Watchtower 2011

Page 1

34567 5 ˙ 6>55

ı ı• • )˙

˚

34567

S`*3B 86 5:6 >>> S/*2bnaq 5<< Y\,*YS

NOVEMBER 1, 2011

˚ w ı " x ]\Wq-*2 , b\YdE k\+ ]`\aW*,WqbS \-* -\,d qV 1`f\,Z\-\ `*,Sb1Wq a1a,TbdD \/T+Z\ qV 4 ,*`b\,Sf +*jb d /*,ZSZd +dW\ /\+`1 ,S/Z\E k\ ,T/+d,*2bnaq ,/*W1hSZTE Z* ab\`TZV*f gn\-\ 3d`Z*Wd ]`\ab13d2bnaq `\4,Sb\V a,Tb\,Sf ]\/Ty d a,TbWT +T+WTyZSf ]`\`\gb,D w *`b\,* +*jb*x ]\bTj*2 Wp/1y /\+`\p Z\,SZ\p ]`\ b1E k\ \31 *`ab,\ P ,ab*Z\,W1ZSy d Z1+T d`q/ P Z14*+*`\Y ]\VW*/1 V`*y dan\Yd 4Wd T ]1`1YTZSbn 41YWp Z*

`*yD *a\]Sa 4YTgZp2 ,T`d , ıada* `Sab*E qVSy ]\Y1`E k\+ YS Y\-WS \b`SY*bS ,ThZ1 3SbbqE T qVSy b1]1` ab\^bn Z* h\WT \3\-\ *`ab,*D ,T/VS -\,S +14]1`1`,Z\ ,S/*pbn g1y 3d`Z*W 4 5<;= `\VdD TZ 2 ]\WTbShZ\ Z1yb`*WnZSY

T š`dZbd2bnaq Z* T+WT^D

1 /Wq ]`\/*3dD S/*ZZq gT2^ ]d+WTV*gT^ 2 h*abSZ\p ,a1a,TbZn\^ ]`\-`*YS +T+WTyZ\^ \a,TbSE qV* ]T/b`SYd2bnaq /\+`\,TWnZSYS ]\31`b,*YSD `S gSbd,*ZZT ,`1yanVSf Sa*Zn ,SV\`Sab\,d2bnaq ]1`1VW*/ -T2ZV* L,S/*ZZq 6>>6 `\VdE ZdY1`*gTq a*WYT, 4-T/Z\ 4 ,S/*ZZqY 5==> `\VdME * `SabSqZanVSf `1gnVSf Sa*Zn P w 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,TbdxD ıZjT /31`1W* gSb*bB dWDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ dWTj*C P w 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,Tbd ,qb\-\ SanY*x L4 ]`SYTbV*YSE *Z-WDMC \YDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ \Y1ZV*D

ı ı 7 \Yd ,*3WS,\ 4Z*bS ,T/]\,T/nH 8 ˙1aqbn 4*]Sb*Zn ]`\ a1VaD T+WTyZT ,T/]\,T/T < \Yd ,*`b\ 3SbS 4* +T+WTyZSYS ]`SZgS]*YSH

& 5> T+WTq 4YTZp2 3Sbbq 56

S ,S 4Z*2b1H

57

1V`1bS k*aWS,\^ aTYG^D \4,S,*yb1 /df\,ZTabn d ]\/`d33T

5:

\-\ ,hSbn \31 W\,\D \Yd b`1+* /\b`SYd,*bSan \3Sf 4*V\ZT,H

65

*+WS3*yY\an /\ \-*D SV\ZdyY\ a,Ty \+\,Gq4\V ]1`1/ \-\Y

6=

Sb*hT 4*]Sbdpbn

7>

˙Wq pZSf hSb*hT,D `qb\,*ZT 4 \-Z1ZZ\^ ]1hT

˝ ˚ ı

& 5< )V +*bnV\,T ab*bS +WS4nVSY a,\2Yd aSZ\,TH 66

\WS +d, 4ZSk1ZSy ab*`\/*,ZTy `da*WSYH `\ k\ a,T/h*bn -WSZqZT b*+WShVS

˝ ˛

,T/]\,T/nH w) ]\h*W* 4dab`Th*bSaq 4 fW\]gqYS , 5> `\VT,D ]1`jd YS ]`\ab\ b`SY*WSan 4* `dVS T gTWd,*WSanE *W1 Z1,/\,4T ]\h*WS b\`V*bSan ab*b1,Sf \`-*ZT, \/Z1 \/Z\-\ b* ]`\+d,*bS `T4ZT ,S/S a1VadD 59 `\VT, q ,W*jbd,*W*an Z* `\+\bdE T b*Y /\ Y1Z1 ab*WS hT]WqbSaq W*aT Z* a1Va h\W\,TVSD ) +*3*W* ,S-Wq/*bS adh*aZ\pE b\Yd ]\-\/3d,*W*an

Z* ^fZT ]`\]\4SgT^D ˙d31 f\bTW\an +dbS , V\W1VbS,T a,\2pE T h1`14 g1 q ]\h*W* ]`\+d,*bS k\`*4 Z\,TjT e\`YS ab*b1,Sf ab\adZVT,xD ˚• 1 L ı)M

1 ıYGq 4YTZ1Z\D

˝ E ,*a 4/S,d2E *W1 1yb ,SO `\ab*W* , `1WT-TyZTy `\/SZTD *bnVS ,Sf\,d,*WS ^^E Z*Y*-*phSan ]`Sk1]SbS Y\`*WnZT Z\`YS 4 T+WT^D W1 ,\Z* ]TjW* TZjSY jWqf\YD ˙Wq +*-*bn\f Wp/1y `Tj1ZZq 1yb Y\O 31 ,S/*,*bSan Z\`Y*WnZSYD \ZS ,,*3*O pbnE k\ +T+WTyZSy ]\-Wq/ Z* a1Va d31 /*,Z\ 4*ab*`T,D ıZjSY 4/*2bnaqE k\ Y\3O Z* +dbS -WS+\V\ `1WT-TyZSY T ,\/Z\h*a ,1abS +14W*/Z1 ab*b1,1 3SbbqD

S ,*3WS,\ 4Z*bS Z\`YS T+WT^ k\O /\ a1Vad T /\b`SYd,*bSan ^fH q VZS-* Z*bfZ1Z* \-\Y T V\`SaZ* /Wq Z*,h*ZZq L6 SY\eTq 7B5:MD )Vk\ ,S ,T`Sb1E k\ WpO /1y ab,\`S, \- T T+WTq 2 y\-\ Z*bfZ1ZSY

‹ W\,\YE b\ ,*`b\ /\,T/*bSanE k\ ,\Z* V*O 31 Z* gp b1YdD * 3*WnE hSY*W\ Wp/1y Z1 4Z*pbn +T+O WTyZ\-\ ]\-Wq/d Z* a1VaD 1WT-TyZT ]`\O ,T/ZSVSE V\b`T b,1`/qbnE ZT+S Z*,h*pbn 4 T+WT^E \+ab\ppbn ad]1`1hWS,T ]\-Wq/S Z* Y\`*WnD 1Y* a1Vad ab*W* ]`1/Y1b\Y ]\/TO W1Zn YT3 +*-*bnY* ]`\,T/ZSYS `1WT-TqYSD 1 ,*`b\ ]1`1yY*bS ]\-Wq/S TZjSfD *3WS,\ a*YSY /\aWT/SbS gp b1YdD Z*O abd]ZTy ab*bbT `\4-Wq/*2bnaq /1aqbn Z*yO ]\jS`1ZTjSf 4*]Sb*Zn ]`\ ]\-Wq/ T+WT^ Z* a1Va T /*pbnaq hTbVT ,T/]\,T/TE k\ š`dZO bdpbnaq Z* \3\Yd W\,TD ˛ b`1bn\^ ab*bO bT gT2^ a1`T^ ,S /\,T/*2b1anE h\Yd ,*3WS,\ Y*bS ]`*,SWnZSy ]\-Wq/ Z* a1VaD " ˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

7

˙˚ ) & ˛ & ˚

T+WTyZT ,T/]\,T/T 1 S ab*b1,T 4Z\aSZS +dWS bSY ]1`,\`\/ZSY -`Tf\YE qVSy dhSZSWS /*Y 4 ,\p , Ëš/1YanV\Yd a*/dH

2 S a1Vad*WnZ1 4*/\,\W1ZZq P g1 -`TfH

34567 S ,S f\bTWS + \b`SY*bS +TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ k\+ 4 ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\aq +14V\jb\,Z1 /\Y*jZ2 +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqH `\aSY\ Z*/TaW*bS a,\2 ]`\O f*ZZq ,T/V*Y -\,S Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/]\,T/ZSf */`1aE ]\/*ZSf ZS3h1D \,ZSy ]1`1WTV */`1a /S,Tbnaq Z* a*ybT www.watchtower.org/addressD

8

ˇ T/]\,T/nD *-*b\ Wp/1y ]1`1V\Z*ZTE k\ 4*+\`\Z1ZSY ]W\/\Y Z*a]`*,/T +dWS ab*b1,T ab\adZVSD ,bTYE T+WTq Z1 ]T/b,1`/3d2 gn\-\ ]\-Wq/dD #1 /\ ab,\`1ZZq ,S \- Z*V*4*, /*Y\,T Z1 ^abS ]W\O /d w4 /1`1,* 4Z*ZZq /\+`* y 4W*x L dbbq 6B59P5<MD q 4*O +\`\Z* Z1 Y\-W* ab\ad,*bSaq ab*b1,Sf 4Z\aSZE \aVTWnVS /*Y Z* b\y h*a k1 +d, \/SZD `TY b\-\E \- /*, /*Y\O ,T b* ,T hTbVSy Z*V*4B w W\/Tbnaq y `\4YZ\3dyb1aqE T Z*]\,Zpyb1 41YWpx L dbbq 5B6<MD ˙\+`Sy \- Z1 YT- Z*O V*4*bS ]1`jTy ]*`T Z*]\,Zp,*bS 41YWpE k\ +dW\ + Z1O Y\3WS,SY +14 ab*b1,Sf 4Z\aSZE * ]\bTY 4*ad/SbS ^f Z* aY1`bn 4* ,SV\Z*ZZq gn\-\ Z*V*4d L5 Ĺ,*Z* 8B<MD ˙\ b\-\ 3E V\WS ,* w,4qW* 4 4*+\`\Z1Z\-\ ]W\/dE b* y 4G^W*xE /*Y* ]\`dh Z1 +dW\D Sj1 4-\/\Y ,\Z* /*W* b\y ]WT/ wh\W\,TV\,T a,\2YdEP T ,TZ 4G^,x L dbbq 7B:MD \- Z1 \ad/3d,*, /*Y* T ,d 4* b1E k\ ,\ZS Y*WS ab*O b1,T 4Z\aSZS T Z*`\/3d,*WS /Tb1y L dbbq 8B5E 6MD ˛`\4dO YTW\E 4*+\`\Z1ZSY ]W\/\YE qVSy ^WS /*Y T ,*E Z1 +dWS ab*b1,T ab\adZVSD 1 +d, +dV,*WnZSyE 4T`,*ZSy 4 /1`1,* ]WT/D

ˇ T/]\,T/nD 1`j* VZS-* T+WT^ `\4]\,T/*2E k\ \- ab,\O

`S, wh\W\,TV* b* 3TZVdxD ,\`1gn aV*4*, ]`\ /TW\ a,\^f `dVB w 1WnYS /\+`1 ,\Z\x L dbbq 5B6;E 75MD T4ZTj1 ]T/ \O 3SY Z*bfZ1ZZqY \/SZ +T+WTyZSy ]SanY1ZZSV ]\`*/S, h\O W\,TV*YB w */Ty h1`14 3TZVd b,\^f pZSf WTbDDD ^^ ]1`a* Z*O ]\qbn b1+1 V\3Z\h*aZ\x L `S]\,Tab1y 9B5<E 5=MD S gT aW\,* Z*bqV*pbn Z* b1E k\ T+WTq 4*+\`\Zq2 \b`SYd,*bS a1Vad*WnZ1 4*/\,\W1ZZqH

`-1ZbSZ*B Casilla 83 (Suc 27B), C1427WAB Cdad. Aut. de Buenos Aires. TW\`danB 66>>7>E SZaVE *Nq =D 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTqB The Ridgeway, London NW7 1RN. Äą4`*^WnB PO Box 29345, ´ 61293 Tel Aviv. Äąa]*ZTqB Apartado 132, 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz (Madrid). Äąb*WTqB Via della Bufalotta 1281, I-00138 Rome RM. *Z*/*B PO Box 4100, Georgetown, ON L7G 4Y4. \W/\,*E ˘ 1a]d+WTV*B PO Box 472, MD-2005 Chi ¸sinau. TY1hhSZ*B 65617 Selters. \Wnk*B ulD Warszawska 58E >9O<7> NadarzynD \`bd-*WTqB Apartado 91, P-2766-955 Estoril. \aTqB 5=;;7=E *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-E ]D \WZ1hZ\1E dWD `1/ZqqE :D W\,*hhSZ*B PO Box 2, 830 04 Bratislava 34. " B 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. V`*^Z*B *Na =99E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE ;=8=5D `*ZgTqB BP 625, F-27406 Louviers Cedex.

The Watchtower (ISSN 0043-1087) is published semimonthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; M. H. Larson, President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibel- und Traktat-Gesellschaft der Zeugen Jehovas, e. V.E Selters/Taunus. Verantwortliche Redaktion: Ramon Templeton, Selters/Taunus. ˘ 2011 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. aT ]`*,* 4+1`T-*pbnaqD Printed in Germany.

Vol. 132, No. 21

Semimonthly

UKRAINIAN

\- ab,\`S, ab*b1,T \`-*ZS Z1 bTWnVS /Wq b\-\E *+S WpO /S Z*`\/3d,*WS /Tb1yD TZ /*, gT \`-*ZSE k\+ \/`d31Z* ]*`* Y\-W* ,S`*3*bS a,\p Wp+\, T W*aVd \/Z1 \/Z\YdD Ë›*,/qVS gn\Yd h\W\,TV T 3TZV*E YT3 qVSYS ]*Zdpbn +WS4nVT y b1]WT ab\adZVSE Y\3dbn 4*/\,\WnZqbS a,\^ eTO 4ShZT b* 1Y\gTyZT ]\b`1+SD

3 S T+WTq /\4,\Wq2 h\W\,TV\,T b* 3TZgTE qVT Z1 ]1`1+d,*pbn d 4*V\ZZ\Yd jWp+TE 3SbS `*4\YH

ˇ T/]\,T/nD T+WT^ hTbV\ aV*4*Z\B w \- 4*ad/Sbn +Wd/O

ZSVT,x L ,`1^, 57B8MD `1gnV1 aW\,\ ]\`Z1T*E qV1 ]1`1VW*O /*2bnaq aW\,\Y w+Wd/xE Y*2 jS`\V1 4Z*h1ZZq T ab\ad2bnaq Z1Z*W13Z\-\ ,SV\`Sab*ZZq ab*b1,Sf \`-*ZT, YT3 \a\+*O YSE qVT Z1 2 \/`d31ZT \/Z1 4 \/ZSY1D b31E \- 4*ad/3d2 a]TWnZ1 3Sbbq h\W\,TV* T 3TZVS /\ jWp+dE Z*,Tbn qVk\ ,\ZS Y*pbn Z*YT` 4-\/\Y \/`d3SbSaqD *,Tbn qVk\ h\W\,TV T 3TZV* /d31 V\f*pbn \/Z1 \/Z\O -\E 4-T/Z\ 4 \3\p ,SY\-\p ,\ZS Y\3dbn Y*bS ab*b1,T ab\adZVS WSj1 ]TaWq \/`d31ZZqD \- ab,\`S, Z*a T4 4/*bO ZTabp Wp+SbSD *Y1 Wp+\, 2 y\-\ Z*y,S4Z*hZTj\p `SO a\pD \3 ,TZ Y*2 ,aT ]T/ab*,S ,SY*-*bSE k\+ ab*b1,SYS ab\adZV*YS Z*a\W\/3d,*WSaq WSj1 ]\/`d3ZT ]*`SD `\ g1 ybSY1bnaq , Z*abd]ZTy ab*bbTD 1 \`Z1T* b*V\3 ab\ad2bnaq TZjSf /TyE qVT ad]1`1h*bn \3\Yd Z*YT`d k\/\ ,SV\`Sab*ZZq ab*b1,Sf \`-*ZT, Wp/1yD p/S Y\3Z* 4*`*fd,*bS ]1O `1Wp+E -\Y\a1Vad*WT4Y T aV\b\W\4b,\D

4 )V \- ab*,Sbnaq /\ +*-*b\jWp+Z\abTH

Ë™ & ) 5<< B *41`+*y/3*ZanV*E *41`O +*y/3*ZanV* LVS`SWShZ1 ]SanY\ME *yY*`*E *W+*ZanO V*E *Yf*`anV*E *Z-WTyanV*687 Lb*V\3 j`Seb\Y `*yWqME *`*+anV*E *e`SV*ZaE *h\WTE +*dW1E +1Y+*E +1Z-*WnanO V*E +TV\WnanV*E +T`Y*ZanV*E +TaW*Y*E +\W-*`anV*E ,*WO WTaTyanV*E ,*`*yO,*`*yE ,1Z/*E ,G2bZ*YanV*E ,T`Y1ZO

anV*E ,T`Y1ZanV* L4*fT/Z*ME -*E -*^bqZanV* V`1\WnanV*E -*ZE -TW+1`banV*E -TZ/TE -`1ZW*Z/anV*E -`1gnV*E -`d4SZO anV*E -d*`*ZTE -d/3*`*bTE /*banV*7E 1,1E 1ab\ZanV*E 1eTVE 2,`1yanV* LT,`SbME 4*Z/1E 4dWdE T+\E TW\V*ZanV*E TZ/\O Z14TyanV*E TaW*Z/anV*E Ta\V\E Ta]*ZanV*687E Tb*WTyanV*67E ‹ y\`d+*E V*4*fanV*E V*Z*/*E V*\Z/1E V1hd*E V1hd* L ZO V*jME V1hd* L qVdh\ME V1hd* L \WT,TqME V1hd* L daV\ME VS`-S4nV*E VSb*yanV*7 L*d/T\4*]Sa bTWnVS Y*Z/*`SZO

ˇ T/]\,T/nD 1,ZSy h*a \- /\4,\Wq, h\W\,TV*YS Y*O bS +TWnj1E ZT3 \/Zd /`d3SZd L dbbq 8B5=C 5:B5P8C 6=B5<P7>B68MD W1 \- Z1 4*]\h*bVd,*, 4,Sh*p +*-*b\O jWp+Z\abTD TZ /*, /*Y\,T bTWnVS \/Zd /`d3SZdD

,\`1gn /\`dhS, ıadad `Sabd Z*Z\,\ db,1`/SbS ]\O h*bV\,d Z\`Yd k\/\ \/Z\jWp+Z\abT Lı,*Z* <B6<MD \WS ıada* 4*]Sb*WS ]`\ jWp+E ,TZ ,T/]\,T,B w \yE fb\ ab,\O `S, ^fE ,T/ a*Y\-\ ]\h*bVd ab,\`S, ^f qV h\W\,TV* T 3TZO VdH ı fT+* Z1 hSb*WSE k\ ,TZ aV*4*,B r \Yd ]\VSZ1 h\W\O ,TV +*bnV* T Y*bT` b* ]`SWT]Sbnaq /\ a,\2^ /`d3SZSE T ab*Zdbn \+\2 \/ZSY bTW\Ysx L *b,Tq 5=B8E 9MD

anV\p Y\,\pME VSb*yanV* La]`\k1Z1 ]SanY\ME VTVdypE VTZnq`d*Z/*E VT`dZ/TE V\Z-\E V\Z-\ LV\WSjZq Y\Z\VdbdO +*ME V\`1yanV*67E V\a*E Vd*Z-*WTE Vd*ZnqY*E VfY1`anV*E W*bSanV*E WSb\,anV*E W\4TE Wd+*E Wd,*W1E Wd-*Z/*E WdZO /*E Wd\E Y*,`SVTyanV* V`1\WnanV*E Y*yqE Y*V1/\ZanV*E Y*W*-*aTyanV*E Y*W*qW*YE Y*WnbTyanV*E Y*`*bfTE Y*`O j*WWnanV*E Y+dZ/dE YT4\E YTf1E Y\`1E Z-*W*E Z/1+1W1E Z/\Z-*E Z1]*WnanV*E Z41Y*E ZT/1`W*Z/anV*67E ZTY1gnO V*67E ZTd1E Z\`,14nV*67E ZnqZ1V*E \`\Y\E \a1bSZanV*E \b1b1W*E ]*W*dE ]*Z-*aSZ*ZanV*E ]*]GqY1Zbd L p`*a*\ME ]1/TE ]1Z/3*+anV*E ]1`anV*E ]T/3SZ \W\Y\Z\,Sf \abO `\,T,E ]\WnanV*67E ]\Z*]1E ]\`bd-*WnanV*687E `*`\b\Z-*E `\aTyanV*67E `dYdZanV*E a*Y\*E a*Z-\E a*]\b1V LıabYdaME a,*4TE a1+d*ZanV*E a1yj1WnanV* V`1\WnanV*E a1`+anV*E

a1`+anV* LW*bSZanV1 ]SanY\ME a1adb\E aSZ-*WnanV*E aW\O ,*gnV*E aW\,1ZanV*E a`*Z*ZOb\Z-\E ad*fTWTE b*-*WnanO

V*7E b*^bqZanV*E b*yanV*E b*YTWnanV*E b*b*`anV*E b,TE b1O Wd-dE b1bdYE bS,E bS-`SZnqE b\VO]TaSZE b\Z-*E b\b\Z*VE b`dVE ba,*Z*E ba\Z-*E bd,*WdE bdY+dV*E bd`1gnV*E d-\`anO

V*67E d4+1gnV*E dV`*^ZanV*E dY+dZ/dE d`/dE d`ddZ/E eTO /3TyanV*E eTZanV*7E e`*Zgd4nV*687E f*da*E fTWT-*yZ\ZE fTO `TOY\bdE f\`,*banV*E g\gTWnE h1anV*7E hSh1,*E hTWd+*E hTb\Z-*E j,1/anV*7E j\Z*E q]E q]\ZanV*67D 6 *V\3 CDD 8 *V\3 MP3 CD-ROMD 7 d/T\4*]SaS b*V\3 /\abd]ZT Z* www.jw.org.

