'$%#$1,.+,$31$4(#&3%1#$"#.$2"*+$0(,01)+>$
92%)$3,"#)%3%1#$02")+$M,%)23%#"$2")$-++#$&"3")3,102%&$41,$32+$(,-"#$ .+*+'10:+#3$"#.$[("'%3L$14$'%*%#/$&1#.%3%1#)>$J+41,+$32+$V",H$d(/\ 1)'"*%"$V")$%#$&2",/+$"#.$32+L$:%Q+.$"''$0'"#)>$92%)$:+"#3$32"3$32+$ :")3+,0'"#$ 14$ M,%)23%#"$ V")$ "$ :%Q3(,+$ 14$ "''$ .%44+,+#3$ 0'"#)$ 4,1:$ 132+,$&%3%+)$V%32%#$d(/1)'"*%">$W3$V")$"$-,+"<$V%32$32+$1'.H$2%)31,%&"'$ "#.$*+,#"&('",$",&2%3+&3(,+$"#.$)+,*+.$"':1)3$")$"#$+Q0+,%:+#3"'$ 0'"&+$%#$32%)$:1.+,#%)3%&$"00,1"&2$"#.$%.+"')$"-1(3$32+$&%3L>$91\ ."LH$32+$01'%3%&%"#)$2"*+$32+$%#3+#3%1#)$31$)+3$"$/1"'$V%321(3$"#L$ /11.$-"&</,1(#.$,+)+",&2$1#$%3>$92+$+))+#3%"'$)1'(3%1#$%)$"$)3"-'+$ #+V$/1*+,#:+#3$%#$1,.+,$31$0,1&++.>$92%)$%''+/"'$21()%#/$0,1&+))$ V")$"$,+)('3$14$32+$/"0$%#$32+$0'"##%#/$"#.$/1*+,#:+#3"'$)L)3+:>$ W3$V")$"$'1/%&"'$&1#)+[(+#&+$V2+#$32+,+$V")$#++.$41,$21()%#/>$ W#$32"3$3%:+H$V+$.,"43+.$"$'"V$1#$.+"'%#/$V%32$%''+/"'$-(%'.%#/$-(3$ V%321(3$"$'$01'%3%&"'$V%''$31$+#41,&+$32"3$'"V>$92+$.+*+'10+,)$V+,+$ :"L-+$+*+#$0",3$14$32+$01'%3%&"'$)L)3+:$"#.$2".$#13$:(&2$V%''$%#$ +#41,&%#/$32"3$'"V>$R,1:$6!7E$32+$%''+/"'$-(%'.%#/)$)3100+.$V%32$ 32+$:(#%&%0"'$.+&%)%1#$31$0(3$"$21'.$1#$"#L$&1#)3,(&3%1#>$92%)$'"V$ %)$ 1#$ 3,+"3%#/$ 32+$ %''+/"'$ -(%'.%#/)$ -(3$ %3$ %)$ "$ '"V$ 1#$ '+/"'%e"3%1#$ 14$32+$)%3("3%1#$V2%&2$:+"#)$32+,+$%)$#13$L+3$"$)0"3%"'$0'"#$1,$"$ &1#.%3%1#)$31$'+/"'%e+>$a1$0,10+,3L$1,$1V#+,)2%0$%)$%#$0'"&+>$W3$%)$ #1V$Y()3$32+$'+/"'%e"3%1#$14$32+$-(%'.%#/>$XV#+,)2%0$0,1-'+:)$",+$ )3%''$32+,+q$32%)$#++.)$31$-+$"..,+))+.>$T+/%)3,"3%1#$"3$32+$&".")3+,$ V%32$32+$'+/"'$1V#+,$14$32+$'"#.$%)$32+$#+Q3$)3+0>$W#$32+$0,+*%1()$ 7B$L+",)$",1(#.$6B>!!!$21()+)$V+,+$%''+/"''L$-(%'.$"#.$32+,+$",+$ 1#'L$7!!!$0+,:%3)$/%*+#$31$-(%'.>
Sadije Kelmendi UN-Habitat Kosovo $
B$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$M,%)23%#"
Interviewer|$]2"3$%)$32+$,1'+$14$Ia\_"-%3"3`)$0'"##%#/$.+0",3:+#3$ +#41,&+:+#3$14$)3,"3+/%&$0'"##%#/>$ %#$32+$&1#3+Q3$14$c1)1*1f Interviewer|$$_1V$.%.$32+$0",3%&%0"31,L$)3,"3+/L$1,$&110+,"3%1#$ Sadije|$$92+$Ia\2"-%3"3$%)$1#+$14$32+$:"%#$+)3"-'%)2+,)$14$32+$F%\ V%32$32+$)1&%+3L$V1,<+.f #%)3,L$14$U#*%,1#:+#3$"#.$M'"##%#/>$92+L$&":+$2+,+$.%,+&3'L$"43+,$ 32+$V",$%#$7ZZZ>$5&&1,.%#/$31$0'"##%#/$"#.$32+$Ia\2"-%3"3$"#.$G"\ Sadije|$ 92+,+$",+$.%44+,+#3$V"L)$-(3$:1)3'L$"$:(#%&%0"'%3L$)3",3)$ .%Y+$c+':+#3%H$32+L$V1,<$1#$32+$41''1V%#/$,+/('"3%1#$"#.$"00,1"&2$ V%32$ "#$ )(,*+L>$ 91$ &1''+&3$ ."3"$ "#.$ :"<+$ 32+$ 0,1-'+:)$ &'+",>$ W#$ &"''+.$ 32+$ F",33%$ 523%)"",%$ 0"&<"/+$ 14$ .+&+#3,"'%e"3%1#$ V2%&2$ .+\ n,"&"#%&"H$-+&"()+$%3$V")$"$#+V$:(#%&%0"'%3L$"#.$)1$"$&+#)()$14$ &+#3,"'%e+.$1(,$&1(#3,L$%#31$@8$:(#%&%0"'%3%+)$"#.$V+,+$)+0","3+.$ 32+$010('"3%1#$V")$#13$"*"%'"-'+$.(+$31$32+$1,%/%#$14$32+$010(\ -")+.$1#$+32#%&$-"&</,1(#.$"#.$)3,(&3(,+>$92%)$%)$#13$*+,L$/11.$ '"3%1#H$V2%&2$%)$G+,-%"#H$"$)(,*+L$V")$2+'.$31$&1''+&3$-")%&$."3">$ 41,$0'"##%#/H$%#3+/,"3%1#$"#.$&12+)%1#$)++#$4,1:$"#$(,-"#%)3$"#.$ M10('"3%1#$#(:-+,)$",+$#+*+,$*+,L$3,(+H$"#.$)21V$#13$"'V"L)$32+$ %#&'()%*+$.+*+'10:+#3$0+,)0+&3%*+>$W#$n,"&"#%&"H$"$G+,-%"#$+#&'"*+$ "&3("'$%#2"-%3"#3)>$W#$32+)+$)%3("3%1#)H$"$)(,*+L$%)$)++#$")$"$01'%\ )1(32$14$32+$&"0%3"'$V2%&2$V+,+$41,:+.$%#$32+$+#.$14$6!!Z$32+$Ia$ 3%&"'$c1)1*",$311'$31$/"%#$."3"$"#.$32%)$%)$#13$*+,L$V+'&1:+.$-L$ )3",3+.$V%32$"$&110+,"3%1#$V%32$:(#%&%0"'%3L$)3",3+.$0,1*%.%#/$2+'0$ G+,-%"#$ 010('"3%1#>$ ]+$ %#*1'*+.$ 32+:$ %#$ V1,<)210)$ "#.$ 0(-'%&$ V%32$*%)%1#%#/$"#$(,-"#$)3,"3+/L>$5$311'$"')1$.+*+'10+.$31/+32+,$ 0,+)+#3"3%1#)H$V+$V+#3$31V",.)$32+:H$#+",$32+:H$"#.$&"''+.$32+$ V%32$1(,$:"%#$&1#3,%-(31,)H$R,"#<$91#H$5$J+'/%(:$0'"##+,>$F1)3$14$ *%''"/+$,+0,+)+#3"3%*+$31$)0+"<$41,$32+:$31$)0+"<$"-1(3$32+$*%''"\ 32+$:(#%&%0"'%3%+)$)3",3$V%32$32%)$*%)%1#%#/$V1,<)210>$W#$B$."L)$"''$ /+,)$#++.)$"#.$0,1-'+:)>$W3$#++.+.$:(&2$:1,+$V1,<$%#$1,.+,$31$ )3"<+21'.+,)q$32+$:%#%)3,LH$:(#%&%0"'%3LH$&%*%'$)1&%+3LH$0,14+))%1#"')H$ )21V$ 32+$ 1,/"#%e"3%1#`)$ /11.$ %#3+#3%1#)$ ")$ "$ #+(3,"'$ %#)3%3(3%1#>$ "''$0",3%&%0"3+$%#$:"<%#/$"$*%)%1#$41,$32+%,$:(#%&%0"'%3L>$R,1:$32+,+$ To be flexible to integrated everybody into the planning making. 32+$0'"##%#/$)3",3)$31$.,"43$"$:(#%&%0"'$0'"#$V%32$32+%,$1V#$41,&+)>$ ]1:+#H$&2%'.,+#H$/+#.+,$%#3+/,"3+.H$0",3%&%0"3%1#H$%#&'()%*+#+))>$ 5$Ia\_"-%3"3$:+:-+,$V")$1#$"$."%'L$-")%)$/(%.%#/$32+$)3"44H$V2%&2$ W#$*%)%1#$:"<%#/$%#*1'*+:+#3> V+,+$ #13$ *+,L$ +Q0+,%+#&+.H$ V%32$ .,"43%#/$ 0'"##%#/$ .1&(:+#3)>$ W3$ 2"00+#+.$ %#$ "#$ %#\21()+$ V"L$ -(3$ #+Q3$ 31$ 32"3$ %3$ 2"00+#+.$ "')1$ W#$32+$0,+*%1()$0'"##%#/$"00,1"&2$32+,+$V+,+$B$4"&+)$%#$32+$0'"#\ %#$"$0",3%&%0"31,L$V"L>$Ia$V")$32+$1#+$31$0,101)+$"#.$,+)('3+.$%#$ ning structure; the Profile the existing, the Vision, the Principles '1&"'$)3"44$+:-,"&%#/$32%)$3+&2#%&$%#$1,.+,$31$2"*+$32+%,$0'"#)$-+33+,$ "#.$ n1"')H$ 32+$ G0"3%"'$ .+*+'10:+#3$ &1#&+03O4,":+V1,<H$ "&3%1#$ %:0'+:+#3+.$%#$"$:1,+$0",3%&%0"31,L$V"L$.(,%#/$32+$0'"##%#/>$W3$%)$ 0'"#$ "#.$ %:0'+:+#3"3%1#$ 0,1*%)%1#>$ d1($ &"#$ 1#'L$ %#*1'*+$ 41,$ %#\ #1V$%#$41,&+$4,1:$6!7E$g(#+>$W3$%)$:(&2$+")%+,$31$:"<+$0'"#)$V%32$ )3"#3$&2%'.,+#$%#$1#'L$;%)%1#%#/$%#$1,.+,$31$:"<+$%3$4(#&3%1#"'> involvement of local government together with the influence of lo\ &"'$)1&%+3L$32+$31$%:01)+$+*+,L32%#/$4,1:$"#$1(3)%.+$0+,)0+&3%*+>$ Interviewer|$$]2"3$%)$32+$Ia\_"-%3"3$%#*1'*+.$V%32$%#$,+'"3%1#$31$ W3$ /%*+)$ "#$ "'%-%$ 41,$ 32+$ 0'"#$ V2+#$ '1&"'$ )1&%+3L$ "#.$ /1*+,#:+#3$ 32+$P"0%3"'$M,%)32%#"f ",+$32+$"&3("'$0'"##+,)>$92%)$0",3%&%0"31,L$V"L$&1('.$-+$%:0,1*+.$ -L$32+$":1(#3$14$)1&%+3%+)$%#0(3>$92+$"&3%1#$0'"#$32"3$&1:+)$1(3$ Sadije|$ T+&+#3'L$Ia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tant is that the project needs to be identified from a strategy not an )+$P"0%3"'$%#*+)3:+#3$0,1Y+&3)>$92%)$%)$"$.%44+,+#3$)3,"3+/L$-+&"(\ ".$21&$-")%)>$92+$:(#%&%0"'$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$hFKMi$V")$'%<+$32%)$ )+$32+$0",3%&%0"3%1#$%)$.1#+$"43+,$"$0,%:",L$"#"'L)%)$14$32,1(/2$"$ -+41,+$"#.$)1$#13$*+,L$)3,"3+/L$-")+.>$S"3+,$32%)$&2"#/+.$V%32$32+$ G]X9\:+321.$"#.$32+#$%#*1'*+:+#3$14$32+$0(-'%&$V2+#$.,"V%#/$ 7@7
