Awake 2011

Page 1

!"#2 ˙ ˚ & 6 > 5 5

( ˚ ˝

˛ #

!"#2 ˚ ˚˙ ı• ˝B 7= =57 >>> ˙ & ) <7

p VZS-d ˚ ˝

˛ # 7 ZTV*WnZ* VZS-*E k\ ]1`13SW* ,aT Z*]*/S 8 ]`\+S 4ZSkSbS T+WTp : \ZS f\,*WS \31 W\,\ ,T/ Wp/1y

5> \-Wq/ T+WT^D S \- /+*2 ]`\ b,*`SZH 56 ˙\f`SabSqZanV1 ]\f\/31ZZq `T4/,qZ\^ qWSZVS 58 dZ*YT , )]\ZT^ 6>55 `\VdD \4]\,T/T \h1,S/gT, 65 •\-\ /\]SbWS,Sy `\4dY /\aT ,`*3*2 66 T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*D )V ,\Z* ab*W* ]\]dWq`Z\p 69 \W\/T Wp/S 4*]Sbdpbn #\ `\+Sbn b\,*`SanVd 4dab`Th a]`*,/T gTV*,\pH 6< \,SZS 4 dan\-\ a,Tbd 6= ıZ/1Va w `\+d/SanIx 4* 6>55 `TV 7> +YT`Vdyb1 d `\/SZZ\Yd V\WT 76 w `\ab\ T ,\/Z\h*a -WS+\V\x

5957 /\ ZD 1DP +WD =< ZD 1D

5>>

8>9

T+WTq ]Sa*W*aq 2,`1yanV\pE *`*Y1yanV\p T -`1gnV\p

˛Gq,Wq2bnaq 4`dhZ* T+WTq d e\`YT V\/1Vad

ı2`\ZTY ]1`1VW*/*2 T+WTp W*O bSZanV\p

ı & E # ˚ ˚˝ ı ˙ w˛ b*V\p aSWnZ\p ]`\bS/T2p Z1 abSV*W*aq 3\/Z* TZj* VZS-*C \/Z*V gp VZS-d Z1 4Y\-W* 4/\W*bS *ZT ,W*/*E *ZT fSabE *ZT V`*aZ\Y\,ab,\xD T+WTq -T/Z* ,*j\^ d,*-SH *a*YO ]1`1/E qV a,T/hSbn a*Y* T+WTqE ,\Z* 2 W\,\Y \-* L6 SY\eTq 7B5:MD ı ,S +*-*b\ ,b`*bSb1E qVk\ Z1 +d/1b1 ^^ hSb*bSD

`TY b\-\E T+WTq P \/Z* 4 Z*y/*,ZTO jSf VZS-E qVT /TyjWS /\ Z*j\-\ h*adD *O V\3 ,\Z* ,T/\Y* d ,an\Yd a,TbT T ]1`1VW*O /1Z* Z*y+TWnj\p VTWnVTabp Y\,D T+WTq +dW* b* 4*WSj*2bnaq a,Tb\,SY +1aba1O W1`\YD ,T/h1ZZq T+WT^E ^^ ,TV b* ]\jS`1ZTabn k1 +TWnj1 ,`*3*pbn 4 \-Wq/d Z* hSaW1ZO ZT a]`\+S 4*-WdjSbS ^^ 4,TabVdD w˛ b*V\p aSWnZ\p ]`\bS/T2p Z1 abSV*W*aq 3\/Z* TZj* VZS-*C \/Z*V gp VZS-d Z1 4Y\-W* 4/\W*bS *ZT ,W*/*E *ZT fSabE *ZT V`*aO Z\Y\,ab,\xEP aV*4*, b1\W\- XIX ab\WTbbq Wn+1`b *`Z4D ˛* aW\,*YS gn\-\ 3 +T+W1^ab*E Wp/1y 4*O 4,Sh*y ,`*3*2 da1E k\ ,Sb`SYd2 hSaW1ZZT d/*`S hS WSf*D w `\b1 3\/Z* *`YTq Z1 ,SO b`SY*W* abTWnV\f Z*]*/T,E aVTWnVS ,Sb`SO

Y*W* T+WTqEP ]`\/\,3d2 *`Z4EP 3\/Z* ab*`\/*,Zq e\`b1gq Z1 ]1`13SW* abTWnO V\f \+W\- T Z1 4*WSjSW*an Z1]\`djZ\p d -\`ZSWT ,TyZS b* ,S`T h*adE 3\/Z* aV1Wq Z1 ,gTWTW* ]T/ /T2p abTWnV\f `dyZT,ZSf f,SWnxD *-*b\ ab*`\/*,ZTf ]Sa1YZSf ]*YGqb\V +dW\ ,b`*h1Z\E 4ZSk1Z\ *+\ ]`\ab\ 4*+dO b\D *b\YTabn T+WTq ,S3SW* ]\]`S hSaO W1ZZT Z*]*/SD ˙1fb\ gTZ\p ,W*aZ\-\ 3SbO bq Z*Y*-*,aq 4`\+SbS ^^ /\abd]Z\p /Wq ,aTf Wp/1yD dWS y bTE fb\ ,S`S,*, gp VZS-d 4 `dV a]`*-WSf hSb*hT,E * b*V\3 ]`SWp/Z\ a]*Wp,*, qV a*Yd T+WTpE b*V T ^^ ,W*aZSVT,D \Yd 3 \/ZT Wp+SWS T+WTpE * TZjT Z1O Z*,S/TWSH )VT Z*]*/S ,\Z* ,Sb`SY*W*H b\ Z*Y*-*,aq ^^ 4ZSkSbS TE k\ ,*3WSO ,Tj1E h\Yd ,\Z* ,gTWTW*H \Yd ^^ 4,TabO V* ]\,SZZ* ,*a gTV*,SbSH T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZq ,S 4Z*y/1b1 d Z*abd]ZSf ab*bbqfD

" ˚ ) ı ıı 57<> ^VWTe ]1`1VW*/*2 T+WTp 4 W*O bSZanV\^ Z* *Z-WTyanVd

5899

59<5

5=7<

6>55

db1Z+1`- /`dVd2 ]1`jSy ]`SYT`O ZSV T+WT^

˛Gq,Wq2bnaq

ab`\4nV* T+WTqE qV* Wq-W* , \aZ\,d ]1`j\-\ dV`*^ZanO V\-\ ]1`1VW*/d

T+WTq /`dVdO 2bnaq ]\Z*/ 5>>> Y\,*YS

˙\abd]Z* ]\Z*/ 69>> Y\,*YS

7

Ë› # Äą Äą( E k\ d,TyjWS , 4+T`VdE ,T/\Yd an\-\/ZT qV T+WTq *+\ ,qb1 SanO Y\E ]Sa*WSaq ]`\bq-\Y +TWnj ZT3 5:>> `\VT,D 1`jT 4 ZSf dVW*, \ya1yE * \aO b*ZZp Z*]Sa*, \/SZ 4 dhZT, Äąada* `Sab* Y*y31 h1`14 ab\ `\VT, ]TaWq Z*`\/31ZZq a,\-\ hSb1WqD ]`\/\,3 Tab\`T^ P /\ Z*j\^ 1`SE ]`\O bq-\Y a1`1/Zn\,Thhq T 4* Z*jSf /ZT, P ]`\bS,ZSVS Z1 `*4 Z*Y*-*WSaq 4*-WdjSO bS +T+WTyZd 4,TabVdD /Z* 4 Z*y/*,ZTjSf 4-*/\V ]`\ g1 aq-*2 h*aT, \3\-\ ]`\`\V* `1YT^D TZ 3S, 4* :>> `\VT, /\ Z*`\/31ZO Zq Äąada* `Sab*D

1]\]dWq`Z* 4,TabV* \- Z*V*4*, ]`\`\Vd `1YT^ 4*]Sa*bS d ad,Ty 4,TabVd \ad/d /Wq -`TjZSf Y1jO V*ZgT, ab*`\/*,Zn\^ (/SD \- ]\]1`1/S,B qVk\ ,\ZS Z1 ]\V*pbnaqE b\ ^fZq ab\WSO gqE `da*WSYE +d/1 4`dyZ\,*Z*D 1V`1b*` `1YT^E Z* TYGq *`dfE ]`\hSb*, gp 4,TabO Vd ]1`1/ Z*`\/\YE k\ 4T+`*,aq , `da*O WSYanV\Yd f`*YTD \bTY ,TZ ]`\hSb*, ^^ ]1`1/ VZq4qYS (/SE * ,\ZS ]1`1/*WS adO ,Ty g*`p -\qVSYdD *`p Z1 a]\/\+*WSaq \3T ]1`1ab\`\-SE b\3 ,TZ `\4`T4*, ad,Ty Z* jY*bVS T a]*WS, L `1YT^ 7:B5P67MD

!"#2

Ë™*WT \- Z*V*4*, `1YT^B w T4nYS a\O +T 4Z\,d TZj\-\ 4,\qE T Z*]SjS Z* Zn\O Yd ,aT ]1`jT aW\,*E k\ +dWS Z* ]1`O j\Yd 4,\^E qV\-\ a]*WS, -\qVSYE g*` (/SZx L `1YT^ 7:B6<MD 1`14 5; `\VT, \O 3* 4,TabV*E qVd ]1`1/*, `1YTqE a]\,ZSO W*an , daTf ]\/`\+SgqfB `da*WSY +d, 4ZSk1ZSyE hSY*W\ ]`\,T/ZSVT, Z*`\/d P ,+Sb\E * Y1jV*ZgT, YTab* ,T/,1WS , Z1,\O Wp /\ *,SW\Z*D )V a*Y* 4,TabV* ]1`1O ab\`\-SE b*V T `\4]\,T/n ]`\ Z*Y*-*ZZq ^^ 4*-WdjSbS /TyjWS /\ Z*jSf /ZT, d +T+O WTyZTy VZS4T `1YT^D

˛Z\,d d ,\-ZT /\f`SabSqZanVT h*aS ]*WSbS \31 W\,\ Z*Y*-*,aq Z1 WSj1 -\qVSYD TaO Wq `\4V\Wd `1gnV\^ TY]1`T^ Ĺ4`*^W1Y ]`*O

˚• Ë? Ë™ & ) /Wq ,aT2^ `\/SZSD TZ ]\,T/\YWq2 ,Sa,TbWp2 `1WT-TyZT Z\,SZSE `\4]\,T/*2 ]`\ Wp/1y 4 `T4ZSf V`*^ZE T Z*dV\,T ]Sb*ZZqE ]\V*4d2E qV Y\3Z* /\W*bS an\-\/ZTjZT ]`\+W1YSD TWnj1 b\-\E d Zn\Yd Z1 bTWnVS /1b*WnZ\ \+-\,\`ppbnaq ]\b\hZT ]\/T^E * y `\4V`S,*2bnaq ^fZ2 a]`*,3Z2 4Z*h1ZZqD 1y h*a\]Sa 4*,O 3/S 4*WSj*2bnaq ]\WTbShZ\ Z1yb`*WnZSY T Z1 4,1WShd2 3\/Z\^ `*aS hS Z*gT\Z*WnZ\abTD Z*y-\W\,ZTj1E ,TZ ,a1Wq2 ,]1,Z1ZTabn d b\YdE k\ ,\`1gn Z14*+*`\Y a]\,ZSbn a,\p \+TbZSgp P 4ZSkSbn ZSZTjO Zp aSab1Yd 4W* b* ,ab*Z\,Sbn YS`ZSy Z\,Sy a,TbD 8

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

q ]d+WTV*gTq Z1 /Wq ]`\/*3dD \Z* 2 h*abSZ\p ,a1a,TbO Zn\^ ]`\-`*YS +T+WTyZ\^ \a,TbSE qV* ]T/b`SYd2bnaq /\+`\O ,TWnZSYS ]\31`b,*YSD )Vk\ Z1 ,V*4*Z\ 3\/Z\-\ /31`1W*E ,`1yanVT Sa*ZZq L b*`Sy Ë›*,TbM gSbdpbnaq 4 T+WT^ d ]1`1O VW*/T -T2ZV* L,S/*ZZq 6>>6 `\VdME * `SabSqZanVT `1gnO VT Sa*ZZq L \,Sy Ë›*,TbM P 4 w 1`1VW*/d Z\,\-\ a,TbdxD ÄąZjT /31`1W* gSb*bB dWDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ dWTj*C P w 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,Tbd ,qb\-\ SanY*x L4 ]`SYTbV*O YSE *Z-WDMC \YDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ \Y1ZV*D Awake! (ISSN 0005-237X) is published monthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; M. H. Larson, President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. Periodicals Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibel- und Traktat-Gesellschaft der Zeugen Jehovas, e. V., Selters/Taunus. Verantwortliche Redaktion: Ramon Templeton, Selters/Taunus. 5 2011 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. aT ]`*,* 4+1`T-*pbnaqD Printed in Germany.

Vol. 92, No. 12

Monthly

UKRAINIAN

,SW* /SZ*abTq 1W1,VT/T,D /SZ 4 ^^ g*O `T,E ZbT\f Ëš]Te*Z L]`*,S, d ]1`T\/ 5;9P5:8 ``D /\ ZD 1DME +*3*phS \+G2/Z*O bS a,\p TY]1`TpE 4*,4qb\ ,]`\,*/3d,*, -`1gnVdE *+\ 1WWTZTabShZdE VdWnbd`dD TZ Z*a*/3d,*, a1`1/ p/1^, ]\-Wq/SE 4,Sh*^ b* `1WT-Tp -`1VT,D

`S+WS4Z\ d 5:< `\gT /\ ZD 1D ZbTO \f a]WpZ/`d,*, f`*Y -\,S , `da*WSO YTD \,1`f 31`b\,ZSV* -\,T ,TZ 4,T, TZjSy P Z* h1abn -`1gnV\-\ +\-* ˛1,a*D ZbT\f 4*+\`\ZS, p/1qY ,T/4Z*h*bS adO +\bd T \+`T4d,*bS a,\^f aSZT,D 1]\aWdf V*`*,aq aY1`bpD *Y*-*phSan ,SV\`1ZSbS `1WT-Tp p/1O ^,E ZbT\f ,S`TjS, 4ZSkSbS ad,\^ ˛*O V\Zd , gTW\Yd Ĺ4`*^WTD /Z*V y\Yd Z1 ,/*W\aq a]*WSbS ,aTf `dV\]SaT,D ˙1qVT ]`SYT`ZSVS ,`1yanVSf Sa*Zn +dWS ab*O `*ZZ\ af\,*ZT y dZSVZdWS ,\-ZpD `TY b\O -\E hSY*W\ ad,\^, 4+1`1-W\aq , p/1yanVSf -`\Y*/*f 4* Y13*YS Ĺ4`*^WpD

V*4 ˙T\VW1bT*Z* ˛ZSkSbS Sa*ZZq Z*Y*-*,aq k1 TZO jSy ,T/\YSy ]`*,Sb1Wn P `SYanVSy TYO ]1`*b\` ˙T\VW1bT*ZD 7>7 `\gT ZD 1D ,TZ ,S/*, a1`Tp ad,\`Sf dV*4T, ]`\bS f`SaO bSqZD 1 a]`ShSZSW\ w 1WSV1 ]1`1aWT/dO ,*ZZqxE qV y\-\ Z*4S,*pbn /1qVT Tab\`SO VSD ˛-T/Z\ 4 ]1`jSY dV*4\YE aWT/ +dW\ a]*Wp,*bS ]`SYT`ZSVS ,qb\-\ SanY* T `dyZd,*bS a]\`d/SE /1 f`SabSqZS ]\O VW\ZqWSaq \-\,TD *``T 1Y+WE ]`\e1a\` `1WT-T24Z*,ab,* 4 T`-TZanV\-\ dZT,1`aSO b1bdE aV*4*,B w˙T\VW1bT*Z ]`S]daV*,E k\

S/*2bnaq b*VSYS Y\,*YSB *W+*ZanV*E *Yf*`anV*E *Z-WTyanO V*67E *`*+anV*E *e`SV*ZaE +1Y+*E +T`Y*ZanV*E +TaW*Y*E +\W-*`O anV*E ,G2bZ*YanV*E ,T`Y1ZanV*E -TZ/TE -`1gnV*E -`d4SZanV*E -d/3*`*bTE /*banV*7E 1,1E 1ab\ZanV*E 2,`1yanV* LT,`SbME 4dWdE T+\E TW\V*ZanV*E TZO /\Z14TyanV*E TaW*Z/anV*E Ta]*ZanV*67E Tb*WTyanV*67E y\`d+*E V*Z*/*E VS`-S4nV*E VSb*yanV*7 L*d/T\4*]Sa bTWnVS Y*Z/*`SZanV\p Y\,\pME VSO b*yanV* La]`\k1Z1 ]SanY\ME VTZnq`d*Z/*E VT`dZ/TE V\`1yanV*67E V\a*E W*bSanV*E WSb\,anV*E W\4TE Y*V1/\ZanV*E Y*W*-*aTyanV*E Y*W*qW*YE Y*WnbTyanV*E Z-*W*E ZT/1`W*Z/anV*67E ZTY1gnV*67E Z\`,14nV*67E ]1/TE ]1Z/3*+anV*E ]\WnanV*67E ]\`bd-*WnanV*687E `*`\b\Z-*E `\aTyanO V*67E `dYdZanV*E a*Y\*E a1+d*ZanV*E a1`+anV*E a1adb\E aSZ-*WnanO V*E aW\,*gnV*E aW\,1ZanV*E ad*fTWTE b*-*WnanV*7E b*yanV*E b*YTWnanV*E b\VO]TaSZE b\Z-*ZanV*E ba,*Z*E ba\Z-*E bd`1gnV*E d-\`anV*E dV`*^ZanO V*E d`/dE eT/3TyanV*E eTZanV*7E e`*Zgd4nV*687E fTWT-*yZ\ZE f\`,*banO V*E h1anV*7E hSh1,*E hTb\Z-*E j,1/anV*7E j\Z*E q]\ZanV*67D 6 *V\3 CDD 8 *V\3 MP3 CD-ROMD 7 d/T\4*]SaS b*V\3 /\abd]ZT Z* www.jw.org.

