Awake 2012

Page 1

!"#2 ˚ & 6>56

\WS 3 Z*ab*Z1

˚˙ ı &H

!"#2 ˚ ˚˙ ı• ˝B 85 >86 >>> ˙ & ) <8

\WS 3 Z*ab*Z1

˚˙ ı &H 7 ˝*W\ Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abT 8 \`1ZT Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abT : )V ab*bS +TWnj a]`*,1/WS,SY < `TdYe a]`*,1/WS,\abT ]T/ ]`*,WTZZqY

\3\-\ d`q/d

5> \-Wq/ T+WT^ w `*,/* 4`\+Sbn ,*a ,TWnZSYSxD #\ g1 \4Z*h*2H 56 w g1 ZTaIx 59 T+WTq P VZS-* b\hZSf ]`\`\gb,D *abSZ* 5 5= \W\/T Wp/S 4*]SbdpbnD \Yd +*bnVS Z1 f\hdbn Y1Z1 4`\4dYTbSH 66 ˛*/dY hS ,S]*/\VH */V`SW* Z*YT+anV\-\ 3dV* 67 5>>> ˛*WT, *`ab,*I \`/Tabn *W*,T 6: T+1`*b*V*I 6= \,SZS 4 dan\-\ a,Tbd 7> +YT`Vdyb1 d `\/SZZ\Yd V\WT 76 w 1 4-*/*pbnaq `1hT V\WSjZTE T Z1 ]`Sy/dbn Z* a1`g1x

˝ ˚ ˚˙ ı 6>5> `\gT *yVW ,Syj\, T4 ,Gq4ZSgT , 1O f*aT L " MD TZ ,T/aS/T, 6; `\VT, 4* 4W\hSZE qV\-\ Z1 ,hSZS,D •\-\ 4,SZd,*bSWS d 4š,*Wbd,*ZZTD W1 b1]1` g1 4,SZd,*h1ZZq 4ZqWSE V1`dphSan /*ZSYS ˙ Ob1abT,E V\bO `Sf `*ZTj1 Z1 `\+SWSD ˛-\/\Y \`-*ZS ,W*/S 4Z*yjWS ,SZZSfE \/Z*V 4*ad/SbS ^f +dW\ Z1O Y\3WS,\ 4* /*,ZTabp 4W\hSZdD

*-*bn\Y ]\`djZSV*Y ,/*2bnaq dZSVZdbS ]\V*`*ZZqD *]`SVW*/E d 1WSV\+`Sb*ZT^E qV ]\,T/\YWq2 TZb1`Z1bO,S/*ZZq w 1W1-`*exE w4* \ab*ZZ2 /1aqbSWTbbq ]\/,\^W*an VTWnO VTabn Z1`\4V`SbSf d+S,ab,E T Wp/S +\qbnaqE k\ ]\WTgTq b* ad/S Z1 4Y\3dbn ab`SY*bS ]\O jS`1ZZq Z*aSWnZSgnVSf 4W\hSZT,xD a1`]ZT 6>55 `\Vd +`Sb*ZanV* ]\WTgTq 4TO bVZdW*aq T4 4W\hSZZTabp TZj\-\ `\/dD ıy /\O ,1W\aq hSZSbS \]T` `\4Wph1ZSY Z*b\,]*Y d T`YTZ-1YTE T,1`]dWTE \Z/\ZT b* TZjSf YTab*fD h*aZSVS 4*,\`dj1Zn ]T/]*Wp,*WS +d/SZVS y *,b\Y\+TWTE `\4+S,*WS ,Tb`SZS Y*O

-*4SZT, T `\4V`*/*WS b\,*`D Z*aWT/\V gn\O -\ +*-*b\ fb\ ,b`*bS, Z1 WSj1 +T4Z1aE /TY hS Y*jSZdE *W1 y daT 4*a\+S /Wq TaZd,*ZO ZqD )V* ]`ShSZ* b*V\-\ Z*aSWWqH SY*W\ Z*]*/ZSVT, V1`d,*W\aq ,T/,1`b\p 3*/\+\pD ıZjT ,,*3*WS a,\^ /T^ ,T/]W*b\p 4* Z1a]`*O ,1/WS,TabnD ˛* aW\,*YS /1qVSf V\Y1Zb*b\O `T,E a1`1/ dh*aZSVT, 4*,\`dj1Zn +dW* `\4h*O `\,*Z* wY*`-TZ*WnZ*x Y\W\/nE k\ ,S`\ab*W* , +T/ZSf V,*`b*W*fE Z1 Y*phS ]1`a]1VbS, Z* Y*y+dbZ2D ˛-*/*ZSy d T+WT^ h\W\,TVE Z* TYGq •\,E aV*4*,B w) -\W\jd P T Z1Y* ad/d a]`*,1/WSO ,\-\Ix L•\,* 5=B;E w T+WTq 4 V\Y1Zb*`qYSxMD n\-\/ZT +*-*b\ Wp/1y b13 ,\W*2 ]`\ a]`*O ,1/WS,TabnE *W1 ^fE 4/*2bnaqE ZTfb\ Z1 hd2D S V\Ydan ]T/ aSWd ]\VTZhSbS 4 Z1a]`*,1/WS,TaO bpH S Z*/Tq Z* a]`*,1/WS,1 ada]TWnab,\ P WSj1 e*Zb*4Tq Z*^,ZSfH #\+ 4Z*ybS ,T/]\O ,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZqE a]1`jd b`1+* ,S4Z*hSO bS V\`1ZT Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abTD `\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

7

\`1ZT

˚ ˚˙ Ĺ

Ë› /,T bSaqhT `\VT, b\Yd , T+O WT^ +dW\ b\hZ\ \]Sa*Z1 adh*aZ1 ada]TWnO ab,\D ZTy -\,\`SbnaqB w \ab*ZZT /ZT ]`SO y/dbn aV`dbZT h*aSE V\WS 3SbS +d/1 /d31 ,*3V\D \ b\/T Wp/S +d/dbn a*Y\Wp+ZTE -`\O j\Wp+ZTDDD Z1,/qhZTD \ZS Z1 ,Sq,WqbSYdbn ,T//*Z\abTE Z1 Y*bSYdbn ]`S`\/Z\^ Wp+\,TE a*Y\,W*/*ZZqE Z1 ybSYdbn Z* 3\/ZT ]\abd]O VSE Z1 Wp+SbSYdbn ,1WSV\/djZ\abTD `TY b\-\E Wp/S +d/dbnDDD 4`*/ZSVSE a,*,TWnZTE -\`/TE ,\ZS Wp+SbSYdbn 4*/\,\W1ZZqE * Z1

\-*x L6 SY\eTq 7B5P8MD *W\ fb\ 4*]1`1hSbnE k\ , Z*j h*a /1/*O WT +TWnj1 Wp/1y ,Sq,Wq2 b*VT Z1-*bS,ZT `SO aSD 1 d a,\p h1`-d a]`Sq2 3*/\+T b* d]1`1O /31ZZp T ]\`\/3d2 *a\gT*WnZd ]\,1/TZVdE V\`d]gTp b* V`Shdkd Y*b1`T*WnZd Z1`T,O ZTabnD \4-WqZnY\ V\31Z hSZZSV \V`1Y\D

!"#2

8

Z1a]`*,1/WS,d \gTZVd TZjSY T Z*,Tbn ]\4O +*,Wqpbn ^f /1qVSf ]`*, h1`14 Z*gT\Z*WnO ZTabnE V\WT` jVT`SE ab*bnE a\gT*WnZSy ab*O bda hS `1WT-TpD *]`SVW*/E \/SZ 4 V\YTb1bT, 4Gqad,*,E k\ , ]1,ZTy V`*^ZT T,/1ZZ\^ Y1`SVS d WTV*`ZT ]\Y1`W* ,*-TbZ* 3TZV*E qVTy , TZj\Yd Y1/ShZ\Yd 4*VW*/T Z1 Z*/*WS Z*W13Z\^ /\]\Y\-S h1`14 1bZThZ1 ]\f\/31ZO Zq b* a\gT*WnZ\O1V\Z\YThZSy ab*ZD V`*yO ZTf ,S]*/V*f d]1`1/31ZZq ]`S4,\/SW\ /\ 3*fWS,\^ Z1a]`*,1/WS,\abTE qVO\b 1bZThZSf hSab\V T -1Z\gS/dD

Äą & ˚˙Ĺ D V\`\bV\Yd \-Wq/T ]T/`dhZSV* w a\gT*WnZ* ]\,1/TZV*x aV*4*Z\B w#\`\Vd h1`14 *a\gT*WnZd ]\,1/TZO Vd `\4]*/*pbnaq /1aqbVS bSaqh aTY1yE `dyZdO pbnaq a\bZT bSaqh 3SbbT, T ZSkSbnaq Y*yZ\ ,*`bTabp , YTWny\ZS /\W*`T,D Ë?\`ab\VTabn b* *-`1aTq ab*WS Z1,T/G2YZ\p h*abSZ\p Z*j\-\ ada]TWnab,*D 1 /S,Z\E qVk\ , Y*y+dbZn\Yd Tab\`SVS Z*4,dbn \ab*ZZT /1aqbS`Thhq /,*/O gqb\-\ ab\WTbbq Z1 rV\aYThZ\p 1`\ps hS rTZO e\`Y*gTyZ\p /\+\psE * r*a\gT*WnZ\p 1`\ps P ]1`T\/\YE V\WS ada]TWnab,\ `\4]\h*W\ ,TyO Zd ]`\bS a1+1x LwHandbook of Antisocial Behav iorxMD Ë› h*ad ,S/*ZZq gT2^ VZS3VS , 5==; `\gT ]\,1/TZV* T YSaW1ZZq Wp/1y Z1 4YTZSWSaqD

˚• Ë? Ë™ & ) /Wq ,aT2^ `\/SZSD TZ ]\,T/\YWq2 Z\O ,SZSE `\4]\,T/*2 ]`\ Wp/1y 4 `T4ZSf V`*^ZE ,Sa,TbWp2 `1WT-TyZT T Z*dV\,T ]Sb*ZZqE ]\V*4d2E qV Y\3Z* /\W*bS an\-\/ZTjZT ]`\+W1YSD TWnj1 b\-\E d Zn\Yd Z1 bTWnVS /1b*WnZ\ \+-\,\`ppbnaq ]\b\hZT ]\/T^E * y `\4V`SO ,*2bnaq ^fZ2 a]`*,3Z2 4Z*h1ZZqD 1y h*a\]Sa 4*,3O /S 4*WSj*2bnaq ]\WTbShZ\ Z1yb`*WnZSY T Z1 4,1WShd2 3\/Z\^ `*aS hS Z*gT\Z*WnZ\abTD Z*y-\W\,ZTj1E ,TZ ,a1Wq2 ,]1,Z1ZTabn d b\YdE k\ ,\`1gn Z14*+*`\Y a]\,ZSbn a,\p \+TbZSgp P 4ZSkSbn ZSZTjZp aSab1Yd 4W* b* ,ab*Z\,Sbn YS`ZSy Z\,Sy a,TbD

Top left: 5 Adam Dean/Panos Pictures; top center: 5 Matthew Aslett/Demotix/CORBIS; top right: 5 David Turnley/CORBIS

Ë? Ë™ D Ë™1V\WS Y\3Z* ]\hdbS ,SaW\,SB wË?*/T+ZTabn Z1 ]\`\Vx *+\ wË?*/T+ZTabn P g1 /\+`1xD * Z*a]`*,/T 3*/T+ZTabn P g1 4W\I *Y1 3*/\+* W13Sbn , \aZ\,T eTZ*Za\O ,Sf ]T`*YT/ T jb\,f*2 /\ +df-*Wb1`anVSf Y*fTZ*gTy b* Z1`\4ad/WS,Sf ]\4SVD Z*aWTO /\V eTZ*Za\,Sf V`S4 +*-*b\ Wp/1y 4*4Z*2 ,b`*b T +\WpD Ë›,Sh*yZ\E /1fb\ ab`*3/*2 h1O `14 ,W*aZd 3*/T+ZTabnD /Z*V Z1`T/V\ b1`O ]TbS 4+SbVS /\,\/Sbnaq T h1aZSY b`d/T,O ZSV*YD Ë™1qVT 4 ZSf ,b`*h*pbn /\YT,VS y ]1ZaT^D

Ëš ˚˙Ë?Ëš )D ]1`1/31ZT Wp/S /*pbn

q ]d+WTV*gTq Z1 /Wq ]`\/*3dD \Z* 2 h*abSZ\p ,a1a,TbZn\^ ]`\-`*YS +T+WTyZ\^ \a,TbSE qV* ]T/b`SYd2bnaq /\+`\,TWnZSYS ]\31`b,*YSD )Vk\ Z1 ,V*4*Z\ 3\/Z\-\ /31`1W*E ,`1yanVT Sa*ZZq L b*`Sy Ë›*,TbM gSbdpbnaq 4 T+WT^ d ]1`1VW*/T -T2ZV* L,S/*ZZq 6>>6 `\VdME * `SabSqZanVT `1gnO VT Sa*ZZq L \,Sy Ë›*,TbM P 4 w 1`1VW*/d Z\,\-\ a,TbdxD ÄąZjT /31`1W* gSb*bB dWDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ dWTj*C P w 1`1VW*/ Z\,\O -\ a,Tbd ,qb\-\ SanY*x L4 ]`SYTbV*YSE *Z-WDMC \YDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ \Y1ZV*D Awake! (ISSN 0005-237X) is published monthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; L. Weaver, Jr., President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. Periodicals Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibelund Traktat-Gesellschaft der Zeugen Jehovas, e. V., Selters/Taunus. Verantwortliche Redaktion: Ramon Templeton, Selters/Taunus. 5 2012 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. aT ]`*,* 4+1`T-*pbnaqD Printed in Germany.

Vol. 93, No. 5

Monthly

UKRAINIAN

D Sb*^ ]\WTgTq *`1jbd,*W* h\W\,TV*E qVSy +`*, dh*abn d YT31bZThZ\Yd V\ZeWTVbT

D *b\,] -`*+d2 T ZSkSbn Y*yZ\ , \Z/\ZT L 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTqM D Ë?*fWS,* +T/ZTabn d b*+\`T +T31ZgT, d d*Z/T

Äą)D \/Z\Yd 4,TbT ]`\ V\`d]gTp 2^ Y1bS b*V T Z1 ,/*W\aq /\aq-bSD Ë›-\/\Y , 4*4Z*h*W\aqE k\ d]`*,WTZZp \f\`\ZS 4/\`\,Gq ]1,Z\^ ]`\,TZgT^ V`*^ZS 4* a1YS`ThO ZSy ]1`T\/ ,S/TWSWS 69E6 YTWny\Z* `*Z/T, LZ* b\y h*a 8 YTWnq`/S /\W*`T, " MD /O Z*V ]\Z*/ <5 ,T/a\b\V gT2^ adYS +dW\ ,SV\O `Sab*Z\ Z1 4* ]`S4Z*h1ZZqYD w \jbS Y*WS ]TbS Z* db`SY*ZZq WTV*`1ZnE VWTZTV T Y1/O g1Zb`T, d ]`\,TZgT^xEP -\,\`SW\aq , 3d`Z*O WT w *+WTV Y1Z1/31`xD

# Ëš Äą & Ëš Äą Äą &D 6>>9 `\gT +WS4nV\ 7> ,T/a\bVT, adY*`O Z\-\ k\`ThZ\-\ /\f\/d +`Sb*ZgT, wZ*W1O 3*W\ 9 ,T/a\bV*Y Z*y+*-*bjSf \/1`3d,*O hT, /\f\/T,xE qV ]\,T/\YWqW\aq , 3d`Z*WT w *yYxD Ë›* /*ZSYS gn\-\ 3 ,S/*ZZqE Z* TZO j\Yd +\gT bW*ZbShZ\-\ \V1*ZdE d " E w]\Z*/ 77 ,T/a\bVS /\f\/T,DDD Z*W13Sbn 9 ,T/a\bV*Y Z*y+*-*bjSf *Y1`SV*ZgT,xD \ gTW\Yd a,TbT +WS4nV\ 5E8 YTWnq`/* Wp/1y 3S,1 Z* 5E69 /\W*`* , /1Zn *+\ y Y1Zj1D #\O /Zq 69 >>> /Tb1y ]\YS`*2 ,Z*aWT/\V +T/Z\abTD

S Y\3Z* ]\VTZhSbS 4 Z1a]`*,1/WS,TabpH 5=<; `\gT b\/TjZTy ]`1YG2`OYTZTab` ,abO `*WT^ ]\\+Tgq,E k\ /\ 5==> `\Vd 3\/Z* *,abO `*WTyanV* /SbSZ* Z1 3SbSY1 , 4WS/ZqfD TO

Ë™ & ) B *W+*ZanV*E *Yf*`anV*E *Z-WTyanV*67E *`*+anV*E *e`SV*ZaE +1Y+*E +T`Y*ZanV*E +TaW*Y*E +\W-*`anV*E ,G2bZ*YanO V*E ,T`Y1ZanV*E -TZ/TE -`1gnV*E -`d4SZanV*E -d/3*`*bTE /*banV*7E 1,1E 1aO b\ZanV*E 2,`1yanV* LT,`SbME 4dWdE T+\E TW\V*ZanV*E TZ/\Z14TyanV*E TaW*Z/anV*E Ta]*ZanV*67E Tb*WTyanV*67E y\`d+*E V*Z*/*E VS`-S4nV*E VSb*yanV*7 L*d/T\4*O ]Sa bTWnVS Y*Z/*`SZanV\p Y\,\pME VSb*yanV* La]`\k1Z1 ]SanY\ME VTZnqO `d*Z/*E VT`dZ/TE V\`1yanV*67E V\a*E W*bSanV*E WSb\,anV*E W\4TE Y*V1/\ZanO V*E Y*W*-*aTyanV*E Y*W*qW*YE Y*WnbTyanV*E Z-*W*E ZT/1`W*Z/anV*67E ZTY1gnV*67E Z\`,14nV*7E ]1/TE ]1Z/3*+anV*E ]\WnanV*67E ]\`bd-*WnanV*687E `*`\b\Z-*E `\aTyanV*67E `dYdZanV*E a*Y\*E a1+d*ZanV*E a1`+anV*E a1adb\E aSZ-*WnanV*E aW\,*gnV*E aW\,1ZanV*E ad*fTWTE b*-*WnanV*7E b*yanV*E b*YTWnO anV*E b,TE b\VO]TaSZE b\Z-*ZanV*E ba,*Z*E ba\Z-*E bd`1gnV*E d-\`anV*E dV`*O ^ZanV*E d`/dE eT/3TyanV*E eTZanV*7E e`*Zgd4nV*687E fTWT-*yZ\ZE f\`,*banV*E h1anV*7E hSh1,*E hTb\Z-*E j,1/anV*7E j\Z*E q]\ZanV*67D

6 *V\3 CDD 8 *V\3 MP3 CD-ROMD 7 d/T\4*]SaS b*V\3 /\abd]ZT Z* www.jw.org.