#++.)$"#.$+))+#3%"')>$92%)$%)$.%44+,+#3$4,1:$32+$-")+$:"0$V%32$32+$ actual situation. This identifies challenges and are translated them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n(%."#&+$14$32+$)0"&+$%)$#++.+.$%#$ 1,.+,$31$0,13+&3$32+$4(#&3%1#$"#.$.+)%/#> Interviewer|$$$]2"3$",+$32+$"))+3)$14$M,%)23%#"$")$"$&"03%3"'$&%3Lf Sadije|$$$ M,%)23%#"$2")$"$*+,L$/11.$#%/23'%4+>$W3$2")$"$*+,L$10+#$"#.$ V+'&1:%#/$&('3(,+$31$+*+,L1#+H$31$W#3+,#"3%1#"'$0+10'+$"#.$#"3%\ 1#)>$W3$%)$"$*+,L$21)0%3"-'+$&%3L>$W3$2")$"#$(,-"#$)0%,%3>$5$&('3(,+$14$ &144++$"#.$411.>$]2"3$%)$.1+)$:"<+$"$.%44+,+#3$0'"&+$%)$32+$0+10'+H$ it is an integration of nationalities. The conflict was not really inside 32+$&%3LH$0+10'+$V+,+$)3%''$41,&+.$1(3$14$32+%,$21:+)H$-(3$32+,+$V")$ #13$"$,+"''L$/(#$)2113%#/$"#.$3+,,1,$%#$32+$&%3L>$S(&<%'L$%3`)$#13$"$.%*%\ .+.$&%3L$'%<+$F%3,1*%&"$"#.$F1)3",$%#$J1)#%">$G2100%#/$%#$M,%)23%#"$ V%32$,+&+#3$.+*+'10:+#3)$14$)2100%#/$:"'')$%)$+#2"#&%#/$32+$"3\ 3,"&3%*+#+))$14$32+$&%3L>$]+$",+$#13$0,1(.$14$32+$&1#&,+3+$:"))$"#.$ (,-"#$&1#.%3%1#)$,+'"3+.$31$'%*%#/$*+,L$&'1)+$31$+"&2$132+,>$5#$"))+3$ %)$ 32+$0",<$14$n+,#%"H$"$0,13+&3+.$0",<$V2%&2$%)$"$0'+")"#3$ 0'"&+$ 31$ -+$ "#.$ )0+#.$ 3%:+>$ ]+$ .1$ :%))$ "#$ +&1'1/%&"'$ #+3V1,<$ V%32%#$ 32+$ &%3L$ 321(/2>$ 92+,+$ %)$ "$ 0",<$ %)$ 32+,+$ -(3$ #13$ :"%#3"%#+.$ V+''$ "#.$#13$*+,L$V+''$&1##+&3+.$"#.$"&&+))%-'+>$W3$%)$"$[(%3+$"#.$)"4+$ &%3L>$5$'13$14$)3(.+#3)$",+$&1:%#/$2+,+$+*+#$4,1:$4(,32+,$"V"L$'%<+$ F"&+.1#%"$"#.$G+,-%"$31$)3(.L>$W#$+Q$d(/1)'"*%"$%3$V")$"$+.(&"3%1\ #"'$210$V%32%#$32+$,+0(-'%&$"#.$32%)$,+:"%#)$%#$32+$67)3$&+#3(,L>$5$ (#%*+,)%3L$&%3L$V2%&2$%)$/,1V%#/>$W3$2")$)1:+$0",3)$14$X331:"#$+,"$ "'321(/2$32+)+$V+,+$:1)3'L$.+)3,1L+.$.(,%#/$32+$d(/1)'"*%"#$0+,%\ 1.>$5$3%:+$V2+#$#+V$:1.+,#$.+*+'10:+#3$V")$.+)3,1L%#/$32+$1'.$ 3,".%3%1#"'O'1&"'$)3L'+)$"#.$)3,(&3(,+)$14$32+$&%3L>$92+$2%)31,%&$e1#+$ %)$32+,+$-(3$#13$*+,L$'",/+$"#.$&1:0'+3+>$]+$'%*+$%#$2",:1#L$V%32$@$ .%44+,+#3$,+'%/%1#)>$U32#%&%3L$V")$:1,+$%:01,3"#3$32+#$,+'%/%1#>$]+$ &"##13$ )++$ 32+$ .%44+,+#&+$ "#.$ V+$ Y1%#$ .%44+,+#3$ &+'+-,"3%1#)$ "#.$ '%*+$%#$2",:1#L$"#.$0+"&2$31/+32+,> Interviewer|$$$]2"3$2")$-++#$32+$)%3("3%1#$%#$32+$0")3$7B$L+",)f Sadije_ The influx of people made the demand for housing very 2%/2>$]%32$32%)$0,1&+))$)3",3%#/$%::+.%"3+'L$"43+,$32+$V",H$32+$"-\ )+#&+$14$"$:(#%&%0"'$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"#$"#.$#1$/(%."#&+$41,$"#.$ &1#3,1'$1#$.+*+'10+,)H$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$V+#3$"&&1,.%#/$%#.%*%.("'$ %.+")$"#.$%#3+,+)3>$W#$6!!8$L1($&1('.$2"*+$"$4++'%#/$V%32$32+$%#&,+\ .%-'+$":1(#3$14$&1#)3,(&3%1#$/1%#/$1#$32"3$32+$[(+)3%1#$V")$V2+\ ,+$0+10'+$V+,+$'%*%#/$"3$32"3$:1:+#3>$R'"3)H$21()+)H$"0",3:+#3)H$ +*+,L."L$ #+V$ -(%'.%#/)$ V+,+$ &1#)3,(&3+.>$ R%#"''LH$ #1V$ 32+,+$ %)$ "$ 3%:+$14$'+/"'%e"3%1#$"#.$0+10'+$2".$"$.+".'%#+$31$"00'L$41,$"$0+,\ :%3$"#.$+#3+,$32+$,+/%)3+,>$W3$&1('.$-+$.1#+$32,1(/2$)+#.%#/$32+%,$ -'(+0,%#3)$31$)++$%4$32+L$&1('.$'+/"'%e+$32+$+Q%)3%#/$1,$#13>$W3$%)$"$ &2"''+#/%#/$)%3("3%1#$"#.$%#*1'*+)$"$'13$14$V1,<>$]+$&1('.$()+$32+$ +Q0+,%+#&+$14$92+))"'1#%<%$V2+,+$V%321(3$,+)0+&3%#/$32+$.+*+'10\ :+#3$0'"#)$-(%'.%#/)$V+,+$-(%'.H$32+L$2".$31$.1#"3+$6!o$14$32+%,$ 0'13$31$0(-'%&$)0"&+>$5$)3,++3H$"$)&211'$1,$Y()3$0(-'%&$)0"&+>$92%)$%)$ 21V$32+L$3,L$31$,+/('"3+$V")$V")$/1%#/$%#$"#$%#41,:"'$V"L$2"00+\ #%#/$1#$32+$/,1(#.>$92%)$%)$V2L$"$'",/+$0",3$14$M,%)23%#"$%)$"&3("''L$ "#$%#41,:"'$)+33'+:+#3>$92+$'+/"'%e"3%1#$,('+)$%#$c1)1*1$",+$:(&2$ +")%+,$ 31$ "&2%+*+>$ 92+,+$ ",+$ #1$ #+V$ ,('+)$ 1,$ )3"#.",.)$ "..+.$ %#$ 1,.+,$ 31$ &2"#/+$ 0",3)$ 14$ )3,++3)>$ c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t"/,+-$%)$%#$0,1&+))>$ 7@6
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nterviewer|$$]2"3$%:01,3"#3$)3+0)$)21('.$-+$3"<+#$%#$M,%)23%#"f Sadije|$]+$.%.$#13$3"<+$%#$&1#)%.+,"3%1#$32+$+Q%)3%#/$0'"#)H$+)\ 0+&%"''L$41,$M,%)23%#">$n1*+,#:+#3$31'.$+*+,L1#+$32"3$321)+$0'"#)$ V+,+$#13$/11.$"#.$#+V$0'"#)$2".$31$-+$:".+H$0,1-"-'L$"')1$41,$ 32+%,$1V#$".*"#3"/+>$92+)+$V+,+$:".+$31/+32+,$V%32$32+$Ia$%#$ 6!!@>$W#$32+$:+"#3%:+H$32+$3%:+$-+3V++#$32+$+#.$14$32+$V",$"#.$ 32+$ 0(-'%&"3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ #+V$ )3,"3+/%&$ 0'"#H$ 32+$ &%3%e+#)$ V+,+$ #13$ "-'+$ 31$ V"%3H$ 32+$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 14$ "''$ <%#.)$ 14$ -(%'.%#/)$ 41,$ 21(\ )%#/$ )3",3+.$ 31$ 010$ (0>$ M+10'+$ V"#3+.$ :1,+$ ,11:)$ "#.$ )0"&+$ 41,$32+$+#3%,+$4":%'L$31$'%*+$31/+32+,$-(3$32%)$V")$:1)3'L$#13$:1,+$ 32+#$A!:6>$53$32"3$3%:+$21()%#/$01))%-%'%3%+)$V+,+$32+$&1,+$%))(+$ -(3$V%321(3$"$0'"#$31$/(%.+$"''$32+)+$.+*+'10:+#3)>$921)+$(,/+#3$ #++.)$ ",+$ #1V$ #13$ "#L:1,+$ %#$ 0'"&+$ 41,$ 21()%#/>$ a1V$ 0+10'+$ V"#3$:1,+$[("'%3L$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$'%*%#/H$2%/2+,$&1:41,3>$G3,%\ <%#/$%)$32"3$"$,+&+#3$&+#)()$01%#3+.$1(3$32"3$@!o$14$"0",3:+#3)$ ",+$*"&"#3$%#$c1)1*1>$K+:"#.$"#.$144+,$%)$#13$%#$-"'"#&+.>$]+$ need a housing profile for the housing developments and plans. 53$ 32+$ :1:+#3$ V+$ ",+$ :1,+$ 41&()+.$ 1#$ %#4,")3,(&3(,+$ "#.$ #13$ focused on a good housing profile and needs of the current citi\ e+#)>$R%/(,+)$)21V$32"3$,+")1#)$",+H$"$'",/+$.%")01,"$V%32$)+&1#.$ 21()+)$%#$c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e+.>$X#'L$"$):"''$ ":1(#3$%)$)3%''$%#$/1*+,#:+#3$01))+))%1#$V2%&2$%)$313"''L$.%44+,+#3$ 4,1:$32+$0+,%1.$-+41,+$32+$V",> 92+$32%#/$31$.1$%)$31$+#2"#&+$32+$0(-'%&\0,%*"3+$,+'"3%1#)2%0)>$5$ *",%+3L$ 14$ )1&%"'$ 0,1-'+:)$ 2"*+$ +:+,/+.$ 1*+,$ 32+$ L+",$ ,+'"3+.$ 31$32+$-(%'.%#/)$1#$0'13)H$32+$)%e+)$14$321)+$-(%'.%#/)H$32+$,%/23)$ 14$+Q%)3%#/$-(%'.%#/)>$92+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$)21('.$2"*+$%#3+,*+#+.$%#$ 1,.+,$31$&,+"3+$"$&12+)%*+$0'"#$V2%&2$%)$V1,<%#/$41,$+*+,L1#+>$]+$ #++.$1#+$:1,+$%#)3,(:+#3$32"3$-,%#/)$)3"<+21'.+,)$31/+32+,$"#.$ :+,/+$0'13)$"#.$'"#.)$%#$1,.+,$31$2"*+$:1,+$"#.$-+33+,$)%3("3%1#>$ K1$#13$Y()3$'+"*+$%3$31$32+$0,%*"3+$)+&31,$31$.+&%.+$-+&"()+$32+$ )1&%+3L$")$"$V21'+$V%''$.+&,+")+$%#$[("'%3L$32+#>$W$V1('.$)3"#.$41,$ "$E32$'+*+'$%#$32+$(,-"#$0'"##%#/$)L)3+:$14$32+$&%3%+)H$,+'"3+.$31$ 32+$%:0'+:+#3"3%1#$14$32+$0'"#)>$92%)$*+,L$#++.+.$&1#&+,#%#/$32+$ 3L0+$14$0'"#$32+$#+V$t1#%#/$F"0$)L)3+:$%)$-,%#/%#/$31$c1)1*1>$ y$ y$ y$ y$
F(#%&%0"'$.+*+'10:+#3$0'"# F(#%&%0"'$e1#%#/$0'"#$#13$%#$'%#+$V%32$U(,10+ K+3"%'+.$ ,+/('"31,L$ 0'"#)$ V2%&2$ ",+$ #13$ 1-'%/"31,L$ %4$ L1($ 2"*+$32+$e1#%#/$:"0 E32$'+*+'$#++.+.$%:0'+:+#3"3%1#$0'"#
F%)(#.+,)3"#.%#/)$ 4,1:$ 0,1Y+&3)$ "-1(3$ ,(,"'$ ",+")$ V2%&2$ V+,+$ #13$ &1*+,+.$ -L$ FKM)$ "#.$ I,-"#$ .+*+'10:+#3$ 0'"#)$ V+,+$ #13$ .+3"%'+.$+#1(/2>$G1$%#$1,.+,$31$)1'*+$32%)$"$.+3"%'+.$e1#%#/$:"0)$ ",+$ #++.+.$ 41,$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ -(3$ "$ .+3"%'+.$ &+#)()$ ."3"-")+$ %)$ #+&+))",L$ 41,$ &1,,+&3$ :"00%#/>$ G1$ %3$ V1('.$ -+$ +")%+,$ 31$ V1,<$ V%32$I,-"#$,+/('"31,L$0'"#)$+)0+&%"''L$41,$M,%)23%#">$M,+0",%#/$32%)$ e1#%#/$:"0$%)$2",.$31$.,"43>$W#$32+$'")3$6$L+",)H$4,1:$32+$:1:+#3$ 14$ /1*+,#:+#3"'$ &2"#/+$ "#.$ 0,101)+.$ e1#%#/$ :"0H$ #132%#/$ %)$ "&2%+*+.$"#.$.,"43+.$L+3>$a1$"&3)$",+$32+,+$L+3$31$V1,<$")$"$/(%\ .+'%#+$41,$)0"3%"'$"&3)>
