VOLUME 15, ISSUE 3 | 2013
IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR: POSITION STATEMENT
Ever wish for something to hand out at community events or open houses that easily explained or visually showed some aspect of Montessori that didn’t overwhelm the reader? Who better than the people who wrote the book, The Montessori Way, to introduce such a product!
Three Pamphlets Now Available in Spanish!
NINE Montessori pamphlets now available. Use the form below to order.
Why would you start your threeyear -old in school?
What can Montessori offer our nfants & toddlers?
Montessori Nurtures Curiosity, Creativity & Imagination
The Importance of Montessori for the Kindergarten Year The Montessori Foundation
The Montessori Foundation © 2009
© 2009
The Montessori Foundation
The Montessori Foundation
© 2009
© 2009
Each pamphlet bundle contains 50 of the same title and is incredibly affordable at $15 USD per bundle plus postage. The items are in stock and ready to ship. They may be purchased the following ways: 1. Through our online publication center located at the Foundation’s website: www.montessori.org (go right into the ‘bookstore’ tab) 2. By calling Margot at 800 632 4121 (IMC school members receive a discount on this item and will need to call with credit card. Should your IMC school membership need to be renewed, we will do that at the same time.) 3. Use this order form and either mail or fax your order. Make checks payable to: The Montessori Foundation and mail to 19600 E State Road 64, Bradenton, FL 34212 USA. Fax number is 941 359 8166. Please select: USPS Flat Rate Priority or expedited courier service, such as FEDEX/UPS, which can be substantially more expensive (price is determined by weight and location by the courier). We will estimate this for you before charging out). Couriers cannot deliver to a PO BOX. 1. What is Montessori? q English q Spanish
_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $_______
2. Why would you start your three-year-old in school? q English q Spanish_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $_______ 3. Montessori Nurtures Curiosity, Creativity & Imagination
_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $_______
4. What can Montessori offer our infants & toddlers?
_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $_______
5. Creating a Culture of Partnership, Kindness, Respect & Peace
_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $_______
6. The Importance of Montessori for Kindergarten q English q Spanish _____#of bundles @$15 Total due $______ 7. Joyful Scholars: Montessori for the Elementary Years
_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $______
8. Research & Montessori
_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $______
9. Montessori in the Home
_____#of bundles @$15 Total due $______
Shipping Method: q USPS FLAT RATE PRIORITY q COURIER (FedEx/UPS) q 1 - 3 bundles $6.45 q 4 - 12 bundles $12.95 q 13+ bundles $14.95
Shipping Amount $______ TOTAL DUE
$______
IMC membership number ___________ for discounted pricing of $12.50 per bundle. To obtain shipping-cost information for orders outside US, call 941-309-3961 or email: margot@montessori.org. (Note: We do not accept Discover cards.) Credit card#___________________________ Name on Card____________________________________Exp. date_________ EMAIL address where receipt should be sent___________________________________________________ (please print clearly) Mailing address and name of contact person___________________________________________________ (please print clearly) Phone number in case we have a question(_____) ______________________________________________ SAMPLES ARE
$1.00 EACH PLUS $1.44 S&H (US) ($2.44 CANADA) (S&H APPLIES FOR UP TO NINE BROCHURES). CIRCLE: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
Montessori Leadership is the official magazine of the International Montessori Council, a non-profit organization. The opinions expressed in Montessori Leadership editorials, columns, and features are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the position of the magazine or the IMC. Acceptance of advertising does not represent endorsement of any product or service. The International Montessori Council does NOT grant permission to reprint material from Montessori Leadership in any other form (e.g., book, newsletter, journal). Copies of this issue or back issues are available for purchase online at www.montessori.org .
Copyright 2013 by The International Montessori Council. All rights reserved.
Chair Tim Seldin, M.Ed Editor Joyce St. Giermaine joycestgiermaine@montessori.org Art Director/IMC Membership Director/ Conference Coordinator and Bookstore Manager: Margot Garfield-Anderson Margot@montessori.org 800 632 4121 Phone 941 309 3961/FAX: 941 359 8166 Article submissions and Consulting: Sharon Caldwell | SharonCaldwell@montessori.org IMC Accreditation & Consulting Tim Seldin | TimSeldin@montessori.org IMC Accreditation Director Hillary Drinkell | HillaryDrinkell@montessori.org Layout & Design Katrina Costedio katrina@katrinacostedio.com Tomorrow’s Child Online: The Montessori Family Connection Lorna McGrath Phone: 941-729-9565/1-800-655-5843 Fax: 941-745-3111 email: lornamcgrath@montessori.org For immediate service, use our secure online bookstore at www.montessori.org. For questions regarding an order, email: margot@montessori.org Subscriptions & Bookkeeping Don Dinsmore Phone: 941-729-9565/1-800-655-5843 Fax: 941-745-3111 email: dondinsmore@montessori.org Classified & Display Advertising Chelsea Howe Phone: 410-504-3872 Fax: 941-745-3111 tcmag@montessori.org
Montessori Leadership Features 4
Work Plans in the Montessori 3-6 Class
by Tim Seldin
6
Common Core Standards:
An Opportunity for Montessori to Shine
by Anita Amos Ph.D.
10 Leadership Montessori Style
by Suzanne Pugin
13 Montessori in the Public Sector: Position Statement
by David Kahn
15 Book Review: Kids in the Kitchen
by Sharon Caldwell
16 Art, Music, Dance: Specialist Teachers
& Extra Lessons in the Children’s House
by Tim Seldin
20 Montessori Congress: the world’s largest
international gathering of Montessorians
by Glenn Goodfellow
22 Letter from the IMC Chair: A Watershed Year
by Tim Seldin
24 Update on the New IMC Accreditation
by Hillary Drinkell
25 Visiting Montessori’s First Casa dei Bambini
by Melissa Kemendo
28 Understanding the Relationship Between
Classroom Management and the Path to
Learning in a Montessori Environment
by Dr. Christine Sacerdote
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
3
by Tim Seldin
M
ontessori is based on a child’s freedom of
do things for themselves, and how to make care-
choice. An adult-designed work plan tells
ful observations of what happens day after day.
him or her what is to be accomplished. Some schools will not allow children to
Do we teach? Of course we do! But the question is how we
choose work freely until the tasks on
go about presenting lessons and what we do if a child is not
their work plan are completed. It amazes me that these schools
interested or fails to develop the skills and knowledge that we
could come up with such an idea, having read Dr. Montes-
hoped to see.
sori’s writings. It should be a case where no disagreement is possible.
These topics are worthy of many essays exploring each aspect in great depth and normally constitute a major
Children are placed in a carefully prepared environment, designed to stimulate their curiosity and interest and to support learning independently and from one another, using beautifully crafted and highly appealing learning materials. Within that environment of the physical design, along with a carefully gathered group of children and carefully trained adults, the individual child must be allowed almost perfect freedom to choose activities for him or herself. Obviously, that freedom is not absolute. They may do no harm to themselves, one another, or the environment. They may not disturb the peace. We model appropriate behavior patterns. We attempt to entice them through lessons, gentle suggestions
A work plan that restricts freedom of choice is contradictory to the very essence of Montessori. It tells the child what must be done.
about possible work, or by taking something
4
portion of any thorough Montessori teacher education program. For now, let me simply sketch out a few key ideas. The first is that we teach in many ways. We model specific behavior. We take work off the shelf and work with it. We teach by asking one child to give a lesson to another. And, of course, we invite children to lessons. Those lessons might be pre-planned or spontaneous, based on our intuition, a child’s request, or our ongoing observation of the class. A lesson may be presented to the entire group, a small group, or to an individual. The key concept is that we invite children to the lesson; we do not demand that they participate. We need to consider whether an invitation from one’s teacher is not inherently something
off the shelf to work with on our own, in hope of triggering or
that most children will accept without question, or whether
reawakening interest in this among the children. The commu-
we have used that tone of voice that means ‘this is expected,
nity is called a Children’s House for good reason. This is their
not truly a request.’ On the other hand, few Montessori teach-
community, which works within a physical and social envi-
ers will fail to notice if a child is unfocused or disinterested,
ronment engineered by the Montessori-trained adults, who
which is normally the cue to suggest that we can come back
designed it and maintain it to a specific level of order. Our goal
to this later. The relationship between a trusted Montessori
is to teach the children how to make their own choices, how to
teacher and her or his students will normally be one where
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
the children are almost always happy to
...but in Montessori, the motivation to
cooperate or follow the teacher’s suggestion. This is because their relationship
learn should come from the child, not from
is based on a culture where the children have a great deal of autonomy and free-
the adult forcing her will upon the child.
dom of choice in activity, rather than one where the adult directs their focus and activity from one moment to the
where even the means by which chil-
that fear is justified, you might want to
next.
dren may learn basic skills and knowl-
look at why it would be true.
edge of the world are accomplished in Can we always give the children free
a playful, relaxed, individualized, and
Have you admitted an entire class
choice? No, there are some things that
hands-on manner, we create conditions
of 20 to 30 children brand new all at
must be learned by a certain age, and
where learning comes naturally. More
once? Clearly older children will have
there are expectations about the way we
importantly, we create an environment
missed many of the experiences and the
act toward each other. Our goal, how-
in which children feel very grown up,
years needed to become normalized and
ever, is to accomplish those goals with
free from adult direction with constant
to reach the academic levels we normally
the child’s voluntary cooperation when-
approval and disapproval. Children usu-
see in Montessori children by age 6.
ever possible and the lightest touch of
ally love adults and enjoy their praise,
external control when it is truly neces-
but in Montessori, the motivation to
Are you experiencing major turn-
sary.
learn should come from the child, not
over in your children: 50 percent or
from the adult forcing her will upon the
more in one year? If so, your class has
Work plans are sometimes used in Mon-
child. By allowing children to master
been reborn this year, and must repeat
tessori classes to provide a degree of
the everyday living skills needed to run
the process of becoming strong. Retain-
structure and planning for the child’s
the house, by designing the environ-
ing about 2/3 of your students is essential
week. They might be a set of suggested
ment to allow them to make their own
to a good Montessori program.
tasks or perhaps a journal in which the
choices, and by creating a pattern of how
child records what she or he has done.
things are used and where they are to be
Are the adults in the room confused
Usually, journals begin to be used in
returned, we help children develop the
and uncertain? If so, perhaps they are
the elementary levels (ages 6 to 12), but
basic Montessori goals: an inner sense of
untrained or poorly trained. In that case,
more and more, early childhood teach-
order, concentration, coordination, and
there is nothing to do except to either
ers are beginning to use them with their
independence.
hope that they learn from experience or
5-year-olds and even younger children.
continue their professional education in
As a result, in any well-run Montessori
some way until they ultimately develop
A work plan that restricts freedom of
class, children should typically develop
the understanding and skills or leave
choice, as described above, is contradic-
academic skills far ahead of when most
Montessori, having realized that they do
tory to the very essence of Montessori. It
other children will do so in traditional
not really agree with its philosophy and
tells the child what must be done.
programs. More importantly, they will
practices.