]`1YG2`OYTZTab` ,S4Z*,E k\ /*, ]\a]TjZd \+TgqZVdD \3 f\h +S qV\p +*-*b\pE ,T/\Y\p hS ,]WS,\,\p +dW* Wp/SZ*E ,\Z* WSj1 Wp/SO Z*E T ^y Z1 ]T/ aSWd ,SV\`1ZSbS Z1a]`*,1/WSO ,TabnD Ë› Z1a]`*,1/WS,Tabp abSV*pbnaq Z*O ,Tbn ,S/*bZT \a\+SD \ZSE qV T ,aTE ab*`Tpbn b* ]\YS`*pbnD q `1*WnZTabn WSj1 ]T/b,1`O /3d2 /,T +T+WTyZT TabSZSB w 1 , ,\WT Wp/SZS /\`\-S ^^E Z1 , aSWT WpO /SZSE V\WS ,\Z* f\/SbnE V1`Yd,*bS a,\^Y V`\V\Yx L `1YT^ 5>B67MD w 1 Z*/Tyb1an Z* VZq4T,E Z* Wp/anV\-\ aSZ*E +\ , Zn\Yd a]*aTZZq Z1Y*x L a*W\Y 58:B7MD a,T/\YS,jS gT /,T TabSZSE ,S Z1 +d/1b1 `\4h*`\,*ZTE V\WS ]\+*hSb1E k\ 4daSWWq WpO /1y ,ab*Z\,SbS a]`*,1/WS,Tabn Z1 /*pbn +*3*ZSf `14dWnb*bT,D * Z1,31 Z1Y*2 3\/O Z\^ Z*/T^H */Tq 2I Ë› \ab*ZZn\^ ab*bbT gT2^ a1O `T^ ,S /T4Z*2b1anE k\ Z14*+*`\Y d a,TbT 4*]*O Zd2 a]`*,1/WS,TabnD W1 Z*,Tbn b1]1` ,S , aSWT k\an 4YTZSbSD Ë›*]Sb*yb1 a1+1B w S YT- +S q +dbS +TWnj a]`*,1/WS,SY d ab*,O W1ZZT /\ TZjSfH h\Yd b`1+* ]\V`*kSO bSanHxD *abd]Z* ab*bbq YTabSbn V\`SaZT ]\`*/SD

Äą Äą &"Ëš Äą ĹĹ # Ë› O Ë™ ˚˛ " Ëš Ë™ " Ëš ) Äą ĹĹH `\aSY\ Z*/TaW*bS a,\2

]`\f*ZZq ,T/V*Y -\,S Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/]\,T/ZSf */`1aE ]\/*ZSf ZS3h1D \,ZSy ]1`1WTV */`1a /S,Tbnaq Z* a*ybT www.watchtower.org/addressD `-1ZbSZ*B Casilla 83 (Suc 27B), C1427WAB Cdad. Aut. de Buenos Aires. TW\`danB 66>>7>E SZaVE *Nq =D 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTqB The Ridgeway, London NW7 1RN. Äą4`*^WnB PO Box 29345, 61293 Tel Aviv. ´ Äąa]*ZTqB Apartado 132, 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz (Madrid). Äąb*WTqB Via della Bufalotta 1281, I-00138 Rome RM. *Z*/*B PO Box ˘ 4100, Georgetown, ON L7G 4Y4. \W/\,*E 1a]d+WTO V*B PO Box 472, MD-2005 Chisin ¸ au. TY1hhSZ*B 65617 Selters. \Wnk*B ul. Warszawska 14, 05-830 Nadarzyn. \`bd-*WTqB Apartado 91, P-2766-955 Estoril. \aTqB *Nq 5<6E *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-E 5=>>>>D " B 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. V`*^Z*B *Na =99E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE ;=8=5D `*ZgTqB BP 625, F-27406 Louviers Cedex.

)V ab*bS +TWnj

˚˙ " ,\`1gn ]`*-Z1E k\+ YS +dWS k*aO WS,TE Y*WS /dj1,ZSy YS` b* a]`SqWS k*abp TZjSfD \Yd ,TZ 4*\f\hd2 Z*a whSO ZSbS ]`*,\ad//qE T YSW\a1`/q Wp+SbSx L Sf1q :B<MD )V 4*ab\ad,*bS gp ]\`*/dH 1\+fT/Z\ `\4,S,*bS , a\+T /\+`T `SaSE qVT 4`1jb\p ,SbTaZqbn 4 Z*j\-\ a1`gq ]\-*ZT Z*fSWSD \/S,TY\anE qV T+WTq Y\31 /\]\O Y\-bS d gn\YdD

*aWT/dphS \3d Wp+\,E Y\3Z* ]\/\W*bS d]1`1/31ZZq

˙\`\bT ]\+d,*W* Z* \/Z\Yd 4 4T+`*Zn ,T/O

) ˝ ˙ D *yY\-dbZTj* VT, -\,SD ı^ -WS+\V\ 4,\`djSW* b1]W\b*E 4+`\q ]`\bS 3*/T+Z\abT P g1 Wp+\,D •/1bnO aq Z1 ]`\ `\Y*ZbShZ1 ]\hdbbqE * ]`\ a*O Y\31`b\,Zd Wp+\, /\ TZjSfD )V aV*4*Z\ , 5 \`SZeqZ 57B8E 9E b*V* wWp+\,DDD /\+`*xE ,\Z* wZ1 jdV*2 ,W*aZ\^ ,S-\/SxD `TY b\-\E gq Wp+\, ]\jS`p2bnaq Z1 WSj1 Z* aTYGp b* /`d4T,D w)Vk\ ,S Wp+Sb1 bSfE fb\ Wp+Sbn ,*aE b\ qV* ,*Y 4* g1 Z*-\`\/*Hx P a]Sb*, ıada T /\/*,E k\ Z*,Tbn Z1,T`dphT Wp+Wqbn bSfE fb\ Wp+Sbn ^f L *b,Tq 9B8:MD ) ˚ ˚˙˝˚ )D ˙T^ 5>B78E 79 -\,\`SbnaqB w \- /TyaZ\ Z1d]1`1O /31ZSy T , V\3Z\Yd Z*`\/T y\Yd /\ ,]\/\O +S b\yE fb\ +\^bnaq y\-\ b* hSZSbn ]`*O ,1/ZTabnxD ˙*phS Wp/qY a]*aTZZqE \- Z1 4,1`b*2 d,*-S Z* ^fZp Z*gT\Z*WnZTabnE a\O gT*WnZ1 ab*Z\,Sk1 hS ab*bnD \3Sf \h*f wZ1Y*2 ,31 ZT p/1qE ZT -`1V*E ZT `*+*E ZT ,TWnZ\-\E ZT h\W\,TV*E ZT 3TZVSx L *W*bT, 7B6<MD \3E Z*aWT/dphS \-*E YS 4Y\31Y\ ]\/\W*bS d]1`1/31ZZqD an ]`SVW*/ ˙\`\O bTE qV* 3SW* d " D ˙\`\bT /d31 \+d`p,*W\ `*a\,1 d]1`1O /31ZZqD \Z* Z*,Tbn f\bTW* ,4qbS dh*abn d 4+`\yZ\Yd ]\,ab*ZZTE k\+ ]\W1-jSbS ab`*3/*ZZq b1YZ\jVT`Sf Wp/1yD )V\an :

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

qVd ,Sq,SWS /\ Z1^ T h\`ZTE T +TWT ,T/VSD 1,/\,4T ˙\`\bT da,T/\YSW*E k\ bTWnVS

\- Y*2 aSWd 4YTZSbS hSpan \a\+SabTabnD \WS 3TZV* ,T/hdW* kS`d Wp+\, 4 +\Vd +TO W\jVT`Sf ,T/VT,EP Wp/1yE V\b`Sf `*ZTj1 w+14 ,*-*Zn Y\-W* + d+SbS 4*`*/S `1,\O WpgT^xEP ^^ a1`g1 `\4b*ZdW\ T ,\Z* `\4`SO /*W*anD

T`d//TZ 4 /`d3SZ\p ˛*`\p

) ı & ˚˙ı D ˙1qVT Wp/S , ]1`j\Yd ab\WTbbT k1 /\ b\-\E qV ab*WS ]\aWT/\,ZSV*YS `Sab*E +dWS ]GqO ZSgqYSE 4/S`ZSV*YSE WSf\aW\,*YS b* -dO WqV*YSD W1 4 \3\p /\]\Y\-\p ,\ZS ,SO V\`1ZSWS ]\-*ZT afSWnZ\abTE `\4,SZd,jS b*VT f\`\jT `SaSE qV Wp+\,E /\+`\bd T ,1WSO V\/djZTabn L5 \`SZeqZ 9B55C :B=P55C *O W*bT, 9B66MD n\-\/ZT YTWny\Z*Y Wp/1y b13 ,/*W\aq 4YTZSbS 3Sbbq 4*,/qVS b\YdE k\ ,\ZS ]T4Z*WS \-*D 1`1/ ZSf T T`d//TZE qVSy 3S,1 , 41`+*y/3*ZTD T`d//TZ ,Sf\,d,*,aq , aS`TbanV\Yd ]`SbdWVdE /1 h*ab\ +S, TZjSf fW\]gT,D \O WS ,TZ ,S`TaE b\ ab*, TZab`dVb\`\Y 4 `dO V\]*jZ\-\ +\pD w) +d, -`d+SY b* 3\`aO b\VSYEP V*31 T`d//TZDP )Vk\ ]T/ h*a \+T/d Y\q /`d3SZ* ˛*`* 4*+d,*W* k\an ]`SZ1abSE f\h* + T 4d+\hSabVdE q YT- ^^ ]\O +SbSD 1 a*Y1 q YT- 4`\+SbS T 4 bSYE fb\ /SO ,S,aq Z* /`d3SZdE V\WS YS yjWS ,dWSO g1pxD )V\an T`d//TZ /\,T/*,aqE k\ ıada ]\O ]`\aS, \-* ]`\+*hSbS a\W/*b*YE qVT +`*O WS dh*abn d y\-\ ab`*bT L dVS 67B78MD 1 /d31 y\-\ ,`*4SW\D TZ ]\/dY*,B w *V YT- ]\,1abSaq WSj1 \3Sy SZxD TaWq gn\-\ T`d//TZ ]\h*, jdV*bS \-*D \WS ,T/VS -\,S 4*]`\]\Zd,*WS y\Yd ,S,h*O bS T+WTpE ,TZ \f\h1 ]\-\/S,aqD 14*+*`\Y +T+WTyZ1 4Z*ZZq ,]WSZdW\ Z* \a\+SabTabn h\W\,TV*D TZ ab*, Z*abTWnVS Wp+Gq4Z\ ]\O ,\/SbSaq 4 ˛*`\pE k\ ,\Z* b13 4*f\bTO W* ,S,h*bS T+WTpD n\-\/ZT ,\ZS 3S,dbn d YS`T b* 4W*-\/T T `*4\Y aWd3*bn \-dD ˛,Sh*yZ\E ]\V`*kS,jS a,\p \a\+SaO bTabnE YS Z1 4YTZSY\ gTW\-\ a,TbdD /Z*V g1 ]T/ aSWd \-dI TZ Y*2 Z*YT` ae\`Yd,*O bS Z\,1 a]`*,1/WS,1 ada]TWnab,\D ˛-*/*yO Y\ aW\,* 4 6 SY\eTq 7B5P8E ]`\gSb\,*ZT Z* ]\h*bVd ]\]1`1/Zn\^ ab*bbTD T+WTq hTbO V\ ]1`1/`1VW*E qVSYS +d/dbn Wp/S , Z*j h*aD 1 ]`\`\gb,\E qV T +*-*b\ TZjSfE a]\,O Zq2bnaq /\ Z*yY1ZjSf ]\/`\+SgnD \3 /\O ,T`Gq /\ \3\^ \+TgqZVS ]\VTZhSbS 4 Z1O a]`*,1/WS,Tabp *3 ZTqV Z1 a,T/hSbn ]`\ Z*^,ZTabnD \- ,SV\Z*2 a,Ty Z*YT`D )V a*O Y1H `\ g1 ]T/1 Y\,* d Z*abd]ZTy ab*bbTD

" ˚˙ ı w 1Z1 \+d`p,*, `*aS4YE ,TyZSE +T/O ZTabn b* TZjT ,Sq,S Z1a]`*,1/WS,\aO bTD ) jdV*W* ,S`Tj1ZZq gSf ]`\+O W1YEP ]`S-*/d2 *y/1 4T " EP b\Yd ]`S2/Z*W*an /\ `dfd 4* -`\Y*O /qZanVT ]`*,*E * 4-\/\Y P /\ ]\WTO bShZ\^ ]*`bT^D W1 ab*W\ \h1,S/ZSYE k\ ,a1 g1 Z1 ]`SZ\aSbn Tab\bZSf 4YTZD 1ZT 4/*,*W\aqE k\ ]\b`T+ZT +TWnj `*/SV*WnZT 4YTZSE T `df fT]T ,a1Wq, d Y1Z1 Z*/TpD ,bTYE ]T4ZTj1 q `\4O h*`d,*W*an T , Zn\YdD *-*bn\f fT]T +TWnj1 gTV*,S, a1VaE Z*`V\bSVS T YdO 4SV*E ZT3 4YTZS , ada]TWnab,TD \WS q g1 da,T/\YSW*E Y1Z1 \f\]SW* /1]`1O aTqD b\y h*a q ]\4Z*y\YSW*an 4 3TZO V\pE V\b`* +dW* ,T/V\Y -\,SD \Z* ]\V*4*W* Y1ZT , T+WT^E qVT 4YTZS \Y*2 Z*YT` 4/TyaZSbSE T ]`\hSb*W* /1O VTWnV* +T+WTyZSf d`S,VT,E 4\V`1Y*

+Gq,W1ZZq 65B7E 8D *Y -\,\`SbnaqE k\ \- ,Sb`1 ,aT aWn\4S 4 Wp/anVSf \h1y b* dadZ1 3*W\+dE -\W\aTZZq T +TWnE qVT Z1`T/V\ 2 Z*aWT/V*YS Z1O a]`*,1/WS,\abTD ) 4*]Sbd,*W* a1+1B r 1,31 g1 ]`*,/*Hs \^ adYZT,S `\4,TqWSanE V\WS q /TO 4Z*W*aq 4 T+WT^ ]`\ \3d aSWd b* WpO +\, T ]\+*hSW* gp Wp+\, a1`1/ ,T/O VT, -\,SD 1]1` q 4 Z1b1`]TZZqY h1V*p a]\,Z1ZZq \3Sf \+TgqZ\VxD

ı ˚˙ ı ]T/ ]`*,WTZZqY \3\-\ d`q/d ı

ı• ı ]`\`\gb,* -\,\`qbnE k\ \Z1,/\,4T 4*YTZSbn b1]1`TjZTy a,Tb Z\O ,SYD gn\Yd Z\,\Yd a,TbT +d/1 WSj1 \/SZ d`q/ P \31 *`ab,\E Z* h\WT qV\-\ ab\qO bSY1 g*` ıada `Sab\a L +Gq,W1ZZq 55B59MD )V \31 *`ab,\ ,SV\`1ZSbn Z1a]`*,1/O WS,TabnH \Z\ 4*,/*abn gTy 4WTy aSab1YT ]\/,TyZ\-\ d/*`dD

5D \31 *`ab,\ ]\VW*/1 V`*y Z1a]`*O ,1/WS,\Yd b* Z1,YTW\Yd Wp/anV\Yd ]`*,WTZZpD ˙*ZS^W* 6B88 Z*]Sa*Z\B w˛* /ZT, bSf g*`T, d`q/T, 1+1aZSy \- ]\O ab*,Sbn g*`ab,\DDD \Z\ ]\b\,h1 y ]\VTZO hSbn daT bT ,ab*Z\,W1ZT Wp/nYS g*`ab,*E * a*Y\ +d/1 ab\qbS Z*,TVSxD

6D \31 *`ab,\ 4ZSkSbn 4WSf T 4+1O `131 a]`*,1/WS,SfD an k\ aV*4*Z\ d a*WYT 7;B5>B w#1 b`\fS P y Z1 +d/1 +14O +\3Z\-\xD 6<Oy ,T`j -\,\`SbnB w p+Sbn \a]\/n a]`*,1/WS,TabnE T TZ +\-\+TyZSf ,\^f Z1 ]\VSZ1EP ,\ZS +d/dbn Z*,TVS +1O `131ZTxD

\-\+\q4WS,T Wp/S ]\+*h*bn a]\,Z1ZZq aWT,E qVT ıada ]`\Y\,S, d Y\WSb,T w bO h1 Z*jxD TZ ]`\aS,B w 1f*y ]`Sy/1 b,\2 g*`ab,\D 1f*y ,SV\Zd2bnaq b,\q ,\Wq qV Z* Z1+TE b*V T Z* 41YWTx L *b,Tq :B5>MD , h\Yd ]\Wq-*2 ,\Wq \-* k\/\ 41YWTH

* 41YWT ]T/ ]`*,WTZZqY

\3\-\ *`ab,*DDD

1 +d/1 V\`d]gT^ b* dbSaVdD ,`1^, 5B= ]`\ ıada* -\,\`SbnaqB w S ]\Wp+S, ]`*O ,1/ZTabn T 4Z1Z*,S/T, +144*V\ZZqE b\Yd <

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

\-E b,Ty \-E ]\Y*4*, b1+1 \WT2p ,1O WSV\^ `*/\abT +TWnj1E ZT3 b,\^f b\,*`SO jT,xD ıada +d/1 a]`*,1/WS,SY `*,Sb1O W1YE T w,S4,\WSbn ,TZ +T/*`qE k\ -\W\aSbnE b* ,+\-\-\E k\ Z1Y*2 a\+T /\]\Y\-SIDD T/ V`S,/S y Z*aSWWq ,`qbd2 ^fZp /djdE ^fZq V`\, /\`\-* +d/1 , \h*f y\-\Ix L a*W\Y ;6B56P58MD

aT Y*bSYdbn d/\ab*Wn ^3TD `\ b\y h*a

d T+WT^ aV*4*Z\B w˛1YWq ,`\3*y a,Ty /*O W*EP \- ]\+W*-\aW\,S, Z*aE Z*j \-Ix L a*W\Y :;B;MD w * 41YWT +d/1 4+T33q +*O -*b\E Z* -T`anV\Yd ,1`fd 4*jdYSbnDDD y\-\ ]WT/x L a*W\Y ;6B5:MD ıada VTWnV* `*4T, hdO /\Y Z*-\/d,*, bSaqhT Wp/1yD 1 ]\V*4d2E qVT /TW* ,TZ 4/TyaZSbn 4* /\]\Y\-\p \3\O -\ *`ab,* L *b,Tq 58B59P65C 59B76P7<MD

Tfb\ 4 Wp/1y Z1 4*,*/Sbn ,ab*Z\,W1ZO Zp a]`*,1/WS,\abTD w 1Y*2 b*V\-\ ab,\O `TZZqE qV1 +dW\ + Z1,S/SY1 /Wq n\-\ \O -* E *W1 ,a1 Z*-1 y ]\,ZTabp ,T/V`Sb1 ]1`1/ \hSY* •\-\ P \-\E V\Yd 4/*Y\ 4,Tbx L ,O `1^, 8B57MD ]`\ `Sab* d T+WT^ aV*4*Z\B w TZ Z1 Z* ]\-Wq/ \h1y a,\^f +d/1 ad/SbSE T Z1 Z* ]\aWdf dj1y ,\^f +d/1 `Tj*bSE *W1 +d/1 ad/SbS d+\-Sf 4* ]`*,/\pE T ]`*,\O ad//q hSZSbSY1 aWdjZ\ adYS`ZSY 41YWTx Lıa*^ 55B7E 8MD

T/ ]`*,WTZZqY \3\-\ *`ab,* Wp/ab,\ Y*bSY1 ,/\ab*Wn ^3TD * 41YWT ]*Zd,*bSY1 a]`*,1/WS,Tabn T Z1 +d/1 d]1`1/31Zn

14*+*`\Y *`ab,\ ]\hZ1 ]`*,SbSI ,Tb ab*2 /1/*WT -T`jSYE T g1 a,T/hSbn ]`\ y\-\ +WS4nVSy VTZ1gnD w \WS Z1a]`*,1/WSO ,T `\abdbnE qV b`*,*E T g,Tbdbn ,aT 4W\hSZgTE b\ Z* b1E k\+ Z*,TVS +dWS ,\ZS 4ZSk1ZTxEP 4*]Sa*Z\ d a*WYT =6B<D )V ,*Y dZSVZdbS