T4ZTj1 \/SZ 4 ıada\,Sf dhZT, ]T/ \3SY Z*bfZ1ZO ZqY Z*]Sa*,B w 1f*y V\31Z h\W\,TV Y*2 a,\p /`d3SZdE * 3TZV* P h\W\,TV*x L5 \`SZeqZ ;B6MD T+WTq b*V\3 -\O ,\`SbnE k\ \/`d31ZSy h\W\,TVE V\b`\Yd Z*/*pbnaq \a\+O WS,T \+\,Gq4VS d f`SabSqZanV\Yd 4+\`TE ]\,SZ1Z +dbS wh\W\,TV\Y \/ZT2^ /`d3SZSx L5 SY\eTq 7B6E 56MD

5 S 2 -`Tf\YE V\WS ]\/`d3ZT ]*`S ,SV\`Sab\,dpbn ]`\bS4*]WT/ZT 4*a\+SH

ˇ T/]\,T/nD T ıadaE ZT y\-\ dhZT Z1 Z*V*4d,*WS f`SabSqO Z*Y Y*bS /Tb1yD `TY b\-\E ZT/1 , T+WT^ Z1 4*ad/3d2bnaq ,SV\`Sab*ZZq ]`\bS4*]WT/ZSf 4*a\+T,D \/`d3ZT ]*`S Y\3dbn a*YT ,S`Tjd,*bSE hS Y*bS /TO b1yE aVTWnVS ^f Y*bS T V\WSD )Vk\ h\W\,TV b* 3TZV* f\O hdbn ,SV\`Sab\,d,*bS Z1*+\`bS,ZT V\Zb`*g1]bS,SE b\ g1 ^fZ2 \a\+Sab1 `Tj1ZZq b* ,T/]\,T/*WnZTabn1D Tfb\ Z1 ]\O ,SZ1Z ^f 4* g1 4*ad/3d,*bS L SYWqZ 58B8E 5>P57MD 1 TWnj1 ]`\ +T+WTyZSy ]\-Wq/ Z* ab1`SWT4*gTp Y\3Z* /T4Z*bSaq 4T ab*bbT w˛*]Sb*ZZq hSb*hT,xE Z*/`dV\,*ZTy d w *`b\,Ty +*jbTx 4* 59 h1`,O Zq 5=== `\VdE aD 6;E 6<D

6 S *+\`b P g1 -`TfH

7 S T+WTq /\4,\Wq2 `\4Wdh*bSanH

: "

ˇ T/]\,T/nD ˙Wq \-* 3Sbbq 2 a,qk1ZZSYE T Z*,Tbn 4*`\O /\V ,TZ ,,*3*2 Z\,SYE \V`1YSY 3SbbqY L a*W\Y 57=B5:MD ˛-T/Z\ T4 4*V\Z\Y \-* b\yE fb\ 4*,/*, jV\/S Z1Z*`\/31O ZTy /SbSZTE ZTa 4* g1 ,T/]\,T/*WnZTabnD \3Sf \h*f 4ZSO k1ZZq Z1Z*`\/31Z\^ /SbSZS P g1 ,+S,ab,\ L SfT/ 6>B57C 65B66E 67MD qV +dbS , V`SbShZTy aSbd*gT^E V\WS ]T/ h*a ]\W\-T, ]\/`d33p b`1+* 4`\+SbS ,S+T`B 3Sbbq Y*b1`T hS Z1Y\,O WqbSH b*V\Yd `*4T h\W\,TV T /`d3SZ* ]\,SZZT a*YT ,SO `TjSbSE hS2 3Sbbq `qbd,*bSD

ˇ T/]\,T/nD *VD ,bTYE ıada ]\qaZS,E k\ 2 WSj1 \/Z* ]T/ab*,* `\4T`,*bS jWp+E aV*4*,jSB w b\ `\4Wdh*2bnaq 4T a,\2p /`d3SZ\p Z1 h1`14 +Wd/ ]\4*jWp+ZT ab*b1,T 4Z\aSZS T \/`d3d2bnaq 4 TZj\pE b\y hSZSbn ]1`1Wp+x L *b,Tq 5=B=MD \- Z1Z*,S/Sbn `\4Wdh1ZZqE 4`\+W1Z1 4 ]T/abd]ZSY Z*O YT`\YD TZ \a\+Sab\ ]`Sbq-Z1 /\ ,T/]\,T/*WnZ\abT Wp/SO ZdE qV* W1-V\,*3Z\ ]\VS/*2 jWp+Z\-\ ]*`bZ1`*E 4\V`1O Y* /Wq b\-\E k\+ 3SbS 4 TZj\p \a\+\p L *W*fT^ 6B57P5:C *`V* 5>B=MD

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

8 )V \- ab*,Sbnaq /\ -\Y\a1Vad*WT4YdH

9 S ,,*3*2bnaq -`Tf\Y a1Va ]\ b1W1e\ZdE a1VabSZ- b* VT+1`a1VaH

10 #\ T+WTq -\,\`Sbn ]`\ Y*abd`+*gTpH

ˇ T/]\,T/nD \31 W\,\ hTbV\ 4*ad/3d2 +Wd/E /\ qV\O -\ Z*W13*bn b*V\3 -\Y\a1Vad*WnZT ab\adZVS L SYWqZ 5B6:E 6;C *W*bT, 9B5=P65MD \h* T+WTq -\,\`SbnE k\ \- Z1 af,*Wp2 b*V\^ ]\,1/TZVSE d ZTy b13 aV*4*Z\B w \- b*V ]\O Wp+S, a,TbE k\ ,T//*, a,\-\ 2/SZ\`\/Z\-\ SZ*E *+S V\O 31ZE fb\ ,Sq,Wq2E k\ ,T`Sbn d Zn\-\E Z1 +d, 4ZSk1ZSyE * \b`SY*, 3Sbbq ,ThZ1x Lı,*Z* 7B5:MD `*,/S,T f`SabSqZS Z1 \]`*,/\,dpbn -\Y\a1Vad*WT4O YdE \/Z*V ,\ZS ,Sq,Wqpbn /\+`\bd /\ ,aTf L *b,Tq ;B56MD \- f\h1E *+S YS j*Zd,*WS w,aTWqVSf Wp/1yxD \Yd a]`*,3ZT f`SabSqZS Z1 ,Sq,Wqpbn Z1Z*,SabT hS Z1]`SO q4ZT /\ -\Y\a1Vad*WTabT, L5 1b`* 6B5;MD ˇ T/]\,T/nD 1Va ]\ b1W1e\Zd P g1 `\4Y\,S ]`\ a1Va *+\ ]`\aWdf\,d,*ZZq ,T/,1`bSf 1`\bShZSf b1VabT, ]\ b1W1O e\ZdD 1VabSZ- ab\ad2bnaq Z*/aSW*ZZq h1`14 Y\+TWnZSy b1W1e\Z 1`\bShZSf 4\+`*31Zn hS ]\,T/\YW1Zn a1Vad*WnO Z\-\ 4YTabdD T+1`a1Va P g1 \ZW*yZ\,Sy ]1`1-Wq/ ]\ ıZO b1`Z1bd 1`\bShZSf /TyD T+WT^ ZTh\-\ Z1 -\,\`Sbnaq ]`\ a1Va ]\ b1W1e\ZdE a1VabSZ- hS VT+1`a1VaD W1 , ZTy aV*4*Z\B w 1f*y +Wd/ T ,aTWqV* Z1hSab\b* y Z1Z*aSbZTabn Z*,Tbn Z1 4-*/dpbnO aq a1`1/ ,*aE +\ g1 Z1 WShSbn a,qbSYD 1 WShSbn T -*O Z1+Z* ]\,1/TZV*E +14-Wd4/* +*W*V*ZSZ* b* Z1]`Sab\yZT 3*`bSx L˚e1aqZ 9B7E 8MD dh*aZT ,T`bd*WnZT ,S/S a1VO ad a]\b,\`ppbn ]\-Wq/ Z* ab*b1,1 3Sbbq T ]T/jb\,fdO pbn Wp/1y 4*/\,\WnZqbS a,\2 a1Vad*WnZ1 +*3*ZZq ]\4* jWp+\YD \ZS Z1 /\]\Y*-*pbn V\Zb`\Wp,*bS ab*b1,Sy ]\bq-E * a]\ZdVdpbn 4*/\,\WnZqbS ,W*aZd ]\fTbnD

ˇ T/]\,T/nD T+WT^ Z1 4-*/d2bnaq aW\,* wY*abd`+*gTqxE qV1 \4Z*h*2 Z*,YSaZ1 ]\/`*4Z1ZZq ab*b1,Sf \`-*ZT,E k\ ]`S4,\/Sbn /\ ab*b1,\-\ 4+d/31ZZq b* \`-*4YdD `\b1 \O 31 W\,\ Z*V*4d2 f`SabSqZ*YB w Y1`b,Tbn ]\`\VSE V\b`T Z*`\/3dpbnaq d ,*jSf 41YZSf bTW*fB +Wd/E Z1hSab\bdE ]\fTbnx L \W\aqZ 7B9MD *abd`+*gTq e\`Yd2 a]\b,\`1ZSy b* 1-\^abShZSy ]\O -Wq/ Z* a1VaD T+WTq 4*]1,Zq2E k\ \- /*2 waSWdE qV* ]1O `1,1`jd2 Wp/anVdxE *+S bTE fb\ +\`1bnaq 4 gT2p 4,ShV\pE Y\-WS ^^ ]\4+dbSaq L6 \`SZeqZ 8B;C SWS]GqZ 8B57MD " ˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

;

˝ ˛

+T+WTyZSYS ]`SZgS]*YSH ı ı• • ]\-Wq/ Z* a1Va 4*ab*O `TWSy T Z*/b\ ad,\`SyH 3 ZTqVD T+O WTq /\]\Y*-*2 Z*Y dZSV*bSB

ˇ f,\`\+E k\ ]1`1/*pbnaq ab*b1,SY jWqf\Y

]\4*jWp+Z\ ^ ,*-TbZ\abT ˇ ˇ +\WTaZSf Z*aWT/VT, `\4+Sb\-\ ]\/`d3Zn\-\ 3Sbbq YdV adYWTZZq ˇ ˇ ,b`*bS a*Y\]\,*-S

,\`1gnE \- -\,*1E f\h1E k\+ V\31Z 4 Z*a ,bTj*,aq y\-\ /*`*YSD TZ wZ*,h*2 b1+1 ]`\ V\`SaZ1x Lıa*^ 8<B5;MD \yE fb\ /\b`SYd2bnaq +T+WTyZSf ,V*4T,\V k\/\ a1VadE Y*2B

ˇ af,*W1ZZq ,T/ \-* ˇ /dj1,ZSy YS` ˇ YTgZd aTYGp ˇ /\+`d `1]db*gTp ˇ a*Y\]\,*-d

\yE fb\ Z1fbd2 +T+WTyZSYS ]`SZgS]*YSE Z1`T/V\ 4*4Z*2 -WS+\V\-\ +\Wp < "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

k\E V\WS ,S Z1 3S,1b1 4* +T+WTyZSO YS ]`SZgS]*YS Y\`*WTH S ,*Y ]T/ aSWd 4YTZSbS a,Ty a]\aT+ 3SbbqH S \- V*`*O bSY1 ,*a 4* V\WSjZp ]\,1/TZVdH \/dY*yY\B /1qVT `*ZZT f`SabSqZS V\O WSan +dWS +Wd/ZSV*YSE ]1`1Wp+ZSV*YS T -\Y\a1Vad*WTab*YSD W1 ,\ZS 4YTZSWS a,\2 3Sbbq y \b`SY*WS ,1WSVT +W*-\aW\O ,1ZZq L5 \`SZeqZ :B=P55MD SZT bSaqO hT Wp/1y ]\ gTW\Yd a,TbT ,31 ,T/VSZdWS V\WSjZTy a]\aT+ 3SbbqD \ZS ]1`1ab*O WS ]\,\/SbSan `\4+1k1Z\ T ,T/hdWS `*O /Tabn ,T/ b\-\E k\ /\b`SYdpbnaq +T+WTyO 1 -\,* P g1 \a\+Sab1 TYGq \-*E qV1 4-*/d2bnaq , T+WT^D

ZSf ]`SZgS]T,D gn\Yd ]1`1V\Z*W*aq 1ybE ]`\ qVd `\4]\,T/*W\aq , ]1`jTy ab*bbTD w) ,T/`*4d ,T/hdW* ]\W1-j1ZZqx 1yb ]\+*hSW*E k\ ^^ +14W*/ZSy a]\aT+ 3Sbbq Z1 ]`SZTa +*3*Z\^ a,\+\/S T 4*/\O ,\W1ZZqD \Z* `\4]\,T/*2B w) 4`\4dYTW*E k\ Y\2 adYWTZZq ]`Sbd]SW\aqD dW\ /dO 31 a\`\YZ\E T q +\qW*aq 4*,*-TbZTbS *+\ ]T/f\]SbS 3*fWS,d f,\`\+dD Y1Z1 ZTO V\WS Z1 ,SZSV*W\ adYZT,T,E k\ \- TaZd2 T k\ Y\q ]\,1/TZV* 4*,/*2 y\Yd +\WpD ) ]\hd,*W*an +`d/Z\pE T g1 /d31 -ZTO bSW\xD Ë›`1jb\pE 1yb ,T/,*3SW*an 4YTZSbS a,\2 3SbbqD \Z* ]\]`\aSW* +*bnVT,E qVT 2 ,T/V*YS -\,SE /\]\Y\-bS ^yD *V\3 ,\Z* 4,1`ZdW*an ]\ /\]\Y\-d /\ f`SaO bSqZanVSf ab*`TyjSZ YTag1,\-\ 4+\`dD 1yb ]`S-*/d2B w 1Z1 ]`S2YZ\ ,`*4SW* b1]W\b* T Wp+\, +*bnVT, b* ab*`TyjSZD ) ,T/`*4d ,T/hdW* ]\W1-j1ZZqxD

1]1` 1yb a*Y* ,Sf\,d2 /,\f /Tb1yD \Z* V*31B w) Z1 ]`Sf\,dp ,T/ a,\^f ‹ /Tb1y b\-\E k\ 4*4Z*W* , 3SbbTD ˙d31 f\h1bnaqE k\+ ,\ZS `\4dYTWSE /\ h\-\ ]`S4,T, YTy Z1]\aWdf \3SY 4*V\Z*YD ) ,T/ dan\-\ a1`gq ]`*-ZdE k\+ /TbS da,TO /\YWp,*WS gTZZTabn \3\-\ ]\-Wq/d Z* a1VaE +\ g1 a]`SqbSY1 ^fZn\Yd eT4ShZ\O YdE `\4dY\,\Yd b* 1Y\gTyZ\Yd 4/\`\,GpD \- /*, Z*Y Y\`*WnZT ]`SZgS]SE +\ Z1 f\h1E k\+ YS 4*4Z*,*WS +\WpxD S b*V\3 Y\31b1 ]1`1V\Z*bSan d gTZO Z\abT \3Sf ,V*4T,\V1D T+WT^ 4*]Sa*O Z* b*V* \+TgqZV*B w ]`*,1/WS,T \a]\/ZT Z*V*4SE +\ a1`g1 ,\ZS 4,1a1WqpbnD ˛*]\O ,T/n \a]\/* hSab*EP ,\Z* \hT ]`\a,TbO Wp2DDD , /\b`SY*ZZT ^f P Z*-\`\/* ,1WSO V*x L a*W\Y 5=B=E 56MD 1 )Vk\ ,S +*3*2b1 /\,T/*bSan +TWnj1 ]`\ /TO 2,T ]\`*/S 4 T+WT^E 4,1`b*yb1an /\ ,T/VT, -\O ,S d ,*jTy YTag1,\abTD +\ ]SjTbn Z* ,T/]\,T/Zd */`1adE k\ Z* ab\`TZgT 8E hS ,T/,T/*yb1 Z*j a*yb www.watchtower.org

\yE fb\ /\b`SYd2bnaq +T+WTyZSf ]`SZgS]T,E Y*2 hSab1 adYWTZZq T YTgZd aTYGp " Ë™ 5 Ë™ 6>55

=

ı ı) ˛ ı ( ˝ ) # *4*`bZ\-\ -`*,gq T 4W\/Tq ]\+\`\bS a,\p 4*W13ZTabn T 4YTZSbS a]\aT+ 3SbbqH `\hSb*yb1E k\ ,TZ a*Y ]`\ g1 V*31D

w) +d, e*Z*b\Y aV*V\,Sf V\Z1yx ı ˙ (

ı ˙˝˚ )B 5=:9 ˙˚ ˙ )B ) • ˛ ˝ )B ˛ ˚ ı ˛ ˚

˚D ) ,S`\ab*, d +T/Z\YdE -daO b\Z*a1W1Z\Yd `*y\ZT TZ-ab\Z* P ab\WSO gT )Y*yVSD *Y ]*Zd,*WS +14`\+Tbbq T 4W\hSZZTabnD *Z/S Z*-*ZqWS Z* Wp/1y ab`*fD *W\ Z1 k\/Zq /\,\/SW\an hdbS ab`TWqZSZdD *Y* +*-*b\ ]`*gp,*W*E k\+ YS 4 Y\O W\/jSY +`*b\Y T a1ab`\p Z1 f\/SWS -\O W\/ZTD \Z* ab*`*W*an /*bS Z*Y /\+`d \a,TbdD * Y1Z1 Y*W\ gTV*,SW\ Z*,h*ZO Zq P q +d, e*Z*b\Y aV*V\,Sf V\Z1yE b\O Yd ,bTV*, 4 d`\VT, Z* T]\/`\Y T Z*,Tbn ^4O /S, ,1`fSD 1,/\,4T Y1Z1 4*bq-ZdWS *4*`bZT T-O `S P q ]\h*, `\+SbS ab*,VS Z* VTZZSf ]1`1-\Z*fD ) b13 ,bq-Zd,aq , Z1Y\`*WnO Zd ]\,1/TZVd T ab*, 4*,4qbSY +*+T2YD `TY b\-\E Vd`S, Y*`Sfd*Zd T -`*+d,*, Wp/1yE k\+ Y*bS -`\jTD Y1Z1 +dW\ +*O -*b\ ]Tab\W1bT,E *W1E Z* k*abqE ]T/ h*a ]\-`*+d,*Zn 3\/Z* 4 Y\^f 31`b, Z1 ,b`*O bSW* 3SbbqD 5> "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

