"Th e Re vol ving Door, A Re vol ting Acce s s " W h o re al l y be ne fits from w ar? W ar profite e rs de pe nd m ainl y on gove rnm e ntcontracts . Im agine w h at Lock h e e d M artin w oul d be w ith outth e ir Pe ntagon contracts ! Atth e s am e tim e gove rnm e nts ne e d an e xcus e for s pe nding s uch h uge s um s ofm one y e .g. “w ar agains t te rror”, “nationals e curity”, “pe ace force s ”, e tc. Since w ar profite e rs de pe nd on gove rnm e nt contracts th e y ne e d to be in th e pos ition to infl ue nce th e m . Th rough th e ye ars th e y h ave pos itione d th e m s e l ve s to h ave an im m e ns e pol iticalpow e r w ith in gove rnm e nts , and th e y e njoy privil e ge d acce s s to de cis ion-m ak e rs th atth e ge ne ralpubl ic can onl y dre am of. In orde r to s e l lth e ir products , th e w ar profite e rs ne e d acce s s to inform ation, and acce s s to th e diffe re ntde cis ion bodie s . H ow do th e y do it?By th e s o-cal l e d re vol ving door factor, and h e avy l obbying. Th e te rm 're vol ving door' re fe rs to th e m ove m e ntofe m pl oye e s be tw e e n gove rnm e ntand corporations . Form e r m il itary ge ne ral s or m e m be rs ofde fe nce m inis trie s m ove to h igh pos itions in th e w ar indus try. As th e y m ove to “de fe ns e contractors ” th e y com e w ith al lth e ir conne ctions and inform ation from th e ins ide for h ow to ge tth os e pre cious contracts . Th e re vol ving door al s o w ork s th e oth e r w ay around, w h e n e x-corporate bigw igs w ork ing for w ar profite e rs m ove to th e de fe nce de partm e nts or oth e r gove rnm e nt de fe nce contractde cis ion bodie s , w h e re th e y are in th e be s tpos ition to infl ue nce w h ich com panie s th e contracts are aw ard to. Th e re are m any cas e s ofth e re vol ving door, Dick Ch e ne y be ing th e m os tfam ous one , w h e n h e w e ntfrom be ing th e Se cre tary of De fe ns e to th e CEO ofH al l iburton to vice pre s ide ntofUSA. Buth e is notth e onl y one ! Jus tto m e ntion tw o in th e UK : Jul ian Scope s is BAE Sys te m s ' m os ts e nior pol iticall obbyis t and a form e r M oD civils e rvant, Scope s is re porte d to h ave re taine d h is al l -are a acce s s pas s to th e M oD, w h e re h e coul d e as il y vie w confide ntialinform ation. BAE h as not confirm e d or de nie d w h e th e r oth e r s e nior m e m be rs ofs taffh ave s im il ar acce s s . In anoth e r cas e Lord Inge , Ch ie fofDe fe nce Stafffrom 19 9 4-19 9 7, be cam e Non-e xe cutive Ch airm an atAe gis De fe nce Se rvice s . H e avy l obbying h appe ns w h e n com panie s h ave an officialrol e in m ak ing pol icy and contractde cis ions . Exam ine th e Europe an Union to s e e h ow th is w ork s . For m any ye ars th e arm s indus try trie d h ard to infl ue nce Brus s e l s ' de cis ion m ak e rs , prom oting th e conce ptth ata s trong m il itary Europe ne e ds a s trong arm s indus try. W h il e drafting th e te xt for th e cons titution th e Europe an Conve ntion's w ork ing group on de fe nce invite d a num be r of“e xpe rts ” to give advice on w h ats h oul d be incl ude d in th e tre aty te xt. Th re e ofth e th irte e n e xpe rts re pre s e nte d th e inte re s tof th e arm s indus try: Corrado Antonini, pre s ide nt ofth e Europe an De fe nce Indus trie s Group, Anth ony Parry from BAE Sys te m s and Je anLouis Ge rgorin from EADS. Th e m e s s age ofa s trong Europe an arm s indus try for a s trong m il itary Europe w as th e re . A s im il ar s ituation e xis ts in th e USA w ith th e De fe ns e Pol icy Board w h ich w as cre ate d in 19 85, m ade up of30+ re pre s e ntative s of indus try, te ch nol ogy and m il itary contractors . Th e De fe ns e Pol icy Board m e e ts four tim e s a ye ar to advis e th e Se cre tary ofDe fe ns e on w h atw e apons s ys te m s to buy, w h atcountrie s