\3\-\ \ad/d b* +dbS a1`1/ bSfE V\Yd \4+1`131 3SbbqH ıada `Sab\a aV*4*,B w#\+ \b`SY*bS ,ThZ1 3SbbqE ]\b`T+Z\ ]T4Z*,*bS

˚ ˝ ) ˛˙ & ) ˚ ˚˙ ˚YTWTE V\b`* 3S,1 d " E ,Sq,SWS W1yV1YTp k1 , aTY `\VT,D \/T qV ^^ /`d4T h*a ,T/ h*ad Y*WS 4*abd/d hS f,\`TWS Z* -`S]E ˚YTWT /\,\/SW\an `\V*YS a1`y\4Z\

b1+1E 2/SZ\-\ ]`*,/S,\-\ \-*E T ]\aW*Z\-\ b\+\p ıada* `Sab*x Lı,*Z* 5;B7MD S f\bTWS + ,S Y*bS b*V1 gTZZ1 4Z*ZZqH ,T/VS -\,S 4 `*/Tabp /\]\Y\3dbn ,*Y y\-\ Z*+dbSE qV /\]\Y\-WS *y/1E ˙\`\bT T T`d//TZdD \ZS `*/\ Z*/*/dbn ,*Y ,T/O ]\,T/T Z* ,*jT 4*]Sb*ZZqD *VT \+-\,\`1ZO Zq +14]W*bZT T ZT /\ h\-\ ,*a Z1 4\+\,Gq4dO ,*bSYdbnD

WTVd,*bSanE d b\Yd hSaWT ]`\f\/SbS Vd`aS fTYT\b1`*]T^D \Z* V*31B w 1yV1YTq P g1 ab`*jZ\Ix \h* 3Sbbq 4*,/*W\ ˚YTWT ,*3V\-\ d/*O `dE ,\Z* Z1 ,]*/*2 , `\4]*hD ˙T,hSZ* h1V*2 h*adE V\WS ]T/ ]`*,WTZZqY \3\-\ *`abO ,* wZ1 aV*31 Y1jV*Z1gn r) f,\`SyIsx Lıa*^ 77B68MD w \^Y dWp+W1ZSY ,T`j1YEP `\4O ]\,T/*2 ˚YTWTEP 2 *`V* 56B7>B r p+S

-\,dE \-* a,\-\E ,aTY a1`g1YE ,aT2p /dO j1pE ,aTY `\4dY\Y b* ,aT2p aSW\p a,\2psD \WS Y\Wpaq /\ -\,SE ,TZ /*2 Y1ZT aSWSD ) /qVdp y\Yd 4* aTYGpE 4+T` T Z*/Tp Z* ,ThZ1 3Sbbq , *p Z* 41YWTD q Z*/Tq Y1Z1 /d31 4YTgZp2xD

)˙ ı ıı

w `*,/* 4`\+Sbn ,*a ,TWnZSYSxD #\ g1 \4Z*h*2H ı &• Wp/1y ,,*3*pbn a1+1 ,TWnO ZSYSE f\h* Z*a]`*,/T g1 Z1 b*VD *O ]`SVW*/E +*-*b\ 4 ZSf ]1`1+d,*2 , ]\W\ZT 4*+\+\ZT,D ˙1fb\ Y*2 ab`*f ]1`1/ ]\Y1`WSO YS T ab*`*2bnaq 4*/\+`SbS ^f /\`\-SYS ]\O /*`dZV*YSD ıZjT ]*ZThZ\ +\qbnaq aY1`bTE */31 Z1 4Z*pbnE k\ Z* ZSf h1V*2E V\WS ,\O ZS ]\Y`dbnD T ab`*fS ,]WS,*pbn Z* YSaO W1ZZq T ]\hdbbq Wp/1yE * b\ y +Gpbn ]\ VSj1ZTD S Y\3Z* 4,TWnZSbSaq ,T/ gSf ab`*fT,H ,313I ˛ ıada\,Sf aWT,E Z*,1/1O ZSf d Z*4,T gT2^ ab*bbTE ,S/Z\E k\ VWph1Y /\ a,\+\/S 2 ]`*,/*D W1 ]`\ qVd ]`*,/d y/1bnaqH *Y ıada ]\qaZS,B w)Vk\ ,S T /*WT ]1O `1+d,*bSY1b1 , Y\^y Z*dgTE b\ a]`*,/T +d/1b1 Y\^YS dhZqYSD S ]T4Z*2b1 ]`*,O /dE T ]`*,/* 4`\+Sbn ,*a ,TWnZSYSx Lı,*O Z* <B75E 76MD *dVd ıada* Y\3Z* 4Z*ybS , T+WT^D \WS ıada aV*4*,B w `*,/* 4`\+Sbn ,*a ,TWnZSYSxE b\ Z*a*Y]1`1/ Y*, Z* d,*O 4T 4,TWnZ1ZZq ,T/ -`Tf* b* aY1`bTD `*,/* 4 \3\-\ W\,* b*V\3 4,TWnZq2 Z*a ,T/ 4*O +\+\ZT,E ab`*fd ]1`1/ ]\Y1`WSYS T Z*/YT`O Z\-\ ab`*fd ]1`1/ aY1`bpD \Yd Y\3Z* b*V aV*4*bSH 5D ˛,TWnZ1ZZq ,T/ 4*+\+\ZT,D *-*b\ fb\ ,T`SbnE k\ ]1,ZT ]`1/Y1bS *+\ hSaW* ]`SO Z\aqbn Z1k*abqD ıZjT Wp/S Z1 ]`SyY*pbn ,*3WS,Sf `Tj1ZnE ]\VS Z1 \b`SY*pbn /\+O `\-\ 4Z*Vd *+\ Z1 ]\/S,Wqbnaq , -\`\aO V\] hS Z1 ]\`*/qbnaq 4 bSYE fb\ ,SVWSV*2 /dfT,D )V T+WTq 4,TWnZq2D +T+WTyZT h*aS /1fb\ 4 \3\-\ Z*`\/d ]\b`*]S, ]T/ ,]WS, 4*+\O +\ZT, T Z*,Tbn ]\h*, ]\VW\ZqbSaq +\-*Y

5>

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

d/*hT y /\WTD #\ /dY*, ]`\ g1 \- -\,*H an qV ,TZ \gTZS, ^fZT /T^B w \+SWS WSf1 , \^f \h*fx Lıa*^ :9B55E 56MD *VSy a*YSy ]\-Wq/ ,TZ Y*, T Z* bSfE fb\ 4,1`b*,aq 4* ]\`*/*YS /\ Wp/1yE qVT ,SVWSV*WS /dfT,D T+WT^ -\,\`SbnaqB w S/\b* /Wq \a]\/* V\31ZE fb\ hSZSbn b*V1x L \,b\`1ZZq ˛*O V\Zd 5<B55E 56MD T`* , 4*+\+\ZS T 4,1`Z1ZZq /\ bSfE fb\ ,SVWSV*2 /dfT, ]\Y1`WSfE 4*,/*pbn WpO /qY jV\/SE */31 2 wfSb`\k*YS ˙Sq,\W*xE qV\-\ ıada Z*4,*, w+*bnV\Y +`1fZTx L˚e1O aqZ :B55C ı,*Z* <B88MD S 4,1`ZdWSaq + ,S /\ +`1fdZ*E jdV*phS ]\`*/S d ,*3WS,Ty a]`*,TH ˛,Sh*yZ\E ZTD \3 +dW\ + Yd/`\ dZSV*bS ,an\-\E k\ ]\,Gq4*Z1 4 w+*bnV\Y +`1fZTxD +S Z*jT `Tj1ZZq +dWS ,/*WSYSE YS ]\b`1+d2Y\ Yd/`\abTE qV* š`dZbd2bnaq Z* b\hZ\Yd 4Z*ZZT +T+WTyZSf ]`SZgS]T, T \O 3\-\ Z*YT`d k\/\ Wp/ab,*D `S]\,Tab1y 6B: aV*4*Z\B w \a]\/n /*2 Yd/`TabnE 4 •\-\ dab P 4Z*ZZq y `\4dYxD

6D ˛,TWnZ1ZZq ,T/ ab`*fd ]1`1/ ]\Y1`O WSYSD SY*W\ Wp/1y ,T`SbnE k\ w/dfSx ]\Y1`WSf ]`1/VT, Y*pbn ,]WS, Z* ^fO Z2 3SbbqD \ZS ,,*3*pbnE k\ gSf w/dO fT,x b`1+* 4*/\+`p,*bS ,aTWqVSYS /*`*O YSE TZ*Vj1 bT `\4-ZT,*pbnaqD `14dWnb*bT /1fb\ ,W*4Sbn d +\`-SE k\+ ]\V`SbS ,Sb`*O bS Z* 31`b,S T /\`\-T `Sbd*WSD )V T+WTq 4,TWnZq2D \31 W\,\ `\4V`SO ,*2 ]`*,/d ]`\ ab*Z ]\Y1`WSfD *]`SVW*/E ıada aV*4*,E k\ ]\Y1`WT wa]Wqbnx Lı,*Z* 55B55E 58MD #\ ,TZ Y*, Z* d,*4TH T/]\O ,T/n Y\3Z* ]`\hSb*bS , ˚VVW14Tqab* =B9E /1 Z*]Sa*Z\B w˛Z*pbn 3S,TE k\ ]\Y`dbnE

T+WTyZ* ]`*,/* 4,TWnZq2 Wp/1y ,T/ 4*+\+\ZT,E ab`*fd ]1`1/ ]\Y1`WSYS T Z*/YT`Z\-\ ab`*fd ]1`1/ aY1`bp * ]\Y1`WT ZTh\-\ Z1 4Z*pbnxD ı a]`*,/TE Y1`b,TE Z*h1 d -WS+\V\Yd aZTE ZTh\-\ Z1 da,T/\YWppbnD \ZS ]1`1ab*WS TaZd,*bSE b\Yd Z1 Y\3dbn `\+SbS Z*Y *ZT /\+`*E *ZT 4W*D /Z*V /1fb\ b,1`/SbnE ZT+S a]TWVd,*,aq 4 ]\Y1`WSYSD )V g1 Y\3WS,\H T+WTq 4Z\O ,d /*2 ,T/]\,T/nD ZTy `\4]\,T/*2bnaqE k\ Z* ]\h*bVd Wp/anV\^ Tab\`T^ /1qVT *Z-1WS 4+dZbd,*WSaq ]`\bS \-* L6 1b`* 6B8MD T 4WT /dfSE *+\ /1Y\ZSE Z*Y*-*pbnaq ,,\/SO bS Wp/ab,\ , \Y*Zd L5 SY\eTq 8B5MD /SZ 4T a]\a\+T, P ,S/*,*bS a1+1 4* ]\Y1`WSfD *V ,\ZS ]\jS`ppbn +`1fZpE ZT+S Y1`b,T Z*a]`*,/T ]`\/\,3dpbn TaZd,*bS , TZjTy e\`YT 3Sbbq *+\ , TZj\Yd a,TbTD

7D ˛,TWnZ1ZZq ,T/ Z*/YT`Z\-\ ab`*fd ]1O `1/ aY1`bpD T+WTq Z*4S,*2 aY1`bn ,\`\O

-\Y L5 \`SZeqZ 59B6:MD \3 ]`S`\/Z\E k\ YS +\^Y\aq ^^ b* ]`*-Z1Y\ ,T/,1`ZdbSD `\O b1 Z*Y Z1 aWT/ Y*bS Z*/YT`Z\-\ ab`*fdD )V T+WTq 4,TWnZq2D \31 W\,\ Z1 bTWnVS `\4V`S,*2 ]`*,/d ]`\ ab*Z ]\Y1`WSfE *W1 y `\4]\,T/*2 ]`\ \3Sy Z*YT` ]\,1`ZdO bS Y1`b,Sf /\ 3Sbbq h1`14 ,\aV`1aTZZqD w */f\/Sbn h*aEP V*4*, ıadaEP V\WS ,aTE fb\ ]1`1+d,*2 , ]*YGqbZSf -`\+ZSgqfE ]\O hdpbn y\-\ `Sab* -\W\a T ,Sy/dbnx Lı,*O Z* 9B6<E 6=C ˙T^ 68B59MD \WS ]\Y1`WT w,Sy/dbnxE b\ qVSYS ,\ZS +d/dbnH ˛`\4dYTbS g1 /\]\Y\3dbn ]`SVW*O /S ,\aV`1aTZZqE qV1 4/TyaZp,*, ıadaD aTE V\-\ ,TZ \3S,Wq,E ]\,1`b*WSan /\ 3SbO bq b*VSYSE qVSYS +dWS /\ aY1`bT L *`V* 9B79P86C dVS ;B55P5;C ı,*Z* 55B87E 88MD ˙\ `1hTE a*Y1 aW\,\ w,\aV`1aTZZqx , ]1`1VW*/T 4 -`1gnV\^ +dV,*WnZ\ \4Z*h*2 w,ab*,*bSxD ,\2Yd WTbZn\Yd aWd3Sb1Wp ˙*ZS^Wd \aV*4*,B w T/]\hSZ1jE T ,ab*Z1j Z* a,\p /\Wp ]T/ VTZ1gn bSf /ZT,x L˙*ZS^W* 56B57MD )V 31 gT aW\,*E Y*+dbnE ]\bTjSWS ˙*ZS^W* T /\]\Y\-WS y\Yd 4dab`TbS aY1`bn Yd3Zn\ b* 4 -T/ZTabpI /ZSY T4 4*,/*Zn ıada* +dW\ w]`\]\,T/dO ,*bS ]\W\Z1ZSY ,S4,\W1ZZqx L dVS 8B5<MD aVTWnVS y\-\ ,h1ZZq 4*]Sa*ZT , T+WT^E ,\ZS ]`\/\,3dpbn k\/Zq 4,TWnZqbS WpO /1y 4 ]\W\Zd e*WnjS,Sf dh1ZnD S kS`\ a]\/T,*2Y\anE k\ ]`*,/* 4 \3\-\ W\,* ,S4,\WSbn T ,*aD

& ı H

)V ]`*,/* 4 T+WT^ 4,TWnZq2 Z*a ,T/DDD ˘ 4*+\+\ZT,H Lıa*^ <B5=E 6>C :9B55E 56M ˘ ab`*fd ]1`1/ Y1`b,SYSH L˚VVW14Tqab* =B9C ı,*Z* 55B55E 58M ˘ ab`*fd ]1`1/ aY1`bpH Lı,*Z* 9B6<E 6=C ˙T^ 68B59M

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

55

w g1

ZTaIx ˚ b*V `1*-dpbn Wp/SE V\WS ,]1`j1 +*h*bn /\,-Sy YGqaSabSy ZTa a*Ygq Z\O a*h*1D p Y*,]d k1 Z*4S,*pbn V*f*dD Ta a*Ygq Y\31 ,S`\abS *3 /\ 5< a*ZbSY1bO `T, P ]`S+WS4Z\ h,1`bT /\,3SZS y\-\ bTO W*D aVTWnVS g1y wf\+\bx Z*,Sa*2 Z*/ `\O b\Y b* ]T/+\`T//qY b,*`SZSE ,\Z* YdaSbn ,T/ad,*bS y\-\ ,+TVE V\WS ^abnD )V+S ,S Y*WS ZTa b*V\^ ]`\]\`gT^E ,TZ 4,Sa*, +S /\ a1`1/SZS ,*jSf -`d/1yD ˙Wq h\-\ a*Ygp V*f*d b*VSy ZTaH2 ıaO Zd2 VTWnV* ]`S]dk1ZnD \3WS,\E g1y \`O -*Z ,S,\/Sbn Z*/WSj\V b1]W* *+\ 3 /\O /*2 4,dhZ\abT -\W\adD #1 \/Z* /dYV*B ZTa aWd3Sbn 4Z*V\Y ]1`1ab\`\-S /Wq TZjSf a*YgT,D ı a]`*,/TE V\WS ,*b*3\V `\4/`*O b\,*ZSyE y\-\ ZTa Z*+`qV*2 b* h1`,\ZT2D ˙1fb\ ,,*3*2E k\ ZTa ]`S,*+Wp2 a*Y\VE 4YdjdphS ^fZ2 a1`g1 +SbSaq j,S/j1D ,bTYE ZTa V*f*dE Y*+dbnE ,SV\Zd2 /1O VTWnV* edZVgTyD `\ /1qVT 4 ZSf YS 4Z*2O Y\ Y*W\E * b\ y ZTh\-\D

`d-W1ZnVT 3S,\bSVS

5 Peter Lilja/age fotostock

*,]S Z\a*hT Y*pbn hSY*WSy ZTa T ]d4\

56

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

*,]S Z\a*hT ,S`T4Zqpbnaq k1 TZO j\p ]\YTbZ\p \4Z*V\p P hSY*WSY ]dO 4\YD YTab ^fZn\-\ jWdZV* Y\31 ,*3SbS h,1`bn ,*-S ^fZn\-\ bTW*D 1`14 g1 T a*YgTE T a*YVS ,S-Wq/*pbn w,ThZ\x ,*-TbZSYSD \Yd , ZSf b*VSy 3S,TbH "WdZ\V V*f*dE qV T , V\`\,SE Z*]\,O Z1ZSy `T/V\p adYTjjp `\aWSZZ\^ ^3T b* +*Vb1`TyD ab*ZZT ,SVWSV*pbn +`\/TZZq y `\4k1]Wppbn VWTbV\,SZdE * b*V\3 ]1,ZT `\aWSZZT b\VaSZSE qVT /Wq TZjSf b,*`SZ 1 *,]* Z\a*h 3S,1 Z* \ab`\,T \`Z1\D Tag1,T 3Sb1O WT Z*4S,*pbn ^^ \`*Zš +1W*Z/*E b\+b\ w-\WW*Z/1gnxD 2 *YVS b13 Y*pbn ,1WSh1ZnVSy ZTaE *W1 Z1 b*VSyE qV d a*YgT,D

+dWS + aY1`b1WnZSYSD ˛*,/qVS gTy hd/\O ,Ty aSab1YT b`*,W1ZZq Z\a*hT Y\3dbn f*`O hd,*bSaq WSabqYE Z1a\W\/VSYS e`dVb*O YSE +\+\,SY hS ]*WnY\,SY Z*aTZZqY b* TZjSYS `\aWSZ*YSD * b*VTy ^3T TZjT ]`SO Y*bS /\,-\ Z1 ]`\bq-ZdWS +D ı ,a1 3 ]\bd3Z* b`*,Z* aSab1Y* Z\a*O hT, Y*2 Z1/\WTVD ,*`SZ*Y Z1 Y\3Z* ^aO bS a\W\/VSf e`dVbT,E */31 bT ]\hSZ*pbn j,S/V\ +`\/SbSD )Vk\ Y*,]* 4G^abn b*VSy e`dVbE ^^ 3S,Tb `\4/d2bnaqE k\ Z*,Tbn Y\O 31 a]`ShSZSbS +\WTaZd aY1`bnD aVTWnVS V*f*d Y*pbn \a\+WS,Sy jWdO Z\V T ^fZTy `*gT\Z +*-*bSy Z* VWTbV\,SZdE b`*,W1ZZq ^3T 4*+S`*2 +*-*b\ h*adD \3 ]TaWq aSbZ\-\ aZT/*ZVd Y*,]*Y V\Zh1 b`1O +* ]\/`TY*bSE TZ\/T ]`\bq-\Y /1VTWnV\f -\/SZD