˛`1jb\p Y1Z1 4W\,SW* ]\WTgTq T 4* aV\2ZT 4W\hSO ZS VSZdW* 4* š`*bSD `\b1 ]TaWq 4,TWnZ1ZZq q 4Z\,d ,4q,aq 4* ab*`1E * Z*,Tbn ab*, k1 -T`jSYD ı f\h* 4 ,S-Wq/d q 4/*,*,aq W*-T/O ZSYE Z*a]`*,/T +d, ,]1`O bSYE *-`1aS,ZSY b* 3\`aO b\VSY T /dY*, WSj1 ]`\ a1+1D

) ı ı) ˛ ı ˝

)D \VS q ,T, +dyZ1 3SbbqE Y*Y* ,S,h*W* T+O WTp T ab*W* ,T/V\Y -\,SD 1Z1 /d31 4*gTV*,SW\E h\Yd ,\Z* Z*aVTWnVS 4YTZSO W*aqD 1 a]\ZdV*W\ Y1Z1 b*V\3 ]\h*bS \+-\,\`1ZZq T+WT^ 4T ,T/V*YSD ˛ h*a\Y q ]\+*hS,E k\ ,h1ZZq ,T/VT, -\,S ,T/`T4Zqpbnaq ,T/ dh1Zn TZjSf `1O WT-Ty T k\ ,aT a,\^ aW\,* gT Wp/S ]T/b,1`O /3dpbn ,T`j*YS 4 T+WT^D Sj1 ,\ZS ]`\]\,T/d,*WS ,T/ /\Yd /\ /\YdE qV g1 `\+SWS ]1`jT f`SabSqZS L *b,Tq 6<B5=C ˙T^ 6>B6>MD \WS q ]\+*hS,E qV* kS`* Wp+\, ]*Zd2 YT3 ZSYSE b\ ]1`1V\Z*,O aqE k\ 4Z*yj\, ]`*,/S,d `1WT-Tp Lı,*Z* 57B79MD T+WTq /\]\Y\-W* Y1ZT 4`\4dYTbSE k\ b`1+* /\V\`TZZ\ YTZqbS 3SbbqD ) /\,TO /*,aqE k\ \- -\,* Z1Z*,S/Sbn +Wd/ TE k\+ ]\/\+*bSan \-\,TE b`1+* ,T/VSZdbS ,a1E k\ Y1Z1 \]\-*Zp2 L6 \`SZeqZ ;B5C ,`1^, 57B8MD 1Z1 4,\`djSW\ b1E k\ -\O ,* Y*2 ]\hdbbq T a,\^YS ,hSZV*YS Y\3O Z* *+\ 4*aYdbSbS y\-\E *+\ ]`SZ1abS y\O

Yd `*/Tabn L `S]\,Tab1y 6;B55MD \Yd q ,S`TjS, VSZdbS ]*WSbS Y*`Sfd*ZdE ]\4O +d,aq ,aTf ]Tab\W1bT, T ]\h*, ]`*gp,*bS Z*/ a,\^YS `Sa*YS f*`*Vb1`dD *y,*3h1 +dW\ ]\VSZdbS Z1Y\`*WnZSy a]\aT+ 3SbO bq y *4*`bZT T-`SD ]1`jd q ]`Sf\,d,*, ,T/ /`d4T,E k\ ,S,h*p T+WTp 4T ,T/V*YS -\,SD W1 ,a1 4YTZSW\an ]TaWq b\-\E qV q ]`\hSb*, *b,Tq 5>B77E /1 4*]Sa*Z\ ıada\,T aW\,*B w b\ 4`1h1bnaq Y1Z1 ]1`1/ Wp/nYSE b\-\ T q 4`1hdaq ]1`1/ Y\^Y Z1+1aZSY *bnO V\YxD 1 a]\ZdV*W\ Y1Z1 `\4]\,TabS ]`SO qb1WqY ]`*,/dD \ZS +dWS j\V\,*ZT y Z1 ,T`SWSE k\ b*VSyE qV qE 4*f\bT, ab*bS ,T/V\YD ) ]\qaZS, /`d4qYE k\ ,S`TjS, ]\`,*bS 4 YSZdWSYD ) • ˝ ) D *Y* /dO 31 `*/TW*E V\WS q ]\h*, 3SbS 4* +T+WTyO ZSYS ]`SZgS]*YSD \Z* +TWnj1 Z1 b`SO ,\3SbnaqE k\ q ,hSZp k\an 3*fWS,1D

1]1` YS 4 Z1p Y\31Y\ `\4Y\,WqbS ]`\ ‹ b1E k\ Z*a 2/Z*2 P ]`\ Wp+\, /\ -\,SD ıZV\WS q 4-*/dp ]`\ a,\2 YSZdW1D 3 Z1 ,T`SbnaqE k\ Y\2 3Sbbq Z*abTWnVS 4YTZSO W\aqD 1 ab*W\ Y\3WS,SY 4*,/qVS \-\O

w 1Z1 4,\`djSW\ b1E k\ -\,*

Y*2 ]\hdbbq T a,\^YS ,hSZV*YS Y\3Z* *+\ 4*aYdbSbS y\-\E *+\ ]`SZ1abS y\Yd `*/Tabnx

,TD 1Z1 +TWnj1 Z1 ]`S,*+Wppbn -`\jT b* Z1Y\`*WnZTabnE qVT V\WSan +dWS b*VSYS 3*/*ZSYSD )V+S Z1 +T+WTyZ* ]`*,/*E q +d, +S ,31 /*,Z\ Y1`b,SY *+\ aS/T, +S 4* š`*b*YSD

1]1` d Y1Z1 2 hd/\,* T k*aWS,* aTYGqD *4\Y 4 /+*yWS,\p /`d3SZ\p T aWdfZqO Z\p /\hV\p YS `*/TaZ\ aWd3SY\ \-d -\,TD ) ,/qhZSyE k\ ,TZ /\4,\WS, Y1ZT ]`S2/Z*bSan /\ hd/\,\-\ f`SabSqZanV\O -\ +`*bab,*D k1 ,/qhZSy ,T/V*Y 4* ,aT ^fZT 4daSWWq Z*,hSbS Y1Z1 ]`*,/SD ) /\`\3d bSYE k\ b*V\3 Y*p 4Y\-d ]1`1O /*,*bS Wp/qY +T+WTyZT TabSZSD a\+WS,\ /qVdp \-d -\,TE qVSy ,Sq,S, a1`/1hO Zd /\+`\bd T ]`S,T, Y1Z1 /\ a1+1D

˛ /`d3SZ\p T /\ZnV\p ) ]\+*hS,E Z*aVTWnVS aSWnZ\ Y*Y* 4YTZSW*aq

" ˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

55

˛ ˚H ˛* qVT V\jbS ]T/b`SYd,*W\aq aWd3TZZq ]`S f`*YT -\,S , `da*WSYTH

& ˚ Top: Clara Emit, Courtesy of Israel Antiquities Authority; bottom: Zev Radovan

ˇ T4ZT ,S/S aWd3TZZq ]`S f`*YT ]T/O b`SYd,*WSaq 4*,/qVS \]\/*bVd,*ZZpE 4/1+TWnj\-\ 4*,/qVS \+\,Gq4V\,\Yd 4+\`d /1aqbSZSD `\b1 ,SV\`Sab\,d,*O WSaq b*V\3 TZjT e\`YS \]\/*bVd,*ZZqD

*]`SVW*/E 4* h*ad ]\+d/\,S aVSZT^ -\,* aV*4*, \ya12,T 4T+`*bS ]\ ]\O W\,SZT a`T+Z\-\ j1V1Wq 4 V\3Z\-\ T4O

`*^WnbqZSZ*E qVSy ]`\yj\, ]1`1]SaD 1 Y*W\ +dbS w]`SZ\j1ZZq /Wq \a]\/*x L SfT/ 7>B56P5:MD h1,S/Z\E 4 h*a\Y d,TyjW\ d 4,Sh*y b1E k\+ V\31Z 2,`1y 31`b,d,*, a*Y1 gp adYd qV k\`ThZSy f`*Y\,Sy ]\/*O b\VD W*aZ1 g1y ]\/*b\V ıada Z*V*4*, 1b`\,T a]W*bSbS Y\Z1b\pE 4Z*y/1Z\p , `\bT `S+S L *b,Tq 5;B68P6;MD TWnV* `\VT, b\Yd , `da*WSYT ,T/O V\]*WS /,T a`T+ZT Y\Z1bSE qVSYS V\WSan

a]W*hd,*WS f`*Y\,Sy ]\/*b\VD /Zd Y\Z1bdE ,SV*`+d,*Zd , S`T 66 `\O Vd ZD 1DE 4Z*yjWS d ,\/\abThZTy V*Z*,T ]1`j\-\ ab\`ThhqD * \/Z\Yd +\gT j1O V1Wq ,SV*`+d,*Z1 4\+`*31ZZq 1WnO V*`b*E b\+b\ **W*E -\W\,Z\-\ bS`anO V\-\ +\31ab,*E * Z* /`d-\Yd P \`1WE k\ aS/Sbn Z* Z\aT ad/Z*D ıZjd Y\Z1bd 4Z*yjWS a1`1/ V*YGqZSf +`SWE qVT ,SO

yZqWS 4 f`*Y\,\^ -\`SD \Z* /*bd2bnaq ]1`jSY `\V\Y p/1yanV\-\ ]\,ab*ZO Zq ]`\bS SYd L::P:; `TV ZD 1DMD * ZTy ,SV*`+d,*Z\ h*jd T b`S -`*Z*b\,T +db\ZSE * b*V\3 Z*]SaSB w T,j1V1Wqx T w ,qbSy `da*WSYxD `\e1a\` 1y+O `T1W *`V1y 4*4Z*hS,E k\ Z* gTy Y\Z1O bT w2 aWT/S ]\jV\/31Zn ,T/ ,\-ZpE \h1O ,S/Z\ ,T/ ]\313TE , qVTy ;> `\Vd ZD 1D +d, 4ZSk1ZSy ˙`d-Sy `*YxD

*aVTWnVS ,1WShZSYS +dWS +d/T,1WnZT ]`\1VbS ,*,SW\ZanV\-\ g*`q *,df\/\Z\a\`*H

ˇ +T+WTyZTy VZS4T ˙*ZS^W* 4*]Sa*ZT

ı"

b*VT aW\,* *,df\/\Z\a\`*B w S 3 g1 Z1 ,1WShZSy *,SW\ZE k\ q 4+d/d,*, y\-\ Z* /TY g*`ab,* YTggp ]\bd-S a,\O

2^ b* Z* aW*,d Y\2^ ]SjZ\bSHx L˙*ZSO

^W* 8B6;MD S a]`*,/T ab*`\/*,Z2 YTaO b\ *,SW\Z +dW\ b*VSY ,1WShZSYH ıab\`SVS ,S4Z*pbnE k\ *,df\/\O Z\a\` +d/d,*, f`*YSE ]*W*gSE YTanO VT Yd`S T `\4VTjZSy a*/ Z* b1`*O a*fD \W\,ZSy f`*Y d g1Zb`T *,SW\Z* Y*, ,13d L4SVd`*bME qV*E Y\3WSO ,\E +dW* 4*,,SjVS ]\Z*/ ;> Y1b`T,D `\b1 wZ*y,S4Z*hZTjSY 4/\+dbV\Y *,df\/\Z\a\`* ab*W* /\`\-* `\g1O aTy T +`*Y* +\-SZT ıjb*`xEP aV*4*Z\ , \/ZTy VZS3gT ]`\ ab*`\/*,ZTy *O

56 "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

,SW\ZD ˙\`\-* `\g1aTyE qV* ]`\f\O /SW* h1`14 +`*Yd +\-SZT ıjb*`E +dW* ]`SV`*j1Z* +*`1Wn2e*YS T4 4\+`*O 31ZZqYS W1,T,E k\ y/dbnD `\ a*Yd

+`*YdE Z*y]SjZTjSy ,G^4/ /\ *,SW\O Z*E d bTy 31 VZS3gT -\,\`SbnaqB w \O Z* +dW* ]\,ZTabp \+WShV\,*Z* b1YO Z\OaSZn\p -W*4d`\,*Z\p g1-W\p b* \4/\+W1Z* 4\+`*31ZZqYS a\b1Zn +SVT, T /`*V\ZT, d `daTD \WS d ab\WSgp TYO

]1`T^ ,f\/SWS Wp/SE +`*Y* a]`*,WqW* Z* ZSf Z14*+dbZ2 ,`*31ZZqxD * ]\h*bVd XX ab\`Thhq *`f1\W\-S ,T/V\]*WS bSaqhT e`*-Y1ZbT, /\`\-S

`\g1aTy T +`*YS +\-SZT ıjb*`D ıfZT

`1V\Zab`dVgT^ ZSZT Y\3Z* ]\+*hSbS

, 1`-*YanV\Yd Yd41^ d 1`WTZTD

˚ ˚ # ı ı Gı

\4,S,*yb1 /df\,ZTabn d ]\/`d33T `1/1`TV1B w * ]\h*bVd Z*j\-\ ]\/`d3Zn\-\ 3Sbbq YS 4 /`d3SZ\p /\Y\O ,SWSan ,S,h*bS T+WTp `*4\YD ) ab*`*,aqE *+S ]T/ h*a Z*jSf ,S,h1Zn T*Z

Z1 `\4]\`\jd,*W* a,\2^ d,*-SD W1 ^y +dW\ ,*3V\ 4\a1`1/3d,*bSanD ı V\WS q ab*,S, 4*]Sb*ZZqE ,\Z* ,T/]\,T/*W* bTWnVS wb*Vx *+\ wZTxD ) 4\,aTY Z1 b*V

dq,Wq, ,S,h1ZZq T+WT^xD T*ZB w) ,SyjW* 4* `1/1`TV* d 5< `\VT,D S `1-dWq`Z\ ,S,h*WS `*4\Y

T+WTpE ]`\b1 ,TZ ,SV\`Sab\,d,*, V\3Z1 ,S,h1ZZqE *+S ,V*4d,*bS Z* Y\^ Z1/\WTVS T Z* b1E qV\p /`d3SZ\p q Y*p +dbSD 1 4*,/*,*W\ Y1ZT +\Wp T /d31 4Z1\f\hd,*W\xD

TaZd,*W* ]`\+W1Y* d ab\adZV*f `1/1`TV* T T*ZH ZSf +dWS /\+`T Z*YT`SE \+\2 Wp+SWS \-* T `\4dYTWSE k\ b`1O +* a]TWnZ\ ,S,h*bS T+WTpD W1 a*Y1 b1E k\ Y*W\ + 4YTgZp,*bS ^fZT ab\adZVSE Z*a]`*,/T `dyZdO ,*W\ ^fD \/`d33q `*4\Y ,S,h*O W\ T+WTpE ]`\b1 Z1 `\4,S,*W\ a,\2^ /df\,Z\abTD #\ b*V1 /df\,ZTabnH \Yd ]\/`d3ZTY ]*`*Y b`1+* ^^ `\4O ,S,*bSH )VT b`d/Z\kT ,\ZS Y\O 3dbn Y*bS T qV /\W*bS ^fH

#\ \4Z*h*2 +dbS /df\,Z\p Wp/SZ\pH ˙df\,Z* Wp/SZ* Y*2 +T+WTyZSy ]\-Wq/ Z* 3Sbbq T V1`d2bnaq \3SYS Z\`Y*YS L(/S 5<E 5=MD *,W\E \/SZ 4 ]SanY1ZZSO VT, T+WT^E 4,1`b*2 d,*-d Z* `T4ZSgp YT3 bSYE qV ab*,Sbnaq /\ 3Sbbq /df\,Z* WpO /SZ*E * qV P ]W\banV*D *,W\ ]\V*4d2E k\ b\yE fb\ afSWnZSy /\ ]W\banV\-\ YSaW1ZO ZqE +TWnj1 4\a1`1/31ZSy Z* a\+TE * Z1 Z* 1 ıY1Z* 4YTZ1Z\D

TZjSfD *V* Wp/SZ* hSZSbn b1E k\ ]`*O ,SWnZ1 d ,W*aZSf \h*fE T Z1 +*3*2 3SbS 4* \3SYS ]`SZgS]*YS L5 \`SZeqZ 6B58C *W*bT, 9B5=E 6>MD \b Wp/SZ*E V\b`* Y*2 /df\,ZSy ]\O -Wq/ Z* 3SbbqE /\`\3Sbn \3SYS Z\`Y*O YSD \Z* ,,*3*2 \-* -\,d a,\^Y ˙`d-\Y T Z*Y*-*2bnaq Z*aWT/d,*bS y\-\ \a\+SaO bTabn L˚e1aqZ 9B5MD \Yd , ab\adZV*f " ˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

57

4 TZjSYS b*V* Wp/SZ* ,Sq,Wq2 Wp+\,E /\+`\bd T W*-T/ZTabn L SfT/ 78B:MD \O Z* aWdf*2bnaq \-* Z*,Tbn b\/TE V\WS g1 Z1 4\,aTY ,S-T/Z\ L a*W\Y 59B5E 8MD ˙*`O `1ZE qVSy 3S,1 , *Z*/T b* \/`d31ZSy d31 79 `\VT,E V*31B w˙df\,Z* Wp/SZ*E Z*O aVTWnVS q g1 `\4dYTpE 4*,3/S /dY*2E qV ^^ aW\,* T ,hSZVS ,]WSZdbn Z* /`d3+d 4 \O -\YxD ˙31yZE /`d3SZ* ˙*``1Z*E /\/*2B w) ,,*3*pE k\ /df\,Z* 3TZV* P b*E qV* k\O /Zq 4 daTf aSW ab*`*2bnaq ,Sq,WqbS ]WT/ \3\-\ /dfdx L *W*bT, 9B66E 67MD ˛,Sh*yZ\E k\+ `\4,S,*bS /df\,ZTabnE Z1 V\Zh1 +dbS \/`d31ZSYD T+WTq V*31E k\ V\3Z* Wp/SZ* Y*2 \+\,Gq4\V Z*,h*O bSan ]`\ \-* T Z*aWT/d,*bS y\-\ L˙T^ 5;B6:E 6;MD

\Yd ]\/`d3ZTY ]*`*Y b`1+* `\4,S,*bS /df\,ZTabnH

\Yd \/`d31ZSY Wp/qY ,*`b\ `\4,SO ,*bS /df\,ZTabn d a,\2Yd ]\/`d33TH 1 Y\3Z* ]\qaZSbS Z* b*V\Yd ]`SVW*O /TD ˙,* -\a]\/*`T Y*pbn a]TWnZSy -\`\/ T ]W*Zdpbn ,S`\kd,*bS Z* Zn\Yd \,\hTD /SZ V*31E k\ b`1+* ]\aTqbS Z*aTZZq b\O /TOb\E * TZjSy ,,*3*2E k\ ]T4ZTj1D 1`O jSy f\h1 d/\+`SbS š`dZbE * /`d-Sy 4 ZSY Z1 ]\-\/3d2bnaqD /SZ f\h1 k\/Zq ]`*O gp,*bS , -\`\/TE * TZjSy ,\WT2 ZTh\-\ Z1 `\+SbSE * ]`\ab\ h1V*bS Z* ,`\3*yD ˛* b*V\-\ -\a]\/*`p,*ZZq Z* -\`\/T Y\31 k\an ,S`\abSD `\b1 ,`\3*y +d/1 4Z*hZ\ +TWnjSYE V\WS \+\2 -\a]\/*`T, ]\-\/qbnO ‹ aqE k\ `\+SbSE T /\VW*/*bSYdbn a]TWnZSf 4daSWnD

