RECONSTRUCTION OF THE CASTLE OF AVIGLIANA A touristic center for Susa Valley Final Thesis Book by Vitรณria Luppi
1
POLITECNICO DI MILANO School of Architecture Urban Planning Construction Engineering Master of Architecture - Built Environment Interiors
Author: VITÓRIA LUPPI Student ID: 896376
Supervisor: ALESSANDRO ROCCA Academic Year 2019/2020
2
3
ÂŤWe excavate the past in order to find memories that are embedded in places, like the work of archaeologists. It is a searching and researching process that drives our curiosity. It allows deep thinking and also facilitates encountering things that have been forgotten, erased or vanished by our global modernization. This is the first step of our process often full of surprises and discoveries through which we begin to believe in the idea of excavating collective memories. Then that archaeology, the process of thinking from the past to the future, slowly becomes architectureÂť (Tsuyoshi Tane, Archaeology of the Future, Tokyo, TOTO Publishing, 2018).
4
5
I dedicate this work to everyone that helped me in this process, even with small attitudes. My biggest thanks goes to my father, my mother and my grandfather, who always believed in my potential and made my dreams possible.
6
7
ABSTRACT
This thesis work presents a design proposal for a touristic center in the archaeological site of the Avigliana’s Castle, in the Avigliana city, Susa Valley, now characterized by the presence of the castle’s walls architectural ruins. Located in the top of the Pezzulano peak (+440) and accessible only by walking through a stone natural path, the ruins’ grandiosity and importance remains, but in need for a reconnection with the city and the Valley. The Susa Valley is rich in history and nature, with touristic attractions like the Sacra di San Michele, however there isn’t any reference point to organise the tourism and its activities in the Valley. Based on the understanding of the castle’s history and on the analysis of the present tourism, a specific site project was designed with three pavilions and a connection path, which dialogues with the ruins in a way that evokes the place’s imaginary and realm and its memory. The project aims to bring the castle’s importance back to the city and to the valley by telling its history, promoting encounters and appreciation, and respecting the archaeological site and its contemplative elements.
Keywords: Avigliana’s Castle; Avigliana; Susa Valley; Topography, Archeology; Reuse; New Intervention; Peak; Archeological Site
8
9
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CONTEXT p. 13
ANALISYS p. 25
CONCEPT p. 57
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL p. 65
DESIGN DEVELOPMENT p. 103 Final Thesis Studio D p. 105 Thesis FAUUSP p. 117 Final Thesis p. 133
REFERENCES p. 237
BIBLIOGRAPHY p. 251
10
11
CONTEXT
12
13
ITALY
14
15
PIEDMONT
16
17
SUSA VALLEY
18
19
AVIGLIANA CITY
20
21
CASTLE OF AVIGLIANA
22
23
ANALYSIS
24
25
SUSA VALLEY TOURISM
The tourism is one of the most important activities on the Susa Valley. With data from the Tesori del Valle di Susa, it was possible to understand the most requested touristic attractions (many of them related to culture) and also that the italians are interested on their own country history. Unfortunately, the existent info points and cultural spaces are not well spreaded for tourists or local population.
26
27
28
29
AVIGLIANA CITY
Avigliana, Vian-a in piemontese, with 23,22 km² and 12.480 inhabitants (sense of 2017, January), is a town and commune of Turin in the Piedmont region. The city rises 383 meters from the sea level, and its about 25 kilometers from Torino by walking trough Val di Susa, a strategical position in an economically and military sense. The landscape was mostly formed during the big glacial periods, when the valley received mass of detritus from moraine period and generated two lakes, called Piccolo (365 meters from sea level) and Grande (352 meters from sea level, approximately 100 hectares, maximum profundity 30 meters), today used by aquatic sports’ lovers. It was during the last two glacial periods (Riss, 230.000 years ago, and Wurm, 120.000 yeras ago) that the lakes were formed, but nowadays only these two lakes remained in Avigliana.
