WEEKEND EDITION / THURSDAY, SEPT. 29, 2016 VOLUME 91 ISSUE 19 CAMPUS
CAMPUS
Nail, Nafees file formal OCR complaint against President, Texas Tech University
State of the University address hits on points of emphasis for the future
MAKENZIE HARRISON /The Daily Toreador
NAFEES
NAIL
By MICHAEL CANTU
regards to a grade changing complaint and a Title IX complaint regarding a News Editor visiting professor from Chile that was After an alleged verbal agreement was working with the Rawls college, according broken by Texas Tech President Lawrence to the email. Schovanec, Lance Nail, former dean of Nail currently serves on the Tech Inthe Jerry S. Rawls College of Business novation Hub and Research Park advisory Administration, and Saba Nafees, former board and is a professor of finance. Student Government Association GraduIn exchange, Nail said in the email ate Vice President, have filed a complaint that was sent on Wednesday afternoon, he against Tech. would not sue the university or speak to the media on subjects regarding an incident of discrimination against Nafees, a graduate student biology from Fort I glanced at it (email from Lance Nail on in Worth, by the Dean of the formal complaint). I saw some things the Graduate School, Sheridan. that I emphatically refute. With that said, Mark “ N o w t h a t D r. I think we handled that whole process ap- Schovanec is the this good propriately, and I should probably refrain president, faith agreement has from any further comment at this time. been violated,” Nail wrote in the email. — Lawrence Schovanec The review never Texas Tech President happened, and the vice presidential role was not offered, The complaint, which was filed on according to the email. Sept. 12, asked the Office of Civil Rights, The root of Nafees’ complaint came a federal office, to conduct an investigation primarily from an incident she had with into the Equal Employment Opportunity Sheridan, according to the email. In and the Title IX practices of Tech and the a meeting with Sheridan, Nafees was Office of the President, according to an updating him on ongoing projects, while email from Nail sent to his friends and she was still graduate vice president for colleagues and to The Daily Toreador. the SGA. The catalyst for this complaint was a “In that meeting, Dean Sheridan put broken verbal agreement between Scho- his finger in her face and told her that she vanec and Nail, according to the email had better learn her place and would not sent Wednesday afternoon. The agree- remove his finger from her face until she ment was to have an independent entity would state that he was the sole person review earlier complaints regarding Nail in charge of all graduate related matters,” and to give Nail a new vice presidential Nail wrote in the email. role for Nail at the Tech Innovation Hub. The independent entity review was in SEE ORC, PG. 2
TIMELINE OF EVENTS EARLY JUNE
Horn professor Jay Conover attends graduation ceremony. He sees three MBA students graduate even though they did not pass his class. Conover contacts the Office of the Provost.
2015
MORNING OF JULY 29, 2015
2015
1:39 P.M. JULY 29, 2015
2015
SEPTEMBER 2015
2015
LATE OCTOBER 2015
2015
NOV. 10, 2015
2015
FEBRUARY 2016
2016
MAY 26, 2016
2016
JUNE 1, 2016
2016
AUG. 1, 2016
2016
SEPT. 16, 2016
2016
Conover goes to the media with the gradetampering allegations. In at interview with The Daily Toreador, Conover said College of Business Dean Lance Nail signed on the grade-change form as the instructor.
Provost Lawrence Schovanec releases a statement saying he formed a committee to review the alleged changes.
Saba Nafees alleges to Nail discrimination by Graduate School Dean Mark Sheridan.
Ad hoc committee submits written report to Schovanec.
Tech releases report, and Nail announces his resignation as dean effective Dec. 31.
Nafees officially files complaint to EEO about Sheridan.
CAMPUS
Letter details alleged Title IX, EEO violations By AMY CUNNINGHAM Editor-In-Chief
In a June 1 letter, Lance Nail, former dean of the Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration, alleges President Lawrence Schovanec and Graduate School Dean Mark Sheridan violated Title IX and EEO policies during events involving a graduate student. Nail provided the letter, which was addressed to Vice Chancellor and General Counsel John Huffaker, as an attachment to an email titled, “An Important Message for Texas Tech Stakeholders.” The email was sent Wednesday afternoon from Nail’s personal email account. Saba Nafees, 2015-16 graduate vice president of the Student Government Association and a graduate student in biology from Fort Worth, told Nail about two separate incidents involving then-Provost Schovanec and Sheridan, according to the letter.
Nail has been an informal mentor to Nafees since 2014, according to the letter. On Wednesday after the State of the University event, Schovanec said “I glanced at it (email from Lance Nail on the formal complaint),” Schovanec said. “I saw some things that I emphatically refute. With that said, I think we handled the whole process appropriately, and I should probably refrain from any further comment at this time.” The Daily Toreador reached out to Michele Moskos, senior director of communications and marketing for the College of Business, for comment. In an email, Moskos directed all inquiries to Chris Cook, managing director of the Office of Communications and Marketing, who said Schovanec’s remarks were currently the university’s only statement.
SEE LETTER, PG. 2
Nail files complaint to General Counsel John Huffaker.
Official memo regarding Nail’s complaint is sent.
Schovanec takes office as Tech president.
Nafees and Nail file official complaint to the federal Office of Civil Rights.
President Lawrence Schovanec gives his annual State of the University address on Wednesday in the Student Union Building Ballroom. In his address, Schovanec provided a list of statistics and improvements the university has made within the past year regarding student success, enrollment and upcoming campus installations.
By REECE NATIONS Staff Writer
Texas Tech President Lawrence Schovanec, in his first State of the University address, discussed student achievement while focusing on how the university will continue to sustain its tradition of excellence and work toward greater and broader research accomplishments. “Twenty years ago in 1996, the Board of Regents established the Texas Tech University System,” Robert Duncan, Tech System chancellor, said. “At that time it consisted of Texas Tech University with 22,000 students, a medical school and a nursing school across the Marsha (Sharp Freeway). 20 years later, we now have two comprehensive medical institutions, Angelo State University, and a $1.1 billion endowment.” The goal of the system is to exemplify academic achievement and increase awareness of the outstanding accomplishments of Tech’s students and faculty, Duncan said. By expanding the system in its mission to strive for greatness, the prestige of Tech’s identity will grow in the same way. In his introduction of Schovanec, Duncan highlighted the president’s qualities as a well-respected leader with the experience to lead the university to further achievement. Schovanec was appointed president of the university by the Board of Regents in July and officially took office on Aug. 1, according to the Tech website. “It’s an honor and a privilege to work with (Duncan), and to work with our regents.” Schovanec said, “As well as the deans, faculty, staff and students of Texas Tech University.” Schovanec emphasized the accomplishments of students and the institution as a whole in his address. Enrollment is at 36,551 students, a record high for the university. While enrollment from the freshman class is down, total enrollment remains high because of a first-year retention rate of almost 84 percent, the highest in 10 years. Hispanic enrollment is at 24.2 percent, less than 1 percent away from qualifying as a Hispanic Serving Institution, he said. “This year, we’ve already committed to funding a new program called the Program of Inquiring and Investigative Thinking,” he said. “We’re going to recruit 100 students per year for the next four years to be in this program. We will pay them a stipend to be involved in creative activity and research, and then they will be paired with a faculty mentor. We want to connect our students to faculty mentors early on and for them to remain partners in their success for a lifetime.”
SEE STATE, PG. 2