wp_K_20111201

34567 5 ˙ ) 6>55

bSfTyZT WSf* ˚

ı˙

H

34567

S ` * 3 B 8 6 5: 6 > > > S/*2bnaq 5<< Y\,*YS

DECEMBER 1, 2011

˚ w ı " x ]\Wq-*2 , b\YdE k\+ ]`\aW*,WqbS \-* -\,d qV 1`f\,Z\-\ `*,Sb1Wq a1a,TbdD \/T+Z\ qV 4 ,*`b\,Sf +*jb d /*,ZSZd +dW\ /\+`1 ,S/Z\E k\ ,T/+d,*2bnaq ,/*W1hSZTE Z* ab\`TZV*f gn\-\ 3d`Z*Wd ]`\ab13d2bnaq `\4,Sb\V a,Tb\,Sf ]\/Ty d a,TbWT +T+WTyZSf ]`\`\gb,D w *`b\,* +*jb*x ]\bTj*2 Wp/1y /\+`\p Z\,SZ\p ]`\ b1E k\ \31 *`ab,\ P ,ab*Z\,W1ZSy d Z1+T d`q/ P Z14*+*`\Y ]\VW*/1 V`*y dan\Yd 4Wd T ]1`1YTZSbn 41YWp Z*

`*yD *a\]Sa 4YTgZp2 ,T`d , ıada* `Sab*E qVSy ]\Y1`E k\+ YS Y\-WS \b`SY*bS ,ThZ1 3SbbqE T qVSy b1]1` ab\^bn Z* h\WT \3\-\ *`ab,*D ,T/VS -\,S +14]1`1`,Z\ ,S/*pbn g1y 3d`Z*W 4 5<;= `\VdD TZ 2 ]\WTbShZ\ Z1yb`*WnZSY

T š`dZbd2bnaq Z* T+WT^D

1 /Wq ]`\/*3dD S/*ZZq gT2^ ]d+WTV*gT^ 2 h*abSZ\p ,a1a,TbZn\^ ]`\-`*YS +T+WTyZ\^ \a,TbSE qV* ]T/b`SYd2bnaq /\+`\,TWnZSYS ]\31`b,*YSD `S gSbd,*ZZT ,`1yanVSf Sa*Zn ,SV\`Sab\,d2bnaq ]1`1VW*/ -T2ZV* L,S/*ZZq 6>>6 `\VdE ZdY1`*gTq a*WYT, 4-T/Z\ 4 ,S/*ZZqY 5==> `\VdME * `SabSqZanVSf `1gnVSf Sa*Zn P w 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,TbdxD ıZjT /31`1W* gSb*bB dWDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ dWTj*C P w 1`1VW*/ Z\,\-\ a,Tbd ,qb\-\ SanY*x L4 ]`SYTbV*YSE *Z-WDMC \YDP ,qb1 SanY\E ]1`1VW*/ \Y1ZV*D

ı ı 7 S \- Z*aSW*2 Z* Wp/1y V*`SH 8 \Yd b*V +*-*b\ abSfTyZSf WSfH : )V a1+1 4*fSabSbSH < \WS abSfTyZSf WSf d31 Z1 +d/1

5> 58

Sb*hT 4*]Sbdpbn

Sab 4 \`,1-T^

5:

\-\ ,hSbn \31 W\,\D )V 4Z*ybS f\`\jSf /`d4T,H

66

S ,S 4Z*2b1H

6:

*+WS3*yY\an /\ \-*D w ,qbE a,qbE a,qb \a]\/nx

*,h*yb1 a,\^f /Tb1yD

ıf Z*4S,*WS waSZ*YS -`\Ydx

7>

˝ ˚ ı 55

b\ Y\31 bWdY*hSbS ]`\`\gb,*H

5<

Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\`* T \31 TYGq

67 w *a V\f*bS T h*a Z1Z*,S/TbSx

6; ) f\bTW* +dbSE qV ıeb*f\,* /\hV*

Z*aSW*2 Z* Wp/1y V*`SH

w 1ZT /d31 jV\/* 31`b, gT2^ V*b*ab`\eSE *W1E 4/*2bnaqE b\ +dW\ b1Y+*gd L]\V*`*ZZq ,T/ \-*MxEP b*V ,SaW\,S,aq ,T/\YSy q]\ZanVSy ]\WTbSV ]TaWq b\-\E qV d +1`14ZT 6>55 `\Vd )]\ZTq ]\ab`*3/*W* ,T/ =O+*WnZ\-\ 41YW1b`dad T gdZ*YTD \WS , aThZT 6>5> `\Vd ]\Z*/ 66> >>> Wp/1y 4*-SZdW\ ,T/ 41YW1b`dad

, *^bTE 4Z*ZSy b1W1]`\]\,T/ZSV 4*q,S,E k\ g1 ab*W\aq h1`14 b1E k\ -*^bqZS wdVW*WS d-\/d 4 Z1hSab\p aSW\px T Z1 w]\,1`ZdWSan /\ ,T`SxD w \- f\h1 `\4+d/SbS Z*j1 ]`Sa]*Z1 T 4+*y/d3TW1 adYWTZZqxEP aV*4*, V*b\WSgnVSy a,qk1ZSVE V\WS , bSaZq,TE k\ ab*W*aq d ab\WSgT TWT]]TZE *ZTWTE

4*-SZdW\ ;= \aT+D Ë&#x203A;* ]\,T/\YW1ZZqY YTag1,\^ -*41bSE w65 ,T/a\b\V /\`\aWSf ,,*3*pbnE k\ \- ,SWS,*2 a,Ty -ZT,E Z*aSW*phS 4ad,S Å¡`dZbdE b*yedZS y TZjT

WSf*xE V\b`T h*ab\ ,`*3*pbn V`*^ZdD ]`\ b1E k\ \- a]`\,*O /3d2 WSf*E *+S ]\V*`*bS ]\-*O ZSf Wp/1yE Z1 Z\,*D Ta*+\ZT 5;99 `\Vd ab*,aq 41YW1b`daE qVSy a]`ShSO ZS, ,1WSVd ]\313d T gdZ*YT b* 4*O +`*, 3Sbbq ]`S+WS4Z\ :> >>> Wp/1yD

Ë&#x203A;-*/dphS ]`\ bT ]\/T^E ,T/\YSy eTW\O a\e \Wnb1` 4*]Sb*,B w S 4Z*y/1O Z\ +dW\ ]\`\Vd +TWnj1 , Ta*+\ZTE *ZT3 d fbS,\Yd *`S3T P d gn\O Yd +14a\`\YZ\Yd ]`Sb\ZTHx *-*b\ fb\ 4*/dYd2bnaqE hS a]`*,/T \- ,SO V\`Sab\,d2 ]`S`\/ZT V*b*VWT4YS /Wq ]\V*`*ZZq Wp/1yD `T4ZSf h*abSO Z*f a,Tbd Wp/S Z*4S,*pbn b*VT WSf* w \3\p V*`\pxD Ë&#x203A; \-Wq/d Z* ,a1 g1 ,SZSV*2 4*O ]Sb*ZZqB w S \- /TyaZ\ ]\aSW*2 abSfTyZT WSf*E k\+ V*`*bS Wp/1yH

S V*b*ab`\eS 2 \4Z*V\p \3\-\ -ZT,dHx Ë&#x2122;1fb\ +14/dYZ\ 4,SZd,*hd2 \O -*E Z*,\/qhS +T+WTyZT `\4]\,T/T ]`\ b1E qV \- V*`*, -`TjZSVT, 4* /\]\O Y\-\p aSW ]`S`\/S L dbbq ;B5;P66C

Ë&#x2122;

5<B6>C 5=B68E 69C SaW* 5:B75P79MD /O Z*VE d,*3Z\ `\4-WqZd,jS bT `\4]\O ,T/TE 4,1`ZTY\ d,*-d Z* b`S ,*3WSO ,T e*VbSD \O]1`j1E V\3Z\-\ `*4d ]1`1/ ]\V*`*ZZqY \- /*,*, ]\]1O `1/31ZZqD \O/`d-1E Z* ,T/YTZd ,T/ ZSZTjZTf abSfTyZSf WSfE qVT ]\4+*,O Wqpbn 3Sbbq T /\+`SfE T ]\-*ZSfE 4ZSk1ZZq ,T/ \-* +dW\ ,S+T`V\,SYD \- V*`*, bTWnVS 4*]1VWSf -`TjZSO VT, T bSfE fb\ ,T/VS/*, y\-\ ]\]1`1O /31ZZqD \Ob`1b2E ]T/ h*a ]\V*`*ZZq \- 4*,3/S /*,*, Z*-\/d ,`qbd,*O bSan Z1,SZZSY Wp/qY L dbbq ;B5E 67C 5=B59P5;C SaW* 5:B67P6;MD SZT +14WTh V*b*ab`\e `dyZd2 3SbO bq YTWny\Z*Y Wp/1yD W1 Z1Y*2 3\/O Z\-\ /\V*4dE k\ g1 /TW\ \3Sf `dVD

\Yd 3 b\/T 3*fWS,T WSf* b`*]O Wqpbnaq /1/*WT h*abTj1H )V /*,*O bS a\+T `*/d 4* b*VSf \+ab*,SZH S Z*ab*Z1 h*aE V\WS ,31 Z1 +d/1 ]`SO `\/ZSf V*b*VWT4YT,H T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZq ,S 4Z*y/1b1 d Z*abd]ZSf ab*bbqfD

" Ë&#x2122; 5 Ë&#x2122; ) 6>55

7

\Yd b*V +*-*b\ Äąâ&#x20AC;˘ H

Ë&#x203A; Y*a\,\^ TZe\`Y*gT^ /1/*O WT h*abTj1 ]\,T/\YWqpbn ]`\ `T4ZT abSfTyZT WSf*D Ë&#x203A;`\ab*2 VTWnVTabn 31`b,D

Ë&#x203A;-T/Z\ 4 ]\,T/\YW1ZZqY \/Z\^ Z*dV\O

,\^ dab*Z\,SE WSj1 6>5> `\Vd ,T/+dW\an 7;7 V*b*ab`\eSE , qVSf 4*-SZdW\ 6=: >>> Wp/1yD Ë&#x203A;* \ab*ZZT /1aqbSWTbbq ]\YTbZ\ 4`\aW\ hSaW\ V*b*ab`\eD `SYT`\YE ,T/ 5=;9 /\ 5=== `\Vd k\`ThZ\ ,T/+d,*W\aq Y*y31 7>> abSfTyZSf WSfD ,bTYE 4 6>>> /\ 6>5> g1 hSaW\ ,31 ab*Z\,SW\ 8>>D 1Y*W\ WpO /1y 4*]Sbd2B w \Yd a*Y1 b1]1` ab*2bnO aq b*V +*-*b\ V*b*VWT4YT,Hx p/S h*ab\ Z*4S,*pbn b*VT Z1k*abq w \3\p V*`\pxE *W1 g1 4\,aTY Z1 b*VD \- Z1 Y*2 ZTh\-\ a]TWnZ\-\ 4 WSf*YSE ,T/ qVSf ]\b1`]*2 abTWnVS Wp/1yD `\O

b1 , T+WT^ ]1`1/`TV*W\aqE k\ 4* Z*j\O -\ h*ad ,T/+d,*bSYdbnaq abSfTyZT WSf*D *]`SVW*/E d *b,Tq 68B;E < 4*]Sa*ZT b*VT aW\,* Äąada*B w \/Z\Yd YTagT 4* TZO

34567

S ,S f\bTWS + \b`SY*bS +TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ k\+ 4 ,*YS ]`\,\/SW\aq +14V\jb\,Z1 /\Y*jZ2 +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqH `\aSY\ Z*/TaW*bS a,\2 ]`\O f*ZZq ,T/V*Y -\,S Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/]\,T/ZSf */`1aE ]\/*ZSf ZS3h1D \,ZSy ]1`1WTV */`1a /S,Tbnaq Z* a*ybT www.watchtower.org/addressD

8

jSY +d/1 -\W\/ T ,T/+d,*bSYdbnaq 41YO W1b`daSD a1 g1 WSj1 ]\h*b\V Z1ab1`]O

ZSf YdVxD \Yd Äąada ]1`1/`TV gT ]\/T^ T qV1 4Z*h1ZZq ,\ZS Y*pbn /Wq Z*aH Sk14-*/*ZT aW\,* Äąada* +dWS ,T/]\O ,T//p Z* ]\ab*,W1Z1 y\Yd 4*]Sb*ZZqB wË&#x203A;* qV\p \4Z*V\p Y\3Z* +d/1 ]\+*hSO

bSDDD 4*VTZh1ZZq gT2^ aSab1YSHx L *b,Tq 68B7MD TZ ]\qaZS,E k\ ,T/+d,*bSYdbnaq

`T4ZT ]\/T^E a1`1/ qVSf b*V\3 abSfTyZT WSf*D T/b*V Äąada aV*4*, ,*3WS,T aW\,*B w \WS ]\+*hSb1E k\ ,a1 g1 ,T/+d,*2bnO aqE 4Z*yb1B g*`ab,\ \31 +WS4nV\x L dO

VS 65B75MD T ]\/T^ Y*pbn /Wq Z*a Z1*+SO qV1 4Z*h1ZZqE */31 ,\ZS ,V*4dpbn Z* ,1WSVT 4YTZSE qVT ,31 Z1 4* -\`*YSD b\ ,SZ1Z d abSfTyZSf WSf*f *-*b\ fb\ 4*]Sbd2B w)Vk\ Z1 \- ]\O aSW*2 abSfTyZT WSf* Z* Wp/1yE b\/T fb\ *+\ k\Hx T/]\,TabS Z* g1 4*]Sb*ZZq /\]\Y\31 \/Z* ,*3WS,* +T+WTyZ* TabSO

`-1ZbSZ*B Casilla 83 (Suc 27B), C1427WAB Cdad. Aut. de Buenos Aires.

TW\`danB 66>>7>E SZaVE *Nq =D 1WSV\+`Sb*ZTqB

The Ridgeway, London NW7 1RN. Äą4`*^WnB PO Box 29345, ´ 61293 Tel Aviv. Äąa]*ZTqB Apartado 132, 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz (Madrid). Äąb*WTqB Via della Bufalotta 1281, I-00138 Rome RM. *Z*/*B PO Box 4100, Georgetown, ON L7G 4Y4. \W/\,*E Ë&#x2DC; 1a]d+WTV*B PO Box 472, MD-2005 Chi ¸sinau. TY1hhSZ*B 65617 Selters. \Wnk*B ulD Warszawska 58E >9O<7> NadarzynD \`bd-*WTqB Apartado 91, P-2766-955 Estoril. \aTqB 5=;;7=E *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-E ]D \WZ1hZ\1E dWD `1/ZqqE :D W\,*hhSZ*B PO Box 2, 830 04 Bratislava 34. " B 25 Columbia Heights,

Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. V`*^Z*B *Na =99E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE ;=8=5D `*ZgTqB BP 625, F-27406 Louviers Cedex.

The Watchtower (ISSN 0043-1087) is published semimonthly by Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York, Inc.; M. H. Larson, President; G. F. Simonis, Secretary-Treasurer; 25 Columbia Heights, Brooklyn, NY 11201-2483. Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm Bibel- und Traktat-Gesellschaft der Zeugen Jehovas, e. V.E Selters/Taunus. Verantwortliche Redaktion: Ramon Templeton, Selters/Taunus. Ë&#x2DC; 2011 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. aT ]`*,* 4+1`T-*pbnaqD Printed in Germany.

Vol. 132, No. 23

Semimonthly

UKRAINIAN

Left: Ë&#x2DC; Mark Henley/Panos Pictures Middle: Ë&#x2DC; Jeroen Oerlemans/Panos Pictures

Z*B w 1an a,Tb W13Sbn d ,W*/T Ë&#x203A;W\-\x L5 Äą,*Z* 9B5=MD T aW\,* ,Sq,WqpbnE k\ ]`ShSZ\p ab`*3/*Zn d a,TbT 2 Z1 \-E * , +*-*bn\f ,S]*/V*f y\-\ ,\`\- P Ë&#x203A;WSyE b\+b\ Ë&#x2122;Sq,\W L +Gq,W1ZZq 56B=E 56MD 1y a*Y\Wp+ZSy ,\`\- \-* ,,*3*2 Wp/1y 4* ZTk\D aVTWnVS ,TZ V\Zb`\Wp2 ,1an a,TbE b\ ,ap/S ]\jS`p2 /df a*Y\O Wp+ab,*D T+WTq ]T/b,1`/3d2 g1E V*3dO hSE k\ w, \ab*ZZT /ZTDDD Wp/S +d/dbn a*Y\Wp+ZTE -`\j\Wp+ZTE h,*ZWS,TE ]SO f*bTx L6 SY\eTq 7B5E 6MD \3 Z1 /S,Z\E h\Yd Ë&#x2122;Sq,\W ae\`Yd,*, a,Tb\,Sy dabO `TyE , qV\Yd ]1`1,*3*pbn gT b* TZjT `SaSD *b*Z* ]T/jb\,fd2 Wp/1y /\ a*O Y\Wp+ab,* T ]\3*/WS,\-\ ,SV\`Sab*ZZq ]`S`\/ZSf `1ad`aT,E k\ Z1`T/V\ ,1/1 /\ 4-d+ZSf Z*aWT/VT,D )V g1y ]\3*/WS,Sy a,Tb ]`S4,\/Sbn /\ `\abd VTWnV\abT abSfTyZSf WSfH \/O Z\Yd 4,TbT

]`\ -W\+*WnZT V*b*VWT4O YS 4*4Z*h*W\aqB w p/S /d31 h*ab\ a1O Wqbnaq , b*VSf ]\b1ZgTyZ\ Z1+14]1hZSf YTagqfE qV 4*]W*,S `TVD `TY b\-\E h1`14 4ZSk1ZZq WTaT, b* \adj1ZZq +\WTb ]\O `djd2bnaq 4/*bZTabn ]`S`\/S 4*]\+T-*O bS abSfTyZSY WSf*YD *y+TWnjd 4*-`\O 4d Z1a1 T4 a\+\p 4YTZ* VWTY*bd 41YWT b* ]T/,Sk1ZZq `T,Zq a,Tb\,\-\ \V1*O ZdE ,SVWSV*ZT 4+TWnj1ZZqY V\Zg1Zb`*O

Ë&#x161; Ë&#x161; Ë&#x161; Ë&#x161; )

gT^ ]*`ZSV\,Sf -*4T,DDD h1`14 Wp/anVd /TqWnZTabnxD *V* /TqWnZTabn a]`qY\,*O Z* ZT+Sb\ Z* 1V\Z\YThZSy ]`\-`1aE *W1

Z*a]`*,/T , ^^ \aZ\,T W13Sbn 1-\^4Y b* ]\3*/WS,TabnE qVSYS ]`\aqVZdbSy g1y a,TbD *-*b\ e*fT,gT, ,S4Z*pbnE k\ `dyO ZT,Z* aSW* abSfTyZSf WSf 4+TWnjd2bnaq h1`14 Z1V\Zb`\Wn\,*Zd Wp/anVd /TqWnO ZTabnD *V Wp/S -`*pbn Z* `dVd Ë&#x2122;Sq,\O W\,TD Ë&#x203A;`\4dYTW\E hSY*W\ abSfTyZSf WSf 4dO Y\,W1ZT Wp/anV\p Z1/+*WTabpD Ë&#x2122;1qVT V*b*ab`\eS Z1 ]`SZ1aWS + abTWnVS `dyO Zd,*ZnE qV+S ,T/+dWSan /1TZ/1D +*O

-*bn\f V`*^Z*f Z*aWT/VS ]`S`\/ZSf V*O b*VWT4YT, +dWS 4Z*hZ\ ,*3hSYS h1`14

4W\hSZZT /T^ +14]`SZgS]ZSf \aT+D ÄąZj\p ]`ShSZ\p 2 b1E k\ +14WTh Wp/1y h1`14 1V\Z\YThZd T a\gT*WnZd Z1`T,ZTabn 4YdO j1ZT 3SbS , Z1+14]1hZSf YTag1,\abqfD Ë&#x203A;,Sh*yZ\E /1fb\ ]\b1`]*2 ,T/ abSfTyZSf WSf Z1 b\YdE k\ fb\an ]\YSWS,aq hS ,SO q,S, Z1/+*WTabnE * b\Yd k\ wh*a T ,S]*O /\V ]*Zdpbn Z*/ daTY*x LË&#x161;VVW14Tqab* =B55E \aV*W1ZV\MD `ShSZS abSfTyZSf WSf Y\3dbn +dbS `T4ZSYSD k\ `\+SbSE V\WS ,S ab*WS 31`b,\p b*V\-\ WSf*H \4-WqZnY\ VTWnO V* ]`*VbShZSf ]\`*/D