30
31
Excavations along time found fossils of molluscs and other animals, an entire paleofauna, what motivated the regional law nº 46 in 1980, May 16th, founding the natural park of Avigliana’s lakes (410 hectares) in order to maintain the environmental heritage. The alps panorama was formed specially during the Mesozoic with under the sea volcanos, giving origin to lava rocks which formed the Pirchiriano peak, where is located the Sacra di San Michele (962 meters), and the Pezzulano peak, with Avigliana’s castle in the top (467 meters). The landscape, with an ecological and climate peculiarities (lakes, mountains, city), is extremely attractive for tourism, which unfortunately is not well disclosure nowadays.
32
The historical centre of the city goes up the Pezzulano peak, with the ruins of the castle visible specially from the Piazza Conte Rosso, surrounded by medieval houses and where was concentrated many public activities in the past during the medieval period, having now the Municipality and Tribunal of the city. The main city’s activities before the Second World War were agriculture, livestock and handicraft, being still current nowadays. After the war, there was a notable shift of people to the cities, phenomena that happens even in small cities.
33
34
35
36
37
CASTLE OF AVIGLIANA
Before talking about a new architecture and a new project, it’s necessary to understand the castle’s history over time, its importance and how it was seen before becoming the ruins now, even those with major importance to the city nowadays. Even with many different elements and languages, for example the two towers, one circular and another square shape, all of them dialogue with one another. The current situation of the castle is due to two major historical events: the French invasion and the carelessness of correct administration over time, not earthquakes or atmospheric events. In order to situate these events, a timeline with the main events is going to be presented along the paper. In the 574, the Lombardo King Cleph (Clefi) built the castle of Avigliana on the
38
39
top of the Pezzulano peak, but there is no documentation of it being used as residence or military. From 750, with the end of Lombardo domination, the population of Avigliana gradually moved from the Dora river margins to the peak Pezzulano, in order to escape from the instability due to the passage of many people in the Val di Susa. It was documented that the peak of Pezzulano was fortified in the X Century, but the first document that mentions the castle is on 961. The city depended from the Abbey of Novalesa, but from 888 some invasions of the Saracens made people take refuge inside the Sacra di San Michele to do not succumb to foreign domination. The fight against the Saracen was won by the Arduin di Ivreva, or Arduin V, in the XI Century, which also built the first settlement of Avigliana’s castle. In 1046,
40
his granddaughter married Oddone di Savoia, bringing interest in the region of Piemonte, mainly commercial. It was in the 1174 that the castle was destroyed by Federico Barbarossa in his assaults. During the Savoia’s expansion to Turin and their subsequent transference to the court at Torino, they used Avigliana as house to the Savoia’s counts and the castle gained importance as military fortress. For the inhabitants of the city it didn’t change their routine, even if Avigliana city was always important as a traffic point for those who walked along the alps. The ‘strada del Cenisio’ and ‘del Monginevro’ were used for the merchants that attended the big fairs at Fiandre and Champagne zone, and passing by the city, a toll should be paid to the city.
Until 1386, the Savoia lived their golden period, specially by the toll from the roads and commercial activities. Between the XII and XIV century, Avigliana’s castle gained two different fortifications. In the XV Century, Avigliana was made important by being strategic to defend the borders from the French’s invasion being used for the Savoia court occasionally. With the death of Amedeo VIII di Savoia, in 1451, there were five successors in a period of half century, having Filiberto II di Savoia as the last of this period. Filiberto II made agreements with Luigi XII, current France’s king, and allowed French military troops to access and go through Val di Susa to access Lombardia. After the death of Filippo II, the situation got worse due to problems with French crimes. Carlos III, Savoia count, closed the borders and Francis I, new king of France, sent his army
by orders of the marshal De Montmorency. In 1536, after conquering the city of Susa, the French army partially destroyed the castle of Avigliana by gun firing it. The walls, which were not built to resist the new armoury, did not resist and the enemy was able to open a hole and penetrate the fortress. For about twenty years, the Piemonte region was disputed between France and Spain. It was only with Emanuele Filiberto, who won the San Quintino battle, that the Savoy won back their prestige and in 1559 the countries signed a peace agreement. In 1627 the war between France and Spain has been resumed, attacking the castle. The Duke Carlo Emanuele, by the side of the Spanish, was forced to ratify the peace agreement at the Castello di Avigliana. The Avigliana’s population
41
decayed from 2000 to 260 and many houses destroyed. In 1655 the castle was restructured and modernized probably by Amedeo di Castellamonte, but in 1691 that a French army, by the command of Catinet general, exploded the fortification of the castle, from which it remains only the ruins now.