+d/nOqV* f`SabSqZanV* -`\Y*/*E f\h +S /1 ,\Z* +dW*E Y*W* 4+T`Vd VZS-E k\ /\]\O Y*-*W* ^Y ,S3SbSxD ,a1,Ty 1a*`TyanO VSy 4 *W1abSZSE g1`V\,ZSy Tab\`SVE V\bO `Sy 3S, d g1y ]1`T\/E ]Sa*,B w S Z* ,W*aZT \hT +*hSWSE qV /\ a*YSf ]T/,*WSZ `dyZd,*WS Y\WSb\,ZT /\YS T a]*Wp,*WS ]\a1`1/ ]W\k Z*bfZ1ZT \-\Y a,qk1ZZT

Sa*ZZqxD ˛* /1qVSYS /31`1W*YSE h1`14 b`S YTO aqgT ]TaWq dV*4d ˙T\VW1bT*Z* ]`*,Sb1Wn ]T,ZThZ\O*e`SV*ZanV\-\ YTab* S`b* Lan\-\/ZT \Zab*ZbSZ*M Z*V*4*, f`SabSO qZ*Y ,T//*bS ,aT a,\^ wV\]T^ 4*V\Zdx b* w]`SYT`ZSVS ]Sa*ZnxD ˙\VdY1ZbS b\-\ 3 ]1`T\/d ]\V*4dpbnE k\ f`SabSqZS `*/j1 +dWS -\b\,T 4*4Z*bS b\`bd` T aY1`bTE *ZT3 ,T//*bS T+WT^ Z* a]*W1ZZqD

\Yd b*V* Z1Z*,SabnH aT 4-*/*ZT ]`*,Sb1WT P -\qVSYE ZO bT\f b* ˙T\VW1bT*Z P Y*WS \/Zd Y1O bdB 4ZSkSbS \31 W\,\D /Z*V T+WTq ,gTWTW* ]\]`S hSaW1ZZT Z*]*/SD SYanO VT TY]1`*b\`SE qVT ]`*,SWS ]TaWq ˙T\VO W1bT*Z*E 4*q,WqWS ]`\ a,\2 Z*,1`Z1ZZq Z* f`SabSqZab,\D ,bTYE a]`\+S 4*-WdO jSbS +T+WTyZd 4,TabVd Z1 ]`S]SZSWSaqD \YdH ˙1`3*,ZT ]`*,Sb1WT T Z*,Tbn g1`V\,Z\O aWd3Sb1WT b,1`/SWSE k\E a]*WpphS ]`SO YT`ZSVS T+WT^E ,\ZS Z1 ]`*-ZdWS 4ZSkSO bS \31 W\,\E * WSj1 f\bTWSE k\+ ^^ Z1 hSb*WS ]`\abT Wp/SD W1 h\Yd gn\-\ ]`*-ZdWS g1`V\,Z\aWd3Sb1WTH Ĺ k\ ,\ZS `\+SWSE *+S /\aq-bS a,\2^ Y1bSH

S ,S f\bTWS + \b`SY*bS +TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ k\+ 4 ,*YS ]`\,\/SWS +14V\jb\,Z1 /\Y*jZ2 ,S,h1ZZq TO +WT^H `\aSY\ Z*/TaW*bS a,\2 ]`\f*ZZq ,T/V*Y -\,S Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/O ]\,T/ZSf */`1aE ]\/*ZSf ZS3h1D \,ZSy ]1`1WTV */`1a /S,Tbnaq Z* a*ybT www.watchtower.org/addressD `-1ZbSZ*B Casilla 83 (Suc 27B), C1427WAB Cdad. Aut. de Buenos Aires. TW\`danB 66>>7>E SZaVE *Nq =D 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTqB The Ridgeway, London ´ NW7 1RN. Äą4`*^WnB PO Box 29345, 61293 Tel Aviv. Äąa]*ZTqB Apartado 132, 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz (Madrid). Äąb*WTqB Via della Bufalotta 1281, I-00138 Rome RM. *Z*/*B PO Box 4100, George˘ town, ON L7G 4Y4. \W/\,*E 1a]d+WTV*B PO Box 472, MD-2005 Chisin ¸ au. TY1hhSZ*B 65617 Selters. \Wnk*B ul. Warszawska 14, 05-830 Nadarzyn. \`bd-*WTqB Apartado 91, P-2766-955 Estoril. \aTqB *Nq 5<6E *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-E 5=>>>>D " B 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. V`*^Z*B *Na =99E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE ;=8=5D `*ZgTqB BP 625, F-27406 Louviers Cedex. 1fTqB PO Box 90, 198 00 Prague 9.

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55 9

˝˚ ı˙ (˙˚• h*aE T T+WTp ]\h*WS ]1`1VW*O /*bS Y\,*YSE qVSYS `\4Y\,WqW* +TWnjTabn Wp/1yD *W\ fb\ YT- hSb*bS T+WTp 2,`1yanV\p hS -`1gnV\p P Y\,*O YSE V\b`SYS ,\Z* +dW* Z*]Sa*Z*D n\-\/ZT YS Z*,`q/ hS Y\-WS + 4`\4dYTbS \31 W\O ,\E qV+S ,\Z\ Z1 +dW\ ]1`1VW*/1Z1 4 bSf ab*`\/*,ZTf Y\,D *y31 4* 7>> `\VT, /\ ]`Sf\/d ıada* Z* 41YWp ,`1yanVT Sa*ZZq ]\h*WS ]1`1VW*O /*bSaq -`1gnV\pD 1`1VW*/ \b`SY*, Z*O 4,d 1]bd*-TZb*D `S+WS4Z\ h1`14 ;>> `\O VT, ı2`\ZTY ab,\`S, dWn-*bd P ]1`1VW*/ ,`1yanVSf T `1gnVSf Sa*Zn W*bSZanO V\pD b\y h*a a*Y1 gq Y\,* +dW* ]\jS`1O Z\p , SYanVTy TY]1`T^D ˛-\/\Y W*bSZanV* ]\h*W* ,Sf\/SbS 4 d3SbVdE T ^^ 4Z*WS WSj1 ,Sa\V\\a,Th1ZT Wp/SD *b\WSgnV* g1`V,* ]`\bS/TqW* ]1O `1VW*/d T+WT^ Z* TZjT Y\,SD 1WT-TyZT ]`\O ,T/ZSVS b,1`/SWSE k\ bTWnVS 2,`1yanV*E

`\abT Wp/S Y*y31 Z1 Y*WS /\abd]d /\ T+WT^D 1 /*,*W\ /dfT,ZSgb,d 4Y\-d ]*Zd,*bS Z*/ ZSYS

-`1gnV* b* W*bSZanV* 2 ,T/]\,T/ZSYS Y\O ,*YS /Wq \3\-\ W\,*1D

\4V\W g1`V,S T ]1`1VW*/ T+WT^ IX ab\WTbbT ZD 1D S`SW\ T 1e\/TyE ]`\]\,T/ZSVS 4 YTab* 1aa*W\ZTVSE qVT ]`1/ab*,WqWS fT/Zd L,T4*ZbTyanVdM 1`VO ,dE Z*Y*-*WSaq 4`\+SbS Y\,d aW\,GqZ \eTO 1 p T/1pE \h1,S/Z\E ,SadZd, Ta]*ZanVSy 2]SaV\] ıaSO /\` 1,TWnanVSy L9:>P:7: ``D ZD 1DMD TZ b,1`/S,B wıaZd2 b`S a,qbT Y\,SEP 2,`1yanV*E -`1gnV* y W*bSZanV*EP T ,\O ZS ,SkT 4* ,aT TZjTD *Y1 gSYS b`n\Y* Y\,*YS SW*b 4*O ]Sa*, Z* f`1abT \+,SZd,*h1ZZq ]`\bS \a]\/*xD W1 3 `Tj1ZZq 4*]Sa*bS \+,SZd,*h1ZZq gSYS b`n\Y* Y\,*YS ]`SyZqWS `SYWqZSOq4ShZSVSD 1 Z1 +dW* \3* ,\WqD

˙ ı ı( +WD :7: ZD 1D

5>;= ıaS/\` 1,TWnanO VSy b,1`/SbnE k\ 2,`1yanV*E -`1gnO V* b* W*bSZanV* 2 wa,qbSYSx Y\,*O YS T b\Yd T+WTq Y*2 TaZd,*bS WSO j1 gSYS Y\,*YS

55== *]* `S-\`Ty VII V*b1-\`ShZ\ ,T/Y\,Wq2 `*bSaO W*,dE V\WS b\y ]`\aSbn /\4,\Wd ,3S,*bS ab*`\aW\O ,GqZanVd , g1`V,TD *]* b,1`/SbnE k\ ,qb1 SanY\ Z1 Y*2 +dbS /\abd]O ZSY /Wq wY*W\O \a,Th1ZSf Wp/1yx

*]* ıZ\V1ZbTy III ,,*3*2 2`1bSV\Y +d/nOV\-\E fb\ Z*O aYTWp2bnaq ]1`1O VW*/*bS b* \+-\O ,\`p,*bS T+WTpD p/1yE qVT Z1 aWdf*pbnaq Z*V*O 4d ]*]SE V*bdpbn T ,+S,*pbn

Pope Gregory VII: 5 Scala/White Images/Art Resource, NY; Pope Innocent III: 5 Scala/Art Resource, NY; Council of Trent: 5 Scala/White Images/Art Resource, NY; Pope Paul IV: 5 The Print Collector, Great Britain/HIP/Art Resource, NY

gTyZ\p g1`V\,Z\p Y\,\pD \ZS ]`*-ZdWSE k\+ aW\,GqZanVT Z*`\/S fT/Z\^ ,`\]SE qVT Z1 `\4dYTWS ZT -`1gnV\^E ZT W*bSZanV\^E /T4Z*,*WSan ]`\ \-*D

`\b1 gT ]`\]\,T/ZSVS 4TbVZdWSaq 4 WpO bSY \]\`\Y ZTY1gnVSf a,qk1ZZ\aWd3Sb1O WT,E qVT ]`*-ZdWS ab`SY*bS ]\jS`1ZZq ,TO 4*ZbTyanV\-\ f`SabSqZab,* T b\Yd 4*,4qb\ ,T/ab\p,*WS W*bSZanVdD ˛,TaZ\E ]\WTbShO ZT TZb1`1aS +dWS /Wq ZSf ,*3WS,TjTE ZT3 \+\,Gq4\V /*,*bS Wp/qY 4Z*ZZq ]`\ \-*D ˙1/*WT aSWnZTjT b1`bq YT3 4*fT/Z\p b* afT/Z\p -TWV*YS f`SabSqZab,* ]`S4,1WS /\ `\4V\Wd T db,\`1ZZq , 5>98 `\gT `SY\OV*O b\WSgnV\^ b* ]`*,\aW*,Z\^ g1`V\,D

`\bS/Tq ]1`1VW*/d T+WT^ SY\OV*b\WSgnV* g1`V,* ]\h*W* ,,*3*O bS W*bSZanVd Y\,d a,qb\pD ıE V\WS 5>;= `\O Vd VZq4n \-1YT^ `*bSaW*, ]\]`\aS, /\4O ,\Wd ,3S,*bS ]T/ h*a +\-\aWd3TZn d y\-\ V`*^ ab*`\aW\,GqZanVd Y\,dE ]*]* `S-\O `Ty VII Z*]Sa*,B w S , 3\/Z\Yd `*4T Z1 Y\31Y\ 4*/\,\WnZSbS g1 ]`\f*ZZqxD \O Yd ZTH w TE fb\ `\4/dYd2 Z*/ gSYEP aV*4*, ]*O ]*EP `\4dYTpbnE k\ \-\,T ,-\/Z\E *+S /1O qVT YTagq ,qb\-\ SanY* 4*WSj*WSan b*O 2YZSg1pD ıZ*Vj1E qV+S ,\Z\ +dW\ ]\,ZTabp 4`\4dYTWSY /Wq ,aTfE b\E Y\3WS,\E y\-\ + Z1 /d31 gTZd,*WS T Z1 j*Zd,*WS *+\ 3 Y*O W\\a,Th1ZT Wp/S Y\-WS + y\-\ Z1]`*,SWnZ\ `\4dYTbSE T g1 /\,\/SW\ + ^f /\ -`Tf*xD

598:

`\abSy Z*`\/ Y*y31 Z1 Y*, /\abd]d /\ T+WT^D 1 +dW\ Z* `dVd ]`\,T/ZSV*Y g1`VO ,SE +\ /*,*W\ Y\3WS,Tabn db`SYd,*bS Z*/ ZSY ,W*/dD Ë™dfT,ZSgb,\ Z1 +*3*W\E k\+ ]`\abT Wp/S ,b`dh*WSan d a]`*,dE qV\pE Z* y\-\ /dYVdE Y*WS 4*yY*bSaq WSj1 aWd3SO b1WT g1`V,SD 55== `\gT ]*]* ıZ\V1ZbTy III d a,\2O Yd WSabT ]Sa*, ]`\ w2`1bSVT,xE qVT ]1`1O VW*WS T+WTp e`*Zgd4nV\p T Z*aYTWp,*O WSan \+-\,\`p,*bS ^^ YT3 a\+\pD ıZ\V1ZbTy 4*ab\ad,*, /\ ZSf aW\,* ıada*B w 1 /*O ,*yb1 a,qb\-\ ]a*Y T Z1 VS/*yb1 ]1`O WSZ a,SZqYx L *b,Tq ;B:MD \Yd ,TZ b*V ,SaW\,S,aqH *]* ]\qaZS,B w#\+ 3\/Z* ]`\ab* y Z1,h1Z* Wp/SZ* Z*,Tbn Z1 Z*,*O 3d,*W*an \aq-ZdbS ,1WShZTabn a,qbSf SO a*Zn T ]`\]\,T/d,*bS ^f TZjSYxD aTfE fb\ ]`\bS,S,aq Z*V*4d ]*]SE ,T//*,*WS TZVO ,T4Sb\`*YE qVT b\`bd`*YS 4Ydjd,*WS /\ ]\V*qZZqD p/1yE V\b`T 4*WSj*WSaq Z1]\O fSbZSYSE a]*Wp,*WS 3S,g1YD \`\bn+* 4* ]`*,\ ,\W\/TbS T+WT2p T hSO b*bS ^^ +dW* /\,-\p b* ,SaZ*3WS,\pD Sab ]*]S ıZ\V1ZbTq h*ab\ aWd3S, ]T/ab*,\p b\O -\E k\+ 4*+\`\ZqbS Wp/qY V\`Sabd,*bSan T+WT2p b* ]1`1VW*/*bS ^^ Z* TZjT Y\,SD 1O ,/\,4T ]TaWq Z*V*4d ıZ\V1ZbTq ]\h*WS a]*O Wp,*bS T+WT^E ]1`1VW*/1ZT ]\jS`1ZSYS Z* b\y h*a Y\,*YSD ]*Wp,*WS b*V\3 ,W*aZSO VT, gSf T+WTyD ]\/*WnjT ab\WTbbq 2]SaO V\]S T ]`*,Sb1WT V*b\WSgnVSf /1`3*, ,O `\]S 4*]\]*/WS,\ ,SV\Zd,*WS Z*V*4 ]*]SD

599= Ë›-T/Z\ 4 `TO j1ZZqY `S/1ZbO anV\-\ a\+\`dE /`dVd,*bS +d/nO qVSy ]1`1VW*/ T+WT^ Y\3Z* WSO j1 4 /\4,\Wd V*O b\WSgnV\^ g1`V,S

*]* *,W\ IV 4*O +\`\Zq2 Y*bS T+O WTp ]\jS`1ZSYS Z* b\y h*a Y\,*YSD 1`1VW*/S V\ZeTaO V\,dpbn T a]*WpO pbnE Z1`T/V\ a]*O Wppbn T ^fZTf ,W*aZSVT, `\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55 ;

From Foxe’s Book of Martyrs

SfE fb\ Y*, T+WTp *+\ Z*,*3d,*,aq ^^ `\4]\,ap/3d,*bSE a]*Wp,*WS Z* ab\,]*f hS /\,ThZ\ d,Gq4Zp,*WS

,qk1ZZ\aWd3Sb1WT 4Z*WSE k\ +TWnO jTabn ,h1Zn V*b\WSgnV\^ g1`V,S Å¡`dZbdO pbnaq Z* ^^ b`*/SgTqfE * Z1 Z* T+WT^D 14dY\,Z\E g1 +dW* \/Z* 4 ]`ShSZE h\Yd ,\ZS 4*+\`\ZqWS a,\^y ]*ab,T hSb*bS ,qO b1 SanY\D W1ZS /dfT,ZSgb,* `\4dYTWSE k\E \b`SY*,jS +T+WTyZT 4Z*ZZqE Wp/S ]\O +*h*bn ,1WSVd `T4ZSgp YT3 g1`V\,ZSYS /\Vb`SZ*YS T ,h1ZZqYS T+WT^D

*aWT/VS 1e\`Y*gT^ ˛ ]\q,\p ]`\b1ab*ZbS4Yd `1WT-TyZ* V*`O b* ,`\]S 4YTZSW*aqD *`bTZ pb1` Z*O Y*-*,aq `1e\`Yd,*bS V*b\WSgnVd g1`V,dC /\ gn\-\ y\-\ a]\ZdV*W\ Z*+db1 4 T+WT^ 4Z*ZZqD `\b1 4daSWWq pb1`* +dWS Y*`ZTD ˛`1jb\p 5965 `\Vd ,TZ \ab*b\hZ\ `\4T`,*, ab\adZVS 4 g1`V,\pD pb1` +d, 4/T+ZSY ]1`1VW*/*h1Y T ]\ab*Z\,S, 4`\+SbS T+O WTp /\abd]Z\p /Wq +*-*bn\fD T+WTq pb1`* ZTY1gnV\p Y\,\p ab*W* /d31 ]\]dWq`Z\pE T g1 ]`S,1`ZdW\ d,*-d `SY\OV*b\WSgnV\^ g1`V,SD ˙Wq ]`\bS,*-S g1`V,* \/`*4d 3 ,S`TjSW* ,S/*bS a,Ty ]1`1VW*/D 1,/\,4T ,SyjW\ *3 /,* ]1`1O VW*/S ZTY1gnV\p Y\,\pD /Z*V 598: `\O VdE Y1Zj1 ZT3 h1`14 69 `\VT,E `SY\OV*b\O <