are “th re ats ”, w h e re th e y ne e d a “pre e m ptive s trik e ”, w h atcountry th e y s h oul d occupy. For e xam pl e , in 2006 th e De fe ns e Pol icy Board incl ude s Jack Sh e e h an w h o w as in th e US M arine Corps , Ge ne ralin NATO , Supre m e Al l ie d Com m ande r in th e Atl antic w h o l e ftth e m il itary and be cam e Se nior Vice Pre s ide ntatBe ch te l . Be ch te lis one of th e l arge s tcontractors groups in th e w orl d, and h as one ofth e l arge s t contracts in Iraq to w ork on its re cons truction. In m any countrie s w ar profite e rs can l e gal l y donate l arge s um s ofm one y to pol iticalcandidate s , e xpe cting th e ir l oyal ty w h e n vote s com e up for w e apons s ys te m s . O fcours e bribe ry al s o tak e s pl ace . In th e US th e re are m any ins tance s ofCongre s s voting for contracts th atth e Pe ntagon h as not Ph oto: ScottSch ae ffe r - Duffy during a vigil e ve n as k e d for, butth e corporation h as outs ide Rayth e on a “s pe cialfrie nd” in Congre s s w h o h as w ays . pus h e d th e de fe ns e contractth rough . W e apons m anufacture rs h ave be com e s o pow e rfulth atth e y can te l lth e gove rnm e nt w h atth e y w antand don’tw ant. BAE Sys te m s (form e rl y Britis h Ae ros pace ) h as tol d th e UK gove rnm e ntth atifitdoe s notbuy from th e m th e y w il lpul loutofth e UK and go to th e US. According to th e US De partm e ntofDe fe ns e , BAE Sys te m s (th e y droppe d th e w ord “Britis h ” to be com e m ore trans national ) w as th e Pe ntagon’s s e ve nth l arge s ts uppl ie r in 2005. Th e com panie s cl aim th atth e y l e ave th e m oralde cis ions to th e gove rnm e nt, and th at th e y are onl y “doing th e ir patriotic duty” by re s ponding to w h atth e gove rnm e ntne e ds .
W h atcan w e do? An im portants te p tow ards s topping th e w ar profite e rs is to s top th e ir pow e rfulinfl ue nce ove r gove rnm e nts pe nding on w e apons . H ow can w e do th at?Th e pow e r ofw ar profite e rs s e e m s s o ove rw h e l m ing, m ore pow e rfule ve n th an th e pow e rfulgove rnm e nts th e y s e l lto. A com m on anti-corporate s trate gy, boycotts , is difficul tw ith w ar profite e rs be caus e th e m ajor com panie s do noth ave civil ian products . Th e one s th e y do h ave – airl ine rs , cons truction proje cts – are not cons um e r products , butare bough tby corporations or m unicipal itie s . Ann Fe l th am ofCam paign Agains tth e Arm s Trade s ugge s te d w e “tack l e th is around th e e dge s ”, and w e dis cus s e d m any ofth os e s trate gie s atth e W ar Profite e rs Th e m e Group atth e W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnationalConfe re nce Gl obal is ing Nonviol e nce . M onitor th e com panie s and th e pol icy com m itte e s and boards th e y s iton. Vis ibil ity is th e ir vul ne rabil ity. Expos e th e m as w ar profite e rs . De s cribe th e e ffe cts ofth e ir w e apons , and th e h um an righ ts viol ations of th e countrie s th e y s e l lto. Educate th e taxpaye rs re garding th e fact th atth e gove rnm e ntis us ing th e ir m one y to fund w ar profite e rs . Expos e th e bribe ry th ath appe ns in th e w ar profite e rs w orl d. Th e re are m any cas e s and th e y ne e d to be m ade k now n to th e publ ic. Th is can be done in cre ative and dram atic