42
43
44
45
MASTERPLAN
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
46
47
CONTEXT TRANSVERSAL SECTION
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
48
49
CONTEXT LONGITUDINAL SECTION
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
50
51
From the ruins today, it is still possible to recognize some aspects of the castle planimetry, such as the base of the square tower, the door between the high and low court; the high courtyard presented the residential part and the lower courtyard, before the entrance to the central tower, there were the warehouse, the oven and the stalls. The biggest remaining feature is the fake round tower, the highest existing wall, which existed to impose a sense of power on the castle (and still does), without any specific function. Nowadays, the ruins of the castle are open for visitation, with no control and little maintenance ( just cutting the plants). The local administration cannot administrate the management of a large cultural asset, and the suggestion of the local archaeologist and the Associazione Archeologica Aviglianese is an awareness of the importance of space as history and memory and the need to respect the ruins, for tourists and local population as well.
52
53
SITE VIEWS
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
54
55
CONCEPT
56
57
WHAT _A touristic center divided into three pavilion and connected by a pathway. The three pavilions: museum, open theatre and belvedere HOW _Three pavilions made of wood structure with superficial foundation points - not agressive on the archeological site _Pathway with natural stone from Avigliana city following the existing pathway track sequel
WHY _Organise the tourism of the Susa Valley into one main point of reference _Value the history of the Castello di Avigliana and its’ importance to Avigliana city _Respect to the archeological site _Understand the history of the place _Highlight the natural views and landscape of Susa Valley and Avigliana city
58
59
60
61
62
63
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
64
65
CONTEXT ELEVATIONS MODEL
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
66
67
AXONOMETRY VIEW MODEL CONTEXT
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE VS RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
68
69
AXONOMETRY VIEW MODEL
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE VS RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
70
71
MASTERPLAN
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
72
73
CONTEXT LONGITUDINAL SECTION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
74
75
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
76
77
LEVEL +434
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
78
79
LEVEL +436.7
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
80
81
LEVEL +440
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
82
83
LONGITUDINAL SECTION ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
84
85
LONGITUDINAL SECTION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
86
87
TRANSVERSAL SECTION ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
88
89
TRANSVERSAL SECTION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
90
91
EAST ELEVATION
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
92
93
EAST ELEVATION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
94
95
NORTH ELEVATION
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
96
97
NORTH ELEVATION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
98
99
SOUTH ELEVATION
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
100
101
SOUTH ELEVATION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
102
103
WEST ELEVATION
ARCHAEOLOGICAL SITE
104
105
WEST ELEVATION
RECONSTRUCTION PROPOSAL
106
107
DESIGN PROCESS
108
109
FINAL THESIS STUDIO D
During the Final Thesis Studio D, with the supervision of professor Alessandro Rocca and other studio professors, it was developed an initial idea of the touristic center. All the pavilions would be squareshaped and only museum + facilities, with an open air museum pathway made of steel and closed museum area. Also, some panels at the soil level were added to create a contrast between the new and the old with new textures and views.