Ë&#x203A; #Ë&#x161; ) Äą Äą

Ë&#x2122; & ) 5<< B *41`+*y/3*ZanV*E *41`O +*y/3*ZanV* LVS`SWShZ1 ]SanY\ME *yY*`*E *W+*ZanO V*E *Yf*`anV*E *Z-WTyanV*687 Lb*V\3 j`Seb\Y `*yWqME *`*+anV*E *e`SV*ZaE *h\WTE +*dW1E +1Y+*E +1Z-*WnanO V*E +TV\WnanV*E +T`Y*ZanV*E +TaW*Y*E +\W-*`anV*E ,*WO WTaTyanV*E ,*`*yO,*`*yE ,1Z/*E ,G2bZ*YanV*E ,T`Y1ZO

anV*E ,T`Y1ZanV* L4*fT/Z*ME -*E -*^bqZanV* V`1\WnanV*E -*ZE -TW+1`banV*E -TZ/TE -`1ZW*Z/anV*E -`1gnV*E -`d4SZO anV*E -d*`*ZTE -d/3*`*bTE /*banV*7E 1,1E 1ab\ZanV*E 1eTVE 2,`1yanV* LT,`SbME 4*Z/1E 4dWdE T+\E TW\V*ZanV*E TZ/\O Z14TyanV*E TaW*Z/anV*E Ta\V\E Ta]*ZanV*687E Tb*WTyanV*67E â&#x20AC;š y\`d+*E V*4*fanV*E V*Z*/*E V*\Z/1E V1hd*E V1hd* L ZO V*jME V1hd* L qVdh\ME V1hd* L \WT,TqME V1hd* L daV\ME VS`-S4nV*E VSb*yanV*7 L*d/T\4*]Sa bTWnVS Y*Z/*`SZO

anV\p Y\,\pME VSb*yanV* La]`\k1Z1 ]SanY\ME VTVdypE VTZnq`d*Z/*E VT`dZ/TE V\Z-\E V\Z-\ LV\WSjZq Y\Z\VdbdO +*ME V\`1yanV*67E V\a*E Vd*Z-*WTE Vd*ZnqY*E VfY1`anV*E W*bSanV*E WSb\,anV*E W\4TE Wd+*E Wd,*W1E Wd-*Z/*E WdZO /*E Wd\E Y*,`SVTyanV* V`1\WnanV*E Y*yqE Y*V1/\ZanV*E Y*W*-*aTyanV*E Y*W*qW*YE Y*WnbTyanV*E Y*`*bfTE Y*`O j*WWnanV*E Y+dZ/dE YT4\E YTf1E Y\`1E Z-*W*E Z/1+1W1E Z/\Z-*E Z1]*WnanV*E Z41Y*E ZT/1`W*Z/anV*67E ZTY1gnO V*67E ZTd1E Z\`,14nV*67E ZnqZ1V*E \`\Y\E \a1bSZanV*E \b1b1W*E ]*W*dE ]*Z-*aSZ*ZanV*E ]*]GqY1Zbd L p`*a*\ME ]1/TE ]1Z/3*+anV*E ]1`anV*E ]T/3SZ \W\Y\Z\,Sf \abO `\,T,E ]\WnanV*67E ]\Z*]1E ]\`bd-*WnanV*687E `*`\b\Z-*E `\aTyanV*67E `dYdZanV*E a*Y\*E a*Z-\E a*]\b1V LÄąabYdaME a,*4TE a1+d*ZanV*E a1yj1WnanV* V`1\WnanV*E a1`+anV*E

Ë&#x203A; Ë&#x2122; Ë&#x161; )

a1`+anV* LW*bSZanV1 ]SanY\ME a1adb\E aSZ-*WnanV*E aW\O ,*gnV*E aW\,1ZanV*E a`*Z*ZOb\Z-\E ad*fTWTE b*-*WnanO

V*7E b*^bqZanV*E b*yanV*E b*YTWnanV*E b*b*`anV*E b,TE b1O Wd-dE b1bdYE bS,E bS-`SZnqE b\VO]TaSZE b\Z-*E b\b\Z*VE b`dVE ba,*Z*E ba\Z-*E bd,*WdE bdY+dV*E bd`1gnV*E d-\`anO

V*67E d4+1gnV*E dV`*^ZanV*E dY+dZ/dE d`/dE d`ddZ/E eTO /3TyanV*E eTZanV*7E e`*Zgd4nV*687E f*da*E fTWT-*yZ\ZE fTO `TOY\bdE f\`,*banV*E g\gTWnE h1anV*7E hSh1,*E hTWd+*E hTb\Z-*E j,1/anV*7E j\Z*E q]E q]\ZanV*67D 6 *V\3 CDD 8 *V\3 MP3 CD-ROMD 7 d/T\4*]SaS b*V\3 /\abd]ZT Z* www.jw.org.

)V a1+1 4*fSabSbSH bSfTyZSf WSf ab*2 hSY`*4 +TWnj1

T ^fZT Z*aWT/VS /1/*WT 3*fWS,TjTD )V 4*fSabSbS a1+1H an VTWnV* ]`*VbShZSf ]\`*/D

S ,S ]`S-\bd,*WS adYVd 4 `1h*YS

]1`j\^ Z1\+fT/Z\abTH

˛,*3*yb1 Z* ]\]1`1/31ZZqD T+WT^ aV*4*Z\B w d/`Sy +*hSbn WSf1 P T f\,*2bnO aqE * +14dYZT y/dbn T V*`*pbnaqx L `S]\,TaO b1y 66B7MD q ]\`*/* /d31 aWdjZ*E V\WS Z*ad,*2bnaq abSfTqD )Vk\ ]\]1`1/3*pbn ]`\ Y\3WS,1 ,S,1`31ZZq ,dWV*Z*E ]\,TZn hS d`*-*ZE Yd/`* Wp/SZ* `\4dYT2E k\ b`1+* 1,*Vdp,*bSan d +14]1hZ1 YTag1D ˝Sbbq Z14`T,ZqZZ\ gTZZTj1E ZT3 +d/SZ\V *+\ Y*b1O `T*WnZT ab*bVSD

˙1fb\ ,S`Tjd2 ,4*-*WT ]1`1^f*bS 4 Z1O

+14]1hZ\^ YTag1,\abTD /SZ ,T/\YSy ]\WTbSV aV*4*,B w /1qVSf b1`Sb\`Tqf \a\+WS,\ h*ab\ ab*pbnaq abSfTyZT WSf*D Sj1 Z1+*-*b\ YTaO g1,\ab1y Z* Z*jTy ]W*Z1bT 2 , gn\Yd ]W*ZT Z*y`S4SV\,*ZTjSYSE T +TWnjTabn Y*y+dbZTf V*b*VWT4YT, ab*Zdbnaq a*Y1 b*YxD 1 ab\adO 2bnaqE Z*]`SVW*/E `T,ZSZZSf ]`S+1`13ZSf b1`Sb\`Ty T a1yaYThZ\ *VbS,ZSf 4\ZD )Vk\ Y\3WS,\E Z1 a1WTbnaq , b*VSf YTag1,\abqf

*+\ ]1`1^/nb1 4 ZSf /1TZ/1D *V ,S 4Y1ZjSb1 `S4SV ab*bS 31`b,\p abSfTyZ\-\ WSf*D

W*Z 1,*Vd*gT^D \]`S ,aT 4*ab1`13ZT 4*f\/S ,S ,a1Ob*VS Y\31b1 \]SZSbSaq , 4\ZT abSfTyZ\-\ WSf*D #\+ Z1 ab*bS 31`b,\p abSO

fT^E ,*`b\ Z*W13Z\ ]T/-\bd,*bSanD 1 b*V\3 : "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

a,T/hSbSY1 ]`\ /*W1V\-Wq/ZTabn T ]`\ b1E k\ ,S /T2b1 4-T/Z\ 4T aW\,*YS 4 `S]\,Tab1y 66B7D S ,S ]`S-\bd,*WS adYVd 4 `1h*YS

]1`j\^ Z1\+fT/Z\abTH \/ZTy ]d+WTV*gT^E , qVTy YTabqbnaq ]\`*/S k\/\ /Ty ]T/ h*a abSfTyZSf WSfE ]\/*2bnaq a]Sa\V Z*yZ1\+fT/O ZTjSf `1h1yE a1`1/ qVSfB Y1/SV*Y1ZbSE

]SbZ* ,\/*E ^3*E V\b`* /\,-\ 4+1`T-*2bnaqE T ,*3WS,T /\VdY1ZbSD *V\3 ,*`b\ ]1`1-WqO ZdbS 4 `T/ZSYSE qVT a*Y1 abSfTyZT WSf* Y\3dbn b`*]SbSan d ,*jTy YTag1,\abT T qV b\/T ]\,\/SbSanD

T/b`SYdyb1 +WS4nVT ab\adZVS 4 \O

-\YD 1 b`1+* `\+SbS 4*,3/SD T+WT^ ]`\

\-* aV*4*Z\E k\ ,TZ P w *bnV\ -WS+\V\-\

a]T,hdbbq b* \- daTWqV\^ ]\bTfSD TZ ]\bTj*2 Z*a d ,aTf WSf*fxD •\-\ b*V\3 Z*4,*Z\ \O -\YE wqVSy ]\bTj*2 ]`S-ZTh1ZSfx L6 \`SZeqZ 5B7E 8C ;B:MD

\- kS`\ gTV*,Sbnaq \+ab*,SZ*YS bSfE fb\ ,T`Sbn d Zn\-\D \- 2 Wp+\,E T ,TZ 4Z*2E qV ]\bTj*bS y ]T/+*/n\`p,*bS ,T`ZSf y\Yd Wp/1y L5 ı,*Z* 8B<MD 1WSVd aSWd b*V\3 Y*2 Y\WSb,*D W1 ]`\aSbS \-* b`1+* Z1 ]`\ ]\`qbdZ\VE * ]`\ a,qbSy /dfE qVSy ]T/b`SY*2 Z*a 4* +d/nOqVSf \+ab*,SZD ,qbSy /df Z*O

\WSbSan b`1+* Z1 ]`\ ]\`qbdZ\VE * ]`\ a,qbSy /dfE qVSy ]T/b`SY*2 Z*a 4* +d/nOqVSf \+ab*,SZ

-*/*2 +T+WTyZT d`S,VSE qVT ]\bTj*bn T 4*a]\V\O qbn d h*a +T/SD \/T Y\3Z* +d/1 aV*4*bSE qV

Ë&#x2122;*,S/E g*` ab*`\/*,Zn\-\ ı4`*^WpB w \WS q

]T/d f\h* + Z*,Tbn /\WSZ\p aY1`bZ\^ b1Y`qO ,SE b\ Z1 +d/d +\qbSaq 4W\-\E +\ S ]`S Y1O ZTEP ,\2 314W\ y ,Ty ]\a\f P ,\ZS Y1Z1 ,bTj*bnx L a*W\Y 67B8MD

Ë&#x2122;\]\Y\-* ,T/ \/Z\,T`gT,D ]1`j\Yd ab\`ThhT f`SabSqZanVSy ]`\`\V -*, aV*4*,E k\ w]\ ,aTy Z*a1W1ZTy 41YWT Z*ab*Z1 ,1WSVSy -\W\/xD *Y1 b*V T ab*W\aq 4* /ZT, W*,/TqD

SY*W\ ıada\,Sf dhZT, , (/1^ 4*4Z*WS +T/S

h1`14 g1y ,1WSVSy -\W\/D )V 4`1*-d,*WS ^fZT

\/Z\,T`gT 4 TZjSf V`*^,E V\WS ]\hdWS ]`\

ab`*3/*ZZq a,\^f /df\,ZSf +`*bT, T a1ab1`H

T+WTq ]\,T/\YWq2B w hZT ]\ab*Z\,SWSE k\ V\31Z 4 ZSf ]\jW1 /\]\Y\-d +`*b*Y

, (/1^ P fb\ k\ Y\31x LË&#x2122;T^ 55B6<E 6=MD \ZS ,T/ dan\-\ a1`gq ,T/-dVZdWSaq Z* ]\O

b`1+d \/Z\,T`gT, T Z*/*WS ^Y /\]\Y\-dD \WS 4* Z*j\-\ h*ad ,T/+d,*pbnaq 3*fO WS,T V*b*ab`\eSE \3T aWd3Sb1WT b*V a*Y\ ,T/-dVdpbnaq Z* ]\b`1+S ]\b1`]TWSfD ,T/VT,

-\,S 4Z*pbn qV bSfE fb\ 4*,3/S \f\h1 /\]\O Y*-*2 ]\b1`]TWSY \/Z\,T`gqYD *]`SVW*/E V\WS 6; Wpb\-\ 6>5> `\Vd , SWT ab*,aq ]\O

,T/VS -\,S /\]\Y*-*pbn a,\^Y \/Z\,T`gqY

/\W*bS Z*aWT/VS abSfT^

bd3ZSy 41YW1b`daE ,T/VS -\,S ,T/`*4d ]`SyjWS Z* /\]\Y\-dD *`W*E hSy /TY 4`dyO Zd,*W\ gdZ*YTE `\4]\,T/*2B w 31 Z*abd]Z\-\

/Zq ]\h*WS ]`S+d,*bS Y\^ \/Z\,T`gT 4 TZjSf YTag1,\ab1yE k\+ Z*/*bS /\]\Y\-dD 1 Y1Z1 /d31 ]T/+*/n\`SW\ T ]`SZ1aW\ ,1WSVd `\4`*/dD -\,* 4YTgZS, Z*a h1`14 gSf a]T,hdbWS,Sf /\+`\,\WnO gT,D ) ,T/hdW*E k\ Y1Z1 Wp+Wqbn T /+*pbn ]`\ Y1Z1xD Ë&#x2122;T/dan *`WSE qVSy Z1 2 ,T/V\Y -\,SE a]\ab1`T-*,E qV /\]\Y*O -*WS y\-\ ,ZdhgTD TZ aV*O w) ,T/hdW*E k\ 4*,B w) ZTh\-\ ]\/T+Z\-\ Y1Z1 Wp+Wqbn T /+*pbn Z1 +*hS, a1`1/ ]*`*eTqZE ]`\ Y1Z1x 4 qVSYS +*-*b\ `\VT, f\/3d /\ g1`V,SxD TaWq gn\-\ ,TZ ]\]`\aS, ,T/VT, -\,S ,S,h*bS 4 ZSY T+WTpD )Vk\ ]1`1+d,*bS a1`1/ bSfE fb\ Wp+Sbn

\-*E b\ 4* h*ad WSf ,\ZS Y\3dbn Z*Y /d31 /\]\Y\-bSD hS Z*ab*Z1 b*VSy h*aE V\WS WpO /S ,31 Z1 +d/dbn ]\b1`]*bS ,T/ ]`S`\/ZSf V*b*VWT4YT,H \/S,TY\anE k\ ]`\ g1 V*31

T+WTqD

" Ë&#x2122; 5 Ë&#x2122; ) 6>55

;

\WS abSfTyZSf WSf d31 Z1 +d/1 ı• WSf aV\`\ ,31 Z1 +dO w /1Ix )V+S fb\an ,*Y b*V1 aV*4*,E ,SE Z*]1,Z1E ]\/dY*WS +B w * g1 3 Z1O Y\3WS,\I *b*ab`\eS 4*,3/S +dWS y +d/dbnD TZ 3*`bd2xD \h* ]`S`\/ZT V*b*VWT4YS ]`\/\,O 3dpbn /\jVdWqbS Wp/ab,dE TaZd2 a]`*,3Zq Z*/TqE k\ 4*,3/S b*V Z1 +dO /1 T , Y*y+dbZn\Yd ,T/+d/dbnaq ,1WSO VT 4YTZSD W1 b*VT 4YTZS 4*]`\,*/qbn Z1 Wp/SE qVT Z1 , ab*ZT /\ VTZgq `\4dO YTbS ,aT ]`\g1aS , ]`S`\/TD `TY b\-\E Wp/S Z1 Y*pbn 4Y\-S d]`*,WqbS gSO

YS ]`\g1a*YS hS 4YTZp,*bS ^fD *`

ab*`\/*,Zn\-\ ı4`*^WpE \W\Y\ZE 4Z*O ZSy a,\2p Yd/`Tabp T a]\ab1`13WS,TaO bpE aV*4*,B w 1 Y\31 Wp/SZ* 4+*-ZdO bS hSZdE ]T/ a\Zg1Y dhSZ1Z\-\I \Yd aVTWnVS Wp/SZ* Z1 b`d/SbnaqE k\+ /\O jdV*bSan gn\-\E b\ Z1 4Z*y/1E T V\WS y Yd/`Sy aV*31E k\ 4Z*2EP Z1 4Y\31 4Z*ybSx L˚VVW14Tqab* <B5;MD

b31E Wp/S Z1 Y\3dbn ab`SYd,*O

bS ]`S`\/ZT WSf* *+\ 4*]\+T-*bS ^YD fb\ Y\31H T+WTq `\4]\,T/*2E k\ g1 ]T/ aSWd Z*j\Yd ,\`g1,TD TZ ab,\O `S, `T4ZT 1V\aSab1YS T gSVWSE qVO\b V`d-\\+T- ,\/S L˚VVW14Tqab* 5B;MD ıE Z* < "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

,T/YTZd ,T/ Wp/1yE \- ,\W\/T2 Z1O \+Y131Z\p aSW\pD 1 ]T/b,1`/S, ]`\O `\V `1YTqB w \a]\/SE \31I S Z1+\ b* 41YWp ab,\`S, ,\2p ]\bd3Z\p aSO

W\p b* ,\^Y ,Sbq-Z1ZSY `*Y1Z\YEP ZTh\-\ /Wq 1+1 Z1Y* Z1Y\3WS,\-\x

L `1YT^ 76B5;MD \- ab,\`S, 41YWp b* ,a1 Z* ZTyE b\Yd WSj1 ,TZ 4Z*2E qV V1O

`d,*bS ,aTY* ^^ ]`\g1a*YS T qV /\]\O

Y\-bS Wp/qY 3SbS d a]\V\^ b* +14]1O gT L a*W\Y 7;B55C 559B5:MD )V \- 4*]`\,*/Sbn ]\b`T+ZT 4YTZSH

/`d-Ty ab*bbT gT2^ a1`T^ \+-\,\`p,*O W\aqE k\ +*-*b\ 3*fWS,Sf ]\/Ty d ZSO ZTjZn\Yd a,TbT 2 h*abSZ\p \4Z*VS

w4*VTZh1ZZq gT2^ aSab1YSxD ıada ]\qaO ZS,B w \WS ]\+*hSb1E k\ ,a1 g1 ,T/+dO ,*2bnaqE 4Z*yb1B g*`ab,\ \31 +WS4nO V\x L *b,Tq 68B7C dVS 65B75MD \31 *`ab,\ P Z1+1aZSy d`q/E qVSy ,ab*O Z\,S, ,\`1gnEP 4/TyaZSbn /\V\`TZZT 4YTZS Z* 41YWT y ,T4nY1 ]T/ a,Ty V\ZbO `\Wn Z*,Tbn aSWS ]`S`\/SD ı f\h* \ -\,* Y*2 aSWd 4/TyaZSbS b*VT 4YTZSE ,TZ /\`dhS, g1 4*,/*ZZq a,\2Yd SZ\O

,TD `\`\V ˙*ZS^W aV*4*, ]`\ \3\-\ SZ*B w•\Yd +dW\ /*Z1 ]*Zd,*ZZq y aW*,* b* g*`ab,\E T ,aT Z*`\/SE ]W1Y1O

Z* b* q4SVS +d/dbn aWd3SbS •\Ydx

L˙*ZS^W* ;B58MD ıada `Sab\a \b`SY*, Z1\+fT/Zd ,W*/dE k\+ ]1`1b,\`SbS 41YWp Z* ]`S2YZd /\YT,Vd /Wq Wp/1yD ˙,* bSO aqh\WTbbq b\Yd ıadaE ]1`1+d,*phS Z* 41YWTE ]\V*4*,E k\ 4/*bZSy d]`*,WqO bS aSW*YS ]`S`\/SD /Z\-\ `*4d ıada 4 dhZqYS ]WS, h\,Z\Y ]\ *WTW1yanV\O Yd Y\`pE w*3 `*]b\Y 4ZqW*aq aSWnZ* +d`qE T f,SWT ,/*`qWSan \+ h\,1ZE b*V k\ ,TZE Z*]\,ZS,jSan ,\/\pE Y*W\ Z1 4*b\Zd,xD hZT /d31 Z*WqV*WSanD #\ 4`\+S, ıadaH TZ w,-*Yd,*, ,Tb1` T aV*4*, Y\`pB r kdfZSI ˛*a]\V\yaqIs Tb1` dkdfE T Z*ab*W* ,1WSV* bSj*xD hZTE ,`*31ZT ]\+*h1ZSYE ]\h*WS /SO ,d,*bSaqB w b\ 3 ,TZ b*VSyE k\ Z*O ,Tbn ,Tb1` b* Y\`1 aWdf*pbnaq y\-\Hx L *`V* 8B7;P85MD 1]1` ıada ]1`1+d,*2 , Z1+T T ,\W\O /T2 k1 +TWnj\p aSW\p b* ,W*/\pD dO /dhS *`1Y \3\-\ *`ab,*E ,TZ Y*2 \+\,Gq4\V T 4/*bZTabn 4/TyaZp,*bS ,aT Z1\+fT/ZT 4YTZSE k\+ Wp/S 3SWS Z* 41YWT , YS`T b* +14]1gTD ,bTYE hSY*W\ ]`\+W1Y T WSf a]`SO hSZq2 *+\ ]\aSWp2 a*Y* Wp/SZ*E +\ ]\O,*`,*`anVS T Z1Z*aSbZ\ 1Va]Wd*O bd2 ]`S`\/dD #\ \31 *`ab,\ 4`\O +Sbn 4 bSYSE fb\ Z1 4*f\h1 4YTZSbS a,\-\ ab*,W1ZZq /\ /\,VTWWqH T+O WTq V*31E k\ \a]\/n ıada w4Gq,Sbnaq