Rudina Qerimi, Lumnije Gashi & Drita Nushi Pro Planning, Kosovo Center for Urban Research $
$
$
$
A$a1*+:-+,$6!7BH$M,%)23%#"
Interviewer|$$]2"3$",+$32+$%))(+)$&2"''+#/%#/$(,-"#$'%4+$%#$M,%)2\ 3%#"f PRO Planning|$ 92+$G1&%"'%)3$)L)3+:$2".$"$&1#*+#3%1#"'$0'"#\ #%#/$)L)3+:$V2%&2$%)$"$310$.1V#$"00,1"&2>$W#$32+$&")+$14$c1)1*1$ 32"3$)L)3+:$:+"#3$32"3$32+$0'"#)$V+,+$:".+$1#$#"3%1#"'$)&"'+$14$ d(/1)'"*%">$M'"##%#/$"#.$)0"3%"'$'"V)$&":+$4,1:$&"0%3"'$J+'/,".+>$ ]2%&2$V")$41,$"$'1#/$3%:+$"$.%44+,+#3$&1(#3,L$"#.$.%44+,+#3$-"&<\ /,1(#.)>$ W#$ 32%)$ j41,+%/#k$ 0'"##%#/$ )L)3+:$ 32+$ '1&"'$ "(321,%3%+)$ V+,+$ :"<%#/$ 32+$ (,-"#$ 0'"#)H$ 32+$ ):"''\)&"'+$ 0'"#)$ -(3$ "''$ V%32$ %.+"')$4,1:$32+$)3"3+$)&"'+$%#$J+'/,".+>$92+$0'"&+$V2+,+$32+$3+&2\ #%&"'$)3"44$V")$"#.$V2+,+$32+$+.(&"3%1#$%#$I#%*+,)%3%+)$V")$/11.>$ Kosovo got its first university in 1969. W#$7ZZZ$"''$32+)+$:%))%#/$'%#<)$%#$32+$/1*+,#:+#3"'$)L)3+:$2".$31$ -+$+)3"-'%)2+.$"#.$41,:+.>$5$#+V$01'%3%&)$"#.$"$#+V$'"V$)L)3+:$ &":+$31$c1)1*1$V%32$32+$%#3+#3%1#)$31$-+$:1,+$0",3%&%0"31,L$V%32$ "''$)3"<+21'.+,)H$"$.+:1&,"3%&$)L)3+:>$92+$41,:+,$0'"#)$V+,+$#+\ glected and when the first spatial plan in 2004 was published it 2".$32+$41,:$14$"$)3,"3+/L>$W3$)21('.$2"*+$-++#$:1,+$3,"#)0",+#3H$ 0",3%&%0"31,LH$ %#*1'*%#/$ )3"<+21'.+,)H$ .%44+,+#3$ &1::(#%3%+)$ "#.$ actors, but it did not at the time. With the difficult circumstances in 32+$L+",)$"43+,$32+$V",$%3$311<$(#3%'$6!7@H$V%32$"$#+V$/1*+,#:+#3H$ 31$&2"#/+$32+$0'"##%#/$)L)3+:$41,$32+$-+33+,>$]%32$32+$)310$1#$%'\ '+/"'$.+*+'10:+#3$"#.$0,+*+#3%#/$#+V$1#+)$%#$6!7@$%#$32+$&"0%3"'$ city has put its first step to control the urban development. This V")$*+,L$(,/+#3$%#$1,.+,$31$/+3$&1#3,1'$1*+,$32+$.+*+'10:+#3)$14$ 32+$&%3L> 92%)$(#&1#3,1''+.$.+*+'10:+#3$2")$-++#$4(+'+.$-L$32+$#+V$4,++$ :",<+3$ +&1#1:L$ 14$ c1)1*1$ "#.$ %#$ 32+$ &")+$ 14$ M,%)23%#"$ -L$ 32+$ high influx of new- and returning residents after the war. For many L+",)H$32+$'1&"'$/1*+,#:+#3$V+,+$#13$&"0"-'+$14$&1#3,1''%#/$"#.$ ,+/('"3%#/$32+$.+*+'10:+#3>$W3$%)$#1V$32+$3%:+$41,$:1,+$41&()$1#$ 3"<%#/$"&3%1#)$%#$%:0,1*%#/$0(-'%&$)0"&+H$.,%#<%#/$V"3+,H$2+"3%#/H$ V")3+H$0(-'%&$3,"#)01,3H$0(-'%&$)+,*%&+)>$92%)$%)$"$01)%3%*+$)2%43$31\ wards the future. Nevertheless, it is difficult to change things with 32+$V"L$32+$.+*+'10:+#3$2"00+#+.>$ 5$'",/+$":1(#3$14$&1#)3,(&3%1#$V")$-(%'3$)%#&+$32+$V",$"#.$:"#L$ of them are built with sufficient standards. It is not just the con\ )3,(&3%1#$14$21()+)$32"3$",+$)1:+3%:+)$%#$011,$&1#.%3%1#$-(3$"')1$ +'+:+#3)$ '%<+H$ 0(-'%&$ )0"&+H$ 0(-'%&$ /,++#H$ )3,++3$ [("'%3LH$ 0(-'%&$ 3,"#)01,3$)L)3+:H$)1&%"'$21()%#/H$0",<%#/$)0"&+)H$0"*+.$)%.+V"'<)H$ )"4+$)0"&+)$41,$&2%'.,+#H$"&&+))$31$0(-'%&$4"&%'%3%+)$V2%&2$",+$:%)\ )%#/$1,$14$011,$[("'%3L$%#$32+$&%3L>$91."LH$32+$&%3%e+#)$",+$+Q0+&3%#/$ :1,+$ &1:41,3$ "#.$ [("'%3L$ %#$ 32+%,$ .%,+&3$ '%*%#/$ +#*%,1#:+#3$ "#.$ are not fulfilling their needs as an urban resident. In the beginning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nterviewer|$$]2"3$+'+:+#3)$%)$32+$&%3L$,+%#*+)3%#/$%#$#1VH$V2%&2$ V+,+$#+/'+&3+.$.(,%#/$32+$,+-(%'.%#/f PRO Planning_ The first attempt to give space to it citizens in M,%)23%#"$V")$.1#+$32,1(/2$0+.+)3,%"#%e%#/$F132+,$92+,+)"$J1(\ '+*",.$%#$32+$2+",3$14$32+$&%3L>$W3$2")$%:0,1*+.$32+$)1&%"'$'%4+$"#.$ %#&,+")+.$ 32+$ ":1(#3$ 14$ 4"&%'%3%+)$ "'1#/$ 32+$ )3,++3>$ F1)3$ 14$ 32+$ 4"&%'%3%+)$",+$,+'"3+.$31$+#2"#&+$32+$)1&%"'$%#3+,"&3%1#$&"0"-%'%3L$'%<+$
&"4v)$"#.$,+)3"(,"#3)>$921)+$0'"&+)$",+$4":%'%",$31$'1&"')H$-+41,+$ 32+$V",$32+)+$V+,+$32+$)1&%"'$0'"&+)$31$:++3$0+10'+$-(3$"')1$31$ .1$-()%#+))H$+Q0+,%+#&+$&('3(,+$"#.$31$:++3$4,%+#.)$N$4":%'L>$G1H$ ,+'"3+.$31$32+$&('3(,+$14$M,%)23%#"$"#.$132+,$c1)1*1$&%3%+)$&144++\ 21()+)$",+$%#$%:01,3"#3$+'+:+#3$31$2"*+$%#$1,.+,$31$)3%:('"3+$"#.$ 4"&%'%3"3+$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+>$a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`)$:%#.)+3$"#.$32%#<%#/$"-1(3$&",$()+>$W3$%)$"$)3,"#/+$ )%3("3%1#$-+&"()+$%#$32+$C!`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space but poor in quality or difficult to access. This is very much 2"00+#%#/$%#$32+$#+V'L$.+*+'10+.$#+%/2-1,211.)$"#.$32+$:1,+$ &+#3,"'$1#+)$V21$V+,+$.+)3,1L+.$-+&"()+$14$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$+Q\ 0'1)%1#>$ 53$ 32+$ :1:+#3H$ 32+$ #+V+)3$ 0'"#$ %)$ )3%''$ #13$ &1#&+,#%#/$ 32+$'%*%#/$[("'%3L$14$321)+$&+#3,"'$2%/2$.+#)%3L$#+%/2-1,211.)$"#.$ %)$+*+#$0'"##%#/$31$&1:0'+3+'L$V%0+$1(3$32+$'1V+,$21()%#/$&1#\ )3,(&3%1#$%#$1,.+,$31$-(%'.$:1,+$"#.$:1,+>$92%)$%)$2"00+#%#/$%#$32+$ #+%/2-1,211.)$1#$32+$+")3$)'10+q$K1.1#"$"#.$F1.,"Y+3>$92+)+$ 0'"#)$",+$#13$/11.$41,$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$"#.$%3)$)0"&+$"#.$%)$0(33%#/$ :1,+$0,+))(,+$1#$32+$&+#3+,`)$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$"#.$4"&%'%3%+)> Interviewer|$$$W)$32+,+$)3%''$"$#++.$41,$21()%#/f PRO Planning|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h6Aoi$14$+:03L$21()%#/$32,1(/21(3$ c1)1*1>$5$)+&1#.$0,1-'+:$V2%&2$:"%#'L$&1#&+#3,"3+)$1#$M,%)23%\ #"$%)$32+$,+/%)3,"3%1#$14$32+$010('"3%1#>$W#$32+$&1::(3+,)`$)L)3+:H$ "$'13$14$0+10'+$V1,<$%#$32+$&"0%3"'$-(3$'%*+$"#.$",+$,+/%)3+,+.$%#$ 32+%,$21:+$31V#)$%#$32+$&1(#3,L)%.+>$K(,%#/$32+$V++<H$32+)+$0+1\ 0'+$&1::(3+$."%'L$31$32+$&%3L$1,$+*+#$'%*+$32+,+>$92+)+$0+10'+$",+$ #13$&1(#3+.$")$,+)%.+#3)$14$M,%)23%#"$"#.$)1$#(:-+,)$41,$0(-'%&$ 3,"#)01,3$",+$4"')+$-(3$"')1$32+$+Q"&3$#(:-+,)$14$,+)%.+#3)$",+$4"'\ )+>$92+$#"3%1#"'$.%*%)%1#$14$4(#.)$-L$2+".$0+,$:(#%&%0"'%3L$'+"*+)$ M,%)23%#"$V%32$/"0)$%#$32+%,$0(-'%&$-(./+3)>$92+$2%/2$#(:-+,$14$
7@@
0,1Y+&3%1#)$V+,+$%#$4"*1,$14$32+$&1#)3,(&3%1#$&1:0"#%+)$V2%&2$V1,<$ for their own profit. They could build lots of apartments. The chan\ /+$14$)L)3+:H$31V",.)$32+$4,++$:",<+3$+&1#1:L$"#.$32+$0,%*"3%e"\ 3%1#$14$41,:+,$G1&%"'%)3$'"#.$"#.$+#3+,0,%)+)$2")$.%)$-"'"#&+.$32+$ .+*+'10:+#3>$921)+$+&1#1:%&$:%/,"#3)$,+)('3+.$.(+$31$32+$V,1#/$ "00,1"&2$%#$32+$*%''"/+)$V2%&2$41&()+.$1#$,+-(%'.%#/$32+$21()%#/$ )+&31,$-(3$'"&<+.$%#$"#$".+[("3+$"00,1"&2$31$32+$)1&%1\+&1#1:%\ &"'$")0+&3> Interviewer|$$]2"3$&"#$V+$'+",#$4,1:$M,%)23%#"f PRO Planning|$$d1($#++.$31$)+3$"$0'"#$41,$.+*+'10:+#3$31$0,1\ &++.$"43+,$"$&%*%'$)3,%4+$'%<+$%#$c1)1*1$2"00+#+.>$]+$#1V$)++$32"3$ %4$ L1($ .1#`3$ 2"*+$ 32%)$ %#)3,(:+#3$ %#.%*%.("')$ V%''$ 3"<+$ ".*"#3"/+$ 14$32"3$4,++.1:$"#.$#+/'+&3$32+$&1::1#$/,1(#.$14$"#$(,-"#$+#\ *%,1#:+#3>$ 53$ 32%)$ :1:+#3H$ 0'"##%#/$ %)$ :+,+$ "$ 311'$ 41,$ .":"/+$ &1#3,1'H$31$)++$V2"3$01))%-%'%3%+)$",+$32+,+$%#$1,.+,$31$,+/+#+,"3+$ ",+")$ 31V",.)$ :1,+$ 0+10'+$ 4,%+#.'L$ 0'"&+)>$ W3$ %)$ 01%/#"#3$ 31$ )++$