110
111
112
C
+435
+432.3
B'
+430
+432
+431
+431
+429
+428
+427
A'
A
+438
+439
+438
+437
+436
+435
+434
+433
432
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
B
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
+437
+433
+434
+435
+436
1/100
PLAN LEVEL +435
C'
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
113
114 115
C
+441
+432.3
B'
+430
B
+441
+441
+432
+431
+431
+429
+428
+427
A'
+441
A
+438
+439
+438
+441
+439
+434
+433
432
+437
+433
+434
+435
+436
+440
PLAN LEVEL +441 1/100
C'
116
C
+444.7
+432.3
B'
+430
B
+444.7
+444.7
+444.7
+432
+431
+431
+429
+428
+427
A'
A
+438
+439
+438
+444.7
+436
+441
+439
+435
+434
+433
432
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
+437
+433
+434
+435
+436
PLAN LEVEL +444.7 1/100
C'
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
117
EAST ELEVATION 1/100
SECTION A-A1 1/100
118
119
120
121
THESIS FAUUSP
Being an double degree student, I decided to continue to develop this project also in Brazil, on which I had a different perspective together with professor Luis Antonio Jorge. The concept was the same, but the material would be concrete, all elevated and all pavilions the same. The focus was on the material and on the elevated pathway.
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
FINAL THESIS POLITECNICO DI MILANO
From the intense analysis of the Castle of Avigliana over the past processes (Studio and USP Thesis), I was able to develop a more critical approach and make an intervention that would impact positively the archaeological site and the surroundings (Avigliana city and Susa Valley), but without disrespecting the history of the place. The idea was to communicate directly with the ruins with an architecture that would also have meaning, strength and would be used by the tourists and local population. Having the professor Alessandro Rocca as supervisor along this design process was essential, in order to develop the site-specific architectural language, suitable techniques, technologies, communication with the new and the old. The final result is a reconstruction of an architecture of impact, a strong language, like once was the Castle of Avigliana
138
139
PAVILION 1 - MUSEUM
140
141
PAVILION 1 EXPOSITION + SERVICES
FIRST REVISION
PLAN LEVEL +434 1.200
142
143
PAVILION 1 EXPO + SERVICES
LONGITUDINAL SECTION 1.50
TRANSVERSAL SECTION 1.50
144
145
SECOND REVISION
PLAN LEVEL +434 1.200
NORTH ELEVATION 1.200
146
WEST ELEVATION 1.200
147
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
148
149
THIRD REVISION
PLAN LEVEL +434 1.200
NORTH ELEVATION 1.200
150
WEST ELEVATION 1.200
151
WOOD CEILING
WOOOD BEAM (XLAM SYSTEM) 300x100mm
ROUND STEEL COLUMN Ø250mm
WOODEN BRISE SOLEIL SYSTEM
STEEL STAIRCASE
XLAM PANELS
CURTAIN WALL GLASS PANELS
AXONOMETRY
152
ELEVATION 1.50
SECTION 1.50
153
FOURTH REVISION
N PLAN LEVEL +434 1.50
154
155
PAVILION WEST ELEVATION 1:50
PAVILION SECTION 1:50