4 Z1+* `*4\Y 4T a,\^YS Y\-dbZTYS *ZO -1W*YS , ]\WdYGqZ\Yd ,\-ZT y a]`\,*O /Sbn ]\Yabd Z* bSfE fb\ Z1 4Z*2 \-*

b* Z1 aWdf*2bnaq /\+`\^ Z\,SZS ]`\ Z*j\-\ \a]\/* ıada*xD \/T Z*ab*Z1 h*a w4ZSkSbS bSfE fb\ ZSkSbn 41YO Wpx L6 1aa*W\ZTVTygT, 5B;E <C +Gq,O W1ZZq 55B5<MD TaWq gn\-\ w *` Z*/ g*`qYSxE ıada `Sab\aE ,T4nY1 ]T/ a,Ty V\Zb`\Wn daT

aSWS ]`S`\/S L +Gq,W1ZZq 5=B5:MD TZ ]\/+*2 ]`\ b1E k\+ ]T/ ]`*,WTZZqY y\O -\ *`ab,* +TWnj1 ZTfb\ Z1 ab*, 31`bO ,\p abSfTyZSf WSf T k\+ ]\-\/* b* VWTO Y*bShZT ]`\g1aS Z1 4*,/*,*WS Wp/qY jV\/SD *V ,SV\Z*2bnaq /*,Zq \+TgqZO

V* \-* -\,SB w˙*Y ,*jT /\kT , ^fZTY h*aTE T 41YWq /*abn a,Ty d`\3*yE * ]\O Wn\,1 /1`1,\ /*abn ]WT/ a,Tyx L 1,Sb 6:B8MD p/S 4Y\3dbn +d/d,*bS /\YSE

Z1 +\qhSanE k\ ^f 4`dyZd2 abSfTqD `\

g1 , T+WT^ aV*4*Z\B w˙\YS ]\+d/dpbnE T Y1jV*bS +d/dbnE T 4*a*/qbn ,\ZS ,SO

Z\-`*/ZSVSE T +d/dbn ^fZTy ]WT/ a]\3SO

,*bSx Lıa*^ :9B65MD #\ ,SY*-*2bnaq ,T/ ,*aH *YE qV T +*-*bn\Y TZjSYE Z*]1,Z1E ]`S2YZ\ hdbS ]`\ a,TbE /1 Z1 +d/1 `dyO ZT,ZSf V*b*VWT4YT,D k\ `\+SbSE *+S +dbS b*YH T+WTq V*31E k\ bTE fb\ wZ1

4Z*2 \-* b* Z1 aWdf*2bnaq /\+`\^ Z\O ,SZSxE Z1 ]\b`*]Wqbn d a,TbE ,TWnZSy ,T/ abSfTyZSf WSfD b31E b\yE fb\ f\O h1 ]\+*hSbS b*V1 3SbbqE ]\,SZ1Z Z*O ,h*bSan ]`\ \-* T ]T/b`SYd,*bS y\-\ ]`*,WTZZqD ,\`1gn ,SY*-*2E k\+ YS ]T4Z*,*WS y\-\ T V\`SWSan /\+`Ty Z\O ,SZT ]`\ *`ab,\E qV1 ,TZ ,ab*Z\,S, h1`14 a,\-\ SZ*D ˙Wq gn\-\ b`1+* ab*`*ZZ\ ,S,h*bS

T+WTpD ˛ Z1^ ,S /\,T/*2b1anE qVT 4YTO ZS Z1\+fT/Z\ 4`\+SbS d a,\2Yd 3SbbTE *+S ,bTj*bSaq gTWV\,Sb\p +14]1V\p ]T/ ]`*,WTZZqY *`ab,*D \]`\aTbn ,T/VT, -\,S d ,*jTy YTag1,\abTE k\+ ,\ZS ,S,h*WS 4 ,*YS T+WTpD \ZS ,*Y `*/\ /\]\Y\3dbnD )Vk\ ,S +d/1O b1 ]T4Z*,*bS \-* T V\`SbSan \3\O Yd *`ab,dE b\ ]\+*hSb1 ,SV\Z*ZZq

+T+WTyZ\^ \+TgqZVSB w b\ Y1Z1 aWdf*2E b\y +d/1 3SbS +14]1hZ\E T +d/1 a]\VTyO ZSy ,T/ ab`*fd ]1`1/ 4W\Yx L `S]\,TaO b1y 5B77MD

" ˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

=

ı ˛ ( & S VTZ1gn a,Tbd Z*ab*Z1 6>56 `\VdH /3*2bnaq k\`*4 +TWnj1 bSfE fb\ ,T`Sbn d Z*ab*ZZq *]\V*O WT]aSa*D \ZS ,,*3*pbnE k\ VTZ1gn a,Tbd ]`Sy/1 65 -`d/O Zq 6>56 `\VdE , /1Zn 4*O ,1`j1ZZq 9569O`ThZ\-\ gSVO Wd ab*`\/*,Zn\-\ V*W1Z/*`q Y*yqx Lw TO TO T ZnpaxMD \h +S k\ ]1`1/+*h*WS `1WT-TyZT /TqhTE V\b`T ]`\]\,TO /dpbn 4ZSk1ZZq 41YWTE ]a1,O /\Z*dV\,gT b* +*-*b\ adh*aZSf ]`\,S/gT,E Z*j* ]W*Z1b* Z1 +d/1 4ZSk1Z* 6>56 `\O VdD \Z* TaZd,*bSY1 T , /*W1V\Yd Y*y+dbO Zn\YdD

T+WTq -\,\`SbnB w \V\WTZZq ,T/f\/SbnE y ]\V\WTZZq ]`Sf\/SbnE * 41YWq ,TV\,ThZ\ ab\O

^bnx L˚VVW14Tqab* 5B8MD `TY b\-\E , ıa*^ 89B5< aV*4*Z\B w *V ]`\Y\,Wq2 \a]\/nDDD

k\ 41YWp ,e\`Yd,*, b* ^^ ,hSZS,E T YTgZ\

]\ab*,S, ^^C Z1 qV ]\`\3Z1hd ^^ ab,\`S,EP

Z* ]`\3S,*ZZq Z* ZTy TZ ^^ ,e\`Yd,*,D ) P \a]\/nE T Z1Y* +TWnj1 TZj\-\ \-*xD q,TbnE k\ /\+`Sy +*bnV\ 4Y*yab`d,*, Z* `*/Tabn a,\2Yd aSZ\,T V\`*+WSV *+\ /\ZngT f*bVd /Wq WqWn\VD S ,TZ `\4b`\kS, +S b*O VSy ]\/*`dZ\V ,T/`*4d ]TaWq b\-\E qV /*, y\-\ /SbSZTH 1 +dW\ + 3\`ab\V\D #\an ]\O /T+Z1 Y\3Z* aV*4*bS ]`\ \-*D TZ ab,\`S, 41YWp ]1`1/daTY Z* `*/Tabn Wp/qYD 1`O jTy Wp/anVTy ]*`TE /*Yd T ,TE \- aV*4*,B w W\/Tbnaq y `\4YZ\3dyb1aqE T Z*]\,Zpyb1 41YWpE \,\W\/Tyb1 Z1pxD TaWq gn\-\ w]\O +*hS, \- da1E k\ ,hSZS,D ı \b\EP ,1WnYS /\+`1 ,\Z\x L dbbq 5B6;E 6<E 75MD \- Z1 4*O +d, ]`\ a,Ty Z*YT` /Wq 41YWTD \Yd ,TZ 5> "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

Z1 /\4,\WSbnE k\+ ,\Z* +dW*

4ZSk1Z*D `\ ,aT a,\^ \+TO gqZVS -\,* aV*4*,B w W\,\ \2E k\ ,Sf\/Sbn T4 dab \O

^fB ]\`\3ZTY /\ 1Z1 ,\Z\ Z1 ,1`b*2bnaqE *W1 4`\+SbnE k\ ) ]\3*/*,E T +d/1 Y*bS ]\,\/31ZZq , b\YdE Z* k\ )

y\-\ ]\aSW*,x Lıa*^ 99B55MD `\b1 -\,* ]\ab*Z\,S, w4ZSkSbS bSfE fb\ ZSkSbn 41YWpx L +Gq,W1ZZq 55B5<MD

\3\Yd W\,T 4*]Sa*Z* b*V* \+TgqZO V*B w˛*Y1jV*pbn ]`*,1/ZT 41YWpE T Z1,SZO ZT 4\ab*Zdbnaq , ZTyE * +14+\3ZT 4 41YWT

+d/dbn ,S-d+W1ZTE T ]\,S`S,*pbnaq 4 Z1^ Z1O ,T`ZTx L `S]\,Tab1y 6B65E 66MD \WS g1 ab*Z1bnaqH Tfb\ 4 Wp/1y gn\-\ Z1 4Z*2D ıada aV*4*,B w `\ /1Zn b\y hS -\O /SZd Z1 4Z*2 ZTfb\B ZT *Z-1WS Z* Z1+TE ZT SZE * bTWnVS *bnV\x L *`V* 57B76MD ,T/O VS -\,S Z1 Z*Y*-*pbnaq ,S4Z*h*bS /*bdE V\WS \- dadZ1 4WSfD \h* ,T/VS 4,*3*pbn Z* \4Z*Vd VTZgq T ]1`1V\Z*ZTE k\ Wp/ab,\ 3S,1 , ]1`T\/E qVSy T+WTq Z*4S,*2 w\ab*ZO ZTYS /ZqYSxE ,\ZS Z1 4Z*pbnE V\WS a*Y1

\- ]\hZ1 ZSkSbS 4WSf L *`V* 57B8P<E 77C 6 SY\eTq 7B5MD ,T/VS Z1 Y*pbn adYZT,dE k\ -\,* T y\-\ SZ Z*yV`*k1 4Z*pbnE V\O WS g1 4`\+SbSD SY h*a\Y ,T/VS -\,S Z1 aS/qbn aVW*,O jS `dVS , \hTVd,*ZZT VTZgqD \ZS 4*yZqbT

]`\]\,T/d,*ZZqY /\+`\^ Z\,SZS ]`\ \31 *`ab,\ P Z1+1aZSy d`q/E qVSy ]`*,SbSY1

Z*j\p ]W*Z1b\p T ]1`1b,\`Sbn ^^ Z* `*yD \/T wda]*/Vdpbn ]`*,1/ZT 41YWpE T ]\,TV +d/dbn 3SbS Z* ZTyx L a*W\Y 7;B6=MD

Image Science and Analysis Laboratory, NASA-Johnson Space Center

ˇ w e`*Zgd4nV1 a1W\ 4G^3O

b\ Y\31 bWdY*hSbS ]`\`\gb,*H

˛-T/Z\ 4 ]1`1V*4*YSE -\`/T^, ,d4\W +d, Z*y+TWnj\p 4*-*/V\p 4* /ZT, W1Va*Z/`* *V1/\ZanV\-\D \yE fb\ a]`\YT-aq `\4,Gq4*bS g1y ,1WnYS 4*]Wdb*ZSy ,d4\WE ,,*3*,aq /d31 Yd/`\p Wp/SZ\p T ,1WSVSY 4*,\y\,ZSV\Y1D W1Va*Z/` `\4,Gq4*, gp 4*-*/Vd ]`\ab\B `\4`d+*, ,d4\W Y1h1YD

) ,TVT, Yd/`1gT Z*Y*-*WSaq Z1 bTWnVS `\4,Gq4d,*bS aVW*/ZT ,d4O WSE *W1 y ,T/-*/d,*bS 4*-*/VSE bWdY*hSO bS ]`\`\gb,* T Z*,Tbn ]1`1/`TV*bS Y*yO +dbZ2D W1 Z1`T/V\ `\4,Gq4d,*bS b*2YZSgT k\O /\ Y*y+dbZn\-\ +dW\ /Wq ZSf Z*/b\ aVW*/ZSY 4*,/*ZZqYD *]`SVW*/E ,*,SO W\ZanVT Yd/`1gT Z1 4Y\-WS ,SbWdY*hSbS aWT,E qVT hd/\Y 4Gq,SWSaq Z* abTZT ]*W*gd g*`q *Wb*a*`* ]T/ h*a -dhZ\-\ +1ZV1bdD

Sj1 ˙*ZS^WE ab*`1ZnVSy ]`\`\V \-* -\,SE qVSy dYT, w`\4]Wdbd,*bS ,d4WSxE

4YT- ,SbWdY*hSbS ]`\`\hT aW\,* L˙*ZS^O W* 9B56MD 1 ]`\`\gb,\E qV1 ab\ad,*W\O

aq 4*-S+1WT *,SW\ZanV\^ TY]1`T^E ,SV\O

Z*W\aq bT2^ 3 Z\hT L˙*ZS^W* 9B5E 8P<E 69P7>MD

1 -`1gnVTy W1-1Z/T `\4]\,T/*2bnaqE qV d \`/T\O

ZT Lab\WSgT `S-T^M ]`S,Gq4*WS /\ ab\,]* V\WTaZSgp \`/TqE 4*aZ\,ZSV* YTab*D d4\W +d, Z*abTWnVS 4*O ]Wdb*ZSYE k\ y\-\ YT- `\4,Gq4*bS WSj1 Y*y+dbZTy

4*,\y\,ZSV 4T^D

#\ b*V1 ]`\`\gb,\H `\`\gb,\ P g1 ]1`1/+*h1ZZq Y*y+dbO Zn\-\E ]\/TyE ]`\ qVT 4*]Sa*Z\ 4*4/*W1O -T/nD `*,/S,1 ]`\`\gb,\ 2 Z*bfZ1ZSY \-\Y ]\,T/\YW1ZZqY P daZSY *+\ ]SO

a*ZSYD \Z\ 2 ,Sq,W1ZZqY \3\^ ,\WT

b* Z*YT`dD T+WT^ YTabqbnaq ]`\`\gb,* ]`\ b1E V\WS 4Gq,Sbnaq 1aTq T qV y\-\ Y\3Z* +d/1 `\4]T4Z*bSD b13 ]`\`\gb,*

]`\ w4*VTZh1ZZq gT2^ aSab1YSx b* ad/\,T

,S`\VS ,T/ \-* L *b,Tq 68B7C ˙*ZS^W* =B69MD SZTjZT wYd/`1gTx P Z*dV\,gTE 1V\Z\O YTabSE Y1/SVSE ]\WTbSVSE 1V\W\-S b\O k\ P Z*Y*-*pbnaq ]1`1/+*hSbS Y*y+dbO

Z2D `\ ^fZT ]1`1/+*h1ZZq ]\,T/\YWqpbn Y*aOY1/T*E T Wp/S \f\h1 g1 hSb*pbnD a1 3 gT ]1`1/+*h1ZZqE , WT]j\Yd `*4TE 2 Z*dV\,SYS ]`S]dk1ZZqYS b* \a\+SabSO YS YT`Vd,*ZZqYSD `TY b\-\E Z* V\3Z1 b*V1 ]`S]dk1ZZq *+\ *`-dY1Zb 4*,3/S Y\3Z* 4Z*ybS ]`\bSW13Z1 ]`S]dk1ZZq *+\ V\Zb`*`-dY1ZbD b31E b*V1 ]1`1/+*O h1ZZq Y*y+dbZn\-\ /d31 Z1]1,Z1D ˙1 4Z*ybS Z*/TyZT ]`\`\gb,* \3 /1 4Z*ybS Z*/TyZT ]`\`\gb,* T fb\

Y\31 ^f bWdY*hSbSH ]\ab\W 1b`\ Z*O ]Sa*,B w˝\/Z1 ]`\`\gb,\ , Sa*ZZqf Z1 ]\f\/Sbn ,T/ hSy\-\an ,W*aZ\-\ bWdY*O h1ZZqx L6 1b`* 5B6>MD `1gnV1 aW\,\E ]1O `1VW*/1Z1 qV wbWdY*h1ZZqxE Z1a1 , a\+T /dYVd ]`\ w`\4,Gq4*ZZqE ,Sq,W1ZZqxD \O Yd , ]1`1VW*/T dWTj* 1b`\,T aW\,* 4,dh*bn b*VB w˝\/Z1 VZS3Z1 ]`\`\gb,\

Z1 /T2bnaq a,\^Y `\4,Gq4*ZZqYxD q,Tbn a\+T Y\`qV*E qVSy ,]`*,Z\ 4*O ,Gq4d2 WSZ,d d aVW*/ZSy ,d4\WD p/SZ*E qV* ZTV\WS gSY Z1 4*yY*W*anE +*hSbnE qV fSb`\Yd/`\ dVW*/1ZT ]1bWTE *W1 `\4,Gq4*O bS ,d4W* Z1 Y\31D *V a*Y\ y Wp/S +*O h*bnE /\ qVSf aVW*/ZSf ]`\+W1Y Y\3dbn

]`S4,1abS ]\/T^ d a,TbTE *W1 Z1 , ab*ZT b\hZ\ aV*4*bSE qV a*Y1 +d/dbn `\4,Gq4*ZT gT ]`\+W1YSD

" ˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

55

`\`\VS /*,ZSZSE b*VT qV Ë&#x2122;*ZS^WE +dO WS Z*bfZ1ZT \-\YD \ZS Z1 ab*`*WSan Z* ,W*aZSy `\4ad/ /1b*WnZ\ \]Sad,*bSE qVSY +d/1 Y*y+dbZ2E f\h* y Y\-WS ,a1O

+ThZ\ 4,*3d,*bSE /\ h\-\ ]`S,1/dbn ]\/T^

^fZn\-\ h*adD )V+S ,\ZS ]\VW*/*WSaq WSO j1 Z* a,\p Yd/`Tabn b* \+T4Z*ZTabnE b\ ]1`1/*,*WS + ,W*aZT ]\-Wq/SD *VT ]`\O `\gb,* +dWS + hSab\ Wp/anVSYS y Å¡`dZO bd,*WSaq + Z* Z1]1,ZTy \aZ\,TD an h\O Yd 1b`\ ]\qaZS,B w `\`\gb,\ ZTV\WS Z1 4Gq,WqW\aq 4 ,\WT Wp/SZSE *W1 Wp/S -\,\O `SWS ,T/ \-*E V1`\,*ZT a,qbSY /df\Yx L6 1b`* 5B65MD w \-* ,T/-*/VSx `S+WS4Z\ 7;>> `\VT, b\Yd , 2-S]1banO Vd ,Gq4ZSgp ,VSZdWS /,\f h\W\,TVT,D \O /T V\3Z\Yd 4 ZSf ]`SaZS,aq /S,ZSy a\ZD 1 Y*phS 4Y\-S 4*]Sb*bS ]`\ bWdY*h1ZO Zq , Yd/`1gT,E bT ,Gq4ZT 4,1`ZdWSan ]\ /\O ]\Y\-d /\ â&#x20AC;¢\aS]*E aV*4*,jSB w ZS,aq Z*Y a\ZE * ,T/-*/*bS y\-\ Z1Y*2 V\YdxD â&#x20AC;¢\aS]E qVSy +d, aWd3Sb1W1Y ]`*,/S,\-\ \-*E ]\]`\aS, `\4]\,TabS y\Yd bT aZSD TZ ]\qaZS,B w S 3 Z1 , \-* ,T/-*/VSHx L dbbq 8>B<MD TWnVS -\,* \- 4/*bZSy `\4bWdY*hd,*bS ]`\`\gb,*E ]\/T+Z\ qV /\a,T/h1ZSy Y\`qV 4/*bZSy `\4,Gq4d,*bS aVW*/ZT ,d4WSD \- 2 bSYE fb\ /*2 ]`\O