32"3$1#$1(3)<%,3)$14$&%3+)$"&3("'$%#41,:"'$)+33'+:+#3)$2"*+$"00+"\ ,+.$ "#.$ 32"3$ 32+$ [("'%3L$ 14$ &+,3"%#$ #+%/2-1,211.)$ )21V$ +[("''L$ difficult circumstances to the living quality. It is to think of the local &"0"&%3%+)H$31$/(%.+$"#.$"))%)3$32+:$.+*+'10%#/$"$-+33+,$0'"&+$41,$ '%*%#/>$d1($#++.$"$&1:0,+2+#)%*+$"00,1"&2$"#.$32%#<$"-1(3$.%44+\ ,+#3$)&+#",%1)$41,$32+$&%3L>$53$32+$)":+$3%:+H$%#$M,%)23%#"$"''$32+$41,\ :+,$0'"#)$V+,+$/%*+#$32+$)3"3()$14$#1#\"00'%&"-'+$"#L:1,+$+*+#$ 321(/2$)1:+$*+,L$-")%&$+'+:+#3)$")$,1".$"#.$3+&2#%&"'$%#4,")3,(&\ 3(,+$ V+,+$ ".+[("3+$ "#.$ V1('.$ 2"*+$ /%*+#$ )1:+$ /(%."#&+>$ a1V$ &('3(,"'$2+,%3"/+$2".$-++#$'",/+'L$.+:1'%)2+.H$0(-'%&$)0"&+)$",+$ )&",&+$"#.$011,$14$[("'%3L$"#.$/,++#$"#.$#"3(,"'$":+#%3%+)$"':1)3$ #1#\+Q%)3%#/q$32+$0(-'%&$+'+:+#3)>$a+*+,32+'+))H$32+$#+V$"00,1"&2$ %)$ "$ )3+0$ 41,V",.$ "#.$ %)$ 0(33%#/$ 0",3%&%0"3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ )1&%+3L$ %#31$ "&&1(#3>$$5$#++.$41,$)1&%+3"'$"V",+#+))H$"&3%*%):$14$&1::(#%3%+)H$ %#*1'*+:+#3$ %#$ %#%3%"3%*+)$ &1::(#%3L$ &1(#&%')H$ '1&"'$ (#%3%+)$ %#$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.)$41,$&'1)+$,+)%.+#3$,+'"3%1#)H$:1,+$3,"#)0",+#&LH$%#\ *%3"3%1#)$31$:(#%&%0"'$0'"#)$"#.$%.+")$",+$+))+#&+$%#$"$.+:1&,"3%&$ 0,1&+))$"#.$+)3"-'%)2%#/$"$'",/+$-1.L$14$)1&%+3"'$)(001,3>$
I'3)0$:/03; F.#&)%'#%$ Kosovo Architecture Foundation $
$
$
$
78$R+-,(",L$6!7AH$M,%)23%#"
Interviewer_ What is the socio-spatial structure of a post-conflict &%3Lf I'3)0|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q$32+$ G+,-%"#$&1::(#%3L$%)$%#+Q%)3+#3$%#$M,%)23%#"$"#.$32+$)":+$/1+)$41,$ 32+$T1:"$1#+> Interviewer|$$]2"3$.1$L1($32%#<$%)$+))+#3%"'$V2+#$.+)%/#%#/$%#$"$ post-conflict city? I'3)0|$ n%*%#/$ :1,+$ %:01,3"#&+$ 31$ 32+$ )1&%"'$ %))(+)H$ ,"32+,$ 32"#$ )0"3%"'H$L1($)21('.#`3$/1$%#31$"$0'"&+$V%32$"$3"-('"\,")"$:+#3"'%3L$ that nothing ever existed before me! Do build a post conflict city 3"<+)$:1,+$32"#$)2++,$#(:-+,$14$)[(",+$:+3+,)> Interviewer_ What is the image of a post conflict city?
,+&+%*+.$"#L$"#)V+,)$,+/",.%#/$32+%,$#++.)$31$,+-(%'.$1,$&1#)3,(&3$ #+V$)3,(&3(,+)H$)1$32+L$Y()3$)3",3+.$-(%'.%#/$V%321(3$"#L$0+,:%)\ )%1#>$ ]2"3$ :".+$ %3$ +*+#$ V1,)+$ V")$ 32+$ 4"&3$ 32"3$ 1#+$ 0",3%&('",$ ,+0,+)+#3"3%*+$ 14$ IaFWc$ V+#3$ 0(-'%&$ "#.$ .+&'",+.$ j32+,+$ %)$ #1$ G+,-%"#$,+/%:+$"#L$:1,+$31$)310$L1($4,1:$-(%'.%#/$L1(,$21:+)zk$$ That basically fuelled construction in Prishtina. The first person 32"3$,+"''L$3,%+.$31$)310$32+$32%#/)$2"00+#%#/$%#$32+$&%3L$V")$32+$ first local appointed head of the planning department Rexhep S(&%H$V21$Y()3$4+V$."L)$"43+,$.+&'",%#/$32+$"''$1(3$V",$31$32+$%''+/"'$ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ V")$ /(##+.$ .1V#$ -L$ "#$ (#<#1V#$ %#.%*%.("'>$ W3$ "''$ ,+3(,#+.$31$)[(",+$e+,1$"#.$0+10'+$"/"%#$)3",3+.$V%32$32+$%''+/"'$ &1#)3,(&3%1#>$W3$V")#`3$,+"''L$(#$3%''$6!7!$V2+#$32+$&%3L$)3",3+.$+#\ 41,&%#/$ &1#)3,(&3%1#$ ,+/('"3%1#)$ "#.$ "/"%#$ L1($ 2".$ 0+10'+$ 32"3$ would bribe the officials and occupy public land. The first person 31$,+"''L$)310$"''$14$32+$%''+/"'$&1#)3,(&3%1#$V")$32+$&(,,+#3$.%,+&31,$ 14$0'"##%#/$S%-(,#$5'%(>$J(3$")$W$)"%.$32+$:"Y1,$.":"/+$31$M,%)2\ 3%#"$ V")$ .1#+$ .(,%#/$ IaFWc$ 3%:+H$ "':1)3$ 7!!$ -(%'.%#/)$ V2%&2$ were protected by the state till 1999 were destroyed in the first 3V1$01)3\V",$L+",)H$:1,+$32"#$BH!!!$)3,(&3(,+)$V+,+$&1#)3,(&3+.$ 1#$0(-'%&$'"#.$3%''$6!!A$"#.$32+,+$",+$:1,+$32"#$@!!H!!!$%''+/"'$ )3,(&3(,+)$Y()3$%#$32+$&%3L$14$M,%)23%#"$32"3$V+,+$,+/%)3+,+.$-L$32+$ 0'"##%#/$.+0",3:+#3$.(,%#/$6!7E\6!7A>$
Interviewer|$92%)$#1#\,+/('"3+.$-(%'.%#/$-11:$31$)2+'3+,$"'$32+$ I'3)0|$$$X#+$ 14$ )(44+,%#/$ "#.$ 210+>$ d1($ .1$ )++$ .+)3,(&3%1#$ h,+3(,#%#/i$&%3%e+#)$14$32+$&%3L$"#.$-+L1#.$V")$"$0,%*"3+$%#%3%"3%*+>$ throughout a post conflict city like Sarajevo, but you also saw hope ]")$ 32+%,$ #1$ &1#&+,#$ 1,$ h%#3+,#"3%1#"'i$ 1,/"#%)"3%1#$ 32"3$ 311<$ %#$0+10'+H$%#$32+$V"L$32+L$3,%+.$31$,+-(%'.$32+%,$21:+)H$#+%/2-1(,\ &2",/+$1*+,$32+$#++.+.$)2+'3+,$#(:-+,)f$ 211.)H$&%3%+)> I'3)0|$ $ d+)$ %3$ V")$ 313"''L$ "$ 0,%*"3+$ %#%3%"3%*+$ "#.$ L+)$ 32+$ %#3+,\ Interviewer|$ $ W#$ 92+$ a+32+,'"#.)H$ 32+$ ,+-(%'.%#/$ V")$ *+,L$ 0,"/\ #"3%1#"'$ 1,/"#%)"3%1#)$ V+,+$ #13$ &1#&+,#+.$ 3%''$ "43+,$ 32+$ -%//+)3$ :"3%&H$0'"##+.$"#.$/1*+,#:+#3$'+.$"43+,$]]mmH$21V$.%.$%3$/1$%#$ .":"/+$V")$.1#+>$W4$L1(`,+$,+4+,,%#/$31$32+$"/+#&%+)$32"3$,+-(%'3$ .+)3,1L+.$21()+)$32"3)$"$.%44+,+#3$)31,LH$"/+#&%+)$)(&2$")$IG5WK$ c1)1*1$"43+,$32+$V",f$ .%.$ ,+-(%'.$ :"#L$ 0,%*"3+$ 21()+)$ -(3$ 32+$ :"Y1,%3L$ 14$ 32+$ .+)3,1\ I'3)0|$$ ]+''$ V2"3$ 2"00+#+.$ %#$ c1)1*1$ )21('.#`3$ 2"00+#$ %#$ L+.$21()+)$V+,+$%#$*%''"/+)H$"#.$32+,+$V+,+$#1$&")+)$14$&1''+&3%*+$ other post conflict cities in the world, and really shouldnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t be left 21()%#/$-'1&<$32"3$V")$,+&1#)3,(&3+.$1,$-(%'3$"43+,$32+$V",>$92+,+$ 31$Ia\_"-%3"3$")$32+L$",+$32+$:"%#$&"()+$14$32+$0,1-'+:>$c1)1*1$ V+,+$ &")+)$ 14$ )1&%"'$ 21()+)$ 32"3$ V+,+$ -(%'3$ -L$ 32+$ /1*+,#:+#3$ ")$L1($<#1V$V")$".:%#%)3+,+.$-L$32+$Ia$F%))%1#$%#$c1)1*1H$)21,3$ 41,+%/#$ "#.$ '1&"'$ "#.$ 32+L$ V+,+$ ,+"''L$ -(%'3$ V%321(3$ 0"L%#/$ "#L$ IaFWc>$$W3)$*+,L$%#3+,+)3%#/$V2"3$2"00+#+.$Y()3$:1#32)$%4$#13$."L)$ "33+#3%1#$31$32+$)1&%"'$%#3+/,"3%1#$14$32+$:",/%#"'%)+.$/,1(0)$32"3$ after the conflict ended. There was no Serbian municipal authority benefited. )1$IaFWc$$:1*+.$%#$31$&1*+,$32+$*"&((:$"#.$Y()3$'%<+$%#$"$<%.)$ /":+$ 1,$ )1:+32%#/$ )%:%'",$ 31$ :1#101'LH$ #":+.$ 0+10'+$ 32"3$ ",+$ Interviewer|$$]2"3$%)$.%44+,+#3$%#$M,%)23%#"$&1:0",+.$31$132+,$%#\ /1%#/$31$,(#$32+$&%3L$.+0",3:+#3)$h1#+$14$32+:$32+$0'"##%#/$1#+i>$ 41,:"''L$-(%'.$(,-"#$",+")$%#$32+$V1,'.f$ W$:()3$#13+$32"3$"''$V+,+$41,+%/#z$$5)$%#$32+$d(/1)'"*$3%:+$"#.$'"3+,$ %#$G+,-%"#$3%:+$L1($,+"''L$&1('.#`3$+*+#$&1#)3,(&3$"$):"''$V11.+#$ I'3)0_ Well fist and foremost, the context. Other than that it )2+.$V%321(3$"$0,10+,$.1&(:+#3"3%1#$"#.$0+,:%))%1#$-L$32+$"(\ .+0+#.)$V%32$V21:$L1($&1:0",+$%3z$W4$%3)$W)3"#-('$32"#$#132%#/$ 321,%3%+)>$ G1$ 0+10'+$ V+#3$ 31$ 32+$ &%3L$ "(321,%3%+)$ "#.$ 32+%,$ #+*+,$ .%44+,)H$%4$L1($&1:0",+$%3$31$F(:-"%$32"#$%3)$0,1-"-'L$&1#)3,(&3%1#$ 7@E