\W\,TV* T /`d3SZd Y\3Z* ]\`T,ZqbS 4 bSYS /,\Y* -\a]\/*`qYSD )Vk\ +\/*y fb\an \/SZ 4 ]\/`d33q `\4,S,*2 /df\,O ZTabnE ab\adZVS YT3 h\W\,TV\Y T /`d3SO Z\p Y\3dbn ]\WT]jSbSan L5 1b`* 7B5E 6MD W1 Z*aVTWnVS V`*k1E V\WS ,\ZS \+\2 \f\O h1 /\b`SYdpbnaq \3Sf ,SY\- T Z*]\W1-O WS,\ ab*`*pbnaq ]T/b`SYd,*bS \/Z1 \/Z\O -\ , aWd3TZZT \-\,TD d/`Sy g*` \W\Y\Z aV*4*,B w `*k1 /,\YE qV \/Z\YdxD \YdH w \ Y*pbn f\`\jd 4*]W*bd 4* b`d/ a,TyE 58 "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

T qV+S ,\ZS ,]*WSE ]T/TyY1 \/Z1 a,\-\ /`dO -*x L˚VVW14Tqab* 8B=E 5>MD S `*4\Y 4 ]\/`d3ZTY ]*`bZ1`\YE +14O ]1`1hZ\E ]`*-Z1b1 `\4,S,*bS /df\,ZTabnD ,bTYE a*Y1 WSj1 ]`*-Z1ZZq Z1 ]`SZ\O aSbn +*3*ZSf `14dWnb*bT,E ]\/T+Z\ qV a*O Y1 ]`*-Z1ZZq -\a]\/*`q -\`\/d Z1 ]`SZ\O aSbn ]W\/T,D \4-WqZnY\ /,T ]1`1]\ZSE qVT Y\3dbn -*WnYd,*bS `\4,Sb\V /df\,Z\abTE T qV ^f /\W*bSD

˚ " ˚ ˚ D *Y +`*Vd2 h*adD w \W\,TV 4*+S`*2 Y1Z1 4 `\+\bS \ 9Oy ,1O h\`*EP `\4]\,T/*2 GpE qV* Z1/*,Z\ \/`dO 3SW*anDP \WS ]`S^3/3*2Y\ /\/\YdE Z*a h1V*pbn `T4ZT f*bZT a]`*,SD ı bdb ]\hSZ*O 2bnaq +\`\bn+* YT3 `\4dY\Y b* ]W\bbpB `\4dY V*31 `*4\Y Z*,h*bSan ]`\ \-*E * ]W\bn V*31 ,T/]\hSbSxD

S`Tj1ZZqD `Sab\a\,dyb1aq \/Z1 /\ \/Z\-\ y a]T,]`*gpyb1 YT3 a\+\pD Gp V*O 31B w S 4 h\W\,TV\Y ,S`TjSWS ,ab*,*bS `*ZTj1 TE ]1`j ZT3 ]TbS Z* `\+\bdE a]TWnZ\ hSb*bS b* \+-\,\`p,*bS qVSyan d`S,\V 4 T+WT^D `TY b\-\E h\W\,TV /\]\Y*-*2 Y1O ZT , /\Y*jZTf a]`*,*fE k\+ YS +TWnj1 h*O ad ]`\,\/SWS `*4\YxD \-\ ,*`bT b*VT 4dO aSWWqH ˚/E h\W\,TV GpE ]\qaZp2B w \WS YS 4 /`d3SZ\p `1-dWq`Z\ \+-\,\`p2Y\ +T+WTyZT /dYVSE Z*Y W1-j1 /\W*bS ]`\+W1O YS T b`S,\-SxD \b`T+Z\ Z1 bTWnVS `\4Y\,WqbS \/Z1 4 \/ZSYE *W1 y k\/Zq ,S/TWqbS VTWnV* f,SO WSZ Z* a]TWnZT Y\WSb,SD )V ,\ZS /\]\Y*O -*pbnH w 1/*,Z\ YS 4 3TZV\p ]1`13SWS /d31 ,*3VSy ]1`T\/ d Z*jSf ab\adZV*fEP V*31 *qZE qVSy \/`d31ZSy d31 5: `\O VT,DP W1 YS k\,1h\`* ,S/TWqWS h*a /Wq a]TWnZ\^ Y\WSb,SE , qVTy `\4]\,T/*WS \O -\,T ]`\ a,\^ ]1`13S,*ZZqD ) 4`\4dYT,E k\ b*VT Y\WSb,S /\]\Y\-WS Z*Y ,S`TjSO bS ]`\+W1YS T ,T/Z\,SbS `*/Tabn d ]\O /`d33TxD

# ˝ ˛ D T/ VTZ1gn V\3O Z\-\ /Zq ,S/TWqyb1 ,an\-\ VTWnV* f,SWSZ Z* \+-\,\`1ZZq /\+`Sf a]`*,E V\b`T ,S

4`\+SWS `*4\Y T 4* V\b`T Y\3Z* ]\/qVd,*O bS \-\,TD *V\3 ]\-\,\`Tbn ]`\ a,\^ b`d/O Z\kTE \a\+WS,\ bTE qVT ,*3V\ ]\/\W*bS +14 \3\^ /\]\Y\-SD W1 , 3\/Z\Yd `*4T Z1 ,SV\`Sab\,dyb1 Y\WSb\, qV Z*-\/d 4-*/*O bS ]`\ ,*/S a,\2^ /`d3SZSD \WS 3 Y\WSO b1aq `*4\YE -\,\`Tbn WSj1 ]`\ b1E Z*/ hSY b`1+* a]TWnZ\ ]`*gp,*bSD *abd]Z\-\ /Zq /Tyb1 4-T/Z\ 4 bSYE ]`\ k\ Y\WSWSaqD

˙ ˚ ˚ D S b*VT `T4ZTD w) Z1 4 bSfE fb\ Wp+Sbn a]\VTyZ\ aTabS T hSb*bS VZS3VdxEP V*31 \ZTD •\-\ /`d3SZ*E *O b*WTE -\,\`SbnB w 1ZT /d31 ]\/\+*2bnaq hSb*bS T `\4]\,T/*bS ]`\ b1E k\ q /\,T/*O W*anD ıZV\WS 4/*2bnaqE k\ \ZT b`\fS ZTqO V\,T2E V\WS YS \+-\,\`p2Y\ bT hS TZjT +T+O WTyZT b1YSxD

S`Tj1ZZqD 1 V`SbSVdyb1 a,\-\ ]*`bO Z1`* T Z1 4Y*-*yb1aq 4 ZSYE * ]T/b`SYdyb1 y\-\D T/+*/n\`pyb1 T f,*WTbn \/Z1 \/O Z\-\D \ZT V*31B wıZV\WS 4*,4qbbq /`dO 3SZS ]T/ h*a \+-\,\`1ZZq `T4ZSf +T+WTyO ZSf TabSZ b`\fS Y1Z1 ab\YWp2D *ZTj1 q Z1\f\h1 `\4Y\,Wq, 4 *b*WT Z* +T+WTyO ZT b1YSD `\b1 ,\Z* Y1Z1 /d31 ]T/b`SO Yd2D 1]1` YS `1-dWq`Z\ `\4Y\,Wq2Y\ ]`\ /df\,Z1E T Y1ZT g1 /d31 ]\/\+*2bnaqD ) 4`\4dYT,E k\ Z1Y*2 h\-\ +\qbSanD 1 /\O ]\Y*-*2 Z*Y qV ]\/`d33p 4Y1Zjd,*bS Z*]`d31ZZq T a]`Sq2 YS`dxD

SY*W\ ]\/`d33T, ]1`1V\Z*WSaqE k\ ^fZT ab\adZVS ]\WT]jSWSanE V\WS ,\ZS ]\O h*WS `1-dWq`Z\ k\bS3Zq ,S/TWqbS h*a Z* a]TWnZ1 hSb*ZZq T /\aWT/31ZZq T+O WT^D W1 ,*`b\ ]*YGqb*bSB V\31Z Z1f*y 4*O ab\a\,d2 ]\`*/S a]1`jd /\ a1+1E * Z1 /\ a,\-\ ]\/`d3Zn\-\ ]*`bZ1`* L *W*bT, :B8MD 1 \+-\,\`pyb1 ]`\+W1Y a,\-\ ]\/`d33q ]T/ h*a a]TWnZSf ,S,h1Zn T+WT^D \Yd g1 ,*3WS,\H \4-WqZnY\ ]`SVW*/D S , `\/SZZ\Yd V\WT a]\3S,*2b1 ^3dD S +d/1b1 4* \+T/ZTY ab\W\Y ]1`1,Gq4d,*bS a\+T -ZTyZd `*ZdH 1,Z\E k\ ZTI S 3 4T]ad2b1 ,aTY *]1bSbD ıada aV*4*,E k\ Z*,h*ZZq ]`\ \-* T ,SV\O

Z*ZZq y\-\ ,\WT 2 Z*h1 ^3* L *b,Tq 8B8C ı,*Z* 8B78MD )Vk\E `\4-\`b*phS T+WTpE ,S V\3Z\-\ `*4d ]\hSZ*2b1 -\,\`SbS ]`\ a,\^ 1Y\gTyZT `*ZSE 4 h*a\Y ,*j ]\/`d3O ZTy ]*`bZ1` Y\31 ,b`*bSbS /df\,ZSy *]1O bSbD ˛,Sh*yZ\E ]`\+W1YS b`1+* \+-\,\`pO ,*bSD W1 ,S/TWqyb1 /Wq gn\-\ TZjSy h*a L `S]\,Tab1y 5>B5=C 59B67MD

# ˝ ˛ D ˛*]SjTbn /,TOb`S `SaS ,*j\-\ ]\/`d3Zn\-\ ]*`bZ1`*E qVT ,*Y \a\+WS,\ ]\/\+*pbnaqD *abd]Z\-\ `*4dE `\4Y\,WqphS Z* /df\,ZT b1YSE 4-*O /*yb1 ]`\ bT `SaS y aV*3TbnE h\Yd T hSY ,\O ZS ,*Y ]\/\+*pbnaqD

#\ ]\aT2b1E b1 y ]\3Z1b1 )Vk\ ,S `*4\Y aT2b1 y 4`\kd2b1 /dO f\,ZTabnE b\ ]\3Z1b1 YS` T `*/Tabn d aTO Y1yZ\Yd 3SbbTD 1/*`Y* d \3\Yd W\,T aV*4*Z\B w#\ Wp/SZ* ]\aT2E b1 y ]\3Z1x L *W*bT, :B;MD `1/1`TV b* T*ZE 4-*/*ZT Z* ]\h*bVd ab*bbTE Z* a\+T ]1`1V\Z*WSan d ]`*,/S,\aO bT gn\-\ ]`SZgS]dD ˛* 89 `\VT, ]\/`d3Zn\O -\ 3Sbbq ,\ZS ]\+*hSWSE Z*aVTWnVS ,*3O WS,\ 4YTgZqbS a,\p /df\,ZTabnD `1/1`TV `\4]\,T/*2B w˛* +`*V a]TWVd,*ZZq q Z1`T/O V\ 4,SZd,*hd,*, /`d3SZdD `\b1 4 h*a\Y 4`\4dYT,E k\ Y1ZT b*V\3 b`1+* /\VW*/*bS 4daSWnxD T*Z /\/*2B w h*aS Z*]`d31ZO Zq T ]`\+W1Y Z*Y /d31 /\]\Y*-*W* kS`* Wp+\, /\ \-* -\,SD S `1-dWq`Z\ T ,31 +*-*b\ `\VT, a]TWnZ\ ,S,h*2Y\ b* Y\WSY\O aqD \WS +*hdE qV `1/1`TV ab*`*2bnaq k1 WT]j1 ,Sq,WqbS f`SabSqZanVT `SaSE b\ Wp+Wp y\-\ k1 +TWnj1xD

˛ • ˚ ˚ ˚B ˇ \WS ,\ab*ZZ2 YS a]TWnZ\ Y\WSWSaqH ˇ #\ Y\3Z* 4`\+SbSE *+S YTy ]\/`d3ZTy ]*`bZ1` \f\hTj1 `\4Y\,Wq, 4T YZ\p Z* /df\,ZT b1YSH

" ˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

59

& ˝˚

\Yd b`1+* /\b`SYd,*bSan \3Sf 4*V\ZT,H

ab*bbT `\4-Wq/*pbnaq 4*]Sb*ZZqE qVT Y\3dbn ,*a gTV*,SbSD db b*V\3 Z*,\/qbnaq +T+WTyZT ,T`jTE V\b`T YTabqbn ,T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZqD \/*ZT ,T`jT

,S 4Z*y/1b1 d a,\^y T+WT^D ,T/VS

-\,S `*/\ \+-\,\`qbn ^f 4 ,*YSD

5D \Yd b`1+* aWdf*bSaq \-*H Wdf*bSaq \-* b`1+* b\YdE k\ ,TZ 2 Z*jSY ,\`O g1YD *,Tbn ıada , dan\Yd aWdf*,aq \-* Lı,*Z* :B7<C +Gq,W1ZZq 8B55MD ˙\b`SYdphSan 4*V\ZT, \-*E YS ]\O V*4d2Y\E k\ Wp+SY\ y\-\D L `\hSb*yb1 5 ı,*Z* 9B7MD aT 4*V\ZS -\,S 2 Z*Y WSj1 Z* /\+`\D \ZS ,1/dbn Z*a Z*yWT]jSY 3Sbb2,SY jWqf\Y d31 ZSZT y ]\V*4dO pbnE qV \b`SY*bS ,ThZT +W*-\aW\,1ZZq , Y*y+dbZn\YdD

L `\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 5=B<E 56C ıa*^ 8<B5;E 5<MD

6D )V \3T 4*V\ZS a]`Sqpbn Z*j\Yd 4/\`\,GpH \3Sy 4*V\Z 4*ad/3d2 ]Sqgb,\ T gSY 4*fSk*2 Z*a ,T/ Z1+14]1hZSf f,\`\+ b* Z1k*aZSf ,S]*/VT,D ˛W\O ,3S,*ZZq *WV\-\WnZSYS Z*]\qYS ,SVWSV*2 4*W13O

ZTabn T jb\,f*2 Wp/SZd /\ +14-Wd4/\^ ]\,1/TZVS L `SO ]\,Tab1y 67B6>E 6=E 7>MD -\,* /\4,\Wq2 ,3S,*bS *WV\-\WnE *W1 `*/Sbn `\+SbS g1 ]\YT`V\,*Z\D L `\O hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 5>8B59C 5 \`SZeqZ :B5>MD -\,* b*V\3 ]\]1`1/3*2 ]`\ Z1+14]1Vd `1,Z\kT,E Z1V\Zb`\Wn\,*Z\-\ -ZT,d b* TZjSf ,S/T, ]\,1/TZVSE qV* jV\/Sbn Wp/SZTD )Vk\ +d/1Y\ aWdf*bSan y\-\ ]\O `*/E b\ Y*bSY1Y\ Z*+*-*b\ WT]j1 4/\`\,GqD L `\hSO b*yb1 `S]\,Tab1y 58B7>C 66B68E 69MD

7D )V Z*a 4*fSk*2 \3Sy 4*V\ZH \3Sy 4*V\Z 4*+\`\Zq2 Y*bS ab*b1,T 4Z\aSO

ZS 4* Y13*YS jWp+Z\-\ dab`\p L ,`1^, 57B8MD )Vk\ ]\/`d3Zq ]*`* 3S,1 4-T/Z\ 4 gSY 4*V\O Z\YE ,\Z* ]\hd,*2bnaq +TWnj 4*fSk1Z\p T , `\O /SZT TaZdpbn a]`SqbWS,TjT dY\,S /Wq Z*W13Z\O -\ ,Sf\,*ZZq /Tb1yD ˛ TZj\-\ +\VdE ]1`1Wp+ 2 ]`ShSZ\p f,\`\+E `\4Wdh1ZZqE Z*aSWWqE 1Y\gTyO

ZSf b`*,Y b* /1/*WT +TWnj\^ VTWnV\abT Z1]\,ZSf aTY1yD L `\hSb*yb1 `S]\,Tab1y 9B5P=MD )Vk\ YS dZSV*2Y\ aSbd*gTyE V\WS 4Gq,Wq2bnO aq a]\Vda* Y*bS ]\4*jWp+ZT ab*b1,T 4Z\aSZSE b\ 4+1`T-*2Y\ /`d3+d 4 \-\YD S b*V\3 Z1 4*,O /*,*bSY1Y\ TZjSY Y\`*WnZ\-\ +\WpD L `\hSO b*yb1 5 1aa*W\ZTVTygT, 8B7P:MD

8D )V1 /\+`\ ]`SZ\aSbn j*Z\+WS,1 ab*,W1ZZq /\ /*`d 3SbbqH p/SE qVT j*Zdpbn \3Sy /*` 3SbbqE Y*pbn WT]j1 4/\`\,GqE +\ ]\4+dWSan b*VSf 4-d+ZSf 4,Sh\VE qV VdO `TZZqE ,3S,*ZZq Z*`V\bSVT, b\k\ L6 \`SZeqZ ;B5MD

˙Wq \-* 2 gTZZSY Z*,Tbn 3Sbbq Z1Z*`\/31Z\^ /SbSO ZSE qV* `\4,S,*2bnaq , Y*b1`SZanVTy db`\+T L SfT/ 65B66E 67MD \Yd Z1 Y\3Z* a,T/\Y\ ,+S,*bS Z1Z*`\O /31Zd /SbSZdD `TY b\-\E bTE fb\ Y*2 \3Sy ]\-Wq/ Z* 3SbbqE ab*`*pbnaq /\b`SYd,*bSan ]`*,SW +14]1VS Z* `\+\bTE ,/\Y* hS 4* V1`Y\Y *,b\Y\+TWq L \,b\`1ZO

Zq Ë›*V\Zd 66B<MD \ZS Z1 `S4SVdpbn a,\^Y 3SbbqY 4*O /Wq `\4,*-SE +\ 3Sbbq P g1 /*` ,T/ \-*D L `\hSb*yO b1 a*W\Y 7:B5>MD

9D \Yd V\`SaZ\ ]\,*3*bS a,qbTabn V`\,TH `\, 2 a,qb\pE */31 \- aV*4*,E k\ ,\Z* aSY,\O WT4d2 3SbbqE b\+b\ /djdE 3S,Sf Tab\b L dbbq =B7E 8MD WdfZqZTabn \3\Yd 4*V\Zd ]`\ V`\,E 4-T/Z\ 4 qVSY ,\Z* 2 `T,Z\gTZZ\p 3SbbpE T/1 Z*Y Z* /\+`\D \YdH \Yd k\ V`\, dY\3WS,Wp2 ]`\k1ZZq -`TfT,D L `\hSO

b*yb1 1,Sb 5;B55P57C ,`1^, =B66MD `\, ıada* \a\+WS,\ gTZZ*E */31 ,TZ +d, /\aV\Z*O WSYD ıada ]`1/ab*,S, \-\,T b1E k\ aSY,\WT4d,*W\ y\O

-\ 3SbbqEP a,\p V`\, L ,`1^, =B56MD `\WS,jS V`\,E ıada ,T/V`S, /Wq Z*a /\`\-d /\ ,ThZ\-\ 3SbbqD L `\O hSb*yb1 *b,Tq 6:B6<C ı,*Z* 7B5:MD

TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ ,S 4Z*y/1b1

d 56OYd T 57OYd `\4/TW*f gT2^ VZS3VSD ZS3V* \]d+WTV\,*Z* ,T/V*YS -\,SD

Z*a]`*,/T

& ı ı)H

5;

)V +*bnV\,T ab*bS +WS4nVSY a,\2Yd aSZ\,TH E 4,T/VS bS ,a1 4Z*2jHx S ,*j aSZ ab*,S, ,*Y b*V1 4*]Sb*ZZqH SE Z*]1,Z1E ]Sj*2b1anE k\ 2 +*bnV\YD W1 qVk\ aSZ Z1 ]`\ab\ aWdf*2 ,*jSf ]\`*/E * 4*ab\a\,d2 ^f T h1`14 g1 y\Yd /\+`1 ,1O /1bnaqE ,*j1 a1`g1 ]1`1]\,Zp2 k1 +TWnj* `*/Tabn1 L `S]\,Tab1y 67B59E 68MD W1 V\WS ,*j aSZ ]T/`\ab1E hS +d/1 4*O f\]Wp,*bSaq ,*YS b*V a*Y\E qV b1]1`H