One reason why we begin with such
normally still enjoy coming to school
young children in Montessori is that,
day after day. They should learn joy-
In a well-run Montessori Children’s
traditionally, society has few expecta-
fully, not as a burden.
House, work plans are not only unnec-
tions for children’s achievement at age
essary, but could even prevent children
2, 3, 4, and 5. By beginning at age 2 or
Work plans are created by teachers who
‘normalizing’
3, and by placing children in such an
fear that without them children will not
activity, which results from work freely
intellectually stimulating environment,
progress and master essential skills. If
chosen.
through
spontaneous
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
5
by Anita Amos, Ph.D
T
he Common Core State Standards (CCSS) is a controversial topic,
Let’s start with two general facts about
widely debated in nearly every circle in the field of Education. Perhaps
the Common Core:
nowhere is the concept of an outside, mandated set of standards met with more cynicism and philosophical aversion than in the Montes-
1. The Common Core State
sori community. This reaction is understandable, as the Montessori approach to
Standards define baseline expectations
education encompasses rich traditions based on scientific study regarding how chil-
for each grade level in English, Lan-
dren develop and learn. Montessori differs significantly from traditional approaches
guage Arts, and Mathematics for publicly
to education, and Montessorians are justifiably protective of a curriculum that is
funded schools.
elegant, complex, and research-based. In Montessori: The Science behind the Genius, Dr. Angeline Stoll Lillard states:
“...no other single educational curriculum comes close to the Montessori curriculum in terms of its levels of depth, breadth, and interrelationship across time and topic.”
2. Forty-five states, the District
of Columbia, four territories, and the Department of Defense Education Activity have adopted the Common Core State Standards. Alaska, Minnesota, Nebraska, Texas, and Virginia are the only states that have yet to adopt the Common Core. Now that we have established, in a very broad sense, what CCSS “is” and who it
At the root of the anxiety many Montessorians feel regarding the Common Core
presently “affects,” we can begin a mean-
is a fear that an educational approach continuously confirmed by modern science
ingful analysis.
may be forcibly diluted to more closely resemble traditional failed methodologies.
6
However, by applying a mindful, analytical approach to studying the correlation
The many factions involved in the educa-
between Montessori and the Common Core, it becomes apparent that this appre-
tion reform debate in the United States
hension may not be necessary. To the surprise of Montessorians everywhere,
over the years have frequently become
the Common Core may actually represent an unexpected opportunity for
bogged down in heated disagreements
Montessori.
over “What” and “When” to teach.
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
For better or worse, the Common Core
topics in which concepts are revisited
has defined a set of common learning
in increasingly greater depth, are vital
goals for specific grade levels, effectively
components of a successful educational
removing those topics from the table.
methodology.
now move past “What” and “When”
What follows are selected excerpts from
to teach and advance to “How” we
the Common Core website towards this
should effectively teach students the
point:
multitude of skills they will need to be
For serious education reformers, the “How” question necessitates a closer examination of existing educational pedagogies. In this shifting landscape, the Common Core has created an opportunity for Montessori to truly shine and influence the education reform decisions that will impact our children for decades to come. Therefore, regardless of individual affiliations and nuanced classroom methods,
understanding develop over time.”
understanding, to make sure stu-
curriculum in the United States must
become substantially more focused and coherent in order to improve
mathematics achievement in this country. To deliver on the promise of common standards, the standards
must address the problem of a curriculum that is ‘a mile wide and an
inch deep.’ These Standards are a
every corner of the country and around
cedural skill but also conceptual dents are learning and absorbing the critical information they
need to succeed at higher levels – rather than the current practices
by which many students learn enough to get by on the next test,
but forget it shortly thereafter, only to review again the following year.”
http://www.corestandards.org/resources/key-pointsin-mathematics
Sound familiar? The concept of provid“These Standards endeavor to follow
such a design, not only by stress-
yields intriguing insights that even the
mathematical knowledge, skill, and
the conclusion that the mathematics
performing countries have pointed to
http://www.corestandards.org/Math
standing of the Montessori philosophy,
is known today about how students’
“The standards stress not only pro-
galvanize Montessori advocates from
Core, combined with a deep under-
dards began with research-based
of mathematics education in high-
substantial answer to that challenge.”
An intensive study of the Common
this, the development of these Stan-
http://www.corestandards.org/Math
“For over a decade, research studies
the “How” question should unite and
the globe.
tunate and unwise.’ In recognition of
learning progressions, detailing what
Proponents of education reform can
successful in the 21st century.
ful study of learning, would be unfor-
ing conceptual understanding of key ideas, but also by continually
returning to organizing principles,
such as place value or the laws of
ing a child with a deep understanding of concepts through experiences with concrete materials in place of superficial knowledge and rote memorization is a key tenet of the Montessori Method and is achieved with beautifully designed
biggest Common Core skeptic cannot
arithmetic to structure those ideas.”
materials found in Montessori class-
ignore. Indeed, it appears that in devel-
http://www.corestandards.org/Math
rooms around the world.
“In addition, the ‘sequence of topics
Mapping a highly detailed and sophisti-
oping research-based learning goals for Language and Mathematics, aimed at achieving meaningful understanding of core concepts, the developers of the CCSS have caught on to aspects of what Dr. Maria Montessori discovered all those years ago! The crucial importance of the passage to abstraction for a solid foundation of understanding, combined with a spiral approach to
and performances’ that is outlined in a body of mathematics standards must also respect what is known
about how students learn. As Confrey (2007) points out, developing ‘sequenced obstacles and challenges
for students…absent the insights about meaning that derive from care-
cated alignment of the measurable learning objectives defined within the Montessori Scope & Sequence was both an exhaustive and delightful process. Time and time again, the Montessori approach not only met but oftentimes greatly exceeded the standards set forth by the Common Core. Below are multiple
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
7
examples from the Mathematics align-
Stair, the Teen Board, the Tens Board,
ments that highlight the complemen-
the Hundred Board and the Hundred
tary nature of the Common Core and
Chain. These traditional Montessori
the Montessori Mathematics materials.
Math materials were designed to pro-
Indeed, there are situations in which it
vide concrete experiences for students to
nearly seems as though the standard
connect counting with actual amounts. Ê
Describe
measurable
attri-
butes of objects, such as length or Ê
Compose
and
decompose
weight. Describe several measur-
numbers from 11 to 19 into ten
able attributes of a single object.
ones and some further ones, e.g.,
(K.MD.A.1).
the staggering amount of information available today in print and digitally.
They actively seek the wide, deep, and thoughtful engagement with
tional texts that builds knowledge, enlarges experience, and broad-
ens worldviews. They reflexively demonstrate the cogent reasoning
and use of evidence that is essen-
tial to both private deliberation and
by using objects or drawings,
responsible citizenship in a demo-
and record each composition or
There are 17 defined measurable objec-
decomposition by a drawing or
tives in the Scope & Sequence that
equation (such as 18 = 10 + 8);
align with this standard, 11 of which are
who meet the Standards develop the
understand that these numbers
related to Sensorial materials such as the
skills in reading, writing, speaking,
are composed of ten ones and one,
Pink Tower, the Brown Stairs, Thermic
two, three, four, five, six, seven,
Tablets, Baric Tablets, and more.
cratic republic. In short, students
and listening that are the foundation for any creative and pur-
poseful expression in language.”
eight, or nine ones. (K.NBT.A.1) The stated goals behind the Common
http://www.corestandards.org/ELA-Literacy
There are 19 defined measurable objec-
Core’s English Language Arts Standards
tives in the Scope & Sequence that align
are also very much in line with the goals
A primary goal of Montessori classrooms
with this standard. These measurable
of a Montessori classroom.
is to provide students with a combina-
objectives are associated with materi-
tion of guidance and a prepared environ-
als such as the Ten Bead Bars and the
Here is an excerpt from the Common
ment in which to develop the necessary
Short Bead Stair, the Tens Board and
Core website regarding the English Lan-
skills in reading, writing, speaking, and
the Golden Beads, the Addition Strip
guage Arts Standards:
listening that facilitate effective com-
Board, the Addition Snake Game, and more.
munication and expression. Montessori “As a natural outgrowth of meeting the charge to define college and
students have always been encouraged to be independent and critical think-
Ê Understand the relationship career readiness, the Standards also
ers; to analyze, question, and contribute
between numbers and quantities;
their own thoughts on a topic. Montes-
connect counting to cardinality. (K.CC.B.4)
lay out a vision of what it means to
be a literate person in the twenty-first
century. Indeed, the skills and understandings students are expected to
There are 25 defined measurable objectives in the Scope & Sequence that align to this standard! These measurable objectives are associated with materials such as the Red and Blue Number Rods, Spindle Box, Cards and Counters, Golden Beads, the Short Bead
8
necessary to pick carefully through
high-quality literary and informa-
was written with the Montessori approach in mind!
habitually perform the critical reading
demonstrate have wide applicability outside the classroom or workplace.
sori students from a very young age are encouraged to “actively seek the wide, deep, and thoughtful engagement with high-quality literary and informational texts that builds knowledge, enlarges
Students who meet the Standards
experience, and broadens worldviews.”
tive reading that is at the heart
The Common Core gets very specific in
readily undertake the close, atten-
of understanding and enjoying complex works of literature. They
providing goals for building the necessary skill sets for reading, writing, and
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
speaking effectively from kindergarten
walk home; Tomorrow I will walk
ANITA AMOS, Ph.D. is an
through high school. And yet, as with
home). (L.1.1e)
experienced and passionate educa-
Mathematics, time and time again, the
tor, developing curriculum and
standards are met or exceeded by the
This Grade 1 standard has five mea-
working with students ranging from
Montessori Scope & Sequence.