:"3+,%"'H$1,$%4$L1($&1:0",+$%3$31$32+$4"*+'")$32"#$0,1-"-'L$32+$:1,+$ )3,(&3(,+$"#.$)+,*%&+)$32"3$&2","&3+,%)+$&1#3+:01,",L$U(,10+"#$&%\ .+&+#3$&1#)3,(&3%1#$:"3+,%"'$"#.$:1,+$,+)0+&3$41,$'%/23$"#.$3L01\ 3%+)>$5)$L1($0,1-"-'L$)"V$41,$L1(,)+'4$:"#L$#+%/2-1(,211.)$V+,+$ '1/L$+#"-'%#/$:1,+$,"3%1#"'$()+$14$32+$'"#.H$32"3$%)$%#$32+$&%3L$%3)+'4>$ .+*")3"3+.$"43+,$32+$V",$"#.$32+L$'1)3$32+%,$%:"/+$14$0'"#+.$#+%/\ 2-1(,211.)$)1$",&2%3+&3(,+$V%)+$%3$%)#`3$"$j-+"(3%4('k$&%3L$+%32+,>$5$ Interviewer|$$_1V$%)$%3$31$'%*+$%#$M,%)23%#"f$ &%3L$ 32"3$ %)$ &2","&3+,%)+.$ -L$ )%.+V"'<)$ 3"<+#$ -L$ &",)H$ %#".+[("3+$ 0(-'%&$ 3,"#)01,3H$ #1$ -%<+$ '"#+)H$ #1$ &1::(#%3L$ &+#3+,)H$ ,(--%)2H$ I'3)0|$$ W3$.+0+#.)$%#$V2"3$&"0"&%3L$.1$L1($V"#3$:+$31$"#)V+,$ +3&>$921)+$.1#`3$:"<+$%3$"$0'+")"#3$0'"&+$31$'%*+$%#>$J(3$:1,+$32"#$ 32%)$[(+)3%1#H$%4$%3)$%#$:L$&"0"&%3L$")$"#$",&2%3+&3$"#.$(,-"#$.+)%/\ the insufficient physical infrastructure it is the social ones that are #+,$32"#$W$32%#/$32"3$%#$:"#L$%#)3"#&+)$M,%)23%#"$:%))+)$*%3"'$%#4,"\ ,+"''L$:%))%#/>
Eliza Hoxha Urban Planner University of Prishtina $
$
$
$
78$F"L$6!7AH$M,%)23%#"
Interviewer|$$]2"3$V")$)%3("3%1#$-+41,+$32+$V",f Eliza|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n+,:"#LH$GV%3e+,'"#.H$5()\ 3,%"H$J+'/%(:$"#.$a+32+,'"#.)$&'()3+,+.>$W#$32"3$3%:+H$"':1)3$+*+,L$ 4":%'L$2".$"$,+'"3%*+$"-,1".$V21$V")$)+#.%#/$:1#+L$21:+>$92+L$ 1,/"#%e+.$32%)$0","''+'$)L)3+:$14$+.(&"3%1#$%#$1,.+,$41,$32+%,$4":%'L$ "#.$%3)$&2%'.,+#$31$&1#3%#(+$V%32$"#$+.(&"3%1#>$]2%&2$V")$4(#.+.$ 41,$@o$-L$32+$.%")01,"H$%3$V")$&"''+.$32+$.%")01,"$4(#.$41,$+.(&"\ 3%1#$"#.$2+"'32>$92%)$<+03$32+$5'-"#%"#)$%#$c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nterviewer|$$]2"3$%)$32+$)%3("3%1#$14$2%)31,%&"'$#+%/2-1,211.)$14$ M,%)23%#"f Eliza|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d1($V%''$)++$ 0+10'+$3"<%#/$&",+$14$)0"&+$#13$4(,32+,$32+#$32+%,$32,+)21'.>$92+L$ define it, wall it, put fences. So, you have all these nice spots or %)'"#.)$%#$M,%)23%#"$"#.$%#$-+3V++#$"$'13$14$(#V"#3+.$)0"&+)>$_1V$ &"#$ V+$ &2"#/+$ 32+$ )%3("3%1#$ 41,$ 0+10'+$ 31$ 10+#$ 32+%,$ :%#.$ "#.$ &2"#/+$"$'%33'+$32+%,$-+2"*%1,$"#.$-+&1:+$:1,+$10+#$31$32+$0(\ -'%&f$U*+,L-1.L$&1#3,%-(3+)$31$32"3$%#$.%44+,+#3$V"L)H$-(3$%4$L1($.1$ #132%#/$"3$'+")3$.1#`3$.+)3,1L$%3$1,$32,1V$/",-"/+>$92%)$%)$"#$(,-"#$ :+#3"'%3L$"#.$32%)$)21('.$-+$,+)2"0+.$-%3$-L$-%3> Interviewer|$$]2"3$",+$32+$,+")1#)$32"3$#+%/2-1,211.)$'%<+$K1.1\ #"$",+$)(44+,%#/$#1V"."L)f$ Eliza|$W$2"*+$#13$)3(.%+.$K1.1#"$#+%/2-1,211.$%#$.+3"%'$-(3$W$&"#$ )"L$ "$ &1(0'+$ :L$ &1#&+,#)$ ,+/",.%#/$ 32+$ &1#.%3%1#$ 14$ 32+$ .+*+\ '10:+#3)$ "#.$ ",+$ ,+0'%&"-'+$ "')1$ %#$ 32%)$ #+%/2-1,211.>$ R%,)3H$ 32+$ &%3L$-+&":+$'%<+$32%)$%#$/+#+,"'$)0+&%"''L$"43+,$32+$6!!!$V2+#$32+$ :"%#$",&2%3+&3$V")$)213>$53$32"3$:1:+#3H$2+$V")$3,L%#/$31$.1$"$*%\ )%1#$"-1(3$32+$&%3L$"#.$1,%+#3$32+)+$.+*+'10:+#3)$"#.$)310$%''+/"'$ &1#)3,(&3%1#)$"#.$)310$32+)+>$543+,$32"3$#1$1#+$%#$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$ 0,"&3%&"''L$)1$31$)"L$&",+.$"-1(3$V2"3$V")$/1%#/$1#>$92%)$2")$31$.1$ V%32$32+$)2",+.$&1:0+3+#&+)$V%32$32+$:"L1,H$)2",+.$&1:0+3+#&+)$ -+3V++#$%#3+,#"3%1#"'\$"#.$'1&"'$0+10'+$-+&"()+$14$32%)$0,1*%)%1#"'$ )+'4\/1*+,#"#&+$%#)3%3(3%1#)$14$c1)1*1$.%.$#13$2"*+$01V+,>$W#$32+$ period from ’99 – ’02 when the first elections came, this provisional )+'4\/1*+,#"#&+$)L)3+:$V")$#13$%#$01V+,$"#.$32+)+$.+&%)%1#$:"\ <%#/$Y1-)$V+,+$:"%#'L$3"<+#$-L$%#3+,#"3%1#"'$V1,<+,)>$5:$#13$-'"\ :%#/$"#L1#+$-(3$%4$L1($2"*+$&1:0+3+#&+)$31$1,%+#3$1#$32+$&%3L$%3)$ conflicting elements you should take action and not give permits. G1H$4,1:$32"3$:1:+#3$1#$%3$V")$#13$32"3$#1-1.L$&",+.$-(3$0+10'+$ V+,+$"4,"%.$:"L-+$31$&1#4,1#3$V%32$32+$)&+#+$14$%''+/"'%3L$"#.$:1\ #+L$'"(#.,L>$]2L$V")$2+$)213f$_+$V")$32%#<%#/$"-1(3$V2"3$V1('.$ 2"*+$-++#$/11.$"#.$&1,,+&3$41,$M,%)23%#"$-(3$:"L-+$2+$V")$)3+0\ 0%#/$ %#$ )1:+1#+`)$ %#3+,+)3f$ _+$ V")$ #13$ "$ 01'%3%&%"#q$ 2+$ V")$ 32+$ 2+".$ 14$ 32+$ I,-"#%):$ .+0",3:+#3$ "#.$ <#+V$ V2"3$ 2+$ V")$ .1%#/$ -+&"()+$2+$:".+$32+$(,-"#$0'"#$14$7Z8B>$_+$V")$3,L%#/$31$&10+$ V%32$32+$#+V$&1#.%3%1#)H$32+$4,++$:",<+3$+&1#1:L$)%3("3%1#>$92%)$ V")$&1:0'+3+'L$#+V$31$c1)1*1$-+&"()+$-+41,+$32+$V",$32+$)3"3+$ V")$1V#%#/$32+$'"#.H$.+*+'10%#/$32+$'"#.$"#.$:"#"/%#/$32+$'"#.>$ U*+,L32%#/$32"3$V")$0(-'%&$"#.$"')1$&1''+&3%*+$V")$3"<+#$&",+$41,$-L$ 32+$)3"3+H$-+)%.+)$32+$0,%*"3+$21()+)>$U*+,L32%#/$+')+$V")$%#*+)3+.H$ :"#"/+.H$.+*+'10+.$"#.$1V#+.$-L$32+$)3"3+>$R1,$32+$0,%*"3+$32+\ ,+$V+,+$14$&1(,)+$)3,%&3$,('+)$"-1(3$32+$3L0+$14$-(%'.%#/$"#.$%4$%3$V")$ "#$X331:"#$21()+$%3$V")$#13$31$&2"#/+$"#L32%#/$"-1(3$%3> G1H$32%)$%)$V2L$.(,%#/$^Z!`)$32+$%''+/"'%3L$)3",3+.$")$"$#++.>$W#$32"3$ 3%:+$"$0,%*"3+$5'-"#%"#$21()+$V")$/%*+#$31$-+&1:+$"$)&211'$32+$
7@B
#++.$V")$32+,+$31$-(%'.$+Q3+#)%1#)$1#$32+$0'13$41,$"$'%*%#/$0'"&+>$ 92%)$V")$32+$):"''$)&"'+$14$%''+/"'%3L$-+&"()+$14$32+$#++.$"#.$32%)$ "44+&3+.$ 32+$ 3L01'1/L$ 14$ 21()+)>$ 5#.$ "43+,$ 32+$ V",$ 32%)$ -+&":+$ -11:%#/>$d1($&"#$)++$32+$+#32()%"):$%#$0,"&3%&"''L$"''$32+$.%:+#)%\ ons like socially, culturally, physically, financially and economy wise, 32+$4,++.1:$31$.1$V2"3+*+,$L1($V"#3>$W3$V")$"$)1,3$14$,+'%+4$32"3$ #1$1#+$V")$&1#3,1''%#/$"#.$&",%#/$L1($"#L:1,+$"#.$0+10'+$&1('.$ .1$,+"''L$V2"3+*+,$32+L$V"#3+.>$G1:+$41,$32+$/11.$-(3$"')1$:"#L$ /,")0+.$V2"3$32+L$&1('.$/+3$-+&"()+$L1($2"*+$.%44+,+#3$3L0+$14$ 0+10'+>$]2"3$V")$0,1.(&+.$V")$:1,+$<%''%#/$32+$&%3L$32+#$/%*%#/$%3$ "#132+,$*"'(+H$"#$"..%3%1#"'$*"'(+>$J+&"()+$V2+,+$1#+$21()+$V")$ on a plot, now the plot was filled up to its limits and over it, and 32+#$"#132+,$1#+$"#.$"#132+,$1#+>$a1$)0"&+$41,$0",<%#/H$/,++#H$ /,++#+,L>$5#.$32%)$#13$Y()3$&1#&+,#)$Y()3$32+$0(-'%&$'%4+$-(3$"')1$32+$ &'%:"3+>$92+,+$V")$1#'L$&1#&,+3+$"#.$L1($&1('.$4++'$32"3$32+,+$V")$ #1$"%,$%#$32+$&%3L$"#L:1,+>$ J(3$ '+3$ :+$ &1#&+#3,"3+$ 1#$ 32+$ #+%/2-1,211.)>$ ]2"3$ 2"00+#+.$ V")$ V2+#$ 32+L$ )3",3+.$ 32+$ 0'"#$ 14$ 6!!EH$ 32+$ )3,"3+/%&$ 0'"#$ "#.$ 32+$):"''+,$,+/('"31,L$0'"#)$V+,+$:".+>$5''$32+)+$,+/('"31,L$0'"#)$ 41,$32+$#+%/2-1,211.)H$"#.$"')1$41,$K1.1#"H$0,"&3%&"''L$32+L$.1#`3$ ,+)0+&3$32+$1'.$0"33+,#>$F"L-+$32+$,1".$V")$<+03H$-(3$32+#$32+L$ V%.+#+.$32+$,1".$"#.$.+:1'%)2+.$)1:+$21()+)$%#$&")+)$1,$32+L$ /"*+$#+V$#(:-+,)$31$32+$2+%/23$14$-(%'.%#/)$%#$0",3)$-(3$.%.$#13$ &",+.$"-1(3$32+$+Q%)3%#/$21()+)$V2%&2$V+,+$1#'L$(0$31$6Bo$14$32"3$ 2+%/23>$ G1H$ #+V$ -(%'.