Why We Must Fight For Community-Based High School Athletics in Texas

Texas high school athletics are more than just games—they are the heart of our communities. The traditions, pride, and identity tied to local high school teams unite towns across the state. Unlike other states, Texas has maintained a model of education-based athletics where student-athletes compete for their hometown schools, coached by teachers and administrators who invest in their growth on and off the field. But this unique and valued system is at risk.

It is essential that coaches, teachers, and parents can articulate and speak about the reasons why it is important to save community and education-based athletics. Without a strong and unified voice, the values that have long defined Texas high school sports could be lost.

The Heart of Community-Based Athletics

High school sports in Texas are more than just athletic competitions—they represent the spirit and identity of local communities. Student-athletes grow up together, attend the same schools, and share experiences that forge lifelong connections. Athletics are not just for the athletes—they provide opportunities for cheer and band, student council, and spirit groups to participate in the shared pride and excitement of competition, fostering a deep sense of belonging and school spirit.

When student-athletes are allowed to transfer freely for athletic purposes, schools risk losing their homegrown talent, diminishing the pride and unity that high school athletics bring to towns both large and small.

What We Can Learn from Other States

The consequences of unrestricted transfers are clear in states that have already adopted these policies. Florida, for example, has experienced a dramatic shift since implementing a transfer rule. Community engagement has declined, attendance at games has dropped, and many schools struggle to maintain local fan bases. When athletes no longer represent their hometowns, the emotional connection between teams and their communities’ fades.

Additionally, some states have implemented policies allowing for unrestricted athlete transfers, leading to the rise of “all-star teams,” recruitment battles, and a decline in community support. Texas, however, has upheld fairness and integrity through its current transfer policy, which is overseen by the University Interscholastic League (UIL) and supported by the Texas High School Coaches Association (THSCA). This model ensures that Texas high school athletics remain a foundation for education, character development, and community unity. We must protect this system to avoid the pitfalls seen elsewhere.

The Lessons at Risk

High school athletics teach valuable life lessons that extend far beyond the field or court. The ability to fight through adversity, learn from mistakes, and stay loyal to a team fosters resilience and character.

Being part of a team means standing for something bigger than oneself. It means putting the needs of the group ahead of personal ambition, learning to work with others, and seeing the fruits of hard work and commitment over time. When student-athletes can leave at will, they lose the opportunity to develop perseverance, dedication, and a deep sense of belonging.

Education-based athletics means that these lessons are an extension of the classroom. Time management, discipline, and balancing responsibilities are all skills learned through athletics that prepare students for success beyond high school. These lessons create productive citizens who contribute meaningfully to their communities, but if we shift toward a system that prioritizes athletic success over education, we lose a key element that makes Texas high school athletics unique.

The Economic and Cultural Impact

The impact of weakened community-based athletics extends beyond the schools themselves. Many small businesses rely on the economic boost from game days, with local restaurants, retailers, and service providers benefiting from the crowds and excitement of high school sports. When attendance drops and community engagement diminishes, local economies feel the loss.

Moreover, the identity of Texas high school sports has always been rooted in community spirit. When student-athletes are no longer seen as hometown kids but instead as temporary competitors moving from team to team, the loyalty that fuels high school athletics begins to erode.

Why We Must Stand Firm

Texas has set the standard for high school athletics nationwide, and we cannot afford to follow in the footsteps of states that now regret their decision to loosen transfer policies. We must continue to fight for the values that make Texas high school athletics special—community, integrity, and education-based sports.

This is not just about competition; it’s about preserving the traditions and community bonds that define our state. Coaches, teachers, and parents must be able to clearly communicate why this fight matters. Our student-athletes deserve more than just a game—they deserve a community that stands behind them, a school system that prioritizes both education and competition and a legacy that remains intact for years to come. The fight for community-based athletics in Texas is a fight for the future of our towns, our schools, and our youth.

THSCA Legislative Info: See what bills THSCA is tracking this session/read important notes & alerts throughout the session at www.thsca.com/legislature/

Want to read the entire February 2025 issue of Texas Coach magazine? https://issuu.com/thscacoaches/docs/feb25upload?fr=xKAE9_zU1NQ