surable objectives from the Scope and
preschool to the college level. Anita completed her
Sequence
activi-
B.A. in Biological Sciences at Wellesley College
ties such as the “Three Fundamental
and performed research at Harvard Medical School,
Tenses” from the History curriculum
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and the
Ê Follow agreed-upon rules for
that is commonly presented at the Pri-
National Institutes of Health. Prior to beginning
discussions
mary level.
a doctoral program at the University of Pennsylva-
Here are a few examples:
(e.g.,
listening
to
aligned
including
others and taking turns speaking
nia, Anita traveled extensively, teaching preschool
about the topics and texts under
While the cynicism among Montessori-
students in Japan and elementary/high school stu-
discussion). (SL.K.1a)
ans who have yet to thoroughly research
dents in Nepal. Upon earning her Ph.D. from
the Common Core is fully understand-
UPENN, she taught high school Biology and
This standard has eight measurable
able; however, ignoring or fearing this
spent time as an adjunct college professor, teaching
learning objectives from the Scope &
new reality is not going to make it go
Anatomy, Physiology, Biology, Chemistry, and
Sequence aligned; four of these learn-
away. In fact, anything less than a prag-
Physical Science. Anita also co-founded an Online
ing objectives are from the Practical Life
matic and collaborative approach to
SAT Prep company, developing custom curricu-
curriculum. Two Grace & Courtesy
this issue from the Montessori com-
lum and tutoring students for all three sections of
sub-categories (General Language &
munity runs the risk of missing out on
the SAT exam: Mathematics, Critical Reading,
Actions and Group Etiquette) address
a very unique, time-sensitive window
and Writing. She also served as regional Admis-
practical life skills related to commu-
of opportunity. A comprehensive Mon-
sions Representative for her alma mater, Wellesley
nicating effectively and politely with
tessori Scope & Sequence that includes
College. A Montessori preschool student during her
others.
very specific measurable learning objec-
early childhood in Homer, Alaska, Anita became
tives aligned to the Common Core State
intrigued with the Montessori Method when her
Ê Distinguish shades of meaning
Standards can provide the missing piece
first child entered a Montessori school in Penn-
among verbs describing the same
of the puzzle that education reform-
sylvania. Anita co-founded Montessori Compass
general action (e.g., walk, march,
ers have been desperately seeking. The
along with her husband Rob to help simplify record
strut, prance) by acting out the
Common Core, for better or worse,
keeping for Montessori educators while bridging
meanings. (L.K.5d)
has defined “What” and “When” to
the communication gap between home and school.
teach. The Montessori Method is
Anita and Rob live in Pennsylvania with their four
The fact that the link between move-
the answer to the final question of
Montessori children.
ment and understanding has always been
“How” to teach.
reflected in the Montessori curriculum is highlighted as this standard has nearly a dozen measurable learning objectives from the Scope & Sequence aligned including Activity Word and Command Card activities. Ê Use verbs to convey a sense of past, present, and future (e.g., Yesterday I walked home; Today I
Publish in Montessori Leadership Montessori Leadership Journal seeks well-written articles that appeal to Heads of School, Administrators, Boards and Classroom Management. For further information on our submission requirements please email, SharonCaldwell@ montessori.org. We publish 4 times annually.
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
9
by Suzanne Pugin, Ph.D. Head of School, Ghent Montessori, Norfolk, VA
I
n response to the request for information or guidelines
is no practice without theory and only useless theory with-
concerning leadership or administrative style, I spent
out practical application. We know that in the classroom such
some time considering what could be of interest to
practice is necessary to enable the children to learn. Adults
others in the Montessori community. In other words,
must also learn to use practical techniques to reach theoretical
what have I learned about administration after 37 years of ad-
goals.
ministration and over 40 years as a Montessorian? We also must recognize that schools are made up of separate At Ghent Montessori, we are fortunate to have a seasoned
entities. Each has a different perspective as to the overall ob-
staff. All lead staff members have at least six years at the school,
jectives of the school. For example, these entities might in-
and some have been here as long as 20 years. There have been
clude: children, parents, teachers, administrators and, in some
some rough spots in the past, and there have been those who
cases, Boards of Directors. Each group has tasks to accom-
were uncomfortable with a participative leadership style.
plish in relation to achieving the overall goals and have varying
However, during this time, communication skills were prac-
authority within the organization. The menu for conflict is
ticed and trust grew. We no longer require a yearly evaluation
clearly spelled out. That is the nature of most organizations.
of staff. We are not smug about this. We know that you can-
Schools are not exempt, not even Montessori schools. With
not take relationships of any kind for granted. Continual effort
this in minds, awareness of the complexity involved tells us
from everyone has to be encouraged and facilitated. This year,
that creating peaceful development is not going to be easy. If
our staff will review the evaluation process with different goals
we are to be effective, we must understand that authority is
in mind. We plan to observe and evaluate at different levels
needed to make correct decisions, not incorrect ones, and that
in order to increase our knowledge and appreciation of each
correct decisions are most easily made when there is adequate
other. Often we know more about other school environments
information.
than we do about those in our own school. To facilitate communication, information from each other is needed.
Management is about achieving tasks that lead us to our goals, with the inclusion of people in the environment. We are really
For most of us, as Montessori administrators, there is always a
talking about human behavior, people in association with one
struggle to assimilate our beliefs regarding children with our
another.
leadership of adults. I would suggest that associating theory
10
with practice applies not only in the classroom but in my role
As leaders or managers in a school environment, we first have
as administrator as well. They are not separate entities. There
to realize that what we do and how we do it affects others in
Š MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
both positive and negative ways. If you teach children and have prepared a beautiful lesson, only to see it go to waste, or, as an administrator, you have provided exceptional resources for teachers and had a lukewarm response, perhaps you have experienced this. What you have learned is that sometimes your best is not enough. We may look around and see if there are other people or conditions to blame. Hopefully, you will consider that there is a need to find out how YOU could have improved the result. When you do this, you are embracing the concept of evaluation.
Our focus in the
effects on one another and cause many
classroom includes the
to knowledge and skill. Personal be-
overall needs of the
and can be less readily controlled by
child and the welfare
Unless we recognize the effects of the
of the entire class.
decision-making process will occur. In
This proposes that we
a matter and believe that administrative
take our inspiration
to the complexities of human behavior.
from the situation.
disruptions. Professional behavior relates havior relates to and involves emotions administrative guidelines or protocols. one upon the other, disruption of the other words, it is not sufficient to shelve procedures will substitute for facing up A memo won’t work! We always hope that our leaders have su-
True evaluation is not about correcting
ways the most vulnerable. In the case of
perior talent, but we know they do not
past mistakes; rather, it has to do with
a school, that would be the children.
have it exclusively and sometimes not
improving in the future. The only way
at all. We must recognize that fallibility
to do that is to acknowledge what we do
It is recognized by a Montessori teacher
of anybody. Autocratic leadership can
without fear of repercussions. We have
in the classroom that the teacher, as the
have successful consequences. Everyone
to provide environments that protect
person in authority, does not issue arbi-
knows what they have to do and where
and honor open communication.
trary orders or commands. Our focus in
they are heading. But what happens
the classroom includes the overall needs
when, and if, the leadership changes or
We all agree that the behavior of adults
of the child and the welfare of the entire
if it is at fault? If an evolutionary mode
towards children should be of an ethical-
class. This proposes that we take our in-
of operation is not in place, an upheaval
ly sound nature and that it is part of our
spiration from the situation. People are
will take place and that may not be what
responsibility to educate our students
part of that situation. Just as we value the
is needed. Leadership has usually been
in the ways of ethical conduct. Montes-
Montessori materials, when we observe,
associated with power and the leaders’
sori education is firmly based on this
we take into consideration the child’s in-
ability to exert his or her will to create
premise. We acknowledge support, en-
tent as he uses the material. With adults,
achievements. Should we not consider,
couragement, cooperation, teamwork,
this would necessitate the use of observa-
as we do with the children, that every-
service to others, giving and receiving
tion, careful consideration, and, in some
one in the school should aspire to this
freely as aspects of our philosophy. If the
cases, consultation with those involved.
leadership and the qualities required
conduct of other individuals in the envi-
Some people might say, “Things seem
with freedom and responsibility in order
ronment is unsympathetic to that con-
to be going ok. If it ain’t broke don’t fix
to create group power rather than just
struct, either in the classrooms, between
it.” However, if you don’t look, how do
personal power. The task of the head of
colleagues or parents in both profes-
you know it isn’t broken?
school would be to have people cooper-
sional and personal matters, then incon-
ate by agreement for the development of
gruence occurs. There will, almost cer-
We have to recognize that both profes-
themselves and the school. Often, this
tainly, be conflict of a destructive kind,
sional and personal behavior is in effect
does not happen. Those who are seeking
and the effect will cause dysfunction in
in any work environment. These two
power for themselves, without concern
the school. Those who will suffer are al-
aspects of behavior can have dramatic
for the welfare of the entire school, can
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
11
radically diminish the process. Most of us communicate much less effectively than we think we do. Leaders often surmise that they are understood or, even worse, don’t care about how they are perceived. If we are to truly evaluate our communication skills, then we must rely on feedback. Often, it is too little and too late. There are many issues
Responsibility is not something that we can give, but we should attempt to ensure that it is taken.
to overcome: perceptual bias; omission;
Believing that they are supported by the administration or leader, individuals will move forward and step into the arena of leadership. Within the Montessori construct, this means freedom with responsibility. We all know that does not mean license. Our task should be to identify whether (and to what extent) we are achieving our goals. In order to continue to
distortion; body language; trust or lack
Responsibility is not something that we
achieve our goals, we have to go for-
of trust; status; etc. It is the responsibil-
can give, but we should attempt to en-
ward confidently, acknowledge our own
ity of all members of any organization
sure that it is taken. As a leader in your
strengths and abilities (individually and
to establish an atmosphere that supports
school, that does not absolve your re-
collectively), and recognize the value of
everyone in it.
sponsibility. You must help to prepare
accessibility to each other’s roles and the
those who seek leadership. It is essential
need for mutual support. That is Mon-
Evaluation should be the basis for all that
that you let go of tasks you can do well
tessori Leadership.
we do. Again, it is not an activity which
not just those you don’t like. How can
completes a process. Evaluation should
you act as a mentor otherwise? This is
be used to determine what should be
a strategy to improve competence, de-
done and how it should be done before
veloping a group of people who can be
the event. It should be a positive activ-
more effective and able to make contri-
ity, which validates and provides for the
butions, knowing that sometimes the
future. Done correctly, in an open and
most competent will avoid responsibili-
participative manner, informed deci-
ties out of fear for the result.
sions could be made. Essential information would be collected. Good decisions
Maintaining necessary administrative
for the future would be made.
control merely means the safeguarding
To view the PDF of Ghent Montessori’s teacher evaluation document in its entirety log into the IMC area of our website and look under http://tinyurl.com/ pyw98tg. We thank Suzanne for sharing this wonderful tool with our community.
of the activity and the people involved.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR CONTINUED SUPPORT Remember to renew early and recommend joining the International Montessori Council to a friend.