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

WSgnVSy `S/1ZbanVSy a\+\` ]\ab*Z\,S,E k\ g1`V,* +d/1 V\Zb`\Wp,*bS /`dVd,*ZZq ,aT2^ `1WT-TyZ\^ WTb1`*bd`SE d b\Yd hSaWT ]1`1VW*/T, T+WT^D an k\ ,S`TjS, `S/1ZbanVSy a\+\`B w T/b1]1` a,qk1ZZT Sa*ZZqDDD Y*pbn /`dO Vd,*bSaq Z*W13ZSY hSZ\YC ZTV\Yd Z1 /\4O ,\Wq2bnaq /`dVd,*bS *+\ 4*Y\,WqbS /`dV +d/nOqV\^ VZS3VS /df\,Z\-\ 4YTabdE Z1 ,V*4*,jS TYGq *,b\`*E hS ]`\/*,*bS ^f d Y*y+dbZn\YdE hS Z*,Tbn Y*bSE /\]\VS gT VZS3VS a]\h*bVd Z1 af,*WSbn YTag1,Sy 2]SaV\] xD 599= `\gT ]*]* *,W\ IV ,]1`j1 \]d+WTO Vd,*, a]Sa\V VZS-E 4*+\`\Z1ZSf `SY\OV*b\O WSgnV\p g1`V,\pD gn\Yd a]SaVd +dWS ]1`1VW*/S T+WT^ *Z-WTyanV\pE Ta]*ZanO V\pE Tb*WTyanV\pE ZT/1`W*Z/anV\pE ZTY1gnO V\p T e`*Zgd4nV\p Y\,*YSE * b*V\3 /1O qVT ]1`1VW*/S W*bSZanV\pD \yE fb\ f\bT, hSb*bS T+O WTpE ]\,SZ1Z +d, \b`SY*bS ]SanY\,Sy /\4,TW 2]SaV\]T, *+\ TZV,T4Sb\`T,D W1 b\/T b*V* Wp/SZ* ]\b`*]WqW* /\ hSaW* ]T/\4`p,*ZSf d 2`1aTD )Vk\ fb\an Y*, T+WTp \/ZT2p 4 ]\jS`1ZSf Y\, *+\ Z*,*3d,*,aq ^^ `\4]\,apO /3d,*bSE b\ ,]*/*, d Z1YSO WTabn V*b\WSgnV\^ g1`V,SD *-*bn\f *`1jb\,d,*WSE a]*Wp,*WS Z* ab\,]*fE 4*O aY*3d,*WS Z* `\3ZTE /\,ThO Z\ d,Gq4Zp,*WS hS ,T/]`*,O WqWS Z* -*W1`SD SWdh1ZT T+WT^ ]*WSWSD *b\WSgnVT a,qk1ZSVS ]`\/\,3d,*WS V\ZeTaV\,d,*bS T a]*Wp,*O bS T+WT^ *3 /\ XX ab\WTbbqD

,bTYE Z1 Y\3Z* aV*4*bSE k\ ]`\b1ab*ZO bS4Y /\,T, a,\p ,T//*ZTabn T+WT^D 1b\/SE qVSYS ]\aWd-\,d,*WSan /1qVT ]`\b1ab*ZbO anVT b1\W\-S XVIII b* XIX ab\WTbnE ab*WS ,T/\YT qV ,Sk* V`SbSV*E b\+b\ Z*dV\,* V`SbSV* T+WT^D Ë›-\/\Y hSY*W\ Wp/1y ]`SO yZqWS ae\`Y\,*ZT ]T/ ,]WS,\Y b1\`T^ Ë™*`O ,TZ* ,h1ZZqE ZT+S 3Sbbq 4Gq,SW\aq ,S]*/O V\,\ d ]`\g1aT 1,\WpgT^E * Z1 +dW\ ab,\`1Z1 \-\YD 1\W\-S T Z*,Tbn hSY*W\ ]`1/ab*,ZSVT, /dfT,ZSgb,* ]1`1V\Zd,*WSE k\ T+WTq 4/1O +TWnj\-\ YTabSbn W1-1Z/S b* YTeSD an h\O Yd an\-\/ZT /1fb\ 4 ]`\b1ab*ZbanVSf a,qO k1ZZ\aWd3Sb1WT, b* hW1ZT, ^fZTf g1`V\, ,T/VS/*2 *,b\`Sb1b T+WT^E V*3dhSE k\ ,\O Z* 2 Z1b\hZ\p 4 Tab\`ShZ\-\ ]\-Wq/dD \3WS,\E ,*a /S,dpbn hSaW1ZZT a]`\+S /SaV`1/Sbd,*bS T 4ZSkSbS \31 W\,\D /Z*V daT gT Z*]*/S ,Sq,SWSan Y*`ZSYSD T+WTq ^f ,Sb`SY*W*D

\Yd T+WTq ,gTWTW* *-*b\ Wp/1y gTZd,*WS T+WTp b* +dWS -\b\,T ]\Y1`bSE 4*fSk*phS ^^D `\b1 /\ Z*jSf /ZT, ,\Z* /TyjW* Z1 4*,/qVS Wp/O

anVSY 4daSWWqYE * 4*,/qVS \3Ty aSWTE */31 a*Y1 \- Z*/SfZd, a,\^f aWd3Sb1O WT, Z*]Sa*bS gp VZS-d Lıa*^ 8>B<C 5 1b`* 5B69MD #\/1ZZ1 hSb*ZZq T+WT^ b* 4*ab\ad,*ZO Zq ^^ ]\`*/ ]\V`*kd2 Z*j1 3SbbqE 4/\`\O ,Gq b* ab\adZVS , aTYG^D \- 4*fSk*2 a,\2 W\,\ T /+*2 ]`\ b1E k\+ YTWnq`/S Wp/1y Y\-WS hSb*bS T+WTp `T/Z\p Y\,\pD TZ f\h1E k\+ Wp/S /T4Z*WSan ]`\ Zn\-\E ]\O Wp+SWS y\-\ b* aWd3SWS y\YdE * , Y*y+dbO Zn\Yd ,bTj*WSaq ,ThZSYS +W*-\aW\,1ZZqO YSD T+* Z1 gn\-\ ]`*-Z1 V\31Z 4 Z*aH Y\WSb,T /\ a,\-\ Z1+1aZ\-\ *bnO V* ıada aV*4*,B w ,\2 aW\,\ P g1 ]`*,/*x Lı,*Z* 5;B5;MD 1`14 T+WTp P \31 W\,\E qV1 hSb*, T qV\-\ Z*,h*, ıadaEP \- ,T/]\O ,T/*2 Z* 4*]Sb*ZZq kS`Sf Wp/1yD Ë›*\f\hd2Y\ ,*a /T4Z*bSaq +TWnj1 ]`\ \3d 4,TabVd /Wq Wp/ab,*E 4*]Sa*Zd , T+WT^D ,T/VS -\,SE ,S/*,gT gn\-\ 3d`O Z*WdE \f\h1 /\]\Y\3dbn ,*Y 4/\+dbS b*V1 4Z*ZZq1D 1 S Y\31b1 Z*]Sa*bS Z* \/Zd 4 */`1aE k\ Z* 9Oy ab\`TZO gT gn\-\ 3d`Z*WdE *+\ 4*ybS Z* a*yb www.watchtower.orgD 1 ,*a ZT /\ h\-\ Z1 4\+\,Gq4d,*bSY1D

ı ı• ı ıË™ ıË™ı ,\`1gn f\h1E k\+ YS 4Z*WS ,T/]\,T/T Z* b*VT ,*3WS,T 4*]Sb*ZZqB ˘ h\Yd Y1b* 3SbbqH ˘ \Yd abTWnVS ab`*3/*ZnH ˘ Ë™1 ]1`1+d,*pbn ]\Y1`WTH ˘ #\ h1V*2 Z* Wp/ab,\H T+WTq YTabSbn ,T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZq T ]\V*4d2E qV ab*bS a]`*,/T k*aWS,SYSD

)˙ ı ıı

S \- /+*2 ]`\ b,*`SZH ( b,*`SZ 4*-`\3d2 ,1WSV* Z1O +14]1V*D * /dYVd ,h1ZSfE +*-*O b\ ,S/T, 4ZSV*2 Z*/4,Sh*yZ\ j,S/VSYS b1Y]*YSD ,*`SZS ab`*3/*pbn ,T/ b\-\E k\ Wp/SZ* `dyZd2 ^fZ2 ]`S`\/Z1 a1`1/\O ,Sk1D *`b\ b*V\3 4-*/*bS 3\`ab\VT Y1O b\/S b,*`SZZSgb,*E a\+*hT b* ]T,ZqhT +\^ T 3*Wp-T/ZSy ab*Z YTWny\ZT, /\Y*jZTf dWp+W1ZgT,E qVSf ]\VSZdWS -\a]\/*`TD

1`1/ \hSY* ]\ab*2 4\,aTY Z1,bTjZ* V*`O bSZ*D ˙1fb\ ,,*3*2 g1 Z1YSZdhSY Z*aWT/O V\Y Wp/anV\-\ ]`\-`1adD W1 hS b*VSY +d, \3Sy Z*YT`H S \-d +*y/d31E k\ Wp/SZ* 4Zdk*2bnaq Z*/ b,*`SZ*YSH S ,TZ /+*2 ]`\ ZSfH

˝

d`+\b* ,T/ a*Y\-\ ]\h*bVd

\WS \- ab,\`S, `S+E ]b*fT, T 4,T`T,E b\ +d, /d31 4*/\,\W1ZSy `14dWnb*b\YD )V -\,\`Sbnaq , T+WT^E ,\`1gn w]\+*O hS,E k\ /\+`1 ,\Z\x L dbbq 5B65E 69MD a1 b,\`TZZq \-* P ,T/ Z*yY1Zj\-\ /\ Z*yO +TWnj\-\ P ,T/hd,*W\ Z* a\+T y\-\ bd`+\O bd T Wp+\,D TZ Z1 WSj1 ,VW*, d b,*O `SZ Yd/`T TZabSZVbSE *W1 y ab,\`S, /Wq ZSf hd/\,1 a1`1/\,Sk1D an qV ,WdhO Z\ g1 \]Sa*Z\ , T+WT^B w \ZS ,aT h1V*O pbn 1+1EP k\+ S h*ad a,\-\ ]\3S,d ^Y /*,D ˙*2j ^Y P 4+S`*pbn ,\ZSE `dVd ,\p `\4V`S,*2j P /\+`\Y Z*aSh*pbnO aqx L `S]\,Tab1y 7>B68C a*W\Y 5>8B68E 69E 6;E 6<MD ,*`SZS ]T/V\`qWSaq ]1`j\Yd h\W\,TO V\,TE /*YdD \- Z1 Z*/TWS, ^f 4/*bZTaO bp YSaWSbS T `\4,S,*bS ab\adZVS 4 ZSY L6 1b`* 6B56C (/S 5=MD * ,T/YTZd ,T/ 5>

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

b,*`SZE Wp/SZ* +dW* ,Sk\p e\`Y\p 3SbbqE \aVTWnVS \- ab,\`S, ^^ wZ* ,Ty \+`*4xD /*Y YT- ,T//41`V*Wp,*bS `SO aS a,\-\ ,\`gqE -\,S L dbbq 5B6;C SO fT/ 59B7MD /Z*V g1 Z1 /*2 Wp/qY ]`*,* ]\,\/SbSan T4 b,*`SZ*YS ,ad]1`1h ,\WT ,\`gqD *]`SVW*/E \- f\bT,E k\+ /*Y /*, b,*`SZ*Y TY1Z*D -\,* Z*,Tbn /\]\Y*O -*, y\Yd , gn\YdE */31 w]`S,T, b,*O `SZ E k\+ ]\+*hSbSE qV ,TZ ^f VWSV*bSO Y1x L dbbq 6B5=MD p/SZ* Y\-W* Z*W13Z\ ]TVWd,*bSaq ]`\ b,*`SZ bTWnVS b\/TE V\O WS aWdf*W*aq \-*D

\- a]`*,/T /+*2 * 3*WnE /*Y 4+dZbd,*,aq ]`\bS a,\O -\ ,\`gqD 1 Y*W\ b`*-ThZT Z*aWT/VS qV /Wq Wp/ab,*E b*V T /Wq ,an\-\ 3S,\-\ Z* 41YWTD a1 3 ,\`1gn /*, hTbVT ,V*4T,VS k\/\ b\-\E qV ab*,SbSan /\ b,*`SZD \O h* \- /\4,\WS, Wp/qY ,+S,*bS ^f 4*O /Wq ^3T b* TZjSf ]\b`1+E ,TZ ZTV\WS Z1 af,*Wp,*, 3\`ab\V\-\ ]\,\/31ZZq 4 ZSO YSD T+WTq V*31B w TVWd2bnaq ]`*,1/ZSy 3SbbqY fd/\+S a,\2^E * a1`g1 +14+\3ZSf 3\`ab\V1x L `S]\,Tab1y 56B5>MD \- Z*,Tbn /*, ab*`\/*,Zn\Yd Z*`\O /d ı4`*^Wn 4*V\ZSE V\b`T a]`SqWS /\+`\O +dbd b,*`SZD *]`SVW*/E 4*,/qVS 4*V\O Zd ]`\ ad+\bZTy /1Zn Y\-WS ,T/]\hSbS Z1 WSj1 Wp/SE *W1 T ^fZq fd/\+* L SO fT/ 67B56MD \h* , g1y a,qk1ZZSy /1Zn Z1 /\4,\WqW\aq ]`*gp,*bSE Wp/S Y*WS /\]\Y\-bS b,*`SZTE qV* ]\b`*]SW* , +TO /d L dVS 58B9MD `TY b\-\E \- 4*+\O `\ZS, 4*,Gq4d,*bS +SVd `\b*E V\WS b\y

5>B6=MD *b\YTabn Wp/S Z1 4*,3/S 4*/dO Ydpbnaq Z*/ bSYE qV ^fZT /T^ ,]WS,*pbn Z* /\,VTWWqD +S -\a]\/*`p,*bS Z* ]W*O Z1bT b*VE k\+ Z1 4*,/*,*bS jV\/S b,*`SO Z*YE Wp/qY b`1+* 4YTZSbS YSaW1ZZqD T+WTq -\,\`Sbn ]`\ h*aE V\WS ]T/ ]`*,O WTZZqY \3\-\ *`ab,* w41YWq +d/1 ]\,O Z* ]T4Z*ZZq \a]\/Zn\-\x Lıa*^ 55B=MD ˛*,/qVS b*V\Yd 4Z*ZZp Wp/S Z*,h*bnaq ]`*,SWnZ\ -\a]\/*`p,*bS Z* 41YWTD ,\O `1gn ]\/+*2E k\+ YT3 Wp/nYS b* 4,T`*YS

& ı H

˘ S \-* f,SWp2E qV Wp/S ab*,Wqbnaq /\ b,*`SZH L `S]\,Tab1y 56B5>C *b,Tq 5>B6=MD ˘ S Y\3WS,\E k\+ Wp/S T b,*`SZS 3SWS , -*`Y\ZT^H Lıa*^ 55B:P=MD

´ ´ La Voz de Galicia/Fotografo: Vıctor Mejuto

Y\W\bSbnE * b*V\3 Z*VW*O #\+ 4,*3*bS Z* /*bS Z* ,GphZSf b,*`SZ Z1]\aSWnZT bq-*`T L SfT/ b,*`SZE Wp/qY b`1+* 67B9C \,b\`1ZZq ˛*V\Zd 4YTZSbS YSaW1ZZq 69B8MD ˛-T/Z\ 4 TZjSY 4*V\O Z\YE Z1 Y\3Z* +dW\ 4*]`qO -*bS +SV* `*4\Y 4 \aW\YE *+S b,*`SZS h*a\Y Z1 ]\O `*ZSWSan L \,b\`1ZZq ˛*O V\Zd 66B5>MD b31E T+WTq ,hSbnE k\ /\ b,*`SZ b`1O +* ab*,SbSaq 4 Z*W13Z\p d,*-\p T a]T,hdbbqYD *-*b\ Wp/1yE /+*phS ]`\ ,W*aZT TZb1`1aSE Z1 /dO Y*pbnE qV g1 ,]WSZ1 Z* b,*`SZD W1 \- a]T,hdbO WS,SyE ,TZ 4*,3/S 4,*3*2 Z* V\3Z1 a,\2 ab,\`TZZqD 1 /\+`1 ,S/Z\ 4 \]\,T/T ]`\ •\ZdD \WS ]*Zd,*W* -*`Y\ZTqE T ,T/Z\,Sbn Z* 41YWT Y1jV*ZgT TZ1,T^ ]\V*qWSaq T \- ,S`TO `*yanVT dY\,SE V\b`T +dWS Z* a*Y\Yd ]\O jS, Z1 V*`*bS ^fE ]`\`\Vd 4*+`*VW\ YSO h*bVd Tab\`T^D W\a1`/qD \/T -\,* 4*]Sb*,B w ) Z1 an qV T+WTq \]Sad2 gT hd/\,T 4YTZSB 4YSWd,*,aq + Z*/ TZ1,T2pEP gSY ,1WSO wı 4*Y1jV*2 ,\,V T4 ,T,g1pE T +d/1 W1O VSY YTab\YE k\ , Zn\Yd +TWnj1 /,*Z*/O 3*bS ]*Zb1`* 4 V\4WqYE T +d/dbn `*4\Y gqbS /1aqbSaqh\V Wp/dE qVT Z1 ,YTpbn b1WqbV\ y W1,hdVE b* b1Wq ,T/-\/\,*Z1E `\4`T4ZqbS ]`*,SgT a,\2^ ,T/ a,\2^ WT,SgTE * /SbSZ* Y*W* ^f ,\/SbSY1I V\`\,* y b* hSaW1ZZ* fd/\+*Hx L•\ZS 8B55MD ,\O ,1/YT/n +d/dbn ]*abSaq `*4\YE `*4\Y +dO `1gn ]\3*WT, Z*,Tbn b,*`SZI /dbn W13*bS ^fZT /TbSE T W1, +d/1 ^abS a\O W\Yd Z1Y\, b* fd/\+*I ı +d/1 +*,SbSaq *y+dbZ2 b,*`SZ \-d Z1 +*y/d31E qV Wp/S ]\,\/qbnaq Z1Y\,WqbV\ Z*/ /T`V\p -*/*E T ,T/Zqb1 4 b,*`SZ*YSD \3Sy Wp+Sy SZE ıadaE Z*O ,T/ ]1`a /SbSZh* ]`\abq-Z1 a,\p `dVd -*/pVSxD )V1 3 aW*,Z1 Y*y+dbO ,Tbn aV*4*,E k\ 3\/1Z -\`\+1gn Z1 ,]*/1 Z*/ Z\`d Z2I Lıa* ^ 55B:P<MD Z* 41YWp +14 ,T/\Y* y\-\ *bnV* L *b,Tq