%#/)$ V+,+$ #+Q3$ 31$ 1'.$ 21()+)$ "#.$ -'1&<%#/$ )(#$ "#.$ "%,$ 41,$ 32+$ +Q%)3%#/$ 3%))(+>$ R%,)3H$ V2"3$ 2"00+#+.$ 32+#$ %)$ 32"3$0+10'+$/"*+$(0$32+%,$21()+$31$-+$3,"#)41,:+.$-+&"()+$'%*%#/$ V")$#13$/11.$"#L:1,+>$G+&1#.H$32%)$e1#+$V")$#":+.$-L$32+$:(\ #%&%0"'%3L$")$2%)31,%&"'$e1#+H$-(3$41,$V2"3f$R1,$32+)+$&(,*+.$#",,1V$ ,1".)$ 32"3$ ",+$ 32+,+f$ a132%#/$ %)$ 2%)31,%&"'$ 32+,+$ "#L:1,+H$ "0",3$ 4,1:$)1:+$):"''$)013)>$W#$)1:+$0",3)H$1#'L$32+$0'13$.%*%)%1#)$1,$32+$ 4":%'%+)$32"3$&1('.$#13$"441,.$31$&2"#/+$32+%,$21()+$%)$V2+,+$L1($ &"#$)++$32+$2%)31,%&"'$0%&3(,+>$J(3$V2"3$W$":$32%#<%#/$%)$32"3$c1)1*1$ ")$"$)3"3+$&1#&+,#%#/$0'"##%#/$)3%''$2")#`3$&"03(,+.$32+$:1:+#3$14$ &10%#/$V%32$32+$#+V$+&1#1:%&$&1#.%3%1#)$41,$:"#L$,+")1#)>$R%,)3H$ 32"3$)3%''$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$32%#<)$32"3$32+L$2"*+$31$.1$+*+,L32%#/$-(3$ 32+L$&"##13$.(+$31$32+%,$-(./+3)>$92+L$.1#`3$)++$32+:)+'*+)$")$"$ /(%."#&+$0'"L+,$31$/(%.+$32+$0,1&+))$%#)3+".$32+L$)++$32+:)+'*+)$ ")$32+$"&3%1#$0'"L+,>$W3$%)$#13$")$%#$G1&%"'%):H$L1($&"##13$,+Y+&3$32+$ 0,%*"3+$41,&+)H$L1($2"*+$31$&10+$V%32$32+:H$31$-,%#/$32+:$"3$32+$ table. Why? Because there is still not a law that defines where the 01'%3%&"'$:1#+L$%)$&1:%#/$4,1:>$5''$32+)+$-%/$&1#)3,(&3%1#$&1:0"\ #%+)H$1,$:"Y1,$)01#)1,)$14$32+$01'%3%&"'$0",3%+)$2"*+$01V+,$32,1(/2$ financing the political sector. If one comes into power, they are +Q0+&3+.$ 31$ .+'%*+,$ )1:+32%#/>$ J+41,+$ 32+$ +'+&3%1#$ +*+,L32%#/$ %)$ (#.+,$32+$3"-'+$"#.$"43+,$+*+,L32%#/$)3"L)$(#.+,$32+$3"-'+>$W4$32+$ '"V$1#$)0"3%"'$0'"##%#/$)"L)$32"3$"''$32+$)3"<+21'.+,)$)21('.$-+$"$ 0",3$14$32+$0,1&+))H$321)+$V21$&"#$%:0"&3$32+$0'"#$"#.$321)+$V21$ ",+$%:0"&3+.$-L$32+$0'"#$14$32+$&%3LH$%#$32+$-+/%##%#/H$32+)+$32%#/)$ (#.+,$32+$3"-'+$V%''$#13$2"00+#>$G1H$%4$"$.+*+'10:+#3$V%''$2"00+#$ +*+,L-1.L$V%''$V%#H$-+&"()+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$V%''$:"<+$)(,+$32+L$2"*+$ their own interest and public interest is their first one. Since then, I .1#`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`3$2"00+#$ L+3$/+#+,"''L$%#$M,%)23%#">$92%,.H$"-1(3$0(-'%&$)02+,+H$32+,+$",+$.%4\ ficulties in managment and owning land for public places. Ther is '%33+,'L$#1$)L)3+:$32"3$%)$&1#3,%-(3%#/$31$%#&,+")+$)0"&+)$41,$0(-'%&$>
V"L$-+&"()+$L1($&"#$)++$V2"3$2")$-++#$0,1.(&+.$%#$32+$&%3L>$J(3$ )3%''$%3$%)$"$0,1&+))$"#.$32+$&%3L$%)$)(44+,%#/$4,1:$32"3$(#3%'$L1($"-)1,-$ 32+)+$-%/$&2"#/+)$)1&%"''L$"#.$&('3(,"''L$"#.$+&1#1:%&"''L>$]2"3$ L1($ &"#$ )++$ %#$ 32+$ &%3L$ &"#$ ,+"''L$ 01%#3$ 1(3$ V2"3$ V")$ 32+$ +#+,/L$ 14$32+$&%3L$"#.$%3)$&%3%e+#`)$4++'%#/)$"-1(3$"$V"L$14$'%*%#/>$J+&"()+$ %3$V")$"$4,++.1:$%#$+*+,L$)+#)+$"#.$%3$V")$32+$.+)%,+$31$.+*+'10$ %#$+*+,L$)+#)+$"#.$:"L-+$V%32$"$'"&<$14$<#1V'+./+$"-1(3$32+)+$ #+V$&1#.%3%1#)$+&1#1:%&"''L$"#.$01'%3%&"''L$"#.$:"L-+$)1:+-1.L$ "-()+.$32"3H$-(3$%3$%)$'%<+$32"3>$]+$",+$#13$32+$1#'L$&")+q$L1($:%/23$ )++$32"3$%#$:"#L$01)3\V",$&%3%+)>$-(3$32%)$%)$V2L$W$":$"4,"%.> J(3$%4$L1($)++$32+$-%/$0%&3(,+H$c1)1*1$V")$(#.+,.+*+'10+.$+*+#$ %#$ d(/1)'"*%"#$ 3%:+H$ "#.$ V2"3$ 132+,$ ]+)3+,#$ &%3%+)$ +Q0+,%+#&+.$ c1)1*1$+Q0+,%+#&+.$32"3$%#$"$.+&".+>$92%)$%)$V2"3$L1($)++$%#$32+$ 02L)%&"'$)3,(&3(,+H$#1-1.L$3"'<)$31$"#L-1.L$"#.$+*+,L-1.L$)++<)$ %3)$1V#$-()%#+))>$W4$L1($'11<$"3$32+$02L)%&"'$)3,(&3(,+$L1($)++$32"3$ #1-1.L$&",+.>$92%)$%)$#13$/11.H$0+10'+$",+$3"'<%#/$-(3$32+L$",+$#13$ .+-"3%#/$V%32$+"&2$132+,H$32+,+$%)$#1$&1::1#$/,1(#.>$92+$*%)%1#$ %#$32+$0"0+,$14$32+$:(#%&%0"'%3L$%)$"$*%)%1#$14$"$/,1(0$14$0+10'+$-(3$ )3%''$%3$%)$#13$"$*%)%1#$14$32+$&%3%e+#)>$d1($2"*+$31$-,%#/$32"3$+#+,/L$ %#$32+$0,1&+))>$92+$)+&1#.$%3$%)$32+$L1(#/)3+,)$"#.$+.(&"3+.$0+1\ 0'+$"#.$32+%,$+#+,/LH$32+L$",+$#13$0",3$14$32+$0,1&+))$-(3$32+L$&"#$ -,%#/$ :(&2$ :1,+$ 31$ 32+$ 0,1&+))$ 14$ &%3L$ :"<%#/>$ U*+,L-1.L$ 3"'<)$ "-1(3$32+$/11.$+#+,/L$14$32+$&%3L$"#.$%3)$0+10'+$-(3$V2L$",+$321)+$ 0+10'+$ #13$ %#3+/,"3+.$ %#$ 32+$ 0,1&+))$ 14$ 32"3$ )":+$ &%3Lf$ J+&"()+$ 32+$ :(#%&%0"'%3L$ %)$ #13$ 10+#$ +#1(/2>$ J+&"()+$ 32+$ 0,1&+))$ %)$ )3%''$ #13$&'+",$21V$V+$)21('.$/1$41,$32+$#+V$&%3L>$a+V$#13$%#$32+$)+#)+$ 14$.+:1'%)2%#/$%3$-(3$32%)$#+V$"/+#."$"-1(3$&10%#/$V%32$32+$&%3L$ "#.$V2+#$%3$&1:+)$31$M,%)23%#"$V+$)21('.$-+$:1,+$0,"&3%&"'$+*+#$ %#$32+$'"L+,)$32"3$V+$.1#`3$'%<+H$3"<+$:1:+#3$"#.$,+)0+&3$32+:>$J+\ &"()+$32+)+$'"L+,)$32+,+$%#$&%3L$"#.$V2"3$%3$-+&":+$-+&"()+$14$()>$ Interviewer_ What is the first step for municipal- and planning .+0",3:+#3)f Eliza_ Maybe this can be a nice moment to reflect and under\ )3"#.$V2"3$V+$V%''$#13$.1$"/"%#$%#$32+$4(3(,+$"#.$31$'+",#>$]+$.1#`3$ #++.$31$+,")+$32+:$+*+#$321(/2$"+)32+3%&"''L$"#.$*%)("''L$%3$%)$#13$ #%&+$ -(3$ %4$ 321)+$ 0+10'+$ '%*+$ 32+,+$ %#$ 2"00%#+))$ 32+L$ ",+$ %:01,\ 3"#3>$92%)$V")$#+*+,$.1#+$%#$M,%)23%#"H$32+$)1&%"'$")0+&3$14$32+$&%3LH$ V2L$&%3%e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e"3%1#H$U(,10+"#%)"3%1#H$Ia%\ )"3%1#$+3&>
Interviewer|$$]2"3$",+$L1(,$&1#&+,#)$,+/",.%#/$32+$)%3("3%1#f Eliza|$ R1,$32%,3++#$L+",)`$0+10'+$V+,+$3,"%#+.$"#.$+.(&"3+.$"#.$ /+33%#/$4":%'%",$V%32$32%)$#+V$'"V$"#.$+*+#$321(/2$#13$%#$32+$-+)3$ 7@A
APPENDIX 2 Local survey & Questionnaire
THE PUBLIC SURVEY written and visual questionnaire on urban conditions and public needs
Delft University of Technology
Thomas Victor Vink translated in Albanian by Vjollca Podvorica 7@8
What would you like to have in the streets / Dodona neighborhood? Çfarë dëshironi të keni në rrugët/lagjen tuaj Dodona?
Clear street use Qartësi për përdoruesin
Streetcrossing paths Kalim për këmbësorë
Parking spaces Vende parkimi
Community gardens / urban farming Kopshte të komunite t / fermat urbane
7 votes
8 votes
19 votes
10 votes
Places with shading Strehim
Urban greenery Gjelbërim
Pedestrian zones Zonat e këmbësorëve
Places for sitting / relaxing Vende për të ulur / çlodhur
4 votes
15 votes
13 votes
14 votes
Spaces for meeting friends Hapësira për të takuar miq
Places for children Vende për fëmijë
Street markets Tregjet rrugë
Social activities Aktivitete sociale
7 votes
12 votes
2 votes
15 votes
7@C
PYETËSOR: CILËSIA E JETËS DHE JETA SHOQËRORE/PUBLIKE NE KONTEKST URBAN Public survey about the neighborhoods quality of public life and spaces. Lagjja Dodona / Dodona neighborhood Pyetje të përgjithshme §
1. Cila është gjinia juaj? (What is your gender?)
§
2. Cila është moshta juaj? (What is your age?)
Mënyra e banimit (housing situation) §
3. Numri i njerëzve që jetojnë me ju (What is the number of people living with you?)