5 Juniors Bildarchiv/Alamy

da]TWnZ* b,*`SZ* \a*hT, `T/V\ ]\+*hSj Z*\/SZgTE f\h +S k\ ,\ZS `\+SWS P ^WS hS ,T/]\hS,*WSD *YgTOWT/1`S \h\Wppbn -*`1Y 4 Y*VaSO YdY ,\anYS a*Y\V b* Y\W\/ZqV*D \WS Y\W\/T a*YgT ]T/`\ab*pbnE ^f ,S-*Zqpbn 4 -`d]SE T ,\ZS ]\hSZ*pbn a*Y\abTyZ1 3SbbqD \/T ,\ZS \+G2/Zdpbnaq 4 TZjSYS Y\W\/SYS a*YgqYS d 4-`*pE /1 -\W\,d2 \/SZ *+\ /,\2 +TWnjSf V*f*dD 1/\a,T/O h1Z1 \V\ Y\31 ]1`1]Wdb*bS b*Vd -`d]d 4 -*`1Y\YD ]\,1/TZgT Z\a*hT, 2 k1 TZj* gTV*,* \a\+WS,TabnB ^fZT -*`1YS h*ab\ 4YTjdpbnO

aqE 4\V`1Y* ,1h\`*YSE V\WS 4+S`*pbnaq +TWq `Th\VD )Vk\ \/Z\Yd 4 a*YgT, 4/*O 2bnaqE k\ TZjSy gTV*,Sbnaq y\-\ w3TZO V*YSxE ,TZ /1Y\Zab`d2 a,\p aSWdD ˛*O 4,Sh*y g1y ab`S,\31ZSy a*Y1gn P * ,TZ Y\31 ,*3SbS +WS4nV\ 6> VTW\-`*YT, P ab*2 Z* h\bS`S W*]SE ,S]SZ*2bnaq ,]1`1/ 4 jS`\V\ ,T/V`Sb\p ]*k1p T ,Sb`Tk*2bnO aq Z* ad]1`ZSV*D w)Vk\ g1 Z1 a]`*,Wq2 ,`*31ZZqEP -\,\`Sbnaq , VZS3gT w \a*O hT \`Z1\xEP a*Y1gn `T4V\ y Z1a]\/T,*O Z\ ]\hSZ*2 aV*V*bS ]\ /1`1,*f b* -dhZ\ V`Sh*bSD 1`T/V\ ,TZ ]`S41YWq2bnaq Z* adfSf -TWV*fE V\b`T W*Y*pbnaq 4 \-WdjO WS,SY b`TaV\YE ab,\`pphS k1 +TWnj1 jdO Ydx LwProboscis Monkeys of BorneoxMD ıZ\/T ab*pbnaq +TyVSE *W1 /\ gn\-\ `T/V\ /\f\O /SbnD w \a*hT /S,ZT Z1 WSj1 4 ,S-Wq/dE ,\ZS k1 y ,S/*pbn gTWSy `q/ Z14,Sh*yZSf 4,dO VT,xEP -\,\`Sbnaq d ,Sk14-*/*ZTy VZS4TD T Y*,]S `\fV*pbnE `1,dbnE `Sh*bn T ,1`1O k*bnE \a\+WS,\ ,,1h1`T +TWq ,\/SD 1`1/ b*V\^ V*V\e\ZT^ Y*YS a]\VTyZ\ -\/dpbn T h1]d`qbn a,\^f aSZn\WSgSf Y*WqbD *O `1jbTE V\WS WTa \-\`b*pbn adbTZVSE b,*`SO ZS -\bdpbnaq /\ aZdD \ZS ,Y\kdpbnaq Z* /1`1,*f P 4*4,Sh*y g1 ,Sa\VT /1`1,* V\W\ `ThVSD

*,]* 4 ]1`1bSZh*abSYS W*]*YS *f*d Y*pbn Z1 bTWnVS hd/1`Z*gnVSy ZTaE *W1 y W*]SE Z* qVSf VTWnV* ]*WngT,

Ta a*Ygq Z*,Sa*2 Z*/ `\b\YE b\Yd y\-\ b`1+* ,T/ad,*bS ]T/ h*a ^/S

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

57

\a*hT, `T/V\ ]\+*hSj Z*\/SZgTE f\h +S k\ ,\ZS `\+SWS P ^WS hS ,T/]\hS,*WS

T/ 4*-`\4\p ,SYS`*ZZq \a*hT ,Z1a1ZT /\ a]SaVd ,S/T,E qVSY 4*-`\3d2 ,SYS`*ZZqD ]`S`\/T ^f 4*WSO jSW\an WSj1 VTWnV* bSaqhE T ^fZ2 hSaW\ ]\abTyZ\ 4Y1Zjd2bnaq P -\W\,Z\ 4 ,SZS Wp/SZSD \313TE WTa\4*-\bT,WqE Z1V\ZbO `\Wn\,*ZSy bd`S4YE ,S`d+V* WTaT, ]T/

5D VSZTq LZ*Y1bME qV* ]\V`S,*W* V\,h1-D 6D `e*D 7D d`Y*D 8D =5 >>>D 9D D ıË™ ıË™ı Ë™ ı 7>E 75

58

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

]W*Zb*gT^ \WTyZ\^ ]*WnYS ZSk*bn ]`SO `\/Z1 a1`1/\,Sk1 V*f*dD ıfZq ]\]dWqgTq aV\`\hd2bnaq T ,Z*aWT/\V ]\Wp,*ZZqD Ë™1O fb\ ,+S,*2 Z\a*hT, ]`\ab\ 4*/Wq `\4,*O -SE TZjT P 4*`*/S YGqa* hS ,S-\b\,W1ZZq b`*/SgTyZSf WTVT,D T Y*,]S \a\+WS,\ +144*fSaZTE \aVTWnVS a]Wqbn Z* /1`1,*f ]\+WS4d `Th\VE /1 ^f /\+`1 ,S/Z\D \/O ZTy YTag1,\abTE Vd/S Z* Y\b\`ZSf h\,O Z*f h*ab\ Z*,T/d,*WSaq YSaWS,gTE VTWnO VTabn V*f*d 4* ]Gqbn `\VT, 4Y1ZjSW*an d/,ThTD `S`\/\\f\`\ZgT Z*Y*-*pbnaq /\]\Y\O -bS Wp/qY da,T/\YSbSE , qV\Yd 3*Wp-T/O Z\Yd ab*Z\,SkT \]SZSWSaq gT b,*`SZSD * \ab`\,T \`Z1\ Z\a*hT \f\`\Zqpbnaq 4*V\Z\YD S g1 ^f ,`qbd2H *a ]\V*31D )Vk\ V*f*d 4ZSVZdbnE YS /d31 +*-*b\ ,b`*bSY\E */31 gT Y*,]S P a]`*,3Z2 /SO ,\ ]`S`\/SD Sbd*gTp ]\-T`jd2 T b1E k\ ,\ZS ]\-*Z\ ]\hd,*pbnaq , Z1,\WTD Ë›,Sh*yZ\E Z\a*h P WSj1 \/SZ 4 +*-*O bn\f ,S/T, b,*`SZE V\b`SY 4*-`\3d2 ,SO YS`*ZZqD SY*W\ TZjSf ,S/T, d31 4ZSVO W\D W1 2 /\+`* Z\,SZ*D 1,/\,4T \,T/Z\,Sbn ]\,ZSy V\Zb`\Wn Z*/ 41YW1pE dadZ1 4WSf Wp/1y T Z*,hSbn a,\^f aWd3SO b1WT, ]`*,SWnZ\ -\a]\/*`p,*bS Z* ]W*Z1O bT L `S]\,Tab1y 6B65E 66MD -\,* \+Tgq2B w 1 ,hSZqbn WSf\-\ b* jV\/S Z1 4`\+Wqbn Z* ,aTy a,qbTy \^y -\`TE +\ 41YWq +d/1 ]\,Z* ]T4Z*ZZq \a]\/Zn\-\ b*VE qV Y\`1 ,\/* ]\V`S,*2x Lıa*^ 55B=MD

5 Peter Lilja/age fotostock

4G2/Z*ZT ]1`1bSZV*YSD Ë›*,/qVS gn\Yd Z\O a*hT /\+`1 ]W*,*pbnE * b*V\3 Z1 -`d4Zdbn d +*-ZpgT Y*Z-`\,Sf 4*`\ab1yD *`b\ Z*O -*/*bSE k\ d ,\/*f b`\]ThZSf Y*Z-`\,Sf WTaT, ,\/qbnaq V`\V\/SWSD )V 31 Z\a*h*Y ,/*2bnaq dZSVZdbS Z1]`S2YZSf 4dab`Th1y 4 gSYS fS3*V*YSH *,]S bSf1ZnV\ 4*f\/qbn d ,\/d T ZS4O V\pE \/Z* 4* \/Z\pE ]1`1bSZ*pbn `ThO VdD \ZS ]WS,dbn ]\Oa\+*h\YdE Y*y31 Z1 4/TyY*phS +`S3T,D )Vk\ 3 `ThV* ,d4nV*E V*f*d ,/*pbnaq /\ TZj\^ b*VbSVSD \ZS ,SW*4qbn Z* /1`1,*E 4 `\4-\Zd ab`S+*pbn 4 -TWVSE ]`\WTb*pbn Z*/ ,\/\p +WS4nV\ = Y1b`T,E ]Wpf*pbnaq 3S,\b*YS , `ThVd T k\/dfd ]WS,dbn `1jbd /Sab*ZgT^D 1 `\+Wqbn Z*,Tbn a*YSgTE b`SY*phS Y*WqbD ıZ\/T d ,\/d aV*h1 gTW* -`d]* P T Y1`kTy /\ +1`1-*I ,bTYE Z*y+TWnjSy ,\`\- Z\a*O hT, P Z1 V`\V\/SWD

5

6

7

8

9

:

;

<

ı ı)

w *`\/\Y ,1WSVSY b1+1 ) ,hSZpx q a1`Tq 4 ,\anYS ab*b1y ]`Sa,qh1Z* \a\+O WS,\abTE qV* ,S`T4Zq2 T+WTp 4O]\YT3 daTf TZO jSf VZS-EP ^^ ]`\`\gb,*YE *+\ ]1`1/`1h1ZO ZqYD S +T+WTyZT ]`\`\gb,* P WSj1 ,Sb,T` Wp/anV\-\ `\4dYdH S 2 /\V*4S b\-\E k\ ,\ZS +dWS Z*bfZ1ZT \-\YH ˛*\f\hd2Y\ ,*a `\4-WqZdbS ZS3h1]\/*ZT e*VbSE k\+ \b`SY*O bS ,T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZqD

˚ ( \4Z*V\p Z*j\-\ h*ad 2 aV1]bSgS4Y T adYZT,SD *VSy dY\Z*abO `Ty b*V\3 ,]WS,*2 Z* ab*,W1ZZq Wp/1y /\

T+WT^D * 3*WnE +*-*b\ fb\ e\`Yd2 a,\p /dYVd ]`\ gp VZS-d Z* \aZ\,T ]\hdb\-\ ,T/ TZjSf b* Z1 ]`S/TWq2 /\ab*bZn\ h*ad Z* ^^ š`dZb\,Z1 /\aWT/31ZZqD ]\/T,*2Y\anE ,S Y*2b1 TZ*VjSy ]T/fT/D ˛*]`\jd2Y\ ,*a 4/TyaZSbS ]\/\`\3 d YSZdW1 T `\4-WqZdO bS e*VbSE V\b`T /\]\Y\3dbn ]1`1V\Z*bSan d /\ab\,T`Z\abT T+WT^D ]\h*bVd YS +TWnj1 /T4Z*2Y\an ]`\ h\O W\,TV*E qV\-\ /\aT j*Zdpbn T f`SabSqZSE T p/1^E T YdadWnY*ZSD TZ +d, 2,`12Y b* 3S, d ]1`T\/ 4 6>5< /\ 5<87 `\Vd /\ ZD 1D1 •\-\ 4,*WS ,`**Y2D ,`**Y +d, -\W\,Z\p ]\ab*bbp /1qVSf Z*y/*,ZTjSf +T+WTyZSf ]`\`\gb,E V\b`T ab\adpbnaq T Z*aD L˙S,Tbnaq ad]`\,T/Zd TZO e\`Y*gTp w W*-\aW\,1ZZq /Wq r,aTf Z*`\O /T,sxMD +T+WTyZTy VZS4T dbbq 4*]Sa*ZT

1 V\`\h1ZZq w/\ ZD 1Dx \4Z*h*2 w/\ Z*j\^ 1`SxD 2 ]\h*bVd ,`**Y Y*, TYGq ,`*YD

b*VT ]1`1/`1h1ZZqB 5M *k*/VS ,`**Y* ab*Zdbn Y\-dbZTY Z*`\/\YD 6M \ZS ]1`1O +d,*bSYdbn d `*+ab,T , hd3\Yd V`*^D 7M ıf +d/1 ,S4,\W1Z\E T ,\ZS 4*,\W\/Tpbn V`*2Y *Z**ZD \4-WqZnY\ gT ]`\`\gb,* /\VW*/O ZTj1D

`S ,S4Z*hZT ]`\`\gb,*

`\`\gb,\ 5B w *`\/\Y ,1WSVSY b1+1 ,`**Y* ) ,hSZpx L dbbq 56B6MD

]\,Z1ZZqD *k*/VS ,`**Y* ]\ WTZT^

ıa*V* b* )V\,* LZ*4,*Z\-\ b*V\3 ı4`*^W1YM db,\`SWS ab*`\/*,ZTy Z*`\/ ı4`*^WnD ˛ h*O a\Y +dW\ ae\`Y\,*Z\ Z14*W13Zd /1`3*,d Z* h\WT 4 g*`qYSE k\ ]\f\/SWS 4 b\-\ 3 Z*O `\/dD

ıab\`ShZT e*VbSD ˘ T+WTq /1b*WnZ\ `\4]\,T/*2 ]`\ Z*O k*/VT, ,`**Y*E d b\Yd hSaWT bSfE qVT ]\O f\/qbn ,T/ ıa*V*E )V\,* b* y\-\ 56 aSZT,D ˙\ gn\-\ `\/\,\/d Z*W13Sbn +*-*b\ g*`T, `\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

59

ı4`*^Wp b* (/SD TYZ*/gqbn 4 ZSf 4-*/dO pbnaq , Z1+T+WTyZSf /31`1W*fD 1y e*Vb ]T/b,1`/3d2 +T+WTyZd \]\,T/n ]`\ b1E k\ Z*k*/VS ,`**Y* ]\ WTZT^ ıa*V* b* )V\,* ab*WS Z*`\/\Y1D

`\`\gb,\ 6B w \b\Yab,\ b,\2 ,`**Y* +d/1 ]`Sf\/nV\Y , 41YWT Z1 a,\^yD ı +d/dbn aWd3SbS ,\ZSDDD ]\V\WTZZq h1b,1`b1 ]\,1`Z1bnaq ap/Sx L dbbq 59B57E 5:MD

]\,Z1ZZqD 1`14 -\W\/ d *Z**ZT h\O bS`S ]\V\WTZZq Z*k*/VT, ,`**Y* 3SWS , -S]bTD ]\h*bVd ,\ZS +dWS ,TWnZSYSE * ]\bTY ^f 4`\+SWS `*+*YS T 4YdaSWS ,S-\O b\,WqbS g1-Wd 4 -WSZS b* a\W\YSD * ]`SO VW*/T \/Z\-\ 4 ]`*,ZdVT, ,`**Y*E 1,TqE 1 ˙S,Tbnaq 5 `\ZTV 5B6;P78C 6B5P59C 7B5P68D ˛* h*ad ]`*,WTZZq 1f*,G*Y*E aSZ* g*`q \W\Y\Z*E T4`*^WnanVSy Z*`\/ ]\/TWS,aq Z* /,* g*`ab,*B ]T,ZThZ1 T ]T,/1ZZ1D T/b\/T , ı4`*^WT \/Z\h*aZ\ ]`*,SW\ /,\2 g*`T, L5 *`T, 56B5P68MD

qVSy ]1`1a1WS,aq /\ -S]bd `*4\Y 4T a,\O ^Y WTbZTY +*bnV\YE Y\3Z* ]\+*hSbSE k\ ]\V\WTZn a]`*,/T +dW\ h\bS`SB 5M 1,TyE 6M y\-\ aSZ 1-*bE 7M ,ZdV Y`*Y T 8M ]`*O ,ZdV \ya1y L SfT/ :B5:E 5<E 6>MD 5957 `\O gT /\ ZD 1D \ya1y ,S,T, T4`*^WnbqZ 4 -S]O bdD L˙S,Tbnaq af1Yd ,ZS4d T ad]`\,T/Zd TZe\`Y*gTp w \hZ* f`\Z\W\-TqxMD

ıab\`ShZT e*VbSD ˘ ˛* aW\,*YS ˙31yYa* \eeY*y2`*E ]`\e1a\`* ab*`\4*,TbZ\^ *`f1\W\-T^ b* *`O f1\W\-T^ WS4nV\-\ f\/dE 2-S]1banVT /\O VdY1ZbSE * b*V\3 *`f1\W\-ThZT 4Z*fT/VS a,T/h*bnE k\ ]T/ h*a -\W\/d a1YTb*Y L/\ qVSf Z*W13*WS T ab*`\/*,ZT 2,`1^M /\4,\O WSWS ]`SybS /\ -S]bd `*4\Y 4 ^fZTYS \b*O `*YSD W1 hS a]`*,/T T4`*^WnbqZS ab*WS b*Y `*+*YSE qVT ,S-\b\,WqWS g1-WdH ˘ 2-S]1banVSf /\VdY1Zb*f T4`*^WnO bqZS ]`qY\ Z1 4-*/dpbnaqE *W1 4 `dO V\]SaT, T Y*WpZVT, Z* -`\+ZSgqf ,S/Z\E

Y1`bn ,`**Y*

)VT, `*4\Y T4 aTYG2p ]1`1a1WqO 2bnaq , -S]1b

Y1`bn •\aS]*

\ya1y *`\O /31ZZq ,S,\O \ya1q /Sbn T4`*O ^WnbqZ 4 -S]bd

Y1`bn )V\,*

\bS`S ]\V\WTZZq Z*k*/VT, ,`**Y* 1,Ty 1-*b Y`*Y \ya1y 5:

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

58;7

5957

59=7

5:9;

5;55

5<87

L ˙ D ˚DM

5;6<

# ˙ ı ı˙

Y1`bn \ya1qD ıada *,SZ ,,\/Sbn T4`*^WnbqZ d f*Z**ZanO VSy V`*y

`\`\gb,\ 7B wË™*Y ) b\+T b* ]\b\Yab,d b,\2YdDDD d,1an `*y f*Z**ZanVSyx L dbbq 5;B<MD

]\,Z1ZZqD \ya1y ,S,T, T4`*^WnbqZ 4 -S]bdE * Äąada *,SZ 58;7 `\Vd /\ ZD 1D d,T, ^f /\ f*Z**ZanV\-\ V`*pD

*Yd^W ]\Y*4d2 *dW* Z* ]1`j\-\ g*`q Äą4`*^Wq *`\/31ZO Zq Ë™*,S/*

˚ ) ˙ ) w Ĺ ˙Ĺ x \- ]\\+Tgq,E k\ h1`14 ]\b\YV* ,`**Y* Wp/S 4 wdaTf Z*`\/T,x 4Y\O 3dbn \b`SY*bS +W*-\aW\,1ZZq L dbbq 66B5<MD ˛-T/Z\ 4 \3SY Z*YT`\YE Z*O k*/VS ,`**Y* Y*WS ab*bS Z*`\/\YE 4 qV\-\ ]\,SZ1Z +d, ,SybS 1aTqE Y*yO +dbZTy a]*aSb1Wn dan\-\ Wp/ab,*1D

b31E \3* \+TgqZV* ,`**Yd ab\adO 2bnaq T ,*aI Äą,*Z* 7B5: Z*]Sa*Z\B w \- b*V ]\Wp+S, a,TbE k\ ,T//*, a,\-\ 2/SZ\`\/Z\-\ SZ*E *+S V\O 31ZE fb\ ,Sq,Wq2E k\ ,T`Sbn d Zn\-\E Z1 +d, 4ZSk1ZSyE * \b`SY*, 3Sbbq ,ThZ1xD 1 `\`\gb,* ab\a\,Z\ 1aT^ \+-\,\`p,*bSYdbnaq , 7Oy T 8Oy h*abSZ*f gT2^ a1`T^ ab*b1yD