`T4/,qZ\^ qWSZVS

˙\f`SabSqZanV1 ]\f\/31ZZq

& ˙ ı , +*-*bn\f h*abSZ*f a,Tbd ,ThZ\41W1Z* qWSZV* P Z14YTZZSy *bO `S+db `T4/,qZSf a,qbVd,*Zn T b\`-T,WTD ,bTYE g1 /1`1,\ ,SV\`Sab\,d,*WS , `1WTO -TyZSf \+`q/*f k1 , aS,d /*,ZSZdD gn\Yd Y\3Z* ]1`1V\Z*bSanE qVk\ ,T/O ,T/*bS \+W*abn \fdaW1Z Z* 4*fT/Z\Yd +1O `14T ",1gT^ T adaT/Zp \+W*abn ˚abe\WW , \`,1-T^D b\Yd `1-T\ZT Y\3Z* ]\+*hSO bS ;9 >>> \V`1YSf Z*aV1WnZSf 4\+`*31Zn d ]`S+WS4Z\ 9>>> YTagnD * /dYVd *`f1\W\O -T,E +*-*b\ gSf 4\+`*31Zn +dW\ 4`\+W1Z\ d ]1`T\/ YT3 5<>> T 9>> `\V*YS /\ ZD 1D1

˛ Z*aV1WnZSf 4\+`*31Zn ,S/Z\E k\ q4ShZSgnV1 ]\VW\ZTZZq ,ThZ\41W1ZSY /1`1,*Y ]\h*W\aq k1 4*/\,-\ /\ Z*`\/31ZZq `Sab* T dZTV*WnZT 4\+`*31ZZq ]`\WS,*pbn a,TbW\ Z* ,T`d,*ZZq Wp/1yE qVT 3SWS 4*O /\,-\ /\ Z*`\/31ZZq ıada* 4 *4*`1b*D *O ]`SVW*/E /1qVT ,h1ZT 4*4Z*h*pbnE k\ V\O WSan Z* b1`Sb\`T^ adh*aZ\^ ",1gT^ b* \`,1-T^ ,ThZ\41W1ZT /1`1,*E qVO\b qWSZVSE +dWS a,qk1ZZSY aSY,\W\YD \Yd Wp/S Z* gSf ,T//*W1ZSf ]T,ZThZSf +1`1-*f ,S`T4n+Wp,*WS Z* V*Y1Zqf 4\+`*O 31ZZq qWSZ\VH )V ]`S]daV*pbn Z*dV\,gTE \/ZT2p 4 ]`ShSZ +dW\ b1E k\ d /\f`SabSqZO 1 ˙1qVT YTagq 4 Z*aV1WnZSYS Y*WpZV*YS , \fdaW1ZT ,Z1a1ZT /\ ]SaVd ,a1a,TbZn\^ a]*/kSZS ( ˚ D

56

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

anVT h*aSE V\WS ab,\`p,*WSan bT 4\+`*31ZO ZqE qWSZVS b`*]WqWSaq `T/V\D T /1`1,* ]\abTyZ\ 41W1ZTE b\+b\ w3S,TxE d b\y h*a qV TZjT 4 ]\h*bV\Y f\W\/T, w]\YS`*pbnxD \3 /Wq Wp/1y qWSZVS +dWS /d31 4*-*/V\O ,SYSD +*-*bn\f VdWnbd`*f a,Tbd /1`1,* ,,*O 3*WSaq aSY,\W\Y 3Sbbq b* +14aY1`bqD 1 /\]\Y*-*2 4`\4dYTbSE h\Yd 4\+`*31ZZq /1O `1,E af\3Sf Z* ,ThZ\41W1ZT qWSZVSE +dWS ,S`T4n+W1ZT Z* V*Y1Zqf d \fdaW1ZT b* ˚abO e\WWT 4* +*-*b\ ab\WTbn /\ b\-\E qV gT /1`1O ,* b*Y ]\jS`SWSaqD VZS3gT w *aV1WnZT 4\+`*31ZZq d ]`SO V\`/\ZZSf 41YWqfxE \]d+WTV\,*ZTy 4* a]`SO qZZq *gT\Z*WnZ\^ `*/S 4 ]Sb*Zn VdWnbd`O Z\^ a]*/kSZS ",1gT^E aV*4*Z\B w *aV1WnZT 4\+`*31ZZq /1`1, ]\V*4dpbnE k\ , +`\Z4\O ,Sy ,TV ]T,/1ZZ* V*Z/SZ*,Tq +dW* h*aO bSZ\p ,1WSV\-\ `1-T\ZdE qVSy ,S`T4Zq,O aq a]TWnZSYS VdWnbd`ZSYS b* `1WT-TyZSYS 4,Sh*qYS T qVSy \f\]Wp,*, ,ap ,`\]d b* 4Z*hZd h*abSZd 4T^D 1jV*ZgT gn\-\ `1-TO \Zd 4*yY*WSaq 41YW1`\+ab,\Y T `\4,\/SWS b,*`SZE k\ ,]WSZdW\ Z* ^fZp `1WT-Tp b* dq,W1ZZq ]`\ ,a1a,TbD \h* TY1Z* +\31ab, ,T/`T4ZqWSaqE Wp/SE ]\ adbTE ]\VW\ZqWSaq bSY a*YSY +\-*Yx LRock Carvings in the BorderlandsMD `\jd`*E ,S/*Z* \fdaW1ZanVSY Yd41O 2YE -\,\`SbnB w *aV1WnZT Y*WpZVS P g1 Z1 ]`\ab\ 4\+`*31ZZq b\-\h*aZ\-\ ]\+dbdD * Z*jd /dYVdE ,\ZS +dWS a,\-\ `\/d Y\WSbO ,*YS *+\ 4,1`Z1ZZqYS /\ +\-T,xD +`\jd`T b13 aV*4*Z\E k\ w, \aZ\,T ,T`d,*Zn W1O

*aV1WnZT 4\+`*31ZZq /1`1, d ",1gT^B 5M \`a+\C 6M *VV*C 7M 1V1+1`5

6

7

¨ ¨ ¨ / Courtesy Stiftelsen for dokumentation av Bohuslans hallristningar

3*, Z1aVTZh1ZZSy gSVW 3SbbqE Z*`\/31ZO Zq /Tb1yE aY1`bT b* ,T/`\/31ZZqx LThe Rock Carving TourMD ]SadphS \/Zd dZTV*WnZd V\W1VgTp Z*O aV1WnZ\-\ YSab1gb,*E qV* 4Gq,SW*aq Z*O +*-*b\ `*ZTj1E ZT3 ]SanY\ d ]T,ZThZTy ,`\]TE Z*gT\Z*WnZ* 1ZgSVW\]1/Tq ",1O gT^ 4*4Z*h*2B w SY*W* VTWnVTabn Y*WpZVT, a1Vad*WnZ\-\ 4YTabd ]\V*4d2E Z*aVTWnVS ,1O WSVd `\Wn ,T/T-`*,*, VdWnb `\/ph\abT a1O `1/ Y1jV*ZgT, T,Z\hT d ]1`T\/ +`\Z4\,\-\ ,TVdx LNationalencyklopedinMD h1,S/Z\E k\ \+`q/SE ]\,Gq4*ZT 4 ,ThO Z\41W1ZSYS /1`1,*YSE -WS+\V\ d,TyjWS , 3Sbbq +*-*bn\f Z*`\/T,D w `Sb*ZanVTy 1ZgSVW\]1/T^x ]`\ `T4/,qZd qWSZVd -\,\O `SbnaqB w ,`\]T q4ShZSVSE qV ]`*,SW\E ]\VW\ZqWSaq /1`1,*YE T ]TaWq a,\-\ Z*,1`O Z1ZZq Z* f`SabSqZab,\ ,\ZS Z1 ]1`1ab*WS gn\-\ `\+SbSxD \VW\ZTZZq /1`1,*Y 4+1`1-O W\aq , `T4ZSf \+`q/*f b* 4,Sh*qfE qVO\b w4,Sh*yDDD ab*,SbS y\WnanV1 /1`1,\ , +dO /SZVd *+\ ]`S ,f\/T ]T/ h*a a,qb* a1`1/SZS 4SYSxD WS3h1 /\ Z*j\-\ h*ad qWSZV* Z*+dW* ]\]dWq`Z\abT ]TaWq b\-\E qV Z* T4/,\ 5<85 `\Vd +`Sb*ZanV* V\`\WT,anV* `\/SZ* ]\ab*O ,SW* ]`SV`*j1Zd qWSZVd d a,\2Yd ]*W*gTD n\-\/ZT `T4/,qZd qWSZVd 4Z*pbn ]\ gTO W\Yd a,TbTD ı k\`\Vd ]T/ h*a a,qbVd,*Zn ]\]Sb Z* a]`*,3ZT hS jbdhZT /1`1,* Z1 4Y1Zjd2bnaqD ,bTYE aV*Z/SZ*,anVT Z*O aV1WnZT Y*WpZVS /*pbn +14Y\,Z1 P ,SV*`O +d,*Z1 Z* V*Y1ZT P a,T/h1ZZqE k\ `T4/,qZ* qWSZV* Y*2 Z1f`SabSqZanV1 ]\f\/31ZZqD

ı ) ıı 6>55

\4]\,T/T \h1,S/gT, ˙T4Z*yb1an 4 ]1`jSf dab ]`\ 41YW1b`da T gdZ*YT , )]\ZT^ b* ]`\ ]\hdbbq bSfE fb\ ]1`13S, g1 3*fTbbqD , JIJI PRESS/AFP/Getty Images

G) ( 55 +1`14Zq 6>55 `\VdE \ 58B8:E , )]\ZT^ ab*,aq ]\bd3ZSy 41YO W1b`daD 1 +d, \/SZ 4 h\bS`n\f Z*yaSWnO ZTjSf 41YW1b`daT,E ]`\ qVT ,T/\Y\ Tab\O `T^D ]`ShSZ1Z1 ZSY ,1WSh14Z1 gdZ*YT T ]\/*WnjT ]\jb\,fS k1 ,]`\/\,3 bS3O ZT, b`SY*WS Wp/1y d ab`*fdD WS4nV\ 6> >>> Wp/1y 4*-SZdW\ *+\ ]`\]*W\ +14O ,TabSD /Z*V bSaqhT ]1`13SWS g1 WSf\D an `\4]\,T/T /1V\-\ 4 ZSfD */*pVT 4 /`d3SZ\p *`dYT +dWS d a1O +1 ,/\Y* , ıaTZ\Y*VT L]`1e1Vbd`* Tq-TMD

58

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

*]b\Y ,\ZS ]\hdWS -d`VTbE T ^fZTy +d/SO Z\V ]\h*W\ aSWnZ\ b`qabSD w S ,S+T-WS Z* ,dWSgp T 4*,Y1`WS ,T/ 3*fdB 41YWp ,V`S,*WS b`TkSZSEP `\4]\,T/*2 */*pO VTDP *j +d/SZ\V fSb*W\ ,4*/ T ,]1`1/E * ,T/ abTZ 4/TyY*WSaq fY*`S ]SWdxD ˚]Tg1Zb` 41YW1b`dad +d, 4* 56= VTW\Y1b`T, ,T/ d4+1`133q Tq-TD dZ*YT 4`dyZd,*W\ :;> VTW\Y1b`T, bSf\\V1*ZanV\-\ d4+1`13O *`dYT T */*pVT

VSf g1Zb`*fD ıZjSf ,4qWS /\ a1+1 `\/ShT *+\ /`d4TD Ë™1aqbVS bSaqh Wp/1y 4*-SZdWS *+\ 4*4Z*WS b`*,YD SaqhT bTW b*V T Z1 4Z*yjWSD

TWn ,b`*bS

3q )]\ZT^D /1qVSf YTagqf ]\+WS4d adO jT f,SWT aq-*WS 59 Y1b`T, 4*,,SjVSD \O ZS ]\4YS,*WS Y\WSE f,SW1`T4S b* +1`1-S `Th\V T 4*yjWS ,-WS+ \ab`\,* ]\/1Vd/S Z* 8> VTW\Y1b`T,D dWS ]\,ZTabp 4ZSk1ZT aSab1YS 1W1VbO `\OE -*4\O T ,\/\]\ab*h*ZZqD dZ*YT 4`dyO Zd,*W\ hS ]\jV\/SW\ 5:> >>> 3SbW\O ,Sf +d/SZVT,E Y*-*4SZT, b* ]T/]`S2Yab,D ]1,ZSy ]1`T\/ *3 88> >>> ]\ab`*3/*O WSf 3SW\ d ]`S+WS4Z\ 69>> bSYh*a\,Sf ]`SbdWV*fE qVO\b d jV\W*f b* -`\Y*/anO

T/ gdZ*YT 4*-SZdW\ Z*+*-*b\ +TWnj1 Wp/1yE ZT3 ,T/ 41YW1b`dadD •\TbTE qVSy 3S, d YTabT TVd/41ZO *V*b* L]`1e1VbdO `* ı,*b1ME ,T/`*4d 4+*-Zd,E k\ ]TaWq 41YO W1b`dad ,SZSVZ1 gdZ*YTD TZ ,T/,T, +*bnO VT, /\ dV`Sbbq T ]Tj\, ]1`1,T`SbSE hS ,a1 /\+`1 , adaT/T,D d`+dphSan ]`\ +*bnVT,E •\TbT 4 /`d3SZ\p *gdV\ ,S`TjSWS ]\O ,1`ZdbSan /\ ZSfE *W1 ]\hdWS ]\]1`1O /31ZZq ]`\ gdZ*YTD \ZS ]\+T-WS /\ TZj\-\ dV`SbbqE ]`\b1 Z1 4Y\-WS d,TybS /\ +d/SZVdE +\ ,fT/ 4*O ,*WSW\ dW*YV*YSD 3 \an ]\/`d33q ]\O +*hSW\E k\ Z* ZSf adZ1 h\`Z* +d/T,Wq YTag1,\^ ]SW\`*YSD w TV*yY\Ix P 4*V`SO h*W* *gdV\D Ë›`1jb\p ,\ZS /\+T-WS /\ jVTWnZ\O -\ ]\/,T`Gq Z* d4,SjjTD Ë›,T/bS ]\/`d3O 3q +*hSW\E qV f,SWq 4YSW* ,ap ^fZp \V\WSgpD b\an V`Sh*,B w Ty +d/SZ\V 4Z\aSbnIx dZ*YT 4`dyZd,*W\ Y*y31 b`S h,1`bT TVd/41ZO *V*bS T 4*+`*W\ +*bnVT, •\TbTD *bnV* b*V T Z1 4Z*yjWSE * bTW\ Y*b1`T 4Z*yjWS ]T4ZTj1D \`d ]`*gp,*, Z* e*+`SgT , ]`S+1`13O Z\Yd YTabT ıaTZ\Y*VTD TaWq 41YW1b`dad ,TZ Z1-*yZ\ ,aV\hS, d Y*jSZdE k\+ /TaO b*bSaq +14]1hZ\-\ YTagqD \`d a]\ZdVdO ,*, TZjSf bTV*bS ,T/ gdZ*YTE qV1E Z* y\O -\ /dYVdE Y*W\ Z1,/\,4T ]`SybSD w) ,S`djS, /\ a,\-\ /\YdE qVSy ab\q, Z* d4,SjjTD /Z*V Z* /\`\4T db,\`S,O aq 4*b\`EP `\4]\,T/*2 \O `dDP \ `*/T\ ]\,T/\YSWSE k\ gdZ*YT /\aq-W\ adaT/O Zn\-\ YTab*E b\3 q ,T/V`S, ,TVZ\ Y*jSZSE *+S ,SWT4O bS 4 Z1^E qVk\ Z*/Ty/1 f,SWqD 14*+*`\Y Z* Y1O Z1 ,31 Z*ad,*W*an h\`Z* •\TbT y *gdV\

\Y* L dVdaTY*M TVd/41ZO *V*b* Lı,*b1M

*Y*^aT TVd/41ZO *V*b* ıaTZ\Y*VT TZ*YTO *Z`TVd \Y*

ı)

) ıaTZ\Y*VT L Tq-TM

b\YZ* ab*ZgTq d dVdaTYT

ı

˚+TZ* TWT*W ,T/VT, -\,S

*Y*^aT Lı,*b1M TZ*YTO *Z`TVd L Tq-TM

/,\Y1b`\,* abTZ* ,\/SD *jSZS a]1`1/d ,T/VSZdW\ Z* Y\pE T Z*a daTf ]\Z1aW\ ,-WS+ adjTD #\yZ\ q ,S+`*,aq 4 Y*jSZSE qV Y1Z1 ]T/f\]S, Y*aWqZSabSy aY1`/phSy ]\bTVD ) \]SZS,aq , *,b\Y*yab1`ZTE /1 af\]S,aq 4* af\/S T ]T/Zq,aq Z* /`d-Sy ]\,1`fD 1ZT ,/*W\O aq ,Sbq-ZdbS k1 b`n\f Wp/1yD *W\ fb\ ]1`13S, Z*bSaV ,\/S T f\W\/ZdE aZT3Zd ZThD S Z1 Y\-WS /\]\Y\-bS ,aTYE fb\ ,\O W*, ]`\ ]\`qbdZ\VxD

1`1/ 41YW1b`da\Y T/\`T \`d 4 *Y*^aT L]`1e1Vbd`* ı,*b1M ,T/,T/d,*W* /T/daq T +*+dapD \Z* k\O yZ\ 4*VTZhSW* jV\Wd T ]\V*4d,*W* *b1aO b*b /T/da1,TE qVSy ,31 /1qVSy h*a Z1 YT- f\/SbSD TZ ]`\hSb*, *b1ab*b d-\W\a T ]\f,*WS, T/\`T 4* da]TfSD 1`14 ]Gqbn /ZT, ]TaWq b*V\-\ ]`S2YZ\-\ a]TWVd,*ZO Zq ab*,aq 41YW1b`daD \qhSan gdZ*YTE T/\`T b* ^^ Y*bS (V\ +W*-*WS ab*`1ZnVSf ]TbS /\ af\,Sk*D W1 /T/dan aV*4*,B w) Z1 ]T/dD dZ*O YT ZTV\WS Z1 /\f\/SW\ b*V /*W1V\xD \ZS Z*Y*-*WSaq ,SZ1abS y\-\ 4 /\YdE ]`\b1 Z1 Y\-WS ]T/ZqbS T ]TjWS 4* /\]\Y\-\pD * b\y h*a f,SWq ,31 /\aq-W* +1`1O -*D w V\`Tj1I bTV*yb1Ix P V`Sh*WS Wp/S 4 ]\+WS4nO (V\ b* T/\`T V\-\ ]*-\`+*D dZ*YT ]\O -WSZ*W\ \/SZ +d/SZ\V 4* TZjSYD \,Tb`q `\4`S,*, ,T/h*y/djO ZSy V`SV T/\`TB w˙T/dI *+\Ix T4ZTj1 4Z*yjWS bTW\ ^^ /T/daqE * +*+dap ,T/Z*yO bS Z1 ,/*W\aqD