All memberships begin on July 1 of any given year. Your membership may be prorated
during the first year to move your date accordingly. Join through our online bookstore. Individual Membership ($60 USD/year) www.montessori.org School Membership ($250 USD/year) Or call our membership office at Business Membership ($250 USD/year) 1 (800) 632-4121 Montessori Organization Member ($250 USD/year)
12
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
MONTESSORI IN PUBLIC SECTOR: POSITION STATEMENT
M
by David Kahn
ontessori Education in the
this number upward again, to 600 pro-
training or by teachers who were not
public sector is at the cross-
grams or more in the next few years.
trained for the levels they were asked to
roads of a massive rebirth,
teach. Another contributing factor was
or the possible loss of its root principles,
The
North
American
Montessori
the tendency of non-Montessori trained
as its growth cycle drives expansion in
Teachers’ Association (NAMTA) was
principals to dictate curriculum poli-
the present and again in the future. The
at the heart of Montessori public school
cy without a secure understanding of
stakes are high; here is one narrative of
development and promotion during this
Montessori principles and practice. This
what needs to be considered.
first thirty years, culminating in 1991
further diluted the Montessori character
with the founding of the now defunct
of many schools. Where textbooks and
The first public sector Montessori pro-
Montessori Public School Consortium
workbooks replaced worn Montessori
grams appeared in the mid to late sev-
(MPSC), which directly served Cleve-
materials and where children without
enties as district schools started by par-
land, Indianapolis, Milwaukee, Spo-
Montessori background were admitted
ents, then in the eighties and nineties,
kane, Akron, Canton, Hartford, District
at any age throughout the kindergarten
they were largely supported by magnet
of Columbia, and Denver in their for-
and elementary years, Montessori prin-
school funding for purposes of desegre-
mative years. NAMTA also sponsored
ciples and practice were further diluted.
gation. Public sector Montessori pro-
national Montessori public school an-
grams, which in the nineties were the
nual conferences for many years.
What is most serious is that early child-
number one school of choice, are cur-
hood Montessori programs are either
rently expanding mostly in the charter
The MPSC was supported in part by
missing or are shackled by regulations
school movement.
Montessori Development Partnerships
that do not allow full age range Montes-
(MDP), NAMTA, Nienhuis and The
sori programs to be implemented. Au-
Montessori programs are favored because
Hershey Foundation. The Hershey
thentic Montessori early childhood
they typically attract a diverse range of
Foundation had a particular interest
programs serve children from the age of
socio-economic groups, which unite to
in the Marotta Schools, which oper-
three (even two and a half) through the
form cohesive, integrated communi-
ated five early childhood campuses in
age of six. Regulated starting ages of four
ties. The programs are developmentally
Cleveland. NAMTA supported a na-
or five years, and/or imposed lotteries
appropriate, they feature carefully pre-
tional early childhood urban model as
disrupt continuity into the kindergarten
pared child-centered environments, and
it developed local Montessori solutions
year, compromising the Montessori de-
they also produce a high level of parental
in Cleveland. The Hershey Foundation
sign which is most successful when work
engagement. These programs also rou-
consistently supported both local and
with four and five year-olds is founded
tinely achieve high test scores.
NAMTA initiatives.
upon their experiences in Montessori
programs entered as they turned three.
Montessori public school programs had
At present, the passage of forty years
grown to approximately 100 by 1987. In
has washed out much of the clarity and
Systemic
the nineties, this number swelled to al-
precision of the original Montessori
Kahn,1992) is so bad that Montessori in
most 500, with an additional 100 charter
implementation in many public-sector
public schools has sometimes been re-
schools (almost 600 schools in total). By
Montessori programs. This has been
ferred to as “Public School Montessori,”
2013, this number had declined slightly
particularly evident in locations where
a term that reveals the pernicious belief
to approximately 500, but initiatives
well-trained pioneer teachers were re-
that public-sector Montessori is differ-
currently underway promise to drive
placed by teachers with insufficient
ent from private-sector Montessori and
erosion
(Brown,
1991,
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
13
At present, the passage of forty years has washed out much of the clarity and precision of the original Montessori implementation in many public-sector Montessori programs.
the Dekko Foundation, the Hershey
tions at one table, creating a united front
Foundation, and the Oppenheimer
for Montessori public school programs
and Lillard families made it possible for
(Cossentino and Whitecarver, 2012).
NAMTA to take Montessori adolescent
They have also built a research safety net.
program development to a researched
completion of six-year middle school/
NCMPS is working to develop creden-
high school design: from Montessori
tialing and implementation standards for
Erdkinder (farm school for adolescents
early childhood, elementary and adoles-
12-15 years old) to Montessori High
cent Montessori public school programs
School (adolescents 15-18 years old).
in the US. When this work has been
completed, the foundation for imple-
NAMTA’s five-week summer profes-
mentation of authentic Montessori pub-
sional development program began in
lic school programs across the Montes-
2003 to support and prepare specialists
sori continuum, from early childhood
that the urban poor get a watered down
to work at the 12-18 year level. The
through high school, will be firmly in
“Monte-something” because this is all
Erdkinder (land school) culture promot-
place.
that is possible in urban districts.
ed a new emphasis on nature education
and pointed to a “pedagogy of place on
The good news is that we have before us
Of additional concern is the fact that
the land” approach for both rural and
an alliance of the Association Montes-
Montessori public schools have been
urban locations. The majority of Mon-
sori Internationale-USA (AMI-USA),
moved away from their mission of at-
tessori secondary (high school) activity
AMS, NAMTA and the Association
tracting a socio-economic balance of
took place in the public sector (Grove in
Montessori Internationale (AMI) all
50/50, urban/suburban children in the
Redlands California, Montessori High
converging on the challenge of provid-
name of desegregation (formulated
School in Milwaukee, Compass Mon-
ing “Montessori for All Children.” This
during the Montessori magnet school
tessori School in Golden, Colorado and
project features training and model
growth surge). Many Montessori public
Great River High School in St. Paul,
school collaboratives in Hartford, St.
schools are now required to provide pre-
Minnesota), so NAMTA’s contribution
Paul, the District of Columbia and (very
pared environments for 70-80% urban
to public sector Montessori was contin-
soon) in Cleveland, designed to create
poverty students (as measured by free
ued by its adolescent work.
a national implementation culture built
lunch programs). Montessori teachers in
14
around a Montessori organization that
these programs work to provide a Mon-
What is the Vision for 2013?
tessori education to these children, but
Montessori public school programs.
it is clear that a better social mix would
Montessori public-sector district, dis-
The organization will ensure that these
be more effective for the delivery of an
trict charter, or charter schools are more
programs remain authentic and true to
authentic Montessori experience.
than ever in need of “advocacy, technical
Montessori with a charter-authorizing
support, convening and networking, and
agency that ensures quality and, most
NAMTA’s early involvement in public
research and dissemination” says a new
importantly, compliance with Montes-
sector was supplanted by its focus on
and independent organization funded
sori principles and standards.
adolescent design because it is a small
by the American Montessori Society
organization with just one pedagogical
(AMS), charged with working across
NAMTA’s new CMO will not be there
staff person. Under these circumstances,
the whole of the Montessori movement.
just to assist, but rather to sustain and
the organization could not continue to
The National Center for Montessori in
regulate all elements of systemic imple-
be active in both public sector and ado-
Public Sector (NCMPS) has success-
mentation that govern a school, right
lescent heavy-duty reform. The aid of
fully convened all Montessori organiza-
down to assessment. This is a distinct
trains, hires, administers, and regulates
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
departure from past Montessori imple-
�
BOOK REVIEW
mentation efforts which merely provided training and induction. The CMO will mediate district systemic management which may continue to change and diminish the Montessori impact in local districts simply because local districts can be politically motivated and subject to
Kids in the Kitchen by Sara E. Cotner and Kylie D’Alton designed by Angie Coussirat
photography by Kylie D’Alton
legislative change and evolving bureaucratic controls.
Reviewed by Sharon Caldwell
The objective of this initiative is to defeat
There have been a number of recipe
the Sisyphean cycle of Montessori public
books written for children, even some
school start-ups, followed by erosion of
with a specifically Montessori slant,
Montessori principles and practice, then
but Kids in the Kitchen : Simple
Montessori start-ups, and erosion again,
Recipes That Build Independence
etc. This is clearly an unsustainable cycle;
and Confidence the Montessori Way
it is also a tragic waste of resources and
is, nonetheless, a worthy addition to
energy. To obtain comprehensive results,
any bookshelf. The authors are Mon-
the public sector must respect and fully
tessori moms from opposite corners
support Montessori program develop-
of the globe. Their enthusiasm for the
ment and maintenance from the start and
approach and their love and respect
for the many generations of superinten-
for their children shines through every
The recipes are clearly set out with
dents, teachers, families and children to
page of this book. This is what makes
photos of each step, which would al-
come.
Kids in the Kitchen more than a col-
low children who are not yet read-
lection of recipes. The book places the
ing to follow the processes with only
Sustaining power must come from the
child at the center rather than simply
minimal assistance.
Montessori associations. It is our respon-
giving guidance as to how to prepare
sibility to make good on the Montessori
child-friendly meals.
promise not for Montessori’s sake but for
There is nothing trite or condescending about these recipes. The authors
the child’s optimal development in the
Sections include: the rationale be-
public sector, where the best develop-
hind encouraging children to cook;
are interested in cooking rather than
mental programs lead to real educational
how to prepare the kitchen so that
making clown faces on pizzas or cut-
reform, the essential fire of educational
children are able to do as much as
ting out heart-shaped sandwiches.
change, and not the smoke.
possible unassisted; how to choose
This is about real food that children
appropriate utensils; and how to help
can prepare and which would be ac-
David Kahn is Executive Director of the North
a child develop the necessary skills in
ceptable for adults to eat as well.
