The role of carbon in climate change: a life‐cycle‐thinking approach to a complex issue Dr. Marco Raugei The Bri(sh Carbon Group, University of Manchester 20th December 2012
The Earth’s atmosphere
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
2
Solar Radia>on
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
3
The Greenhouse Effect
With NO Greenhouse Effect the avg. temperature of the Earth would be -19˚C (-2 ˚F)!
H2O, CO2, CH4, N2O, …
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
4
The Carbon Cycle
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
5
The Carbon Cycle Exchange pool: •
The primary source of carbon to the atmosphere is outgassing from the Earth's interior at mid‐ocean ridges, hotspot volcanoes, and subduc(on‐ related volcanic arcs. • Some of the outgassed carbon remains as CO2 in the atmosphere • Some is dissolved in the oceans as HCO3‐ • Some is fixed by photosynthesis as biomass
Reserve pool: •
Carbon is slowly removed into long‐term storage through • Pedogenesis (soil forma(on) • Fossil fuel forma>on (especially coal and black shales) • Sedimentary carbonate rock forma>on (largely biogenic)
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
6
Homeosta>c climate control
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
7
Climate records
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
8
Climate records
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
9
Climate records 392
(2012)
(1950) T ∝ 18O/16O ratio
(1950)
Source: J.R. Petit, J. Jouzel. et. al. Climate and atmospheric history of the past 420 000 years from the Vostok ice core in Antarctica, Nature 399, pp 429‐436, 1999 UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
10
Anthropogenic carbon emissions
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
11
Fossil fuel burning
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
12
Deforesta>on
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
13
Soil erosion
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
14
CaLle husbandry
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
15
Non‐linearity and unpredictability: Oceanic ‘conveyor belts’
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
16
Non‐linearity and unpredictability: Arc>c methane
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
17
Non‐linearity and unpredictability: El Niño Southern Oscill.
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
18
Two possible reac>ons 1. Anosognosia (noun): Real or feigned ignorance of the presence of disease. 2. Precau>onary principle: “if an ac(on or policy has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of scien(fic consensus that the ac(on or policy is harmful, the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking the ac(on”. •
In some legal systems, as in the law of the European Union, the applica(on of the precau(onary principle has been made a statutory requirement.
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
19
Technological fixes: the importance of Life Cycle Thinking
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
20
Technological fixes: the importance of Life Cycle Thinking •
The search for alterna(ve (less carbon‐intensive) energy sources…
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
21
Technological fixes: the importance of Life Cycle Thinking The search for alterna(ve (less carbon‐intensive) energy sources…
•
…must obey the laws of physics!
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
22
Technological fixes: the importance of Life Cycle Thinking
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
23
EROI of Photovoltaics: new calcula>ons
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
24
EROI of Photovoltaics: new calcula>ons 90 80 70
EROI
60 50 40 30 20 10
0 mono‐c Si multi‐c Si ribbon Si CdTe PV Oil (min.) Oil (max.) PV (PE‐ PV (PE‐ PV (PE‐ (PE‐eq.) eq.) eq.) eq.) UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
Coal (min.)
Co (ma
25
Geo‐engineering solu>ons: uncertain and risky
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
26
Beyond technological fixes
I = P ∙ A ∙ T Technology Impact
Affluence Population
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
27
Addressing ‘P’ and ‘A’ •
‘The Limits to Growth’ (Club of Rome/MIT, 1972)
•
‘De‐growth’ (Georgescu‐Roegen, 1979)
•
‘A Prosperous Way Down’ (Odum and Odum, 2001)
•
‘Sustainable retreat rather than sustainable development’ (Lovelock, 2006)
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
28
Conclusions •
Recognizing the problem
•
Life Cycle Thinking
•
‘Out of the box’ thinking
•
Paradigm shiZ
•
‘Way down’ does NOT have to mean ‘back to the cave’!
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
29
Thank you •
Ques>ons?
•
Comments?
•
Concerns? Dr. Marco Raugei (marco.raugei@esci.upf.edu) UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change, ESCI – Pompeu Fabra University, Barcelona, Spain Faculty of Technology, Design and Environment, Oxford Brookes University, Oxford, UK Center for Life Cycle Analysis, Columbia University, New York (NY), USA
UNESCO Chair in Life Cycle and Climate Change
30