˙\]\Y\-* ]\ab`*3/*WSY )]\ZanVSy d`q/ ,T/`*4d Y\+TWT4d,*, ]\313ZSVT,E ]\WTgTp T aSWS a*Y\\+\`\O ZS 4 daT2^ V`*^ZSD ˛* V\`\bVSy h*a d `qbdO ,*WnZ\O]\jdV\,Sf `\+\b*f +`*W\ dh*abn ]\Z*/ 57> >>> \aT+D ˛-\/\Y /\]\Y\-* Z*/TO

*jSZ*E qV\p ^f*, \`d

yjW* b13 4 TZjSf V`*^Z b* YT3Z*`\/O ZSf \`-*ZT4*gTyD * YTag1 WSf* ]`S+dWS /1aqbVS `qbd,*WnZSf 4*-\ZT, T Y1/]`*O gT,ZSVSD \ZS jdV*WS ,gTWTWSfE Z*/*O ,*WS Y1/ShZd /\]\Y\-d T `\4+S`*WS 4*O ,*WSD T4ZT \`-*ZT4*gT^ ]\a]TjSWS Z* ]\`qO bdZ\V a,\^Y hW1Z*YD 1 +dWS ,SZqbV\Y T ,T/VS -\,SD /`*4d 3 ]TaWq 41YW1b`dO ad y gdZ*YT , ]GqbZSgp ]\]\Wd/ZT ,T/VS ]\h*WS 4Gqa\,d,*bSE hS ,aT ^fZT \/Z\,T`gT d +14]1gTD `\b1 h1`14 ,T/adbZTabn 1W1VbO `SVSE b1W1e\ZZ\-\ 4,Gq4Vd T 4*,*WS Z* /\O `\-*f ]`\ +*-*bn\f 4 ZSf +dW\ /d31 ,*3O V\ /T4Z*bSaqD \-\ 3*fWS,\-\ /Zq *V*pVTE \/SZ 4T ab*`TyjSZ 4+\`d ,T/VT, -\,S , YTabT \Y* L]`1O e1Vbd`* dVdaTY*ME 4YTaV\Zb*Vbd,*bSaq WSj1 4 VTWnV\Y* `\/SZ*YSD w *O abd]Z\-\ /Zq Z* a,Tb*ZO Vd q ,S`djS, Z* ]\jdO VS TZjSfEP V*31 ,TZDP ) *V*pVT ,S^f*, Y*jSZ\pE * ]\bTY Tj\, ]TjVS T ]\,1`Zd,aq *3 d,1h1`TD ]\jdV*f \/Z\,T`gT, q \+TO yj\, 6> YTagnE d b\Yd hSaWT ]`SbdWVS /Wq ]\ab`*3/*WSfD \WS q 4Z*yj\, ^fE b\ hSO b*, ^Y ,T`jT 4 T+WT^ T Y\WS,aq 4 ZSYSxD `\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55 5;

V*YS /\-\`S V\W1a*YSD ZTy b13 +d, b`d]xD pZ/4T `\4jdV*, a,\^f \/Z\,T`gT, d ]`SbdWV*f T ,T/hd, ,1WSV1 ]\W1-j1ZZqD TZ V*31B w˛dab`T,jSan 4 ZSYSE q da,TO /\YS,E Z*aVTWnVS ,\ZS Y1ZT +WS4nVTxD

w *V j,S/V\Ix ˙,T Y\W\/T 3TZVSE ,T/VS -\,SE qVSf 4,*bS (^ b* T/4dVTE 3SWS ]\`q/ d YTabT TZ*YTO *Z`TVd L]`1e1Vbd`* Tq-TMD TaO Wq 41YW1b`dad ,\ZS ,S+T-WS Z* ,dWSgp T ]\+*hSWS \/Z* \/ZdD ˝TZVS ]\a]TjSWS

ı• ıı dZ*YT ]\jV\/SW\ `1*Vb\O `S Z* *b\YZTy 1W1Vb`\ab*ZO gT^ w dVdaTY*O5xD q b`S,\3O Z* 4,TabV* \+W1bTW* ,1an a,TbD */ )]\ZT2p b* TZjSYS V`*^Z*YS Z*,SaW* `*/T*gTyZ* 4*-`\4*D SaqhT Wp/1y +dW\ 1,*Vdy\,*Z\E k\+ 4*fSabSbS ^f ,T/ aY1`b1WnZSf /\4 `*/TO *gT^D w *j +d/SZ\V +d, ]\`q/ 4 *b\YZ\p ab*ZgT2pEP `\4O ]\,T/*2 1-dYTDP 1`14 /1Zn ]TaWq 41YW1b`dad Z*Y ]\,T/\YSWS ]`\ *,*`Tp Z* ab*ZgT^ T aV*4*WS Z1-*yZ\ ]\VSZdbS gp 4\ZdxD ı^ a1ab`* *gdYT ]`S-*/d2B w ]\,Tb`T V`d3WqWS ,1`b\Wn\bSE ,SWS aS`1ZS T 4,T/daTWn WdZ*, Z*O V*4 ]`\ 1,*Vd*gTpxD ]`\O /\,3 Z*abd]ZSf bS3ZT, a1abO `S 3SWS d = `T4ZSf YTagqfD ˛-\/\Y ^Y /\4,\WSWS ]\,1`O ZdbSan /\/\Yd WSj1 Z* /,T -\/SZSE *+S 4*+`*bS /1qVT `1hTD

5<

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

TV*V\E qVTy ,31 4* :> `\VT,E +dW* , *YT2 L]`1O e1Vbd`* dVdaTY*MD w \WS ab*,aq 41YW1b`daEP `\4]\O ,T/*2 3TZV*EP q ]\+T-W* /\ af\,Sk*D S 4 aSZ\Y b* /\ZnV\p ]`\,1WS b*Y +14a\ZZd ZThE */31 ]\jb\,O fS ]\,b\`p,*WSaq 4Z\,d T 4Z\,dD an\YTy `*ZVd Z*Y Z*V*4*WS Z1-*yZ\

^f*bS /\ af\,Sk* , TZj\Yd YTabTD * /\`\-*f +dWS 4*b\`SE b\3 YS ]`S^f*WS /\ ,S4Z*h1O Z\-\ YTagq \ b`1bTy ]\]\Wd/O ZTD *Y YS /T4Z*WSaq ]`\ ,S+df Z* *b\YZTy ab*ZgT^D ) /dY*W*E k\ YS Z14*+*`\Y ]\,1`Z1Y\an /\/\YdE b\Yd ZTh\-\ 4 a\+\p Z1 ,4qW*xD TV*V\ b* ^^ aTYGq ]1`1^3/3*O WS 4 YTagq Z* YTag1E *3 ]\VS Z1 4Z*yjWS ]\Y1jV*ZZq /*W1V\ ,T/ /\YdD

Photo by DigitalGlobe via Getty Images )

pZ/4T 4 ıaTZ\Y*VT `\4O ]\,T/*2B w S ab,\`SWS -`d]S /Wq ]\jdVd \/Z\O ,T`gT,D \WS YS ]`S+dWS , 4\Zd abSfTyZ\-\ WSf*E b\ +dWS ]`\ab\ j\V\,*ZTD pZ/4T *jSZS ,SaTWS Z* 1W1VbO `ShZSf ab\,]*fE +d/SZVS ab\qWS \/SZ Z* \/Z\YdE * -\`S aYTbbq +dWS ,SkT 4* a*YT +d/SZVSD * /*fd \/ZT2^ Y*jSO ZS YS ]\+*hSWS Y1`b,1 bTW\D q WpO /SZ*E \h1,S/Z\E Z1 ]1`13SW* f\W\/Z\^ Z\hTD ıZj* Y*jSZ* ,SaTW* YT3 +d/SZO

Z* d4,SjjqD 1 YSZdW\ y /1aqbS f,SWSZE qV d ZSf Z* \h*f ,1WSVT f,SWT 4YSO WS gTW1 YTab\ `*4\Y 4 ^fZTO YS /\Y*YSD ]`SbdWVd (^ b* TO T/4dVT /4dVT 4dab`TWS 4Z*y\YSf b* (^ ,T/VT,E T ,aT `*4\Y ]\Y\O WSWSaqD *abd]Z\-\ `*ZVd ,T/VS 4 ^fZn\-\ b* adaT/O ZTf 4+\`T, ]1`1yjWS -\`d T ]`SZ1aWS ^3d b* ,a1 Z1O \+fT/Z1D (^ b* T/4dVT ,SO -dVZdWSB w S 4Z*WSE k\ T/1f*`d ,S ]`Sy/1b1E *W1 k\+ b*V j,S/V\Ix

`SbdW\V /Wq ]\ab`*3/*WSf ,T/,T/*, T/1f*`dE \/SZ 4T ab*`TyjSZ 4+\`d ,T/O VT, -\,S , \Y1D TZ `\4]\,T/*2B w ap ZTh q Z*Y*-*,aq ,T/jdV*bS Z*jSf /`dO 4T,E qVT 3SWS ,4/\,3 d4+1`133qD *`1jO bT \ 8Oy `*ZVd q /T4Z*,aqE k\ /1fb\ 4Z*yO j\, ]`SbdW\V d jV\WTD \/T \ ;Oy -\/SZT +WS4nV\ /1aqbS \aT+ 4T+`*WSaqE k\+ ]`SO -\bd,*bS `Sa\,T VdWnVSD `\2 4 Z*a ]\^f*O WS Y*jSZ\p ,T/,14bS ^3dD TWnjTabn /\O `T- +dWS Z1]`\fT/ZSYSE T YS /Tab*WSaq /\ jV\WS 4 ,1WSVSYS b`d/Z\k*YSD *,Tbn bTE fb\ ,b`*bS, a,\^ /\YT,VSE ]WThO\O]WTh 4 Z*YS /\]\Y*-*WS TZjSYxD

d`+\b* ]`\ /df\,ZT ]\b`1+S ,T/VS -\,S `1-dWq`Z\ 4+S`*pbnaq /Wq ,S,h1ZZq T+WT^D ˙1qVT 4+\`SE qVO\b d TVd/41ZO *V*bTE ]`\,\/qbn 4T+`*ZZq ]\ ]GqbZSgqfD gn\Yd YTabT gdZ*YT 4`dyO Zd,*W\ ˛*W *`ab,* P YTag1 ]\VW\ZTZZq ,T/VT,D /SZ ,T/\V 4*]`\]\Zd,*, ,a1 3 b*VS ]`\,1abS 4T+`*ZZqD S`TjSWS \+`*bS +d/SZ\VE V\b`Sy Z1 b*V aSWnZ\ ]\ab`*3O /*,E T ]\,T/\YSWS TZjSf hW1ZT, 4+\`dD ˚W1Vb`SVS Z1 +dW\E *W1 4Z*yj\,aq -1O Z1`*b\`D `SyjW\ 5: \aT+D \W\/Sy )adO pVTE qVSy ,b`*bS, /\YT,VdE V*31B w S ]W*V*WS ,T/ `*/\abTE +\ Y*WS Z*yV`*kSy ]`SbdW\VxD T/1V\ ]`S-*/d2B w˛T+`*ZZq

h*ab\ ]1`1`S,*W\aq h1`14 aSWnZT ]\jb\,O fSE *W1 , g1y h*aE V\WS YS +dWS `*4\YE q 4*+dW* ]`\ ,aT ab`*fS T b`S,\-SxD T/b\/T 4+T` `1-dWq`Z\ ]`\,\/Sbn daT 4T+`*ZZqD 1`14 /,* /ZTE d Z1/TWpE +dW\ ,S-\W\j1Z\ ]`\Y\,d Z* b1Yd w a1a,TbZ2 +`*bab,\ ,`qb\,*Z1 ,T/ WSf*xD

*/*ZZq /\]\Y\-S 14*+*`\Y `T4ZT d`q/\,T \`-*ZT4*gT^ ]\O h*WS Z*/*,*bS /\]\Y\-d bSYE fb\ ]\O ab`*3/*,D TWT*W ,T/VT, -\,S , ˚+TZT Z1]\/*WTV \VT\ b*V\3 aVW*, ]W*Z /\]\O Y\-SD 31 d ad+\bdE /1Zn ]TaWq 41YW1b`dO adE 4\Z* abSfTyZ\-\ WSf* +dW* `\4/TW1Z* Z* b`S h*abSZSD , ]\Z1/TW\VE h1`14 b`S /ZT ]TaWq 41YW1b`dadE ]`1/ab*,ZSVS eTO WT*Wd ,T/,T/*WS gT b1`Sb\`T^D qbT,ZT `\+\bS b`S,*WS k1 ]`\bq-\Y YTaqgT,D ,T/VS 31`b,d,*WS /Wq ]\ab`*3O /*WSf ^3d T Z1\+fT/ZT `1hTD ]1,ZSy ]1`TO \/ \/Z\h*aZ\ /TqW\ 7 g1Zb`S /\]\Y\-S T k1 65 ]dZVbE /1 Y\3Z* +dW\ \b`SY*bS ,a1 Z1\+fT/Z1D `\bq-\Y ]1`jSf /,\f YTO aqgT, a\bZT /\+`\,\WngT, `\4/*WS +TWnj1 qV 69> b\ZZ ^3TE \/q-d b* TZjSf `1h1yD SO Y*W\ ,T/VT, /TWSWSaq \b`SY*ZSY 4 Wp/nO YSE qVT Z1 +dWS ^fZTYS \/Z\,T`gqYSD ,T/VS -\,S 4T 4+\`T, d TVd/41ZO *V*bT T adaT/Zn\Yd edZ*b\ Z*/*pbn YTag1,SY 3Sb1WqY /df\,Zd ]T/b`SYVd d a,\2Yd ,T/Z\,W1Z\Yd ˛*WT *`ab,*D *V*

˛*,4qb* ]`*gq /\+`\,\WngT,

˝ ı ˛-*/*ZSy `*ZTj1 •\TbT 4 TVd/41ZO *V*bSE V\b`Sy ,b`*bS, Y*yO 31 ,a1 a,\2 Y*yZ\E V*31B w) Z* ,W*aZ\Yd /\a,T/T ]1`1V\Z*,aqE k\ Y*b1`T*WnZT `1hT Z1 -*`*Zbdpbn +14]1VSxD \/T+Zd /dYVd k1 4/*,Z* ]\/TWqWS \3T aWd3Sb1WTE 4\V`1Y* ]\aWT/\,ZSVS ıada*D \ZS Z*,hSWSaq ,T/ Zn\-\ ,*3WS,\-\ d`\Vd P \3* W*aV* b* y\-\ +W*-\aW\,1ZZq Z*+*-*b\ gTZZTjT 4* +d/nOqV1 Y*yZ\ L *b,Tq :B5=E 6>E 77E 78MD an TZjSy ,*3WS,Sy d`\VB V\WS /*pbnaq ]\]1`1/31ZZqE b`1+* /TqbSD T/ gn\-\ 4*W13Sbn Z*j1 3SbbqD )]\ZT^ Wp/SE V\b`T ,T/`*4d bTV*WS Z* d4,SjjqE Z1`T/V\ `qbd,*WS a\+T 3SbbqD

˛*W *`ab,* , TVd/41ZO *V*bT ]TaWq gdZ*YT

ı˙ ı˙ı ˙ ı 7>E 75

T/+d/\,d 4*,1`j1Z\

5D * \/Z\Yd Y*WpZVd *Z-1W Y*2 jTabn V`SWE * Z* /`d-\Yd P h\bS`SD 6D ]`*,* *Z-1W b`SY*2 , `dV*f kS]gTE * 4WT,* P Y1hD 7D * \/Z\Yd Y*WpZVd ,d-TWO Wq b\`V*2bnaq -d+ ıa*^E Z* /`d-\Yd P y\-\ `dVSD 8D D 9D 75 9>>D :D D

`S YTaqgT ]\ b\Yd

]T/b`SYV* /\]\Y*-*2 +*-*bn\Y ]\ab`*3O /*WSY ]\,1`ZdbSan /\ Z\`Y*WnZ\-\ 3SbO bq T 4*WTVd,*bS 1Y\gTyZT `*ZSE qVSf 4*,/*WS 41YW1b`da b* gdZ*YTD 4\ZT abSfTyZ\-\ WSf* ]`\3S,*W\ ]\Z*/ 58 >>> ,T/VT, -\,SD ˛ ZSf 56 \aT+ 4*-SZdW\E 6 4ZSVWS +14,TabSD *-*b\ ,T/VT, -\,SE qVT ]1`13SWS d,1an 3*f abSfTyZ\-\ WSf*E Y\3dbn aV*O 4*bS b1 a*Y1E k\ y \/Z* aTYGqB w \WS YS bTV*WSE b\ V\31Z Y*, ]`S a\+T WSj1 \/Zd adYVdD W1 \/Z\,T`gT ]\/+*WS ]`\ ,aT Z*O jT ]\b`1+SxD )V hd/\,\E k\ aWd3Sb1WT ]`*,/S,\-\ \-* -\,S \+G2/Z*ZT d ,a1aO ,TbZ2 +`*bab,\E ]`\ V\b`1 -\,\`S, ıada b* y\-\ *]\ab\WSI T d4S Z1 4`dyZd2 3\/Z1 gdZ*YT hS +d/nOqV1 TZj1 abSfTyZ1 WSf\ Lı,*Z* 57B78E 79C ,`1^, 5>B68E 69C 5 1bO `* 9B=MD

• ˚ TV*`*-d*

•\-\ /\]SbWS,Sy `\4dY /\aT ,`*3*2 ı ˙ ˚ ˚

˘ )V\p Wp/SZ\p ,S f\bTWS + 4*WSjSbSan d ]*YGqbT TZjSfH )V* /dYV* ]`Sy/1 ^Y Z* `\4dY ]`S 4-*/gT ]`\ ,*aH *-*b\ fb\ ]`*-O Z1 /\aq-bS da]Tfd , Z*dgTE ]\WTbSgTE a]\`bT b* YSab1gb,TE *+S 4*WSjSbS ]TaWq a1+1 aWT/D k\E V\WS ]`\ ,*a ]*YGqb*WS + 4*,/qVS ,*jSY 4*]Sb*ZZqYH Gqba\b `\VT, b\Yd , 1Zb`*WnZTy Y1`SgT 3S, h\W\,TVE qVSy ab*,S, -WS+\VT 4*]Sb*ZO ZqD 1y h\W\,TV +d, ,\3/1Y YTag1,\-\ ]W1O Y1ZTE T 4,*WS y\-\ TV*`*\D T/ gn\-\ TY1ZTE \h1,S/Z\E ]\f\/Sbn Z*4,* w TV*`*-d*xE qV\p ]\4Z*h*pbn y\-\ ]W1YGqE V`*^ZdE /1 ,TZ 3S,E T ,1WSV1 \41`\D W1YGq TV*`*\ 3SW\ Z* aYd4T 41YWT YT3 SfSY \V1*Z\Y b* ,1WSh14ZSY \41`\Y TO V*`*-d*D 1,/\,4T ]TaWq b\-\E qV \WdY+ ,T/V`S, \,Sy ,TbE Ta]*ZgT ,S`djSWS `\4,T/d,*bS gp b1`Sb\`TpD *]Tb*Z TWn