American Montessori Teachers’ Association. He
line with Montessori principles. Brief
is a leading implementer of Montessori adolescent
descriptions of the different skills a
projects. He was the Founding Director of the
child will need in order to prepare
Ruffing Montessori School East, the Hershey
these meals are illustrated with full-
Montessori School Farm adolescent programs,
color photos of children performing
and as the Montessori High School at University
the various activities.
are addressing this to children, who
Circle, all of which are located in Ohio. VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
15
by Tim Seldin
W
hat we tend to call ‘special
consideration of the rights and feelings
ü to awaken a sense of the human
classes’ are core cultural
of others. The class is not Miss Sally’s
spirit within each of our lives. We
subjects that should flow
class, or Jenny and Sue’s class, but the
hope to provide: a first experience
naturally throughout the daily experi-
Children’s House. We so easily forget
of being connected to all living
ence of the children; they should not be
that core principle of Montessori. We
things on Earth and all men and
considered as ‘separate’ classes taught by
prepare the environment within which
women, past present and those
outsiders on a time schedule convenient
the children learn to live their lives in-
yet to be born; the first stirrings
to the adults.
dependently.
of awe and inspiration at the universe and the world in which
Ideally, the adults who spend their day in the class with the children are, be-
There are several implications here:
sense of philosophical inquiry into
tween themselves, talented and more
A.
than able to teach music appreciation,
is not a core goal, no matter how
wrong, of what is compassionate
choral singing, dance, art, second lan-
much parents (and sometimes ad-
and loving and what is unkind
guages, and movement or physical edu-
ministrators) think it is. Our goal is:
and destructive, of what is worth
Teaching lessons to children
cation to the children. No outside in-
the nature of what is right and
loving and protecting, and what
structors are needed. Art, music, dance,
ü to help children retain
is wrong and should be opposed.
drama, movement, etc. are taught in an
their sense of wonder,
We, ideally, want to instill in
organic way within the ongoing experi-
16
we live; and the beginnings of a
children a sense of the cosmic
ence of the class by people who not only
ü to inspire in a passion for
picture of our lives and work
know the children well but know how
doing things with precision
and their ability, even while very
to teach in a manner totally consistent
and a love of order and
young, to add to goodness in the
with Montessori principles.
excellence in their work,
world and, as the Quakers would
ü to nurture the curiosity,
say, “Let their lives speak.”
The adults are clear that Montessori is
creativity, and imagination
essentially about helping children to find
with which they were born
B. If the class is a Children’s House,
their individual sense of identity, inde-
(to paraphrase Montessori,
and not a ‘Teacher’s House,’ what is
pendence, and autonomy, counter bal-
‘we want not passive minds,
our correct role as adults? Obviously
anced by self-discipline, courtesy, and
but eager active ones’), and
the children do not start off knowing
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
how to prepare and maintain the order
of laminating to cut out
polish the wood and to dust and inspect
of the environment. As young chil-
while watching television?
the materials. (Use a photo of the shelf
dren, their interests tend to lie in other
completely set up as your control of er-
directions, and while they need a sense
ü If so, why do we call our
ror.) After a short time, even pristine
of ownership, they are not likely to de-
classes Children’s Houses?
materials build up oils and dirt on their
velop the ability to play the role of envi-
shiny surfaces. They should be care-
ronmental engineer. While they can re-
ü Or, more relevantly,
fully cleaned and polished. They need
teach skills that they have learned, they
what did Maria challenge
to be inspected for dings and scratches.
are not likely to replace the adults as ‘the
us to do and not do?
Damaged materials should be taken to a
link between the child and the environ-
special ‘hospital’ shelf where they can be
ment.’ While they can play a crucial role
There is a reason why the tables, chairs,
repaired. With some careful thought and
in maintaining the peace of the class and
and even shelves are supposed to be
preparation (and the correct paints and
settling disagreements.
light enough that the children can move
replacement materials), older children
them.
can actually assist in the process of re-
I know that this essay is about special-
sanding or touching up slightly ‘dinged’
ists, but bear with me while we consider
Practical life is not supposed to be the
this issue of the children’s need for ‘psy-
impractical life of carefully sequenced
chological ownership’ of the class in a bit
and color-coded, eye-hand coordina-
Laminated card materials can be cut in
more detail.
tion exercises on the shelves. Those ex-
class by you or your assistant, co-teacher,
ercises are simply used to introduce new
or even a parent volunteer. We need to
There are things that we can and should
skills and tools to very young children
sit on our hands more anyway and stop
do or not do which speak volumes to the
and to break skills down into small sub-
with the endless presentation of lessons.
children about who is really in charge:
skills. Practical Life is intended to be the
“Let my children work!” wrote Jack
real life of maintaining the environment,
Blessington so many years ago. Perhaps
ü Do you and your fellow
going about daily life, preparing food,
more importantly, why can’t we allow
Montessorians long for more
cleaning up and caring for our needs.
children to help us cut laminated mate-
time in the room each day
material.
rials if they wish, once they can demon-
before the children arrive or
Materials should be introduced when
strate that they possess the self-discipline
after they leave to prepare or
the children are present and are aware
and eye-hand control needed to do this
refresh the environment?
of what we are doing. They should not
delicate job correctly? After all, it is the
only know where each item will live on
Children’s House, not your classroom,
ü Do you set out new activities
the shelf and how it is carried and used,
isn’t it?
on the shelves to introduce to
but why. New materials should literally
the children the next day?
be unwrapped with a sense of wonder
Furniture should be rearranged while
with all the children present and passed
the children present, with the children
ü Do you reconsider the layout
from hand to hand. The careful way
or by the children, not magically rear-
of your classroom and rearrange
that they are made, the beauty of an un-
ranged while they are sleeping.
the furniture for the next day?
scratched piece of material, the care with
ü Do you clean up
which they must be handled are all key
C.
introductory lessons.
when we invite children to a les-
after the children? ü Do you take home stacks
And finally, as with any lesson,
son, they have to have the option to Children should take down the mate-
politely decline, to choose another
rials on each shelf every day to dust or
task, or to wait another day. This is
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
17
a delicate balance, because their freedom
New materials should literally be unwrapped with a sense of wonder with all the children present and passed from hand to hand.
of choice is not complete. They may not choose to destroy the room or run outside into the street. And sooner or later, local academic expectations will catch up, and we will be forced to become more highly directed to overcome the child’s preference to play and not work. (But didn’t they teach us in training that children would always choose work over play? Hmmm...)
to play their instruments (think Suzuki
I know that music. It’s Pacabell’s Canon
violins or flutes for example) or sing.
in D Major.)
a sense of trust and autonomy with chil-
F.
We should remember that art,
The same is true in art or any other area.
dren that allows them to let you lead the
music, dance, and movement are
We can teach the children different art
dance from time to time. Sometimes,
not only creative, but also sensorial,
forms; oil painting, water colors, and
they need to accept our role as mentor
exercises and small and large motor-
pastels; still life and self-portraits; im-
and guide, and not just as friend and fa-
skill activities. There is both a creative
pressionism or the art of Picasso. We can
cilitator of their free choice.
‘doing’ side and a cultural literacy side
teach them the history of art. They can
involving the history and appreciation of
learn to mix their own paints.
The secret is to use our power lightly and sparingly, because our goal is to cultivate
D. And so, with specialists, lessons
the subject.
should be by invitation, not a command performance.
And so it goes on... In music, we have the issue of the Montessori Bells and the ability to distin-
No, not all of us feel comfortable with
Whenever possible, we prepare
guish between notes that are higher or
art or can play an instrument. We do
an environment that allows children
lower and to match identical pairs. We
not all dance or know what to do with
to practice the skills that we intro-
can extend the exercise by separating
physical education. But ideally, we press
duce in art, music, or other special
the two sets of bells across the room and
through those things that we do not
areas and to explore new avenues.
challenge the children to hold the note
know for the sake of the children as well
They should be able to do art, listen to
struck in their minds as they walk back
as for our own growth. And we learn
music, or practice their dance moves
to the other set.
along with them, revealing our lack of
E.
quietly with a mirror and little bar as
18
knowledge and present role as a fellow
they wish. Ideally there might be a little
We can teach children about the lives
student. Nothing is more liberating to
art annex off each classroom, open so
of the great composers. They can learn
the child’s soul than to know that she is
that the adults can oversee activities but
to recognize specific instruments in re-
loved and that the adults that she loves
set up for independent work. Ideally, we
corded music. They can be taught to ap-
in turn are not perfect or all knowing
should either immerse the children in a
preciate something about the culture of
either.
second language or duplicate the lan-
the people who create specific musical
guage area in both languages. In a per-
forms from around the world, from tra-
Learning is the one constant experience
fect situation we ought to have sound-
ditional tribal music to jazz and rock and
of our lives, young or old.
proof, glassed-in music practice rooms
roll. They can learn to recognize spe-
where children could go individually
cific musical compositions. (“Mommy,
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
Go to www.MontessoriCensus.org to fill out the form and participate in the census today.
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | Š MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
19
THE WORLD’S LARGEST INTERNATIONAL GATHERING OF MONTESSORIANS
O
by Glenn Goodfellow
n July 31st, 2013 the 27th Interna-
sori’s teachings of a child’s capacity to
tion featured three large interactive class-
tional Montessori Congress began,
explore and study nature.
rooms: Assistants to Infancy (ages 0-3),
marking the world’s largest international
Primary (3-6), and Elementary (6-12),
gathering of Montessorians. Nearly 2500
The 2013 International Montessori
and included activities for children and
people from over 55 countries convened in
Congress allowed participants to look
information for parents. Montessori in
Portland, Oregon to explore the universal
more closely at how Montessori educa-
the Square was the ideal, highly-visible
aspects and unique facets of Montessori.
tion is guided by children’s natural de-
platform for Montessori to shine.
velopment and how that growth fosters a Dr. Maria Montessori established the
respectful relationship with the environ-
Thousands of people passed by the model
International Montessori Congress in
ment. The Congress theme, “Montes-
classrooms to watch the children work in
1929 to raise awareness and understand-
sori: Guided By Nature,” took root in
their beautifully-prepared environments,
ing of Montessori education. Since then,
that dynamic relationship and celebrated
and were in disbelief that even in such
25 subsequent Congresses have followed
the ways in which we are all uniquely
a public venue children were focused and
around the world, with one held ap-
tied to the physical and ecological make-
working as normal! Trainers and guides were
proximately every four years. It has been
up of our surroundings.
on hand to assist viewers with questions.
