The Argonaut | February 1, 2024

Page 1

February 1, 2023

UIARGONAUT.COM

FOR, OF AND BY THE STUDENTS SINCE 1898

‘I don’t want to be ashamed to be a vandal’ Volleyball player details alleged abuse by coach Joanna Hayes ARGONAUT

Three weeks into the season, hope seemed lost. Three weeks into the season, the alleged abuse started waving its red flag. Three weeks into the season, she wondered if she wanted to quit. A player from the 2023-24 University of Idaho women’s volleyball team shared her personal experience and accounts of the alleged abuse from Head Coach Chris Gonzalez with the Argonaut. The scandal made headlines initially in the Orange County Register in late December, when several anonymous and named volleyball members told their stories to the California

news outlet. They detailed physical, emotional and mental abuse as well as experiences on and off the court with Gonzalez, a former Olympic volleyball coach who has had 15 coaching positions in 21 years. One player decided to tell her story as a Vandal, and as someone who hopes and desires to stay a Vandal. She told the Argonaut that she saw the signs three weeks into her time as a Vandal athlete. The Argonaut granted her anonymity in telling her story, because of the sensitive nature of the issue and an ongoing investigation into the matter by UI. After spending her freshman and sophomore years at a different college,

the former Idaho assistant coaching staff recruited the player. She had little to no interaction with Gonzalez before signing to the university and arriving in Moscow for summer training. A few weeks after her initial commitment, the assistant coaching staff, those who she had interacted with, and learned about the program from, left. She says she almost never saw Gonzalez during summer training. The season seemed bright and hopeful. She had made the leap, crossed the river from a different college to a NCAA Division I school. She was ready for the competition to rise exponentially. She was prepared for higher expectations, for grueling training. She was ready to be a Vandal.

James Taurman-Aldrich | Argonaut

All that changed after the team’s third tournament of the 2023 season. The Idaho volleyball players travelled to Edwardsville, Illinois, where they would reach a record of 1-9 (the team’s record over the last two years in 5-51). She said that Gonzalez put Idaho in this tournament to win. He thought they would win these games, and then they didn’t. “He freaked out on us on the bench,” the player said. “He took us aside and threw the line up at us and said ‘I don’t even know who wants to f---- play.’ It kind of felt like at that point he had given up on us.” Hope wanes The Sept. 8-9 tournament was the moment this player’s vision for the season blurred red. She could only see warning signs, signs to leave, after that moment. A coach she barely knew, barely interacted with, gave up hope three weeks in, she said.   “I’ve played the game for 14 years, and I’ve never had a coach behave like that. And I’ve had some hard a-- coaches,” she said. The signs and alleged abuse became ever more frequent as the season went on, as the losses piled up and the players became exhausted. She said after the team traveled to Northern Arizona University on Sept. 23, Gonzalez held a team meeting. This was nothing out of the ordinary. However, at this meeting Gonzalez reportedly proceeded to show a failure montage video of a single player, a video of mistake after mistake one player made.   The player said the team has an audio recording of this meeting. The NAU incident motivated players to approach administration. They brought forward audio recordings, video evidence and, as the player put it, an approximately 26-page long document that details any and all accounts of physical, mental and emotional abuse they allegedly were victims of at the hands of Gonzalez. SEE VOLLEYBALL, PAGE 3

Players celebrate a point against Montana State University

Reaction to King Road Demo Law Students on ui school opinion decision sued Rebekah Weaver ARGONAUT

three students claim discrimination Andrea Roberts ARGONAUT

The University of Idaho College of Law is facing its third lawsuit in the past few years. Three students filed the lawsuit in September of 2023. The original lawsuit has been amended in December of 2023. The three students in the lawsuit are referred to as Jane Doe, Kelly Doe and John Doe. According to court documents and public records, the University’s Law Department receives federal funding. Due to this, they must follow non-discrimination laws. According to the plaintiffs, this policy has not been met. The plaintiffs are current and former students at the College of Law and claim that they have endured discriminatory treatment from the staff, fellow students, and the university itself. The plaintiffs also claim that these actions have caused them to leave Idaho for their safety. All the plaintiffs identify with the LGBTQIA+ community and have disabilities. Furthermore, two are people of color. Kelly and John Doe currently attend school remotely, and Jane Doe has switched schools. SEE LAWSUIT, PAGE 4

News, 1

Life, 6

Sports, 8

Opinion, 10

The demolition of the King Road house, site to the crime scene where four University of Idaho students were murdered last year, took place in the early morning of Thursday, Dec. 28, during the university’s Christmas break. This led to an array of different reactions from current students at UI. Despite the victims’ families issuing a statement that begged for it not to be done, the university still went ahead with the demolition as planned. The school aimed to reduce the effect of the demolition on students by scheduling the demolition to occur over the break, as opposed to during the semester. Students had varying reactions to the news that the demolition had occurred over the break, ranging from strong agreement with the timing of the demolition and the need for healing to questioning if it was truly the right call. Jorja Darrow, a sophomore at UI, gave her opinion as to why she believed it was a mistake. “It was demolished a little too soon, because it’s an ongoing investigation and the trial hasn’t even begun,” Darrow said. “I know they [the university] wanted to do it for healing purposes but I think it’s more important to have the evidence than tear it down.” Darrow also expressed her concern towards potential lack of evidence, with a trial date for Bryan Kohberger not having been set thus far. She commented on how she thought the demolition of the house did not make a big difference in the healing process.

Samantha Shaffer, a senior at UI, had a varying point of view. “The scene was already contaminated enough with how many people were in and out of there. I think it gave the parents a little bit of relief and resolution,” Shaffer said. “There is no resolution for the parents with a trial right now, since it hasn’t started yet, and a jury wouldn’t even be able to go in there, so they would have to go off the pictures anyways.” Shaffer continued to agree with the university as to how the destruction of the King Road house will only bring about more healing. She added that students do not need to be constantly reminded of what has happened. “I don’t think we need a reminder [of the murders] up and still standing,” Shaffer said. The demolition of the house was also

remarked upon by Erik Brown, former UI student. “I understand their desire for healing within the student body, regarding what happened, but I’m more concerned with a suspect actually being convicted,” said Brown. Brown described how he felt it made more sense to wait until a conviction happened to ensure there is no longer a need for the house. He thought it would be smart to give the police and jury every chance to convict a suspect. “Even if they are determined that they have gathered all the evidence they need, it would have made more sense to me to wait. I think that starting the trial would bring much more closure and healing than just tearing down the house,” Brown said.

Ben DeWitt | Argonaut

Construction crews were able to bring down the house in about 90 minutes University of Idaho

Volume 125, Issue no. 5

Recyclable


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
The Argonaut | February 1, 2024 by The Argonaut - Issuu