PM#0382659799
Friendship Centre helps with school PAGE 13 Vol. 40 No. 37
Annual Fall Harvest delights PAGE 7
Welcome video made for students PAGE 8 8000 copies distributed $1.50
September 19, 2013 Northern Ontario’s First Nation Voice since 1974
www.wawataynews.ca
Treaty 3 communities reclaim land
Aboriginal people underrepresented in mainstream media Newly released human rights report calls provincial news coverage ‘stark’ Rick Garrick Wawatay News
While Aboriginal people are usually “barely on the radar” at most print and online media outlets in Ontario, a Journalist’s for Human Rights report says Aboriginal stories spike during major events. “It clearly shows that when there is a major event or the federal government is involved, that correlates directly to an increase in news stories,” said Robin Pierro, JHR’s international and domestic programs manager and lead writer of the report. “So things like the Idle No More movement and the hunger strike, these direct action initiatives, really did result in a spike in news coverage. I don’t want to encourage people to protest, but it is interesting to see that resulted in what I think Aboriginal people who were protesting wanted, which was the attention on a certain issue.” The JHR report, Buried Voices: Media Coverage of Aboriginal Issues in Ontario, found that Aboriginalrelated stories accounted for “just 0.28 per cent” of all news stories produced by 171 print and online news outlets across Ontario from June 1, 2010 to May 31, 2013.
“...First Nations and Aboriginal people are seen as either noble environmentalists, pitiful victims or angry warriors...”
“There is nothing new in the fact that media do not tend to cover very much of First Nations issues,” said Maurice Switzer, communications unit director for the Union of Ontario Indians. “What they do tend to cover is what we would call negative or stereotypical.” Switzer said the Royal Commission on Aboriginal People and the Ipperwash Inquiry both included sections on media coverage of Aboriginal issues. “There is a famous quote in (RCAP’s) report, in which they said in the eyes of most Canadians, largely because of the media treatment or lack of it, First Nations and Aboriginal people are seen as either noble environmentalists, pitiful victims or angry warriors,” Switzer said. Switzer said the UOI has held conferences to create more awareness of
Aboriginal issues and media coverage, noting they recently awarded the ninth Debwewin Citation, for excellence in storytelling on First Nations and Aboriginal issues in Anishinabek territory, to Jody Porter, a CBC journalist based in Thunder Bay. “The first thing we do is we cite good journalistic practices,” Switzer said. “We believe in criticizing bad reporting, but also saluting good reporting. By good, we don’t just mean things that are favourable to First Nations, we mean fair reporting.” Switzer said the UOI is open to working with other organizations to make journalism the craft it can be. “We’ve had several student interns who now work for the Aboriginal Peoples Television Network, for Global television, for CBC,” Switzer said. “That is a commitment that we made to that lack of (Aboriginal) representation.” Rachel Pulfer, JHR’s executive director, said the JHR report included a number of “stark” findings. Released on Sept. 4, the report is available on the JHR website at www.jhr.ca. “The really interesting piece of (the report) for us is simply the lack of coverage in print and online is stark — because the findings are so stark and the percentages are so small,” Pulfer said. “And also this interesting point that emerged where the commentary spikes during an event, and the commentary tends to trend pretty negative.” The report found that the largest proportion of negative stories are opinion columns and editorials wherein Aboriginal people were criticized for their protests or direct action initiatives. Over the three years studied, there was an 11 per cent increase in the number of stories that portrayed Aboriginal people in a negative light. “We’re not saying that people sitting in downtown Toronto are not entitled to their opinions, but having been myself a card-carrying member of the mainstream media, there is a difference between uninformed and underinformed opinions and informed opinion weighing in on a topic,” Pulfer said. “Informed opinion is more valuable, so that’s what we’re encouraging the folks who do that kind of commentary and punditry on take on board, that rather than leaping into a panel discussion about a topic they are very far from, to make a few phone calls or look at a few studies just to have a frame of reference that is grounded in fact.” see Media Report page 15
Cargo Services
Jana-Rae Yerxa/Special to Wawatay News
Treaty 3 community members came out Sept. 14 to Pithers Point in Fort Frances for Manoominikedaa Neyaashing. Organizers say it was an event that had over 30 fires roasting wild rice the traditional way but it was also an act of nationhood and reclamation over the land that is currently in dispute with the town of Fort Frances and the government. (See Page 5 for more.)
Ring of Fire in jeopardy, says Cliffs Critical all-weather road proposal rejected by commissioner Jamie Monastyrski Wawatay News
It’s one step ahead and two steps behind lately for the future development of the Ring of Fire. The controversial proposal by Cliffs Natural Resources for an easement to build an all-weather road that would connect to the Ring of Fire was rejected Sept. 10 by Ontario’s Mining and Lands Commissioner in a 43-page ruling. “The decision by the commission was very disappointing,” said Jason Aagenes, director of environmental affairs for Cliffs Natural Resources in an interview. “We view the north-south corridor as critical to the Ring of Fire development as well as a key component of our project. This does jeopardize the viability of the project going forward unless it is resolved.” The ruling found the easement breaches rival company KWG
Resources Inc.’s rights under Ontario’s Mining Act and that Cliffs did not demonstrate the 350-km road is in the public interest. The proposed road would cross over mining claims owned by KWG, an exploration stage company, which staked the ground in 2009 for a future railroad. Regardless of the decision Aagenes said that Cliffs would move forward and consider all their options after further analysis of the decision. “This is Crown land and in partnership with First Nations and the traditional land oversight that they possess, we feel that if the Ring of Fire is to proceed, this needs to be addressed by the government,” he said. Cliffs applied for the easement to build the all-weather road to transport ore from its Black Thor deposit in the Ring of Fire, about 540 km northeast of Thunder Bay, to Nakina, On. Aagenes said that Cliffs put considerable effort into the proposal stating
that a road is a better option than the KWG railroad “idea” because the First Nations would benefit. “The road would be the best option. The road would allow First Nations to connect to the all-weather road system and create more economic benefit for the First Nation communities as well as other resource companies and government in the region. The province would benefit as a whole,” he said. KWG formed a subsidiary, Canada Chrome, to oversee the railroad venture which would build a railroad from its isolated Big Daddy chromite deposit south 328 km to a point on the CN line near Nakina. “We will continue to work with the First Nation communities, the province and other companies in the area to come up with a solution to overcome this significant roadblock,” Aagenes said.
With over 15 years experience, Wasaya Airways is equipped to transport numerous goods such as food, lumber, gas & diesel fuel, boats, motors, snowmachines, medical and ofÀce supplies. 1.807.928.2244 Pickle Lake | 1.807.662.1119 Red Lake
Call us for all your transportation needs.
Connecting Communities • 1.877.492.7292 • www.wasaya.com