`\gb,*E T b\Yd 4Z*2 ^fZp `\4,Gq4VdD \3 ,*`b\ jdV*bS bWdY*h1Zn ]`\`\gb, WSj1 d \-*D an h\Yd â&#x20AC;¢\aS] aV*4*,E k\ ,T/O -*/VS aZT, /*2 WSj1 \-D qV \- /*2 ,T/-*/VSH TWnV\Y* a]\O a\+*YSD Ë&#x2122;1qVT +T+WTyZT ]`\`\gb,* +dWS 4*]Sa*ZT `*4\Y 4 ]\qaZ1ZZqY b\-\E qV ,\O ZS ,SV\Z*pbnaqD *VT ]`\`\gb,* ]\`T,O ZqZ\ W1-V\ bWdY*hSbSE ]\/T+Z\ qV W1-V\ `\4,Gq4d,*bS ,d4WSE V\WS Y\`qV ]\qaO ZSbnE qV g1 4`\+SbS L dbbq 5<B58C 65B6MD ıZjT ]`\`\gb,* Y\3Z* `\4GqaZSbS T ,SO bWdY*hSbSE /\aWT/S,jS V\Zb1VabD `\O

`\V Ë&#x2122;*ZS^W \b`SY*, ]`\`\h1 ,S/TZZq ]`\ +*`*Z* 4 /,\Y* `\-*YSD n\-\ +*`*Z* 56 "

Ë&#x2122; 5 Ë&#x2122; ) 6>55

,/*`S, ,\W\f*bSy V\41WE qVSy Y*, w`\-*

YT3 a,\^YS \hSY*xD \Zb1Vab ]\V*4d2E k\ +*`*Z 4 /,\Y* `\-*YS aSY,\WT4d,*, wg*`T, YT/qZ b* ]1`aT,xE * V\41W P wg*`q

`1gT^x LË&#x2122;*ZS^W* <B7P<E 6>P66MD `\yjW\ ]\Z*/ 6>> `\VT, T W1Va*Z/` *V1/\ZO anVSy P w,1WSVSy `T-x P ]\h*, 4*,\y\O ,d,*bS 1`aTpD Ë&#x203A;* aW\,*YS 2,`1yanV\-\ Tab\`SV* â&#x20AC;¢\aSe* W*,TqE W1Va*Z/`\,T

]T/ h*a ,TyanV\,\^ V*Y]*ZT^ , \V\WSgqf `da*WSY* ]\V*4*WS g1 ]`\`\gb,\E T ,TZ ]\-\/S,aqE k\ y/1bnaq a*Y1 ]`\ Zn\-\D \- /*2 ,T/-*/VS k1 , TZjSy a]\aT+D â&#x20AC;¢\aS]E ,T`ZSy aWd3Sb1Wn \-* -\,SE ]T/ ,]WS,\Y a,qb\-\ /dfd 4`\4dYT, 4Z*h1ZZq Z14,Sh*yZSf aZT, Wp/1yE qVT +dWS `*4\Y 4 ZSY d ,Gq4ZSgT L dbbq 85B7<MD \WS \3T aWd3Sb1WT Z*j\-\ h*ad f\hdbn 4`\4dYTbS qV1an ]`\`\gb,\E ,\ZS Y\Wqbnaq ]`\ \O 3Sy /df T `1b1WnZ\ /\aWT/3dpbn Z*bfZ1O Z1 /df\Y ,qb1 SanY\D \- /\]\Y*-*2

^Y 4Z*f\/SbS +T+WTyZT d`S,VSE qVT `\4O V`S,*pbn adbn bSf hS TZjSf ]`\`\gb,D -\,* Z1 `\4V`S,*2 4Z*h1ZZq ]`\`\gb, d Z*/]`S`\/ZSy a]\aT+ h1`14 qVdan Wp/SO

ZdD \- /*2 `\4dYTZZq a,\^Y /df\Y T W\O ,\YD b31E ]\qaZ1ZZq ]`\`\gb, Z1 ]\f\O /Sbn ,T/ ]`\,S/gT,E qVT Z1 a]S`*pbnaq Z*

T+WTp LË&#x2122;T^ 59B56P65MD \- b*V\3 /*2 ,T/-*/VSE V\WS ,S`Tjd2E hS qV1an ]`\`\gb,\ Y*2 ab*bS 4`\4dYTO WSY /Wq y\-\ ,T`ZSf 41YZSf aWd-E hS k1 ZTD Ë&#x203A;Z*h1ZZq ]`\`\gb,* Y\31 +dbS 4`\4dO YTWSY /\E ]T/ h*a *+\ ]TaWq y\-\ ,SV\O Z*ZZqD aVTWnVS \- w4,Gq4*,x ]`\`\gbO

,*E b\ ,TZ `\4,Gq31 ^f d ,T/]\,T/ZSy P a,Ty P h*aD â&#x20AC;¢\aS] ,SbWdY*hS, aZS /,\f ,Gq4ZT, 4* b`S /ZT /\ ,SV\Z*ZZq ]1`1/`1h1Z\-\ , gSf aZ*f L dbbq 8>B57E 5=MD T4ZTj1E V\WS â&#x20AC;¢\aS]* ]`S,1WS /\ Y\3Z\,W*/Z\O -\ e*`*\Z* ]\qaZSbS 4Z*h1ZZq e*`*\O Z\,\-\ aZdE Y*, `\4]\h*bSaq ,T/WTV a1O YS `\VT, /\ab*bVdD \- /\]\YT- â&#x20AC;¢\aS]\,T

a,\^Y /df\Y `\4-*/*bS 4Z*h1ZZq e*`*\O

Z\,Sf aZT,E T b\Yd +dW\ aVW*/1Z\ ]W*ZSE k\+ 4T+`*bS T 4+1`1-bS ]1`1/`1h1ZSy `qaO ZSy ,`\3*y L dbbq 85B6=E 7=E 8>MD ıZjT ]`\`\gb,* ab*pbn ]\,ZTabp 4`\4dO

YTWSYS /Wq \3Sf aWd- bTWnVS ]TaWq ^fO Zn\-\ ,SV\Z*ZZqD SY*W\ ]\/Ty ıada\,\O -\ 3Sbbq +dWS ]1`1/`1h1ZT 4* ab\WTbbq /\ y\-\ Z*`\/31ZZqE *W1 dhZT /\ VTZgq

4`\4dYTWS ^f WSj1 ]TaWq y\-\ ,\aV`1aTZO Zq L a*W\Y 66B5=C 78B65C ı,*Z* 5=B68E 7:MD

Ë&#x203A;`1jb\pE ,T/]\,T/Z\ /\ aWT, 4 Ë&#x2122;*ZS^W* 56B8E /1qVT ]`\`\gb,* Y*WS +dbS 4*]1h*O b*ZT w*3 /\ h*ad VTZgqxE V\WS w`\4YZ\O 3Sbnaq ]`*,/S,1 4Z*ZZqxD S 3S,1Y\ a*Y1 , g1y h*aE V\WS b*VT ]`\`\gb,* ,SV\O Zdpbnaq1D )V +T+WTyZT ]`\`\gb,* ,]WS,*pbn Z* ,*a

â&#x20AC;¢\aS] T Ë&#x2122;*ZS^W 4Gq,WqWSaq ]1`1/ \+O WShhqY g*`T, b* ,S-\W\O jd,*WS ]`\`\gb,*E qVT b\`V*WSaq Z*`\/T, T /1`O \qaZpphS 3*,D `SabSqZS ]1`j\O 4Z*h1ZZq ]`\`\gb,*E -\ ab\`Thhq ,Sabd]*WS

â&#x20AC;¢\aS] T Ë&#x2122;*ZS^W ]1`1/ a,\^YS adh*aZSV*O -\,\`SWSE k\ YS qV `1hZSVS -\,SE

`\4dYTZZq ^Y \-* ]`\`\gb,D *V ,\ZS /*, \ab*WS a]`*,3ZTY +W*-\O aW\,1ZZqY /Wq bSfE fb\

â&#x20AC;¹ ]`SaWdf*,aq /\ ^fZTf aWT,D Z*j h*a ,T/VS -\,S ]\ gTW\Yd a,TbT ]`\-\W\jdpbn ]`\`\hd 4,TabVd P /\+`d Z\,SZd ]`\ \31 *`ab,\ P T ]\,T/\YWqO pbn Wp/qYE k\ ıada\,1 ]`\`\gb,\ ]`\

w4*VTZh1ZZq gT2^ aSab1YSx ,T/+d,*2bnaq

Z* ^fZTf \h*f L *b,Tq 68B7E 58MD S 4Z*2b1 ,SE ]`\ k\ y/1bnaq T qV g1 ,]WSZ1 Z* ,*aH ,T/VS -\,S 4*Wp+VS /\]\Y\3dbn ,*Y 4`\4dYTbS g1 ]`\`\gb,\ P \/Z1 4 Z*y,1O WShZTjSf +T+WTyZSf ]`\`\gb,D 1 Sb*yb1 a1`Tp ,abd]ZSf ab*b1y w: +T+WTyZSf ]`\O `\gb,E qVT a]\,Zppbnaq Z* ,*jSf \h*fx d w *`b\,Ty +*jbTx 4* 5 b`*,Zq 6>55 `\VdD

" Ë&#x2122; 5 Ë&#x2122; ) 6>55

57

˛

˚ ıı

+14V`*p +TWd ]dab1Wp ˙ ı 4SY*D *Z\O,`*ZgT YS ,S-WqO /*2Y\ h1`14 ,TVZ\E k\+ ]\+*hSbSE qV* ZSZT ]\-\/*D d/\,\I */ -\W\,\p hSab1 +W*VSbZ1 Z1+\I S ,S`dj*2Y\ Z* b`S /ZT ]`\]\,T/d,*bS , TZZY*`Va,T//d P ,1WSO V\Yd -T`anV\Yd ]W*b\ 4* ]\Wq`ZSY V\W\YD

4SYVd , \`,1-T^ /\aSbn f\W\/Z\E b\3

YS b`\fS +\^Y\aq ^f*bS Z* ]T,ZThD W1 4-\O

/\Y 4*a]\V\p2Y\anE */31 4 Z*YS ^/1 b`\2 ,T/VT, -\,SE qVT Y1jV*pbn d bTy YTag1O ,\abTD \ZS 4Z*pbnE qV b*Y d b*Vd ]\`d T h\-\ Y\3Z* a]\/T,*bSan ,T/ ]\-\/SD

* ]T,Z\hT \`,1-T^ /\`T- Z1+*-*b\D ˙\ Wp/1yE V\b`T 3S,dbn d ,T//*W1ZSf YTagqfE Z*yWT]j1 /\+S`*bSan Y\b\a*ZqYSD S 4*O

,*Zb*3d2Y\ Z* Y\b\a*ZS \/q-E 4*]*aS ^3T b* /\/*bV\,1 ]*WS,\ T ,S`dj*2Y\D 1`1/ Z*YS *3 /\ \+`Tp ]`\abq-*2bnaq +14V`*2 4*aZT31Z1 -T`anV1 ]W*b\D ZT- ,S+WSaVd2 Z* a\ZgTE Z*h1 YT`T*/S /T*Y*ZbT,D 3 /df ]1`1f\]Wp2I * ]W*b\ TZZY*`Va,T//* 3S,dbn ]T,O ZThZT \W1ZTE W\aTE `SaTE 4*ygTE WSaSgTE `\O a\Y*fS b* Z1,1WSV* VTWnVTabn ,1/Y1/T,D W1 Z*a Z*y+TWnj1 gTV*,Sbn Z*-\/* ]`\]\O

,T/d,*bS Wp/qYE qVT Y1jV*pbn d gn\Yd ,T//*W1Z\Yd V`*pD a\+WS,\ f\h1bnaq 4dO ab`TbS Wp/1yE qVT `\4Y\,Wqpbn a**YanV\p Y\,\pD \ZS 4/1+TWnj\-\ 4*yY*pbnaq `\4O ,1/1ZZqY ]T,ZThZSf \W1ZT, b* db`SYdpbn -T`anVT ]`SbdWVS /Wq YSaWS,gT,D 1]\/*WTV ,T/ ]1`j\-\ -T`anV\-\ ]`SbdWO Vd YS 4dab`Th*2Y\ VTWnV\f jV\Wq`T,E qVT

+1`dbn dh*abn d WS3Z\Yd V`\aT 4T a,\^Y VW*a\YD \ZS 4d]SZqpbnaq T 4*]SbdpbnE ‹ k\ YS bdb `\+SY\D SE +14]1`1hZ\E 4 `*/TaO

bp ]\qaZp2Y\ Y1bd a,\2^ ]\^4/VSD \WS YS 4 ZSYS ]`\k*2Y\anE \/SZ fW\]1gn V*O 31B w a]TjZ\-\ ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZqIx ˛-\/\Y

Z* a,\^f Y\b\a*Zqf YS ]1`1bSZ*2Y\ ,1WSV1 4*Y1`4W1 \41`\ T 4*aZT31ZT ]`\ab\`SE qVT W13*bn 4* ZSYD S ,/*abnaq Z*Y ]\+*hSbS ab*/\ \W1ZT,H

\WS ]T/G^3/3*2Y\ /\ Z1,1WSV\-\ +d/SO Z\hVdE Z*a 4dab`Th*2 ]`S,TbZSy h\W\,TVD TZ \/SZ 4 Z1+*-*bn\fE fb\ bdb ]\abTyZ\ ]`\3S,*2D \+*hS,jSE k\ \/ZT 4 Z*jSf a*Z1y b`\fS ]\W*Y*ZTE h\W\,TV 4*]`\]\ZdO

,*, ,T/`1Y\Zbd,*bS ^fD TZ ]`*gp2 ]\O ,\WTE */31 bdb ZTfb\ ZTVd/S Z1 a]TjSbnD

WSY\aq 4 ZSY VTWnV\Y* ]T/+*/n\`WS,SYS

/dYV*YS 4 T+WT^D TaWq `\4Y\,S ,TZ ]\V*O 4d2 Z*Y V\`\bjd /\`\-dD

ab*ZZn\-\ /Zq ]\^4/VS YS ,G^3/3*2Y\ Z* b1`Sb\`Tp Z*gT\Z*WnZ\-\ ]*`Vd b*+O +d`a/*W1ZD )VT 3 bdb V`*2,S/SI 1ZO-1Z P 4*aZT31ZT ,1`jSZSE k\ ,S+WSaVdpbn Z* a\ZgTD ı \an YS +*hSY\ ,1WSV1 ab*/\ ]T,ZThO ZSf \W1ZT,D \ZS a]\VTyZ\ ]*adbnaqE `\4O -`T+*phS V\]Sb*YS aZT-E k\+ /Tab*bSan /\

Y\fdD `\fS /*WT Z* a,\^f Y\b\a*Zqf aSO /Sbn a**YTD \W\,TV a]\VTyZ\ a]\ab1`T-*2

4* \W1ZqYSE * y\-\ ]1a ,YTW\ ]T/-*Zq2 ^f T ab13SbnE k\+ ab*/\ Z1 `\4+`1/*W\anD * f,SWp ]1a 4d]SZq2bnaq T ]\hSZ*2 ,ZpfdO ,*bSan d Z*j\Yd Z*]`qYVdE *W1 j,S/V\

]\,1`b*2bnaq /\ a,\2^ a]`*,SD S ]T/f\/SO Y\ /\ ]*abdf* T ]`\]\,T/d2Y\ y\YdD 1y ]`S,TbZSy h\W\,TV d,*3Z\ Z*a aWdf*2D * 4,\`\bZ\Yd jWqfd YS ]`S-*/d2Y\

,aTfE V\-\ 4dab`TWS ]T/ h*a Z*j\^ 7>>OVTO

W\Y1b`\,\^ Y*Z/`T,VSD )V ]`S2YO Z\E k\ ,/*W\aq ,Z1abS a,\p h*abO Vd , a]`*,d ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZq Wp/qY d gTy ,1WSh14ZTy +TWTy ]dab1WTD

" ˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

59

5 Norway Post

•\-\ a]\VTy ]1`1/*2bnaq T Z*YD TaWq ,an\-\ YS /qVd2Y\ y\Yd T V\`\bV\ ]\qaZpO

2Y\ Z* \aZ\,T T+WT^E h\Yd \- /\]daO V*2 ab`*3/*ZZqD \W\,TV d,*3Z\ aWdf*2D

1`1/ ,T/G^4/\Y YS /*2Y\ y\Yd VZS3Vd w \-\ Z*a]`*,/T ,hSbn T+WTqHx b* 3d`Z*O WS w *`b\,* +*jb*x T w `\+d/SanIxD aO YTfZd,jSanE ,TZ V*31B w˙qVdpE k\ 4*,TO b*WSxD S ,T/,T/d2Y\ k1 VTWnV\f Wp/1yD \WS ]\h*W\ adb1ZTbSE YS ]`qYd2Y\ /\ f*bSZSE /1 +d/1Y\ Z\hd,*bSD 3 \an Z1a]\/T,*Z\ ]\+*hSWS WSaSgpD ı^ `d/1 fdb`\ -*`Z\ ,SO +WSaVd2 Z* bWT +TW\-\ aZT-dD SaSgq Z* f,SWnVd 4d]SZq2bnaqE 4/S,\,*Z\ /S,Sbnaq Z* Z*a T +T3Sbn /*WTD \hSZ*2 aZT3SbS T YS

+\^Y\aq 4*+WdV*bSD ˛`1jb\p YS b*VS 4Z*O f\/SY\ f*bSZdD \4]*Wp2Y\ ]ThVdE T , VTYO

Z*bT ab*2 b1]W\D \h* ]TaWq gTW\/1ZZ\^ ^4/S Z* Y\b\a*Zqf ,T/hd,*2bnaq ,b\Y*E YS `*O /T2Y\D ",S/V\ ]`\Y*yZdW* ZThD 1`14*,*Zb*O

3S,jS Y\b\a*ZSE YS ^/1Y\ `ThV\,\p /\O WSZ\p /\ Z*abd]Z\-\ -T`anV\-\ ]`SbdWVdD *Y 4dab`Th*2Y\ Y\W\/\-\ h\W\,TV* T /TO

& ˝˚ ab*bbT `\4-Wq/*pbnaq 4*]Sb*ZZqE qVT Y\3dbn ,*a gTV*,SbSD db b*V\3 Z*,\/qbnaq +T+WTyZT ,T`jTE V\b`T YTabqbn ,T/]\,T/T Z* gT 4*]Sb*ZZqD \/*ZT ,T`jT

,S 4Z*y/1b1 d a,\^y T+WT^D ,T/VS

-\,S `*/\ \+-\,\`qbn ^f 4 ,*YSD

)V 4Z*ybS f\`\jSf /`d4T,H

5D \Yd b`1+* a1`y\4Z\ ab*,SbSan /\ ,S+\`d /`d4T,H

TWnjTabn Wp/1y ]`*-Z1 ]\/\+*bSaq TZjSYD 1`14 b*V1 +*3*ZZq YS Z1`T/V\ Z*aWT/d2Y\ bSfE fb\ 2 ]\O `q/ 4 Z*YSD ˙`d4T /d31 ,]WS,*pbn Z* ]\-Wq/S y /dYO VSE k\ e\`Ydpbnaq d Z*j\Yd a1`gTD \Yd ,T/ ,S+\`d /`d4T, h*ab\ 4*W13SbnE qVSYS Wp/nYS YS ab*Z1Y\D L `\hSb*yb1 `S]\,Tab1y 8B67C 57B6>MD

T+WTyZSy ]SanY1ZZSV ˙*,S/ Yd/`\ \+S`*, /`dO 4T,D TZ b\,*`Sjd,*, 4 bSYSE fb\ /\]\Y*-*, y\Yd 4*WSj*bSan Z1]\`\hZSY aWd3Sb1W1Y \-* L a*W\Y 6:B8E 9E 55E 56MD *]`SVW*/E ˙*,S/ /d31 gTZd,*, /`d3+d 4 •\Z*b*Z\YE */31 •\Z*b*Z 4*\f\hd,*, y\O

-\ ]\VW*/*bSaq Z* -\,dD L `\hSb*yb1 5 *Yd^W* 67B5:P5<MD

6D )V ab*bS /`d-\Y \-*H \h* -\,* 2 ,a1Y\-dbZTYE YS Y\31Y\ +dbS y\-\ /`d4qYSD `SYT`\YE ,`**Y ab*, /`d-\Y \-*D 1y h\W\,TV /\,T`q, -\,T T aWdf*,aq y\-\E b\Yd -\,*

,,*3*, y\-\ a,\^Y /`d-\Y L dbbq 66B6E =P56C )V\O ,* 6B65P67MD )Vk\ YS /\,T`q2Y\ -\,T y `\+SY\ b1E k\ ,TZ Z*a ]`\aSbnE b\ b13 Y\31Y\ ab*bS y\-\ /`dO 4qYSD L `\hSb*yb1 a*W\Y 59B5E 6MD

5: "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

7D \Yd YS ]\b`1+d2Y\ f\`\jSf /`d4T,H ]`*,3ZTy /`d- 4*,3/S ,T`ZSy T /\]\Y*-*2 ,*Y ]\,\/SbSan ]`*,SWnZ\ L `S]\,Tab1y 5;B5;C 5<B68MD W*aZ1 b*VSY /`d-\Y +d, •\Z*b*ZD \O h* •\Z*b*Z +d, ]`S+WS4Z\ Z* 7> `\VT, ab*`jSY