Pre s s ure gove rnm e nts to re gul ate th e s e com panie s , de m anding trans pare ncy and corporate accountabil ity. W ar profite e rs can’t s tand up to th os e s tandards . Look atth e rol e th atbank s and Export Cre ditAge ncie s pl ay in s upporting and s ubs idiz ing th e w ar indus try w ith l oans and cre dits , as th e y m ak e itl ook as ifth e de alis com pl e te l y s afe for both th e gove rnm e ntand th e indus try. H ow do taxpaye rs and bank de pos itors fe e laboutth e ir m one y be ing us e d for w e apons production? O rganiz ations and individual s can buy s tock in th e s e com panie s . Sh are h ol de rs can put pre s s ure on corporations th rough s h are h ol de rs re s ol utions and atannual m e e tings . O r e ncourage pe ns ions funds , unive rs itie s and m unicipal itie s to dive s tin com panie s th at profitfrom w ar (incl uding al lw ar profite e rs , notjus tw e apons m anufacture rs .) To e ffe ctive l y ch al l e nge th e w ar profite e rs w e ne e d cam paigns th attarge tth e various l ink s in th e ch ain ofh ow th e corporations ge t m il itary contracts . To do th atw e ne e d to coordinate am ong groups w ork ing agains t arm s trade , financialins titutions and Export Cre ditAge ncie s th ats upportarm s s al e s and th e w ide r antim il itaris tand nonviol e nt m ove m e nt. Joanne Sh e e h an and Javie r Gárate
Editorial
Th is is s ue ofTh e Brok e n Rifl e focus e s on w ar profite e rs . During W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnationalConfe re nce “Gl obal is ing Nonviol e nce ” th at took pl ace in Eringe rfe l d Ge rm any be tw e e n th e 23-27 of Jul y 2006, w e h ad a th e m e group w h o w ork e d on w ar profite e rs . Th is th e m e group w as an e s s e ntials te p in th e de ve l op ofW RI's Gl obal Initiative Agains tW ar Profite e rs . M os tofth e m ate rial you w il lfind in th is is s ue com e s from th e w ork ofth atw e e k . During th e th e m e group w e l e arne d from s e ve ral organiz ations cam paigning agains tw ar profite e rs . A com m on unde rs tanding ofh ow to targe tth e s e corporations w as th e ne e d ofw ork ing to el im inate th e pow e r th atth e s e corporations h ave to infl ue nce gove rnm e nt pol icie s to ge t th e ir contracts . Th e firs tarticl e ofth e Brok e n Rifl e de s cribe s h ow corporations infl ue nce th e gove rnm e ntand th e de cis ionm ak ing bodie s th at de cide m il itary pol icy and m il itary contracts , and w h atcan w e do to s top th e m . During th e l as tw e e k of Augus ta m e e ting in Col om bia organiz e d by Re d Juve nilde M e de l l in on antim il itaris t initiative s and US inte rve ntion w il lbe l ook ing atth e rol e th at corporations h ave in th at re gion. An articl e w ritte n by th e organiz e rs ofth e m e e ting re ve al s h ow th e s e big corporations h ave dirty h ands in Col om bia. Atth e e nd of Se pte m be r a confe re nce of gras s roots w ork ing to Stop th e M e rch ants ofDe ath , organis e d by W ar Re s is te rs ' Le ague , is tak ing pl ace in M inne apol is USA. Starting w ith th e cas e s tudy on th e H one yw e l lproje ct th atw as bas e d in M inne apol is , w e s e e ath ow nonviol e nt cam paigns can be e ffe ctive agains tth e w ar profite e rs . I e ncourage you to re ad th is is s ue ofTh e Brok e n Rifl e w ith an e ye on h ow you can ge t invol ve d in cam paigning agains tth e w ar profite e rs . Javie r Gárate
Th e Brok e n Rifl e
Th e Brok e n Rifl e is th e ne w s l e tte r ofW ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational , and is publ is h e d in Engl is h , Spanis h , Fre nch and Ge rm an. Th is is is s ue 71, Se pte m be r 2006. Th is is s ue ofTh e Brok e n Rifl e w as produce d by Javie r Gárate . Spe cialth ank s go to Joanne Sh e e h an and Acción K ol e ctiva por l a O bje ción Fis cal FO K A from Col om bia, and oth e rs w h o provide d th e inform ation us e d in th is is s ue . If you w ante xtra copie s ofth is is s ue ofTh e Brok e n Rifl e, pl e as e contactth e W RI office , or dow nl oad itfrom our w e bs ite . W ar Re s is te rs ' Inte rnational , 5 Cal e donian Road, London N1 9 DX, Britain te l+ 44-20-7278 4040 fax + 44-20-7278 0444 info@ w ri-irg.org h ttp://w riirg.org/pubs /br71_ e n.h tm