S Z1 ,T/hd,*2b1 ,SE k\ 4 h*a\Y y\-\ ]\O ,*-* /\ ,*a 4Y1Zjd2bnaqH )V 4*WSj*O bSan +WS4nVSY a,\2Yd aSZ\,TE V\WS ,TZ /\`\aWTj*2H ]1`jd `\4-WqZnY\E 4 qVSO YS ]`\+W1Y*YS /\,\/Sbnaq abSV*bSaq +*bnV\,TD

w

`S Z*y]\jS`1ZTjT ]`\+W1YS 5D D +*-*bn\f V`*^Z*f Z*y,*O -\YTjSy ,Z1a\V d +p/31b `\/SZS `\+O Wqbn h\W\,TVSD 1`14 `\+\bd ,\ZS Z1`T/O V\ 4Ydj1ZT ]`\,\/SbS +TWnjd h*abSZd /Zq ]\4* /\Y\YD `*]Wq2bnaqE k\ +*bnV\ Y*2 /d31 Y*W\ h*ad /Wq /Tb1yD 1/*,O Z2 \]Sbd,*ZZqE ]`\,1/1Z1 d `*ZgT^E ]\O V*4*W\B h\W\,TVS ,T//*pbn a,\^Y /TbqY k\/Zq , a1`1/Zn\Yd Y1Zj1 ZT3 56 f,SO WSZD 1 \h* , gTy ab*bbT y/1bnaq ]`\ \a\+WS,T ab\adZO VS YT3 +*bnV\Y T aSZ\YE Z*,1/1ZT , ZTy ]`SZgS]S b*V\3 +d/dbn V\`SaZSYS d ab\adZV*f YT3 +*bnV\Y T /\ZnV\pD

5< "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

˙ • ˚D VTWnVS h*ad ,S ]`\,\/Sb1 4T a,\^Y aSZ\YH \]`\+dyb1 \/SZ hS /,* bS3ZT 4*]Sad,*bSE aVTWnVS h*ad ,S ]`\O ,\/Sb1 `*4\YD 14dWnb*b Y\31 ,*a 4/S,dO ,*bSD 6D ˙ ˙ D ˙1qVT h\O W\,TVS Z1 Y*WS , /SbSZab,T +WS4nVSf ab\adZVT, 4T a,\^YS +*bnV*YSD ˝*ZO *O `TE qVSy 3S,1 d `*ZgT^E `\4]\,T/*2B w S 4 b*b\Y `T/V\ ]`\,\/SWS h*a `*4\YxD )V g1 ,]WSZdW\ Z* ˝*ZO *`TH w˛Gq,SWSaq ]`\+O W1YSE qVSf q 4\,aTY Z1 a]\/T,*,aqEP V*O 31 ,TZDP 1ZT ,*3V\ ,1abS 4T a,\^YS aSO Z*YS 4YTab\,ZT `\4Y\,SxD d,*2 y b*VE k\ Wp/SZ* /\+`1 4Z*2 a,\-\ +*bnV*E *W1 Z1 Y*2 4 ZSY /\+`Sf ab\adZVT,D TWT]O ]1E qV\Yd 87 `\VSE ]`S-*/d2B w *bnV\,T +dW\ ,*3V\ ,Sq,WqbS Y1ZT Wp+\,D 1`14 g1 q Ydjd /\VW*/*bS ,1WSVSf 4daSWnE k\+ 4 b1]W\b\p ab*,SbSan /\ aSZ*xD

˙ • ˚D S ,]WS,*2 Z* ,*jT ab\adZO VS T4 aSZ\Y b1E qVT ab\adZVS ,S Y*WS 4T a,\^Y +*bnV\YH S TZV\WS ]\YTh*2b1E k\ Z*aWT/d2b1 /\+`T *+\ ]\-*ZT 4,ShVS a,\-\ +*bnV*H 7D ˙ ˙D /1qVSf adaO ]TWnab,*f +*bnV\,* `\Wn d ,Sf\,*ZZT /TO b1y ]1,Z\p YT`\p ]`SY1Zj1Z*D w˛* Y\-\ /SbSZab,*EP `\4]\,T/*2 dV*E qVSy ,SO

`\ab*, , \/ZTy 4*fT/Z\2,`\]1yanVTy V`*^O ZTEP ,,*3*W\aqE k\ /\-Wq/ 4* /SbSZ\p P g1 3TZ\h* a]`*,*xD TZjSf V`*^Z*f ,T/ h\W\,TVT, ,SY*-*pbn WSj1 \/Z\-\ P ab*O ,SbSan /\ a,\^f /Tb1y /d31 ,SY\-WS,\D ˝\`3E qVSy `Ta , \/ZTy *e`SV*ZanVTy V`*O ^ZTE V*31B w Z*j\Yd ada]TWnab,T Z1 ]`SO yZqb\E k\+ h\W\,TV Y\WS,aq `*4\Y 4T a,\O ^YS /TbnYSE +\ b*V ,TZE ZT+Sb\E ,b`*bSbn *,b\`Sb1b , ^fZTf \h*fD \3 Y1ZT 4*,3/S +dW\ ,*3V\ a]TWVd,*bSaq 4 aSZ\YxD

˙ • ˚D )Vd `\Wn d ,*jTy YTag1,\abT ,T/,1/1Z\ -\W\,*Y `\/SZH S ^Y V*3dbnE k\ ,Sf\,*ZZq /Tb1y P 3TZ\h* a]`*,*H S 4*\f\hdpbn h\W\,TVT, ,Sq,WqbS Wp+\, T ZT3ZTabn a,\^Y aSZ*YE hSE Z*,]*VSE -*YdO ,*bS gT ]\hdbbqH )Vk\ ,*Y qV +*bnV\,T ,*3V\ ]T/b`SYdO ,*bS /\+`T ab\adZVS T4 aSZ\YE ZS3h1Z*,1O /1ZT ]\`*/S Y\3dbn /\]\Y\-bSD

\VS aSZ k1 Y*WSy ˛*4,Sh*y 4Y*W1hVd aSZS Y*pbn aSWnZ1 +*3*ZZq Z*aWT/d,*bS +*bnV*D *bnVSE ,SO V\`Sab\,dyb1 b*V1 +*3*ZZq Z* /\+`\ a,\O -\ aSZ*D )V g1 `\+SbS T /1 4Z*ybS h*a Z* /SbSZdH )Vk\ Y\3WS,\E 4*Wdh*yb1 aSZ* /\ ,SV\O Z*ZZq +d/1ZZSf a]`*,D *]`SVW*/E Z1f*y ,TZ /\]\Y*-*2 ,*Y ]\ -\a]\/*`ab,dD ˙*yO b1 aSZ\,T Z1,1WShVSy ,TZSV *+\ W\]*bVdD •\YdE Z*]1,Z1E a]\/\+*2bnaq ]`*gp,*bS ]\`q/ 4 bSYE VSY ,TZ b*V 4*f\]Wp2bnaqD \3WS,\E ,SV\Z*ZZq qV\^an `\+\bS 4*yY1 b`\fS +TWnj1 h*adE *W1 b*V ,S 4YTgZSb1 ,*O jT d4S T 4Y\31b1 Z*,hSbS /SbSZd ab*`*ZZ\ ]`*gp,*bSD T+WTq 4*\f\hd2 V\3Z\-\ +*bnO V* 4*Wdh*bS a,\^f /Tb1y /\ ,SV\Z*ZZq +dO /1ZZSf a]`*,E * b*V\3 ,SV\`Sab\,d,*bS ,aTWqVd Z*-\/dE k\+ a]TWVd,*bSaq 4 ZSYS T Z*,h*bS ^f L \,b\`1ZZq ˛*V\Zd :B:P=MD q ]\`*/* 4*,3/S *Vbd*WnZ*D `TY ]`*gT T4 aSZ\YE ,S/TWqyb1 b*V\3 h*a Z* a]TWnZT T-`SD ı-`S ,]WS,*bSYdbn Z* Zn\-\ +TWnj1E ZT3 TZjT ]`S2YZT a]`*O

,SE qVSYS Y\3Z* 4*yY*bSaq `*4\YD ˙\aWTO /31ZZq ]\V*4dpbnE k\ V\WS +*bnVS +*,O Wqbnaq 4 /TbnYSE b\ gSY 4*\f\hdpbn ^f +dbS aYTWS,TjSYS b* ,]1,Z1ZTjSYSD ı-`S +*bnV* T4 aSZ\Y ,T/T-`*pbn k1 \/O Zd /d31 ,*3WS,d `\WnD w W*aZ1 ]T/ h*a -`SEP ]\qaZp2 /\aWT/ZSV Tj1Wn T4EP fW\]1gn Z*yWT]j1 V\Zb*Vbd2 4 +*bnV\YxD

\/T +*bnV\ Y\31 ,Sq,WqbS aSZ\,T a,\^ ]\hdbbq aW\,*YS b* /TqYSD ˛*,/qVS gn\O Yd ,TZ Z*,h*2 aSZ* b*V\3 ,S`*3*bS a,\^ ]\hdbbqD w \WS YTy aSZ +d, /SbSZ\pEP ‹ `\4]\,T/*2 Z/`1E qVSy 3S,1 , TY1hO hSZTEP YS h*ab\ +*,SWSaq `*4\YD ) +`*, y\-\ , \+TyYSE T b*V ,TZ Z*,hS,aq ,T/]\,TO /*bS Y1ZT Wp+\,GpxD *bnV\ Y\31 4YTgZqbS a,\^ d4S Wp+\O ,T 4 /SbSZ\p T b\/TE V\WS ,\Z* y/1 a]*O bSD 1-dWq`Z\ hSb*yb1 aSZ\,T qVTan Tab\`T^ b* aWdf*yb1 y\-\ `\4]\,T/T ]`\ ]`S2YZT hS Z1]`S2YZT ]\/T^ /ZqD *V ,TZ j,S/j1 4,SVZ1 /TWSbSaq a,\^YS /dYV*YS T +d/1 `\+SbS g1E V\WS ]T/`\ab1D

"dV*yb1 a]TWnZSf 4*Zqbn ˙1qVT ]T/WTbVSE 4/*2bnaqE Z1 ,T/-dVdO pbnaq Z* +*bnV\,T ab*`*ZZq a]TWVd,*bSaq 4 ZSYSD )Vk\ ,S /dY*2b1E k\ aSZ dfSWqO 2bnaq ,T/ ,*jSf 4*]Sb*ZnE Z1 `\+Tbn ,SO aZ\,VT,E ZT+S ,TZ 4\,aTY Z1 +*3*2 4 ,*YS `\4Y\,WqbSD TZ Y\31 +dbS +TWnj afSWnO ZSY ,T/V`SbSaqE qVk\ ,S /1 , h\Yd 4YTZSO b1 a,Ty ]T/fT/ /\ Zn\-\D ˝*VE qVSy 3S,1 d `*ZgT^E TZV\WS Y*, b`d/Z\kT d a]TWVd,*ZZT 4T a,\^Y aSZ\YE ˝1`\Y\YD W1 ,TZ Z1 4Ydjd,*, aSZ* `\4O Y\,WqbSE * 4YTZp,*, a,Ty ]T/fT/ /\ Zn\O -\ P -`*, 4 ZSY d edb+\WD w TaWq eT4ShO Z\-\ Z*,*Zb*31ZZqEP ]\qaZp2 ˝*VEP YS aT/*WS Z* b`*,d T ,T/]\hS,*WSD *Y1 , b*O VT Y\Y1ZbS aSZ `\4V`S,*, Y1ZT a,\2 a1`g1D Sj1 b1E k\ YS ]`\,\/SWS h*a `*4\Y T q +d, ]\`q/E 4YTgZSW\ Z*jT ab\adZVSxD k\E V\WS ,*j aSZ Z1 gTV*,Sbnaq a]\`O ‹ b\YH Z/`1 4 b1]W\b\p ]`S-*/d2E qV ,\ZS 4 aSZ\Y Z1 `*4 a]\ab1`T-*WS 4* 4\`qYSD " ˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

5=

w 1]W\ \/q-Zd,jSanE YS aT/*WS Z*/,\`T , j14W\Z-SEP V*31 ,TZEP TE ]\an\`+dphS h*yE `\4-Wq/*WS ZThZ1 Z1+\D S `\4Y\,WqO bS ]`\ \-\E fb\ ab,\`S, 4\`TD *V\3 -\,\O `SWS ]`\ a,\^ a]`*,S T b\`V*WSaq Y*y31 ,aTf b1Yx Lıa*^ 8>B69E 6:MD #\ `\+SbSE V\WS ,*Y Z1 ]\/\+*2bnO aq 4*yY*bSaq bSYE k\ gTV*,Sbn aSZ*H

\/TE Y\3WS,\E ,*`b\ ,T/Y\,SbSan ,T/ /1O qVSf a,\^f d]\/\+*Zn L SWS]GqZ 6B8MD ı*ZE qVSy 3S,1 d T,/1ZZTy e`SgTE `\4]\,TO /*2B w) gTV*,S,aq a]\`b\Y +TWnj1E ZT3 YTy aSZ \dZD TZ 4*f\]Wp,*,aq WTb*V*YS y V\Y]Gpb1`*YSD \Yd q b13 ]\h*, gTO V*,SbSan gSYD ) +`*, y\-\ Z* *,T*gTyZT ,Sab*,VS T -`*, 4 ZSY Z* V\Y]Gpb1`Z\O Yd *,T*aSYdWqb\`TD aVTWnVS YS `*4\Y 4*O yY*WSan ]`S2YZSYS a]`*,*YSE \dZ ab*, 4T YZ\p ,T/V`SbTjSYxD

˙\]\Y*-*yb1 aSZ\,T Z*+dbS ,]1,Z1Z\abT , a\+T w *bdE /S,SanIx S ,S hdWS ,T/ a,\-\ Y*W1ZnV\-\ aSZ* b*VT aW\,*E V\WS ,TZ Z*O ,hS,aq h\-\an Z\,\-\H )Vk\ b1]1` ,TZ ]T/WTb\VE hS y /*WT ]`*-Z1 ,T/ ,*a ]\f,*O WSH \3WS,\E y ZTD W1 ,TZ ]\b`1+d2 gn\O -\E k\+ ab*bS -*`Y\ZTyZ\ `\4,SZ1Z\p WpO /SZ\pD \- -\,* /*, ]`SVW*/ b\-\E qV ab*,SO bSan /\ a,\^f aSZT,D \WS ıadaE +d/dhS Z* 41YWTE Y*, `\4]\h*bS \a\+WS,1 aWd3TZZqE \- ]`SWp/Z\ ,SaW\,S, a,\^ ]\hdbbq /\ Zn\-\B w 1 SZ YTy dWp+W1ZSyE qV\-\ q af,*Wppx L *b,Tq 7B5;C 9B8<MD S qV +*bnO V\ Y*2b1 \+\,Gq4\V ,Sf\,d,*bS y Z*,h*bS 6> "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

a,\-\ aSZ* L˚e1aqZ :B8MD W1 ,S b*V\3 ]\O ,SZZT jdV*bS Z*-\/E k\+ f,*WSbS y\-\ 4* /\+`T ,hSZVS T aW\,*D ˙1V\Yd 4 h\W\,TVT, ,*3V\ ,SaW\,Wp,*O bS af,*W1ZZq hS b1]WT ]\hdbbqD b\anE Y\3WS,\E ,S`\ab*, d `\/SZTE /1 h*aO bTj1 ,V*4d,*WS Z* ]\YSWVSE * Z1 Z* /\+`T ,hSZVSD )Vk\ ,*a b*V ,Sf\,d,*O WSE b\ Z1\+fT/Z\ /\VW*/*bS a,T/\YSf 4dO aSWnE *+S /\]\Y*-*bS aSZ\,T `\4,SZdbS ,]1,Z1ZTabn d a\+TD )V g1 `\+SbSH dV*E 4-*/*ZSy `*ZTj1E `1-dWq`Z\ 4*yY*2bnaq /\Y*jZTYS a]`*,*YS 4T a,\^Y 59O`ThZSY aSZ\Y *Zd1W1YD TZ `\4]\,T/*2B wıZV\O WS q ]`\jd *Zd1Wq a*Y\Yd `\4]\h*bS qVdan `\+\bd T V*3dE k\ V\WS ]\b`T+Z\E b\ /\]\Y\3dD ˛/1+TWnj\-\ y\Yd a*Y\bd3VS ,/*2bnaq ^^ 4*,1`jSbSD TZ 4*/\,\W1ZSy a,\^YS da]Tf*YSE T b*V 4`\ab*2 y\-\ ,]1,O Z1ZTabn d a\+TD \WS y\Yd k\an ,/*2bnaqE q y\-\ f,*WpD V\WS k\an ,Sf\/Sbn Z1 b*VE qV ,TZ f\bT,E q ,a1 \/Z\ f,*Wp y\-\ 4* 4daSWWqxD S b*V\3 Y\31b1 /\]\Y*-*bS aSZ\,T Z*+dbS ,]1,Z1Z\abT , a\+TE V\WS +d/1b1 ab*,SbS ]1`1/ ZSY /1/*WT a1`y\4ZTjT gTWTD k\E V\WS aSZ /\aq-*2 qV\^an Y1bS Z1 b*V j,S/V\E qV +S ,*Y f\bTW\anH +\ y\-\ gTWTE f\h* y Z1 2 ]\-*ZSYSE ,T/`T4Zqpbnaq ,T/ bSfE ]`\ qVT /dY*WS ,SH b*V\Yd `*4T ,*YE Y\3WS,\E b`1+* 4YTZSbS a,\^ a]\/TO ,*ZZqD ˝*VE ]`\ qV\-\ yjW\aq `*ZTj1E `\4]\,T/*2B w) Z*Y*-*pan /\]\Y*-*bS aSO Z\,T ab*,SbS ]1`1/ a\+\p /\aq3ZT gTWTD `\b1 ab*`*panE *+S bT gTWT +dWS y\-\E * Z1 Y\^D \/T Z*-*/dp a\+TE k\ ,TZ Y*2 /\aq-*O bS bd hS TZjd Y1bd a,\^Y b1Y]\YxD )Vk\ ‹ ,S ]`SaWdf*2b1an /\ /dY\V aSZ*E f,*WSb1 y\-\ 4* da]TfS b* 4*\f\hd2b1 /\W*bS Z1O ,/*hTE b\ /\]\Y\31b1 y\Yd ,SV\Zd,*bS a,\^ 4*/dYSD ˛,Sh*yZ\E ,*jT ab\adZVS 4 aSZ\Y Z1 4*O ,3/S +d/dbn T/1*WnZSYSD W1 , VTZg1,\Yd ]T/adYVd aSZE Z*]1,Z1E 4*f\h1 4*WSj*bSan +WS4nV\p ,*Y Wp/SZ\pE */31 V\31Z +*O 3*2 +dbS /`d-\Y b\YdE fb\ ]`\ Zn\-\ /+*2D

˝ • & ˙

SV\ZdyY\ a,Ty \+\,Gq4\V ]1`1/ \-\Y

V\WSan gTV*,SW\E d h\Yd Y1b* 3SbO bqH -\,* ab,\`S, Z*a Z1 WSj1 T4 4/*bZTaO bp `\4/dYd,*bS Z*/ b*VSY 4*]Sb*ZZqYE *W1 y 4 ]\b`1+\p 4Z*bS ,T/]\,T/n Z* Zn\-\D ,\`1gn

Z1 ]`Sf\,d2 ,T/]\,T/T Z* g1 4*]Sb*ZZq P ^^

Y\3Z* 4Z*ybS , •\-\ W\,TE T+WT^D \4-WqZnO Y\ aW\,* g*`q \W\Y\Z*E 4*]Sa*ZT , ˚VVW14TO qab* 56B57D *` \W\Y\Z 4 ,W*aZ\-\ /\a,T/d 4Z*,E qV 4Z*ybS k*abq T a1Za d 3SbbTD \- /*, y\Yd Z*/O 4,Sh*yZd Yd/`TabnE ,1WSh14ZT ab*bVS b* ,W*/dD \W\Y\Z Y*, 4Y\-d `1b1WnZ\ 4,*3d,*bS Wp/O anVT ]`*-Z1ZZqE , b\Yd hSaWT 3*-d /\ +*-*babO ,* y aW*,S L˚VVW14Tqab* 6B8P=C 8B8MD T/