last held in the United States, and its re-
An initial component that made Congress
Concurrently, 550 conference attend-
turn built much excitement.
attendees feel truly welcome in Portland
ees boarded buses to visit local Montes-
was the attention paid by conference
sori schools throughout the city. Fifteen
The International Montessori Congress
organizers to broadcasting the event, as
schools opened their doors to Congress
is a tradition maintained by the Associa-
well as general messages about Montes-
visitors to walk them through their learn-
tion Montessori Internationale (AMI),
sori education, throughout the city. As
ing environments, explain how the school
and remains open to anyone interested
delegates arrived at the airport, their trains
was established, and answer questions.
in Montessori education. This year’s
featured large ads for Montessori. Street
In a twist of efficiency, conference-goers
Congress was unique with its broad
banners hung around town advertised the
didn’t know which three schools they
support from so many national and lo-
Congress, and interviews with prominent
would be attending until they boarded
cal Montessori membership organiza-
Montessorians were heard on the radio.
their bus. Many people commented on
nearly 40 years since the Congress was
tions, as well as endorsements from edu-
how much they enjoyed visiting learning
cational foundations, universities, and
The very first event most attendees partic-
communities that featured classrooms for
local schools. The Congress was orga-
ipated in was “Montessori in the Square,”
ages at which they themselves did not teach.
nized and administrated by Montessori
a public glass-classroom event held in the
Northwest, formerly the Montessori
heart of downtown Portland. Pioneer
The 2013 Congress daily schedule in-
Institute Northwest, Portland’s AMI
Courthouse Square is a large public plaza
cluded 5 time-blocks, each allowing up
teacher training center.
in the center of the city which regularly
to 6-10 simultaneous “breakout” pro-
plays host to various events such as music
grams, for a total of 70 programs with
Portland, Oregon, nestled within the
festivals and vocational fairs. Organizers
varying numbers of attendees in each.
American Pacific Northwest, is a region
knew that it would be the perfect venue
Conference-goers gathered each day to
known for both its rich biodiversity and
for an event intended to attract both Mon-
hear moving keynote addresses from both
vibrant Montessori community. Here
tessorians and non-Montessorians alike.
a Montessorian and a non-Montessorian.
the study of volcanoes and old growth trees runs in tandem with Dr. Montes-
20
Together these co-presenters led attendThis celebration of Montessori educa-
ees to look at meaningful subjects through
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
Clockwise from back row and around to front John Moncure, President, MEPI; Tim Seldin, Executive Director, The Montessori Foundation; Virginia McHugh, Executive Director, Association Montessori lnternationale-USA; Jackie Cossentino, Senior Associate, National Center for Montessori in the Public Sector; Mark Powell, Montessori teacher and grassroots Montessori advocate; Trevor Eissler, author of Montessori Madness and grassroots Montessori advocate; Sue Pritzker, President, MAA; Richard Ungerer, Executive Director, AMS; Laurie McTeague, Trustee, Trust For Learning; Marianne McCall, Trustee, Trust For Learning; Stephanie Miller, Executive Director, Trust For Learning; Jennifer Davidson, Executive Director, Montessori Institute Northwest and Coordinator of the International Montessori Congress 2013; Jacquie Maughan, Board, NAMTA; David Kahn, Executive Director, NAMTA; Ginny Riga, Principal, Montessori Public School Consulting, LLC; Janet McDonnell, Board, Association Montessori lnternationale Members not able to be present for this photo Stephen Hughes, Pediatric Neuropsychologist and Montessori researcher; Rebecca Pelton, Executive Director, MACTE; Joyce Pickering, Board President, AMS; John Snyder, Board Chair, AMI-EAA
different lenses. Keynote speakers in-
heard André Roberfroid, AMI President,
Japan and Thailand arrive, hearing the
cluded cosmologist Dr. Brian Swimme,
announce Prague, Czech Republic as the
applause for the fabulous keynote speak-
naturalist Paul Hawken, disability advo-
location of the next Congress in 2017.
ers, the smell of Earth filling the massive
cate Judith Snow, and eco-feminist Dr. Vandana Shiva.
exhibit halls from the interactive nature Montessorians from around the world,
displays, the delicious food at the closing
many from diverse backgrounds and train-
Gala Portlandia, on and on and on…
Conference-goers were allowed to es-
ings, came together at the Congress and
tablish their own breakout programming
shared their commonalities with each other.
The staff at Montessori Northwest ex-
tract, giving them more choice to craft a
That spirit of unity and empowerment is
tend their appreciation to the many
uniquely personal Congress program.
still in the air. Closer to home, employees
people who helped make the 27th In-
of Montessori Northwest have an increased
ternational Montessori Congress a great
Other components of the Congress, for
awareness of their ability to achieve great
success, attendees and volunteers alike.
which there is not adequate descriptive
goals together and with broad community
Your hard work created something truly
space in this article, were: an afternoon of
volunteer support.
special and unique for us all.
art displays, a vendor fair featuring nearly
In a way, the individual memories of a
Until this event reconvenes in four years,
100 exhibitors, a museum dedicated to the
Congress attendee are a bit of a dream-
we Montessorians can look forward
role of nature in Montessori, excursions
scape. With so many moving pieces, it
to seeing where the spirit of this year’s
into the beautiful wilds surrounding Port-
was impossible to witness every com-
Congress take the movement next.
land, and a glamorous closing gala party.
ponent. One’s mind recalls the thrill
The closing address of the conference
of seeing busloads of colleagues from
parent education workshops, interactive
See you in Prague!
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
21
Letter from the IMC Chair
A WATERSHED YEAR
O
ver the last year I believe that
year-old Montessori Leaders Collaborative
the Montessori movement
(MLC) in the USA.
quite possibly has reached a
by Tim Seldin
IMC Chair &
Executive Director of the Montessori Foundation
watershed, a metaphor to the
It is important to note that the Montes-
point in terrain where water flowing down-
sori Leaders Collaborative began as an in-
hill begins to flow in a different direction
formal network of Montessori leaders of
than at the lower points that were climbed
AMI, AMS, IMC, MEPI, MF, NAMTA,
to reach that critical spot. We are hopeful
several other AMI-affiliated groups, and
that we have reached a point that will lead
MACTE. Over the course of quite a few
to greater understanding and collaboration
in-depth meetings and conference calls,
among the many Montessori organizations
friendships have been formed and joint
around the world.
initiatives begun. During the Congress the MLC members formalized our commit-
On July 31, 2013, the Association Montes-
ment to continue to seek opportunities to
sori Internationale (AMI) opened its first
work together whenever possible to pro-
International Montessori Congress to be
mote Montessori with a united voice. This
held in the United States in many years.
was an important milestone.
Many things made the event remarkable.
22
The venue was the lovely city of Port-
While limited to Montessori in the United
land, Oregon. The program was master-
States, the Montessori Leaders Collabora-
fully organized. But, for many of us, the
tive offers real hope that the Montessori
essential aspect of the celebration was that
community may be on the right path to re-
it truly welcomed, and was supported by,
spond more effectively to the need for edu-
a number of other Montessori organiza-
cational reform in the US, and may serve as
tions not affiliated with AMI, including the
a model for Montessori in other countries as
American Montessori Society (AMS), the
well. It is important to note that the MLC
International Montessori Council (IMC),
is not a new membership organization; it is
Montessori Educational Programs Interna-
an effective forum for collaboration. Some
tional (MEPI), the Montessori Foundation
promising initiatives have begun, including
(MF), the Montessori Australia Foundation
a collaborative Montessori research project,
(MAF), Montessori Aotearoa New Zea-
a census of Montessori schools in the US,
land (MANZ), and the Trust For Learning:
and a joint effort to strengthen advocacy for
the new foundation that convened the two-
Montessori at the state level. Â
Š MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
Efforts to find ways of working together within the
where the common good is best served by coopera-
Montessori community are not new. I have been part
tion, not competition.
of a number of efforts to build enduring collaborations that were fueled by good will but ultimately
The International Montessori Council was formed
faded because of limited resources, time, and no clear
in 1998 by the Montessori Foundation, in part to
sense of what could be done together or how to begin. encourage Montessori teachers and schools to look beyond the different ways in which they understand In the late 1970s, as an AMS board member, I repre-
and implement Dr. Montessori’s work, to form grass-
sented the society in a series of meetings with AMI.
roots collaborations to expand awareness of, and in-
In the mid-1990s, an informal Montessori Leadership
terest in, Montessori education and, thereby, build
Council, made up of representatives of AMS, AMI,
greater enrollment and stronger schools. Of course,
the Montessori Foundation, NAMTA, and Nienhuis
our primary mission will always will be to be a source
met twice a year and even made a joint proposal to
of affordable help, service, and support to Montessori
the US Department of Education for a joint Mon-
schools worldwide.
tessori-Head Start initiative. The process took a step forward in 2007 with the centennial of the opening
A number of countries have developed umbrella na-
of the first children’s house in Rome. AMI and AMS
tional organizations, including New Zealand, South
decided to send representatives to formally attend one
Africa, the UK, and Australia. A challenge that each
another’s celebrations. After decades of coolness to-
faces is to find ways to work together under an um-
ward each other, leaders of each organization shared
brella that supposedly represents them all without
the same stage.
disempowering one or more segments of the national community. Another is to reach consensus on what
At the local and state/provincial levels, we have long
needs to be done, who will accomplish it, and how
seen fairly informal organizations of Montessori edu-
will it be funded.
cators’ schools. Over the years, some have waxed and waned according to the time and energy of the cur-
There is no one answer, but here in the United States,
rent leaders, but many have endured and show signs
the consensus seems to be that while the organiza-
of growing more organized and increasingly effective.
tions are independent, we will seek ways to work to-
It is my personal belief that the most important work
gether where it serves the common good: pursuing
in the years ahead will come at the state/provincial
advocacy; encouraging and providing assistance to
level, where Montessorians will have the need and
non-aligned state and local organizations; exploring
opportunity to work together. The teacher-educa-
initiatives to promote interest and understanding of
tion and school-certification organizations like AMI,
Montessori; conducting research; and fully imple-
AMS, IMC , MEPI, et. al. will continue to play vital
menting Montessori programs in the public sector.