156
157
STRUCTURE WARM WOOD CEILING
STRUCTURE WOOD BEAM (GUGLAM SYSTEM) 500x100mm
STRUCTURE SQUARE WOOD COLUMN 300mm WITH INTERMEDIATE STEEL BRACING ON OUTSIDE COLUMNS
FAÇADE VERTICAL WOOD BRISE SOLEIL 40MM WITH INTERMEDIATE HORIZONTAL WOOD
FAÇADE CURTAIN WALL GLASS SYSTEM
PAVILION EAST ELEVATION 1:50
STRUCTURE WARM WOOD SLAB WITH INTEGRATED WOOD STAIRCASE
158
159
FINAL DESIGN
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
PAVILION 2 - OPEN THEATRE
170
171
PAVILION 2 OPEN SQUARE + PATH
FIRST REVISION
PLAN LEVEL +436.7 1.200
SECTION 2-A 1.200
172
SECTION 2-B 1.200
173
PAVILION 2 OPEN SQUARE + PATH
LONGITUDINAL SECTION 1.50
TRANSVERSAL SECTION 1.50
174
175
SECOND REVISION
176
177
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
179 178
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
THIRD REVISION
PLAN LEVEL +440 1.200
LONGITUDINAL SECTION 1.200
180
TRANSVERSAL SECTION 1.200
181
WOOD CEILING
SECONDARY WOODEN BEAM SYSTEM
WOOD BEAM (XLAM SYSTEM) 300x100mm
ROUND STEEL COLUMN Ø250mm
ELEVATION 1.50 PLYWOOD SLAB
STEEL STAIRCASE
AXONOMETRY
182
SECTION 1.50
183
FOURTH REVISION
N PLAN LEVEL +440 1.50
184
185
DRY PLYWOOD CEILING
WOOD BEAM (GUGLAM SYSTEM) 500x100mm
CABLE SYSTEM CONNECTED TO BEAM AND COLUMN SYSTEM
SQUARE WOOD COLUMN 300mm WITH INTERMEDIATE STEEL BRACING
SECTION 1:50
PLYWOOD SLAB WITH INTEGRATED WOOD STAIRCASE
186
187
PAVILILON EAST ELEVATION 1:50
PAVILION NORTH ELEVATION 1:50
188
189
FINAL DESIGN
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
PAVILION 3 - BELVEDERE
200
201
PAVILION 3 COFFEE + BELVEDERE
FIRST REVISION
PLAN LEVEL +442.5 1.200
SECTION 3-A 1.200
202
SECTION 3-B 1.200
203
PAVILION 3 COFFEE + BELVEDERE
TRANSVERSAL SECTION 1.50
204
LONGITUDINAL SECTION 1.50
205
SECOND REVISION
206
207
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
PRODUCED BY AN AUTODESK STUDENT VERSION
209 208
THIRD REVISION
PLAN LEVEL +447 1.200
PLAN LEVEL +4403 1.200
EAST ELEVATION 1.200
210
PLAN LEVEL +450 1.200
SOUTH ELEVATION 1.200
211
WOOD BEAM (XLAM SYSTEM) 300x100mm
SECOND FLOOR COFFEE + VIEW
WOOD BEAM (XLAM SYSTEM) 300x100mm
FIRST FLOOR COFFEE
WOOD BEAM (XLAM SYSTEM) 300x100mm
ROUND STEEL COLUMN Ø250mm
STEEL STAIRCASE
GLASS LIFT
AXONOMETRY
212
ELEVATION 1.50
213
SECTION 1.50
214
215
N
FOURTH REVISION
N
PLAN LEVEL +440 1.50
PLAN LEVEL +443 1.50
216
217
PAVILION SECTION 1:50
218
219
N N
PLAN LEVEL +447 1.50
PLAN LEVEL +450 1.50
220
221
PAVILILON EAST ELEVATION 1:50
222
223
STRUCTURE
TOP FLOOR
COLD WOOD SLAB WITH GREEN ROOF MODULES
GREEN ROOF + VIEW
STRUCTURE WOOD BEAM (GUGLAM SYSTEM) 500x100mm
STRUCTURE COLD WOOD SLAB ON OPEN AREA AND WARM SLAB ON CLOSED AREA SECOND FLOOR MEET + VIEW
STRUCTURE WOOD BEAM (GUGLAM SYSTEM) 500x100mm
STRUCTURE COLD WOOD SLAB ON OPEN AREA AND WARM SLAB ON CLOSED AREA FIRST FLOOR COFFEE + VIEW STRUCTURE WOOD BEAM (GUGLAM SYSTEM) 500x100mm
STRUCTURE SQUARE WOOD COLUMN 300mm WITH INTERMEDIATE STEEL BRACING