,T/ ˙*,S/* T YT- ]\ ]`*,d ab*bS g*`1Y ı4`*^O WpE ,TZ ,T`Z\ ]T/b`SYd,*, ˙*,S/*E `\4dYTphSE k\ a*Y1 gn\-\ h\W\,TV* \- ,S+`*, Z* g*`qD `*,/S,\Yd /`d-\,T ,Sab*hSbn Yd3Z\abT 4`\O +SbS 4*d,*31ZZqE V\WS ,S ]\,\/Sb1an Z1`\4O ad/WS,\ L a*W\Y 585B9MD `Sqb1WnE qVSy WpO +Sbn \-*E /\]\Y*-*bSY1 ,*Y `\4,S,*bS /\+`T 4,ShVSD L `\hSb*yb1 5 \`SZeqZ 59B77MD \4Z*y\YSbSan 4 Wp/nYSE qVT ]\/TWqpbn ,*jd Wp+\, /\ b\-\E k\ ]`*,SWnZ1E ,S Y\31b1 , ˛*WT *`ab,* ,T/VT, -\,SD *Y 4Z*y/1b1 /`d4T,E V\b`T ]T/b`SY*pbn ,*a d ,*jSf ab*`*ZZqf /\-\O

/3*bS \-\,TD L `\hSb*yb1 ,`1^, 5>B68E 69MD * 3*WnE Z*,Tbn /`d4TE qVT Wp+Wqbn \-*E h*a ,T/ h*ad +d/dbn ,*a `\4h*`\,d,*bSD 1 ]\a]TO

j*yb1 \+`*3*bSaq Z* ZSf h1`14 ^fZT ]`\,SZS L˚VVW14Tqab* ;B=E 6>P66MD *YGqb*yb1B 3\/1Z /`d- Z1 2 /\aV\Z*WSYE * /`d-E qVSy Wp+Sbn \O -*E /d31 gTZZSyD \31 W\,\ 4*\f\hd2 Z*a ]`\O k*bS ]\YSWVS \/Z\,T`gT,D L `\hSb*yb1 \W\O aqZ 7B57MD

8D )V +dbSE V\WS w/`d4Tx hSZqbn ,*Y \]T`H

*-*b\ Wp/1y ]\+*hSW\E k\E qV bTWnVS ,\ZS ]`SO yY*pbn /\]\Y\-dE *+S V`*k1 4`\4dYTbS \31 W\O

,\E /1qVT ^fZT /`d4T ]\hSZ*pbn hSZSbS ^Y \]T`D \3WSO ,\E b*VT /`d4T Z1 da,T/\YWppbnE Z*aVTWnVS Yd/`T b*

]`*VbShZT ]\`*/S YTabqbnaq , T+WT^E T Z1 4Z*pbnE k\ ,\Z* /*2 hd/\,d Z*/Tp Z* Y*y+dbZ2D ]`\+dyb1 /\O

]\Y\-bS ^Y 4`\4dYTbS g1D L `\hSb*yb1 \W\aqZ 8B:MD ˙1qVT w/`d4Tx Y\3dbn ,SaYTp,*bS /\+`d Z\,SZdE 4*]Sa*Zd , \3\Yd W\,T L6 1b`* 7B7E 8MD \ZS Y\O 3dbn -Wd4d,*bS 4 ,*jSf ab*`*Zn `\+SbS b1E k\ ]`*O ,SWnZ1 L5 1b`* 8B8MD \/T ,*YE Y*+dbnE /\,1/1bnaq

,S+S`*bSB 4*WSj*bSan ^fZTY /`d-\Y hS +dbS /`d-\Y

\-*D )Vk\ ,S+1`1b1 /`d3+d 4 \-\YE b\ Y*bSY1b1 Z*yV`*k\-\ /`d-*D L `\hSb*yb1 )V\,* 8B8E <MD

TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ ,S 4Z*y/1b1

d 56OYd T 5=OYd `\4/TW*f gT2^ VZS3VSD ZS3V* \]d+WTV\,*Z* ,T/V*YS -\,SD

Z*a]`*,/T & ı ı)H

5;

Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\`* Äą Ë?Ë&#x161; Äą G)

5< "

Ë&#x2122; 5 Ë&#x2122; ) 6>55

´ ´ Decree: Courtesy of the Archivo Historico Provincial, Avila, Spain

& â&#x20AC;˘ V\`\Wn 1`O ,h1ZSf b\-\ h*adE 4*aZ\,O /SZ*Z/ T V\`\W1,* Äą4*O ZSV dZT,1`aSb1bdE V*`/SO +1WW* 58=6 `\Vd ,S/*O Z*W TY1Z1a /1 TaZ1`\aE WS /1V`1bB w S Z*V*4d2Y\ 4*`dhS,aq y\-\ ]T/b`SYO ,aTY 2,`1qY T 2,`1yV*Y 4T V\p , dVW*/*ZZT Y\ZdY1ZO

a,\^YS aSZ*YS y /\hV*O b*WnZ\^ ]`*gT P \Y]WpO

YSE 4T aWd-*YS b* aWd3ZSO b1ZanV\ ^ ]\WT-W\bSD q gqYSE ,aTY 2,`1yanVSY `\O j1abSb\YZ* T+WTq YTabSO /SZ*YE Y*WSY T ,1WSVSYE W* a,qk1ZZT b1VabS 2,`1yO ,aTY ab*`SY T Y\W\/SY /\ anV\pE -`1gnV\pE W*bSZO VTZgq WS]Zq gn\-\ `\Vd anV\p Y\,*YS b* /1qVT Ë&#x2122;Ë&#x161; Ë&#x161; E Ë&#x2122; â&#x20AC;˘ Ë&#x161;

]\VSZdbS Z*j1 V\`\WT,abO d`S,VS *`*Y1yanV\p1D Ë&#x161; ( Äą ĹĹE 58=6 Äą

,\ b* y\-\ ]T/,W*/ZT b1`SO T+W1^ab *`T*Z\ 1,TO

b\`T^xD Wnq TV\E -\,\`qhS ]`\ Ë&#x203A;-T/Z\ 4 /1V`1b\YE V\3O g1y ]`\1VbE 4*d,*3S,B wË&#x203A; Z* 2,`1yanV* `\/SZ* , ÄąaO b`n\f 2,`1yanVSf Z*,1`O

]*ZT ^ Y*W* ,S+T`B ]TbS Z1ZSfE V\b`T /\]\Y*-*O d ,S-Z*ZZq *+\ 4`1VbSaq WS *`/SZ*Wd TaZ1`\ad

a,\2^ `1WT-T^D *++T d*Z , y\-\ `\+\bTE Z*y,S/*bZTO /1 *Y\`*E Z*]1,Z1E ,,*O jSY 2 Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\O 3*,E k\ WT]j1 Z*,1`ZdO `*D TZ Z1 WSj1 e*fT,1gn

bSan Z* V*b\WSgS4Y T 4*O 4 W*bSZanV\^E -`1gnV\^E 2,O

WSjSbSan , Äąa]*ZT ^E Z* `1yanV\^ b* *`*Y1yanV\^E

41YWT a,\^f ]`1/VT,D Ë&#x203A; \-O *W1 y -`*Y*bSabE eTW\O Äą Ë&#x161; Ë&#x161; & OË&#x2122;Ë&#x161;OË&#x161; Ë&#x161; Wq/d Z* 2,`1yanV1 ]\f\O a\e b* 4Z*,1gn *WYd/dxD /31ZZqE d*ZE Y\3WS,\E Ë&#x203A;/\+dbT 4Z*ZZq /\]\Y\-O ,T/]`*,S, a,\-\ aSZ*E Wne\Za\E d YTab\ WS *Y\`T /TybS ,SaZ\,VdB k\+ 4`\+SbS

*Y\`* Z* Z*,h*ZZq d ,T/\YTy jV\WT 4 ,SO b\hZSy ]1`1VW*/ T+WT^E Z1\+fT/Z\ Y*bS

-WS+\V1 `\4dYTZZq Y\, \`S-TZ*WdD Wne\ZO ,h1ZZq 2,`1yanV\^ Y\,SD Ë&#x203A;-\/\Y Wne\Za\ a\ ab*, \/ZSY 4 Z*bfZ1ZZSVT, ,T/`\/31ZZq ab*, /\+`1 \+T4Z*ZSY d W*bSZanVTyE -`1gnO +T+WT24Z*,ab,*E qV1 ]\h*W\ `\4V,Tb*bS d VTy b* *`*Y1yanVTy Y\,*fD Ë&#x203A;*VTZhS,jS Z*O ]1`jTy ]\W\,SZT XVI ab\WTbbqD ,h*ZZqE pZ*V ]\h*, ,SVW*/*bS 2,`1yanVd , *W*Y*ZanV\Yd dZT,1`aSb1bTD 1,/\,4T

/Z*V *Y\`* 3S, d h*aSE V\WS ]\jSO y\-\ Y\,\4Z*,hSy /\a,T/ ab*, gTZZSY Z*O `p,*bS +T+WTyZT 4Z*ZZq +dW\ Z1+14]1hZ\E

/+*ZZqY /Wq +T+W1^abT, daT2^ ,`\]SD \aVTWnVS /d31 *VbS,Z\ /TqW* Ta]*ZanV* TZV,T4SgTqD *b\WSgnV* g1`V,* ,S4Z*,*W* 5956 `\gT Z\,\db,\`1ZSy dZT,1`aSb1b , WnV*W*O/1OË&#x161;Z*`1a ]`S4Z*hS, Wne\Za\

1 TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ ]`\ Tab\`ShZ1 4Z*h1ZZq \Y]O

/1 *Y\`d ]`\e1a\`\Y -1+`*^abSVSD aVTWnO Wpb1ZanV\^ ]\WT-W\bS ,S 4Z*y/1b1 d w *`b\,Ty +*jO VS *Y\`* +d, \/ZSY 4 Z*y]`\-`1aS,ZTjSf bTx 4* 59 V,TbZq 6>>8 `\VdE ab\`TZVS 6<P75D

Äą

1`1VW*/ \3\-\ TY1ZT

˛ ı &"˚ ˚ ˛ ˝˚ ) ˚• & ı ˚ E ) ˚ ˚ wJEHOVAHx

a\+WS,d d,*-d ]`S,1`b*2 b1E qV WnO e\Za\ /1 *Y\`*E ,h1ZSy 2,`1yanV\-\ ]\O f\/31ZZqE b`*ZaWTb1`d,*, TYGq \-*D )V ]\4Z*h1Z\ Z* e\b\-O

`*eT^E d ]`SYTbgT Z* ]\Wqf a,\-\ 2,`1yanO V\OW*bSZanV\-\ ]T/O `q/Z\-\ ]1`1VW*/d VZS-S dbbq *Y\`* Z*]Sa*, \31 TYGq d e\`YT wjehovahxD h1,S/Z\E *Y\`* ,3S,*, g1y ]1`1VW*/

\3\-\ TY1ZT b*V\3 W*bSZ\pD `\bq-\Y XVI ab\WTbbqE V\WS T+WTp ]1`1VW*/*WS \aZ\,O ZSYS 2,`\]1yanVSYS Y\,*YSE g1 *+\ ]\/T+Z1 Z*]Sa*ZZq ]1`1yZqW\ +*-*b\ ]1`1O

VW*/*hT, T+WT^E qVO\bB TWnqY SZ/*Wn L*Z-WTyanV\pE 597>ME 1+*abnqZ pZab1` LW*bSZ\pE 5978ME G2` \+1` WT,1b*Z Le`*Zgd4nV\pE 5979M T *ay\/\`\ /1 1yZ* LTa]*ZanV\pE 59:=MD *Y\`* ab*, \/ZSY 4 ]1`jSf dh1ZSf XVI ab\WTbbqE V\b`T ]`\WS,*WS a,TbW\ Z* TYGq \O -*D \31 TYGq ,SyjW\ 4 d3SbVd ]1`1/daTY h1`14 2,`1yanVT 4*+\+\ZSE qVT 4*+\`\ZqWS

,SY\,WqbS g1 TYGqD T/ ,]WS,\Y 2,`1yanV\^

b`*/SgT^ f`SabSqZanVT ]1`1VW*/*hTE Z*]`SVO

W*/ ı2`\ZTY L]1`1VW*/*h W*bSZanV\^ dWnO -*bSME 4*YTZSWS \31 TYGq b*VSYS bSbdW*YSE qV w \a]\/nx T w \-xD

" ˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

5=

dWn-*bd P W*bSZanVSy ]1`1VW*/ T+O

WT^ P 2/SZSY wdf,*W1ZSYx ,*`T*Zb\Y T+O

WT^D ,bTYE d31 Z* b\y h*a V*b\WSgnVT /\aWT/ZSVS ]\YTbSWSE k\ b1Vab dWn-*bS /*W1V\ Z1 Z*yV`*kSyD * ]\h*bVd XVI ab\O WTbbq Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\`* b* TZjT ]\ab*O Z\,SWS ,S]`*,SbS gp aSbd*gTpD

w˙Wq a]*aTZZq Z*`\/T, Z1\+fT/ZSy ]1`1VW*/x ˛ daTf ]`\1VbT,E Z*/ qVSYS ]`*gp,*, *O Y\`*E Z*y,S4Z*hZTjSYE +14 adYZT,dE +dW\ ,S/*ZZq 2,`1yanV\p Y\,\p VZS- b*`\O

-\ ˛*,Tbd T ^fZTy ]1`1VW*/ W*bSZanV\pD Wne\Za\E yY\,T`Z\E Y*, Z*YT`E k\+ gq ]`*gq ]\aWd3SW* ]`S dVW*/*ZZT \Y]O

Wpb1ZanV\^ ]\WT-W\bSD /SZ 4 y\-\ `dO V\]SaT, LV*b*W\-T4\,*ZSy qV G-IO8M Y\3O Z* 4Z*ybS d +T+WT\b1gT ˚aV\`T*WnE k\ +TWq */`S/*D TZ YTabSbn dap VZS-d dbbq 2,`1yanV\p Y\,\p `*4\Y 4 ]T/`q/V\,SYE 4`\+W1ZSY aW\,\ , aW\,\E ]1`1VW*/\Y Z* W*bSZanVdD ]1`1/Y\,T /\ gn\-\ `dV\]Sad aV*4*Z\B w˙Wq a]*aTZZq Z*`\/T, Z1\+fT/ZSy ]1`1O VW*/ ,qb\-\ SanY* TZjSYS Y\,*YSDDD S ,,*3*2Y\DDD Z1\+fT/ZSYE *+S V\31Z ,TO

`dphSy Y*, /\aWT,ZSy ]1`1VW*/ T+WT^E 4`\+W1ZSy b*VE k\+ /\ V\3Z\-\ 2,`1yanV\O -\ aW\,* +dW\ ]\/*Z\ `T,Z\4Z*hZ1 W*bSZanO V1 aW\,\xD Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\`* Y*, ]\O b`T+Zd ]T/-\b\,VdE k\+ d4qbSaq 4* Z\,Sy ]1`1VW*/ Z* W*bSZanVdE */31 ,TZ +d, ,SO

4Z*ZSY 4Z*,g1Y 2,`1yanV\^D w) Z1 4Z*f\/3d a]\V\p

/Wq a,\2^ /djTx ]1,Z\Yd `\4dYTZZT ıa]*ZTq XVI ab\O WTbbq +dW* T/1*WnZSY YTag1Y /Wq /TO qWnZ\abT b*VSf ,h1ZSfE qV *Y\`*D ˛* h*ad a1`1/Zn\,Thhq ıa]*ZTq ab*W* g1ZbO

`\Y 2,`1yanV\^ VdWnbd`SD w `Sb*ZanVTy

1ZgSVW\]1/T^x -\,\`SbnaqB w 1`1/Zn\,ThO Z* ıa]*ZTq 4 hSaW1ZZSY YdadWnY*ZanO VSY b* 2,`1yanVSY Z*a1W1ZZqY +dW* 2/SZ\p +*-*b\Z*gT\Z*WnZ\p T +*-*b\`1WTO

-TyZ\p V`*^Z\p d ˛*fT/ZTy ,`\]TD *Y1 6> "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

g1y e*Vb \a\+WS,\ ]\a]`Sq, `\4,SbVd `1O

WT-T^E WTb1`*bd`SE YSab1gb,* b* *`fTb1VbdO

`S Ta]*ZanV\^ gS,TWT4*gT^ d ]T4Zn\Yd a1`1/O Zn\,ThhTxD

aVTWnVS , ıa]*ZT^ ]`\3S,*W\ +*-*b\

2,`1^,E `dV\]SaT, T+WT^ 2,`1yanV\p Y\O ,\p +dW\ hSY*W\D ,`1yanVT ]1`1]SadO

,*hT , `T4ZSf h*abSZ*f ıa]*ZT^ ab*`*ZZ\ V\]Tp,*WS gT `dV\]SaSD SYS V\`Sabd,*O WSan ]T/ h*a ]d+WThZ\-\ hSb*ZZq Sa*Zn

d aSZ*-\-*fD D \W/jYT/b d a,\^y VZS3gT

]`\ ]1`jT ,S/*ZZq T+WT^ 2,`1yanV\p 4*O 4Z*h*2E k\ wa1`1/ 2,`1yanVSf ,h1ZSf aW*O ,SWSaq a,\2p b\hZTabp Z1 WSj1 Ta]*Z\O

]\`bd-*WnanVT V\]T^ GqbSVZS33qE *W1 y

Y*ZdaV`S]bSE 4 qVSf gT V\]T^E * b*V\3 ]\O WT-W\b* +dWS ]1`1]Sa*ZTxD

\h* , ıa]*ZT^ TaZd,*WS a]`SqbWS,T dY\O ,SE bTE fb\ +*3*, ]1`1VW*/*bS T+WTpE abSV*WSaq 4 ]`\bS/T2pD 58=6 `\gT V*b\O WSgnV* *`YTq V\`\Wq 1`/SZ*Z/* T V\`\W1O ,S ı4*+1WWS 4*,\p,*W* \ab*ZZp b1`Sb\`Tp

Y*,`T, , ıa]*ZT^D )V 4-*/d,*W\an `*ZTj1E b\-\ 3 `\Vd Y\Z*`fS ,S/*WS Z*V*4E k\+

daTE fb\ b`SY*2bnaq 2,`1yanV\^ `1WT-T^E ]\O VSZdWS ıa]*ZTpD 1`14 5> `\VT, b*VSy a*O YSy dV*4 +d, ,S/*ZSy k\/\ YdadWnY*ZD ˛ b\-\ h*ad V*b\WSgS4Y ab*, /1`3*,Z\p

`1WT-T2p ıa]*ZT^E daT TZjT `1WT-T^ +dWS 4*+\O `\Z1ZTD

)V `1WT-TyZT 4YTZS d V`*^ZT ,]WSZdWS Z*

]1`1VW*/ T+WT^H 1 hTbV\ ,S/Z\ Z* ]`SO VW*/T Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\`SD \h* g1y 1`dO /\,*ZSy 2,`1y Z*,1`Zd,aq Z* V*b\WSgS4YE Ta]*ZanV* `1WT-TyZ* ,1`fT,V* ,]1`b\ ,T/O Y\,WqW*aq 4*+dbS ]`\ y\-\ ]\f\/31ZZqD ˙1qVT ]`\bS,ZSVS \ad/3d,*WS V*`/SZ*W* TaZ1`\a* 4* b1E k\ ,TZ 4*WdhS, 2,`1yanO V\-\ Z*,1`Z1Z\-\ /\ ]`*gT Z*/ a,\2p ]\O WT-W\b\pD *VT 4*VS/S 4*,/*,*WS *Y\`T Z1*+SqV\-\ +\WpD \/Z\Yd `dV\]SaTE k\ 4+1`T-*2bnaq , */`S/anV\Yd dZT,1`aSb1O bTE YTabqbnaq aW\,*E qVT ,TZ 4 adY\Y ]`\O Y\,S,B w)DDD ]\VSZdbSy T 4Z1Z*,S/31ZSy

daTY* a,\^YS /`d4qYSE qVT ab*WS Y1ZT ,\`\O

-*YSE Z1 4Z*f\/3d a]\V\p /Wq a,\2^ /djTE

*ZT \]\`S /Wq a,\2^ Z\-SxD

ı ı˙ )˙ ˚ ˚ ˙

/ZSY 4 y\-\ -\W\,ZSf ,\`\-T, +d, d*Z *,1`*E qVSy ]T4ZTj1 ab*, -1Z1`*WnZSY

TZV,T4Sb\`\Y Ta]*ZanV\^ TZV,T4SgT^D *Y\O `d Z*abTWnVS ,SaZ*3SWS Z*]*/S *,1`SE k\ ,TZ ,S`TjS, 4,1`ZdbSaq /\ ]*]SD y\O -\ WSabT 4\V`1Y* +dW\ aV*4*Z\B w S +W*-*O 2Y\ *aE *j* ,qb\ab1E /\]\Y\-bS Z*YDDD T 4*fSabSbS ,T/ Z*j\-\ ,\`\-*E 2]SaV\]* \W1/\E ˙\Z d*Z* *,1`SD #\/Zq ,TZ +14O d]SZZ\ 4*,/*2 Z*Y dbSaVT,DDD 1 ]`SZ\aSbn Z*Y ,1WSVT ab`*3/*ZZqE */31 , y\-\ \h*f YSE qV fd/\+* Z* +\yZTDDD )Vk\ *j* ,qO ‹ bTabn ]`SaWdf*2bnaq /\ Z*j\-\ ]`\f*ZZqE r)-,1 +d/1 *jSY 4*fSab\Y T Z1 /*abn *O jTy Z\4T a]TbVZdbSaqs L `S]D 7B67Mx1D

