WEDNESDAY, NOV. 11, 2015 VOLUME 90 ■ ISSUE 46
EDITORIAL
BASKETBALL
PG. 4
R AW L S T I M E L I N E
PG. 8
ONLINE
INDEX OPINIONS LA VIDA SPORTS CROSSWORD CLASSIFIEDS SUDOKU
4 6 7 2 7 6
RAWLS COLLEGE OF BUSINESS
NAIL RESIGNS BUSINESS COLLEGE DEAN TO RESIGN DEC. 31, REMAIN TENURED PROFESSOR AS RESULT OF GRADE-TAMPERING INVESTIGATION By AMY CUNNINGHAM
T
Managing Editor
he resignation of Lance Nail, dean of the Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration, is effective Dec. 31 as a result of a university committee’s conclusion that he violated grade-change procedures. According to the ad hoc committee’s report, which was submitted to Provost Lawrence Schovanec in late October, the dean’s decision to change the grades of four Master’s of Business Administration students was unanimously considered unjustified and “badly flawed.” Nail will remain a tenured professor of finance in the college, according to a Texas Tech news release, and he will stay as the chairman of the Texas Tech University Innovation Hub at Research Park board of directors. Nail also used intimidation tactics to sway the testimonies of witnesses, according to the report. Jay Conover, Horn professor of statistics who reported the grade tampering, said the committee wrote a good report that clearly states the dean is guilty of violating the grade operating procedures outlined in OP 34.03. “I’m further surprised that he still hasn’t been relieved of his duties now that the report has come out,” Conover said. “He won’t be relieved of his duties until the end of December, and I think that’s very unfortunate.” Conover said he first reported the grade changes in early June after seeing three students graduate with MBAs, even though they did not pass his graduate-level statistics course. Nail disregarded operating policy because, according to the report, he said Conover was biased against the students and poorly taught the course. The committee found no evidence to
support Nail’s claims that Conover had any prejudice against the students or that his classroom conduct was unsatisfactory, according to the report. “I think he did it because he wanted to get me out of the business school,” Conover said, “and he offered these four students an opportunity if they would write a bad report saying what a terrible teacher I am and the grade was a result of bad teaching.” Nail told the committee, according to the report, he felt pressured to not follow OP 34.03 because graduation was coming up and there were possible job opportunities being lost for the MBA students. However, the committee concluded the dean had ample time to form a grade appeals board because Conover informed students of final grades March 18, two months before the semester ended, according to the report. “Given the circumstances we find no justification for bypassing OP 34.03,” according to the report. There is no indication Nail considered a formal grade appeal because, according to the report, a March email shows Nail decided the students would take an alternative exam shortly after Conover told them their final grades. Direct evidence shows five students in the graduate statistics course were given an alternative exam, which was requested by Nail, according to the report. A faculty member, whose name was redacted from the report, wrote the test but did not know the test would be treated as an equivalent of a face-to-face, in-class exam. Other students were not given the opportunity to take the alternative exam, according to the report, and only four of the five students had their grades changed.
SEE RESIGNATION, PG. 2
TO VIEW THE COMMITTEE’S FULL R E P O R T, V I S I T D A I LY T O R E A D O R . C O M
BACKGROUND
BIOGRAPHY
How We Got Here: College of Business dean resigns
Nail spent three years in college dean position By AMY CUNNINGHAM Managing Editor
Lance Nail began his time at the Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration in the Fall 2012 semester. Nail was appointed as dean of the college on Aug. 15, 2012, according to his
faculty biography on the college’s website. He was previously the dean of the University of Southern Mississippi’s business college. Nail was chosen as dean out of more than 50 applicants, according to an August 2012 article in The Daily Toreador.
SEE BIO, PG. 2
CAMPUS
Students react to dean’s resignation announcement By KRISTEN BARTON News editor
Lance Nail, dean of the Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration, announced his resignation Tuesday, effective Dec. 31. In July, the College of Business was investigated for allegations of grade tampering, according to a previous article in
The Daily Toreador. Texas Tech Provost Lawrence Schovanec formed an advisory committee to look into the allegations. Jay Conover, Horn professor of statistics, reported the grade tampering after the May commencement ceremony, according to the article. He noticed students who had performed poorly in his classes and said four Master’s of Business Administration
students had their grades changed after he looked at their transcripts. Conover said he requested the transcript of all 42 students he had taught during the semester and saw the grades did not match his grade book, according to the article. Two students had D’s changed to B’s, one a D to an A and a fourth a C to an A.
SEE BACKGROUND, PG. 2
By KRISTEN BARTON News editor
O n Tu e s d a y, L a n c e Nail, dean of the Jerry S. Rawls College of Business Administration, announced his resignation after an investigation of grade-tampering allegations. Once these allega-
tions were made, Lawrence Schovanec, Texas Tech provost, formed a committee to investigate. The report revealed the official operating policy for allowing a grade change was not followed by Nail.
SEE REACTIONS, PG. 2