VERTICAL CIRCULATION STEEL STAIRCASE STEEL + GLASS LIFT
GROUND FLOOR ACCESS + VIEW
FAÇADE VERTICAL WOOD BRISE SOLEIL 40MM WITH INTERMEDIATE HORIZONTAL WOOD STRUCTURE COLD PLYWOOD SLAB ELEVATION 1.50
224
225
FINAL DESIGN
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
REFERENCES
242
243
SILENT PAVILION ARQUITECT_ Simon Ungers LOCATION_ No specific location FUNCTION_ Cathedral MATERIALS_ Steel
244
245
SHELTER FOR ROMAN RUINS ARQUITECT_ Peter Zumthor LOCATION_ Graubünden, Switzerland FUNCTION_ Shelter for ruins MATERIALS_ Wood; steel
246
247
CASA DE SUIZA ARQUITECT_ DELLEKAMP ARQUITECTOS LOCATION_ Alameda central, Ciudad de México, México FUNCTION_ Open theatre MATERIALS_ Wood; steel
248
249
PERGOLADO BONDINHO ARQUITECT_ A+ Arquitetura LOCATION_ Rio de Janeiro, Brazil FUNCTION_ Open Square MATERIALS_ Wood; steel
250
251
ZINC MINE MUSEUM ARQUITECT_ Peter Zumthor LOCATION_ Allmannajuvet zinc mines, Sauda, Norway FUNCTION_ Museum; Coffee; Services MATERIALS_ Wood; steel
252
253
ACROPOLIS PATHWAY ARQUITECT_ Dimitris Pikionis LOCATION_ Athens, Greece FUNCTION_ Pathway MATERIALS_ Stones (variable)
254
255
BIBLIOGRAPHY
256
257
AA.VV., I castelli della bassa valle di Susa tra IX e XV secolo: S.Mauro di Almese, Villardora, Avigliana, S. Ambrogio, Caprie, [coordinamento del progetto e revisione dei testi Paolo Denicolai, Ugo Gherner, Piero Del Vecchio]. Condorve: Editrice Morra, 1998.
PATRIA, Luca. Medioevo sul Pezzulano: documenti vecchi e “nuovi” per la storia di Avigliana. Segusium, 2009. VOLTERRANI, GIlibert. Valsusa com’era Tèra ‘d n’òstri vej. Susa: Ed. Delphius. Susa, 1977.
BRAYDA, Riccardo; RONDOLINO, F. Villarbasse: la sua torre, i suoi signori. Torino: C.E. Bertolero, 1886.
Websites
CAPELLO, Ezio. Avigliana: storia, personaggi, ricordi, immagini di uma città milenária. Grugliasco: Arti grafiche San Rocco, 1995. ENRICHETTO, Martina. La Lettura di Avigliana Medioevale: e la sua verifica secondo la teoria del potenziamento visivo. Torino: Edizioni Quaderni di Studio, 1967. FABRETTI, Ariodante. Scavi di Avigliana. Torino: Atti dela Società di Acheologia e Belle Arti per la Provincia di Torino, 1875. FIRPO, L. Theatrum Sabaudiae: Teatro dagli stati del Duca di Savoia. Torino: Archivio storico della Città di Torino, 1984-1985.
Archdaily Associazione Archeologica Aviglianese. Available at: https://www.facebook.com/ AssociazioneArcheologicaAviglianese/ Città di Avigliana. Available at: https://www.comune.avigliana.to.it/ Maps.stamen.com Valle Susa Tesori. Available at: https://www.vallesusa-tesori.it/en/
GONIN, Enrico. Album delle principali castella feudali della Monarchia di Savoia. Torino: Doyen, 1845 - 1857. LIEURE, J. Jacques Callot: Catalogue of the Graphic Work. Paris, 1927. Livros │ Books NOTA, Marco. Il castello di Avigliana: indagine storica e ipotesi di riuso. Torino : Politecnico di Torino : Facoltà di Architettura, 2000.
258
259
260
261