5>78

Ë› 5>;>

*aS ad//T,

55>;

Ų Š& ) 555;

5 Israel Museum, Jerusalem/The Bridgeman Art Library International

k\ , -S]bT hd3\41YgT ,S-\b\,WqWS g1-O Wd 4 Z*YdWd b* a\W\YSD -S]1banVT /\VdO Y1ZbS ]\V*4dpbnE k\ Z*h*WnZSVS Y*WS ]SanY\,T ,V*4T,VS ]`\ b1E aVTWnVS g1-WS b`1+* 4`\+SbSD 1 d4-\/3d2bnaq 4 T+WTO 2p L SfT/ 9B58E 5=MD `\e1a\` \eeY*y2` V*31B w -S]1banVT /31`1W* 4*a,T/hdpbnE k\ , ]1`T\/E V\WS T4`*^WnbqZS 4*4Z*,*WS -ZTbdE ]`SYda\,* ]`*gq TZ\41YgT,DDD +dW* 4,ShZSY q,Sk1YD b31E ]1`1+d,*ZZq ab*O `\/*,ZTf 2,`1^, d -S]bTDDD ]T/ h*a -\W\/d T ^fZ2 ]\/*Wnj1 ]\Z1,\W1ZZq Y\3Z* ,,*O 3*bS `1*WnZSYS e*Vb*YSxD

\W\Y\Z ]\hSZ*2 +d/T,ZSgb,\ f`*Yd

Ë™*,S/ ab*2 g*`1Y Äą4`*^Wq

Äą) TZZTabn b\hZ\^ +T+WTyZ\^ f`\Z\W\-T^ Y\3O Z* ]\+*hSbS Z* \/Z\Yd 4 ]`SVW*/T,D 5 *`T, :B5 -\,\`Sbnaq ]`\ h*aE V\WS \O W\Y\Z `\4]\h*, +d/T,ZSgb,\ f`*Yd , `dO a*WSYTB w \Vd h\bS`Sa\b\-\ y ,TaTY/1aqb\O -\ ]\,ZSf 8;= `\VT, ]\ ,Sf\/T Äą4`*^W1,Sf aSZT, 4 2-S]1banV\-\ V`*pE h1b,1`b\-\ `\Vd

`*-Y1Zb 4Z*y/1Z\^ , 1WnO˙*ZT ab1WS 4 Z*]Sa\Y w˙TY ˙*,S/*xD q ]*YGqbV* 2 \/ZSY 4 /31`1WE /1 4-*/dpbnaq g*`TE V\b`T +dWS Z*k*/V*YS

,`**Y* T ]`*,SWS , Äą4`*^WT *+\ (/T

\W\Y\Z\,\-\ g*`p,*ZZq Z*/ Äą4`*^W1YE YTO aqgq 4T,*E ]\h*, ,TZ +d/d,*bS b\y f`*Y /Wq \a]\/*xD Ë›* +T+WTyZ\p f`\Z\W\-T2pE h1b,1`bSy `TV ]`*,WTZZq \W\Y\Z* ]`S]*/*2 Z* 5>78 `TV /\ ZD 1D )Vk\ /\ gn\-\ `\Vd /\/*bS ]\,ZSf 8;= `\VT,E \b`SYd2Y\ 5957 `TV /\ ZD 1DP `TVE d qV\Yd T4`*^WnbqZS ,SyjWS 4 -S]bdD

ıab\`ShZT e*VbSD ˘ `f1\W\-S Y*pbn `T4ZT /dYVS k\/\ /*bE * ,bTYE qV Z*]Sa*, 4*aWd31ZSy ]`\e1O a\` 2-S]b\W\-T^ D Tbh1ZE wY\3Z* ,]1,Z1O Z\ aV*4*bSE k\ T4`*^WnbqZS d,TyjWS /\ *Z**Zd y \a1WSWSaq b*YxD ˘ T+WT^ -\,\`SbnaqE k\ ıada *,SZ w *g\`* f*Z**ZanV1 YTab\ a]*WS, \-O Z1Yx Lıada* *,SZ* 55B5>E 55MD T/ h*a `\4O V\]\V gn\-\ YTab* *`f1\W\-S Z*b`*]SWS Z* b`S f*Z**ZanVT f`*YSE qVT +dWS ]\,ZTaO bp 4`dyZ\,*ZTD \ZS b*V\3 4Z*yjWS /\V*O 4S b\-\E k\ YTab\ a]*WSWS d 58>>ObT `\VS /\ ZD 1D a1 g1 d4-\/3d2bnaq 4 +T+WTyZ\p \]\,T//pD ˘ ıZj* gTV*,* 4Z*fT/V* P f*Z**ZanV1 YTab\E `\4b*j\,*Z1 ]`S+WS4Z\ 4* 5> VTO W\Y1b`T, ,T/ `da*WSY*D \WS *`f1\W\-S `\4V\]*WS 7> -W1V\,Sf `dh\V 4 ,SbSaZ1O Z\p Z* ZSf Z*4,\p YTab*E b\ 4Gqad,*W\O aqE k\ g1 ˘T,G\ZD * ,T/YTZd ,T/ Y1jV*ZO gT, *g\`*E ab*`\/*,ZT šT,G\ZTbqZS dVW*WS YS` 4 ıada\Y *,SZ\YD TZ ]`S4Z*hS, ^f wZ\aTqYS ,\/Sx Lıada* *,SZ* =B7P;E 67MD \Yd ,\ZS Y*WS ,SV\Zd,*bS a*Y1 b*Vd `\O

+\bdH ˛-T/Z\ 4 \]Sa*YS , 6 *Yd^W* 6B57 b* `1YT^ 85B56E d ˘T,G\ZT +dW\ hSY*W\ ,\/O ZSf /31`1WD * ]T/b,1`/31ZZq gn\-\ , \/O ZTy ]`*gT -\,\`SbnaqB w˘T,G\Z ,S`T4Zq,aq Z*y+TWnj1 bSYE k\ +d, +*-*bSy Z* ,\/dB Y*, \/Z1 ,1WSV1 /31`1W\ T aTY Y1ZjSfx LwArchaeological Study Bible, New International VersionxMD ˘ ˙1aqbVS TY1ZE 4-*/*ZSf d T+WT^E ]T/O b,1`/31ZT TZjSYS /31`1W*YSD ˙\ gn\O -\ hSaW* ,f\/qbn TY1Z* 5; g*`T, P Z*O k*/VT, ,`**Y*E qVT ]`*,SWS , ı4`*^WT *+\ (/TE ]`\ k\ yjW\aq ,Sk1D 1`1/ ZSf f*,E f*4E ˙*,S/E 41VTqE *Z*aTq b* 4O 4TyqD ıaZd,*ZZq g*`anV\^ /SZ*abT^ 2 ]1`1O V\ZWS,SY /\V*4\Y b\-\E k\ Z*`\/ ı4`*^Wn d,Tyj\, /\ f*Z**ZanV\-\ V`*p y \a1WS,O aq b*YD ˘ 5<=: `\gT /\aWT/ZSVS 4Z*yjWS ab1Wd 1`Z1]b*f* d T,*f L -S]1bMD * ZTy \]SO a*Z\ ,TyanV\,Sy ]\fT/ e*`*\Z* 1`Z1]b*O f* /\ *Z**Zd +WS4nV\ 565> `\Vd /\ ZD 1D q ]*YGqbV* 2 ]1`j\p a1`1/ 4Z*y/1ZSf Z1O +T+WTyZSf /\VdY1ZbT,E , qVSf 4-*/d2bnaq ]`\ ı4`*^WnD \Z* aWd3Sbn k1 \/ZSY /\V*O 4\Y TaZd,*ZZq gn\-\ Z*`\/dD

\/`\+SgT T /\ab\,T`ZTabn T+WT^

P ı & ˘ b1Vab*f Z* -WSZqZSf b*+WShV*f ]\O h*bVd /`d-\-\ bSaqh\WTbbq /\ ZD 1D 4-*/dO pbnaq YTab*E Z*4,*ZT TY1Z*YS ,`**Y\O ,Sf `\/ShT,B 1W1š*E 1`dš*E *f\`*E 1`*f* T *`*Z* L dbbq 55B5;P76MD ˘ dbbq 55B75 Z*]Sa*Z\E k\ ,`**Y 4 aTYG2p ]\VSZd, w ` f*W/1yanVSyxD d^ZS gn\-\ YTab* 4Z*yjWS Z* ]T,/1ZZ\Yd af\O /T ı`*VdD T+WT^ b*V\3 aV*4*Z\E k\ ,O `**YT, +*bnV\ 1`*f ]\Y1` d YTabT *`*Z L\h1,S/Z\E Z* b1`Sb\`T^ adh*aZ\^ d`1hO hSZSME * /`d3SZ* ,`**Y* *``* ]\Y1`O W* d 1,`\ZTE \/Z\Yd 4 Z*y/*,ZTjSf YTab WS4nV\-\ f\/dE , qV\Yd /\aT 3S,dbn Wp/S L dbbq 55B76C 67B6MD

)V YS ]\+*hSWSE T+WTq YTabSbn hSY*W\ ]\/`\+Sgn ab\a\,Z\ Wp/1yE YTagn T ]\/TyD 1 /*2 Y\3WS,Tabn 4Tab*,SbS +T+WTyZT \]\O ,T/T 4 Z1+T+WTyZSYS /31`1W*YS y ]1`1V\O Z*bSan d a]\,Z1ZZT +T+WTyZSf ]`\`\gb,D *VbS ]\V*4dpbnE k\ \3T \+TgqZVS k\O /\ ,`**Y* b* y\-\ Z*k*/VT, ,SV\Z*WSO aqB ]\b\YVS ,`**Y* db,\`SWS Z*`\/E ab*O WS `*+*YS , -S]bT T ]T4ZTj1 4*,\W\/TWS f*Z**ZanVSY V`*2YD a1 g1 Z*-*/d2 aW\O ,* *]\ab\W* 1b`*E qVSy Z*]Sa*, , \/ZTy 4 +T+WTyZSf VZS-B w `\`\gb,\ ZTV\WS Z1 4Gq,WqW\aq 4 ,\WT Wp/SZSE *W1 Wp/S -\,\O `SWS ,T/ \-*E V1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\Yx L6 1b`* 5B65MD TaWq 4*,\p,*ZZq *Z**Zd , Tab\`T^ T4O `*^WnanV\-\ Z*`\/d ,T/+dWSan ]\/T^E qVT Y*WS b`*-ThZT Z*aWT/VSD T Z*aWT/VS b*O V\3 +dWS ]1`1/`1h1ZT , T+WT^E ]`\ k\ ]T/1 Y\,* , Z*abd]Z\Yd Z\Y1`TD

Ë™ı (Ë™ Ë› ( &

\Yd +*bnVS Z1 f\hdbn Y1Z1 4`\4dYTbSH Ë› ) & ı( GqbZSgqE j\ab* ,1h\`*D TYZ*/gqbS`ThO ZSy W1- j,S/V\ ]`qYd2 /\ /,1`1y T VS/*2 +*bnV*YB w d ,a1E +d,*yb1Ix W\]1gn a]\/T,*2bnaq dZSVZdbS Z14YTZO Z\-\ 4*]Sb*ZZqD W1 ,TZ Y*, +S V`*k1 4Z*bS a,\^f +*bnVT,D w \WS bS ]\,1`Z1jaqE W13SVdHx P 4*]Sbd2 Y*Y*D W\]1gn 4d]SZq2bnaq T k\an +d`Y\h1B w OYOYDDD q-*yb1 +14 Y1Z1E /\+`1Hx W1- Y*f\Y ,T/hSZq2 /,1`TE T y\Yd Y*yO 31 ,/*2bnaq ,SaWS4ZdbS 4 /\YdD `\b1 +*bnV\ -dV*2 ,aWT/B w W131E 4*h1V*yIx W\]1gn 4Z\,d 4d]SZq2bnaq T hd2 Z1,+W*O -*ZZSy +*bnVT, -\W\aB w S 4Z*2j ]`*,SO W\B ,/\Y* P `T,Z\ \ /1aqbTyD ı 3\/ZSf ,SZqbVT,Ix w dE b*bdI P aVS-WSbn W1-DP 1ZT a\O `\YZ\ V*4*bS /`d4qYE k\ q Ydjd +dbS ,/\Y* b*V `*Z\xD *bnV\ 4*WSj*2bnaq Z1]\fSbZSYD w T,Z\ \ /1aqbTyEP ]\,b\`p2 ,TZEP T +14 `\4O Y\,Ix

) ) 4 b\+\p k\an ]\/T+Z1H S +d,*W\E k\ , ]Sb*ZZqf Yd4SVSE \/q-dE `13SYd /Zq *+\ ,S+\`d /`dO 4T, b,\^ +*bnVS ,ab*Z\,Wp,*WS hTbVT y 4*WT4ZT ]`*,SW*H an /1qVT ,SaW\,Wp,*ZZq b,\^f \/Z\WTbVT,D w \WS Y*Y* \/`d3SW*aq 4 Y\^Y ,TbhSY\YE ,TZ `\4V`SO bSVd,*, Yd4SVdE qV* Y1ZT ]\/\+*W*anD 1ZT /\,1W\aq ,SO VSZdbS ,aT a,\^ /SaVSIx L `1Z/\Z1MD

1 ˙1qVT TY1Z* , ab*bbT 4YTZ1Z\D

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

5=

) ˛ • ı & w) 4`\4dYTW*E k\ V`SV\Y ZTh\-\ Z1 /\+G2jaqD )Vk\ bS d,*3Z\ aWdf*2j a,\^f +*bnVT, T Z*Y*-*2jaq 4`\4dYTbS ^fZTy ]\-Wq/E ,\ZS +TWnj afSWnZT 4`\+SbS b1 a*Y1x L T*ZZMD `\hSb*y SWS]GqZ 6B7E 8D w 1 \-`S4*yaqI ) `\+SW* g1 ]\abTyZ\E *3 ]\VS da,T/\O YSW*E k\ ad]1`1h\VE * \b31E T ]\V*`*ZZqE Y\3Z* +dW\ + dZSVZdbSE qV+S q ab`SYd,*W* a,Ty q4SVx L˙*ZT1WWMD `\hSb*y `S]\,Tab1y 5;B6;C 65B67D w \h1V*y aWdjZ\-\ Y\O Y1ZbdE V\WS +*bnVS +d/dbn -\b\,T b1+1 ,SaWdf*bSx L \WW1bbMD `\hSb*y `S]\,Tab1y 69B55D w *bnVS f\hdbn +*hSbSE k\ bS ^f ]\,*3*2j T a]`*,/T aWdO f*2jD \Yd a]\h*bVd 4*]1,ZS ^fE k\ bS ]\hd, T 4`\4dYT, ^fZT aW\,*E * ,31 ]\bTY -\,\`S ]`\ a,\^ ]\hdbbqx L˚YTWTMD `\hSb*y `S]\,Tab1y 67B66C )V\,* 5B5=D

˛ ˝ )

w *Y* /\`TV*2 Y1ZTE k\ q Z1 Y*p /`d4T,D V\WS 4*]SbdpE hS Y\3d ]\-dWqbS 4 VSY\anE ,\Z* V*O 31 rZTsE +\ Z1 4Z*2 bT2^ Wp/SZSD 1 b*V /`*bd2Ix L 1`\WMD w *b\ T Z*4,*Z* Y*bS /\4,\Wqbn Y1ZT \/q-ZdO bS edb+\WVd WSj1 b\/TE V\WS ,\Z* +d/1 Z* `\4O YT` +TWnj\pD b*b\ ,,*3*2B qVk\ j\`bS ,Sk1 V\WTZE ,\ZS 4*V\`\bVTIx L 1`1Z*MD #\ `\+SbSE V\WS +*bnVS 4 b\+\p , h\Ydan Z14-T/O ZTH S YT- +S bS \+-\,\`SbS g1 4 ZSYSH w˛*4,SO h*y +*bnVS Z1 f\hdbn Y1Z1 aWdf*bSxEP aV*`3Sbnaq 5;O`ThZ* ˙3\*ZZD 59O`ThZ* ˚YT V*31B w \WS +*hdE k\ +*bnVS Y1Z1 Z1 `\4dYTpbnE q ]`\ab\ Y\,hdxD \h +S qV b*Y +dW\E Z1 ,*`b\ \]daV*bS `dVD *bnO VS Y\3dbn +dbS +TWnj afSWnZSYS b1+1 ]\aWdf*bSE ZT3 bS \hTVd2jD \YT`VdyB Z*,Tbn ,1WShZSy \- ,SaWdf\,d2 WpO /1yE qVT 4,1`b*pbnaq /\ Zn\-\ 4T a,\^YS a]`*,*YSD *]`SVW*/E -\,* ,SaWdf*, \ya1qE V\WS b\y ]`\O aS, 4* Z1aWdfZqZSf T4`*^WnbqZ L SfT/ 76B;P58C \O ,b\`1ZZq ˛*V\Zd =B58E 5=MD \+T Y\31 4/*,*bSanE k\ +*bnVS Z1 b*VT `\4ad/O WS,TE qV \-D * y ]`\aSbS , Y*YS T b*b* /\4,\Wd ]`SybS /\/\Yd ]T4ZTj1 P Z1 b1 a*Y1E k\ +W*-*bS -\,d ]`\ /\Wp gTW\-\ Z*`\/dE qV g1 `\+S, \ya1yD ı ,a1 3 gT /,T aSbd*gT^ Y*pbn /1k\ a]TWnZ1D

)Vk\ ]`\f*ZZq `\4dYZ1E b\ \a\+*E Z*/TW1Z* ,W*/\pEP d b,\2Yd ,S]*/Vd +*bnVSEP Y\31 b1+1 ,SaWdf*bSD a1 4*W13Sbn ,T/ b\-\E qV bS ]\/*,*bSY1j a,\p a]`*,dD \4-WqZn V`\VSE V\b`T /\]\Y\3dbn b\+T 4`\+SbS g1 ]`*,SWnZ\D 5D S4Z*h ]`\+W1YdD ˛*]SjSE d h\Yd b,Ty ]\O -Wq/ `\4f\/Sbnaq 4 ]\-Wq/\Y +*bnVT,D ˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝

1 \+\,Gq4V\,\ \+-\,\`p,*bS ,aT Z14-\/SD ˙1V\WS ,*`b\ ]\aWdO f*bSan +T+WTyZ\^ ]\`*/SB w \4YSjWqyb1 d ,*jSf a1`gqfE b* y Y\,hTbnx L a*W\Y 8B9MD ˙T,hSZ*E Z* TYGq 1*b`TaE -\,\`SbnB wıZ\/TE V\WS ]\/dO Y*pE Z*aVTWnVS Z14Z*hZ\p gq ]`\+W1Y* +d/1 4*,b`*E b\ y Z1 f\h1bnaq k\an 4Gqa\,d,*bSD ) ]`\ab\ ]`\ Z1^ 4*+d,*pxD

6D ˛`\4dYTy a,\^ ]\hdbbqD \`\bV\ \]SjSE qVT ]\hdbbq ,SVWSV*2 , b1+1 ]\-Wq/ +*bnVT, Z* a]`*,dB bS \+`*3*2jaqE 4*aYdhd2jaqE ZTqV\,T2jE ,T/hd,*O 2j +`*V /\,T`S b\k\D L `SVW*/B d aSbd*gT^ Z* ]\O h*bVd ab*bbT W1-d +dW\ + a\`\YZ\ aV*4*bS /`dO 4qYE k\ +*bnVS ,SY*-*pbn ]\,1`ZdbSan /\/\Yd \ 5>Oy ,1h\`*MD ˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝

7D \ab*, a1+1 Z* YTag1 +*bnVT,D q,S a1+1 , `\O WT +*bnV* hS Y*b1`TD S Y*2j /SbSZdO]T/WTbV*E qV* 4TbVZdW*aq 4 ]`\+W1Y\pE V\b`d bS 4*4Z*hS,LW*M d ]dZVbT 5D #\ b1+1 b\/T Z*y+TWnj1 Z1]\V\^W\ + T h\YdH L `SVW*/B +*bnVS W1-* , aSbd*gT^ Z* ]\O h*bVd ab*bbT Y\-WS +\qbSaqE k\ 4 fW\]g1Y k\an b`*]SbnaqMD ˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝ ˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝

8D \/S,San a,T3SY \V\YD ˛*]SjS ,T/]\,T/T Z* b*VT 4*]Sb*ZZqB h\Yd /dYV* +*bnVT, 2 V\`SaZ\pH ˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝

)V `\4,TqbS ^fZT ab`*fSH

˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝

9D +-\,\`S ]`\+W1Yd 4 +*bnV*YS T ]\YT`Vdy `*4\Y 4 ZSYSE qV ^ ^ ,S`TjSbSD ˛`\+S,jS ,Sk1Z*O ,1/1ZT V`\VSE * b*V\3 4*ab\ad,*,jS ]\`*/S 4 `*YO VS w)V 4Z*ybS a]TWnZd Y\,dxE bS ]\+*hSjE k\ Y\31j a]TWVd,*bSaq 4 +*bnV*YS w]\O/\`\aW\YdxD *Y1 b*VT ab\adZVS 4 Y*Y\p T b*b\Y Y*2 1WWTD \Z* V*31B w d]1`1hV* ZT /\ h\-\ Z1 ]`S,1/1E /\ b\-\ 3 d b1+1 Z1Y*2 j*ZaT, ^^ ,S-`*bSD Ty a1VO `1b P /TybS a]TWnZ\^ 4-\/S 4 +*bnV*YSD S Y*y31 4*,3/S y/1Y\ \/Z1 \/Z\Yd Z* ]\abd]VSE T ,aT WSj*O pbnaq 4*/\,\W1ZSYSxD #\+ ]`\hSb*bS TZjT ab*bbT 4 `d+`SVS w \W\/T Wp/S 4*]SbdpbnxE 4*,*Zb*3 ]\]1`1/ZT ,S]daVS 3d`Z*Wd w `\+d/SanIx T4 a*ybd www.jw.org

˚ ˛ ) ˛ & H

˛*]Sb*yB w)V ,S ,S`Tjd,*WS Z1]\`\4dYTZZq 4T a,\^YS +*bnV*YSH )V+S ,S Y\-WS ]\,1`ZdO bSan d YSZdW1E b\ hS 4`\+SWS + k\an TZ*Vj1H )Vk\ b*VE b\ k\ a*Y1Hx

# ˝ &

˙ ı ^Z/TqB w) /\+`1 \+/dYdpE k\ -\,\O `SbSD 1`d /\ d,*O -S ]\-Wq/ +*bnVT, T Y\WpaqE ]1`j ZT3 k\an aV*4*bSD )Vk\ Y\^ aW\,* Y\3dbn ]`S4,1abS /\ ad]1`1hVSE q ab*`*pan Y\,h*bS T -\,\`SbS WSj1 b\/TE V\WS 4*a]\O V\panxD

\aaB w \WS Z*O ]`d31ZZq 4`\ab*2E q Z*Y*-*paq ]1O `1V\Z*bS a1+1E k\ Z1 ,*`b\ ]ad,*bS `1jbd /Zq h1`14 Y*`Zd ad]1`1hVdD ) ]\YTbS,E k\ b1O ]1` /`*bdpan Z1 b*V j,S/V\E qV `*O ZTj1E V\WS +d, Y\O W\/jSYxD

*Y\Z*B w `SO aWdf*bSaq /\ /dYO VS +*bnVT, 4*,3/S Yd/`\D *ab\ ,\Z* Z1 aSWnZ\ ,T/`T4ZqO 2bnaq ,T/ Y\2^ T `\4+T3Z\abT Z1 b*VT ,31 y ,1WSVTE qV q Y\-W* a\+T g1 dq,WqbSxD

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

65

Ë› Ë™ Ë™ H

*/V`SW*

Z*YT+anV\-\ 3dV*

`*]1WnVS ,\/S 4+S`*pbnaq Z* Z*/V`SW*f T abTV*pbn d `\b 3dV*

˘ \ gTW\Yd a,TbT ]`S+WS4Z\ =>> YTWny\O

ZT, Wp/1y Z1 Y*pbn /\abd]d /\ ]SbZ\^ ,\O /SD +*-*bn\f YTag1,\abqf 3TZVS y /TbS /\W*pbn ,1WSVT ,T/ab*ZTE k\+ `\4/\+dbS ,\/d /Wq a,\2^ aTYG^D w) /dY*pE g1 3*fWSO ,\E k\ +T/ZSY /\,\/Sbnaq ybS -\/SZ*YSE *+S \b`SY*bS Z1\+fT/Z1 /Wq 3SbbqxEP V*31 "`T`*Z- *b`TE TZ31Z1` *aa*hda1bO anV\-\ b1fZ\W\-ThZ\-\ TZabSbdbdD `*-ZdhS /\]\Y\-bS Wp/qYE *b`T b* y\-\ V\W1-S /\aWT/3dpbnE qV 4+S`*bS ,\W\-d 4 bdY*ZdD * b*Vd T/1p ^f Z*/SfZd, 3dV Stenocara gracilipesE qVSy 3S,1 , *e`SV*ZanVTy ]daO b1WT *YT+D \YT`Vdyb1D #\`*ZVd bdY*Z Z1Z*/\,O -\ ,V`S,*2 ]`\ab\`S ]dab1WT *YT+D \/T 3dV ab*2 ]`\bS ,Tb`d ]T/ ]1,ZSY Vdb\Y1D \,1`fZq Z*/V`SW 3dV* Y*2 \]dVW\abT 1 ıZjT ,S/S 3dVT, 4+S`*pbn ,\/d ]\/T+ZSY hSZ\YD

4 -T/`\eTWnZ\^ `1h\,SZSE Z* qVSf 4+S`*pbnO aq V`*]1WnVS ,\/SD \ZS ]\abd]\,\ e\`YdO pbn ,1WSVT V`*]WTE k\ ]T/ ,W*aZ\p ,*-\p abTV*pbn d 3\W\+VS Z* Z*/V`SW*f 3dV*D \,1`fZq 3\W\+VT, d a,\p h1`-d ,T/jb\,O fd2 ,\/dE b\Yd V`*]WT abTV*pbn ]\ bTWd 3dV* /\ y\-\ `\b*D *b`T b* y\-\ V\W1-S f\hdbn ,SV\`SaO b*bS ]\/T+ZSy ]`SZgS]E *+S 4+S`*bS ]SbZd ,\/d /Wq Wp/1yD Ë›,Sh*yZ\E Z*Y /Wq ,S3SO ,*ZZq ]\b`T+Z\ +TWnj1 ,\/SE ZT3 ]dab1WnO Z\Yd 3dVdD `TY b\-\E ]\/T+ZT `\4`\+VS ,SO Y*-*pbn ,1WSh14ZSf V\jbT,D * /*ZSy h*aE 4* aW\,*YS ]*Z* *b`TE \b`SY*ZZq ,\/S 4 bdY*Zd 4*WSj*2bnaq ]`\1Vb\YE Z*/ qVSY w,1/dbnaq `\+\bSxD )V ,S ,,*3*2b1B -T/`\eTWnZ* ]\,1`fZq Z*/V`SW ]dab1WnZ\-\ 3dV* 4Gq,SW*aq 4*,O /qVS 1,\WpgT^ hS ,Z*aWT/\V 4*/dYdH Photo: Chris Mattison Photography/photographersdirect.com

5>>>

5>>> Ë›*WT, *`ab,*I Ë™ı & ı

ı Z1 /dY*,E k\ b*V1 Y\3WS,1 d *W*,TIx P ,S-dVZd, -1abTZD TZ Y*, Z* d,*4T +d/T,ZSgb,\ +*-*bn\f Ë›*WT, *`ab,* P b*V ,T/VS -\,S Z*4S,*pbn a,\^ YTagq ]\VW\ZTZZq \-\,TD 5==7 `\gT 7> >>> ,T/VT, d *W*,TE Z1,1WShVTy V`*^ZT Z* ]T,/1ZZ\Yd af\/T e`SVSE Z1 Y*WS Z*O W13ZSf ]`SYTk1Zn /Wq ]\VW\ZTZZq b* ,SO ,h1ZZq T+WT^D /Z*V an\-\/ZT aSbd*gTq 4\,aTY TZj*D ,1`1aZT 6>5> `\Vd d YTabT W*Zb*y` Y*O W*,TyanVT ,T/VS -\,S 4*VTZhSWS +d/T,O ZSgb,\ a,\-\ bSaqhZ\-\ Ë›*Wd *`ab,*I1 Ë›,T/VS 3 d *W*,T 4Gq,SW\aq 7> >>> ,T/O VT, k1 ]1`1/ bSYE qV ,\ZS ]\h*WS +d/d,*O bS YTagq /Wq ]\VW\ZTZZqH )V ^Y ,/*W\aq 4,1abS 5>>> 4*WT, 4* ,T/Z\aZ\ V\`\bVSy h*a d V`*^ZT 4 \+Y131ZSYS `1ad`a*YSH ıE Z*`1jbTE qV gq /S,\,S3Z* +d/T,1WnO Z* ]`\-`*Y* ,]WSZdW* Z* Y*W*,TyanVSf ,T/VT, b* ^fZTf V`*qZH

w

*aS ,S]`\+d,*Zn * ]\h*bVd 5=>>Of `\VT, ,T/VS -\,SE ,T/\YT b\/T qV Ë™\aWT/ZSVS T+WT^E ]\h*WS ]\jS`p,*bS , *W*,T +T+WTyZd ]`*,/dD 5=:; `\gT ^fZq VTWnVTabn ab*Z\,SW* ,31 5; >>>D \/T+Z\ /\ f`SabSqZ I ab\WTbbqE ,\O ZS Y*WS `1]db*gTp 4*V\Z\aWdfZqZSf WpO /1yE qVT ]\,*3*pbn ,W*/dD `TY b\-\E qV T ]1`jT f`SabSqZSE ,T/VS Z1]\fSbZ\ b`SO 1 n\-\/ZT hSaW\ Ë›*WT, *`ab,* d *W*,T ]1`1,Skd2 5>7>D

Y*WSaq ]\4SgT^ Z1yb`*WTb1bd , ]\WTbShO ZSf a]`*,*f Lı,*Z* 5<B7:C Ë™T^ 9B6=MD * 3*WnE d a1`1/SZT 5=:>Of `\VT, ^fZT b,1`/T ]1`1V\Z*ZZqE k\ Å¡`dZbdpbnaq Z* ‹

T+WT^E ,SVWSV*WS Z1,/\,\W1ZZq d`q/dE T 5=:; `\Vd /TqWnZTabn ,T/VT, 4*+\`\ZSO WSD 1,/\,4T +*-*b\ 4 ZSf ,b`*bSWS `\+\O bdE * ^fZ2 Y*yZ\ V\ZeTaVd,*WS *+\ 4ZSO kSWSD 1`14 3\`ab\VT ]1`1aWT/d,*ZZq b* 4*-`\4d -1Z\gS/d bSaqhT ,T/VT, ,b1VWS /\ adaT/Zn\-\ \4*Y+TVd T Ë›*Y+T^D Ë›-\/\Y d *W*,T ab*,W1ZZq /\ ,T/VT, -\,S 4YTZSW\anE T +TWnjTabn 4 ZSf Z* ]\O h*bVd 5==>Of ]\,1`ZdWSaq /\/\YdD *`1jO bT 56 a1`]Zq 5==7 `\Vd 6:O`ThZd 4*+\`\Zd Z* ^fZp /TqWnZTabn +dW\ 4Zqb\D Sj1Zn dqO ,TbnE qV ,\ZS `*/TWSI /Z*V ,SZSVWS Z\,T b`d/Z\kTD \Z*/ 7> >>> ,T/VT,E \+G2/Z*ZT d 9<7 4+\`SE Z1 Y*WS Z*W13ZSf YTagn /Wq ]\VW\ZTZZq \-\,TD )VSy +dW\ 4Z*y/1Z\ ,SfT/H

p+\, Z* /TWT ]`\/\,3 ]1`jSf j1abS `\VT, ]TaWq 4Zqbbq 4*+\`\ZS YTag1,T ,T/VS ]\]`S 1V\Z\YThZd aV`dbd /\VW*/*WS ,1WSh14O ZSf 4daSWnE k\+ +d/d,*bS Ë›*WS *`abO ,*D `\b1 k\`\Vd VTWnVTabn ,T/VT, Z1,O ]SZZ\ 4`\ab*W*E T 4*/\,\WnZqbS ]\b`1+d , YTagqf ]\VW\ZTZZq ab*,*W\ /1/*WT ,*3O h1D )V +dW\ ,S`Tj1Z\ gp ]`\+W1YdH ,T/O VS -\,S 4*ab\ad,*WS +T+WTyZSy ]`SZgS] 4 6 \`SZeqZ <B58B w4*,/qVS `T,Z\YT`Z\Yd `\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

67

Ë™\ b\-\ qV d *W*,T ]\h*WS +d/d,*bS Ë›*WS *`ab,*E 4T+`*ZZq ]`\,\/SWSan ]`\ab\ ]T/ Z*,Ta*YS 4 b`*,S

1]1` 4+\`S ,T/VT, ]`\,\/qbn a,\^ 4T+`*ZZq , b*VSf Ë›*W*f *`ab,*

(

`\4]\/TWdx Z*/WSj\V V\jbT, , TZjSf V`*^Z*f w/\]\,ZS, b1E h\-\ +`*Vd2x , b*O VSf V`*^Z*fE qV *W*,TD 5=== `\gT 1O `T,ZSy \`-*Z ,T/VT, -\,S 4*]`\,*/S, a]1gT*WnZd ]`\-`*Yd +d/T,ZSgb,* YTagn ]\VW\ZTZZq , V`*^Z*f 4 \+Y131ZSYS `1O ad`a*YSD Ë›*,/qVS gTy a1`/1hZTy /\]\Y\O 4T +d/T,ZSgb,\ Ë›*WT, *`ab,* d *W*,T 4Z*hZ\ ]`Sj,S/jSW\aq1D *ZTj1 4+\`S , *W*,T ]`\,\/SWS f`SaO bSqZanVT 4T+`*ZZq d jVTWnZSf VW*a*fE ]T/ Z*,Ta*YS hS Z*,Tbn d bTZT /1`1,D 1]1` 567> 4+\`T, Y\3dbn 4+S`*bSaq /Wq ]\VW\O ZTZZq \-d T ,S,h1ZZq T+WT^ , -T/ZSf a]\O `d/*fE ]`S4Z*h1ZSf /Wq ]\jS`1ZZq +T+O WTyZ\^ ]`*,/SD \Z*/ ;9 >>> ,T/VT, -\,S d *W*,T -WS+\V\ ,/qhZT 4* ]T/b`SYVdE qVd ^Y Z*/*pbn /df\,ZT +`*bS y a1ab`S 4 dan\-\ a,TbdD #\ k1 /\]\Y\-W\ ,T/V*Y 4* b*VSy V\O `\bVSy h*a ]\+d/d,*bS abTWnVS YTagn /Wq ]\VW\ZTZZqH V`\YZT ,SY\-SD \ZS Z1 ]`*-ZdWS 4,1abS ]\Y]14ZT +d/T,WTD ıfZq Y1b* P +d/d,*bS ]`\abTE 4`dhZT b* -*`ZT Ë›*WS *`ab,*E V\b`T Z1adbn h1abn \-\,T T /*pbn Y\3WS,Tabn \+-\,\`p,*bS y ,SO ,h*bS T+WTp , Z*W13ZSf dY\,*fD 1 Ë› 5=== `\Vd ,T/VS -\,S 4,1WS 67 ;<: Ë›*WT, *`aO b,* d 595 V`*^ZT 4 \+Y131ZSYS `1ad`a*YSD

68

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

]`*,3Z2 +W*-\ YSZdW\Yd , *W*,T 4T ,T/VT, -\,S Z*aYTf*WSaqE +\ ,\ZS Z1 Y*WS Z*W13ZSf YTagn /Wq ]\VW\ZTZZqD \Yd /1qVT ,T/O VS h*a*YS ,*-*WSaq 4*]`\jd,*bS Wp/1y Z* 4T+`*ZZqD q,TbnE qV ,T/VS ]Sj*WSaqE ]\+d/d,*,jS Z\,TE ]`S,*+WS,T Ë›*WS *`O ab,*I 1]1` ,\ZS Y\-WS aYTWS,\ 4*]`\O jd,*bS Z* f`SabSqZanVT 4T+`*ZZq adaT/T, T bSfE 4 VSY ,S,h*WS T+WTpD )V\an , \/O ZTy YTag1,\abT d Z\,\4+d/\,*ZSy Ë›*W *`O ab,* ]`SyjW\ *3 :=< \aT+I SY*W\ ,T/VT, b* TZjSf Wp/1y ZTV\WS Z1 /dY*WSE k\ Y*bSYdbn b*VT -*`ZT T /\+O `\bZT a]\`d/S d a,\^y YTag1,\abTD Ë›-*/*O ZSy Z* ]\h*bVd ab*bbT -1abTZ ]*YGqb*2E qV \/SZ 4+T` ]`\,\/S, 4T+`*ZZq ]T/ /1`1O ,\YD w ]\adjWS,Sy ]1`T\/ /d31 ]`S2YZ\ ]1`1+d,*bS , bTZT /1`1,*EP V*31 ,TZEP b* V\WS Z*ab*2 a14\Z /\kT,E ,\Z\ ,*a Z1 ,`qO bd2Ix )Vk\ ,S V\WSOZ1+d/n ]\b`*]WqWS ]T/ b`\]ThZd 4WS,dE b\ /\+`1 `\4dYT2b1E k\ Y*2 Z* d,*4T -1abTZD -1abTZ ]`S-*/d2E qV \/Z\-\ `*4d ,T/,TO /d,*, 4+T` d SY,*Z/31D TZ `\4]\,T/*2B w S ]`\,\/SWS 4T+`*ZZq ]T/ Y*W1ZnVSY Z*,Ta\Y 4 b`*,SE qVSy b`SY*,aq Z* /1`1O ,GqZSf ]*WqfD Tfb\ Z1 4Z*,E k\ d b`*,T ]\a1WS,aq ,1WSVSy \b`dyZSy ]*,dVD *]O