Z*bfZ1ZZqY ,T/ \-* ,TZ ]T/adYd,*, a,\^ `\4O /dYS b*VB w \-* +TyaqE T hSZS •\-\ 4*]\,T/TE +\ Z*W13Sbn g1 V\3ZTy Wp/SZT w, gn\Yd ,1an \+\,Gq4\V Wp/SZSxE xD SYS aW\,*YS ]1O `1/*Z\ adbn Z*y+TWnj ,*`bTaZ\-\ T jWqf1bZ\-\ ]`*-Z1ZZq Wp/SZSD w \-* +TyaqxD ˙dYV* ]`\ ab`*f ]1`1/ \-\Y a]1`jd Y\31 ,T/jb\,fd,*bSD W1 b*O VSy ab`*f P g1 +W*-\b,\`ZSy ab*Z a1`gqE

* Z1 ab`*fE qVSy Y*2 `*+E k\ +\^bnaq `\4/`*bdO ,*bS ad,\`\-\ ]*Z*D 1 `*/j1 ab`*fE qVSy Y\O 31 ,T/hd,*bS /SbSZ*E V\b`* f\h1 , dan\Yd ]\O /\+*bSaq a,\2Yd /\+`\Yd +*bnV\,TD \/ZTy ]`*gT aV*4*Z\E k\ ab`*f ]1`1/ \-\Y P g1 w-WS+\V* ]\,*-* b* j*Z\+WS,Sy ab`*fE qVT ,SO q,Wqpbn aWd3Sb1WT \-* /\ n\-\E \aVTWnVS Wp+Wqbn •\-\ T ,S4Z*pbn •\-\ ,W*/d b* ,1O WShxD b`*f ]1`1/ \-\Y a]\ZdVd2 Z*a ]T/V\O `qbSaq ,\WT \-*E +\ YS Wp+SY\ y\-\ T 4Z*2Y\E k\ ,TZ Wp+Sbn Z*aD 1y V\`SaZSy ab`*f Z1 2 WSj1 ]\hdbbqYE ,TZ ,Sq,Wq2bnaq d ,hSZV*fD )VH w SZS •\-\ 4*]\,T/TxD b`*f ]1`1/ \O -\Y -\,\p a]\ZdVd2 Z*a V\`SbSan y\YdE T g1 `\4dYZ\D S`\+ZSV ]1,Z\-\ b\,*`d Z*yWT]j1 4Z*2E qV V\`Sabd,*bSaq ZSYE ]\/T+Z\ Z*j ,\O

`1gn 4Z*2E qVSY Y*2 +dbS Z*j1 3SbbqD `TY b\-\E -\,* kS`\ ]`*-Z1 /Wq Z*a Z*yV`*k\-\D TZ f\h1E k\+ YS +dWS k*aWS,SYSE T y\-\

,SY\-S P WSj1 Z*Y Z* /\+`\ Lıa*^ 8<B5;MD ]\ab\W ı,*Z aV*4*,B w p+\, 31 /\ \-* ]\O Wq-*2 , b\YdE k\+ YS ,SV\Zd,*WS y\-\ 4*]\,TO /TE * gT 4*]\,T/T Z1 \+bq3WS,Tx L5 ı,*Z* 9B7MD ,\2p aWdfZqZTabp YS ]\V*4d2Y\E k\ Wp+SY\ \-*E * y\-\ 4*]\,T/T a,T/h*bnE k\ ,TZ WpO +Sbn Z*aD w gn\Yd ,1an \+\,Gq4\V Wp/SZSxD *3O WS,\ aWdf*bSaq \-* T Y*bS ]1`1/ ZSY ab`*fE +\ g1 \+\,Gq4\V Wp/SZSD -\,* 2 Z*jSY ,\`O

g1YE b\3 a,\^Y 3SbbqY YS 4*,/qhd2Y\ ]1`1/O daTY y\Yd L a*W\Y 7:B5>MD S 4\+\,Gq4*ZT aWdf*bSan \-*D \WS d4-\/3d2Y\ 3Sbbq 4 y\O -\ ,SY\-*YSE b\ gSY ,SV\Zd2Y\ a,Ty \+\O ,Gq4\VD \3 d h\Yd Y1b* 3SbbqH )Vk\ aV*4*bS V\`\bV\B , b\YdE *+S ,SV\Zd,*bS \3d ,\O WpD Tk\ TZj1 Z1 Y\31 a]\,ZSbS Z*j1 3Sbbq -WS+jSY 4YTab\YD ˛*]`\jd2Y\ ,*a +TWnj1 ]TO 4Z*,*bS ,\Wp -\,S T /\,T/*bSanE qV 4YTZSbS a,\2 3SbbqE *+S ,\Z\ ,T/]\,T/*W\ •\-\ ,\WTD gn\Yd ,*Y /\]\Y\3dbn ,T/VS -\,SD

˙ı • ˚ ı ı• • ˛ `S]\,Tab1y 66 P TaZq Z*/ ]TaZqYS <

65

1 /`d-* 4 /,\f ab*b1yE , qVSf `\4-Wq/*pbnaq 4*]Sb*ZZq ]`\ /*bd 4ZSk1ZZq ab*`\/*,Zn\-\ `da*WSY*D b*bbT /*pbn ,Sh1`]ZT ,T/]\,T/T Z* 4*]Sb*ZZqE qVT +1Zb13*bn /1qVSf hSb*hT,D T ,T/]\,T/T š`dZbdpbnaq Z* T+WT^ b* `14dWnb*O b*f `1b1WnZSf /\aWT/31ZnD

\WS +d, 4ZSk1ZSy ab*`\/*,ZTy `da*WSYH ˙

# ı˙ & ) ı

# ( & ˚ "ı• ıB

ˇ h1ZT b,1`/qbnE k\ `da*WSY

Photograph taken by courtesy of the British Museum

+d, 4`dyZ\,*ZSy 9<; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D ˇ T+WTyZ* f`\Z\W\-Tq ,V*4d2E k\ 4ZSk1ZZq `da*WSY* ,T/+dW\aq :>; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D ˇ h1ZT a]S`*pbnaq Z* ]`*gT *ZbShZSf Tab\`SVT, T V*Z\Z b\W1Y1qD ˇ ˙1qVT ]`*gT *ZbShZSf Tab\`SVT, YTabqbn -`d+T ]\YSWVS T Z1 4*,3/S d4-\/3dpbnaq 4 VWSZ\]SaZSYS b*+WShV*YS1D

ı ı) V*31E k\ p/1^ ]1`1+d,*WS , Z1O ,\WT d *,SW\ZTE w]\VS Z1 aVTZhSW\aq ;> `\VT,DDD k\+ a]`*,/SW\an aW\,\ \a]\/O Z2 h1`14 dab* `1YT^x L6 `\ZTV 7:B65E ]1`1O VW*/ \Y1ZV*MD \WS 3 ,\ZS +dWS 4,TWnO Z1ZTH w]1`jSy `TV g*`p,*ZZq T`*E

1 Sb*yb1 ab*bbp w \WS +d, 4ZSk1ZSy ab*`\/*,ZTy `da*WSYH \Yd g1 Y*2 Z*a gTV*,SbSD `\ k\ a,T/O h*bn /\V*4Sx d Z\Y1`T 4* 5 3\,bZq 6>55 `\VdD

66 "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

g*`q ]1`anV\-\x L6 `\ZTV 7:B66MD ı T+WTqE T a,TbanVT Tab\`SVS ]T/b,1`/3dpbnE k\ ]1O `T\/ ,*,SW\ZanV\^ Z1,\WT 4*VTZhS,aq ]TaWq b\-\E qV T` 4*,\p,*, *,SW\ZE 4,TWnZS, p/1^, T ,\ZS 97; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D ]\,1`ZdWSaq , `da*WSYD T+WTq hTbV\ -\,\`SbnE k\ ,SO -Z*ZZq b`S,*W\ ;> `\VT,D b31E y\-\ ]\h*O b\V ]`S]*/*2 Z* :>; `TV /\ ZD 1D ı ,a1 3 +TWnjTabn ,h1ZSf b,1`/SbnE k\ `da*WSY +d, 4ZSk1ZSy 9<; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D )Vk\ a]S`*bSan Z* gp /*bdE b\ ,S-Z*ZZq p/1^, b`S,*W\ bTWnVS 9> `\VT,D \Yd ,h1ZT ]\/*pbn a*Y1 9<; `TV /\ ZD 1DH * k\ ,\ZS a]S`*pbnaqH ˛* \aZ\,d a,\^f ]T/`*fdZVT, /\aWT/ZSVS +1`dbn ab*`\/*,ZT VWSZ\]SaZT b*+WShVSE qVT YTabqbn ]\/`\+SgT ]`\ *O ,df\/\Z\a\`* II T y\-\ Z*abd]ZSVT,5D SO Y*W\ bSf /\VdY1ZbT, +dWS Z*]Sa*ZT h\W\O ,TV*YSE V\b`T 3SWS , ]1`T\/ 4ZSk1ZZq `da*WSY* *+\ Z1,/\,4T ]TaWq gn\-\D W1 Z*aVTWnVS /\ab\,T`ZSYS 2 ]T/`*fdZVSE qVT ,V*4dpbn Z* 9<; `TV /\ ZD 1DH #\ Z*a]`*,O /T ,Sq,Wqpbn -WSZqZT b*+WShVSH #\+ ,T/]\,TabS Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZqE `\4-WqO ZnY\ b`S -`d]S /\VdY1ZbT,E Z* qVT a]S`*O pbnaq ,h1ZTB 5M ,*,SW\ZanVT f`\ZTVSC 6M /TO W\,T /\VdY1ZbSC 7M *ab`\Z\YThZT 4*]SaSD

BM 21901 and BM 35382: Photograph taken by courtesy of the British Museum; BM 21946: Copyright British Museum; BM 22047, 25124, 25127: ˘ The Trustees of the British Museum

*,SW\ZanVT f`\ZTVS

#\ g1 b*V1H *,SW\ZanVT f`\ZTVS P g1 a1`Tq b*+WSh\VE , qVSf \]Sa*ZT -\W\,ZT ]\O /T^ Tab\`T^ *,SW\ZT^6D #\ V*3dbn 1Va]1`bSH `\,T/ZSy 1VaO ]1`b 4 ,S,h1ZZq VWSZ\]SaZSf /\VdY1ZbT,E D *VE 4*4Z*h*2E k\ f`\ZTVS Z1 \]Sadpbn daTf ,*3WS,Sf ]\/Ty1D )V V*31 g1y e*fTO ,1gnE Tab\`SV*Y b`1+* 4,1`b*bSaq /\ w/\O /*bV\,Sf /31`1WDDD *+S b\hZ\ ,S4Z*hSbSE k\ ,T/+d,*W\aqxD `\ k\ a,T/h*bn /\VdY1ZbSH ,*,SO W\ZanVSf f`\ZTV*f 2 ]`\-*WSZS7D L˙S,TbnO aq ad]`\,T/Zd TZe\`Y*gTp w *,SW\ZanVT f`\ZTVS P Z1]\,Z* Tab\`TqxMD \3 ,SZSV*2 4*]Sb*ZZqB Z*aVTWnVS /\ab\,T`ZT ,SaZ\O ,VSE 4`\+W1ZT Z* \aZ\,T Z1]\,ZSf /*ZSfH

˙TW\,T /\VdY1ZbS

#\ g1 b*V1H TWnjTabn b*+WSh\V Z\,\O ,*,SW\ZanV\-\ ]1`T\/d P g1 p`S/ShZT /\O 1 ˛,1`ZTbn d,*-dB 3\/1Z 4 e*fT,gT,E hS^ aW\,* gSO bdpbnaq d ab*bbTE Z1 ,,*3*2E k\ `da*WSY +d, 4ZSO k1ZSy :>; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D

VdY1ZbSD * ZSf ,V*4*ZSy /1ZnE YTaqgn T `TV ]`*,WTZZq g*`qD *]`SVW*/E Z* \/ZTy 4 b*+WSh\V 4*]Sa*Z\E V\WS ,T/+dW*an ]1,O Z* d-\/*B w Taqgn ZTa*ZE /1Zn 6;OyE `TV 55Oy *,df\/\Z\a\`*E g*`q *,SW\Z*x8D \WS g*` ]\YS`*, *+\ ]`S]SZq, ]`*,SO bSE * ]`1ab\W 4*yY*, TZjSyE `1jb* YTaqgT, \ab*ZZn\-\ `\Vd y\-\ ]`*,WTZZq ,,*3*WSO aq `\V\Y af\/31ZZq Z* b`\Z Z\,\-\ ]`*,SO b1Wq19D ıZjSYS aW\,*YSE 4YTZ* ]`*,Sb1Wq ,T/+d,*W*an , \/SZ T b\y a*YSy V*W1Z/*`O ZSy `TVD b31 W\-ThZ\E k\ b*+WShVSE Z*]SO a*ZT d `TV af\/31ZZq Z* b`\Z Z\,\-\ g*O `qE Y*WS /*bd,*bSaq \/ZSY 4 YTaqgT,E qVT yjWS ]TaWq \ab*ZZn\-\ YTaqgq ]`*,WTZZq ]\]1`1/Zn\-\ g*`qD #\ V*3dbn 1Va]1`bSH D *V /\aWTO /S, hSY*W\ /TW\,Sf /\VdY1ZbT, Z\,\O ,*,SW\ZanV\-\ ]1`T\/dD 5=;6 `\gT ,TZ Z*]Sa*,E k\ Z\,T Z1\]d+WTV\,*ZT b1VaO bS 4 `Sb*ZanV\-\ Yd41pE /\ qVSf ,TZ 1 TV af\/31ZZq Z* b`\Z P YTaqgTE qVT 4*WSj*WSO aq /\ Z*ab*ZZq Z*abd]Z\-\ `\VdE V\WS g*` \eTgTyZ\ ]\hSZ*, ]`*,SbSEP Z1 4*`*f\,d,*,aq /\ `\VT, y\-\ ]`*,WTZZqD

BM 65=>5

& ı ı P ˚ ı ı) BM 65=8:

*,SW\ZanVT f`\ZTVS \f\]Wppbn WSj1 79 `\VT, Z\,\,*,SW\ZanV\-\ ]1`T\/dE qVSyE qV ,,*3*2bnaqE b`S,*, +WS4nV\ << `\VT,D BM 797<6

ı E ˚ ˛ ˙ • ı

ı E ˛ ˙ • ı

& •

*,df\/\Z\a\` II

*+\]*W*a*`

BM 6956;

BM 66>8;

˚ ı ˙

Y1WnO *`/dV

1`T-WTaa*`

BM 69568

˚

*+\ZT/ *+*jTO *`/dV

ab*, ,,*3*bSE k\ `da*WSY +d, 4`dyZ\,*O ZSy 9<; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D1

ab`\Z\YThZT 4*]SaS

#\ g1 b*V1H 1 VWSZ\]SaZT b*+WShVSE , qVSf \]Sa*Z\ ]\W\31ZZq \ZgqE TaqgqE ]W*Z1b T 4T` b* ]\/*Z\ Tab\`ShZd TZe\`Y*O gTpE qVO\b `TV ]`*,WTZZq b\-\ hS TZj\-\ g*`qD *]`SVW*/E d b*+WShgTE ]\V*4*ZTy ZS3h1E YTabSbnaq \]Sa YTaqhZ\-\ 4*b1YO Z1ZZqE V\b`1 ,T/+dW\aq ]1`j\-\ YTaqgq ]1`j\-\ `\Vd ]`*,WTZZq g*`q VTZO41`*55D #\ V*3dbn 1Va]1`bSH ˚Va]1`bS ]\-\O /3dpbnaqE k\ ,*,SW\ZqZS aVW*/*WS /1O b*WnZT V*`bS T af1YS /Wq b\-\E *+S ,S4Z*h*bSE V\WS Z*yTY\,T`ZTj1 Y*WS ,T/O +d,*bSaq 4*b1YZ1ZZq56D hS Y\-WS ,*,SW\ZqZS ,S4Z*h*bS h*a 4*b1YZ1ZnE V\b`T ,T/+dWSan d YSZdW\YdH `\e1a\` ˙3\Z bTW 4*4Z*h*2B w TWV\Y Y\3WS,\E k\ af1YS b*V\3 ,SV\`Sab\,dO ,*WSE *+S ,S`*fd,*bS /*bS /1qVSf 4*b1YO Z1ZnE qVT ,T/+dWSan /*,Z\ d YSZdW\YdE T ,V*4*bS gT /*bS , /\VdY1ZbTx57D `\O e1a\` ˙1y,T/ `*dZ ,,*3*2E k\ *ab`\O 1 ˛* ,aT `\VSE qVT ]`SyZqb\ ,,*3*bS Z\,\,*,SW\ZO anVSY ]1`T\/\YE TaZdpbn b*+WShVS 4 /TW\,SYS /\VdO Y1Zb*YSD )Vk\ ]T/adYd,*bS `\VS ]`*,WTZZq daTf g*O `T, T ,T/`*fd,*bS g1 hSaW\ ,T/ ]`*,WTZZq *+\ZT/*E \ab*ZZn\-\ g*`q Z\,\,*,SW\ZanV\-\ ]1`T\/dE b\ ,SO y/1E k\ `da*WSY +d, 4ZSk1ZSy 9<; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D /O Z*V gT ]T/`*fdZVS Y\3dbn +dbS b\hZSYS WSj1 4* dY\,SE k\ V\31Z g*` 4*abd]*, TZj\-\ d b\y a*YSy `TV T YT3 ^fZTY ]`*,WTZZqY Z1 +dW\ ]1`1`,D

˝ ı ) # 7667< q b*+WShV* YTabSbn 4-*/VS ]`\ YTaqhZT 4*b1YZ1ZZqD W1 ,\Z* +dW* Z*]Sa*Z* WSj1 ]TaWq \ab*ZZn\-\ 4-*/*Z\-\ , ZTy 4*b1YZ1ZZqE qV1 ,T/+dW\aq ]`S+WS4Z\ h1`14 8>> `\VT, ]TaWq ]1`j\-\D aVTWnVS *,b\` b*+WShVS Z1 a]\ab1`T-*, daTf bSf q,SkE b\ h*a ]1`j\-\ 4*b1YZ1ZZq ,TZ ,S4Z*hS,E \h1,S/Z\E 4* /\]\Y\-\p Y*b1Y*bShZSf \+hSaW1ZnD )Vk\ Z* ]T/b,1`/31ZZq ,ab*Z\,W1ZSf ZSY /*b Z1 TaZd2 /\/*bV\,Sf /\V*4T,E gp b*+WShVd Z1 Y\3Z* ,,*3*bS Z*/TyZSY /31`1W\Y /Wq ,S4Z*h1ZZq Tab\`ShZSf /*bD 68

˘ The Trustees of the British Museum

\b`SY*, /\abd]E w]\,ZTabp a]`\ab\,dO pbnx ]\]1`1/ZT ,SaZ\,VS k\/\ ]1`1f\O /d ,W*/S ,T/ *,df\/\Z\a\`* II /\ y\O -\ aSZ* Y1WnO *`/dV* L,T/\Y\-\ b13 qV ˚,TWO 1`\/*fM:D \YdH *V 4Z*,E k\E 4-T/O Z\ 4 b*+WShV*YSE *,df\/\Z\a\` II ,a1 k1 ]`*,S, d j\ab\Yd YTaqgT a,\-\ \aO b*ZZn\-\ L87O-\M `\Vd ]`*,WTZZqD W1 Z\,T `\4jSe`\,*ZT /\VdY1ZbSE Z*]Sa*ZT , `TV af\/31ZZq Z* b`\Z Z*abd]Z\-\ g*O `qE Y1WnO *`/dV*E /*bdpbnaq h1b,1`O bSY T ]GqbSY YTaqgqYSE qV ,,*3*pbnE b\-\ a*Y\-\ `\Vd;D 1 \h1,S/Z* `\4+T3O ZTabnD `\ k\ a,T/h*bn /\VdY1ZbSH dW\ ,SO q,W1Z\ y TZjT `\4+T3Z\abT k\/\ b\-\E V\O WS ,W*/* ]1`1f\/SW* ,T/ \/Z\-\ g*`q /\ TZj\-\D `SYT`\YE TaZd2 /\VdY1ZbE qVSy ]\V*4d2E k\ *,df\/\Z\a\` II k1 ]`*,S, d /1aqb\Yd YTaqgT P jTabn YTaqgT, ]TaO Wq b\-\E qV ZT+Sb\ ]\h*, ]`*,SbS y\-\ Z*abd]ZSV<D \/T+Zd `\4+T3ZTabn ,Sq,SO WS k\/\ h*ad ]1`1f\/d ,W*/S ,T/ Y1WnO *`/dV* /\ 1`T-WTaa*`*=D