\Za*W1a ˙*,TW* ]\,T, a,\^ 4*-\ZS Z* ]T,ZTh ,T/ \ab*O SVS T 5967 `\Vd ZD 1D abd]S, Z* 41YWp TV*`*\D q,Tbn f,SWp,*ZZq /\aWT/ZSVT,E qVT ]`\+SO `*WSaq Z1,T/\YSYS jWqf*YSD \ZSE Y*+dbnE /d31 4`*/TWSE 4dab`T,jS ,\3/q TV*`*\D dO +TWngT ,Sq,SWS /\ Ta]*ZgT, Z*/4,Sh*yZd k1/`TabnE /*WS ^Y hSY*W\ ]\/*`dZVT,E d b\Yd hSaWT +*-*b\ 4\W\b*D #1/`Tabn T /\aT 4*WSj*2bnaq f*`*Vb1`Z\p \a\+WS,Tabp ZTO V*`*-d*ZanV\^ VdWnbd`SD TV*`*\ ]`*-Zd, \b`SY*bS ,T/]\,T/T Z* 4*O ]Sb*ZZqE ]`\ qVT ,31 /\,-\ `\4/dYd,*,D V\WS ]`SyjWS Ta]*ZgTE d Zn\-\ ,SZSVWS

k1 TZjT 4*]Sb*ZZqD an ]`\ k\E 4-T/Z\ 4 4*O ]Sa*YSE 4`\+W1ZSYS , bT h*aSE TV*`*\ 4*]Sb*, V*]Tb*Z* \Za*W1a*B

w S bS hd, ]`\ ,1WSVSy ]\b\]E qVSy 4ZSO kS, Wp/1y T b,*`SZH S Z*jW1 \- 4Z\,d Z* 41YWp ]\b\]H #\ ab*2bnaq ]TaWq aY1`O bTH )V `df*pbnaq a\Zg1E YTaqgn b* 4\`TH * h\Yd ,\ZS b`SY*pbnaqH )V /*W1V\ /\ ZSfH

\WS a\Zg1E YTaqgn b* 4\`T ]`S]SZqbn a,TbSO bSH ˛,T/VS +1`1bnaq ,Tb1`H \Yd 2 f\W\/ T a]1V*E a,TbW\ T b1Y`q,*H \Yd ]`\bq-\Y `\Vd /ZT +d,*pbn `T4Z\^ /\,3SZSHx 14dY\,Z\E TV*`*\ ]`*-Zd, +TWnj1 4Z*bS ]`\ Z*,V\WSjZTy a,TbE T y\-\ 4*]Sb*ZZq ,Sq,O WqpbnE d k\ ,TZ ,T`S,D *-*bn\f Wp/1y an\-\O /ZT bd`+dpbn ]\/T+ZT ]Sb*ZZqD TV*,\E k\ TV*`*\ b* y\-\ ]W1YGq 4Z*WS ]`\ ]\b\]E qVSy b*V\3 4-*/d2bnaq , T+WT^ L dbbq ;B5;P5=MD 1`1/ ]W1Y1ZT TV*`*\ +d, ]\jS`1ZSy a]T`SbS4Y b* Wp/anVT 31`b,\]`SZ\j1ZZqE ]`\b1 ,\3/n ]1`1yY*,aq 4,Sh*qYS b* ]\O ,1/TZV\p y\-\ Wp/1yD ˛*]Sb*ZZq TV*`*\ a,T/h*bnE k\ V\3Z* Wp/SZ* Z*/TW1Z* adYO WTZZqYD `\ g1 b*V\3 ]Sa*, *]\ab\W *,O W\B wıfZ2 adYWTZZq a,T/hSbn `*4\Y 4 ZSYS P b\/T ^fZT /dYVS 4,SZd,*hdpbn ^f *+\ 3 ,S]`*,/\,dpbnx L SYWqZ 6B58E 59MD n\-\/ZT ]\+WS4d YTagqE /1E qV ,,*3*pbnE TV*`*\ ,]1`j1 4dab`T, Ta]*ZgT,E ,\3/p ]\ab*,SWS ]*YGqbZSVD 1y /\]SbWS,Sy h\W\O ,TVE qVSy -WS+\V\ `\4/dYd,*, ]`\ 3Sbbq b* Z*,V\WSjZTy a,TbEP ]`SVW*/ /Wq Z*a L SYWqZ 5B6>MD

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55 65

T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,* )V ,\Z* ab*W* ]\]dWq`Z\p

Art Resource, NY )

5:55

& `\Vd , Z-WT^ ,T/+dW\aq hSY*W\ a,qbVd,*Zn Z* h1abn 8>>O^ `ThZSgT ,SO /*ZZq w T+WT^ V\`\Wq )V\,*xE ,T/\Y\^ b13 qV w ,b\`S4\,*Z* ,1`aTqxE b\+b\ \eTgTyO Z\ af,*W1ZSy ]1`1VW*/D Ty ,S4Z*hZTy /*bT ]`Sa,qbSWS hSY*W\ `*/T\O T b1W1]`\-`*YE * b*V\3 V\Ze1`1ZgTyE W1VgTy b* a1YTZ*`T,D

`SZg *`Wn4 ,4q, ]`\,T/ d ,j*Z\,d,*ZO ZT \+G2Vb* Z*gT\Z*WnZ\^ a]*/kSZSE V\b`Sy Z\aSbn TYGq )V\,* IE V\`\Wq Z-WT^D ˛*,/qO VS h\Yd w T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*xE ,S/*Z* d b`*,ZT 5:55 `\VdE 4Z*yjW* ,T/-dV d a1`gqf *Z-W\Y\,ZSf hSb*hT,H

1`1VW*/*gnV* ]`*gq Z*+S`*2 \+1`bT,

`S+WS4Z\ , a1`1/SZT XVI ab\WTbbq d ,O `\]T ]\h*W* 4`\ab*bS 3*-* /\ +T+WTyZSf 4Z*ZnD ˙,\Y* ab\WTbbqYS `*ZTj1E d 57<6 `\O gTE ˙3\Z ^VWTe 4+d/S, *]1bSb *Z-W\Y\,O ZSf Wp/1yE ]1`1VW*,jS T+WTp 4 W*bSZanO V\^D ]`\/\,3 ]\/*WnjSf /,\f ab\WTbn y\-\ ]\aWT/\,ZSVSE W\W*`/SE `\4]\,ap/3dO ,*WS `dV\]SaZT V\]T^ gn\-\ ]1`1VW*/d ]\ ,aTy Z-WT^D *abd]Z\p ,Tf\p d ]\jS`1ZZT +T+WTyZSf 4Z*Zn ab*, \,Sy ˛*,Tb TWnqY* SZ/*WqD h1ZSy ]1`1VW*, y\-\ 4 -`1gnV\^ Z* *Z-WTyO anVd /\ 5969 `\VdD 1,/\,4T ]TaWq gn\-\E 66

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

d 5979OYdE *yW4 \,1`/1yW ]T/-\bd,*, ]1O `1VW*/ ]\,Z\^ T+WT^D ˛* `TV /\ gn\-\ 1Z`Tf VIII `\4T`,*, ab\adZVS 4 V*b\WSgnV\p g1`VO ,\p T \-\W\aS, a1+1 -\W\,\p *Z-WTV*ZanV\^ g1`V,SD `*-ZdhS 4YTgZSbS a,\2 ab*Z\,SO k1E V\`\Wn 4`\+S, ab`*b1-ThZSy V`\VB 4*Y\O ,S, ]1`1VW*/ T+WT^ Z* *Z-WTyanVdD 1`1O VW*/ \b`SY*, Z*4,d w 1WSV* T+WTqxD q -`\YT4/V* VZS-* +dW* Z*/`dV\,*Z* aVW*/O ZSY -\bShZSY ]SanY\Y d 597= `\gTD

d`Sb*ZS b* TZjT ]`\b1ab*ZbanVT ,S-Z*ZO gT 4 gTW\^ ,`\]S \a1WSWSan d ˝1Z1,T L",1yg*`TqMD 59:> `\gT 4Gq,SW*an w˝1O Z1,anV* T+WTqx P ]1`j* *Z-WTyanV* T+O WTqE , qVTy `\4/TWS +dWS ]\/TW1ZT Z* ,T`jTE * j`Seb +d, W1-VSY /Wq hSb*ZZqD 1 ,SO /*ZZq ]`S,14WS /\ Z-WT^E T ,\Z\ j,S/O V\ Z*+dW\ ]\]dWq`Z\abTD ˛-\/\YE d 59;:OYdE w˝1Z1,anVd T+WTpx Z*/`dVd,*WS T , Z-O WT^D `SYTbVS Z* ^^ ]\Wqf T V*`bS /\]\O Y*-*WS V`*k1 `\4dYTbS b1VabD `\b1 /1O qVT hSb*hT Z1 a]`SyZqWS gp T+WTpE */31 d ]`SYTbV*f V`SbSVd,*W\aq ]*]ab,\D

1]`\ab1 4*,/*ZZq w 1WSV* T+WTqx Z1 Y*W* jS`\V\-\ ,SO 4Z*ZZqE * w˝1Z1,anVd T+WTpx V`SbSVd,*O WS 4* ^^ ]`SYTbVSD \3 ,S`TjSWS ]T/-\bd,*O

w ˚ & • ˙ • ˚ ˚ ˙x 5=>5 `\gT +d, \]d+WTO V\,*ZSy w Y1`SV*ZanVSy ab*Z/*`bZSy ]1`1VW*/xE 4`\+O W1ZSy Z* \aZ\,T w T+WT^ V\`\O Wq )V\,*xD ]1`1/Y\,T /\ Zn\-\ -\,\`SbnaqB w S ]`*-ZdO WS 4+1`1-bS V`*ad T ,S`*4O ZTabn abSWpE 4* qVd a]`*,1/O WS,\ gTZdpbn r ,b\`S4\,*Zd ,1`aTpsxD ı ,a1 3 w Y1`SV*ZO anVSy ab*Z/*`bZSy ]1`1O VW*/x YTabS, Tab\bZd 4YTZdD

˙*WT d ]1`1/Y\,T aV*4*Z\B w TaWq `1b1WnZ\-\ *Z*WT4d *Y1`SV*ZanVT ,h1ZT /TyjWS \/Z\ab*yZ\-\ ,SaZ\,VdE k\ 2,`1yanVSy 4*+\+\ZE 4-T/Z\ 4 qVSY \31 ıYGq Z*/b\ a,qb1E k\+ y\-\ ,SY\,WqbSE +TWnj1 Z1 ]\,SZ1Z ,]WS,*bS Z* *Z-WTyanVSy hS +d/nOqVSy TZjSy ]1`1VW*/ b*`\-\ ˛*,TbdD ıE Z* k*abqE hSaW1ZZT adh*aZT ]1`1VW*/SE 4/TyaZ1ZT YTaT\Z1`*YSE Z1 ]T/]*WS ]T/ ,]WS, gn\-\ 4*+\+\ZdxD

bS Z\,1 ,S/*ZZq T+WT^E 4* \aZ\,d qV\-\ ,4qWS w 1WSVd T+WTpxD ı^ ]1`1-Wq/ /\`dO hSWS 2]SaV\]*Y *Z-WTV*ZanV\^ g1`V,SE T , 59:< `\gT ,SyjW* w ]SaV\]anV* T+WTqx P ,1WSVSy b\Y 4 +*-*bnY* -`*,p`*YSD /Z*V aW\,\ w2]SaV\]anV*x /`*bd,*W\ V*Wn,TZTaO bT,E qVT ,T/VS/*WS `1WT-TyZT bSbdWSD \3 4*-*W\Y , Z-WT^ w ]SaV\]anVd T+WTpx Z1 ]`SyZqWSD 5:>7 `\gT *Z-WTyanVSy b`\Z ]\aT, )VT, I1D TZ 4*/dY*, ab,\`SbS Z\,Sy +T+WTyO ZSy ]1`1VW*/D \`\Wn ,,*3*,E k\ gq T+O WTq Z1 Y*2 YTabSbS 3\/ZSf \+`*4WS,Sf ]`SO YTb\V hS V\Y1Zb*`T,D

\`\Wn )VT, ]\h*, ,bTWp,*bS 4*/dY d 3SbbqD ˛-\/\Y 8; ,h1ZSf 4 gTW\^ V`*^ZSE qVT db,\`SWS jTabn \V`1YSf -`d]E ]T/-\bd,*WS h*abSZS b1VabdD \ adbTE ,\ZS ]1`1-WqZdWS w ]SaV\]anVd T+WTpxE ,SV\`Sab*,jS ]1O `1VW*/S SZ/*Wq T \,1`/1yW*D T ,h1ZT b*V\3 ]\aWd-\,d,*WSaq w˝1Z1,anV\p T+O WT2px T `SY\OV*b\WSgnVSY ]1`1VW*/\Y \O ,\-\ ˛*,TbdE 4`\+W1ZSY 59<6 `\Vd , 1yYaTD 1 )VT, Z*`\/S,aq 59:: `\VdD 59:;OYd +d, V\`\Z\,*O ZSy qV )VT, VIE V\`\Wn "\bW*Z/T^D 5:>7 `\gT ,TZ +d, V\`\Z\,*ZSy qV )VT, IE V\`\Wn Z-WT^E T ,T/b\/T ab*, ]`*,Sb1W1Y \+\f V`*^ZD ˛ 5:>8 `\Vd Z\aS, bSbdW \`\Wn 1WSV\^ `Sb*ZT^D

1 Y\3Z* aV*4*bSE k\ w T+O WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*x ,4*-*WT Z1 YTabSbn \3\-\ TY1ZTE -\,*D \Z\ 2 d h\bS`n\f ,T`j*fB SfT/ :B7C a*W\Y <7B5<C ıa*^ 56B6C 6:B8D `\b1 , w Y1`SO V*ZanV\Yd ab*Z/*`bZ\Yd ]1O `1VW*/Tx 5=>5 `\Vd g1 TYGq ]\,1`ZdWS Z* y\-\ Z*W13Z1 YTag1D gn\Yd ]1`1VW*/T TYGq -\,* ,3S,*2bnaq +WS4nV\ ;>>> `*4T,D

5=>5

*Y Y\Z*`f +d, j*Z\,*ZSY /\aWT/ZSV\Y T+WT^E T aW\,* ]`Sa,qbSB w *y,1WShZTj\Yd T Z*yY\-dbZTj\Yd V\`\WpE )V\,dx P a,T/O h*bnE k\ Z\,Sy ]1`1VW*/ ,Syj\, 4 y\-\ TZTgT*bS,SD Z-WTygT ,,*3*WSE k\ V\`\Wn )VT,E qV -\W\,* *Z-WTV*ZanV\^ g1`V,SE ,SO V\`Sab*, a,\p ,W*/dE k\+ \+G2/Z*bS Z*gTpD

Tb1`*bd`ZSy j1/1,` ˙dfT,ZSgb,\ 4 `*/Tabp ]`SyZqW\ ,T/ V\`\O Wq T+WTpE w]`S4Z*h1Zd /Wq hSb*ZZq , g1`VO ,*fxD W1 hS a]\/\+*W*aq ,\Z* Z*`\/\,TH ]\h*bV\,Ty `\4jS`1ZTy ]1`1/Y\,T /\ T+WT^ ]1`1VW*/*hT ,SaW\,SWS a,\^ ]\+\pO ,*ZZq k\/\ b\-\E qV Wp/S 4`1*-dpbn Z* Z\O ,Sy ]1`1VW*/D ,bTYE *Z-WTygT a]`SyZqWS y\-\ /\+`1E f\h* 4Z*/\+SW\aq k1 7> `\VT,E /\VS gq T+WTq 4*,\p,*W* ^fZT a1`gqE ,SbTaO ZS,jS w˝1Z1,anVd T+WTpxD VZS3gT w T+WTq y *Z-W\a*Va\ZgTx -\O ,\`SbnaqB w * b\y h*a ,\Z* +dW* \eTgTyZ\ af,*W1ZSY ]1`1VW*/\YE \/Z*V a,\2 ,S4Z*ZO Zq 4/\+dW* ,SVWphZ\ 4*,/qVS ,W*aZTy /\O ,1`j1Z\abTx (The Bible and the Anglo-Saxon People)D \an qVSy ,SaZ\,\V 4*]Sa*Z\ d w 1Y+`S/3anVTy Tab\`T^ T+WT^xB wı^ b1Vabd Z*/*,*WS b*V\^ a,qb\abTE Z*h1 g1 +d, -\W\a a*Y\-\ \-*C YTZqbS k\an d r T+WT^ V\`\Wq `\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55 67

˚ ı & ˚ ˙ ) 5=>; `\gT d " Z* 4*Y\,W1ZZq T+WTyZ\-\ T b`*Vb*bZ\-\ b\,*`Sab,* w *`b\,* +*jb*x +dW\ Z*/`dV\,*Z1 a]1gT*WnZ1 ,S/*ZZq w T+WT^ V\`\Wq )V\O ,*xD \Z\ YTabSW\ ,1WSVSy /\/*b\V 4* Z*4,\p w 1`TyanVT /\aWT/31ZZq T+WT^D \aT+ZSV /Wq ,hSb1WT,xD ˛-\/\Y ,T/VS -\,S /`dVd,*WS w T+WTp V\`\Wq )V\,*x Z* ,W*aZSf ,1`ab*b*fD ˙\ 5==6 `\Vd ,\O ZS ,S-\b\,SWS 5 <9< 7:< ]`SYT`ZSVT, gT2^ T+WT^D

ı & • • ˚ ˚ ˙ ˛* \ab*ZZT ]T,ab\`Thhq 4Gq,SW\aq hSY*W\ +T+WTyZSf ]1`1VW*/T,E /1qVT 4 ZSf +*-*bnO Y* Y\,*YSD 1`1/ ZSf \a\+WS,\^ d,*-S 4*aWd-\,d2 w ,qb1 SanY\D 1`1VW*/ Z\,\O -\ a,TbdxD dW\ Z*/`dV\,*Z\ T `\4]\,ap/31O Z\ ]\Z*/ 5;> YTWny\ZT, ]`SYT`ZSVT, gn\-\ ]1`1VW*/d 5>> Y\,*YS LgTW\^ T+WT^ *+\ ^^ h*abSZMD 1 ,S/*ZZq Y*2 V*`bSE *We*,TbZSy ]\V*3hSV T /\/*b\VE qVT /\]\Y*-*pbn hSb*h*Y V`*k1 4`\4dYTbS adbn +T+WTyZ\^ 4,TabVSD