roles, but the critical need is to reframe our way of thinking from loyalty to one branch of the Montessori community to the whole, at least in those areas
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
23
Letter from IMC Accreditation Director
I
t is with great enthusiasm that I can
be recognized by the state as an accredited
announce a formal change in the
school. We are prepared to do the same for
IMC’s accreditation process. Those
any other states that may require the docu-
members who have been following
mentation, so that the IMC’s accreditation
the articles on the pilot accreditation pro-
can be recognized within that particular
cess will be pleased to know that the board
state. If this is a requirement of your state,
of trustees has approved the new IMC ac-
we ask members to provide the IMC Mem-
creditation format.
bership Director, Margot Garfield-Anderson, with the correct contact information
by Hillary Drinkell
IMC Accreditation Director
We still have a few tweaks to finalize as a
for the required documentation.
result of feedback from the trustees’ schools that have worked through the initial pilot
We will be glad to share our new suite of
phase, but these are minor, and we will be
documents once we’ve completed our up-
ready to roll out the member pilot phase at
dates from our trustees’ pilot schools, and
the November conference. So, what does
we expect to have these available by the
this mean to IMC school members? At the
November conference. We are also look-
November conference, we will be ready for
ing for any qualified educators, who might
some of our members’ schools to enroll in
be interested in serving on accreditation
what will be our second pilot phase. This
teams; we will be doing validator training
will include all the updated information
at the upcoming conference.
from the feedback we received from our trustees’ schools, but it also means that any
We hope this news encourages your school
member pilot-phase schools will be given
community to go through the accredita-
the opportunity to weigh in with their
tion process. More and more Montessori
comments and ideas. This will provide us
schools are being asked whether they are
with final feedback, which will enable us to
accredited, and the beauty of the IMC’s
finalize the new accreditation process. Af-
new accreditation format is that it is user-
ter the second pilot phase, we will be ready
friendly, easily understood, and affordable
to completely provide the new accredita-
to the school. It also allows for diversity
tion format to all schools around the world.
amongst schools, while concentrating on the central issue of what one should expect
We have also sent all relevant documenta-
to find in a responsible school that wishes
tion to the Maryland Board of Education
to represent itself as being a Montessori
for review. We expect them to approve the
program of integrity.
documentation, which will allow for any Montessori schools in the State of Maryland, who receive IMC accreditation, to
24
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
by Melissa Kemendo
A
s a young student in Montessori teacher training, I loved to envision the early Children’s Houses opened
by Dr. Montessori. I dreamed of one day seeing the very first Casa dei Bambini myself and was determined to one day make that dream a reality. All those years ago, it seemed like a far-off, distant dream, but now I am thrilled to say that I have finally done it, and it was every bit
I had traveled to Italy with my daugh-
akin to a museum. I expected to find all
as wonderful as I could have hoped.
ter, then nearly two years old, to visit a
of the information I needed and more in
dear friend in the north and to journey
a quick internet search. In reality, it end-
Historic places are not something that
to Rome to make my dream of seeing
ed up taking more than that just to find
typically excites me. They’re interesting,
the first Casa dei Bambini a reality. Like
the exact address of the first San Loren-
sure, but nothing I would go out of my
every good tourist, I stopped in Venice,
zo school, and I realized that things were
way to see. This is different. I am so in-
took a peek at the Coliseum, and enjoyed
not going to be all that simple.
spired by Montessori’s work, her words,
some authentic gelato, but I would have
the very idea of what she gave to those
been satisfied with my visit to the Casa
Eventually, I found the school’s contact
children all those years ago, and to all
alone. Unfortunately, I didn’t do my
information and, from there, I expected
children, that visiting the first Casa dei
homework and, for a few days, it looked
that arranging a visit would be a breeze.
Bambini really did feel something like I
like that visit might not happen. I knew
I tried email first, and when my message
imagine a spiritual pilgrimage would. I
that there was currently a school oper-
bounced back, I started to worry. Then
had a grin on my face that could be ri-
ating on that location, but my blinding
I spoke with someone at the Opera Na-
valed only by that seen on my wedding
passion for Montessori led me to expect
zionale Montessori, who explained that
day or in the hours following the births
that many others like me would want to
it is “impossible to visit,” since it is a
of my children.
visit the site daily. I expected something
public school. My heart sank.
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
25
I walked inside the building and came to the school’s doorway. Okay, now I’m really, really here! I knocked and waited, containing myself as much as possible. Thanks to my poor planning and inabil-
it, I saw the words CASA BAMBINI di
ity to speak Italian, I feared I had ruined
MARIA MONTESSORI on the wall. I
my chances, but I decided to try anyway.
got butterflies and pulled out my camera.
I sheepishly explained my situation to the
At that point, I thought to myself: Even if
lovely, bilingual girl who ran our bed and
this woman refuses to see me, I was here!
breakfast and asked her if she would call
I am here!
the school on my behalf and beg for permission to visit. I told her I only wanted
I walked inside the building and came
to go in, just for a minute, and would even
to the school’s doorway. Okay, now I’m
extend my stay in Rome if needed. She
really, really here! I knocked and waited,
called. I listened in anticipation. I heard
containing myself as much as possible.
ahs and mhms, as she looked at me, de-
A woman answered, and I nervously ut-
feated, and shook her head ‘no.’ I almost
tered the name of the person I had been
cried. Then, she stamped her foot and
instructed to ask for. She asked some-
waved her fist in triumph, and I almost
thing that I hope I understood and an-
cried again, this time in joy. She hung
swered correctly, but who knows, really?
up and gave me a name, explaining that I
She held up a finger and closed the door.
should go during the children’s 45-min-
I waited, fingers crossed.
ute lunch period and ask for this person, and maybe she would show me everything.
The door opened again and I was invited in. Inside! I was now with two women,
26
The next morning, I set out with my
who noticed my now sleeping daughter
daughter on my back, directions in my
on my back and smiled, oohed, and ah-
hand, and a heart full of hope and deter-
hed. My hostess kindly showed me in-
mination. If nothing else, I would stand
side the classroom that was just inside
outside the gate and take a picture. I
the door. I apologized for my inability
walked to San Lorenzo, made it to Via
to speak Italian, and she sweetly spoke as
dei Marsi, and felt like I was bouncing
much English as she could manage. She
on air as I looked for addresses on the
allowed me to look around, and to take
buildings and walked in the direction of
pictures, but I was filled with so much ex-
the school. I found the school’s address
citement and nervousness that I couldn’t
and walked through a little walkway
focus. I took quite a few shots, but none
and toward the garden. A kindly, elderly
of them very good. It was a once-in-a-
man pointed me in the direction of the
lifetime opportunity, but I felt so grate-
school’s entrance, and, as I walked toward
ful that this woman was giving up some
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
of her lunch break for me, that I didn’t want to be too greedy. I have mixed feelings about that now, but then again, who cares? I made it! Next, I was led outside, through the garden, and into another little classroom. My hostess kept telling me, half apologizing, how “little” it was. She was such a lovely woman. Looking at some of the things on the shelves that were not Montessori materials and at the little tables and chairs, I couldn’t help but think
door play area. It was strange to see the
worked up the courage to ask her to take
how wonderful it is that these items no
contrast between old and new, with the
our picture. It’s funny now how very
longer need to be specially made just for
modern playground equipment against
nervous and shy I felt, as though I were
Montessori schools. They’re actually
the backdrop of buildings well over a
in the presence of a celebrity.
available from many sources and offered
hundred years old. Looking at the gar-
to children in virtually every early-years
dens themselves, I imagined the children
She headed back inside, as my daughter
setting. Progress – and it had all been set
of the current school cultivating the
and I lingered in the garden, soaking up
in motion from this very place!
same soil that children first transformed
as much of the wonder of that space as
into a garden in 1907. Our tour ended
we could. She had just woken up from
there, and as my hostess said goodbye, I
her nap, so I took her out of the mei tai
Finally, I was led to the children’s out-
on my back and she ran around for a moment, while I took pictures of her ev-
WASHINGTON MONTESSORI INSTITUTE AT LOYOLA UNIVERSITY MARYLAND
erywhere. I could not have been happier!
“
As we continue the Montessori approach to education and more and more children and families are exposed to it, communities will begin to change and as the communities change, the nation will change.
“
That’s how I drive education forward.
There was an urgency I had felt since arriving in Rome to see and do as much as possible in our short visit. As I stood there in the courtyard, the urgency all melted away. I had what I’d come for. Melissa Kemendo is an MCI trained Chil-
RHONDA LUCAS-SABATER, M.ED. ’08
dren’s House guide, writer, and mother to two
Founder and Principal, Shining Stars Montessori Academy, PCS Washington, D.C.
young children. She is currently developing and serving as guide for a cooperative Montessori program outside Washington, DC, a first step in the creation of a nonprofit organiza-
LOYOLA.EDU/MONTESSORI 410-617-7777 LEARN MORE ABOUT OUR PRIMARY AND ELEMENTARY ACADEMIC YEAR PROGRAMS
INFO SESSIONS: Sept. 26 and Oct. 24 IN AFFILIATION WITH ASSOCIATION MONTESSORI INTERNATIONALE
tion that will help make a quality Montessori education available to all who desire it for their children. Melissa writes about issues pertinent to Montessori and parenting on her blog, vibrantwanderings.com.
School of Education
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
27
MONTESSORI ENVIRO
”x48” time
Christine M. Sac UNDERSTANDING THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CLASSROOMDr. MANAGEMENT AND THE PATH TO LEARNING IN A MONTESSORI ENVIRONMENT
it to y, same
Introduction
ill nd
The Participants
The students were working toward their Montessori certification allowing them to teach in a Montessori school. The majority of the students were concurrently working towards a Master’s degree in Education. The students had completed the academic phase of the Montessori course work during the summer. The majority of the students were in their first year in the classroom as head teachers. The student teachers began questioning children’s use of the classroom materials. Were the children exploring or were they using the classroom materials inappropriately?
r).
r call
Di
Years of Experience
31%
50%
1 - 7 yrs 8 - 11 yrs 12 - 15+ yrs
19%
004
Level
ew nto
Research Questions How do novice teachers determine what is appropriate exploration with classroom materials How do novice teachers gain the understanding of the relationship between the line they establish in the classroom and classroom management strategies they adopt?
older der. cepts
Methodology
e
r, size e
This study used a mixed method design to take advantage of the strengths of both qualitative and quantitative research. The quantitative data came from the conference questions and responses, using technology from Turning Point for immediate responses from participants. The qualitative data came from the discussion during the sessions. The mixed method allows the qualitative data to tell the story with the quantitative data to support the findings. The participants used clickers to respond to questions during the conference sessions. The best way to get the opinions of Montessori educators is to go to where they congregate. The researcher attends two Montessori conferences per year; a small internationally known conference in Sarasota, Florida sponsored by the Montessori Foundation and the largest annual Montessori conference held in a rotating location across the United States, sponsored by the American Montessori Society (AMS). Selection of the participants at the conferences was a convenience sample. The study needed Montessori teachers to participate in the surveys. The conferences were gatherings of Montessori teachers. The participants were aware the workshop sessions were data gathering sessions as described by the write-up in the conference brochure and by signing consent forms upon entering the room.