\Yd gT `\4+T3Z\abT ,*`bT d,*-SH )V 4-*/d,*W\an `*ZTj1E ,*,SW\ZanVT f`\ZTVS Y*pbn ]`\-*WSZS T 4*]Sa*Z* , ZSf Tab\`Tq Z1]\,Z*5>D S Y\-WS YT3 ,Sk14-*/*ZSYS g*`qYS ]`*,SbS k1 TZjT g*`TH )Vk\ b*VE b\ Z\,\,*,SW\ZanVSy ]1`T\/ Y*, b`S,*bS /\,j1D b31E ZT ,*,SW\ZanVT f`\ZTVSE ZT /TW\,T /\VdY1ZbS Z1 /*pbn ,*-\YSf ]T/O

Z\YThZT V*`bS YTabSWS ]`\-Z\4SE 4`\+W1O ZT Z14*/\,-\ /\ \]Sad,*ZSf q,SkD /Z*V ,TZ ]`S]daV*2E k\ /1qVT 4 bSf /*b Y\-O WS +dbS w,S`*fd,*ZT ]\abe*VbdY ,h1O ZSYS IV ab\WTbbq /\ ZD 1D *+\ ]T4ZTjSf ab\WTbnx58D )Vk\ gT ]T/`*fdZVS +dWS 4`\+O W1ZT ]\abe*VbdY T Z1Y*2 TZjSf /\V*4T, Z* ^f ]T/b,1`/31ZZqE b\ hS Y\3Z* ,,*3*O bS ^f b\hZSYSH V*3TY\E 4*b1YZ1ZZq a]`*,/T ,T/+dW\an d ,V*4*Zd /*bdD W1 hS g1 \4Z*h*2E k\ TaO b\`ShZ* TZe\`Y*gTqE ]\,Gq4*Z* 4 gT2p /*O b\pE 2 b\hZ\pH 1 \+\,Gq4V\,\D h1ZSy D ,*Z /1` ]1V ]\qaZp2B w 1VabS b*+WSO h\V dVW*/*WS *ab`\W\-SE * Z1 Tab\`SVSxD ıab\`ShZT /*ZT , b*+WShV*fE 4* aW\,*YS ]1V*E w/\aSbn ]`S+WS4ZTxE T b\YdE ]\aSO W*phSan Z* ZSfE ,*3WS,\ w+dbS `\4+T`WSO ,SYx59D `\ k\ a,T/h*bn /\VdY1ZbSH T4nYTY\ /Wq ]`SVW*/d b*+WShVd VAT 8=9:D ]1`O j\Yd `q/Vd gT2^ b*+WShVS Z*]Sa*Z\B w TV 7;Oy *,df\/\Z\a\`*E g*`q *,SW\Z*x5:D Ë™*WT YTabqbnaq /1b*WnZT \]SaS `\4b*jdO ,*ZZq Taqgq T ]W*Z1b k\/\ `T4ZSf 4TO `\V b* ad4T`G^,D b*+WShgT b*V\3 4-*/dO 2bnaq YTaqhZ1 4*b1YZ1ZZqD h1ZT V*3dbnE k\ 4-*/*Z1 , b*+WShgT `\4b*jd,*ZZq Z1O +1aZSf bTW a]\ab1`T-*W\an d 9:<N9:; `\gT /\ ZD 1D 1 \4Z*h*2E k\ 5<Oy `TV ]`*,WTZZq *,df\/\Z\a\`* II P `TVE V\WS ,TZ 4ZSkS, `da*WSYEP ]`S]*/*2 Z* 9<; `TV /\ ZD 1D

W1 hS gT *ab`\Z\YThZT /*ZT ,V*4dpbn WSO j1 Z* 9:<N9:; `TV /\ ZD 1DH b*+WShgT 4-*/*Z\ ]`\ YTaqhZ1 4*b1YO Z1ZZqE qV1 4-T/Z\ 4 ]T/`*fdZV*YS ,T/+dO W\an 59O-\ /Zq aTY*ZdE b`1bn\-\ YTaqgq 4* ,*,SW\ZanVSY V*W1Z/*`1YD n\-\ YTaqgq L8 WS]Zq 4* pWT*ZanVSY V*W1Z/*`1YM 9:< `\Vd /\ ZD 1D a]`*,/T ,T/+dW\aq YTaqhZ1 4*O b1YZ1ZZqD ,bTYE 4* 6> `\VT, /\ b\-\E 59 WS]Zq 9<< `\Vd /\ ZD 1DE +dW\ k1 TZj1 4*O b1YZ1ZZq5;D )Vk\ 9<< `TV /\ ZD 1DP g1 7;Oy `TV ]`*,O WTZZq *,df\/\Z\a\`* IIE b\ 5<Oy `TV y\-\ ]`*,WTZZq ]`S]*/*2 Z* :>; `TV /\ ZD 1DP `TV 4ZSk1ZZq `da*WSY*E Z* qVSy ,V*O 4d2 T+WTqD L˙S,Tbnaq f`\Z\W\-ThZd jV*Wd ,ZS4dMD S YTabqbnaq d b*+WShgT VAT 8=9: TZjT /\V*4S Z* ]T/b,1`/31ZZq :>; `\Vd /\ ZD 1DH V`TY ,Sk14-*/*Z\-\ 4*b1YZ1ZZqE d b*+WShgT 2 k1 57 \]SaT, `\4b*jd,*ZZq Taqgq T 59 \]SaT, `\4b*jd,*ZZq ]W*Z1bD ZSf ,V*4*Z\ ]\W\31ZZq Taqgq *+\ ]W*O Z1b k\/\ ]1,ZSf 4T`\V hS ad4T`G^,5<D b*+O WShgT b*V\3 ]\/*Z\ ,TaTY h*a\,Sf ]`\O YT3VT, YT3 af\/\Y T 4*f\/\Y a\Zgq b* YTaqgq5<*D aVTWnVS TZe\`Y*gTq ]`\ ]\W\31ZZq TO aqgq , b*+WShgT VAT 8=9: Z*/TyZTj*E ZT3 \]SaS `\4b*jd,*ZZq ]W*Z1bE Z*dV\,gT `1O b1WnZ\ /\aWT/SWS 4-*/*ZT 57 \]SaT, ]\W\O 31ZZq TaqgqD \ZS ]`\*Z*WT4d,*WS /*ZT

) • ı Ë› VAT 8=9:B 9<;O• :>;O•H Ë›

b*+WShgT \]Sa*Z\ *ab`\Z\YThZT q,Sk*E V\b`T ,T/+dWSaq 7;O-\ `\Vd ]`*,WTZZq *,df\/\Z\a\`* IID

Ë›

*,df\/\Z\a\` II 4`dyZd,*, `da*WSY d 5<Oy `TV a,\-\

]`*,WTZZq L `1YT^ 76B5MD

)Vk\ 7;Oy `TV ]`*,WTZZq

*,df\/\Z\a\`* II ]`S]*/*2 Z* 9:< `TV /\ ZD 1DE b\ `da*WSY +d, 4ZSk1ZSy 9<; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D

9<; :5> `TV /\ ZD 1D

:>>

9=>

9<>

9;>

9:>

:>;

)Vk\ 7;Oy `TV y\-\ ]`*,WTZZq ]`S]*/*2 Z* 9<< `TV /\ ZD 1DE b\ `da*WSY +d, 4ZSk1ZSy :>; `\Vd /\ ZD 1DE qV T ,V*4d2 +T+WTyZ* f`\Z\W\-TqD

Ë›

Ë™*ZT VAT 8=9: +TWnj1 a,T/h*bn Z* V\`Sabn :>; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D

# Ë? ˙Ĺ Äą VAT 8=9:H

2

3

4

bpk / Vorderasiatisches Museum, SMB / Olaf M. TeĂ&#x;mer

\Yd ]\ab*2 g1 4*]Sb*ZZqH

b`1bn\Yd `q/Vd gT2^ b*+WShVS -\,\`SbnaqE k\ , wZTh =O-\x hSaW* ]1`j\-\ YTaqgq LZTa*Zd *+\ ZTa*ZM w Taqgn ab\q, 5 WTV\bn ]1`1/ Ă&#x; Ë™T,SxD /Z*V d 5=59 `\gT \y-1+*d1` T *y/Z1`E -\,\`qhS ]`\ 9:< `TV /\ ZD 1D LqVSy ]T/b,1`/3d,*, +S 9<; `TV /\ ZD 1D qV `TV 4ZSk1ZZq `da*WSY*ME Z*]Sa*WSE k\ b\-\ `\Vd w Taqgn ab\q, 5 WTV\bn ]1`1/ gT2p 4T`V\p < ZTa*Z*E * Z1 = ZTa*Z*x LVd`aS, Z*jMD ,bTYE b*V1 `\4b*jd,*ZZq Taqgq a]\ab1`T-*W\aq = ZTa*Z* 9<< `\Vd /\ ZD 1DE k\ ]T/b,1`/3d2 :>; `TV /\ ZD 1D qV /*bd 4ZSk1ZZq `da*WSY*D

1

)V1 b\ +dW\ hSaW\B =Ob1 hS <OY1H 5M * e\b\-`*eT^ hTbV\ ,S/Z\ *VV*/anVSy aSY,\W /Wq ]\4Z*h1ZZq gSe`S =D 6M `*ZaWTb1`dphS VWSZ\]SaZSy b1VabE \y-1+*d1` T *y/Z1` 4YTZSWS w=x Z* w<xD 7M 1E k\ , b1VabT \`S-TZ*Wd +dW\ w=xE ,\ZS ,V*4*WS WSj1 , ]`SYTbgTD 8M *,Tbn d ]1`1VW*/T ZTY1gnV\p gT ,h1ZT 4*WSjSWS w<xD 9M 5=<< `\gT *Va T dZ-1` \]d+WTVd,*WS b1Vab b*+WShVS 4 gSe`\p w=xE qV T ,V*4*Z\ , \`S-TZ*WTD :M *Z-WTyanV\Yd ]1`1VW*/T ,\ZS Z*]Sa*WS w=xE *W1 ,V*4*WSE k\ g1 w]\YSWV*B Y*2 +dbS <xD

4 b*+WShVS 4* /\]\Y\-\p V\Y]Gpb1`Z\^ ]`\-`*YSE qV* ]\V*4d2 `\4b*jd,*ZZq Z1+1aZSf bTW d ]1,ZSy Y\Y1Zb d YSZdW\Yd5=D #\ ]\V*4*W\ /\aWT/31ZZqH 1 ,aT \]SaS `\4b*jd,*ZZq Taqgq ,T/]\,T/*pbn 9:<N9:; `\Vd /\ ZD 1E \/Z*V ,aT 57 ,T/]\,T/*pbn 9<<N9<; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D /SZ 4 e`*-Y1ZbT,E /1 \]SaS ]\W\31ZZq Taqgq ,T/]\,T/*pbn 9<< `\Vd /\ ZD 1D Z*,Tbn +TWnj1E ZT3 9:< `\V\,T /\ ZD 1DE Y\3Z* ]\+*hSbS Z* TWpab`*O gT^E ]\/*ZTy Z* gSf ab\`TZV*fD b`1bn\Yd `q/Vd -WSZqZ\^ b*+WShVS \]Sad2bnaq ]\W\31ZZq Taqgq , wZTh =O-\ ZTa*Zd xD /Z*V ,h1ZTE V\b`T /*bd,*WS g1 q,Sk1 9:< `\V\Y /\ ZD 1D LO9:; `TV 4-T/Z\ 4 *ab`\O Z\YThZSY V*W1Z/*`1YME ,S4Z*pbnE k\ , b\Yd `\gT Taqgn Y*, b*V1 `\4b*jd,*ZZq w<O-\E * Z1 = ZTa*O ZdxD T/ab\pphS /dYVd ]`\ 9:< `TV /\ ZD 1DE ,\ZS b,1`/SWSE k\ *,b\` b*+WShVS ]\YSWV\,\ Z*]Sa*, w=x 4*YTabn w<x6>D `\b1 ,*`b\ 4*4Z*hSbSE k\ ]\W\O 31ZZq TaqgqE 4-*/*Z1 , b`1bn\Yd `q/Vd b*+WShO VSE b\hZ\ ,T/]\,T/*2 = ZTa*Zd 9<< `\Vd /\ ZD 1D65

\3 \h1,S/Z\E k\ 4Z*hZ* VTWnVTabn *ab`\Z\YThO ZSf q,SkE \]Sa*ZSf d VAT 8=9:E ,T/]\,T/*2 9<< `\O Vd /\ ZD 1D *Y1 g1y `TV +d, 7;OY `\V\Y ]`*,WTZZq *,df\/\Z\a\`* IID \b31E `da*WSY +d, 4ZSk1O ZSy :>; `\Vd /\ ZD 1DE qV T ]\V*4d2 T+WTqD

T+WTq P VZS-*E -T/Z* /\,T`S n\-\/ZT +TWnjTabn Tab\`SVT, /*bdpbn 4ZSk1ZO Zq `da*WSY* 9<; `\V\Y /\ ZD 1D /Z*V +T+WTyZT ]`\`\VS `1YTq T Ë™*ZS^W ]`qY\ -\,\`qbnE k\ p/1^ +dWS d ,S-Z*ZZT ;>E * Z1 9> `\VT, L `1YT^ 69B5E 6E 55C 6=B5>C Ë™*ZS^W* =B6MD 1 /*2 Z*/TyZd ]T/ab*,d ,,*O 3*bSE k\ `da*WSY +d, 4ZSk1ZSy :>; `\Vd /\ ZD 1D h1ZT ]\abTyZ\ ]T//*pbn adYZT,d /\ab\,T`ZTabn T+WT^D ,bTYE Z\,T 4Z*fT/VS k\`*4d ]T/b,1`/3dO pbn b\hZTabn gT2^ VZS-S1D TE fb\ /\,T`q2 T+WT^E Y*pbn daT ]T/ab*,S /Wq gn\-\D ıaZd2 hSY*W\ /\V*O 4T,E k\ ,\Z* YTabSbn b\hZT ]`\`\gb,*E * b*V\3 2 /\ab\,T`Z\p 4 ]\-Wq/d Tab\`T^ b* Z*dVSD T /\V*4S 4YTgZqpbn ,T`d , b1E k\ T+WTq a]`*,/T Z*bfZ1Z* \-\Y L6 SY\eTq 7B5:MD \Yd + ,*Y Z1 ]1`1,T`SbS gT /\V*4SH \3WS,\E ,S /Ty/1b1 b*V\-\ 3 ,SO aZ\,VdD

5 6

1 TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ Z* gp b1Yd ,S 4Z*y/1b1 , 8OYd b* 9OYd `\4/TW*f VZS3VS w T+WTqD W\,\ \-* hS Wp/SZSHxE \]d+WTV\O ,*Z\^ ,T/V*YS -\,SD " Ë™ 5 Ë™ 6>55

6;

`SYTbVS /\ ab*bbT w \WS +d, 4ZSk1ZSy ab*`\/*,ZTy `da*WSYH *abSZ* /`d-*x 1. WSZ\]Sa P g1 e\`Y* ]SanY*E qVd db,\`ppbn 4* /\]\Y\-\p ]*WShVS 4 4*O -\ab`1ZSY VWSZ\]\/T+ZSY VTZg1YD SO a*` Z*Z\aS, `T4Z\Y*ZTbZT 4Z*VS Z* k1 aS`d -WSZqZd b*+WShVdD 2. Assyrian and Babylonian Chronicles, by A. K. Grayson, published 1975, 2000 reprint, page 8. 3. \,\,*,SW\ZanVSy ]1`T\/ ]\h*,aq d VII ab\WTbbT /\ ZD 1DE V\WS /SZ*abTq f*WO /1yanVSf g*`T, ]`*,SW* *,SW\ZanV\p TY]1`T2pD 1`jSY g*`1Y +d, *+\]*O W*a*`E +*bnV\ *,df\/\Z\a\`* IID 1y ]1`T\/ 4*VTZhS,aqE V\WS 97= `\Vd /\ ZD 1D ]1`anVSy g*` T` aVSZd, \ab*ZZn\-\ g*O `qE *+\ZT/*D 4. Neo-Babylonian Business and Administrative Documents, by Ellen Whitley Moore, published 1935, page 33. 5. Archimedes, Volume 4, New Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science and Technology, “Observations and Predictions of Eclipse Times by Early Astronomers,â€? by John M. Steele, published 2000, page 36. 6. Amel-Marduk 562-560 B.C.—A Study Based on Cuneiform, Old Testament, Greek, Latin and Rabbinical Sources. With Plates, by Ronald H. Sack, published 1972, page 3. 7. *+WShVS BM <>=6> T BM 9<<;6 /*bdO pbnaq h1b,1`bSY T ]GqbSY YTaqg1Y `\VdE , qVSy Ëš,TWO 1`\/*f 4Tyj\, Z* b`\ZD ÄąfZTy b1Vab \]d+WTVd,*, D *V (AmelMarduk 562-560 B.C.—A Study Based on Cuneiform, Old Testament, Greek, Latin and Rabbinical Sources. With Plates, pages 3, 90, 106)D 8. q b*+WShV* 4 `Sb*ZanV\-\ Yd41p LBM 99<>:M /*b\,*Z* /1aqbSY YTaqg1Y 87O-\ `\VdD 9. *+WShVS BM ;95>: T BM :5769 /*b\,*ZT an\YSY T /1aqbSY YTaqgqO YSE qV ,,*3*pbnE \ab*ZZn\-\ L/`d-\O -\M `\Vd ]`*,WTZZq g*`q Ëš,TWO 1`\/*O f* L Y1WnO *`/dV*MD /Z*V b*+WShV* BM ;98<= /*b\,*Z* /`d-SY YTaqO g1Y `\Vd af\/31ZZq Z* b`\Z y\-\ Z*O abd]ZSV* 1`T-WTaa*`* (Catalogue of the Babylonian Tablets in the British Museum, Volume VIII, (Tablets From Sippar 3) by Erle Leichty, J. J. Finkelstein, and C.B.F. Walker, published 1988, pages 25, 35). Catalogue of the Babylonian Tablets in the British Museum, Volume VII, (Tablets From Sippar 2) by Erle Leichty and A. K. Grayson, published 1987, page 36. Neriglissar—King of Babylon, by Ronald H. Sack, published 1994, page 232. Ë™`d-Sy YTaqgnE ,V*4*ZSy d b*+WShgTEP g1 YTO aqgn *yq`dD 10. \4-WqZnY\ ]`SVW*/ 1`T-WTaa*`*D g*`anVSf 4*]Sa*f ]`\ Zn\-\ -\,\O `Sbnaq qV ]`\ waSZ* 1WOjdYOTjVdZ*E g*`q *,SW\Z*x LVd`aS, Z*jMD ÄąZjSy Z*O ]Sa Z*4S,*2 1WOjdYOTjVdZ* wYd/`SY VZq41YxD W\,\ `d+dE ]1`1VW*/1Z1 qV wVZq4nxE 2 bSbdW\Y T Y\31 b*V\3 \4Z*h*O

bS wg*`E ]`*,Sb1WnxD )V YS ,31 ]\+*hSO WSE TaZd2 ad]1`1hZTabn k\/\ h*ad ]`*,O WTZZq 1`T-WTaa*`* T y\-\ ]\]1`1/ZSV* Y1WnO *`/dV*D S YT- wg*` *,SW\O Z*xE 1WOjdYOTjVdZE ]`*,SbS YT3 gSYS /,\Y* g*`qYSH `\e1a\` D Ë™\-1`bT