5=>;

)V\,*s ,,*3*W\aq Y*W\ Z1 +\-\4Z1,*-\px (The Cambridge History of the Bible)D

˙\ V`*p 41YWT

\WS 4 Z-WT^ /\ T,ZThZ\^ Y1`SVS ,S`djSWS ]1`jT ]1`1a1W1ZgTE ,\ZS ,4qWS 4 a\+\p w˝1Z1,anVd T+WTpxD /Z*V ]T4ZTO j1 +TWnj\^ ]\]dWq`Z\abT , Y1`SgT Z*+dW* w T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*xD \WS ,]WS, `SO b*ZanV\^ TY]1`T^ ]\jS`S,aq Z* ,1an a,TbE 4*,/qVS 4daSWWqY ]`\b1ab*ZbanVSf YTaT\O Z1`T, gq T+WTq ]\b`*]SW* , `T4ZT Vdb\hVS 41YWTD aVTWnVS +*-*b\ ]1`1VW*/*hT, T+WT^ Z* YTag1,T Y\,S Z1 4Z*WS 2,`1yanV\^ b* -`1gnV\^E ,\ZS +`*WS 4* \aZ\,d *Z-WTyanVd w T+WTp V\`\Wq )V\,*xD ˛* /*ZSYS `Sb*ZanV\^ +T+WT\b1VSE wa1O `1/ *Z-W\Y\,ZSf ,S/*Zn r T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*sE *+\ r ,b\`S4\,*Z* ,1`aTqsE +dW* Z*/`dV\,*Z* d Z*y+TWnjTy VTWnV\abTxD ˙1O qVT ]T/`*fdZVS ]\V*4dpbnE k\ hSaW\ /`dO V\,*ZSf ]`SYT`ZSVT, gT2^ T+WT^ ]1`1,Skd2 YTWnq`/D

\`* 4YTZ ]`\/\,3 ab\WTbn +*-*b\ fb\ ,,*3*, w T+WTp V\`\Wq )V\,*x 2/SZ\p w]`*,/SO ,\px T+WT2pD 5<;> `\gT , Z-WT^ `\4O ]\h*WS ]\,ZSy ]1`1-Wq/ gn\-\ ]1`1VW*/dE 68

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

5=:5

T +dW* ,S/*Z* w 1`1-WqZdb* ,1`aTqxD * ^^ \aZ\,T 4Gq,S,aq /1k\ 4YTZ1ZSy w Y1`SV*ZO anVSy ab*Z/*`bZSy ]1`1VW*/x1E ]T/-\b\,O W1ZSy 4* dh*abp *Y1`SV*ZanVSf ,h1ZSfD ]1`1/Y\,T /\ Z1k\/*,Z\ ]1`1-WqZdb\^ w ,b\`S4\,*Z\^ ,1`aT^x L5=<6 `TVM P w \,\^ T+WT^ V\`\Wq )V\,*x P -\,\`SbnaqE k\ +dO W\ /\VW*/1Z\ 4daSWnE *+S w4+1`1-bS WTb1`*O bd`ZSy abSWnE 4* qVSy b*V gTZdpbn r ,b\O `S4\,*Zd ,1`aTpsx 5:55 `\VdD T+WTq T /*WT 4*WSj*2bnaq a,Tb\,SY +1abO a1W1`\YE * ]1`1VW*/ w T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*x 2 Z*y+TWnj ]\jS`1ZSYD W1 \an qV ,SaW\O ,S,aq ]`\e1a\` Th*`/ \Wb\ZB w#\ YS bTWnVS Z1 `\+SWS 4 ,`1yanVSYS b* `1gnO VSYS Sa*ZZqYSDDD S ]1`1VW*/*WS ^f T ]1O `1-Wq/*WS gT ]1`1VW*/SDDD /SZ1E k\ 4*WSO jSW\aqEP g1 ]`\ab\ hSb*bS T+WTpxD 14dY\,Z\E w T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*x P WTO b1`*bd`ZSy j1/1,`E qVSy gTZdpbn 4* Z1O 4`T,ZqZZd V`*ad ,SaW\,T,D k\ aV*4*bS ]`\ a*Yd 4,TabVd T+WT^H *bfZ1ZT \-\Y

Sa*ZZq ,V*4dpbn Z* /31`1W\ ,S`Tj1ZZq daTf Wp/anVSf ]`\+W1YD \h +S qVSY ]1`1O VW*/\Y ,S V\`Sabd,*WSanE ,T/VS -\,S `*O /\ /\]\Y\3dbn ,*Y /\aWT/SbS T+WTpD 1 ˙S,Tbnaq ad]`\,T/Zd TZe\`Y*gTp w Y1`SV*ZanVSy ab*Z/*`bZSy ]1`1VW*/xD

˙ı (˙ ˛ ( &

#\ `\+Sbn b\,*`SanVd 4dab`Th a]`*,/T gTV*,\pH #\ b1+1 Z*y+TWnj1 ]`S,*+Wp2 d b\,*`SanO VSf 4dab`Th*fH \ab*, O M ^3* M b*ZgT M T-`S M a]TWVd,*ZZq 4 /`d4qYS M Z\,T 4Z*y\Yab,* M TZj1

ı &"ı & fW\]gT, T /T,h*b /d31 Wp+O Wqbn 4+S`*bSan `*4\YE T g1 ]`S`\/Z\D *O ,Tbn d T+WT^ af,*WnZ\ -\,\`Sbnaq ]`\ /1qVT b\,*`SanVT 4dab`ThTD

S bS 4Z*2jDDD ˘ SZS •\,* ,W*jb\,d,*WS aTY1yZT 4dab`ThT L•\,* 5B8MD ˘ ıada ,T/,T/*, /\aSbn ,1WSV1 ,1aTWWq Lı,*O Z* 6B5P55MD ˘ `SabSqZS , ]1`j\Yd ab\WTbbT 4+S`*WSaq d /\Y*f \/Z\,T`gT, L˙T^ 6B8:E 8;MD Tfb\ Z1 4*]1`1hd2E k\ 4 /`d4qYS ]`S2YZ\ 4+S`*bSaqD /Z*V ]TaWq /1qVSf 4dab`Th1yE Z* 3*WnE 4*WSj*pbnaq -T`VT a]\-*/SD

) w 1Z1 4*]`\aSWS Z* ,1hT`VdE Vd/S YT- ]`SybS +d/nOfb\D \Z* Y*W* ]`\,\/SO bSan d /\YT \/Z\-\ fW\]gqD b\y h*a y\-\ +*bnO VS ]\^f*WS 4 YTab*D ) ,S`TjSW* Z1 ybS T 4\,aTY ]`\ g1 Z1 jV\/dpD *abd]Z\-\ /Zq q /T4Z*O W*anE k\ Z* ,1hT`gT *WV\-\Wn WS,aq `TV\p T /1O fb\ ]\Z*]S,*,aqD `\2 fW\]gT, Z*,Tbn 4Z1]`SO b\YZTWSD #1 b*Y ab*W*aq +TyV*E ]TaWq h\-\ ]`S^f*W* ]\WTgTq T ,aTf `\4T-Z*W*x L˙31Z1WnMD

& ˙ I

ı

˚

+/dY*y ,a1 Z*]1`1/I 1O 4*W13Z\ ,T/ b\-\E hS g1 bS 4*]`\jd2jE hS 4*]`\jdpbn b1+1E ,*3WS,\ ,T/]\O ,TabS Z* 4*]Sb*ZZqE ]\YTk1ZT Z* Z*abd]ZSf ab\`TZV*fD \/T Z*+*-*b\ +TWnj1 j*ZaT,E k\ ,T/ ,1hT`VS , b1+1 +d/dbn WSj1 f\`\jT ,`*31ZZqD `\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55 69

r

Wp/SE 4 qVSYS ,*`b\ a]TWVd,*bSanE * 2 y b*VTE fb\ Wp+Sbn -`*bS 4 ,\-Z1YD #\+ ,1hT`V* +dW* ,T/a,T3O Z\pE b`1+* `1b1WnZ\ \+S`*bS -\ab1y

s

˘ #\ +d/1 ,T/+d,*bSanH TV\Wn

˘ b\ b*Y +d/1 T aVTWnVSH w *`b\ 4*]`\jd,*bS WSj1 bSfE V\-\ 4Z*2j \a\+Sab\E * Z1 ,aTf ]T/`q/D 1 b`1+* V*4*bS 4*]`\O j1ZSYE k\ ,\ZS Y\3dbn ]`S,1abS 4 a\+\p /`d4T,x L 1Z1MD w)Vk\ Z1 \+Y13SbS VTWnVTabn -\ab1yE b\ ,a1 Y\31 ,SybS 4O]T/ V\Zb`\WpD S 4*]`\jd2j 6> WpO /1yE ,\ZS ]`S,\/qbn k1 5> TZjSfE * gT 5> P k1 V\-\anDDD ) a*Y* b*V1 +*hSW*Ix L \W1bbMD w 1WSVT 4dab`ThT Z*+*-*b\ ,*3O h1 V\Zb`\Wp,*bSD d/`Tj1 4+S`*bSaq Y1ZjSYS -`d]*YSx L W1VaTaMD

w b\ 4 Yd/`SYS f\/SbnE b\y Yd/`SY ab*2E * fb\ b\,*`Sjd2 4 +14dYZSYE b\y WSf* Z*+d/1x L ı ˚• 57B6>MD

w)Vk\ bS \`-*ZT4*b\` ,1hT`VS T Z* ZTy ab*2bnaq k\an ]\-*Z1E ]\ab`*3/*2 b,\q `1]db*gTqx L `T/31bMD w#\+ ,1hT`V* ]`SZ1aW* `*/Tabn V\3O Z\YdE b`1+* 4*4/*W1-T/n ,a1 ]`\/dY*bSD ˛*,+*hWS,Tabn /\]\Y\31 dZSVZdbS +*-*O bn\f ]`\+W1Yx L 1bMD w /SZ YTy ]`Sqb1Wn aV*4*,E k\ Z1 4*]`\jd2 Y1Z1 Z* a,\^ ,1hT`VSE +\ Y\^ +*bnVS Wp+Wqbn ]Sb*bSB r b\ b*Y +dO /1HsE r VTWnVS ,\Z* b`S,*bSY1Hs T ]\/T+Z1D •\Yd Z1 ]\/\+*2bnaq b*VSy V\Zb`\WnD ı g1 /d31 Z*ab\`\3d2I )Vk\ y\-\ /`*bdpbn ,31 a*YT 4*]Sb*ZZqE b\ hS ,*`b\ Y1ZT ybS Z* gp ,1hT`VdHx L˚W1ZMD

wıab1 ,S hS ]G2b1E hS `\+Sb1 k\an TZj1 P da1 `\+Tbn Z* \3d aW*,dx L5 ) 5>B75MD

w ˚ •" ˙ x w \WS YS 4+S`*WSaq , Y\2^ ]\/`d3O VSE ^^ Y*Y* 4* ,aTY ]SWnZd,*W*D *O ,Tbn V\WS q ]TjW* /\ Y*jSZS 4* Vd`bV\pE ,\Z* 4*]Sb*W*aqE Vd/S q y/dD S ,\Z* 4*Z*/b\ ]1`1ab`*f\,d,*O W*anH \3WS,\D W1 q Z1 \+`*3*W*aqE +\ `\4dYTW*E k\ WT]j1 b*VSy Z*-Wq/ T a]\VTyE ZT3 ]\,Z* a,\+\/* T ]\bTY a\O `\Yx L TYMD w) +d,*W* Z* gTV*,Sf ,1hT`V*fD ˙dO Y*pE ,a1 ]`\yjW\ hd/\,\E +\ a1`1/ 4*]`\j1ZSf +dWS Wp/S `T4Z\-\ ,TVdD k1 \`-*ZT4*b\`S ,a1 /\+`1 ]`\/dO Y*WSE b\3 ZTfb\ Z1 Zd/n-d,*, T Z1 ,T/O \V`1YWp,*,aqx L Z/`1*MD

r

) +d,*, Z* ]`S2YZSf b\,*`SanVSf 4dab`Th*fD `-*ZT4*b\`S ,ab*Z\,O Wp,*WS hTbVT ]`*,SW*E qVT \+1`T-*WS ,T/ daTWqO VSf ]`\+W1YD ˛*,/qVS gn\Yd ,aT ]\hd,*WSan +14]1hZ\ T \b`SYd,*WS `*/Tabn

˚Z/`p

s

˘ #\ bS `\+SbSY1jE V\WS b1+1 k\an

Z*ab\`\3SbnH w Y1Z1 2 ]W*Z ,T/abd]dD * ,1hT`gT q 4*,3O /S b1W1e\Zdp +*bnV*YE k\+ aV*4*bS ^YE V\WS ]\,1`ZdanD \/T ,\ZS ]Sb*pbn Y1Z1E hS ,a1 /\+`1D )Vk\ q V*3d rZTsE ,\ZS Z*-*/dpbn ]`\ \+\,Gq4VSE qVT q k1 Y*p ,SV\Z*bSD ˛*VTZhS,jS `\4Y\,dE q V*3d /`d4qYE k\ +*bnVS ]`\aqbn Y1Z1 j,S/j1 ]\,1`ZdbSanE b\Yd Ydjd ybSx L 1`14*MD w)V\an Z* ,1hT`Vd ]`SyjW\ /,\2 fW\]gT,E qVSf Z1 4*]`\jd,*WSD `\ \/Z\-\ 4 ZSf +dW\ ,T/\Y\E k\ ,TZ ,3S,*, Z*`V\bSVSD ) ,*-*W*anE b* ,a1 3 4*b1W1e\Zd,*W* b*b\,T T ]\]`\aSW* ]`S^f*bS 4* YZ\px L 1`TMD

w +*hZSy +*hSbn WSf\E y f\,*2bnaqE * W1-V\,*3ZT y/dbn /*WT P y 4*4Z*pbn V*`Sx L ı ˚• 66B7E ˚ ˚ ˙ ıD ˚ MD

˘ b\ Z*-Wq/*bSY1H w)Vk\ Z* 4dab`ThT 4`TWT \a\+S Z*-Wq/*bSYdbn 4* bSYE k\ ,T/+dO ,*2bnaqE b\ ,a1 +d/1 /\+`1x L *`VMD w *ZTj1 q a\`\YSW*an +*bnVT,E V\WS ,\ZS +dWS Z* 4dab`Th*fD W1 b1]1` `\4dYTpE k\ ^fZ2 ]SWnZ1 \V\ P WSj1 Z* /\+`\D `SadbZTabn +*bnVT, Z1 \4Z*h*2E k\ bS Z1 4Y\O 31j `\4,*3SbSanx L *d`*MD

w *yb1 hSab1 adYWTZZqx L5 ˚ 7B5:MD

˚ ˛ ) ˛ & H

˙T4Z*yaqE qVT ,1hT`VS ]\O /\+*WSaq b,\^Y +*bnV*Y d pZ\abTD #\ ,\ZS 4YTZSO WS + d ,1hT`V*fE qVT \`-*ZTO 4\,d,*WS *+\ Z* qVT ^f +dW\ 4*]`\j1Z\H

" ˚ ı H \-\,\`S ]`\ g1 4 +*bnO V*YS T /\+`1 \+/dY*y b*VT 4*]Sb*ZZqB 5D \-\ 4*]`\aSbSH 6D VTWnVS +d/1 Wp/1yH 7D ˙1 ]`\,1abSH 8D b\ +d/1 Z*-Wq/*bSH 9D )V* +d/1 ]`\-`*Y*H

#\+ ]`\hSb*bS TZjT ab*bbT 4 `d+`SVS w \W\/T Wp/S 4*]SbdpbnxE 4*,*Zb*3 ]\]1`1/ZT ,S]daVS 3d`Z*Wd w `\+dO /SanIx T4 a*ybd www.jw.orgD `\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55 6;

˛ & ı

*]* Z1 Y\31 +dbS /\Z\`\Y \`-*ZT, ˛-T/Z\ 4 ]\,T/\YW1ZZqY Tb*WTyanV\^ -*41bS w * `1]d++WTV*xE V*`/SZ*W `SY\OV*b\WSgnV\^ g1`V,S •\41e *bgTZ-1` +d, d a]SaVd ]\b1ZgTyZSf /\Z\O `T, Wp/anVSf \`-*ZT,D `\b1 ]TaWq b\-\E qV y\-\ \+O `*WS ]*]\p 1Z1/SVb\Y XVIE ,TZ ,31 Z1 2 /\Z\`\YD \YdH w TW\ ]\ZbSeTV* Z*W13Sbn daTy g1`V,TxEP ]\qaZp2 *`fT2]SaV\] ˛S-YdZ/ ˛SY\,anVSy 4 ,*bSO V*ZanV\^ T2`*`fT^D w \3 4`\4dYTW\E V\WS ]*]* ]\O Y`1EP -\,\`Sbn *`fT2]SaV\]EP y\-\ bTW\ Y*2 4*WSO j*bSaq Z1djV\/31ZSYE \aVTWnVS , Y*y+dbZn\Yd y\-\ bTW\ E Y\3WS,\E +d/dbn ,j*Z\,d,*bSxD

˝Sbbq , \+YTZ Z* -`\jT S -\b\,T Wp/S \+YTZqbS `TV a,\-\ 3Sbbq Z* YTWny\Z 2,`\H ˛-T/Z\ 4 \/ZSY \]Sbd,*ZZqYE 5 4 8 h\W\,TVT, T 5 4 : 3TZ\V d TY1hhSZT -\b\,T Z* b*VSy \+YTZ L4* /*ZSYS TZabSbdbd ,S,h1ZZq -`\Y*/anV\^ /dYVS Emnid Z* 4*Y\,W1ZZq w T/1`4 /*y/31ab ˙\yhW*Z/xMD \W\/jT \a\+S +dWS +TWnj afSWnZT ]`SyZqbS b*Vd ]`\]\4SgTp P 6= ý \aT+ ,TO V\Y ,T/ 58 /\ 6= `\VT, T 69 ý ,TV\Y ,T/ 7> /\ 7=D /O Z*V 4 `\V*YS Wp/S ]\hSZ*pbn +TWnj1 gTZd,*bS 3SbbqD Sj1 57 ý \aT+ ,TV\Y 9>P9= `\VT, b* 55 ý bSfE V\Yd 4* :>E +dWS -\b\,T ]TbS Z* b*V1D