1\gTZ1ZZ* a]*/kSZ* *Y\`S 14,*3*phS Z* daT ]1`1jV\/S 4 +\Vd ]`\bS,ZSVT,E *Y\`* ]`\/\,3d,*, a,\p 1 TV*,\E k\ d a,\2Yd 4,1`Z1ZZT /\ ]*]S `SYanV\O -\ *Y\`* ,3S,*2 \31 TYGqE * Z1 bSbdWD Ta]*ZanO V\Yd ]1`1VW*/T gn\-\ 4,1`Z1ZZq \31 TYGq ]\/*Z\ qV w)-,1xD \hZ\ Z1 ,T/\Y\E , qVTy e\`YT ,\Z\ ,3S,*O W\an , \`S-TZ*WnZ\Yd W*bSZanV\Yd b1VabTD `\ ]1`1O VW*/ *Y\`S T b1E qV ,TZ ,3S,*, \31 TYGqE hSb*yb1

d ad]`\,T/ZTy TZe\`Y*gT^ w 1`1VW*/ \3\-\ TY1ZTxE k\ Z* ab\`TZgT 5=D

]`*gpE qV* +dW* /d31 gTZZ\p /Wq bSfE fb\ /\aWT/3d,*, T+WTpD \h* Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\`* Z1 ]1`1VW*, ,qb\-\ SanY* Z* Y\,d Z*`\/dE ,TZ 4*WSjS, Z1\gTZ1ZZSy Z*O +db\V /Wq TZjSf ]1`1VW*/*hT,D #\+ 4+*-O ZdbSE qVSY +d, y\-\ ,Z1a\VE b`1+* ]*YGqb*O

bSE k\ /Wq ]1`1VW*/d T+WT^ ]\b`T+Z\ /,T -`d]S ,h1ZSfD \O]1`j1E ]\b`T+ZT Z*dV\,O gTE V\b`T /\aWT/3dpbn `dV\]SaS a,qk1ZO ZSf ]Sa*Zn Y\,*YS \`S-TZ*Wd P 2,`1yanO V\pE *`*Y1yanV\p b* -`1gnV\pD *V ,\ZS Y\3dbn dVW*abS /\ab\,T`ZSy b1Vab gSYS Y\,*YSD Sj1 b\/T ]1`1VW*/*h Y\31 ,SV\O

`Sab\,d,*bS ^fZTy b1Vab qV \aZ\,d a,\-\ ]1`1VW*/d Z* Y\,d ]`\ab\-\ Z*`\/dD Wne\Za\ /1 *Y\`* +d, ]`\,T/ZSY ,h1O ZSYE qVSy ]T/-\bd,*, T d/\aV\Z*WS, 2,`1yO anVT b1VabSE V\b`T 4`1jb\p +dWS \]d+WTO V\,*ZT , \Y]Wpb1ZanVTy ]\WT-W\bT 5966 `\VdD L•\-\ 2,`1yanV\OW*bSZanVSy aW\,O ZSV T 2,`1yanV* -`*Y*bSV*E qVT ,f\/qbn /\

bT2^ 3 ]`*gTE b*V\3 4Z*hZ\ ]\W1-jdpbn ]`*gp ]1`1VW*/*hT,MD ˚`*4Y \bb1`/*YO anVSyE adh*aZSV *Y\`SE 4/TyaZS, ]\/T+O Z1 4*,/*ZZq P ]T/-\bd,*, b1VabS `1gnO VSf Sa*ZnE b\+b\E qV ]`SyZqb\ Z*4S,*bSE \,\-\ ˛*,TbdD )V bTWnVS gT ]1`1-WqZdbT b1VabS 2,`1yanV\p T -`1gnV\p Y\,*YS ab*O WS /\abd]ZTE TZjT ]1`1VW*/*hT Y\-WS ,4qO bSaq 4* ,*3WS,1 4*,/*ZZq P ]1`1VW*abS T+WTp `T/Z\p Y\,\p ]`\abSf Wp/1yD TO WnqY SZ/*WnE ]1`1VW*/*phS T+WTp Z* *Z-WTyanVdE +d, \/ZSY 4 ]1`jSf ]1`1VW*O /*hT,E qVT aV\`Sab*WSaq 2,`1yanVSY b1VaO

b\Y 4 \Y]Wpb1ZanV\^ ]\WT-W\bSD

"S`\V1 `\4]\,ap/31ZZq T+WT^ , Z*j h*a P Z*yV`*k* ]\/qV* 4* ]`*gp b*VSf h\W\,TVT,E qV *Y\`*E V\b`T ]`Sa,qbSWS a,\2 3SbbqE *+S YS WT]j1 `\4dYTWS ,qb1 SanY\D *Y\`* da,T/\YWp,*,E k\ a]*aTZO Zq Wp/1y ,1WSV\p YT`\p 4*W13Sbn ,T/ b\O -\E Z*aVTWnVS ,\ZS `\4dYTpbn T+WTp T 4*O

ab\a\,dpbn ^^ ]`SZgS]S Lı,*Z* 5;B7MD \Yd Z1\+fT/Z\ ]1`1VW*/*bS T+WTp Z* Y\,SE 4`\4dYTWT Wp/qYD Sj1 b*V +T+WTyZ* ]`*,O /* b\`VZ1bnaq a1`/1gn T `\4dYT, YTWny\ZT, Wp/1yD

" ˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

65

˛ ˚H

˛ ˙ ( &

Courtesy of SDC Colour Experience (www.sdc.org.uk)

˚ )

ı˙ G) ˙˚ ) ı 77

#\ b*V1 V*`Y*4SZE *+\ h1`,1ZnE ]`\ qVSy h*ab\ 4-*/d2bnaq d +T+WTyZTy VZS4T SfT/H ˇ ˛-T/Z\ 4 T+WT2pE g1Zb`\Y ]\VW\O `\ab1 Z* WS4nV\Yd f\/T b* d4+1O

ZTZZq ab*`\/*,ZTf T4`*^WnbqZ +dW* `133T 1`1/41YZ\-\ Y\`qD )aV`*O aVSZTqD ˙Wq ,S-\b\,W1ZZq ]\W\bZ*E ,\Oh1`,\Z* +*`,* YTabSbnaq , qyO

4 qV\-\ `\+SWS ^^ \-\`\3d b* ,\`\b*E gqfE qVT Y*pbn d a,\^f h1`1,gqf

,SV\`Sab\,d,*WS w+W*VSbnE T ]d`]d`E a*YVS h1`,1gT,D * gTy ab*/T^ a*YVS T h1`,1Zn b* adV*ZSy ,Ta\Zx L SO af\3T Z* q-\/SE `\4YT`\Y 4 -\`\O fT/ 6:B5C 7<B5<MD w ,qk1ZZT j*bSx jSZSE ]`SV`T]W1ZT /\ WSabVT, b* -TO a,qk1ZSVT, b*V\3 `\+SWS 4 h1`,1ZT W\h\V /d+*D \Y*f 4+S`*WS ,`dhZd L SfT/ 6<B5P:MD b* ,Sh*,Wp,*WS 4 ZSf +*`,ZSVD \O

*`,ZSV h1`,1ZnE 4,*ZSy b*V\3 bTY y\-\ `\4+*,WqWS ,\/\pE T e*`O V\j1ZTWWpE Y*2 qaV`*,\Oh1`,\ZSy +* -\b\,*D SYanVSy Tab\`SV WTZTy V\WT`D •\-\ /\+d,*pbn 4T a*Y\V V\O b*`jSy ]Sa*,E k\ 4* y\-\ h*O Y*f h1`,1gT, LTZj* Z*4,* P V\j1O ad h1`,1Zn ,,*3*,aq /d31 /\`\-SY ZTWnMD T V\Y*fS 3S,dbn Z* V\j1ZTO +*`,ZSV\YD W1,\Yd /d+T LQuercus cocciferaME qVSy b\ 4 ]SanY1ZZSVT, `SabSqZanVSf `1gnVSf Sa*Zn +d, ]`SadbZTY Z* a,qbT GqbS/1aqbZSgT 77 `\Vd ZD 1DH ˇ \3Z* 4`\+SbS ,SaZ\,\VE k\ b*Y dbTV ,T/ bSfE fb\ ,Z\hT ]`Syj\, 4*O +dW\ j1ab1`\ 4 ,\anYS ]SanY1ZZSO *`1jbd,*bS ıada*D h1,S/Z\E *`V\

VT, gT2^ h*abSZS T+WT^D Y*, Z* d,*4T a1+1E */31 Z* Y\Y1Zb

˛-T/Z\ 4 VZS-\p ˙T^E ıada aV*4*, *`1jbd TZjT dhZT ,31 ]\VSZdWS ıadO dhZqYB w 1 ,Sf\/nb1 4 `da*WSY*E a* L *`V* 58B9>P96MD *`V\E yY\O * h1V*yb1 b\-\E k\ \+Tgq, *bnV\x ,T`Z\E Z*W13*, /\ Z*y]1`jSf dhZT,

L˙T^ 5B8MD bTy 31 VZS4T `\4]\,TO TE Y\3WS,\E +d, ]`SadbZTY Z* a,qbT /*2bnaqE k\ Y*y+dbZT ]SanY1ZZSVS GqbS/1aqbZSgTD

T+WT^ P *b,TyE ı,*Z T 1b`\ P #1 /,\Y* ]SanY1ZZSV*YS `SaO ]\aWdf*WSan gn\-\ Z*V*4d b* 4T+`*O bSqZanVSf `1gnVSf Sa*Zn +dWS WSan w, \/Z\Yd /\YTx `*4\Y 4 TZjSO *,W\ b* dV*D 77 `\gT ZD 1D *,O YS dhZqYSD 1`1/ bSf dhZT, +dWS W\ k1 Z1 +d, f`SabSqZSZ\Y L *W*bT, )VT, b* (/* LZ1 ıaV*`T\bME qVT ]T4ZTO 5B5;E 5<MD dV*E Z*]1,Z1E b13 Z1 +d, j1 Z*]Sa*WS /,T +T+WTyZT VZS-SE Z*O Z* a,qbT GqbS/1aqbZSgT 77 `\Vd ZD 1DE

4,*ZT ^fZTYS TY1Z*YS L *b,Tq 57B99C \aVTWnVS Z1 -\,\`S, ]`\ a1+1 qV ]`\ )V\,* 5B5C (/S 5MD \h1,S/gq ıada\,\-\ aWd3TZZq L dVS

*`V\ d a,\2Yd ,*Z-1WT^ `\4]\O 5B5P7MD ,T/*2 ]`\ Y\W\/\-\ h\W\,TV*E qVSy

66 "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

w *a V\f*bS ı ˚ ˙ı x

2 Wp+\,xD /1qVSf V`*^Z*f Wp/S +1`dbn gp e`*4d , `*YVd T ,S,Tjdpbn

Z* abTZT d a,\^y VTYZ*bTD ı Z1/*`Y*E */31 , ZTy ]1`1/*Z\ adbn b\-\E k\ \- 2 d\a\+O W1ZZqY Wp+\,TD * 3*WnE hSY*W\ Wp/1y Z1 4Z*2E k\ gT

aW\,* ,4qb\ 4 T+WT^D ıf 4*]Sa*, *]\ab\W ı,*ZB w b\ Z1 Wp+SbnE b\y \-* Z1 ]T4Z*,E \aVTWnVS \- 2 Wp+\,x L5 ı,*Z* 8B<MD ı,*Z b*V\3 ]\qaZS,E k\ a*Y1 4 Wp+\,T \- /*, 4* Wp/ab,\ ,SVd]B w \- b*V ]\Wp+S, a,TbE k\ ,T//*, a,\-\ 2/SZ\`\/Z\-\ SZ*E *+S V\31ZE fb\ ,Sq,Wq2E k\ ,T`Sbn d Zn\-\E Z1 +d, 4ZSk1ZSyE * \b`SY*, 3Sbbq ,ThZ1x Lı,*Z* 7B5:MD ˛Z*phS ]`\ g1E /1fb\ Y\31 /dY*bSE k\ \- -\b\,Sy ]`\k*bS +d/nOqVT Z*jT ]`\O abd]VS T -`TfSD *VT Wp/S ,,*3*pbnE ZT+S

\- Z1 ]`Sbq-Z1 ^f /\ ,T/]\,T/*WnZ\abTE f\h +S k\ ,\ZS hSZSWSD W1 hS b*VSy ]\O -Wq/ ]`*,SWnZSyH S \- Wp+Sbn daTf P /\+`Sf T 4WSfH S +d,*2 b*V1E k\ \- Z1O Z*,S/Sbn V\-\an *+\ k\anH

w

S Y\31 \- Wp+\,T Z1Z*,S/TbSH d/`Sy g*` \W\Y\Z aV*4*,B w˙Wq ,an\O -\ a,Ty h*aE T -\/SZ* a,\q V\3ZTy a]`*,T ]T/ Z1+\YDDD h*a V\f*bS T h*a Z1Z*,S/TbSx L˚VVW14Tqab* 7B5E <MD ˛-T/Z\ 4 gSYS aW\,*O YS \- Y\31 Z1Z*,S/TbSE f\h* ,TZ 2 /\+O `SY b* ,Sq,Wq2 Wp+\,D

qV\Yd `\4dYTZZT T+WTq ,3S,*2 aW\O ,\ wZ1Z*,S/TbSxH 1,ZSy +T+WTyZSy /\O ,T/ZSV 4*4Z*h*2B w ,qb\Yd SanYT 4Z*h1ZZq aW\,* rZ1Z*,S/TbSs Y*2 VTWnV* ,T/bTZVT,D \Z\ Y\31 \4Z*h*bS aSWnZd ,\O `\3TabnE ]\abTyZd Z1]`Sq4ZnE qV* Z1`T/V\ ad]`\,\/3d2bnaq 4W\+\pD *V* Z1Z*,Sabn Y\31 +dbS `dyZT,ZSY ]\hdbbqYE qV1 ]\`\O /3d2 , Wp/SZT +*3*ZZq 4*,/*bS jV\/S b\YdE V\-\ ,\Z* Z1Z*,S/SbnxD W*aZ1 g1 4Z*h1ZZq aW\,* wZ1Z*,S/TbSx a]*/*2 Z* /dYVdE V\WS YS y\-\ hd2Y\E T ]\ gTW\Yd

a,TbT ,T/hdbZT Z*aWT/VS b*V\^ Z1Z*,SabTD `\b1 , b\Yd 3 /\,T/ZSVd ]\qaZp2bnaqB w 1 aW\,\ b*V\3 Y\31 ]1`1/*,*bS /dYVd ]`\ aSWnZd *ZbS]*bTpD W1 b*V* *ZbS]*O bTq Z1 ad]`\,\/3d2bnaq Z*YT`\Y 4*,/*bS

jV\/S \+G2Vbd a,\2^ Z1Z*,SabTxD gTy ab*bbT y/1bnaq ,W*aZ1 ]`\ b*V1 4Z*h1ZZq aW\,* wZ1Z*,S/TbSxD \Z\ ab\O

ad2bnaq Z*/4,Sh*yZ\^ ,T/`*4S b* gTWV\O

,Sb\^ \-S/S /\ V\-\an *+\ h\-\anE * Z1 4W\+SE Z1]`Sq4ZT hS +*3*ZZq 4*]\/TqbS jV\/dD S \- Y\31 Y*bS b*Vd Z1Z*O ,SabnH ˛,1`ZTbn d,*-d Z* aW\,* 4 `SO ]\,Tab1y :B5:P5=B w gSf jTabn Z1Z*,SO /Sbn \a]\/nE * gT aTY P b\ -S/\b* /djT •\-\B \hT ]SjZTE +`1fWS,Sy q4SVE T `dO VSE k\ V`\, Z1]\,SZZd WWpbnE a1`g1E k\ ]W1V*2 4W\hSZZT /dYVSE Z\-SE k\ aV,*]O Z\ +T3*bn Z* WSf1E a,T/\V +`1fWS,SyE k\

w gSf jTabn Z1Z*,S/Sbn \a]\/nE * gT aTY P b\ -S/\b* /djT •\-\B \hT ]SjZTE +`1fWS,Sy q4SVE T `dVSE k\ V`\, Z1]\,SZZd WWpbnE a1`g1E k\ ]W1V*2 4W\hSZZT /dYVSE Z\-SE k\ aV,*]Z\ +T3*bn Z* WSf1E a,T/\V +`1fWS,SyE k\ +`1fZT `\4/Ydfd2E T fb\ `\4aT,*2 a,*`VS YT3 +`*bT,x L ı ˚• :B5:P5=M

" ˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

67

w)Vk\E \b`SY*,jS b\hZ1 4Z*ZZq ]`*,/SE YS a,T/\Y\ f\/SY\ , -`TfdE b\ ,31 Z1 4*WSj*2bnaq 31`b,S 4* -`TfSE * qV1an ab`*jZ1

\hTVd,*ZZq ad/dx L ˚ı 5>B6:E 6;M

*bnV\ 4 Wp+\,Gp ,Sf\,d2 /SbSZdE

+\ +*3*2 ^y /\+`*

+`1fZT `\4/Ydfd2E T fb\ `\4aT,*2 a,*`VS YT3 +`*bT,xD ˛ gSf aWT, ,S/Z\E k\ ]1,ZT ,hSZVS \Z1Z*,S/SbnD a1 3 ,TZ Z1 \+\,Gq4V\,\ Z1O

Z*,S/Sbn Wp/SZdE qV* ^f hSZSbnD \- +1`1 /\ d,*-S \+ab*,SZSE k\ ]\YGqVjdpbn ]`\O ,SZdE b*VT qVB ]W\banVT aW*+V\abTE dY\,S 3SbbqE Z*aWT/VS ,Sf\,*ZZq hS Z1,T-W*abO ,\ L dbbq <B65C SYWqZ 9B56MD SanY1ZZSV VZS-S `S]\,Tab1y ]\qaZS, g1E 4`\+S,jS b*V1 ]\`T,ZqZZqB w \-\ \a]\/n Wp+SbnE V*`b*2 b\-\E T V\f*2E Z1Y\, +*bnV\ aSZ*x L `S]\,Tab1y 7B56MD *bnVS Y\3dbn Z1Z*O ,S/TbS ]\-*ZT ,hSZVS /SbSZSE *W1 ,\ZS y

/*WT Wp+Wqbn ^^ b* ab*`*pbnaq ,S]`*,SbS ,Sf\,ZSYS 4*f\/*YS Z1]`*,SWnZd ]\,1O

/TZVdD *V a*Y\ -\,*B ,TZ d a,\^y Wp+\,T `\+Sbn da1 Y\3WS,1E k\+ -`TjZSV Y*, 4Y\-d \b`SY*bS a]*aTZZqD

\WS 2 ]T/ab*,S /Wq Z1Z*,SabT #\E V\WS fb\an 4Z*2 \3d ,\WpE *W1 Z1

+*3*2 ^^ ,SV\Zd,*bSH *V* Wp/SZ* Y\31 a]\/T,*bSan Z1 Z* Wp+\, \-*E * Z* y\-\ 68 "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

\ad/D )Vk\ fb\an a,T/\Y\ hSZSbn b1E k\ -\,* Z1Z*,S/SbnE b\ gSY ,SVWSV*2 •\-\

Z1Z*,SabnD T+WT^ aV*4*Z\B w \a]\/n ,SO ]`\+\,d2 ]`*,1/Z\-\E * +14+\3Z\-\ y b\-\E fb\ Wp+Sbn Z*aSWWqEP Z1Z*,S/Sbn /dj*