b\YE ]\a1`1/ Y\2^ ]`\Y\,SE g1 ab,\`TZZq ,]*W\ ]`qY\ Y1ZT ]T/ Z\-SI b\an ]1`1WqO V*Z\ ,S-dVZd,B r Sy y\-\E -1abTZ1I SyIs ) b*V T 4`\+S,D )V +*hSb1E q /\aT 3S,SyxD 1]1` b\y 4+T` 4+S`*2bnaq , Z\,\Yd ˛*WT *`ab,* T Z1 Y*2 ]\/T+ZSf VW\]\bT,D w V`*a* Z*j\^ -`\Y*/Sx ˛*,/qVS gTy /S,\,S3ZTy ]`\-`*YT +dO /T,ZSgb,* ˛*WT, *`ab,* ,T/VS -\,S 4/\+dWS ]`SfSWnZTabn T ]\,*-d +*-*bn\f -`\Y*/ b* YTag1,\^ ,W*/SD an VTWnV* ,SO aW\,Wp,*ZnD O w d/T,ZSgb,\ Z\,\-\ YTagq ]\VW\O ZTZZqE * b*V\3 Wp+\, T 2/ZTabnE qVT ,Sq,O Wqpbn ,T/VSEP a]`*,3Zq \V`*a* Z*j\^ -`\Y*/SD 1 -T/ZSy ]`SVW*/ /Wq TZjSf g1`V\,x L]`1/ab*,ZSV ,W*/S d *+,1Z4TMD O w *y+TWnj1 Y1Z1 4*f\]Wp2 2/ZTabnE qV* ]*Zd2 a1`1/ ,T/VT,D S +d/d2Y\ Z*O jd g1`V,d ,31 /1aqbn `\VT,E T ZTfb\ Z1 4Z*2E V\WS YS ^^ 4*VTZhSY\D ) /d31 ,*Y ,/qhZSyE k\ ,S 4,1WS b*Vd ]`1V`*aZd +dO /T,Wp , Z*jTy YTag1,\abTx L-\W\,* a1W* S-,1Z1Y+1MD O w) , 4*f,*bT ,T/ ,*j\^ ]`*gTD S `\+Sb1 ,a1 b*V j,S/V\ y *Vd`*bZ\I *O +dbnE ,S /d31 /`d3ZTx L]`1/ab*,ZSV ,W*O /S d Td4T`TMD `\-`*Y* +d/T,ZSgb,* ˛*WT, *`ab,* ab*W* Z*abTWnVS ,T/\Y\p , *W*,TE k\ , \/Z\Yd aW\,ZSVd ]T/ 4*-\W\,V\Y w ,T/O VS -\,Sx 2 b*VT aW\,*B w ,T/VS -\,S ]\O +d/d,*WS +*-*b\ ˛*WT, *`ab,* x LwChichewa/Chinyanja—English DictionaryxMD

w 1 hd/\E k\ YS Y*2Y\ ˛*W *`ab,*x `S/gqb1 aThZq 6>55 `\Vd ab*W\ ,S4Z*hO ZSY /Z1Y /Wq 4+\`d ,T/VT, -\,S w *ZO y\,1x d W*Zb*y`TE 4-*/*Z\Yd `*ZTj1D \O ZS ]`Sa,qbSWS \-d Z\,Sy ˛*W *`ab,*D TZ ab*, bSaqhZSY ˛*W\YE qVSy ]\+d/d,*O WS , *W*,TD w 1 hd/\E k\ YS Y*2Y\ ˛*W *`ab,*EP aV*4*, \/SZ hW1Z 4+\`dDP 1 Z*h1 4/TyaZ1ZZq 4*]\,TbZ\^ Y`T^xD ˙T,hSZV* 4 b\-\ 4+\`d ]`S-*/d2B w) Z1 ]`\]dabSW* 3\/Z\-\ /Zq +d/\,SD ) /d31

k*aWS,*E k\ b13 Y\-W* +d/d,*bS bdb -*`O Z1 YTag1 /Wq ]\VW\ZTZZq \-\,TxD /SZ ab*`TyjSZ* 4+\`d `\4]\,T/*2B w W*/* Z1 f\bTW* /*,*bS /\4,TW Z* +d/T,O ZSgb,\ Z*j\-\ Ë›*Wd *`ab,*D TWnV* `*O 4T, YTanVT hSZ\,ZSVS ,T/Y\,WqWSaq ]T/O ]Sad,*bS Z1\+fT/ZT ]*]1`SD /Z*V YTaTa

TZ1aa SV*\Z1V*E ]`1/ab*,ZSgq YTag1O ,\^ ,W*/SE /\VW*W* ,1WSVSf 4daSWnE k\+ ]1`1V\Z*bS hSZ\,ZSVT, ]T/]Sa*bS /\4O ,\WSxD )V\an YTaTa SV*\Z1V* ]TjW* `*4\Y 4T ab*`TyjSZ\p /\ hSZ\,ZSV*D \Z* aV*4*W* y\YdB w) f\hdE k\+ ,T/VS ]\+d/d,*WS Ë›*W *`ab,* , Y\2Yd a1WTD \ZS f\`\jT Wp/SD 1ZT 3\/Z\-\ `*4d Z1 /\,\/SW\O aq `\4,Gq4d,*bS ad]1`1hVSE d qVT +dWS + ,bq-ZdbT ,T/VSxD SZ\,ZSV ]T/]Sa*, daT ]*]1`SD /1Zn ]`Sa,qh1ZZq Ë›*Wd *`ab,* YTaTa SV*\Z1V* /d31 `*/TW*D w) ]Sj*paq bSYE k\ , Y\2Yd a1WT b1]1` 2 b*V* ]`1V`*aZ* +d/T,WqIx P ]`\Y\,SW* ,\Z*D ,T/VS -\,S b* TZjT Wp/S d *W*,T ]`\/\,3dpbn ,SaW\,Wp,*bS ]\/qVd 4* ]`\-`*Yd +d/T,ZSgb,* Ë›*WT, *`ab,*D Ë›*,/qVS a*Y\31`b\,Z\abT b* ,*3VTy ]`*O gT ,T/VT, d gTy V`*^ZT VTWnVTabn 4+\`T,E V\b`T ]\b`1+dpbn Ë›*WT,E adbb2,\ 4Y1ZjSO W*anE ]\`T,ZqZ\ 4 5==7 `\V\YD ,bTYE ]\O b`1+* 4*WSj*2bnaq ,1WSV\pE */31 hSY`*4 +TWnj1 Wp/1y ,T/-dVd2bnaq Z* w/\+`d Z\O ,SZd ]`\ \31 g*`ab,\x T e\`Ydpbnaq Z\,T 4+\`S L *b,Tq 68B58MD \3 ,T/VS /dO 31 gTZdpbn /\]\Y\-d b* k1/`T ]\31`b,S ^fZTf \/Z\,T`gT, 4 dan\-\ a,Tbd1D W1 Z*y+TWnj1 ,\ZS ,/qhZT a,\2Yd \O -dE -\,TD ıfZT ]\hdbbq ,WdhZ\ ]1`1/*ZT aW\,*YS ]a*WY\]SanY1ZZSV*B w aT Z*`\O /SE qVSf S ab,\`S,E ]\]`Sf\/qbn T ]\]*O /*pbn ]1`1/ WSg1Y ,\^YE \a]\/SE b* ıYGq ,\2 aW*,SbS +d/dbnE ,1WSVSyO+\ SE b* hd/* ,hSZq2jx L a*W\Y <:B=E 5>MD 1 a1a,TbZq /TqWnZTabn ,T/VT, -\,S ]T/b`SYd2bnO aq WSj1 /\+`\,TWnZSYS ]\31`b,*YSD

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

69

ı ˚ I

˙Wq 4/TyaZ1ZZq VT+1`*b*V f*V1`S ]\aWd-\,dpbnaq gTW\p *`YT2p V\Y]Gpb1`T,E /\ qVSf ,\ZS 4/\+dWS /\abd]

) ı & aSbd*gTpB -`d]* /\a,T/h1ZSf V\Y]Gpb1`ZSf 4W\hSZgT,E ]\aWd-\,dpO hSan ıZb1`Z1b\YE ]1`1f\]Wp2 V\Zb`\Wn Z*/ +*-*bnY* V\Y]Gpb1`*YS b* \+G2/Zd2 ^f d Y1O `13TD T V\Y]Gpb1`ZT Y1`13TE ,T/\YT qV +\bO Z1bS L,T/ *Z-WD botnetB ro]bot T net[work ME 4*]daV*pbn jV,*W `dyZT,ZSf ]`\-`*YE a]`qO Y\,*ZSf ]`\bS qV\^an /1`3*,SD ˛* VTWnO V* f,SWSZ ]1`1ab*pbn ]`*gp,*bS ,1+Oa*yO bS ,TyanV\,SfE eTZ*Za\,Sf b* V\Y1`gTyZSf dab*Z\,E * b*V\3 +*ZV\Y*bS y b1W1e\ZZT WTZT^D Tb*VS Z1 Y\3dbn 4W1bTbSE V\Y]Gpb1O `S T aSab1YS +14]1VS *b\YZ\^ 1W1Vb`\ab*O ZgT^ ,Sf\/qbn 4 W*/dD )V `1*-d,*bSYdbn Wp/SH #\ ,\ZS `\+SbSYdbnH k\ 4`\+SO WS + ,SH *V* aSbd*gTq af\3* Z* ap31b e*Zb*aO bShZ\-\ eTWnYdD /Z*VE 4* aW\,*YS Th*`/* W*`V*E V\WSjZn\-\ V\\`/SZ*b\`* 4 ]Sb*Zn +14]1VSE +\`\bn+S 4 b1`\`S4Y\Y b* 4*fSabd TZe`*ab`dVbd`S " E ]\/T+Z1 Y\31 ab*bSO aq , `1*WnZ\Yd 3SbbTD TWnj b\-\E VT+1`*b*O VS ,31 b`*]WqWSaq1D \3WS,\E ^f 4*4Z*,*O WS Z*,Tbn ,SD

1 T+1`*b*V* P g1 Z*Y*-*ZZq ,Z1abS 4YTZS , `\+\bd V\Y]Gpb1`ZSf aSab1Y hS Y1`13E ,S,1abS ^f 4 W*/dE 4`dyO Zd,*bSE * b\ y 4ZSkSbS TZe\`Y*gTp hS ]`\-`*YSE qVT , ZSf 4+1`T-*pbnaq *+\ qVT ,\ZS ]1`1/*pbn L *gT\Z*WnO Z* Z*dV\,* `*/* " MD

6:

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

*,Tk\ 4W\,YSaZSVS 4/TyaZppbn VT+1`O *b*VSH )V ,T/+d,*pbnaq *b*VSH ı qV 4*fSaO bSbS a1+1 ,T/ ZSfH

T`bd*WnZ1 ]\W1 +\p

p/S ,/*pbnaq /\ VT+1`*b*V 4 `T4ZSf ]`SO hSZD *]`SVW*/E b1`\`SabS *+\ d`q/S Y\O 3dbn ]`\ZSV*bS , V\Y]Gpb1`ZT Y1`13T a,\^f ,\`\-T, T V`*abS a1V`1bZT /*ZT *+\ ]\jV\O /3d,*bS \+W*/Z*ZZqE qVSY V1`dpbn gT Y1O `13TD 6>5> `\gT 4*abd]ZSV YTZTab`* \+\O `\ZS " TWnqY TZZ III ,S4Z*,E k\ w,\`\-Sx Z1\/Z\`*4\,\ *b*Vd,*WS 4*a1V`1O h1ZT V\Y]Gpb1`ZT Y1`13T " y ,SV`*/*O WS wbSaqhT e*yWT,DDD d b\Yd hSaWT ]`\1VO bS 4+`\^E ]W*ZS \]1`*gTy b* /*ZT `\4,T/VSxD L˙S,Tbnaq TZe\`Y*gTp , `*YgT w 1k\/*,ZT VT+1`*b*VSxMD \Y]Gpb1`ZT 4W\hSZgT ,SV\`Sab\,dpbn ]\/T+ZT Y1b\/SE k\+ V`*abS TZb1W1Vbd*WnZd ,W*aZTabn hS eTZ*Za\,d TZe\`Y*gTp 4 V\`O ]\`*bS,ZSf Y1`13 *+\ ]1`a\Z*WnZSf V\YO ]Gpb1`T,D )V ]\,T/\YWqpbn /1qVT /31`1O W*E k\`\Vd 4*,/qVS Y*fTZ*gTqY , ıZb1`Z1bT j*f`*^ \b`SYdpbn ]`S+dbVS , YTWnq`/S /\O W*`T,D ˙Wq 4/TyaZ1ZZq VT+1`*b*V f*V1`S ]\aWdO -\,dpbnaq gTW\p *`YT2p V\Y]Gpb1`T,E /\ qVSf ,\ZS 4/\+dWS /\abd]D 6>>= `\gT \/Z*

V\Y]*ZTqE k\ /+*2 ]`\ TZe\`Y*gTyZd +14O ]1VdE ,SV`SW* +*Z/d 4W\hSZgT,E V\b`T Z* ,T/ab*ZT V\Zb`\Wp,*WS -W\+*WnZd Y1`13d 4 +WS4nV\ /,\f YTWny\ZT, V\Y]Gpb1`T,D SO Y*W\ gSf V\Y]Gpb1`T, Z*W13*W\ ]`S,*bZSY \a\+*YD ˛* Z1k\/*,Zn\p \gTZV\p `-*ZT4*O gT^ 1V\Z\YThZ\-\ a]T,`\+TbZSgb,* T `\4,SbVd L ˚ ME V\31Z b`1bTy V\Y]Gpb1`E ]T/VWph1O ZSy /\ ıZb1`Z1bdE V\Zb`\Wp2bnaq f*V1`\YD qV k\/\ ,*j\-\ V\Y]Gpb1`*H S qVSyan 4W\,YSaZSVE +d,*E Z1 ,SV\`Sab\,d2 y\-\ d ,W*aZSf gTWqfH

Sb`T YSaWS,gT ˛W\hSZgT /Tpbn 4* b*V\p af1Y\pD \ZS ,SaSW*pbn h1`14 ıZb1`Z1b jVT/WS,d ]`\-`*O YdD \WS ,\Z* Z*b`*]Wq2 Z* ,*j V\Y]Gpb1`E b\ \+1`13Z\ ]1`1,T`q2 aSab1YS y\-\ 4*fSaO bdD ˛Z*yj\,jS wj]*`SZVdxE gq ]`\-`*Y* ]`\ZSV*2 d ,*jd Y*jSZd T ZSj]\`Sbn d ]\O jdV*f V\`SaZ\^ TZe\`Y*gT^1D \Z* Y\31 4YTO ZSbS hS ,S/*WSbS qVTan e*yWSE ]\b`*]SbS

/T^ Z1`T/V\ /*pbn 41W1Zd ,dWSgp jVT/WS,Ty ]`\-`*YTE qV* *,b\Y*bShZ\ TZab*Wp2bnaq Z* ,*j V\Y]Gpb1` T /\4,\Wq2 f*V1`*Y V\Zb`\O Wp,*bS y\-\ Z* ,T/ab*ZTD )V /T4Z*bSaqE hS ,*j V\Y]Gpb1` h*a\Y Z1 4*`*31ZSyH 1 +d,*2 Z1W1-V\D * \an VTWnV* aSY]b\YT,B V\Y]Gpb1` *+\ ıZb1`Z1b ]`*gpO pbn /d31 ]\,TWnZ\E Z1 ]`*gppbn qVTan ]`\O -`*YSE ,S`SZ*pbn ,TVZ*E V\b`T a]\ZdVdpbn ,*a k\an TZab*Wp,*bSE *+\ V\Y]Gpb1` edZVO gT\Zd2 Z1 b*VE qV 4*,3/SD )Vk\ ,S ]\YTbSWS qVSyan T4 gSf aSY]b\YT,E b\ ]\]`\aTbn Z*O /TyZ\-\ e*fT,gq ]1`1,T`SbS V\Y]Gpb1`D

˚# ˙ ı ı ˚

4 ,*j\-\ V\Y]Gpb1`* Z* TZjT h1`14 1W1Vb`\ZO Zd ]\jbd *+\ ,T/]`*,SbS f*V1`d ]*`\WTE eTO Z*Za\,T /*ZT hS TZjd V\ZeT/1ZgTyZd TZe\`O Y*gTpD *V1`S Y\3dbn Z*,Tbn 4*Y*ZSbS ,*a d ]*abVdE T ,S a*YT Z1a,T/\Y\ 4*`*4SO b1 jVT/WS,\p ]`\-`*Y\p ,W*aZSy V\Y]GpO b1`D 1 Y\31 ab*bSaqE V\WS ,S ,T/V`S,*2b1 +14Z1,SZZSy Z* ]1`jSy ]\-Wq/ /\/*b\V /\ 1W1Vb`\ZZ\-\ WSab*E *VbS,d2b1 ]\aSW*ZZq Z* ,1+Oab\`TZgTE 4*,*Zb*3d2b1 b* TZab*WpO 2b1 +14V\jb\,Zd ]`\-`*YdE ]T/G2/Zd2b1 /\ V\Y]Gpb1`* 4*`*31ZSy Z\aTy TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ ]`\ab\ ,T/,T/d2b1 adYZT,ZSy ,1+Oa*ybD *VT

6>>7 `TVD \Y]Gpb1`ZSy f`\+*V Slammer j,S/V\ ]\jS`S,aq ıZb1`Z1O b\YE d`*4S,jS ]`S+WS4Z\ ;9 >>> V\YO ]Gpb1`T, dan\-\ 4* 5> f,SWSZ1D ",S/O VTabn ıZb1`Z1bd ,]*W* Y*y31 /\ ZdWqE ]1`1ab*WS ]`*gp,*bS +*ZV\Y*bS b* hSO Y*W\ ,1+Oa*ybT,D 1 Y\-WS 4W1bTbS WTb*O VSE * Z* \/ZTy 4 *b\YZSf 1W1Vb`\ab*ZgTy ,SyjWS 4 W*/d V\Y]Gpb1`S b* V\Y]Gpb1O `S4\,*ZT aSab1YS +14]1VSD 6>>; `TVD 1`Tp VT+1`*b*V +dW\ 4/TyaZ1Z\ Z* ˚ab\ZTpD \ZS +dWS aV1`\O ,*ZT Z* V\Y]Gpb1`ZT aSab1YS d`q/dE * b*O V\3 +*ZVT, T 4*a\+T, Y*a\,\^ TZe\`Y*gT^D TWnjTabn gSf *b*V ]\f\/SWS 4 Y1`13 L+\bZ1bT,ME qVT Z*`*f\,d,*WS ]\Z*/ YTWnO y\Z V\Y]Gpb1`T, d ;9 V`*^Z*fD aT gT Y*O jSZS *b*Vd,*WS 4-*/*ZT YTj1ZT W*,SZ*O YS e*WnjS,Sf 4*]SbT, ]`\ TZe\`Y*gTpD 6>5> `TVD Sa\V\b1fZ\W\-ThZSy V\YO ]Gpb1`ZSy f`\+*V Stuxnet *b*Vd,*, aSaO b1YS V\Zb`\Wp Z*/ ,S`\+ZShSY ]`\g1O a\Y Z* *b\YZTy 1W1Vb`\ab*ZgT^ , ı`*ZTD

1 ˛* /1qVSYS /*ZSYSE d 6>55 `\gT f*V1`*Y +dW\ ,T/\O Y\ ]\Z*/ 89 >>> ,`*4WS,Sf YTagn d V\Y]Gpb1`ZSf ]`\-O `*Y*fD SV\`Sab\,dphS gT ,`*4WS,T YTagqE 4W\,YSaZSVS Z*Y*-*pbnaq TZab*Wp,*bS jVT/WS,1 ]`\-`*YZ1 4*+14]1O h1ZZq Z* hSyan V\Y]Gpb1` +14 ,T/\Y* y\-\ ,W*aZSV*D

1 \Y]Gpb1`ZT f`\+*VS P g1 jVT/WS,T ]`\-`*YSE qVT *,b\Y*bShZ\ ]\jS`ppbnaq 4 V\Y]Gpb1`* Z* V\Y]Gpb1` h1`14 ıZb1`Z1bD \Y]Gpb1`ZSY f`\+*V*YE qV T TZjSY jVT/WS,SY ]`\-`*Y*YE /*pbn TY1Z*E qVO \b SlammerD

˛* \gTZV\p ˚ E V\31Z b`1bTy V\Y]Gpb1`E ]T/VWph1ZSy /\ ıZb1`Z1bdE V\Zb`\Wp2bnaq f*V1`\Y

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

6;