,S4Z*,E k\ wg1 a,T/h1ZZq k\/\ g*`anV\^

WTZT^ 1`T-WTaa*`* Z1 Y\3Z* ,T/VS/*bSx (Nabonidus and Belshazzar—A Study of the Closing Events of the Neo-Babylonian Empire, by Raymond P. Dougherty, published 1929, page 61). 11. Astronomical Diaries and Related Texts From Babylonia, Volume V, edited by Hermann Hunger, published 2001, pages 2-3. 12. Journal of Cuneiform Studies, Volume 2, No. 4, 1948, “A Classification of the Babylonian Astronomical Tablets of the Seleucid Period,â€? by A. Sachs, pages 282283. 13. Astronomical Diaries and Related Texts From Babylonia, Volume V, page 391. 14. Mesopotamian Planetary AstronomyAstrology, by David Brown, published 2000, pages 164, 201-202. 15. Bibliotheca Orientalis, L N° 1/2, JanuariMaart, 1993, “The Astronomical Diaries as a Source for Achaemenid and Seleucid History,â€? by R. J. van der Spek, pages 94, 102. 16. Astronomical Diaries and Related Texts From Babylonia, Volume I, by Abraham J. Sachs, completed and edited by Hermann Hunger, published 1988, page 47. 17. Babylonian Eclipse Observations From 750 BC to 1 BC, by Peter J. Huber and Salvo De Meis, published 2004, page 186. Ë›-T/Z\ 4 b*+WShV\p VAT 8=9:E g1 4*b1YZ1ZZq ,T/+dW\aq 59 hSaW* b`1bn\-\ YTaqgq 4* ,*,SW\ZanVSY V*W1Z/*`1YD b31E YTO aqgn aTY*Zd ]\h*,aq 59 /ZqYS `*ZTj1D )Vk\ 4*b1YZ1ZZq ,T/+dW\aq 59 WS]Zq 9<< `\Vd /\ ZD 1D L4* pWT*ZanVSY V*W1ZO /*`1YME b\ ]1`jSy /1Zn aTY*Zd ]`SO ]*/*2 Z* 7> h1`,ZqN5 WS]Zq 9<< `\Vd /\ ZD 1D 1 \4Z*h*2E k\ ]\h*b\V ]1`j\-\ YTaqgq b\-\ `\Vd LZTa*ZdM ]`S]*/*, Z* 6N7 b`*,Zq L/,\Y* YTaqgqYS `*ZTj1MD TV gn\-\ 4*b1YZ1ZZq Y*, +S `\4]\h*O bSan 7N8 V,TbZqD /Z*V d :OYd `q/Vd b*+O WShVS VAT 8=9: 4*4Z*h*2bnaqE k\ ]TaWq /,*Z*/gqb\-\ L\ab*ZZn\-\M YTaqgq L*/O /*`dM ]\]1`1/Zn\-\ `\Vd +dW\ /\/*Z\ k1 \/SZ YTaqgnD L b*+WShgT Z*]Sa*Z\B w<Oy /1Zn YTaqgq XII6 b\+b\ b`SZ*/gqb\O -\ YTaqgq xMD \3 Z\,Sy `TV ]\h*,aq 6N7 b`*,ZqD b31E 9<< `TV /\ ZD 1D b\hZ\ ,T/O ]\,T/*2 /*bT 4*b1YZ1ZZqE ,V*4*ZTy Z* b*+WShgTD ¨ 18. Berichte uber die Verhandlungen der ¨ ¨ Konigl. Sachsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig (Reports Regarding the Discussions of the Royal Saxonian Society of Sciences at Leipzig); Volume 67; May 1, 1915; the article “Ein astronomischer Beobachtungstext aus dem 37. Jahre Nebukadnezars IIâ€? (An Astronomical Observer’s Text of the 37th Year Nebuchadnezzar II), by Paul V. Neugebauer and Ernst F. Weidner, pages 67-76.

gn\Yd /31`1WT 4-*/d2bnaq 57 \]SaT, `\4b*jd,*ZZq Taqgq k\/\ ]1,ZSf 4TO

`\V hS ad4T`G^,D *Y b*V\3 ]\/*2bnaq 59 \]SaT, ]\W\31ZZq ]W*Z1b (Pages 7276)D b\y h*a qV VWSZ\]SaZSy 4Z*VE k\ ]\4Z*h*2 TaqgnE hTbVSy b* \/Z\4Z*hZSyE /1qVT 4Z*VS /Wq TY1Z ]W*Z1b b* \]Sad

^fZn\-\ ]\W\31ZZq ,SVWSV*pbn adYZTO ,SD (Mesopotamian Planetary Astronomy —Astrology, by David Brown, published 2000, pages 53-57)D 1`14 g1 \]SaS ]\W\31ZZq ]W*Z1b b`*Vbdpbn ]\O`T4Z\O YdD \4b*jd,*ZZq Taqgq ,S4Z*hSbS Z1 aVW*/Z\D \b31E 4 /\aSbn ,Sa\V\p b\hO ZTabp Y\3Z* ,S4Z*hSbS T /*bd,*bS ]\W\O 31ZZq y TZjSf Z1+1aZSf bTWE 4-*/*ZSf d 4,Gq4Vd 4 Taqg1Y d VAT 8=9:D 18a. T h*a\,T ]`\YT3VS P g1 ,T/bSZO VS h*ad ,T/E aV*3TY\E 4*f\/d a\Zgq /\ 4*f\/d YTaqgq d ]1`jSy /1Zn V*W1ZO /*`Z\-\ YTaqgq T ]`\bq-\Y /,\f TZjSf ]1`T\/T, b\-\ 3 YTaqgqD h1ZT ]`S,GqO 4*WS gT ]`\YT3VS /\ V*W1Z/*`ZSf /*bD (“The Earliest Datable Observation of the Aurora Borealis,� by F. R. Stephenson and David M. Willis, in Under One Sky —Astronomy and Mathematics in the Ancient Near East, edited by John M. Steele and Annette Imhausen, published 2002, pages 420-428)D #\+ ,S4Z*hSbS h*O a\,T ]`\YT3VSE ab*`\/*,ZTY a]\ab1`TO -*h*Y ]\b`T+1Z +d, -\/SZZSVD ˛`\4dO

YTW\E k\ ^fZT ,SYT`S +dWS Z1b\hZSYSD (Archimedes, Volume 4, New Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science and Technology, “Observations and Predictions of Eclipse Times by Early Astronomers,� by John M. Steele, published 2000, pages 6566)D ˛ TZj\-\ +\VdE `\4b*jd,*ZZq TaqO gq k\/\ TZjSf Z1+1aZSf bTW ,SYT`p,*WS 4 +TWnj\p b\hZTabpD 19. Z*WT4 ]`\,1WS 4* /\]\Y\-\p V\YO

]Gpb1`Z\^ ]`\-`*YS TheSky67D `TY b\O -\E 4*,/qVS dZT,1`a*WnZTy +14V\jb\,ZTy ]`\-`*YT Cartes du Ciel/Sky Charts (CDC) T V\Z,1`b1`d /*bE Z*/*Z\Yd TyanV\,\O Y\`anV\p \+a1`,*b\`T2p " E ,h1ZT 4Y\-WS 4`\+SbS +TWnj `\4jS`1ZSy *Z*O WT4D aVTWnVS VWSZ\]SaZT 4Z*VS /Wq \]SO ad ]\W\31ZZq ]W*Z1b Y\3Z* b`*Vbd,*bS ]\O`T4Z\YdE /*Zd TZe\`Y*gTp Z1 ]T//*O ,*WS V\Y]Gpb1`Z\Yd *Z*WT4dE Y1b* qV\O -\ P ,S4Z*hSbS `TVE V\WS ,T/+d,*WSan gT *ab`\Z\YThZT q,Sk*D ¨ 20. Berichte uber die Verhandlungen der ¨ ¨ Konigl. Sachsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig (Reports Regarding the Discussions of the Royal Saxonian Society of Sciences at Leipzig); Volume 67; May 1, 1915; “Ein astronomischer Beobachtungstext aus dem 37. Jahre Nebukadnezars II, (-567/66)â€? (An Astronomical Observer’s Text of the 37th Year Nebuchadnezzar II), by Paul V. Neugebauer and Ernst F. Weidner, page 41. 65D b`1bn\Yd `q/Vd VAT 8=9: Z*]Sa*O Z\B w Taqgn ab\q, 5 WTV\bn 6 -`*/dO aS ]1`1/ Ă&#x; Ë™T,SxD Sk14-*/*ZSy *Z*WT4 ]\V*4*,E k\ =O-\ ZTa*Z* Taqgn ab\q, 6{>81 ]1`1/ 4T`V\p Ă&#x; Ë™T,S T >{ ZS3h1 ,T/

Z1^D b31E \]Sa d b*+WShgT 2 b\hZSYD

ı ˛ ( & S ]\,SZZT +*bnVS Z*,h*bS a,\^f /Tb1y ]`\ a1VaH ˇ *-*b\ +*bnVT, /\VW*/*pbn daTf 4daSWnE

*+S 4*fSabSbS a,\^f /Tb1y ,T/ Z1+14]1hZSf 4*f,\`p,*ZnD *bnV*Y b*V\3 ]\b`T+Z\ 4*O fSk*bS /Tb1y ,T/ Y\`*WnZ\-\ 4T]adbbqD ˙Wq gn\-\ Z1\+fT/Z\ /*,*bS /TbqY 4`T,Z\,*31O Z1 ab*b1,1 ,Sf\,*ZZq L `S]\,Tab1y 9B7P67MD *V1 +*bnVT,anV1 ,Sf\,*ZZq b* ]\`*/S k\/\ Y\`*WT /d31 ,*3WS,TE b\Yd k\ /TbS /1/*WT h*abTj1 abSV*pbnaq 4 Y*b1`T*W*YS ,T/,1`b\ a1Vad*WnZ\-\ f*`*Vb1`d Z* b1W1+*h1ZZTE , ıZO b1`Z1bTE d VZS3V*f T V\YTVa*fD ˙*2Z* 1,TZE ]`\e1a\`V* \a,TbS y *,b\`O V* Z*dV\,Sf ]`*gnE ]\qaZp2B w `\+W1Y* Z1 , b\YdE k\ Z*jSf /Tb1y Z*,h*pbn ]`\ a1VaE

* , b\YdE h\-\ ^f Z*,h*pbnE , qV\Yd ,TgT T fb\ g1 `\+SbnD ˙TbS \b`SYdpbn /d31 *-`1aS,Zd T `dyZT,Zd TZe\`Y*gTp ]`\ a1Va ,T/ e*fT,gT, 4 Y*`V1bSZ-d b* ,T/ Y*aVdWnbd`SxD

*bnV*Y ]\b`T+Z\ 4*fSk*bS a,\^f /Tb1y ,T/ a]\b,\`1ZSf b* *Y\`*WnZSf ]\-Wq/T,E qVT ]adO pbn Z*j1 ada]TWnab,\ L `S]\,Tab1y 9B5C ˚e1O

aqZ :B8MD ˙TbS Y*pbn 4Z*bSE qV edZVgT\Zd2 ^fO Z2 bTW\E qV ]TVWd,*bSan ]`\ ,W*aZd -T-T2Zd T qV 4*fSk*bSan ,T/ Y\`*WnZ\ 4T]a\,*ZSf WpO /1yD ˙\ ]\h*bVd ]1`T\/d ab*b1,\-\ /\4`T,*ZO Zq /\hV* ]\,SZZ* 4Z*bS ]`\ b1E qVT 4YTZS ,T/O

+d/dbnaq , ^^ bTWTE b* `\4dYTbSE h\Yd T qV ,T/+d,*2bnaq Y1Zab`d*gTqD \/T+Z\ fW\]1gn Y*2 4*4/*W1-T/n 4Z*bS ]`\ ]\WpgTp LYSY\O

,TWnZ1 ,SbTV*ZZq aTYGq , \aT+ h\W\,Th\^ ab*O

bT ]T/ h*a aZdMD \WS /TbS k1 Y*WTE +*bnV*Y

,*`b\ ,hSbS ^fE qV ]`*,SWnZ\ Z*4S,*pbnaq ab*b1,T \`-*ZSD ˙+*yWS,T +*bnVS Z*,h*pbn /Tb1yE k\ gT h*abSZS bTW* 2 5M \a\+WS,SYSE 6M ]`\ ZSf Z1 Y\3Z* -\,\`SbS 4Z1,*3WS,\

T 7M ^fE 4*4,Sh*yE Z1 Y\3Z* ZTV\Yd ]\V*4d,*O bS y ZTfb\ Z1 Y*2 ]`*,* /\ ZSf b\`V*bSaqD YT`d b\-\ qV /TbS ]T/`\ab*bSYdbnE +*bnVS a*YT ]\,SZZT ,S`TjSbSE V\WS `\4]\,T/*bS /TO bqY ]`\ b1E qV 3TZV* ab*2 ,*-TbZ\p1D \WS +*bnVS Y*pbn ]\hSZ*bS b*V1 Z*,h*ZO ZqH *+*-*b\ `*ZTj1E ZT3 ,S /dY*2b1D ˙T,O hSZV* Y\31 Y*bS ]1`jd Y1Zab`d*gTp d ,TgT 5> `\VT, *+\ Z*,Tbn `*ZTj1D fW\]gq Y\O 31 ,T/+dbSan ]1`j* ]\WpgTq d ,TgT 55 *+\ 56 `\VT,D *VT eT4T\W\-ThZT 4YTZS Z1`T/V\ /dO 31 +1Zb13*bn /SbSZdE qVk\ ,\Z* Z1 `\4dO YT2E k\ 4 Z1p ,T/+d,*2bnaqD ˙TbqY b`1+* V*4*bSE k\ , gn\Yd Z1Y*2 ZTh\-\ ]\-*Z\-\D

`TY b\-\E ^Y b`1+* /\]\Y\-bS 4`\4dYTbS gTZO

ZTabn T ,*3WS,Tabn Y\`*WnZSf Z\`Y 4 T+WT^E ]`\ qVT +TWnjTabn a,TbanVSf ]`\-`*Y 4T ab*O b1,\-\ ,Sf\,*ZZq Z1 4-*/dpbn L `S]\,Tab1y :B6;P79MD 1 *bnVS Y\3dbn 4Z*ybS ]`*VbShZT ]\`*/S Z* gp b1Yd , ]d+WTV*gTqf ,T/VT, -\,SB 3d`Z*W w `\+d/SanIx 4* b`*O ,1Zn 6>>: `\VdE ab*bbq w \WS ,*j* /\Z1hV* ab*2 /T,hSO Z\pxE ab\`D 5>P57C VZS3V* w˛*]Sb*ZZq Y\W\/Sf Wp/1yD `*VbShZT ]\`*/SxE b\Y IIE `\4/D :E w#\ 4T YZ\p ,T/+d,*O 2bnaqHxC 3d`Z*W w *`b\,* +*jb*x 4* 5 WSab\]*/* 6>5>

`\VdE w 1V`1bS k*aWS,\^ aTYG^D +-\,\`pyb1 4T a,\^YS /TbnO YS ]Sb*ZZq a1VadxE ab\`D 56P58D

6=

˙ ) ( ı

`qb\,*ZT 4 \-Z1ZZ\^ ]1hT ˛Z*y/S a]\VTyZ1 YTag1 T ]`S/TWS /\ab*bZn\ h*ad /Wq ,SV\Z*ZZq gSf 4*,/*ZnD \WS hSb*bSY1j +T+WTyZSy d`S,\VE dq,Wqy a1+1 dh*aZSV\Y ]\/TyD *Y*-*yaq ]\hdbS 4,dVS y -\W\aS b* ]\+*hSbS b1E k\ ,T/+d,*O 2bnaqD `\yY*yaq ]\hdbbqYS ]1`a\Z*3T,D 1f*y +T+WTyZ* \]\,T/n ab*Z1 /Wq b1+1 `1*WnZ\pD h*aZSVS ]\/TyB "*/`*fE 1j*fE ,1/O 1š\ b* *,df\/\Z\a\`D \`\bVSy \-Wq/B T`* b`n\f 2,`1yanVSf fW\]gT, ,S]`\+\,d2bnaqD

–

• ı ı˛ • ˙ ı 7B5P7>

)VT 4,dVS bS whd2jxE hSb*phS ,T`jT 7P;H

)V bS dq,Wq2j a\+T ,S-Wq/ \-Z1ZZ\^ ]1hTH

)VT ]\hdbbq bS ,W\,Wp2j d -\W\aT *,df\/\Z\a\`*E V\WS ,TZ Z*V*4d2 Z*]*O WSbS ]Th da1Y1`\ +TWnj1E ZT3 4*4,Sh*yH L `\hSb*y ,T`jT 5= T 6>M

)V bS dq,Wq2j a\+T ,S-Wq/ h1b,1`b\-\ h\W\,TV* , ]1hTH L `\hSb*y ,T`jT 68 T 69M

)VT `SaS ]\YTh*2j d "*/`*f\,TE 1j*f\,T b* ,1/O 1š\E V\WS ,\ZS 4,1`O b*pbnaq /\ *,df\/\Z\a\`* L,T`jT 5:P5<MH

—

ı • "˚

\jdV*y /\/*bV\,d TZe\`Y*gTp ]`\ `\4YT`S WTVbq T a]`\+dy ]\`*fd,*bSE

qV\^ ,Sa\bS +d, +\,,*ZE 4`\+W1ZSy *,df\/\Z\a\`\YD L `\hSb*y k1 `*4 ,T`j 5M

\`T,Zqy ,T`jT 5=E 6> 4 ,T`j*YS 6<E 6= T aV*3SE qV\p Wp/SZ\pE Z*]1,Z1E +d, *,df\/\Z\a\`H

7> "

˙ 5 ˙ 6>55

˜

˙ ) ˚ ˚D ˛ " E # ˙ı˛ ) DDD

b1E qV ,Sq,WqbS ]\j*Zd /\ Wp/1yE Z*/TW1ZSf ,W*/\p

,*3WS,Tabn 4*fSk*bS a,\^ ,T`d,*ZZq

b1E qV -\,* ]T/b`SYd2 4* h*ad ,S]`\+d,*Zn

) ˚ & ) ˚ ˚H

˛* qVSf \+ab*,SZ Y\31 +dbS ,S]`\+d,*Z* b,\q ,T`*H

)V `\4]\,T/n ]`\ "*/`*f*E 1j*f* b* ,1/O 1š\ /\]\Y*-*2 b\+T 4*WSj*bSaq ,T`O ZSYH

# ı• ˛ ı˙ı ˛ ˚ ˚

• ı &"˚ ı H

) #

˚ "

ı ııE

ıı ı˙ ı • • ı

www.watchtower.org °

™

S ,,*3*2bnaq -`Tf\Y a1Va ]\ b1W1e\ZdE a1VabSZ- b* VT+1`a1VaH ı ;

#\ \4Z*h*2 +dbS /df\,Z\p Wp/SZ\pH

ı 57E 58

)V \3T 4*V\ZS a]`Sqpbn Z*j\Yd 4/\`\,GpH

ı 5:

)V +*bnV\ Y\31 /\]\Y\-bS aSZ\,T `\4,S,*bS a*Y\]\,*-dH ı 6>

S +*bnV*Y b`1+* Z*,h*bS /Tb1y ]`\ a1VaH

ı 6=

S ,S f\bTWS +E k\+ ,*a ,T/,T/*WSH *,Tbn d gn\Yd Z1a]\VTyZ\Yd a,TbT ,S Y\31b1 ab*bS k*aWS,SYSE Z*+d,*phS b\hZ\-\ +T+WTyZ\-\ 4Z*ZZq ]`\ \-*E y\-\ *`ab,\ y hd/\,d Y1bd k\/\ Wp/ab,*D )Vk\ ,S +*3*2b1 \b`SY*bS +TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ k\+ ,*a fb\an ,T/,T/d,*, T ]`\,\/S, 4 ,*YS +14]W*bZ1 +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqE ]`\aSY\ ]Sa*bS /\ ,T/VT, -\,S Z* */`1O adB 1Zb` ,T/VT, -\,SE *Na =99E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE ;=8=5E *+\ Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/]\,T/ZSf */`1aE k\ Z* ab\`TZgT 8D www.watchtower.org

wp11 11/01-K

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.