•\-\x L a*W\Y 55B9MD ˙Wq b*V\^ Z1`\4V*qO

Z\^ Wp/SZS Z1 TaZd2 ]`\k1ZZqD `\ g1 hTbO V\ aV*4*Z\ , SabT *]\ab\W* *,W* /\ 2,`1yanVSf f`SabSqZB w)Vk\E \b`SY*,jS b\hZ1 4Z*ZZq ]`*,/SE YS a,T/\Y\ f\/SY\ , -`TfdE b\ ,31 Z1 4*WSj*2bnaq 31`b,S 4* -`TfSE * qV1an ab`*jZ1 \hTVd,*ZZq ad/d T ]*Wph* `1,ZTabnE k\ -\b\,* ]\31`bS ]`\O

bS,ZSVT,x L ,`1^, 5>B6:E 6;MD \Yd \- WpO +\,T b*V ab*,Sbnaq /\ 4*bqbSf -`TjZSVT,H \WS fb\an a,T/\Y\ hSZSbn bq3VT -`TO fSE ,\ZS Y\3dbn ab*bS Z1,T/G2YZ\p h*abSZ\p y\-\ \a\+Sab\abTD *Vd WpO /SZd Y\3Z* ,,*3*bS ,V`*y 4T]a\,*Z\p b* Z1,S]`*,Z\pD T+WTq ]`S`T,Zp2 Z1O `\4V*qZ\-\ -`TjZSV* /\ W1\]*`/*E qVSy

Z1 , ab*ZT ]\4+dbSaq a,\^f ]WqY L `1YT^ 57B67E MD *VSy -`TjZSV hSZSbn b1E k\

, T+WT^ Z*4,*Z\ w,ThZSY -`Tf\YxE 4* qVSy d31 Z1Y*2 ]`\k1ZZq L *`V* 7B6=MD 1,S]`*,ZSYS -`TjZSV*YS +dWS /*Y T ,*E * b*V\3 (/* ıaV*`T\bD \- ab,\`S, /*Y* 4 ,\p /\aV\Z*WSYS T hTbV\ ]\]1O

`1/S, ^f ]`\ Z*aWT/VS -`Tf*D \ZS /\+`1 `\4dYTWS \3Sy Z*V*4D /*Y 4 ,\p 4-`TO jSWS a,T/\Y\ T Z*,YSaZ\E b\Yd Z1 Y\-WS a]\/T,*bSan ]`\k1ZZqD \WS ]T4ZTj1 /\ ZSf ]`\Y\,Wq, \-E b\ Z1 ]`\]\Zd,*, `\4O V*qbSaq L dbbq 7B5:P68MD (/* +d, Z1/\O aV\Z*WSYE *W1 h*ab\ ]1`1+d,*, d b\,*O `Sab,T ıada* `Sab*D \]`S g1 ,TZ ab*, 4`*/ZSV\YD ıada Z*4,*, y\-\ waSZ\Y 4*-SO +1WTx Lı,*Z* 5;B56MD T+WTq b*V\3 ]\V*O

4d2E k\ Ë&#x2122;Sq,\W 2 4*V\`1ZTWSY -`TjZSV\YE qV\-\ h1V*2 WSj1 4ZSk1ZZq L5 ı,*Z* 7B<C

+Gq,W1ZZq 56B56MD aT gT \a\+S ,SVWSV*WS \3d Z1Z*,SabnD * Z*a ]\bTj*2 4Z*ZZq ]`\ b1E k\ Z1 V\O 31Z -`TjZSV 2 ]`\]*kSYD -\,* /d31 b1`O ]1WS,Sy T Z1 ]`*-Z1 V*`*bS bSfE fb\ -`TO

jSbn h1`14 Z14Z*ZZq L 41VT^Wq 77B55MD TZ

4*]`\jd2 ^f ]\V*qbSaq y \b`SY*bS ]`\O

k1ZZqD ıa*^ 99B; aV*4*Z\B w *y +14+\3O

ZSy ]\VSZ1 /\`\-d a,\pE * V`dbTy P a,\^ 4*/dYSE T f*y /\ \a]\/* 4,1`Z1bnaqEP T y\-\ TZ ]\YSWd2E T /\ Z*j\-\ \-*E +\ TZ ]`\+*h*2 +*-*b\xD

`*,SWnZSy ]\-Wq/ Z* Wp+\, T Z1Z*,Sabn `*,/S,T f`SabSqZS Y*pbn Z*aWT/d,*O bS \-*D \Yd b`1+* `\4dYTbSE V\WS 2 wh*a V\f*bSxE * V\WS P wh*a Z1Z*,S/TO bSxD )Vk\ Z*/b\ ]T//*,*bSan ]\hdbbqYE b\ Y\3Z* Y*bS ,SV`S,W1ZSy ]\-Wq/ Z* Wp+\, T YSW\a1`/qD `*,SWnZ\ `\4dYTbSE k\ b*V1 YSW\a1`/q T k\ b*V1 Z1Z*,Sabn /\ -`Tf*E /\]\Y*-*pbn aW\,*B w `\/\,O 3dyb1 ,Sq,WqbS YSW\a1`/q bSYE fb\ Y*2

adYZT,SC `qbdyb1 ^fE ,Sf\]WpphS 4 ,\-O ZpD W1 ,Sq,Wqyb1 YSW\a1`/q y TZjSYE `\+WqhS g1 4T ab`*f\Y T +`S/qhSan Z*,Tbn a]T/ZTY \/q-\YE 4*]WqY\,*ZSY ]W\bbpx L(/S 66E 67MD b31E b`1+* Z1Z*,S/TbS 4W\E * Z1 Wp/SZdE qV* y\-\ hSZSbnD `SabSqZ*Y b*V\3 Z*V*4*Z\ ,Sq,WqbS

Wp+\, /\ a,\^f ,\`\-T,E hSZqhS /Wq ZSf /\+`\D ıada aV*4*,B w 1 ]1`1ab*,*yb1 WpO

+SbS a,\^f ,\`\-T, T Y\WSbSaq 4* a,\^f -\O ZSb1WT,x L *b,Tq 9B88MD an h\Yd ,T/VS -\,S Z1 ]1`1ab*pbn ]`\]\,T/d,*bS /\+`d

Z\,SZd ]`\ \31 *`ab,\ a,\^Y +WS3ZTY

w *y +14+\3ZSy ]\VSZ1 /\`\-d

a,\pE * V`dbTy P a,\^ 4*/dYSE T f*y /\ \a]\/* 4,1`Z1bnaqEP T y\-\ TZ ]\YSWd2DDD TZ

]`\+*h*2 +*-*b\x Lı ı 99B;M

]\]`S b1E k\ Z1 ,aT Wp/S ]`SyY*pbn ^^ L *b,Tq 68B58MD ab*,W1ZZT /\ Wp/1y ,T/O VS ab*`*pbnaq /\b`SYd,*bSaq +T+WTyZSf ]`SZgS]T,E b\Yd ,,*3*pbn V\3Z\-\ -T/O ZSY Wp+\,T b* YSW\a1`/q -\,SD *,Tbn V\WS fb\an Z1 gTZd2 4daSWn ]`\]\,T/ZSVT, *+\ ab*,Sbnaq /\ ZSf 4 Z1Z*,Sabp hS ]1`1O

aWT/d2 ^fE ,\ZS aWdf*pbnaq ]\`*/S *]\ab\O W* *,W*B w W*-\aW\,Wqyb1 bSfE fb\ ,*a ]1`1aWT/d2E +W*-\aW\,Wqyb1E * Z1 ]`\VWSO Z*yb1DDD TV\Yd Z1 ,T//*,*yb1 4W\Y 4* 4W\x L SYWqZ 56B58E 5;MD ,T/VS ]*YGqb*pbnE k\ WSj1 -\,* ,S4Z*hSbnE fb\ 4*aWd-\,d2 y\O -\ Wp+\,TE * fb\ P Z1Z*,SabTD Sj1 ,TZ Y\31 ,SZ1abS \ab*b\hZSy ,S`\V d a]`*,T

3Sbbq T aY1`bT L ,`1^, 5>B7>MD 14]1`1hZ\E w \- 2 Wp+\,xD *Y b`1+* +dbS -WS+\V\ ,/qhZSYS 4* y\-\ Wp+\, T kS`\ Z*Y*-*bSaq k1 +TWnj1 ]T4Z*,*bS y\O

-\ ,\Wp b* ,SV\Zd,*bS ^^D ,T/VS -\,S d ,*jTy YTag1,\abT 4 `*/Tabp /\]\Y\3dbn ,*Y /\,T/*bSan 4T ,qb\-\ SanY*E , h\Yd ]\Wq-*2 \3* ,\Wq T qV 3SbS 4-T/Z\ 4 Z1pD Ë&#x203A;*,/qVS gn\Yd ,S 4Y\31b1 dZSVZdbS \O

3\^ Z1Z*,SabT y ,T/hdbS y\-\ Wp+\,D SY*W\ ,Gq4ZT, a]T4Z*WS

\3d Wp+\, T YSW\a1`/q

˝ • & ˙

w ,qbE a,qbE a,qb \a]\/nx # ,*a ]\]`\aSbS \/ZSY aW\,\Y \]SO a*bS \a\+SabTabn \-* -\,SE b\ qV1 aW\O ,\ ,S ,S+1`1b1H VIII ab\`ThhT /\ ZD 1D ]`\`\V ıa*q \b`SY*, ,S/TZZqE , qV\Yd hd, -\W\O aS /df\,ZSf Tab\bD \ZS aW*,SWS -\,d aW\O ,\YE qV1 ]1`1/*,*W\ adbn y\-\ \a\+Sab\aO bT P a,qbTabnD 1E k\ ıa*q +*hS, T hd,E Y*2 a]\,ZqbS Z*a -WS+\V\p j*Z\p /\ -\,S T Z*O

+WS3*bS /\ Zn\-\D \4-Wq/*phS aW\,* 4 ıa*^ :B5P7E dq,TbnE ZT+S ,S a*YT +*hSb1 g1 ,SO /TZZqD w *hS, q \a]\/*E k\ aS/T, Z* ,Sa\V\Yd b* ]T/Z1a1Z\Yd ]`1ab\WTxEP `\4]\,T/*2 ıa*q L,T`j 5MD *a]`*,/T ]`\`\V Z1 +*hS, -\,SE */31 +dV,*WnZSYS \hSY* Z1Y\3WS,\ +*hSbS

b\-\E fb\ 2 /df\,ZSYD T+WT^ hTbV\ aV*4*Z\B w Tfb\ 4 Wp/1y \-* ZTV\WS Z1 +*hS,x Lı,*Z*

5B5<MD ıa*q +*hS, ,S/TZZq1D W1 /Wq ıa*^ ,SO /TZZq +dW\ /d31 qaV`*,SY T `1*WnZSYD `\O `\V +d, ]T/ b*VSY ,`*31ZZqYE k\ aV*4*,B w *hS, q \a]\/*xD b\Yd 3 ,S/TZZT ıa*q ]\+*hS, b1E k\ TZjT Wp/SE 4/*2bnaqE Z1 +*hSWS d ,S/TZZqfD TZ Z*O ]Sa*,B w 1`*eSYS ab\qWS 4,1`fd •\-\ -\O ,S E ]\ jTabn V`SW d V\3Z\-\B /,\Y* 4*V`SO ,*, \+WShhq a,\2E T /,\Y* 4*V`S,*, Z\-S

a,\^E * /,\Y* WTb*,x L,T`j 6MD 1`*eSYS P g1 /df\,ZT Tab\bSE qVT 4*yY*pbn /d31 ,Sa\V1

ab*Z\,Sk1D ˛ daTf ]SanY1ZZSVT, T+WT^ ]`\ ZSf 4-*/d2 WSj1 ıa*qD T Tab\bS 4*,3/S -\b\,T ,SO V\Zd,*bS Z*V*4S T ,\Wp \-*D \ZS 4*V`S,*O

pbn a,\^ \+WShhq T Z\-SE ]\V*4dphS gSYE k\ -WS+\V\ ]\,*3*pbn \-\E V\Yd Y*pbn h1abn aWd3SbSD

)

1 w \WS \- /*,*, Wp/SZT ,S/TZZq Z1 d,T aZTE ,\Z\ 4Gq,WqO

W\an , ^^ a,T/\Y\abTD T4ZTj1 g1 ,S/TZZq Y\3Z* +dW\ a\+T Z*O -*/*bS T `\4]\,TabS TZjSY *+\ 4*]Sa*bS ,W*aZSYS aW\,*YSxD L `*gq w `\ZSVWS,Tabn d adbn ,qb\-\ SanY*xE \]d+WTV\O ,*Z* ,T/V*YS -\,SMD

6: "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

‹ ıa*q , 4*f,*bT Z1 WSj1 ,T/ b\-\E k\ +*hSbnE ‹ *W1 y ,T/ b\-\E k\ hd2D TZ hd2 Z1+1aZSy f\` a1`*eSYT,E qVT -\W\aZ\ a]T,*pbnD ıa*q ]Sj1B w WSV*, \/SZ /\ \/Z\-\ y -\,\`S,B r ,qbE a,qbE a,qb \a]\/n *,*\bsx L,T`j 7MD ,O `1yanV1 aW\,\E ]1`1VW*/1Z1 qV wa,qbxE Z1a1 /dYVd ]`\ hSab\bd T Z1]\`\hZTabnD 1 aW\,\ b*V\3 ,V*4d2 Z* w]\,Zd a,\+\/d T ,T/\V`1YO W1ZTabn ,T/ -`Tf*xD 1`*eSYS b`ShT ,Sa]T,dO

˛Z*phSE k\ -\,* a,qbSyE YS ]\,SZZT 4 daTf aSW Z*+WS3*bSaq /\ Zn\-\

pbn aW\,\ wa,qbxE Y\3WS,\E *ZbSe\Z\YE b\+O b\ ]\h1`-\,\E ]T/V`1aWpphS gSYE k\ -\,* Z*ya,qbTjSy Z*/ daTY* L +Gq,W1ZZq 8B<MD bO 31E a,qbTabn 2 y\-\ ,S4Z*hZ\p `Sa\pD -\,* 2 Z1]\`\hZSyE hSabSy T +14/\-*ZZSyD ˛Z*phSE k\ -\,* a,qbSyE YS ]\,SZZT 4 daTf aSW Z*+WS3*bSaq /\ Zn\-\D \YdH * ,T/YTO Zd ,T/ Wp/anVSf ]`*,Sb1WT,E qVT h*ab\ ab*pbn V\`dY]\,*ZSYS T 4W\,3S,*pbn ,W*/\pE -\O ,* Z1 Y*2 ZTh\-\ a]TWnZ\-\ 4 -`Tf\YD •\-\ a,qbTabn 2 4*]\`dV\p b\-\E k\ ,TZ 4*,3/S +dO /1 Z*yWT]jSY *bnV\YE a]`*,1/WS,SY `*O ,Sb1W1Y T +14ab\`\ZZTY d//1pD S Y*2Y\ ,aT ]T/ab*,S +dbS ]1,ZSYSE k\ \-E qVSy 2 Z*y,Sk\p YT`\p a,qbSYE ZTV\WS Z1 `\4h*O `d2 Z*aD

˙ ı • ˚ ı ı• •

˛ ıa*^ 5P67

) ı E )

ı ˙ ˛ ı ˙˝

#1 , ]T/WTbV\,\Yd ,TgT , Y1Z1 4Gq,SW\an +*3*ZZq P +dbSE

qV ıeb*f\,* /\hV*D \hd `\4]\,TabSE k\ g1 \4Z*h*2 T qV ,/*W\aq

/\aq-ZdbS gT2^ Y1bSD

˚ "˚ Z* V\Z-`1aT ,T/VT, -\,S q ]\O +d,*W* 5=9: `\Vd , TZ/TyanV\Yd YTabT

\Y+1^ Lb1]1` dY+*yMD \y V\Z-`1a 4YTO ZS, da1 Y\2 3SbbqD a\+WS,\ 4,\`djSW* ]`\Y\,* ]`\ ıeb*f\,d /\hVdD

SE Y\3WS,\E hSb*WS , T+WT^ `\4]\,T/n

]`\ b1E qV ıeb*f\,* /\hV*E k1 +d/dhS , pZ\Yd ,TgTE ]\-\/SW*aq Z1 ,Sf\/SbS 4*O

YT3D ˛*,/qVS gn\Yd `Tj1ZZp ^^ +*bnV\ YT,SV\Z*bS \+TgqZVdE /*Zd \-\,TD \3 /\hO

V* ıeb*f* ,a1 a,\2 3Sbbq aWd3SW* , /\YTE b\+b\ a,qbSZTE -\,SE 4*WSj*phSan Z14*O YT3Zn\p L d//T, 55B6<P8>MD

) /d31 ]`*-ZdW* +dbSE qV ıeb*f\,* /\hO V*D W1 TaZd,*W* \/Z* ,1WSV* ]`\+W1Y* P

d bT `\VS , ıZ/T^ ,,*3*W\an ]\`dj1ZZqY

b`*/SgT^E V\WS /T,hSZ* 4*WSj*W*an Z14*O YT3Zn\pD

\q `\/SZ* ) +dW* ]Gqb\p 4 j1abS /Tb1y 1Z/3*YTZ* T *`a1WTZS \*ZaT,E qVT 3SWS , YTabT /TO

]TE k\ Z* 4*fT/Z\Yd d4+1`133T ıZ/T^D *O j* `T/Z* Y\,* P bdWdE Z1p `\4Y\,Wqpbn +WS4nV\ /,\f YTWny\ZT, Wp/1yD `\b1E qV T +TWnjTabn Y1jV*ZgT, /T]TE , jV\WT YS ‹ Z*,h*WSan Y\,\p V*Z*/*D Z*jTy YTag1,\abT ,,*3*W\aqE k\ d 3SbbT Z*y,*3WS,Tj1 \/`d3SbSaq T Z*`\O /SbS /Tb1yD /SbSZab,T q Z*,Tbn Z1 hdW* aW\,* Y\,\p bdWdE qV1 + \4Z*h*W\ w+14O jWp+ZTabnxE wa*Y\bZTabnx *+\ wbd-* 4* /\O Y\YxD ˛/*,*W\anE ZT+S b*V\-\ bdb ,4*-*WT Z1 +d,*2D Z*j\Yd /\YTE ]`SYT`\YE 3SWS

/T/daT 4 +*+daqYSE /q/nVS y bTbVS b* 4 /1O aqb\V /,\p`T/ZSf +`*bT, T a1ab1`D ˛* b`*/SgT2p Z*j\-\ Z*`\/d , `\/SZT ]*Zd,*W* ]1,Z* e\`Y* Y*b`T*`f*bd P `\O

/\,T/ ,T,aq ]\ Y*b1`SZanVTy WTZT^D \Yd /\hVS \b`SYd,*WS +TWnjd h*abSZd a]*/O VdD bdb1jZTf a1W*f /T,hSZ*E ,Syj\,jS 4*YT3E ]`\/\,3d,*W* 3SbS 4 Y*Y\pE * h\O

W\,TV ]`Sf\/S, 3SbS /\ ^fZn\-\ /\YdD

aVTWnVS Z*j* `\/SZ* a]\,T/d,*W* f`SabSqZab,\E , /\YT +dWS b`\fS TZjT ]\O `q/VSD #\,1h\`* /T/dan ]`\,\/S, a,\-\ `\/d +\-\aWd3TZZq P Y\WS,aq T ,-\W\a hSO b*, T+WTp Y\,\p bdWdD \WS ,TZ `\4-\`O b*, a,\p ]\j*`]*Zd T+WTpE Z*Y 4/*,*O W\anE ZT+S ,TZ ,T/V`S,*, aV*`+ZShVdD aT YS +dWS , 4*f,*bTI a\+WS,\ Y1Z1 4*gTV*O ,S, a*W\Y 67B5 L ME /1 aV*4*Z\B w -\O ,* P YTy *abS`E b\3 Y1ZT Z1 +`*Vd2 ZTh\O -\xD ) 4*]Sbd,*W* a1+1B w b\ b*VSy -\,* T h\Yd ,TZ Z*4,*ZSy *abS`1YHx

T+S WdaV* ,T/]*W* ,T/ Y\^f \h1y

TaWq 4*VTZh1ZZq ˙`d-\^ a,Tb\,\^ ,TyZS

3Sbbq +dW\ /d31 ,*3VSYE \b31 YS ]1`1^O f*WS /\ YTab* \Y+1qE k\ 4* =>> VTW\O Y1b`T, ,T/ Z*j\-\ /\YdD *Y 5=89 `\Vd /\ +*bnV* ]`SyjWS /,\2 ,T/VT, -\,S T /*WS y\Yd +T+WTyZd +`\jd`VdD *bnV\ 3*/T+Z\ ]`\hSb*, +`\jd`VdE ]\/T+Z\ qV a]`*-W* 41YWq 3*/T+Z\ ,a\bd2 ,\/dD TZ \/`*4d ]\h*, /TWSbSaq 4/\+dbSYS 4Z*ZO ‹ ZqYS 4 Wp/nYSE qVT `\4Y\,WqWS V*Z*O /*D \abd]\,\ db,\`SW*an Z1,1WSV* -`d]*D

" ˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

6;