§
4. Madhësia e shtëpisë/banesës? (What is the size of the house?) o Më pak se 25m2 (smaller then 25m2) o 25 – 50 m2 o 50 – 100 m2 o Më shumë se 100 m2 (bigger then 100m2)
§
5. Hapësirat e jashtme i keni private apo i ndani me të tjerët. Keni: (Do you have one of the following:) o Ballkon (balcony) o Kopsht privat (Private garden) o Oborr te cilin e ndani me dike (shared courtyard) o Tjetër: (other)
§
6. Lloji i objektit të banimit? (Type of residence)
o o o o
Shtëpi historike (historical house) Shtëpi private e re (private new house) Objekt banesor (shumëkatësh) (apartment building high rise) Tjetër: Other
Përgjigje tjera varësisht nga i/e intervistuara (në marrëdhënie punë, punon në lagje, që sa vite jeton në lagje, grupi social etj.) (What is your employment status?)
Pyetje rreth cilësisë së jetës urbane (questions on the quality of urban life)
7. Cila është rëndësia e karakteristikave të mëposhtme urbane, si dhe kushteve në ambientin që ju rrethon në mënyrë direkte? (What is the importance of the following (urban) properties and conditions in your direct living environment?) (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) Aspak me Jo dhe aq me Neutral Deri diku me Shumë me rëndësi rëndësi rëndësi rëndësi Not Rather not Rather important Very important important important at all Shumëllojshmëria e programit & funksioneve Variety of program Pamjet e këndshme të rrugëve dhe ndërtesave §
7@Z
Visual pleasant streets Gjendja e ndërtesave përreth Conditions of buildings Afërsia e hapësirave pubike Close proximity to public space Sasia e hapësirave publike të gjelbëruara Amount of public green spaces Përzierja e kulturave & njerëzve (etni, të moshuar, fëmijë, etj) Mix of cultures Siguria në rrugë Street safety Numri i njerëzve me të cilët mund të ketë bashkëveprim Amount of people living close to interact with Shërbimet publike & ndërtesat e dedikuara për komunitet Public services & community buildings Vende për ndërveprim social Places for social interaction Qasje në këmbë Accessibility by foot Qasje me veturë Accessibility by car Qasje me transport publik Accessibility by public transport Tjetër: Other:
8. Sa të kënaqur jeni në përgjithësi, në shkallën 0 deri 10, me vendin ku aktualisht jetoni How satisfied would you say you are on a scale from 0-10 with your current place of living? Shumë i/e pakënaqur Shumë i/e kënaqur 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 §
Vlerësimi i të qenurit i/e kënaqur me kontekstin fizik (evaluations of the satisfaction with the physical context)
§
9. Ju lutem tregoni/shënoni se sa pajtoheni me deklarimet e mëposhtme. Niveli juaj i kënaqshmërisë lidhur me gjendjen fizike urbane në ambientin që ju rrethon në mënyrë direkte, në Dodona. (please indicate to what extend you agree or disagree with each of the following statements. Your satisfaction level in relation to the urban physical situations in your direct living environment, Dodona.
7E!
(1) Nuk pajtohem aspak Disagree strongly
(2) Nuk pajtohem disagree
(3) Neutral
Kushtet e jetesës janë të një standardi të mirë Living conditions are up to good standards Balans i mirë mes zonave të hapura dhe atyre të ndërtuara Open and build-up areas are wellbalanced Hapësirë shumë e vogël mes ndërtesave There is too little space between buildings Organizimi i hapësirës krijon rehati The organization of space is comforatable Nganjëherë ndërtesat kanë madhësi të tepruar The size of buildings is too excessive at some point Lëvizja në këmbë është e këndshme It is pleasant to move around on foot Pamja e ndërtesavë është e këndshme The look of builings is pleasent Mundësitë për të shfrytëzuar hapësirat e gjelbruara janë të mira Opportunities to use green space are good Mundësitë për të shfrytëzuar hapësirat publike janë të mira Opportunities to use public space are good Ecja është e këndshme Walking is a pleasant activity in Dodona Mundësitë e socializimit janë të mira Social interaction possibilities are good Hapësira të mjaftueshme në rrugë për të kaluar kohën jashtë Enough space in the street to spend time outside Hapësira cilësore për të zhvilluar aktivitete jashtë Quality space is provided to pursue your choice of activities outside
Nëse keni elemente tjera me të cilat nuk jeni të kënaqur në lagjen tuaj, ju lutem shënoni: Other elements you are not satisfied with in your neighborhood please indicated:
7E7
(4) Pajtohem agree
(5) Pajtohem plotësisht Agree strongly
Hulumtim i jetës shoqërore lokale, socializimi me të tjerët (Exploration of local public life)
§
10. I njoh fqinjët në rrugën time. (I know my neighbors)
o o o o
§
Pothuajse të gjithë (most of them) Disa (a few) Asnjë (none)
11. Më pëlqen jeta shoqërore dhe atmosfera në lagjen time. (I like the public life and atmosphere in my neighborhood)
o o o o
§
Po, të gjithë (yes all of them)
Po, gjithnjë (yes, always) Po, mirëpo konteksti nuk ofron hapësirë (yes, but the context does not provide adequate spaces) Kaloj më shumë kohë jashtë lagjes (I spend more time outside the neighborhood) Nuk ndihem i/e lidhur me lagjen (I don’t feel attached to it)
12. Pyetje lidhur me sjelljen tuaj në jetën shoqërore/publike në lagje. (Questions on your behaviour in the public life of the neighborhood) (1) Asnjëherë never
(2) Ndonjëherë sometimes
Ndihem pjesë e komunitetit në lagjen time I feel part of a community in my neighborhood E kaloj kohën e lirë jashtë në lagje I spend free time outside in the neighborhood Marrë pjesë në aktivitete sociale I engage in social activities Mundohem të kontaktoj/socializohem me të tjerët kur jam jashtë I try to make contact when am outside Takohem me shokë në hapësira publike I meet with friends in public places I takoj shokët & familjen jashtë lagjes I meet with friends & family outside the neighborhood I ftoj shokët & familjen të vijnë në lagjen time I invite friends & familiy to come to my neighborhood Jam i/e interesuar të bëj shokë të ri në lagje I am interested in making new friends in the neighborhood Marrë pjesë në tubime publike I participate in public gatherings
7E6
(3) Herë pas here occasionally
(4) Shumicën e kohës Most of the time
(5) Gjithmonë always
§