Z*WT4 Y*4VT,E ,4qbSf 4 VW*,T*O bd`S +*ZV\Y*bT, d g1Zb`*f *Z-WTyanVSf YTabE ,Sq,S,E k\ Z* ZSf +TWnj1 ]\b1ZgTyZ\ Z1O +14]1hZSf +*Vb1`TyE ZT3 Z* aSO /TZZqf dZTb*4T, d -`\Y*/anVSf bd*W1b*f Lw ˚ ˚ xE ˚ O ı)MD

w˙1qVT 41YW1b`daS qVO\b d \,Ty ˛1W*Z/T^ gn\-\ `\Vd b* Z* *^bT b\`TV ab*WS /Wq Z*dO V\,gT, Z1a]\/T,*ZV\pE \aVTWnO VS ,T/+d,*WSaq d4/\,3 /\aT Z1,T/\YSf `\4W\YT,DDD \Yd ]\ab*2 b`S,\3Z1 4*]Sb*ZZqB aVTWnVS k1 41YW1b`daT, Y\31 ab*bSan d `*y\ZT `\4W\YT,E qVT Z1 ,Sq,W1ZTE *+\ , `*y\ZT `\4O W\YT,E Z1+14]1Vd qVSf Z1/\O \gTZppbnHx Lw &( • • xE " MD

w \bS`S Z*y+*-*bjT Wp/SZS a,TbdDDD ,\W\/Tpbn +TWnjSY

+*-*bab,\YE ZT3 9; Z*yO +T/ZTjSf V`*^Z d a,TbTx Lw ı ı ıxE aTh1ZnOWpbSy 6>55 `\VdE " MD

*b\WSgnV* g1`V,* d `*4SWT^ jb`*ed2 Z*`1h1ZSf Z* 7>> *Y1`SV*ZanVSf /\W*`T,E qVk\ bT a]T4Zppbnaq Z* ,TZh*ZZqD *`S ]\,SZZT ,S]Sa*bS h1V ]1`1/ ,1aTWO WqYD •\-\ ]\,1`b*O pbn WSj1 b\/TE V\WS ,\ZS ]`S+d/dbn ,h*aO Z\ LG5E ˛ ı)MD

6<

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

W*aZSVS => ý ]\WnanVSf V\Y]*ZTy 4*q,SWSE k\ 4* \aO b*ZZT /,* `\VS ab*WS 31`bO

,*YS V`*/T3VS hS \+Y*O Zd 4 +\Vd a,\^f ]`*gT,ZSVT, Lw˘ ˛˚ xE &# MD

ı ˙˚ w ˙ &Ix ˛ 6>55 ı

!"#2 S `1WT-Tq

a]`Sq2 YS`dH

!"#2

!"#2

!"#2

!"#2

!"#2

`*,/* ]`\

\VdWnbS4Y

) ı " ˛˙ G)

G) & ˙

)V /\W*bS Z1ab1`]ZSy +TWn ,b`*bS

˚ " ı˛

\Yd ,\ZS ab*pbnaqH \WS ]`S]SZqbnaqH

˙ ˝ • ˙

˚ ı ı ) )V `\4]\`q/3*bSaq -`TjYS =D55 ˝ ˝SbbqE a]\,Z1Z1 +W*-\aW\,1Zn L D \yO -*`/bM 6D55 ˛Z*yjW* \-\E fb\ ]\VTZhSbn 4 Z1a]`*,1/O WS,Tabp L D 1ZZ1M 55D55 *gSabS Y1Z1 Z1 4W*Y*WS L D TaV*M <D55

\`,*, 4 Z*aSWWqY L D 1+`1`*M 8D55 #*aWS,Sy ]*abS` L D 1VY*Z\,M 7D55 #\an gTZZTj1 4* ]`1abS3Zd V*`G2`d L D ı+*O bdWWTZM :D55 ˛˙

G) ı ˚˙ 14]1V* /Wq ab*`1ZnVSf 6D55 *`qhV* /1Z-1 55D55 \a]TaZ* Y1/SgSZ* ;D55 T-`1Zn 5D55 d/`T ]\`*/S P WTVS /Wq a1`gq <D55 *V Y\W\hZ\^ 4*W\4S <D55 *V d /SbSZS 9D55 SZ/`\Y ˙*dZ* , /SbSZS :D55 \Z 5D55 )V ]\WT]jSbS 4/\`\,Gq 7D55 ı ı (˙ \/\a]*/ 1`hSa\Z L -*Z/*M =D55 ˙3\Z \Va L Z-WTqM 55D55 ˙\]SbWS,Sy `\4dY L,\3/n TV*`*\E TV*`*O -d*M 56D55 ˝S,\]Sa bTZ-*bTZ-* L *Z4*ZTqM 55D55 ˛* 4\W\b\Y d /*W1VSy V`*y L ,ab`*WTqM 6D55 ı+Z *bdb* ,T/V`S,*2 a,Tb <D55 w ZS-* b`*jZ\-\ ad/dx L Z-WTqM =D55 1/\,T Yd`*fS L ,ab`*WTqM 9D55 w 1VaSV*ZanVSy ]\a\Wx Lb1VTW*M 55D55 TZT*bp`ZT ]*W*gS b*Y+dW* L d`1hhSZ*M 5D55 d4ShZT TZab`dY1ZbS ab*`\/*,Zn\-\ ı4`*^Wq 7D55 \4]Sa ]\ /1`1,d L \aTqM =D55 ,*Z1bTq P V`*^Z* +*jb L `d4TqM :D55 *b*`S =D55

!"#2

!"#2

1WnanVT ,T,h*`T ;D55 dZ*YT , )]\ZT^ L6>55 `TVM 56D55 "Wqf `*+T, L 1ZTZM 9D55

(˙ & ı ˙\+`1 ,Sf\,*bS /SbSZd 5>D55 SZ/`\Y ˙*dZ* , /SbSZS :D55 )V /\W*bS +TWn ,b`*bS 8D55 ˙ı (˙ ˛ ( & ˙\ qV\^ V\Y]*ZT^ ]`Sab*bSH 8D55 ˛*W13ZTabn ,T/ 1W1Vb`\ZZSf T-`*j\V 5D55

SY q 2H 5>D55 \gT*WnZT Y1`13T ;D55C <D55 b\ 2 Y\^YS a]`*,3ZTYS /`d4qYSH =D55 S q Z1,/*f*H 9D55 \Yd +*bnVS Z1 /\4,\Wqpbn Y1ZT `\4,*3*O bSanH 6D55 #\ Y1ZT aWT/ 4Z*bS ]`\ Vd`TZZqH 7D55 #\ `\+Sbn b\,*`SanVd 4dab`Th gTV*,\pH 56D55 )V \+S`*bS `\4,*-SH 55D55 )V a]`*,SbS /\+`1 ,`*31ZZqH :D55 ˛*/dY hS ,S]*/\VH 5D55C 6D55C 7D55C 8D55C 9D55C :D55C <D55C =D55C 55D55 *j \`-*ZT4Y P /S,\,S3ZSy /*` 9D55

ı • ˚ ˙ ı 5D55C 6D55C 7D55C 8D55C 9D55C :D55C ;D55C <D55C =D55C 5>D55C 55D55C 56D55 )˙ ı ıı ˙\ h\-\ Y*pbn ]`*-ZdbS +*bnVSH 5>D55 *Y\V*bd,*ZZq 7D55 S T+WTq ,S]`*,/\,d2 `*+ab,\H ;D55 S T+WTq d4-\/3d2bnaq 4 Z*dV\pH 6D55 S \- /+*2 ]`\ b,*`SZH 56D55 S \- 2 ,ap/SadkSyH 8D55 S \- af,*Wp2 ,TyZS , Z*j h*aH <D55 S ,T`* ad]1`1hSbn 4/\`\,\Yd -Wd4/dH 5D55 S ]1,ZSy /1Zn bS3Zq Y*2 +dbS a,qbSYH =D55 \Yd ]`*,/S,Sf ]\aWT/\,ZSVT, ıada* Z1Z*O ,S/qbnH 9D55

!"#2

!"#2

\Yd aWT/ 4,*3*bS Z* a,\p Y\,dH :D55 )V /\aq-bS k*abq , jWp+TH 55D55 ˙ıı ı ı

WTY*bShZT a*YTbS 55D55 1`*VbS :D55

˚ ı ı) w T+WTq V\`\Wq )V\,*x 56D55 w ZS-* Ydh1ZSVT,x ˝*Z* `1a]1Z* 7D55

ZS-*E k\ 4*aWd-\,d2 /\,T`Gq L T+WTqM 5D55C 6D55C 7D55C 8D55C 9D55 T4/,qZ* qWSZV* 56D55 p VZS-d Z1Y\3WS,\ 4ZSkSbS L T+WTqM 56D55 S TaZdpbn ,*-\YT ]T/ab*,S ,T`SbS , ,\`O gqH 55D55 S `1WT-Tq a]`Sq2 YS`dH 5D55 w) Z1 ,Y1`x =D55 ı˛ ˚ ,*`T^ Z* /\`\-*f ;D55 ˙S,\ Z*`\/31ZZq 5D55 ˝Sbbq +14 ab`*3/*Zn ;D55 d4SV* <D55 VdWnbS4Y 6D55

\-\/* T fT/ Tab\`T^ :D55 ab* P wZ*ygTZZTjSy ]\ad/xH 9D55 *a\YT`S YSZdW\-\ L-\/SZZSVSM 5D55 S `1*WTabShZT ,*jT gTWTH 6D55 ı˙

ZS3V* w *,h*yaq d 1WSV\-\ hSb1Wqx 56D55

\Z-`1aS w 1f*y ]`Sy/1 \31 *`ab,\Ix 9D55 w *]SjTbn Zb\ZdIx =D55 w 1 Y\-W* ,T/T`,*bSan ,T/ Z1^x LVZS3V* w˛*]Sb*ZZq Y\W\/Sf Wp/1yxE b\Y 6M 8D55 ı

\`\V ;D55 1/\,T Yd`*fS 9D55

`d/V\Z\-T V`*a1ZT L*`*+anVT aV*VdZSM 8D55 S+\W\,Wq ]\O]b*jSZ\Yd =D55

!"#2

!"#2

˛ )V ,\Z* ,]WS,*2 Z* ,*aH

)V

\WS YSZdbn daT ab`*3/*ZZqH

)

˛ )˙˝ ) ı"

/\+`1 ,Sf\,*bS /SbSZd ˚ ı & ˚ ˙ )

ı ( & ı ı˙ ı )H

( ˚ ˝

˛ #

ı • ˚ ˙ ı

h\Yd `T4ZSgqH ˛Z*y/Tbn b`S ,T/YTZZ\abT YT3 Y*WpZV*YS T E 4*]SjTbn ^f ,ZS4d T `\4Y*Wpyb1 Y*O WpZVSD ı˙ ˛ B ]`\hSb*yb1 ıa*^ :B5P<D

5˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝ 6˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝ 7˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝ 8D )VSy 4 /,\f Y*WpZVT, ,T/]\,T/*2 +T+WTyO Z\Yd \]SadH ˘ T/]\,T/T Z* ab\`TZgT 6>D

7>

`\+d/SanI `d/1Zn 6>55

ı &D )V ıa*q ]\ab*,S,aq /\ a,\-\ 4*,/*ZZqH )V YS Y\31Y\ ]\V*4*bSE k\ 2 aYS`1ZZSYS T \f\hSYS ,SV\Zd,*bS /\`dh1ZO ZqH ı˙ ˛ B ]`\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 55>B7C *b,Tq 6<B5=E 6>D ˛ ˙ ) ˙ ) ı GıD 1f*y V\31Z

hW1Z aTYG^ ]\jdV*2 gTV*,T e*VbS ]`\ *Z-1WT,D \bTY d `\/SZZ\Yd V\WT \+YTZqyb1an gT2p TZe\`Y*gT2pD *]`SVW*/E k\ ,f\/Sbn , \+\O ,Gq4VS *Z-1WT,H ı˙ ˛ B ]`\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 78B<C ,`1^, 5B58C +Gq,W1ZZq 58B:E ;D S ,\ZS /Tpbn \`-*ZT4\,*Z\H ı˙O

˛ B ]`\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 5>7B5=P65D S *Z-1WS aYS`1ZZ\ b* \f\h1 /\]\Y*-*pbn TZjSYH ı˙ ˛ B ]`\hSb*yb1 d//T, 57B5;E 5<C dVS 66B87C +Gq,W1ZZq 66B<E =D

)Vk\ +*3*2b1 `\4/`dVd,*bS gT ab\`TZVSE 4*,Tb*yb1 Z* a*yb www.jw.org

TV*,\ T ]\,h*WnZ\

*]Sa*Z* \ab*ZZq VZS-* T+WT^ ˝S, d VIII abD /\ ZD 1D

ı ) ˛ ˝ )D T`ZSy ]`\`\VE qVSy ]\/+*,E k\+ y\-\ aTYGq \+G2/Z*Z\ ]\VW\ZqW*an -\,TD TZ ab*`*ZZ\ ,SV\O Zd,*, aWd3TZZq T gSY ]\/*,*, hW1Z*Y a,\2^ aTYG^ /\+`Sy ]`SVW*/D •\-\ /`dO 3SZd Z*4S,*WS ]`\`\hSg1p Lıa*^ ;B7C <B7E 5<MD ıa*q aWd3S, -\,T ]`SZ*yYZT 8: `\VT,D ıYGq ıa*q \4Z*h*2 w ]*aTZZq ,T/ -\,SxD

b,\`1ZSy /*Y

ı˙ ı˙ı AD •\-\ aSZ "1*`O)jd, Lıa*^ ;B7MD D w an qEP ]\jWS S Y1Z1Ix Lıa*^ :B<MD

D wDDD]T4Z*ZZq \a]\/Zn\-\x Lıa*^ 55B=MD 8>6: `TV /\ ZD 1D

ı ı•

56

˛ ) D b\ `*4\Y 4 ıa*2p ]Tj\, ]1`1/*bS 4,TabVd g*`p f*4dH D )V\p +dW* ,T/]\,T/n ıa*^E V\WS -\O ,* 4*]Sb*,B w \-\ ) ]\jWpxH

D ıa*q ]1`1/`TVB w˛1YWq +d/1 ]\,O Z*DDDxD

˝S, d `da*WSYT `da*WSY

ı )

5 `TV ZD 1D

=< `TV ZD 1D

S`T3b1E 4T-ZTbn ]\a1`1/SZT T 4+1`T-*yb1

p/S T V`*^ZS

9D *a 4,*bS ,T-* ^W b* `TqE T Z*Y = b* ; `\VT,D

´ & La Voz de Galicia/Fotografo: ´ Vıctor Mejuto

S 3S,1Y\ , ıZ/T^D VTWnVS ]`S+WS4Z\ ,T/VT, -\,S Z*WThd2bnaq , ıZ/T^B 75 9>>E 9= :>> hS <: >>>H :D +,1/S V`*]VdE qV* ]\V*4d2E /1 Z*j* V`*^Z*D \ab*, V`*]Vd b*YE /1 bS 3S,1jE T ]\/S,SanE hS g1 /*W1V\ ,T/ ıZ/T^D

˛*,/*ZZq /Wq /Tb1y * qVSf ab\`TZV*f ]\YTk1O Z\ gT TWpab`*gT^H ]SjS a,\^YS aW\,*YSE k\ 4\+`*O 31Z\ Z* V\3ZTy 4 ZSfD

w `\ab\ T ,\/Z\h*a -WS+\V\x

\Yd a*Y*`qZSZ +d, /\+`SY +WS3ZTYH

˘ *V ,SaW\,S,aq hSb*h 4T jb*bd 1O +`*aV* L " M ]`\ VZS3VdE qVd Z1k\O /*,Z\ ]`\hSb*,D TZ -\,\`SbnB w 1ZT 9: `\VT,E T q Z1\/`d31ZSyD * /Zqf q 4*O VTZhS, hSb*bS VZS3Vd r *,h*yaq d 1O WSV\-\ hSb1WqsD ) +d, ,`*31ZSyE Z*O aVTWnVS ]`\ab\ T ,\/Z\h*a -WS+\V\ ]\/*2bnaq TZe\`Y*gTqD aq ]d+WTV*gTq Z*]Sa*Z* 4 Wp+\,GpxD \W\,TV /\/*2B wıWpab`*gT^ ]`\ab\ /S,\,S3ZTD ˙dY*pE qV+S q +d, +*bnV\Y hS /T/da1YE b\ qV\O Y\-* +TWnj1 h*ad ]`\,\/S, +S 4T a,\2p Y*W1h1pE hSb*phS VZS3Vd T `\4-Wq/*pO hS Y*WpZVSxD ˝TZV* 4T jb*bd ˙3\`/3Tq L " M ]`\ gp ]d+WTV*gTp V*31B w \q j1abS`ThZ* ]W1YTZZSgq ˚,1`T ,4qW* VZS3Vd /\ jV\WSE *+S ]\V*4*bS ^^ \/Z\VW*aZSV*YD TaWq b\-\ qV ˚,1`T ]1`1V*4*W* VW*ad \/Zd 4 Tab\`TyE ,hSb1WnV* +dW* d 4*f,*bT T /\4,\WSW* k\/Zq hSb*bS 4 VZS3VS qVdan Tab\`TpxD ˝TZV* ]`\/\,3d2B w)V1 hd/\,1 a,T/h1ZZq /Wq \/Z\VW*aZSVT, b* ,hSb1WnVSIx q -*`Z\ TWpab`\,*Z* 69:Oab\`TZV\,* VZS3V* Y*2 b*VSy a*YSy e\`Y*bE k\ y w `\+d/SanIxD +S \b`SY*bS ^^E 4*]\,O ZTbnE +d/n W*aV*E ZS3h1]\/*ZSy Vd]\Z T ,SjWTbn y\-\ Z* ,V*4*Zd */`1ad *+\ Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/]\,T/ZSf */`1a Z* 9Oy ab\O `TZgTD

Q 1 +1`dhS Z* a1+1 3\/ZSf 4\+\,Gq4*ZnE q f\O hd 4*Y\,SbS gp VZS3VdD )V\p Y\,\p

\Yd

d/S L*/`1a*E TZ/1VaM

Q `\jd 4,Gq4*bSaq 4T YZ\p /Wq ]`\,1/1ZZq +14]W*bZ\-\ /\Y*jZn\-\ ,S,h1ZZq T+WT^D

• )

˚

˚ )

www.watchtower.org

g11 12-K

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.