* ]\h*bVd 5=9>Of ,\Z*

ab*W* ]1`jSY d \Y+1^ 4+\`\YE /1 4T+`*ZZq ]`\O ,\/SWSan gT2p Y\,\pD *b\ 4 Y*Y\p Z*,h*WS Z*aE /Tb1yE 4*]\]*/WS,\ /\aWT/3d,*bS \31 W\O ,\ T +dbS /\+`SYS ,hSO b1WqYS +T+WTyZSf TabSZD #\/Zq ,\ZS 4Z*f\/SWS Z*-\/S Y\WSbSaq T ,SO ,h*bS 4 Z*YS L \,b\`1ZO Zq ˛*V\Zd :B:E ;C 6 SO *bnV\ ,Sabd]*2 Y\eTq 7B58P5:MD )V\anE 4 ]`\Y\,\p

]T/ h*a hSb*ZZq T+WT^E , \Y+1^E

5=9>ObT `\VS 4 Y\^f \h1y ZT+S WdaV*

,T/]*W* L˙T^ =B5<MD ) 4`\O 4dYTW*E h\Yd -\,* ]`S`T,Zp2bnaq /\ ]*aO bS`qD /31 ,TZ ,1/1E -\/d2 T 4*fSk*2 a,\O

^f aWd3Sb1WT,E Z*h1 ]*abdf \b*`d L a*W\Y 67B5P:C <7B5=MD

-\,* ,4q, Y1Z1 4* `dVd ) \f`1abSW*aq Z1,/\,4T ]TaWq Z14*+dbO

Zn\-\ V\Z-`1adE k\ ,T/+d,aq , \Y+1^ 5=9: `\VdD 1`14 jTabn YTaqgT,E 4* ]`SVW*O /\Y a,\-\ ab*`j\-\ +`*b* `*+-*V*`*E q

ab*W* ]\,Z\h*aZSY ]`\]\,T/ZSV\Y /\+`\^ Z\,SZSD dW\ ,1WSV1 +*3*ZZq `\4]\,T/*O bS Wp/qY +T+WTyZT TabSZSE *W1 qV bTWnVS

]\hSZ*W* `\4Y\,d ]`\ a,\^ ]1`1V\Z*ZZqE

d `\bT ]1`1aSf*W\E q 4*^V*W*anE -\W\a b`1YO bT,D w `\]\,T/d,*bS 4Y\3d WSj1 4 ]\YThO hp -\,SIx P , `\4]*hT ]\/dY*W* qD -\,* /\]\YT- Y1ZT h1`14 YTaT\Z1`T, \O Y1` T db *VVT 4 *Z*/SE qVT 5=8; `\Vd Z*,h*WSan d YTaT\Z1`anVTy jV\WT ,T/VT, -\,S , npO•\`VdD \ZSE b*V +S Y\,SbSE ,4qWS Y1Z1 4* `dVdE T q Z1,]1,Z1Z\ 4`\+SO W* ]1`jT V`\VS d aWd3TZZTD db `*4 d `*4 f\/SW* 4T YZ\p ]`\]\,T/d,*bS ,T/ /\Yd /\ /\YdD \Z* /\+`1 4Z*W*E qV /\]\Y\-bS Y1O

ZT 4*a]\V\^bSanD 1`dhS Y1Z1 4* `dVSE ,\Z* V*4*W*B w 1 f,SWpyaqE a1ab`ShV\D \/TY\

/\ Z*abd]ZSf /,1`1yxD ı^ a]\VTy ]1`1/*,*,O aq Y1ZTD )V\an Y1ZT aV*4*WSE k\ ]*`bZ1`V\p d aWd3TZZT /Wq Y1Z1 ]`S4Z*hSWS ab*`jd ,TO 6< "

˙ 5 ˙ ) 6>55

V\Y b* /\a,T/h1Zd ]`\]\,T/ZSgp ˚WTO 4*+1b *V`*Z*`*qZD T/`*4d a]*W\ Z* /dYVdB w S ,/*abnaq 43SbSaq 4 gT2p a1ab`\pH \Z* ,T/ Y1Z1 Z*+*-*b\ ab*`O j*xD W1 h*a ]\V*4*,E k\ ˚WT4*+1b +dO W* a*Y1 b\p ]*`bZ1`V\pE qV* Y1ZT ]\O b`T+Z*D

w S Z1 2 \/SZ\VSYSx ]\h*bVd Z*a ,T/]`*,SWS aWd3SbS , Tab\`ShZ1 YTab\ ,`*Z-*+*/E 4* 8>> VTO W\Y1b`T, Z* afT/ ,T/ \Y+1qD S j,S/O V\ 4+*-ZdWSE k\ +dWS 2/SZSYS ,T/V*O YS , YTabTE /1 Y1jV*W\ Y*y31 YTWny\Z Wp/1yD `TY b\-\E b`1+* +dW\ ,S,hSbS Y\,d Y*`*bfTE qV\p b*Y `\4Y\,WqWSD ˛ h*a\Y ]T/abd]SW\ ]\hdbbq a*Y\bZ\aO bTD *h1 aS`\b*E q TZV\WS -T`V\ ]W*V*W*D W1 4 Y*b1`SZanV\p b1]W\b\p , -\W\aT ˚WT4*+1b ]\bTj*W*B w˙1V\WS YS ]\hd,*2Y\aq a*O Y\bZTYSE ]`\b1 ZTV\WS Z1 2 \/SZ\VSYSD S /*W1V\ ,T/ /`dO 4T, T `T/ZSfE *W1 -\,* 4*,3O /S ]\`dhD )Vk\ ,TZ +d/1 b,\O

^Y /`d-\YE a*Y\bZTabn 4ZSVZ1xD ı^ aW\,* /\aT 4T-`T,*pbn Y1ZT a1`g1D \WS , Z*a +dW\ Y*W\ -`\O j1yE Z*Y k\/Zq /\,\/SW\an TbS ]TjVS ]\ 6> VTW\Y1b`T,E Z1O 4,*3*phS Z* ]SWpVd hS +*-Z\E a]1Vd hS f\W\/D WTbVd b1Y]1O `*bd`* Z* ,dWSgT h*ab\ aq-*W* 8> -`*/daT,D a14\ZS Yda\ZT, Z* VTWnV* YTaqgT, h*abSZ* Z*O ˛ ˚WT4*+1b

j\^ b1`Sb\`T^ ab*,*W* +\W\b\YD Z14*/\,-\

a1 3 /Wq Z*a +dWS +TWnj\p /\ ^^ aY1`bT b`d/ZTabp Z1 ]\-\/ZT dY\,SE

* ]1,ZT 4,Sh*^ b* ]\-Wq/S YTag1,Sf Y1jO V*ZgT,D *]`SVW*/E 3TZVS Z1 a]TWVd,*WSaq 4 h\O

W\,TV*YS ]`SWp/Z\E fT+* k\ +dWS ^fZTO YS `\/Sh*YSD 1 +dW\ ]`SyZqb\E *+S 3TZO V* Z*,h*W* h\W\,TV*D \3 YS abSVZdWSaq ‹ 4 Z*aYTjV*YS b* \+`*4*YSD T,`\Vd k\bS3O Z1,T 4T+`*ZZq YS ]`\,\/SWS WSj1 ,/,\fD * 4 h*a\Y /\ Z*a /\WdhSWSaq 4*gTV*,W1ZT

]`*,/\p Wp/SD *V db,\`SW*an Z1,1WShV* -`d]*D ˙1fb\ Z*,Tbn f\/S, 4 Z*YS , aWdO 3TZZqD

w /\aV\Z*Wpy a,\2 ,YTZZqx `S+WS4Z\ h1`14 /,* 4 ]\W\,SZ\p `\VS Z*a ]`S4Z*hSWS Z*4*/ d \Y+1yD ˚WT4*+1b ]`\/\,3SW* ]`*gp ]`\]\,T/d,*ZZqE * Y1O Z1 ]\]`\aSWS /\]\Y*-*bS +*bnV\,TE qVSy

+d, 2/SZSY ]1`1VW*/*h1Y Z*j\^ +T+WTyO ‹

Z\^ WTb1`*bd`S Z* Y\,d V*Z*/*D TZ gTO Zd,*, Y\p /\]\Y\-dE \aVTWnVS +d, /d31 4*yZqbSy ,SV\Z*ZZqY `T4ZSf \+\,Gq4VT, d 4+\`TD ˛-\/\Y 5=:: `\Vd +*bnVS ,S`TjSWS ]1`1O

^f*bS Z*4*/ /\ `T/Z\-\ YTab* /T]TD \O WSj*phS \Y+1yE b*b\ aV*4*, Y1ZTB w˙\O ZpE ,/\aV\Z*Wpy a,\2 ,YTZZqD 1`1VW*/*y ]`\ab\ T 4`\4dYTW\D ZSV*y a*Y\,]1,Z1Z\aO bT y 4*WSj*yaq aYS`1ZZ\pD \VW*/*yaq Z* -\,dxD 1 +dW* \ab*ZZq +*bnV\,* Z*ab*O

Z\,*E +\ Z1,/\,4T ]TaWq ]`S^4/d , /T]T ,TZ ]\Y1`D 3 /\ZSZTE ]`*gpphS ]1`1VW*/*O

h1YE q ab*`*paq aWdf*bSan gT2^ ]\`*/SD w S Z1 f\h1j 3SbS Z\`Y*WnZSY 3SbbqYHx

˛-T/Z\ 4 b`*/SgT2p , ıZ/T^ +*bnVS ]`*-O

Zdbn \/`d3SbS a,\^f /Tb1y , pZ\Yd ,TgT y

4*\f\hdpbn ^f Y*bS ,1WSVd aTYGpD \3 Y1O Z1 h*ab\ 4*]Sbd,*WSB w S Z1 f\h1j 3SbS Z\`Y*WnZSY 3SbbqYH b\ ]\/+*2 ]`\ b1+1 d ab*`\abTH \+T Z1 a*Y\bZn\Hx ıZV\WS b*VT ,SaW\,Wp,*ZZq ]`S-ZThdO

pbnD * q Z1 ]\V*4dp a,\^f ]\hdbbT,E *E qV bTWnVS +d,*p Z* a*Y\bTE `\4]\,T/*p ]`\

*4\Y 4 TZjSYS \]\,Tk*p

]`\ +T+WTyZd ]`\Y\,d , \Y+1^E 5=:> `TV

ZSf -\,TD TZ Z1 ,,*3*2 Y1Z1 \+/TW1Z\p h1`14 b1E k\ q a*Y*E T g1 /d31 ]\bTj*2D +S T /*WT aWd3SbS y\Yd 4 ]\,Z\p ,T//*h1pE q `\4/dYdp ]`\ ıeb*f\,d /\hVdE * b*V\3 ]`\ ıada*D ı ,\Z*E T ,TZ 4*WSj*WSan Z1\/`d31O ZSYS b* gTWV\Y ,T//*,*WSaq aWd3TZZp \O -\,T Lı,*Z* 8B78MD

˙*` ,T/ -\,S *y31 9> `\VT, YS 4 ˚WT4*+1b +dWS +WS4nVSYS ]\/`d-*YSD \Z* ]\Y1`W* 6>>9 `\Vd , =<OWTbZn\Yd ,TgTD ab*ZZTYS `\V*O YS h1`14 ]\-*ZSy 4T` ,\Z* Z1 Y\-W* hSO b*bS T+WTpE b\Yd k\/Zq /\,-\ T ]*WV\ Y\WSW*an /\ \-*D ıZV\WS q /dY*W*E k\

˚WT4*+1b d a,\^y VTYZ*bT \+-\,\`p2 4 VSO Y\an T+WTpE b* Z*a]`*,/T ,\Z* `\4Y\,WqO

W* 4 -\,\pE qVSy +d, /Wq Z1^ `1*WnZ\p

a\+\pD \Z* 3SW* b*VE ZT+S \- +dV,*WnO

Z\ +d, ]\`dh 4 Z1pD 1 Z*,hSW\ Y1Z1 \/Z\^

TabSZSB k\+E ]\/T+Z\ /\ ıeb*f\,\^ /\hVSE 4*WSj*bSan Z1]\fSbZ\p d aWd3TZZT \-\O ,TE b`1+* 4*,3/S w+*hSbSx y\-\ ]\`dh T4 a\+\pD ) /d31 ,/qhZ* -\,TE k\ , Y\2O Yd 3SbbT +dW* gq ab*`j*E 4`TW* a1ab`*E qV* Z*,h*W* T 4YTgZqW* Y1Z1 , Y\W\/\abTE * \a\+WS,\ 4* h*ad ,S]`\+d,*Zn L˚VVW14TO qab* 8B=E 5>MD

*V a*Y\ qV /\hV* ıeb*f*E q a]T4Z*O W* hSY*W\ +W*-\aW\,1Zn d aWd3TZZT -\,TD ˛*,/qVS b\YdE k\ q 4*WSj*W*an Z14*YT3O Zn\p T 4*ab\a\,d,*W* +T+WTyZT ]\`*/SE Y\2 3Sbbq +dW\ /df\,Z\ +*-*bSY T ]\,Z\gTZO ZSYD *V Y1ZT ,/*W\an +*-*b\ `\VT, w]\O abTyZ\ +14 ,T/,\WTV*Zn aWd3SbS \a]\/dx L5 \`SZeqZ ;B79MD

]1`1VW*/*gnV\Yd ,T//TWT

â&#x20AC;˘ Ë&#x161; Äą Ë&#x2122;Äą Ë&#x161;â&#x20AC;˘

Äąf Z*4S,*WS waSZ*YS -`\Ydx

&E bS Z1 `*4 hd,E qV ]T/ h*a +d`T Z1O +\Y `\4V\hd2bnaq \-WdjWS,Sy -`TYD S b1+1 V\WSan WqV*, -`TYH LDDDM1 Äąada Z*4S,*,

/,\f a,\^f dhZT, waSZ*YS -`\YdxD \/S,TY\an h\YdD

T /,* dhZT Äąada* P g1 )VT, b* Äą,*ZE `T/ZT +`*bSD ÄąfZn\-\ +*bnV* 4,*WS Ë&#x203A;1,1/1yE * Y*O Yd P *W\YTqD \Z*E yY\,T`Z\E +dW* a1ab`\p

*`T^E Y*b1`T Äąada*D b31 ÄąadaE )VT, b* Äą,*Z Y\-WS +dbS /,\p`T/ZSYS +`*b*YS T /`d4qYS 4 /SbSZab,*D

)VT, b* Äą,*ZE qV T ^fZTy +*bnV\ Ë&#x203A;1,1/1yE +dO WS `S+*WV*YSD +\2 +`*bT, +dWS a1`1/ ]1`O

jSfE V\-\ Äąada ,S+`*, a,\^YS dhZqYSD \WS

Äąada 4*]`\]\Zd,*, ^Y ab*bS dhZqYSE ,\ZS \/O `*4d 4*WSjSWS `S+*Wnab,\ T ]TjWS 4* ZSYD T4ZTj1 Äąada ,S+`*, 56 dhZT,E qVT ab*WS *]\aO b\W*YSD 1`1/ ZSf +dWS )VT, b* Äą,*ZD

Ë&#x203A;* VTWnV* YTaqgT, /\ a,\2^ aY1`bT Äąada `*O 4\Y 4 *]\ab\W*YS ]`\f\/S, -\`Sab\p YTag1O

,Tabp *Y*`T^D T/ ,1hT` daT aSWnZ\ ,b\YSWSO aqD W1 a*Y*`qZS , \/Z\Yd a1WT Z1 4*f\bTWSE k\+ Äąada b* y\-\ *]\ab\WS ]1`1Z\hd,*WS , ZSfD Ë&#x203A;Z*2j h\YdH LDDDM \/S,TY\anD Äąada 4 *]\ab\W*YS +dWS 2,`1qYSE * a*Y*`qO

ZS /\ +TWnj\abT 2,`1^, ab*,SWSan Z1]`Sq4Z\D `\b1 Äąada ab*,S,aq /\ a*Y*`qZ /\+`1D *V a*Y\ Y*WS + ab*,SbSan /\ ZSf )VT, b* Äą,*ZD W1 ,\ZS `\4a1`/SWSan Z* a*Y*`qZ h1`14 b1E

k\ bT Z1 f\bTWS ]`SyZqbS ^fE T 4*]Sb*WS Äąada*B w \h1jE YS Z*V*31Y\E k\+ 4 Z1+* 4Tyj\, ,\O 1 `S V`*]VS , /d3V*f \4Z*h*pbnE k\ 4*]Sb*ZZq ]1`1/ ZSYS aV1`\,*Z1 /\ /Tb1yD )Vk\ ,S hSb*2b1 gp ab*bbp 4 /SO

bSZ\pE 4d]SZTbnaq T /*yb1 ^y Y\3WS,Tabn ,T/]\,TabSD

7>

-\Zn T ,SZSkS, ^fHx #\E Z* b,\p /dYVdE ,T/]\,T, ıadaH LDDDM TZ aV*4*, )V\,d b* ı,*O ZdE k\ ,\ZS Z1 ]\,SZZT b*V -\,\`SbSD )VT, b* ı,*Z Y*WS Z*,hSbSaq +dbS +TWnj YSW\a1`/O ZSYSD ıZj\p ,1WSV\p ]`\+W1Y\p )V\,* y ı,*Z* +dW\ b1E k\ ,\ZS f\bTWS 4*yY*bS ,S/*bZ1E ,SO k1 ,T/ TZjSf Wp/1y ab*Z\,Sk1D 1,/\,4T ]1O

`1/ ıada\,\p aY1`bp ,\ZS aV*4*WS a,\^y Y*O YT ]T/TybS /\ Zn\-\ T ]\]`\aSbSB w˛*Y\, aW\,\E

k\+ \+S/,* gT Y\^ aSZS aS/TWS d b,\2Yd g*`aO b,T P \/SZ ]`*,\`dh ,T/ b1+1E * /`d-Sy WT,\O `dhxD \hd,jS ]`\ g1E /1aqb1`\ TZjSf *]\aO b\WT, `\4T4WSWSan Z* )V\,* b* ı,*Z*D bS `\4T4WS,aq +H LDDDM \3WS,\D *Y Z1 ]\/\+*2bnaqE V\WS TZjT f\hdbn +dbS , dan\Yd ]1`jSYS T Z*y,*3WS,TO jSYSD T4ZTj1 )VT, b* ı,*Z 4`\4dYTWSE k\ aSWnZ\ ]\YSWqWSan T ]\,\/SWSan Z1]`*,SWnZ\D ˛`1jb\p ,\ZS 4YTZSWSan b* ]\h*WS ab*,SbSan /\ Wp/1y 4 Wp+\,Gp T /\+`\b\pD \-\ YS

,hSY\aq 4 gT2^ `\4]\,T/TH LDDDM T/ ıada* YS ,hSY\aq b\-\E k\ b`1+* +dbS /\+`\4ShWS,SYS \/ZT /\ \/ZSfD ıada ab*,S,aq /\ ,aTf P h\W\,TVT,E 3TZ\VE /Tb1y P 4 /\+`\O b\pD S bS ]\ab*`*2jaq ]*YGqb*bS g1y ]`SVW*/ /\+`\bS T ]\,\/SbSan b*V a*Y\E qV ıadaH LDDDM

• ˚ ı ıı

*`V* 7B5; *b,Tq 6;B99E 9:C *`V* 59B8>E 85 *b,Tq 8B5<P66 ı,*Z* 8B8P59E 65P6:C dVS =B95P99 *b,Tq 6>B6>P68C *`V* 5>B79P7;E 85

)V /TqbSE V\WS ,S \]SZSWSaq , 4\ZT abSfTyZ\-\ WSf*H ı :E ;

S Z*ab*Z1 h*aE V\WS V*b*ab`\eS ,T/Ty/dbn d Z1+dbbqH ı <E =

b\ Y\31 bWdY*hSbS +T+WTyZT ]`\`\gb,*H ı 55P57

#\ /\]\Y\31 ,*Y 4Z*ybS a]`*,3ZTf /`d4T,H ı 5:E 5;

#\ \4Z*h*pbn +T+WTyZT aW\,* ]`\ b1E k\ 2 wh*a V\f*bS T h*a Z1Z*,S/TbSxH ı 67P69

S ,S f\bTWS +E k\+ ,*a ,T/,T/*WSH *,Tbn d gn\Yd Z1a]\VTyZ\Yd a,TbT ,S Y\31b1 ab*bS k*aWS,SYSE Z*+d,*phS b\hZ\-\ +T+WTyZ\-\ 4Z*ZZq ]`\ \O

-*E y\-\ *`ab,\ y hd/\,d Y1bd k\/\ Wp/ab,*D )Vk\ ,S +*3*2b1 \b`SY*bS +TWnj1 TZe\`Y*gT^ *+\ k\+ ,*a fb\an ,T/,T/d,*, T ]`\,\/S, 4 ,*YS +14]W*bZ1 +T+WTyZ1 ,S,h1ZZqE ]`\aSY\ ]Sa*bS /\ ,T/VT, -\,S Z* */`1O adB 1Zb` ,T/VT, -\,SE *Na =99E n,T,O `pf\,ShTE ;=8=5E *+\ Z* \/Zd 4 ,T/]\,T/ZSf */`1aE k\ Z* ab\`TZgT 8D www.watchtower.org

wp11 12/01-K