13. Cilat janë arsyet e mundshme, lidhur me jetën shoqërore/publike, për shkak të cilave do të largoheshit nga Dodona? (mund të ketë më shumë së një përgjigje) (What are possible reasons for leaving Dodona related to the public life (more answers possible)) o Niveli i sigurisë rrugore (aksidente, krim, trotuare të dëmtuara, etj.) (level of street safety) o Niveli i kushteve të banimit (Level of housing conditions) o Hapësira publike të pakta (scares facilitation of public spaces) o Sasi e paktë e elementeve dhe hapësirave të gjelbëruara (scares amounts of green amenities) o Mundësitë e ndërveprimit me fqinjët (opportunities to interact with neighbors) o Qasje në këmbë nëpër lagje (accessibility by foot) o Qasje me veturë (accessibility by car) o Mbipopullim i lagjes (the crowdedness of the neighborhood) o Tjetër: ___________________________ Other: 14. Pyetjet e mëposhtme kanë të bëjnë me pikëpamjet personale për të ardhmen (The following questions are about personal views towards the future)
§
Do të kaloja më shumë kohë jashtë në qoftë se do të kishtë hapësira cilësore? (I would spend more time outside if quality spaces were provided)
§
Është me rëndësi të ketë një komunitetit të bashkuar në lagje (It is important to have some form of a cohesive neighborhood community)
§
Familja ime janë shokët e mi, apo lagjja ime është familja ime? (My family are my friends rather than my neighborhood is my family)
§
Vendtakime të reja në lagje do të më inkurajonin për të kaluar më shumë kohë jashtë (New meeting places in the neighborhood would encourage me to go out more in the street)
§
Do të dëshiroja të jem pjesë e jetës sociale në lagje (I would like to be part of the neighborhoods social life)
§
Hapësirat publike janë të nevojshme për një jetë më të mirë shoqërore/publike në lagje (Public spaces are needed for a better neighborhood public life)
§
Pikëpamje tjera për një të ardhme me të mirë lidhur me jetën shoqërore/publike në lagjen tuaj? (other views towards a better future in your neighborhood public life)
7E@
APPENDIX 3
9:
;<
R&9&-2%.+-7&$&+-'%#,(%4*%$+%2++7%'$#-7#,7'
C=@B>
P*(-%#-7%54&07S4*%#,(#'%#,(%1(00S5#0#-.(7
CH@E> C=@B> DF@E>
T"(,(%&'%(-+42"%'*#.(%<%7&'$#-.(%5($1((-%54&07&-2'
?D@F>
T"(%+,2#-&U#$&+-%+/%'*#.(%&'%.+)/+,$#50( !"#$%&'%$"(%'&U(%+/%$"(%"+4'(:
!"#$%&'%$"(%$8*(%+/%,('&7(-.(:
E==^%)D BA@?>
]&'$+,&.%]+4'( DE@A>
K*#,$)(-$ BC@G>
V$%&'%*0(#'#-$%$+%)+9(%#,+4-7%+-%/++$%3*"8'&.#06
GD@D> DF@E>
T"(%0++W%+/%54&07&-2'%&'%*0(#'#-$
=>
B@C>
=>
=>
B@C> EC>
=>
EC>
EC>
EC>
B@C>
DF@E> CH@E> DF@E>
?@A>
=>
B@C> BA@?> CB@?>
B@C>
?@A>
B@C> CB@?> CB@?> DF@E> C=@B> DF@E> DF@E>
N+.&#0%&-$(,#.$&+-%*+''&5&0&$&('%#,(%2++7
!"#$%+4$7++,%'*#.('%"#'%$"(% *,+*(,$8:
=>
BA@?> EA@?> DE@A>
!#0W&-2%&'%#%*0(#'#-$%#.$&9&$8%&-%X+7+-#%3/4-.$&+-#06
!"#$%&'%$"(%"+4'("+07%'&U(:
EC>
T"(%'&U(%+/%$"(%54&07&-2'%&'%#$%#**,+*,&#$(%'&U('
P**+,$4-&$&('%$+%4'(%*450&.%'*#.('%#,(%2++7
O,&9#$(%-(1%"+4'( BA@?>
EC> CH@E> EA@B>
EC> DE@A> DF@E> DF@E>
P**+,$4-&$&('%$+%4'(%2,((-%'*#.(%#,(%2++7
G=SE==)D BA@?>
#2,((%'$,+-208
L(GD@D>
#2,((
!+)(BA@?>
7&'#2,((%'$,+-208
!"#$%&'%8+4,%#2(:
!"#$%&'%8+4,%2(-7(,:
7&'#2,((
=7,-",%&'()'/)%*#)$,%&$/,>%&'()4&%*)%*#)6*.$&>,-)>'(%#?%
2#(#0,-)+"#$%&'($
-(&$"(,%#2,((%-+,%7&'#2,((
Results of the local survey in Dodona
=>
EC>
B@C>
EC>
B@C> CH@E> CH@E>
B@C>
Y-+42"%'*#.(%&-%$"(%'$,(($%$+%'*(-7%$&)(%+4$'&7(
CB@?>
?@A> CB@?> DE@A>
=>
Z4#0&$8%'*#.(%&'%*,+9&7(7%$+%*4,'4(%8+4,%."+&.(%+/%#.$&9&$&('
C=@B>
B@C> CB@?> C=@B>
=>
P$"(,%(0()(-$'%8+4,%#,(%-+$%'#$&'/&(7%1&$" &-%8+4,%-(&2"5+,"++7%*0(#'(%&-7&.#$(
A%**0 EC>
[&2%7&//(,(-.(%5($1((-%*#,W%<%-(&2"5+,"++7%+**+,$4-&$&('%/+,%'+.&#0%&-$(,#.$&+\+%)4-&.&*#0%&-&$&#$&9('%+,%'4**+,$%/,+)%/+,%0+.#0%&-&$&#$&9('@%,(2#,7&-2%/#.#7(%,(*#&,
AB>
](#98%$,#//&.%Q%.#,'%*#,W(7%+-%'&7(1#0W' B?>
G%**0 DE@A>
=?6-'0,%&'()'/)%*#)-'>,-)6"1-&>)-&/#
E?>
EC> DF@E>
V%/((0%*#,$%+/%#%.+))4-&$8%&-%)8%-(&2"5+,"++7
=>
?@A>
B@C> DE@A> FG@D>
=>
=>
B@C>
EC> ?D@F>
I+-7&$&+-'%+/%'4,,+4-7&-2%54&07&-2'
=>
=>
?@A>
?@A> ?D@F>
I0+'(%*,+J&)&$8%$+%*450&.%'*#.(
=>
B@C>
EC>
EC> FH@F>
K)+4-$%+/%*450&.%2,((-%'*#.('
=>
=>
=>
B@C> HG@A>
9(,8%&)*+,$#-$
-(4$,#0
;#,&($8%+/%*,+2,#)%<%/4-.$&+-' ;&'4#008%*0(#'#-$%'$,(($'%<%54&07&-2'
B@C>
EC>
N$,(($%'#/($8
=>
=>
K)+4-$%+/%*(+*0(%0&9&-2%.0+'(%$+%(#."%+$"(,%$+%&-$(,#.$%1&$"
=>
B@C> EA@C> DF@E> GD@D>
O450&.%'(,9&.('%<%.+))4-&$8%54&07&-2'
=>
EC>
O0#.('%/+,%'+.&#0%&-$(,#.$&+-
=>
B@C> EA@C> BA@?> C=@B>
)+'$%+/%$"(%$&)(
+..#'&+-#008
EC>
V%)(($%1&$"%/,&(-7'%&-%*450&.%*0#.('
EC>
EC> EA@B> C=@B> DF@E>
V%)(($%/,&(-7'%<%/#)&08%&-%$"(%-(&2"5+,"++7
C=@B> EA@B> EA@B> EA@B>
V%&-9&$(%/,&(-7'%<%/#)&08%$+%.+)(%$+%)8%-(&2"5+,"++7
EA@B> DF@E> EA@B>
V%#)%&-$(,('$(7%&-%)#W&-2%-(1%/,&(-7'%&-%$"(%-(&2"5+,"++7
EC> C=@B> DF@E> CH@E> DE@A> DE@A>
V%*#,$&.&*#$&(%&-%*450&.%2#$"(,&-2'
EC>
EC> DF@E> EC> EA@B> ?@A>
?@A>
!"#$%#,(%*+''&50(%,(#'+-'%/+,%0(#9&-2%X+7+-#% ,(0#$(7%$+%$"(%*450&.%0&/(%3)+,(%#-'1(,'%*+''&50(6
EC> DE@A> GF@G> B@C> HE@B>
CG>
CG>
EC> C=@B> BC@B> B@C>
DF>
EA>
EC> ?D@A> H>
?@A> BC@G> CB@?> =>
C=>
DD>
DD>
H>
EC>
EC> A?@C> R(9(0%+/%%'$,(($%'#/($8 3.,&)(@%#..&7($-'6
P$"(, !#'$(%.+00(.$&+-%Q%O,+2,#))('%
]+1%'#$&'/&(7%1+407%8+4%'#8%8+4%#,(%+-%#%'.#0(% /,+)%=SE=%1&$"%8+4,%.4,,(-$%*0#.(%+/%0&9&-2:
P$"(,
B@C>
V%1+407%-+$%0(#9(% X+7+-#
=>
?@A>
I,+17(7-(''%+/%$"(% -(&2"5+,"++7
?@A>
EC>
B@C> CB@?> DF@E> DE@A>
K..(''&5&0&$8%+/%$"(% -(&2"5+,"++7%58%.#,
K..(''&5&0&$8%58%*450&.%$,#-'*+,$
CB@?> EA@B> DF@E>
K..(''&5&0&$8%+/%$"(% -(&2"5+,"++7%58%/++$
?@A>
EC> EA@B> DE@B> EA@B>
V%$,8%$+%)#W(%.+-$#.$%1"(-%#)%+4$'&7(
P**+,$4-&$&('%$+%&-$(,#.$% 1&$"%-(&2"5+,'
=>
B@C>
V%(-2#2(%&-%'+.&#0%#.$&9&$&('
N.#,.(%/#.&0&$#$&+-%+/% *450&.%'*#.('
=>
K..(''&5&0&$8%58%.#,
K..(''&5&0&$8%58%/++$
C=@B>
N.#,.(%#)+4$%+/%2,((-% #)(-&$&('
L&J%+/%.40$4,('%<%*(+*0(%3($"-&.@%(07(,08@%."&07,(-@%($.M6
?@A> DF@E> DF@E>
V%'*(-7%/,((%$&)(%+4$'&7(%&-%$"(%-(&2"5+,"++7
R(9(0%+/%"+4'&-2% .+-7&$&+-'
!"#$%&'%$"(%&)*+,$#-.(%+/%$"(%/+00+1&-2%34,5#-6% *,+*(,$&('%#-7%.+-7&$&+-'%&-%8+4,%7&,(.$%0&9&-2% (-9&,+-)(-$:
,#$"(,%&)*+,$#-$
,#$"(,%-+$%&)*+,$#-$
-+$%&)*+,$#-$#$%#$%#00
!"#$%&'($)'()%*#)+",-&%.)'/)"01,()-&/#
'+)($&)('
-(9(,
-+%+4$7++,%'*#.(
N"#,(7%.+4,$8#,7
[#0.+-8
O,&9#$(%2#,7(-
=>
#01#8'
F%**0 DE@A>
3*#)/'--'4&(5)+"#$%&'($),0#),1'"%)6#0$'(,-) 7&#4$)%'4,08$)%*#)/"%"0# V%1+407%'*(-7%)+,(%$&)(%+4$'&7(%&/%_4#0&$8%'*#.('% 1(,(%*,+9&7(7: DF>
V$%&'%&)*+,$#-$%$+%"#9(%'+)(%/+,)%+/%#%.+"('&9(% -(&2"5+,"++7%.+))4-&$8:
EA> EC>
H>
H>
?D>
EC>
\(1%)(($&-2%*0#.('%&-%$"(%-(&2"5+,"++7%1+407% (-.+4,#2(%)(%$+%2+%+4$%)+,(%&-%$"(%'$,(($
H>
E==>
FG>
B> => E
D
C
B
G
V%1+407%0&W(%$+%5(%*#,$%+/%$"(%-(&2"5+,"++7'%'+.&#0% 0&/(
=> F
A
?
H
E=
O450&.%'*#.('%#,(%-((7(7%/+,%#%5($$(,% -(&2"5+,"++7%*450&.%0&/(
7EE
FH>
E==>
!"# <=>?@A'ABC<#! renewal of post-conflict transitioning districts
!