˛ ı & ˚ ˚I 5D ab*Z\,Tbn Z* ,*j V\Y]Gpb1` *ZbS,TO `daE +`*Z/Y*d1` T ]`\-`*YdE k\ ,Sq,Wq2 j]S-dZanV1 ]`\-`*YZ1 4*+14]1h1ZZqD 1O -dWq`Z\ TZab*Wpyb1 Z*yZ\,TjT \Z\,W1ZZq +14]1VS /Wq gSf ]`\-`*Y b* \]1`*gTyZ\^ aSab1YS ,*j\-\ V\Y]Gpb1`*D

\/+*yb1 ]`\ ,W*aZd +14]1Vd , ıZb1`Z1bT

w d/`Sy 4,*3*2 Z* V`\VS a,\^x V`1YT Wp/S b* gTWT /1`3*,S ab*pbn /1/*O WT 4*W13ZTjSYS ,T/ V\Y]Gpb1`ZSf b1fZ\O W\-TyE b\Yd VT+1`*b*VSE Y*+dbnE b`*]WqbSO Ydbnaq hSY`*4 h*abTj1D an h\Yd +*-*b\ V`*^Z ab,\`ppbn ,1WSVT ]T/`\4/TWS VT+1`4*O fSabdE * /1qVT Z*,Tbn ]`\,\/qbn jS`\V\O Y*ajb*+ZT ,S]`\+d,*ZZqE k\+ ]1`1,T`SbSE Z*aVTWnVS /\+`1 ^fZT V\Y]Gpb1`ZT Y1`13T Y\3dbn ]`\bSab\qbS VT+1`*b*V*YD ı ,a1 3E 4* aW\,*YS bT,1Z* *+TZanV\-\E /\a,T/h1O Z\-\ 1Va]1`b* 4 VT+1`+14]1VSE V\b`Sy ]`*gp2 d 1/1`*WnZ\Yd +p`\ `\4aWT/d,*Zn " E wqVk\ ,\`\- Y*bSY1 /\ab*bZn\ h*adE Y\O bS,*gT^ T V\jbT,E ,TZ 4*,3/S P 4*,3/SI P 4Y\31 ]`\ZSVZdbS , ]1,Zd aSab1YdxD )V 31 4*fSabSbS a1+1 ,T/ Z1]`\f*ZSf -\aO b1yH ˙\aq-bS ]\,Z\^ +14]1VS , ıZb1`Z1bT Z1Y\3WS,\E ]`\b1 ,*Y ]T/ aSWd 4*fSabSO bS a,Ty V\Y]Gpb1` ]`SZ*yYZT ]1,Z\p YT`\pD L˙S,Tbnaq TZe\`Y*gTp , `*YgT w˛*fSabTbn a1+1IxMD T+WT^ -\,\`SbnaqB w d/`Sy 4,*O 3*2 Z* V`\VS a,\^x L `S]\,Tab1y 58B59MD 1y ]`SZgS] /\]\Y\31 ,*Y +dbS \+*hZSYSE V\O WS 4*f\/Sb1 , ıZb1`Z1bD 6<

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

6D ˙\+`1 ]\/dY*yb1E ]1`j ZT3 ,T/V`SbS qV1an ]\aSW*ZZq hS /\/*b\V , 1W1Vb`\ZZ\O Yd WSabT *+\ YSbb2,\Yd ]\,T/\YW1ZZTE Z*O ,Tbn ,T/ ,*jSf /`d4T,D d/nb1 \a\+WS,\ \+1`13ZSYSE V\WS \b`SYd2b1 ]\,T/\YW1ZO ZqE qV\-\ ,S Z1 h1V*WS T , qV\Yd YTabSbnaq 4*]Sb ]`\ \a\+Sabd TZe\`Y*gTp hS ]*`\WTD 7D TV\WS Z1 V\]Tpyb1 T Z1 4*]daV*yb1 ]`\-`*Yd Z1,T/\Y\-\ ]\f\/31ZZqD 8D SV\`Sab\,dyb1 ]*`\WT 4 ]`SZ*yYZT ,\anYS 4Z*VT,E d b\Yd hSaWT gSe` T aSY,\O WT,D 1-dWq`Z\ ^f 4YTZpyb1D ˙Wq V\3Z\-\ \+WTV\,\-\ 4*]Sad ,3S,*yb1 TZjSy ]*`\WnD 9D ˙TW\,T hS eTZ*Za\,T \]1`*gT^ h1`14 ıZb1`Z1b 4/TyaZpyb1 WSj1 4 bSYS V\Y]*O ZTqYSE V\b`T Y*pbn /\+`d `1]db*gTp T ,SO V\`Sab\,dpbn jSe`\,*ZT 4G2/Z*ZZq /Wq ]1`1/*hT /*ZSf1D :D 1 ,SaSW*yb1 V\ZeT/1ZgTyZd TZe\`O Y*gTp ]`\ a1+1 *+\ a,\^ `*fdZVSE V\WS V\O `Sabd2b1an Z14*fSk1ZSY 4G2/Z*ZZqY Wi-FiE aV*3TY\ , ]d+WThZSf YTagqfD ;D SYSV*yb1 V\Y]Gpb1`E V\WS Z1 V\O `Sabd2b1an ZSYD <D 1-dWq`Z\ ab,\`pyb1 `141`,ZT V\]T^ e*yWT, T ]\/+*yb1E k\+ ,\ZS Z*/TyZ\ 4+1`TO -*WSanD 1 "Se`\,*ZT ,1+Oab\`TZVS Z* ,1+O+`*d41`*f d ]\WT */`1aS YTabqbn 4Z*h\V 4*YV* *+\ whttpsB//xD Tb1`* s \4Z*h*2 w4*fSk1ZSyxD

˛ & ı

\b\,T /\ *]\V*WT]aSadH -*41bT w npO•\`V b*yYax +dW\ Z*/`dV\,*Z\ ab*bO bp 4* Z*4,\p w \aT+ZSV /Wq p`SabT, Z* ,S]*/\V *]\V*WT]aSad , npO•\`VdxD b*bbq ]\,T/\YWq2 ]`\ ]d+WTV*gTp \eTgTyZ\-\ ]\aT+ZSV* /Wq ad//T, T p`SaO bT,D Zn\Yd \+-\,\`ppbnaq aVW*/ZT ]Sb*ZZqE V\b`T Y\3dbn ,SZSVZdbS d 4,Gq4Vd 4 wb1`\`SabShZSY *VO b\YE 1]T/1YT2p *+\ Y*ajb*+ZSY `*/T\*VbS,ZSY hS fTYThZSY 4*+`d/Z1ZZqYxD \aT+ZSV ,S/*Z\ d/\,\p aSab1Y\p jb*bd npO•\`V `*4\Y 4 a\gT*gT2p */,\O V*bT, gn\-\ jb*bdD ˛* y\-\ /\]\Y\-\p Y\3Z* j,S/O V\ /T4Z*bSan ]`\ hSZZ1 4*V\Z\/*,ab,\ k\/\ V*`*ZbSO ZdE Y*a\,\^ 1,*Vd*gT^E \+jdVd +14 \`/1`*E 4ZSk1ZZq TZeTV\,*ZSf b,*`SZ T bSYh*a\,\-\ ]`S]SZ1ZZq /T^ ]1,ZSf 4*V\ZT,D

#\ V`S2bnaq , ab*`Sf ]\/djV*fH `b *V1`E ]`\,T/ZSy VWTZTgSab WTV*`ZT Barts d \Z/\ZTE ab,1`/3d2E k\ ]T/ hSab\p Z*,\W\hV\p Y\O 31 w+dbS k\an /d31 +`S/V1xD ˛,Tb ]`\ /\aWT/31ZO Zq gn\-\ ,h1Z\-\ \]d+WTVd,*W* W\Z/\ZanV* -*41b* w *yYaxD 4,TbT 4*4Z*h*W\aqE k\ ]TaWq /,\f `\O VT, ,SV\`Sab*ZZq b`1bSZd ,*-S ]\/djVS waVW*/*pbn 3S,T y Y1`b,T ]SW\,T VWTkTE 1VaV`1Y1ZbS ]SW\,Sf VWTkT,E jY*b\hVS Y1`b,\^ jVT`SE * b*V\3 +*Vb1`T^xD \/djVS Z*V\]Shdpbn *W1`-1ZS T 2 /\+`SY a1`1/\,SO k1Y /Wq YTV`\+T, b* VWTkT,D )V ,S`TjSbS gp ]`\+W1O YdH w WTkTDDD ,SaSf*pbn T -SZdbn ]T/ /T2p a\ZqhZ\-\ a,TbW*EP -\,\`Sbnaq , w *yYaxEP * \b31E 1e1VbS,O ZSY d +\`\bn+T 4 ZSYS 2 ab*`Sy 4,Sh*y ]`\,Tb`p,*bS ]\abTWnxD SW\ Z1 ,+S,*2 gSf V\Y*fD #\+ ^f ]\4+dO bSaqE ]\/djVS b`1+* ,S]`*bS d ,\/T ]`S b1Y]1`*bd`T ]\Z*/ :> -`*/daT, T /\+`1 ,S]\W\aV*bSD

npO•\`Vd ,,1WS 4*O +\`\Zd Z* Vd`TZZq Z* ]WqO 3*fE d ]*`V*f T Z* ]Tj\fT/ZSf ]W\k*fD \`djZSVS V*`*bSO Ydbnaq jb`*e\Y d 9> /\W*O `T,D W*/* YTab* a]\/T,*2bnaqE k\ 4*+\`\Z* wZ1 ,SY*-*bSY1 4*f\/T,E *+S 4*+14]1hSbS ^^ ,SO V\Z*ZZqx Lw O ˙˝ ˚ xE " MD

w ıZ/T^ adbb2,\ 4`\aW* VTWnVTabn *+\`bT, a1`1/ 3TZ\VE qVT ,SZ\jdpbn /T,h*b\VE \a\+WS,\ qVk\ , aTYG^ ,31 2 \/Z* /T,hSZO V*xD 5==> `\gT , aTYGqfE V\b`T ,31 Y*WS ]1`,TabV*O/T,O hSZVdE Z* bSaqhd Z\,\Z*`\O /31ZSf fW\]hSVT, ]`S]*/*W\ =>: Z\,\Z*`\/31ZSf /T,h*O b\VE * 6>>9 `\Vd P WSj1 <7:D Lw ˚ xE ˚ ı)MD

a1a,TbZq \`-*ZT4*gTq \f\`\ZS 4/\`\,Gq 4*`*fd,*W* `*/T\h*aO b\bZT 1W1Vb`\Y*-ZTbZT ]\WqE wqVO\b ab,\`p,*ZT ]`Sab`\qO YS +14/`\b\,\-\ 4,Gq4VdxE /\

w]\b1ZgTyZ\ V*Zg1`\-1ZO ZSf /Wq Wp/SZSxD L ı˝ O ˙ ˚ ˚ ˛ ˚ ) E ı)MD

`-*ZT4*gTq +G2/Z*ZSf *gTy ,T/4Z*hSW* ]1`1O Y\-d Z*/ hdY\p ,1WSV\^ `\-*b\^ fd/\+SD 1 w]1`O j1 4*f,\`p,*ZZq b,*`SZE 4ZSk1Z1 4*,/qVS 4daSWWqY Wp/SZSE T /`d-1 ]TaWq ,Ta]S 4*O f,\`p,*ZZqE qV1 +dW\ ]\,ZTaO bp ,SV\`1Z1Z1x L ˙ & ı & & ˙ & ıO ˛ ı) ı˛ ıı G ˙ O ı•E ı ı)MD

ı • ˚ ˙ ı

ı &D S ]\/\+*2bnaq -\,TE V\WS , ]\VW\ZTZZT y\Yd YS ,SV\`Sab\,d2Y\ a]T, b* Yd4SVdH \Yd ,S b*V /dY*2b1H ı˙ ˛ D `\hSb*yb1 6 `\ZTV 9B57E 58C ˚e1aqZ 9B5=D S Y\31b1 ]`S-*/*bSE /1 k1 , T+WT^ -\,\`Sbnaq ]`\ a]T, qV h*abSZd ]\O VW\ZTZZq \-\,TH ı˙ ˛ D `\hSb*yb1 SfT/ 59B5P6>C *`V* 58B6:C ˙T^ 5:B69D \Yd ,*`b\ ]`\aW*,WqbS -\,d a]T,\YE Z*,Tbn qVk\ bS a\`\YGq4WS,Sy *+\ b\+T 4/*2bnaqE k\ TZjT a]T,*pbn V`*k1 4* b1+1H ı˙ ˛ D `\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 77B5P7D

\-\ +`*Vd2 Z* gn\Yd Y*WpZVdH `\hSb*yb1 5 `\ZTV 5:B5E 6E 8 P5>D b1]1` ]\/S,Tbnaq Z* Y*WpZ\V T 4*]SjTbn ,ZS4dE h\-\ Z* Zn\Yd +`*Vd2D ˛*,1`jTbn Y*WpZ\VE 4G2/Z*,jS ]\ ]\`q/Vd V`*]\hVSE * b\/T `\4Y*Wpyb1 y\-\D

5˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝ 6˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝

˛ ˙ ) ˙ ) ı GıD 1f*y V\31Z

hW1Z aTYG^ ,S+1`1 dWp+W1Zd ]TaZp 4 ]Ta1ZO ZSV* w ]T,*yb1 -\,TxD ]T,*yb1 ^f `*4\YE ]\VS /\+`1 Z1 4*a,\^b1D

7˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝˝ ˘ T/]\,T/T Z* ab\`TZgT 58D 9=

:> 9<

6

5

:5 :6

:7

ı ˚ &

9;

:8 9: 6: 7 8 6=

7>

;

98 99

< 55 56

75

59 5: 6;

6<

5= 6> 67

97 96 85 68 7< 86

95

69

8> 7;

87

76

7=

9>

7: 8= 77 9 : = 5> 57 58

79 5; 5<

65

66

78 88

8:

8<

8;

89

˙\/*bV\,T ]`SYT`ZSVS ab*b1y 4 gT2^ `d+`SVS ,S Y\31b1 `\4/`dVd,*bS 4 a*ybd www.jw.org

TV*,\ T ]\,h*WnZ\

*]Sa*Z* \ab*ZZq VZS-* T+WT^

=< `TV ZD 1D

S`T3b1E 4T-ZTbn ]\a1`1/SZT T 4+1`T-*yb1

"ı"

TZ1,Tq

5 `TV ZD 1D

˘*bO 1e1`

˝S, d IX abD /\ ZD 1D

•

8>6: `TV /\ ZD 1D

˛ ) D •\Zd +dW\ ]\aW*Z\ ]`\]\,T/d,*bS d E /1 3SW\ ]\Z*/ Wp/1yD

D ]\h*bVd •\Z* ]\+\q,aq ,SV\Zd,*bS a,\2 4*,/*ZZq T ,bTVD W1 Z* k\ ,TZ ,T/O ,*3S,aq 4*/Wq ]\`qbdZVd TZjSfH D ˛*,1`jTbn `1h1ZZq 4 T+WT^B wı +d, •\Z* , a1`1/SZTDDDxD

˛ ˝ )D Wd3S, ]`\O `\V\Y -\,S 4* ]`*,WTZZq g*`q

`\,\*Y* II L6 *`T, 58B67P69MD

-\,* ]\V*4*, •\ZTE k\ b`1+* /+*O bS ]`\ TZjSfE * Z1 4\a1`1/3d,*bSaq Z* a\+T L•\ZS 8B:P55MD \4]\,T/n ]`\ •\Zd Z*,h*2 Z*aE k\ -\,* Z*/4,Sh*yZ\ b1`]1WS,SyE YSW\a1`/O ZSy T /\+`Sy /\ -`TjZSf Wp/1yD ı˙ ı˙ı D TZ1,TqC 56> >>> L•\ZS 5B5E 6C 8B55MD

D TZ Z*V*4*, Y\`qV*Y VSZdbS y\-\ 4* +\`bE k\+ 4*a]\V\^bS Y\`1 L•\ZS 5B7E =P5:MD D wDDDgT2^ `S+S b`S /ZT b* b`S Z\hTx L•\ZS 6B5MD

b,\`1ZSy /*Y

• ı ı•

5;

bTV 4 ˘*bO 1e1`* /\ *`jTjd

p/S y V`*^ZS 8D *a 4,*bS 1WTaa* b* ˚/TW\E T Z*Y = T ; `\VT,D S 3S,1Y\ Z* d+TD VTWnVS ]`S+WS4Z\ ,T/VT, -\O ,S 3S,1 Z* d+TB 95 >>>E =5 >>> hS 575 >>>H 9D +,1/S V`*]VdE qV* ]\V*4d2E /1 Z*j* V`*^Z*D \ab*, V`*]Vd b*YE /1 3S,1j bSE T ]\/S,SanE hS g1 /*W1V\ ,T/ d+SD

˛Z*y/S Y*WpZ\V * qVSf ab\`TZV*f ]\YTk1O Z\ gT TWpab`*gT^H ]SjS a,\^YS aW\,*YSE k\ 4\+`*O 31Z\ Z* V\3ZTy 4 ZSfD

`\+d/SanI `*,1Zn 6>56

75

w 1 4-*/*pbnaq `1hT V\WSjZTE

T Z1 ]`Sy/dbn

Z* a1`g1x *j ,\`1gn ,Sq,S,E k\ ,TZ 4`\+Sbn d Z1/*W1V\Yd Y*y+dbZn\YdB

w an ) ab,\`p Z\,1 Z1+\ b* 41YWp Z\,dE T Z1 4-*/*pbnaq `1hT V\WSjZTE T Z1 ]`Sy/dbn Z* a1`g1Ix Lı ı :9B5;MD #\ 3 g1 4* w`1hT V\WSjZTxE qVT wZ1 ]`Sy/dbn Z* a1`g1xH ˛ V\Zb1Vabd ,S/Z\E k\ y/1bnaq ]`\ Z1a]`*,1/WS,TabnE f,\`\+SE ab`*3/*ZZq b* +*-*b\ TZjSf WSfE ,T/ qVSf ]\O b1`]*pbn Wp/SD )V ]`S]SZqbnaq ,aT gT WSf*H S`Tj1ZZq 4-*/*ZSf ]`\+W1Y bTaZ\ ]\,Gq4*Z1 4 wZ\,SY Z1+\Yx b* w41YW1p Z\,\pxD

˛Z*h1ZZq gSf ,SaW\,T, T b1E qV ,\ZS ab\adpbnaq Wp/ab,*E ]\qaZp,*bSY1bnaq , ]`\Y\,T w 1 4-*O /*pbnaq `1hT V\WSjZTE T Z1 ]`Sy/dbn Z* a1`g1xD ı^ Y\3Z* +d/1 ]\hdbS Z* \+W*aZSf V\Z-`1a*f ,T/VT, -\,SE qVT ]`\f\/SbSYdbn ]\ ,an\Yd a,TO bT ]T/ -*aW\Y w b1`13S a,\2 a1`g1IxD V`*^ZT V\Z-`1aS ]\hZdbnaq d h1`,ZTD

www.watchtower.org/k

1`/1hZ\ 4*]`\jd2Y\ ,*a ]`SybS Z* \/SZ 4 ZSfD #\+ /T4Z*bSaq ]`\ Z*y+WS3h1 YTag1 ]`\,1/1ZO Zq V\Z-`1adE 4,1`ZTbnaq /\ YTag1,Sf ,T/VT,

-\,S *+\ Z*]SjTbn ,S/*,gqY gn\-\ 3d`Z*Wd Z* \/Zd 4 */`1a Z* 9Oy ab\`TZgTD * ,1+Oa*ybT www.jw.org ]\/*Z\ a]Sa\V YTabE /1 ]`\f\/SbSO Ydbn V\Z-`1aS , V`*^ZTD

g12 05-K

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.