Statistics
Glasgow & Hicks (2003) • 2 million new teachers in next 10 years • 50% of new teachers gone in 3 to 5 years • 17% of new teachers won’t last the year • It takes 5 years to embrace a sense of community
Number
Percent
Early Childhood (3-6)
194
79%
EC & Elem I (3-9)
10
4%
Elementary I (6-9)
2
1%
Elem I & II (6-12) Elementary II (9-12)
1 0
0% 0%
All Levels
6
2%
No Answer
34 247
14%
Total
The Results Definition Exploration Exploration is looking, feeling and touching, judging and matching, juxtaposition and finding your own way or a new way to do something. 100% were in agreement with the definition
Materials Used for Exploration 200 150 100
The pictu to th dam thes is the
50 0
Pink T Bead
Divisio
Definition Misuse Misuse of classroom materials is hurting someone with the material, damaging the material, dangerous for the child and the materials, disrespect, swaying from the intent of the materials and using the materials with a lack of purpose. Agreement was split 50 / 50 The definition of misuse and the pictures displayed below
Materials Misused
Divisio Africa Cubin 100 B
Pink T Bead
100 80 60 40 20
Divisio
0
Divisio
Africa
Cubin
100 B
page. B icon.
28
RESEARCH POSTER PRESENTATION DESIGN © 2012
www.PosterPresentations.com
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
SSORI ENVIRONMENT
This Po (versio comm If you templa
Christine M. Sacerdote
By CHRISTINE M. SACERDOTE, PH.D
Did the results match the definition? 90 80 70 60 50
1 - 7 yrs
40
8 - 11 yrs
30
12 - 15+ yrs
20 10
ent
0
%
%
%
% %
Conclusion • Each teacher draws the line of acceptable behavior and use of classroom materials based on prior experiences. • Novice teachers need to be able to recognize the difference between exploration and misuse of the materials and become comfortable enough to let the children explore with the materials. • The study demonstrates more professional continuing education is needed to give the novice teachers the confidence they need to set the line in their classrooms. • The slides demonstrate that the years of experience have an effect on the participant’s responses. • Teacher education programs need to present novice teachers with an understanding of the importance of classroom management skills • The management of the classroom sets the tone for the learning process. • If the children feel free to explore, then the learning will naturally occur through the exploration process.
70
References
60
%
50
%
40
1 - 7 yrs
30
8 - 11 yrs
20
12 - 15+ yrs
10 0
way to
e material, aterials, sing the
The results from the polling of the participants of the two pictures were the materials were being misused. Going back to the definition of misuse the materials are not being damaged and children are not in harms way. What makes these pictures an example of misuse? The determining factor is the number of years of classroom experience. 1 - 7 Years Experience
Pink Tower/Stairs Bead Bars
Exploration 108 49% 101 47%
12 18
Misuse 60% 72%
No Answer 3 43% 4 44%
Division Board 3
67
45%
49
60%
7
41%
Division Board 6 Africa Cubing 100 Board
52 29 57 47
48% 33% 47% 45%
56 82 38 52
47% 58% 49% 54%
15 12 28 24
71% 67% 58% 53%
12 + Years Experience Exploration
Misuse
No Answer
Pink Tower/Stairs
68
31%
7
35%
1
14%
Bead Bars
71
33%
3
12%
2
22%
Division Board 3
50
34%
19
23%
7
41%
Division Board 6
39
36%
34
29%
3
14%
Africa
34
39%
36
26%
6
33%
Cubing
38
31%
22
29%
16
33%
100 Board
34
32%
25
26%
17
38%
• Creswell, J. W. (2009). Research design qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. • Csikszenentmihalyi, M. (1996). Creativity. New York, NY: HarperCollins. • Garrahy, D. A., Cothran, D. J., & Kulinna, P. H., (2005). Voices from the trenches: An exploration of teacher’s management knowledge. Journal of Educational Research, 99(1), 56-63. • Glasgow, N. A., & Hicks, C. D. (2003). What successful teachers do. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. • Gordon A. M., & Browne, K. W. (2004). Beginnings and beyond (6th ed.). Clifton Park, NY: Thompson Delmar. • Lillard, P. P. (1972). Montessori a modern approach, New York: NY. Schocken. • Malm, K. (1992). Behavior management in K-6 classrooms. NEA Early Childhood Education Series. Washington, DC. National Education Institute. • Marzano, R., & Pickering, D. (2003), Classroom instructions that works. Alexandria, VA: Marzano & Associates. • McCombs, B. & Miller, L. (2007). Learner-centered classroom practices and assessment. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. • Montessori, M. (1966). The secret of childhood. New York: NY. Ballantine Books. • Montessori, M. (1967). The discovery of the child. New York: NY. Ballantine Books. • National Association for the Education of Young Children. (2007). Our history. Retrieved from: http://naeyc.org/about/history • Perry, B. D. (2003). Why young children are curious. Early Childhood Today, 17(4). p. 26. • Ramachandran, R. (Ed.). (1998). Creative development in the child the Montessori approach. Kalakshetra, India: Thiruvanmiyur. • Sokal, L., Smith, D. G., & Mowat, H. (2003). Alternative certification teacher’s attitudes toward classroom management. High School Journal,86(3), 8-9. • Stormont, M., Lewis, T. J., & Beckner, R. (2005). Positive behavior support systems: Applying key features in preschool settings. Teaching Exceptional Children, 37(6), 42-49. • Turning Point Technologies (2012). Audio response system defined. Retrieved from: http://www.turningtechnologies.com • Weinberg, D. R. (2011-12). Montessori, Maslow and self-actualization. Montessori Life, 23(4), 16-21. Dr. Christine M. Sacerdote Lander University CPO 6011 320 Stanley Avenue Greenwood, SC 29646 csacerdote@lander.edu
Verify Go to prefer the siz be prin poster 100% a before
Using To add placeh a plac your c to this its new Additio side of
Modify This te differe Righton the click o the lay The co cannot layout
Impor TEXT: placeh left sid neede PHOTO click in TABLE extern adjust table t click F change
Modify To cha the “D choose can cr
© 20
211 Ber pos
Contact VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | © MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
29
Cent e
Ch
ld
i
rM r fo on
sori Le tes
Tomorrow’s
Ma
rshi ade p
gaz
emy
shelf /
eace
Acad
rnati ona dit a io n t
Inte
re
on ati
ve
ent
es
De
pm
nc
Board lo
h o o l Ac c
re
sult Sc
November 7-10, 2013
at The Hyatt Regency Sarasota Bay, 1000 Blvd of the Arts, Sarasota, FL USA.
l Confe
l Co n
S choo
e Book
M CG S
i ne
The P
Th
Join the Montessori Foundation, The International Montessori Council and all of our wonderful exhibitors, keynote speakers (Dr Paul Epstein, Stephanie Miller, Sharon Caldwell, and Dr. Andrew Cutler) and presenters for a weekend of Rejuvenation and Inspiration.
Go to montessori.org to download our conference brochure and registration details. Not on our email list? Just email margot@montessori.org to be added on to the list. We’ll be sending several emails with details about the event and other exciting IMC news such as The IMC’s new Accreditation Program which is being introduced at this event.
MARK YOUR CALENDARS FOR MARCH 20-22, 2014 to attend the West Coast Conference at the beautiful Dolce Hayes Mansion, 200 Edenvale Ave, San Jose, CA, USA. Look for emails early next year for full details.
IMC members get a big discount off the regular price of our conferences, so make sure your membership dues are current, and join us at these events.
30
© MO N T E SSO R I L E A DE R SH I P | W W W. M O NTESSORI.ORG/IMC | VOLUME 15 ISSUE 3 w 2013
2013-2014 MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP INSTITUTE ONLINE!
Distance learning is fast becoming the easiest way for busy administrators and administration personnel at your school to keep up with new information or gain valuable insights. This is an excellent way for first time administrators to learn from the bottom up.
UPCOMING CLASSES Building a World Class Montessori School 28 September to 20 December 2013 Montessori School Boards 4 October to 15 November 2013 Starting a World Class Montessori School from the Ground Up 4 October to 15 November 2013
LOCATION Your office or home, on your computer! INSTRUCTORS Tim Seldin and Sharon Caldwell of the Montessori Foundation Special discount for IMC members and multiple attendees from the same IMC school. For complete information visit the Montessori Leadership wing on our website: www.montessori.org
Check our website www.montessori.org for when our next cohort starts.
VO LU ME 1 5 I SSU E 3 w 2 0 1 3 | WWW.MONTESSORI.ORG/IMC | Š MONTESSORI LEADERSHIP
31
The International Montessori Council 19600 E SR 64 • Bradenton, FL 34212
Non-Profit Org U.S. Postage PAID St. Petersburg, FL
Online Montessori Record Keeping Software Classroom Management | School Administration | Parent Communication *Includes Comprehensive Scope & Sequence with Common Core Alignment!
Record daily classroom activity & observations in mere seconds from ANY web-enabled device! No cumbersome steps, no needlessly long learning curve. MC is a great solution for busy Montessori Educators who are seeking a record keeping solution that just works. All record keeping data is saved and tagged to student profiles in real-time. Progress reports can be generated instantly and parent communication has never been easier. MC includes a comprehensive Montessori Scope & Sequence (Infant - Age 12) with CCSS alignment. In addition, parentfriendly descriptions & photos of Montessori materials are available to help educate the parent alongside the child.
Classroom Management Features: Record Keeping Classroom Observations Attendance Lesson Plans Customized Trackers & Much More!
iPad
Montessori Compass is the user-friendly online record keeping system you have been searching for!
School Management Features: Student Profiles Messaging School Calendar Real-Time Student Metrics Standards Alignment & Much More!
Parent Communication Features: Online Parent Portal Classroom Photos Daily/Weekly Activity Reports Comprehensive Progress Reports School Directory & Much More!
888-619-2229 | www.MontessoriCompass.com www.facebook.com/MontessoriCompass.com | www.twitter.com/MontCompass